Latest / Keen On America / Yes, It's Fascism: Jon Rauch on Trump and the F Word
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, my name is Andrew Keen.
- 0:03Welcome to Keen on America, the Daily Interview Show about the United States.
- 0:29Hello everybody.
- 0:30A couple of weeks ago, an article came out in the Atlantic by an old
- 0:34friend of the show, Jonathan Raush.
- 0:36Um, he announced that, "yes, it's fascism," big picture of Donald Trump.
- 0:42Uh, he announced that he believed that Donald Trump was, in many ways a fascist.
- 0:47The article has gone viral.
- 0:49Uh, I saw Jon, uh, on all sorts of shows including Andrew Sullivan, Sam
- 0:56Harris, some of the top podcasts.
- 0:59Uh, and in contrast with Sullivan and Harris, you get this podcast for
- 1:04free, so you don't have to subscribe to, uh, hear our whole conversation.
- 1:08Jon is joining us, as always, from Washington DC.
- 1:12Jon, were you surprised with the response to this article?
- 1:16Did you expect it to be as popular?
- 1:19My sense from listening both to the the Sullivan and the, uh, the
- 1:24Harris, uh, shows was that they were really pleased with this article.
- 1:30It was almost as if you were legitimizing their thinking.
- 1:35You know, Andrew Sullivan said, ex exactly that.
- 1:37Um, I thought it might get a readership.
- 1:42I I was right about that.
- 1:45I thought it would be controversial.
- 1:46I was wrong about that.
- 1:48I have yet to see a single substantial article that has argued
- 1:56with it in any substantive way.
- 1:58You know, there've been a couple of hahas on social media.
- 2:01But apparently, uh, the proposition that Donald Trump is a fascist in,
- 2:08in a very real sense, a documentable sense went almost overnight from being
- 2:13farfetched to being uncontroversial.
- 2:15Apparently.
- 2:17I actually, uh.
- 2:19Perhapsie'll be your first critic.
- 2:21I don't agree.
- 2:22Uh, maybe we can get that into that, into the conversation.
- 2:25But before we start, lay out your arguments.
- 2:28Why in your view is Trump a fascist?
- 2:34I, I was one of those people like you, Andrew, and like so
- 2:37many others who thought the term fascism should be avoided.
- 2:43Because first of all, it's been.
- 2:46Defined and misdefined and overextended and stretched beyond all recognition by
- 2:50progressives who call you a fascist if you oppose affirmative action or abortion.
- 2:56Uh, second, because I thought it was likely to pointlessly, alienate the
- 3:00people who voted for Trump, but who were not convinced he was a fascist
- 3:04and who are not themselves by any stretch of the imagination, fascists.
- 3:09And third, because I just thought there was too much about
- 3:12Trump that just didn't fit.
- 3:14Uh, I went with, in, in a book I wrote last year.
- 3:17I went with the term semi fascist, which Joe Biden actually used in a speech.
- 3:22And the reason I went with that is that I went down a list of, of
- 3:27items, characteristics that are often associated with fascism.
- 3:31And Trump met about half of them, but he didn't meet the other half.
- 3:34You know, he wasn't invading other countries, for example.
- 3:38And so I thought the term, uh, just didn't fit and the events of the
- 3:43last few weeks and months convinced me that I was wrong because he was
- 3:48ticking so many of those boxes.
- 3:50So I sat down, I made a list.
- 3:51I came up with 18 characteristics that are all frequently found in fascism.
- 3:57And all of which are inconsistent with liberal democracy and there they all were.
- 4:03And at that point I decided it's just perverse to withhold the label for
- 4:06what's what someone just seems to be.
- 4:11My biggest problem is that you seem to, if not confuse, gloss over the difference
- 4:18between fascism and authoritarianism.
- 4:21You bring up Franco, for example, who wasn't a fascist, who never
- 4:25got on well with Hitler, was very different from Mussolini.
- 4:29What for you is a fascist and how the, how, how, how would you distinguish a
- 4:33fascist from a traditional authoritarian like Franco and so many other.
- 4:40Political leaders in in human history?
- 4:42Well, or, or for that matter.
- 4:44From a Patrimonial list, which I think,
- 4:46right.
- 4:47And, and we've done shows on Patrimonial.
- 4:49The book on Paton was authored by our friends, uh, Steve Hanson.
- 4:53Jeff Cote has also been on the show.
- 4:56Yes.
- 4:56And who are correct about that.
- 4:58I think Trump's being a patrimonial list is literally uncontroversial.
- 5:02He just clearly is one.
- 5:04Fascism is, well, I'm.
