Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Episode 1-Clue
Transcript
- 0:00This is the first episode of a new series on five g f D.
- 0:03This was made possible by my Patreon backers. This one will be going out
- 0:07on this feed for free for everyone to listen to. The rest of them
- 0:12will be released exclusively on Patreon, where we'll look into the Seventh Seal and
- 0:18Battleship and Dungeons and Dragons on all of these great movies that are attached to
- 0:23board games. I hope you enjoy this episode, and I hope you consider
- 0:26coming over to patreon dot com forward slash five g f D and helping these
- 0:31shows get made. Thank you for listening. Yeah, So, I was
- 0:41just saying, like, I think I've seen him in something else. I
- 0:44think it's totally that guy? Is it that guy? Is that guy?
- 0:46Right? King on a second yet? Hello? Yeah? Can you stop
- 0:49talking please? I'm just having a chat with my wife. You shouldn't have
- 0:52a chat with your bloody your business, No, it's my business when you're
- 0:55interrupting the bloody film, Will you please mind your own business? Who do
- 0:59you think I think I'm better than you? It's fired you for d at
- 1:06the movies. Wh Stevie? So you you've got popcorn in your beard?
- 1:15You look like you've been sticking your face in it. Yeah, I mean,
- 1:19do you do that thing where you cut up a hole in the bottom
- 1:21of the popcorn? You know, you know how you miss is to get
- 1:23some popcorn? You know how you're always giving me a ship for being middle
- 1:26class? Yeah, and I deny it, like, you know, humorously.
- 1:30Yeah, yeah, I actually have a popcorn machine in my flat.
- 1:33You have a popcorn machine? Yeah? Yeah, of course it's next to
- 1:37the home theater. That's true. That's that's that's where I watched the film.
- 1:40What amazes me is that you have a revolving staff of ushers and that
- 1:46when we came to watch the movie. So usually for the listeners, this
- 1:49Welcome to the five. The first inaugural, the first inaugural, stud first
- 1:53inaugural. What does that imply? Well, that's a tautology, isn't it.
- 1:57Yeah? I think so. I mean, we didn't do this last
- 1:57year. No, like it would be like the inaugural edition. Yeah,
- 2:02it's not an anniversary show. No, it's the inaugural. Would you have
- 2:06a second inaugural? No, because inaugural it just doesn't it doesn't make sense
- 2:09to say first inaugural, right, No, I know, I'm that's what
- 2:12I'm saying, because I stop myself mid sentence because I said first inaugural,
- 2:15and then I realized that's a huge tautology. Is the first inaugural? I
- 2:21suppose like augur as in you know, like read the future kind of thing,
- 2:25like bringing in something. I guess maybe I don't know. I'm not
- 2:29looking. I'm not looking at my Latin dictionary right anyway, So yeah,
- 2:31it's the first movie show listeners welcome. It started off as focused as always.
- 2:37As always so usually for the listeners, we will talk about the movie
- 2:43before we watch it, but due to come to scheduling conflicts, we'd like
- 2:46to watch the movie then come back and do the original. Wait we're opening,
- 2:51bit, you have a you have an idea for how this will normally
- 2:53go, oh yeah, I've got structure it night and everything. So it
- 2:55didn't happen the first time, no, but for sure every other time every
- 3:00time. So we're going to do what. We're gonna watch the movie.
- 3:02No, we talk about the movie, what we expected to be, what
- 3:06are what our thoughts, Then we watch the movie, then we come back
- 3:10and talk about thee like the same day. Well, yeah, that's that's
- 3:15the idea. It seems like a lot more work. Well, I mean,
- 3:19if you think talking a bit and then watching a movie's work, I
- 3:23mean, you're a member of the working class, have the softened paths of
- 3:28the terminally middle class, though, don't you. So I can also tell
- 3:31you what my expectations were in retrospects. Yeah, so well so, so
- 3:37I'm leading the show just because you get a couple of compliments on the discords.
- 3:40I don't think so this is yours. You know, they're not all
- 3:44here for you. It's amazing, Steve, They're not all here. It's
- 3:46amazing. Someone says something nice about you, and suddenly you've got these fucking
- 3:49delusions of grandeur. Yeah, someone says something nice about me, and suddenly
- 3:53you are fucking completely threatened by it. You feel I feel like you're a
- 3:55personally. I just think you should. I just think you should write in
- 4:00the charm of bit. What did you text to me the minute it happened
- 4:02you're fired? Well, I just like quoting your presidents in mind Trump,
- 4:09very good, very good. So anyway, So the thing is, what's
- 4:13interesting about Clue is it seems to me to be a kind of cult American
- 4:17iconic movie. It doesn't have that same resonance in Britain, And so this
- 4:24is not Is this a movie that I wouldn't necessarily say you grew up with,
- 4:28but you were kind of aware of since you were a kid. Yeah,
- 4:31I mean I wouldn't call it even a B movie. Actually, I
- 4:33think I don't think it is. It's just actually well known. I mean
- 4:38we're going to talk about this like well known but a cult movie. Yeah,
- 4:42I think that's I think that's fair. I mean Tim Curry himself is
- 4:45something of a cult figure. I guess sure it is. I mean everybody
- 4:47in this film is pretty much a cult figure. Yeah. And did you
- 4:51did you see it around the time it came out? So, I mean
- 4:57I don't remember. I have definitely seen it before, but it's been so
- 5:00long I didn't remember a thing. I mean, I don't even think I
- 5:02could have appreciated it, Like I couldn't have appreciated who each cast member was,
- 5:06Like I know who they are now and what they've done even since then,
- 5:10and like how significant it was that this is the group of people that
- 5:13came together to make this movie. I mean, what a cast, right,
- 5:16I don't even know if it was like that at the time, Like,
- 5:19so I'm gonna do Tim Curry already famous? I don't even know,
- 5:21Well he done already famous, Martin mull I mean he's done Rocky Horror.
- 5:27Yeah, and he'd done Legend. I think. Okay, I think Tim
- 5:30Curry was always one of those actors from from Rocky Horror that was that was
- 5:35a cult actor. Like Legend. I think is one of the best performances
- 5:39in cinema, but it's a very cult, weird performance. Have you seen
- 5:43Legend? No, I haven't where he plays the Devil. I haven't even
- 5:45seen Rocky Horror. Oh my god. We've got to try and tie Rocky
- 5:49Horror into board game somehow so we can watch Rocky Horror. My wife and
- 5:53I were in Washington, DC one year. I don't this is like ten
- 5:57years ago, and it was on Halloween, and I guess everybody goes and
- 6:00sees Rocky Horror Picture Show on the Halloween. So she dressed me up in
- 6:04drag wearing. I was dressed like a lady. Okay, in what sense?
- 6:11She make up and did something in my hair and I don't remember,
- 6:14you have a dress or something. There's a photo we'll get a photo for
- 6:16you. We'll put it on the disc I'm not I'm not looking now.
- 6:18I don't need that kind of distraction while recording a show. We'll put it
- 6:21on the discord. So if you're not in the discord, you better get
- 6:24in the discord. Bit like a lady on that picture of you with Ralph
- 6:30Nadery, Is that a compliment you're saying, like I look youthful? Right,
- 6:33No, I'm saying you got sort of stupid hippie hair attracted to me,
- 6:36is what you're trying to say. Way, I don't think that was
- 6:40ever in any di stave. Yeah. So we went and I so this
- 6:46this took some time to you know, to do this makeover. Yeah right,
- 6:47And I'm like, you know, maybe you should buy the tickets in
- 6:50advance for this film, right, so, no, no problem, it's
- 6:55not going to sell out, like it never sells out, never doesn't happen.
- 6:58No problem, Like, well, why don't you just buy them anyway?
- 7:01Because it takes like two seconds? Like sure, there's really it's no
- 7:04trouble to buy tickets online. But no, she was chill, right,
- 7:08yeah, no, I mean her friend. Oh right, So we were
- 7:11visiting her friend in Washington who lived there, and it was her idea that
- 7:15we do this. Yeah, and she didn't book the didn't book the tickets.
- 7:17So then we got to the theater. Then guess what, there were
- 7:20ample seats and you just easily found it and you sat down and you put
- 7:26newspapers on your heads like Rocky erapic suhre Nope, Nope, turned out.
- 7:29I walked in high heels to the movie theater in Washington, DC, our
- 7:31nation's capital, on Halloween for nothing excellent. And to this day I have
- 7:36not made up for this. I've not seen Rocky Heart pictures. Well,
- 7:39for the listeners, you've got to try and tell us how we can tie
- 7:42this into ball games so we can watch it, because it's absolutely brilliant.
