Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #14: Applying the CSR to Week 0, Week 1 Preview and Interview with Steve Helwick from SB Nation
Transcript
- 0:17Michael (4): Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:21Michael (4): On this episode, I'll talk about the eight games from week zero and apply the Common Sense Rankings methodology to those results.
- 0:28Michael (4): I'll talk about the most important games to the CSR in week one, and then we will wrap this episode with a first interview in CSR podcast history.
- 0:38Michael (4): So eight games are in the books, week zero, and there was an inarguable way to order the winners and of those games, which I will get to shortly.
- 0:46Michael (4): First, let's follow the Common Sense Rankings and how they varied throughout the day on Saturday.
- 0:53Michael (4): First, North Carolina survived TCU holding them to zero points after the first quarter, overcoming the rain and becoming the first team to win a game in the twenty twenty-six season.
- 1:03Michael (4): So what does that mean for the CSR?
- 1:06Michael (4): The ACC now has a one and O record against the Big Twelve, making the ACC based on on-the-field results superior to the Big Twelve thus far through the season.
- 1:15Michael (4): I know it's only one game, but we roll with the data we have.
- 1:18Michael (4): So due to UNC's win, a result against an ACC team is now worth more than a result against a Big Twelve team.
- 1:26Michael (4): Next, Southern Cal took down San Jose State by sixteen on the West Coast.
- 1:31Michael (4): So a Big Ten team has now defeated a Mountain West team, making the Big Ten now equal to the ACC by virtue of each conference having a winning record against one other conference.
- 1:42Michael (4): So now a win over an ACC or a Big Ten school would give the most positive points, while a win over any other conference would have less.
- 1:52Michael (4): The next result was an ACC matchup.
- 1:54Michael (4): So Virginia dismantled NC State thirty-four to eight.
- 2:00Michael (4): Since the ACC has that winning record against the Big Twelve due to North Carolina's win earlier in the afternoon, this win over an ACC team is worth the most of any win so far, making Virginia the temporary number one in the Common Sense rankings.
- 2:14Michael (4): North Dakota State proved they belong in the FBS, throttling Jacksonville State thirty-three to seven to give the Mountain West a winning record over Conference USA.
- 2:23Michael (4): So since the Mountain West now has one other conference beat, a win versus a Mountain West team is now more impressive.
- 2:31Michael (4): So USC's earlier win against San Jose State now has a higher value attached to it in the CSR, putting them on the same level as Virginia.
- 2:41Michael (4): So essentially a tie for that number one spot.
- 2:45Michael (4): The next game completed was another conference game, this time between two MAC teams.
- 2:49Michael (4): Eastern Michigan rode a great second quarter to have a win over the FBS newcomer Sacramento State.
- 2:56Michael (4): Because these were two MAC teams, it does not impact the value of the MAC since all they did was beat a team from their own conference.
- 3:03Michael (4): They're still, they're still waiting to play their first game against any other conference.
- 3:08Michael (4): The next result was Stanford surviving Hawaii.
- 3:11Michael (4): Hawaii scored three touchdowns in the fourth quarter, but Stanford still came away with the win, giving Stanford a one and O start to twenty twenty-six.
- 3:19Michael (4): The ACC now is better than the Big Twelve and the Mountain West, so a win over the ACC team is going to have the most value attached to it, meaning Virginia's win over NC State is now the most impressive win of week zero, giving Virginia back the number one spot.
- 3:36Michael (4): Next up, Florida State beat New Mexico State.
- 3:39Michael (4): That gives ACC three conferences against which they have a winning record, further giving Virginia that number one ranking in the CSR.
- 3:47Michael (4): Finally, the last game of the night, Memphis won an absolute thriller as they went across the country to beat UNLV, giving the American a winning record over the Mountain West.
- 3:56Michael (4): This doesn't impact USC's total common sense ranking because the Mountain West still has the winning record over Conference USA.
- 4:04Michael (4): It just does not have a winning record against the Big Ten and then the American.
- 4:09Michael (4): So we still have Virginia at number one, um, followed by any other team that has beaten a Mountain West school.
- 4:17Michael (4): So we have eight one and O teams that would occupy the theoretical top eight spots if they were to be released after week one.
- 4:25Michael (4): So I view these rankings as indisputable regardless to what anyone says to the contrary.
- 4:31Michael (4): Number one, Virginia, number two, Stanford, number three, Southern Cal, four, Memphis, five, Florida State, six, North Carolina, seven, North Dakota State, and eight, Eastern Michigan.
- 4:43Michael (4): So those rankings are based strictly on the field wins and losses, not in preseason speculation.
- 4:49Michael (4): There's not statistical analysis or assumptions made.
- 4:52Michael (4): That is truly just what has happened on the field in week zero.
- 4:56Michael (4): So the natural question is, what would be the tiebreakers?
- 4:59Michael (4): Because a lot of these teams beat other teams from the same conference.
- 5:02Michael (4): So while numbers two through four, Stanford, USC, and Memphis have the same total CSR points, the first tiebreaker is then going to be conference affiliation because the ACC is the strongest conference through week zero.
- 5:15Michael (4): Stanford gets that bump.
- 5:16Michael (4): Then the Big Ten has that winning record over the Mountain West, as does the American.
- 5:21Michael (4): So USC and Memphis are still tied, so then it comes down to the win margin of which USC had the better, putting USC at three and Memphis at four.
- 5:31Michael (4): Uh, I know that I said that it was all based on wins and losses.
- 5:34Michael (4): Win margin shouldn't matter, conference affiliation shouldn't matter.
- 5:37Michael (4): However, early in the season when there's only one or two data points per team, there has to be something to delineate those teams and put one higher than the other.
- 5:46Michael (4): Starting in about week four or week five, every team is going to have a different CSR total points, therefore, the tiebreakers are not going to matter.