- 5:06I should say I am not a leading scholar on this subject, but
- 5:10fascism is not a well-defined idea.
- 5:12It was incoherent from the start.
- 5:15People who called themselves fascists were very different.
- 5:17Hitler, Mussolini, very different.
- 5:20Hitler wound up having contempt for Mussolini.
- 5:22My understanding is that Franco did define self-defined as a fascist.
- 5:27I think Orwell certainly thought of him that way.
- 5:29Um, I think Imperial Japan was probably a form of fascism, but.
- 5:33But I don't wanna, you know, my, my goal is not to get hung
- 5:37up on particular taxonomies of the early to mid 20th century.
- 5:42What I tried to do is look at characteristics, which we associated
- 5:46with the particular form of authoritarianism that we identify
- 5:49with fascists, for instance.
- 5:52The philosophy, the political theory of Carl Schmidt, for example, the
- 5:56idea that we, in a, in a society, we don't have political adversaries, we
- 6:02have enemies, and you've gotta crush them, which we saw emerge under Trump.
- 6:09Um.
- 6:10The, uh, territorial ambitions which we saw emerge under Trump, the
- 6:15explicit embrace of might is right.
- 6:18The kind of, uh, nihilistic, fascistic idea that if you're strong,
- 6:23you do what you get away with and the weak suffer what they must.
- 6:26So all of these, it seemed to me, and, and, and others on the
- 6:30list give a sense of ideological directionality to this administration,
- 6:37which I had not seen before.
- 6:41You mentioned Orwell.
- 6:42You bring him up in the book, and Sullivan is a big fan of Orwell.
- 6:47He wrote, of course, his famous essay politics in the English language
- 6:50and the English language in which he argued the word fascism and he,
- 6:55I think he was writing this in 1946.
- 6:58I think the word fascism has now no meaning except insofar
- 7:03as it signifies something.
- 7:05Not desirable.
- 7:06You talked about that, Jon, and obviously, um, that's still true, but
- 7:12shouldn't we be situ? I mean, the word fascist was invented by Mussolini.
- 7:15It came out of a specific moment in European and world history.
- 7:20It came after the first World War, and if you turn it into this generic term,
- 7:26it loses any kind of real meaning.
- 7:31I'd agree with that if I were using it as a generic term, but I think I'm using
- 7:35it in reference to 18 specific items which align with what I think a lot of
- 7:42people today would identify as fascism.
- 7:45You know, the dual state which we saw under Nazim, I already mentioned.
- 7:50Schmidt, um, I mentioned the idea that might is right and the,
- 7:53the strong take what they like.
- 7:55Uh, um, we could go through this list.
- 7:58Sam Harris did well,
- 7:59although, again, the point is, I, I'm a bit kind of nitpicky, but the
- 8:03idea of might is right, is certainly not just, uh, an idea of, of fascism.
- 8:10I mean, you, you can go right back to the beginnings of.
- 8:14Western philosophy on politics and power to find that.
- 8:17I mean, even Machiavelli suggests that sometimes, certainly, uh, Plato covers it.
- 8:23He, and, and, and the word fascism didn't exist in, in antiquity.
- 8:28So, uh, but coming back, Jon, too.
- 8:32I mean, for me, the most interesting thing about this, and it's a wonderful piece.
- 8:37I mean, I think everyone watching listening should read it.
- 8:39It's extremely coherent and in some ways convincing.
- 8:45Um, for me, the interesting thing about Trump is what makes
- 8:49him different from fascist.
- 8:51Hmm.
- 8:52Although.
- 8:53I agree with you that some of the, the features that you describe him
- 8:57as, uh, makes him like, I guess a, a post, uh, an an interwar fascist.
- 9:05But the two things that come to mind that make him unlike a
- 9:09fascist or make this moment unlike fascism in America is firstly.
- 9:14The fact that fascism came out of this catastrophe of the first World War.
- 9:18And secondly, it was a, a movement of young people and Mussolini
- 9:24Hitler were young political leaders.
- 9:25The thing that seems to me about Trump is he is an old man, and, and this
- 9:30is in some ways is a cratic movement.
- 9:34How does the generational element play in here?
- 9:38Can old people be fascists?
- 9:42I suppose they can, I, we, we may differ in that.
- 9:48I am not all that interested in asking the question, how much does what Trump
- 9:57is doing resemble the particular forms of fascism that we saw in the 1930s.
- 10:01'cause I don't think it has to.
- 10:03The question I'm interested in asking is if you invent.
- 10:09Uh, if you, if you take the core ideas of those regimes, the things that they
- 10:13tended to have in common, you know, the dehumanization of the opponents,
- 10:16the military adventurism, uh, and so forth, the things we're discussing
- 10:22and you apply them in the 21st century in America, what would it look like?
