Latest / The Vegan Report / Big Ag's Secret Army of Misinfluencers. With Maddy Haughton-Boakes | Ep. 100
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you are listening
- 0:03to The Vegan Report. Today we lift the veil on
- 0:07a world of lies, confusion, spying, corruption
- 0:11and hypocrisy. We expose the meat, dairy and
- 0:16egg social media war strategy unleashed against
- 0:20vegans. A real conspiracy of PR firms, scientists,
- 0:26health experts, environmental organizations.
- 0:29and more. To tackle this issue, I have with me
- 0:32Maddie Houghton -Bokes, a senior campaigner at
- 0:36Changing Markets Foundation. Changing Markets
- 0:39has been doing amazing work in investigating,
- 0:43documenting, and reporting on the current Miss
- 0:46and Disinformation campaign about food systems.
- 0:51The reports are fascinating. Visit the episode
- 0:55notes to access them. And for more conversations
- 0:59like this, follow and subscribe to the show,
- 1:03please consider leaving a good review, and share
- 1:06this episode with the vegans you know. We need
- 1:09to alert our movement of these cowardly tactics.
- 1:25confessing of, you know, being part of this misinformation
- 1:31campaign. I think he was paid about $17 an hour
- 1:36to create multiple accounts in order to disparage
- 1:42people from going vegan or spread lies about
- 1:47plant -based veganism. So I guess my first question
- 1:51for you is, are you surprised by that? No, not
- 1:56surprised. I'm not surprised by it. Our research
- 1:59at Changing Markets has shown that this kind
- 2:03of attacks on vegan products is, it's a classic
- 2:08tool used by the meat and dairy industry. And
- 2:11they have a number of different avenues for doing
- 2:15this, including paying and training people to
- 2:20attack these products online. There's a whole
- 2:22program called the Masters of Beef Advocacy run
- 2:25by the National Cattleman Beef Association in
- 2:28the US. And it's basically like a training program
- 2:32for kind of promoting meat products online, but
- 2:35also in how to attack. Yeah. vegan products as
- 2:40well. So we're not surprised by it. And we see
- 2:44a huge amount of funding and attention going
- 2:47towards influencers to attack vegan products
- 2:51as well as promote meat products and dairy products
- 2:54as well. So it's all just part of this kind of,
- 2:58yeah, online battleground, I think. Before getting
- 3:02into what's happening, you know, on the platform,
- 3:06I want to just spend a moment talking about the
- 3:09platforms themselves. So when I think of, for
- 3:13instance, Facebook or Instagram, I think of the
- 3:17owner of those platforms who is, you know, Mark
- 3:20Zuckerberg, and how he is absolutely not, you
- 3:25know, sympathetic to the vegan or plant based
- 3:28cause. He actually is a rancher, he's raising
- 3:33cattle on a Hawaiian island where, you know,
- 3:38ecosystems are really fragile. And so do you
- 3:41think you know, those platforms do you think
- 3:43the game is rigged against, you know, this kind
- 3:47of discourse in the first place? Is there any
- 3:52evidence of, you know, post getting not as much
- 3:58attention as they're supposed to get because
- 4:02of the platform itself that does not want to
- 4:05support that kind of discourse. And how should
- 4:09we think about the fact that the owners of those
- 4:14platforms are against the very causes that we
- 4:18represent? Yeah, I think it's a really interesting
- 4:20question. I mean, I think there's a huge amount
- 4:24of research out there about the algorithms of
- 4:29these platforms and how they promote kind of
- 4:34sensationalist far right leaning climate conspiracy
- 4:39information. And I think for a lot of people
- 4:43talking about vegan diets or high plant -based
- 4:48diets, they fall into this. category of often
- 4:52being aligned with like environmental causes
- 4:54and stuff and so they definitely suffer from
- 4:56the algorithms in that way. I'm not aware of
- 5:00any research and our research hasn't hasn't specifically
- 5:02looked into this that really kind of shows a
- 5:05direct anti -vegan kind of setup but I think
- 5:10it's part of how these platforms are geared towards
- 5:14that more extremist content and we see what our
- 5:18research has shown is that We see a lot of far
- 5:22-right ideologies aligning themselves with carnivore
- 5:25diets and other very heavy meat diets. And we
- 5:28know that those types of discussions are definitely
- 5:34favored by the algorithms. And Elon Musk with
- 5:36X is... I'm not sure if he's a carnivore diet
- 5:40himself, but he's definitely friends with a lot
- 5:42of the carnivore bros. Like they are, yeah, they're
- 5:45very much in that world of kind of meat is masculine
- 5:48and that's part of their identity. So it's, even
- 5:52if it's not explicit, it's kind of part of the
- 5:56broader bias that they have there. You don't
- 6:03think you don't need to research that in order
- 6:06to observe that it's quite evident. What is the
- 6:11scale of this whole campaign of disinformation
- 6:15and in seeding confusion? Yeah, it's vast, definitely.
