Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Australia's EV Road Tax Debate: Balancing Funding, Innovation, and Climate Goals
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome back to the Deep Dive. We're here to sift through the
- 0:12sources on key topics so you get the real story.
- 0:15And today we're diving into something that, well, frankly,
- 0:18it made me do a double take when I first heard about it.
- 0:21We're talking Australia electric vehicles and a specific Rd. user
- 0:26tax just for EVs. It just feels so backward,
- 0:30doesn't it, with the big push for green tech trying to get
- 0:33everyone into cleaner cars and then tax go.
- 0:35But OK, let's unpack this. Yeah, it really is a
- 0:39surprisingly complex not to untangle.
- 0:42You've got environmental goals bumping right up against, you
- 0:45know, economic realities. And then there's the whole legal
- 0:47side, too. What's fascinating here is just
- 0:50how many different threads come together.
- 0:52We've looked at government papers, industry takes, even
- 0:54High Court decisions, policy analysis, the lot.
- 0:56Our mission today explore all sides, all the arguments, so you
- 0:59can really understand what's at stake.
- 1:00Cause fundamentally, surely we should be encouraging cleaner
- 1:03cars, right? Finding ways to support that
- 1:05shift, not penalize it. It's about respecting the
- 1:08environment, fostering cleaner air that feels like the
- 1:10healthier path. Absolutely.
- 1:11My first thought, my gut reaction was just hang on,
- 1:14aren't we trying to incentivize EVs?
- 1:17Taxing them seems like hitting the brakes when we should be,
- 1:20you know, accelerating towards cleaner transport.
- 1:22It feels wrong for where Australia needs to go.
- 1:25You're definitely not alone there.
- 1:26That sentiment comes through strongly and some of the
- 1:29sources, like there's an article on the driven 10 reasons why
- 1:32Labor's proposed EV only Rd. user tax is bad policy and it
- 1:37doesn't mince words, calls the tax foolish, even a political
- 1:40dog whistle. It really goes head to head with
- 1:43this idea that EV drivers aren't paying their fair share, Which,
- 1:47you know, is often the justification, But the article
- 1:49argues it's just not accurate. Honestly, these kinds of
- 1:52policies can feel like an unhealthy distraction from the
- 1:54bigger picture, aiming for that cleaner, healthier future for
- 1:57everyone. Foolish wow and political dog
- 1:59whistle. All the pretty pointed language.
- 2:01So what makes it seem so surprising or ill conceived from
- 2:05their perspective? What are the specifics?
- 2:06Right, so the articles first big point tackles what it calls the
- 2:10false assertion that EV drivers don't pay their fair share head
- 2:14on. It highlights that EV owners,
- 2:16like like every other car owner, already pay into the system for
- 2:19Rd. maintenance. They pay vehicle registration,
- 2:22taxes, driver license fees. That money supports state roads.
- 2:26And you know, if they own property, they pay local
- 2:29government rates, which helps fund council roads.
- 2:32These aren't extras, they're existing contributions.
- 2:34But what about? Fuel excise, that tax on petrol,
- 2:37I mean for years the understanding was that's what
- 2:39pays for roads, right? Isn't that the dedicated Rd.
- 2:41fund? Yes, and this is where it gets
- 2:44really interesting, kind of an aha moment for a lot of people.
- 2:47The source makes it crystal clear.
- 2:49Fuel excise money in Australia, It's gone into general
- 2:52government revenue since 1992. Since 92.
- 2:54Yep, for decades now it hasn't been specifically earmarked just
- 2:58for roads. So there's this huge gap between
- 3:01what people think and how Rd. funding actually works
- 3:04financially. And that misunderstanding it
- 3:06kind of fuels these arguments against EV drivers, even if they
- 3:10don't stack up. When you look at the total
- 3:11picture, it's like we're stuck on an old idea that holds back
- 3:14progress. That really does change the
- 3:16whole conversation, doesn't it? So if they're already paying
- 3:19through rego and rates and fuel excise isn't the road fund
- 3:22people think it is, what about the other benefits E VS bring?
- 3:26The things this tax might actually put at risk.
- 3:29Exactly. And that's where the Driven
- 3:30article really digs in. It lists several big societal
- 3:33pluses from E VS that this kind of tax could undermine.
