Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / State Fair (1933)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:16at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:18every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Do you like the State Fair?
- 0:23I do. Yeah, you're a big fan? Every time that
- 0:26it comes to town, whether it be, you know, the
- 0:28big one or like... in the unfortunately this
- 0:32resonates with a lot of people i'm sure the parking
- 0:34lots of our malls that just have like little
- 0:36fairs that pop up yeah i'm always very excited
- 0:39to go it used to be like on a date thing and
- 0:41now especially like if we go to like a state
- 0:44fair like it's still going to be fun to go to
- 0:46with like taylor but now it's like let's take
- 0:50our niece like let's take our niece to like the
- 0:52state fair and everything or the fair and she'll
- 0:54have a great time as an adult Like if I was just
- 0:57going to go to the fair, probably not. Yeah.
- 0:59But I mean, as a kid, it was one of the most
- 1:01exciting things you could do. What about you?
- 1:03Yeah. Yeah. I like the fair. The last time I
- 1:05went to the fair with Ziggy, one of my favorite
- 1:07memories is we were getting in line for the kind
- 1:10of like the people mover, the sky ride thing.
- 1:13Yeah. And we passed by a sign on the gate that
- 1:17said, uh, no goldfish permitted. And I just,
- 1:21it was like, your goldfish can't ride this. And
- 1:24I was like, man. In the year 2025? To be that
- 1:27exclusionary? Yeah, like, I thought we were past
- 1:30this. It's crazy. But beyond that, I have a good
- 1:33time at the fairs, other than the prejudice.
- 1:36Yeah, I mean, that's... We here at the Once Upon
- 1:41a Time in the Oscars podcast believe in fair,
- 1:44equal rights, including for goldfish. Yeah, for
- 1:46all fish. Yeah, if I want to go on a roller coaster
- 1:50and die, that's my business. I do want to point
- 1:55out when it comes to state fairs, or fairs in
- 1:57general, the only thing that I think we could
- 1:59probably do a little bit better on is we can
- 2:01probably get licensing on some things. I don't
- 2:03love going and seeing Dumbo, and they're like,
- 2:05here's Jumbo. Sure. All right. There's also one
- 2:08ride specifically that's a very fast -moving
- 2:11vehicle that's called the Ride of the Stars or
- 2:13something like that. And then there's just like
- 2:15murals of separate musicians and stars above
- 2:18it. But it's like just different enough to where
- 2:21you're like, is that Michael Jackson? No, that's
- 2:24Mikey Jackson. Right, right. Okay. Is that Freddie
- 2:27Mercury? No, that's the lead singer of a band
- 2:29called King. Okay. Classic. All right. All very
- 2:33good. I wish we could do that. But the games,
- 2:35you can't deny the games. No, you can win a goldfish.
- 2:37You can even win a fake Pearl Revolver. Yeah,
- 2:41that's true. That's very true. At least you could
- 2:43in 1933. This is true. Hey, before we get started
- 2:47with the movie, though, I just want to do a little
- 2:49call to action. Sure. I save it for the end all
- 2:52the time. Yeah. But if you do have opinions about
- 2:56these movies... I do want you to reach out to
- 2:59us because we read those responses at the ceremony
- 3:01episodes. That's going to be on the 27th of this
- 3:03month. So if you have any thoughts on anything
- 3:06that we've talked about movie related or about
- 3:08the rights of goldfish, be sure to have those
- 3:11words into us by May 24th. O -U -T -A -O podcast
- 3:16at gmail .com. And then also you can vote. If
- 3:20you're a Patreon member, you can vote on which
- 3:21movie you think deserves to win Best Picture.
- 3:24That's a fun little perk we do. We don't want
- 3:27to see Cavalcade take home the win. So please
- 3:30get in there, vote, do what you can. Patreon
- 3:33.com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast. Usually I put
- 3:36that at the end of the episode. Nice to start
- 3:39at the beginning. Yeah, now you guys have to
- 3:40sit through it. What I will put at the end of
- 3:42the episode. I have a state fair slash carnival
- 3:46story. So stay tuned for that. Everyone's just
- 3:49immediately skipping to the end of the podcast.
- 3:50Yeah, they're like, I need to hear this. And
- 3:52you'll probably be disappointed. I also like
- 3:54the idea of you getting a couple emails on this
- 3:57episode specifically, and it's all like glub,
- 3:59glub, glub, like goldfish responses. Yeah. If
- 4:03you translate, I'm sure it's like, we appreciate
- 4:04your stand for the fight. Thank you for standing
- 4:08alongside us. Swimming alongside us. That feels
- 4:13offensive. You're right. You can't just do that.
- 4:16Whoops. We're talking about the State Fair today.
- 4:20This is going to be the next entry in our sixth
- 4:22Academy Award coverage. And this one is kind
- 4:26of a big one in the sense that, you know, if
- 4:29you go online right now and Google State Fair,
- 4:32you're going to find a couple versions of this.
- 4:33Yeah. This has been made a couple times, similar
- 4:36to the Broadway melody of... broadway melody
- 4:38broadway melody of 1940 i think there's another
- 4:40one too yeah um state fair was remade a couple
- 4:43times this ultimately became a this is a rogers
- 4:46and hammerstein picture right they adapted this
- 4:48you tell me i believe this was adapted as a musical
- 4:51by uh rogers and hammerstein like later correct
- 4:53i see i see uh this was not what this was gotcha
- 4:57because this is not a musical No. State Fair.
- 4:59This is in 1933. A couple things about this.
- 5:02Two nominations in total. This is for Adapted
- 5:05Screenplay, which was Sonia Levian and Paul Green.
- 5:09Yep. Might be Levine. Sonia and Paul took the
- 5:13nomination for this for Adapted Screenplay. An
- 5:15outstanding production, and this was... By Fox.
- 5:19Yeah. Kyle, what am I going to ask you? Probably
- 5:22a couple things as time goes on, but more importantly...
- 5:26Including what I just did. I asked you there.
- 5:28Yeah, you did. You mentioned this was nominated
- 5:31for Adapted Screenplay. It was. This is the first
- 5:33of three adaptations. Correct. Adapted from the
- 5:371932 novel by Phil Strong. Philip Strong. Philip!
- 5:42Yeah, show some respect. You're right. Man, I'm
- 5:44offending everybody. Fish and Phil's alike. This
- 5:47film was directed by Henry King, starring, say
- 5:51it with me, Janet Gaynor. Oh, my heart. I've
- 5:56missed her. As Margie Frake, Will Rogers as her
- 6:00father, Abel Frake, and also the return of Lou
- 6:03Ayers of All Quiet on the Western Front fame,
- 6:06playing Pat Gilbert. Those are my three headliners,
- 6:11and the big ones, specifically because I think
- 6:13Janet and Lou are very cute together. A couple
- 6:16of quick things to you. Sally Ehlers as Emily
- 6:18Joyce. We turn to her. That's true. Norman Foster
- 6:21as Wayne Frake and Louise Dresser as Melissa
- 6:25Frake. That would be Margie. I don't know why
- 6:28it took me a second. Margie's mother. Margie's
- 6:30mom. So you're correct that those are the top
- 6:32three billing that you mentioned. But in reality,
- 6:35this really is the story of the Frake family.
- 6:37And then also includes Pat and Emily, who are
- 6:42introduced at the state fair. So how would you
- 6:45describe? The log line of State Fair. Picture
- 6:49it. Typical family of Iowa heads to the State
- 6:53Fair, heads for an exciting weekend at the State
- 6:57Fair, full of contests, tribulations, and romance.
- 7:02And heartbreak. Yeah. And pigs. A lot of pigs.
- 7:07A lot of pig content. I want to go ahead and
- 7:08start off by saying I want to call out your excellent
- 7:10work on Letterboxd. And you left a review of
- 7:13this movie. And you left a phrase in there that
- 7:16I think is something that stuck with me. And
- 7:18that's, this is the most notable example of swine
- 7:23time in a Best Picture nominee since Babe. So,
- 7:28love that. Yeah. Because at first I was like,
- 7:30swing time? Are you referencing the... Is it
- 7:34Fred Astaire? Fred Astaire movie? Yeah. No, you
- 7:36said swine time. That's right. So I just want
- 7:38to give you a platform to explain that a little
- 7:40bit. There's a lot of pig content in this movie.
- 7:43And not even just like with Babe. A clip of a
- 7:46pig. Yeah, yeah. It's just like, guys, we need
- 7:49to fill up the time a little bit. Point the camera
- 7:53at those pigs for like 20 minutes. In the first
- 7:56two minutes of this movie. There are at least
- 7:5830 seconds of footage of pigs. Right. You are
- 8:01correct about that. I also want to set up very
- 8:03quickly the Frake family, who we follow for the
- 8:06entirety of this film. They do raise on a farm
- 8:10pigs. And the main allure of them going to the
- 8:13state fair, which they often do, is to contribute
- 8:16on Abel's side, the father, the ability to have
- 8:20a show prize pig. And on the mother's side, Melissa,
- 8:23the ability to have her hopefully award -winning
- 8:27mincemeat and pickles. Yeah. There's another
- 8:30thing that she makes, too. But those are the
- 8:32main ones. I can't remember what the third one
- 8:34is. Well, we'll get there. So that's why the
- 8:36pigs play such a big part of this. Now, it's
- 8:39not just that there's footage of pigs. There
- 8:41are at least two separate instances of a scene
- 8:44between two pigs. Where they're almost talking
- 8:48to each other. Yeah. The way the camera cuts
- 8:50back and forth. It's like a standoff. It's a
- 8:52standoff. Or like almost a meat cute, if you
- 8:55will. Yeah. Well. I was about to make a really
- 8:58dumb barbecue joke. Like a bacon joke. Like meat
- 9:00cute. It was like a meat cute between two pigs
- 9:02at one point. Oh, but it ends in like. It's a
- 9:05fight. Yeah. Yeah. Well, it's a lover's quarrel.
