Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Housing Shortage in Kentucky
Transcript
- 0:05[MUSIC]
- 0:05Good evening, and welcome to
- 0:07Kentucky tonight. I'm Renee
- 0:08Shaw. It's good to be back with
- 0:10you for Kentucky tonight. We
- 0:11appreciate you joining us this
- 0:12evening. Our topic the housing
- 0:14shortage in Kentucky Kentucky
- 0:16needs more than 200,000 housing
- 0:18units, according to recent
- 0:20analysis, to meet the demand.
- 0:22And it will only get worse.
- 0:23There are predictions the state
- 0:24will be 287,000 units short by
- 0:28the year 2029. Single family
- 0:30home and rental prices have
- 0:32increased sharply over the last
- 0:33few years, and the state had
- 0:35about 5800 homeless people in
- 0:382024. During this 60 day
- 0:40legislative session, Kentucky
- 0:41lawmakers are considering
- 0:43policies to ease the housing
- 0:44crisis. And we're going to talk
- 0:46about some of those ideas
- 0:47tonight. We have some of those
- 0:49lawmakers with us, along with
- 0:50other housing advocates and
- 0:52interest groups in our
- 0:53Frankfort studio. We welcome
- 0:54State Senator Robbie Mills, a
- 0:56Republican from Henderson,
- 0:58Senate Majority Caucus chair
- 1:00and co-chair of the Kentucky
- 1:01Housing Task Force. In our
- 1:03Lexington studio, we're joined
- 1:04by Wendy Smith deputy executive
- 1:06director of housing programs at
- 1:08the Kentucky Housing
- 1:09Corporation, J.D. Chaney
- 1:11executive director and CEO of
- 1:13the Kentucky League of Cities,
- 1:14and State Representative Joshua
- 1:16Watkins, a Louisville Democrat
- 1:18and member of the Kentucky
- 1:19Housing Task Force. And in our
- 1:21studios in Louisville. State
- 1:23Representative Susan Whitten, a
- 1:24Republican from Louisville and
- 1:26co-chair of the Kentucky
- 1:27Housing Task Force and George
- 1:29Eklund director of education
- 1:30and advocacy at the coalition
- 1:33for the homeless. We appreciate
- 1:34all of them for being with us
- 1:36tonight. And of course, we want
- 1:37to hear from you. You can send
- 1:39us your questions and comments.
- 1:40By X. Formerly known as Twitter,
- 1:42at Pub Affairs KET or send an
- 1:44email to KY Tonight at Keturah
- 1:47or use the web form at Keturah
- 1:50Jessica KY tonight. Or you can
- 1:52simply give us a call at one
- 1:57(800) 494-7605. Well, thank you
- 1:58to all of our guests for being
- 1:59here. We had this program
- 2:01scheduled last week and Mother
- 2:03Nature had different plans. So
- 2:05we appreciate all of you being
- 2:07accommodating and adjusting
- 2:08your schedules to be with us.
- 2:09We're going to kind of break a
- 2:11little news tonight, Senator
- 2:12Robby Mills, because a few
- 2:14hours ago, around 130 this
- 2:17afternoon, you presented and
- 2:18filed your House Bill nine. And
- 2:20I want you to tell us about
- 2:22that bill. And then we're going
- 2:23to kind of go back a little bit
- 2:25and talk about the task force
- 2:27and other recommendations. What
- 2:28does the measure do that you
- 2:29filed today, sir?
- 2:30>> Well, Renee, thank you so
- 2:32much for having us on tonight
- 2:33and talking about housing. It's
- 2:34such an important issue across
- 2:36the Commonwealth. Today, I
- 2:38filed Senate Bill nine that
- 2:41actually gives local
- 2:43governments a couple of tools
- 2:45to work with their local
- 2:48developers to hopefully get
- 2:50housing starts going again in
- 2:52their communities all across
- 2:55Kentucky. And basically what
- 2:57Senate Bill nine does is it
- 2:59creates what we're calling a
- 3:01residential infrastructure
- 3:02development district, which
- 3:04actually gives local
- 3:05governments the power to issue
- 3:07bonds to pay for infrastructure
- 3:09costs. One of the things that
- 3:11in our housing task force that
- 3:14we heard is that there might be
- 3:16developers sitting off to the
- 3:17side and not developing
- 3:19property because of some of the
- 3:21big, larger costs that are
- 3:23involved in infrastructure
- 3:26water, water lines, sewer lines,
- 3:29pumps that take water to and
- 3:30from the the streets, gutters,
- 3:34curbs, all those things are
- 3:35huge costs to a developer that
- 3:37they have to put into a piece
- 3:39of land before a house can
- 3:41actually be developed as a
- 3:43subdivision or a single lot. So
- 3:46this bill gives that tool to a
- 3:50local developer to negotiate
- 3:52with the with the local
- 3:54government and makes those
- 3:56costs paid upfront. Another
- 3:58thing that it does is it
- 4:00creates what we're calling
- 4:01housing development districts.
- 4:03And this also gives local
- 4:05governments the ability to
- 4:07negotiate with developers in
- 4:09their community and helps them
- 4:11possibly rebate back some or
- 4:14all of the property tax for
- 4:17several years after the house
- 4:18is built. We really think that
- 4:21these two tools put in the
- 4:24right hands of local government
- 4:26to do what's right and best for
- 4:28their area could very well see
- 4:31several hundred new homes built
- 4:33over the next year and be
- 4:35compounded over over time where
- 4:37we're we're we'll be adding
- 4:38hundreds of homes in the future.
- 4:42>> J.D. Chaney you're with the
- 4:43Kentucky League of Cities, and
- 4:44I know you have a good partner
- 4:46with counties, and you've
- 4:47probably heard a little bit
- 4:48about House Bill nine. What are
- 4:50your initial thoughts about it?