- 5:54Michael (4): But up to this point, it goes conference affiliation and then win margin.
- 5:58Michael (4): Of those eight teams that won in week zero, Stanford has the best chance to be number one when the first official Common Sense rankings, uh, come out after Labor Day.
- 6:08Michael (4): They play Miami on Friday night, so if they start two and O, they are the most likely team to be number one in the first CSR of the season As we move into the first full weekend of games, we do have several matchups that have big implications in the Common Sense rankings.
- 6:23Michael (4): So matchups between conferences that only play once or maybe twice throughout the season have huge impact as far as who should make the college football playoff.
- 6:32Michael (4): There are three matchups in week one featuring just a sing- the single matchup between two conferences all season, and then there are a couple more matchups where the conference is only twice all season.
- 6:43Michael (4): So again, the fewer times you play, the more crucial it is for one conference to win all of those games for the Common Sense rankings.
- 6:50Michael (4): The first matchup is a repeat from last year, Duke and Tulane.
- 6:54Michael (4): That is the only ACC versus American matchup all season.
- 6:58Michael (4): They'll play on the ACC network at three thirty Eastern.
- 7:01Michael (4): With the ACC starting so hot in week zero, a Blue Devils win would lock up a winning record at the end of the season against the American and give the ACC a chance to rise to be the best conference in the country.
- 7:14Michael (4): But a win for the American would not give the ACC a chance to make up that ground because Duke and Tulane are the only teams playing each other from those conferences this season.
- 7:24Michael (4): So huge matchup in Durham.
- 7:27Michael (4): Kent State from the MAC is headed down to Columbia, South Carolina to take on the Gamecocks in week one.
- 7:32Michael (4): That is at twelve forty-five Eastern on SEC Network.
- 7:35Michael (4): That is the only time the SEC will play the MAC all year.
- 7:39Michael (4): So all sixteen SEC teams really need South Carolina to win because if the- they do not, the SEC cannot gain a winning record over the MAC, and it lowers their ceiling for their Common Sense conference strength.
- 7:55Michael (4): The Texas Longhorns will play the only matchup the SEC has against the Pac-12 this season, where they host Texas State in week one.
- 8:03Michael (4): Similar to the Gamecocks, the SEC really needs Texas to hold to form here because a loss would not allow the SEC to catch up and again, lower their ceiling.
- 8:12Michael (4): That game will be on ESPN at three thirty Eastern.
- 8:16Michael (4): So those are the three matchups between conferences that only play once this year.
- 8:20Michael (4): There are heavy favorites, there are underdogs, but if any of those were to go the underdogs way, it would really cause chaos in the Common Sense rankings for the rest of the season.
- 8:29Michael (4): So now for the matchups between conferences that only played twice, of which one of those games is in week one.
- 8:34Michael (4): First, Oklahoma State visits Tulsa.
- 8:37Michael (4): It's one of just two Big 12 versus American matchups, and while neither team can claim a spectacular twenty twenty-five, uh, their matchup in twenty six will be huge for the Common Sense ranking.
- 8:49Michael (4): So if the Big 12 wants to remain among the elite conferences in college football, they have to beat Tulsa.
- 8:55Michael (4): So that game will be at three forty-five Eastern on ESPNU Marshall visits Penn State in week one, which is one of just two matchups between the Big Ten and the Sun Belt this season.
- 9:05Michael (4): So while Penn State is heavily favored, a Marshall upset would lower the ceiling of the Big Ten because they could not get a winning record against the Sun Belt this year.
- 9:14Michael (4): That game will be on FS1 at 3:30 Eastern on Saturday.
- 9:19Michael (4): UTEP heads north to play at Oklahoma in week one.
- 9:23Michael (4): That is just one of two matchups between the SEC and the Mountain West.
- 9:27Michael (4): The SEC had a winning record against each of the other conferences last season, giving it the claim of the best conference in the land.
- 9:34Michael (4): So in order to claim, uh, that 20- that title again in 2026, the Sooners need a dub over the Miners.
- 9:40Michael (4): So that is it for my week zero review and what games to look forward to in week one.
- 9:46Michael (4): The first version of the Common Sense rankings for 2026 will come out after Florida State plays SMU on Labor Day, coinciding with the AP poll, and I look forward to discussing what the AP poll voters did wrong after just week one.
- 10:01Michael (4): So I'm going to now interview Steve Helwig, a college football writer associated with Underdog Dynasty on SB Nation.
- 10:09Michael (4): This is my first interview with the CSR podcast and, uh, I think I'm, I think I did it all right.
- 10:15Michael (4): So without further ado, here is my interview with Steve
- 10:20And now for the first time in Common Sense Rankings podcast history, you will hear a voice other than my own.
- 10:26That voice will belong to Steve Helwig.
- 10:27Steve, thank you
- 10:31Steve Helwick: Yes Uh-huh Thanks for having me on, Michael.
- 10:48Steve Helwick: I'm really excited to be on the show and just excited football's back.
- 10:51Steve Helwick: I thought it was a great week zero with eight matchups across the board on Saturday.
- 10:55Steve Helwick: I was at that Memphis UNLV game on Saturday night.
- 10:58Steve Helwick: Great end to a spectacular weekend.
- 11:01Steve Helwick: We had the TCU North Carolina game to kick us off.
- 11:04Steve Helwick: We saw Virginia do some real interesting things out in Charlottesville, and some North Dakota State and Sac State made their FBS debuts.
- 11:10Steve Helwick: I thought overall it was a fun weekend of college football.
- 11:13Steve Helwick: Can't wait for, to dive deeper into it this week one.
- 11:18Michael (3): I, I'm glad you're as excited as I am, but for all of the listeners, please give us a little bit more about yourself and why you are the ideal first guest for the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 11:27Steve Helwick: Yes, uh, Common Sense Rankings.
