Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 227-Double Indemnity w/ Authors Alain Silver and James Ursini
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with doug Hess here on Jiljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcasts and memories of yesteryear. My
- 0:25name is doug Hess and if you're tuning in Forgotten Hollywood for the first time,
- 0:29what I do on this podcast is teake you on a journey back in
- 0:32time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may not know
- 0:35about. And today we have two very special guests with us today, Alan
- 0:41Silver and James Ersini, and they're going to be talking about their latest book
- 0:47that they have released called From the Moment They Met It Was Murder, Double
- 0:52Indemnity and the Rise of Film the War. Gentlemen, welcome to Forgotten Hollywood.
- 0:58Thank you, thanks for having us well, thank you for spending a
- 1:00few minutes with us today to talk about your book. And maybe the first
- 1:07thing we'll do is just allow you to talk a little bit to the audience
- 1:11about what this book is about. Okay, it's a complicated question. It
- 1:23is largely about the film Double Indemnity, which is the most important film noir
- 1:29in the whole period of time, in the most influential one. But It
- 1:33also deals a lot with the background of the movie, including the true crime
- 1:37that was its basis, the biographies of the people who largely were responsible for
- 1:44making the film, and then the aftermath of the film, like what influence
- 1:49it had on the movie industry and the movement, on the careers of the
- 1:53people involved, and on the development of things like Neo and Noah Are and
- 2:00so forth in the in the in the seventies and eighties. So anyway,
- 2:02that's a thumb nail, sure, And how did this book come about?
- 2:09How does it what? How did the about? Yeah, you know,
- 2:16in long term interest on our part on film noir, But I'd say most
- 2:22specifically, this book came out of a couple of things. A lecture that
- 2:28I did at a college four years ago about Double Indemnity as a film noir.
- 2:35It was part of a series of screenings of movies directed by Billy Wilder,
- 2:40and then also the previous book we did, which is called film Noir
- 2:45Fatal Women, featured a lot of shots of Stanwick, who portrays the them
- 2:52fittal double indemnity philospeedricson. So a couple bunch of things came together, not
- 3:01the least of which with the interest of Running Press and our editor at City
- 3:07Sin Paula in the movie. So it was a fairly straightforward process of saying,
- 3:15how about a study of this movie and the answer yeah, sure,
- 3:17that great. Yeah, we've been We've been writing about film nor for twenty
- 3:22thirty years. You know, I have numerous books about it. So it's
- 3:28a field that we have a special interest in, and so it was sort
- 3:34of a natural thing to center on what most people and including us, consider
- 3:39the key film noir, Double Indemnity. Sure, and this book is coming
- 3:46out at a great time. It's kind of hard to believe that it's been
- 3:50eighty years since since the movie has been released. Yeah, it's it is.
- 3:57It is quite a bit of time. The the film itself is always
- 4:03young in many ways because I teach classes over the decades, college classes and
- 4:09so forth, and I've taught and in high school classes too. I've taught
- 4:15this movie numerous times over the years in different places. And no matter what
- 4:24generation it is, whether it's Generation X or millennial generation or whatever, they
- 4:29always have an interest in this movie. So it's sort of timeless, largely
- 4:34I think because of the sort of cynicism of it and this sort of very
- 4:41hip dialogue, the very you know, layered dialogue that's sort of combined,
- 4:48the sort of sarcasm, the sort of poetic noir style, and the suspense
- 4:59it still creates, even though people are used to much more films with much
- 5:03more activity in them, but the suspense in this film is created a different
- 5:09way, but it's still younger audiences react to it. So in that case,
- 5:15it's obviously an important film to try to to bring to these audiences so
- 5:20that it doesn't really die in the graveyard of cinema. Yeah, I don't
- 5:30think the movie will suffer the faith of a lot of other projects from the
- 5:34forties and even the fifties and sixties and disappear simply because so many contemporary filmmakers,
- 5:45three generations new are still influenced by it. And you can see that
- 5:51in a lot of new pictures. The whole body of classic period films are
- 6:00who trains roughly from nineteen forty to nineteen sixty, entertaining us new influence new
- 6:08generations of not just American filmmakers worldwide. No, absolutely, And every time
- 6:15I watch the film, you know, like you said, it does feel
- 6:20young, if I can use that word. It doesn't feel like it's a
- 6:25film that's been made eighty years ago and it still feels relevant today. I
- 6:30have two teenage boys at home, and so when I had them sit down
- 6:33and watch it, I always love to watch the reactions because I'm afraid they're
- 6:39just going to get up and leave. You know, during the middle of
- 6:42the film, they're like, Dad's making me watch this black and white film.
