Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / What to Expect in 2024 at NCUA
Transcript
- 0:35Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:38Welcome to January, I'm recording this on January 14th.
- 0:41It may sound a touch bit different because I don't have my normal microphone with
- 0:47me, and that's because I traveled to visit my new granddaughter who was born
- 0:53a couple days ago, a couple weeks early, so a little Shift in our plans here,
- 0:57and accordingly, this is going to be a different podcast than I thought I was
- 1:01going to be launching today, but NCUA.
- 1:05keeps me busy with the things that they've got going on.
- 1:08Credit unions there's a lot of things in the news.
- 1:10So this is going to be an update on what's happening at the NQA board
- 1:15this Thursday, which I will follow up on after it actually occurs, a
- 1:20discussion about what's going on.
- 1:22In Navy in particular, who's getting beat up by the Senate and what might happen
- 1:29relative to NCOA's priority letter.
- 1:32First off Navy is.
- 1:36Had a CNN article that came out about their challenges with the denial rates
- 1:43with minorities and the both sides of the Senate wrote their own letters.
- 1:49But the one signed by Sherrod Brown, the Democratic side that went to HUD and it
- 1:56went to CFPB basically concludes that as the regulator with primary responsibility
- 2:03for enforcing ECOA and the Fair Housing Act, we ask that you thoroughly review
- 2:07Navy Federal's mortgage lending practices and outcome for compliance With all
- 2:12federal fair housing and fair lending laws and regulations, Navy Federals
- 2:17members have made countless sacrifices in their service to our country.
- 2:21We must do all we can to ensure illegal barriers are not placed
- 2:25on their path to home ownership.
- 2:27Thank you for your prompt attention to this issue.
- 2:31I would expect there's going to be some hearings on this.
- 2:34I would expect both those agencies will go into this large credit union.
- 2:39Which once they arrive, CFPB in particular, they stay for quite a while.
- 2:43And I think there will be tentacles, ramifications to this.
- 2:47I also think that, if you've listened to me historically
- 2:50here, this is our third season.
- 2:52I've talked a lot about how Chairman Todd Harper is a big champion of consumer
- 2:56compliance, big champion of consumer rights, and I can only think, this is
- 3:01my opinion only, that this occurrence has has put, has, is only going to have
- 3:08him refocus more resources on this.
- 3:10I think the government in general is going to be, the agencies in general are going
- 3:13to be tasked and asked to put a focus on this, last year we had Silicon Valley
- 3:18Bank, we had liquidity issues, etc, etc.
- 3:21And that became a focus.
- 3:23There's no doubt this type of news is going to increase the focus in this arena.
- 3:27That means more fair lending exams.
- 3:29If that means at mid year of next year, they'll add fair lending examiners.
- 3:34Todd now has his second democratic vote, which I'll get to here shortly
- 3:38about what's coming up on their agenda.
- 3:40So this News, public news about Navy is going to have an impact.
- 3:44Obviously when those folks go into Navy, we won't hear those specifics because
- 3:49that's confidential, but it's going to have, it's going to trickle down.
- 3:52It's going to trickle down how it trickles down.
- 3:54We'll remain to be seen, but Chairman Harper is now positioned to have it
- 3:58trickle down within the walls of NCA.
- 4:01Anyway, he sees fit and again, that's always been one of his one
- 4:06of his focal points and we're about to see where he wants to take this.
- 4:10So that's number one.
- 4:11Number two, the NCA Board agenda.
- 4:14Bear with me.
- 4:15Go to their website.
- 4:16You gotta click to, by the way, to get to the NCA Board agenda.
- 4:20You click.
- 4:21News you click board meeting agendas and results and you scroll down to
- 4:25the current meeting and I scroll down too far because it's a new year.
- 4:31And there are 2 items on the agenda.
- 4:35The 1st item is the N.
- 4:37C.
- 4:37U.
- 4:37A.
- 4:37S.
- 4:372024 to 2026 diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility strategic plan.
- 4:44The second item is NCOA's 2024 annual performance plan.
- 4:49I'm going to speak more to the annual performance plan but that
- 4:52links in my mind to the diversity, equity, and inclusion strategic plan.
- 4:57Now, we have a new board member NCOA has a new board member, Tanya Atsuka actually
- 5:02came from Sherrod Brown's staff or the banking committee staff over there.
- 5:07Imagine that.
- 5:08So, Sherrod Brown writes a letter to a large credit union.
- 5:11And oh, by the way we have a board member that's brand new that knows
- 5:14how more than anybody, how the banking committee works over there.
- 5:19This is going to be an interesting year as it relates to that whole topic.
- 5:22But I digress.
- 5:23So the annual performance plan is on the docket.
- 5:29Yeah.
