Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 135 - Jody Underwood: Homesteading, Microschooling & Living Off-Grid
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:13My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 135 of the Free Cities podcast. This episode is brought
- 0:38to you as always by our most excellent sponsor Veritas Village. They're building an off-grid
- 0:44village for freedom lovers like yourself in Panama amongst other places. Energy self-sufficient
- 0:50luxury homes all in the process of being built right now and you can own a portion of that if
- 0:56you choose to. They're all close to the beaches and amenities but in a slightly elevated location
- 1:03so there is a perfect climate for growing your own food. Every home comes with its own solar
- 1:10system included. You can also get wind because energy independence is one of their goals paired
- 1:18with a modern luxury lifestyle. Get in touch with them and go and see the project to take a look at
- 1:24the house is currently being built if you'd like to know more about their ethos as well click on
- 1:29this link www.ecovillages.life forward slash free cities for more info there's also an interview
- 1:37there I did with Patrick their founder at last year's free cities conference and that will give
- 1:42you a sense of who they are and whether you would like to do business with them right today's show
- 1:48I am back in New Hampshire and I'm also back at the Underwoods off-grid homestead.
- 1:57You may well have heard me speaking to former NASA planetary scientist and author Ian Underwood
- 2:05in episode 129. Very interesting one that. Check it out if you've missed it. This week I'm talking
- 2:12with his equally fascinating wife Jodie. Now Jodie runs an education non-profit so it was
- 2:20inevitable that we ended up talking about education and in particular Jodie's speciality
- 2:25homeschooling in all its myriad contemporary forms and I learned a new word this week.
- 2:33Micro schools if you don't know what those are listen on and you can add that to unschooling
- 2:40self-directed education, classical charter school education, co-ops, learn everywhere,
- 2:47lots of new ways to homeschool your children. In this conversation we also talk about the reality
- 2:52of off-grid living and community life in New Hampshire amongst liberty-minded folk. Now that
- 3:00also includes local government educational politics and Jodie's fascinating story about
- 3:07the time that a local town meeting was convinced to back a motion that slashed the yearly education
- 3:14budget in half basically because tax is theft why not and when I say in half that's a 1.7 million
- 3:22dollar budget getting slashed to 800 000 dollars what ensued was quite chaotic and it ended up
- 3:31with the former budget being reinstated on a very small technicality.
- 3:37But what it does do is it gives you a fascinating insight into the incentive models,
- 3:42which influence state school programs.
- 3:46Jody's not a fan, as you can imagine.
- 3:48Anyway, many thanks to Jody and Ian for hosting me on their awesome homestead.
- 3:53Hope to see you both again soon.
- 3:56Sometime, right, Noster and Strategic Bitcoin Reserve.
- 3:59and this week I've got a pre-announcement of an announcement if you like those kind of things
- 4:07things are happening over at Fountain and the Free Cities podcast going forward will be migrating
- 4:14all of our content over to their brand new hosting program which opens up a ton of new features
- 4:22potentially including subscriptions amongst other things and bonus episodes etc etc now
- 4:29I'm not exactly sure how I'm going to play this moving forward.
- 4:33As you know, I've been a fan of Fountain since the start, but especially since their NOSTA integration.
- 4:41So I'm happy to partner with the project.
- 4:43I just need to work out how to configure the new system.
- 4:48Any suggestions? Obviously greatly received.
- 4:51send me a message on NOSTA or you can do the old-fashioned way email podcast at free-cities.org
- 5:00next week I'll actually be publishing a huge three and a half hour interview with the extremely
- 5:06popular guest Ben Gunn so I had a thought that I might actually try splitting that episode in half
- 5:15and then offer the second part as a bonus episode for the first week so people can get early access
- 5:25to it just as an experiment I mean I really would like to see this project funded by listeners
- 5:32and that's not easy however fountains currently I think the best option I have for that anyway
- 5:40it's a work in progress so please bear with me but I think already and I'm looking at it now you
- 5:48can actually subscribe to this podcast via a button on fountain now so please do that if you're
- 5:55a regular listener and you can just make a small donation each month to help run the show and that
- 6:03will be greatly appreciated many thanks okay right strategic bitcoin reserve thanks for the sats
- 6:11goes to justin dovidas and on and on user 67 bc bob justin bianchi the other justin says i'm
- 6:24strongly considering a move to connecticut why aren't all bitcoin as a part of the free state
- 6:30project good question i don't know i suppose you need to live in america but also connecticut is not
- 6:37new hampshire right no it's it's just below but i suppose the nearer you are to new hampshire the
- 6:43better if you're a libertarian that would be my advice anyway 67 bc says talking also about the
- 6:50free state project is this a bitcoin a project uh no it's not but quite a few of the very early
- 6:58adopters of Bitcoin in the States were an R3 status at least that was my experience traveling
- 7:04around New Hampshire is I met a ton of Bitcoiners and a lot of them were extreme OGs 2013 and and
- 7:14and beyond so no it's not a Bitcoiner project yes it has a lot of Bitcoiners in it right
- 7:21oh a lot of people also looking forward to the chat i've just had with ben gunn starting next
- 7:29week that i mentioned on nostra music to my ears what a legend yes he is and yes it will be it was
- 7:36a really great conversation can't wait to put that one out right time to retreat back into the
- 7:42homestead i suppose you could always pull up a rocking chair this week why don't you grab your
- 7:48favorite pipe that's what my impression of a homestead is it's completely wrong anyway whilst
- 7:55you do all that please sit back relax and enjoy my conversation with Jodie Underwood
- 8:18it's probably worth mentioning that actually i'd like to set the scene before we start speaking
- 8:23because funnily enough when i knew i was coming to new hampshire and it was all kind of free
- 8:29status and people like that i assumed everyone was going to be living in places like this
- 8:33because that's what i think about you know if you're into liberty and freedom i always associate
- 8:39that with living right down the end of a track in the middle of nowhere because but obviously that's
- 8:44that's me and that's not true and that's not even a a useful um idea really but you have chosen to
- 8:52live what is it like a mile and a half into the wilderness it's you're already in the wilderness
- 8:57and then you drive a mile and a half down a snowy track if you call wilderness five minutes off the
- 9:02highway then sure we're in the wilderness five minutes that's dubious it took me more than five
- 9:08minutes to get from the highway to the bottom of our road it's only four miles yeah but it's it's
- 9:14it was let me let me just re-establish that was single track snow on the ground and ice
- 9:21no that's the mile and a half that's not five minutes oh right i mean from the highway to
- 9:26the turn on to forehand road okay i'm just going to turn you down okay um oh okay so
- 9:35What do you class that last bit then that we just did?
- 9:38The mile and a half.
- 9:39Oh, how long does that?
- 9:40Well, when the conditions are perfect, it takes me five minutes.
- 9:45But most people take a lot longer than that because I know my road, right?
- 9:48Yeah.
- 9:49And actually.
- 9:50How long did it take you to drive up?
- 9:51Well, I was all right.
- 9:53I mean, I lived down the end of a track.
- 9:55So the only thing I was nervous about was the fact I was in someone else's car.
- 9:59Number one, I'm in a higher car, you know.
- 10:01And two, I did get out at the very end there and check it, as you saw.
- 10:05because I know from experience that starting hills is easy.
- 10:09Completing them is difficult.
- 10:11And if you get it wrong, getting out of that situation is even harder.
- 10:16Trying to reverse back down a hill on ice, which it is.
- 10:19It's an icy hill there.
- 10:21It's literally my worst nightmare.
- 10:23Anyway, we are in the middle of nowhere, yes.
- 10:25So why is that then?
- 10:28Why did you – you're a freestater through and through, right?
- 10:32You came here because of the Free State Project?
- 10:35I would say mostly because of the Free State Project.
- 10:39I mean, we heard about the Free State,
- 10:41and you might want us to talk about this on the thing.
- 10:44No, I want to talk about everything, Jody.
- 10:47I'll tell you now.
- 10:48I've already spoken to a lot of people about the Free State Project,
- 10:51so I'm absolutely happy to go off on any tangent you like.
- 10:55Are we recording?
- 10:56Yes, we're recording.
- 10:57Oh, you said you wanted some background.
- 10:59No, no, no.
- 10:59I didn't know.
- 11:00Oh, now you tell me.
- 11:01Okay, I'm good.
- 11:02I don't do beginnings and endings.
- 11:04Well, I do do an ending, but anyway, go on.
- 11:06Okay.
- 11:07Ah, yeah.