- 9:07Oh, okay. That's kind of sweet. Well, you listen
- 9:11to the fight. It doesn't sound very sweet. They
- 9:12say pork is the sweet meat. Yeah, they sure do.
- 9:16There is more to this movie than pigs. There's
- 9:20a lot of pigs. There's a lot of pigs. And there's
- 9:23just the underlining line here is swine time.
- 9:26So I'm glad you liked it. Thank you for that.
- 9:29I appreciate that. But you're right. The majority
- 9:31of this movie is the Frank family traveling.
- 9:34You know, Abel wants to see his prize pig or
- 9:39his in his eyes prize pig, Blue Boy, take the
- 9:42prize for, you know. Greatest pig, biggest pig,
- 9:45whatever. Melissa wants to see her efforts in
- 9:48the kitchen pay off through the contest as well.
- 9:51And then their children, Margie and Wayne. Wayne
- 9:55has been practicing ever since last year with
- 9:57his mother's embroidery hoops to try and win
- 10:01the hoop game. Yeah. And he got swindled last
- 10:05year by a barker. So he wants to try his best
- 10:08this year. And Margie just wants to have a good
- 10:12time. Yeah. That's all she wants. She has a suitor
- 10:14who's coming to visit her all the time. Who is
- 10:16so annoying. Oh, my God. This guy, he is the
- 10:19Eddie Haskell. He's just like, oh, how are you,
- 10:21Mrs. Frigg? You know when Bobby Hill... Has that,
- 10:25like, he goes to Louisiana. Yeah, yeah. And he's
- 10:28like, this flower is wilted. Yeah, I have the
- 10:32vapors. Like, that is her suitor here. He's so
- 10:36annoying. And honestly, just the way he kind
- 10:37of comes to their house and, like, immediately
- 10:39sits on the couch next to her, the swinging couch
- 10:42outside. Ugh. Yeah, I don't like him at all.
- 10:45And, you know, pretty obvious, Janet Gaynor,
- 10:48not a fan of, what's his name? Harry? Sure. Yeah.
- 10:52Harry sounds right. But it's funny. She's kind
- 10:54of like, he's revolting to her, but it's not
- 10:57until he kind of like butters up better, butters
- 10:59her up a little bit and makes her feel a little
- 11:03more important that you can kind of see her like
- 11:04leaning into his face and like be more accepting
- 11:07of this idea. So I think she's almost kind of
- 11:09like accepting is a good word for it. She's almost
- 11:12kind of like, well, look out here on the farm.
- 11:14What are my options out here on the farm? Isn't
- 11:16that a guns and roses song? Sure. I think it
- 11:19is out here on the farm. Yeah, I gotta look into
- 11:22that. You, like, triggered something in my brain.
- 11:23For some reason, I'm hearing CCR, like, coming
- 11:26around the bend. I like that song, too. Down
- 11:29here on the farm. That's not gonna work. I'm
- 11:32so sorry for the audience. So a couple things
- 11:34about this. I want to point out the things that
- 11:36I really liked about this first. Yeah. That might
- 11:38paint the picture a little bit broadly for the
- 11:40audience, but the way this was filmed was really
- 11:43interesting. They didn't film this entirely at
- 11:47the State Fair. What they did is they actually
- 11:50filmed in two separate stints. The first stint
- 11:52was they filmed at the Iowa State Fair and Exposition
- 11:55for background material. So whenever you see
- 11:58green screens, and there's some obvious green
- 12:01screens here, they didn't film that at the fair.
- 12:04Exactly. Green screen is a funny term. Blue screen,
- 12:07whatever. Well, like there's a... Background.
- 12:09There's a projector. Right. Like playing the...
- 12:13right they weren't doing green screen back then
- 12:15you're absolutely right but the idea of like
- 12:16a background image that isn't actually there
- 12:18in the time being yeah the projector you're right
- 12:20but this would be for the background material
- 12:22and those scenes And then they would film separately
- 12:25the footage later. Background plates, atmospheric
- 12:28shots, race sequence with the horses. Those were
- 12:32all filmed in the first stint at the Iowa State
- 12:33Fair. And then it was filmed afterwards. So that
- 12:37helps it feel like it actually is taking place
- 12:39entirely at a state fair, but also get like the
- 12:42conditions of, you know. The shots that you can't
- 12:44really have a lot of control over with your actors
- 12:47there. You filmed those two things separately.
- 12:49Almost like B -footage in a way. Kind of. Yeah,
- 12:52like a B -roll. But purposefully filmed, of course.
- 12:56Oh, of course. So the opening of this movie,
- 12:58I really like that title crawl or whatever, the
- 13:01title card. Yes. They talk about what's going
- 13:05to happen at the state fair. Love, loss. sheep
- 13:10and blue ribbons or shape and blue eyes and i
- 13:14love that it's you know ma and pa are going to
- 13:16the fair for their competitions with pigs and
- 13:19pickles or whatever but then there's also like
- 13:21the the hopes to find romance in the form of
- 13:25shape and blue eyes i thought that was really
- 13:28clever play on words and yeah it was the movie
- 13:31and it's a little more poetic than the movie
- 13:33tends to be sure I also think that it has a little
- 13:37bit of a tone problem, because that opening does
- 13:41make it seem kind of like this five -star final
- 13:44in the sense of, like, this film takes place
- 13:46in a far -off land or mythical land. Mythical
- 13:49kingdom, I think is what it says. That's how
- 13:52this one kind of opens. And then when it shows
- 13:54the family, it says, we start with the Frigg
- 13:56family. I was like, oh, so this is segmented.
- 13:59Got it. Nope. that's that's it we start and we
- 14:02end we start continue and end yeah with the frake
- 14:05family and that's where we see that like poetic
- 14:07nature and kind of like um fantasy -esque or
- 14:11not fantasy but like you know storytelling aspect
- 14:13of that um feature end is when the family is
- 14:17just introduced and then the entirety of the
- 14:19movie is just the frake family and their day
- 14:22at the fair yeah multiple days multiple days
- 14:25to be clear you're right because what they're
- 14:27doing is they're setting up camp like they're
- 14:29they're literally camping and then going to the
- 14:31fair i wasn't sure if it was a weekend or a series
- 14:33of days because it seemed like it might be longer
- 14:35than just like a friday saturday sunday type
- 14:37thing yeah i'm not sure but it's at least multiple
- 14:39days right right and everyone's there for different
- 14:41reasons obviously you know wayne is excited to
- 14:44do this uh the the game ring a bottle Right.
- 14:48But also he's at the age or rather his sister
- 14:51is at the age Margie where she is interested
- 14:55more in the fair now, but he still has to like
- 14:57take care of her. Yeah. So when she's going to
- 14:59go, he has to be available. And he's like, well,
- 15:02first things first, let me get my money back.
- 15:04Let me stack up a bit and get some money here.
- 15:06I do want to talk about this scene of him with
- 15:10the Barker. playing the game i thought the game
- 15:13the movie was a little sleepy for me leading
- 15:15up to this i mean there's some interesting interactions
- 15:17between melissa and abel right abel yes in the
- 15:21kitchen when okay a moment for abel's um accent
- 15:26in this movie oh will rogers everyone is doing
- 15:30a pretty good job including uh janet gainer who
- 15:33actually has a line that i i wrote down because
- 15:35i thought was interesting when she's talking
- 15:36with her brother there's a scene and i loved
- 15:39this scene where they're walking from the barn.
- 15:43I think it's a barn or at least a little shed
- 15:45where he's practicing. And they're walking towards
- 15:48the house, entirely outside. And they're walking
- 15:51from the barn to a completely opposite side of
- 15:54the farm to the house. And the audio that's captured
- 15:57is perfect. And it's clearly just hovered above
- 15:59them as they're walking. A huge evolution. of
- 16:02where we've been previously of not being able
- 16:04to capture this audio outside when someone's
- 16:06moving, even inside when they're moving. So I
- 16:08thought this was a really like kind of breathtaking,
- 16:10like small feat that I really liked. But while
- 16:13this scene is happening, Janet Gaynor says, sometimes
- 16:16don't you feel like you'd like to go away somewhere
- 16:18and just raise hell? And this was interesting
- 16:23because in a movie that I was like, this is the
- 16:24squeakiest clean kind of idea for a movie that
- 16:27you can make. It was nice to hear like Janet
- 16:30Gaynor, who is trying to be like, you know, the
- 16:31sweet little farm girl. Talk about raising hell.