- 4:51>> We appreciate, Senator Mills
- 4:52for carrying that piece of
- 4:54legislation. It's something we
- 4:56worked as a broader coalition
- 4:57on with with the Kentucky
- 5:00Chamber of Commerce, the Home
- 5:01Builders Association, and
- 5:03others, because it really
- 5:05identifies what one of the key
- 5:06obstacles are to to housing
- 5:09development, and that is
- 5:10infrastructure, infrastructure
- 5:11costs. It's a big impediment
- 5:13for us. It has a it has a much
- 5:15outsized role in in what's
- 5:19holding holding it back. We
- 5:21have caps from the division of
- 5:23water with, with regard to
- 5:26connections and things of that
- 5:27nature. But this is a great
- 5:29tool. It's worked well in
- 5:30Indiana and I think it'll work
- 5:31well. A similar program, I
- 5:33think it'll work well here. And
- 5:34it's about partnerships. At the
- 5:36end of the day, it's about the
- 5:37state being partners with their
- 5:39local governments and making
- 5:41community based decisions on
- 5:42how this will go.
- 5:43>> Representative Whitten, what
- 5:44are your thoughts about this?
- 5:45Any downsides to this idea? Do
- 5:48you see?
- 5:51>> I really don't see a
- 5:52downside. I think this is
- 5:54wonderful. I'm really excited
- 5:56about Senator Mills bill. Just
- 5:58like JD said, this has been
- 6:01done on the the Residential
- 6:04infrastructure Fund has been
- 6:05done in Indiana for the last 3
- 6:08or 4 years with incredible
- 6:10success. And as somebody who
- 6:11lives in Louisville, who, you
- 6:13know, competes with Indiana
- 6:15right across the river, I'm
- 6:17seeing the fruits of that
- 6:19infrastructure fund that they
- 6:21have taken advantage of. And I
- 6:23really want Kentucky and
- 6:26Kentuckians to take advantage
- 6:27of of what Indiana has been
- 6:29doing the last couple of years.
- 6:30So I'm really excited about it.
- 6:32>> Wendy Smith what are your
- 6:34thoughts? We should follow
- 6:35Indiana.
- 6:36>> Fresh for me. Yeah, but we
- 6:37were a big proponent of the
- 6:39residential infrastructure fund
- 6:40that Indiana has and that the
- 6:42task force looked into. My one
- 6:44concern with this is small
- 6:48cities might have a hard time
- 6:49setting up, you know, kind of a
- 6:51complex structure and the
- 6:53bonding and just wanting to see
- 6:54how they get some technical
- 6:55assistance to make sure they're
- 6:57able to make it happen.
- 6:58>> Right. Representative
- 6:59Watkins, your thoughts?
- 7:00>> Well, I think it's I like it.
- 7:03It's what I'm going to consider
- 7:05like I'm going to compare it to
- 7:06like having ice cream. What's
- 7:08more than one scoop of ice
- 7:10cream? What's better than
- 7:11having two. So I think it's
- 7:12really great. I want to see
- 7:14more done in the realm of
- 7:15housing. I want us to see more
- 7:17on funding some more
- 7:18developments. I love the tools
- 7:19that we're giving local
- 7:20governments, but I believe that
- 7:22the work in the task force has
- 7:23proven that we need to spend a
- 7:25little bit of money in the
- 7:27Commonwealth to make sure that
- 7:28we're getting the supply we
- 7:29need for everyday people.
- 7:30>> Before I go to Mr. Ecklund,
- 7:32I want to go back to Senator
- 7:34Mills and ask, you know, to
- 7:35Miss Smith's point about how
- 7:36would this impact smaller
- 7:37businesses or smaller local
- 7:38governments and cities who may
- 7:40not have this kind of template
- 7:41with something like that be
- 7:42provided to help them get off
- 7:44the ground with this kind of
- 7:46idea?
- 7:47>> Yeah, I think we can
- 7:48actually take this. You know,
- 7:51she's exactly right. This is
- 7:52more geared toward larger
- 7:54developments. You know, the
- 7:56infrastructure, the residential
- 7:57infrastructure development
- 7:59district is required, a $5
- 8:01million investment on five plus
- 8:04acres. But I think we could
- 8:05actually shorten this down to
- 8:08smaller rural communities that
- 8:09are looking to add a street of
- 8:1215 homes or a smaller 25 home
- 8:16development. The interesting
- 8:18thing about Kentucky is our
- 8:20geography is so diverse. We've
- 8:23got small communities that need
- 8:25homes like Henderson County,
- 8:27but we haven't had a lot of
- 8:29homes built and we just had a
- 8:30large development come in in
- 8:32the last couple of years, and
- 8:33they've seen a lot of success.
- 8:35I also represent Webster and
- 8:37Union County, which if they had
- 8:38a couple of streets developed
- 8:40of new homes, that would be
- 8:42that would be a Boone to their
- 8:44community. So I think, you know,
- 8:45this is step number one. This
- 8:47bill costs nothing to our
- 8:49budget. I think in the future
- 8:51you're going to see some budget
- 8:52language where we're asking for
- 8:54money for affordable housing
- 8:56and for for a revolving loan
- 9:00fund. But these development
- 9:02districts are free tools that
- 9:04local governments can have that
- 9:06want to negotiate and work with
- 9:07their developers. So, you know,
- 9:09I'm wide open to trying to
- 9:12customize this to fit a smaller
- 9:14community as much as it does a
- 9:16larger community.
- 9:18>> Mr. George Eklund there in
- 9:19Louisville, tell us your
- 9:20thoughts about this. Where do
- 9:21you stand on this particular
- 9:23provision and Bill?
