Latest / The Vegan Report / Masterclass in Fundraising. With Marina Boulos-Winton | Ep. 64
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you are listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05It is said that money is the nerve of war, and in the war of making a better world for
- 0:11animals, the same rule applies.
- 0:14The only reason why professional vegan non-profits such as Mercy for Animals, PETA, the Paul
- 0:21Watson Foundation or Suchafarm exist and thrive is because of money, and that money does not
- 0:28grow on trees, it is the result of extensive fundraising efforts.
- 0:35And for today's episode, my wish is for vegan organizations, both big and small, to become
- 0:42champions of fundraising.
- 0:44To help us achieve this goal, I am thrilled to welcome Marina Boulos-Winton, a rock star
- 0:50in the philanthropic world, who has graciously agreed to share with us the secrets behind
- 0:56her success.
- 0:58Marina is currently the Executive Director of Yes Employment Plus Entrepreneurship.
- 1:03She previously served for 10 years as the Executive Director of Chez Doris, a day shelter
- 1:10for women in difficulty.
- 1:12Prior to this, she held the position of President and CEO at the Foundation of Greater Montreal.
- 1:19Her professional journey also includes serving as the Acting Executive Director of the High
- 1:24Water Women Foundation, as President and CEO of the National I Have a Dream Foundation,
- 1:31as Assistant National Executive Director of the YWCA, as well as Senior Executive Positions
- 1:39with the National Fundraising Consulting Firm CCS Fundraising Inc. and with the United Way
- 1:45of New York City.
- 1:47So welcome Marina, thank you so much for having accepted my invitation.
- 1:53I'm so glad to have you on for so many different reasons.
- 1:58I should tell listeners that you were my teacher in college and you were one of the main reasons
- 2:07why I decided to launch myself into a career in fundraising.
- 2:14You were very inspiring and I always had so much respect for your professionalism, for
- 2:21your expertise and I feel like this is a gift.
- 2:26This is a gift for me to help.
- 2:30Thank you.
- 2:31I remember you as one of my first students and that you were very keen, very eager to
- 2:39learn, accepting of all the information that you were given.
- 2:47And for me, preparing the syllabus, so it was my first time teaching, it was a great
- 2:57way for me to prepare a syllabus and topics for my students that also perfected my work,
- 3:07my actual work.
- 3:08So it was also beneficial for me.
- 3:11So thank you for that.
- 3:14And I find it extremely rewarding that from one course that I taught, which was about
- 3:25prospect research, like finding donors that I now see many years later, my old students
- 3:34in positions where they're really my equals, right?
- 3:39So it's very rewarding.
- 3:42That's amazing.
- 3:43And prospect research is my favorite step in getting fundraising.
- 3:50I just love it.
- 3:53It's so fun.
- 3:54And maybe we should start with that.
- 3:57I think that when people hear about fundraising, they get anxious and they're not really interested
- 4:06in doing the fundraising.
- 4:08So they are passionate about the cause and they want to pursue their goals as nonprofit
- 4:16leaders.
- 4:17But then the fundraising is like the legume you don't want to eat.
- 4:23Yes.
- 4:25So why is fundraising fun?
- 4:28Can you make the case for loving fundraising?
- 4:32Well, if you're working for a great cause, fundraising, I think, is an honor and a privilege
- 4:41because you are a solution to the problem.
- 4:51And our charities exist because private citizens decided to put together this organization
- 5:04because a problem existed that wasn't getting solved by the government.
- 5:10And so you have many, many great mission-based organizations that need people's philanthropic
- 5:22dollars.
- 5:23And if you believe in the mission, it's an honor to be raising money to solve societal
- 5:29problems.
- 5:31So I think that's how it has to be seen.
- 5:35If there's a problem with the mission, then you have a problem.
- 5:41If it's not compelling, if you're not solving problems, then you're not going to raise any
- 5:48money.
- 5:51I think that I mentioned how you could feel anxiety from doing fundraising.
- 6:00And maybe this has to do with the ask, this asking for funding.
- 6:06So do you have any thoughts about that, how to facilitate the ask?
- 6:12So it's very stressful asking people for money.
- 6:16There's many ways of asking people for money, whether people still do, believe it or not,
- 6:23direct mail or grant writing or events.
- 6:31There's lots of different ways to raise money.
- 6:34And so you have to see what is the best way to ask for money and within people's means.
- 6:45There's a difference between asking somebody for $50 versus $500 versus $5,000, $50,000,
- 6:57half a million dollars or $5 million.
- 7:01So those are all asks.
- 7:08So your question was, so why is it so difficult or how do you encourage somebody to not be
- 7:18so...
- 7:25Like I think some people have a fear of being rejected, right?
- 7:32But the first piece of advice I would have to say in starting your fundraising career,
- 7:40let's say, is to learn how to tell a compelling story about your cause.
- 7:51So I think people give to people.
- 7:58I'm now with a different cause and while my cause might not be of interest to everyone
- 8:10that donated to my former cause, people still return my phone calls.
- 8:16People give to people.
- 8:18It's important to develop a relationship with our donors to be honest, to communicate, to
- 8:30communicate the impact and to share real life success stories to create that emotional connection.