- 16:34Yeah. And she has like this, like, you know,
- 16:36wild oats that she wants to sow. And I thought
- 16:39that was a very interesting scene. But then that
- 16:41leads to, you know, Will Rogers in the kitchen.
- 16:44And everyone has their accent. This is Iowa after
- 16:47all. But Will Rogers is laying it on. Oatmeal
- 16:51thick. Yeah. Oh, my God. Because Melissa is talking
- 16:55about her mincemeat. She's like, yeah, it's perfect
- 16:57the way it is. And he's like, you ought to add
- 16:59some brandy. And it's so hard to make out what
- 17:02he's saying all the time. And then that brings
- 17:05us to a Three Stooges -esque routine of him adding
- 17:09some brandy while she's on the phone. And then
- 17:11she pours the entire bottle. Yeah. She finds
- 17:14the recipe that does call for brandy. And she's
- 17:16like, oh, my gosh. He was right? Yeah, I need
- 17:19to add some. Just, they go nuts. Well, I thought
- 17:23he went a little nuts, because he's pouring,
- 17:24like, more than a finger. And I was like, that
- 17:27bowl isn't that big. Yeah, well, I think he poured,
- 17:29like, two glugs or swigs or whatever of it, and
- 17:33then she's the one that was like... Oh, she turned
- 17:36it over. Yeah. And just, like, dumped it out.
- 17:38So it was like a whole bottle of brandy. A whole
- 17:40bottle of brandy. And again, not a big bowl.
- 17:42So I was like, this is all Apple Brandy. What
- 17:45are we doing? And then while she's like packaging
- 17:47the mincemeat from the bowl into a container
- 17:49to take with her, there's like a scene that goes
- 17:52on maybe 10 seconds too long of her trying to
- 17:55like stop Abel from being able to see what she's
- 17:57doing. Yeah. She's using her body to block. And
- 17:59he just moves side to side. And it's funny the
- 18:01first five seconds. And as it goes on, you're
- 18:03like, okay, we're done. And it just. meeting
- 18:08like Henry or Harry or whatever his name was,
- 18:10you're just kind of like, okay, yeah, I'm following
- 18:12along. Sure, whatever. The time that I was most
- 18:14invested after that was the Barker scene. Yes.
- 18:17Where Wayne goes and this is where we kind of
- 18:21expect, it's like the 30 minute mark of the movie.
- 18:23You're kind of expecting him to fail here and
- 18:26that sets up the rest of the movie. But instead,
- 18:28imagine my surprise, he cleans house. He does.
- 18:31He absolutely destroys this game and shows that
- 18:35the Barker is like, you know, Absolutely scared.
- 18:37He offers him $3. He's like, look, I'll put a
- 18:39dollar on each of these. And if you get it, great.
- 18:42And that's my little gift to you. And that's
- 18:44to get interest and get people in and play these
- 18:46games. But because Wayne's been here before,
- 18:48he knows what's coming. Right. And he knows to
- 18:50expect that this is not going to go the way that
- 18:52he thinks it is without him being prepared. And
- 18:54thankfully he is. And he cleans house. And this
- 18:57brings us to Emily Joyce. Yeah. And Emily is
- 19:01a trapeze artist. At the time, we're not sure
- 19:05about this, right? No, no, no. It's not until
- 19:07later. She just introduces herself as like, hey,
- 19:09this isn't fair what the Barker is doing to this
- 19:10guy. Yeah. She shows up and she's just like,
- 19:12hey, flirt, flirt, flirt. You're real good at
- 19:15throwing those hoops, kid. Yeah. Yeah. Ultimately,
- 19:18though, we discover that she does work at the
- 19:21state fair and she's a trapeze artist. And this
- 19:25is like the start of their little romance. I
- 19:28want to circle back to when he's playing the
- 19:31game, though. Yeah, yeah. Because while this
- 19:34was the moment that you were like, oh, okay,
- 19:36I'm invested in this story. I agree. I like what
- 19:39happens on screen. But you never see him actually
- 19:42throw the rings. The camera sits on his face
- 19:45and... The second time. The first time when he
- 19:48gets the $3, it shows him throw it and then the
- 19:51camera cuts to him like landing the... Well,
- 19:53not him, but like the ring landing on the bell
- 19:56with the dollar. Does it? Okay. But then the
- 19:58second time that he plays... And of course, the
- 20:01barker is hesitant. He's like, yeah, all right,
- 20:02kid, get out of here. What are you doing? Get
- 20:04out of here. But he's like, hey, I got a dime
- 20:06right here. Let me play. He's like, fine. And
- 20:07he lets him play. And that sequence, that's when
- 20:10Emily is over his shoulder. Whenever he throws
- 20:13it, it doesn't show it. It just shows his reaction.
- 20:16And it's not timed perfectly. No, I have some
- 20:19issues with this movie when it comes to editing.
- 20:21And granted, this is less the editor's fault
- 20:24and more. This is not a perfect restoration of
- 20:27this film. So there's a lot of cuts. There's
- 20:30a lot of things that don't line up perfectly.
- 20:32But this scene specifically doesn't feel like
- 20:34a restoration problem. It feels like an editing
- 20:36issue. Yeah. Where he makes a face of like. Oh,
- 20:39you see that? I got it. A little smug. Like one
- 20:42second before the bell rings. Right. So he's
- 20:44like smug just before it lands. And just in general,
- 20:47like the way that the part that sticks in my
- 20:50mind where the camera doesn't cut at all. So
- 20:52you're just seeing his face. Yes. You can see
- 20:55that he threw and then you just hear the bell
- 20:57ring reaction, whatever. Like there was no innovation
- 21:01there in this shot at all. And this was the moment
- 21:04I said, okay, I like the acting in this movie.
- 21:07I'm invested enough in the story, even though
- 21:11they all are very like small and not really of
- 21:16any big consequence, really. I mean, before we
- 21:20even show up to the fair, you know that Janet
- 21:23Gaynor has boy drama. Yep. Abel has placed a
- 21:27$5 bet on his pig, and then you have the spiked
- 21:29pickle incident. So like you're going in with
- 21:31these little storylines, but... in a way this
- 21:36felt like like an episode of uh oh yeah the andy
- 21:41griffith show or or something similar to that
- 21:43you name dropped a little house on the prairie
- 21:45yeah yeah that's exactly what it kind of felt
- 21:48like but i think that as much as i enjoy like
- 21:51those little made for tv storylines that this
- 21:54felt so much like that moment specifically with
- 21:58the game the the camera movements and things
- 22:00and all of that the setup visually felt so uninspired
- 22:04that i was like okay well i'm only gonna get
- 22:05so much from this yeah yeah i think you're right
- 22:09i mean the one thing i did i don't know if i'm
- 22:12gonna say like but like notice was that there's
- 22:15definitely a farm boy stereotype where wayne
- 22:17is the older brother the older sibling yeah and
- 22:20he goes to play this game and he even says like
- 22:23last year i won a pearl handed revolver but his
- 22:26actions and the way he talks almost makes it
- 22:28sound like he's eight Where when the barker is
- 22:31like, all right, man, you're working me now.
- 22:34You got to get out of here. He's like, well,
- 22:35I have a hard -earned dime, and I've been working
- 22:38so hard to prove you wrong. And everything he
- 22:40says is like, man, you're an adult. You need
- 22:44to chill out a little bit. So when Emily's like,
- 22:46wow, you play really well. I was like, he's kind
- 22:48of childish right now. What do you mean he plays
- 22:50really well? But that scene was interesting to
- 22:52me because it showed, like, whereas any of the
- 22:54state fair was kind of this, the way they were
- 22:57hyping up, at least. And the way you must imagine
- 22:59people feel in the 30s was that this was like
- 23:02the peak of entertainment. Yeah. So the idea
- 23:05of this guy who was like very clearly taking
- 23:07advantage of people, I thought was like an interesting
- 23:09like, oh, we're going to see like the dirty side
- 23:11of the state fair as well. It kind of ends with
- 23:14him a bit. Honestly, he is kind of the corrupt
- 23:17nature, which at the end of the day, the Barker
- 23:19is probably the most, you know, the easiest target
- 23:22for something like that. And that's still the
- 23:24case. You know, you go play a game now and you're
- 23:26like, wait a minute, this hanging challenge,
- 23:28that pole is spinning. Yeah. So how fair is this
- 23:31really? Yeah. And that's kind of where his quest
- 23:34ends. But his new quest is to get the attention
- 23:39of Emily now that he's met her. And that's where
- 23:42he gets to see her perform in her trapeze act.
- 23:44Yeah, which is kind of fun the way that that
- 23:47is filmed. It's almost like you're standing just
- 23:50below. Wow, what is his name? Wayne. You're kind
- 23:54of over his shoulder a little bit. Right, but
- 23:56from like below as well. So you can look up.
- 24:00You're on his shoulder looking up. You're almost
- 24:01behind his shoulder looking up because you can
- 24:03see the outline of his face on the left. Yes.
- 24:05But the focus is Emily spinning. So high up in
- 24:09the air. Exactly. Yeah. I did like that shot.
