Latest / Film And Whiskey / Oscars 2026 Recap + Season 10 Bracket Challenge Begins (Round of 32)
Transcript
- 0:00On today's Film and Whiskey, we're talking about the Oscars
- 0:032026. We'll give a quick recap of all
- 0:06of our thoughts on this year's winners and then Brad.
- 0:09Dude, it's bracket time. That's all ahead on film and
- 0:15whiskey. Well, hey everybody, welcome
- 0:35into the Film and Whiskey podcast.
- 0:37I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad Jeep.
- 0:40And Brad, we're coming at you with another special bonus
- 0:46episode. Bonus episode.
- 0:48I'll tell you what, dude, there is nothing like getting on the
- 0:51horn with you at the butt crack of dawn.
- 0:55Talk about last night's Oscars 'cause we had the option to stay
- 0:59up real late and talk about the Oscars and I said no, let's
- 1:01sleep on it. You know, I want my first words
- 1:03that I audibly say to be captured on Mike tomorrow
- 1:07morning. Absolutely.
- 1:08My my Husky sexy voice is here to talk all about last night's
- 1:13Academy Awards, which I think the banner headline of this
- 1:17year's Oscars is Brad G watched some of this.
- 1:22That's true. I watched a lot of this, Bob.
- 1:25I think I started watching at like 8:30 or so and I I watched
- 1:29through to the end. My wife was sleeping in bed next
- 1:32to me and I had my laptop open. Break it.
- 1:35Breaking all the marriage rules. You've ever heard of the
- 1:37Christian Marriage Conference? I'm so proud of you, first of
- 1:41all, for, for watching the Oscars telecast, Brad.
- 1:45And I have to say, you know, I found what I watched of it last
- 1:49night to be pretty good. Not a bad telecast.
- 1:52I don't usually like award shows in general.
- 1:54You know, I watched the Oscars most years, but this one seemed
- 1:57to move at a decent pace it it did not break the four hour
- 2:01mark, which really is insane that these things would ever go
- 2:044 hours. But yes, I'd like to hear your
- 2:06thoughts, just in general, as a guy who never watches the
- 2:10Oscars. What'd you think of the
- 2:11telecast? I I think that you've used the
- 2:14word telecast 3 times and that's a very old fashioned word.
- 2:19You know, I have to, I have to use it now because it's going to
- 2:21go straight to YouTube in a couple years here.
- 2:23Then you definitely can't call it a telecast anymore.
- 2:26It's not. A.
- 2:26It's live telecast. Right.
- 2:29I thought it was pleasant, I I really enjoyed Conan O'Brien.
- 2:33I thought he was he was usually short, to the point and like his
- 2:38jokes landed and that's. That's all I feel like you can
- 2:42ask for from a host when I think it was the K pop Demon Hunter
- 2:47song one. The lady was talking about K pop
- 2:50and how cool it was. And she thanked everybody.
- 2:53And then like the dude swooped in and was like, and I also want
- 2:55to thank. And they pulled the mic on him
- 2:59and Conan just goes, man, to retract a mic on a man in the
- 3:03middle of his speeches. Hilarious.
- 3:09It was parade killed man. I was yeah.
- 3:12I was laughing very hard. I like Conan.
- 3:14He has just enough of like the old fashioned showman in him,
- 3:20but he also has that like David Letterman streak of very
- 3:23irreverent host. And it's a nice balance because
- 3:26he's not offensive to the guests in the room and he's willing to
- 3:31tell a joke so stupid that he knows it's not going to land.
- 3:34And I think you need somebody with that sort of charisma to be
- 3:38hosting the Oscars. It's it's been really nice, man.
- 3:41I do. I do still worry about the
- 3:42future of the Oscars. I just think that, like, most
- 3:44people don't care. Like, no one cares what wins an
- 3:46Oscar anymore except people like you and me.
- 3:49And I think that's a brilliant segue into talking about this
- 3:52year's winners because after all of this hoopla, Brad 1 Battle
- 3:57After another did in fact, take home the Oscar for best picture.
- 4:00It won, I believe, 5 or 6 Oscars on the night, 6 Oscars on the
- 4:05night because it added that new category of best casting.
- 4:09So the Oscars included best picture, best director, best
- 4:12adapted screenplay, best supporting actor, best casting,
- 4:16and then I believe, best editing.
- 4:18It won as well, which means that it did edge out Sinners, which
- 4:22was its primary competition in best picture.
- 4:25Sinners took home, I believe, 4 Academy Awards last night.
- 4:28So they both did kind of, you know, share the wealth a little
- 4:31bit. Brad, I know that you personally
- 4:35just truly hate everything that one battle after another stands
- 4:38for. So now that it's actually just
- 4:40done the job of winning picture and director, what are your
- 4:44immediate takeaways here? I mean, it's a sign of our
- 4:47times, right? For me, what made me realize it
- 4:52was There Will Be Blood did not win best picture.
- 4:57Right. A very subtle and beautiful
- 5:01critique of American capitalism of a fanatic American church.
- 5:06Culture, but beautiful for sure. Compared to 1 battle after
- 5:10another, it was it is subtle. I'm like, I'm sorry compared to
- 5:15that. And so I think that's why I say
- 5:17it's a sign of our times. Like we don't have any subtlety
- 5:21anymore as an American culture it like we want to be just
- 5:26slapped in the face with our own political beliefs so that we can
- 5:30feel good about ourselves. And that's what that's what we
- 5:34got. We got it good and hard Bob we
- 5:36got we got 1 battle after another just a bad movie.
- 5:40The more I reflect on it, the more.
- 5:43I just listen, I don't think it's a bad movie.
- 5:45I do think now, now we can put a pin in 2025 and I can just
- 5:50definitively say I am not on this train of like every year's
- 5:54a great year for movies. Like 2025 was a down year for
- 5:57me. Yeah.
- 5:59I mean, like there were good movies.
- 6:00I don't think I saw any transcendent 10 out of 10
- 6:04masterpieces the way. There was no past lives.
- 6:07No past lives, no Oppenheimer, no holdovers, no Anatomy of a
- 6:10Fall, no Godzilla minus. 1/20/23 was a freaking banner year for
- 6:14movies and the last two years have not lived up to that.
- 6:17And that's OK. Like we have these ebbs and
- 6:19flows. But to your point, Brad, like
- 6:22There Will Be Blood did not win the Oscar in 2008 for the year
- 6:262007. It's because 2007 was an
- 6:29incredible year for movies. Like look at the nominees in
- 6:322007. You've got Michael Clayton,
- 6:34you've got There Will Be Blood, you've got Atonement, you've got
- 6:38I believe Juno snuck in there. And then the winner is No
- 6:41Country for Old Men. That's like, that's a great
- 6:43lineup of best picture nominees and not including the ones that
- 6:46didn't get in because we only had a field of five back then.
- 6:50And I think if one battle after another comes out in 2007, it's
- 6:54not even nominated for best picture.
- 6:55And I know that critics love it. I know that people are telling
- 6:59you it's the best movie of the decade.
- 7:00I just happen to disagree. I thought it was a good movie,
- 7:03but like, kind of just like a Nora last year.
- 7:07It's like, I just don't know if this is going to have the
- 7:09staying power where we look back on this 10 years from now and
- 7:12think, like, oh, my God, one battle after another.
- 7:15That movie year must have been awesome.
- 7:17Yeah. I just don't see it man.
- 7:19I mean even Anora, I think Anora was a way better film than one
- 7:23battle after another. Like at at the end of the day
- 7:27Anora had a message that was about the human soul and
- 7:33experience whereas 1 battle after another was just this
- 7:37political like very shallow piece of garbage so.
- 7:43Wow dude, I. Bro.
- 7:45You're coming in spicy today. And yet only in one of those
- 7:49films did anyone drink a few small beers.
- 7:51Brad, that's. Dude, Benicio is great.
- 7:55Like, I'm sorry, Benicio's incredible in that movie.
- 8:00You know what I will give a quick plug.
- 8:02I I Benicio Del Toro was nominated for best supporting
- 8:05actor. He did not win because Sean Penn
- 8:07won, which I know Brad probably has a spicy take about that one
- 8:10as well. I have said all year long, I
- 8:13think Benicio should have gotten more attention for the Wes
- 8:16Anderson movie, The Phoenician Scheme that came out this year
- 8:19'cause he's the star of that movie.
- 8:21He is unbelievable in that movie.
- 8:24And I think Brad, especially if you're looking for movies that
- 8:27are like ultimately about the human soul and experience, I
- 8:30would love for you to go back and watch The Phoenician Scheme
- 8:33because it's Benicio, it's Wes Anderson, and it's maybe Wes's
- 8:37best examination of like what it means to be a person.
- 8:41And I, I think you'd really, really like it.
- 8:43I wish that movie had gotten more love this year.
- 8:46Yeah, I I remember you talking about it when it came out.
- 8:48I never got around to it, which should surprise 0 people.
- 8:53Yeah. All right, let's let's get to
- 8:56the other big award for the night, which I think was
- 8:59probably the most contested one, which was best actor.
- 9:02Yeah, I will say I think this was kind of a down year for
- 9:05movies. Every performance in the best
- 9:07actor category was fantastic. And I really could have seen
- 9:11this award going multiple different directions.
- 9:13So for a long time. And and here's the thing about
- 9:16the Oscars is like, it's not just a case of who was the best,
- 9:20it's a case of we're going to nominate what we believe to be
- 9:23the five best or five representative people here, and
- 9:27now they're going to spend two months campaigning.
- 9:30And so it's this weird combination of like, you know, a
- 9:33presidential election with the campaign and how they run their
- 9:37campaign and how they position themselves.
- 9:39And, and like the performance that preceded it.
- 9:42It's like if American Idol was they give one performance and
- 9:46then they spend two months trying to convince you after the
- 9:49fact that they're a good person instead of just like a
- 9:51performance and a vote. And so, like, Timothy Chalamet
- 9:55had been in the lead for Marty Supreme for essentially the
- 9:59entire Oscars race. But there had been this sort of
- 10:03like, bubbling under the surface that people were getting kind of
- 10:06sick of Timmy because the Marty Supreme marketing campaign
- 10:13started off with him essentially, like, impersonating
- 10:17his character, who's like, a very cocky asshole in the movie.
- 10:21And it took a long time for people to figure out that, like,
- 10:23the reason that Chalamet was acting so cocky was because he
- 10:27was trying to get, like, Gen. Z to go see this movie, Marty
- 10:30Supreme. And it worked.
- 10:31It made $100 million like that movie.
- 10:33There's no way that movie should have made $100 million.
- 10:36And it did. But it left a bad taste in
- 10:38people's mouths. And then he gave this interview
- 10:41a couple weeks ago where he said something to the effect of,
- 10:44like, I want to help keep the movies alive.
- 10:48I don't want the movies to become irrelevant like ballet
- 10:51and opera. And the people who were looking
- 10:54for outrage said we love ballet and opera.
- 10:58It's like, first of all, no you don't.
- 11:01Do not buying tickets to the ballet and the.
- 11:02Opera. I saw a stat after that happened
- 11:05because even I heard about this Bob, that I think it was like
- 11:0952% of American adults had been to the movies in the last year
- 11:15and .7% of American adults had been to the ballet or opera in
- 11:20the last year. It's like the thing.
- 11:23People, I think people are really starting to turn on
- 11:25Timmy. This is bad for his image and
- 11:27his career. Like he's, he's entering that
- 11:29weird Anne Hathaway zone where like people hated Anne Hathaway
- 11:32for a while and she had to do like a complete I, I don't know,
- 11:36it happened. It happened, but I think it's
- 11:40because he's dating a Kardashian and he seems to a lot of people
- 11:44and like, you know, this, he's going to have to go back to the
- 11:48drawing board here. I will also say I am in complete
- 11:52agreement with what he said. If you actually listen to what
- 11:54he said, all he was saying was like, I want to help keep the
- 11:58movies relevant. He's not talking about like, is
- 12:01opera good or bad? Is ballet good or bad?
