Latest / Ahead At The Apex / Mercedes or Red Bull, Who's Looking Good After F1 Shakedown?
Transcript
- 0:00Turns out listening to Lewis Hamilton might be.
- 0:03Actually, actually a good idea. Do you know what I'm excited
- 0:06for? It's.
- 0:06Not really about. It's 5
- 0:38They were able to run the final day, but it did delay them,
- 0:40you're right, because they were waiting on parts to come across
- 0:42from Milton Keynes, I know. Such a funny state, I know.
- 0:47So I mean all of this Mercedes speculation disproven really.
- 0:53I mean just gone. They might as well give up and
- 0:55pack it in. Hello, everybody and welcome
- 1:38back to Ahead of the Apex once again joined by Tim and Katie as
- 1:42I was last week. For those who didn't listen to
- 1:47last week, we we've just changed.
- 1:49Obviously it's a different, different week, different day.
- 1:53Not definitely, definitely not. Still the same recording as last
- 1:57time, Tim. I don't know what you're talking
- 2:00about. Great.
- 2:02So the in this episode we are going to be talking about
- 2:05shakedown. I know that for listening date
- 2:09that's going to be 3 weeks since and you're going to be midway
- 2:14through the 1st lot of pre season testing.
- 2:18But as of date of recording on the 6th of Feb, we have just had
- 2:23shakedown at last week and this is our first day back recording
- 2:28for the 26th season. So obviously we're going to talk
- 2:30about it. OK, so a little bit about
- 2:37shakedown, Katie, you had many questions about shakedown when
- 2:41it was happening about, you know, is this can we believe
- 2:44this sort of times? Can we believe?
- 2:46What can we take from this? Why is it not televised, that
- 2:50sort of thing? So to answer those questions as
- 2:52somebody who's been around for a long, a long fucking time. 1000
- 2:57years I guess some put of that. This isn't the first time we've
- 3:00had a shakedown F1 testing session.
- 3:02This isn't the first time we've had an F1 testing week that was
- 3:07not open to the media. In fact, the only media that was
- 3:09allowed there was F1's cameras themselves because of a couple
- 3:15of things, actually. So the first one is is a whole
- 3:17new generation of cars and. Next generation racers.
- 3:22The last time they opened up testing of a new generation of
- 3:27cars to the the media was the Pulp Singh incident.
- 3:30And that was that didn't look good on F1.
- 3:32It didn't look good on the FAA. It didn't look good on the
- 3:34teams, doesn't look good on the sponsors.
- 3:38And the last time that they had a private one was when they
- 3:42launched the V6 turbo hybrids in 2014.
- 3:47And that was because they were worried about the engines just
- 3:50failing and causing a huge amount of embarrassment right to
- 3:57to teams who just had a lot of money given to them by sponsors
- 4:01to then have their cars breaking down after 5 laps.
- 4:03And that being all over the Internet and the only thing that
- 4:06anybody ever sees. So it was completely private for
- 4:09that reason for the new engines and the new regs.
- 4:11Wasn't it for the? It was actually the teams who
- 4:14wanted the. Teams wanted privacy first.
- 4:16Yeah, yeah, because because they don't want to embarrass
- 4:19themselves or the sponsors. The teams also requested, which
- 4:22I was going to bring up later, but I'm glad you brought it up,
- 4:24Katie. Some of the teams requested that
- 4:27they don't, that they were given permission from the FIA to not
- 4:32run the sustainable fuels shakedown and to run whatever
- 4:36fuel they wanted. For the FIA to grant that it
- 4:38can't have just been one team. We don't know which teams, but
- 4:44yeah, you know. I heard that there.
- 4:45Was feel free to speculate in this podcast.
- 4:47Quite a large police presence. Yeah, I've heard that.
- 4:51People would be told to move along if they were trying to get
- 4:54pictures of the cars on the track, which is quite rude to be
- 4:57honest. It is a bit I, I mean, no, I get
- 5:01it. I do get it.
- 5:03But then, you know, Ferrari rolled out in their track and
- 5:09just fans camped out by the fence.
- 5:11So it's not like, yeah, I don't know who that came from.
- 5:15I don't know who wanted to privacy.
- 5:16My guess would be teams like Audi and Mercedes who have, you
- 5:21know, if if Ferrari breakdown, do Ferrari fans stop supporting
- 5:27Ferrari? No, if Mercedes and Audi
- 5:31breakdown, do they lose car sales?
- 5:33Yes, big time. So I guess it's come from them.
- 5:37I think the fans of Ferrari and what not, Ferrari, Audi and
- 5:41Cadillac at the moment are, are the actual fans of say Bottas.
- 5:44Yeah, driving. Fans.
- 5:46Right. All of Mexico blast.
- 5:49But it doesn't look good if you know, Cadillac roll out and then
- 5:53they breakdown, right? But it particularly doesn't look
- 5:56good for Audi who are running their own engine.
- 5:58So I you know that This is why it was hidden.
- 6:02I think it was only Aston Martin who had Aston Martin and Alpine
- 6:06who had engine failures which were reported.
- 6:10Aston said it was some sort of electrical fault, easy fix and
- 6:14Alpine had a random Mercedes failure but nobody else running
- 6:18a Mercedes engine had any failures so they said it was it
- 6:21was a one off maybe driver induced issue.
- 6:23One crash I believe, which was Isaac Casual, Yeah, I don't
- 6:28think there was any other crashes that were.
- 6:30Who crashed in the only place visible from 1000 meters away.
- 6:34But people I I heard rumours that it was just a driver thing,
- 6:37but then I also heard the opposite.
- 6:38That was a car issue that caused the crash but I know it delayed
- 6:42some of their. Were they able to run the final?
- 6:44They were able to run the final day, but it did delay them,
- 6:46you're right, because they were waiting on parts to come across
- 6:48from Milton Keynes, I know. Such a funny state I know.
- 6:54Did Ocon get any penalties? None.