- 3:36First up, public health. Cleaner cars mean cleaner air.
- 3:41Less traffic pollution means lower government health care
- 3:44bills. Simple, right?
- 3:46There's a study they mentioned UTA Center for Clean Air
- 3:48attributes 1800 premature deaths every year in Australia.
- 3:51Just a traffic. Pollution 1800 That's that's
- 3:54more than the annual Rd. toll, isn't it?
- 3:56It is staggering. So the argument is we should be
- 3:59incentivizing clean air, not penalizing the vehicles that
- 4:02help provide it. Then there's Rd. safety.
- 4:04Lots of EV's come packed with advanced driver assistance
- 4:07systems ADS. Think automatic braking, lane
- 4:10assist. These things are proven to make
- 4:12roads safer. Fewer accidents, fewer
- 4:14fatalities, lower costs for things like the NDIS, less lost
- 4:19productivity. Right.
- 4:20Those hidden costs of accidents add up significantly.
- 4:22They really do, and the article leverages exactly that point.
- 4:25The health and economic upsides are huge, so why discourage the
- 4:28tech that delivers them? Thirdly, thinking bigger
- 4:31picture, climate change and national security.
- 4:34More EVs mean fewer emissions damaging the climate, which
- 4:37helps reduce the financial hit from extreme weather, fires,
- 4:40floods, you name it. And for national security,
- 4:43reducing reliance on imported fossil fuels makes Australia
- 4:46more self-sufficient, especially vital in emergencies.
- 4:50We've got sun, we've got wind. Let's use them.
- 4:52OK, so the case against isn't just about whether EV drivers
- 4:55pay enough tax already. It's a taxing them actively
- 4:57works against national goals on health, safety, climate, even
- 5:01security. You've nailed it.
- 5:02That's the core argument. And beyond those big goals, the
- 5:05article points out other taxes EV drivers do pay.
- 5:09GST on the electricity they use, GST on the car itself, which is
- 5:13often pricier, even luxury car tax on high end models.
- 5:17There's a quote from Kathy Davies.
- 5:18She was involved in that High Court case we'll get to.
- 5:20She said now is not the time to tax electric vehicles.
- 5:23It is the time to do everything possible to encourage people to
- 5:26switch to cleaner cars on on. It's a really clear call for
- 5:31policies that help, not hinder this shift, which just feels
- 5:35like the smarter, healthier choice for Australia's future,
- 5:38doesn't it? These are definitely strong
- 5:39points for why we should want more EVs, but the the how how
- 5:43policy gets made without hitting snags, that's where it gets
- 5:46tricky. All right, let's pivot a bit.
- 5:47Let's talk about the legal side, because this is where it gets
- 5:49really interesting. Victoria actually tried this,
- 5:50didn't they? And EV Rd. tax, What happened
- 5:53there? They did, yes, and it hit a
- 5:55major constitutional wall. In October 2023, the High Court
- 5:59ruled on Vanderstock V the State of Victoria.
- 6:03The court basically said Victoria's ZLEV charge that zero
- 6:07and low emission vehicle charge was invalid.
- 6:09That was the one charging 2.8 cents a kilometer for full
- 6:12electrics and hydrogen and 2.3 cents for plug in hybrids.
- 6:16Invalid on what grounds? This sounds like it could stop
- 6:20other states trying the same thing.
- 6:21Absolutely. It was huge.
- 6:23The High Court decided the charge was technically an excise
- 6:25duty and under the Australian Constitution, only the federal
- 6:28government, the Commonwealth, can levy excise duties, not the
- 6:31states. It's a fundamental separation of
- 6:33powers thing designed way back at federation.
- 6:36So yeah, this ruling effectively slammed the door on states like
- 6:38NSW and WA, which has similar EV tax plans in the works.
- 6:42It's set a really strong precedent.
- 6:44OK, so the states are blocked, but federally people like Tanya
- 6:48Plibersek, the Treasury, Jim Chalmers, they've called an EV
- 6:51Rd. tax sensible, OK. So if it's so controversial and
- 6:55states can't do it, why is the federal government still talking
- 6:58about it? What's their angle on road
- 6:59funding? Well, the federal government is
- 7:01looking at a pretty stark economic reality.