- 12:04It's just the fact that like culturally they do not have an
- 12:07impact anymore. I'm sorry.
- 12:08Like he's right and I want a guy who wants to champion the
- 12:11movies. Like that's, that's just who I
- 12:13am. That's what happens when you let
- 12:16crime run rampant in your cities.
- 12:17Bob and a prominent family like the Wayne's get shot and killed
- 12:22outside the opera. I'm sorry.
- 12:24Listen, man, yeah, this is all the Joker's fault.
- 12:28That's exactly what we're saying.
- 12:31So anyway, all that to say, Timmy was in the lead.
- 12:35He really lost the lead. And in the last couple weeks,
- 12:37it's been like, who's going to win this award?
- 12:39Because we had the used to be called the SAG Awards, now
- 12:42called the Actor Awards. Michael B Jordan wins best
- 12:46actor. And everyone's like, Oh, we kind
- 12:49of forgot about this guy through the whole race.
- 12:52And you could tell that in the background his his publicist,
- 12:56his like, you know, the marketing team at Warner
- 12:58Brothers was pushing this narrative of like, but he played
- 13:01twins because every like anonymous Oscar voter article
- 13:07that I've seen over the last couple weeks, they've been like,
- 13:09who you voting for for best actor?
- 13:10And if it's Michael B Jordan, it's like I'm voting for Michael
- 13:13B Jordan. He played twins.
- 13:15That was like two different roles in one movie.
- 13:18So it worked, man. And Michael B Jordan wins best
- 13:21actor. And I will say I really like
- 13:24Michael B Jordan. And he seems like, you know,
- 13:27every report I've heard is like he's a great person to work
- 13:30with. He's a genuinely good dude.
- 13:32The the Academy seems to like him.
- 13:34And I think he has like movie star charisma and persona.
- 13:38I don't think he was even the best part of the movie Sinners.
- 13:41But like, I don't hate the win. It's nice to see somebody under
- 13:4550 win this award for a change. It gives me a little bit of hope
- 13:48for the future of Hollywood. But I don't know, man, where,
- 13:51where are you at on the Michael B Jordan win?
- 13:54I loved it. I, I think he, you know, of all
- 13:57the, of all the best actor movies I saw this year, I
- 14:03thought all two of them. I thought he did a really good
- 14:06job. I think it would have made sense
- 14:08if Leo got it. I think that this would be
- 14:10another example of like if Leo hadn't won for the revenant.
- 14:15I think he wins for one battle after another, right?
- 14:20It is fascinating that there I found myself thinking like, man,
- 14:26Leo got away from another Oscars without a, without a little
- 14:30statue that like that was one of my first thoughts when Michael B
- 14:33Jordan got it. As far as Michael B himself
- 14:36goes, like that's great, man. He's a great I, I can't even
- 14:39call him young anymore. He's probably in his 40s,
- 14:42thirty. He's like. 393839 Yeah.
- 14:45OK, yeah. So I mean, he's got another 20
- 14:48to 30 years ahead of him. I'm curious to see where he goes
- 14:51with this. It's not quite an Emma Stone,
- 14:54though, who has won, like, what, 3 best, best actress?
- 14:59So I, you know, we've got some young people, Bob.
- 15:01There's hope. You can hold on.
- 15:03It does. Remind me a little bit of like
- 15:05when Jamie Foxx won for Ray and I think Jamie Foxx is better in
- 15:09Ray than than Michael B Jordan is in Sinners.
- 15:11But it's been a long time since like just an objectively cool
- 15:15guy, one best actor and a guy that like is going to go make
- 15:19movies that aren't Oscari movies and open those movies to a lot
- 15:23of box office because he's just a cool guy.
- 15:26Like, Will Smith wins his Oscar in horrific fashion a couple
- 15:30years ago, but he had also kind of already crested as like a
- 15:34cool guy that you go see in the movies.
- 15:35So it's it really is nice to see somebody that's still kind of on
- 15:39top in the movie star. Like he's still got the juice,
- 15:42you know what I mean? When you're when your wife is
- 15:44openly cheating on you, I I think your your peak was a while
- 15:47ago but. Yeah, dude, we, we don't support
- 15:50cucks financially the way that we do other one.
- 15:54Thing America is still not down with.
- 15:57No, not at all. All right, man, listen, I don't
- 16:00want to give a full list of the Academy Award winners from
- 16:04tonight. There was 24 different
- 16:05categories. We already talked about the two
- 16:07biggest winners in one battle and sinners.
- 16:11I think Frankenstein wins three Oscars below the line, which is
- 16:14great. You know, like they love
- 16:15Guillermo del Toro in the Academy.
- 16:17I thought that movie kind of sucked, but like, what are you
- 16:19going to do, you know? I will say Jessie Buckley, I did
- 16:23not see Ham Net. I really liked her speech out of
- 16:27every person who won an award. I just was like, wow.
- 16:30She just talked about the beauty of motherhood and how thankful
- 16:33she is to be a mom and make a movie about moms.
- 16:37And thank you Academy. I was like I was in.
- 16:41I want to go see Hamnet now. First of all, Hamnet pretty
- 16:45good. Jessie Buckley, all time great
- 16:50performer. Like, it is really crushing.
- 16:53Dude. She's so good in that movie that
- 16:56for the entirety of awards, she won every award.
- 16:59Like no one has even remotely challenged her this entire award
- 17:02season. And so to get to the finish line
- 17:04and have people still like you this much says a lot about how
- 17:08good that performance was. And she's a great actress.
- 17:10So it's nice to see her like, finally get an Oscar here.
- 17:13Here's my question. Is voting for the Oscars open
- 17:17through all of these other awards?
- 17:21So some of the awards are like, I don't, you know, everything's
- 17:25a precursor, right? But some of the awards are kind
- 17:27of like where we whittle down what's going to get nominated.
- 17:31So at the very end of the the calendar year, you'll have your
- 17:35critics guilds give their awards out.
- 17:38And that kind of gives us a sense of like, here's going to
- 17:40be the major players, like 1 battle after another is winning
- 17:43everything. That's probably going to be a
- 17:45major player, you know, sinners, whatever it might be.
- 17:48And then you get to the beginning of January, and some
- 17:51of the Oscar categories have what's called short lists.
- 17:54So like, I don't know, like the visual effects category.
- 17:57Well, I don't know if that's one of them or not, but that's where
- 18:00the 400 movies like that could be.
- 18:03Yeah. Like the just the visual effects
- 18:05department of the Oscars will say like, hey, we're going to
- 18:09focus our nominees on this list of like, 20 movies.
- 18:12And we think that this is the short list.
- 18:14Let's pick 5 from this. Now, not everything is voted on
- 18:17that way, but then you kind of get into the early awards like
- 18:20the Golden Globes and the Sags and everything else, and that
- 18:23kind of helps narrow down what's going to get nominated.
- 18:27And so when the Academy Award nominations come out in mid
- 18:31January, it's like, OK, here's the nominees.
- 18:34I think there's a couple weeks off and then voting opens.
- 18:37But even if voting's not open, all those other award ceremonies
- 18:42are part of your Oscar campaign. Like if you win a Golden Globe,
- 18:46it's nice to have a Golden Globe.
- 18:48Your speech better be damn good because it's your first chance
- 18:50to impress Academy voters. You know what I mean?
- 18:52So like, it's, it's interesting how they do it.
- 18:55I wish there weren't so many award shows because then by the
- 18:58time we get to the Oscars, like everyone, it's March, dude.
- 19:02Like, I don't care about 2025 anymore.
- 19:04I want to watch 2026 Movies Now. Yeah, that, that is interesting.
- 19:08I, I feel like it would be better for the voting if it was
- 19:13just like before all the other awards.
- 19:16Now I know that you lose all the gossip and like hype around it.
- 19:20Then to me, if you want a pure like vote just based on the
- 19:25performance, not on if Timotei is talking about ballet and and
- 19:30opera. Like you got to vote right after
- 19:34nominations are put out and not let all this other stuff
- 19:37influence you. I know that that's not our
- 19:39culture, but. Yeah, and, and I'm in, I'm the
- 19:42same way, but mostly because it doesn't make sense practically
- 19:45for like the movie's performance, like because of the
- 19:49way movies are released. It used to be that like
- 19:52Christmas was the big Oscar push.
- 19:54And so movies that hadn't come out yet, it was like, we'll drop
- 19:56it at Christmas. It'll get a ton of end of year
- 19:59buzz. It will get an Oscar nomination
- 20:01out of that. And then that'll really spike
- 20:02this movie's performance 'cause it's still in theaters from
- 20:05three weeks before, right. And now it's like some of these
- 20:08movies don't even release wide. Because it's such a small movie
- 20:13that they're only hoping for Oscar nominations.
- 20:15And so if it doesn't get any Oscar nominations, they'll just
- 20:17kind of dump it and they don't lose that much money and no
- 20:22one's heard of it and no one's seen it until mid January.
- 20:26And then they'll finally be like, here you go Ohio.
- 20:28You can have one theater showing this movie now that it's
- 20:30nominated for Oscars. It's really screwed up the like
- 20:33the economics of the Oscars. Because if I've never heard of
- 20:37it, I like me personally. I get curious.
- 20:40I'll go see that movie. But like John and Jane Doe in
- 20:44Ohio, they're looking at the. List of like.
- 20:47Right, like what's nominated for best picture and it's like it's
- 20:51January. I didn't hear about this movie
- 20:54all of last year. Like I don't understand.
- 20:56And so I'm I'm with you. I think that like nominations
- 21:00should happen and the, the Oscars should happen soon after
- 21:03that because the only thing that gives these movies the potential
- 21:06for a box office bump is an Oscar win.
- 21:09And so to have the, the nominations come out mid January
- 21:13and the awards not happen until mid March, there's two months
- 21:18where most of America is not even thinking about these
- 21:21movies. They're certainly not in
- 21:23theaters anymore. We're not going to see them.
- 21:25They're not making more money. So you're just giving yourself 8
- 21:28weeks to like hobnob with people in LA and it just like it.
- 21:33By the time they actually get awarded, the relevance of those
- 21:37movies has declined significantly in terms of like
- 21:40public discourse. I mean, if there's anything we
- 21:42know about people in LA, though, Bob, it's that they like to
- 21:46hobnob with people in LA. They sure, sure do, man.
- 21:51Brad, we are here today not to talk about the Oscars.
- 21:53We're here to talk about the season 10 bracket challenge,
- 21:57which I want to get to here in 60 seconds, but I want to turn
- 22:00it over to you. I've been doing a lot of talking
- 22:02here, overall impressions of this year's Oscars, and did it
- 22:06inspire you to go watch anything that you have not seen yet?
- 22:10A ham nut. I, I, I really enjoyed Jesse
- 22:13Buckley. I'm curious to, to see that.
- 22:17I, I think that the overall the Oscars were nice.
- 22:21There's only a few people who like got up on their political
- 22:24soapbox and I was like, OK, whatever, let's let's move on.
- 22:29It was enjoyable. I I think I'd watch the Oscars
- 22:31again, Bob. We did it.
- 22:35I will. Say we did it the.
- 22:37The tribute to Rob Reiner was really beautiful.
- 22:42How did I forget? Bob?
- 22:44Bob, this is the most important thing that happened at the
- 22:48Oscars last night during the In Memoriam section.
- 22:53Our boy Robert Duvall sadly passed away last year.
- 22:57And do you want to know, do you want to take a guess as to what
- 23:01movie they pulled from for his? Like, here's the dude.
- 23:07Here's the line that represents Robert Duvall.
- 23:11Of all the Robert like the Godfather, The Godfather too,
- 23:15like the Great Santini, I don't know, freaking like To Kill a
- 23:19Mockingbird. Boo Radley.