- 6:21So our first piece of research that we did on
- 6:23disinformation and food systems was for a report
- 6:27called Truth Flies Culture Wars, which we put
- 6:30out a couple of years ago. And we started this
- 6:33because we at Change Your Markets have been campaigning
- 6:36on methane from meat and dairy as a major climate
- 6:41source of climate heating emissions. for several
- 6:46years now and we were really coming up against
- 6:48this like a lot of misinformation online around
- 6:52supposedly sustainable credentials of meat like
- 6:57that that methane from cows and methane is a
- 7:00very potent for people that don't know is a very
- 7:02potent greenhouse gases 80 times more warming
- 7:04than carbon dioxide over 20 year period and is
- 7:09a key source of emissions to tackle. right now
- 7:12if we're going to have any chance of kind of
- 7:15keeping the 1 .5 degrees Celsius global temperature
- 7:19increases within reach. And we were coming up
- 7:23against all this kind of greenwashing trying
- 7:25to suggest that cows are part of a natural cycle
- 7:28and absorb carbon and all of this. And so we
- 7:31wanted to look into this misinformation. And
- 7:33actually what we discovered was that obviously
- 7:36that's the stuff we were seeing because our algorithms
- 7:39are geared towards the topic of methane, but
- 7:42actually what we discovered was that there's
- 7:45the vast majority of food system misinformation
- 7:48out there around meat and dairy is kind of attacks
- 7:51on alternative diets and alternative products,
- 7:55vegan diets, vegan products, and undermining
- 7:57the science and conspiracy theories. It was the
- 8:01vast majority, vast amount of this misinformation
- 8:04and it was quite a large data set as well that
- 8:06we looked at. And the scale was quite shocking
- 8:09to us. We hadn't really kind of tapped into that
- 8:12before. And that's just one piece of the puzzle
- 8:16as well. Our research since then has kind of
- 8:19taken us into looking a lot at the meat and dairy
- 8:22industry lobby tactics. And we know that the
- 8:26narratives that we see online, like attacking
- 8:29vegan diets and vegan products, are one piece
- 8:32of the puzzle and they're doing this in their
- 8:35lobbying efforts in parliament, the EU parliament,
- 8:39and in lobbying efforts in the US as well and
- 8:41in the UK. Those are the main places where we've
- 8:44looked but also recently looked in research in
- 8:48Brazil as well. Yeah, they're attacking all of
- 8:53these alternatives, they're trying to undermine
- 8:54the science and it's just part of this kind of
- 8:57vast wheelhouse of trying to maintain the high
- 9:01meat and dairy consumption status quo that there
- 9:03is at the moment, at the same time as portraying
- 9:06themselves as the victim. We often see this narrative
- 9:09that like they're the underdogs and that, you
- 9:13know, they're trying to go back to some time
- 9:16when meat was viewed positively. Whereas actually,
- 9:20if you look at dietary patterns in North America
- 9:24and, you know, many places in the global north
- 9:27in general, meat consumption and dairy consumption
- 9:30is still really high. They're not the underdogs,
- 9:32the people who are advocating for dietary shifts
- 9:34and food system transformation and more plant
- 9:37-based diets. That's actually like the minority
- 9:40and trying to, yeah, to kind of shift the system.
- 9:46An incredible statistic I read on one of your
- 9:51reports, excellent reports, I recommend people
- 9:55to read them, link in the episode notes, was
- 10:01about the money that those companies spend on
- 10:05marketing and PR, which is more than product
- 10:10development. Now that shocked me. Can you comment
- 10:15on that? Yeah. Yeah. I mean, yeah, these companies
- 10:21know that the reality is that, you know, a lot
- 10:26of the kind of the battleground is played out
- 10:30in a kind of comms war these days. And again,
- 10:34this was another one where we were kind of maybe
- 10:37not surprised, but still shocked that yet, like
- 10:40more money is spent on advertising and that includes
- 10:44greenwashing advertising. Most adverts these
- 10:48days have or often adverts have a really strong
- 10:51kind of green focus within them and more money
- 10:54is spent on that than actually developing products
- 10:56that have got genuine solutions. So an example
- 11:00of that might be like Nestle had a they produced
- 11:07a KitKat that they claimed was going to be carbon
- 11:09neutral by 2025 or they claimed that KitKats
- 11:11were going to be carbon neutral by 2025 and there
- 11:14was this big song and dance about it and then
- 11:17it's just kind of quietly disappeared. There's
- 11:19no update on whether that is now carbon neutral
- 11:22and you know what have they actually been doing
- 11:25in the meantime? I think it's just insetting
- 11:27and which is a form of kind of buying offset
- 11:30credits but within their own supply chains and
- 11:33you know it's these really kind of shocking contradictions
- 11:36between what they're saying out there and then
- 11:38and then the reality of it and we saw this really
- 11:42starkly last month when we were at COP 30 in
- 11:47Brazil and there was so at COPs you have the
- 11:52the climate conferences you have the official
- 11:54blue zone then you have a green zone which is
- 11:56for the public and at this one you also have
- 11:59the agri zone which was this whole space kind
- 12:03of dedicated to supposedly solutions from the
- 12:07agricultural sector and what it was really is
- 12:09just like a roadshow for the big agribusiness
- 12:11giants and it had sponsorship from Nestle, from
- 12:15Bayer, the major pesticides company. We also
- 12:20saw JBS, the world's biggest meat company, sponsored
- 12:23the media center in there. Like it was just really
- 12:27their chance to showcase themselves and you know,
- 12:31these weren't small sponsorships that they were
- 12:33doing, and they put a lot of money and time into
- 12:36kind of how they were presenting themselves as
- 12:39having the solution, rather than actually investing
- 12:44in genuine solutions to shift their supply chains.
- 12:48And we see this So one of the solutions that
- 12:53the industry pushes quite often, particularly
- 12:55around the methane issue, is feed additives for
- 12:59cows that essentially reduce the amount of methane
- 13:02that cows burp out. And often companies... will
- 13:06invest in trials of these, and then when it comes
- 13:10to actually scaling that up within their supply
- 13:12chains, and they'll make a big song and dance
- 13:14about what an amazing solution this is, and then
- 13:17when it comes to actually scaling it up in their
- 13:19supply chains, they'll say that it's too expensive
- 13:21and they can't invest in it enough and they want
- 13:22public subsidies for it. And yet they've invested
- 13:25all this in the marketing and then, and they'll
- 13:27present themselves as having the solutions that
- 13:29these kind of road shows at cop. Um, so the money
- 13:32is being diverted into this kind of fanfare around.
- 13:36Yeah. How great they are rather than actually
- 13:39any kind of lasting solutions to the problem.
- 13:43Here's a bit of a touchy question. Um, what is
- 13:48the role that environmental nonprofits play in?
- 13:53this game because, you know, I, I can't imagine
- 13:57a nonprofit, you know, spending lots of money
- 14:00to convince one of those big corporations to
- 14:04make some positive efforts. And then what they
- 14:09do is release all of that marketing content and
- 14:15the nonprofits turns to their donors and say,
- 14:18Hey, look at all the good work we've done. Um,
- 14:21and then No accountability or you know an example
- 14:28that is closer to home here you know i live in
- 14:32quebec canada here the government decided to
- 14:36give subsidies to different corporations that
- 14:40were doing lots of harm to the environment with
- 14:45the idea of them you know using that money to
- 14:48offset their environmental negative impact. And
- 14:54instead of developing, you know, technologies
- 14:57or anything of the sort, they spent that money
- 15:02on sponsorship and donations for local environmental
- 15:08organizations. So that's something I witnessed.
- 15:13Have you, you know, looked at this closely or?