- 11:07So, I mean, we heard about the Free State Project in Reason Magazine a long time ago.
- 11:13And we thought to ourselves, wow, what a great idea.
- 11:17One day when we're ready to go on an adventure, let's look at moving there for the Free State Project.
- 11:23And fast forward some good number of years.
- 11:25And that was probably, God, I don't know.
- 11:27I don't remember when it was.
- 11:29But it was after the vote.
- 11:30So we didn't even hear about the Free State Project until the vote, which you've presumably heard about.
- 11:36Yes.
- 11:36You're deciding where it was going to be, basically.
- 11:38Right.
- 11:38Which state in the U.S., yes.
- 11:41And so fast forward to, goodness, 2007 or so.
- 11:47No, that's when we moved here.
- 11:48So prior to that, we made friends with a couple of people who the four of us together decided that we wanted, they wanted to move to New England.
- 11:56He wanted to ski, live in a large property off grid.
- 12:00And we had sort of three people, like sets of three had different goals that they wanted to do.
- 12:08So three of us want to live off grid in large property and three of us wanted to do something with alternative education.
- 12:16So we chose New Hampshire partly because they wanted to move to New England and we wanted to do this adventure thing.
- 12:22And so we just did it.
- 12:23And where did you come from? Which state?
- 12:25We lived in Pennsylvania before moving here.
- 12:27Okay.
- 12:28I'm originally from New York City, so completely different now.
- 12:33That's amazing because New York is the polar opposite of what I'm experiencing here, I would say.
- 12:38Yeah, for sure.
- 12:39And even, as someone pointed out the other day, the state motto here is live free or die.
- 12:47The state motto in New York is the empire state, right?
- 12:50The empire.
- 12:50And actually, that's very telling.
- 12:54And yeah, do you know Melissa?
- 12:56Melissa Cream?
- 12:57I think you do.
- 12:58I do.
- 12:58Yeah, I spoke to her yesterday.
- 12:59She's a New Yorker as well, originally.
- 13:01Upstate New York, though.
- 13:02Yes.
- 13:03Very different animal.
- 13:04Yes, nicer, I think calmer.
- 13:07It's very like New Hampshire, actually.
- 13:10So this is a question that I've been asking a lot of people since I've been here then.
- 13:15When you leave New Hampshire, do you feel that it's different?
- 13:21Like, is it really better here?
- 13:23Is it really like, and I'm talking about day-to-day things,
- 13:26It's like generally the people you meet, the police say, the bureaucracy, the this, the that.
- 13:32Is it like, you know, can you tell you're in New Hampshire?
- 13:36I feel it.
- 13:37That's what everyone said.
- 13:39I don't know.
- 13:40I don't know how to quantify that.
- 13:42But a lot of people have said that.
- 13:43I just feel like I'm coming home when I come, when I get off the plane or when I blah, blah, blah.
- 13:47Yeah.
- 13:47There's something very freeing about it.
- 13:49But, you know, I've gone to New York City a number of times from here and it takes me a minute to like readjust my attitude.
- 13:58And how walking in Manhattan, just how you have to feel all the people around you all the time.
- 14:04I'm not used to that anymore.
- 14:06So there's just an overall.
- 14:09What about the kind of, you know, the day to day living?
- 14:12Would it be if you were in I mean, you wouldn't be able to live in New York in a place like this.
- 14:17But I don't know. I think it's somewhere else. Somewhere else. I don't know. Let's go to the other end of the spectrum. Then let's go to California. It would be hotter, obviously. But if you were living remotely in California, do you think your day to day life would be different?
- 14:33Oh, so, all right, that's a good question.
- 14:35I mean, we lived in suburbs in California,
- 14:37but so you have friends who sort of live in the middle of nowhere.
- 14:41The laws and the people there would make it feel different than here.
- 14:45They're much more restricting.
- 14:47The people are much more, I don't know, woke, for lack of a better word.
- 14:53No, I think that is the word, unfortunately.
- 14:55Yeah.
- 14:56So tell me about this place that you have here then.
- 14:59Did you always live here?
- 15:01so when you came here you're like me basically i like places like this i thrive in places like this
- 15:08and um you know i would have done exactly the same thing i might even have gone even further up
- 15:14the lane or somewhere i don't know but um tell me a bit about this property and tell me a bit about
- 15:20what you're doing here are you running it so you're obviously off grid completely off grid
- 15:25um but what about like things like farming and forestry i don't know what's going on
- 15:30Um, so we own two set, two properties on this road. The first one is where we lived first. Um,
- 15:40and so, you know, when you came up the road, there was that fork. If you'd gone right,
- 15:43that's where we lived first. Um, and we still own that property and Neil and Emily, the ones we
- 15:48mentioned, um, they, they live there and they run a farm. They run a pig farm there, pigs and cows
- 15:53at this point. Um, some chickens and eggs and things like that. And they've gone through a
- 15:58number of different things so we get all our meat from there so from a farming perspective that that
- 16:02works really well for us when they started having kids this property became available and we worked
- 16:08out uh how to get this property and then ian and i moved up here um what but we lived in the house
- 16:15with them uh down at the farm all right you both lived in the same so you moved over here as a group
- 16:19literally we did ah right i didn't realize yeah we bought the property together yeah wow that must
- 16:24been interesting and how many kids were running around during that time no no kids yeah so they're
- 16:2920 years younger than us and um they weren't married when we first came up they got married
- 16:34in the first year um and we got two piglets as a as a we see i do this they got two piglets as a
- 16:40gift for their wedding and we all raised them you know and uh we harvested them at the end of the
- 16:47year and it's like wow that was easy let's do that again so your your free state experience was
- 16:53kind of an off you're an off-grid one it's like let's go try and be were you trying to be self
- 16:58sufficient at all or to whatever extent we we could sure and how's that worked out because that's a
- 17:04that's a big question I think about when it comes to people that want to live off-grid when you're
- 17:09sitting on watching YouTube and looking at people who've done it going that must be amazing
- 17:13it's all very well but when you actually come and do it you you can't have a job at the same time
- 17:19not in my experience, not if you're running a proper farm. It takes up so much of your time.
- 17:24And I think possibly the reality is a lot different to what people expect. How was it for you?
- 17:31Sure. So I always had that full-time job while other people ran the farm. And that's what allowed
- 17:37us to do this because I don't think the farm could have supported the mortgage that we have,
- 17:41for example. I retired a little over a year ago though, and we're doing okay. But I mean,
- 17:47the interesting thing to me is when people hear that we live off grid, they say, Oh, so you don't
- 17:51have electricity. And it's like, no, we do have electricity. And, you know, we had to make some
- 17:59compromises as we got used to where we were. Look, we were both from city suburb areas. I mean,
- 18:06Ian's more suburb than me, but he's lived in and around cities, whatever. And so living in the,
- 18:14in the country, living off grid, you know, the self-sufficient idea, we just had to get used to
- 18:21how it works. So minimizing our electric, you know, needs was the first thing. Now that we've
- 18:28upgraded our solar, that's less important, but still important. I mean, we can't just go nuts
- 18:33with electricity. But it's not a hardship. It just, it feels just fine. But right, so that's
- 18:41what people don't understand we live normal lives right we use electricity almost like everybody
- 18:46else does um and water and you know we have a great well so that makes it easy but um you know
- 18:52who knows what can happen with that and what about food and stuff when you uh apart from meat have
- 18:58you have you gone down that route of trying to be you know properly self-sufficient even in
- 19:04vegetables and you know right so we have a large garden at the farm never done it to the point of
- 19:09farming, but mostly, but we also have a short season for that.
- 19:13So, I mean, one of the things I do want to do, and we've been here over 17 years already,
- 19:17we moved in 2007 is to build a greenhouse so that we actually can do more extend the season and stuff like that We just haven done it yet They too busy on the farm with their animals
- 19:29And so that's something that I'm probably going to do.
- 19:31So they're running that as a business now?
- 19:32Correct.
- 19:33Right.
- 19:34That is useful.
- 19:35How does it work here with, like if you raise animals, can you kill them yourself?
- 19:41Or is there a lot of, like we're not allowed to.
- 19:44So it depends, is the answer.
- 19:46if you're going to, you are allowed to raise animals, quote, for other people and then slaughter
- 19:52them yourselves and, you know, butcher them and then give them to the people that you raised them
- 19:57for. But if you're going to sell parts, like, I mean, ground meat, like a pound of ground beef,
- 20:04then it has to be USDA. Probably both slaughtered and butchered and packaged.