- 10:26And I think it looks something like this.
- 10:28Uh, yeah.
- 10:29Trump is old.
- 10:30He's been saying the things he's been saying For a long time
- 10:33I was on someone else's show.
- 10:35And he read a quote, which I hadn't seen, which I would've used if I
- 10:38had, it's from 1990 and it's Trump in an interview saying that the
- 10:44problem with Gorbachev, I'm loosely paraphrasing, but this is the right idea.
- 10:48The, the problem with Gorbachev is that he wasn't tough enough and
- 10:51that Trump admired the Chinese for cracking down in Gentleman Square.
- 10:56That's how you do it.
- 10:57So he's been like this a long time.
- 10:59Um, I would point out that the people around him are
- 11:02not as old as he is JD Vance.
- 11:05Stephen Miller, uh, Russell V and others in that group, many of whom are the
- 11:11ones who are actually building this out into something more like an ideology.
- 11:16Yeah, I think the best, the best example of a fascist in the administration
- 11:20is, is, is probably Miller.
- 11:21I'm not sure about, uh, vo.
- 11:24Um, but coming back to this I issue of,
- 11:26yeah,
- 11:26I would say vote is not probably an ideological
- 11:29fascist,
- 11:29but he
- 11:29adopts this back to this, this idea of a gerontocracy, uh, Samuel Moyne, as I said.
- 11:34Coming out with a book about it.
- 11:37Can old people be fascist?
- 11:40Uh, Jon, I mean, the whole idea of fascism is a, a dynamic rejection of modernity,
- 11:46a love of speed, almost a, a, a very ambivalent attitude towards technology.
- 11:53Should
- 11:53we be?
- 11:54I guess I'd have to say since we're seeing those things from
- 11:56our president, we saw them in big, bold letters in Doge, for example.
- 12:01Um, in the revolutionary language that they've employed that, that
- 12:04Russell VO has employed, um, and that, uh, Chris Ruffo has employed.
- 12:09I, I guess I have to see apparently old people can be fascists
- 12:14because that's what they're doing.
- 12:16You talk about blood and soil nationalism, again, I, I mean, it goes without saying.
- 12:21I'm, I'm not a. Supporter of Trump, but I wonder whether a, a, a high profile, uh,
- 12:29invasion a day invasion of, of Venezuela.
- 12:35Conforms to the kind of fascist militarism that Mussolini or
- 12:41Hitler, uh, were responsible for.
- 12:44I mean, Trump's foreign policy, his theatricality over Greenland, this
- 12:50odd chapter over Venezuela, it doesn't strike me as blood and soil nationalism.
- 13:00This is one of the factors that tipped me over into applying the term, and
- 13:09it is certainly not the first time by a long shot that the United States
- 13:15has thrown its weight around in the Western Hemisphere or anywhere else.
- 13:18You know, uh, Woodrow Wilson had Poncho Villa, uh, chase,
- 13:21poncho Villa, all over Mexico.
- 13:24Um, among many other examples, what's different?
- 13:28The reason that this got my attention was Trump said, Venezuela, we want the oil.
- 13:38We're getting the oil.
- 13:40Rubio comes out, secretary of State, and says, no, there are a bunch
- 13:44of other reasons why we did this.
- 13:46You know, we're interested in human rights and Iran has a foothold
- 13:49down there, and this regime is supporting Cuba and so forth.
- 13:52And Trump comes out and says, no, no, we want the oil.
- 13:56They're gonna play ball.
- 13:56We'll get the oil.
- 13:58Greenland, they have land.
- 14:01We want the land.
- 14:02We're gonna threaten them to take the land.
- 14:04He didn't.
- 14:05In the end, this is not the way Americans have talked in the fast, but it is
- 14:13characteristic of fascist regimes.
- 14:15They tend to be ideological, aggressive and in their early stages, revolutionary.
- 14:21So.
- 14:23When I saw that, when I saw of course Minneapolis, when I saw Steven
- 14:27Miller's statement that, uh, force power is the iron law of the world,
- 14:34when I saw his statement saying that of progressives, you are nothing, uh,
- 14:41I couldn't turn a blind eye to that.
- 14:45But Jon, the, this foreign adventurism that you describe was a feature of
- 14:5219th, certainly 19th century America.
- 14:54As you, as you, as you say, certainly of the colonial states of 19th century
- 15:00Europe, does any state that seeks any kind of adventurism overseas, is it fascist?
- 15:10I know I keep on coming back to the F word.
- 15:13I'm not denying that Trump is guilty of some of the things that you
- 15:18talk about, but it's not fascist.