- 11:28Steve Helwick: I mean, that's what I've been doing since, uh, 2007 since I was in fifth grade.
- 11:33Steve Helwick: I've been ranking every single FBS team every single week.
- 11:36Steve Helwick: I haven't mi- mi-- I have not missed a week since 2007 in ranking all one teams.
- 11:41Steve Helwick: It started out as the Helwig 120, now it's the Helwig 138.
- 11:45Steve Helwick: So more teams getting added, more teams to rank.
- 11:47Steve Helwick: So I've been huge in ranking teams, and I'm-- I always view myself as the all 138 guy, where I don't just cover one team or two teams where I watch all 138 teams.
- 11:59Steve Helwick: I specialize in all 138 teams, and I just love college football in general.
- 12:03Steve Helwick: So yeah, I've been writing for college football.
- 12:06Steve Helwick: This is my 11th season now.
- 12:08Steve Helwick: I've covered The Daily Texan back when I was at college at University of Texas, and I've been writing on SB Nation platforms, Underdog Dynasty, Hustle Belt, which is now independent and by the belt, and some other platforms over the past 11 years.
- 12:21Steve Helwick: So really enjoy covering college football, and you can usually find me at a stadium, maybe multiple in a single week.
- 12:31Michael (3): Awesome.
- 12:31Michael (3): Glad to have the super fan here on the, uh, CSR podcast.
- 12:34Michael (3): Um, so you went through a few of the week zero games, but the bulk of college football teams haven't yet started their season.
- 12:41Michael (3): How much weight do you give preseason polls going into week one, and how far into the season do you think preseason expectations should factor into rankings?
- 12:51Steve Helwick: I give almost zero.
- 12:52Steve Helwick: I mean, after week one, you do have to use some preseason expectations because half the teams are playing FCS competition, and those are, what, 51 to three beatdowns or something.
- 13:02Steve Helwick: But what bothers me with AP voters is I think a good case is last year in LSU.
- 13:09Steve Helwick: Going into the season, we thought LSU was great.
- 13:12Steve Helwick: We thought Clemson was great, too.
- 13:13Steve Helwick: So LSU beats Clemson week one, and voters accordingly keep LSU super high in the polls.
- 13:19Steve Helwick: But then we see Clemson lose to Georgia Tech.
- 13:22Steve Helwick: We see Clemson lose some other games, and people don't adjust LSU's ranking after LSU barely beats Louisiana Tech and Clemson's struggling.
- 13:30Steve Helwick: People don't realize right away that LSU is not a top 10 team.
- 13:34Steve Helwick: And I think that too much weight is put into preseason expectations and people aren't factoring those.
- 13:40Steve Helwick: Instead, it's just a team wins, we move them up a couple spots.
- 13:44Steve Helwick: If a team loses, we move them down a couple spots.
- 13:46Steve Helwick: No, your week one to week two to all the way through like week four, your team should be going up 20 spots, down 20 spots.
- 13:53Steve Helwick: You should be comfortable doing that.
- 13:55Steve Helwick: And I think more voters should abide by that policy
- 14:02Michael (3): Gosh, we are in, we are in the same boat here,'cause I feel exactly the same way, and that's why the Common Sense Rankings was started.
- 14:09Michael (3): So You're looking at the preseason top 25 this year.
- 14:13Michael (3): Are there any biases that you're seeing in these preseason rankings?
- 14:16Steve Helwick: One I would actually say is anti Big 12 bias.
- 14:20Steve Helwick: Last year, there were five Big 12 teams that finished the season ranked, and not a single one was ranked higher this year.
- 14:27Steve Helwick: They were all ranked lower.
- 14:29Steve Helwick: Now, Texas Tech fell from number seven in last year's final rankings to 12 in this preseason rankings.
- 14:34Steve Helwick: BYU from 11 to 14, Utah from 14 to 21, Houston from 22 to 23, and TCU went from 25 to unranked.
- 14:35Steve Helwick: Now, Utah and TCU I can understand a bit because they lost a lot of pieces.
- 14:46Steve Helwick: They didn't have much continuity.
- 14:48Steve Helwick: But you look at Texas Tech, BYU, and Houston, those teams retained a lot of talent, all Big 12 talent, and they're dropping in the polls.
- 14:56Steve Helwick: I don't understand that, and I do think that there has been a lot of anti Big 12 bias baked into the rankings recently because you see BYU, 2024, they get a non-conference win over an SMU team that makes the playoff.
- 15:09Steve Helwick: They're an 11 and two team.
- 15:10Steve Helwick: They're not even close to the playoff conversation.
- 15:12Steve Helwick: And last year, BYU had another spectacular season.
- 15:14Steve Helwick: Their only losses were two losses at Texas Tech, which was a four seed in the CFP, and you didn't even hear BYU in those conversations with Notre Dame and Miami at the end of the year.
- 15:24Steve Helwick: So I would say that anti Big 12 bias is probably the top thing that you see in the rankings early on in the year
- 15:33Michael (3): We're on the same page with BYU last year,'cause according to the CSR, they should've been in the playoff.
- 15:38Michael (3): So you, uh, again, we, we are speaking the same language here.
- 15:42Michael (3): Um, so you mentioned the Big 12 bias.
- 15:44Michael (3): What other things did you see in that preseason poll that you feel like was an egregious misstep
- 15:49Steve Helwick: One of them was already ki- I mean, it's just one game, it's just one sample size, you can't prove anything after that.
- 15:55Steve Helwick: But I was a big advocate of why is Virginia not ranked?
- 15:59Steve Helwick: Virginia is coming off an 11 and three season.
- 16:02Steve Helwick: They were in the ACC Championship.