- 20:12Has to be done officially.
- 20:13That sounds a lot fairer than our system. We don't have any options. You have to register every animal you own. It has to go through. It basically becomes a number in the system and goes through the system. But I've always wanted that version of it back home.
- 20:30You know, it just seems, you know, well, if you go back, even not in that too far into the distant past, when most people had a couple of animals who lived out in the countryside, it is a sign of the times that now, unfortunately, I'm going to say the government is basically sticking their nose in your business, even right down the end of a two mile track.
- 20:54Yeah, that's right. There's also limits on the number of chickens you can sell, like raise to sell. Anyway, yeah, there's all sorts of things. There are. It's not perfect.
- 21:04we've just had a new law in the uk where everyone has to register their chickens now in the
- 21:10even if you have two or one and and here's the theory behind it which i can understand it's
- 21:18quite hard to argue against if you believe in in the state running everything it's very hard to
- 21:25because we now have i think you have it here as well chicken flu which is the avian flu avian flu
- 21:30yes right and um and the price of eggs has gone up not for us but if um but the the new law is you
- 21:43have to keep them inside so and now you can see why everyone wanted they wanted to register all
- 21:49the animals i think and unfortunately the truth of the matter is because we have foot and mouth
- 21:54disease a number of years ago do you know about that one with cattle that is and the the strategy
- 22:00for stopping that is literally to cull absolutely everything so if a if if if it arises somewhere on
- 22:07a farm all the farms around there have all their animals slaughtered instantly and burnt and people
- 22:12were you losing herds that were 100 years old you know what i mean like some farmed herds that
- 22:18would have been the same herd for so long so i don't know i think you you kind of i don't know
- 22:26Well, you moved here to get away from all that stuff, I suppose.
- 22:31Yeah, we're trying, right?
- 22:32I mean, New Hampshire isn't perfect.
- 22:34Nor is the US government.
- 22:36Correct.
- 22:37Right.
- 22:38So as early movers then, tell me about your experience with the whole project.
- 22:47Is it something you closely monitor or part of?
- 22:51I've heard from different people.
- 22:53Before I came here, I imagined the Free State Project was going to be this all-encompassing thing.
- 22:59And now you realize there's people that come here, hear about it and come here, but don't really join in.
- 23:05There's people that really join in.
- 23:06There's also subgroups of people.
- 23:09There's now little satellite groups of free staters who all believe in the same principles and who all kind of stick together.
- 23:17So where do you fall on that spectrum?
- 23:19I was on the board for a number of years of the FSP organization.
- 23:25That was already a long time ago.
- 23:28And so I was involved in, you know, Porkfest and Liberty Forum and that level of thing.
- 23:33But very, it was a pretty hands-off thing.
- 23:36I was asked to join and, you know, whatever.
- 23:39They had a, you know, a slot.
- 23:41But what you've also probably heard is that everybody really just, we're just residents of the state.
- 23:47and we do what we want, what we can if we're interested.
- 23:52Some people just come and want to raise their families among like-minded people.
- 23:56There's a lot of people like that.
- 23:58Other people run for office and, you know, whether it's local, select board or school board
- 24:03or state level, state rep or senator.
- 24:08We actually, I think we have our first senator now who is a free stater.
- 24:15So, yeah, people get involved at different levels.
- 24:17And, you know, some people are more anarchistic where they don't even want to get involved at the government level.
- 24:24They don't think the laws are the things to do.
- 24:26They just want to do, you know, civ dis and just live the way they want to live.
- 24:32But, of course, there are problems with that.
- 24:36So where do I fall?
- 24:38So I was on the school board for over 12 years.
- 24:42that's the the kind of local scoreboard as in the the old old-fashioned nothing to do with the free
- 24:49state project the correct right yeah has nothing to do right this is where people just act individually
- 24:53um i and again there i was asked if i wanted to join when somebody stepped down or left town or
- 24:59whatever it was um and so i was involved in that local government it's an elected position so i
- 25:05um after that first appointment to the end of that year then i had to run and nobody ran against me
- 25:12for years. Last time somebody did and they won and that was that. So 12 plus years and it was
- 25:18sort of a big deal that happened a year before that that made me lose actually.
- 25:25I think I know the story. Do you mean something to do with the way it's funded and basically
- 25:34slashing the funds basically? Yeah. This is fascinating because it really does show you
- 25:40the incentive model at work here. Can you kind of break that whole thing down for me? Because
- 25:46I've heard about it and I can see exactly why it's happened, but I'd love to hear it from
- 25:52your perspective. Sure. I'll tell you mine, but I'll also suggest that you talk to Ian about it.
- 25:57Okay. Yep. So every year we have what they call a traditional town meeting and traditional
- 26:04annual district meeting. And there are sort of other versions that different towns and cities
- 26:10in the state have. But so basically, we have an election day on a Tuesday in March, which is like
- 26:16next week here. And then the following Saturday, we have these meetings where people get together
- 26:21and vote on things for the town budgets, mostly, but it's really all budget related.
- 26:28and so at this particular district meeting the school board as usual put forth the budget for
- 26:35the coming year for the town to vote on except this time one of the residents who happens to
- 26:42be my husband and I was chair of the school board at the time he put a pamphlet out on the registration
- 26:49the sign-in table not registration the sign-in table when people came in if they wanted to take
- 26:53when they could and they'd have something to read while waiting for the meeting to start
- 26:56and basically it laid out why um there it is the very same pamphlet go on right budget or ransom
- 27:06there we go croydon school district meeting uh-huh right go on then yep um and so do you know the
- 27:12difference between a budget and a ransom um well i think so but go on tell me i'm probably missing
- 27:19something aren't i no probably not um i mean the way our our taxes go so wait the way budgets go is
- 27:24you have some income and you have expenses that you need to have and you figure out what you can
- 27:29spend on what and what's important and you prioritize and sometimes you don't buy things
- 27:34because you can't afford it right that's a budget right but a ransom is we tell you how much we want
- 27:39and if you don't give it to us we're going to hurt you right and those are taxes
- 27:44correct so it lays that out and explains that um in in the pamphlet and then it also explains many
- 27:52reasons why it doesn't matter how much you spend on schools, the outcomes the same. And so there's
- 27:59a chart in there that shows states that spend very little per student and very, you know, a lot per
- 28:05student and how their achievement levels are basically the same across the board. So it doesn't
- 28:10matter what you spend. So they read this pamphlet. And then it comes down to voting on the budget.
- 28:17And so then Ian gets up and he makes a motion on the floor and anybody can do this to change the amount of the budget.
- 28:24Now, this is a bottom line budget, too.
- 28:26So that means that whatever gets passed, that's what the school board gets.
- 28:30They don't have to necessarily spend it on the same line items that they have, like each thing.
- 28:35Right. So bottom line.
- 28:36Quick question. Does it come from the federal government or the local government?
- 28:39Our property taxes pay for all of it.
- 28:42We get some revenue from the state and some grants and contracts from the federal government, but that's less than 6% federal government for, on average, across the U.S., like what the schools get, because schools are a local issue.
- 28:58The federal government really has no written powers to do anything with government at the state level.
- 29:05Not government, sorry, with education.
- 29:06I said that wrong.
- 29:07At the state level.
- 29:08and the state provides revenue to the town so it offsets the cost but it doesn't change the budget
- 29:19at all right and that that's called an adequacy grant so it's supposed to mean that you that they
- 29:27will goodness provide the bare minimum is it well an adequate education undefined okay right but
- 29:36everyone's quoting a different level every state's quoting a different yeah of course and they're
- 29:41doing way more than just the bare minimum and even and they're not really measuring what's adequate
- 29:46right people graduate half the country graduates from high school reading at below a sixth grade
- 29:52level i mean that's just absurd that they're allowed to do that and yet nobody seems to care
- 29:57honestly and that's something that sort of came out of all of this even in our small town our town
- 30:02has a population of 800 people, by the way. And so at this particular district meeting,
- 30:06what were there? 35 people showed up and they were the same people that show up every year.
- 30:11And they make the decisions for the town. 35 out of 800. It's crazy. So he makes this motion.
- 30:19So I'm going to pop back to that. And he explained what was explained in the pamphlet for those who
- 30:25didn't read it and he gave his you know little um explanation for it and basically came to the
- 30:32idea that it should cost no more than ten thousand dollars per kid we have about 80 kids we actually
- 30:38upped the number a little bit for a little fluff room there was discussion around the room um and
- 30:43um the town voted for it to go it can happen that quickly can it someone raises a point and then
- 30:51That's right.