- 24:11It's a cool shot. Their romance as well is one
- 24:16of the few things, I say few, everything was
- 24:19being targeted by the production code at this
- 24:21time, but it is one of the major components that
- 24:24the production code was against. Ultimately in
- 24:27the book, they do have a very hot and heavy romance
- 24:31and that was altered in this. And now there is
- 24:35the classic pre -code. presentation of you know
- 24:39cut to the next morning and you see somebody
- 24:42buttoning up their shirt or you see like an article
- 24:45of clothing laying at the foot of the bed kind
- 24:47of thing well there's actually an interesting
- 24:49thing here that i'm not sure you caught on to
- 24:51that i really really liked so when wayne and
- 24:54we're kind of jumping ahead a little bit here
- 24:56but when wayne first uh sleeps with emily uh
- 24:59he goes back to her place or at least like a
- 25:01room and he's kind of like you know playing up
- 25:04my ear and she just shows up in lingerie um or
- 25:06her robe and he's taken when she shows up there's
- 25:09a butterfly on the back of her robe and she disrobes
- 25:13and this is their subtle way of like i mean obviously
- 25:17we know where this is implying but it's not just
- 25:19that they sleep together it's that he's losing
- 25:21his virginity and her having the butterfly on
- 25:24her robe and disrobing that shows that metamorphosis
- 25:26for him of that transition for losing your virginity
- 25:30so i thought that was really interesting too
- 25:32because that also felt kind of like a maybe a
- 25:35slight dig of what they can and can't show, of
- 25:38not just, like you said with Aerosmith, that
- 25:41if it's implied, it probably happened. And in
- 25:43this, it's implied, but that disrobe and the
- 25:46butterfly on the robe is just an additional,
- 25:48like, the meaning of this is that not just only
- 25:51have they slept together, but this is his first
- 25:52time, and he's losing that innocence. Yeah, you're
- 25:55getting a little... poetic nature to it as well
- 25:58yeah so i i liked i liked that a lot and i thought
- 26:01that was a really nice touch um that was confirmed
- 26:03later on too that that was an intentional thing
- 26:05to kind of suggest his transformation from his
- 26:08virginity so i thought that was really smart
- 26:10interesting i like that now i think the best
- 26:12way to kind of do this is just tackle each family
- 26:14member because like they bleed back and forth
- 26:17but in reality the sole um story for wayne after
- 26:22the barker incident is really just his relationship
- 26:25with emily yeah and him chasing that and he excuses
- 26:29this with his parents of like oh i'm with some
- 26:32like guys and there's guys we're hanging out
- 26:33with there's a really funny scene with i think
- 26:36abel does a little bit but it's mostly melissa
- 26:38his mom where they have a conversation back at
- 26:41the camp of how he's spending so much time with
- 26:44the boys and she's like oh yeah you're sleeping
- 26:46with him huh he's like maybe like there's little
- 26:50lines that she'll say that are so funny in the
- 26:52context of what's really happening right but
- 26:55she's excusing it of like are they keeping you
- 26:57up all night it's like okay all right i see what
- 27:00we're doing yeah so that was cool um but the
- 27:03way this play bleeds into his sister with margie
- 27:05our beloved janet gainer is that he's supposed
- 27:09to be holding her hand through this he's supposed
- 27:11to be taking her to the state fair and kind of
- 27:13like protecting her through this so ultimately
- 27:15she has to go on her own And when she goes on
- 27:17her own, she finds herself on a roller coaster
- 27:19with our boy Lou Ayers. Yes. And I got to tell
- 27:23you, this movie was pretty slow for me and I
- 27:27wasn't really rocking with it. Any rating that
- 27:29I give this movie that we talk about, I want
- 27:32you to go ahead and count a full star for the
- 27:34chemistry between Janet Gaynor and Lou Ayers.
- 27:36Yeah. This is where the movie is dynamite is
- 27:39not just their story, but they're like chemistry.
- 27:42A hundred percent. And that's the funny thing.
- 27:44I feel like we spent so much time talking about
- 27:46Wayne and his relationship with Emily. I don't
- 27:50care. I'm not interested at all. This to me,
- 27:54like Abel and is it Melissa? Yes. Like their
- 27:58competition stories and stuff. They're fun. They're
- 28:01cute. It's all side plot. They provide a couple
- 28:04laughs. Yeah. I am here for Janet and Lou and
- 28:07they have such a nice memorable meet cute. On
- 28:12this roller coaster. Because Janet gets on. Is
- 28:14she trying to kill herself, by the way? I don't
- 28:17think so. I didn't understand this. They need
- 28:19the height requirements on this ride, though.
- 28:21Because Janet Gaynor is tiny. I was shocked when
- 28:25I saw her on screen. And I don't know if it's
- 28:28just perspective. Or she happens to be standing
- 28:31next to the tallest man in the history of the
- 28:33universe. But she's itty bitty. She is. And the
- 28:37reason I asked that question is when they're
- 28:39on the roller coaster, she sits next to them.
- 28:41And there's actually, I don't know if you went
- 28:43back and watched this, in the introduction of
- 28:45her, their meet cute, Lou Ayers is actually hidden
- 28:50behind someone. So you can't see him. And his
- 28:52hat's kind of down a little bit, almost like
- 28:53an Indiana Jones type thing. And he's just sitting
- 28:56there waiting. And I kind of liked the reveal
- 28:59of this, of like his character sitting next to
- 29:01her. Like we're supposed to know him, but he's
- 29:03just hidden. So you're not even thinking, okay,
- 29:05who's she sitting next to? Yeah. Like that. But
- 29:07as the roller coaster goes. There's another shot.
- 29:10And this is the other shot of the movie where
- 29:12I was like, this is like breathtaking. They mounted
- 29:14a camera on the roller coaster itself, which,
- 29:17you know, makes sense. And then you see the footage
- 29:19of like the first person of like the roller coaster
- 29:20going up the hill. And then a scene I'm going
- 29:23to get to. But the first thing that happens is
- 29:26that the camera is mounted on the actual ride
- 29:30itself. And it's facing the patrons who are riding.
- 29:34Yeah. And it catches the car as it's coming out
- 29:37of the port. Like, leading up to the ramp. Yep.
- 29:39And this was almost cooler than, like, it actually
- 29:42being on, like, the roller coaster itself to
- 29:44see the way it, like, took off. Because they
- 29:46could have done anything else. And to just mount
- 29:47it and capture, like, the natural lighting of
- 29:50them coming out of, like, the port and then,
- 29:52like, back up that, I thought was so cool. Because
- 29:54Lou Ayers is, like, hidden in this, too. He's,
- 29:57like, shadowed naturally. And it was just such
- 29:59a, like, simple little, like, didn't mean anything,
- 30:02but just such a cool little shot. And that leads
- 30:04to them going up the first hill. And at the very
- 30:07top of the hill, there's a sign that says, do
- 30:10not stand. Right. And Janet Gaynor's like, that
- 30:13doesn't mean anything to me. I can't read. And
- 30:16she stands up. And the only way that I can kind
- 30:19of decipher this is something that Lou Ayers
- 30:21says afterwards, where he pulls her down. And
- 30:23he says something that's a little misogynistic,
- 30:25but he was like, women, they love the thrill
- 30:28of danger, but they can't ever commit. Or something
- 30:31like that. I kind of took that as like she's
- 30:34trying to kind of like raise hell to her point.
- 30:37Right. She's just trying to do something she's
- 30:39not supposed to do. She sees a sign that says
- 30:40do not stand. She's like, well, here I go standing.
- 30:42Yeah. But my first thought is you're going to
- 30:44get decapitated. Like if you stand right at the
- 30:46sign that says do not stand, you're decapitated.
- 30:48Sure. So maybe don't do that. But he brings her
- 30:51down and then just kind of talks her through.
- 30:53And then he's like, hey, you're going to write
- 30:54it again. And this is kind of the beginning of
- 30:56the chemistry of like he protects her. Then ultimately,
- 30:58are you going to do it again? You should do it
- 30:59again. You should try again. Yeah. And I really
- 31:02liked this. What about their chemistry stood
- 31:03out to you? I think that the way he promotes
- 31:07like what she wants to be doing. Yes. He supports
- 31:10it. She wants to raise hell. And he's like, hey,
- 31:13that was pretty dumb what you just did. Let's
- 31:16ride it again, though. Like, I know what you're
- 31:19looking for, this thrill, this excitement. I
- 31:21support that. But I also I'm going to be there
- 31:23for you. And I just think that he spends a lot
- 31:26of time sweet talking her in a way that doesn't
- 31:29feel like. Like there's a motive behind it. Like
- 31:33he seems genuinely interested in her. And I think
- 31:36that it helps that I think Lou Ayers is like
- 31:39a hunk. Janet Gaynor, obviously, since episode
- 31:43one of this podcast, I think we've both been
- 31:46like, she's. Very cute. Yeah. They just, they
- 31:48work so well together, and I really enjoyed seeing
- 31:51them together. I think that's a great meet -cute,
- 31:53too. It is. We get to know a little bit more
- 31:56about Pat Gilbert himself. So he's a reporter.
- 31:58He's a journalist, actually, at something called
- 32:01The Register. He mentions this is a Republican
- 32:03publication, but not to hold that against him.