- 6:57None yet, but 5 second penalty. Do you know who does have to
- 6:59serve a penalty in Australia? Yeah.
- 7:03For smashing into someone. In in Abu Dhabi, yeah, no, so
- 7:09the Isaac Kaja, I think Kate, I think it was probably I've heard
- 7:13both sides. And I I guess the easiest way to
- 7:16describe it for people who aren't familiar with it is is
- 7:19the color science in Australia thing last year where it was
- 7:23like, yes, it's a driver issue, but it's, it's a driver car
- 7:27issue, right? It's not.
- 7:29It's not like he made a mistake and dropped it on the grass or
- 7:32the car just randomly spun it out.
- 7:34But I guess it's getting used to the car and not.
- 7:36It's a translation. It's a translational thing,
- 7:39right? Right.
- 7:45So that's out of the way. Shakedown is entirely pointless.
- 7:51There's nothing we can learn from Shakedown at all about how
- 7:55the cars are going to perform. First of all, there is nothing
- 7:59to say that the teams turned up with a car that they intend to
- 8:01run at all. They don't have to.
- 8:06They could be benchmarking old variants of the cars against
- 8:11simulation modes. They could be trying to
- 8:15intimidate other teams. I'm thinking Aston Martin here.
- 8:20They could be running huge amounts of fuel, they could be
- 8:23running absolutely no fuel. They could be running
- 8:24experimental fuels tyres. There's absolutely nothing.
- 8:29Anyway, Lewis Hamilton goes top, so obviously Ferrari are going
- 8:33to win the world championship. Yeah, it's good to say.
- 8:35I mean, all of this Mercedes speculation disproven really.
- 8:40I mean, just gone. They might as well give up and
- 8:42pack it in. Obviously.
- 8:44That's exciting. You know Charles Leclerc, all
- 8:47fastest of the entire week, sandbagging Lewis Hamilton
- 8:51fastest. Obviously, Ferrari are going to
- 8:54win the title this year, right Kay?
- 8:57That's what this means. I mean, we may as well stop the
- 8:59podcast here. I mean, I have other reasons
- 9:01which I think we'll get we'll get onto later in the broadcast
- 9:04on why Ferrari you're going to win this year, but you've.
- 9:09Got to stop with that, right? So just I'll just run through.
- 9:15The times are pretty meaningless.
- 9:17But Lewis went top, then George Norris, the Claire Antonelli,
- 9:21Piastry, Verstappen, Ghazli, Hajar, Ocon, Berman Lindblad,
- 9:25Lawson, Colapinto, Hulkenberg, Borteletto Alonso, Bottas,
- 9:28Perez, Stroll. Most of those lap times set on
- 9:32Day 5. Yes, first of all.
- 9:34Most of those lap times set either day 5 or 4.
- 9:38Sorry, some set on day three. I mean Colapinto and Hajjar on
- 9:43day 2 actually set his fastest lap.
- 9:46So my question is, do they bring one car or two cars?
- 9:50They bring one car. So they're sharing the cars.
- 9:52They're sharing the cars, they're not allowed to run 2
- 9:53cars at the same time, and you'll find that in testing as
- 9:56well. Next next week or the week after
- 9:58whenever it is. In Bahrain they're only allowed
- 10:03to run one car at a time. Most of the teams were doing
- 10:06sort of half day half day rotations I think.
- 10:11Was it? Cadillac did a day and a day and
- 10:13then 1/2 day split. That's quite common too.
- 10:17I know Mercedes did a perfect split.
- 10:19They're usually quite fair about that.
- 10:21Ferrari did another perfect split.
- 10:25Red Bull are another team that run, tend to run one day, one
- 10:27day, and then half the the, I think the attitude there is then
- 10:32if you know Hajjah makes a mistake in the morning, it
- 10:35doesn't delay Max, it just delays Hajjah.
- 10:37I think that's the theory. The yeah, they were the only
- 10:42ones who had a, a crash incident.
- 10:44So they were the only ones affected by that.
- 10:47But yeah, Hajjah running on day 2, his lap time is completely
- 10:50useless because the track is unused.
- 10:53Spanish Grand Prix circuit during the winter, completely
- 10:58freezing cold temperatures absolutely irrelevant.
- 11:01The day five lap times are obviously going to be quicker
- 11:03than the day one lap times because they've had five days of
- 11:06F1 cars running on them right. So that's completely relevant,
- 11:10but Ferrari at the top. So Forza, Ferrari and.
- 11:14And everyone give up. What is important though at this
- 11:18time is mileage. Very important mileage for the
- 11:23cars and for the cars to be reliable.
- 11:26And of course, at the top of that list with the perfect half
- 11:29millennia of laps is Mercedes 500 laps.
- 11:32Do you think they did that intentionally?
- 11:34No, Like, whoa, whoa, guys, we've hit 500 laps.
- 11:37We have to stop now. That's that's a nice number.
- 11:39I feel like they hit 482 and then went.
- 11:42Oh wow, let's. Just do a few more.
- 11:45We might as well go out and do one more.
- 11:48But also, I think they might have just planned and it was
- 11:51just that precise. They were like, well, they ran
- 11:53without any issues, right? They ran basically like 1 1/2
- 11:57race distances per driver per day, just without incident.
- 12:02Ferrari then with 440, Haas 3391, Alpine 349, Racing Bulls
- 12:08319, Red Bull three O 3, McLaren 291, Audi 244.
- 12:14They had a lot of issues. Cadillac 164 and Aston Martin 65
- 12:18laps. It turned up for only two days.
- 12:22There is a team missing off that list.
- 12:24Which team is that key? Williams.
- 12:26And what happened to Williams? Why were they not there?
- 12:28Well, they allegedly didn't pass the FIA crash test and had car
- 12:34weight problems, but I feel like with everything you hear
- 12:38different things. So I've heard that James Files
- 12:44was like 2026 is going to be our year.
- 12:47He was, and now we're hearing this.
- 12:50It's not great, right? In James we trust, but then.