- 16:04Steve Helwick: All three of their losses last year were close games.
- 16:06Steve Helwick: They could have won all three of them.
- 16:07Steve Helwick: But what Virginia had was experience, especially in the positions where it matters, and that's the O line and D line.
- 16:13Steve Helwick: And they have more starts than anyone else in the FBS.
- 16:16Steve Helwick: They have more snaps than anyone e- else in the FBS.
- 16:18Steve Helwick: They spent a lot on their roster this off-season.
- 16:21Steve Helwick: They have some good pieces back.
- 16:22Steve Helwick: I think it's just people aren't used to Virginia being a good team, and they th- uh, last year was a one-off season.
- 16:28Steve Helwick: And I guess when you lose your star quarterback and star running back, then people lower your expectations.
- 16:33Steve Helwick: But Virginia reloaded well in the portal.
- 16:36Steve Helwick: Bo Perbula played pretty well at Mizzou last year before his injury, especially in that Kansas game, and he can pro- bring that running element to the QB position as well.
- 16:44Steve Helwick: You saw how their offensive line dominated NC State last week.
- 16:47Steve Helwick: It was just run the ball.
- 16:48Steve Helwick: They threw 11 passes, they ran 57 times.
- 16:51Steve Helwick: So I thought Virginia not being ranked was one of the more shocking things to me
- 17:00Michael (3): It might be just a, an anti-Big 10, anti-SEC bot.
- 17:03Michael (3): Or I'm sorry, anti-Big 12, anti-ACC, where they're just over-inflating the SEC and the Big 10 teams while everyone else just takes a back seat.
- 17:11Michael (3): I can see that.
- 17:12Michael (3): Um, so for, for viewers of college football who drop in starting in August, not the passionate fans that we are who live and breathe this 24/7, when they just look at the numbers next to the names, wha- what's something that you wish they would, uh, consider more or think more about when looking at the rankings?
- 17:30Steve Helwick: Uh, I-I don't know exactly how to answer this, but I think rankings would be better if the voters ranked all 138 teams.
- 17:42Steve Helwick: And I think you can improve rankings a lot that way because I don't think a lot of AP voters can contextualize what it means if, uh...
- 17:53Steve Helwick: I-I'm trying to think of an example last year.
- 17:55Steve Helwick: Uh, oh, no, I'll, I'll say like an example was like in 2017 when Alabama beat Fresno State.
- 18:02Steve Helwick: I don't think a lot of people saw the quality win it was at the time of that, and Fresno State was a really good team.
- 18:09Steve Helwick: They were in the Mountain West Championship that year.
- 18:12Steve Helwick: And I-- So, so I think that if voters could rank all 138 teams and understand what every single win means, like what-- If Texas beats Texas State this week, like what's that gonna mean later in the season?
- 18:26Steve Helwick: You need to be able to follow all 138 teams so you can understand what every single data point means on a resume when it's time to compare later in the season.
- 18:34Steve Helwick: And I think that can improve rankings by a lot.
- 18:39Michael (3): For sure.
- 18:39Michael (3): So instead of looking at like the big losses or the big wins, you have to consider every single team
- 18:44Steve Helwick: Well, like last year, BYU...
- 18:45Michael (3): well said.
- 18:46Michael (3): so let's say,
- 18:47Steve Helwick: I was gonna say BYU beat East Carolina on September.
- 18:49Steve Helwick: That was a win people weren't really monitoring at the time.
- 18:52Steve Helwick: At the end of the year, ECU's nine and four team, they...
- 18:56Steve Helwick: I mean ECU I know was in their bowl game after the playoffs were decided.
- 18:59Steve Helwick: ECU beats Pitt wh- while being pretty shorthanded, the Pirates were.
- 19:03Steve Helwick: So I, I don't think people understood like that ECU was a pretty quality win on BYU's non-conference schedule
- 19:11Michael (3): Sure.
- 19:12Michael (3): Yeah.
- 19:12Michael (3): Like I said, they should have
- 19:13Steve Helwick: Mm-hmm.
- 19:14Michael (3): On that we agree.
- 19:16Michael (3): so let's say you get an AP vote for this season.
- 19:20Michael (3): Uh, how would you evaluate teams, especially early in the season when there aren't as many data points, like you were talking
- 19:27Steve Helwick: When there aren't as many data points, I will sometimes give a lot of credit to teams that have quality wins and, like, double down.
- 19:36Steve Helwick: I remember in 2020 trying to rank teams was d- very difficult when some teams had played four games, some teams had played one.
- 19:41Steve Helwick: But I remember when we didn't really know too much about Mississippi State or LSU, I gave Mississippi State a ton of credit for that, their f- season opening win over LSU where KJ Costello threw for, like, 600 yards.
- 19:53Steve Helwick: So, but then when Mississippi State loses to Arkansas the next week, I feel completely fine moving them from, like, number five in my rankings to, like, number, like, 54 because I know mo- more about the team.
- 20:06Steve Helwick: So early in the season, I will look at some of those wins that I...
- 20:10Steve Helwick: 'Cause you have to, you have to bake some preseason biases because or else it's impossible to rank teams for the first three weeks.
- 20:16Steve Helwick: But you also cannot cling onto those preseason biases when you have data points.
- 20:21Steve Helwick: Another thing I do early in the season is I will always rank teams that won over teams that lost until we have a circle of parity.
- 20:29Steve Helwick: So when Northern Illinois beat Notre Dame in 2024, I know Notre Dame made the national championship, I kept NIU above Notre Dame until there was a circle that basically brought it back where NIU lost to a team that eventually beat Notre Dame.
- 20:45Steve Helwick: So I kind of use actual on-field results to determine my rankings rather than just saying,"I think this team is better." I mean, I still think TCU is a better team than North Carolina.