- 32:05I really liked his character. I think he's good
- 32:09on his own. She's good on her own. But their
- 32:12chemistry is so undeniable in this that you're
- 32:14right. Whenever it cuts back to Wayne, he's like,
- 32:16yeah, I think I'm really interested in Emily.
- 32:17You're like, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. All right,
- 32:19move along. Let's move along. And thankfully,
- 32:21they don't give us too much with Abel and Melissa
- 32:23until like maybe the 75 % way mark. Right. Like
- 32:27three fourths through. Then they start focusing
- 32:30a bit more on their contests and everything,
- 32:31which we can get into. But like the log line
- 32:34of this movie is that the chemistry between.
- 32:36Lou Ayers and Janet Gaynor is just unbelievable.
- 32:39It's so good. I think that it's good that these
- 32:42contests exist in this movie because it does
- 32:45break up what could eventually turn into melodrama.
- 32:49There is some comedy there. The pickle contest
- 32:51is fun enough. You know, the judges really like
- 32:55this food that Melissa has made because, of course,
- 32:59it spiked with so much alcohol. Right. She ends
- 33:01up winning in every category she enters in. They
- 33:05very, very rushed the idea of an introduction
- 33:10of who normally would win. Yeah. And there's
- 33:14someone right over their shoulder at all times
- 33:15who very loudly is like, I can't wait to win.
- 33:18Yeah. And you're like, okay, great. This is the
- 33:19person to beat. And not only does she win in
- 33:22every category, I think there's three separate
- 33:23things and then an overall. So four total. Not
- 33:26only does she win in those, but she gets first
- 33:28place over. The person who normally wins who
- 33:31got second place. Just completely sweeps. Absolutely
- 33:33sweeps. And this is like the Oscars for pickles.
- 33:37It is the Oscars for pickles. And I do want to
- 33:40point out, I'm sure this is done for laughs,
- 33:42but the absolute length of time that was taken
- 33:45to show the judges eating the pickles. Right.
- 33:49To a point, I was like, is this the joke? Is
- 33:51the joke that like we're on this shot for like
- 33:5445 seconds of just them like not munching on
- 33:57pickles, but just like a straight up. Like, just
- 33:59a little bite. Yeah. And then just, like, chew,
- 34:01chew, chew, chew for so long. And the moment
- 34:04that I knew it was a joke is when they bring
- 34:05out someone who sprays what I can only assume
- 34:08is, like, water or, like, air. Yeah, it's like
- 34:10a palate cleanser. Like a palate cleanser. And
- 34:13into their mouth directly through, like, a little,
- 34:14like, puff. And then they have to, like, breathe
- 34:16through it. My favorite thing about this, though,
- 34:18and it's almost in the background. Like, it's
- 34:20not the forefront of the shot, is the fourth
- 34:23person that he goes to do this to is to the guy
- 34:25eating the mincemeat. When they do this for the
- 34:28mincemeat, everyone has that puff. And then for
- 34:30the guy, the first guy who eats the mincemeat,
- 34:32he's the dude who gets a whole, like, not spoon,
- 34:35ladle full. And then just starts eating from
- 34:37the ladle. Right. He's obsessed with it. And
- 34:40when they cut to him. or they cut to the shot.
- 34:42He's in the background and the puffer goes up
- 34:45to him to puff in his mouth and he just waves
- 34:46him off. He's like, no, I want to live with this.
- 34:48Thought that was great. And I liked that aspect.
- 34:50So there's good comedy in this, but there are
- 34:53some scenes that last a little too long. I think
- 34:55there being four awards and all of them being
- 34:57the exact same thing of like, first place is
- 35:00Melissa Frake of this and then second place is
- 35:02this. That scene's just like five minutes. Yeah.
- 35:04Does not need to be that long. You know, we just
- 35:06talked about She Done Him Wrong and it's the
- 35:08shortest length nominee of all time. I think,
- 35:11this one would have done well at right around
- 35:12the 65 minute mark. And you could have trimmed
- 35:15off a lot of these, like the judges eating pickles
- 35:18or a big one for me is when you get to the pig
- 35:21competition and you have the judges introduced,
- 35:24like they're the Avengers. We got to talk about
- 35:28one, one of those. You're right. The way they're
- 35:30introduced is kind of like the heroes have arrived.
- 35:32Yeah. And there's one judge who I think is wearing,
- 35:36I'm trying to find my best way to describe him
- 35:38to you. I think he's wearing white pants. There's
- 35:40a moment where he's judging Blue Boy. And this
- 35:44guy is just getting his calisthenics in, man.
- 35:46Like he is just like, he's leaning so far to
- 35:49the ground with his one leg extended out. And
- 35:51he's just like trying to get all angles of this
- 35:53pig. And the shots of him just almost look like
- 35:56a Michael Jackson music video. Yeah. Of like,
- 35:58check out what I can do. And you're like, what
- 36:00is he doing? It's so funny to me. And it has
- 36:03absolutely nothing to do with anything. Like,
- 36:05I was like, can we get back to, like, Janet Gaynor
- 36:07real quick instead of just this dude who's, like,
- 36:09lunging to see underneath a pig? And here's the
- 36:12thing. Like, this is the Iowa State Fair. This
- 36:15is a monumental fair. And historically, this
- 36:18has always been one of the biggest fairs in the
- 36:21country. So there's part of me that wonders,
- 36:24were any of these judges, like, important people
- 36:27that we should know? Well, like, was one of these
- 36:30the mayor of this town? Oh, I see. Or, you know,
- 36:34like. government officials or something i thought
- 36:37you meant like famed iowa state fair pig judge
- 36:40which who knows maybe it is like that could be
- 36:43the extent of like how big this fair is where
- 36:46everybody knows the main judge of the hog competition
- 36:50i gotta tell you if that's true and that one
- 36:54judge i'm talking about is like a famed judge
- 36:56i know it was his idea to be like what if i lunged
- 36:59a lot he's like well this is what i do normally
- 37:02so and there's no way that's true And he's just
- 37:04like, what if I get, I need screen time, babe.
- 37:06Yeah. Lou, Lou airs and Janet Gaynor in this
- 37:09movie. How am I going to compete? She's like.
- 37:12Show off those gams. And he does like the anti
- 37:16-gravity thing almost, but with one leg. He's
- 37:18got his fedora down. It's so funny. So that scene
- 37:21stood out to me pretty heavily. Thank you for
- 37:23bringing that up. You know, it's funny because
- 37:26we talked about how this was an adaptation, but
- 37:28also was adapted two more times after this for
- 37:31the film, or for the screen. 1945 and 1962. And
- 37:35confirmed, both of those are musicals. And I
- 37:38haven't seen either of those versions yet, but
- 37:39I have to imagine having seen this, a musical,
- 37:42I don't want to say schtick, but application
- 37:44to this really might change the pacing problems
- 37:47that I have with it. Yeah. Now, if it makes it
- 37:49two hours, we've gone backwards. Sure. But I
- 37:53think that might change the pacing of this because
- 37:54obviously you see the musical aspect behind Margie
- 37:59and Pat. But also I could see like a song between
- 38:02like Emily and Wayne or like a song for Wayne,
- 38:05a song for like the hog contest. Like there's
- 38:07a lot that can be done for that. So I'm interested
- 38:09in watching the musicals now because I think
- 38:11that might help pick up the pace on this that
- 38:13otherwise it does have a pacing problem. Yeah,
- 38:16I would love to see the musicals because I want
- 38:18to know if there is a pig number. I believe that
- 38:21at least one of the musicals is on Tubi. Okay,
- 38:24cool. Because I was looking this up. It was very
- 38:25like I had to be specific. So like no, the 1933
- 38:28version. Right. So the pigs. The pigs. Swine
- 38:32time. Yeah. Swine time, baby. Swine time. Like
- 38:36we said at the top of the show, there is a back
- 38:38and forth with two pigs. And it really is like
- 38:42the speed of these cuts back and forth just escalates
- 38:47until it's like pop, pop, pop, pop. Like I would
- 38:50almost argue that the chemistry between the pigs
- 38:52is only outmatched by Lou and Janet. Yeah. It
- 38:57feels like. the the music from kill bill anytime
- 39:01she sees one of the cobra units yeah and she's
- 39:04just she's seeing red and she's got blood like
- 39:08that's what's happening with these pigs it is
- 39:12it is palpable it's crazy and ultimately abel
- 39:16and blue boy take home the win and it's this
- 39:19big thing the whole movie too blue boy has been
- 39:22sick and you're kind of following this story
- 39:25of a sick pig yeah it's I don't know. I get it.
- 39:29I get how this could be fun. And like, especially
- 39:32in a time during depression, you see these very,
- 39:35very relatable human people in this country just
- 39:38trying to go and enjoy their time at the state
- 39:41fair. And the most traumatic thing being, well,
- 39:44the pig is sick or, oh, I really boozed up these
- 39:47pickles. This is some high intensity drama. For
- 39:52an Iowa family. Right. When the pig does win.
- 39:55Um, everybody's celebrating and everybody's happy.
- 39:58People are literally leaping out of this, like
- 40:00the audience area. Yeah. To go greet the pig
- 40:03and Abel. And clearly this is too much for the
- 40:07pig because we've got an all out pig brawl. There's
- 40:10bacon bits flying everywhere. Like it's intense.