- 12:53We we hyped him up so much last year and now we look like.
- 12:56Idiots. No.
- 12:56Whoa, Yeah. We look like whoa.
- 12:58No, no. Already we look like idiots.
- 13:00You're sound like idiots too. You're I think this is a loss of
- 13:05faith that he would not appreciate.
- 13:09But they've come in with how like so was it 2020?
- 13:13They had like 6 sponsors on the car and now they've got about 21
- 13:17I want to say. Oh, I mean, don't get me wrong,
- 13:19they've done, he's done great things, but where's the car?
- 13:22This is what started happening to Claire and we all know what
- 13:26happened there. Forgot about Claire.
- 13:28I mean, you know, jeez. OK, so no, Williams, you're
- 13:35right, 2026 is going to be our year, Rocky start, blah blah
- 13:38blah. But they are in a Mercedes
- 13:39engine, so let's not write them off just yet.
- 13:42Why is it important for mileage, particularly with a engine
- 13:47regulation change, you want to make sure that your new engine
- 13:50is going to be able to do at least a race distance.
- 13:52And these engines have to last, what, 5 or 6 races now?
- 13:56So you ideally, you know, Mercedes have just done roughly
- 14:008 race distances. I think the Barcelona circuit is
- 14:0566 laps. So then that means Aston hasn't
- 14:09even done one race. Correct.
- 14:11Very well noted. And Aston are running a Honda
- 14:14engine this year. So the Honda engine hasn't even
- 14:17done a race. Yes, Cadillac done about two
- 14:22race distances, but they're part of the Ferrari stable.
- 14:24So I think, I think I haven't done the maths, some somebody
- 14:28might want to do that, but I think Ferrari ended up with the
- 14:30most mileage. Out of everybody, one thing I
- 14:34wanted to ask, which we were talking about the other day, is
- 14:36obviously there's Mercedes engines, Ferrari engines.
- 14:39They've had years of sort of developing these engines.
- 14:42So they've got a whole load brick load of data.
- 14:45Yeah, so Ferrari and Mercedes are going to be ahead of their
- 14:47customer teams. Do they have to give that data
- 14:51to their customer teams? No, not at all.
- 14:55And actually, that's why so, so expecting Ferrari and Mercedes
- 15:01to be at the top of the mileage chart and then they are, is
- 15:05exactly what I would expect. That's a weird way of saying
- 15:07that phrase that didn't make any sense.
- 15:09That's exactly what I'd expect because of that reason, right.
- 15:11So when most of the teams are rolling out for the first time
- 15:15on a racetrack, proper racetrack with a supplied engine from
- 15:19Mercedes or Ferrari, for instance, they're trying to run
- 15:23through the systems, trying to figure out how to get the the
- 15:26the battery power to deploy in an efficient way, trying to make
- 15:28sure they've got gear sync going on.
- 15:31Most teams run the Ferrari gearbox or the Mercedes gearbox
- 15:34with these, whereas Mercedes and Ferrari have already done that
- 15:38right. They've had it on a dyno for the
- 15:40last six years since these engines were announced, and they
- 15:44can hit the track and do their testing programs, testing
- 15:47regimes, race Sims, all of that, right?
- 15:50So this is exactly what I'd expect.
- 15:51What really has shocked me is Hassan, Alpine during nearly 400
- 15:56laps compared to McLaren and Cadillac, who are the other
- 16:01customer teams. That's big, especially from
- 16:06Alpine, who had nothing but trouble last year, and Haas, who
- 16:08have typically turned up to testing late.
- 16:11Yeah, yeah. They're, they're working in the
- 16:13as big, they're working in the MMDD frame.
- 16:17So they're always a bit off the mark.
- 16:20That's big Red Bull. I'm not sure we can learn much
- 16:24about their mileage because it's a new engine package.
- 16:26They would, you know, Red Bull themselves had issues, but
- 16:29they've done 600 mile, 600 miles, 600 laps on those
- 16:33engines, so that's pretty good. It puts them up with Mercedes.
- 16:37Are Racing Bulls and Red Bull allowed to share their data?
- 16:42No, no, I don't think so because they're separate.
- 16:47Teams, they're different teams. That's like, I mean, I guess
- 16:50they could, it just wouldn't be in Oh, I don't know, it like I'm
- 16:54just trying to think if this was Ferrari and McLaren, could they
- 17:01maybe would they know? I don't know.
- 17:04But Red Bull and Racing Bulls aren't competing against each
- 17:06other. Ferrari and McLaren are.
- 17:10But as far as the FIA concerned? So that's really that's really
- 17:13knocked me for six. I did not expect that question.
- 17:16OK, so Ferrari, Mercedes or Ferrari McLaren, they're not
- 17:22allowed to share data between each other and also not allowed
- 17:25to give each other drawings, designs, whatever.
- 17:30But Red Bull's in house engine team are allowed to gather data
- 17:36from both Red Bull and VV cab racing bulls.
- 17:41In the same way that Mercedes have an engine guy at McLaren
- 17:45and they have an engine guy at Alpine and they have an engine
- 17:48guy at who else is running their engines?
- 17:50Nobody is here but Aston Martin last year, right?
- 17:53So, so there is in the same way that Pirelli Williams, in the
- 17:56same way that there's a Pirelli person in the garage at all
- 17:59times, right, gathering the data from the various teams.
- 18:02What they're not allowed to do is share that back out with the
- 18:05teams separately, but they are allowed to use it to develop the
- 18:09engine, which is why Mercedes used to have the best engine,
- 18:13because they had like 5 customer teams all feeding data back into
- 18:16the Mercedes powertrain department.
- 18:18Now, yes, if the Mercedes powertrain department goes out
- 18:22for a beer with Toto, is he going to tell him some stuff?
- 18:25Yeah, probably. But, well, this is the Susie
- 18:28Wolf pillow talk. Hey, hey, whoa, whoa, hey.