- 8:41So I still have a connection with a lot of my donors.
- 8:46Like sometimes my donors would even invite me, let's say, their other cause was, let's
- 8:52say, the opera or something like that and they would invite me to concerts.
- 8:57So of course I would go and I've kept in touch with them.
- 9:02It's important to reach out to people who already care about the cause.
- 9:08So if you're starting cold, it's not the best thing to do, right?
- 9:16It's much harder starting with a blank slate like where am I going to shake the bushes
- 9:22to get donors than looking at a list that you already have.
- 9:29It's also important to know what people's capacity is.
- 9:39It's one of the most important elements.
- 9:43So a very good example, a mistake that actually one of my colleagues made yesterday was that
- 9:50she was making a request for a hundred thousand dollar gift.
- 9:56She didn't do her research and they never give more than ten thousand dollars.
- 10:03And they responded to us right away saying, well, like, our assets are so small, we don't
- 10:10have that capacity.
- 10:12Can you resubmit your proposal?
- 10:14Thankfully, they gave us that opportunity, right?
- 10:18It's also important to focus again on relationships.
- 10:22So in crafting proposals or making asks, you try to see if you have a commonality.
- 10:35So with the same donor, well, the president of the board is somebody that I went to high
- 10:40school with.
- 10:42So I mentioned it.
- 10:43I mentioned that this person may not know me well, but she knows about the quality of
- 10:50my work.
- 10:54I also mentioned that I remember very well the founder of this foundation or the person
- 11:02who this foundation is named after and why there is such a great link to our cause.
- 11:11So it's a bit of marketing, really.
- 11:15It's to try to grab people, get their attention and to say, hey, look at me, right?
- 11:24Look at me like there's a lot of great causes, but you have to find the connection.
- 11:30And really, it's with practice.
- 11:34I've been doing this for more than 30 years.
- 11:37It's with practice that you get really good at it.
- 11:41And the people I find who are the pros at finding a connection with people are people
- 11:49in planned giving, people who are successful in getting people to think of their cause
- 12:01and put it in their will.
- 12:03Yes, planned giving.
- 12:05That's something...
- 12:06Well, could you explain what planned giving is and why it's important to think about it?
- 12:11So it's called planned giving because you're not giving now, you're giving later.
- 12:17And so you either put the name of a charity in, let's say, an insurance policy or your,
- 12:26I don't know, your RRSPs, any type of savings that when you... or a will, your last living
- 12:36testament.
- 12:39And you can give either a percentage of your estate, a fixed amount, fixed assets, such
- 12:53as a house.
- 12:56So just to give you an example, it was a very dear lady who...
- 13:02And the people who are really the most susceptible to putting charities in their wills are people
- 13:10who have no children.
- 13:12So it's important to look at your donor list, look at who is a faithful donor, faithful,
- 13:20regular donor.
- 13:21Those are the people who are, even though they give small amounts, maybe they're on
- 13:26a fixed income, but it's important to look at who are your faithful donors and then start
- 13:34having conversations or getting to know them over time.
- 13:40And if you publish literature on like a brochure or an advertisement or an email about, have
- 13:49you thought about putting us in your will or to plan a gift after you leave, they respond.
- 14:04So in one case, one woman, just a conversation, no children wants to leave her legacy behind,
- 14:12wants to be remembered.
- 14:14How can she be remembered?
- 14:16She doesn't really have any money other than her house.
- 14:19And I said, well, why not your house?
- 14:22And she said, that's an excellent idea.
- 14:25And so, it's important to develop like a friendship.
- 14:31It's such a huge honor to be being given someone's house and then having to take care of selling
- 14:40it, emptying out the contents.
- 14:43It's something that needs to be done in a very respectful way.
- 14:48Definitely.
- 14:50I feel like giving, the way you portrayed it and fundraising is about creating relationships
- 15:04and then deepening those relationships.
- 15:07Is this a good way to summarize?
- 15:09That is it in a nutshell.
- 15:11Thank you.
- 15:13And what about the person who thinks, I'm just starting here.
- 15:20I don't have the many years of experience that Marina has.
- 15:25And I'm just starting this new organization, this new cause.
- 15:32How do I get it off the ground?
- 15:35Starting from scratch.
- 15:37Is there any hope for me to fundraise for my cause if I don't have already that pool
- 15:45of supporters?
- 15:48How do I go from zero to 10?
- 15:52So, I'm working.
- 15:55So look, I've worked for a couple of causes.
- 16:02Right now I'm working for a third where they didn't have many donors.
- 16:05Like they had, they didn't have zero, but they had like maybe 250 at best.
- 16:14And it takes time.
- 16:18It takes, I think after two years you will start seeing the results.
- 16:23But it's the ability to tell your story first and to be in social media, the media in general,
- 16:35like the more people who know about you and what you want to do is key.
- 16:44Because after repeating your name or your cause and what you do after so many times,
- 16:51that's how you develop brand recognition.
- 16:55And that's what causes like the charitable sector has to do all the time as well, as
- 17:02well as inform, let's say the media, right?
- 17:07And have stories written about the work that they're doing.
- 17:12So but it's difficult to do your work with no money.