- 6:46But it's one of those films that it's got a great cast in it,
- 6:48some very talented actors and actresses, and it really just kind of keeps
- 6:53your attention from beginning to end. Yeah, that's the value of it.
- 7:00And and that's the great achievement that James Kane did in his novel and then
- 7:06in Raymond Chandler and Billy Wilder did in their scripts, was to create a
- 7:12piece of work that was the remains relevant. And also, you know,
- 7:20it should should mention also the source of this, and maybe Alan can talk
- 7:25a little bit about that. But it's based on a famous murder case.
- 7:30Yeah, the first chapter of the book focuses on true crime as it relates
- 7:38to double anddemnity. It it's interesting that you know the concept of what is
- 7:46a crime of the century has also evolved. But the sixth or seventh crime
- 7:51of the twentieth century was a murder committed by rich Snyder and her boyfriend John
- 8:00Gray. They murdered her husband. They didn't get away with it. They
- 8:03were arrested, tried, convicted, and sent to the electric chair in less
- 8:09than a year. And there's a notorious photo taken by a young photographer brought
- 8:16in from Chicago of the actual execution that was frontage on the Daily News and
- 8:24sold two million copies. It was a notorious, highly publicized, covered by
- 8:31every major newspaper, not just in New York and around world trial that while
- 8:37we could never really determine for certain whether Kane attended the trial, he worked
- 8:43for the New York Herald at the time. He works for the New York
- 8:46World. He works for the New York World. He works in the New
- 8:50York World. He worked for the New York World at the time as the
- 8:52human interest writer, and he was certainly very familiar with it, and it
- 8:58inspired, or two different words, his first novel, postmon Always rnks twice
- 9:05and with regards to the double indemity part which was real. The novella which
- 9:11came out a couple of years later, in thirty six. Yeah, and
- 9:18what's really interesting is, you know, you read the book, you also
- 9:22know a little history of the film. They had shot the execution scenes,
- 9:31but because of censorship, if I understand it correctly, Uh, that was
- 9:35kind of a big no no back then, and they cut that from the
- 9:39film. Is that right? I can't say that it was cut for the
- 9:46reason, just the reason you side. Okay. There is a long standing
- 9:50objection on the part of the administrators of the Motion Picture Code known as the
- 9:56Hayes Office, and the administrator would to bring on this movie was made.
- 10:01They on the one hand, wanted punishment for crime to be clear, criminals
- 10:07couldn't get away with it. On the other hand, they didn't want anything
- 10:11sort of to drizzling. The scene was always on the script. It was
- 10:16shot, but it was unused, mostly because the filmmakers, led by Wilder,
- 10:22determined that it was a little too much. You didn't need it.
- 10:26The ending as it exists is the one that was always uh, the intention
- 10:33of Wilder, and the script itself lists to what's called sequence as a possible
- 10:41alternate ending, but the actual ending as it is the movie conforms the execution
- 10:48was shot as a contingency that wasn't needed. But if you look at the
- 10:54stills from it that exist and they're in the book, it's a beautiful sequence
- 11:01and Billy Wilder said in later years that it was probably the best sequence he
- 11:03ever shot. And the power of the emotions is as you know, the
- 11:11two friends keys, who eventually is is Nef's undoing his boss, but still
- 11:16they have this relationship which was a sort of subtext of homo eroticism in it
- 11:24he has to witness or he promises Nef that he'll witness his execution. And
- 11:28you see it in these two stills, in the faces of Edward Gie Robinson
- 11:31as keys and in the blank face of of Nef Fred McMurray, that this
- 11:39is a powerful scene. They they they built a gas chamber based on San
- 11:48Quentin and based on another gas chamber that they visited in Arizona, so there's
- 11:52a lot of authenticity to it. It's it seems like a wonderful sequence.
- 11:58The reason for it being cut change wild They're told different stories over the years,
- 12:01so we're never exactly sure, but what the reason, what the reason
- 12:07was. My hope is always at some day they'll find this sequence and then
- 12:11they'll put it in a DVD or as an extra. It's not as not
- 12:16as likely that they'll find it, because you know, this has been the
- 12:20eighty years, but things, things turn up in the strangest places, some
- 12:24sixteen millimeters print and you know in the Soviet Union or Russia, and that
- 12:31things like that happen all the time, used to happen all the time.