- 9:27>> You know, I think this is a
- 9:29really important piece of the
- 9:30puzzle, like when we look at
- 9:31the entire housing continuum
- 9:33where we have rising
- 9:34homelessness, we have people
- 9:35that are struggling to find
- 9:36places to rent. We have people
- 9:38that are struggling to find
- 9:39their first time home buyer
- 9:40option, like we need to look at
- 9:42the friction points along the
- 9:43housing continuum and really
- 9:44cater policies to address those.
- 9:46How can we grease the skids?
- 9:48How can we reduce regulation?
- 9:49How can we incentivize? How can
- 9:51we get more housing subsidy to
- 9:53build more units that more
- 9:55waitresses can afford, more
- 9:56pre-K teachers can afford, and
- 9:57more medical professionals can
- 9:59afford here in Kentucky. So I
- 10:01think this is an incredibly
- 10:02important piece of the puzzle,
- 10:04especially when you put it in
- 10:05context. The whole task force
- 10:06and the recommendations that
- 10:07they put forth.
- 10:08>> Yeah. Thank you. Didn't mean
- 10:10to cut you off there. And let's
- 10:11talk about some of that
- 10:13regulatory reform. And maybe
- 10:15Representative Whitten can can
- 10:16join in now because we know
- 10:17these bills are still being
- 10:18filed. There's still some time
- 10:20to do that. What other ideas do
- 10:22you have from a regulatory
- 10:24perspective that you may file
- 10:25or that you know could be filed
- 10:26this legislative session?
- 10:31Representative Whitten sure.
- 10:32>> When we were talking in the
- 10:33in the task force, yes. When we
- 10:37were talking the task force, we
- 10:39really tried to organize the
- 10:42the the bills in mainly three
- 10:44buckets, like planning and
- 10:46zoning, building codes,
- 10:49regulatory and inspection and
- 10:50then the funding piece. And so
- 10:53I'm I'm still working on a
- 10:54couple bills that that address
- 10:58both of those that address the
- 11:00planning and zoning, and then
- 11:02one that addresses the building
- 11:04code piece. One is is kind of
- 11:08adjusting the building code to,
- 11:10to make multi small
- 11:13multi-family buildings more
- 11:15affordable to build. Because
- 11:17that is a big issue is that
- 11:19when when we are overregulated
- 11:22and our developers and our
- 11:23builders, when everything costs
- 11:25more to them, those prices are
- 11:27going to go towards Kentuckians
- 11:30and they're just going to pay
- 11:31more. So if we can, while
- 11:33obviously while keeping
- 11:34everything safe to try to
- 11:37deregulate a little bit and,
- 11:38and be able to build less
- 11:42expensively than, than that's
- 11:43what we're going to try to do.
- 11:45>> Representative Watkins, do
- 11:46you have any concerns about
- 11:48regulatory reform that perhaps
- 11:49it would affect the quality of
- 11:51homes?
- 11:51>> Absolutely. I do, and I
- 11:53think we're hearing from some
- 11:54of our other trades
- 11:55professionals and public safety
- 11:56professionals. I immediately go
- 11:57to firefighters, for example,
- 11:59and there's a bill, I think,
- 12:00that talks about single
- 12:03stairwells and whatnot. And I
- 12:04want to be in favor of all
- 12:06tools in the toolbox. But when
- 12:07I think about having a building
- 12:09potentially be six storeys high
- 12:11and not having to have another
- 12:13exit point, I think about a
- 12:15firefighter rushing in and a
- 12:16person running out in the
- 12:18stairwell. To me, that that
- 12:19already gives me anxiety just
- 12:21saying it. But even deeper than
- 12:22that, in some of those places
- 12:25you have to have a specific
- 12:26type of truck to a ladder truck
- 12:28to get to some of those higher
- 12:30buildings. And some of our
- 12:31cities and small cities and
- 12:32counties can't even afford to
- 12:34upkeep the vehicles that they
- 12:35have right now. So that is a
- 12:37thing that comes to mind. And
- 12:39from my local government
- 12:40experience, I believe that
- 12:41regulations should be adaptable.
- 12:43But I think that sometimes if
- 12:45they if they're done too
- 12:46quickly, they can sacrifice
- 12:48quality and safety.
- 12:49>> What are your concerns?
- 12:51>> J.D. Chaney on the on the
- 12:52regulatory. Regulatory front,
- 12:53we are working collaboratively
- 12:55with Representative Whitton on
- 12:57some of the planning and zoning
- 12:59reforms. We've we've been an
- 13:00advocate for our local
- 13:02governments to look at their
- 13:03individual land use policy.
- 13:04It's so intimately local land
- 13:07use law here in Kentucky. And
- 13:09as Senator Mills pointed out,
- 13:11every community is different.
- 13:12Every demographics, geography
- 13:15and things of that nature. But
- 13:17our local governments are
- 13:18looking at those things. Many
- 13:19of them have already allowed
- 13:21high density development in
- 13:23places where it's it's a good
- 13:25place we want to do we want to
- 13:26be a partner. But at the same
- 13:28time, you know, there's
- 13:29reticence with regard to trying
- 13:30to do a one size fits all when
- 13:33Kentucky communities are so are
- 13:34so diverse. But I think we can
- 13:37we can work through work
- 13:39through some of those issues in
- 13:40order to to address that for
- 13:42best practices. And we're
- 13:44seeing what other cities cities
- 13:46are doing generally. Does that
- 13:48get to the affordability issue?
- 13:50Probably. Probably not as well.
- 13:52I mean, just removing
- 13:54regulations is a small piece of
- 13:55the puzzle. You're probably
- 13:57going to see higher, higher
- 13:59income developments be
- 14:02developed. It's a small piece
- 14:03of the puzzle when we're
- 14:04dealing with construction costs,
- 14:06financing costs, labor
- 14:08shortages and infrastructure.