- 17:17Starting a charitable endeavor is very entrepreneurial and it requires a lot of sacrifice on behalf
- 17:26of the social entrepreneur.
- 17:31So how does one start?
- 17:33I really believe in investing money in prospect research.
- 17:41So the, so your podcast is international, right?
- 17:48So but I guess people could Google what type of prospect research is available.
- 17:58I personally use something called charity can and grant connect in Canada.
- 18:06I know that in the US and maybe it's international is a software called I wave I w a V E, which
- 18:17has people from all over the world.
- 18:21So and also you need to realize, okay, what type of donors are the ones who will be the
- 18:33most attracted to my cause?
- 18:36Is it individuals?
- 18:37Is it companies?
- 18:39Is it charitable foundations?
- 18:44Is it another segment of the corporate world?
- 18:53Is it the government?
- 18:55So in my case right now, for instance, most of our, the bulk of the money comes from government
- 19:04because we help the economy.
- 19:08Whereas a homeless organization or an organization that helps, let's say stray animals, it will
- 19:18largely be individuals and it depends largely on marketing, social media to get those individual
- 19:26donors.
- 19:27And the only other donors that are corporate in nature would probably be corporations that
- 19:39produce pet food or pet store, like well, pet supply stores, right?
- 19:49So you really have to see which segments of the population are the most.
- 19:54And then also foundations who have a mission that's similar to yours.
- 19:59So it requires interest capability and would they be interested in you?
- 20:10So you have to try to develop a relationship.
- 20:13So it could even be sending e-newsletters, right?
- 20:19So you bring people in that way.
- 20:21So the last charity I worked for, which was an organization for homeless women, actually
- 20:29the mission evolved over time.
- 20:31It made it more compelling.
- 20:33It was strictly a day shelter for vulnerable women.
- 20:38A lot of lonely women came, but with the lack of housing that I think the whole world is
- 20:47experiencing, the lack of housing, the cost of living increasing.
- 20:54It was evident that we also had to serve homeless women and the donor base grew from certainly
- 21:01250 to well over 15,000 in no time and its budget grew tenfold.
- 21:11So that's the advice I have to give for somebody who's starting out with a clean slate.
- 21:17Let's go back to the prospecting tools because I feel like it's not that it's a secret, but
- 21:25I feel like this is not something we often talk about in the fundraising world, that
- 21:30those powerful tools are available to us.
- 21:35So what does Grant Connect, iWave, what's their function and what's the price range
- 21:44of getting those softwares, those data banks?
- 21:49So it could range anywhere from something that you might be able to find at the library
- 21:57if you ask the reference librarian to get it.
- 22:01So it could cost as little as maybe $800 to something that could cost as much as $3,000
- 22:07or $4,000 per year.
- 22:10What they do is they do data mining.
- 22:15And so if you were to do it by hand, which I have done like at the very beginning of
- 22:21the last charity that I worked for, is I would go online and look at similar charities and
- 22:29look at their donor list.
- 22:32I would look at their annual reports, who they were thanking.
- 22:37Sometimes it's broken down by their biggest donors by categories, and it would tell me.
- 22:43But this is a very painstaking process.
- 22:47It's very long.
- 22:49You know, you write it out by hand or you start typing and you put it on an Excel spreadsheet
- 22:54and then you have to figure out, okay, so how much do they give per year?
- 23:03You have no idea.
- 23:04It's like taking a stab in the dark.
- 23:07What these data mining softwares do is that you can tell it, you know, give me all the
- 23:19organizations, let's say in Montreal or New York or whatever, in Montreal who donate to
- 23:30the environment and I'm only interested in, I don't know, organizations that have assets
- 23:42of 50 million dollars or more, which means that, you know, it's a decent sized charity
- 23:52and it'll give you a list.
- 23:55And it could even produce an Excel spreadsheet for you.
- 24:00You can choose the ones that you want.
- 24:02It gives you the contact information, phone number, everything.
- 24:09So for instance, just like my colleague who made the error of not looking in the prospect
- 24:16research software, she would have known that this foundation is a very small foundation.
- 24:24They only, I don't know, they don't have assets of more than half a million dollars, right?
- 24:33And so they only have like $25,000 to give every year.
- 24:38So of course they're going to say, we're going to only consider requests no more of $10,000.
- 24:44And if they have, you know, they used to get five to 10 requests, as the person explained.
- 24:50Well, now they're getting 30 requests per year.
- 24:54So it's more work for just amount of the same amount of money because their assets are always
- 25:01the same.
- 25:02They're never changing.
- 25:03So eventually these foundations become smaller.
- 25:07Well they're the same size, but they don't keep up with inflation.
- 25:13So you have to focus on the big ones first and then the smaller ones later.
- 25:20I think it's also important to talk about restricted and unrestricted gifts with that.
- 25:29So people might think that, you know, well you've got it made if you're able to get really
- 25:35large gifts, like let's say from the government or foundations.
- 25:40But the reality is, is that the little gifts, the $50 gifts, the dinner that you're going
- 25:50to, the gala that costs $500, $1,000, whatever, those are super important as well because
- 26:02the smaller gifts is your unrestricted funding.
- 26:07And so when your costs are increasing, you know, like your rent, your wages, because
- 26:17the cost of living is getting higher and your grants are not indexed for inflation.