- 23:21This is Robert Duvall and the movie they pull for him.
- 23:24Brad second hand Lions. What are the greatest movies of
- 23:27all time? Bob I literally.
- 23:30Jumped out of my seat and like cheered.
- 23:32I was so freaking jazzed. That's what I will just send you
- 23:38like the Vin Diesel GIF of him just saying like the movies.
- 23:42Yes, that's what the movies are about.
- 23:44Is Brad jumping out of his chair at the In Memoriam?
- 23:47First of all, not not the etiquette you're supposed to
- 23:50have during the In Memoriam segment.
- 23:53If I had been in whatever theater they were in, everybody
- 23:56would have been like, this guy needs to.
- 23:58Be escorted out of here right now.
- 24:01It's a little bit better than like when I, I was telling my
- 24:04buddy, we were talking about when Robert Duvall died and his
- 24:08only frame of reference is the Family Guy episode where they're
- 24:12all about to drown and, and Peter does the I don't like the
- 24:15Godfather. It insists upon itself because
- 24:17Chris's reaction is just Robert Duvall.
- 24:21Like he just screams Robert Duvall.
- 24:23That was my buddy's reaction. And I was like, oh, did you see
- 24:25Robert Duvall died? Robert Duvall.
- 24:28The guy that Chris screams about, well, it's good though.
- 24:34It's good to know that you have friends who are less informed
- 24:37about cinema than me that that makes me feel.
- 24:40I, I want to have an Oscars party one of these years, not
- 24:43because I care that much about the actual broadcast, but just
- 24:46because, like, it's fun to get together and have a party, but
- 24:49like, nobody watches movies anymore, Brad.
- 24:52It's just me and you, dude. I was to say Zach would have to
- 24:55come up from Kentucky and it'd be you, me and him drinking
- 24:58whiskey alone, cheering in a room, cheering about Robert
- 25:01Duvall's death. All right, dude, it's time for
- 25:06us to get into the Season 10 bracket.
- 25:09What do you say, dude? Let's get to it, man, I'm ready.
- 25:17All right, Brad, it's bracket time.
- 25:19It's time for the moment, we're actually here for today.
- 25:21Let's. Freaking go man I'm ready.
- 25:24Listen, every season I only do the movie reviews to get us to
- 25:28bracket challenge time. That's right, Brad, this is this
- 25:30is by far the best and most fun series of episodes every season.
- 25:35Absolutely. And I think part of that is
- 25:37because there's there's a structure to it, but there's so
- 25:42much chaos thrown into the structure that it's just like,
- 25:45I'm just winging this thing with my friend here and we're going
- 25:47to see how mad we can get each other.
- 25:49Yeah. And I have a feeling, Bob, that
- 25:52we're going to get pretty. And by we, I mean you are going
- 25:55to get pretty heated this this first episode.
- 25:59It's going to be a crazy one. Let's take a step back because
- 26:02it's possible that someone has never listened to a bracket
- 26:05challenge episode of ours before.
- 26:07So the way this works is each of our seasons are structured by
- 26:10reviewing 32 movies so that at the end of each season, we can
- 26:14put those movies into a madness style bracket.
- 26:17Now, the timing this time is super fortuitous.
- 26:19Brad. I don't know if our bracket
- 26:21Challenge episodes have ever coincided with March Madness,
- 26:25The real March Madness. I don't think.
- 26:26So, but this is freaking great. We're going to get so much
- 26:28content out of this. I'm excited.
- 26:31So the way we're going to do it folks, is we're breaking this
- 26:33across 3 episodes over the next three weeks.
- 26:36So the last episode, the championship matchup of this
- 26:40bracket, will be coming to you on March 31st.
- 26:44So today we're just going through the round of 32.
- 26:48Next time around we're going to do the round of 16 and 8 and
- 26:51then the final episode we'll get to the final four and our
- 26:54championship match up. Now, the operative assumption as
- 26:57we talk about these movies is that when they're facing each
- 27:01other in a match up, you have to ask yourself which one of these
- 27:06movies, if one of them had to get thrown into the fiery chasm,
- 27:11the pits of hell to be completely annihilated and never
- 27:14seen again? And you have to choose one.
- 27:17Which movie would that be? Sometimes it's very easy for us
- 27:21to throw something in the fiery chasm.
- 27:23Other times, Brad, it really is like choosing between two of
- 27:26your own children and trying to decide which of these two things
- 27:29I love has to get destroyed in front of me.
- 27:31That would be. It's a harrowing experience,
- 27:33that. 'D be harder for you, Bob,
- 27:35because you only have two kids. For me, I would at least.
- 27:37Have two kids leftover. You've got her.
- 27:40You've got a spare. Is that what you're saying?
- 27:42Yeah, exactly. That's great.
- 27:44Now, OK, we're going to go through the bracket here in just
- 27:47a moment, and I guess to explain how it is seeded.
- 27:50The number one seed in our bracket really did earn that
- 27:54spot. So at the end of every episode
- 27:55when we review a movie, we give it a score out of 10.
- 27:58So a movie will have Brad and my score out of 10.
- 28:01And it's very easy to kind of sort, hey, which movies did the
- 28:04best at the end of the season. Sometimes we'll have like 2
- 28:08movies that came out to an average of a nine out of 10.
- 28:11And in order to determine the tiebreaker between those two,
- 28:14we'll go to the IMDb score so that we kind of have like an
- 28:17audience vote. So whichever one has a higher
- 28:20IMDb score gets the bump. Now we've got a nice ordered
- 28:23list of movies. But what we figured out in the
- 28:26first couple seasons of doing this is that sometimes just
- 28:29because you gave a movie a 9 1/2, just because you respect a
- 28:33movie, doesn't mean that it's one of those ones that that has
- 28:38your heart. Absolutely.
- 28:39If you're holding 2 movies over the edge, sometimes you'd drop a
- 28:439 1/2 movie instead of an 8 1/2 movie.
- 28:45And for that reason, at the end of every season, Brad and I go
- 28:49through and do kind of our heart list, our vibes based list of
- 28:53just here's how I would rank these on this particular day
- 28:57based on nothing but vibes. So we come, we come away with
- 29:00three different lists. We average the ranking of all
- 29:04those three lists to come out to our final seating.
- 29:07And it's very complicated. It's way more work than it
- 29:10probably needs to be for something like this, Brad.
- 29:12But I'll tell you what, It produces a bracket that neither
- 29:16of us like at the end of the day.
- 29:17And I think that's a sign that it's like the perfect bracket.
- 29:20It often does. And like, if there's not a
- 29:23better sign of our our entering middle age, if not our love for
- 29:28a good spreadsheet, complicated formulas that like this is
- 29:32absolutely beautiful in my opinion.
- 29:35You know, we say complicated formulas we could definitely
- 29:37just use like the auto sum feature.
- 29:39It's it's the most basic of all formulas on Excel.
- 29:41It's, and I love it for that, the meme from Hangover when he's
- 29:48doing all the math in his head. How do I average 3 numbers?
- 29:54Yeah, dude. All right, I think it's time for
- 29:56us to dive into this bracket. Any final thoughts before we
- 29:59start revealing what the bracket is and what it looks like?
- 30:02Curious since most of these movies other than two are movies
- 30:08we did in season 1. Did did Pulp Fiction win our
- 30:13first bracket? Or was it Vertigo?
- 30:16I can't remember. I'm fairly certain it was Pulp
- 30:19Fiction. I remember making like the
- 30:21little announcement picture to put on Instagram.
- 30:24So I believe Pulp Fiction was our winner the first time
- 30:27around. And that's a great point.
- 30:28Every movie except for two that we are doing this season is a
- 30:31revisit movie now. We had a couple movies that did
- 30:34not qualify for this season that we replaced with this year's 2O
- 30:38frontrunners, Sinners and 1 Battle After Another.
- 30:42You can go back and listen to those episodes.
- 30:44And you've just listened to the Oscar recap, so I assume some
- 30:48Oscar gold was at play between those two movies.
- 30:51Hi Brad. I think it's time for us to dive
- 30:53into this. I'm going to go ahead and share
- 30:54my screen just for a moment so that if people are watching
- 30:57this, they can see the bracket themselves.
- 30:58I'll take it down in a moment. If you would like to download
- 31:01your own bracket and follow along, you can find it at
- 31:03filmwhiskey.com. It's right there up on the
- 31:06banner Season 10 bracket. The nice thing is that since
- 31:10we're only doing the first round matchups, you still have time to
- 31:13fill out your bracket and let us know who would win your Season
- 31:1610 bracket. Brad, let's do it, man I'm
- 31:20ready. I'm pulling up the bracket here.
- 31:23Let's take a look at it. And we're going to be starting
- 31:26here up in the upper left quadrant as we always do.
- 31:30Our number one seed for season #10 is Alfred Hitchcock's
- 31:35Vertigo, dude. Now, I think we should make a
- 31:37quick note that after all three of our lists got averaged, our
- 31:421-2 and three overall seeds were still tied for points.
- 31:47That's how good the top three movies in this bracket are
- 31:51compared to everything else. And it, it was kind of painful
- 31:55to have to decide which one to put at #1 So we ended up using a
- 31:58randomizer. And you know, I have no say in
- 32:01it at this point, Brad. It is in Fate's hands.
- 32:04The randomizer said that Vertigo is the number one seed of season
- 32:0810. And a very well deserving.
- 32:12There's a reason I couldn't remember if it was Vertigo or
- 32:15Pulp Fiction that won our entire bracket.
- 32:18Interestingly enough, Pulp Fiction, our fourth seed in this
- 32:22bracket. Yeah, I thought that was very
- 32:24interesting. That's The funny thing about
- 32:27these brackets too, is I think I was lower on Pulp Fiction than
- 32:30you were. I want to say it was like my six
- 32:32overall seed, but it was like it's my six seed.
- 32:34It's not like I gave it a bad ranking.
- 32:37And yet because these other three films were so high between
- 32:40the two of us, they came out ahead.
- 32:43So Vertigo is going to be our number one seed and it's going
- 32:46up against a kind of surprising 32 seed, 1 battle after another,
- 32:51which we've just talked about now.
- 32:53This was a movie that Brad and I, you know, Brad liked it less
- 32:56than I did. I think I came out to an 8 out
- 32:58of 10. I like it fine.
- 33:00Brad was a little cooler on it than I was and because of that
- 33:03the average came out to I think something as low as a 7.25 for
- 33:07us. Which is.
- 33:08Pretty low. Your vibes list was also not
- 33:10kind to 1 battle after another Brad.
- 33:13Yeah, I I'm pretty sure it was my lowest ranked film and I but
- 33:17I will say this is a this is a composite this you had your vibe
- 33:21ranking in there. We had IMDb in there like I I
- 33:25don't think 1 battle after another is quite as historic as
- 33:29people are making it out to be. Yeah, I do not find it to be the
- 33:33transcendent masterpiece that everyone is claiming it's going
- 33:36to be. And I, I kind of always like,
- 33:38balk at this idea that, like, I can pinpoint the year something
- 33:42comes out, what's going to be remembered 15 years from now.
- 33:47There's only a few times that people have been able to
- 33:49accurately call that. And I just I don't see one
- 33:51battle after another being one of those movies.
- 33:53And because of that, Brad, I think this is a pretty easy
- 33:56first match up in the round of 32.
- 33:59So I'm going to take Vertigo here, the number one seed to
- 34:03move on. What do you think?
- 34:04Yeah, I'm also going to pick Vertigo, Bob.
- 34:07That's an easy, easy moving on. Vertigo's one of the best films
- 34:11ever made, so. Yeah.