- 14:09Like we mentioned before, that
- 14:11should be done again on a
- 14:13mainly on a local level.
- 14:15>> Senator Mills, I want to I
- 14:17want to come back to you
- 14:19because today during your press
- 14:20conference, you know, you
- 14:21talked about renters who are
- 14:23paying 1600 and $1,700 a month
- 14:25in just rent. And the
- 14:28affordability issue is probably
- 14:29crucial to this discussion more
- 14:31than anything else. I'd like to
- 14:33get your thoughts on that. And
- 14:34does your bill really address
- 14:35the affordability concerns?
- 14:38>> Yeah, I mean, it does it
- 14:41does. Because, you know, when
- 14:43people actually own a home,
- 14:46they're building equity in a
- 14:47home. I think that makes them
- 14:49good, better citizens, that
- 14:51makes them connected more to
- 14:53their community. So that's what
- 14:55this, you know, my bill does is
- 14:57hopefully will make homes
- 15:00available, whether they're
- 15:01single family homes, duplexes,
- 15:03triplexes something that people
- 15:04can actually own a part in
- 15:07versus renting. I think some of
- 15:09the frustration of the housing
- 15:12challenges that are out there
- 15:13right now is that, you know,
- 15:15rents are going up. The people
- 15:16that are paying the rent aren't
- 15:18making any equity in that
- 15:20property, and they just kind of
- 15:21feel like they're dumping their
- 15:22money down the drain. So, you
- 15:24know, if we can move people to
- 15:26homeownership, I think that's a
- 15:27great step. You know, we we do
- 15:30need rental property,
- 15:32reasonably priced rental
- 15:34property. But in order to have
- 15:35that, you know, landlords have
- 15:37to make a profit. They're
- 15:40seeing costs increasing as well.
- 15:42Property taxes are going up.
- 15:44Building costs are going up.
- 15:45Repair costs, you know, heating
- 15:47and air, electrical, all those
- 15:48things are rising. So it's a
- 15:51unfortunately it's a perfect
- 15:52storm. But I think if we can
- 15:53move people to homeownership, I
- 15:56think that starts making people
- 15:58think that their money is going
- 15:59somewhere. And that gives them
- 16:01a better feeling about, you
- 16:02know, what they're paying for
- 16:04housing.
- 16:04>> George Eklund I want to come
- 16:06to you and ask you about the
- 16:08affordability issue, because
- 16:09perhaps some of the population
- 16:10you deal with, they are not
- 16:11even thinking about owning a
- 16:12home. They're just trying to
- 16:14maintain their their rental
- 16:15space. Right. So talk to us
- 16:17about where you see the
- 16:18conversation needing to go when
- 16:20it comes to affordability.
- 16:24>> Yeah I think for us like
- 16:26every day I talk to case
- 16:27managers that are trying to
- 16:28work to get people that are
- 16:30homeless back into housing. And
- 16:31I can't tell you how many times
- 16:33that they run into barriers
- 16:34that they're navigating by
- 16:36through the application process,
- 16:37but also they just cannot find
- 16:39places that a voucher will
- 16:41cover. We see Louisville having
- 16:43some of the fastest growing
- 16:44rents in the country, and every
- 16:46time we see the average rent go
- 16:49up $100, we see a pretty
- 16:52noticeable increase in
- 16:53homelessness by 5 or 6%. So at
- 16:56the end of the day, like we are
- 16:58looking for more units that we
- 16:59can rent for, you know, 800,
- 17:01$900 a month where we just
- 17:03don't see those on the market.
- 17:04So like anything that's going
- 17:05to increase supply of rental
- 17:07options, that I can use a
- 17:09voucher to get somebody that
- 17:10has been, you know, a victim of
- 17:14domestic violence, somebody who
- 17:15is trying to go to college but
- 17:17cannot afford the rent,
- 17:18somebody who is trying to
- 17:20maintain sobriety but just
- 17:23needs a place to to call home a
- 17:25foundation stone, if you will
- 17:27like. That is what we need at
- 17:28the end of the day here. And so
- 17:30any policies, any initiatives
- 17:32that are going to increase
- 17:33supply for those that are
- 17:34earning the least amount in our
- 17:36communities, that's what we
- 17:37need from my point of view.
- 17:38>> Yeah. Wendy, I'd like to ask
- 17:40you your thoughts on this.
- 17:41>> Yeah. Thank you. Renee, I
- 17:43want to just piggyback on what
- 17:44George has said, and it relates
- 17:46to what Senator Mills has
- 17:47talked about. This is a part of
- 17:49a continuum, a housing
- 17:50continuum or housing market,
- 17:51however you want to think about
- 17:52it. And that connects from
- 17:55homeowners all the way down to
- 17:56people who are at risk of or
- 17:58experiencing homelessness. And
- 17:59it all gets back to supply. So
- 18:01any of these bills that will
- 18:04contribute to more housing
- 18:06being developed, that is a good
- 18:08thing. So that might range from,
- 18:10you know, regulatory barriers
- 18:13being stripped down to funding
- 18:15to financing options. We really
- 18:18need everything. There's not 1
- 18:20or 2 solutions that are going
- 18:22to get at this. It has got to
- 18:23be kind of a menu of all
- 18:26options on deck, because when
- 18:28homeowners do have options that
- 18:29they can afford, they're going
- 18:31to free up a rental unit for a
- 18:33middle or upper income person
- 18:35who is no longer going to rent
- 18:37the unit. They really didn't
- 18:38want that, then pushed out a
- 18:39lower income person, and so on
- 18:41and so on. There is a filtering
- 18:43up and down when there's plenty
- 18:44of supply. People can filter up.