- 7:45Is it like the casting of Tim Curry though? Is this somehow like troping
- 7:49on his cult status? Honestly, I don't think so. Now. I
- 7:53think now I think we're looking at it from twenty twenty four eyes. I
- 7:57think he was just cast because he was very good, and we'll get into
- 8:00how good he is in this film. But no, I don't think it
- 8:03was an ironic trophy thing. Yeah, it makes it less interesting to talk
- 8:07about if it wasn't though, does it? I mean, I want,
- 8:11I want to historicize this film. The thing is, the thing is what's
- 8:13what's fascinating about Tim Curry. So so the cast is wonderful. You've got
- 8:18Michael McKean, freshly out of Spinal Tap, very different, also culty also
- 8:22Culti. I mean Spinal Tap is definitely a CULTI movie. You've got Tim
- 8:26Curry. You've got maddling fucking Madeline Conn maddeling Khan in a very unmaddling khn
- 8:33role. For me, she's being very restrained here. Leslie and Warren as
- 8:37Miss Scarlett is brilliant. Martin mull who plays Colonel Mustard. Yeah, Christopher
- 8:43Lloyd, Christopher Lloyd. This was released the same year famous Back to the
- 8:50Future, probably famous from the TV show Taxi at that time, right,
- 8:54and this was released the same year as Back to the Future, which makes
- 8:58you realize how good the makeup was in buta the futures. It never occurred
- 9:01to me the professor what's his what's he called it? Back to the Future
- 9:03Brown, Doc Brown? Doc Brown wasn't a really old bloke, right,
- 9:07Yeah, Yeah, I'm a woman and I've just got to look up her
- 9:11name because I think the woman who plays, Interestingly enough, though both films
- 9:16set in nineteen fifty five, Aileen Brennan, who plays Missus Peacock, I
- 9:20think, is brilliant in many ways, steals the show. And so the
- 9:24thing is, this wasn't a film for me that was on my radar,
- 9:28particularly until I got into board games, right and then you know board games.
- 9:33So have you seen recently how the board game you probably wouldn't have,
- 9:37but how the board game community went nuts? The White ben the board game
- 9:41community, what is that it exists? Is in it? You are am
- 9:46I You're like a paramount sort of leader of it. How do you figure?
- 9:48I think if you did a random survey of like one thousand members of
- 9:52the supposed board game community, zero of them will have heard of me.
- 9:56Well, all of them will. So, but recently the bad game world
- 10:00went nuts because Pandemic is on a shelf in the first episode of the New
- 10:05True Detective. Okay, great, so everyone was screenshotting it and putting it
- 10:09on the internet. It's a bit sad, and Matt Lee Coock was like,
- 10:11oh that's cool. I get a grip people, and and so you
- 10:15know, little bit board games are bigger than TV now. Well, and
- 10:18the thing is, so I this is this is gonna be I think this
- 10:22is going to be a comment that I say a lot during these shows.
- 10:26I saw this film fairly recently. Before we watch every film that has ever
- 10:28been reed. I watch a lot recently, and I saw this because of
- 10:35being into board games right about Cone and the Barbarian. Haven't seen it recently?
- 10:37No, No, it's great though, I should go back. I
- 10:41mean it's vaguely board game related because there is a Conan and Barbarian the Predator
- 10:45recently. But Commando no, because I saw it once in his crap recall,
- 10:50I haven't seen it recently. No. The Running Man, No,
- 10:54I haven't seen it. Should see the Running Man. He's a game.
- 10:58Definitely Running Man. Anyway, So I watched this because of its connection to
- 11:01board games and what's really interesting. So going into this viewing, what did
- 11:07you expect of Clue? I expected it to be funny. Yeah, that's
- 11:16about it. Like funny, but like nineteen eighty is funny. What you
- 11:20mean by nineteen ninety is funny? It's not this like super bad sort of
- 11:24style of comedy that came like later, like late nineties two thousands kind of
- 11:28comedy, more like The Sting. You remember the Sting? Yeah, I
- 11:33don't know if that was the eighties home me a bit less edgy, classic
- 11:39classic Hollywood comedy type of thing. Yeah, But you know, I didn't.
- 11:43I didn't think a lot about it. I figured, I don't remember
- 11:46this movie that well. Probably it's aged a bit, but maybe like comedy
- 11:50that's a bit more sophisticated than what you tend to see today, Like it's
- 11:54not dumb and dumber style comedy. So first actually it was more slapstick than
- 11:56I remembered, right, So firstly I got it conf used with Murdered by
- 12:00Death, which is the Neil what's his name, the famous American playwright wrote
- 12:07the Old Couple Neil Simon. Yeah, I thought it was the Neil Simon
- 12:11movie Murdered by Death, which is a spoof on Agatha Christie. You thought
- 12:13what was this was? I got them confused, clue, and that murdered
- 12:16by murdered by death is like the late seventies, I think, And it's
- 12:20an Agatha Christie spoof, which is essentially what clue is, right, and
- 12:24murder murdered by death not death by murder, No, murdered by death?
- 12:26Okay? And about a game is it? No, it's a it's an
- 12:30Agatha Christie spoof. Okay, So we can't use it. No, we
- 12:31can't Unfortunate to Death. But was there a train in it? Oh?
- 12:35God, I have no idea. Do you think any film with qualify for
- 12:37the show. So I remember watching this a couple of years ago and thinking,
- 12:43I wait a second, I just had a brilliant thought, what's this?
- 12:46Sorry to interrupt, No you're not. I mean, because you're talking
- 12:48Agatha Christie. What is she famous for? Murder? I mean, what
- 12:54what is clue? It's a murder mystery? So is every murder mystery,
- 12:58like, is this Jean inherently again ludic? Well, it might be inherently
- 13:03ludic because you're trying to work out a puzzle, which is quite a ludological
- 13:07thing. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, So if we run out of films,
- 13:11we come back to this point exactly. Murder on the Orient Express,
- 13:13Murder Mystery plus Train exactly. It's the Double Board Game film. Anyway,
- 13:18So I remember watching this and thinking this is shit. Clue a couple of
- 13:22years ago. Clue, Yeah? Why? Because I thought it's hacky,
- 13:26and it's not very funny, and it has that kind of weird slow pace
- 13:33that older films have, where two out of three of those comments I think
- 13:37are pretty accurate. But no, sorry one out of three the other two
- 13:41or not. But we'll get we'll get to this. But this, this
- 13:43viewing, it was completely different. Were you looking at it through different eyes?
- 13:48No, I just we were doing it for this show. Yeah,
- 13:52maybe maybe I was analyzing it more. But I realized there were a couple
- 13:56of things that I that I really enjoyed. I think the pace is great,
- 14:00and I think the acting. I think the performances are wonderful, and
- 14:03the script is very funny. The last line of the movie is apple,
- 14:07We'll get to it is absolutely fantastic, incredible last line of the film.
- 14:11The first line as well, if you recall read well, we'll get to
- 14:15that in a minute. So before we go on, wait wait, there
- 14:18is one thing that I realized in retrospect I might have expected and probably should
- 14:22have, but didn't right, And was I guess delightfully surprised it didn't turn
- 14:28out to be this way. This movie was not about product placement for the
- 14:33board game Clue. No. Parker Brothers. It was just that genuinely inspired
- 14:37by Clue. Yeah, Like I was thinking, how would I compare this
- 14:39to other films that are sort of like films about a product like Barbie is
- 14:46a recent one, the Dungeons and Dragons film Super Mario Brothers. I didn't
- 14:50see the recent one, but there's the older one, and D and D
- 14:54I think is very much in the spirit of D and D. Absolutely.
- 14:58I think Barbie and Clue have maybe something in common in that the Barby is
- 15:03trying to be very knowing and ironic while at the same time being a massive
- 15:07fucking advert for barb But I was going to say there is there is something
- 15:11like there is a cynicism in Barbie that I find deeply, deeply unpleasant.
- 15:15I was going to say something about the political commentary, but I also found
- 15:18Barbie to be much more blatantly like an infomercial for for Hasbro. Yeah,
- 15:24Mattel, Mate, Mattel. Whereas this which which is really fascinating. And
- 15:30so so we're gonna so I've prepared some quiz questions for you because we're gonna
- 15:35do this. Every show, We're going to do a quiz question, and
- 15:37I've lift why do you do this to me, I've lifted them from the
- 15:41trivia, so I'm supposed to MDB. You know, just why why do
- 15:46you get to quiz me? How about we do you? Are you?
- 15:48We alternate? Well, because are you going to sit down, being the
- 15:52busy executive that you are and fucking write three quiz questions for every movie show?
- 15:58Then? Then exactly? I mean I took I took three pages of
- 16:00notes for this. Yeah, I took loads of pages of notes anyway.
- 16:03So one of the so it's a very faithful adaptation of the board game,
- 16:07which what does that mean? Well, so this particular piece of trivia that
- 16:14I read on the IMDb page, which is not part of the quiz questions,
- 16:15so I can say it. You know the secret passages in the film,
- 16:19Yeah, they are the same as the secret passages on the game board.
- 16:23They lead to the same places, which just chows a kind of level
- 16:29of detail that is singularly uncynical and fascinating. And I think the way the
- 16:36film very similitude. Yeah, but I think the way the film is and
- 16:40we'll get to this, I think the film evokes the board game too,
- 16:44especially the end of that did you happen to go back and read the rules
- 16:47to the game. No, I'm meant to and didn't because I don't really
- 16:51remember how you play Clue. I played it once. I guess you randomly
- 16:55choose the location, the perpetrator and the weapon. Yeah, and you like
- 16:59stick them in and go write the rooms and you ask questions and you you
- 17:02eliminate stuff like everyone is trying to figure it out, and whoever figures it
- 17:06out first. I don't love it. But anyway, so, okay,
- 17:10trivia. You're ready for the question, Steve, we're doing this now?