- 26:25It is very important to be able to count on those small donations, even though there are
- 26:30a lot of work for your friend raising capabilities and to pay for your unrestricted, for your
- 26:37operating expenses that your grants are not paying for.
- 26:42Because it pays for either the highest need.
- 26:45It could pay for a repair that you hadn't an expense that was unforeseen.
- 26:51And there you go, you know, so that's, that's, I think that that's, it's important to keep
- 26:58that in mind.
- 26:59How do you explain that to donors?
- 27:04How do you make them understand that need?
- 27:07Because there are many donors who have that mindset of, I want all of my money to go to
- 27:13this project 100% and I don't want to cover operational costs or anything like that.
- 27:25How do you address that?
- 27:27So a classic example is I was once, I sent a proposal to a donor or a prospective donor
- 27:37at the time and it was all salaries.
- 27:42And she said, but I want to donate to programs.
- 27:48And I said, but the salaries are the program.
- 27:51It's just a different word.
- 27:53They are the people who will feed the homeless women who will provide them the counseling
- 28:03and who will find them an apartment.
- 28:06That's your program.
- 28:09So you can't offer also your programs without a percentage of administrative costs.
- 28:19And so we instituted, it's important to institute or to say that let's say 10 or 15%, 15% is
- 28:29perfectly acceptable.
- 28:30That we'll pay for operational costs such as accounting to make sure that your grant
- 28:36is well spent for the rent, for the heat, and for marketing or communication expenses
- 28:45so that we could tell people what we're doing.
- 28:50It's perfectly acceptable.
- 28:51And when you present it that way, they'll understand.
- 28:57I have not met anyone who did not understand and they said, well, then charge us more for
- 29:06something else so that you'll get, you know, like because we don't like that.
- 29:11Our board doesn't like that word.
- 29:13Right?
- 29:14So the program officer who you're having conversations with, if they like you enough, they will guide
- 29:25you.
- 29:26Another thing that came to mind was how many nonprofits, at least in the animal sector
- 29:34and it's a recurring comment, are dependent on a certain segment of donors, for instance,
- 29:42individual donors and how they wish to diversify and get new donors.
- 29:51What is your answer to that problem?
- 29:53I think that, well, look, I'm realizing I'm working for it.
- 29:59We'll talk about, I'm working in a completely different sector and it's difficult to get
- 30:05individual donors.
- 30:08So your question is, how can organizations that help animals, how can they get away from
- 30:18individual donors?
- 30:20They can't.
- 30:22It's extremely labor intensive to deal with individual donors.
- 30:28I get it.
- 30:30It's also dealing people like really having a relationship with people who have an emotional
- 30:37connection to animals, period, who are very sensitive people affected by when people,
- 30:46when animals are hurt as well.
- 30:49Right?
- 30:50And having to, I see it on social media, like I'm on, you know, like I'm on these community
- 31:02Facebook posts and some people are, for instance, obsessed with taking pictures of cats and
- 31:14they think that they're stray.
- 31:15And so a lot of people chime in or so it gets a lot, when animals are involved, there's
- 31:23a lot of reactions.
- 31:24Right?
- 31:25So it's having to go through all that.
- 31:28It's necessary, unfortunately.
- 31:34And you have to count yourself lucky because at least people are coming to you.
- 31:41Right?
- 31:43And so it's easy to have, it's easier to have conversations with people when they're coming
- 31:49to you as opposed to you going to them.
- 31:55Right?
- 31:57It's important to also use traditional media, I think, as well.
- 32:09And I think the segment of the population who are interested in animals are especially
- 32:15those who are more elderly because their pets are like family.
- 32:22Right?
- 32:23They might be living alone.
- 32:25They have the comfort of their pets.
- 32:28And that's where you, it's, that's the segment of the population that's probably the most
- 32:35interested.
- 32:36Their children have gone away or maybe they don't have children and their pets have brought
- 32:41them a lot of comfort.
- 32:45That's very true.
- 32:46And that's something I never thought about weirdly enough.
- 32:50But yes, in that case, you know, you talked about how it is labor-intensive and it is.
- 33:00And there's also that emotional toll.
- 33:05So let's talk about maybe the cost, the mental health cost of doing fundraising, starting
- 33:15with, you know, rejection, getting rejections, but also managing those relationships.
- 33:27How do you deal with that?
- 33:29First of all, where do you put the boundaries?
- 33:32And then how do you manage your mental health while doing fundraising?
- 33:38So I think there are some causes I've realized that you can be more successful, you will
- 33:51have less rejections than others.
- 33:56So if, for instance, I think since the pandemic, helping the homeless has been very popular
- 34:06because it's a need, like it's evident, like when we were in lockdown, it was evident who,
- 34:14the many, many people who didn't have a home.
- 34:18So it's harder actually for those who are working with the vulnerable who face trauma
- 34:27and or let's say people who work with pets that have been traumatized and you live their
- 34:37trauma.
- 34:40And so it's important to practice self-care and have your limits.
- 34:50And so some people, so I met people who, you know, counselors whose doctors told them,
- 34:58find another living because you're going from charity, like charity to charity, charity
- 35:05with the same mission, but you burn out because you can't handle the trauma that you're listening
- 35:16to or hearing or you're seeing or hearing from your clients.