- 30:51By the end of the meeting, the budgets, what, how much did it?
- 30:55So it was 1.7 million to star and it went to 800,000.
- 30:59Right, 54% of the original budget.
- 31:02And interesting though, I must ask,
- 31:05the people who were voting to slash the budget,
- 31:09were they people that you knew well?
- 31:11Were they libertarians?
- 31:15Were they just looking at it going,
- 31:18well, hell, if we can halve the budget,
- 31:20this makes a lot of sense. We can put money elsewhere.
- 31:23Right. So who are these people? So Croydon, traditionally, I mean, these are people who
- 31:29show up to the town meetings every year. And so I know them from there, mostly. I'm not really
- 31:35good friends with anybody in town, but everybody's, you know, pretty civilized. And
- 31:39most people that we've met and had any level of conversation with, they're all libertarian,
- 31:44except they don't know the term. And so they don't know the philosophy either, but they do know they
- 31:49want the government out of their pockets and out of their bedrooms, right? Those things they would
- 31:53all agree with until it comes to schools. And then probably half of those people, and maybe
- 31:59probably less than half, but the people show up who have connections to the schools, those with
- 32:05kids or grandkids or teachers themselves or something, they just think differently about
- 32:12how schools are funded. And there's a lot of old timers. There's not a lot of kids, 80 kids out of
- 32:19800 people, you know, 300 households to put another perspective on that.
- 32:27Yeah, so more than half.
- 32:29And it was just a majority wins situation at the town meeting.
- 32:33So that put a lot of people's noses out of shape.
- 32:36Yes.
- 32:36And then some people got up and said, oh, no, this isn't happening.
- 32:39And then, right.
- 32:40So fast forward a couple of months, they found a law, a little known law, but it is a law.
- 32:45They were allowed to redo the meeting for this question and they regained the $1.7 million budget.
- 32:53So what was that little get out clause then?
- 32:56What was it?
- 32:58You know, it's funny because nobody knew about it.
- 33:00Our business administrator in the district said, you're just going to have to go to court to fight it, that there's no law that says that you can redo the vote.
- 33:08And then somebody, well, somebody found it.
- 33:11I don't even know who found it.
- 33:13But it existed.
- 33:15and that's fine but then what they did was they did a big smear and fear campaign in town to get
- 33:23everybody afraid of freestaters and ian and me in particular um and i mean they just threw mud they
- 33:29didn't they and they lied about so many things you're gonna see your taxes go up and it's like
- 33:34no the taxes would go down like or the money would go elsewhere presumably i mean that a how much did
- 33:41it save eight it was like 800 000 it was half the budget pretty much we can we can so what happens
- 33:48to that what would have happened to that extra 800 oh our property taxes would go down it wouldn't
- 33:53they wouldn't get it they would the the district would only receive the 800 000 wow yeah and were
- 34:01there unions involved do you have unions here not in our town but the larger towns i think if you
- 34:06have us under a certain number of teachers you're not required to have a union um and so we don't
- 34:10So that wasn't an issue.
- 34:12So when it was re-voted then, the people that voted in favor of it, what convinced them?
- 34:20What was it about this new finding that meant that they suddenly went, ah, we can't do that?
- 34:26Were their hands tied or was it more of a kind of opinionated vote?
- 34:30Do you mean to come to the second vote?
- 34:33The second vote, yeah.
- 34:34So what happened there was they needed a majority of the registered voters to file a ballot, to actually enter a ballot.
- 34:46So it was a closed ballot session.
- 34:47Often it's just raise your hands or yell.
- 34:50But this was a closed ballot.
- 34:53And then the vote would be valid.
- 34:57So 377 people showed up.
- 34:59So they got their quorum, which honestly to all of us was amazing.
- 35:04We didn't even expect them to get a quorum, but they did.
- 35:06But what nobody reported in the news was that 300 people didn't show up.
- 35:11So those people who wanted the $800,000 budget didn't show up.
- 35:16That's interesting.
- 35:18And what would that budget cut off look like in real life if it had happened?
- 35:24I mean, even me, I'm thinking, blimey.
- 35:27What would you do?
- 35:28Well, no.
- 35:28What does that mean?
- 35:29Do they get less books and teachers and whatever?
- 35:33I mean, it does seem like either the original budget was a complete scam or, which it probably was, that's probably what you're going to tell me, or, yeah, there's going to have to be cut.
- 35:46Would it have resulted in any kind of degradation of the service?
- 35:50Right. So you're thinking about this as a cut in budget.
- 35:53But Ian's idea was, no, let's start with a bottom-up budget and let's see what we can do with the $800,000 that we're going to get.
- 36:00And so what ended up happening in reality was that the district administrators stepped back and basically said, we have no idea how to handle this.
- 36:11And they used to sit in the front of the room with us in the school board meetings.
- 36:16They moved to sit with the audience after this happened.
- 36:19I mean, so both by stating it and physically, they did all this.
- 36:23And in hindsight, they should have been fired because it is their job to figure out what to do with the budget that the town votes for.
- 36:30Um, and, but hindsight is always good, right?
- 36:35But when we were there, the school board said, well, if they're not going to do it, we have
- 36:39to.
- 36:40And so then we got ourselves moving and figuring out what we could do.
- 36:44We were, you know, talking to people at the state level and the, you know, the Department
- 36:48of Ed to advise us on what our options were.
- 36:51And so what we ended up deciding on, um, was having these new things called micro schools
- 37:00right that started popping up they started popping up probably back in 2010 but really
- 37:04surged during the um the pandemic um and the state was actually supporting micro schools
- 37:11post pandemic so this is 2022 this happened right i've never heard that term before can you go can
- 37:17you explain what that is is that a bunch of people getting together and just employing a teacher
- 37:21basically yes um micro school so you've never heard that okay no but i mean um we did a similar
- 37:28well we during the during the first lockdown that we had we all thought the same thing and actually
- 37:35opened my eyes to the fact that um we homeschooled for a year after what during the pandemic actually
- 37:42was we went away but that whole thing opened my eyes to the prospect that maybe if i privately
- 37:48funded my kids education i.e found them a teacher and got together with my neighbors we could give
- 37:55them a phenomenal education for a fraction of the price. It sounds like the same theory here.
- 38:00That was the same theory. And so the organizations that the state was supporting,
- 38:06one was called Prenda. And what they do is they bring in somebody who isn't a certified teacher
- 38:11necessarily, although we could require them to be certified, but they just knew how to facilitate
- 38:16student learning. And then half the day, they would be on computers and moving at their own pace.
- 38:22and then there were projects that they would all do together
- 38:25and, you know, things like that, and that's how it would be run.
- 38:28I mean, the town was up in arms about those people who were, you know,
- 38:31against the $800,000 budget, the parents in particular.
- 38:35So, I mean, that's the general idea behind micro schools.
- 38:38So there a whole bunch that have popped up that are there something called Acton I said Prenda already There Kypods and those are like the most famous names But you can How many kids in one of them for example A maximum of like 10
- 38:52And do they have a property or do they do it in someone's house?
- 38:55You have to give them a place.
- 38:56And they would have done it in our school.
- 38:58So that would have been easy.
- 39:01So we only have a K-4 village school is what we call it.
- 39:06and so um you know it's honest we didn't even think about this but we could have reduced that
- 39:13to k to three to even have fewer students but we really have like 25 to 30 kids in those grades so
- 39:18we could have had a few pods like that they call them pods learning pods um it's a good way to
- 39:23describe them yeah um although it's sound derogatory to call it a pod so it's turned into
- 39:29that somehow i don't know why maybe that's because they've been vilified yeah probably
- 39:34And then even micro school, I don't like that they use the term school because it's done
- 39:38differently.
- 39:38Again, it's a grassroots thing to do it.
- 39:40So I'm trying to use learning center as the more generic term.
- 39:43And anybody can start a learning center.
- 39:46You have to, in New Hampshire, actually, probably anywhere, you have to officially homeschool
- 39:50your kid in order for them to attend these learning centers.
- 39:53That wouldn't have been the case, right, had we done the micro school in our school.