- 5:291 things if you again, if you listen to me, 1 thing I'll do is a word search.
- 5:33So I looked at the 2023 annual performance plan, which was approved a year ago.
- 5:38And I looked at some key words and I looked up climate, I looked up diversity,
- 5:43minority inclusion I looked up safe, sound, consumers and compliance.
- 5:48So those key words are words that that are prevalent at
- 5:53some level in the 2023 report.
- 5:56The word of those that's there the most is consumer, which is there 60 times.
- 6:00Second most is sound, which is 35 safe, 26 times compliance, 21 times, and
- 6:08then diversity, minority, and inclusion individually, those words, inclusion, nine
- 6:12times minority, eight times diversity, seven times and climate only five times.
- 6:17So that was issued with a.
- 6:24I'm anticipating some shift in how many words, and words have meaning,
- 6:29how much of the paper, how much of the PDF is focused on particular areas.
- 6:35So here's my predictions on what will happen in the annual report
- 6:39on the usage of these words.
- 6:42I think three of the words will, or the word categories will likely go up.
- 6:47I think climate change is going to have a bigger impact on the presence, because
- 6:52from what I heard, there was efforts to kind of keep that minimalized in 2023.
- 6:58And I believe Chairman Harper will have more discussion on climate
- 7:02change, whether it goes from 5 to 10 words, 5 to 15 words, or only 5 to 7
- 7:06words, or it's just the paragraphs.
- 7:08There's more talking about it there and with some measurable things
- 7:12that they're trying to achieve.
- 7:13And in those regards, there's other agencies out there that
- 7:16have put some templates out and, we can anticipate if we looked at
- 7:19those what those details might be.
- 7:21But climate change, I believe, is going to go up.
- 7:23I think diversity, minority, and inclusion will go up again.
- 7:26Why?
- 7:27Because the Democratic side.
- 7:29Of politicians tends to push this more than the Republican side.
- 7:33So seven, eight, nine words.
- 7:35Will that double to 14, 16 and 18?
- 7:38I don't know, but I'm expecting a bigger footprint on that topic
- 7:42in the annual report, excuse me, in the annual performance plan
- 7:46next next category safe and sound.
- 7:49I don't, I think that's going to probably tread water.
- 7:51Going to be about the same consumers at 60.
- 7:55Maybe up a little bit about the same, but I'm expecting compliance
- 7:58to go up from 21 to some number closer to what safety and soundness.
- 8:03Now, again, if you've listened to my other podcast Chairman Harper believes
- 8:08that those 2 topics can go hand in hand.
- 8:12I'm more of the, yes, consumer compliance can lead to safety and soundness issues.
- 8:17But they are two distinct disciplines.
- 8:19They are two distinct types of people at NCUA.
- 8:22They're two distinct types of people in credit unions, though.
- 8:26Yes, there can be some overlap, but I think there will be more emphasis on
- 8:31consumer compliance at NCUA this year than last, and in 2025 more than 2024.
- 8:38Why?
- 8:38Because The budget was approved by two Republicans and one Democrat.
- 8:43And when we get to the mid year in July and we get to November or
- 8:47December, when they approve the next budget, I think there will just be a
- 8:50continued emphasis here, and that's going to have a footprint on what
- 8:52you need to do at your credit unions.
- 8:55All right, so the other item I wanted to mention is last year, and typically
- 9:00every year, this is the week that NCUA comes up with their annual supervisory
- 9:05priority letter to credit unions, my favorite credit union letter of the year,
- 9:08because it says you, it says what they're going to be looking at when they come in.
- 9:12Now, In the past, I've talked about how if everything's a priority,
- 9:17nothing's a priority, but sometimes they've had 13 priorities.
- 9:21They've gotten wise recently and reduced that to six, although it wasn't really
- 9:25six because they had other considerations at the bottom that they threw in.
- 9:28So it raised it up to seven or eight.
- 9:31But it was a leaner, more focused letter last year, which was good
- 9:34because there are real issues out there that needed to be addressed.
- 9:37So, as a reminder, last year, the priorities, 2023, in order, were interest
- 9:42rate risk number one, liquidity risk number two, credit risk number three,
- 9:47fraud number four, cybersecurity number five, consumer financial protection number
- 9:53six, albeit it had the most number of words donated to it or assigned to it.
- 9:58I'll say consumer.
- 10:00Financial protection was six that was really number one of words.
- 10:03So it's placement was out of order as far as how much how
- 10:08much bandwidth NCOA gave to it.
- 10:10Now, the other considerations are succession planning and climate change.
- 10:14And again, succession planning, I predict that that rule will
- 10:18be coming out at some juncture.
- 10:20As a reminder, it only applies to federal credit unions, the proposed rule.
- 10:24And that proposed rule didn't get a second vote because Chairman
- 10:27Harper didn't have a second vote.