- 7:04The main reason is the massive drop in fuel excise revenue.
- 7:07That tax on petrol and diesel, it used to be a huge source of
- 7:10federal money, but FCAI data that's the car industry body
- 7:14shows excise collected per vehicle dropped over 40% between
- 7:18the early 2000s and 2019. 40% Wow, why is such a big drop?
- 7:222 main things cars becoming way more fuel efficient and of
- 7:26course the rise of EVs which use no petrol or diesel at all so no
- 7:30fuel excise paid. This shrinking pot of money hits
- 7:33the federal budget hard right when they need funds for growing
- 7:36challenges. I think population growth, city
- 7:39congestion which kills productivity and UPS emissions,
- 7:41and road safety results kind of plateauing all need funding.
- 7:45So the genuine budget hole they need to fill somehow.
- 7:47It is, and you could see the states trying to plug that gap
- 7:50themselves before the High Court stepped in.
- 7:53NSW for example, had proposed its own fair and sustainable Rd.
- 7:57user charge. It was meant to eventually cover
- 7:59all drivers but it had specific rates ready for EVs and plug in
- 8:04hybrids around 2.97 cents kilometers for Bevs, 2.38 for pH
- 8:10EVs kicking in from 2027 or when EVs hit 30% of sales.
- 8:15So the states were definitely feeling the pressure to find new
- 8:17revenue streams. The High Court ruling really
- 8:19changed the game. So the whole funding model based
- 8:22on fuel is creaking not just because of EVs but efficient
- 8:24petrol cars too. What about the car industry
- 8:27itself? Do they have solution?
- 8:29An alternative idea? They do actually.
- 8:31The FCAI, the Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries, they've
- 8:34been quite vocal. They're pushing for a nationally
- 8:35consistent Rd. user charging system fit for the 21st century.
- 8:39But, and this is the crucial bit, they say it needs to apply
- 8:41to all vehicles, not just singling out EVs.
- 8:43OK, so a universal charge, not an EV specific one.
- 8:46What's their reasoning? Their argument is basically
- 8:48twofold. One, it would replace clunky,
- 8:51inefficient existing taxes 2 and importantly, it avoids
- 8:56specifically penalizing EV adoption.
- 8:59They argue the targeting only EVs would absolutely slow down
- 9:02the transition to cleaner vehicles.
- 9:04The FCAI even sketched out principles for how it could
- 9:07work. Charge based on distance,
- 9:09vehicle weight, maybe location like higher charges in congested
- 9:12city centers and even time of day.
- 9:15Charging more during peak hours. And did they suggest a rate?
- 9:18They floated an indicative figure around 4.6 cents per
- 9:21kilometer as something roughly equivalent to what a typical
- 9:24driver might pay in fuel excise now.
- 9:26Interesting, so this whole idea of moving away from fuel tax to
- 9:29charging per kilometer, it's not exactly brand new is it?
- 9:32Sounds like it's been kicked around for a while.
- 9:34Oh, absolutely. For years, Major reviews, the
- 9:37Henry Tax Review, reports from the Grattan Institute,
- 9:41Infrastructure Victoria. They've all been saying for a
- 9:43long time that Australia needs Rd. pricing reform.
- 9:47They've consistently pointed out that the current fuel excise
- 9:50model is outdated, inefficient and unsustainable.
- 9:53So this isn't just a sudden reaction to EVs, it's part of a
- 9:56much longer conversation about how we fund our roads properly
- 10:00for the future. Right.
- 10:01This whole tax thing is clearly super complicated, trying to
- 10:04juggle budgets, fairness, environment, all sorts.
- 10:08But stepping back for a second, with all this going on, how is
- 10:11Australia actually doing on EV uptake in emissions compared to
- 10:14say, elsewhere? Where do we sit globally?
- 10:17Yeah, that's a really important question and honestly, the
- 10:19picture isn't great. According to one source
- 10:21comparing our vehicle emissions policies with Europe's, the
- 10:24research found Australian cars are generally bigger, heavier
- 10:27and less efficient. On average, they pump out about
- 10:2943% more CO2 than cars sold in the EU. 43%, that is a huge
- 10:34difference. What's driving that?
- 10:35Well, the main factor, according to the source, is policy.