- 34:14Now we go from that to a match up that I think will immediately
- 34:17spark debate and hatred between us because we're talking about
- 34:21the number 16 overall seed. We're talking right in the
- 34:24middle of the bracket here. Yeah #16 seed Star Wars Colon, A
- 34:30New Hope episode 4, A New Hope versus the number 17 seed, The
- 34:35Shawshank Redemption at before we get to the headline here,
- 34:40which is why is Star Wars at 16? Let's let's get Shawshank out of
- 34:44the way too. Shawshank is a movie that you
- 34:46and I have kind of grappled with over the seasons because you
- 34:49know, it's, it's IMD BS top rated movie of all time.
- 34:52It's a movie that I think everyone on earth would agree is
- 34:55like a nine out of 10. And because of that, it's always
- 34:58ranked at at #1 on IMDb. There's was just a really funny
- 35:02instance of something like this happening a few weeks ago on
- 35:05IMDb where there was an episode of Breaking Bad that has a 10
- 35:09point O. It was the only episode in TV
- 35:11history that had a 10 point O for years and years.
- 35:15And then a bunch of Game of Thrones fans went on and review
- 35:18bombed it down to like a 9.7. And it was this long
- 35:22conversation about fans of other things review bombing.
- 35:25And that's actually how Shawshank got up to #1 was that
- 35:29it had been the Godfather for the longest time.
- 35:32And I think when The Dark Knight came out, the Nolan fan Bros and
- 35:36the Batman fan Bros wanted that movie to be #1 so badly that
- 35:39they started giving The Godfather one star reviews to
- 35:43tank it really. And then Shawshank is just like,
- 35:46no one wants to give Shawshank A1.
- 35:48So they're like, you know, it could, it could be #1 that's
- 35:50fine. I will say they showed it on TV
- 35:52last week. And that's a, that's a very
- 35:54intense movie. But I was flipping through the
- 35:57channels and it was right at the part where Andy escaped.
- 36:02And then Red gets out and goes to Zejuata Nejo.
- 36:05And I was like, hey, my 9 year old come watch the end of this
- 36:09movie with me. And so he watched Andy crawl to
- 36:10freedom. I turn the channel when the
- 36:12warden shoots himself. I don't want, you know, I see
- 36:14that. And he sees sees Red get his
- 36:17freedom too. And I was like, you know what?
- 36:19This is a pretty great movie, dude.
- 36:21I'm not going to lie. Like, it's a it's a really good
- 36:23movie. I don't think it's the best
- 36:25movie ever made, but I also don't think we need to hold it
- 36:28to that standard all the time. No, it feels like it's in a
- 36:32weird similar vibe to Citizens Kane where like it has this aura
- 36:39of like it's been the IMDb number one movie for like 15
- 36:43years now. 20 years. I guess if it's around when The
- 36:46Dark Knight came out that was 2008 since it's insane to me
- 36:51that we have to hold it to this crazy high standard.
- 36:53Like you said, it is so incredibly well made paired with
- 36:58being very likable and uplifting that no, like nobody's going to
- 37:02give it a one. Like there's a few trolls out
- 37:04there, but it also isn't standing up against something
- 37:08like The Dark Knight where you have a crazy passionate fan
- 37:11brace. That's like F Shawshank.
- 37:14It needs to go kick rocks. We're going to, you know, review
- 37:18bomb it. It'll never have anybody do
- 37:19that. So, so here we are.
- 37:22It's great. That's a great flick.
- 37:24Talking about crazy, passionate fan bases that will go to bat
- 37:27for their movie Star Wars at #16 and not just any fan base.
- 37:33Perhaps the craziest of all fan bases.
- 37:35That's rude, Bob. I do.
- 37:37Well, I was going to say I do want to set you aside from the
- 37:40rabidness of the fan base because you don't really care
- 37:43that much anymore. Because I think you've accepted
- 37:45that Disney has just ruined everything at this point.
- 37:49But you'll still go to bat for the original trilogy.
- 37:52Would you say that Episode 4 is the most near and dear to your
- 37:57heart of any Star Wars movie or no?
- 38:02No, I would. That's really tough because I,
- 38:05you know, I saw the the prequels in theaters.
- 38:10I skipped school for the first time to go see a movie to see
- 38:14Episode 3. So in some ways, I would say
- 38:18episode 3 is near and dear to my heart.
- 38:21Probably this is man, this is so hard.
- 38:24I there's a world where Empire Strikes Back is one of my is
- 38:27probably near and dearest. But there's something about
- 38:30Return of the Jedi that the ending of that film just like
- 38:33grabs me on a soul level. I, I will say that this time
- 38:39through, when I watched it for the podcast, I think I was more
- 38:44aware of its flaws than ever before.
- 38:47I still, I think I gave it a 9.5 if not a 10 sure.
- 38:51So like, I, I still think it is a nearly perfect movie that did
- 38:57so much for the world of cinema at large.
- 39:00And so I, I still think that, you know, Shawshank has had a
- 39:04cultural impact because of meme culture and like imitating
- 39:11Morgan, like imitating Morgan Freeman as a narrator, Like it's
- 39:15like meme culture in that or like crawling through poop to
- 39:18get to your freedom. So it's like it's got meme
- 39:20culture, It's got the IMDb mystique, but I don't think it
- 39:24has the cultural impact that Star Wars had.
- 39:27I think it kind of pales in comparison.
- 39:29So for me, this is like an easy I'm moving Star Wars on.
- 39:34Yeah, this is a hard one for me because I also think that
- 39:37Episode 4 might be my least favorite movie.
- 39:41Of all time. Of any of the six that Lucas was
- 39:44involved in, and I don't think it's the worst one.
- 39:48I think episode 1 is like significantly worse than episode
- 39:504. But I I said this in the
- 39:53episode, man, I think episode 4 is kind of amateurish.
- 39:56Like I just think that there's a ton of stuff in that first movie
- 39:58that was saved by the edit. There's a pretty famous instance
- 40:01where Lucas shows all of his film maker friends, you know,
- 40:05Scorsese, De Palma, Coppola, Spielberg, a rough cut of it.
- 40:10And they were like. This sucks, dude, like what are
- 40:12you doing? And only Spielberg saw the
- 40:15potential in it. And then, you know, they edit
- 40:17it. They had the music, it becomes
- 40:18Star Wars. But I think a lot of that
- 40:22amateurishness can't be taken out of the movie.
- 40:25It's edited in a way that you don't notice it as much if
- 40:27you're caught up in it. And for me, Episode 1 is a worse
- 40:32movie with a lot more technical mastery than episode 4.
- 40:37I think I came away this time giving it like an 8 and then I
- 40:40did my vibes list and I was like, I am once again swayed by
- 40:43not trying to hurt Brad's feelings.
- 40:45I I dislike episode 4. I don't think it's a bad movie,
- 40:50I just don't like it. I think it's poorly made.
- 40:53Episode 5 is a masterpiece. Return of the Jedi is flawed,
- 40:58but I have a better time with it.
- 41:00And so I think for me, I'm going to move Shawshank on.
- 41:04And it's only because Shawshank is like a nine.
- 41:07I don't feel passionately about Shawshank.
- 41:09It's just like, I think it's better and I have to move it on.
- 41:12And that means that, Brad, I need you to introduce the Deus
- 41:16Ex machina here that we have called the Coin of Destiny.
- 41:20The the Mary Sue itself, the Coin of Destiny, it used to be.
- 41:25I haven't found it in a while. Oh, I just found it.
- 41:28Bob, give me one second. The real coin of destiny.
- 41:32I literally was cleaning off my bookshelf next to me the other
- 41:35day and I must have revealed it from behind some books.
- 41:38We have a coin of destiny. This is not a sponsorship but it
- 41:43is a we like these guys. It is for Lucky 7.
- 41:48If you can see the video I'm showing it on camera.
- 41:51Lucky 7 distillery. Are they down in Tennessee or
- 41:54are they Kentucky? They source their stuff.
- 41:55I think they're in Kentucky though.
- 41:56OK, anyways, Lucky 7 Distillery sent us this coin, I think in
- 42:01season 1. And so from the start this has
- 42:04been a coin that we flip. Now the heads is the Lucky 7
- 42:10logo and then the tails is the word spelled out.
- 42:17So that's our heads, that's our tails.
- 42:20It is the coin of destiny. It does decide who.
- 42:24It doesn't decide which movie gets thrown into the fire.
- 42:27Inferno Bob. What it actually decides is who
- 42:30God has favor upon you or myself.
- 42:34That's true Now, as the slightly higher ranked seed, Star Wars is
- 42:38going to be heads and Shawshank will be tails, and that means
- 42:41it's time Brad for supremacy over each other.
- 42:45Flip that coin, all right? We have a heads Star Wars
- 43:01moving. On man by the skin of its teeth.
- 43:03Dude, Star Wars is moving on into the second round.
- 43:06I'm going to make a note of that.
- 43:08And we have to say goodbye to The Shawshank Redemption.
- 43:10Andy did not, in fact, make it out of the tunnel of poop where
- 43:14he drowned a horrible death. Yikes.
- 43:17It was a real Oregon Trail situation for him.
- 43:20All right, man, that's probably going to be the longest debate
- 43:22we're going to have today, I would hope.
- 43:24So it's time for us to move on to one that is very easy for me,
- 43:28and that is the #9 overall seed West Side Story up against the
- 43:3324 seed Forrest Gump. Now, again, Forrest Gump kind of
- 43:37falls into that Shawshank thing where most people think it's
- 43:41like an 8 out of 10, nine out of 10 movie.
- 43:43It does have its detractors for being as big and cheesy as it
- 43:46is. I think the story for me here,
- 43:49Brad, is how West Side Story got all the way down to our nine
- 43:51seed. Because on your vibes list, you
- 43:54ranked it pretty low after giving it either a 9 1/2 or a 10
- 43:58out of 10 on the episode. So, you know, explain yourself
- 44:02man. I I really like West Side Story.
- 44:07It's a really fun movie that is bright and bombastic and fun.
- 44:16I it just doesn't, I don't know, man.
- 44:18It's not my, it's not my movie. It's not my musical.
- 44:21I didn't grow up with it. There's something about it that
- 44:24I'm like, yeah, this is great. It it feels how you feel about
- 44:27Shawshank, where I'm like, yeah, this is this is a great movie.
- 44:31I recognize the technical brilliance.
- 44:32It's well written, great performances, but it doesn't
- 44:37hold like any impetus over my soul.
- 44:41So I'm kind of like, yeah, you know, it just.
- 44:42Suffered a little bit. It's one of those movies where
- 44:44like you've got the movie itself and then you've got like the joy
- 44:48of watching, as our friend Zach Johnston would say, watching
- 44:53cinema cinema. And I don't just mean like the
- 44:55machinery, because sometimes, like with Shawshank, I respect
- 44:58the machinery of Shawshank, but like it doesn't really capture
- 45:02me the way some other movies do West Side stories like, yes, the
- 45:05machinery is there. And then there's this layer of
- 45:07just like, oh, I'm watching like a Dutch master at work here.
- 45:11You know what I mean? Like it's just, it's, it's just.
- 45:16Why a Dutch master Bob I? Don't know.
- 45:19I'm trying to think of painters and I'm I'm mixing them up with
- 45:22machinery. Now I'm watching.
- 45:23There you go, this metaphor. All right, dude, I'm going to
- 45:28put West Side Story on here. Do you have any qualms about
- 45:31that with your vibes list? Should Forrest Gump make it on
- 45:35over West Side Story? I mean, I think there's a world
- 45:39where West Side Story makes all the sense in the world.
- 45:43I think I moved Forrest Gump on Man, I just.
- 45:46Dude, no. I just, I just like Jenny.
- 45:48I want to see her move on in the bracket.
- 45:52Now is this totally vibes based because I'm almost positive you
- 45:55gave West Side Story a better score than Forrest Gump.
- 45:59I'm sure that I did. We we can Fact Check this really
- 46:05quickly. Forrest Gump Oh, I guess we
- 46:11there it is. Sorry Forrest Gump I gave a nine
- 46:15out of 10 and West Side Story I gave a 9.5.