- 15:18Yeah. We haven't gone into a huge amount of detail
- 15:21on this specific problem, but in our big report
- 15:25that came out last year, The New Merchants of
- 15:26Doubt, we definitely highlight some of these
- 15:29kind of collaborations between some environmental
- 15:32groups and more likely kind of industry trade
- 15:37groups than specific industry companies. But
- 15:40there was also a really brilliant report by Dismog,
- 15:45I think it was recently that shared examples,
- 15:50specific examples around global roundtable for
- 15:53sustainable beef. And, and they had access to
- 15:56documents that showed that they were kind of
- 15:59strategically partnering with environmental groups
- 16:01to present themselves as having more of a green
- 16:05facade and, you know, we're changing markets
- 16:09as an environmental organization and we regularly
- 16:11work in partnership with a lot of these kind
- 16:13of environmental groups and in the kind of broad
- 16:18food system campaigning world there are a lot
- 16:23of different angles that have to be used you
- 16:26know and there's the kind of campaign as we often
- 16:29talk about inside and outside voices and you
- 16:32do need both often to push for change, you need
- 16:36the people working in partnership and sitting
- 16:38in those meetings after meetings with a company
- 16:40talking them through how they can actually make
- 16:42a change. And you know, we in changing markets,
- 16:44we also engage directly with companies. But yeah,
- 16:48I think where it becomes a real problem is when
- 16:50it's used as a greenwashing tool and as a kind
- 16:56of maybe even a get out of jail free card and
- 17:00We always talk about how we have no permanent
- 17:02allies and no permanent adversaries, because
- 17:05if a company is willing to change and to have
- 17:09open, honest conversations with us, we will absolutely
- 17:11sit down and talk to them about it and look at
- 17:13how they can make improvements. If they start
- 17:16reneging on that, we've got no loyalty. We're
- 17:18not paid by them. We're not going to kind of
- 17:21be friendly to them because they've been good
- 17:23in the past. We'll absolutely call them out.
- 17:25And I think that's one of the Sometimes that
- 17:28doesn't always happen with environmental groups.
- 17:31And that's where they run the risk of, yeah,
- 17:34further kind of endorsing this green facade.
- 17:40And, you know, we need both. We need the inside
- 17:42and the outside. But we also need to to call
- 17:45it out where we see, yeah, abuse of that. That's
- 17:50an excellent policy that everyone should adopt,
- 17:54including, you know, media platforms. um and
- 17:59you know about that i think for someone listening
- 18:03to this for the first time you know learning
- 18:05of those facts for the first time um what's shocking
- 18:09is that there's no law regulating this kind of
- 18:13you know speech um you know i'm all for free
- 18:18speech but this is this is you know seeding lies
- 18:22and confusion and you know there should be some
- 18:27kind of law to hold them accountable. Why aren't
- 18:31there any? Yeah, there have been attempts, definitely.
- 18:35So in the EU, there has been the Green Claims
- 18:41Directive has been in progress. And that was
- 18:44and a couple of other pieces of regulation as
- 18:47well, which kind of combined were going to hold
- 18:53companies accountable for any green claims that
- 18:55they do make. And this policy has basically been
- 19:01derailed through more or less, it kind of looks
- 19:04like the wheels have almost fully come off now.
- 19:06It's, it's really upsetting. It was a really
- 19:10promising piece of regulation combined with other
- 19:12different policies. And there've been a number
- 19:15of studies showing links to lobby groups, including
- 19:18from the oil industry and Yeah, no doubt, lots
- 19:24of agribusiness companies were concerned about
- 19:27this as well, because we see greenwashing claims,
- 19:30we've done a number of investigations into greenwashing
- 19:32claims from food companies. And yeah, this would
- 19:35have held them accountable, you know, they wouldn't
- 19:37have been able to use kind of general claims
- 19:39like carbon neutral anymore. And so yeah, there
- 19:44was a chance with this regulation and it's dying.
- 19:49a death in the policy realm. We do see some optimism
- 19:54in like small case, not small, but like individual
- 19:57cases in different places. So JBS recently settled
- 20:02a lawsuit in New York for greenwashing with it.
- 20:06It had its net zero by I think it was 2050 claim
- 20:09that was backed up by absolutely no evidence.
- 20:14And no clear plan of how they were going to achieve
- 20:16that, you know, this is the world's biggest meat
- 20:19company, it's emissions rival, big fossil fuel
- 20:21companies. And yet they just were like, yeah,
- 20:24we can just go out and say net zero, whatever.
- 20:27And they did, they did settle this, this lawsuit.
- 20:30So there's these instances where the truth is
- 20:34held up. And hopefully what, you know, we're
- 20:39as an organization we're focused on kind of market
- 20:42campaigns and a lot of that does involve because
- 20:45we know that policy and regulation takes a really
- 20:47long time so a lot of that does involve trying
- 20:50to signal to other companies that if you do this
- 20:53you're going to be held accountable and you know
- 20:56this is going to impact your bottom line so it's
- 20:59little signals like this that we hope kind of
- 21:01reduce the impact, reduce the prevalence of these
- 21:04kinds of of greenwashing. But you're right, there
- 21:07is it's it's kind of crazy that companies can
- 21:09just in the first place even go out and say this
- 21:12with nothing to back it up. It's mad. Yeah, it's
- 21:17must be, you know, very frustrating for plant
- 21:20based companies that get sued because they use
- 21:23the label milk on your package. yet those companies
- 21:29can say whatever they want, and they have armies
- 21:33of lawyers to protect them. And the lobbies,
- 21:38of course. Yeah, yes, I would just on that, actually,
- 21:42it's a really good point. And you know, we in
- 21:45contrast to that. what I said about the Green
- 21:47Claims Directive and kind of being derailed recently,
- 21:50at the same time, you've got MEPs, members of
- 21:53the European Parliament, voting to ban meat based
- 21:57terms for vegan and plant based products recently,
- 22:02saying that it confuses consumers. And yet, a
- 22:06completely empty carbon neutral or green claim,
- 22:09equally, it well is actually genuinely and there's
- 22:13evidence to show that it does confuse consumers.
- 22:16And yet there's no evidence really to show that
- 22:18consumers are confused by like a vegan sausage.
- 22:21People know that that's vegan. They're not going
- 22:23to think they're eating a pork product. Um, and
- 22:26yet that's where the, the politicians time and
- 22:28focus has been recently. It's, it's a really
- 22:31frustrating contradiction. Um, and you know,
- 22:35it's got, it's got kind of lobby hands and imprints
- 22:38written all over it. The double standard is just
- 22:41incredible. Um, Okay, so we discussed the scale
- 22:47of this whole operation and we touched on some
- 22:52of the actors What about you know, the social
- 22:56media space what I love is that in your reports
- 22:59you actually name, you know those agents of Misinformation
- 23:04you call them Miss influencers, which you know,
- 23:07I love this term So who are those people active
- 23:13on social media, on the payroll of a big ag and
- 23:18spreading those lies? Yeah. Yeah. Misinfluences
- 23:23is a great term. It was actually, you know, we're
- 23:26using on our reports. It was the research organization,
- 23:30Ripple Research, that came up with that term
- 23:32and absolutely have to credit them for that because
- 23:33that was fun. It was, yeah, we love it. Yeah,
- 23:38it's we kind of forget in the work that we do
- 23:41that sometimes that is really bold to actually
- 23:43name the people. But you know, we're getting
- 23:44the we're putting the information out there.