- 15:20It's just the way authoritarian states behave.
- 15:24And sometimes democratic states, I mean, Britain, America, were semi
- 15:30democracies in the 19th century.
- 15:32There are authoritarian states that do not engage in um, um.
- 15:41What's the word for when you call someone an animal?
- 15:44In that kind of of rhetoric, there are authoritarian states that do
- 15:49not explicitly use coercion to take things from other countries.
- 15:54There are authoritarian states that do not explicitly say.
- 15:58The rule of the strong, that the rule of force is the iron law.
- 16:03Um, many authoritarian states do, of course have, um, national paramilitary
- 16:10police forces, and many authoritarian, you know, it's one could get tied
- 16:14up in watts, knots all day debating.
- 16:17Is this authoritarianism?
- 16:19Is it fascist?
- 16:19Is it patrimonial is my method Here is, I think it's a constellation.
- 16:26There's no textbook, yes, no bright line definition of fascism.
- 16:30'cause fascism itself is incoherent.
- 16:33But what you can do is recognize a whole constellation of characteristics.
- 16:38And if you see them all, that's when I'm willing to pull the trigger.
- 16:43Now, others may not be, but as I said, this surprise is.
- 16:47I've seen very little pushback and I think what we saw in Minnesota.
- 16:52Tell me what you think, Andrew.
- 16:55I don't get the impression that this administration is embarrassed
- 17:00about being identified as fascistic.
- 17:03They're not going to use the term themselves for obvious reasons,
- 17:08but I think they made very obvious.
- 17:11In Minneapolis and in Stephen Miller's statement and in threatening an ally
- 17:16to try to get its land and so on.
- 17:18I don't think they're disguising who they are.
- 17:21I think they want us to know that, and I think the people who are
- 17:25actually squeamish about applying the term fascist are not on their side.
- 17:30They're on our side, and that's what I'd hope to change.
- 17:34I mean, I, I, I don't necessarily disagree with you about Miller,
- 17:38but again, I mean, he's just one figure in this administration.
- 17:41You, in the essay you talk about mobs and street thugs, uh, you talk about,
- 17:48um, Trump's language, uh, in, uh.
- 17:56On January 6th, and of course there's lots of parallels with, um, with Minnesota.
- 18:03Uh, you refer to Hitler's Kris program of 1938.
- 18:09And again, I'm not justifying Jon, what I. Trump and his allies got up
- 18:14to in Minnesota or on January 6th, but when you compare Kristol Knight
- 18:19where 30,000 Jewish men were arrested, the 1400 synagogues were burnt down.
- 18:26Aren't you doing, in a sense, an injustice to history by comparing this.
- 18:34Rather haphazard authoritarianism on the part of the Trump
- 18:39administration with what the Nazis got up to, uh, on Crystal Knight?
- 18:44Yes.
- 18:44If I were saying that I, I would be wrong.
- 18:47Um, a a point I make in the article and perhaps should have emphasized
- 18:51even more by putting it at, at the top instead of the bottom, is that when
- 18:58I say that Trump is a fascist leader.
- 19:03Or even that he's running in practice of fascist presidential administration.
- 19:10I am not saying that America has a fascist government or is a fascist
- 19:17country, and that is very different from Mussolini or Hitler who moved quickly and
- 19:23decisively to seize all levers of power.
- 19:27Um, that is not the case in America.
- 19:30Trump does not control the courts.
- 19:32He may defy them.
- 19:34Uh, he's already playing games with them, but he can't control them.
- 19:37That's become clear.
- 19:38He can't control the media.
- 19:40He's trying very hard.
- 19:41That's an important thing on this list.
- 19:42He's following the whole Orban playbook.
- 19:45He can't control the states.
- 19:47There's sovereign authorities under the Constitution, and he clearly can't control
- 19:52public opinion because it is tanking.
- 19:56Uh, for all those reasons, I think that he is already failing and will
- 20:01fail to turn America into a fascist country with a fascist government.
- 20:08So the point of my article is to alert us to who he is and what
- 20:12he's trying to do in hopes of being better prepared to prevent it.
- 20:17But yes, I think you will fail.
- 20:21You use a term, I think later in the essay, uh, you talk about American
- 20:26fascism, and I think that's a good term.
- 20:28I think that's a more helpful term than just the word fascism.
- 20:32I'm not convinced that that's, uh, the right way of going.
- 20:37What is it about America that.
- 20:42Lends itself to perhaps this 21st century version of fascism.
- 20:47You and I have talked in the past, you're a critic of postmodernism.
- 20:51Is there a, a, a a fascist postmodernism that Trump seems to be peddling here?