- 35:23And it's the same goes for pets is that if it's bad for your mental health, it's important
- 35:32to realize like, is this the right career for me as well?
- 35:38And it's important to be able to distance yourself and not make it a 24-7 career.
- 35:45I'll give you another example of, I think another example of where people have difficulty
- 35:54in their careers.
- 35:57You know, I had the privilege in my last job of working with many Inuit women who live
- 36:03in Northern Quebec.
- 36:06They live in a very, very, well, much more rural environment.
- 36:12They come down to the South, often with not the education, the language, the background
- 36:19needed to work in an urban environment.
- 36:22Especially Indigenous women fall prey to the sex trade.
- 36:30And our counselors also, the counselors that work with these ladies, it's hard for them.
- 36:37But who it's even harder for is if you have an Indigenous employee who works with Indigenous
- 36:48clients who could be relatives, who could be, you know, like in other words, who could
- 36:57be relatives or friends of relatives.
- 36:59It's a small community.
- 37:02And so not only are they helping people nine to five during their work, but they're also
- 37:12helping people because they're successful in, you know, during their private time.
- 37:21So and they tend to burn out very quickly and do not last more than two years.
- 37:29It's very unfortunate.
- 37:30So we can say that for a lot of communities who come, you know, they're successful, they
- 37:37come to another city, they send money back home, or they're the, you know, they're the
- 37:44first to graduate from university and they're helping maybe their own family that might
- 37:51have a lot of problems during their own time.
- 37:56You really have to take the time to rest and be strong for your job, which is, you know,
- 38:05maybe Monday to Friday, nine to five or other times.
- 38:09So I also want to tell you about, speak to you about rejection.
- 38:14So I'm now the executive director of Youth Employment Services in Montreal, also known
- 38:23by its marketing name, yes, Employment Plus Entrepreneurship.
- 38:29And I came to this organization thinking, well, I'm a rock star, like in fundraising,
- 38:35and all of a sudden, I don't feel like a rock star.
- 38:38Right.
- 38:39Why?
- 38:40Because our mission really is to help young people, 18 to 39 year olds, find work and
- 38:54to also help people of any age become entrepreneurs and launch companies, as well as we have a
- 39:07third pillar of service where it's, we help artists, we teach artists how to monetize
- 39:12their work.
- 39:14So we really contribute a lot to the economy, we prevent vulnerabilities, we launch certainly
- 39:21500, 600 or more companies per year.
- 39:26And we contribute to the, like we contribute to the wellbeing and to the fabric of Montreal.
- 39:32Our mission, however, is to help English speakers in Quebec and to help them learn French and
- 39:41prevent them from leaving the province because they can't find work or they can't find their
- 39:47place.
- 39:49It's not a sexy mission, I'm told.
- 39:53It's not sexy because let's say the language of the majority is French.
- 40:00And you know, some people prefer, most people prefer helping everyone regardless of their
- 40:08language.
- 40:09And I've been told that, especially by foundations, that we don't have the curb appeal or the
- 40:19sex appeal that a homeless organization does.
- 40:24So now I have to do my homework in crafting compelling stories and finding the type of
- 40:34donors that would be more interested in us.
- 40:38Yes, the government is interested in us, but you're at, you know, the government can change
- 40:45as we can see in the US right now, right?
- 40:49Lots of changes happening in the charitable sector.
- 40:53It could happen in Canada, it could happen anywhere as soon as there's a change in government.
- 40:58So I have to find the secret sauce of who will find us sexy?
- 41:05And how can I make us more sexy?
- 41:09So is it creating a new program where I'm helping more vulnerable communities such as
- 41:18young people aging out of foster care, veterans, or Indigenous people, or more visible minorities
- 41:28who have a tougher time finding jobs?
- 41:32Absolutely.
- 41:33That's, that's, to think that, you know, you find yourself in this situation with this,
- 41:44it feels like sadistic, like,
- 41:50It's cruel.
- 41:53It's cruel.
- 41:56It doesn't.
- 41:59It's like, what do you mean it's not sexy?
- 42:03It's very sexy.
- 42:04I've been told that several times.
- 42:06You're not sexy.
- 42:09It's a weird problem also to have in North America, you know, not that many people can
- 42:15relate to how come, you know, you're having problem with, with, you know, serving English
- 42:22speaking communities.
- 42:23And it's just the, the crazy circumstances of living in Quebec.
- 42:29And, and thank you so much for sharing that struggle because I'm 100% sure that many of
- 42:38our listeners are facing some kind of same struggles and, and are thinking maybe I'm
- 42:46the problem in this equation.
- 42:49You know?
- 42:50No, no, no, no, no, but it's, it's just, it's a question of finding the solution.
- 42:58And sometimes, you know, there's a lot of finger pointing.
- 43:04I think it's important.
- 43:05Well, first, let me, let me backtrack.
- 43:07First of all, it's important to do a matrix, right?
- 43:11So when you're fundraising, you have a pipeline, you want to know what is your success rate
- 43:19and is your success rate getting better over time and why, right?