- 23:47We're looking at the data and their names are
- 23:49there. And because of the way that most of our
- 23:53social media misinformation analysis has been
- 23:55focused on X, because it is kind of open source
- 23:59content. Whereas if we were looking at meta,
- 24:02we would have various rules around like not being
- 24:05able to disclose that, but it's X is, is yeah,
- 24:08how we've done it means that we can directly
- 24:10name them. So our mis -influencers across the
- 24:13different reports have definitely varied, but
- 24:15there's a few kind of characters that pop up
- 24:18fairly regularly. And they fall into kind of
- 24:23different categories. So our top misinfluencer
- 24:26in our most recent report Meet versus Eat Lancet,
- 24:30which looked at the backlash to the Eat Lancet
- 24:34planetary health diet report that came out in
- 24:372019. And then there was an update this year.
- 24:40And we were kind of trying to preempt a backlash
- 24:43this time, and because there was a huge one last
- 24:46time. The top misinfluencer in that piece of
- 24:49research was a carnivore diet advocate called
- 24:52Sean Baker, who's this kind of like, almost caricature
- 24:57of what you'd expect a carnivore diet advocate
- 25:00to be really. And he has publicly claimed his
- 25:03spot as a top misinfluencer. We've seen pictures
- 25:06of him wearing a t -shirt saying number one misinfluencer
- 25:09and things like that. So he's clearly very proud
- 25:12of his position in our research. I'm curious
- 25:15to know whether that's a real t -shirt or some
- 25:17kind of Photoshop or AI or something in the photo.
- 25:23Yeah, it's people like him, but then you also
- 25:25have the slightly more kind of maybe palatable
- 25:31to policymakers and journalists people or kind
- 25:34of slightly more considered a bit more expert
- 25:38is so there's Frederick Leroy, who is a researcher
- 25:41based in Brussels. And he he's come up several
- 25:46times in lots of our research. He's very focused
- 25:49on the nutritional benefits of meat products.
- 25:53And we don't directly dispute what he's saying
- 25:58about the bioavailability of certain nutrients
- 26:02within a steak and within beef and things like
- 26:04that. But where he falls into becoming a misinfluencer
- 26:07is because he is then attacking things like the
- 26:11eat lancet planetary health diet on various grounds
- 26:14and trying to undermine these things and kind
- 26:18of suggesting that actually we need to health
- 26:22implications like obesity are because of a reduction
- 26:26in meat consumption. And the answer is more meat
- 26:29consumption seems to always be his answer, despite
- 26:31the fact that, yeah, it's, you know, conventional
- 26:35and adopted kind of standardly recognized science
- 26:39shows that there is an over consumption of meat
- 26:42products in Europe where he is based. So these
- 26:46are kind of two of the biggest names that come
- 26:48up but there's like a whole host of them who
- 26:49are very some are more focused on attacking vegan
- 26:53products because of being supposedly ultra processed
- 26:56and saying that that that like ultra processed
- 26:59food is is the worst thing to ever happen to
- 27:02to human diets and and you know all these kinds
- 27:07of lenses and then you've got others there's
- 27:10another one that came up is another scientist
- 27:13called Frank Mitlohner, who is very tied to industry.
- 27:16And there's been tons of investigation showing
- 27:18his links to meat industry. And he's very focused
- 27:24on the kind of greenwashing of meat products
- 27:27and suggesting that there's ways of looking at
- 27:30methane that aren't mean that it's not a problem
- 27:32in reality. So there's kind of like a there's
- 27:37a spectrum of these people and Some of them have
- 27:40got very clear links to industry, some of them
- 27:42we don't have any evidence that they are tied
- 27:43to industry. But what we say is that their line,
- 27:46their narratives are, they benefit the meat industry
- 27:50and the dairy industry status quo and dominance,
- 27:53you know, they're advocating for in the case
- 27:55of Sean Baker and other carnival people, really
- 27:57extreme levels of meat consumption. And others
- 28:00are just trying to kind of overly defend as I
- 28:04said at the beginning, overly defend meat and
- 28:06dairy as if it's suddenly the underdog and no
- 28:09one's touching it. When in reality, we know that
- 28:12there's still, you know, super high levels of
- 28:14consumption of both. Here's a weird question.
- 28:19Could some of those misinfluencers be the victim,
- 28:23be also a victim of big acts of, you know, you
- 28:26mentioned that school of misinfluencers, people
- 28:29who create multiple fake accounts. maybe they
- 28:33can, you know, um, surround those people and
- 28:38create the, um, a certain narrative, you know,
- 28:42on their algorithm feed or on their comment section,
- 28:46um, to, you know, support some of their claims,
- 28:50uh, show that other claims are popular when they're
- 28:54not, um, just a way to, you know, slowly, um,
- 28:59you know, push them into the big ag. a friendly
- 29:03narrative. Yeah, I mean it's entirely possible.
- 29:08We haven't specifically looked into it and we
- 29:10haven't seen any obvious suggestions of this,
- 29:13but one thing we've been trying to keep our eyes
- 29:17out for is this kind of inauthentic account activity
- 29:21and that may be bot accounts or it may be just
- 29:26like this Reddit example of these fake accounts
- 29:29that pop up every so often and There in our data
- 29:32set, there definitely are a lot of accounts that
- 29:35are kind of what we call background noise. So
- 29:38they're not the most engaged with people like
- 29:41Sean Baker and others, but they kind of regularly
- 29:44post on this and will like and boost and retweet
- 29:47and other people's posts. But and lots of them
- 29:52are kind of anonymous accounts and they could
- 29:54well be fake, but it's really hard to to be certain
- 29:58about that, and they could be tied to industry.
- 30:02We haven't yet seen, but it doesn't mean it doesn't
- 30:04exist, kind of mass bot activity on any posts.