- 20:56Steve Helwick: I think TCU handled them in the trenches.
- 21:00Steve Helwick: Uh, they ran the ball well.
- 21:01Steve Helwick: It was penalties and some questionable decision-making by the quarterback which cost them in that game.
- 21:07Steve Helwick: I still think TCU would win that game eight times out of 10, but I have to rank North Carolina higher because the results on the field have to matter
- 21:17Michael (3): So I think we agree, so there's like 58 teams or some absurd number playing an FCS team this
- 21:22Steve Helwick: Mm-hmm.
- 21:23Michael (3): None of those teams should be above any team that beat an FBS team after this first week of games, right?
- 21:30Steve Helwick: I do think you have to use some of your preseason biases still because I'm trying to think of some of the top teams that play FCS teams.
- 21:37Steve Helwick: Uh, uh, I don't know exactly who does on the schedule, but, uh, uh, Geo- Georgia is a good example.
- 21:47Steve Helwick: Georgia plays one, but it's, it's gonna be hard for me to not say Georgia's, like, a top five team.
- 21:52Steve Helwick: I can't just put Georgia below, uh, Eastern Michigan,'cause Eastern Michigan beat an FBS team in Sacramento State, and Georgia's gonna play Tennessee State.
- 22:01Steve Helwick: So I still will use some preseason biases, just I'm not gonna cling onto it for a long time.
- 22:06Steve Helwick: I'm not going to keep putting LSU in the top 10 when they barely beat Louisiana Tech and their quality win over Clemson keeps diminishing each week
- 22:16Michael (3): Mm-hmm.
- 22:17Michael (3): Okay.
- 22:18Michael (3): so this, this gets to a little bit of the College Football Playoff conversation at the end, and when we watch the CFP selection show, the talking heads on that show frequently talk about resume versus the best team.
- 22:31Michael (3): It sounds like you are more of on the resume side.
- 22:35Steve Helwick: Yes
- 22:37Michael (3): Okay, good.
- 22:38Michael (3): That's what the CSR is all about, is what does your resume tell us about your body of work this season?
- 22:44Michael (3): Awesome.
- 22:44Michael (3): Okay, cool.
- 22:45Michael (3): So speaking of the College Football Playoff, there have been a lot of talk about expanding to beyond the 12 teams that it currently is.
- 22:52Michael (3): What would be your ideal way of determining a college football national champion?
- 22:57Steve Helwick: It would not be more than 12 teams.
- 22:59Steve Helwick: I do not think we need to expand the playoff any further than what it actually is.
- 23:03Steve Helwick: The-- I, I honestly like the four-team model.
- 23:05Steve Helwick: The only thing I really like about 12-team is just the access and the fact that it does feel like that more of the 138 teams have a chance.
- 23:15Steve Helwick: Like, in the, under the four-team model, y- half of college football would enter that season without an opportunity to compete for a national championship.
- 23:23Steve Helwick: At least in the 12-team model, most of the 138 teams can go undefeated, and they would probably have a spot in the playoff.
- 23:31Steve Helwick: There are a few exceptions, maybe a CUSA team that has a weak schedule, like, uh, maybe like a 2023 Liberty that had a soft schedule and went 13 and 0 at their regular season conference championship.
- 23:43Steve Helwick: But most of the 138 can run the table just like March Madness, just like basketball, and say,"We can win a national championship if we win-- beat every team in front of us." So I would say, I guess, the 12-team model is good from that perspective, but I don't like how long the calendar lasts.
- 24:02Michael (3): Totally valid.
- 24:02Michael (3): When's the national championship due?
- 24:04Michael (3): January
- 24:04Steve Helwick: S- something like that.
- 24:05Steve Helwick: It's way too late in January
- 24:07Michael (3): Something crazy.
- 24:09Michael (3): Yeah.
- 24:10Michael (3): Um, so you mentioned Liberty 13-0.
- 24:13Michael (3): There've been some very, uh, controversial inclusions into the College Football Playoff.
- 24:19Michael (3): Over the past 12 years, which of the committee's decisions do you feel like was the most controversial?
- 24:25Steve Helwick: I think that it was tough because both of these teams lost their quarterbacks.
- 24:31Steve Helwick: I would say 2018 UCF and 2023 Florida State were definitely among there,'cause those teams had cleared their schedules and they had the resumes to compete for the college football playoff, but they weren't viewed as the best teams.
- 24:48Steve Helwick: 2018 UCF especially, because 2017 they run the table, they're excluded, they beat Auburn.
- 24:53Steve Helwick: Then 2018, they bring a lot of the same guys back.
- 24:56Steve Helwick: This isn't the transfer portal era, and people say,"Well, you have to go undefeated again." They run the table again, but then they lose Mackenzie Milton, and who knows what would've happened against that Joe Burrow LSU team in the Fiesta Bowl if he stayed healthy.
- 25:09Steve Helwick: But still, UCF was pretty dominant over a two-season stretch, and I think they deserved a shot at least in 2018 to compete in that four-team playoff.
- 25:16Steve Helwick: Then Florida State in 2023, although it was kind of justified by what Georgia did, 63 to 3 in that Orange Bowl.
- 25:23Steve Helwick: I mean, Florida State beat everyone in front of them.
- 25:26Steve Helwick: They had the quality wins.
- 25:27Steve Helwick: They beat LSU at open, the season non-conference.
- 25:30Steve Helwick: They ran through the ACC.
- 25:32Steve Helwick: That was just a matter of if Jordan Travis stayed healthy, and I think if he w- did, there's no doubt Florida State's competing in that college football playoff.
- 25:39Steve Helwick: So I don't know.
- 25:41Steve Helwick: That's kind of the best teams thing, is what the committee did in those situations, where you see an injured quarterback and they figure it might not work out.
