Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De’ah 266:12-14. Bris Milah: On Shabbos, Non-Jew, Non-Religious, Yom Tov Sheni, Visiting Israel, Thursday Friday

Transcript

Yoreh De’ah 266:12-14. Bris Milah: On Shabbos, Non-Jew, Non-Religious, Yom Tov Sheni, Visiting Israel, Thursday Friday · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:01
  OK, we are on Resh Samakhva vasmila.
• 0:06
  OK, we are beginning with Gilmore, right?
• 0:11
  Where did we leave off? Yeah, we're beginning with
• 0:13
  Gilmore. Just to point out, we mentioned
• 0:16
  yesterday as far as a so you have a Jew who basically became
• 0:22
  a Christian and so he went. He was with a Jewish regular
• 0:26
  Jewish woman. So we say you still do the
• 0:29
  Bersmila and it's still dokhe Shabbos.
• 0:32
  No problem. If she's and generally Speaking
• 0:36
  of someone is just not from we are dokhe Shabbos.
• 0:40
  We also have Tina Shanishva. That's not an issue.
• 0:43
  Some say if you're going to if the brisk is going to cause all
• 0:47
  the family to drive and be makalo Shabbos.
• 0:49
  So then one should ask Shila if it should be pushed off.
• 0:55
  What if both parents are mumar mumaris?
• 1:00
  So that's a Mach locus. And the postgame the basiosa
• 1:03
  says doesn't matter because you look at the child, the child's
• 1:07
  hive and he needs a bris. He's he's a Jewish boy also a
• 1:12
  mom's there also, same thing a mom's there also, or both
• 1:14
  parents are mamzarian. You still do a bris.
• 1:16
  It's still Doha Shabbos. However, some say both parents
• 1:21
  are mumar, not mamzar. If both parents are mumar, so
• 1:26
  then I think it's the shock. But whatever some say it should
• 1:30
  be not be done on Shabbos because then probably the child
• 1:34
  will continue a tarbutra and it's not shayak to do a bris
• 1:40
  Mila on Shabbos for that. OK, so that's the whole
• 1:45
  question. How much do you look at the the
• 1:47
  upbringing that's there? It's basically from a minor,
• 1:51
  from a Rishon who said the lesson of the Shah Kanarak.
• 1:55
  And the question is how far do you take it?
• 1:58
  You sell Shenoladlo Ben migoya in Malino to the Shabbat.
• 2:03
  So now, so if it's a a Jew and a Jew, of course it's Mila's Dolph
• 2:09
  Hashabbas for the 8th day. Bisman.
• 2:11
  What if one of the parents are non Jewish?
• 2:14
  So if the father is not Jew, is a non Jew.
• 2:17
  So then it it doesn't matter because the mother is Jewish,
• 2:20
  the baby's Jewish, it's Dolph Hashabbas.
• 2:22
  But if the father is a Jew and the mother is a non Jew, that's
• 2:27
  this case. So she's non Jewish.
• 2:29
  So then the baby's non Jewish. So it's certainly not dokhe
• 2:33
  Shabbos if you can do the Mila all together.
• 2:35
  So that's we discussed is the baby is non Jewish.
• 2:39
  What about Yom tov Shani and khusaras?
• 2:43
  Who said also we thought we said the halacha is it's not dokhe
• 2:46
  Yom tov Shani, but what if it's a it's a Suffolk, It's a case of
• 2:53
  Venus schmachus. So it's not exactly lo bizmano,
• 2:56
  but you push it off a half a day because you don't know.
• 2:59
  So there it's a maclocas. Most say you do you do do it on
• 3:03
  a Yom Tosheni, like if it was born, you're not sure if it's
• 3:06
  which day it is. So for that you would do it on a
• 3:09
  Yom Tosheni. That's the note of the Huda
• 3:12
  Shebalevi or Shomon Salman. But the men hassle Azer says no,
• 3:16
  it's Yom Tosheni. We still don't do it.
• 3:18
  That's not called bismano, it's Suffolk bismano.
• 3:21
  OK but everyone's mock more for Rosh Hashanah.