- 18:31We're not throwing any. This he does not speak for ahead
- 18:35of the effect, no. No, but but the idea was that
- 18:37was that was the threat. That was why people were were
- 18:40nervous and concerned of. Course.
- 18:43But yes, that's a good question, Katie, thank you.
- 18:47But no, I don't think so is the answer.
- 18:49They they've never had a relationship like that and
- 18:51they're not allowed to copy designs and and everything else.
- 18:57Should we get into some team discussions?
- 18:59Yeah. Aston Martin is who I want to
- 19:06start with because they might have cooked.
- 19:11Yeah, the NUI, the NUI, the new Nui.
- 19:15Have you seen it? It is very aggressive, lots of
- 19:20Finns, lots of votes. Well, that's what I think.
- 19:22I think obviously newly his, he is an aerodynamicist primarily,
- 19:29yes. And I know that this was a
- 19:31regulation to move away from this stress on aerodynamics, but
- 19:35I think he's gone. OK, yes, explicitly yes, but
- 19:40there are ways that we will be able to.
- 19:44But he's also a good car designer, not just the.
- 19:46Air No, no, no. But, but I feel like that's
- 19:48where, you know, when, when you watch the documentaries with him
- 19:51and all this stuff and it's just this like he draws everything by
- 19:54hand because he feels the air moving with his pencil or
- 19:58whatever. You know, that kind of that kind
- 20:00of argument. And I think he's still gone,
- 20:03right. Though this is not central to
- 20:05the regulation set now, it's still something that we can
- 20:11advantage ourselves with. Yes, and they've gone down that
- 20:14route in terms of outputting it, whereas Mercedes I feel like
- 20:17I've gone for. All right, let's lean into the
- 20:20regulations and just develop an insane engine.
- 20:22Yes. So Aston came seventh last year.
- 20:26Yes. I think you talk about the car,
- 20:29you've got to think about other things as well.
- 20:31So you've got to think about the drivers and you've got to think
- 20:33about the strategy. That's what it's told, innit?
- 20:35And I think that Aston Martin, they have.
- 20:38Fernando Alonso, how many? I've got the team standings up
- 20:41now and I'm going to look at the drivers.
- 20:42So last year Fernando Alonso got 56 points. 56 and Lance Straw
- 20:47got 32. 33 I think it's going to be a good car wasted on a one
- 20:54man team. OK, that's my personal opinion.
- 20:58I think sometimes Asha Aston might have cooked with strategy
- 21:02I think, but I think that came more from a Fernando Alonso's
- 21:06part. He was able to control the pace
- 21:09of the park. Yeah, true.
- 21:11Not let people overtake him to sort of exploit what he needed
- 21:15out of the race. I think the car's performance is
- 21:19going to be wasted on Lance Stroll.
- 21:22I have two words and a number as a retort to you.
- 21:26Max Verstappen, 2023. You're going to have to explain.
- 21:30Great car, 1 driver. Yeah, but good strategy.
- 21:35Yeah, but is is, is Alonso as good as Verstappen?
- 21:40I want to say no. But he was.
- 21:46So where could I see sort of Aston?
- 21:50Whilst they have a good car, I don't think they're going to be
- 21:52a top. Absolutely cooking.
- 21:55I don't. Absolutely cooking.
- 21:56I don't think they're gonna be in the top 4.
- 21:59Adrian new he's put bean wings as suspension, suspension arms
- 22:02as bean wings in an era where bean wings aren't allowed.
- 22:04I mean, this guy, the Viking horns are back the floor, the
- 22:09the the barge boards. I mean, good Lord, either it's
- 22:13like an absolute red herring of him, like being like, hey, guys,
- 22:17look what I've cooked up. And everyone's going, yeah, we
- 22:19should pay attention and. The.
- 22:21Car turns up in Australia and it's like nothing like that
- 22:24whatsoever. And it's like exactly how the
- 22:26Mercedes is right now. But Mercedes spend the next
- 22:28three weeks trying to build an Aston Martin in their own
- 22:30garages. Like I, I have no idea, but man,
- 22:34that car look is the only one that looks really different to
- 22:37anything else. And it's either going to be the
- 22:39best thing in the world or it's going to be nowhere.
- 22:42There is no in between. I think we could.
- 22:45I think it will be exactly in between.
- 22:47We could see an Alonso podium maybe.
- 22:50Oh man, I. Would like to.
- 22:51I'd like to see an Alonso world championship, but that's.
- 22:53Not I think, I think that's why it's only going to be sick and
- 22:56that'll be fine, but it's. One better than last year.
- 23:03OK, OK. The other thing to bear in mind
- 23:10is it's not just as Tim said, not just about the aero package
- 23:14this year, but it is a huge shift in power units.
- 23:17So we're we're from from those V6 turbo hybrids in 2014, we've
- 23:22come a long way. We've dropped the V, the MGUH,
- 23:25which is the one that harvests the turbo hot gases to turn
- 23:28turbines and power battery to an MGUK system.
- 23:32So we're going back to kind of like curs from the early twenty
- 23:3510's and it's almost a 5050 split this year between the
- 23:41combustion engine and the MGUK system.
- 23:44And on top of that, the FAA has limited the amount of power that
- 23:49can be produced by the internal combustion engine by introducing
- 23:53this compression rate limit. So that's the volume in the
- 23:57cylinder that can be compressed. So if it one unit of volume at
- 24:02the top, it needs to be 16 at the bottom.
- 24:05However, as you both have probably heard, Red Bull and
- 24:10Mercedes cheating already. Not even turned a wheel in anger
- 24:14cheating. You know the story.
- 24:17Yeah. So the compression or whatever
- 24:20is better when hot, but then they only measure when cold.
- 24:24Yeah. It'd be very hard to measure the
- 24:26compression rate of an engine when it's hot.
- 24:28I mean, you imagine trying to run alongside an F1 car with a
- 24:31probe. I don't think, don't think the
- 24:34FIA can cover that in the budget.
- 24:36But Ferrari are not happy. Ferrari are really not happy.