- 17:12Yeah, we're doing this is before we start breaking down the movie. Do
- 17:15you think we should do the trivia before the general discussion or yeah? That
- 17:19is like a sort of oh sorry your show. This is like an amuse
- 17:22boosh, okay, amuse my boosh. So Carrie Fisher Princess Princess Leaphan was
- 17:29originally cast as Miss Scarlett. Why did she not do it? A Because
- 17:34her Star Wars contract forbade her from playing villainous roles. B she was in
- 17:40rehab for drugs. I was thinking that one see she had given up acting
- 17:45to pursue writing. Ah. See the answer, Stephen is b for the
- 17:52drugs. She couldn't do the movie. She actually did give up acting to
- 17:55pursue writing at one point. And I was trying to demonstrate scarles from the
- 17:57edge for instance, exactly. I was trying to demonstrate like faith in humanity.
- 18:02You know. I saw her perform live in New York City once one
- 18:03woman show. Did you Is it good? Yeah? It was hilarious.
- 18:07She's very funny. She came out with the lair hair at once. Okay,
- 18:11nice, she's dead now she is blesser. Yeah, so yeah.
- 18:14She was supposed to play Miss Scarlet and Leslie and Warren, who went on
- 18:17to play Miss Scarlet in the movie, was drafted in at the very last
- 18:21moment because poor old Carrie was high on the cokes. Would it have been
- 18:25better with Carrie Fisher? Who can say? Who can say? But I
- 18:27think she's wonderful. I mean, if you look at Wayne's World, right,
- 18:32she plays the psycho girlfriend in the first Wayne's World who carry Fisher?
- 18:36I don't remember. Is it carry fish Hampy? I think it is the
- 18:40psycho girlfriend and the first that's carry fish. They can't be carry Fisher,
- 18:42Yeah, I think so. I think so. I'm just gonna she would
- 18:45be. I think she'd be a bit too old for that at that point,
- 18:48because Wayne's World was what late late eighties or early nine I think it
- 18:52was early nineties, early nineties, so that by that point I think Carrie
- 18:55Fisher would be a little bit too old to play Wayne's crazy girlfriend. Oh
- 19:00interesting fact, Colleen Camp who plays the maid, was also in Wayne's World
- 19:04as what I don't missus Vanderhoff. I don't know. I don't remember who
- 19:08I remember this, No, no, no, She plays the psycho girlfriend
- 19:11in The Blues Brothers. Okay, that's an entirely different film. I do
- 19:18remember the scene in which Wayne it's just like one scene with the psycho girlfriend.
- 19:22She's not like a psycho girlfriend. She's an annoying girlfriend who gives him
- 19:25a gun rack for his birthday, and he's like, I don't own a
- 19:29gun, let alone many guns. So second question necessitating an entire rack.
- 19:34Indeed, what would I do ben with a gun rack? We're not talking
- 19:38about fucking Waynes. That was That was the scene. Excellent. We're not
- 19:41talking about Wayneesworld. I could be an actor though, on product place,
- 19:45your job is fucking easy. The product placement scene was very good. You
- 19:48just you just pretend to be different things, that's all you do. So
- 19:51Leslie and Warren who played with school, that's a British content. You want
- 19:55me to fucking do this? Fresher new drink govnor So Leslie more One,
- 20:00who played Miss Scarlett, couldn't join the rest of the cast playing billiards between
- 20:03takes because A she had argued vociferously with Tim Curry in a previous production and
- 20:10the cast was shunning her for it. Interesting b. As a last minute
- 20:15replacement, she was constantly learning a script and didn't have time to play billiods.
- 20:21You didn't come up with the options, right? Yeah? I did?
- 20:22Yeah, of course it did. You did you really put work into
- 20:26this? See? How did you come up with them? Because I was
- 20:29writing, I just thought, just like cre see this is like a different
- 20:33kind of social deduction gig exactly. See. She wore a constricting courset that
- 20:37didn't allow her to bend over. Which one that seems a bit stupid?
- 20:41Which one? Ste did the first one also have three options? Yes?
- 20:44It did, So we're doing three options. So I have a pretty good
- 20:47chance of getting it right just by guessing. So corset can't end over arguing
- 20:52with Tim Curry learning her line exactly, and also the listeners can join in
- 20:59with this, yeah, like pause the episode, here go and well no,
- 21:03don't no, you guess they don't. They don't need to pull and
- 21:06then I'm gonna give the answer. You should probably go and listen to the
- 21:08entire back catalog of this podcast so that you can try and like into it
- 21:12how Ben thinks and how he's hiding the real answer. I'm sandwiched between two
- 21:18a couple of Well, maybe he thinks is it sandwiched he thinks are plausible?
- 21:22Its sandwiched or is it the bottom? It could be like bread or
- 21:26the top police of bread. That's true. I think so. The first
- 21:30one I think is implausible because why would the entire cast shun one performer simply
- 21:37because of a falling out she may have had with Tim Curry? Like,
- 21:41I don't, I don't think I buy that. The corset thing seems like
- 21:45totally a red herring to borrow a line from the movie A bit. I'm
- 21:51gonna go with, you know, the boring one. I think you're trying
- 21:53to distract me with shiny objects, And I think she just had to learn
- 21:56her lines The answer is Steven, she wore a constrict he calls it over.
- 22:03Yes, indeed, oh to play billiards. Oh okay, one last
- 22:07question, Steven. This doesn't have options, but we're going to try and
- 22:11see if you can work this out because you're a clever lad, although you've
- 22:14got no memory, so this is going to be really difficult. What is
- 22:17the joke about Professor Plum's job? There is a joke written into Professor Plum's
- 22:25job. What is that joke? He's the uh, the psychologist or well
- 22:30he's not exactly. We don't really know what he is, right, he's
- 22:33a yes, psychologist, he's like familiar with psychology. Who does he work
- 22:37for? Not? They all work for the government somehow. Yeah, he
- 22:41works for a particular organization, the World Health Organization, Yeah, which is
- 22:45part of he says, the UN. Yeah and there, Yeah, there
- 22:48was some like joke about the UN. I remember it's the UN organization.
- 22:52Yeah, and he works for the World Health Organization. Yeah. You know
- 22:56who? Boom, you know who that is? The isn't that great?
- 23:03Did you catch that joke? No? No, no, it's in the
- 23:04trivia and I'm DV. I'm on my fucking class all right, So should
- 23:11we go on to talk about the film. I guess we shall. Every
- 23:18person in this room has the perfect motive stand back murder. What do you
- 23:23mean murder? But only one of these suspects is the murderer. Isn't the
- 23:30timid mister Green? Why are you screaming? Because I'm right not screaming?
- 23:36Or the militant Colonel Mustard? Why was the killer? I would kill you,
- 23:41next, said ef Ef. Missus White, who helped her husband on
- 23:47his way. What's a matter of life after death? Now that he's dead,
- 23:51I have a life, Miss Scarlett, who's helped many men along the
- 23:55way. Practice makes perfect. Huh, Professor Plumb, who's looking for a
- 23:59way. I'm lucky. I'm lucky. Missus Peacock. I have absolutely no
- 24:03idea what we're doing here, but I am determined to enjoy myself. Or
- 24:07did the butler do it? Now? Yeah? I remot pictures. Invite
- 24:12you to an evening of misstery murder. This is gonna quite sooner and madness
- 24:23in the movie. That makes a scene of the crying clue, it's not
- 24:30just a game anymore. So we open Steve. Have they seen the trailer,
- 24:38heard the trail. Yes, they've heard heard Well, yeah, yeah,
- 24:41it's a it's a fucking audio medium. This isn't being filmed, Steve,
- 24:45do you see a camera? How do you know that? They didn't
- 24:47go watch the trailer? And a dedicated listener would watch the trailer, Well
- 24:51you should. If you haven't watched the trailer, what are you doing anyway?
- 24:55So we start at the beginning. So the first thing that surprised me,
- 25:00and I should have known because I'd seen the movie before, but I
- 25:04was just surprised that it was set in America. Why because clu CLUDO just
- 25:11feel the manor house, all of that, the colonel, the professor,
- 25:15it all just feels very British, doesn't it. Yeah, I s suppose
- 25:18so I think it's quite an American thing to have a British butler, though,
- 25:22yes, and we call them butlers that I don't think you do,
- 25:26right, We call them butler's. Yeah, I thought you called them something
- 25:29else. A friend of mine from Vienna his father, his father was a
- 25:32butler valet. A valet is a different thing to a butler. Think,
- 25:37I mean, I am not a member of the upper class bend, but
- 25:38ignore British but Yes, a friend of mine, a friend of mine,
- 25:41you have another end. Well, he's quite I see his father was a
- 25:45butler for fifty years. I mean, anyway, this is not what surprised
- 25:49me at first. What surprised you at first? That it wasn't set in
- 25:53the present? Right? Well, I said nineteen fifty five before, I
- 25:57mean close enough to back to the future. Yeah, yeh, nineteen fifty
- 26:00four, right was there? Like the thing is, I think I think
- 26:06for a number of the jokes to work, it needs to be set at
- 26:10that time, and a number of the plot points to work, it needs
- 26:12to be set. I was sort of wondering why, Well, we should
- 26:15probably talk about this. Why did it really need to be a period piece?