- 25:50Steve Helwick: But here's the thing, we- as we've seen it go the other way.
- 25:52Steve Helwick: In 2014, Ohio State was down to their third-string quarterback, and Braxton Miller and J.T.
- 25:58Steve Helwick: Barrett were out.
- 25:59Steve Helwick: And they got-- They beat Wisconsin 59-0 in his debut, and they jumped TCU, they jumped Baylor, and they get that number four spot.
- 26:06Steve Helwick: They win the national championship.
- 26:07Steve Helwick: So I think you just have to let it play out and see what happens with the backup quarterback in a situation like that
- 26:16Michael (3): Right.
- 26:16Michael (3): I, the way I see it, the coaches don't stop recruiting when they get their QB one.
- 26:20Michael (3): Like, they, they're trying to build an entire team, so taking the entire team out of consideration or hurting teams based on the injury to one granted key player seems a little bit drastic in, in my opinion
- 26:33Steve Helwick: I agree
- 26:35Michael (3): Okay, so the Common Sense rankings is all about putting numbers behind all of the results.
- 26:39Michael (3): It uses just wins and losses, and then the quality of the competition involved, including conference strength.
- 26:46Michael (3): going into the twenty twenty-six season, you can take into account week zero results if you want.
- 26:51Michael (3): Do you have an, a hierarchy of conferences going into the season, and how-- what would need to happen for that hierarchy to adjust?
- 27:02Steve Helwick: I don't have a hierarchy of conferences right now.
- 27:05Steve Helwick: I think SMU's head coach, Rhett Lashlee, said it best.
- 27:08Steve Helwick: He said at ACC Media Day,"It's ridiculous that there's something called a preseason strength of schedule, because how do you have a strength of schedule when none of these teams have played yet?" So for me, I kind of determine my hierarchy based on some non-conference results.
- 27:24Steve Helwick: I think a good example was in 2020, s- there was one Saturday when the Sun Belt played the Big 12 three times, and the Sun Belt won all three games.
- 27:33Steve Helwick: So I'm thinking at that point, why, why should I rank Iowa State above Coastal Carolina when we saw Louisiana storm into Ames and beat Iowa by 17 points, and then Coastal Carolina beats that same Louisiana team?
- 27:48Steve Helwick: I, I'm thinking,"Why does Iowa State belong above some of the top Sun Belt teams if they lost by three scores?" And it wasn't like a fluke loss.
- 27:55Steve Helwick: Like, those happen.
- 27:56Steve Helwick: I mean, last year Texas lost to four and eight Florida.
- 27:58Steve Helwick: Like, there, there, we see wonky results in a year, but s- when there's like, especially an assertive win like Louisiana had over Iowa State that year, I was tending to rank Sun Belt teams over the Big 10 teams of similar caliber because we saw a middle-of-the-road Sun Belt team, Arkansas State, beat a middle-of-the-road Kansas State team.
- 28:15Steve Helwick: We saw a top Sun Belt team in Louisiana beat a top Big 12 team in Iowa State.
- 28:21Steve Helwick: So I kind of determine my conference hierarchy based on what I see on Saturdays and Thursdays and Fridays.
- 28:30Michael (3): Oh, man, you are...
- 28:31Michael (3): Yes.
- 28:31Michael (3): Yes.
- 28:32Michael (3): Everything you're saying is absolutely true.
- 28:34Michael (3): Looking at 2025, for example, the Mountain West Conference had a winning record over all their regular season matchups against the ACC, so the whole Power Four Group of 6 thing was a little bit blurred in that regard because the Mountain West, at least according to the common sense rankings, deserve to be on the same level as the ACC.
- 28:52Michael (3): So I agree completely with you.
- 28:54Michael (3): We can't determine conference strength or conference rankings until games have been played.
- 28:59Michael (3): Excellent.
- 29:01Michael (3): Okay, let's talk a little bit about the trouble that the NCAA continues to find themself in with NIL, with, uh, the players coming from NFL teams back to college football.
- 29:14Michael (3): What are your biggest concerns for the future of college sports and specifically college football?
- 29:20Steve Helwick: I would say my biggest concern is if the FBS would ever split when TV deals are up in, like, around 2030, if there would be, like, s- some super league that gets funded heavily by money or a television network or something.
- 29:35Steve Helwick: 'Cause I love the NFL and I love college football, and I love them for different reasons.
- 29:39Steve Helwick: I don't want college football to become an NFL, like, G League, basically, where it's just, like, 32 teams and they just try to be a light version of the NFL.
- 29:48Steve Helwick: I like college football for what it is.
- 29:49Steve Helwick: I like college football because I...
- 29:52Steve Helwick: I don't know.
- 29:52Steve Helwick: I love that Texas plays Texas State in week one, and there's a chance, like, for Texas State to make a historic win.
- 29:59Steve Helwick: I love, like, NIU playing Notre Dame, and that was a game-changing moment for NIU.
- 30:03Steve Helwick: I love those games, and I also love just, uh...
- 30:06Steve Helwick: I mean, we still talk about, like,'07 Kansas, Missouri.
- 30:09Steve Helwick: We still talk about, like, the rivalries matter.
- 30:12Steve Helwick: There'll be these ranked matchups that you'll remember forever, these lops- these seemingly lopsided matchups that will produce a result that can surprise you.
- 30:20Steve Helwick: I love how much, I guess, the lack of parity between the 138 teams that can create some magic in the sport when things don't go according to plan.
- 30:28Steve Helwick: So, if college football would not be the s- s- same 138 team sport in the FBS that we currently have, I think that would be my biggest fear is if some split up happened.
- 30:40Steve Helwick: And those are reasons why I never use the power whatever and group of whatever term was we didn't-- Those terms didn't really start to rise until recently.
