Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA’s 2026–2030 Strategic Plan: What Changed and Why It Matters
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker: Hey, everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Last month at its April board meeting of one.
- 0:05Remember, we've got one board member Kyle Hauptman.
- 0:08No news on when his replacement is coming.
- 0:11I've heard some rumors, but until we have facts, I won't report it here.
- 0:15But at the NCUA board meeting in April, they did several briefings, one of
- 0:20which was on the NCUA strategic plan.
- 0:23And this is the twenty twenty-six to twenty thirty strategic plan, and I'm
- 0:28going to compare this plan to what w- the last plan had in it, which was
- 0:32twenty twenty-two to twenty twenty-six.
- 0:35I've got a couple slides here I'm gonna bl- blow through pretty quick
- 0:38and then a couple other highlights that I wanna hit relative to this.
- 0:41But there are substantial changes, as you would expect, since the twenty
- 0:46twenty-two came out under the Biden administration and the twenty twenty-six
- 0:52came out under the Trump administration.
- 0:55I'm drinking from my Believe Sasquatch cup here.
- 0:59And again, if you're going to believe what NCUA is saying in this document,
- 1:04there's a lot of changes that they're building into the next five years.
- 1:10All right, and
- 1:15This next screen, there are 12 plus three, 15, 19 items that are supposed
- 1:20to be in the plan according to A 11.
- 1:2312 of them are fully met, three of them are partially met, and
- 1:25four didn't appear in either plan.
- 1:27And I'm not gonna get into those because there's some side documents
- 1:30where these items may have been done, and really it's not that important.
- 1:33Because what is there, there's a lot of meat in the tw- in the first plan, and
- 1:37there's a lot of meat in the second plan, and I'm gonna compare those those plans.
- 1:42And first so what was in the 2022 plan, the five-year plan,
- 1:48that's not in the 2026 plan.
- 1:50Number one, there was an economic outlook sec- section.
- 1:54There were eight pages of that which included g- gross domestic product
- 1:58product- productions projections, unemployment forecasts, yield-curve
- 2:03analysis, interest rate outlook, which is now re- replaced with a very brief
- 2:08external factor bullets for each goal.
- 2:11There was a section on credit union system risks that were detailed near and
- 2:16long-term risk analysis, interest rate risk, demographic, fintech competition,
- 2:20concentration risk, management succession, which was a big issue for Harper.
- 2:25And this is now reduced down to a bullet list.
- 2:28There was a section on climate-related financial risk.
- 2:32There was a dede- designated, dedicated subsection and explicit strategic
- 2:36objective, one point four objective one point four in the 2022 plan, and that's
- 2:43not mentioned anywhere in the 2026 plan.
- 2:46Why is that?
- 2:47Democrats believe in climate related financial risk.
- 2:50And the Republicans tend to view that as something that isn't anything
- 2:55they should be getting involved with.
- 2:57That's why it is now absent.
- 2:59Agency programs narrative, there were standalone sections on AMAC, supervision,
- 3:03insurance, consumer financial protection credit union development, and those are
- 3:08now folded into objective narrative.
- 3:10So that appears in different places but with less less words tied to it.
- 3:17I gotta move my little thing here.
- 3:19Small minority low-income credit unions as a standalone objective.
- 3:22Goal t- two point two explicitly named minority depository
- 3:26institution preservation, CDRLF grants, and minority CU chartering.
- 3:32Those are now folded into broader access framing.
- 3:35But it's also more of a D initiative than an R initiative, which is
- 3:39why it would fall out of the plan for the next five years.
- 3:43And again, by the way within a year of a new president coming in, the agency
- 3:47is supposed to have their new plan, the new five-year plan put in place.
- 3:53So if we roll ahead 2028 we will have a new president and if it's an
- 4:00R that R will have a year from that point in time to issue a new report.
- 4:06If it's a D they will have a year to issue a new report, and you can imagine
- 4:11if it's a D, they'll run faster to achieve that than if it's an R because
- 4:15the R will have similar goals and objectives most likely under the next
- 4:21Republican if that's what happens in 2028.
- 4:24But if you pivot to 2028 being a D, you'll see quicker movement.
- 4:29And by the way, NCUA was two months late from the required action timeline.
- 4:34I'm sure that they got a blessing from the powers that be in government to not
- 4:38get it done on time because there's so much going on in the in the way that the
- 4:43Trump administration is getting rid of regulations getting rid of requirements.
- 4:47I'm sure they really didn't care that the strategic plan was two months late.
- 4:50It was more important to them what the chairman was doing in office as opposed
- 4:55to what the plan said he would do.
- 4:57All right, next up, diversity, equity, and inclus- inclusion language.
- 5:012022 goal 3.1
- 5:03centered on diverse workforce and inclusive environment.