- 20:59Yeah.
- 20:59Well that's, that's an interesting.
- 21:02Interesting question.
- 21:03Yeah.
- 21:03I wrote an article last year about the rise of the postmodern.
- 21:07Right.
- 21:07We talked about that on the show.
- 21:09Some people call it the woke.
- 21:10Right.
- 21:10But, but I think neither, we both agreed.
- 21:12We don't really like that term.
- 21:15And the postmodern has more to do with it.
- 21:17And this is kind of their nihilistic attitude toward truth and their
- 21:20deliberate trolling, their use of, of insults and cynicism.
- 21:24Uh, the kind of, uh, nothing LOL, nothing matters mentality that they use to, um.
- 21:30Uh, to goad and neutralize their critics and so on.
- 21:35And we see, I guess, some elements of that in 1930s style fascism.
- 21:42You know, Hitler said somewhere in Amp, uh, it doesn't matter if they mock us
- 21:49or laugh at us, all that matters is that they can't stop thinking about us.
- 21:54But yeah, you've got in, you've got instrumentalities of the internet now.
- 21:59Um, which of course you hadn't seen before.
- 22:03Um, and you've got in the figure of Trump, you know, we call him an old
- 22:08man and obviously he is, but he's so savvy about the use of media to
- 22:14constantly dominate the dialogue so that we're always thinking about him.
- 22:20Um, we can't get him out of our mind.
- 22:21One of the reasons I thought that it's useful.
- 22:26To put him in a box and call it fascism, is that it's so hard to keep track of
- 22:31all the things he's doing that doesn't forget today what he did yesterday,
- 22:35doesn't then that makes it chaotic or postmodern or some sort of new
- 22:41ontology or new way of doing things.
- 22:43Obviously it's bound out with the digital revolution, but there's
- 22:45nothing fascist about that.
- 22:47Well, I think the term fascism, which is I think what we're,
- 22:51what we're arguing about, um.
- 22:54The term fascism first helps people understand the larger picture of what
- 22:59he's doing, and second, to some extent, I think it will have predictive power.
- 23:03What, what his administration has been doing in Minneapolis is not something you
- 23:10do if you're interested in improving your popularity ratings in a democracy, I mean.
- 23:18We see that because their popularity is tanking for that very reason they're
- 23:22even losing Republicans over it.
- 23:25Talking the way Stephen Miller talked at Charlie Kirk's memorial service.
- 23:30Saying of in in, in the same place where Charlie Kirk's widow forgave
- 23:38the assassin, an extraordinary act of Christian forgiveness.
- 23:42Trump got up there and said, I hate my enemies.
- 23:44And Stephen Miller said of.
- 23:46Left that whole half of the country, you are nothing.
- 23:51You are wickedness.
- 23:53You don't do that to expand your coalition and win votes.
- 23:57And I think the explanation for the reason they're doing these things
- 24:00is that they look at the world the way fascists do, which is an all or
- 24:04nothing battle between good and evil.
- 24:07In which you are the side of a revolutionary force that's
- 24:11going to purify society.
- 24:14Get rid of the bad insiders, the traitors who are trying to undermine
- 24:19it, consolidate power, vilify, and dehumanize your opponents.
- 24:26You mentioned in.
- 24:29Your argument, one of the 18, uh, arguments you make is alternative facts.
- 24:34You've written extensively about it.
- 24:35You even have a book, the Constitution of Knowledge, which is an excellent,
- 24:40uh, an an excellent analysis of this alternative facts, uh, um,
- 24:45reality, if that's the right word.
- 24:47You quote Orwell and a rent.
- 24:50But a rent wrote a book, not about fascism, but about totalitarianism in
- 24:55which she covered both the communists or the Stalinists at least, and the
- 25:00Nazis might, again, I know I'm might be being a little pedantic here or.
- 25:07Medieval in distinguishing these words, but might totalitarian be a better
- 25:12word, a rents word than fascist, which Orwell didn't like and a rent was
- 25:18ambivalent about, even though she herself was a refugee from Fascist German.
- 25:23Yes.
- 25:24Well, you know, fascism, as we've said, is such a poorly defined term that
- 25:27it's, its hard for anyone to talk about.
- 25:29You're the
- 25:30one who, who, who has this.
- 25:31Essay called, yes, it's fascism.
- 25:33So,
- 25:34yes, that's right.
- 25:35And then the way I go about that is not a crisp one sentence definition,
- 25:38it's a whole bunch of attributes, but I acknowledge it's fuzzy.
- 25:42Um, so yes, you ask a, a, a, a smart question.
- 25:47Um, why not totalitarianism?
