Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Podcast: Pricing for Value in Engineering Services
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to Engineering Influence Podcast from the American Council of Engineering
- 0:03Companies, coming to you from the 2026 Fall Conference in Phoenix, Arizona.
- 0:08And today we had a great presentation on something that is very important to
- 0:11the industry because it's not just a question about really, you know,
- 0:15how we structure, not just how we price our work, but our value and how we consider our value.
- 0:21And this ties into work that the ACEC Research Institute's been doing really
- 0:26to look at, you know, really how engineering firms are,
- 0:31structuring how they price their work and how they're shifting and could shift
- 0:36to a value-based pricing model.
- 0:38And on stage, we had Greg Kelly, CEO of STV and vice chair of the Research Institute.
- 0:43He was joined by Keith London.
- 0:45He's the president and CEO of Kennedy Jenks out of California.
- 0:48And our own Matt Reifer, who is our VP of Government Affairs for and really
- 0:52handles transportation policy, infrastructure, and then also advocacy council.
- 0:56Great conversation on this piece of research on value-based pricing.
- 1:01Greg, thanks for being on the show.
- 1:04Let's kick off. what is value-based pricing and why should firms be paying attention
- 1:08to this research? Okay. So perhaps just a little bit of history here. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:12Before we talk about specifically what is value-based pricing. Yeah.
- 1:16The ACC Research Institute identified what we saw as a catalyst for change.
- 1:22It's AI. It's all around us.
- 1:24And our work historically has been on a time and material basis.
- 1:29So the level of effort was how many hours does it take to design something?
- 1:34When you think about the evolution of technology around our space,
- 1:38and it's coming, it's here in certain parts of our business today.
- 1:42As that evolves, we're going to see perhaps a reduction in the level of effort required.
- 1:47But when you step back and say, but wait a second, what's the value that's being created?
- 1:51And so this started as a conversation with the Research Institute and then with
- 1:56a lot of support, including BST.
- 1:59Amir Baldor just was absolutely stepped right up and said, this is a really
- 2:03important thing to help fund. We commissioned a study.
- 2:06We hired Paul Janowski at the University of Colorado Boulder,
- 2:10and we interviewed nearly 500 professionals.
- 2:14Dozens of executives for this study to say, what should we be thinking about
- 2:19as an industry in a world where the amount of hours to produce something may
- 2:24get reduced, but the value isn't necessarily reduced.
- 2:28And so the learnings from the study have been very interesting.
- 2:32It started out, a lot of people thought lump sum was value-based pricing.
- 2:37We think of lump sum as a bridge towards value-based pricing.
- 2:41We're in time and material. We move towards lump sum. But in the future,
- 2:46what is the value we're creating for our clients? And that comes in different ways.
- 2:50So that's the genesis of the study. So we were excited the study was released.
- 2:54We were able to talk about it today in front of a thousand plus people.
- 2:57And we're pretty excited about now starting a conversation about how we value this crisis.
- 3:02And the nice thing about the study is that those nearly 500 people that you
- 3:06interviewed, they're not just engineers.
- 3:09You looked at other industries. So you looked at IT, tech, you looked at legal,
- 3:14you looked at other fields because engineers are not kind of on an island to themselves.
- 3:20There are other industries that are facing the same similar challenge.
- 3:23We looked at professionals, other professional services, as you just mentioned,
- 3:26Jeff, say, what can we learn from their journey on value-based pricing?
- 3:30So you could take, say, management consulting as an example.
- 3:33Oftentimes, management consulting will take an assignment, and it will be outcome-based.
- 3:38So I think about hours to outcomes, and where.
- 3:42You work with a client and say, what problem are we trying to solve?
- 3:46What outcome are we looking to achieve?
- 3:48And what is that worth in terms of, you begin to say, what is that worth to you as a client?
- 3:54So it's starting with client value, so you're changing discussion,
- 3:58as opposed to how much does it cost to produce a bridge?
- 4:01Yeah, absolutely. And this is really great because it is moving.
- 4:05You know, we always talk about engineers as trusted advisors to their clients,
- 4:08right? But at the same time, they're still charging based off of the time it
- 4:12takes to do the project, but not on the actual value that they can deliver to the client.
- 4:18And what is that value? Like, if you have a bridge that's going to go from design
- 4:22to construction in, let's say, they say 12 months. Well, let's just put out numbers.
- 4:2712 months, but actually it's going to take eight because you've actually created,
- 4:31you know, a savings. So what's that cost?
- 4:33What's that delta in value? And how should that be priced into the project?
- 4:38Yeah, it starts with a conversation with your client on the front.
- 4:42What are we trying to achieve here? In that case, it's a mobility solution.
- 4:46Yeah. Connecting two communities. It could be a new bridge or replacing an old bridge.
- 4:50What else is important to you as a client? Well, it's important we have it by
- 4:53a certain date because there's a revenue stream being realized.
- 4:56Okay. What else is important to you? You know, the quality or the impact on the community.