- 5:06They replaced that by merit-based hiring in 2026, which is consistent with the
- 5:11D versus the R slant on the importance of diversity, equity, and inclusion.
- 5:16Enterprise risk management section.
- 5:18There's a, there was a full ERM section with risk appetite statement,
- 5:22risk tolerance, portfolio, views, governance structure, now referenced
- 5:26only briefly in the annual performance plan, which was a separate item.
- 5:30So the annual performance plan, each year NCUA has to issue an annual performance
- 5:34plan where they say, "Here's what we're gonna do relative to our strategic plan."
- 5:39So it's referenced in the annual performance p- plan.
- 5:41I'll probably do a separate podcast on that.
- 5:44All right.
- 5:44Cross-agency collaboration section.
- 5:46Dedicated section on FSOC, FFIEC, the FIBIC with narrative explanations.
- 5:52Now one sentence on, in the agency over- overview.
- 5:55I think that's probably a good change.
- 5:57A little less w- verbiage on how the agencies will
- 6:00collaborate, which is a given.
- 6:02So next up We have what's in 2026 that's not in 2022.
- 6:11So what's going on in the world that wasn't really going on so much in 2022?
- 6:15That's artificial intelligence, right?
- 6:17So AI is a standalone strategic objective in the new plan, objective 1.3
- 6:23dedicated to AI.
- 6:25They talk about having a large language model pilot, an AI steering committee at
- 6:29NCUA, an AI ro- roadmap with milestones.
- 6:332022 mentioned technologies, but not a standalone AI objective.
- 6:38Now, a little bit more detail on what's in the report.
- 6:41As I mentioned the 2022 plan mentioned technology in passing.
- 6:45It was folded into a broader objective about delivering
- 6:48improved business processes.
- 6:50In 2026, AI gets its own objective, which makes sense because it's taking
- 6:55all the bandwidth in the market, all the bandwidth when you are out
- 6:58there just watching anything, right?
- 7:00AI gets gets top priority.
- 7:02So it gets its own objective, and it comes with actual deliverables.
- 7:06They're going to depl- deploy a new data-driven risk model.
- 7:10They're gonna complete a large language model pilot program.
- 7:14They're going to establish an AI steering committee, as I mentioned, and
- 7:17refine an AI implementation strategy, all by the end of December 31st, 2026.
- 7:24This isn't aspirational language.
- 7:26These are performance indicators they'll be held accountable to in
- 7:30the annual report and the everything that they do going forward.
- 7:34So what that means practic- practically for credit unions is that examiners
- 7:39are going to start using AI-assisted tools to scope exam programs
- 7:43before they ever walk in the door.
- 7:45The question for you, that you should be asking, "What does my 5300
- 7:51data look in the algorithm," right?
- 7:52'Cause they'll be looking at outliers, and I've been doing a lot of analysis
- 7:55of 5300 data to look at my own outliers for for running my business
- 8:00and working with my clients or past clients or just podcasts, right?
- 8:03But this is going to get a lot of play over the next year.
- 8:07Of course, now you've got Hauptman leaving, a new person potentially
- 8:10coming in and I think that them hitting that 2026 deadline for all practical
- 8:17purposes is going to be a challenge.
- 8:18But it's a aspirational goal, and I'm sure that new chairman, when they come
- 8:23in, are gonna go, "Wow there's a lot of things I've got to get done here."
- 8:26And again, when do they come in, right?
- 8:28Do they come in September?
- 8:29Do they come in October?
- 8:29Do they come in, next week?
- 8:31Time will tell.
- 8:33So next up, Stablecoin Genius Act as a performance target.
- 8:37They're planning on issuing a final stablecoin regulation by year-end.
- 8:41First time digital assets appears in a concrete, measurable deliverable.
- 8:45So it's the clearest signal of where Hauptman's head is at.
- 8:49And when he's out talking, he talks about stablecoin.
- 8:52And here it's embedded as a performance indicator in the annual
- 8:55performance plan issue to issue final regulations on permissible stablecoin
- 9:00activities for all federally insured credit unions by the end of 2026.
- 9:05There's also a proposed rule open right now on the application process that
- 9:09closed April 13th, and a second rulemaking on issuer standards coming soon.
- 9:15For most credit unions, this feels very distant, but for larger ones
- 9:19exploring digital payment rails, this is a regulatory green light
- 9:23that you've been waiting for.
- 9:25And NCUA is committing publicly to get it done this year.
- 9:28Again, we'll see if they're able to do that.
- 9:30Now, NCUA's reorganization is codified as a strategic objective.
- 9:35Here's really what's significant about this.
- 9:37The reorg is no longer an internal management decision.
- 9:41By putting it in the strategic plan as objective 3.2,
- 9:45NCUA has made its five-year commitment with performance accountability.