- 18:47When there's not enough, they
- 18:48filter down and they spend more
- 18:50of their income on housing that
- 18:51isn't even meeting their needs.
- 18:53So I just think it's really
- 18:54important to think about the
- 18:56array of solutions that the
- 18:57legislature is proposing,
- 18:58because we really need an array
- 19:00and not 1 or 2 solutions.
- 19:03>> Representative Watkins, last
- 19:04year you filed a bill to use
- 19:05some of the money in the
- 19:07state's rainy day fund to
- 19:08address the housing crisis. It
- 19:09was called the Kentucky Housing
- 19:11Opportunity Act. Are you going
- 19:12to file a similar bill? Or
- 19:13maybe it's already been filed
- 19:15and I just don't I'm not aware
- 19:16of it.
- 19:17>> There are several pieces of
- 19:18that bill that have already
- 19:20been filed, and I really
- 19:21appreciate what Wendy is saying
- 19:22here about the array of options
- 19:24that we really need. And I
- 19:25agree, I want to give a debt of
- 19:27gratitude to I call them
- 19:28co-chairs, Mills and Whitley,
- 19:29because I think the Housing
- 19:31Task Force was an informative
- 19:32experience for me. But we do
- 19:33need to do more. I think George
- 19:35would like to hear this. On the
- 19:37homelessness prevention side,
- 19:38there was a part in the
- 19:40Kentucky Housing Opportunity
- 19:40Act that added a homeless
- 19:42prevention fund to the tune of
- 19:44$2 million. Where would we pay
- 19:46for that? Well, we have
- 19:47billions of dollars essentially
- 19:49sitting in a piggy bank. And if
- 19:50we have a lot of that money, I
- 19:52think Kentuckians are wondering,
- 19:53what are we going to do with it?
- 19:55And if there isn't a rainy day
- 19:57like a housing crisis, then I
- 19:58don't know what a rainy day is.
- 20:00I also want to highlight just a
- 20:02few other things, if I may. A
- 20:04House Bill 159 by
- 20:05Representative Adrielle Camuel
- 20:06and Representative Roarx that
- 20:07talks about helping seniors and
- 20:09people with disabilities age
- 20:11and stay in their places, what
- 20:13we call aging gracefully. I
- 20:15also want to elevate House Bill
- 20:17426 by our Minority leader,
- 20:19Colonel Pam Stevenson. It's a
- 20:21renter tax credit. So for every
- 20:23renter out there that is making
- 20:26qualified payments on their
- 20:27rent, that gives them up to
- 20:29$1,000 back, and who wouldn't
- 20:31want that as a renter are
- 20:33starting out? And lastly, I'll
- 20:35just talk about the bill that I
- 20:37filed. That's House Bill 229.
- 20:38That's the $100 million
- 20:41affordable housing loan fund.
- 20:42We talked about a lot of
- 20:43options that we need. This is
- 20:45directly giving money to the
- 20:47Kentucky Housing Corporation to
- 20:49expand on the great work that
- 20:50they already do to build those
- 20:53housing needs that we have all
- 20:56over the Commonwealth. And
- 20:57believe it or not, that is an
- 20:59urban problem just as much as
- 21:00it is as it is a rural problem.
- 21:03I have in my district alone,
- 21:04people graduating from college
- 21:06can't buy a starter home. I'm a
- 21:08realtor. Starter homes being up
- 21:09to $300,000. Who can afford
- 21:12that? So we definitely need to
- 21:13spend a little bit more and I
- 21:15think we have the resources to
- 21:17do it.
- 21:17>> So on that last item that
- 21:19you mentioned, Governor Andy
- 21:20Beshear mentioned during the
- 21:21state of the Commonwealth and
- 21:22Budget address, a
- 21:23recommendation of a one time,
- 21:25$150 million investment into
- 21:26the Kentucky Affordable Housing
- 21:27Trust Fund. So you're you're
- 21:30backing that down a little bit
- 21:31from 150 to 100 million.
- 21:34>> So I think the governor, the
- 21:35governor knows the Commonwealth
- 21:37really well. And so he shot out
- 21:38with $150 million to the
- 21:40Affordable Housing Trust Fund.
- 21:41And and I'll say Governor
- 21:44Beshear knows best. We
- 21:46supplemented that for lack of
- 21:47better words because the funds
- 21:48do actually two different
- 21:49things. His is a direct
- 21:51injection of what we need right
- 21:52now. Ours is a revolving loan
- 21:55fund. So instead of either or,
- 21:57why not both?
- 21:57>> And Wendy Smith.
- 21:59>> I mean, I would love all of
- 22:01it. It'd be great. But I really
- 22:03do think one of the most
- 22:04important things would be to
- 22:06create, whether it's seated at
- 22:07Kentucky Housing Corporation,
- 22:08which we would love to do that
- 22:09or elsewhere, something that
- 22:11revolves that does not rely
- 22:13upon regular budget
- 22:16appropriations, but an
- 22:17investment fund that we might
- 22:18charge a little bit of interest
- 22:19on, and it would revolve back
- 22:21and forth so that it can be
- 22:23evergreen. And we really do
- 22:24need some programs like that
- 22:25that can self-fund and keep
- 22:27going.
- 22:28>> Representative Whitten, I'm
- 22:29curious about your take on what
- 22:30you heard Representative
- 22:31Watkins offer and does should
- 22:34money from the Budget Reserve
- 22:35Trust Fund, or i.e. a rainy day
- 22:37fund, go toward the Kentucky
- 22:40Housing Corporation? More
- 22:44perhaps?
- 22:44>> Well, we're we're we've just
- 22:46started looking at the we just
- 22:47started looking at the budget.