- 43:24So I think that one person at the very least should be producing, let's say at the very
- 43:35least 50 proposals a week, right?
- 43:39And if, if they're all successful, that means you have twice the amount of work the following
- 43:46year.
- 43:47You have to be, you have to vision what's going to be your needs later on because that
- 43:52means you're going to have, you're going to be working twice as hard filling out reports
- 43:58and as well as renewing applications or finding new people, right?
- 44:05So you have to think along those lines and you have to think, okay, so if I'm constantly
- 44:12getting rejected, speak to the people who have rejected you and ask them for their advice.
- 44:22Their advice is free and people love to give advice.
- 44:29And so that's what I've been doing is I'm, I'm, I'm asking people for advice actually
- 44:34now I'm, we're doing a strategic plan.
- 44:38We're interviewing people.
- 44:40We're asking people, what do you think of our mission?
- 44:44What would make it more interesting?
- 44:46And I think that, you know, the, the crazy, crazy politics that we're in is that we would
- 44:58be seen, the English speaking community would be seen as a partner in trying to promote
- 45:07the French language and the culture as well.
- 45:12So how like, as they say in French, you cannot now, especially with the new laws that were
- 45:22in place two years ago, you cannot get away with not speaking French because the language
- 45:30of business for companies having 25 people or more has to be in French.
- 45:38And that even includes us.
- 45:40So we're at least 25 employees.
- 45:46So that brings other interesting things because, you know, like even if you have an event planner
- 45:55who has to look for venues, you can't go out there and only speak English when you're looking
- 46:04for a venue and your counterpart is a francophone.
- 46:09It's, it's, it's, it's, you know, it's not done.
- 46:13Right.
- 46:14So I think everybody has to do their part in speaking French, but certainly being bilingual
- 46:22or having more than two languages is extremely desirable.
- 46:26Definitely.
- 46:27And yeah, as you said, in this political climate, I think we should be investing in economic
- 46:35development.
- 46:36I think again, incontournable.
- 46:41I want to talk about that step of crafting a story and a compelling case and maybe start
- 46:50with this problem that I think exists in the animal cause, which is, you know, how much
- 47:00cruelty do I show on social media and how, you know, do I, do I show pictures of dogs,
- 47:08cows, chickens, whatever, being in pain or being happy?
- 47:16And I have had conversations where people have told me, you know, leaders of organizations,
- 47:27there is a, we don't like always peddling the, those negative emotions that come with
- 47:34presenting difficult footage, but it does, you know, people do react more intensely to
- 47:44that and get more engaged, but at the same time, you know, on the long-term, is that
- 47:49a viable strategy?
- 47:52So what are your thoughts on that?
- 47:56I think when someone, when you present a sad story, but then it has a solution, right,
- 48:06is much more compelling.
- 48:09So it's the same thing that goes for homeless people, like we, I started off by showing,
- 48:16I remember the first picture I used was a picture of somebody sleeping in our garbage
- 48:25sheds.
- 48:28Very jarring situation, but I also used a before and after picture of this person sitting
- 48:37on her bed in her brand new apartment.
- 48:44I think, look, I mean, it's marketing, right?
- 48:50And you, is it a necessary evil to show the sad pictures?
- 48:55No, but I think you also have to listen to your donors who will then tell you, you know,
- 49:02I'm tired of always looking at haggard faces.
- 49:08Can you show me smiling faces?
- 49:12Right?
- 49:13So I remember having that effect when we had a fundraising event and we had, we announced
- 49:24a million dollar gift from a donor.
- 49:30And we had, it was like, you know, a simple three person band singing, Here Comes the
- 49:40Sun from the Beatles.
- 49:43And we flashed pictures of smiling women throughout the song.
- 49:51It had such a profound, it touched everybody.
- 49:56There were like 300 people in the room and they were crying.
- 50:02You know, you don't cry so much when, like maybe the recipients, like I know I would
- 50:11cry if somebody gave me a million dollar gift for my cause, but to have everybody crying
- 50:19in the room and then to see all these smiling pictures, some of them toothless, you know,
- 50:28it has, it depends.
- 50:30You have to listen and be intuitive to your audience.
- 50:35You know, I think you have to use all sorts of messaging as well.
- 50:42Like you have to not forget to thank people.
- 50:47I think that's also important that not only to ask for money, but to send pictures of
- 50:54smiling dogs or animals or cats, because I believe that they smile too.
- 51:02They really do.
- 51:05And say thank you.
- 51:07Yes.
- 51:08I think that for many people, there's an inclination to peddling into the more negative emotions,
- 51:15the outrage, the anger, the fear instead of, and there's another, we're overlooking the
- 51:24positive ones and the power they could have and they could bring in.
- 51:28I love this idea of mixing the two and giving a positive twist to that story.
- 51:34Yes.
- 51:35I think it's genius.
- 51:36Yes.
- 51:37As a matter of fact, I mean, I told you an example of what I did at the beginning, but
- 51:43more and more I was using positive stories like the women who went to school, the women
- 51:50who got their kids back, the ones who got off of, went to drug rehab, are living clean.
- 51:59And you know, so I think it's more important to convey the positivity than what I started
- 52:11off with.