- 9:49The language is specific.
- 9:50Consolidate major business units, group similar roles and responsibilities,
- 9:55eliminate non-statutory functions, and shift stakeholder-facing
- 9:58work to the regional offices.
- 10:01That last piece, shifting stakeholder-facing work to the
- 10:04regions, is the one that should get credit unions' attention.
- 10:08It suggests that whatever offices currently handle outreach, policy
- 10:11engagement, or member-facing activities at the headquarters are
- 10:15going to move back to the regions.
- 10:17So when I hear this, I think about field of membership.
- 10:20I think about bylaws, things that were done in in access, the access
- 10:25office cure that will now probably be pushed back towards the regions.
- 10:29The reorg plan won't be finalized until the end of 2026.
- 10:33Implementation runs through 2027.
- 10:36The National Treasury's Employees Union is still impact, i- is still in impact
- 10:42bargaining, the impact on the workers, but this is now officially on the record.
- 10:47Now, I've criticized NCUA for not making their plans public.
- 10:51I know that they told their staff at the end of the year, for example, that ones is
- 10:54going away and other things are happening.
- 10:56I think it's not very good use of the sunshine laws.
- 11:00And I think they talk about we gotta negotiate with union.
- 11:03I think that might be a delay strategy so Hauptman doesn't
- 11:06have to take the final action.
- 11:08He proposed these broad, sweeping things, but he's gonna
- 11:10leave that for the next round.
- 11:13And whether that's one, two, or three board members, right?
- 11:15Because there's still the lawsuit of Harper and Otska.
- 11:18But, changing regulations that say the Office of National Exam and Supervision
- 11:23exi- exists to do A and then having them do B Is something that if I was a single
- 11:29board member and it was not really clear whether or not I could or couldn't act,
- 11:32it's probably something that I wouldn't be comfortable finalizing all by myself.
- 11:36So I think it's wise to wait but I think it's also creating morale
- 11:40problems at NCUA because they hear it's gonna happen, then it doesn't
- 11:43happen, and it's creating a little bit of chaos at NCUA in my in my mind.
- 11:48From what I'm, from what I'm hearing in credit unions and what I'm hearing in some
- 11:52conversations that the agency is having.
- 11:54Next up, real estate footprint reduction.
- 11:56Reducing costs, eliminating underutilized space, maximizing
- 11:59shared federal workspace.
- 12:01There was no prior plan addressed for a physical office strategy.
- 12:05This one, it flew under the radar when they talked about it,
- 12:08but it's in the strategic plan.
- 12:10Aligning the agency's real estate footprint with mission and workforce
- 12:13needs by improving utilization, reducing costs, eliminating underutilized space,
- 12:18and maximizing shared federal workspace.
- 12:20We know NCUA sold the Austin AMAC building.
- 12:23We know the Alexandria headquarters lease situation has been discussed.
- 12:27This language is the strategic cover for whatever real estate decisions are coming.
- 12:31For credit unions, it matters because office footprint decisions
- 12:34affect where staff are physically located, which affects examination
- 12:37of logistics and regional presence.
- 12:39So the regions, there's a regional office in in Alexandria.
- 12:43When I became executive director, the previous board chair and the board chair
- 12:48at the time, Debbie Matz, had moved region two at the time, which was Alexandria,
- 12:53across the build- across the street.
- 12:55When I did a reorganization that closed Albany and closed Atlanta, I also moved
- 13:00that office back into the regional office.
- 13:03Now with NCUA not requiring full-time people full-time, with NCUA doing
- 13:09more remote work you could say that maybe they'll end up se-
- 13:12selling, selling that building.
- 13:13But from what I see buildings selling in that area it's probably worth half of what
- 13:17it was worth maybe five, 10 years ago.
- 13:20But in any event they do have an item here on making sure that they
- 13:24minimize their real estate footprint.
- 13:28Next up, we have merit-based hiring plan as a deliverable.
- 13:32They have the APP indicator number 22, implement the 2026 staffing plan
- 13:37aligned with the merit hiring plan.
- 13:39This is direct DOGE and executive order compliance language dropped into
- 13:43a credit union regul- into the credit union regulators' performance plan, NCUA.
- 13:47What it practically means is that NCUA is rebuilding its workforce
- 13:51under a different philosophy than it operated under for the past decade.
- 13:56It, it took out- the voluntary plan the VSP to took out one in five employees,
- 14:03and it was actually closer to 27%.
- 14:05The people being hired to replace them, if they're being replaced,
- 14:08will be selected under based criteria tied to mission-critical skills.
- 14:14For credit unions, that means examiner examiner listings will look different
- 14:18over the next two to three years.