- 22:49Our our first draft dropped
- 22:52last week. It is a again it is
- 22:55a first draft. And so it is
- 22:57pretty bare bones. And so I
- 22:59think that there's going to be
- 23:00a lot of conversations about
- 23:02about what the budget's going
- 23:04to look like going forward. But
- 23:05I did want to talk. I really
- 23:07wanted to kind of circle back.
- 23:10Most everybody has talked about
- 23:11it, the continuum and the
- 23:14multiple, the multiple options
- 23:16that we have. There are options
- 23:18that I have. You know, I think
- 23:19that Representative Watkins
- 23:20talked about starter homes.
- 23:22I've got a bill that affects
- 23:24planning and zoning that deals
- 23:26with smaller lot sizes for new
- 23:28developments, that, paired with
- 23:32Senator Mills infrastructure
- 23:33bill, would work perfectly
- 23:35together. Because you've got
- 23:36the ability to build these, you
- 23:39know, what we call working
- 23:40family homes. And a lot of the
- 23:42concern that I'm hearing is
- 23:44there are communities that
- 23:45don't want these, these
- 23:48communities built until the
- 23:50infrastructure is either
- 23:51already covered or has a plan
- 23:54for. So I think that both of
- 23:56those bills working together is
- 23:58really a perfect answer for for
- 24:00what we need because we're
- 24:01looking for really our our
- 24:03sweet spot is the is the the
- 24:06missing middle, the working
- 24:07family home.
- 24:09>> And Representative Whitten,
- 24:11when you were last on this
- 24:12program a couple of months ago,
- 24:13I think we talked about this
- 24:15when the task force was kind of
- 24:16wrapping up, and you had
- 24:18mentioned that nearly half of
- 24:19the existing homes in the state
- 24:20are more than 45 years old, and
- 24:23you had made a recommendation
- 24:25that you might work up a bill
- 24:26to offer tax credits to
- 24:28individuals who are restoring a
- 24:29home that's at least 50 years
- 24:31old. Is that a part of your
- 24:33plan this time?
- 24:36>> That that's absolutely
- 24:37something we're working on.
- 24:38That's called the Historic
- 24:40Rehabilitation Tax Credit. It
- 24:42is a fund of $100 million that
- 24:45we have had for several years.
- 24:46And we're just trying to to
- 24:49change. My bill is going to
- 24:50really going to make that
- 24:51better. It's going to number
- 24:53one. It's going to incentivize
- 24:55the the incentivize and and
- 25:01prioritize housing. You're
- 25:02going to give that little extra
- 25:04kicker of tax credit for those
- 25:06developers that are choosing to
- 25:08incorporate housing into their
- 25:11rehabilitation. And it also
- 25:13helps. Right now there is a
- 25:16portion that is used for owner
- 25:18operated and a portion that is
- 25:20used for commercial. A lot of
- 25:22times that owner operated is is
- 25:24not utilized. And so we're
- 25:25going to change that to be have
- 25:28the funds fully fungible so
- 25:30that every year all of those
- 25:32tax credits can be used to take
- 25:35these urban infill and, and
- 25:38make these, you know, these
- 25:41buildings that are in our
- 25:42cities that that have not been
- 25:44used, make them into, into
- 25:46residential properties.
- 25:47>> And one of the things we
- 25:49often hear about after the
- 25:50program is done is, what about
- 25:52helping those who are 65 and
- 25:54older get a little relief on
- 25:56their property taxes? Right?
- 25:57Because oftentimes people who
- 25:59are in that age category on
- 26:01fixed incomes and they've
- 26:02already maybe paid off their
- 26:04house, but they never really
- 26:05feel like they own their own
- 26:06home. Right. Tell us what you
- 26:08think about that idea.
- 26:14>> Sure. Senator Nemes has a
- 26:17bill that would, I believe,
- 26:20freeze the property tax for
- 26:23Kentuckians 65 and older. It
- 26:26would need to be a
- 26:28constitutional amendment. So it
- 26:29would be something that would
- 26:30need to go on the ballot to be
- 26:33voted on. But I think I think
- 26:35that's a that's a great idea.
- 26:36We have to talk about it and
- 26:38make sure that, that the local
- 26:41governments who who get a lot
- 26:42of their money from property
- 26:44taxes, we need to make sure
- 26:45that our local governments are
- 26:47taken care of. But that's
- 26:49certainly something that I'm
- 26:50hearing a lot about from my
- 26:51constituents.
- 26:52>> Yeah. J.D. Chaney I'm going
- 26:53to come right to you on that.
- 26:54Yeah. You knew that one was
- 26:56coming, right?
- 26:57>> Yeah. Senate bill, I believe
- 26:58it's 151. I think Senator Nemes
- 27:01has passed that through the
- 27:02Senate a couple of times. We've
- 27:04we've been not adverse to that.
- 27:07From what we hear from our
- 27:08senior residents at all,
- 27:10because Kentucky has something
- 27:11called the compensating tax
- 27:13rate. And so if, if that comes
- 27:15off the rolls, if a
- 27:16constitutional amendment was
- 27:17approved to extend that
- 27:19homestead exemption for for 65
- 27:22and older and those that are
- 27:24disabled, then the compensating
- 27:26tax rate adjusts. And so it's
- 27:28not a revenue loss type of
- 27:32proposal. So I think that's
- 27:34that's something that probably
- 27:35should get some due
- 27:36consideration. If you're
- 27:37looking at seniors.
- 27:38>> Yeah. George Eklund I want I
- 27:40want to come to you because we
- 27:41know that our population is
- 27:43aging. And of course, housing
- 27:44costs are something that they
- 27:45are increasingly more concerned
- 27:47about. How do these ideas
- 27:49resonate with you, particularly
- 27:50homestead exemption for seniors
- 27:51over 65 and those who have
- 27:54disabilities?
