Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 2 - What Is Supply Chain?
Transcript
- Keith: ⁓ Welcome to episode two of Under the Pallet Wrap with Dan Culverhouse and me, Keith Dupres. A podcast about supply chain. Not necessarily for supply chain people. Hopefully it will be interesting to everybody who works in e-commerce, logistics and the industry in general. And every week we take a question. One simple question related to supply chain. And we mull it over. it takes us into all different directions. No script, no agenda, just general discussion and hopefully some good insights. Last week we talked about our experience up to now, our careers in supply chain, some of the challenges we faced. Today we want to go a little bit deeper into the subject and our question today is what is supply chain? Where does it begin? And where does it end? So I think people would have different opinions on this one, Dan. What do you think? Where do you think the supply chain starts Dan Culverhouse: Well, yes. So it's not an easy question to answer, actually, is it? I it sounds like, oh, well, it starts at beginning of a product and it ends when it lands at a consumer. But actually, there is so much more to it. And a lot of it, I think, depends on the perspective that you're looking at it from. Are you a consumer? Are you the retailer? Are you a distributor, manufacturer, a supplier? And I think all of those would describe the supply chain a little bit differently. If you're the retailer, it starts with where you buy it, and it ends when somebody sells it to you. And then, of course, you start talking about the returns, so it gets a bit more complicated again. And I think probably a good way to probably focus this in, because otherwise we'll just go round and round in circles, would be to consider it from a product perspective, I suppose, too. So we're not worried about who we are. It's a product. So I don't know, why don't we take a blue printed t-shirt or something and start to look at it from that perspective. we go up the supply chain, where does the supply chain start if you're a t-shirt? Of course, You don't become the T-shirt until you've been made, but the supply chain starts before it's been made. So you can go up to the raw materials. And of course, the raw materials are multiple supply chains because there are multiple raw materials, wouldn't you say? Keith: Yeah, I would go so far as it starts with design Yeah, I definitely feel like the Dan Culverhouse: I guess that's the trigger. I guess that's the trigger, right? So, you know, the design is the thing that will trigger a supply chain. Certainly from my perspective, the supply chain is the physical aspect. For me, it's not the thinking about it, it is the physical aspect. But you're right, the trigger is a design. So you have to design something and then that turns into its component parts, I guess, doesn't it? Keith: I think you put it really well actually, Dan, when the physical ⁓ movement of the stock begins. But you say that it's essential to have the supply chain having an input or being at the table when it comes to the design decision? ⁓ We're responsible for the movement, but how important do you think supply chain is to the decision that actually influences the steps that come next? Dan Culverhouse: Well, I'm trying not to sound cynical here, but history would say it certainly can happen without supply chains involvement at the start because it's certainly a regular occurrence. I'm sure most people who've been involved in supply chain would say, well, of course it would make it better, but we're not always asked. So quite often we have to react and respond. But without a doubt, if you involve some supply chain and logistics elements into your design process, then product will probably ⁓ be a better It will also, ⁓ no doubt, be cost effective to create, manage, and move. ⁓ And you could take something really simple as an example. ⁓ And that is when you build your product, and as I say, if we keep to the blue t-shirt scenario, so when you pack it, and you put it into boxes and a number of items per box, et cetera, et cetera, and it ends up palletized. If the supply chain and the logistical people are involved, then that box will fit on a pallet with no wasted space. And therefore, as it moves through a supply chain, it will be efficiently packed. So there's no air, there's no wasted space within a pallet or in a container. You use that modular type approach. And that's just a very simple example of where, you know, that practical operational supply chain view at an early stage can make a significant impact on the cost and the effectiveness of that movement of that supply chain. Keith: we're going to ⁓ suggest that it starts ⁓ at the first physical movement of the goods, is that what we've between us? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I guess we goods means raw materials at this stage. So it's not a t-shirt yet, but it's the component parts that will make up that t-shirt. And you could even start to say, included in that has to be then the machinery that creates that product, because it's all very well having a bunch of cotton and some dye and some print. But if you don't have a machine or a sewing machine to create it or cut it, you know, so but. You can keep going forevermore, right? You can say, ⁓ well, the raw materials are the cotton. Well, that cotton has to get picked off a plant at some point. And at some point, someone has to plant that plant. So it starts with a seed. But we could go on forever, right? From a practical sense, let's say we start with the raw materials, which are things like cotton and dye and things like that. So those component parts have to come together somewhere. so it can be turned into a T-shirt. I would say that is where we would be the start point from this perspective. you know, because if you have your idea, your design, from there you buy your component parts, right? And then you bring them in and that physical aspect, that movement starts with the cotton coming to the manufacturer to be made, to be cut and to be sewed. Keith: What are the pressures that someone in supply chain is facing Dan Culverhouse: think the first and obvious one is quantities. How many should I make? How many should I make of what size? And then it's, well, if I'm making those, then how many should I put into each box of each size? Should I just make single size boxes? Should I make ratio packs with a selection of sizes across it? So I think these are some of the key questions that somebody has to ask early on in the process. So. because it's all very well saying you've got this great t-shirt, but who's going to buy it? Where's it going to be sold? How many different sizes do I need? then which will be the most popular? It's immediately a complicated question. Keith: Absolutely. This is where supply chain have to collaborate very closely with merchandising. I think it's sometimes a surprise to logistics teams that how big a stakeholder buying and merchandising actually are. Time to market, the cost, absolutely everything impacts the whole process, the buying process. The two teams collaborate so closely, but I've worked in lots of operations where the buying team were almost unknown to the supply chain team. But I think we both expressed the key point there. How much do you need? How many products are you shipping? When did I need them by? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. And of course, in the past, that's kind of been really a little bit of just a financial discussion, right? Because, know, you want to make enough so you can sell them and maximise your revenue. But you accept that you won't sell all of them and some of them will be left, you know. But interestingly, we're in a place now, I think, in the next few months, isn't it? That's certainly in the EU, that manufacturers can no longer destroy product they don't sell. And I think that puts even more pressure on that early decision making process about how much of this do I buy? How much do I make? Because if I make a million of them and I only sell 600,000, I can no longer include in my margin the cost of destroying or recycling or repurposing. Recycling and repurposing will still be okay. But you can't, you know, I mean, we've seen the waste that particularly the fashion industry suffers with. You know, so there's an additional new pressure that's coming on getting that question right, right from the beginning. Keith: Absolutely to go back to design designing products that have a longer life cycle that can feed into the circular economy ⁓ be turned into something new Straightforwardly is a whole new element to the the apparel industry So again, it goes it goes back to that ⁓ stage doesn't it? ⁓ So after manufacturing, obviously brings about so many individual pressures, margins and cost inputs. What about the next stage, Would you say wholesale? ⁓ Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, so I guess you get into movement then. You could have to some degree a pretty direct supply chain. So you could have a manufacturer that sells directly to a retailer and then retailers sells to the consumer. But very commonly, a part of that chain will be a wholesaler, a distributor. So somebody who buys that T-shirt in bulk ⁓ and then they do the job of finding retailers around the world realistically to sell in bulk that product too. So a manufacturer may have a relatively simple job of creating it and then selling it to major players and then wholesalers. their outlets are somewhat limited. They wouldn't ever sell to the consumer, for instance. But of course, you're then into international shipments because almost inevitably, you're not selling the product in the country that you manufacture it. Let's be realistic when we're talking fashion. A big location for fashion and manufacturing would be somewhere like Bangladesh. The demand for clothing in Bangladesh is not going to support many of those countries. It has to be a global demand. So immediately you're into big international shipments around the world. Keith: of what sort of skill sets come into play when it comes to international shipping. ⁓ You've got demand and planning, but then you've also got trade compliance, which is a whole different ball game. A little bit different to, you know, some people think logistics is all about warehousing, but ⁓ it's a whole different skill set, getting goods from A to B. What sort of skills do people need to ship goods internationally, especially in the current climate? Dan Culverhouse: Well, you I want you to answer this. This is your game. I am the warehouse guy. So this is yours, my friend. ⁓ Before I get it wrong, I want you to tell them Keith: Well, I've always gone by the three simple rules really. What is it? Where's it going? And when does it need to be there by? It might seem simple, but in asking those three questions to yourself, you get into the world of product compliance. What is it? Where is it? Where are you now? What do you need in order to sell those