- 30:10And the indications of this would be like really
- 30:13big surges, but it doesn't mean that it's not
- 30:15possible because there's, you know, growing amount
- 30:17of evidence and research showing how feasible
- 30:21it is to kind of mobilize these bot armies as
- 30:27they're often called on particular topics and
- 30:31it's actually fairly cheap and would work quite
- 30:35well for the industry to sway around these kind
- 30:39of critical moments. We've not seen evidence
- 30:41of it but it's not out of the realm of possibility
- 30:44that this is happening. Yes, because, you know,
- 30:49audience capture is a thing. And if like 10 %
- 30:53of your audience is made up of bots and misinfluencers,
- 30:57then you know, it's easy to, you know, change
- 31:00your opinions or, you know, make you cover a
- 31:05certain topic under a certain light. Yeah. Yeah,
- 31:11yeah, absolutely. Yeah. And it's Yeah, it's just
- 31:16another tool that can be in the wheelhouse of
- 31:18people. And then, you know, they know that this
- 31:20kind of social media battleground is really key.
- 31:23And we also know from our research that Gen Z
- 31:27audiences are like a really target audience for
- 31:30meat and dairy companies. They've been quite
- 31:32explicit on that with several campaigns. And
- 31:36there is full likelihood that you can sway Gen
- 31:41Z audiences by using, yeah, bot and fake account
- 31:44activity across multiple different social media
- 31:47accounts to kind of create that noise and that
- 31:49kind of consensus online. Another actor are the
- 31:54PR firms. Can you talk about them? Yeah, they
- 32:01are. Yeah. So the PR firms as there's Several
- 32:05examples in our big report, New Merchants of
- 32:08Doubt, that really draws out kind of key PR firms
- 32:11that have been involved in some of these pro
- 32:14meat and dairy campaigns. So one is Edelman,
- 32:17which is a big PR firm that's got ties to the
- 32:20oil industry and also tobacco industry. They're
- 32:23kind of your real like textbook bad guy PR firms
- 32:27and they Yeah, have been involved in in kind
- 32:32of very pro meat campaigns. Another one that
- 32:35was pushed attacking vegan products was by a
- 32:41guy who apparently is quite proud of his name.
- 32:44Dr. Evil is how he's called. His actual name
- 32:49is Richard Berman. And he yeah, he was part of
- 32:54this campaign to focus on the ingredients in
- 32:58vegan products. basically using this idea of
- 33:01like a children's spelling bee and if you can't
- 33:03spell the name of an ingredient uh in a product
- 33:06then maybe you shouldn't be eating it um and
- 33:09he again has been tied to oil industry and tobacco
- 33:14which is why he's got this nickname dr evil um
- 33:17like he's he's one of these only seems to work
- 33:20for dark actors type figures that you see about
- 33:22in the in the pr world um And then what we really
- 33:28wanted to show with our report, The New Merchants
- 33:30of Doubt, is that this kind of textbook and the
- 33:35use of PR firms like these as part of it is being
- 33:38used by the meat and dairy industry. And it's
- 33:40the same playbook used by oil and tobacco before
- 33:44them. And it's being used to distract, delay,
- 33:49and derail climate action. the attacks on vegan
- 33:54products and on vegan diets is part of that and
- 33:57the use of PR firms to kind of muddy the water,
- 34:01greenwash products and part of these attacks
- 34:03is a tool that has been used by multiple industries
- 34:08before. LR Yeah, very interesting. Dr. Evil,
- 34:13my gosh. It's more impressive than Bob. Um, okay.
- 34:25Are they successful at, you know, spreading those
- 34:30lies and misinformation? And of course I'm asking
- 34:33that and I know the answer is yes. Um, because,
- 34:37you know, prior to this conversation, um, actually
- 34:40yesterday I had dinner with my parents and I
- 34:44mentioned that I was going to record this podcast
- 34:46and that, you know, there was a campaign of misinformation
- 34:50from Big Ag on social media. And their answer
- 34:54was, oh, do you mean artificial meat? Like they
- 35:00were confused. And I started, you know, asking
- 35:03some follow up questions and they had that opinion
- 35:08that, you know, I was not aware of that, you
- 35:11know, artificial meat was horrible for your health
- 35:14and that they're trying to impose that on us.
- 35:19And, you know, it's something clone, something
- 35:22like grown in the lab, but it's horrible. And
- 35:25I was just shocked by that, you know, to discover
- 35:27that my parents, you know, who should know better
- 35:30since I'm present that they had developed that
- 35:35opinion from, you know, their social media consumption.
- 35:39Yeah. Yeah. It's, um, I mean, I think there's
- 35:43multiple strands to that. There's like the power
- 35:48imbalance that we are pushing back against the
- 35:52dominant perspective and also generations of
- 35:59marketing around the meat and dairy industry
- 36:01that suggests that meat and dairy is some kind
- 36:06of natural, fluffy industry. I became a mum last
- 36:12year and it's been super stark to me how that
- 36:14kind of idea that farming is lovely is really
- 36:18ingrained in children from so early on. I think
- 36:22I knew it, but it's really shocking reading all
- 36:26these books to my daughter and just realising
- 36:28that the farmer is always this lovely... you
- 36:32know, I'm not saying anything about farmers,
- 36:34like, but you know, it's this idea that the meat
- 36:36and dairy industry is, is just one happy farmer
- 36:39in a field with his animals and, and it is often
- 36:42a he and so we're kind of fighting against this
- 36:47dominant idea with these new developments. And,
- 36:52you know, some of them aren't new, some of them
- 36:54are more new, some of them are like been around
- 36:56for generations, but So there's that power imbalance,
- 37:02but I think in many ways, they are winning in
- 37:06lots of areas. They've got a lot of resources
- 37:09because they are the dominant industry. But at
- 37:13the same time, I think there is, you know, there's
- 37:16growing evidence and growing consensus around
- 37:19the health impacts of an over consumption of
- 37:22meat and dairy, despite the efforts to suggest
- 37:26otherwise by lots of the misinfluencers that
- 37:28we've identified and various other spaces. There's
- 37:33the kind of the evidence and the scientific kind
- 37:36of backing of this is becoming more and more
- 37:40robust, which, you know, often, not always, but
- 37:47often the science and the evidence does win out,
- 37:50particularly in relation to policy. And we see
- 37:53journalists and others becoming I think more
- 37:57clued up on this as well, which is obviously
- 37:58a really crucial area where you can communicate
- 38:01to the public the reality of the situation. So
- 38:05I think they're winning in some areas, but maybe
- 38:10they're also going into it a little bit more
- 38:12guns blazing at the moment because they see a
- 38:14real risk. There is a decline in meat consumption
- 38:17among younger generations and that terrifies
- 38:20them and it terrifies their shareholders because
- 38:23that's Yeah, a big drop off in demand for their
- 38:27products. And at the same time, they're increasingly
- 38:30being held accountable for their climate impacts,
- 38:32not enough yet. But we're seeing the emissions
- 38:35of the meat and dairy industry and agriculture
- 38:38sector, big ag and kind of industrial agriculture,
- 38:41rising up the agenda steadily. Again, not enough.