- 39:59So yeah, there's somebody just in the next town in Newport who she and a friend just
- 40:02started a learning center meant for poorer kids that weren't fitting into the local Newport public
- 40:07schools. And so she has about 15 kids. This is her second year. How many of those micro schools are
- 40:13just four families getting together and educating their own kids? So when they when the families do
- 40:19that, they're called homeschool co-ops. So they're not really hiring somebody to do it. And there's a
- 40:25ton of them. They're uncountable because nobody reports them. They're not like official businesses
- 40:30or anything. But, you know, some families will get, it's like the Upper Valley. We live in the
- 40:35Upper Valley of New Hampshire. It's what the region is called. Sun at B to Dartmouth goes
- 40:39into Vermont a little too, actually. They get together weekly or more. They might hire somebody.
- 40:46They have somebody now who teaches both coding skills, like programming, and what's it called?
- 40:53like acting, but what's it called? Improv. He teaches an improv class. And so the kids who
- 41:00are interested go to that and he's hired to do it. Ian and I, my husband and I also teach a
- 41:07creative writing class this year. We're going to publish a book out of it. Not creative. I keep
- 41:12messing my words up. A short story writing class. And so Ian writes, he's published a number of
- 41:18books. And so he's sort of the expert in that area. And I've done the publishing. So we do this
- 41:22together and we have about i don't know four families kids who come to this or five and it
- 41:27goes up and down each week so anyway that's what they do and we don't even get paid so they're not
- 41:31hiring us we do it because we we're part of the community and we just want to contribute
- 41:35so that's a co-op where and they'll do fun things too they'll go to museums they'll go to parks
- 41:41they'll go skiing you know do the micro schools run as a business then they can yes and they and
- 41:46they generally do yeah are they are they an entrepreneurial thing or are they more of a kind
- 41:51of social thing. Totally entrepreneurial. Yeah. Wow. And what about the funding for them then?
- 41:59So if it was 10,000 per child, like, is there any way to get that 10,000 if you want to homeschool
- 42:05your kids? Right. So, so. Because that, we can't do that back home either. Right. So,
- 42:12so there are these things that are running around the country now called education savings accounts.
- 42:18and this is state funded um i mean people call them grants uh that kids can get they're around
- 42:28five thousand dollars each per year per year um and they can only be used on approved places you
- 42:37know so anybody that you go to so if it's that micro school of learning center they have to be
- 42:41approved by the scholarship organization that that handles the in new hampshire they're called
- 42:47education freedom accounts, EFAs.
- 42:50Everywhere else, education savings accounts, ESAs.
- 42:52And different states call them different things.
- 42:54So that's a new thing.
- 42:55But so again, it is state pays for this.
- 42:58So this is the government getting more involved
- 43:00in homeschool education.
- 43:03It can be used for private schools too.
- 43:04I want to throw that in.
- 43:05Kind of paying for it.
- 43:06$5,000 a year doesn't really fund much, does it?
- 43:10You'd be surprised.
- 43:11Really?
- 43:12So homeschool families tend to spend
- 43:13less than $1,000 per year per kid.
- 43:16that's without funding really but what about i mean what what i loved about the realizations i
- 43:23had during the first lockdown were that online i could find very high class very highly regarded
- 43:31teachers who were prepared to teach groups of people online relatively cheaply because it's
- 43:38you know they make they would they make more money than they would being a physical teacher
- 43:43in real life, if you see what I mean, because each student is charged a smaller amount per student,
- 43:50but they get directly all the money pretty much because it's, you know.
- 43:54Right, no overhead.
- 43:55Yeah.
- 43:55Pretty much, yeah.
- 43:56And in fact, I told this story to someone the other day.
- 43:58I'm a Bitcoiner.
- 44:00I've been a Bitcoiner for a long time.
- 44:01And the most famous Bitcoiner in existence, a guy called Safety in a Moose, he wrote the
- 44:05Bitcoin Standard, which is the kind of Bible of the Bitcoin world.
- 44:08I started studying with him during the pandemic because I I was sitting around thinking what's
- 44:14going on no one's doing anything and I thought online education and it turns out I could study
- 44:20with the most preeminent person in the field I wanted to study and it cost and I did a 10-week
- 44:26course with him for $70 and they were like and this was really he didn't charge you Bitcoin what
- 44:31no you paid him Bitcoin I paid him Bitcoin back then I probably ended up paying about
- 44:35I probably ended up paying $500 now.
- 44:38But, you know, it doesn't matter.
- 44:40Bitcoiners always do that.
- 44:42The point was that I suddenly realized, oh, my God, if I can do that with this, like, imagine if me and five families I knew got together.
- 44:54We could probably hire a very proficient teacher.
- 44:58You know, if we all chipped in, like, a lot, if we put in $10,000, that's $50,000.
- 45:03That's, you know, where we live, that's a salary.
- 45:05you could get you get a full-time very good teacher to teach very closely with just five
- 45:12of your kids anyway it sent my mind reeling and I realized that there were much better ways to do it
- 45:17obviously so you've obviously discovered this a lot sooner than we did yeah but um so what's the
- 45:25current situation with micro schools and and these kind of the pod ones what do you what do you what
- 45:31have you decided to call them? Learning centers. Learning centers. I'll write that down. What about,
- 45:36so are they, are they flourishing? They are still growing. They are. And so, I mean,
- 45:42it's interesting. So this is an interesting segue for me. So more and more families are realizing
- 45:47that the schools aren't giving them everything they need. Right. So, I mean, I just talk about
- 45:52academic achievement, right. With half the kids not really learning to read. I mean,
- 45:56half the adults in the U S read at below sixth grade level. How do they quantify that? I
- 46:01hear those kind of stats all the time and it seems hard to believe that's a good question you know
- 46:05what i don't know how they measure it yeah um do you have anecdotal evidence i mean if i i don't
- 46:13know i thought the way that government schools worked was they they quantified results and if
- 46:19they weren't getting results then they tried to make them better right but that's what except for
- 46:24that last part yeah i agree with you yeah but why but but what's the point of just seeing schools
- 46:29get worse and not doing something about it then that because maybe that's not their goal
- 46:32right schools have turned government schools anyway have turned into daycare centers more
- 46:38than anything because working families right you got two family two parents working they can't or
- 46:43single parents or you know whatever um they what are they going to do with their kids during the
- 46:48day and so then they've added things on like what's the evolution of schools been right it used to be
- 46:53reading and math and that was it it's all they did in the original like one room schoolhouses at least
- 46:58in the US. And now they do everything, right? And, you know, there's nothing wrong with learning arts
- 47:04and gym and music. And there's nothing wrong with that shop and, you know, whatever skills.
- 47:09But why is everybody paying for those things? You know, you know, where I grew up, we didn't,
- 47:15I didn't grow up with a lot of money. And because my parents didn't have a lot of money,
- 47:18I didn't get to do a bunch of things. It's just how it works, right? It's luck of the draw.
- 47:22I didn't feel entitled that somebody else should be paying for ballet lessons for me or whatever.
- 47:28But today people do feel entitled that that's what schools offer and that's what they should
- 47:33always offer.
- 47:34So I'll jump back to the Croydon budget thing.
- 47:36We were asking parents about what their priorities were because we needed to figure this out.
- 47:43And hands down, not one of them mentioned better academics, better reading.
- 47:49They wanted extracurriculars.
- 47:51They wanted sports.
- 47:52They wanted job training.
- 47:54And though they didn't say it, they wanted daycare because they wanted no transportation.