- 14:21Whether that's more or fewer examiners, more specialized or
- 14:24more generalist remains to be seen.
- 14:26I know they're working on that.
- 14:28The reality is they're gonna have a smaller footprint and this is
- 14:31really a de-emphasis of DEI and an emphasis of hiring the most
- 14:35talented person for a position.
- 14:37And you can get into the debate of of if DEI is good or bad.
- 14:41I'm not gonna touch that third rail here today.
- 14:44But the, there's a definite pivot away from DEI.
- 14:48Deregulation quantified as a target.
- 14:50So this is the one that I think Hauptman's probably really proud of.
- 14:56From an accountability standpoint, the performance indicators say issue at least
- 15:0030 regulatory actions or policy revisions that reduce burden by December 31, 2026.
- 15:07Hauptman said today that they're already at 29 proposed rules in phase one.
- 15:11They just came out with one this week so they must have hit their 30.
- 15:15They're they're announ- they announced the tenth round.
- 15:18And phase one runs through year-end.
- 15:20That means by the time you add final rules in the second half of the year,
- 15:24they'll likely blow past 30 because they proposed 30 changes already.
- 15:28But here's the nuance.
- 15:29A proposed rule counts, a final rule counts, and a policy revision counts.
- 15:33So this number is achievable without necessarily finalizing
- 15:37anything significant.
- 15:38Watch the quality, not just the quantity.
- 15:40Happy to glad is not really a change.
- 15:42Now, they did make some changes that made sense, but most of the 30 that are
- 15:46out there are budget dust, if you will.
- 15:48Really don't amount to much, but it's a good banner for Hauptman to be able to
- 15:52wave saying, "Look at what we've done Mr.
- 15:54Trump, President Trump."
- 15:57Chartering automation target.
- 15:58They indicator number 14, deploy an automated chartering system with 50%
- 16:03fewer sections for new charter phase one applications by December 31, 2026.
- 16:10Hauptman is big on making it easier to get a new charter.
- 16:13They just shut down a new charter that they conserved.
- 16:15They chartered it and conserved it, I think, within two or
- 16:18three years and liquidated it.
- 16:20The current chartering process is notoriously cumbersome, and
- 16:23NCUA has historically approved very few de novo applications.
- 16:27I think it's all good to make things a little easier to get a charter.
- 16:31My thoughts are, put a lot of charters out there.
- 16:33If they lose a little bit of money, so be it.
- 16:35But getting new charters out there is a good thing.
- 16:37But really, it's not a panacea because every industry consolidates.
- 16:41But I think having a lower burden to get a new charter out would be a good
- 16:46thing whether you're a D, whether you're an R, whether you're an independent.
- 16:50Supporting programs bulleted per objectives.
- 16:53So this is one of the less exciting items to talk about but it's worth mention if
- 16:58if you live and breathe strategic plans.
- 17:00The 2026 plan actually does something the 2022 plan didn't do as cleanly.
- 17:06It lists specific programs and initiatives under each objective that support it.
- 17:10That's an A111 requirement, and the 2022 plan was somewhat vague on it.
- 17:15This is an, a narrow respect, this, of restructuring that was probably driven
- 17:19by the experts at NCUA who said, "Hey, we should have done this last time.
- 17:23Let's put that in here now."
- 17:25All right, so next slide.
- 17:26The takeaways for the credit unions.
- 17:28Number one a reorganization is a five-year strategic plan.
- 17:34S- excuse me.
- 17:34Reorganization is now a five-year strategic commitment.
- 17:40Number two, safety and soundness is the explicit North Star.
- 17:43It always is.
- 17:44Number three, AI and examinations is coming and will be measurable.
- 17:49Number four NCUA has a deregulation scoreboard which is a good idea although
- 17:56most of what was deregulated really was not much of anything to speak of.
- 18:01There were a few good things, and I've got separate podcasts on the
- 18:04ones I thought warranted it a podcast on the proposal to change the limit
- 18:09on participation loans, auto loans.
- 18:12All right there you have it.
- 18:13NCUA strategic plan is out there.
- 18:15And AI is big.
- 18:17The reorg is big.
- 18:18Safety and soundness is still important, although do, although
- 18:21they're doing it with 27% less staff.
- 18:24And when you have less staff, you can spend less time on site.
- 18:27That could lead to more losses.
- 18:29That could lead to more fra- fraud in credit unions.
- 18:31But in the end, in the short run, if n- less people are coming to your
- 18:34credit union, I'm sure most, if every credit union believes that's a big
- 18:39win from the reorg, and now it's built in here to the strategic plan.
- 18:43All right, that's it.
- 18:44This is Mark Treichel.
- 18:46I wanna thank you for watching.
- 18:47I wanna thank you for listening.
- 18:49I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 18:51Signing off with flying colors.