- 38:46Having just been a cop, it's like not enough.
- 38:48It's not on the table firmly yet, but it's it's
- 38:50getting close. So Yeah, maybe like two steps
- 38:55forwards and one step back is happening. Well,
- 38:59we should say a few words about the recent COP
- 39:04conference. What kind of experience did you have?
- 39:11And, you know, did you at the end of the conference,
- 39:15did you feel more optimistic or, you know, more
- 39:18negative about our future prospect in terms of,
- 39:22you know, creating an environmentally friendly
- 39:26world. Yeah, it's really difficult. I've been
- 39:30trying to figure this out since getting back.
- 39:32I think I've been back like two, three weeks
- 39:34now or something like that. I've been trying
- 39:36to figure out how I feel about it and I'm unsure.
- 39:40But I think, so we went into it with quite a
- 39:43clear focus. So we, before COP, we launched a
- 39:47report called The Meet Agenda that looked at
- 39:51So I mentioned the agri zone earlier, and this
- 39:54really looked at the kind of the run up to the
- 39:56agri zone and how Brazilian big ag companies,
- 40:01particularly the likes of JBS, the world's biggest
- 40:03meat company, how they were kind of preparing
- 40:07themselves for COP. And we saw that there was
- 40:12like a year -long series of events where time
- 40:14and again this narrative that we have the solutions
- 40:17and we're kind of coming to the table to be part
- 40:19of changing the climate game was the primary
- 40:24message and the primary focus and it's all just
- 40:27these big kind of conferences and chances to
- 40:30really refine their communication strategy collectively
- 40:33essentially it looks like. culminating in the
- 40:37agri zone where they had events and policymakers
- 40:39and journalists coming along and hearing all
- 40:41of this stuff and these kind of trade show examples
- 40:45of their so -called solutions which yeah, they're
- 40:51massively over inflating the impacts of. So that
- 40:57kind of element of it was very much on our radar
- 41:01and we went into it with quite a strong focus
- 41:05of seeing how it played out in reality and we
- 41:10did see a lot of industry narratives and they
- 41:14were firmly in kind of crucial conversations
- 41:17around food system transformation where you would
- 41:20hope that the discussion is much more on the
- 41:23evidence -based side and time and again it kept
- 41:25coming back to a need to kind of preserve livestock
- 41:29in very certain situations but that almost being
- 41:32used as a reason to to not have the conversation
- 41:37about reducing meat and dairy consumption in
- 41:39some places. So that's a kind of worrying trend,
- 41:43but at the same time, it was really heartening
- 41:47to connect with so many activists and organizations,
- 41:52particularly with it being in Brazil, where there
- 41:55is a really strong, amazing grassroots movement,
- 41:58and to connect with so many of them that are
- 42:00fighting industrial agriculture companies on
- 42:04the ground and running amazing investigations
- 42:07into deforestation and human rights abuses that
- 42:09take place in Brazil. So I think that's why I
- 42:14started with that uncertainty of not knowing
- 42:16how to answer it, because on the one hand, we
- 42:18saw this industry PR machine working really effectively.
- 42:24But at the same time, an increasingly well connected
- 42:28and grassroots connected Yeah, kind of alternative
- 42:33voice that is making some good progress. And
- 42:39all of that is obviously, you know, that we've
- 42:42got the backdrop of escalating climate emergency.
- 42:44And we heard from a minister from Tuvalu, one
- 42:49of the Pacific islands, talking about the urgency
- 42:52of tackling methane emissions. And it was, you
- 42:57know, I've been working on methane for three
- 43:00and a half years now and even to me someone who
- 43:03talks about the urgency of tackling methane time
- 43:06and again to hear him talk about the fact that
- 43:09methane really is an emergency break like if
- 43:11we cut methane emissions because it's such a
- 43:15potent greenhouse gas and it is also a short
- 43:18-lived gas so it disappears from the atmosphere
- 43:21between 12 and 20 years after 12 and 20 years
- 43:24whereas carbon lives basically forever or over
- 43:27a hundred years. If we cut methane emissions
- 43:30this decade, then we can really slow the rate
- 43:34of warming. And that for someone living in Tuvalu
- 43:38is the difference between their planet, their
- 43:41country being livable and being underwater. Like
- 43:44it's huge for them. And it was, yeah, I think
- 43:49really like stark to hear that reality. you know,
- 43:54voices like that maybe weren't cutting through
- 43:56on the methane issue before and they're rising
- 43:58up the agenda as well. So it's, yeah, this is
- 44:02a very long winded way of saying lots of conflicting
- 44:05feelings about it, which I think anyone working
- 44:07on climate, you have to maintain the hope. But
- 44:10at the same time, you're like starkly aware of
- 44:13the real horrific reality. You raised the point
- 44:17about, you know, big agents visiting those events
- 44:22to get a better understanding on how to counteract
- 44:26the points and all of that. And this has been
- 44:29on my mind for a while now. It reminds me of
- 44:35that book, Siri, the tree body problem, you know,
- 44:41you have aliens and they can read your mind and
- 44:44they're coming to conquer you. And so they need
- 44:47to think of a way to protect the earth. without,
- 44:52you know, making it explicit to those aliens
- 44:56and their technology that is amazing and can
- 44:59read your mind. And, you know, I have this podcast
- 45:04and I have those conversations and it's public.
- 45:06And I'm sure that some agent of big ag, you know,
- 45:11would listen to that for, you know, to counteract
- 45:16those arguments to get a better understanding
- 45:18of who the enemy is. who the target is to use
- 45:23a less loaded word. So what do you make of that?
- 45:29Should we, you know, limit the things we say
- 45:32in public because of that? Yeah, interesting.
- 45:38I think no, like, you know, I've been quite open
- 45:40about the fact that at Changing Markets we have
- 45:42no permanent allies and no permanent adversaries.