- 25:49And I think it's for the very reason I just totalitarians.
- 25:55Take control of the entire society, or at least they try to and
- 25:59they succeed from top to bottom.
- 26:00I think maybe Trump, this is something I don't think I would've
- 26:03said a year ago when we were talking about Patrimonial Andrew.
- 26:07I think back then I would've said, Trump does not have those kinds of ambitions.
- 26:10I would've said he's, you know, he wants to get rich.
- 26:13He wants his family to get rich.
- 26:14He wants to show he can dominate the government and be the godfather, and
- 26:18those things are all true, but I. I think he would've said that he is not
- 26:23someone who wants to, for example, dominate our cultural institutions.
- 26:29Um, well, I've, I've had to have even some second thoughts about that.
- 26:33You know, one, his name is going up on the Kennedy Center, for example,
- 26:37and when he wants to build a triumphal arch, uh, larger than anything except
- 26:42I guess the Washington Monument, you know, you could laugh at these things
- 26:46and say he's just a vain old man.
- 26:49These do start to have some of those overtones.
- 26:52I think, as I said, he will fail.
- 26:54He will not be able to take over the levers, all the levers of power
- 26:57in our society, and thus history will say he was not a totalitarian,
- 27:01whatever he might have wanted to be.
- 27:06There's another argument, another way of looking at it that suggests that all this.
- 27:10Quote, unquote fascism or this, uh, absurd language is a, an attempt by Trump
- 27:18and his people to change the subject.
- 27:20He always seems to be at his most absurd during a political crisis.
- 27:24That was an excellent piece.
- 27:25I'm not sure if you saw it in the Wall Street Journal Over the weekend,
- 27:29one generation runs the country.
- 27:31The ne the next cashed in on crypto.
- 27:34It's by, uh, two Wall Street Journal reporters.
- 27:38Uh, Angus Barrick and, and Elliot Brown.
- 27:41I actually wanna get them on the show, which explains how much money,
- 27:46uh, the Trump inner circle, the families of Trump and some of his
- 27:51associates have made out of crypto.
- 27:53Could one make the argument, Jon?
- 27:55Maybe a Marxist would make the argument, or certainly someone
- 27:59who focused on economics.
- 28:02Uh, that all this quote unquote fascism was just a smoke
- 28:06screen to loot the country.
- 28:09Well, he's, he's, he's certainly doing a pretty good job of, uh,
- 28:14of gathering, gathering the loot,
- 28:16a a and the loot.
- 28:17Andy is so much more meaningful for him as this real estate guy
- 28:21with an obsession with wealth.
- 28:23Than, than any, you know,
- 28:24that's, that's the very thing that I've come to question Andrew.
- 28:27I was there six months ago, I thought, you know, he'll, he'll make himself and
- 28:31his family rich and he'll be incompetent and corrupt and, and then we'll pro
- 28:35and he'll, he'll stack some important institutions and some people will die of
- 28:39measles, but then we'll be done with them.
- 28:41And as I said, what's forced him, what's forced me to question that is
- 28:45the number of things he's, he's done and that his administration have done,
- 28:50which don't make sense if you just want to be, you know, a standard sort
- 28:55of looting, crooked politician because they make him so much less popular.
- 28:59The things you do if you're an ideolog.
- 29:02And if what you're doing is you think you've got four years or maybe only
- 29:05two years, if you think the house might flip in, which you need to do
- 29:09as much as you possibly can to alter this social contract in America so
- 29:14that this becomes a country where US citizens get pumped full of bullets
- 29:20on the street while they're lying face down and have been disarmed and there's.
- 29:27No investigation and the government denied it happened.
- 29:30I'm exaggerating slightly.
- 29:31They now say they'll investigate, but, but they, they're not doing that to become
- 29:36popular from which I reason they must be doing it because they think that's
- 29:41how the social contract should work.
- 29:45They have a degree of popularity.
- 29:47You, you note in the piece.
- 29:48I think this is.
- 29:49Quite right that you point out that there are differences between Trumpism
- 29:53and MAGA and classical European fascism.
- 29:57Uh, you note that mass rall and public rituals, for example,
- 30:01don't exist in in the Trump page.
- 30:04What's replacing them, uh, the Internets hyper-masculinity, misogyny and co-option
- 30:12of Christianity, which are quite fascist.
- 30:14What, where do we see the replacement?
- 30:17And I'm curious, I dunno the answer to this, um, because, uh, um,
- 30:23mass rallies and public rituals were central to both Mussolini
- 30:28and Hitler's versions of fascism.
- 30:31Is this on the internet?
- 30:33I would guess it is.
- 30:35Yeah.