- 24:43They've lodged a formal complaint with the FIA.
- 24:45The FIA have said, well, what do you want us to do about it?
- 24:48You know, and I, I get where Ferrari are coming from because
- 24:51they had their whole fuel pressure.
- 24:54Yeah, well, yeah, which again? Again, they just built a better
- 24:58measurement. Right, I get I get where Ferrari
- 25:01coming from, but Toto Wolff has turned around and said we'll get
- 25:04your shit together and build a better car then.
- 25:06Like literally the most German response.
- 25:09Change your fucking car. Change your car.
- 25:11I want to change. Your car with you.
- 25:14I love that. Do we, do we really think it's
- 25:17worth null .3 seconds a lap? Do we really think the engine is
- 25:19going to make that much of a difference in a in a year with
- 25:22active aero and reliability? Perhaps some you know a year
- 25:27where Lewis Hamilton is happy in a Ferrari and topping timings
- 25:29already. Well, he's happy in in a Kim.
- 25:39I don't know. I, I feel like, yes, the, like I
- 25:43said before, the focus has very much been put on the engine and
- 25:48I feel like everyone's taken this view that that's where the
- 25:51performance will come from and that's where the difference is
- 25:53going to be made. But actually, when you look at
- 25:56the end of the year, and we spoke about this a lot last
- 25:58year, it was not because McLaren had the most efficient
- 26:02aerodynamics. It was because they had the best
- 26:04tire wear. Fine, yes, aerodynamics was a
- 26:06part to play in that, but it was not exclusively the reason why.
- 26:11And it looked as though at the beginning, yes, fine aero is
- 26:14going to be the big thing. That's why Red Bull was so
- 26:16dominant because they had that really efficient aero package.
- 26:19But toward the end it didn't it and it never ends in the same
- 26:23way that it starts. So I feel like what Nui's doing
- 26:26and not necessarily having that focus and maybe what Ferrari are
- 26:29doing in overly focusing as they always do is not the best
- 26:35approach. Also Ferrari have do this every
- 26:38single time there's a regulation change they and I think the
- 26:42reason they're upset is because they didn't think about doing it
- 26:44themselves. Yeah, we've had this discussion
- 26:48before. I think where the teams that
- 26:51tend to push the legalities like Red Bull and Mercedes might be
- 26:56doing here are the teams whose designers, typically their
- 27:01natural language is English, in which the rules are written, but
- 27:04the rules are written in English by a French person.
- 27:08So there are often these spaces and, and you know, it's the,
- 27:14it's the any old discussion, right?
- 27:15Like to a French person who wrote that rule in English, they
- 27:21mean the same thing, but to an English person, they don't mean
- 27:24the same thing. And I, I do wonder that because
- 27:26it has typically been Mercedes and Red Bull and Williams in the
- 27:29past who have pushed the legalities of stuff.
- 27:31I'm McLaren. I'm McLaren, obviously with the
- 27:35tire water. And Ferrari did.
- 27:37Ferrari tried it and it just blew up in the face.
- 27:40Every time Ferrari try it, they get caught.
- 27:42It's like not again. But yeah, it's, it's typically
- 27:48these, these, and again, you know, these are multi national
- 27:51team, sure, but typically speaking, it's the people who
- 27:55have design chiefs like Adrian Newey, whose natural language is
- 27:58English and they can read around the rules.
- 28:03I, I think I'm, I think you're right.
- 28:04I think it's going to be the team that gets the package
- 28:06right, not the team that gets the engine the best.
- 28:09It's not 2014. These cars aren't slippery
- 28:13rocket ships that just you get out of a corner as quickly as
- 28:16possible and you stamp on the throttle and hope for the best.
- 28:18These are. That's not that anymore.
- 28:19We're not in that era anymore. That's why Seb was so good.
- 28:24I know I was about a Ferrari. He couldn't just throw his foot
- 28:26down. Yeah, well, so that Red Bull era
- 28:29with the blown diffuser, Seb had to jab the brakes and the
- 28:32throttle mid corner, and he was really the only driver he could
- 28:35get on top of that, and that's why he was so good.
- 28:38And then, yeah, like you say, he went to Ferrari and as soon as
- 28:40they brought in just the engine regs, he was nowhere.
- 28:44Then they brought in some Arrow regs, he was back again for a
- 28:46bit. And then he just fell off after
- 28:48Hockenheim 2018. But never mind.
- 28:50I was heartbreaking. I mean, I think regardless of
- 28:58the regs, for me the top three teams this season are going to
- 29:02be Mercedes, Ferrari and Red Bull.
- 29:05I think I agree with you. I think McLaren are going to be
- 29:09one of the sort of mid runners. They're going to be the chasing
- 29:13pack because they've only just got this new engine, right?
- 29:17They they're getting on. Board, they've only just got it
- 29:19and. And they were developing late
- 29:22last year. They did so well last year with
- 29:25the car and everything. I just think this year it's not
- 29:28going to be for them and I think that's probably why maybe
- 29:32Piastry last year was getting a bit peed off at Papyrus and
- 29:35stuff because that was his chance and he knows that this
- 29:38year he has not got a chance. Yeah, I think you're right.
- 29:42I think you're right. And that actually brings me on
- 29:44to my next point, which is I actually do think it's going to
- 29:46be, at least to begin with, much like last year actually, Red
- 29:51Bull taking a few races to get going.
- 29:53You and I have spoken about this before because they were
- 29:56developing late last year because they couldn't believe
- 29:59their SIM work anymore. I think they're going to be a
- 30:01few races behind. I think that's totally OK in a
- 30:03calendar of 20. 425 races, Well, we saw that with the Red Bull
- 30:07this year, but you don't need to be on it over the whole year.
- 30:09But if if, say, Red Bull had just gotten that little bit
- 30:13quicker start towards the start of the season, we could have
- 30:16been seeing a different world champion, of course.
- 30:19So was it their detriment last year?
- 30:22I would say. Yes.