- 40:13Hog hustle. Yeah. And, and then it ends and it
- 40:16just, it's over. Well, I mean, it's, it's very,
- 40:20I guess the word is interesting because at times
- 40:23it's very funny. And then other times I'm like.
- 40:25It's almost like Traderhorn, where you're like,
- 40:27how'd you get this shot of the pigs fighting?
- 40:28Yeah. Well, the good news is that we just had
- 40:30them fight. We just made the pigs fight. And
- 40:32you're like, what? All right. I don't think I
- 40:35want to know how you did that. Yeah. There's
- 40:37also a couple jokes in there that are definitely
- 40:39intentional, but just kind of felt weird, where
- 40:41April, I think, is saying something about, yeah,
- 40:44well, Blue Boy's going to help me bring home
- 40:46the bacon. I was like, oh, no. Because Blue Boy's
- 40:50probably like, what? I just made a bacon bits
- 40:52joke. You're doing the same thing. I'm guilty
- 40:56as charged. But there's something comical, admirable
- 41:00maybe, about Henry King including footage of
- 41:04like, all right, so here's where we have the
- 41:07fight. And they're like, great. So the fight's
- 41:09just going to happen because they're pigs, right?
- 41:10He's like, no. There's a conversation that's
- 41:12had between them. And we're going to film it
- 41:14this way. Great. So there's one camera angle
- 41:16where we have the two pigs looking at each other
- 41:17and we just assume they're talking, right? No.
- 41:19I want one shot of Blue Boy. And then I need
- 41:22another shot of this pig. And we're going to
- 41:23cut back and forth. And they're going to be oinking
- 41:26at each other the whole time. So much of this
- 41:29movie, not just swine time, is oinking. And it's
- 41:32just a lot of sniffing and huffing. Because these
- 41:35are not pigs. These are hogs. They're big. They
- 41:38are hogs. And they're just making a lot of grunting
- 41:40noises throughout. Literally almost just did
- 41:44it. And I'm so happy I didn't. But there's just
- 41:46a lot of grunting noises through this movie.
- 41:48And that... Not just the fight, but the lead
- 41:52up between Blue Boy and this other pig is just
- 41:55grunt city. It's intense. It is nuts. And it's
- 41:59almost, again, admirable of them being like,
- 42:02I want to know what the story was. Because I
- 42:04know that Henry King and someone, at least the
- 42:06cinematographer, was like, all right, he did
- 42:08him wrong. Yeah. He's like an old distant cousin
- 42:11and they have, pardon the pun here, beef between
- 42:15each other. And this is what's going to lead
- 42:18to their ultimate escalation. Because it could
- 42:20just be their pigs. Just let them fight. But
- 42:23instead, it almost feels like the end of Rocky,
- 42:25where it's like one pig, one of the other didn't.
- 42:27Yeah. And go. Scene. It's a lot of pig time.
- 42:32Swine time. You know how in Guardians of the
- 42:35Galaxy, Groot, like he has lines. Yeah. Even
- 42:39when he says, I am Groot, like he's supposed
- 42:40to be saying. They're decipherable. Exactly.
- 42:42I want to know. If there is a cut of this movie
- 42:45where the blue boy has like the dirtiest lines.
- 42:50You know what I would love is if he ends up having
- 42:52the lines that are more poetry like in the beginning
- 42:54when it's like we start with the Frank family
- 42:56or the Frank family. Yeah. Where it's him being
- 42:58like, my dearest, you have done me wrong. And
- 43:01that shows that for him. Yep. Great. Different
- 43:03movie altogether. Man, what if we did a commentary
- 43:06track one day of this movie? Of State Fair? Yeah,
- 43:09we just added or even if we just added subtitles
- 43:11to all the pig talk. You know what we should
- 43:13do is we should take every movie that has swine
- 43:16time in it, and we should do that. Yeah. Just
- 43:19add dialogue. Translate the pig talk. Babe, I
- 43:22think we would just have to, like, recite the
- 43:23movie. Yeah, I mean, if the pig actually talks,
- 43:26like, our work here is done. Do you quote Babe
- 43:29at all? I go, yeah, yeah! Yeah, you know me too.
- 43:39No, I've... That's honestly the funniest thing
- 43:43I've ever done. No, my brother and I, and I've
- 43:46gotten Taylor to do it too, we do the transition
- 43:48scene with the mice all the time. Yeah. You know
- 43:51what I'm talking about? The three days later.
- 43:53Right. We do that all the time just to show the
- 43:56passing of time. That's good. I can't remember
- 43:58if that's Babe or Babe Pig in the City, but I
- 44:00think it's both Babe. Can you tell me who directed
- 44:03Babe Pig in the City? Oh, I don't remember. You
- 44:05don't? No. Do you know? Take one guess. Just
- 44:07one guess. Sidney Lumet. Oh, wow. No, you're
- 44:14wrong. The director of Mad Max Fury Road. That's
- 44:19way better. Frank... No, that's wrong. I'm getting
- 44:23that wrong. George Miller. George Miller. I almost
- 44:25said Frank Miller. I was thinking Sin City. Yeah,
- 44:26yeah. George Miller. That's correct. Which means
- 44:29Mad Max, Happy Feet, and Babe Pig in the City.
- 44:33Yeah. And Furiosa. Wow. What a career. What a
- 44:36career. I don't think he did Babe. Incredible.
- 44:38Do you think... What do you think he thinks the
- 44:41pigs are saying in this movie? Oh, I think he
- 44:43did exactly. I think he's a man of genius like
- 44:45we are. Do you think Blue Boy is just like, witness
- 44:48me? Well, Blue Boy, first off, is a fantastic
- 44:50name for a Mad Max character. Yeah. So he's already
- 44:52like halfway there. Man, George Miller's State
- 44:57Fair. Yeah, I checked that out. Now that's something
- 44:59I want to see. I just. Witness me. Can you imagine
- 45:02Emily like spinning at the top during her act?
- 45:05Witness me. Witness me. Listen, we've talked
- 45:08a lot about pigs, and I think that is a great
- 45:12example of this movie. Do you want to hear more
- 45:15about Janet Gaynor and Lou Ayers? Because we
- 45:18do. We did. But we had to sit through all this
- 45:20pig content. Which is equally great. Very excited
- 45:24about pig swine time. This is going to be the
- 45:27weirdest episode for people. I'm for it. I want
- 45:30to hear how much stays of your babe impression.
- 45:37Yeah, you know, the only other thing I want to
- 45:39mention with this is the ending of this movie.
- 45:42It has the romantic ending, even in the rain.
- 45:45Like, it's raining outside, so this is the reunion
- 45:48between Pat, right? Pat and Margie? Right, yes.
- 45:52This scene is just like straight romance. It's
- 45:55exactly what you expected it to be. We didn't
- 45:57think we could be together, but now we can. Fantastic.
- 45:59The thing I really want to talk about is the
- 46:01very end. The last shot. There's a billboard
- 46:04behind them for State Fair. Yeah. And this is
- 46:07great because it kind of acts as like the, you
- 46:09know, this is the end of the movie, State Fair.
- 46:12But then as they leave the shot and it lingers
- 46:16on the billboard for State Fair, the rain causes
- 46:19the poster to start peeling off of the board
- 46:23and it slowly reveals the end behind it. Right.
- 46:26Beautiful. So good. Loved that. And it felt,
- 46:29you know, I mean, I'm sure there's some production
- 46:31behind it, but it felt like such a cool little
- 46:33detail to throw in there. I loved that aspect.
- 46:37So there's some filmmaking to this that I really
- 46:39appreciated, but ultimately the story basically
- 46:42of anyone other than Janet, even here's the tough
- 46:45thing. Janet and Janet Gaynor were cool like
- 46:49that. And Lou Ayers, their chemistry is off the
- 46:53charts, but their story is like fine. Yeah, yeah.
- 46:56And I think that's kind of the whole movie. I
- 46:58mentioned in the last episode someone's remark
- 47:01about she done him wrong. And this is when movies
- 47:05that shouldn't have been nominated for Best Picture
- 47:07were getting nominated. And this really feels
- 47:09like one of those where it's such a small story
- 47:12and of little to no consequence that I don't
- 47:17fully understand it. It's cute. It's fun. It
- 47:20has a few laughs. And I do enjoy Janet Gaynor
- 47:23and Lou Ayers. But that's kind of the extent
- 47:26of it with this movie. It really doesn't go much
- 47:28further than that. No. And I think the most exciting
- 47:31part of this movie is this, like, romantic ending.
- 47:34Because everybody's at home and, you know, the
- 47:37winners are celebrating their ribbons and all
- 47:40of that. And then Harry once again shows up and
- 47:43he's just like, well, hello, my little petunia.
- 47:46And you're like, blah. Yeah, what's even funnier
- 47:49about that scene is he does show up and he does
- 47:51say all those things and is very cringy. And
- 47:54he's like, yes, give me just one second, my dear.
- 47:56I love you so much. Hey, Abel, that bet we made.
- 48:00Yeah. He's like, do I have my $5 coming or what?