- 46:19So I I did give it a higher score.
- 46:21Close enough. Yeah, not by a lot.
- 46:23I think, once again, that Forrest Gump, this is kind of
- 46:28the reverse of the last one. Forrest Gump has lived on in
- 46:32meme culture in a lot of ways. And I also think that just
- 46:38purely on vibes, I gotta pick Forrest Gump, man.
- 46:42It, it's just such, I really hate this.
- 46:44Yeah. It's just such an incredible.
- 46:46So much because you won the last one.
- 46:48I'm I would like to think that I'm due for a win, but I I don't
- 46:52think that's gonna happen. So that's not how West Side
- 46:54Story. That's not how.
- 46:55That's not how Destiny works. No, it's not.
- 46:59West Side Story is the higher seed.
- 47:00It will be heads. Forrest Gump will be tails.
- 47:03Brad, flip the coin of Destiny and also I hate you so much.
- 47:16Man, man, Bob, you should not hate me anymore because we have
- 47:21another. Head.
- 47:22Thank God. Yeah, screw you, Forrest Gump.
- 47:26And West Side Story is moving on.
- 47:30I listened. Back to our Forrest Gump episode
- 47:32the other day in the car, and it is first of all, it's a blast.
- 47:35But I just talked for the whole first half of the episode about
- 47:38how quotable Forrest Gump is, especially out of context.
- 47:42Yes, it is absolutely one of the most quotable movies.
- 47:46We added Anchorman on to this season, also one of the most
- 47:49quotable movies of all time. I think we have some some great
- 47:53quotable films this season and season 1 by.
- 47:57Well, we have one less now because Forrest Gump is gonzo.
- 48:00And that takes us to our next match up here.
- 48:02The number 8 seed, the Tree of Life up against the number 25
- 48:07seed, To Kill a Mockingbird. Now, the tree of Life is also, I
- 48:11think, victim for me. Brad, of.
- 48:13We had a guest on our podcast, Bilga Ibiri, one of the world's
- 48:16most esteemed film critics. And he, I mean, just gushed
- 48:20about the movie. Yeah.
- 48:21And I can see why in the moment, we all gave that movie a 10 out
- 48:25of 10 because I think the totality of it, it's like, such
- 48:30a towering accomplishment. But like the first 40 minutes
- 48:36and the last and and like moments in the middle and then
- 48:39the last like 10 minutes are incredible.
- 48:41But there's about an hour and a half in there somewhere that
- 48:44you've got to be really committed to make it through.
- 48:46Yep. And you really do, if you ask
- 48:49me, on any given day, like, do you want to fire up the tree of
- 48:52life? It's not, that's not going to be
- 48:53one of them. You know what I mean?
- 48:54So like, it's a 10. That's also not a 10 for me.
- 48:58I don't know if that makes sense.
- 48:59Yeah. It does make sense.
- 49:01I mean, even Vertigo, like, I'd be more likely to fire up
- 49:04Vertigo. But Vertigo's a heavy movie,
- 49:06man. I'm not just going to whip that
- 49:07up on a random Thursday night and be like, yeah, it's time to
- 49:10watch, talk, watch Jimmy just, like, slowly lose his mind.
- 49:13That sounds great. I will say on the opposite side
- 49:16of Tree of Life though, we have To Kill a Mockingbird, which
- 49:19while you and I have said like one of the greatest courtroom
- 49:22scenes of all time, like hands down, it's right up there with
- 49:26like You Can't Handle the truth. Not the best movie overall.
- 49:32No, and I think that that it felt a lot creakier this time
- 49:36around in getting through what it tried to do.
- 49:38I don't think it ever found the balance the way the book does
- 49:41between the innocence of childhood being shattered and
- 49:44the realities of the world and you know what the themes that
- 49:48it's trying to accomplish. And I will say, first of all,
- 49:51RIP Robert Duvall, whose first screen role was here in this
- 49:55movie as Boo Radley. I hate to see that go into the
- 49:59fiery chasm here, Brad, but I think Tree of Life does move on
- 50:04here, although I am marking it for a potential upset in the
- 50:07next round. Just because I it doesn't, it
- 50:11doesn't capture my heart the way others do.
- 50:13Totally. I and I, I would argue it
- 50:15captures my heart a little bit more, but that's be rombly
- 50:19because I love Jesus and I'm a better human being than you.
- 50:22So. All right, well, that is the end
- 50:25of that quadrant. So our first four entries into
- 50:29the round of 16 are Vertigo, Star Wars, West Side Story, and
- 50:35The Tree of Life, all four of the favorites.
- 50:39Now we're moving into the bottom left quadrant here where we've
- 50:42got our number four overall seed, Quentin Tarantino's Pulp
- 50:46Fiction up against the number 29 seed, Sinners, a movie that I
- 50:51will note Brad liked more than I did.
- 50:54And so, you know, Sinners is a fun little movie.
- 50:57I think it definitely has artistic merit.
- 50:59I am still a little surprised at how much critical and awards
- 51:04consensus rallied around this movie, which is, you know,
- 51:08again, a very well made movie. I don't think that it even
- 51:11remotely touches Pulp Fiction. Now, I will say, Brad, if you
- 51:16want to give us 30 seconds on spoiling your bracket a little
- 51:19bit, or at least your vibes list.
- 51:21I'm pretty sure Pulp Fiction was like your number one movie of
- 51:24the season on the vibes list, which I was a little surprised
- 51:28by. At I would say for me it's
- 51:32probably between our 2 heavy hitters on this side of the
- 51:35bracket between Vertigo and Pulp Fiction.
- 51:38For me, the those are the two that looking back on our
- 51:42experience in season 1 and then like translating that to like
- 51:46our experience now in season 10, I think those are the 2 movies
- 51:49that stand out to me as seven years ago I was in love with
- 51:55these movies. Now I still find them to be
- 51:58absolute masterpieces. It feels to me like those are
- 52:02the 2 ones that really really just transcend any amount of
- 52:09where I'm at in life when I watch this movie.
- 52:14Yeah, man. And I think that over the years,
- 52:16I cannot recognize the insane cultural phenomenon and
- 52:23influence that this movie was on movies for 10-15 years
- 52:27afterwards. I also think Quentin Tarantino
- 52:30has made better movies since then.
- 52:32And there are moments in Pulp Fiction that I don't know if
- 52:34he's ever topped. Like, it might have the highest
- 52:37highs of any movie of his. Yeah.
- 52:39But I don't know if, like, beginning to end, I would say it
- 52:41is his best movie all the way through.
- 52:44Sure. And so I'm.
- 52:45I mean, I'm this is a pretty easy one for me to move Pulp
- 52:48Fiction on here over sinners. But like the Tree of Life, I
- 52:51think depending on the matchups it faces in the bracket, this
- 52:55could be the victim of an upset here in the next couple rounds.
- 52:57Brad. Wow, that's that'll be you
- 53:00causing an upset, Bob. That won't be me.
- 53:03Yeah, I think we've established that at this point.
- 53:06All right, that takes us to our next matchup.
- 53:08Brad, do you have the bracket pulled up or should I continue
- 53:11introing all of these? So Next up we're talking an
- 53:15absolute bombastic, ridiculous, incredible film 198384. 84.
- 53:26841984's Amadeus the Best Picture winner up against the
- 53:31Best Picture winner from the 535352. 5450 years old, so yeah.
- 53:40That's what a fortuitous match up, Bob.
- 53:42We're talking 1954's On the Waterfront, Bob.
- 53:47Which one of these could have been a contender?
- 53:49Oh, man, now you know not to critique your intro skills here,
- 53:53Brad, but you know this is your first time doing it.
- 53:55Yeah, totally. Step in and say the 13 seed
- 53:58Amadeus up against the number 20 seed on the waterfront.
- 54:02So Amadeus did end up a little higher.
- 54:04And I'm in very different places on these movies than I think I
- 54:07was prior to watching them from for this season.
- 54:10Amadeus, I think is a movie that lives in your memory as a
- 54:14perfect movie. It's been.
- 54:15And you watch it and it's like there's a few moments that are
- 54:18slow. Like it's a really good eight
- 54:21and a half nine movie that has moments of 10 and the moments of
- 54:2610 are what you remember it. It has those moments like a like
- 54:29a piccolo, like a playful little piccolo.
- 54:33And then On the Waterfront is a movie that we were super cool on
- 54:35in season #1 coupled with like, it's always had the reputation
- 54:40of the Elia Kazan. I named names.
- 54:43I'm a traitor, I'm a rat. And now I'm making a movie about
- 54:46how being a rat is OK. And there's a certain segment of
- 54:49like, very liberal film Twitter that will just never get on
- 54:53board with that movie, no matter how good it is.
- 54:55But we watched it this time and I was like, dude, I this is a
- 54:59near perfect movie. Yep.
- 55:02So I really struggled with this one.
- 55:04Brad, I'd like to hear where you came out on this one because
- 55:06I'll be honest with you, I'm looking at my bracket right now
- 55:09and there are two matchups in the whole bracket that I just
- 55:14left blank. Wow.
- 55:15Because I don't know what to do. I think this is not a.
- 55:18Part of that one because it's facing, it's facing Pulp Fiction
- 55:21in the next round. And I kind of think that
- 55:22whatever comes out of this might fall victim to Pulp Fiction
- 55:25totally. But like this is a hard 1 for
- 55:28me. It really is.
- 55:29I think that you are looking at the the prestige level of On the
- 55:36Waterfront. To me, it lives in that Citizen
- 55:39Kane world of like really old black and white film that film
- 55:46critics talk about but the average person hasn't seen at
- 55:49this point in history. And Amadeus is in the this came
- 55:55out of the 80s and who knows what was going on back then.
- 55:58It's wild and fun and about an hour too long.
- 56:02And they were just doing a lot of drugs at the time.
- 56:05So that's what you get with Amadeus.
- 56:08I if I had to pick one just based on vibes and on what I
- 56:15would want to watch again someday.
- 56:17I think Amadeus barely nudges out on the waterfront.
- 56:22I would agree with you. This is one of the hardest
- 56:25decisions of the the first round.
- 56:29I think we need to leave it to fate then.
- 56:31I honestly think that at this moment, I would probably nudge
- 56:34On the Waterfront over it a little bit.
- 56:36You know, especially you get the I should have been a contender.
- 56:39And then the scene where he finds his brother in the
- 56:41alleyway is just, it's so crushing.
- 56:44The moments that work in that movie I think work even better
- 56:47than any moments in On the Waterfront.
- 56:49So, right, I think we're going to do a coin flip.
- 56:52That means that it's going to be the 13 seed Amadeus will be
- 56:55Heads and the 20 seed on the Waterfront tails.
- 56:59Brad, flip that coin. Man, I we need to see if this
- 57:12thing's weighted because we are looking at another heads.
- 57:17Wow. All right, so Amadeus squeaks by
- 57:21in the round of 32 we have to say goodbye to On the
- 57:25Waterfront, and that takes us to another pretty fun match up
- 57:29here, Brad. It's the number 12 overall seed,
- 57:32the Treasure of the Sierra Madre, up against the 21 seed,
- 57:36$1,000,000 baby. I think this kind of also falls
- 57:40in that same realm for me where Treasure of the Sierra Madre was
- 57:43like one of my favorite movies when I first started watching
- 57:47classic old Hollywood movies. And now I've come to the point
- 57:51where I'm like, this is probably a nine and a half.
- 57:54It's no longer A10 for me. I still love it.
- 57:58Whereas $1,000,000 Baby is a movie that I kind of had dipped
- 58:01on. And then on this watch through I
- 58:03was like, it's a flawed movie, but damn, it's it's pretty good.