- 27:57>> Yeah, I think those are
- 27:59worthy policies to really look
- 28:00at and see. Like, is it time to
- 28:02modernize those? Is there is it
- 28:03time to kind of really look at
- 28:05the the amount in the exemption
- 28:06that that is there and, and
- 28:09bring it up to, to today's
- 28:11standards? The other piece of
- 28:12this I think is an opportunity
- 28:14is looking at what happens when
- 28:16a senior gets behind. Like
- 28:18right now, there is a whole
- 28:20industry of people that come
- 28:21and buy tax liens, and that is
- 28:23a lien that they put on the
- 28:25property, and they have ten
- 28:26years to collect that lien. And
- 28:27that puts, you know, seniors in
- 28:29a in a bind where they have an
- 28:31out-of-state company that is
- 28:32sending them mail. That's
- 28:33saying that you owe us all this
- 28:35money. We're charging all this
- 28:36interest. You know, I think
- 28:37that there's a path for local
- 28:39communities to figure out how
- 28:40can we space these payments
- 28:41over the course of the year,
- 28:43not just all in in April, and
- 28:45not put seniors in a bind like
- 28:47that? So I think that is
- 28:49another avenue of like
- 28:50addressing the concerns of
- 28:52seniors that are trying to age
- 28:53in place and retain that asset
- 28:55that they can pass on to their
- 28:56families.
- 28:57>> A lot of head nodding here
- 28:58in the Lexington studio. Miss
- 29:00Smith, what do you think?
- 29:01>> I think it's really just as
- 29:02George said, it's worth looking
- 29:04into. How do we help seniors
- 29:06maintain their affordability? I
- 29:08want to also offer the flip,
- 29:10which is that we have a really
- 29:12significant generational divide
- 29:14around affordability in this
- 29:16country and in this state. What
- 29:18I mean by that is that younger
- 29:20households who are just renting
- 29:22their first house or trying to
- 29:24buy their first house, are
- 29:26facing a far steeper climb than
- 29:29those of us who might have
- 29:30bought a home a long time ago,
- 29:32and that that divide is getting
- 29:35broader and broader. The
- 29:37average, excuse me, median age
- 29:39of a first time home buyer in
- 29:41the United States is now 40
- 29:43years old. That is stunning.
- 29:46That means families who are
- 29:48starting to have children
- 29:50aren't even considering it
- 29:51because they can't afford it.
- 29:53And the amount they are
- 29:54spending. The median homeowner
- 29:57in the US spends 47% of their
- 30:00median income to afford
- 30:02homeownership. So I think it's
- 30:04really important while we're
- 30:05thinking about seniors, that we
- 30:06also think about younger
- 30:08households who are not getting
- 30:09a foothold in building wealth,
- 30:12in having a stake in their
- 30:13community, and that it really
- 30:14is important to balance both.
- 30:16>> And I remember when I was in
- 30:17the home buying market many,
- 30:19many years ago, it's like it
- 30:20should not exceed a third of
- 30:22your take home pay, right? As
- 30:23opposed to 47 something percent.
- 30:25That's quite a bit. Senator
- 30:27Mills, I want to come back to
- 30:29you just to kind of put a pin
- 30:31in where we were, because we
- 30:32got this question from Richmond
- 30:33to you, is the intent of
- 30:35Senator Mills bill that
- 30:36developers will build lower
- 30:37cost housing? They ask, will
- 30:39there be some requirements for
- 30:40builders to build that type of
- 30:42housing to ensure that they are
- 30:43not simply profiting from the
- 30:45infrastructure subsidies of
- 30:46higher cost housing?
- 30:49>> Right. Well, we would hope
- 30:51that that lowers the price of
- 30:52the house. But the beauty of
- 30:54the of my bill of Senate Bill
- 30:56nine is that that's going to be
- 30:59negotiated with the local
- 31:01government. So the local
- 31:02government wants to put some
- 31:03requirements in there that, you
- 31:05know, this this development
- 31:06needs to needs to hit the
- 31:10$229,000 mark or the $250,000
- 31:12mark or their, you know, X
- 31:14amount of beds. You know, that
- 31:16can all be negotiated out. What
- 31:18that community needs to fit its,
- 31:21you know, to fit the housing
- 31:23needs that are the most
- 31:25prevalent that the local
- 31:26government sees, that is most
- 31:28prevalent.
- 31:28>> So this comment while we've
- 31:29got you, Senator Mills Martin
- 31:31rivers from Lexington, had this
- 31:33comment because we reported on
- 31:34your bill on our nightly
- 31:36newscast earlier today, 630 he
- 31:39says, per Kentucky edition
- 31:40earlier tonight, developers can
- 31:41avoid paying property taxes for
- 31:43up to five years per this bill.
- 31:45If I consider how much I pay in
- 31:47property taxes each year, it
- 31:49far outstrips the tiny income
- 31:50tax rollback I've been given by
- 31:52the legislature over the last
- 31:54several years. Why should
- 31:55average citizens not view this
- 31:57as yet another giveaway to
- 31:59developers? While average
- 32:00citizens pick up the tab?
- 32:02>> Yeah, well, this I mean,
- 32:03once again, we're trying to
- 32:06incentivize developers to to
- 32:08put a house in the ground so
- 32:10that rebate back to the
- 32:13developer is actually
- 32:15encouraging them to build a
- 32:17home so that people can live in
- 32:18the community and the community
- 32:20can thrive. I mean, these
- 32:22property taxes, whatever is
- 32:25negotiated with the developer
- 32:26and the local government, but
- 32:28will return back to the local
- 32:30governments after that 5 or 6
- 32:32year period that's negotiated.