• 3:25
  What about a Yosei dolphin AC section?
• 3:29
  And that comes out on Yom Tosheni.
• 3:31
  So that's also Mahlokis. The whole concept of yotse
• 3:34
  dolphin also has a din of a Suffolk.
• 3:37
  How you learned absurdum thrushos, whatever just happens
• 3:40
  to be for Yom Tosheni, that is a Mahlokis Mashao Mazal Munshiwas
• 3:44
  Hanagos says you do do it and or Moshe Feinstein or Vyasha von
• 3:48
  Shaved Levi says you do not, you know, ask yourself.
• 3:52
  I wanted to share an interesting question brings together a
• 3:55
  couple of things you mentioned from I heard this from Arya
• 3:57
  Liebowitz on podcast Yong Toshini.
• 4:00
  So what happens if you have a family visiting from Kutzlawritz
• 4:05
  and they come to Eretz Sistrell and they travelled with the
• 4:08
  baby, even though the baby it was Shiloh Bismano, but it was a
• 4:11
  baby a week old, couple weeks old, whatever it is, and it was
• 4:14
  healthy enough to get on the plane, but it was a case of
• 4:17
  Shilo Bismano, whatever the case is.
• 4:19
  So what do you do in Eretz Israel on so it's sholo bizmano.
• 4:25
  So it's not doka Shabbos, it's not doka Yom Tov.
• 4:28
  And in Israel there's only one day Yom Tov outside of Rosh
• 4:31
  Hashanah. But on a regular, this Ben
• 4:34
  Khuslaritz is holding two days, right?
• 4:37
  That's the general halakhah. The general Mennon is they must
• 4:40
  hold two days, second day. Since we're assuming they're
• 4:43
  holding two days, the father can't do the bris on this
• 4:47
  arcani. So you can't do, let's say
• 4:48
  you're assuming you can't do the bris on the second day, Yom Tov.
• 4:52
  Can he get a mohel who lives in Israel to do the breasts for
• 4:56
  him? So what do you think?
• 4:58
  One might say? One might think no, because the
• 5:01
  mohel's doing it for the father, he's a Shalia.
• 5:04
  However, we learn that the din of a Shalia really is more of a
• 5:08
  qumrah. It's not really a din Shalia.
• 5:11
  That's number one. Number two, the really the
• 5:15
  father is Mukhuyev to do the breast that day, but he's
• 5:22
  prevented even on Yom Tovshani, but he's prevented from his
• 5:26
  personal men hub living in Khuzlarez.
• 5:29
  So the etzem he's also hired. So really there'll be no reason
• 5:33
  why he can't appoint someone to do it for him.
• 5:35
  It's like anytime someone's hired to do a mitzvah, I don't
• 5:38
  know, lighting candles on Hanukkah, you're not going to be
• 5:41
  home that night. You're working, you're at a
• 5:42
  wedding. Whatever it is, you can always
• 5:44
  point to Shuliac for you. So here too, it's not that he's
• 5:47
  not shayak to do the meela. He can do the meela, but he's
• 5:50
  just not able to do it for some secondary reason that's
• 5:55
  preventing him. So there should be no problem.
• 6:00
  I would, I can also, you can also add he's, he's not the only
• 6:03
  one who's Shayev. If he doesn't do it on the
• 6:05
  proper time basin kicks in. So it's really the should.
• 6:09
  You don't even need a shilly F per SE.
• 6:10
  You can have a baisden so the it's not not a problem.
• 6:13
  This is Yong Tosheni and Shiloh Bismana.
• 6:16
  Now if I leave, what's even throws in?
• 6:19
  Now that we learned all this, he says already it's smutter and so
• 6:23
  I also saw Paskin by Oshawa Zalman or Abu Yashi find it
• 6:27
  Pasha's no, not a real question. He also points out you want to
• 6:31
  throw it in the Rambam and the shock says Lakhatila.
• 6:34
  You do a bris anjom tosheni and then you also have another sniff
• 6:39
  is that the ARPO scheme are from SVI and others who say
• 6:43
  Lakhatila. Then Kutzlar who visits Eretz
• 6:47
  Israel should always only keep one day.