- 58:07It's close to a nine for me. So I'd love to hear where you
- 58:11fell on this one. I think that $1,000,000 Baby is
- 58:14a great movie. I think it falls prey to what
- 58:17we've often talked about with with Clint that like he just has
- 58:22no nuance and he has like a little bit here in $1,000,000
- 58:27Baby in the relationship between the two main characters, but
- 58:33man, oh man, he struggles with any sense of nuance.
- 58:36It also, this movie reminds me so much of Gran Torino that I
- 58:43sometimes like get portions where I'm like, wait a second,
- 58:46what about the scene where Clint like brings the chairs up from
- 58:50the basement and I'm like, oh, wait, no, that was Gran Torino.
- 58:54And, and they kind of get mixed up, right?
- 58:56Which means for me, I, I feel like we should, I don't know,
- 59:00man. I feel like we should put
- 59:01$1,000,000 baby out of its misery.
- 59:03We should pull the plug. I think so, yeah.
- 59:06Take a take a pillow too. Well, Maggie Fitzgerald, where
- 59:11we are, we're going to we're going to, what's the word,
- 59:14ethically euthanize you here and we're.
- 59:17Going to ship her, ship her up to Canada.
- 59:19It's going to be the, what is it called, the MAID program.
- 59:22It's going to be great. Fly there, drive back as she
- 59:25said. All right, Treasure of the
- 59:28Sierra Madre is moving on into the round of 32, and that takes
- 59:32us to our last match up here on the left side of the bracket,
- 59:35the number 5 seed Rear Window up against the 28 seed Fight Club.
- 59:42I'm a Fight Club hater. I don't know what to tell you
- 59:44guys. I just don't think it's a good
- 59:45movie, and I think that it is. I don't think it's as dangerous
- 59:50as I tried to make it out to be. Yeah, I think it's
- 59:52misinterpreted and I think that it does exactly what it sets out
- 59:56to do. I just don't think that it is
- 59:59like a very successful movie. And so I'm in a very different
- 1:00:03place than you are on it. Brad, I don't quite remember
- 1:00:06where this landed on your vibes list, but you like Fight Club
- 1:00:09quite a bit more than me. But I also don't think you're
- 1:00:12like, going to bat for Fight Club as one of the best movies
- 1:00:16of this season. No, I'm not.
- 1:00:18It actually fell down my vibes list a little ways it.
- 1:00:22I think it came in at like 20 or 21.
- 1:00:25At the end of the day, Fight Club's a great movie.
- 1:00:28I know that you're just jealous that you don't look like Brad
- 1:00:31Pitt, that that's the real, that's the real reason that
- 1:00:35you're upset about Fight Club. I think Fight Club, when you
- 1:00:39really dive into it, has a very fascinating message about
- 1:00:43society. I think it gets misinterpreted a
- 1:00:45lot of times. I think at the end of the day,
- 1:00:47though, Rear Window is an absolute all time classic where
- 1:00:53you have Hitchcock basically challenging himself to be like,
- 1:00:56all right, instead of like doing all the these wild chase scenes
- 1:01:00or, you know, like a North by Northwest.
- 1:01:03We're travelling all over the country.
- 1:01:05He's like, let's see what I can do if I keep the camera in the
- 1:01:08same room for an entire movie. Yep.
- 1:01:11And it it's, it's just a great, great film.
- 1:01:14You know, he did that with rope as well.
- 1:01:15But even rope has more movements around the room then you get in
- 1:01:20rear windows. So I just rear windows.
- 1:01:22Such a freaking classic dude. Yeah, the suspense in that
- 1:01:26movie, I don't know if there's a Hitchcock movie that is more
- 1:01:29suspenseful than when Grace Kelly tries to sneak into the
- 1:01:33guy's house or apartment. And at the end of the movie,
- 1:01:36when Raymond Burr comes to find Jimmy Stewart.
- 1:01:38Yeah. It's just it's a perfect movie.
- 1:01:40Yep. And I honestly, even putting it
- 1:01:42at #5 on our seating list here felt like a crime in a way.
- 1:01:47So, I mean, Rear Window moves on easily for me here.
- 1:01:50Yeah. Dude, just to comment on the
- 1:01:52whole season, I think my top 18 now probably my top 20 movies
- 1:02:01that like anything from 10 to 20 could have been the 10th overall
- 1:02:05movie for me. Does that make sense?
- 1:02:07Like my top, my top five felt certain.
- 1:02:11My top 6 through 9 felt like any of them could be in that range.
- 1:02:1510 through 20 was just every single one of them was an
- 1:02:19absolute hit and I had a really hard time with a lot of great
- 1:02:22films in the season. What's really funny about it
- 1:02:25too, is like your kind of middle tier on the vibes list is not
- 1:02:29the same as mine. And so it ended up making some
- 1:02:31matchups in the bracket that are like easier than if I had to
- 1:02:35pick between that number on my vibes list.
- 1:02:38And you know what I'm saying? Like my 5 and and 13 or whatever
- 1:02:43are very different than what yours would be.
- 1:02:45And so again, that it makes the bracket this agent of chaos that
- 1:02:49we're not expecting, and it puts us out with four more entries
- 1:02:53into the round of 16 Here, Brad, we're talking about Pulp
- 1:02:56Fiction, Amadeus, Treasure of the Sierra Madre and Rear
- 1:03:01Window. Once again, we have not had one
- 1:03:04lower seated movie advance into the round of 16 yet, but that
- 1:03:09might change. Brad, I think we should take a
- 1:03:10quick break here and then we'll get into the second-half of the
- 1:03:13bracket. What do you say?
- 1:03:14Let's get to it. All right, we are back the round
- 1:03:21of 32 in the season 10 bracket challenge and we're moving over
- 1:03:24to the right side of our bracket where we've got the number two
- 1:03:28overall seed, 12 Angry Men, one of the great Oscar snubs of all
- 1:03:33time, not getting nominated for Best picture, up against the
- 1:03:37number 31 overall seed, an American in Paris.
- 1:03:42Now an American in Paris is one of the more controversial Oscar
- 1:03:45winners of all time. That movie won the 1951 Best
- 1:03:48Picture Academy Award. I think it's a little bit of an
- 1:03:51unfair victim here because this season also includes singing in
- 1:03:56the rain. Brad and I look at it at #31 and
- 1:04:00I'm like, that seems a little. It's a good movie.
- 1:04:03I, I, I don't know if I would call it like an all time great
- 1:04:06movie. I do think it deserves its place
- 1:04:09in cinema history. The scene of Gene Kelly dancing
- 1:04:12with the kids is just like, that's magic, dude.
- 1:04:15Absolutely. Now, I think you're lower on it
- 1:04:17than I am. So I guess the question we're
- 1:04:19all asking is, what the hell, Brad?
- 1:04:21Why did this movie come out so low on our list here?
- 1:04:23It's a great movie, but like you said, when you have a list of 32
- 1:04:28films and you have two musicals with the same actor in the same
- 1:04:33era that look very similar. For me it just kind of felt on
- 1:04:39the rankings based on that. I also think.
- 1:04:42Is 12 Angry Men the most efficient movie of all time?
- 1:04:49So here's the thing about 12 Angry Men.
- 1:04:51It it's weird for me seeing it at #2 and I think part of it is
- 1:04:55because when we reveal our number three seed, you'll
- 1:04:57understand why I feel that way because I like the number three
- 1:04:59seed more than that. No, it is a perfect movie
- 1:05:03mechanically. It is a movie that moves and
- 1:05:07stirs the emotions. So it's not just a movie I
- 1:05:09respect. It is also a movie that like,
- 1:05:13you look at the machinery and you're like, I respect that too.
- 1:05:16And I think that I'm struggling with the fact that, like, I gave
- 1:05:20it a 10 and I love it, but I would put it maybe one step
- 1:05:24behind the number three seed that I'm like, man, is this the
- 1:05:28second best movie we watched this season?
- 1:05:31Now where did you have it on your vibes list, Brad?
- 1:05:34My vibes list I had 12 angry men in the four slots.
- 1:05:39So OK, up there it is very, very close, but not, you know, not #1
- 1:05:46number, not number 2, not even number 31 might say but.
- 1:05:50I think high enough that we could move it on here because I
- 1:05:54don't really think an American in Paris has much of an argument
- 1:05:57to make against 12 angry men. No, it really doesn't.
- 1:06:01Now our next match up, I think it's going to be fascinating.
- 1:06:05We have the number 15 seed Catch Me If You Can versus the number
- 1:06:1018 seed Cinderella Man, the Bulldog of Boygan.
- 1:06:17Bulldog of Boygan James J Braddock.
- 1:06:21We are, and I mean this in the best possible way, the only two
- 1:06:25people on earth that love Cinderella Man as much as we do
- 1:06:28100% Then you go on IMDb and it has like an 8.1 or something.
- 1:06:31Like people like this movie, it's just been forgotten about.
- 1:06:35Completely and we are here to fix.
- 1:06:37That If You can, I think over the last 20 years, Catch Me If
- 1:06:40You Can has taken on this kind of like this Is Spielberg truly
- 1:06:45at the height of his directorial powers and making a light,
- 1:06:49frothy comedy. And we didn't know how good we
- 1:06:52had it. And I think watching Catch Me If
- 1:06:54You Can, like as you watch it, it's like an 8 1/2 out of 10
- 1:06:58movie. And then you start realizing,
- 1:07:00like, oh, Spielberg is really at work behind the scenes here.
- 1:07:05And then it kind of takes on this additional layer of like,
- 1:07:07oh, maybe this is like a nine and a half.
- 1:07:09It's kind of like watching Billy Wilder do something like it hot
- 1:07:12where you're like, you get caught up in the movie of it and
- 1:07:15then you don't realize that there's actually a master behind
- 1:07:17the camera. And I don't say that to
- 1:07:20disparage Ron Howard, but like, you know, he's just not Steven
- 1:07:23Spielberg. And yet, at the end of the day,
- 1:07:28there's a part of me that wants to move Cinderella Man on past
- 1:07:31Catch Me If You Can't. I cry like a baby at Cinderella
- 1:07:34Man. I'm not going to lie.
- 1:07:35Absolutely. And there there's something
- 1:07:37about the messaging of a father looking to do anything he can to
- 1:07:44care for his children that, you know, may or may not be calling
- 1:07:48to us. And I, I also think like the
- 1:07:50messaging of Catch Me If You can is beautiful and like this
- 1:07:55abandoned boy, not of children, not children of men.
- 1:08:04There will be blood. Not, not not a.
- 1:08:07But boy, if abandoned my child. But like this, this orphaned
- 1:08:13child essentially who runs off into the world trying to make
- 1:08:16his way, finding family. Like, where is he going to find
- 1:08:18family? There's something about I'm
- 1:08:21going to find my family in the government that doesn't appeal
- 1:08:24to me as much as I'm going to give money back to the
- 1:08:29government that it gave me because I don't want to feel
- 1:08:33like I, you know, owe it like I took money.
- 1:08:35It really does appeal to both the capitalist and the right
- 1:08:38winger in you Brad A. 100% pretty hardcore.
- 1:08:41I'll love, I'll love me some Cinderella, Man.
- 1:08:43It's a heck of a. Movie OK I know you know what I
- 1:08:45think we're in agreement here in what is perhaps the biggest
- 1:08:49upset I mean the only upset by number yet we're going to move
- 1:08:53Cinderella man on over catch me if you can here.
- 1:08:56Let's go. And I'm OK with it.
- 1:08:58Yeah, I'm. Close.
- 1:08:59I am too. But I'm OK with it.
- 1:09:01Yeah, and I think this is another example of, I think in
- 1:09:04general, people would have Catch Me if You Can ranked higher.
- 1:09:08Like it would be like the 8th to 10th for a lot of people.
- 1:09:11For us, we're just a little bit cooler on it, especially this
- 1:09:13time around. I didn't find it quite as
- 1:09:16triumphant as I have in the past.