- 30:24No, I think that Red Bull shouldn't have even been allowed
- 30:26in the conversation and that was all the McLaren.
- 30:28Fault. No, I agree.
- 30:29So I mean, Max, Max got really pissy about this right in in
- 30:32interviews at the end of last year and actually.
- 30:34Yeah, they said. Oh, your your thing in Spain is
- 30:37why you lost the championship. And Max was like, no, I
- 30:40shouldn't even be in the championship.
- 30:41And if I weren't in the championship, you wouldn't even
- 30:43be talking about my thing in Spain.
- 30:49This was a failure of the McLaren.
- 30:50Team it was, and I. Don't.
- 30:51And again, they they, they go around saying, oh, Papyrus
- 30:54worked and we redefine how we can perform as a team.
- 31:00No, they didn't. I would pay good money to never
- 31:03hear papyrus again. Agreed.
- 31:05Yeah, I'm. I'm bored of it.
- 31:07Agreed. I'm bored of seeing Zac Brown.
- 31:11I'm bored of seeing Papyrus. I just want to have Lando and
- 31:17Oscar actually race. But do I think that Oscar's
- 31:20going to be good this year? No, because I think I don't know
- 31:24what the car was like in so Oscar's been in F1 three years
- 31:29now, so I think he he started in 2023.
- 31:34I don't know if the car for McLaren was good in 2023,
- 31:36started getting good in 24. It was.
- 31:39It was great. That's that of like McLaren were
- 31:42at the back of the grid and now they're winning the world the
- 31:43constructors championship in 24. The car wasn't was at the back
- 31:48of the grid in Bahrain 23, but only because they both had
- 31:52engine failures in Bahrain. That was the whole steering
- 31:55wheel and the water pressure thing.
- 31:57They were actually sort of bottom of the top 10 by the
- 32:00second race. So I, I, I disagree with that
- 32:03start a lot because everybody focuses in on Bahrain 23 because
- 32:07they finished dead last. Yeah, Lando pitted 6 times
- 32:10because of a water pressure thing and Oscar Piastre had his
- 32:12steering wheel do a reboot right mid pit stop.
- 32:16Of course, they finished last, but they qualified 10th and
- 32:1811th, so it's not the same thing.
- 32:22But but no, I mean it was a midfield car, yes.
- 32:25Do you think I'm, I'm just intrigued to see how Oscar, now
- 32:29he's got a few years racing down how he performs with a mid car.
- 32:35That's what I'm I'm sort of intrigued to see, yeah.
- 32:42Is he going to be better than Lando?
- 32:44Is he is he going to be worse? You know, he could if if he's
- 32:48better than Lando, I'll give him his fair credit.
- 32:50Yeah. But I think last year we saw the
- 32:52frustration affect his performance.
- 32:55Yeah, I think it's gonna be hang on, hang.
- 32:56On hang on. Sorry, can I jump in the
- 32:58frustration? So he was better than Lando at
- 33:01the start of the year. The reason you decided not to
- 33:03like him was because you found him boring because he wasn't
- 33:05getting frustrated. And now here we go that, oh, the
- 33:08frustration made him worse. I just think everyone called him
- 33:12Mr. Cool, like he's like level headed and all this lot.
- 33:15And then we see was it at Baku where he didn't qualify well and
- 33:20then he was trying to overtake false start or whatever and then
- 33:24he just crashes. And we we do see Lando also just
- 33:27losing this opportunity like he could have.
- 33:29Losing places on the grids. Wasn't this?
- 33:32Wasn't this also after Oscar had was forced to give his world
- 33:36championship rival a place for no reason initially?
- 33:39I So this is how I see it, right, is why did Lando do that?
- 33:44Lando was not sort of aggressive enough.
- 33:49He should have been like in that race.
- 33:51No, I want to pit first. This is.
- 33:53My race, yeah. And we've had this discussion
- 33:54we've had. That we're not.
- 33:55We don't. Want to Why did he give it away?
- 33:58We already, we already had a couple of comments on our shorts
- 34:01about how we hate McLaren. So let's not, let's not I.
- 34:03Wonder who that's from? Yeah, my brother.
- 34:08Yeah, no, I'm, I'm intrigued to see how McLaren does this year,
- 34:11but I wouldn't be against that as a McLaren fan.
- 34:15I wouldn't be against him not winning as many races just so I
- 34:17don't have to see Zac Brown. Brilliant, brilliant.
- 34:21Lando. So, yeah, I mean, I think it's
- 34:24reading in between the lines there.
- 34:25We both, we all think that Ferrari and Mercedes will be up
- 34:29there, Red Bull will get up there and I think McLaren next
- 34:34in line. I think Ferrari will have a
- 34:35great first two races and then just decay as you.
- 34:38Sure. It's going to the title fight I
- 34:41think between Mercedes and Ferrari for the constructors.
- 34:47OK, I can't see Isaac Kajar doing.
- 34:51I think Red Bull's still going to be a one man team.
- 34:54Great Mercedes that you've got Mr. Consistency, which is why I
- 34:59think George Russell for the championship drivers
- 35:03championship, I think he's just going to be consistent
- 35:05throughout the whole time. Kimi Antonelli started to get
- 35:09better last season, but if he has another wobble like he did?
- 35:13I can see him being podiums, but not not consistent victories.
- 35:16I mean, maybe he will won this victory this year.
- 35:19I agree and I think he will wobble for two or three races in
- 35:23the middle of the year. But he's also, we've got to
- 35:25remember he's 19 years old and it's his only second season and
- 35:29he was thrown in immediately at Mercedes.
- 35:31So like it's like it's a lot of respect if he, if he's not
- 35:35finishing outside the top five consistently, I think he's doing
- 35:38a good job. If Ferrari have a good car, they
- 35:42should win the constructors with the with the drivers.
- 35:45They've Let's go. They should win the constructors
- 35:48if they have a good car and if they change their strategy
- 35:51because their strategy is what lost them last year.
- 35:54OK, lost them a lot of points. Red Bull.