- 26:19Well, there are certain things. We'll get to the characters in a
- 26:22minute, and we'll explain why. But I think Michael McKean's character is only
- 26:26plausible in a period setting. Well, but because they wrote the character that
- 26:29way, they didn't have to add this sort of like Cold war subtext to
- 26:33it. Although I think that could also work in the nineteen eighties, I
- 26:36don't think it would work now, right, But like, if you're sort
- 26:38of using the past as a way of like troping against the present that that
- 26:44does work, and this is often done in its historical figure. So the
- 26:47question is is why science fiction or whatever different different genres will like the will
- 26:52they will set the scene in a different time or place as a way of
- 26:56making some kind of a commentary on the present, is what I'm trying to
- 26:59But it also might just be it might just be Then's looking at his phone
- 27:04again. It might just be a way of being faithful to the game.
- 27:10Again, was it originally published? Well, it was published in Britain first
- 27:14as Cludo as Cludo in nineteen forty nine, Okay, and then let me
- 27:18look when was it published in America? I mean it would stand a reason
- 27:22that well it was published. He was published in nineteen forty nine in America
- 27:26too, So fifty fifty four is strange. I don't know why, but
- 27:32it's still it's still a deliberate choice to set a game that was still being
- 27:37played quite a lot in the eighties, to set the film based on that
- 27:38game in the nineteen fifties. It's still a deliberate choice. The thing is
- 27:41the game. Though the game itself feels like a period piece, doesn't it.
- 27:47So something else I didn't know and I'm going to ask you, and
- 27:48I wrote this down in my notes, who was the famous name that was
- 27:52attached to this? Not part of the cast. There was the guy at
- 27:56the end. No, no, no, no, not a touch of
- 28:00the cast. So not in front of the camera. Oh, I don't
- 28:02know, so these this is what I didn't know is a John Landis movie.
- 28:07Oh no, he didn't write the script and he didn't direct him,
- 28:10but he wrote the story. And you know John Landis American Wealth in London
- 28:15and Animal House and can't think of it. I know this is like a
- 28:22famous comedic writer. Yeah, exactly that time. Does this feel like a
- 28:26John Landis move? I don't know what a John Landis movie feels like.
- 28:30Do you think so? I mean, I guess it has a little bit
- 28:32of the the slap stickiness of Animal House. It's so so John Landis like
- 28:37like it's it's not like realistic. Yeah, this is true. But John
- 28:40Landis always feel always his movies kind of feel a bit transgressive to me.
- 28:45Yeah, I mean there's a bit of a narcic, transgressive humor. I
- 28:48think there is some of that. I think he's really like what just like
- 28:52the sort of leering at the French maid kind of stuff, yes, although
- 28:56that feels much more slapping missus PEAKRD. So so for the listener, there
- 29:00is a french maid who's who's got two very prominent assets that are used extensively
- 29:07in the movie for humor, and that feels much more sort of gentle nineteen
- 29:12fifties humor to me. It feels very idious to me. So Michael McKean
- 29:18his character, So, okay, well we'll get to this. And does
- 29:21it feel John Landercy? I think this maybe is John Landis that feels John
- 29:26Landercy because it's the one aspect that feels kind of so I wrote down that
- 29:32it's gentle humor and it doesn't feel gentle to me. This is just just
- 29:37for the listeners. Ben has put his pen behind his ear, which lends
- 29:40a certain like gravitazed everything he's saying. Absolutely So okay, So we see
- 29:45that the opening of the movie is the Big Manor House, the classic Agatha
- 29:51Christie trope. We have the people arriving. What is the appeal? There
- 29:56was definitely like this sort of I noted a series of cliches in the open
- 30:03delightfully trophy, scary house, French maid. Yeah, barking dogs, bubbler
- 30:08lightning. Yeah. So, so what is the appeal of the manor house
- 30:12do you think? I mean, so, so you show, you show
- 30:17a big house, and you have a storm, Something's gonna happen. So
- 30:19I guess the central question for Clue this movie does it feel postmodern? Does
- 30:23it feel like a film that is rilely ironically commenting on murder mysteries and the
- 30:33game itself? I mean, I think the game itself is doing that kind
- 30:37of postmodern work too. This came up on the discord recently where I was
- 30:41I was speculating, is the question is like are certain games postmodern or not?
- 30:44Are we in a postmodern era of board games? And I was kind
- 30:48of wondering if if all the board games are not postmodern in some way,
- 30:51I mean, you are, you are turning a kind of form of life
- 30:53into an activity of play. So so does postmodern always have to be in
- 31:00this sense cynical, ironic, finkly mocking. I think it often is because
- 31:07like referential and sort of like it can sort of deconstruct a grand narrative.
- 31:12For example, because what really surprises me about Clue and why it feels so
- 31:18actually the thing is Clue is not in earnest about what it's doing. No,
- 31:22but it is not mocking either. I don't think to be Poston matter
- 31:26and you have to mock. Well, this is my question. Yeah,
- 31:30because because Clue does not, Clue clearly comes from a place of affection.
- 31:34It is very affectionate towards the genre. It references the tropes, but it
- 31:40does not devalue the tropes in referencing them, right, I mean, I
- 31:45think you can definitely say it's ironic about the murder mystery genre. Yes,
- 31:48don't mockering, But it doesn't say the murder mystery genre is for shit,
- 31:52right, It doesn't say that at all, don't know. I mean I
- 31:55think when you said troping is I think we've used this word now a couple
- 31:57of times. But it's a good way to put it. You see this
- 32:00in postmodern art and architecture as well. It's very tropy. It's it's not
- 32:07it's irreverent, right, And in the same way that like modernist narratives,
- 32:10I would say, and modernist style is often like reverential or tries to construct
- 32:15like grand narratives or make like self serious statements, and postmodernism is a way
- 32:20of like deconstructing some of that self seriousness. But I think it's very hard
- 32:23to even define what postmodernism means. It's just like, sure, whatever era
- 32:28we are in now, after whatever period modernism was, whenever that ended.
- 32:32I was thinking about Monopoly as as a kind of look as classicists of this
- 32:37movement. Monopoly was originally this landlord game that is itself a I don't know
- 32:44if you want to call it a mockery of capitalism, but it is definitely
- 32:46well in its original intention, a deconstruction of capitalism. And yet you are
- 32:52playing a game in which to succeed in the game, you are doing everything
- 32:54you can to be the worst possible capitalist. Right. But the difference between
- 32:58the Landlord's game and monoton is Monopoly is a sort of unremitting celebration of that
- 33:04kind of behavior, whereas the Landlord's game. But but what but what what
- 33:07makes it that celebration? Like is it inherent to the game itself? Or
- 33:09could you say, well, this game is meant to demonstrate what you do
- 33:13when people get together, compete and poperize one another. Because the point is
- 33:15you have to convey the message, right, and the point is Monopoly doesn't
- 33:19convey the message, but do they both have the same win condition. That's
- 33:22regardless. You need to point to the thing is when you're making a satirical
- 33:27comment, you need to point to the what what what? What the satirical
- 33:30comment is? But what what is the content that's pointing to that? Is
- 33:32it the marketing, the the design of the of the game, the instruction.