- 1:09:19So Cinderella man. We'll say I hate to see one of
- 1:09:22Leo's very best performances get thrown into the fiery chasm.
- 1:09:25It's so good. He he really does work wonders
- 1:09:28in that movie. I think you could hold that up
- 1:09:30as a contender for his best performance.
- 1:09:32Yeah, so sorry, dude, You're not the Bulldog of Bergen we're
- 1:09:35about to tell you. We're also losing.
- 1:09:37Chasm there, but. We're also losing one of the
- 1:09:39best knock knock jokes of all time.
- 1:09:43Knock, knock. All right, man.
- 1:09:46Next match up is the number 10 overall seed, The Great Escape
- 1:09:51up against the number 23 seed, Anchorman.
- 1:09:54I hate, I hate this match. I hate it 'cause they're 2
- 1:09:58movies that I love. They are like great dad movies.
- 1:10:01I remember you texting me when you were putting your list
- 1:10:04together and you said The Great Escape feels like the best
- 1:10:08baseline movie. Like it.
- 1:10:10It's the perfect #16 seed. And I'm curious about that
- 1:10:14because The Great Escape is one of those movies that just works
- 1:10:18for me and I couldn't even fathom having it halfway down my
- 1:10:23list, Brad. So I'm, I'm curious about like,
- 1:10:25does it just not work for you as well as it does for me?
- 1:10:28Or is it just like, I really do hold that up as the baseline for
- 1:10:32like a great movie? And that's where I'm going to
- 1:10:34start my ranking. I think I was, I would say
- 1:10:37specifically for this season, like I got almost halfway
- 1:10:41through my list. I think I was on like the 14th
- 1:10:44and I was looking at it. I was like, I feel like Great
- 1:10:46Escape could be 1415, but the more I thought about it, the
- 1:10:50more I was like, I feel like The Great Escape is the perfect
- 1:10:56middling point for this group of 32 movies.
- 1:11:01Like I can think of 15 movies that are better than it.
- 1:11:04I could probably even put 17 or 18 above it.
- 1:11:08But it for me, it felt like it set the standard of like, if
- 1:11:12you're going to be in the top of this bracket, you got to get
- 1:11:14past The Great Escape because it's such a great film.
- 1:11:18We just have a we just have a lot of good movies this season.
- 1:11:20Now, Anchorman is one of those movies that's like, I don't know
- 1:11:23how to explain it, man. It's kind of like hindered by
- 1:11:25its own ceiling. Like it is, it is so funny and
- 1:11:30it is also like a kind of purposely shitty movie.
- 1:11:34Do you know what I mean? Like it is it is the the
- 1:11:37platonic ideal of a type of dumb comedy.
- 1:11:40And I, I never want to be the guy.
- 1:11:42That's like comedies are less than because I don't think
- 1:11:45that's the case. I also just think The Great
- 1:11:47Escape is a better movie than Anchorman and I I don't really
- 1:11:51know how much more of a defense I need to give for The Great
- 1:11:53Escape on that front. Yeah, it's weird.
- 1:11:56I so I ranked Anchorman in my top 10 on my vibes list.
- 1:12:00Like I, I really think that Anchorman is a top two or three
- 1:12:06comedy of all time. Like it just checks all the
- 1:12:09boxes for me. It's like I remember watching it
- 1:12:12as an eighth grader and a sleepover with some friends.
- 1:12:14Like it is such it has a left an indelible mark on my soul.
- 1:12:20Maybe that explains a lot about me.
- 1:12:21Bob I, I think I'm still going to move the Great escape on,
- 1:12:26even though my vibe was greater on Anchorman.
- 1:12:30I think that the great escape is the bigger cultural impact.
- 1:12:33I think it's the better movie overall.
- 1:12:35And you you just get such an interesting picture of World War
- 1:12:392 from it that I I will move the great escape on.
- 1:12:42All right. We're we are in agreement there.
- 1:12:44So the Great escape is moving on and I think we're coming up to
- 1:12:48another match up that doesn't require a lot of conversation
- 1:12:51here. So we're looking at because
- 1:12:53obviously the overall seed. It's going to just drive on into
- 1:12:57the future. The number seven seed
- 1:12:58Inglourious Basterds up against the 26 seed Green Book.
- 1:13:04I never imagined myself being the type of guy to go to bat for
- 1:13:07Green Book as much as I have. Yeah, I just think the Green
- 1:13:11Book is way unfairly maligned and especially like if you go on
- 1:13:15IMDb, I'm pretty sure it has like a 8.1 or like it's a very
- 1:13:19well liked movie by the general population.
- 1:13:23Now, they also gave Fight Club like an 8.8 or something.
- 1:13:26So, you know, take that with a grain of salt, but you know,
- 1:13:28we're leading. We've been leading up to the
- 1:13:30Oscars the last few weeks. And I've seen so many lists of
- 1:13:33people that are like the worst best picture winners of all
- 1:13:36time. And they'll have Green Book in
- 1:13:38there. And I'm like, OK, maybe if your
- 1:13:41argument is like, it's the worst win in that it didn't deserve to
- 1:13:45win best picture, that's fine. Because what was the other
- 1:13:49option that year? There were a couple.
- 1:13:51Alfonso Cuaron's movie Roma was kind of like the runaway
- 1:13:54favorite to win. I just think that like there are
- 1:13:57a lot worse movies that have actually won Best Picture than
- 1:14:01than Green Book. And like Crash.
- 1:14:04Do I think that the racial politics of Green Book are kind
- 1:14:07of Pollyannish? Sure.
- 1:14:09I also think it's like a really well made movie.
- 1:14:11I think it's gorgeous to look at.
- 1:14:13The performances are good. It's a really good time at the
- 1:14:16movies. I don't I don't know what to
- 1:14:17say, man. It is going into the fiery abyss
- 1:14:20here. Yeah, obviously Inglorious
- 1:14:22Basterds, which I. Dude, this season around, I'm
- 1:14:25like holding Inglorious and Pulp Fiction side by side and I'm
- 1:14:29like, man, I, I don't know which one's better for me at this
- 1:14:33point. It's a that's a tough decision.
- 1:14:35It's an easy decision when I have Green Book next to it,
- 1:14:39which does make me a little sad. I at the end of the day, Bob
- 1:14:43Green Book is a really fun movie and I like I can't describe it
- 1:14:47any other way. It is an ultimate popcorn
- 1:14:50munching like crowd pleasing type of movie that goes into the
- 1:14:56fiery inferno with all of my well regards.
- 1:15:00Yep. And that's that's kind of where
- 1:15:01I'm leaving it as well. So that that means we have our
- 1:15:04next 4 entries into the round of 16, which actually features an
- 1:15:08upset this time Brad. So we've got 12 Angry Men,
- 1:15:12Cinderella Man, a true Cinderella story here, The Great
- 1:15:16Escape and Inglorious Basterds talk about a bunch of guy movies
- 1:15:20getting into our our Sweet 16 here.
- 1:15:23And I think we're going to continue that trend in the
- 1:15:25bottom half of the bracket here. Brad.
- 1:15:27I'm really excited about this match up 'cause I know how easy
- 1:15:29it will be for us. It's the number three overall
- 1:15:32seed Casablanca, up against the number 30 seed, The
- 1:15:37Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford.
- 1:15:41That's right. Now, Bob, I have to say I've
- 1:15:43watched The Assassination of the Jesse of Jesse James by the
- 1:15:46Coward Robert Ford at least nine times since we recorded and I've
- 1:15:51changed my tune. I think it's the greatest movie
- 1:15:54ever made. It's better than Casablanca.
- 1:15:56That's right, dude. I can't.
- 1:15:58I went back into the rewatch for that thinking, man, I hated this
- 1:16:03movie, but at least I get the train scene.
- 1:16:05Like the train scene was incredible.
- 1:16:08And then I saw it and was like, that was not that great.
- 1:16:12I did not remember that accurately.
- 1:16:14It's not as much fun as I thought it was.
- 1:16:16And then the rest of the movie happened so.
- 1:16:20Funny thing is, you were a little higher on the rest of the
- 1:16:22movie than you were the first time around.
- 1:16:24I was like, not much, yeah, but slightly more it.
- 1:16:26Kind of evened out, you know? Listen, Casablanca, if nothing
- 1:16:32else, is one of the most perfect scripts ever written.
- 1:16:36And I think just based on that, it's moving on into the round of
- 1:16:4016. I need we say more, Brad.
- 1:16:43I weird, you know how like you see, you think about buying like
- 1:16:46a Subaru and then you see Subarus everywhere.
- 1:16:50I feel like after this time we watched it, I saw the joke about
- 1:16:54I I'm shocked, shocked to find gambling in this establishment.
- 1:16:57I've seen that joke everywhere since we watched it again.
- 1:17:01So I, yeah, I don't know what's going on, but.
- 1:17:04It's like a Rosetta Stone for understanding references.
- 1:17:07Like he's just, if you haven't seen it, you're like, I can tell
- 1:17:10that this Looney Tunes cartoon is referencing something, but I
- 1:17:13don't know what. And then you see it and you're
- 1:17:15like, Oh my gosh, I I understand everything now.
- 1:17:18Yeah, Casablanca. Very easy to move on.
- 1:17:20This might be one of the easiest choices I've ever made in 10
- 1:17:25seasons worth of brackets. I mean, in fairness, I think
- 1:17:28anything versus Assassination of Jesse James was going to be
- 1:17:31moving on for you. Yeah.
- 1:17:33I mean, I will say Bob Casablanca, Great movie.
- 1:17:36Now we have 2 great movies in our next matchup.
- 1:17:39Brad, why don't you intro this one?
- 1:17:41Because this is a tough one. Kenya #14 is Lion King Shahana.
- 1:17:48The Lion King. Versus the number 19 seed 500
- 1:17:53days of summer. Is that the intro you were
- 1:17:56looking for? I love it, dude.
- 1:17:58No. All right, so here's the thing,
- 1:18:00man. I think on paper, The Lion King
- 1:18:02seems like the easy champion here because every time I watch
- 1:18:07500 Days of Summer before I watch it, I'm like, man, I can't
- 1:18:11believe that I love this movie that much.
- 1:18:12Like this seems like the kind of movie that's not going to hold
- 1:18:14up. And then I make it like halfway
- 1:18:16through and I'm like, I don't know if this is going to hold
- 1:18:18up. And then they land the plane
- 1:18:20every single time. It's just, I've watched it
- 1:18:22enough times that I have to just stamp it and say it's a great
- 1:18:26movie. 500 Days of Summer is a great movie.
- 1:18:29Absolutely. The Lion King, on the other
- 1:18:31hand, is a movie that I have always been like 9 1/2 to 10.
- 1:18:36There's like maybe 1 moment that I don't love.
- 1:18:38I don't, I don't love Timon and Pumba that they take away from
- 1:18:42the overall structure of the movie.
- 1:18:44You've always been like a step cooler on it than I have.
- 1:18:47And I think it's just because it's not Beauty and the Beast,
- 1:18:50which I know is like your favorite, the classic Disney
- 1:18:52movies. But I'm curious here, Brad,
- 1:18:55because I think you also gave The Lion King A9 or a nine and a
- 1:18:58half. So where are you falling on this
- 1:19:01one because it's a tough match up.
- 1:19:02It is a tough match up. I think Lion King is like
- 1:19:05classic Disney cinema. I think it probably is the
- 1:19:09general consensus of 90s Disney movies as like the greatest.
- 1:19:14Like I can't think of another 90s Disney film that's held in
- 1:19:18higher regard. I think at the end of the day,
- 1:19:21I'm just, it's a great movie. It's a great animated film.
- 1:19:26It has a good message about like taking responsibility for your
- 1:19:29life and the emotional moments of the film are really
- 1:19:34impactful. I think it gets way worse when
- 1:19:39you introduce Matthew Broderick and like, as soon as you do the
- 1:19:43time jump, the movie dips in quality.