• 6:50
  So you put it all together and it's no longer much of a
• 6:53
  question. What happens if a Moell from
• 7:00
  Khutzla Aritz is in town in Israel and they need to do a
• 7:03
  Brisa Milo on Yom Tosheni and he's the only mole in town for I
• 7:09
  don't know. I'm not sure if that ever is
• 7:11
  Iraq can happen in arts itself, but let's say it does.
• 7:14
  So Nakuto said if he writes, he could even do the Milo in such a
• 7:18
  case. There is a question.
• 7:21
  I'll just leave it as a question.
• 7:22
  It's, it's a, it's a three-way machlucus.
• 7:25
  If a mole needs to leave his family to do a breasts right,
• 7:28
  there's a, the baby lives in some Hick town where they're out
• 7:32
  of town. There's no, there's, there's,
• 7:34
  there's no way. There's no mole there.
• 7:36
  The only way it's going to be done on Shabbos if he's going to
• 7:38
  have to leave his family. So it's a mukhlaqus if he should
• 7:41
  go or should not go. Obviously there's personal
• 7:44
  things to take into consideration, but in general
• 7:47
  the question is should he go but it affects on the Chavez or Yom
• 7:52
  Tov is even greater. Some Kas Yom Tov.
• 7:55
  So the three different opinions if you should or shouldn't go Le
• 7:58
  Kakila. One last thing we touched upon
• 8:01
  just to clarify when we say Shiloh bizmano.
• 8:03
  So then you have to it's not do kasabos.
• 8:06
  So we learned the in the better Kabait, right Maran in better
• 8:12
  Kabait, the additions to the Basiosa.
• 8:14
  If he writes that once it's Shiloh Bizmano, it's never done
• 8:19
  on a Thursday or Friday because just like going on a boat, you
• 8:24
  know, on a ship that might come, it's, it can lead to Hilo
• 8:27
  Shabbos. So so too, it can lead to Hilo
• 8:29
  Shabbos to take care of the baby.
• 8:31
  I'll say what was that? It's the medical complications,
• 8:35
  medical complications or taking care of it, whatever it is.
• 8:38
  So because of that there I'm not aware of any type of gazeera
• 8:43
  because we don't see this anywhere and most of the
• 8:45
  Rishonian we don't see discussed in the Gemara.
• 8:48
  But maybe me Menhag, maybe it is some kind of a Zeira to kind of
• 8:53
  from, I don't know, middle to ladder we shown him.
• 8:57
  But anyways, so but it is brought down in the videos if
• 9:00
  it's also discussed in the Shah and Tazabid.
• 9:03
  But basically so some say not to do it, but the clear minhag by
• 9:08
  Ashkenazim is most Ashkenazim never heard of such a thing
• 9:12
  because they they all do it on a Thursday on a Friday, even if
• 9:15
  it's Shiloh Bizmano. Most, most Spartan I think
• 9:19
  follow the the custom of almost all the Spartak post scheme that
• 9:23
  are written not to do it on a Thursday and Friday.
• 9:26
  Again, it depends on your minhag and that's what you should
• 9:30
  follow. But it's hard, your new calls on
• 9:33
  those three days, right? So that's similar to a embarking
• 9:36
  on the book trip. That's what they're learning
• 9:37
  from. But there's but in that Gemara
• 9:39
  mission or Brysa, really Brysa and the Gemara, there's no
• 9:44
  mention of brysmila. And then you're pushing off the
• 9:47
  mitzvah. We learned in the beginning of
• 9:49
  El Kosmila how bad it is to push it off.
• 9:51
  That's good to you, darling. Yeesh, Liziah.
• 9:56
  OK, so has the Lasham of Yeish. Yeah, So it's interesting.