- 30:36I, I would guess that the Internet's now a much cheaper and faster way to do that.
- 30:41You know, Trump did try to stage a military parade, and I think
- 30:47he probably imagined himself at the top of a grandstand with,
- 30:51with, um, people marching by and saluting him instead of what he got.
- 30:56But I take your, I take your main point and my guess it's just a guess.
- 31:02That's really all it is.
- 31:03It's a conjecture, is that social media is just a much better way
- 31:07to, to build your audience, to feed the message to the audience, to
- 31:11demand solidarity from the audience.
- 31:14You can do all those things online quickly and cheaply.
- 31:16He's, he's a master at that, however old he may be.
- 31:20Um, I don't know about very stable.
- 31:23He said he is a very stable genius.
- 31:25I don't know about stable, but, but he's, he's some kind of genius, isn't he?
- 31:29When it comes to the use of those media?
- 31:33Marks famously wrote in his, and I think it was in in response to the the
- 31:39Paris Commune, that history repeats itself twice first as tragedy, then as
- 31:43fast, and that seems to be something that somehow captures Trump in terms
- 31:49of fascism, if indeed you are right.
- 31:52I mean, the first version of fascism was.
- 31:56Truly tragic in the terrible death and suffering that the
- 31:59Nazis brought to the world.
- 32:02Uh, but there is something farcical about Trump, if you're
- 32:07right, that he is a fascist.
- 32:08It's a farcical fascism.
- 32:11And in that essay, um, by Marx.
- 32:16He writes about Napoleon ii, trying to be the uncle, trying
- 32:21to be Napoleon Bonaparte.
- 32:23Um, so this seems to be something just ludicrous about this attempt, if you are
- 32:29right to reinvent or reproduce fascism.
- 32:34You mean because Trump himself is so disorganized and, and
- 32:39strange because he's so uncon.
- 32:40I, I mean, maybe you're right.
- 32:41Maybe in his heart if he has a heart, he's a fascist, maybe
- 32:45believes some of the things he says.
- 32:47But as you note, he's been.
- 32:49A failure.
- 32:50You, you, you correctly say in, in your essay that, uh, whilst
- 32:54he might be a fascist president, America isn't a fascist country.
- 32:57And if anything, I think it's less of a fascist country in February,
- 33:012026 than it was in January, 2025.
- 33:04So this is a, a farcical chapter in American history, Jon, isn't it?
- 33:12I don't know yet.
- 33:13I see this period as, um, I don't know if you remember high school physics
- 33:19and the idea of potential energy, and they'd show you a diagram of a ball.
- 33:24A, we didn't
- 33:24study science in England,
- 33:28they show you physics.
- 33:30A picture of, of a ball balanced on top of a hill or a sombrero shaped
- 33:34curve and the potential energy is it, it could, it could fall quickly.
- 33:41In either of two directions and you can't tell which one it might fall in.
- 33:44Maybe one difference between us, Andrew, is that however wacky Trump can seem,
- 33:53there is potential here to do very long-term damage to our institutions.
- 33:59Just to take one example, the, uh, new form of ice that this has taken.
- 34:07This is, this is now in law.
- 34:10This is an agency that has already more than doubled its size and will increase it
- 34:14further, is already, I believe, the 15th largest military force in the world that
- 34:19is not accountable as traditional police are to ordinary limits of jurisdiction
- 34:25that has been told that it has impunity.
- 34:28This organization will be probably around for a long time to come, and those people
- 34:33now who are being trained and recruited to run it will be around for a long time.
- 34:37I talked to a person who used to work in the Homeland Security Department
- 34:41for trumpet in, in the first term, and she's worried sick about this because
- 34:47she said, this is going to be a problem for presidents for some time to come.
- 34:51You can't disband it, but what do you do with it?
- 34:55So the answer is, um, I have reluctantly come to take.
- 34:59What's happening now is, is very serious.
- 35:01If you, if you push me to the wall, I'm gonna say at the end of the day, we'll
- 35:05still be a liberal democracy in 2029.
- 35:08And someone like JD Vance or even Tucker Carlson probably cannot carry
- 35:14on the way Trump has carried on.
- 35:17But I'm not, I'm no longer.
- 35:19All that confident in, in my prediction.
- 35:23Let's end by going back to history.
- 35:26As I said, for me, fascism, I mean obviously it's a, a tragic period
- 35:31and all the rest of it, um, but it.
- 35:34It speaks about a moment in history after the first World War and a
- 35:39fundamental crisis of capitalism.
- 35:42How are we gonna remember this period?
- 35:44You talked a little bit about Orban.