- 10:39Europe has had mandatory CO2 emission targets for car makers
- 10:42for over 15 years now. Those targets have really pushed
- 10:46manufacturers to sell more EVs and improve efficiency across
- 10:49the board. Australia, on the other hand,
- 10:51we've relied more on voluntary standards, which are just less
- 10:54effective. Plus, get this, we still use an
- 10:56official emissions test cycle, the new European drive cycle
- 10:59that dates back to the 1970s. The 70s.
- 11:02Seriously, it was designed for much simpler cars and doesn't
- 11:05reflect modern driving patterns like city traffic or higher
- 11:08speeds. This means there's a big gap
- 11:11between the official lab test results and what happens in the
- 11:13real world. In Australia that gap is maybe
- 11:163035%. In Europe it's more like 1520%
- 11:20because they use more updated tests, and for plug in hybrids
- 11:24it's even worse. Real world emissions can be 3 or
- 11:274 times higher than the official figures, mainly because people
- 11:30don't drive them in electric only mode nearly as much as the
- 11:33tests assume. So relying on these outdated
- 11:35standards means we're not getting an accurate picture and
- 11:38it's definitely not pushing us towards the kind of real world
- 11:40improvements needed for our climate goals.
- 11:42It just feels, well, unsustainable.
- 11:45Wow, okay, that paints a pretty stark picture.
- 11:48So given that gap of the outdated test, what does the
- 11:50research say Australia needs to do to actually hit its own CO2
- 11:53targets? The research is pretty blunt.
- 11:55It suggests Australia needs EV sales to hit something like 60%
- 11:59of all new car sales by 2029. 60% by 2029.
- 12:02That's ambitious. It is, and it won't happen just
- 12:05by setting an emission standard on its own.
- 12:07The message is clear. We need a whole package of
- 12:10complementary policies. Yes, strong standards, but also
- 12:13things like incentives to help people buy EVs, serious
- 12:16investment in charging infrastructure and crucially, we
- 12:20need to update those official test procedures to reflect real
- 12:23driving. Europe's already doing things
- 12:26like using onboard monitors to track actual fuel and
- 12:29electricity use. We need to catch up.
- 12:31It has to be this kind of joined up holistic approach if we're
- 12:34serious about moving from just talking about targets to
- 12:37actually achieving them. It's vital for building that
- 12:40cleaner, healthier future we keep talking about.
- 12:42It's definitely clear that balancing the budget,
- 12:44environmental targets, fairness for drivers, it's a massive
- 12:48juggling act. It really is, and it needs
- 12:50careful forward-looking thinking, focusing on long term
- 12:54health and sustainability, not just short term budget fixes
- 12:58that might actually undermine those bigger goals.
- 13:00So what does this all mean for you?
- 13:02Listening in, we've heard the strong arguments against taxing
- 13:05just EVs, highlighting their benefits for health, climate,
- 13:09even security, and that drivers already pay various taxes.
- 13:13We've seen the High Court basically rule out state based
- 13:16EV taxes, saying only the federal government can impose
- 13:19that kind of excise duty. That really puts the ball in the
- 13:23federal court. And yet we've also heard the
- 13:26very real problem. Fuel excise income is dropping
- 13:29and the government needs a sustainable way to fund roads
- 13:32for everyone. Exactly.
- 13:34So the fundamental question for Australia now isn't really if we
- 13:36need a new way to fund roads because the current system is
- 13:39clearly becoming outdated. The question is how.
- 13:41How do we design a system that's national, fair to everyone and
- 13:45actually supports the vital shift to cleaner transport?
- 13:48We need something that doesn't slam the brakes on progress or
- 13:50feel like a step backwards for the environment we all share.
- 13:53It needs to build a future where we have both well maintained
- 13:56roads and cleaner air that benefits everyone.
- 13:59It's about showing a real commitment to our planet and our
- 14:01collective health. So here's something to think
- 14:03about. Given Australia's climate goals,
- 14:06the High Court's ruling and the clear need for long term Rd.
- 14:09funding, what is the fairest, most effective way forward?
- 14:13How can Australia fund its roads for the future without slowing
- 14:17down the essential move to cleaner, more sustainable
- 14:19transport? It's a question that really
- 14:21forces us to balance the asphalt under our tires with the quality
- 14:24of the air we all breathe.