- 52:14Yes and people, you know, we're living in this same, you know, more or less negative
- 52:21atmosphere with the news cycle and all of that.
- 52:24So we're looking for places where we get our inspiring stories and definitely for the listener
- 52:35who is managing a nonprofit or a fundraiser.
- 52:39You could be that place for your book.
- 52:41I think also it's important to convey the good stories that were had because of a donation.
- 52:56And it makes people dream like I can be that person as well.
- 53:01So when the last organization that I worked for had its first million dollar gift, it
- 53:09made people dream and other people came out of the woodwork to also give their a million
- 53:17dollar gift or more.
- 53:20Yes, I absolutely love this advice.
- 53:25We should feature other donors and share their stories and even give them the mic and let
- 53:33them talk about why they are donors and what made them support this cause.
- 53:39They're in the best position to do this.
- 53:42Right.
- 53:43But I don't think I really answered your question about how do you craft a case, like let's
- 53:49say a case for support.
- 53:50Is that what your question was at some point?
- 53:54So it's important to not only start with a powerful mission and story, but it's also
- 54:03important to define your problem clearly.
- 54:07Like what do you need to solve a problem?
- 54:16You use data.
- 54:20In my case, I would say 40% of young job seekers who are English speaking are struggling to
- 54:30find work due to language barriers or lack of experience.
- 54:37They need this and this type of support.
- 54:40It costs X amount of money.
- 54:45Explain your solution.
- 54:49And what is our success rate in the past?
- 54:56Right.
- 54:57We help over 2,000 job seekers land meaningful work every year and demonstrate an urgency.
- 55:06Like you have to look at your statistics to tell them our calls have increased by 27%.
- 55:15We can't keep up with demand.
- 55:17We need your support.
- 55:22And why would your gift make a difference?
- 55:26Sometimes especially in raising money for animal causes, it's small gifts.
- 55:32So what can you, you know, you break down the gift, the impact of a gift.
- 55:39So what does $50 give you?
- 55:42What does $500 give you?
- 55:45What does $5,000 give you?
- 55:48And you just be inclusive to everybody and all types of donors will show up.
- 55:56Another question about the case is the medium we use to present that case.
- 56:03And you did mention traditional media.
- 56:06You also mentioned direct mail, which surprises a lot of people.
- 56:10Yeah.
- 56:11Especially young people.
- 56:12Yes.
- 56:13There's still an older generation of people who still write out checks and donate to direct
- 56:23mail.
- 56:24We don't get as much direct mail as we used to.
- 56:28The rate of response is higher than in social media.
- 56:36But I guess it depends on the cause really.
- 56:40I would imagine that for the homeless.
- 56:45So the homeless, helping the homeless or food banks or poverty relief organizations tends
- 56:57to attract people who believe in their faith.
- 57:05Right?
- 57:06They're either they come from all sorts of religions.
- 57:10They're faith based.
- 57:13And they have a deep belief in helping those who are disadvantaged and help.
- 57:20It's their beliefs to really help people out of difficult situations.
- 57:27I think when it comes to animal causes, it's probably the same thing.
- 57:33It's older people who probably are the donors.
- 57:38It's important to analyze your donor database.
- 57:43There are also companies that do that that will tell you who, like based on their postal
- 57:54codes, are they from wealthy neighborhoods?
- 57:59Do they have a lot of like their house could be worth a lot?
- 58:05Are they educated?
- 58:07Are they elderly?
- 58:08Are they in an area that is frequented by a lot of elderly people?
- 58:14So I used to once work for our community foundation.
- 58:19I was the CEO.
- 58:21And we would do direct mail or advertising in magazines for seniors.
- 58:35Because the mission of the community foundation is to set up funds, funds that, you know,
- 58:44that where the assets stay in place, but the interest is given in perpetuity.
- 58:50So it's a form of plan giving.
- 58:53And so it's older people who are attracted to that.
- 58:56So where do you find the older people?
- 58:59And sure enough, you know, people would respond to direct mail.
- 59:02Yes, send me more information.
- 59:05And then they have a conversation with the plan giving director or officer and a contract
- 59:12assigned for, you know, maybe donating their house or other assets.
- 59:17I know that many animal nonprofits are on social media a lot.
- 59:25That's where I see many of them.
- 59:28And my feed, you know, as someone who supports this cause is just overcrowded with different
- 59:37animal nonprofits.
- 59:39And I do see their messaging and sometimes their fundraisers and how much, you know,
- 59:49their mission echoes each other.
- 59:53So for instance, you have a sanctuary based in Oregon, another one based in Quebec.
- 1:00:00But it's the same.
- 1:00:01It's a sanctuary for animals and with the same mission.
- 1:00:05And I guess maybe another question I had regarding that is how should you collaborate with other
- 1:00:16nonprofits in your fundraising?
- 1:00:20Maybe to avoid that other, you know, competition of, you know, attention or, you know, how
- 1:00:30do you interpret that situation?
- 1:00:32I think that what I can see from the animal charities is that they're very territorial.
- 1:00:45So for instance, one charity that helps animals is very much in a local newspaper and they
- 1:00:55have space that's given to them for free for adopting pets, right?
- 1:01:04And then people will go to their website.