- 35:46We see the appearance of one kind of Trumpism or MAGA style
- 35:50nationalism elsewhere in the world from Russia, perhaps even
- 35:54China, Hungary, Italy, and so on.
- 35:57How are we going to remember this period, Jon, in terms of its triggers?
- 36:02Are we gonna remember it as a crisis of capitalism, a crisis of technology?
- 36:06We don't have the first World war.
- 36:09So what is the great trauma of the 2020s that has generated this?
- 36:15Well, we were chatting before we started the program that that's
- 36:21such a big important subject.
- 36:22Maybe the subject of, of my next book, we are, we're in this age.
- 36:26You can explain it better than I, because you understand the technology.
- 36:29I'm convinced this is Frank Fukuyama, many other people.
- 36:32A lot of what we're seeing is.
- 36:34Is driven by technological changes that have reduced people's faith in
- 36:39institution and, and increased, you know, used algorithms to, to excite them.
- 36:44We're seeing a global backsliding, not just in the US so we
- 36:48know it can't just be Trump.
- 36:49We're seeing global backsliding from liberal democracy.
- 36:52We're seeing electorates, which all over the world.
- 36:54Again, this isn't the US alone.
- 36:56It's not just Trump that are in a state of constant rebellion.
- 37:03Against whoever's in office, they seem to be almost impossible to please.
- 37:07Um, this, this is a period that I have never lived anything through a period when
- 37:15so many people, in so many places were so unhappy with the governments that were in
- 37:22power and were willing to turn to so many alternatives that you and I think probably
- 37:28would've said, would not have been viable.
- 37:30Even 10 or 15 years ago, and I can't explain that.
- 37:34Um, and not all of it by any means is fascism.
- 37:37I'm certainly, certainly not making that claim.
- 37:40It's everything from higher prices to global mass migration
- 37:44to the decline of Christianity.
- 37:45The subject of my last book, a lot of stuff is going on there in this article.
- 37:50I just wanna say something simple, which is if you look at the stuff Trump is doing
- 37:56and you put it together in a big box.
- 38:00You either need to call it fascism or you need to invent a new word
- 38:05with more or less the same meaning.
- 38:09Yeah, I agree with that Final statement.
- 38:11We need to invent a new word with more or less, but I would say it's
- 38:14the less rather than the more.
- 38:17Let's end up with Orwell who, who understood this as much as anyone,
- 38:21and as I said, his wonderful I essay politics in the English language, uh,
- 38:26suggested that when you have problems with language, you have problems with
- 38:29politics, and they go intimately together.
- 38:31What is writing this and the response Jon taught you about the relationship between.
- 38:39Language, our languaging, the English language, or that could
- 38:43be any language in politics.
- 38:49It taught me.
- 38:52Maybe this isn't a direct answer.
- 38:54We'll see what comes outta my mouth.
- 38:55I, one of the things that I picked up from Orwell, including
- 39:02the S essay you mentioned, is the importance of naming things.
- 39:06Orwell is someone who does not want us to euphemized.
- 39:12Is that a word?
- 39:14Yeah.
- 39:14Well, we know what you mean.
- 39:15Create euphemisms.
- 39:16Yes.
- 39:17He says the hardest thing.
- 39:19I paraphrase again, you'll know the quote.
- 39:21The hardest thing to see is often what's in front of one's nose and.
- 39:28This was an effort to name what I thought and think is in front of our nose.
- 39:36That's the whole exercise.
- 39:39Um, and I guess I'm not sure if that's responsive to the specific question
- 39:46you asked, but it's how I think about what I'm trying at least to do here.
- 39:52So what we're trying to do is put words to describe what's in front of our nose,
- 39:57although we're not always sure, but Jon Roush is always ahead of everybody else.
- 40:01His new essay in the Atlantic is a essential reading.
- 40:04Yes, it's fascism.
- 40:06Brave man.
- 40:06I'm not sure I entirely agree, but I agree in part, I'm not sure he entirely
- 40:11agrees, but he certainly agrees in part.
- 40:13Jon, as always, pleasure, honor, keep your important work.
- 40:17You are.
- 40:18One of the loyal members of the Opposition, and we go where you go.
- 40:22Thank you so much
- 40:24and a loyal member of your audience.
- 40:29Hi, this is Andrew again.
- 40:30Thank you so much for listening or watching the show.
- 40:34Uh, if you enjoyed it, please subscribe.
- 40:36We're on Substack, YouTube, apple, Spotify, all the platforms.
- 40:41Uh, and I'd be very curious as to your comments as well on what you think of
- 40:46the show, how it can be improved, and the kinds of guests that you would
- 40:51enjoy hearing or listening to in future.
- 40:54Thank you again.