- 33:37The problem is not knowing the landlord's game. I can't tell you,
- 33:39but it's people. I'm thinking from the I think it can be argued that
- 33:44Monopoly is a satire, but I don't think it is because it doesn't specifically
- 33:49state that it is, and people just don't think that deeply. No,
- 33:52no, no, I think it's in its moments, it was meant to
- 33:54be something like a satire, and we definitely don't look at it this way
- 33:59now. I think the best equson I can come up with off the top
- 34:01of my head is the way in which Apocalypse Now was an anti war film,
- 34:07but now they show it to soldiers in the Middle East to pump them
- 34:08up to go into bed, which blows my mind. Well, the thing
- 34:12is right, I am sure they don't show the movie. I'm sure they
- 34:15show the sequence with Wagner completely out of context, you take that see also
- 34:20interesting, like given like that music is what is used in that moment to
- 34:23show the like victory and warfare. Within within context, it's clearly the it's
- 34:29clearly the Robert Duval's character as a psychopath and war war elevates these kind of
- 34:34dangerous people. But out of context it looks like a huha. And yet
- 34:38and yet what do the valkyries do? They encourage men to engage in combat
- 34:43so that they can kill each other and then be like brought up to heaven
- 34:45to fight in the wars of the gods. I mean, it's that is
- 34:49deeply cynical. Sure, that's fascinating how these things sort of wend their way
- 34:52through anyway, so various cultural moments. So this is interesting what I was
- 34:58surprised by. And I think it might just be that I'm getting older,
- 35:00and it might just be that I'm tired of sort of we live in a
- 35:06phase where anything that isn't very ocurrant is to be mocked and derided, especially
- 35:14mocked and derided as somehow sexist or racist or And what I loved about Clue
- 35:20is that cynicism isn't there. It is clearly very affectionate towards a genre,
- 35:24whether it's affection towards the game, although although I will argue that I think
- 35:28it is. You watch it and you enjoy it, and it's somehow,
- 35:31it's somehow not making a cultural comment about today. Why Barbie is so intolerable
- 35:39is because it makes an argument that is so easy, is fundamentally mean and
- 35:45very easy to pick apart. Whereas Clue is a film that shows a genuine
- 35:50affection, it doesn't appropriate something to then break it down. It appropriates something
- 35:58and then makes a homage both to the original genre, the Agatha Christi murder
- 36:02mystery, but also to the game. I think I agree that it doesn't
- 36:07seem to be making any kind of social commentary. I might have to think
- 36:10about that point. It's not overt social commentary. Barbie hits you in the
- 36:14face with it, Yes, I mean it. We set piece speeched in
- 36:17which you are hitting the face with it. Indeed, whatever you think about
- 36:20that speech, I mean, I'm not making any commentary on like the specific
- 36:22content. We're not doing Bobbi. If we ever do Barbie, then I'll
- 36:24get into it. Not a game, right, so a clue I think
- 36:30is referencing this sort of Cold War milieu that is still very much alive in
- 36:35the eighties, even though it was set in the nineteen fifties. I thought
- 36:37it was just very interesting that it even discusses things like socialism, communism,
- 36:42right, that it references politics, It talks about things like Unamericanism. It
- 36:45like it gestures vaguely toward you know, government conspiracy. So could you don't
- 36:50find that in like the It doesn't retreat into safety like a lot of films,
- 36:53So could you say the film is actually a lot more serious and daring
- 36:57than it appears on the surf. I think your average film of that time
- 37:00was much more willing to like wade into these waters than now. That's the
- 37:02way I think. I think the entire like cultural production complex has changed.
- 37:08Well, then you everything now is much safer. Then you're looking at a
- 37:12sort of juxtaposition between style and content, because the style of the movie,
- 37:16you have these archetypal characters, right, the fem fatale, the stuffy soldier,
- 37:22the sort of weird nerdy professor, the sort of young, the young
- 37:28sort of daring do the butler, the french maid. It's all very familiar.
- 37:32It's all not only from Clue, but from Agafa. I mean,
- 37:36these people, these these characters are gonna say people, these characters are They're
- 37:38essentially costumes or the rules. And yet the content within it is discussing political
- 37:45corruption, it's discussing the ability of someone to lead their own life based upon
- 37:51their sexuality. It's discussing the mores of prostitution. I mean, this film
- 37:55is basically a D and D campaign in which we gradually learn everyone's backstory exact
- 38:00so, and Tim Curry is the dungeon master, so what we learn.
- 38:02So the film starts with the classic people turning up at the at the Manorhata.
- 38:08We know where we are with the butler, yeah right, and you
- 38:13have the dogs that are set up. You get Chekhov's dogs at the beginning
- 38:17of the movie. They're aggressive, aggressive guard dogs. And then the people
- 38:21arrive and there's that awkwardness because they've all received a letter and they don't know,
- 38:25they don't know why they're there. And Tim Curry is very much our
- 38:30guide at this moment. I mean even throughout the throughout the film, god
- 38:32especially especially the denouement. It's so this is Tim to divorce. Yeah,
- 38:37I think so. So what is really fascinating about this is how good Tim
- 38:43Curry is. And it's kind of so Tim Curry. I don't think he's
- 38:45a weird looking guy. No, I don't think he's an uncharismatic guy.
- 38:52No. I wonder why Tim Curry doesn't go on to be amazing Hollywood star
- 39:01because he's clearly incredibly talented. He can carry a movie like he does.
- 39:06He carries sort of like an er Hugh Grant. Yeah in many ways,
- 39:09but but wasn't in the end and yeah, check your trivia. Then ends
- 39:14up being a sort of cult figure that ends up doing a lot of TV.
- 39:16Is he a stage actor before? Yes? He was. Because this,
- 39:20this, this this film struck me as like it's like a play.
- 39:22It's very much like any and it reminded me. I mean, movies have
- 39:25just changed a whole lot. I've already mentioned these, like these political balances,
- 39:30but I think films used to be much more like filmed plays than they
- 39:34are now. Now it's all about the editing and these jump cuts and special
- 39:37effects, and like I think, I think even this if you look at
- 39:40that, but back then, these films, these films were acted by actors.
- 39:44The thing is, I I think I think, I think you're misremembering
- 39:47or being too romantic, because if you look at the two Christopher Lloyd films
- 39:52that came out that year, Clue and Back to the Future. Back to
- 39:55the Future is nothing like a filmed play. If you look at a lot
- 39:59of a nothing like filmed place, well, Clue is being deliberately an acaratic.
- 40:04There at least were such films back and maybe and maybe that is a
- 40:08reason for setting it in the fifties, because it allows you structurally to film
- 40:15it like that. If it's set in the eighties and it's all sort of
- 40:19modern and people have got car phones and shit, that kind of parlor,
- 40:24that sort of chamber drama. Chamber drama is a good way to put it
- 40:29is not going to be low budget. It seems anachronistic. I don't I
- 40:34don't think you're wrong. I would guess if you compared Back to the Future
- 40:37to the similar sort of movie that comes out today, like what would you
- 40:42call this, like I don't know, science fiction action movie or something.
- 40:45Back to the Future, even in comparison to what passes for that genre today,
- 40:50is going to seem like much slower, much like more like ACTI even
- 40:54much more like a stage play than like The Avengers for example. Sure,
- 40:59but you know, setting that aside, I think you've got more movies like
- 41:02this. But like people, people just were better actors back then. I
- 41:06mean, maybe that's one way of putting it. Or like actorly in this
- 41:08was like more to the four. So this is interesting. I this is
- 41:13where you could disagree because I'm talking out of my ass. I don't I
- 41:15don't think people better actors necessarily, but this feels like I don't know the
- 41:19history of these activists. It was more about the acting, less about you
- 41:22know, whether well the cinematography. I can say that about different kinds of
- 41:25Yeah, I mean this is I see a movie. I did not prepare
- 41:28for this discussion. I went to see a movie the other day. There
- 41:30was two hours of a guy cleaning a toilet essentially what and but it's perfect
- 41:35days, Okay, it's nominated for the Oscar and it's a wonderful movie.
- 41:37And that's all about acting. That is all about performance. It is nothing
- 41:42to do with wizbangs and special effects. So so we have these people assembled.
- 41:47Is it mainstream though? Oh yeah, I think Clue is mainstream.
- 41:52Absolutely. I think that's maybe a big difference. So I think you're right
- 41:55in that sense, we are not allowed. So so mainstream movie is now
- 42:00completely amphetaminized, right in a way the Clue isn't. You could conceive of
- 42:07Clue being a mainstream movie in the eighties in a way I don't think you
- 42:10could nowadays. I don't think so. So the scenes are too long,
- 42:14right, So you have these people and Tim Curry the butler. So there
- 42:16are going to be a lot of spoilers in this. By the way,
- 42:19Tim Curry the Butler reveals that they're all they're all connected by one thing.
- 42:22Blackmail. They're all being blackmail social deduction, right, And what's interesting is
- 42:29they all connected to government. They're all connected to Washington, DC. And
- 42:35so you have Missus Peacock, whose father is whose husband is a corrupt senator.
- 42:40You have Miss Scarlett who runs a brothel. You have mister White,
- 42:47no, Missus White, who killed her husband. You have Colonel Mustard who
- 42:52visited the brothel. You have what mister Greene, who is a homosexual.
- 42:59By oh wait, this is another thing I wanted to mention. I was
- 43:00talking about, like the the the politics of this film. Like for a
- 43:06film in the nineteen eighties to have a character say I am a homost like
- 43:09it later on in the film My secret is it gets under it gets undermined.
- 43:14But still, yeah, that he's a homosexual and he's not. I
- 43:16mean, does that pass for daring in the nineteen eighties, Well, I
- 43:19would think so. The way Michael McKean portrays him, there's no gayness to
- 43:22the character, right, He's like a normal, clean cut fifty man.
- 43:27Yeah, exactly. So that's interesting, and that's where you you look at
- 43:31Landis and you think maybe Landis had a hand in that, you know,
- 43:35something that's a little bit you know, showing a gay guy as a normal
- 43:38person, even in the eighties is quite a subversive act, and to be
- 43:45setting it in the fifties as well, right, And so then the classic
- 43:51thing happens. So the guy who's blackmailing them arrives and he gives them all
- 43:55the gift. And what are the gifts, Stevie? They are the classic
- 44:00weapons of the game Clue. And this is where I think you can argue
- 44:04that this game actually, sorry, this this film actually does love the game.
- 44:08I think, so it is not in mockery of the game because it
- 44:12just gets everything so right. You know, it's it's reverential of the props
- 44:15of the material, like it uses the material it is. In fact,
- 44:20the film is a film of the game, like it is the material.