- 45:45Like we haven't got anything to hide because
- 45:47we, and I'm sure you as well, like, you know,
- 45:50we're coming from a place of real focus on evidence
- 45:56base and issues that are important to us. And
- 46:01we, you know, we're not gonna put our strategies
- 46:05up for like public consumption but we're also
- 46:08like fairly open about where our focus is and
- 46:11what we're looking at and what we're trying to
- 46:13achieve and I think that's important because
- 46:17you have to build trust and yeah and also like
- 46:21I said we you know we haven't got anything to
- 46:22hide in that sense I think where you know we
- 46:26do a lot of investigations and trying to um unpick
- 46:31coordination and plans and strategy of the meat
- 46:34and dairy industry and some of theirs will be
- 46:38very public and very open and out there and I
- 46:40think that's because they also believe they don't
- 46:42have anything to hide, they really believe what
- 46:44they're putting forwards and our argument is
- 46:47that they're often only looking at a very small
- 46:49piece of the puzzle and not the broader kind
- 46:51of evidence base and picture and the things that
- 46:55they will you know, is maybe a little bit harder
- 46:58to obtain. And some people have amazing abilities
- 47:01in getting leaked documents and things like that.
- 47:03That's often the stuff where you hit on a real
- 47:06nugget because they don't want people to see
- 47:08that because they know they're doing something
- 47:09wrong. So, yeah, no, I don't, I think we, I think
- 47:14it's good that we keep the conversations open.
- 47:16And in fact, you know, when we, one of the panels
- 47:19I saw was included someone from Alltech, a big
- 47:24feed company in the US who have just funded this
- 47:27film called A World Without Cows, which is, I
- 47:31haven't seen it, but it's kind of supposedly,
- 47:33you know, sensationalizing this idea that we're
- 47:37all calling for any of us talking about food
- 47:39system transformation and plant based diets are
- 47:42calling for a world without cows, which, you
- 47:44know, I'm sure none of us are doing. And Yeah,
- 47:50so it's kind of sensationalizing and fueling
- 47:52that. And on the panel, they were saying, we
- 47:54really want to open the discussion. We want to
- 47:56engage with people and broaden the debate. And
- 47:58so we were like, OK, we'll go along to this screening
- 48:01of this documentary. That'll be great. And we
- 48:04registered online. And we got an email back saying,
- 48:07I'm sorry, we have to consider each registration
- 48:09because of demand. And we got an email back saying,
- 48:12due to too much demand, there isn't space for
- 48:15you to come along to. The screening and then
- 48:19we know someone that went along and sent us a
- 48:21picture and actually it was really empty and
- 48:23there was like tons of space So I don't think
- 48:25they wanted us in the room. I don't think they
- 48:26wanted to broaden the conversation And again,
- 48:29it just makes you wonder like what are you trying
- 48:31to hide? If you if you really don't want us there
- 48:33and you don't want to talk to us face to face
- 48:36again the double standard they have access to
- 48:40our spaces, but we don't have access to their
- 48:43spaces, you know the There's an organization
- 48:47I love. I'm blanking on their name, but they
- 48:51infiltrate meetings of lobbyists in Washington
- 48:56and in also state meetings. And of course, they're
- 49:03not welcome to those meetings. They have to use
- 49:07all sorts of deep strategies to get in. But ah,
- 49:12the double standard. Yeah, yeah, completely.
- 49:15I mean, you know, often money and resources buys
- 49:18people entry into these spaces, right. And definitely
- 49:22in the case of cop like the it's not cheap to
- 49:26have a what you call a pavilion that which is
- 49:29basically the stands that take up the official
- 49:32blue zone and where you have the various events,
- 49:35it's not cheap and industry has the resources
- 49:38because despite what some people say, they're
- 49:40not the underdogs. It is a very very wealthy
- 49:44industry. And, you know, they'll talk about the
- 49:47kind of vegan elite being this incredibly well
- 49:50funded machine and all of that. But yeah, it's
- 49:55it's a again, it's a double standard. But yeah,
- 49:58there is there's some really exciting and there
- 50:01always has been people who have got ability to
- 50:04find a way into these spaces and these rooms.
- 50:06And it's great. Thank God. Yeah, I joke a lot
- 50:11about that, that I'm part of the global elite.
- 50:14I guess I did not know that. Yeah, we were told
- 50:19that we were part of Big Pharma because of our
- 50:23recent report on the meat versus eat Lancet.
- 50:27I'm not sure how they got that because we've
- 50:29done campaigns into the pharmaceuticals industry
- 50:31before, so I'm not really sure how we're Big
- 50:33Pharma. And apparently we're like incredibly
- 50:36well resourced in that and then i'm like well
- 50:39i'm yet to see the evidence so thanks. Yeah that's
- 50:44amazing um we should laugh about it you know
- 50:48instead of crying that's the healthy response
- 50:51um what what did i want to bring up oh yeah there's
- 50:57another layer of frustration on top of all of
- 51:00this which is that they're getting subsidies
- 51:03from the government. So they're basically using
- 51:06our taxpayer money to fight our interest to fight
- 51:11against our interests. And people are not aware
- 51:16of those subsidies. That's, you know, another
- 51:20frustration. Yeah, yeah, there's, there's, again,
- 51:24this is something we've looked into, and others
- 51:26have looked into that the level of subsidies
- 51:29that goes towards industrial agriculture in general
- 51:34but yeah also meat and dairy and it does it massively
- 51:39skews the system and it makes it really hard
- 51:42for competing products and companies to have
- 51:47a chance at kind of shifting the game in any
- 51:51way and you know in Europe and North America
- 51:55and many places in the world, actually, there's
- 51:58this talk about wanting a fair and free market.
- 52:01And the reality is that the market is massively
- 52:04skewed because of these kinds of subsidies. There
- 52:07was a recent investigation in Europe that showed
- 52:10that subsidies and taxpayer money is going towards
- 52:15funding campaigns that are basically meat industry
- 52:21greenwashing and talking about like the sustainability
- 52:24credentials of meat and dairy products in Europe.
- 52:27And it's, it's part of a campaign to promote
- 52:29European products, but it's because of this,
- 52:32the farming system and the food system in Europe,
- 52:36it massively favors these big companies and industrial
- 52:39animal farming. And yeah, people aren't aware
- 52:43of that. People aren't aware that their money
- 52:45is going towards this and We're also hear this
- 52:48thing about not telling people what to eat all
- 52:50the time. And we hear this being reiterated by
- 52:54policymakers who absolutely should know better
- 52:57and should be evidence -based. And you mentioned
- 53:01like, you know, we'll bring up needing to shift
- 53:04food systems and encourage more plant -based
- 53:06diets or even just diets in line with healthy
- 53:08eating guidelines. And we're told, yeah, but
- 53:10we can't tell people what to eat. But the reality
- 53:13is that people are always being told what to
- 53:15eat through these subsidies that show more marketing
- 53:20for meat and dairy products, also through like
- 53:22school education programs that are funded by
- 53:25meat companies and dairy companies saying that
- 53:27milk is like essential for your development throughout
- 53:30life and is this core part of a healthy diet.
