Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Tender Offers for Buybacks
Transcript
- Lucas: When you hear 'stock buyback,' you probably imagine a company quietly buying shares on the open market over months. But there's another approach that's less common, more dramatic, and sometimes more effective: the tender offer. Luna: Right, where the company basically says to shareholders, 'I'll buy your shares at a premium, but you have to decide by a certain date.' Lucas: Exactly. And today we're going to look at how post ipo companies use tender offers for buybacks. It's a tool that tends to surface when a company wants to repurchase a large chunk of stock quickly, or when it wants to send a very specific signal to the market. Luna: So what's the typical scenario? Is it mostly for companies that have a lot of cash and want to make a big statement? Lucas: Often, yes. Think of a company like Apple. In 2025, Apple announced a $110 billion buyback authorization. But Apple almost always does open-market repurchases—slow and steady. A tender offer is for when you want to move fast. Maybe you think your stock is undervalued, and you want to put a floor under it. Or you want to consolidate ownership before a big strategic move. Luna: Right. And a tender offer typically comes with a premium. The company offers to buy shares at, say, a 5% to 10% markup over the current price. That's the carrot for shareholders to sell. Lucas: Exactly. And the premium is a signal. If a company offers a 10% premium, it's saying, 'We believe our stock is worth at least this much.' That can boost confidence among remaining shareholders. But there's a risk: if too many shareholders tender, the company might have to buy more than it planned. So they often prorate the purchases. Luna: Prorating means if the offer is oversubscribed, each shareholder who tendered only sells a percentage of their shares. That prevents any one seller from dumping a huge block. Lucas: Right. And then there's the Dutch auction variant. Instead of setting a fixed price, the company says, 'We want to buy back $1 billion worth of shares, and we'll accept bids from shareholders between $50 and $55.' Then they figure out the lowest price that lets them buy the full amount. Everyone who bid at or below that clearing price gets that price. Luna: That feels more democratic—let the market tell you the price. But it also reveals information about what shareholders think the stock is worth. Lucas: Exactly. And that's one reason companies might hesitate. You don't want to show the market that your largest institutional holders are willing to sell at $51 when you're trading at $53. That could spook other investors. Luna: So when do we typically see tender offers from post ipo companies? Any patterns? Lucas: One common trigger is lockup expiration. After an IPO, insiders are locked up for 90 to 180 days. Once that lockup lifts, there's often a wave of selling pressure. A company might do a tender offer to absorb some of that supply and stabilize the stock. We saw that with a few companies last year. Luna: Another pattern: companies with activist investors. An activist might push for a buyback, and a tender offer is a way to quickly deliver on that demand while also reducing the activist's stake if they choose to tender. Lucas: Great point. And there's also the tax angle. When a company does a tender offer, shareholders who sell are taxed on their capital gains. But if the company does an open-market buyback, the remaining shareholders benefit from the earnings per share boost without triggering a taxable event for anyone. So tender offers are more of a direct payout to exiting shareholders. Luna: Let's look at the current market. As of July 18th, Apple is at $334, up 5% in the last five days. Microsoft at $394. These are mature companies with huge buyback programs. But for a younger post ipo company trading at, say, $50, a tender offer could be a big deal. Lucas: Right. And the data shows that tender offers are still relatively rare. According to a study by the corporate finance firm Lazard, only about 5% of buybacks are executed via tender offer in a typical year. But when they happen, the average premium is around 8%. Luna: That's a meaningful premium. For a shareholder deciding whether to sell, it's a straightforward math problem: do I think the stock will go up more than 8% in the next few months? If not, I tender. Lucas: And for the company, it's a way to be efficient. Open-market buybacks can take months, and you're subject to volume limits. A tender offer gets it done in a matter of weeks. Plus, you know exactly how many shares you'll buy—assuming it's not oversubscribed. Luna: One thing I've noticed: some companies announce a tender offer and then the stock doesn't move much. That suggests the market had already priced in the buyback. But other times, especially if the premium is high, the stock jumps. Lucas: Right. That's the signaling effect. If the market thought the stock was overvalued, a tender offer at a premium can change that narrative. But it's not a silver bullet. If the company's fundamentals are deteriorating, a buyback is just a band-aid. Luna: So for a post ipo company, you'd want to have a clear reason. Not just 'we have extra cash.' It should be tied to a specific goal: reducing dilution from employee stock options, fending off an activist, or signaling confidence after a rough quarter. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what makes this show useful. If you're building or running a company that recently went public, understanding the full toolkit—including tender offers—can make a difference. These conversations are for operators and builders. Luna: Honestly, if today's episode was worth a coffee to you, there's a link for that. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That kind of support is what keeps this show ad-free and focused on the details. Lucas: Yeah, it really does help. And it means we can keep diving into these niche topics without any outside noise. So if you find value here, consider it. Luna: Back to tender offers: one more angle I find interesting is when companies use them to buy back shares from specific shareholders, like a large institutional holder that wants to exit quietly. That's called a targeted tender offer. Lucas: Right, and that's controversial because it can look like the company is favoring some shareholders over others. The SEC has rules about that—you generally have to offer the same terms to all shareholders. But there are ways around it, like using a 'modified Dutch auction' that effectively targets a certain group. Luna: Is that common with post ipo companies? I think about a company that went public six months ago and has a big venture capital backer that wants to cash out. A tender offer could be a way to let them exit without dumping shares on the open market. Lucas: Exactly. And that's actually a good use case. The VC gets liquidity, the company gets to repurchase shares at a discount to what the market might demand if the VC sold in bulk, and other shareholders don't get hit with a sudden supply shock. It's a win-win if structured right. Luna: But there's also the downside: the company uses cash that could have been invested in R&D or acquisitions. So the board has to decide: is this the best use of capital? Lucas: That's the perennial question. And there's no one-size-fits-all answer. But for companies that have mature cash flows and limited growth opportunities, returning capital to shareholders via a tender offer can be a smart move. Just look at how many mature tech companies do regular buybacks. Luna: And with interest rates still in the 4% range as of mid-2026, cash isn't earning much. So using it to buy back undervalued stock makes sense. Lucas: Right. If your stock is trading at a price to earnings ratio of 15 and your business is growing 10% a year, buying back stock gives you an effective return of over 6% from earnings yield alone. That's better than the risk-free rate. Luna: So for our listeners who are CFOs or investor relations officers at post ipo companies, what's the key takeaway? When should they consider a tender offer over open-market buybacks? Lucas: Three scenarios: one, when you want to make a strong signal that the stock is undervalued. Two, when you need to absorb a large block of shares coming from a lockup expiration or a major shareholder. Three, when you want to execute the buyback quickly and with certainty, like before a major acquisition or a quarterly earnings report where you want a cleaner balance sheet. Luna: And don't forget the tax and regulatory aspects. Tender offers require more disclosure, and they can be more expensive due to fees for the dealer-manager and legal advisors. Lucas: All true. But when it's the right tool, it's a powerful one. And it's part of the evolving playbook for public companies navigating the market in 2026.