- 12:33It still happened actually, so it is possible, you know. But anyway,
- 12:39you can see from those two stills printed in the book that that it
- 12:45looks like a very powerful sequence. And you know the other thing, you
- 12:50know, we were talking about Edward g. Robinson, Fred mc murray,
- 12:54Barbara Stanswick. What a great cast in a great chemistry, especially Fred mc
- 13:00murray and Barbara Stansquick I felt had in that movie. You really could could
- 13:05kind of feel the passion, for lack of a better word, that they
- 13:09that they portray in the film. Yeah, and of course there's many stories
- 13:16about how how how difficult it was for a Wilder to cast this film,
- 13:20how the two two main characters, Fred McMurray and Barbara Stomach didn't want to
- 13:26do it because McMurray was a comedy actor. Mostly he didn't want to play
- 13:31a killer. And and and though Barbara Stamack had played shady roles in the
- 13:37past, you know, like Lady e or even back in the thirties,
- 13:41Babyface, she also didn't want to be a murderous But he convinced them,
- 13:48you know. And Robinson was easier to convince because he offered him a you
- 13:52know, significant sum of money considering he worked fewer days than anybody else.
- 13:58And and as later years went on, and that's covers in the aftermath of
- 14:05the part of the book, both McMurray and Stanlek would always say that that
- 14:11Double Indemnity was their favorite film that they made. And Stanley could always say
- 14:16at the end of her career that that's the film that people asked her about,
- 14:18you know, not not anything else she'd done, not Mister Deeds Goes
- 14:22to Town, or not not the Big Valley, or she was a big
- 14:26star in television, They asked her about Double Indemnity. So, yeah,
- 14:31he did a wonderful job, obviously powerful job in casting it. And it
- 14:35was just his persistence, Wilder's persistence that allowed it, you know, because
- 14:39Wilder was a very persistent person. And you know, they went on to
- 14:46make wide I think it was a total of four films together, and all
- 14:48the films that those two were in, I thought the chemistry was was really
- 14:54great and perfect with those two. Yeah, they were friends, you know,
- 15:00and there they often visit each other's houses and stuff, so theyre had
- 15:05they had a relationship. So that comes out in in the in the and
- 15:11also the playfulness of it. This the sort of sexual playfulness of the of
- 15:16the of the of the two really comes over. And I think a lot
- 15:20of modern audiences react to that. You know, it's not blatant, but
- 15:24it's said in the body language and the sort of you know, clever dialogue,
- 15:31the the double entaundra of the dialogue and so forth. So yeah,
- 15:35it's it's a powerful you know again, powerful performances. Yeah. And I
- 15:41thought the way Fred mc murray almost played it stiff at certain points kind of
- 15:46adds to that mystique and in that chemistry a little bit. Yeah, I
- 15:52think so. I think he he he knew that that character was over his
- 15:58head and a way yes, uh and and and you start to see as
- 16:03the film progresses that he gets more and more frightened even, you know,
- 16:07and the look in his face and uh, and when he's around her or
- 16:12around keys, he starts to stiffen up. You're right, It's like he
- 16:15has that because he knows that that you know, he's he's he's on that
- 16:22street car trolley carr, is it trolley carr? That that's going to lead
- 16:26him to the cemetery at the end, and so that's what he's reacting.
- 16:30Yeah, it plays it perfectly. Doing your research in the writing anything surprise
- 16:34you with this on several things. I think the thing that really surprised me
- 16:45the most in terms of how the script developed. It's very different in terms
- 16:53of its overall plot and in terms of how the specific scene is take place
- 16:59between the care because the dialogue is very much the creation of the screenwriters.
- 17:04I mean, there's pieces of Cane, but not much. What wasn't really
- 17:08clear and we can't clarify completely was what Channeler's contribution was. But we discovered
- 17:17and they're there for anyone to go and look at if they want to.
- 17:22At the Academy Library. The very first test scene that channel wrote, and
- 17:27in the book we do it side by side where you can see that a
- 17:33very substantial portion of the first scenes between Phyllis and nef the dialogue was written
- 17:41by Chandler in his French path essentially got into the movie, and it's pretty
- 17:47clear from reading Chandler that most of the dialogue was his creation. That he
- 17:56brought that case and that style, if you will, the sarcastic, cynical
- 18:04narration and the interchange between the two. And the other thing that we did
- 18:11in the book, which is quite unusual for the time, is that Wilder
- 18:14appreciated this and kept's Chandler on for the entire shoot, very unusual for a
- 18:21studio in the forties, not too mainly the writer who had no direct involvement
- 18:26with the shooting on some other process. Yeah, even though their their relationship
- 18:33was somewhat rocky because Raymond Chandler, the novelist was as an alcoholic and also
- 18:41a bit of a commudgion and Wilder was a much free spirited character. Uh,
- 18:48they fought a lot, you know, but in the final product they
- 18:59managed to bring together both of those qualities sort of the free spirit of Wilder,
- 19:04the comic free spirit of Wilder. There's a lot of comic stuff in
- 19:07the movie itself and then the more poetic you know, Los Angeles Noir,
- 19:15which which Raymond Chandler helped create, you know, in books like The Big
- 19:21Sleep and and Farewell, My Lovely and so forth. So it was a
- 19:25good marriage, even though it was rocky and then and Chandler sort of turned
- 19:30on Wilder in later years and wrote, you know, scathing review of Hollywood.