- 1:19:46For me. I I think that 500 Days of
- 1:19:49Summer is stunningly good. I think that the music video
- 1:19:56scene is incredibly well choreographed and it's bright
- 1:19:59and and vivacious and there's just full of life.
- 1:20:03It, it feels like a Ferris Bueller knock off, but like in a
- 1:20:06really unique and in its own way kind of scene.
- 1:20:11I think that the expectations versus reality, that's one of
- 1:20:18the best scenes I've ever seen. It's so good.
- 1:20:20From any movie ever. Yet.
- 1:20:22So here's where I'm at, though I think I'm going to pick The Lion
- 1:20:25King because. I think.
- 1:20:27Across the board, the Lion King's like half a point better
- 1:20:30for me. I think it has the highest high
- 1:20:34in The Lion King is slightly higher than 500 days for me and
- 1:20:38I think the lowest low in 500 days is a little bit lower than
- 1:20:41than Lion King. And so I think like, as much as
- 1:20:45I love them both, I don't know that I can pick 500 days of
- 1:20:47summer. So we might be doing a coin flip
- 1:20:49here, Brad. Yeah, I, I picked 500 Days of
- 1:20:52Summer to move on. I think it it, it's not like I
- 1:20:55don't like Lion King. I just think I like 500 Days of
- 1:20:58Summer a little bit more. So I'm ready if you are, man.
- 1:21:01All right, The Lion King will be heads. 500 Days of Summer will
- 1:21:06be tails. Brad, flip that coin.
- 1:21:19Dude, I think this coin's waited.
- 1:21:23We've got another heads. We have to go We.
- 1:21:27Have to go back and listen to some old season because I don't
- 1:21:29feel like Heads has won all the time.
- 1:21:32Every time, yeah. No, no, something got messed up
- 1:21:35with that coin. Yeah.
- 1:21:36So I guess, you know, 500 days of summer, Yes, it does get
- 1:21:39thrown into the fiery abyss, but it also doesn't have to go up
- 1:21:42against Casablanca in the next round.
- 1:21:44So, you know, that'd be tough to win.
- 1:21:45It's a moral victory. All right, We've got two more
- 1:21:48match ups for the day, folks. And we're talking next about the
- 1:21:51number 11 overall seed Singing in the Rain up against the 22
- 1:21:58seed American Beauty. I don't know where to start with
- 1:22:01this, Brad. I guess I want to start with
- 1:22:02like, what the hell, my friend? Because the only reason that
- 1:22:06singing in the rain is the 11 seed is solely because of you.
- 1:22:12I don't. Know what you're talking about?
- 1:22:14What I mean, do you not experience joy in your life?
- 1:22:21Mean, do you not when the camera pushes in on Gene Kelly's face
- 1:22:24as he says, come on with the rain, I have a smile on my face.
- 1:22:28Do you not feel anything in that cold, dark heart of yours?
- 1:22:33I mean, you know, I give it an 8.5.
- 1:22:35I'm like 8.5 singing in the rain I like.
- 1:22:40Singing in the rain. It's a good movie.
- 1:22:45Explain yourself. Are you not a musical guy?
- 1:22:48Is that what we're discovering? No, I like musicals.
- 1:22:50I The musicals, yeah. But like, we've got, I mean, we
- 1:22:54have three of the best musicals ever this season and every time
- 1:22:58you've been like, not for me. Yeah, I mean, I don't know man.
- 1:23:03I I am trying to remember musicals.
- 1:23:05I remember watching growing up. I watched 7 Brides for Seven
- 1:23:09Brothers. I remember watching Guys and
- 1:23:12Dolls. Yeah, Guys and Dolls is a good
- 1:23:16one. Lucky a lady tonight, Bob, a
- 1:23:19lucky 7, if you will. I, I really love an American in
- 1:23:27Paris. I think.
- 1:23:28I think it might be what you talked about with comedies.
- 1:23:31I think musicals have a cap, have a ceiling for me that like,
- 1:23:36I love them, they're fun and they're bright and I enjoy them.
- 1:23:40I love Across the Universe like another example of a musical I
- 1:23:44saw when it came out. Really enjoy it.
- 1:23:46Lala Land. Lala land would be the one for
- 1:23:49me that like breaks through the musical ceiling and become
- 1:23:53something more than that. Overall, I I just think that
- 1:23:59these kind of have a ceiling and I'm like I said, I really like
- 1:24:03this movie. I think that Gene Kelly and
- 1:24:06who's his the sidekick, Donald O'Connor.
- 1:24:09Donald O'Connor. Incredible, great performance.
- 1:24:12Man, I think Singing in the Rain is one of those movies that
- 1:24:15like, even when I was at my like most film Bro E and was like
- 1:24:21this Singing in the Rain, you watch it and you're like, OK,
- 1:24:23like I, I have no, I have no qualms with this.
- 1:24:26It's just like it transcends every limitation the musical
- 1:24:31genre could put on because it moves so quickly.
- 1:24:33Like everything either builds to a song or a punchline.
- 1:24:37Like the the plot flows logically from scene to scene.
- 1:24:40It doesn't ever feel the only thing in the movie that feels
- 1:24:42like and then is like the ballet sequence.
- 1:24:46And that's just because Gene Kelly was trying to top American
- 1:24:49in Paris. And even then I can kind of
- 1:24:51forgive it because I think it's a better ballet sequence than
- 1:24:54than American in Paris. So like, I don't know, man.
- 1:24:57I do think that in this match up against American Beauty, which
- 1:25:00we have not talked about at all, this was a really easy one for
- 1:25:04me to move Singing in the Rain on.
- 1:25:06And I am incredibly nervous that you're going to go to bat here
- 1:25:10for Kevin Spacey of all people over Singing in the Rain.
- 1:25:13Don't. Throw me under the bus because
- 1:25:15of a legend. Noted Pervert defender Brad G
- 1:25:22continues to place Kevin Spacey Films in the second round.
- 1:25:26Listen man, American Beauty is an example of Kevin Spacey just
- 1:25:31nailing it. But he's great.
- 1:25:32It's still. It still is one of the greatest
- 1:25:34twists I've ever experienced watching a movie.
- 1:25:37I and I think the messaging about the world that they lived
- 1:25:41in in the 90s was just really well crafted and articulated.
- 1:25:48This was easy for me. I moved American Beauty on.
- 1:25:51You are an insane person, man. You are an insane person.
- 1:25:55And I swear to God, if this is the first time that the coin is
- 1:25:58not heads, I'm going to lose my mind.
- 1:26:00Dude, this is insane. What are we talking about here?
- 1:26:04Like, I, you know me, I defended American Beauty, like I defended
- 1:26:08Green Book, but I came out to like an 8 1/2 on that.
- 1:26:11We're talking about one of maybe the five most beloved films ever
- 1:26:14made since people started making movies in Singing in the Rain.
- 1:26:18And I. I gave said give me more, Lester
- 1:26:20Burnham. I listen man.
- 1:26:23I gave both movies an 8.5. I think that they're both really
- 1:26:27well made. I think American Beauty's a
- 1:26:29better movie. I hate the coin of destiny and
- 1:26:33I'm going to be real mad if something does not go my way
- 1:26:36here. So singing in the rain is going
- 1:26:37to be heads. American Beauty is tails.
- 1:26:40Brad, you have put us in another impossible situation.
- 1:26:44You've got that coin. Yeah, we are talking about
- 1:26:57another heads. Thank God.
- 1:27:01Listen, we will address the weighted coin in another
- 1:27:04episode, but I I will put up with it as long as it's flipping
- 1:27:08in my favor. I'm.
- 1:27:08Going to I'm going to do some testing once we're done with
- 1:27:12this episode and we, we might need, we might need a new coin.
- 1:27:15Like I flipped it 1000 times at 990.
- 1:27:18All right, one more match up here.
- 1:27:20This is an easy one for me, Brad, but I think both movies
- 1:27:23deserve just a little bit of conversation.
- 1:27:25It's the number six overall seed.
- 1:27:27Some like it hot up against the 27 seed.
- 1:27:31Aaron Man, Some like it Hot is one of those movies that it's
- 1:27:35like you respect it, you remember loving it, you think
- 1:27:38it's fun and great and it exists in that like fun, great
- 1:27:42category. And then you watch it again and
- 1:27:45you're like, Oh no, this is actually a perfect movie.
- 1:27:47Like I wouldn't change one jot or title of this script.
- 1:27:52One drunken Marilyn Monroe delivery.
- 1:27:55It's perfect. It's perfect, dude.
- 1:27:58Yeah. It I I think it's the greatest
- 1:28:00comedy of all time like. Yeah, I mean, I wouldn't argue
- 1:28:04with with that because the ones that I like better like the
- 1:28:07apartment it it's so dramatic, like it's it would tip into
- 1:28:11dramedy. Yes.
- 1:28:12And if we're talking about a movie that stays in that sort of
- 1:28:14like classic Shakespeare, everybody gets married at the
- 1:28:17end. You know, that's what makes it a
- 1:28:18comedy. Then like some Like it Hot is
- 1:28:22that movie dude? Yeah, including what's his
- 1:28:27something E Brown, What's his name?
- 1:28:30Joey Brown. Yeah, including Joey Brown and
- 1:28:33Jack Levin get married at the end of this.
- 1:28:37What an absolutely great film. This this was a very nearly as
- 1:28:42easy as Casablanca over the assassination of Jesse James by
- 1:28:46the Coward robber for all. Right, so that is our last entry
- 1:28:48into the round of 16. I'll go ahead and read all of
- 1:28:51the movies that are moving into our second round here, which
- 1:28:54we'll be discussing in our next episode.
- 1:28:56So from the top we've got Vertigo versus Star Wars.
- 1:29:01West Side Story will be going up against The Tree of Life, Pulp
- 1:29:05Fiction versus Amadeus, The Treasure of the Sierra Madre
- 1:29:09versus Rear Window. And then on the other side of
- 1:29:13the bracket, 12 Angry Men versus Cinderella Man, The Great Escape
- 1:29:17versus Inglourious Basterds, Casablanca versus The Lion King
- 1:29:22and Singing in the Rain against Some Like It Hot.
- 1:29:27Guess what, Brad? We watched a ton of great movies
- 1:29:29this season. What a.
- 1:29:30This is just. What a freaking blast.
- 1:29:32This is this has been incredible.
- 1:29:34I think that if you are ever stuck for like, what should we
- 1:29:37watch tonight? It's really easy to look at this
- 1:29:40list and be like, just put it in a randomizer and you're set man.
- 1:29:44You you will find a great movie to watch.
- 1:29:49Guys, thank you so much for tuning in to Part 1 of the
- 1:29:51Bracket Challenge. Thanks for listening to our
- 1:29:53Oscars recap as well. We will be back next week to
- 1:29:57breakdown the round of 16 and the round of eight in our
- 1:30:00Bracket Challenge, But we want to know what you think so far,
- 1:30:03both of our picks, and what you would pick to win your Season 10
- 1:30:08bracket. Don't forget to download your
- 1:30:09bracket at filmwhiskey.com and then you can let us know what
- 1:30:13you think on any of our social media accounts, Facebook,
- 1:30:16Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:30:21Or if you want to join the conversation, we will be talking
- 1:30:24about this bracket on our Discord server, so if you want
- 1:30:28to talk about it there, you can find a link to our Discord at
- 1:30:31the end of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:30:33We'll be back next week talking about Bracket, but until then,
- 1:30:36I'm Bob Book. I like that you call it bracket
- 1:30:39like it's a person. Not the bracket, just bracket.
- 1:30:41We'll be talking about bracket. If you ever have another kid,
- 1:30:45you need to name him Bracket Bracket Book Bracket.
- 1:30:50I'm Brad. I'm Brad G.
- 1:30:52And we'll see you next time.