- 48:03And I did like how it almost felt like he dropped
- 48:05the veil a little bit and was just like, I'm
- 48:08really here for the bet, man. The gamble is all
- 48:10I was here for. It is good. But yeah, the phone
- 48:13rings and at first Margie. ignores it and then
- 48:16when she sees that harry is walking up she's
- 48:19like i'll get the phone picks it up and that's
- 48:21where harry pat pat's his name i almost forgot
- 48:24pat calls pat's on the phone and and this part
- 48:28this does feel like pat died in a car accident
- 48:30yeah did you pick that up at first yes but then
- 48:33janet gainer like it's her big opportunity to
- 48:36really act and and showcase like joy and emotion
- 48:40and love but she's just talking to the phone
- 48:43You can't hear what Pat is saying on the other
- 48:45end, so at first you do think the worst, but
- 48:48then she's elated and she's excited. It's a little
- 48:51cringy for me, if I'm being honest. Yeah. Again,
- 48:54it's not a great execution. And that's why I
- 48:56think, like, I want to preface that their chemistry
- 48:58is phenomenal. But their story that's behind
- 49:01it is just kind of, like, okay. Yeah. Like, I
- 49:03do like the idea of small town, like, farm girl,
- 49:07like, being in a relationship with a guy who
- 49:09is a reporter, who has seen the world, has traveled
- 49:12the world, interviewed, like, political figures.
- 49:14Yeah. And has, like, the adventure that she's
- 49:18looking for. opportunity for her. And I like
- 49:23that idea, but the story of just their budding
- 49:26romance in the state fair doesn't really go much
- 49:29further than their own chemistry. Yeah, small
- 49:31potatoes. And I think that that's indicative
- 49:33of the writing, not just the writing, but how
- 49:36flimsy the story is, that even a chemistry this
- 49:40good can't save that. But it is certainly worth
- 49:44the price of admission just to see their chemistry.
- 49:46Yeah, I definitely agree with that. Again, it's
- 49:49cute. It just feels like a made -for -TV, at
- 49:52most, like a season finale. I do want to take
- 49:55the time, as we're wrapping up here, to say that
- 49:58one benefit of being on the Discord with us is
- 50:01that we have the option to talk about these movies
- 50:03in real time, including where Bryce, longtime
- 50:07friend and patron of the pod, has commented something
- 50:10about the Cimarron book, and I mentioned... Hey,
- 50:13we're recording right now. Do you have anything
- 50:15you want to say? And Bryce's exact words, I don't
- 50:18have anything to say about State Fair, but man,
- 50:20do I love Janet Gaynor in that. There you go.
- 50:23That's the perfect review. Yeah. That might be
- 50:26his review, actually, now that I'm thinking.
- 50:27Maybe he's just reading it. I will say, as excited
- 50:33as I was. to see Janet Gaynor at the top of this
- 50:35movie, she, she does play like young girl in
- 50:38this. So there is kind of that element that I'm
- 50:41like, Oh man, this reporter has been all over
- 50:43the world. And you know, here he is talking to
- 50:46this 16, 17 year old girl. Yeah. Probably. It's
- 50:50not explicitly said, but again, when Wayne kind
- 50:52of behaves like an eight year old at the, the,
- 50:54the, the toss game or the hoop game and she's
- 50:57the younger sister. Yeah. You're like, it just
- 51:00feels really weird. This is getting rough. Yeah.
- 51:02But again, I, I just really love Janet Gaynor.
- 51:05I think she's fantastic. Bryce did point out,
- 51:08too, that Iowa... This is all in caps, by the
- 51:10way, but I'm not going to scream it. The Iowa
- 51:11State Fair is still a huge deal, like, to today,
- 51:14to this day. His in -laws live there, and, like,
- 51:18every year it's like a holiday. So it is, like,
- 51:20a very large deal. I think for us, like, with
- 51:22a state fair in Georgia, we're like, oh, yeah,
- 51:24maybe I'll make it down there, and then you never
- 51:26do. But with an Iowa State Fair, it sounds like,
- 51:28to this day... Is it still a similar, like, we're
- 51:31going to camp out and, like, go to the state
- 51:33fair? Right. Is it, like, Woodstock every year?
- 51:35Yeah. Based on him responding all caps, it sounds
- 51:38like it's, like, Coachella up there. See? And,
- 51:40you know, maybe I would support the Georgia State
- 51:42Fair more if they supported goldfish more. It's
- 51:46funny that you doubled back to goldfish, because
- 51:48I feel like swine time is where we really spend
- 51:50the majority of our animal rights. As far as
- 51:52I know, they let them ride the sky trolley. It's
- 51:54just the fish. So, imagine a blue boy. on the
- 51:58trapeze act up there yeah swinging around him
- 52:02having beef with someone underneath yeah i'd
- 52:06hate to be underneath blue boy oh my god so i'm
- 52:10gonna not linger on this because i think i've
- 52:12described my feelings on it well enough yeah
- 52:14i think so i gave this three stars i think it
- 52:17is like the perfect middle of the road just cute
- 52:20little made for tv movie it feels like yeah i
- 52:24wasn't as uh i was a little lower on this i was
- 52:26two and a half Two and a half stars on this one,
- 52:29and that feels fair, especially with me talking
- 52:31about three stars for She Done Him Wrong and
- 52:33probably a little bit higher. I enjoyed She Done
- 52:35Him Wrong more than State Fair, but again, that's
- 52:40not the indicator of a bad movie or anything.
- 52:43The chemistry is so good in this that it's worth
- 52:47watching alone for their chemistry. But then
- 52:50everything else around it, even though there's
- 52:52some cool shots that I really liked with the
- 52:53roller coaster aspect. And I really liked the
- 52:56production angle of how they filmed it two separate
- 52:58times. It just feels like something's missing
- 53:00in this. And that's what makes me very interested
- 53:02in the musical adaptations that come after this
- 53:04to see if they fill in the gaps and find where
- 53:06that's wrong. But the reason that it feels like
- 53:09kind of a bad omen to do that is you're not going
- 53:12to have this chemistry between Lou Ayers and
- 53:15Jan Gaynor. Yeah, I'm curious. I don't know who
- 53:19stars in the other two films, but... I want to
- 53:21say Judy Garland might be in one of them. That's
- 53:24interesting. Okay. Maybe. I might be thinking
- 53:26of Meet Me in St. Louis. That would be very interesting
- 53:29because Janet Gaynor goes on to be in A Star
- 53:32is Born and then Judy Garland is in a remake
- 53:34of that. I would love to see Janet Gaynor's Wizard
- 53:37of Oz. Man, I think if she had been younger when
- 53:41that movie was being filmed, she would have been
- 53:43a shoo -in for it. You know who's in... Janet
- 53:46Gaynor's adaptation, you know who's going to
- 53:48play Toto? Wallace Beery? That's such a better
- 53:51answer than I was going to say. Blue Boy. Oh,
- 53:53yeah, that's good, too. That's really good. Or
- 53:56maybe we're the flying monkeys. Blue Boy's going
- 53:59to play the flying monkey? Probably. Man, imagine
- 54:01that swooping down and just, like, just crushing
- 54:06the Scarecrow. I'm also just imagining, like,
- 54:08when the Munchkins show up and they do the whole
- 54:10lollipop guild and everything. Yeah. That, like,
- 54:13just with absolutely zero context, like, Blue
- 54:15Boy is just. sitting like standing among them
- 54:17right not moving or anything not even dancing
- 54:19just standing there in like the suspenders and
- 54:21everything like he's got the curly hair this
- 54:25might be the most unhinged episode we've had
- 54:27and it's for like the most vanilla state yeah
- 54:29it's it's cute like that's about any of the mincemeat
- 54:33with the apple brandy in it is that what happened
- 54:35maybe that's what it is that judge that like
- 54:37scarfed it down i like the the newspaper headline
- 54:39where it's like he's in bed like mad I thought
- 54:43this was a nice touch, especially with Melissa
- 54:45and Abel, where Abel's like, yeah, did you see
- 54:48about that judge where he basically passed out
- 54:51because he had a hangover from all the mincemeat
- 54:53he ate? She's like, oh, yeah, that's really weird.
- 54:55He's like, yeah, it's super weird, huh? So weird.
- 54:58But it's funny because with him, he's like, I
- 55:00don't think I added that much apple brandy with
- 55:02her. She's like, I might have lethally dosed
- 55:05this man with apple brandy. The newspaper headline
- 55:08is like... Man runs out into street crazed on
- 55:11apple brandy mincemeat and gets trampled by fire
- 55:14department horse and carriage. Daughter dancing
- 55:16in white dress and couldn't be bothered. Blue
- 55:18boy dancing in white dress can't be bothered.
- 55:21This episode. I appreciate everyone listening.
- 55:23Yeah. This is good. Thanks guys. State fair is
- 55:26worth your time. If not just for the chemistry.
- 55:28Yeah. And again, in a year where we're talking
- 55:30about cavalcade, it's just, it's hard to kind
- 55:33of look at this and say bad. It's just not as
- 55:35enjoyable. This is a highlight compared to cavalcade.
- 55:38Correct. You can find it physical media. Fox
- 55:41put out a DVD. You can. That's about it. I'm
- 55:43looking for it. I'm excited to have that one
- 55:46because it's not too bad. Again, I'm interested
- 55:48to see the adaptations in 45 and 62. Totally.