- 35:58It's just going to be Max so. I think they have also, I think
- 36:03Ferrari have cleaned up a lot in terms of their race team, in
- 36:08terms of strategy, in terms of whatever.
- 36:10I think that's what that's Fred's big impact.
- 36:13I also think with Mercedes, Mercedes need to realize that
- 36:18sort of Russell is the main driver and if he wants to be
- 36:23ahead of Antonelli because he thinks he can do better than
- 36:27Antonelli, then he should be just given that straight away.
- 36:30Like, OK, you go for it. And they need to trust him more
- 36:33because I don't think he's sort of given them any reason not to
- 36:36do like, distrust him. Which is why the the fact that
- 36:39it took so long for them to get the contract sorted was so weird
- 36:43because there was this whole is Max going to be available?
- 36:46Is Max not going to be available?
- 36:48Max, please come and work for us.
- 36:49Max. And then it was like, what?
- 36:52Like I agree with you, I think George has not ever given
- 36:55Mercedes a reason to hesitate, yet they still seem to hesitate,
- 37:00whereas they wouldn't have done that with Lewis.
- 37:03Yes. So then if we go into midfield.
- 37:08Runners well, so midfield runners.
- 37:10I think McLaren will be in the midfield.
- 37:11Runners at the top at the top along with Aston Martin.
- 37:15Aston Martin Williams, I want to say.
- 37:19I want to say Williams, but I have no proof.
- 37:21And then I also want to say Alpine.
- 37:24What about that? I say Alpine.
- 37:26I don't want to say. I don't want to say I want.
- 37:28To say it's going to be race symbols, hopefully Williams,
- 37:33Aston, but McLaren's going to. Be free.
- 37:36So we've got the three at the top, then McLaren and Aston.
- 37:40You want to say Williams? I agree with you and racing
- 37:43Bulls I'm not so sure with with Liam Lawson and Harvard Limblad
- 37:49the rookie. And they've lost.
- 37:50Him, I'm not so sure about that. I I feel what you're putting
- 37:53down based on last couple of years, but I'm not sure I agree
- 37:56with you. Yeah, but then.
- 37:58I want to say Alpine because Gasly has been chefing and
- 38:03they've got a misleading. I do.
- 38:04I do like Gasly. I do like Gasly.
- 38:08But that, I mean, we're running out of midfield slots, right?
- 38:11How long do we think Carla Pinto's the last time?
- 38:13Franco Cola Pinto, I think he's no, I agree.
- 38:16But you've got to you've got to have AI.
- 38:18Don't think Gasly is going to be perform well enough to be in
- 38:24that midfield, I think. I think Gasly will, maybe not
- 38:27Alpine. I think Limblad and Lawson are
- 38:30potentially. OK, so if we take, if we take
- 38:34three at the top, so we want five in the middle and then
- 38:37another three, right? That's correct.
- 38:40So OK, I'll be, I'll I'll bite, I'll be.
- 38:43And then the one that bridges the gap, let's say Alpine,
- 38:46because I think you're right. I think Colour Pinto will be at
- 38:48the back. Yes.
- 38:49And then I think Gasly. Will have enough to to bring him
- 38:52in and then Haas and then it's kind of between the newcomers,
- 38:56right? I think.
- 38:57I think if Haas are last, that's a failure from Haas, but I I
- 39:02don't think they'll hit the ground running well because of
- 39:06the lack of the lack of SIM stuff with the Toyota business
- 39:09that's going on. I.
- 39:10Think I think the expectation that the two newbies are at the
- 39:13back is sensible and not offensive.
- 39:16I think it'll be a successful season for either Audi or
- 39:20Cadillac if they are not last or if they exceed one of the teams
- 39:24that are already out there. Oh.
- 39:26I mean, let's be honest. So Audi?
- 39:29Audi should beat Alpine based on a track record that kick have
- 39:33been beating Arpin. Yeah, late, yeah.
- 39:36But it is a completely new team behind that.
- 39:40You know, it's a new engine, it's a new platform.
- 39:43It's a bunch of experienced people poached from other teams
- 39:45who have never necessarily worked together.
- 39:48There will be translatory problems.
- 39:49So they need to beat Cadillac. If either one of those teams
- 39:53beats an established F1 team, that established F1 team should
- 39:55quit. Yeah, yeah, and and has.
- 40:00I know we always look at Haas like sort of, but they have now
- 40:05been in the sport for nearly a decade.
- 40:08This is their 11th season over a decade now.
- 40:11Bloody hell. Or 12th season, yeah.
- 40:14So over a decade. 2015, Yeah, over a decade.
- 40:18I thought it was 2016. So yeah, either way, either way,
- 40:21this is a decade, A decade, a decade.
- 40:25And I mean, that's their highest finishing position is 4th, 4th
- 40:28or 5th, 4th, I think, and pole position in in Brazil when it
- 40:34was an absolute bucket rain down.
- 40:37So and 4th. They only got 4th last year with
- 40:40Olly Berman. So yeah.
- 40:43So they you know, it's now if they don't if they don't do well
- 40:48this year, Toyota need to buy that team.
- 40:50I know, I know, we spent a good while in the last podcast
- 40:53talking about how Toyota aren't going to buy that team, but they
- 40:56should. I think it's more that Gene has
- 40:59always been very clear that he doesn't really want them to be a
- 41:05brilliant race team and has not given the money.
- 41:14There's not been the injection that the team needs in order to
- 41:17reach the level, the other level that we kind of would want to
- 41:21see as racing people. But that's just not the model
- 41:23that they're going for. Yeah, and at that point, I
- 41:26agree. I think just go away, give up,
- 41:30go away and have Hass be a main sponsor.
- 41:32I'm very conscious about episode length and it's lunchtime and
- 41:36it's lunchtime, but just a couple of things that happened
- 41:40over the Christmas break. Max Verstappen is rumoured to be
- 41:43leaving Red Bull I. Don't think he's going to but.