- 10:29The other board members wanted to treat it as guidance, which is how I would do it.
- 10:32But, you know, there's different ways to do it.
- 10:34And I'm expecting that will hit the end to a board agenda.
- 10:37Now that Chairman Harper has a second democratic vote.
- 10:41All right.
- 10:41So that was 2023.
- 10:42What do I think is going to happen for 2024?
- 10:46Of those that I mentioned, I think fraud potentially could follow
- 10:50up, they bring that up every two or three years, but that's one
- 10:54that is a an occasional priority.
- 10:57They have some priorities that are always there.
- 10:59Consumer compliance is always there.
- 11:01Cyber security is always there.
- 11:02So here's my prediction of the order in which these items will be listed
- 11:07in the letter to credit unions.
- 11:09Going out on a limb, I think consumer financial protection
- 11:12is going to be number one.
- 11:13I think credit risk will be number two and or some focus on commercial
- 11:17credit risk in particular.
- 11:19I think we're seeing trends in the economy, trends in examinations and
- 11:24trends in credit unions, where NCUA has a bit more concern about commercial loans
- 11:28than other types of loans right now.
- 11:30So number one, consumer financial protection.
- 11:33Number two, credit.
- 11:34Which might be also defined separately as commercial loans.
- 11:38Number three, interest rate risk.
- 11:39So it falls from number one to number three.
- 11:42That could be really anywhere in here because it's still a big issue in exams.
- 11:46It's still a big issue in credit unions.
- 11:48Liquidity, I think, is going to fall to four from number two.
- 11:51Cybersecurity.
- 11:52Hey, I got that.
- 11:52I got one of them staying in the same place.
- 11:54So cybersecurity was fifth.
- 11:55I have that staying fifth.
- 11:57I think succession planning is going to move from the other
- 12:00into the actual priorities.
- 12:02And I think that will be number six.
- 12:04And if it's not number six, it's because climate change might be number six.
- 12:08So, those are my thoughts relative to that.
- 12:10Now, one that wasn't mentioned at all last year, which we're seeing talked
- 12:15about a lot at credit unions and by NCUA.
- 12:19Is concentration risk, that's an occasional priority that shows up.
- 12:24So I'm going to predict there will be eight priorities and
- 12:28concentration risk will be added.
- 12:30And in summary, climate goes from other to an actual priority.
- 12:34Succession planning becomes a priority and fraud falls off the letter this year.
- 12:38That's my take on NCUA's letter to credit unions.
- 12:41I'm expecting it'll come out this week.
- 12:43And once it comes out, I'm going to have a, my third annual.
- 12:47Discussion of that letter, the words that are there because again, words
- 12:51have meaning and I'll have my, some of my team members on it with me.
- 12:54Historically, I've had Steve Farr and Todd Miller, and I'm looking forward to
- 12:59having a call with them to discuss that.
- 13:03Now, lastly I've got this list in my book of things I'm planning to
- 13:08do for the podcasts so that when I get the idea, I don't lose it.
- 13:12I track it here in my little notebook.
- 13:14So, Here's some topics I've got on the radar for with flying colors
- 13:19who reviews your exam and what that means is a separate podcast.
- 13:23It'll be coming down the road.
- 13:25But the true cost of a camel downgrade another podcast, a
- 13:29separate 1 on emergency mergers and potentially expanding into mergers.
- 13:34What is an emergency merger?
- 13:35What it means to have an emergency merger?
- 13:37Why?
- 13:37It's a good thing.
- 13:38Why?
- 13:39They're not that frequent, et cetera, et cetera.
- 13:41Organizational reviews.
- 13:42That's a trend in NCOA where document resolutions require
- 13:46organizational reviews.
- 13:47I'm going to talk about what that means for the credit union that
- 13:51gets that document resolution.
- 13:53A separate podcast on letters of understanding and agreements, a
- 13:56separate podcast on cease and desist orders a topic where I will be
- 14:02interviewing a board member at a credit union about succession planning for
- 14:06board members, getting and training board members, et cetera, et cetera.
- 14:11A podcast on how to avoid getting a document resolution and yeah,
- 14:16that's my list as of today.
- 14:17So all of those still have yet to be recorded, but you can expect
- 14:21to see most or all of them in the quarter to come or thereabouts.
- 14:27All right.
- 14:28That's it.
- 14:28I'm going to go.
- 14:30Hold my baby granddaughter for the second time.
- 14:33I now have two granddaughters had two daughters.
- 14:35So this is exciting news here for the Treichel family.
- 14:39And I'm wishing you and yours a great Martin Luther King holiday.
- 14:44That's it.
- 14:44, thank you for listening.
- 14:45I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 14:47Mark Treichel, signing off with Flying Colors.