- 44:22So wonderful is it doesn't feel it also feels like a film. You don't
- 44:27watch it and think, oh my god, they've just Crowbard the fucking game
- 44:30in here, and it seems completely incongruate. It's got a beginning in middle
- 44:34and an end and the way they introduce so there's things that are subtle and
- 44:38things that are not so. When so the blackmailer arrives and he gives them
- 44:43all presents and it's the wrench, and it's the lead pipe, and it's
- 44:45the dagger, and it's the gun, and it's the nows. This this
- 44:47is like the one misstep for me of this film. I felt like the
- 44:51character of mister Body, he didn't make a lot of sense, No,
- 44:54because it wasn't a very good actor. It wasn't a very good actor to
- 44:57know why he's like running away and they they so the old idea is that
- 45:01he's supposed to be this guy who owns this manor house, and yet he's
- 45:07he's he's a mafia gangster guy. Doesn't feel plausible, You're right, but
- 45:12but it's interesting. Also if you notice when Tim Curry is pulling out files
- 45:17and preparing evidence, the envelope looks like the envelope you get in a game
- 45:22of clue, don't It's like a yellow envelope, but envelope, and it
- 45:28feels like the envelope. And I'm sure that's deliberate. And then once he's
- 45:32revealed, the light goes off. You hear various noises, you hear a
- 45:37gun go off, and mister Body is in the center of the room dead,
- 45:42seemingly dead, yeah, seemingly. And then the plot starts and it
- 45:46does this wonderful thing that ramps up tension right from the beginning. And there's
- 45:52something about, so you're a business douche, right, what And I've taught
- 45:58how to give engineering, right, I've taught how to give presentations, right
- 46:01have you? Yeah? Lots of lots of Do you give presentations? I
- 46:06don't, But I so what do you know about? Because I was paid
- 46:08to do it, and when you're paid, if you don't actually do it.
- 46:12I taught business people how to do presentations okay, and part did it
- 46:16help them? Oh god, yeah cool? You make them do like Mark
- 46:20presentations? Absolutely? And then in what way do they improve under your tool?
- 46:23Because I teach them presentation structure and then I also taught them sort of
- 46:29good sentences to use and that five games for Doomsday at gmail dot com.
- 46:34So so, at the beginning of a presentation, you set out what the
- 46:37presentation is going to be. Part of the reason of that is then the
- 46:42audience watching the presentation kind of know when what to expect, and they kind
- 46:46of know when it's coming to an end. And when you don't have that
- 46:50angst of when is this going to end, you can be more focused.
- 46:53Right. I definitely tend not to find most presentations gripping, sure, but
- 46:58this film does something very similar, and it does it quite obviously. Tim
- 47:04Curry runs and he phones the police, and then he says, in forty
- 47:07minutes the police will arrive. Yeah what, But does you've got a ticking
- 47:12clocks straight away? We know how long it is going to take to solve
- 47:15this. Miss I wonder we didn't even bother checking this, But I wonder
- 47:20if forty minutes in movie time actually pass before Yeah, I didn't. I
- 47:25should have said, I should have. If we were responsible film critics,
- 47:30we would go back and watch again and check that and then report to the
- 47:35listeners. But it's you know, it's just the two of us, so
- 47:37we're not going to do that. Yeah. Absolutely, But do you remember
- 47:39the first line of the film, no tell me you have your instructions?
- 47:44Ah? Very good, Yeah, very gamic, very gamic. Absolutely,
- 47:47and I'm sure that's deliberate. I was thinking it must be, and is
- 47:51why I furiously like I'm waiting for these moments to write down, like whoh,
- 47:54you have your instructions? Like obviously, like they are trying to make
- 47:59this as much of a game as possible. I mean, showing all the
- 48:02characters and the weapons, all the cliches that we talked about, the pseudonyms
- 48:07that everybody has, which are completely unnecessary. Everything seems like a game.
- 48:12The black the blackmail bit with like you know, the social deduction component,
- 48:15who's blackmailing you? And why? It's all trying to make us feel like
- 48:19we're in the game. And I have to think that these things are deliberate,
- 48:22deliberate, and so the game that the film I think the film I
- 48:27think has two distinct parts. You have the the paranoia what's going on part,
- 48:35then you have the solving the mystery part and this paranoia what's going on?
- 48:38And the plot in this film it's such a plot ploty film. It's
- 48:42very plotty. I think that somehow the plot, like is plot a kind
- 48:46of game mechanism in a way. Surecause when you're playing the game of clue,
- 48:51your turns, like the turns of a game of clue are essentially what
- 48:54counts as plot in this film. And you see what I mean. There's
- 48:59a section after the after they've sort of worked out that something's going on,
- 49:01they say, we've got to split up and we've got to search the mansion.
- 49:05Mechanisms are the substance of plot, is what I wrote, Right,
- 49:07very good and so and so. Then you do. Then you basically play
- 49:13a well scripted, funny game of pludo. Right, You get shown the
- 49:17seller, you get shown the first floor, you get shown the ground.
- 49:22And I want to say, this game has I keep calling it a game?
- 49:24This film has loads of like witty verbal repartee and puns and like,
- 49:30this is what you're doing when you're playing a game, right, And maybe
- 49:31I'm going a little bit too far, but it's like it has everything that
- 49:35you would expect in a game, including the trash tarp. We will definitely
- 49:38do the D and D movie at some point. And that's why the D
- 49:40and D movie I think works so well, because it feels like people playing
- 49:45D and D right, and the script is great. And not only that.
- 49:51You know, I'm an actor, so I watch acting, and you're
- 49:53right, this is the theatrical movie. What's so great is you have static
- 49:57shots of people doing scene. And what's so great is they pick up their
- 50:01cues so well that the actors make the dynamism, not the editing to such
- 50:07a to a degree. And I've written down a line here. I haven't
- 50:13written in many lines, but it's it's a Missus White line from Maddelin khn't,
- 50:17which is just it's not so, it's it's indicative. I think of
- 50:22the kind of jokes, the kind of a bit hacky, the kind of
- 50:25a bit slapsticky, but nevertheless very good. Life after death is improbable as
- 50:30sex after marriage. Right, It's that kind it's that kind of human It's
- 50:35like a one liner, yeah, exactly, and so so what what's very
- 50:39noticeable about the film is if I was going to describe the acting style,
- 50:45it's mad cap. Yeah, it's perfect, it's mad do you they all
- 50:51run around together, which is like, I don't know. It made me
- 50:53feel like this is also part of the fact that it's a game. Are
- 50:55you turned off by that mad cap style of actor or within the context of
- 51:01this film, do you like you? I'm not turned off by anything that
- 51:04works right, and I think this worked. It could also not have worked.
- 51:09I think that this this this movie is just overflowing with structure, which
- 51:14is also which also makes it feel like. So I watched the police arriving
- 51:17in forty five minutes. Rules, right, there are rules what we're doing.
- 51:22You each get a weapon, right that, you each have a role.
- 51:24They draw lots at one point. Yeah. This it's like a game
- 51:28within it to see who they split up with. Yeah, yeah, it's
- 51:30it's just all like, but what's what's the structure and rules and mechanisms.
- 51:32What's so great because you don't know when they split up because you don't know
- 51:36who the murderer is, and they set it up beautifully. There is any
- 51:38built tension there because anyone could be searching the house alone with the murderer and
- 51:44yet and yet at the same time, and I completely agree. I noted
- 51:46there's never any real tension, and the soundtrack evokes this perfectly because you like
- 51:52the word bethos. This is like the most pathetic of all tracks I have
- 51:57ever heard. Yeah, yeah, and like, there are people being murdered
- 52:00left, right and center in this and it's never disturbing or shocking, and
- 52:04you know why. So I watched the movie with my girlfriend the other day,
- 52:07and it was this Italian movie and she's it's set in Second World War.
- 52:10She said, you've got to watch this. I love it. Sounds
- 52:13like it's gonna be a little bit more serious than Well, then this is
- 52:16the point, right if if she listens to this, she might get offended
- 52:20because I didn't love it. And the big problem was the tone of the
- 52:23movie was so odd. Most of the film was this knock about, kind
- 52:30of zany comedy talking about life is beautiful. No no, although that's a
- 52:35tonally very odd thing, and also kind of a game film, yeah,
- 52:37think about it. So it had this, so it was sort of mostly
- 52:42a knock about comedy and then right in the middle of the movie there's an
- 52:45air raid and two of the characters are killed, and there's this big tragic
- 52:51de new one with all the sweepy music and tears, and it's completely inconsistent
- 52:55with what the film has done previously and looks weird for it. Whereas Clue
- 53:02is tonally brilliant. It sets its tone and it's consistent throughout the entire movie.
- 53:08Now, maybe this is a deliberate move on the part of the director.
- 53:12Well if it's a filmic reason. If it's deliberate, it ends up
- 53:15making the film look stupid. So it doesn't work even if it is deliberate.