- 53:34And And even when you go into a supermarket,
- 53:37the products that you're faced with and the pricing
- 53:39of those and the deals and offers, this all kind
- 53:43of tells people what you should be eating and
- 53:45the advertising and all of it is, yeah, people
- 53:49are always told what they need, what they should
- 53:51be eating. It's part of a food environment. And
- 53:55yeah, I think that even comes down to the kind
- 53:57of consumer level and people have these ideas
- 54:00about Being at being eating a vegan diet or more
- 54:05plant based products is kind of scary to them.
- 54:07And yeah, it's part of this this kind of advertising
- 54:12wheelhouse. Yeah, and the food guides, which
- 54:15is so you know, explicit invitation to eat more
- 54:20dairy meat products. There was a whole scandal
- 54:25about that in Canada a few years ago that at
- 54:29the current, you know, food guide, although the
- 54:32old one was the product of lobbyists and not
- 54:36nutritionists that, you know, yeah, who, but
- 54:41no one is held accountable for that. You know,
- 54:43the harm is done and then people forget. Yeah.
- 54:48And, you know, the really kind of bizarre thing
- 54:51is that we hear particularly from someone I mentioned
- 54:54earlier, Frederick Leroy, one of these kind of
- 54:57pro -meat scientists, often talks about the fact
- 55:00that national food guidelines are, he says, like
- 55:06skewing it the other way, away from meat and
- 55:08dairy and encouraging too many grains and too
- 55:11many plant -based products, and that that is
- 55:14causing like obesity and other health problems.
- 55:19Yeah, it's like this bizarre world where you
- 55:23look at the evidence of which industries have
- 55:26lobbied for guidelines to be put in place in
- 55:28a certain way. And then you hear someone saying
- 55:30that they're doing the opposite. And it's, it's,
- 55:32it's confusing. Yes, I think, you know, people
- 55:37don't realize the how much you can manipulate
- 55:41opinions, true, you know, crafting a message
- 55:47or uh, you know, storytelling, um, as an example,
- 55:53you could say something like, um, Hey, I'm a
- 55:57vegan. I've been vegan for five years. Not true.
- 56:00Um, and you know, I like being vegan, but it
- 56:04causes me lots of problems in my health. And
- 56:06then you go into the list of problems. Like,
- 56:10first of all, you don't know if this is coming
- 56:12from a genuine person, you know, and then you
- 56:16think, This is not helping. Is the person realizing
- 56:20that this is not helping and doing it on purpose?
- 56:24It's maddening. Yeah, and it's this, I think
- 56:28as well, this is a symptom of social media, right,
- 56:31more broadly, but it's this idea that a person's
- 56:34personal story can be taken as evidence. And
- 56:38like you said, you have no idea if that story
- 56:41is genuine, if that person is genuine. And we
- 56:44started by talking about that Reddit post. And
- 56:47when I read it, I was curious about whether this
- 56:51person was real. saying this story, like it's
- 56:55very likely, but you have no way of knowing like
- 56:58who are they and all of this. And but yet someone's
- 57:03individual story is taken as evidence when that
- 57:06won't even necessarily be based on any kind of
- 57:08research of what's actually going on with their
- 57:10bodies or kind of evidence is built up with you'll
- 57:13have like control variables and science is really
- 57:17detailed and complex and nuance and Yeah, instead,
- 57:21we're fed this, like, my story is the truth.
- 57:26And it just, yeah, it creates such a minefield
- 57:30for people in trying to determine any information
- 57:34and social media is often the main source of
- 57:36information for most people now for news stories,
- 57:39but also for dietary trends and interests. And
- 57:44there's got to be a lot more stringent content
- 57:48moderation where these are health claims. And
- 57:52when it comes to food, they are often health
- 57:54claims, and it's going to have a real damaging
- 57:57impact on people. And you can't, you know, say,
- 58:01let's teach people critical thinking. No, it's
- 58:06deeply, you know, psychological, it's, you know,
- 58:09some of that messaging is sometimes, you know,
- 58:12speaks to your subconscious, you know, mind.
- 58:15It's, you don't understand how much you're getting
- 58:18manipulated by those algorithms. It's about feelings.
- 58:22And so you can learn all about, you know, critical
- 58:25thinking and even major in philosophy or whatever,
- 58:28but you'll never, you know, protect yourself
- 58:31against that. No, no, exactly. And that's why
- 58:35we need this kind of like evidence based science
- 58:38that really looks at Yeah, it looks at the bigger
- 58:42picture, it's evidence -based, rather than these
- 58:45kind of, yeah, select stories as being the ideas
- 58:49because we can't, it's not down to us as individuals
- 58:52and it's not down to us as consumers even to
- 58:54make these proper decisions. There's got to be
- 58:57kind of policies and regulation in place that
- 58:59ensure that we're navigating, yeah, we're navigating
- 59:03evidence. Well, I'm so thankful that your organization
- 59:08exists. Truly, I mean, you have so much work
- 59:13to do. It's been a long year. And, you know,
- 59:20what if we want to support changing markets?
- 59:24How should we do so? Yeah, please just kind of
- 59:28follow along. We're on most social media platforms.
- 59:32We have a newsletter that people can subscribe
- 59:34to on our website. We are on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 59:41And yeah, please just kind of follow along and
- 59:43engage with what we're doing and talk about our
- 59:48work. We really love hearing about instances
- 59:51of where our reports pop up and conversations
- 59:54and kind of seeing the information being used
- 59:57out there in the wild and prompting these discussions,
- 1:00:00because that's really what we're trying to do
- 1:00:02when we put out quite a lot of reports. And they're
- 1:00:05always about increasing the evidence base and
- 1:00:07the knowledge and prompting conversations in
- 1:00:09these spaces. So yeah, just keep engaging. Amazing.
- 1:00:15Thank you so much, Maddie. Did you want to add
- 1:00:17something before we stop the recording? Thank
- 1:00:34you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you
- 1:00:37to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:00:40Let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 1:00:44thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 1:00:47next Tuesday for a new episode.