- 30:47Steve Helwick: Head coaches never used them until the past few years.
- 30:50Steve Helwick: I'm a bit concerned seeing those terms more,'cause people are trying to divide up the sport in college football and say, like,"You're in this category or this category," and I think that could scarily maybe lead to a split.
- 31:00Steve Helwick: Like, what's to say, like, Boise State doesn't get a power label when they, all they do is beat all these teams.
- 31:06Steve Helwick: Tulane last year, their favorite over Northwestern and Duke, they ha- ha- handled business in those games.
- 31:12Steve Helwick: That was the expectation.
- 31:13Steve Helwick: But other programs like Boston College and some other teams will just get that power label.
- 31:19Steve Helwick: Purdue, yeah.
- 31:20Steve Helwick: I, I just don't like that.
- 31:21Steve Helwick: I just think it's all 138 or nothing.
- 31:23Steve Helwick: Like, you don't see labels in the NFL.
- 31:26Steve Helwick: You don't see the...
- 31:27Steve Helwick: You don't see consistent winners like the Patriots, Chiefs, Steelers get different labels and teams that are always in the cellar like the Cardinals and Browns.
- 31:39Michael (3): Okay, so stop using Power Four Group of Six.
- 31:41Michael (3): Got it.
- 31:41Michael (3): No, I won't say that anymore.
- 31:43Michael (3): so let's, let's talk a little bit about what your ex- expectations or your predictions for the upcoming season.
- 31:49Michael (3): Give me a team in a more distinguished conference, uh, and a team from a less distinguished conference that you think is gonna outperform expectations this year
- 31:58Steve Helwick: Ooh, I already said my Virginia piece, so I'm going to try to find somebody else in there'cause I do, I do feel very strongly about Virginia.
- 32:08Steve Helwick: I would...
- 32:09Steve Helwick: Let me go to Let me think.
- 32:17Michael (3): Do you want to hear mine
- 32:18Steve Helwick: Yes.
- 32:19Michael (3): I can go first if
- 32:20Steve Helwick: Yes
- 32:22Michael (3): Okay, cool.
- 32:22Michael (3): One team that I think has an opportunity to finish 12 and 1 and a potential college football playoff bid Western Michigan.
- 32:31Michael (3): They've got the Wolverines, Michigan Wolverines in week one, but then after that, their schedule looks very winnable with some wins over teams that would probably carry a little bit of weight, uh, as the season progressed.
- 32:43Michael (3): Um, and their MAC schedule is very manageable.
- 32:45Michael (3): So I, I will take the Western Michigan Broncos.
- 32:48Michael (3): You can keep that receipt
- 32:53Steve Helwick: Yeah, I, I agree.
- 32:54Steve Helwick: They have that Boise State game, which at, at, in Kalamazoo, and Western Michigan returned so many start- They didn't lose a single starter to the transfer portal, just they, they lost only guys to graduation, and you have a power run game back.
- 33:06Steve Helwick: They do need to reload that defensive front.
- 33:08Steve Helwick: But yeah, I do agree that Western Michigan's up there.
- 33:10Steve Helwick: I'll give you one.
- 33:11Steve Helwick: I'll give you the Army Black Knights.
- 33:13Steve Helwick: I mean, two years ago, they had their winningest season ever.
- 33:16Steve Helwick: They went twel- twelve and two, and they were pretty dominant in most of those wins.
- 33:21Steve Helwick: Last year, they fell to seven and six, and I th- think they're, they're flying under the radar this year.
- 33:25Steve Helwick: They have eight returning starters, and their quarterback that-- who wasn't even the starter last year, Kale Hellums, he led all FBS quarterbacks in rushing.
- 33:33Steve Helwick: I think he can make that year two leap that Bryson Dailey made in his second year as a starter.
- 33:38Steve Helwick: The thing about Army that I also just like is, uh, defensively, I think if they can take care of the offense, there's gonna be such limited possession, so other opponents are going to have limited opportunities to score.
- 33:51Steve Helwick: And one other thing is Army had six losses last year.
- 33:54Steve Helwick: Five of those were by one score, and they were all winnable games in the final minute.
- 33:58Steve Helwick: So this is just a team that just needs to execute a little bit better down the stretch, and they're not too far off.
- 34:03Steve Helwick: So I think I have Army winning the American Conference this year.
- 34:06Steve Helwick: I know that's more of a dark horse pick, but I think that they're a team that could really do some damage with Jeff Monken back as head coach
- 34:16Michael (3): So since they play Navy after the American championship, how much do you think that should matter if they are in the running for the college football playoff, having one less data point late in the
- 34:26Steve Helwick: I asked Brian Newberry, Navy's coach, if he understood how that process worked, and he said he didn't really-- nobody's really communicated with him if they're gonna delay the College Football Playoff selection until after the Army-Navy game, which would be very logistically difficult.
- 34:41Steve Helwick: So no one really knows how that's going to work yet.
- 34:44Steve Helwick: I do know that there was talks about delaying it in twenty sixteen when there was a New Year's Six spot between Western Michigan and Navy, but Navy lost the American Conference championship to Temple, which made that a moot point.
- 34:55Steve Helwick: But if they beat Temple, they were only, I think, one or two spots away from Western Michigan in the rankings where Navy could have maybe flipped because they would have gotten a better quality win that week over Temple than Western Michigan did over Ohio.
- 35:06Steve Helwick: So I don't know what happens if a service academy does qualify for the playoff, but I think we will see that scenario more often now because the American keeps losing its top players in the portal every year, while the service academies have the continuity advantage in, in that conference
- 35:21Michael (3): That's right.
- 35:23Michael (3): That's right.
- 35:24Michael (3): Okay.
- 35:25Michael (3): all right, so let's, let's offend some people.