products? Not just domestically but in international markets. There's never been more requirements for products than there are now. know there's tariffs. We hear a lot about tariffs but there's also non-tariff barriers to protect local industry. Managed by things like standards. adopted the general product safety requirements. Sadly the UK in leaving the EU are not involved in those discussions. So there's new obligations for UK suppliers wishing to ship to the EU. But yeah, so the product, what is it? What am I trying to ship? The higher risk, the more standard supply. can involve physical safety elements, but also security. So phones are subject to not just one regulation around safety and catching fire, but also the data within. In terms of where, what size is it? Are there regulations? for input whereby you need to satisfy them before you ship? How can you ship them by air? Are they big? Are they small? Are they fragile? And where you're shipping to? What's the economy like? What's the situation in the country? Every country is different. If you look culturally and economically, I find this very fascinating. It can give you a few clues about what sort of restrictions might be in place or how easy or hard it might be to ship a product to a destination. If you consider something like a phone, can you ship it absolutely everywhere? Or is it likely that each individual country will have a different approach to the electronics industry? Do they manufacture this type of product in their own country? Do they not? Do they import most of their products? That will often give you a clue as to whether the duty rate is going to be high or whether there's going to be additional restrictions or requirements. Dan Culverhouse: ⁓ And I guess a lot of that is determined by are you a consumer market or are you a production market? So the big producers of this world have a very different perspective on this than the consumer market. So if you're the EU or the UK, we're a large consumer market, not a large manufacturing market. Keith: Absolutely. Dan Culverhouse: And I think the one that's probably had the most headlines over recent years has been Chinese EVs, Electric vehicles that Europe feels the Chinese are importing into our market undervalued because the, let's say the Chinese government is alleged to be subsidizing. the cost of the manufacturer so they can sell them across the world at ridiculously low prices that nobody in Europe can compete with. Are they or are they just efficient in what they do? I don't really know. I couldn't answer that question. But it would certainly, you know, it looks very much like there's a lot of subsidizing that's going on because the Chinese are a manufacturing nation and therefore they support their manufacturers. So you get it, right? You can see why they do it. What does that mean? Of course, that means that the EU will put levies and anti-dumping tariffs on them. And I think it's up to 50%. Isn't it? Some of the EVs got charged with on some of the companies depending on, I guess probably depending on connections, but I didn't say that. But depending on how much subsidies they believe is happening at the manufacturing end. which is another huge complication to understand when you're bringing product across the world. Keith: Yes, we hear lot about the US trade deficit and the tariffs that have been designed to pull some of that money back, but I think your point is very clear. I ⁓ if you're importing as a consumer for goods that you want rather than need, then the whole tariff nomenclature is based upon lower tariffs. generally for raw materials and higher tariffs for consumer goods. So to look at things as a flat picture and, ⁓ well, we're paying tariffs on this and that, is not actually in keeping with the manufacturing bases of the world and the consumer bases of the world. It was designed by that, designed to service the consumer market. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, to create balance. Because it's a balance between creating an open market, a sense of competition, you know, because if you do or you can have a sense of protectionism. So if you want to protect your local industry, you make sure that every imported product car in this in this instance has enough tariffs on it to make sure that it's expensive and therefore it favors your local. But again, You know, the design was to find balance, but it's now a political tool. mean, it's used politically a lot these days rather than just trying to find the balance between, you know, local trade and imported trade competition choice for people. And it's to a large degree, it's a political weapon these days, as which we have seen more in the news around tariffs. think more of the people, people in the world know what a tariff is these days than ever. Keith: Certainly more so than ever before. When I've trained my teams around things like classification, I always start with the international trade question and why tariffs, HS codes, classification rules came to be post World War II in order to avoid any sort of conflict of this nature happening again. I think the history is important to understand the context. So there's probably been a few groans when I've started talking about GATT agreements and the birth of the WTO. The team was sitting there thinking, what is he talking about? But I think they've always valued the background to understand why a system came into play. why things like free trade agreements came to be, how they work, how in effect before a few years ago there