• 9:58
  What's the opinion of the actual Sholkhanarov that always
• 10:02
  interests this part in the most? Because they really try and keep
• 10:04
  to the word of the the Sholkhanarov, but he doesn't
• 10:08
  mention it at all. So it's a question which is
• 10:10
  written first, which is written afterwards by Kobayek
• 10:13
  Sholkhanarov. OK, Anyways, one should be
• 10:25
  careful. Again, it's more of a humra or
• 10:30
  it might actually be an depends how you understand to do it when
• 10:36
  you're doing a bris on Shabbos. So you have to be careful you're
• 10:39
  not doing a Kabbalah. So you have to be doing it with
• 10:42
  shame Mila and then it Trump's it's overrides any issue of
• 10:49
  Kabala or Sheeta, right. So then so therefore to have one
• 10:56
  mole do the whole thing, that's fine.
• 10:57
  He's planning to do a Bristol Mila and he does the whole thing
• 11:00
  from beginning to end. Whatever he does, he's
• 11:02
  accomplishing the Mila. If you have two mole in each one
• 11:07
  doing half so, then each one by himself didn't do anything.
• 11:12
  All he did was Kabbalah. So that could be a problem.
• 11:15
  Also, you're marba. We know that there's an isser
• 11:19
  iser abandoned of marba bashi Urim.
• 11:21
  We don't want to do that on Shabbos, right?
• 11:23
  When you cut off a branch, you don't want to.
• 11:25
  You want to do 1 swipe, you don't want to and they're doing
• 11:29
  more branches with with one act. Why you want to try and do it as
• 11:32
  minimal as possible. So too, it's the same concept
• 11:34
  with Marba Anashimkiel that you don't want to have two people
• 11:38
  doing an Avera. The toughest point is he says he
• 11:41
  in his opinion is no, like we said.
• 11:43
  So Makhlakis, if it's an isser mamash or not an isser at all.
• 11:47
  But either way, that is the the halacha is Yeshi Zar.
• 11:50
  We don't do it. Just have one do the whole
• 11:52
  thing. Ella Hamal who Atzma you from?
• 11:56
  The one who does the Mila should do the whole Priya.
• 11:59
  So if the father wants to do it and shabbos ask, ask Shaila if
• 12:03
  it's shayak or not. And we already said not the
• 12:06
  first time. OK, I got the Lomatsathi Rayali
• 12:09
  Dvarov. Now I didn't find the raya for
• 12:12
  this, but Adaraba nearly the Shari, the Hamila Dakya Shabbos
• 12:18
  kemo avodaba mitdash. So he doesn't understand why it
• 12:22
  should be a problem. We split up doing the avoda in
• 12:26
  the base of Megash Shikamakohani Mayodin who mahalo in Shabbat
• 12:30
  because they would have numerous blind break up the avoda for one
• 12:34
  carbon and each one would do part of it and each one would be
• 12:37
  mahalo Shabbos. So whether it's the shiita and
• 12:40
  you're bringing it up and then you're putting it on the fire or
• 12:43
  you're cooking or whatever's going on, then we ahar, the
• 12:45
  Shabbat nitan litot is on Shabbos.
• 12:49
  It's given to me Dehuya harehu kehola khodavar becomes ehola
• 12:53
  khodavar. Well, I'll just point out the
• 12:55
  grub points out over here he agrees that well, khakila one
• 12:59
  shouldn't do it as it says in the shalkhanar.
• 13:02
  But really everything's really hutra.
• 13:05
  It's not exactly a kasha if it's really hutra.
• 13:08
  But anyways, that's whether it's hutra dehuya.
• 13:10
  Fine, I in sham, let's go on Mehan Mitzati bisefa Rachuma
• 13:16
  Yashan akatu, the klaf shikata, the self help Shabbat Bahadiya,
• 13:20
  the Shari that it's mutter divided up the Omna matsati
• 13:24
  bikobits sheeshala or less or But then I saw it's also written
• 13:28
  not to velkin tov la hakama la khatkila of Pisha Medina nearly
• 13:32
  masha katafti. So he goes right, the longer ma
• 13:35
  a little bit to say why it should be mutter and then he
• 13:37
  also agrees. Fine, issues are at the end.
• 13:39
  We'll conclude Hoka Smila.