- 1:01:06And if they're really interested in that charity and helping, you know, foster animals or donate,
- 1:01:13that's their go-to because it's part of the fabric of the community.
- 1:01:19So it's highly unlikely that for instance, a charity, an animal charity in Quebec will
- 1:01:26collaborate with another charity in Oregon.
- 1:01:30But it is interesting that if you are involved, very involved with the charity in Montreal,
- 1:01:36that you want to look at what are their ways of attracting new donors, right, to their
- 1:01:46charity that can be brought here.
- 1:01:50But I don't hear of so many stories of, I don't know, in the US, it's unusual in that
- 1:01:59people will come travel with pets all the way from Kentucky, like in the South, all
- 1:02:07the way to the North in New York City.
- 1:02:09There are plenty of pets also in New York City that need a home, right?
- 1:02:14So people, I think people realize that and they're more territorial and wanting to help
- 1:02:27a charity in their own community.
- 1:02:31So again, in Montreal, you'll have, you know, you'll have places in that are outside the
- 1:02:38island or at the west end of the...
- 1:02:42People are affected by their own community charities, but these charities will always
- 1:02:48become, will most likely always be small boutique charities.
- 1:02:53And that's okay.
- 1:02:54That's okay.
- 1:02:56Yeah.
- 1:02:57That's the weird thing about social media.
- 1:02:59You know, you don't feel like you belong to a certain place.
- 1:03:04Like you see, you develop a relationship with different charities that are not in your neighborhood
- 1:03:11or in your country.
- 1:03:13Right.
- 1:03:14Right.
- 1:03:15But yeah, well, there must be a lot of charities and it must take up a lot of one's time to
- 1:03:22do that, right?
- 1:03:25To pay attention to all these charities.
- 1:03:31I'm not implying that I do.
- 1:03:34Okay.
- 1:03:36Is there a ceiling for fundraising?
- 1:03:41A ceiling?
- 1:03:42What do you mean?
- 1:03:43In terms of capacity.
- 1:03:44So you mentioned how, you know, some sanctuaries, it's more of a boutique model because of the
- 1:03:53limitations of where you are and all of that.
- 1:03:59But how do you assess, you know, I'm the type of charity that will never grow past that
- 1:04:06and that's my ceiling and I should assess my success according to that.
- 1:04:15Is there a way to find that out?
- 1:04:18Well, I think it's, there's a way of finding that out by doing a feasibility study, right?
- 1:04:26Like a feasibility study is basically, usually it's done by a third party who will analyze
- 1:04:34your mission, see if people outside your regular group would be like, you kind of think, okay,
- 1:04:42who would I love to get as a donor?
- 1:04:47And so you ask these people, would you ever donate to my cause and what would I have to
- 1:04:54do for you to be interested in me?
- 1:05:00So there are consultants who do that.
- 1:05:03I'm also, I also do it with my own donors, like I'm well known enough that people will
- 1:05:10take my call to do that.
- 1:05:17But I think sometimes it's also then doing a strategic plan to see how can your mission
- 1:05:25change because you have to turn yourself into a pretzel to be something that you're not
- 1:05:33to change in order for people to donate even more, right?
- 1:05:41So one good example of a charity that I was the executive director of was a national charity
- 1:05:51whose model was to adopt kids, quote unquote adopt, it was a real adoption, kids from underperforming
- 1:06:00schools in challenged neighborhoods where there was a very low high school graduation
- 1:06:10rate, give them the same kids, like let's say from grade three up until grade 12, an
- 1:06:18afterschool program consisting of tutoring, mentorship and fun team activities to the
- 1:06:26same kids.
- 1:06:27It's a very expensive and long model.
- 1:06:33And that's an example of a boutique charity because not everybody is interested in that
- 1:06:39model, right?
- 1:06:41I mean, it'll work, it's great.
- 1:06:43It'll help a few thousand kids per year, but it's not an evergreen model.
- 1:06:58The group that you adopt is the only group that you adopt.
- 1:07:02If they graduate, will you adopt another group?
- 1:07:07And so the model was originally that it had to be a high net worth individual to do it,
- 1:07:13but who, not many people want to spend $1.2 million at the time, or it's probably more
- 1:07:20than that, over 10, 12 years to the same group of kids.
- 1:07:25And that was it, right?
- 1:07:26Well, you've helped people graduate from high school and you also help pay for their college
- 1:07:31education after that, but it doesn't appeal to everybody.
- 1:07:37But that's a boutique charity.
- 1:07:39Definitely.
- 1:07:40Marina, I don't want to take more of your time.
- 1:07:44Do you have any parting words, last advice before we end the recording?
- 1:07:51Just love what you do.
- 1:07:52That's it.
- 1:07:53That's all that's important.
- 1:07:54Love what you do.
- 1:07:55Thank you so much, Marina.
- 1:08:00Thank you very much, valuable advice, and I hope this podcast gets shared among, you
- 1:08:08know, in the animal cause and activists and leaders, because there's a need to do better
- 1:08:16fundraising that space.
- 1:08:19And yeah, so thank you.
- 1:08:21Thank you so much.
- 1:08:22You're very welcome.
- 1:08:23Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:08:25I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:08:29Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:08:32Again, thank you so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.