- 53:20Whereas, whereas this is the great thing in Clue, it is tonally
- 53:23consistent and so people die. So at one point a guy turns up,
- 53:30a guy turns up because his car's broken down. Yeah and yeah, he's
- 53:34also somehow connected to the plot, and he is killed. And a policeman
- 53:37turns up and he is killed. And these are things actually elements coming in
- 53:43a little bit from outside of like the game, right, sure, like
- 53:45they don't have like representations in the game. They don't. But what it
- 53:49does is ramp up the plot because you're then thinking, hmmm, not everything
- 53:52is what it seems, because what's fundamental about this is the film is still
- 53:55a film. It's not just a reimplementation of the game. Has to propel
- 54:01its plot along, and then you get to you get to the best part
- 54:13of the movie. So you have the you have the exploration of the manor
- 54:19house, you have the prenetic not going not knowing what's going on, and
- 54:25then you have the classic Agatha Christie thing and the butler in this one,
- 54:29because of course they're playing with the butler. Did it trope right? The
- 54:34butler turns into the detective and then he explains and he explains what goes on.
- 54:40Now, I'm going to tell you something that when I read this,
- 54:44blew my fucking mind and maybe goes some way to explaining why this film was
- 54:50a flop? Was it? It didn't know? It didn't make back its
- 54:53production bud budget, right. I thought they all do eventually due to various
- 54:57I mean, it became a cult thing, but during that period it didn't
- 55:00make And the thing is, if it doesn't make it back in that period,
- 55:04yeah, subsequent films don't get made right with that cast too. So
- 55:07maybe it was trying to do too much. Maybe it should have been more
- 55:09of a sort of schlocky product placement. What is what is interesting about the
- 55:14end of the film? What is interesting about the end of that there are
- 55:17multiple ending that there are multiple endings, right, that many possibilities of the
- 55:22game. So and I was going to get to that, but in the
- 55:27original theater run they would send the movie with only one of the endings.
- 55:32Ah, you know this, this rings a bell, and so different cinemas
- 55:37would get different endings. They're trying to get people to talk about it.
- 55:39I get, but the interesting gimmick, but it fails because the really cool
- 55:45bit of the film is the multiple endings, not only because it's just a
- 55:50cool thing, but also it evokes the game because games can end in different
- 55:53ways, right, It's that sort of random allocation of the weapon and the
- 55:57murderer and so it it's so the idea that this is a board game avitation.
- 56:01They figured out by accident that this is the way the film always should
- 56:05have been. Well, because the ending that we when it was released on
- 56:07video, it has this ending where there are three. I don't know what
- 56:13to make of this particular authorial choice, right, because it seems like it
- 56:15was discovered not intention It must have been discovered because their original tension. I
- 56:20think is a terrible idea because the point is if so the first ending and
- 56:24this is spoilers, but you know the first ending, Miscarlet did it right?
- 56:29I mean, it almost doesn't matter who did it right? No,
- 56:30because this is the point, right in the first ending, miss Scarlet did
- 56:34it. If the film ended there with the Miss Scarlett explanation, right,
- 56:37would you have felt any satisfaction with the film whatsoever? I mean, I
- 56:42think it would have been a good movie up to that point and then just
- 56:44kind of ended with a thud and you'd have gone, yeah. But the
- 56:47multiple well, like why yeah, The multiple endings elevate the film because it's
- 56:52brilliant writing. You can see the sort of mechanisms. These characters don't actually
- 57:00matter, they don't really have backstory, so to pick one who actually did
- 57:04it is are totally arbitrary, right exactly, And so that's the point.
- 57:07What makes it a great board game adaptation is the multiple ending and and it
- 57:13also has to be the butler who did it who isn't right, it has
- 57:15to be it has to not be the butler who did it, and has
- 57:20to be how can you do both at the same time? Well, they
- 57:22did it. Yeah, exactly, he didn't do it, and he did
- 57:25do it and so and so, but and Andy's not the butler and he's
- 57:30not the butler. He's actually the guy who in the house, but the
- 57:32real total face. And I think it's the bit that people remember when they
- 57:37watch them. British people are always villains people. Indeed, is the Tim
- 57:40Curry telling the story section around this the force it is fucking brilliant. He
- 57:49is absolutely flawless and the energy he brings to it and like, we literally
- 57:53just watched all this stuff happen and he tells it again three times and it's
- 57:59not it's still brilliant because Tim Curry is absolutely flawless. So maddling khn't right.
- 58:06I'm a big meddling KHNT fan because I'm a big what's his name Melbourne
- 58:09Melbrooks fan. Well, she's very understated in this one. Yeah, it's
- 58:13a very unmaddling can but she does one maddling KHNY bit, the bit where
- 58:16she's sort of she's talking about the flame y yeah, and she improvises it
- 58:21seems like in provacy it is it says in the trivia and she does this
- 58:23improvised but she's just brilliant. I'm glad they left that in. Yeah,
- 58:27it's just brilli. It seems like the kind of thing that in this movie
- 58:30they're trying to be like very tight, very lean, and they would cut
- 58:32it out. I'm glad they left this in. When you watch the movie
- 58:35film. Watched this movie in a while, and this encourages you to watch
- 58:38this movie that you'll see that Maddling can't be and it just shows because she's
- 58:43very restrained in this and that little monologue it's about fifteen seconds long, is
- 58:47just pure Maddling khn't and it's fucking brilliant, and it shows why she And
- 58:52then if you haven't seen Blazing Saddles and Young Frankenstein, go back and watch.
- 58:57I mean, you might wonder why she even needs to be in this
- 58:59film because she barely does anything or says anything, like any actress could have
- 59:01done this role. But then she does that bite, and it's all worth
- 59:05it for that bit, and and and so fucking Tim Curry earns his paycheck.
- 59:08It really does. It's an incredible performance. And then and yet the
- 59:15multiple endings I think are integral to this film being the unique prospect that it
- 59:19is if it's just one ending, it's a very very average murder mystery.
- 59:23But it's the way that that evokes, because what does the film want us
- 59:29to be? It want it wants us to be players sitting at the table
- 59:32playing a game. What do you what do you do at the end of
- 59:36the game, You talk about the difference, You tell the story of what
- 59:39just happened in the game. Exactly why do I do this? Why do
- 59:42that? You? You, you complain, you boast, you do all
- 59:45of these things, and that's it this film. So playing a game right
- 59:49promises multiple endings, multiple results, whether it be someone winning or in a
- 59:55co op game losing as a group, and and something like a murder mystery
- 1:00:00game promises cludo is specifically promises different options. And this game what are we
- 1:00:07looking for? Film gives it you what are we looking for? Games?
- 1:00:08Replayability? Right, like games are they don't simply have one ending. They
- 1:00:14have every possible ending that the game promises that like that, the potential of
- 1:00:17the game is, you know, unlimited outcomes and so and it's very hard
- 1:00:22to capture that in film. It is and I think in narrative why this
- 1:00:25is a brilliant board game adaptation is because look how many times both of us
- 1:00:31have said throughout this podcast this game when we mean this film yep, because
- 1:00:37it feels like a game, and I think it's a great success. So
- 1:00:40before we go to the end of the podcast, which is the housekeeping bit,
- 1:00:45oh, we have more stuff to do, just you know, to
- 1:00:47join the discuss. Do you really you really plan these things like you put
- 1:00:51a lot of time and effort into the structure of these shows. I just
- 1:00:53I show up and I sent in front of the mic. Problem is and
- 1:00:55I issue brilliant problem is, Steve, You're kind of genius. Yeap is
- 1:01:00just unquantifiable, uncontainable. So I just want to talk about the last line
- 1:01:06of the movie because it's great joke and I think it's very funny. So
- 1:01:09this whole idea, Michael McKean's character, right has been this gay guy who
- 1:01:15who is going to get outed? This is a very John Lander's joke.
- 1:01:17You might it's a very John Lander's joke, I think, and I don't
- 1:01:21so so people may argue that it's homophobic. I think this probably marks this
- 1:01:25as an adult film. That might be another reason why it flopped, because
- 1:01:30it's a film inspired by a game, and I don't know if maybe adults
- 1:01:32are mostly playing this game, but I'm just thinking about this now. It's
- 1:01:36a very like adult film, like targeted at sophisticated, and I think that's
- 1:01:39fascinating. Board game adaptations would not be as adult as this, I don't
- 1:01:45think today. And so I don't think it's a homophobic thing. I think
- 1:01:49it's a joke about more ais towards homosexuality, both in the eighties and in
- 1:01:54the fifties. So Michael McKean is this gay character whose career will be ruined,
- 1:02:00which is I think more plausible in the fifties in the eighties, though
- 1:02:02it certainly could have been a thing. In the end, well, I
- 1:02:05mean they refer to the house and American activity is exactly and he ends up
- 1:02:10in the third ending being an FBI agent that is there undercover to work out
- 1:02:16this mystery. And the last line is just so great. He just turns
- 1:02:23to the camera and says, I'm gonna go home and sleep with my wife.
- 1:02:29I think his delivery was a bit better, certainly more dead pan anyway,
- 1:02:35but it's just and it ties a beautiful bow. But what does it
- 1:02:39have to do with anything else? Doesn't. It's just just it's a gag.
- 1:02:43It's a funny gag, but it finishes the film on a very funny
- 1:02:46joke, and it is indicative of how brilliantly structured this film is, how
- 1:02:52tight it is. It's not a long film. It never feels slow,
- 1:02:57it never feels boring, and fundamentals short and actually, how long is it?