were so many more conversations about reducing trade barriers, promoting free trade. It's all gone in reverse a bit. It adds a completely new complexity to supply chain stuff, their day-to-day. It shows the absolute importance of being knowledgeable and understanding the effects of these decisions and being able to offer an input into those decisions about where the goods are made and how they're made and how to shit. Dan Culverhouse: And the risk that's attached to that, right? mean, because historically over the last 20, 30 years, it's really been this globalization of product manufacturer demand and supply. But in probably the last five years, maybe a little bit more, you started to see a turn away from that. of global market. think the COVID pandemic started it when obviously everything just ground to a halt and suddenly people realized well all my products in China but my sales are in Europe. I now can't ship anything and now I've got nothing to sell and my business is going down. So suddenly the need for a more nuanced approach to supply is born and suddenly you can't just go for right well it's cheapest to manufacture it in China the shipping costs don't even touch the overall cost so I'm just gonna have everything in deepest China so I can buy it for you know two cents a piece and sell it for 30 pounds ⁓ in the UK and that shipping cost is minute as a percentage of the overall so suddenly thinking well that's great when everything's working but when We go to war and the main route through to Europe is blocked. I've got no product. So suddenly this multi-sourcing of having a near short solution as well as a global solution, which may well be more expensive, but if you're doing say, I don't know, 10, 20 % of your volume manufactured in Europe and the other 80 % in... in Asia, at least you have a chance if there's a blockage or a, yeah, you know, a carrier ship that gets stuck in the Suez Canal. I who would ever thought that would happen? But it did. And it can be starved of your stock suddenly. But if you have some of that product being manufactured in Europe, which is probably considerably more expensive to produce. So you have to kind of balance that in there. And I think that's made that supply chain planning, that merchandising, that design upstream even more complicated today than it used to be because global disruptions are happening more than ever before. It's become the norm that we work within. Keith: Absolutely so much talk about AI replacing jobs, but I don't think supply chain's ever been busier. Reclassification, planning, planning again, moving distribution centers, sometimes within the space of a week. Yeah. Yeah, everyone's begging for some AI to save their time at the moment, but it can't move quick enough. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. We welcome AI. We welcome AI to give us a hand, Keith: So yeah, I think a lot of people working in warehouses even would be amazed that you know, I think they were always a bit amazed about what my team did behind the scenes in order to get the goods for May to be even when it was simpler. But I also think people simplify what happens once the goods arrive, know, once they get to the warehouse door. I think some people think they magic themselves to the customer but there's a whole load of processes that happen from the moment goods arrive. I mean the collaboration between the import-export team and the warehouse is massive anyway in order to help them resource by giving them visibility of what's coming in when. But what happens once the goods arrive at the door? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. And again, various products will vary what happens. You can take the simplest, which is if you have total control over your supply chain and you have a very steady demand, you can effectively use your warehouse as simply a point of bringing in bulk and distributing in small quantities to your customers. And there are products and there are operations that do that on a completely stockless environment. So it comes in in the morning. It's received, it's understood, it's checked, goes through a quality process and is then split, distributed into, let's say, shops, locations, packed and out the door the same day. You know, so it never, never sits in stock. Sometimes it's quite common these days because of the globalization of our supply chains that you bring products say into the UK. Only a portion of it is ever going to get sold in the UK. Some of it will get re-exported and then we get into bonded customs warehousing where you only bring officially into the UK what we would call free circulation. The products that you know you're going to sell in the UK, the rest you hold in a what they call duty suspension, which allows you to then re-export it to another country and pay the duties in that country. So you're not paying the duties in the UK and then paying the duties in another country, which is another additional complexity, which is only a systemic complexity these days. It used to be a physical segregation, used to a cage around your bonded stock so nobody could go in there, whereas nowadays it sits on the same pallet in the same location, it's just systemically split. So there's a there's a there's a complication many products need to have Labeling done to them before they can go out tagging promotional pricing ⁓ Rebagging, you know, there's there's a world of value added services that You know that can be done to a product whilst it's in a warehouse. all of these things