- 47:58who's going to pick them up and drop them off and you know this whole thing um so yeah they're just
- 48:03i don't know less interested in it and i can't explain that well i mean there's no doubt that
- 48:11schooling is changing and i would say it's not all bad because if you look to the schools of the past
- 48:18they were very much they were like production lines to prepare your kids to work in very specific
- 48:26kind of jobs I think you know whereas these days a lot of those jobs I mean the whole job market's
- 48:34changing isn't it the whole of the whole of everything's changing and as a result your
- 48:40priorities in educating your kids this is my experience at least have to be different and
- 48:46even things like university for example when I when I went to university when I was young
- 48:53it was an achievement to get to university it was like i mean it was a very small percentage of
- 48:59people that went and now large amounts of people go to university so it's really just further
- 49:06education it's not it yeah it's so you don't get a you don't get a benefit necessarily it's more
- 49:13like keep them in the system keep the money coming in keep them to the end but you're dilute you've
- 49:18diluted the levels of achievement. That's exactly right. And I mean, it's interesting
- 49:24why that might have happened. So back when we were in college, what they found was that with
- 49:30a college education, you were more successful than if you didn't have one. So therefore,
- 49:34everybody should go to college. But it's not, it's a correlation. It's not a causation. And so now
- 49:40people go to college who aren't really meant for college to learn the things that college are going
- 49:45to teach them um and now of course there's a trend going the other way getting back to the trades
- 49:50and not going to college um so do you know mike rowe you know who he is right mike rowe mike yes
- 49:56yeah so he has like a scholarship for people to go learn the trades so there are you know cool
- 50:02things like that going on you have that problem here as well do you yeah trades people are
- 50:07oh yeah it's hard to find them and trades and would do you find that the trades people that
- 50:12do exist are doing very well in life are they they're they're learning good money they're some
- 50:18are some aren't right yeah that depends on their own you know what they say about starting a
- 50:23business is just because you have the skills doesn't mean you have the business chops so you
- 50:27need a team and not everybody does that they try to do everything right so they don't necessarily
- 50:31do it all um well you know if you will but yeah it's just hard to find them and they don't show up
- 50:37you need a scheduler yeah but that's because it's funny that isn't it when you well in my experience
- 50:44dealing with builders it's one of the only businesses i know where they can completely
- 50:50sort of like let you down but you still kind of have them back you know what i mean like
- 50:54because they're in such demand i think possibly i mean that will obviously the market will change
- 51:00that presumably over the next few years because certainly where we live um trades people are doing
- 51:06very well um you know when i was young um the kind of the white collar jobs were what everyone
- 51:13wanted um and the blue collar jobs were less paid it's now pretty much you know what you would pay
- 51:22on a daily basis i'll give an example so when i was a journalist in london i worked for a national
- 51:27newspaper and i ended up i was the chief photographer at a national newspaper so and this
- 51:32was in the early 2000s so i was doing pretty well and i think my day rate was about 275 pounds a day
- 51:40right now our plumber gets more than that when he comes around and at the time i think a plumber
- 51:47would have been more like 125 pounds a day so that the system has flipped on its head yeah and um
- 51:55especially because i think most plumbers most trades people are also self-employed
- 52:00self-employed you make more money when you're self-employed and if you're a good business
- 52:04person obviously um but you know agreed their costs have definitely gone up yeah well i mean
- 52:11and we that's i'd say that's a good thing i wouldn't say that's a necessarily a bad thing
- 52:15i say that's a fair thing i agree um so it's a market thing exactly the market has but is it to
- 52:21do with the fact that there's less of them or is it to do with the fact that the whole world is
- 52:28changing and um things are becoming i don't know we've got more things that need fixing right
- 52:34haven't we like you know like i i i never fix my own car for example because i can't i open the
- 52:41well i can actually i can now i've gone back to an older car now but the one before that used to
- 52:48bleep at me all the time saying something's wrong and we had to plug it into a computer and in my
- 52:53local garage said sorry mate i can't i can't fix that we have to send that to the dealer you know
- 52:58so so is it is it that there's less trades people or is it that we've got more stuff that needs
- 53:04specialist fixing or i don't know wow both yeah i mean certainly there's fewer trades people um
- 53:12and that's why we need more right um and i don't know about you but if i go to a car guy and i
- 53:17don't like how he fixed my car i'm not going back to him have you got enough choice around here though
- 53:22Oh, yeah. Oh, goodness, yeah.
- 53:25But what about, so at these micro schools and learning centers and all this kind of stuff, what are they teaching then?
- 53:31What's the kind of focus of those places?
- 53:32Do they think in a more contemporary way about education?
- 53:37In the sense that it's individualized learning, yes.
- 53:40The idea is that each kid moves at his own pace to get where he needs to go.
- 53:46And do you need some kind of what we would call a national curriculum?
- 53:48So when the schools, government schools have something called a national curriculum, obviously, if you homeschool, you can you can do whatever you want. But what do you base homes? What are these on the whole? What do these micro schools base their learning on? Is it like, right, get them to this level of maths and English or whatever? And then what? See where the kids, you know, what you call like self-directed education.
- 54:11Right. Try to find their interests. Exactly. And help them move in those directions and try things that that they might like to do, like any homeschool family would. Yeah.
- 54:19And do you have any idea? I know that homeschoolers always say that their kids are much better than I know that everyone says it. I have an anecdotal evidence of that. My kids, when we during the pandemic, we went away for a year to escape the lockdowns, you know, and we homeschooled really basically.
- 54:40basically i just took the school curriculum away with us in a book and thought right as long as they
- 54:46get to the end of this by the end of this year we should be good because they're probably going to
- 54:50go back to school after this right and i did about an hour me and my wife we did about an hour a day
- 54:57if if that and towards the end we would take weeks off you know and they did actually end up in when
- 55:04they went back to school they were ahead of everyone else because nobody else did that well
- 55:08I mean, no, this was when, this was the kids that actually carried on going to school.
- 55:12This was after the pandemic.
- 55:13So it wasn't, you know, it was simply because, Mark, well, my understanding was it was simply
- 55:20because I taught them one-on-one.
- 55:24And as a result, we moved fast through the stuff that they could understand.
- 55:30And we never went past the stuff that they didn't understand.
- 55:33So they understood everything by the end of it.
- 55:36because you know what it's like in a in a classroom when you've got 25 30 people
- 55:40you you if they don't all get it you don't wait for everyone you just move on and half the time
- 55:45no one knows what's going on whereas when you're dealing with a kid one-on-one you can tell when
- 55:51it's clicked and you can read and we had this policy where we don't go past this page until
- 55:56you really understand it actually not that you get the question right through kind of guessing or
- 56:02whatever which is what they do in a lot of schools but you really have to understand what's going on
- 56:06here and after time that meant me understanding it as well because you know the other thing i
- 56:11discovered about school was none of it really well a lot of it didn't matter a lot of what even what
- 56:17i was teaching them at age nine um yeah i don't really use that in real life you know what i mean
- 56:24right and so if you homeschool you have the flexibility to do whatever you think your kids
- 56:28need to learn? Boy, there's so many things that you've said there. So first of all, I would start
- 56:33with this. One of the things they do in school is they start you learning to read in first grade.
- 56:38And actually now it's in kindergarten in the US. And a lot of kids just aren't really ready for
- 56:43that. If you're homeschooling or you're in a micro school, they're going to wait till you're
- 56:47ready. They'll do like things to make you ready, you know, make sure you know your letter sounds
- 56:52and make it, you know, even fun. Kids should be playing at that age. Kids really should be
- 56:56spending time with their parents and their families until they're ready to learn to read.
- 57:01And then they should go to school.
- 57:02But nope, we have mandatory schooling starting at six.
- 57:05So kindergarten is not mandatory here, by the way.
- 57:09And then most homeschool families that I know spend like a maximum of three hours a day on school-related stuff.
- 57:17And then there are some that do unschooling, which they don't sit their kids down to learn this stuff.
- 57:23and they pick it up when they need it and when they're ready.
- 57:27John Holt, he's an author that I first found these ideas from.
- 57:34He said, when a kid is ready to learn, it'll take him about two weeks.
- 57:38You just give him some feedback.
- 57:40Like he'll ask you questions like, what does this say?
- 57:43And so on, two weeks, and he'll be a fluent reader when he's ready.
- 57:46Why push it?
- 57:47Some kids aren't ready until they're nine or so.
- 57:50And then things like the Waldorf School,
- 57:52This is a private school.
- 57:53They have a different approach to teaching than most schools, even private schools.
- 57:59They wait for a kid to be ready before they actually force them to read.
- 58:03Also they don allow them to use any technology But now I would argue that the level of technology today can really help kids learn individually when they ready and not move forward until they know
- 58:15I mean, the thing that, you know, my husband and I have often said, like when you're learning math and you're in school and you get a C, you learn 70% of the stuff.
- 58:23Like which 30% do you not need to move on to the next piece of material?
- 58:28You know, it's just the mind reels to think about that, that this is allowable.