- 1:03:00I don't ninety minutes? So I am going to ask you for two
- 1:03:04schools, right, and this is how we'll end two schools, one as
- 1:03:10a movie, two as an adaptation of a board game. This is for
- 1:03:15the five G for D wiki. Yeah, exactly when one of you finally
- 1:03:19makes it for yes, exactly what the fuck with? Like, how much
- 1:03:22effort do we put into this when we were called? All we're asking someone
- 1:03:24to do is go and listen to every episode of everything that you've ever done
- 1:03:28and make a wiki out of it. As we're recording this, Scott Hill
- 1:03:31is asking advice on what to do with Lariacon, and I'm giving him advice
- 1:03:36as payment. He could just start at five G for D wiki? Can
- 1:03:38I start small? Like you don't have to do all of it at once?
- 1:03:42Put in a couple hours a day, you know, listen slowly over
- 1:03:45time, gather the content, make sure you get all the references of all
- 1:03:49the running jokes, all the different like characters. I mean every episode should
- 1:03:52probably have its own page, right exactly, you know, every every battle
- 1:03:54report should be covered in. They're like, it won't take you more than
- 1:03:59like what six months, A couple hours a day ish. Yeah, I
- 1:04:01mean I don't see why you wouldn't do this for us Scott anyway, So
- 1:04:09what would you give as a movie? Out of ten? Out of ten?
- 1:04:12It's incredibly reductive, but what would you give it as a It's really
- 1:04:15tough. I mean it's not like I think it's one of the greatest films
- 1:04:17of all time. It isn't. Though I really have an affection for it.
- 1:04:20I had a great time watching it. I mean I'm thinking so as
- 1:04:24a film, right as if it were like the BGG scale, I mean
- 1:04:28maybe seven. Yeah, I think I would give it a solid seven,
- 1:04:30which means you want to watch it. It's really good. It's not life
- 1:04:34changing, but it's really good. There are a few bits where I thought,
- 1:04:38like a little bit like missed the mark, but otherwise kind of like
- 1:04:42like Tim Cray is completely on target the whole time. I mean, you
- 1:04:44give Tim Curry a nine for this? Yeah? Absolutely, absolutely So as
- 1:04:48a board game adaptation, you know, I wanted to discuss what it means
- 1:04:53to be a board game adaptation because it's based on a board game, but
- 1:04:59there isn't any game in it, I mean other than the drawing, right,
- 1:05:00So like, what does it mean to be based on a board game?
- 1:05:03Well, it's like as so my idea is as mechanisms, like why
- 1:05:09why this game? Why at this time? Why was this film made?
- 1:05:12It makes a separate question. So my definition of thematic in board games is
- 1:05:17that the mechanism makes you feel like you're doing what you're supposed to be doing,
- 1:05:21right. So I think uve Rosenberg Games Patchwork is a great example.
- 1:05:28You kind of feel like, you know, you're not sewing a quilt,
- 1:05:31but you feel like you're making it. It's very thematic how to make an
- 1:05:34American quilt? Right? So, board game movie, I think this makes
- 1:05:42you feel like the game is And that's a really nebulous, weird comment,
- 1:05:46but you come out of it going, yeah, that felt like cludo.
- 1:05:49I wonder, I wonder if we're gonna ever watch another film that feels quite
- 1:05:55like that, because we have a few on our lists that are not inspired
- 1:05:58by games, but like have something to do with games, or have games
- 1:06:00in them, but not like directly inspired by a board game. So I
- 1:06:03think, I think there's no Monopoly on The only one that comes close is
- 1:06:08Chairs. I think there are probably films that try to evoke a game of
- 1:06:11Chairs. I think this is probably and I think why it's held in such
- 1:06:15affection by people who are into board games is that it's such a good board
- 1:06:20game adaptation. Is it the only board game adaptation? Well, there's loads
- 1:06:25of films. Well, Battleship, for instance, has a movie with starring
- 1:06:29Rihanna. I guess we have to watch. We will at some point,
- 1:06:33all right, So what would you give it as a board game adaptation?
- 1:06:35Out of ten? Yeah, I think, I mean, I think they're
- 1:06:39gonna be the benchmark for I think it is the high watermarket. It's a
- 1:06:42great place to start, all right, So, Steveek, I think part
- 1:06:45of this discussion is also expanding what we consider to be appropriate for this larger
- 1:06:50discussion, like what constitutes a movie about game. We will talk about Clue
- 1:06:55a lot in subsequent episodes, So do the Lord of the Rings films count
- 1:06:59as board game movie. Think about how the how did Dean do? You?
- 1:07:02Get started? Essentially as a way of immersing yourself in a world like
- 1:07:06the world of Tolkien, and it's like a world where there are rules there.
- 1:07:11There's like the formation of the party. You have a quest, the
- 1:07:14objective through the Ring in the Mountain. I won't spoil the ending for you,
- 1:07:16but you know this eventually, I mean no, there doesn't. Yeah,
- 1:07:24I know, so, like, you know, could you look look
- 1:07:26at this as a kind of retcon adaptation of war they if we ever want
- 1:07:31to fucking watch Lord of the Rings, we can come up with an excuse
- 1:07:33to doing so. Anyway. So to wrap up, Steve, how do
- 1:07:38people join the Discord? Go to the five G f D Movies section and
- 1:07:41talk about this show. So I'm gonna I'm gonna work backwards from the five
- 1:07:45G for D Movies channel on the Discord. You need to get into this
- 1:07:48channel to participate in this conversation to recommend a film for us to cover,
- 1:07:53because honestly, right now the list is very short and we need your advice
- 1:07:57listeners. To enter this channel, you have to be part of the discord
- 1:08:00to begin with. To get to the discord, you have to click you
- 1:08:03have to get an invite. How do you get an invite? You click
- 1:08:05the pinned post at the top of five G for d dot com and you
- 1:08:10need to go to that page in order to get to the pin post in
- 1:08:13order to get the invite to get to the discord, to get to the
- 1:08:15channel. I just did a Tim Curry right there. Doing it backwards is
- 1:08:17really confusing. You go to five G f d dot com, click on
- 1:08:20the pin post, there's an invite. You can join the discord and going
- 1:08:24I was trying to do my own little trumping. You just support what I
- 1:08:28get. Thank you, yes, and from time to time. So if
- 1:08:33you want to help me make these shows happen financially, how do they do
- 1:08:42that? Stevie, you would go to Patreon dot com. I don't think
- 1:08:46you need the www anymore. No, you don't. People know I don't
- 1:08:49don't. You don't have to put it in anymore. I mean, just
- 1:08:51like, type patreon five G for d. That's probably gonna get you there.
- 1:08:56Who actually types out the entire address of anything anymore? You are l's
- 1:09:00a pointless Now you don't need to do that, just like five games for
- 1:09:02doomsday Patreon, you're gonna find it like there's only one though this first show
- 1:09:08is on the main feed. All subsequent shows because this show was created because
- 1:09:11it was a Patreon goal. All subsequent shows ten euros a month or above.
- 1:09:15No, it's five years a month. You're giving this away for five
- 1:09:18years, five years a month. Five I think it's too cheap. Well,
- 1:09:23you know this content, the effort that we put into it. I'm
- 1:09:26a man of five euros a month, and listen, you know what,
- 1:09:29get in. Get in on this while you can if it's only five,
- 1:09:30because I'm going to talk Ben into raising it to ten as soon as I
- 1:09:32can. And so if you don't have the means or the inclination to support
- 1:09:38five gf D financially, how could you? How else could you help?
- 1:09:43Compliments? Yeah, complix raise that are on the internet mostly to me have
- 1:09:46a star value attached to them. I see like and subscribe. No that's
- 1:09:53a thing, right, No, that's YouTube. But yeah, you have
- 1:09:56a YouTube channel, Yeah you could. You could subscribe to the YouTube.
- 1:09:58There's nothing to do with this. Yeah, but you still want people to
- 1:10:00subscribe. So how how do they support in general, like and subscribe on
- 1:10:04YouTube and then I don't know iTunes store five star rating. Please right,
- 1:10:11leave a comment, leave a review, leave a review, just say glows
- 1:10:14because reviews really help say glowing things about me. Then if you want,
- 1:10:18yeah, just so do we have a lot of reviews now some not enough
- 1:10:23though, so if you if you want to review, if you want to
- 1:10:25review the show, please do. Unfortunately, to like get anywhere in this
- 1:10:29world today, you need you need like engagement. The more engagement that the
- 1:10:33podcast gets uh in any in any venue, the more that other people will
- 1:10:38find out about it, and that that does genuinely help. And finally,
- 1:10:44if you want to buy merch some with Steve's face, some with my face,
- 1:10:46some of the find you for d logo, you can go to somemeople
- 1:10:50dot com and you can buy t shirts and mugs and all of that good
- 1:10:54stuff. So we're gonna get something new for the film show hopefully, hopefully
- 1:11:00we are some kind of like Ben and Steve go to Hollywood that sort of
- 1:11:02thing. So finally, say thank you to the listeners for listening. Steve,
- 1:11:08thank you to the listeners for listening, and join us next time at
- 1:11:12five G for d at the Movies. Thank you for listening and join us
- 1:11:20next time on five g f D at the Movies.