- 41:46He's been rumoured he's been leaving Red Bull for a year and
- 41:48a half. Mikey said as long as he's got a
- 41:49fast character, stick around. I agree.
- 41:50He also said there's a lot of things that need to come
- 41:52together for him to make a change from Red Bull.
- 41:55Max is Red Bull. Agreed Jack Doing left Alpine.
- 42:01Completely understandable. Going to get any time as a house
- 42:04reserve driver. Agreed, but he is also rumoured
- 42:07to be part of the Toyota backed Super Formula team so I think
- 42:11that's the tie there. And the topic that Katie's been
- 42:20dying to talk about. So hover your finger over the
- 42:23stop recording button because is that Lewis Hamilton is
- 42:28supposedly dating Kim Kardashian.
- 42:31This is why I think that Ferrari gonna win this year.
- 42:35We have Kris Jenner, the absolute monitor of the century.
- 42:40Yeah, Hamilton said. Any management?
- 42:42In all serious though, if they if they do start dating,
- 42:46obviously I'm happy for them, but I don't want it to turn into
- 42:50the Super Bowl where we're just seeing pictures of Taylor Swift
- 42:54or in this case, Kim Kardashian in the garage, I think.
- 42:58What that's my favorite part by race weekends is watching
- 43:01Alexandria Aaron. We are that that weekend that
- 43:05you came to my house, we watched the Moto GP and then the F1 and
- 43:10because 1/2 of Moto GP are Spanish riders.
- 43:13And it was in Spain. They've all and yeah, they've
- 43:16all got Spanish girlfriends who all look exactly identical to
- 43:20Carlos Sainz's partner. And then we watched the F1 where
- 43:24they kept and Charlie Claire's partner who weirdly look alike,
- 43:27then yes, they do. No, they spent the entire time
- 43:31looking at their partners and we're just like, man, we have
- 43:33watched like, no racing. It's just been girlfriends and
- 43:35wives. Yeah, it was fantastic.
- 43:37I think my favorite, my favorite, we came for a while
- 43:39just. Brings in the the bigger issue
- 43:41of the coverage of F1 I think sometimes LAX.
- 43:45It's poor. Yeah, but this is.
- 43:46But this is the whole argument about bringing more people into
- 43:49the sport. It's a lot easier.
- 43:51I mean, look at. It's a lot easier when you've
- 43:53got attractive women on the screen.
- 43:55Tim, how very 1990s of you. No, I'm saying it's it's easier
- 43:58to watch that rather than have some really technical analysis
- 44:01of. What happens?
- 44:03I'm impressed You have a monopoly on F1 in this country
- 44:05and their motto is it's only live once, right?
- 44:08Great. But Carlos Sainz's girlfriend is
- 44:09not only live once. And I'm also talking about
- 44:12there's sometimes last year in qualifying where it took like
- 44:16half of the first qualifier in Q1 to get the actual times up on
- 44:22the on the screen. Yeah, like, and also how many of
- 44:26those reactions are indeed to whatever it was that just
- 44:28happened, right? Because sometimes it'll be like
- 44:30Carlos makes a mistake and then it'll flick to a shot of his
- 44:33girlfriend, right. But the screen that she's
- 44:35watching hasn't yet shown Carlos making a mistake.
- 44:38So is that reaction genuine or is that just a shot that they
- 44:41had of Carlos Sainz's girlfriend?
- 44:42I agree. Look, I think talking about
- 44:44broadcasting standards is a very valid conversation and I think
- 44:47from a racing point of view it has been poor.
- 44:49But also, I think saying OK, we had to watch Carlos Sainz's
- 44:52girlfriend for three seconds in the middle of the race is not
- 44:54the biggest problem for the broadcasting standards
- 44:57perspective. It's not.
- 44:58And, you know, I agree with Katie.
- 45:00I don't want, I don't want, you know, F1 to turn into whatever
- 45:04the Kardashians program is. But equally I think it's
- 45:09probably quite a good thing for the sport.
- 45:13I don't think it'll have as much impact as Taylor Swift in the
- 45:16NFL because I don't think Kim Kardashian has that bigger
- 45:18impact as Taylor Swift. But I think it could potentially
- 45:22bring new new sort of watching group to F1, which.
- 45:30Because we needed more of those, right?
- 45:33TLH. TLH is.
- 45:35Growing something Well this week?
- 45:38I don't know. Oh, I've not been.
- 45:40I've not followed that for a long time.
- 45:42Yeah. I'm excited to see the different
- 45:45episodes. I think we've already talked
- 45:46about this. There's going to be an episode
- 45:48on obviously the whole Lando versus Oscar.
- 45:51Lando. There'll be.
- 45:54Lots of lando. Christian Horner episode.
- 45:58Imagine if it was Lando in a mouse case.
- 46:00In the most case. Lando.
- 46:05No, yeah, I agree. I agree.
- 46:07That's pretty much all I have to talk about.
- 46:09So if we're done with Kim K, then we are done with this
- 46:11week's episode. KB KB KB.
- 46:17Thank you again to Katie for joining us for essentially 2
- 46:21weeks in a row now and I'm honoured.
- 46:24Thanks for Tim for making it through 2 back-to-back episodes.
- 46:29Yeah, yeah. Thanks.
- 46:30The next, the next. Happy to be back.
- 46:33We will be with Jake and we will be talking about Moto GP,
- 46:37basically the same topics that we've just talked about here
- 46:40about Moto GPS season starting. I'm not sure whether Tim's
- 46:43coming to that one or not. I guess we'll find out.
- 46:47We'll find out, but we have got a lot planned and we're hoping
- 46:51to be a lot more consistent this year.
- 46:53Is that fair to say? That is fair.
- 46:55That's my goal, this. Year The road to hell is paved
- 46:57with good intentions. Weekly releases and shorter
- 47:02topics, but in in sort of. In more.
- 47:05Fewer topics in more depth, shorter bytes of information.
- 47:10Perfect. See you next week.
- 47:13Peace, Peace.