- 35:27Michael (3): What top 25 team do you think is gonna fall off a cliff this season?
- 35:32Steve Helwick: Top 20
- 35:33Michael (3): pre-season top 25 teams
- 35:35Steve Helwick: I think I'm not really too high.
- 35:38Steve Helwick: I, I wanna, I, I'm not in the business of offending people.
- 35:40Steve Helwick: I try to please everyone, but I'm not too high on Tennessee, which I think Tennessee will probably start 3-0 with its non-conference schedule.
- 35:50Steve Helwick: But I wouldn't be surprised if Georgia Tech can win that game also.
- 35:53Steve Helwick: But with Tennessee, it's not having a returning quarterback, th- where it gives me questions about how the offense is going to look there, although I know they have five-star recruit that did pretty well at the position.
- 36:06Steve Helwick: So Tennessee does replace a lot, but last year I think Tennessee was a team that was ranked the entire season, but feel like their best resume point was the fact that they almost beat Georgia, because they didn't have too many quality wins there.
- 36:18Steve Helwick: They lost to every single good team that they played, finishing 0-5, I think, against ranked competition or maybe 0-4,'cause Illinois wasn't ranked.
- 36:26Steve Helwick: But Tennessee's a team that I think I could see regress back to like five and seven this year.
- 36:32Steve Helwick: I mean, they, they have some difficult games on the schedule.
- 36:35Steve Helwick: Texas, uh, Alabama, Texas A&M, LSU.
- 36:39Steve Helwick: I, I could see teams like Auburn getting better.
- 36:41Steve Helwick: So I, I would probably say if there's a top 25 team I was surprised to see in the rankings to start the season, it was Tennessee
- 36:51Michael (3): Okay.
- 36:52Michael (3): Well, listen, we're almost at time.
- 36:53Michael (3): Do you mind if I go
- 36:54Steve Helwick: Oh,
- 36:54Michael (3): fire
- 36:55Steve Helwick: feel free.
- 36:56Michael (3): and you
- 36:56Steve Helwick: Yeah, feel free
- 36:58Michael (3): All right, cool.
- 36:59Michael (3): Best in-person atmosphere at a college football stadium
- 37:03Steve Helwick: Penn State White Out
- 37:06Michael (3): Sick.
- 37:07Michael (3): Okay.
- 37:07Michael (3): Best college football
- 37:08Steve Helwick: college football rivalry.
- 37:11Steve Helwick: I say Army-Navy has an entire week dedicated to it, so it's up there.
- 37:16Steve Helwick: But Iron Bowl, I mean, even the bad Auburn teams against the good Bama teams have produced some great results.
- 37:22Steve Helwick: A good Iron Bowl is as good as it gets
- 37:27Michael (3): Good choice.
- 37:28Michael (3): What is the most underrated college football uniform?
- 37:31Steve Helwick: Most underrated college football uniform.
- 37:33Steve Helwick: That's a good one, and I'm a big uniform junkie too.
- 37:37Steve Helwick: I've always loved the Cincinnati Bearcats look.
- 37:40Steve Helwick: I don't know, the black and red look well with the white.
- 37:42Steve Helwick: I, I'm a big Cincinnati Bearcats uniform guy
- 37:47Michael (3): What is the most overrated metric in evaluating teams?
- 37:53Michael (3): take it
- 37:53Steve Helwick: I don't know of past really.
- 37:55Steve Helwick: I, I think the most overrated is just, we, we talked about already is just preseason perception, which people will hang onto for a very long time
- 38:04Michael (3): Your team gets to hire a new head coach and you get to pick who they are.
- 38:08Michael (3): Who are you picking?
- 38:12Steve Helwick: One coach I'll just say, and I do cover a lot of Houston, Willie Fritz has been doing this for 34 years now, and he's never been fired from a job.
- 38:21Steve Helwick: He's just had an entire climb up the ladder his whole career.
- 38:24Steve Helwick: He's won everywhere he's gone.
- 38:26Steve Helwick: Year or two at Houston, he takes them from four and eight to 10 and three, so I gotta go Willie Fritz
- 38:34Michael (3): What's your favorite sport besides college football?
- 38:36Steve Helwick: I love basketball.
- 38:38Steve Helwick: I'm a huge NBA fan, diehard San Antonio Spurs fan.
- 38:41Steve Helwick: Love to hoop, uh, outside of covering games of basketball
- 38:47Michael (3): who is the, that fifth conference champion in the College Football Playoff this year?
- 38:51Michael (3): You said Army, right?
- 38:52Steve Helwick: Uh, no, I had them winning the American.
- 38:55Steve Helwick: I will say my preseason pick was UNLV, but we're recording this after week zero, and U- UNLV does not have a good chance of making it now.
- 39:03Steve Helwick: So I'm gonna say Boise State.
- 39:05Steve Helwick: I think if Boise State can win those Memphis and Western Michigan games, I'll ride with the Broncos
- 39:13Michael (3): Who is your pick for the national champion at the end of the
- 39:16Steve Helwick: I have Texas beating Ohio State in the national championship in a rematch of a week two game, but I do not think Texas wins the SEC
- 39:26Michael (3): Okay, so they'll get in as an at large and then run the
- 39:28Steve Helwick: Yes
- 39:29Michael (3): Okay.
- 39:30Michael (3): Awesome.
- 39:31Michael (3): Steve, thank you so much for your time today.
- 39:33Michael (3): I really appreciate it.
- 39:34Michael (3): This was a great conversation
- 39:35Steve Helwick: for having me on.
- 39:35Steve Helwick: Appreciate it
- 39:39Michael (3): Um, okay, so real quick, I have a sign-off if you'd like to do it for me, that would be awesome.
- 39:44Steve Helwick: Okay.
- 39:45Steve Helwick: As you go about your day today, please use some common sense