happen inside of a warehouse. ⁓ And ⁓ then of course, ⁓ the way that you distribute out of a warehouse is very, very varied. Exports tend to be, can be in bulk, but they can also to consumer. So single The explosion of online and e-commerce means now that you're not just picking full cases and sending them to shops for the shops to sell to the customers. The warehouse is effectively delivering to customers these days. So you then have to go through picking by case, but also picking by single units and shipping those ⁓ beautifully packed. if it's a relatively luxury items, the packing can be a real art form, which means multiple types of boxes, multiple types of packaging, the risk of error becomes much higher. So, within a warehouse itself, the amount of complexity that can go through it. And when you think, you know, a professional large scale warehouse can be shipping millions of units in a week. and the expectation is that they will go out with a 99.5 plus percentage of accuracy is an enormous task, which is why automation and robotics has become such an explosion within warehousing because it makes less errors. It doesn't replace people. It certainly manages the volatility of people because of course, particularly in retail, warehousing is a very volatile environment from demand perspective because if you promote a lot of products or you go into a high promotional period, Christmas would be the most obvious one. You can see volumes more than double. mean, it's not, you you go through a Black Friday, if you're an e-commerce, you can see thousands of percentage of demand increase over a very short space of time, which traditionally would be done by just tripling your staff. Well, if you've ever worked in a warehouse and you run a group of individuals that are picking orders, processing orders, if you suddenly get three times as many people who've never done it before, you've got a lot of problems on your hands and a lot of accuracy issues and a lot of compliance issues. So this is where the automation and robotics has really helped to limit the amount of short term labor. So you're always needing that core skill set of people that really understand how the process works and how to manage orders, but you use machinery and robotics to drive that volume. So yeah, they're hugely complex operations these days and very expensive. Keith: Yes, not only do we have to picking, we have to packing, the consistency of the packing and massive area of waste stuffed in with poor packaging. When there's too many component parts, there's too much space. Obviously the bigger the box, the higher the shipping cost. So someone's monitoring that as well. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: ⁓ Someone is always reviewing the packaging costs. Someone's always reviewing the shipping costs. Someone's of course always reviewing the transit times, the delivery success. You're working with multiple carriers sometimes to distribute the risk and customers demand service as well. Demand choice. So you're managing lots of carrier relationships. Some are tracked, some are un-tracked. You get a number of inquiries from different departments customer service asking about Where's my order? Why is this delayed? What's happening here? And of course you've got that relationship with the carrier manager and you're finding that information out for the whole business Obviously the place of relationship you have with internal departments in the carrier manager You make it for everybody. You take a continuous improvement approach. You take the requests and the complaints that you get and you aim to reduce them by improving the service. But I've been amazed at amount of warehouses I've been into, the amount of businesses I've been into, where again they think that part is almost magic. The courier collects the goods regardless of what address has been... added to the or applied to the chipping label and it's going to get there in one piece. Everything's perfect but there's so much that comes into it and making sure that those deliveries get out on time, get delivered on time, get resolved before the customer even knows about the issue. All sorts can go wrong. Then of course the bugbear of the e-commerce world is returns. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: It's a given really. When I started out in e-commerce, people thought it might not work because of the returns element. How are you going to build a business when people like to return their goods? Well, they were right in a way. It's always been a huge cost for e-commerce businesses in certain fields, less so in some. But of course, returns have to be managed seamlessly as well. They have to be managed back through customs if they're international shipments. Customs regimes duty free. Again, it doesn't happen by magic. Processes have to be established. and aftercare as well. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I think the whole returns piece, think it's a really interesting position. you know, as e-commerce and direct to consumer distribution has grown and grown and grown, you know, and, you know, in fashion and clothing and really consumable items like that, we're talking about a level of returns that are 40 and 50 percent is not unusual. I was talking to someone just this morning that was telling me that through their Zalando, which is a big European marketplace, their returns were close to 70%. Now, just think about the cost and complexity of managing that process. And alongside that, right now we have a consumer that is demanding quicker deliveries. They want free returns. And, you know, all of these things are huge. pressure on a retailer's and a manufacturer's margins to be able to deliver. So we want cheaper products. We want them delivered instantaneously. We want to be able to send 50 % of them back when they don't fit. And on top of that, we want you to be environmentally friendly. We want you to be sustainable. And e-commerce and the level of returns is the biggest driver of inefficiency and environmental impact in the supply chain. think there's is gonna help with this because we have to be to get better ⁓ at ordering the right product. So don't order size nine, 10 and 11 shoes just to check. We need find way that technology can make sure that actually I know I need the ⁓ 11s and I only order the 11s. and that somehow that you can picture yourself in the black ones as well as the blue ones, as well as the red ones, so don't order all three colors and send two of them back because it's just not a sustainable practice going forwards. You know, I think that we have to find ways to stop, you know, this belief that you can just order five, six different items and send four of Keith: Absolutely, there are some very exciting developments. As we speak, this is where AI is benefiting the supply chain very much and with the regulations coming in place sooner than people realise, at beginning of 2027 for textiles, Dan Culverhouse: It really is. Keith: you're forced into action which is a big ask of retailers to actually be forced to manage the environmental element alongside the convenience. Dan Culverhouse: Because ultimately it's just going to push the product up, right? It has to. It has to push the product Unless the approach and retailers can, I don't know, influence their customers to recognize that the only way to keep pricing under control is to change the way that we shop and the way that we consume. It'll just become unsustainably expensive because Companies can't do it without making a margin. They have to make a profit, otherwise they can't afford to keep going. ⁓ I think that, yeah, that there's only one future and that is more responsible consumerism and recycling, repurposing, making sure that those unsold items do get into the market, whether they're debatched or sent to an area where they don't. They don't dilute the brands exclusivity or something like that. But all of these things have got to happen because I think we're on a path that is not sustainable. Keith: There's a concept in Six Sigma called Poker Yoker which is essentially mistake proofing but it can also be looked at as prohibiting the customer from doing the wrong thing. So a lot of that can be built into the design in my view, into the shopping experience. So like you say the customer can't go to 10 units of the same thing. But you also don't want them to drop off at the checkout. So a lot of innovation is needed. It's what keeps me excited. This constant adaptation and innovation in the supply chain. I think it's what's always kept me so interested. It's because of the cost element and the fact that it's normally the highest cost. It's normally the most visible cost because we're judged on cost. There's also a lot of innovation, continuous improvement in making sure quality is maintained whilst keeping costs. at a minimum. We're not sacrificing quality for costs. Knowing what value is. Cheap does not mean less money in the scheme of things. Dan Culverhouse: Yes. Yeah. Interestingly, to almost to circle this round into that, where we started with this question about where does the supply chain start and finish? You know, I think this part of the discussion where we talk about recycling and repurposing of product, this is ultimately feeding the end product in some form or another back to the start of the supply chain. You know, so, you know, clothing can get broken down into its raw materials or products get broken down to the raw materials and they end up right back at the start being recreated into new products. So it's almost as if the supply chain doesn't even have a beginning and an end. It is becoming a circle. And there are lots of wastages and that drop off around, but effectively the supply chain is actually a circle. They're not. Keith: Absolutely It's an eternal chain, hence its name. I think we might have, a year ago, suggested the end, sadly, was landfill in a lot of cases. But I'm so glad that this is no longer acceptable in the eyes of the world. And it's a lot more visible. And I'm glad the focus is on almost eternal life cycle. Dan Culverhouse: in your process. It used to but it still is I think a lot. Yeah, yeah, it has to be the future. But OK, well, I think we're probably at a good spot to go. Let's leave that there. Lots to think about. One thing I think that we've shown without any shadow of a doubt is this thing is complicated. It's complex and very nuanced. So hopefully there's been a whole bunch of things for people to go away with, to think about, to consider. and maybe even to focus on in their roles or in their businesses. But yeah, I think the only thing we can all agree on is it's a very complicated thing. yeah, but I think for this week, that's ⁓ a pretty good place to finish. We're going to be back again next week talking about something new. I think, Keith, I think we've decided it's going to be. What is a warehouse for? And is a distribution center the same thing? Keith: Yes, indeed. See you next time. Dan Culverhouse: Agreed? Yeah, thanks. See you next week.