- 55:52Let's talk about double features. Pretty excited
- 55:54about mine. Yeah. How do you feel about yours?
- 55:56Is this the one that took you a second to find
- 55:58one? That was the last one. Okay. Wow. That was
- 56:01a pretty good double feature for just man. Appreciate
- 56:03it. Let's see if you keep it up. Yeah. Who's
- 56:06going first? You'll go first. Okay. So I went
- 56:08with the concept of like an event being the highlight
- 56:12of the movie. Obviously you have the state fair.
- 56:14This is a big deal. And everything in this movie
- 56:17revolves around this event. Something similar
- 56:21to that is kind of like when you're in school.
- 56:27And you're like, man, I really hate school, but
- 56:30we're supposed to get some bad weather tomorrow.
- 56:32It'd be really cool if school got canceled. Stop
- 56:35it. So I went with the 2000 Nickelodeon film
- 56:40Snow Day. Yes, sir. It's been a long time since
- 56:43I've seen this. This might be the worst movie
- 56:46ever. I don't remember. I got to tell you, man,
- 56:48you're not even done, and I'm going to let you
- 56:49finish. This episode, with everything that we've
- 56:52done, everything we've talked about, everything
- 56:53we've joked about, and you pair it with Snow
- 56:55Day? I mean, what are we doing? What can I say?
- 56:58We are, we can't be stopped. Yeah, this is, it's
- 57:02just a fun movie of like these kids and their
- 57:05antics when they have a snow day and it kind
- 57:07of has everything. I remember like the older
- 57:09brother having a crush on the neighbor girl.
- 57:13I'm totally going to destroy her name. Emmanuel
- 57:17Shikari? Shiraki? Yeah, I mean. I mean, I had
- 57:22the biggest crush on her. when i was a kid watching
- 57:25that movie i mean still she's beautiful no no
- 57:27kidding like i i would say i re -watched this
- 57:29movie many times as a kid that must have been
- 57:33like 90 of the reason i re -watched it she's
- 57:36great and they have like a great like um it's
- 57:38one thing when she's uh like obviously beautiful
- 57:41but then when she has that like great scene where
- 57:43like they connect and they have like a great
- 57:44relationship i think it's like in the indoor
- 57:46pool or something it's great um Great movie.
- 57:49I haven't seen this in so long. Yeah, I mean,
- 57:51there's not much to say. It's just a collection
- 57:53of antics happening on this particular thing.
- 57:57Which, perfect for State Fair. That's it. That's
- 58:00all it is. I was literally just talking with
- 58:01my friend last night about what makes for a five
- 58:03-star movie for me. And I was like, look, technical
- 58:06aspects, emotional resonance, like, it all has
- 58:09to be there. But at the same time, Good Burger
- 58:12is a five -star movie for me. Sure. And as is
- 58:15something like Snow Day. So, I mean, granted,
- 58:17it's probably not when I'm, you know, 37 looking
- 58:19back on it. But still, I loved it. I'd be curious
- 58:21to see if there's a pig in Snow Day. Even briefly.
- 58:23It's the only thing missing. I think a character
- 58:25eats bologna at some point. Well, that's beef
- 58:28usually. Carry on. Anyways, I went in a similar
- 58:33direction, not quite, but pretty similar with
- 58:36my double feature. I also looked at the idea,
- 58:38not so much an event, I guess technically an
- 58:40event, more a destination. Okay. And the family
- 58:42that gets involved in this, and also how that
- 58:46family, the movie follows them in separate stories
- 58:48and how that kind of like bleeds together. But
- 58:51I chose the 1997 film directed by Stephen Kessler,
- 58:55Vegas Vacation. This was much like Snow Day,
- 58:58another classic in my family household when I
- 59:02was growing up. And I watched this so many times.
- 59:04But to me, this is almost the preferred vacation
- 59:08movie for me. Yeah. More than like vacation,
- 59:10European, Christmas. This was the one. This is
- 59:13National Lampoons. You know what's so funny?
- 59:16I didn't see anywhere on here that it was called
- 59:17National Lampoon's Vegas Vacation, but it is
- 59:19that series of National Lampoon's. So that was
- 59:22interesting. But yes, Chevy Chase. Ethan Embry,
- 59:26I think, is rusty in this one. Okay. Juliette
- 59:30Lewis as their daughter. Such a good time. I
- 59:32really enjoyed this, and it felt very similar
- 59:34to the idea of a family going to a destination
- 59:37and the antics that they get into in that. And
- 59:41it's very funny, which I think State Fair misses
- 59:43sometimes. No pigs, if I remember correctly.
- 59:45Bummer. There is a pretty significant amount
- 59:48of Wayne Newton. Oh, nice. Yeah, but no pigs.
- 59:52Okay. But, you know, give and take. Sure, sure.
- 59:55Yeah. No, I like that. The only National Lampoon
- 59:59movie I've ever seen is Christmas Vacation. Sure.
- 1:00:01And I didn't see it until I was like pushing
- 1:00:0430. It was pretty recent for me too. Yeah. Like
- 1:00:06it was after 30. You're right. Yeah. So man,
- 1:00:09I feel like I could make a playlist of just all
- 1:00:11of your double feature recommendations and it
- 1:00:14would be like 97 % movies I haven't seen, but
- 1:00:18it probably should. Yeah. I think 97 % is probably
- 1:00:21a good number. Of like, you should see these
- 1:00:23and other ones don't. Right. But yeah, that sounds
- 1:00:26about right. Because what I want to do is I always
- 1:00:28want to pick something that's not just in theme
- 1:00:30matches, but also like, are you going to have
- 1:00:32a good time with this double feature? And sometimes
- 1:00:35it'll be a sad double feature and I'll say that
- 1:00:37up front. But otherwise, I'm trying to like offset.
- 1:00:39Is this one a little quiet? Do a little louder.
- 1:00:41Is this one a little loud? Do a little quiet.
- 1:00:42Yeah, for sure. But also match the themes. I
- 1:00:45like it. I'm intentional with my chaos. I like
- 1:00:47it. Solid. I mean, that's state fair. There you
- 1:00:52go. Plus a little bit. There you have it. What
- 1:00:54an episode. I had a lot of fun. I had a lot of
- 1:00:57fun, too. I was a little worried, so peek behind
- 1:01:00the curtain. This month is like we're pumping
- 1:01:03out a lot of stuff. It's a three -episode day.
- 1:01:06It's a three -episode day, and we started with
- 1:01:08Cavalcade, and I was a little low energy. Your
- 1:01:11black coffee. Yeah, it was a lot. And then when
- 1:01:13we moved on to She Done Him Wrong, I was excited
- 1:01:15because we got to talk about a movie that I think
- 1:01:17has so much behind the scenes and so much. So
- 1:01:21many little trivia facts and things, fun bits.
- 1:01:25When we got to this, I was like, okay, this is
- 1:01:27kind of in between for me. Winding down. And
- 1:01:29it's the last one. What's the vibe going to be
- 1:01:33like? Are we going to be fading a little bit?
- 1:01:35Nope. Well, maybe. Well, yeah, but not in a...
- 1:01:39Man, write in and let us know what you thought
- 1:01:42of this episode. Like, if you have thoughts about
- 1:01:44the movie, cool. But I want to know, do you want
- 1:01:47to see more of this? Have we been taking this
- 1:01:50podcast in the complete wrong direction? Do you
- 1:01:53want us to just be like, yeah, I don't know.
- 1:01:54Forrest Gump's good, but anyway. You know what
- 1:01:58it didn't have? A lot of horn noises. Yeah. We
- 1:02:03just get a soundboard for the rest of the show.
- 1:02:06It's just the most random. It's Babe doing that
- 1:02:08yell. Would that be the only time that a podcast
- 1:02:11has devolved into a morning radio show? It can't
- 1:02:15be. It can't be. But maybe that's what we're
- 1:02:18missing. Let us know. Yeah, that's all I got.
- 1:02:23Godspeed and thank you for listening, everyone.
- 1:02:25Really excited. It also kind of works out to
- 1:02:28these three episode days we're talking about
- 1:02:29where we're covering a week, right? Monday, Wednesday,
- 1:02:32Friday of these. So very excited. Thank you for
- 1:02:35hanging into this one. Happy weekend if you're
- 1:02:37listening to this on Friday. And catch us next
- 1:02:39week as we talk about our next entry, which is
- 1:02:4242nd Street. So excited. That's a Busby Berkeley
- 1:02:44musical. Yep. So that's going to be cool. It's
- 1:02:49actually been a long time since we've done like
- 1:02:51a straight musical. That's true. Would it have
- 1:02:54to be, I mean, do you count one hour with you?
- 1:02:57Yeah, it would be a Lubitsch for sure. Yeah.
- 1:02:59But, you know, every time we see a musical outside
- 1:03:02of Broadway Melody, it's been a Lubitsch. So
- 1:03:04it's going to be cool to see something else.
- 1:03:06So looking forward to that one. That's going
- 1:03:08to be on Monday, the 18th. Look forward to it.
- 1:03:11That's going to do it for today's episode. As
- 1:03:14always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you
- 1:03:17at the movies.