- 5:01So, what you want to do is uncover what those value drivers are from the client.
- 5:08And then, of course, we're going to design or produce or permit that solution.
- 5:13But it's then you value your service based on what value they're trying to extract from that project.
- 5:18So from your experience in the profession, I mean, where have you seen instances.
- 5:25Of this emerge without, let's say, calling it value-based pricing?
- 5:28But, you know, always you're looking at ways to perform better compared to your
- 5:34competition and also to maintain a long-term existing, you know,
- 5:38a long-term relationship with your client. You're looking for areas of value.
- 5:42You know, what are some examples from your experience where this kind of fits in?
- 5:45I'll give you two examples. One is where a client is working towards a full
- 5:51funding grant agreement and there's a deadline that they have to meet.
- 5:54So working towards deadlines to help them secure what might be that grant to
- 5:59help you build the project, that's an outcome-based way to think about it.
- 6:04A second would be something more recent, where one of our businesses,
- 6:08a particular client in healthcare space, needed a particular piece of medical equipment procured.
- 6:15And they needed it procured on a schedule, accelerated schedule,
- 6:19and they needed it absolutely spec'd the right way before they went out with the procurement.
- 6:23And they turned to our professional and said,
- 6:25We need this. We need it fast. I trust you. I trust your judgment and expertise,
- 6:31and I'll pay you $50,000 to get it done. And by the way, if you have to use
- 6:35AI, that's fine because I trust you in what you're going to produce.
- 6:39What was that client saying?
- 6:41Schedule was important. Quality was important. And what they valued that at.
- 6:47But they valued your expertise you were bringing to the table. So,
- 6:51We as engineers, if we approach our conversation set with what are you looking
- 6:55to achieve and how do we help you achieve that? And that's how you begin to
- 6:58say, what's the value of our service?
- 7:02How many hours does it take to produce X?
- 7:05And that is really important as an anti-commoditization art.
- 7:10So well said, Jeff. Right. So it's saying you're not hiring an engineer just
- 7:14to be a square peg in a square hole, right? You're saying we have an existing
- 7:19relationship with you. We have an objective we want to reach.
- 7:22Let's work collaboratively and get your expertise in how we do this.
- 7:26That is really the underpinning of the entire value argument.
- 7:30You're absolutely right. It starts with the conversation up front.
- 7:32What outcomes are we trying to achieve? And historically, that has not been the case.
- 7:38We're always working side by side with our clients, but it's stepping back at
- 7:42the front end and saying, we're solving a problem. What is that problem?
- 7:46As opposed to, what does it cost?
- 7:49And the way that AI and technology comes in, it's also.
- 7:56Correct me if I'm wrong here, but I've talked to a lot of people who are also
- 8:01promoting the idea of moving beyond just saying, okay, well,
- 8:04the client has come and approached us with an idea of we need a mobility solution.
- 8:09It's going to be a bridge.
- 8:11Our task is to design this bridge, to go and say, we will create a digital product
- 8:16for you that will actually have value beyond the construction of the bridge.
- 8:21We can maintain that data for you over a long term so that when you come up
- 8:25to the point of having to manage the rehabilitation or maintenance of that bridge,
- 8:31we can provide this for you over,
- 8:33a decade or so, not just that one project.
- 8:37You know, how is technology data, we're talking about data connectivity and
- 8:42exactly how firms are managing and structuring the data to create value with their own processes.
- 8:48You know, how is that shifting the conversations?
- 8:51I'm going to start, I'm going to answer your question. I'm going to start with,
- 8:54what some of the popular conversation is out there.
- 8:57And that is AI is going to reduce our hours. It's going to reduce our revenue.
- 9:00And we're going to need fewer engineers and get fewer jobs available.
- 9:04This is how we're going to solve the workforce challenge.
- 9:06And there's a lot of noise out there.
- 9:09Jeff, what you described is exactly the kind of value engineers can bring to clients.
- 9:14We should look at technology and tools as an enabler, not a threat to revenue and to our businesses.
- 9:21And if it can allow us to provide a longer-term service to the client, in this case,
- 9:27what you're describing is full lifecycle asset management, because we've got
- 9:31everything from conception through operation, that is how we should be thinking about value.
- 9:38And how those models work are to be determined just yet, but they're going to
- 9:41come through conversation.
- 9:43I think it's also important to recognize that the existing models of T&M and
- 9:48lump sum and fixed fees, they're not going to go away. They're not going to change overnight.
- 9:54And I think what we learned in this study, the adjacent industries haven't changed
- 9:58overnight either. So there was this frothiness earlier this year around,
- 10:03you know, oh my goodness, We're going to be out of business.
- 10:06That's not proven to be true, nor do I think it will be true.
- 10:09What we're going to do with this study is begin to have those conversations
- 10:12with our clients that will reframe the problems we're trying to solve and look
- 10:17for those longer-term solutions that you're describing.
- 10:20Let's talk about the public sector. And, you know, they're generally slower to adapt, right?