- 58:34hmm yes 100 and unschooling i have unschooler friends back home um and they tend to use online
- 58:44platforms which basically give you a list of things what do you want to study and i wholeheartedly
- 58:52agree with that that idea i'll tell you where i find i find it a bit uncomfortable so for example
- 58:57my daughter my oldest daughter is very intelligent and as a result school's easy for her and we speak
- 59:06very candidly about it and so she's often saying this is a waste of time this is crap or calculus
- 59:13even they're doing calculus at aged 11 and i'm looking at it going what do you think about this
- 59:18and she's like you know how am i going to use this you know but you know and whereas if you
- 59:24compare that to so she's a horse rider if you basically said right Alice you're you're not going
- 59:32to go to school instead run our stables as a business you wouldn't see her she'd be up at six
- 59:38in the morning she'd be doing all that stuff she'd be egging to go she'd see money coming in she'd have
- 59:43to do a cost benefit analysis on stuff she'd have to buy and sell things you know that I know in my
- 59:50heart of hearts would be exactly the way to school her right however this is where this is where i
- 59:58i came up with a problem the problem is right so she wants to be a vet right and you know i know at
- 1:00:0511 you you could you could change your mind right but there's only one way to become a vet in the
- 1:00:11uk and that is to go through five years of further education even six sometimes it's one of the most
- 1:00:16highly contested things you can do you need you need more than than being a doctor yeah in the
- 1:00:23US too right god knows why um but um so so I can't do that for her you know because because I know
- 1:00:32that I want her options to stay open and that my my sort of the way I've made peace with it is that
- 1:00:39we talk about how futile a lot of school is she understands that she understands that if she's in
- 1:00:45a lesson and she's like bored that's absolutely fine that doesn't mean anything's wrong that means
- 1:00:50they're wrong but you're actually in this thing and you kind of have to you have to find a way
- 1:00:55to deal with it she has to keep her eye on the prize yeah and and figure out how to get there
- 1:00:59well it's a good skill to know too actually well exactly yeah and i think i mean what we've always
- 1:01:04taught them and that i think my big realization is being of being a parent is that that this
- 1:01:11the sort of the superpower you can give your kids currently is critical thinking that's all it is
- 1:01:18you don't even really need to point them in particular educational directions because here's
- 1:01:25another good example right so um without prompting at all my daughter the same one um put together
- 1:01:35a book of all the things she knew about horses so she put it together so she did word processing
- 1:01:42she did um you know design she she's got books she worked you know and she'll tell you she'll
- 1:01:50quote things about veterinary science that that i have got no idea but she's read it and she wants
- 1:01:57to find it out she's i'm not telling her right now go and do your veterinary science stuff you know
- 1:02:03and but yeah but you know the only way is to go through the system unfortunately to do that but
- 1:02:09can she could she get a homeschooled high school diploma and then go on to college university
- 1:02:17studying the things she needs she could but i think when you look at the cost benefit analysis
- 1:02:23of that going to school is better simply because now me and my wife both work basically and liz my
- 1:02:32wife was a mum for the first sort of eight or nine years and then she started her own business
- 1:02:38because the kids were going to school more and she personally she doesn't like teaching she's not an
- 1:02:44innate teacher whereas I love it but I can't do it all the time that's the thing because I'm the
- 1:02:49main breadwinner you know so the when you you know like looking at it on paper you the decision is
- 1:02:55okay and the school's great and the bus picks them up from the end of the lane and they've got great
- 1:03:00friends at school and they're happy at school and you know but but but in all honesty if i if i think
- 1:03:05about it truly she could be getting a much better education if we were in a different scenario right
- 1:03:13and if she didn't want to be a veterinarian even then i would still do the same thing i i would well
- 1:03:20like what is she learning at school actually learning that that that is important at that age
- 1:03:27it's it's really not much really what's important is that she likes her friends and she likes hanging
- 1:03:33out and she loves sports and they all do sport together which is and all these things are useful
- 1:03:39and i know homeschooling you could organize your own sport events oh here you can even take them
- 1:03:44in the public schools you can be on the sports teams if you're homeschooling right yeah but that
- 1:03:49would be great i don't know we wouldn't be able to do that i think you're either in or out of the
- 1:03:53system where we are which is weird because you're paying for the system too you should get the
- 1:03:57benefits correct we are and um in fact you even if you go to private school you're still paying
- 1:04:04tax that goes to fund the public school system the private what we call the government school
- 1:04:10is actually we call it public school you here you call it public school is private school in the uk
- 1:04:14i know that and i don't get it no i don't get it i think it goes there's something historical
- 1:04:20you know what other types of schooling are there now you've mentioned unschooling
- 1:04:25micro schools learning centers um self self-directed education like you run a non
- 1:04:33are you running do you run a education non-profit i do what what other kind of
- 1:04:38versions of this are people trying out if any so charter schools and that's also publicly funded
- 1:04:44that's paid for wholly by the state.
- 1:04:48And they're all public charter schools.
- 1:04:50They're supposed to have a different angle
- 1:04:52than the public schools.
- 1:04:53Many of them teach classical education, for example.
- 1:04:57There's a curriculum they follow with Hillsdale College.
- 1:05:00They do nature, for example,
- 1:05:02like that might be their focus.
- 1:05:04They can change,
- 1:05:06they have flexibility in how they run things.
- 1:05:08So they have a charter,
- 1:05:09which signifies what they believe and what they do.
- 1:05:15Correct.
- 1:05:15Are they religious schools often or not?
- 1:05:17They're not.
- 1:05:18Actually, as a publicly funded school, I don't think they can be religious.
- 1:05:22Right.
- 1:05:22Give me an example of one then.
- 1:05:24What's their bent?
- 1:05:25What's their angle?
- 1:05:26Oh, I mean, the ones I know mostly in New Hampshire
- 1:05:28and they're popping up is this classical education.
- 1:05:33Kids wear uniforms.
- 1:05:34They're just stricter about things.
- 1:05:36they still have large class sizes
- 1:05:40and
- 1:05:41the values that they teach
- 1:05:44you know they're not using
- 1:05:46what is it called
- 1:05:49DEI
- 1:05:50diversity equity inclusion
- 1:05:52exactly they don't use things like that
- 1:05:55the critical
- 1:05:55CRT critical race theory stuff
- 1:05:58they don't do that stuff
- 1:05:59so it's really more about the values
- 1:06:01that the parents prefer
- 1:06:03it's funny they call it a classical education
- 1:06:05and it's basically what i don't know how you your education was but that's when my daughters get the
- 1:06:12same education pretty much they wear school uniform they you know i don't know the dei stuff does
- 1:06:20does exist but it's it's more that it rather than being taught it's that you get the odd teacher who
- 1:06:26who likes to talk about it a lot and includes it in their lesson plans and that kind of stuff and
- 1:06:32And it's not as bad, I think, as I've heard it is here.
- 1:06:37Is it really that bad?
- 1:06:38It's hard to say because it's not in the curricula, you know, like you can't look at the materials and say, oh, here's where they're doing it.
- 1:06:45But there's evidence more than I mean, can I just say anecdotal?
- 1:06:49Maybe. I mean, I mean, that's just diversity, equity, inclusion.
- 1:06:55I mean, then they have these books that look like pornography books to me in the children's libraries, you know, which in the school libraries, too, that a lot of parents are really not happy with.
- 1:07:08This is yet another thing that parents aren't happy with here.
- 1:07:11It is hard to know, though, because I always think things like that are taken with a pinch of salt because you hear about them on the news.
- 1:07:20And it is, I've seen that stuff, you know, promoting whatever,
- 1:07:24certain types of sex in kids' books, which is totally unnecessary.
- 1:07:28But that might just be one book in one library and, you know.
- 1:07:32There's more than that.
- 1:07:33So is it a real, is it a thing?
- 1:07:36Is it like, is it really, I know that education's always leaned a little bit
- 1:07:42to the left side of the aisle, or not always, actually.
- 1:07:45I mean, obviously these classical schools, that's why they're existing.
- 1:07:49But certainly since the sort of 60s and 70s, it's been that way, right?
- 1:07:54Yeah, leaning more and more.
- 1:07:55I would agree with that.
- 1:07:56And that sort of trickled down from the colleges for whatever reason.
- 1:08:01Because, you know, schools are meant to feed into colleges.
- 1:08:03So, you know, it used to be you didn't even need high school if you weren't going to college.
- 1:08:08And that still makes sense.
- 1:08:10You know, if you can read and you should, by the time you're done with the fourth or fifth grade, even say eighth grade,
- 1:08:15You should be able to read and think well enough that you can do whatever you want and go start a job, go do whatever, you know.
- 1:08:22Well, the best advert for that is how much does further education cost you here these days?
- 1:08:27Hundreds of thousands, right?
- 1:08:29Oh, university?
- 1:08:30Yeah.
- 1:08:30They're ridiculous.
- 1:08:31The costs have gone up just ridiculously.
- 1:08:35The best advertisement to not go is to say, all right, I'll take that 200,000 and start a business.
- 1:08:42That's right.
- 1:08:42That would be incredible.
- 1:08:43I mean, that's a lot of money.
- 1:08:44I know you might necessarily might not be able to borrow it up front.