- 19:38But for this it wasn't just Wilder, it was the entire system the
- 19:44Chandler disliked from the beginning. But he really could not afford even though by
- 19:51the time he'd got this job there were millions and paperbacks of his novels out
- 19:55there in the world. He wasn't He's getting pennies for each one, not
- 20:00even Tenny's. And he just hated the system. He thought it was absolutely
- 20:08not conducive to creativity on the part of the writer. And he wrote a
- 20:12very scathing article called writers is published ironically, you know, I mean.
- 20:19Chandler then went on to significantly greater earnings based only on his novels, moved
- 20:26to La Jolla, and one of the last jobs he had on his strangers
- 20:32on a train. He refused to come to Warner Brothers to discuss it without
- 20:38Hitchcock. He can't tell Hitchcocks if he wanted to talk to Channel directly to
- 20:42drive down La Joia, which isn't you know, it's a good chunk.
- 20:48It's depending where you're coming is from between seventy five and hundred miles aways.
- 20:52But wasn't impossible to get there? Yeah, no, but it wasn't a
- 20:57Hitchcock greater resented having to do that. And while they're you know, being
- 21:03the first collaborator Chandler had, I think taught him. While they're acknowledged Chandler's
- 21:12contribution, Chandler acknowledged the fact that what he knew about screen on it he
- 21:18learned from Wiler. You know, they did work together physically for almost the
- 21:25entire time, both writing description and as I said, Chandler was there on
- 21:30Payroll's exclusive to double and Leny until the next last day of the shoot.
- 21:36Yeah. And if there's ever any doubt that whether Chandler was there or not,
- 21:38of course you we put in the book and a lot of people don't
- 21:44don't realize this that Chandler appears in the movie as an extra sitting in the
- 21:48office, which we have a frame enlargement from. So you can you can
- 21:53actually see so you know for sure, I mean we had the records anyway,
- 21:59but you know for sure visionsually that Chandler was there for the shoot,
- 22:02which is very unusual again in those days for a writer to stay on shoot.
- 22:07They they you know, as soon as they've turned into scripts, they
- 22:10kicked them out, you know, and if they had any problems, they
- 22:12would bring in like a script doctor, which is what James M. Kaine
- 22:15was for a long time in early Hollywood along with Wilder and also when he
- 22:21came over from Germany. Was they would be like script doctors. They'd give
- 22:23them scripts like a cess be the mill script, and then they have to,
- 22:26you know, fix this up. You know, it's like and that's
- 22:30what they did in those days. So but they yes, very rarely that
- 22:33would they keep the writer on for the entire shoot because he was off to
- 22:37the next assignment probably right right right exactly, Yeah, And that is what
- 22:42happened ultimately to Chandler. I think the best indicator of what Chandler's ultimate attitude
- 22:51toward Hollywood was it was weird. Whereas Wilder obviously went on to munch very
- 23:00long career, switching to comedy later on Chandler got away as soon as he
- 23:07could. He stayed on a Paramount. He infamously wrote the next big script,
- 23:15Blue Dahlia, while drawing, and then ultimately Paramount offered him an astonishingly
- 23:22large sum for the time, two thousand dollars per week to write, produce,
- 23:26and direct anything he wanted. He left. He said no and never
- 23:33came in and worked in an office again. His last job, the only
- 23:37script he worked on for one of his own novels, was at MGM,
- 23:44but that ended in late nineteen forty six and he left Hollywood for good.
- 23:52Well, gentlemen, thank you so much for spending some time with us today.
- 23:55We really appreciate that. And to the audience, please go out and
- 23:57get a copy of the book from Running Press. From the moment they met,
- 24:02it was Murder, Double Indemnity, and the Rise of the film Noir.
- 24:06Gentlemen, again, thank you so much for spending a few minutes with
- 24:08us today. We really appreciate it. Thank you, thanks for having us
- 24:12well, Thank you, and thank you for listening to this episode of Forgotten
- 24:15Hollywood. Just search for dec hask Forgotten Hollywood. You can also foind me
- 24:18on Twitter, Instagram, at hesteg fourteen. If you listen to this podcast
- 24:22on iTunes or another podcast service, please subscribe to rate and review this episode.
- 24:26Tune in next time for the latest episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you
- 24:30for listening, and we will see you then