- 10:27Right. So what is the industry's role in educating and helping the public sector
- 10:32procurement officials understand this?
- 10:36This also goes back into the larger QBS argument of saying, you know,
- 10:39this is why qualifications matter.
- 10:41And this is this value is something special when you're dealing with taxpayer
- 10:45dollars, when you're dealing with, you know, not just the bottom line,
- 10:49but a lot of other stakeholder interests that go into public projects.
- 10:53You know, what is the role of the industry in helping to educate the public
- 10:58sector on the value of value-based products?
- 11:01The role of the industry is vital. It's on us as engineering companies,
- 11:05all our members of ACC, to be informed on the topic.
- 11:11And be thinking about how procurement rules, regulations, existing ways of doing
- 11:17business, processes can be modified to accommodate new ways of thinking.
- 11:21Which, by the way, should be improving the outcomes. Technology should help
- 11:25us improve the outcomes for our public sector customers and our private sector clients as well.
- 11:31So I think ACEC plays a vital role there too.
- 11:34The advocacy team at ACEC has done just a great job. And so having them alongside
- 11:40of us to have those kinds of conversations and perhaps there's an advocacy campaign
- 11:45and just like QBS that you mentioned.
- 11:48I mean, that was the passage of Brooks Law and QBS was the right thing to do.
- 11:55For society and where the engineers work.
- 11:59But also, I think this can have that same sort of impact.
- 12:03Yeah. That we're not looking, we're not racing for the cheapest solution.
- 12:05We're racing for what's the best solution. Yeah.
- 12:08So, I think we should be thinking about value-based pricing as maybe,
- 12:12you know, version two of QBS as we look to the future.
- 12:15Yeah. And that's why I think constant engagement from the advocacy perspective,
- 12:19especially now, because, I mean, no matter who wins a couple of days from the
- 12:23time of this recording, when in the election.
- 12:26There are going to be a ton of new members of Congress coming in and they need
- 12:29to be reminded of why the Brooks Act was important, why QBS is important,
- 12:35what the engineers do and why it benefits society.
- 12:39And, you know, to make a call for advocacy engagement to our members,
- 12:44that's why, because it never ends. It's a continual education process.
- 12:48Something like this, where we're talking about the potential,
- 12:50as you put it, you know, as the potential successor or, you know, evolution of QBS.
- 12:56You know, it starts with a conversation, and it's just sustained engagement and education.
- 13:04And that goes to the ACEC Research Institute in general. I mean,
- 13:07the research that you have provided, not only for the economic impact of the
- 13:12engineering industries and society, but then also the research on AI.
- 13:18You just put out an AI at risk study that was significant.
- 13:21You have, of course, data connectivity coming out. You've got the value-based
- 13:25pricing study. You have the Firm of the Future project. There's so much going on.
- 13:29Of course, you've grown by leaps and bounds in a short period of time.
- 13:33What are you working on right now, and how can the industry contribute to the Institute's mission?
- 13:41Jeff, super proud of what the Research Institute has been able to accomplish.
- 13:46And that's a reflection of the support that we've got from across different
- 13:52industries and members.
- 13:54You know, I mentioned, you know, BST, when we've got, you know,
- 13:57all the MOs and we've got a whole slide of probably a hundred plus firms that
- 14:03are supporting the Institute.
- 14:06And I think that's because of the quality of the research we've put forward
- 14:10that you just mentioned.
- 14:11We had a list earlier this year of about two dozen plus potential research topics,
- 14:18that we gathered from reaching out to our members and supporters.
- 14:22What's on your mind? What would you like to see quality research on to help
- 14:26you improve your business and the business of all of ACEC member firms?
- 14:33And we were able to kind of take that list and consolidate it,
- 14:37and we'd come forward with a handful of research topics for the coming year
- 14:42that we're going to be mobilizing the research team on as we come through the
- 14:45fall and put some work scopes together.
- 14:47This is an ongoing process. I would say with additional support,
- 14:51we could undertake more projects.
- 14:53But right now, we're really trying to focus on ones like Firm of the Future
- 14:57series that we've done, which has been really powerful.
- 15:00When you think about the external factors just in our communities in terms of
- 15:05changing demographic, new workforces, new ways of working, emergence of technology,
- 15:11that whole vision of the Firm of the Future series is really meant to help with that.
- 15:14And you mentioned a couple of those studies already. Yeah, it's providing the
- 15:17intelligence and the information for leaders to be able to prepare for the future
- 15:22and to position their firm.
- 15:23So really would encourage anyone out there to get involved and to check out
- 15:29the research from the ACC Research Institute.
- 15:32ACCresearchinstitute.org. We'll put the link, of course, in the show notes and
- 15:35a link to the study in the show notes.
- 15:38Greg, thank you for a great conversation. I appreciate you taking the time to join us.
- 15:42Always great to be with you, Jeff. Fantastic. And again, this has been Engineering
- 15:46Influence. podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies,
- 15:48and we'll see you next time.