- 1:08:49But just going back to something you were saying,
- 1:08:52when you were talking before about this price per child,
- 1:08:56so it was $18,000, did you say?
- 1:08:58I don't remember saying that, but we'll go with that.
- 1:09:01Oh, well, it was something like when it came down to $10,000,
- 1:09:03it was almost half.
- 1:09:04Oh, I see.
- 1:09:06That $18,000, say,
- 1:09:09is there any way as a homeschooler that you can get hold of that?
- 1:09:12No.
- 1:09:12is anyone trying to make that happen so first of all that's just a calculation
- 1:09:16right you got your budget and you got your number of kids it's the budget that doesn't change you
- 1:09:21lose a few kids that budget stays the same so the cost per kid is just a calculation so you can't
- 1:09:27take it out it's part of what runs the school pays the the heating bills right so you'll never
- 1:09:34be able to it's not that there are people trying to you know change the rules around that apart
- 1:09:40from you're right you can get that five thousand exactly and that's how people view it yeah that
- 1:09:45that that it's their money and that's why they take it to to go to to use it for private schools
- 1:09:50or micro schools or or whatever or extracurricular things for themselves or even curriculum that they
- 1:09:56can purchase with it like you know anything school related anything schools anything government
- 1:10:01schools can buy so can people with these funds with the efas but through registered only certain
- 1:10:09approved vendors approved vendors that's right that already there's already a red flag when i
- 1:10:14hear approved vendor they all they normally well i think part of the reason why school especially
- 1:10:20further education became so expensive is because it's kind of you know guaranteed you've got
- 1:10:28funding coming from government i mean that's true right and that's one of the fears absolutely
- 1:10:33yeah that that's where it's going to go and people that say they're feeling it already
- 1:10:37These have been around three years in New Hampshire, the EFAs.
- 1:10:43You know, I don't have kids.
- 1:10:44I don't get them.
- 1:10:45I don't, you know, I don't, those costs are different for me.
- 1:10:47So I don't, I'm not feeling that directly.
- 1:10:49But the cost of schools will go up to meet whatever that is.
- 1:10:52If they were charging less before, why wouldn't they charge that full amount, right?
- 1:10:55I'm not necessarily against them, by the way, just to, you know, put that out there.
- 1:11:00And EFAs in New Hampshire right now, you have to, there's an income limit that you have to
- 1:11:06qualify for in order to get it. But there are some bills in the legislature right now that are going
- 1:11:10for universal and there are a number of states who have already passed universal ESAs. So what's
- 1:11:17your, when you're with your nonprofit, what, or no, let's say personally, what would you say would
- 1:11:23be the prime best way? If you, if anyone's listening to this, especially if they're in,
- 1:11:30no, I mean, it could be worldwide, but obviously you're very much related to what's going on in
- 1:11:35in New Hampshire, in the States.
- 1:11:37But if someone was bringing up children now,
- 1:11:40thinking about the path forward,
- 1:11:43what would you suggest to them would be the best path forward?
- 1:11:46I always start with homeschooling.
- 1:11:48The best would be the parents guiding their education.
- 1:11:52Yes.
- 1:11:53And then if they can't do that, if they think they can't,
- 1:11:55a lot of people just don't have the confidence to do that.
- 1:11:57Oh, I'm not a teacher.
- 1:11:58It's like, but like, like you said, you and your wife,
- 1:12:01you're not a teacher either, but you are a teacher.
- 1:12:03If you like to teach and you're good at it,
- 1:12:05you're a teacher, you don't need that certification. But they feel like a lot of people feel like they
- 1:12:09need that certification. So I try to encourage them that they don't. In, you know, just anecdotally
- 1:12:16giving stories. Next would be a homeschool co-op where you actually get together with a few families
- 1:12:21and one family who said, there's no way I can homeschool. I live in the middle of nowhere. And
- 1:12:27she just had no idea that there was a big homeschooling community and in that area. And
- 1:12:32And I suggested this idea of homeschool co-op to her.
- 1:12:36And she was like, we're allowed to do that?
- 1:12:38Like she just didn't know.
- 1:12:40So the idea for my organization, so we're called Education Options.
- 1:12:44It's edopt.org.
- 1:12:47We, I lost my train of thought.
- 1:12:50How do you, I'm trying to get out of you some hard, good quality sort of advice.
- 1:12:57Right.
- 1:12:57So I'm probably suggesting that how does your nonprofit advise people?
- 1:13:02Right. And so that's how we go. And so the thing is, is that there's so many things that people just don't know.
- 1:13:08And we want to make sure they learn about all their options. So I start in that direction.
- 1:13:11Then I go to micro schools. Is there a drop off near you if you really need a drop off program?
- 1:13:16And sometimes there is, you know, and then people look into that and they go down those paths.
- 1:13:21And even with the co-op person, she's like, and how do I do that?
- 1:13:26So I sent her to a Facebook group and, you know, told her what to do.
- 1:13:29And she got four responses within a couple of hours of people like right down the road
- 1:13:33from her.
- 1:13:35You know, and then I would go to, I would try to encourage entrepreneurship too at that
- 1:13:41level.
- 1:13:41And then look, if your kid's already in high school and they just hate it there, then we
- 1:13:45have a program in New Hampshire called Learn Everywhere.
- 1:13:48So things that you already do, let's say you're taking flying lessons, because this is actually
- 1:13:52one that's approved, or martial arts, you can get credit in high school for those things that
- 1:13:58you don't have to also take it in high school. So that's a program we have. There's dual enrollment
- 1:14:03in community colleges. So there's a bunch of community colleges in the state that you can take
- 1:14:09classes either at the college or in your high school and get credit in both. So you're already
- 1:14:14working towards a college degree while you're in high school, and that just gets you out sooner.
- 1:14:18So there are things like that. There's, you know, there's apprenticeships. And so there's some
- 1:14:22organizations there's some charter schools that actually focus on apprenticeships so I would point
- 1:14:27people to those if that's that what they were interested in so getting jobs actually right
- 1:14:33starting to figure out what they like to do and and learn you know on the job skills that way
- 1:14:37um well my experience was very much that as soon as I tried tapping into the Hoden school community
- 1:14:47everything was there but sometimes it's it's hard to know how to get into that but all i you know
- 1:14:55like i fortunately i have one friend who's very vocal about homeschooling in the uk and he put me
- 1:15:01into one telegram group and then when we traveled around the world with our family every new place
- 1:15:07we went we just tapped straight into that if we wanted to and there was there was a wealth you
- 1:15:11know they're lovely welcoming people homeschoolers i think they all understand that you're all in the
- 1:15:16same boat you'll never not get a reply from a homeschool family if you if you get or on a
- 1:15:22facebook group or whatever you know i take it's the same round here it really is yeah yeah well
- 1:15:28anyway i've i'm looking at the time here i've taken we've been talking more than an hour did
- 1:15:33you know that i was wondering but it went fast it has gone fast um but anyway yeah thanks thanks
- 1:15:41for spending a bit of time talking about that i do like the homeschool conversations um because
- 1:15:46But like I say, I've always, I always feel like I've, I don't, I haven't let my kids down.
- 1:15:53I haven't.
- 1:15:54But I do know that if I put my mind to it, they could have had like a really exceptionally interesting level of education.
- 1:16:05Because I think most people don't realize it.
- 1:16:10You know, they don't realize what's out there.
- 1:16:11They don't realize how good much value, how good value it is.
- 1:16:16That's right.
- 1:16:16and um and what they can bring to it yes the value they can bring to their kids education
- 1:16:21well yeah and the truth is and i know this from experience that since my kids the more they go to
- 1:16:27school the less they learn from their mom and dad that's as simple as that we used to spend all our
- 1:16:33time together and now they're learning from their peers right and actually that's where it gets a
- 1:16:38little bit dodgy because and that's where the critical thinking stuff comes in if you haven't
- 1:16:42primed them in critical thinking by the time they start learning outside the home you end up with
- 1:16:48blue hair and um strange ideas it's very true yeah you don't like blue hair what well you know what
- 1:16:55i mean i do i'm kidding i don't mind blue hair it's just sometimes people with blue isn't it's
- 1:17:00a meme isn't it um if my kids want blue hair they can go ahead but anyway jody thanks very much
- 1:17:07Thanks for hosting me here as well in this amazing place.
- 1:17:10And, yeah, thanks for spending a bit of time telling us about that.
- 1:17:14It's my pleasure.
- 1:17:14Thank you for having me.