- 32:35I just think it's a win win to
- 32:37get people into the community,
- 32:39to build a house and to live
- 32:41there.
- 32:41>> J.D. Chaney these are
- 32:43Senator Mills is right. These
- 32:44are property taxes that aren't
- 32:45being paid, and it's going
- 32:48right into the infrastructure
- 32:49that's used to support support
- 32:51the housing. So it's it's not,
- 32:53you know, a Boone for
- 32:55developers. It's about the
- 32:56infrastructure development to
- 32:57support that.
- 32:58>> And some of viewers still.
- 32:59Oh go ahead, Senator Mills, I.
- 33:01>> Think and I was going to say
- 33:03in that infrastructure, you
- 33:04know, continues on, if we're
- 33:05talking about water pump
- 33:07stations, water lines, I mean,
- 33:08those are feeding multiple
- 33:10homes, not just one specific
- 33:13house and not just benefiting a
- 33:15developer. You're talking about
- 33:16multiple families that could be
- 33:19their livelihood, could be
- 33:21improved, you know, by this
- 33:24developer getting off the
- 33:26sideline and investing his
- 33:28money to build homes for
- 33:30Kentuckians.
- 33:31>> Jeff Sims from Caldwell
- 33:32County asked this question what
- 33:34protections exist for Kentucky
- 33:36taxpayers, cities and counties
- 33:37against shady developers taking
- 33:40infrastructure or incentive
- 33:41dollars and not completing the
- 33:42promised projects? Our
- 33:43protections included in the
- 33:44different pieces of proposed
- 33:46legislation. Senator Mills,
- 33:47I'll come to you for that.
- 33:49>> Yeah, I think the the the
- 33:51payments, the incentives would
- 33:53be paid over time once the
- 33:55development is done, that's
- 33:57when those incentive payments
- 33:59would start. So the house would
- 34:00have to be built, the homeowner
- 34:02would have to be in the house.
- 34:04And whatever the other local
- 34:06government governments want to
- 34:07put in place, negotiate with
- 34:10the developer as a backstop to
- 34:11make sure that those homes are
- 34:13built. The infrastructure is
- 34:14put in place and and nobody is
- 34:17shortcut.
- 34:18>> Mr. Cheney have anything.
- 34:19>> To add? Local governments
- 34:20can still do performance bonds
- 34:22and and other tools locally
- 34:23that exist right now to help
- 34:25guard them on those on those
- 34:27contracts.
- 34:28>> I want to go back to you,
- 34:30Representative Witten and
- 34:31Louisville, and ask you about a
- 34:32bill that's going to be
- 34:33considered in committee
- 34:34tomorrow. I think it's House
- 34:35local government. It's House
- 34:36Bill 333. One of your
- 34:37colleagues has filed this bill
- 34:39that would allow Kentucky's
- 34:40religious institutions to put
- 34:42affordable housing units on
- 34:43their property. Tell us about
- 34:45this. And was this one of the
- 34:47recommendations that came from
- 34:48the Kentucky Housing Task Force?
- 34:53>> It it is, yes. It's
- 34:55Representative Pollock's bill.
- 34:57It's something that we that we
- 34:58did talk about during the
- 34:59during the housing task force.
- 35:01And it's something that that
- 35:03I'm supportive of, I think that
- 35:04we've worked a lot with, with
- 35:07George and his team as well as
- 35:09other legislators. And we've
- 35:12we've really kind of finessed
- 35:13it to make sure that it is not
- 35:15going to interrupt the, the,
- 35:19the nature and the, the
- 35:22personality of these individual
- 35:23communities that these churches
- 35:24might be in. That's not our
- 35:27intent, but we understand that
- 35:29this is a great opportunity to
- 35:32provide a low cost, additional
- 35:35housing in our communities. And
- 35:36and don't forget, you know, the
- 35:38the you know, for the last two
- 35:40years of our task force, the,
- 35:42the the main thing that we
- 35:44talked about is that we are
- 35:45over 200,000 units short. And
- 35:48so, you know, supply, supply,
- 35:50supply. So everything that we
- 35:52are we can do to increase
- 35:55supply, and we're going to look
- 35:57at those options. And again,
- 35:59like Senator Mills, if we can
- 36:02bring the infrastructure along,
- 36:04because we do know that when
- 36:05you increase supply that it
- 36:07does cause people to to have a
- 36:10little concern. And so that's
- 36:12why I think that a lot of these
- 36:14bills work so well together.
- 36:16>> Yeah. And I want to go to
- 36:18your, your colleague there in
- 36:19the studio with you. George
- 36:21Eklund. What do you think about
- 36:24House Bill? 333 she mentioned
- 36:26that you were very supportive
- 36:27of this measure.
- 36:30>> Yeah, yeah. House Bill 333
- 36:32the bill, the yes in God's
- 36:34Backyard bill is just a bill
- 36:35that's trying to empower
- 36:37churches to develop housing
- 36:38where it's strategically and
- 36:40appropriate in our communities.
- 36:42And most likely, this is about
- 36:43a church who has an old school
- 36:45school building that's been
- 36:46closed down. And rather than
- 36:47let that that building be just
- 36:50demolished by neglect, let's
- 36:51make it an asset. Let's make it
- 36:53a place where seniors can live
- 36:54in close proximity to their
- 36:56house of worship. Let's make it
- 36:57a place that can be more about
- 37:00building a community, not just
- 37:01an eyesore that that sits there.
- 37:04I mean, in my community right
- 37:05now, in my neighborhood,
- 37:06there's a church that is
- 37:07interested in building and
- 37:10developing their old school
- 37:11building into senior apartments.
- 37:12That's what the bill is about.
- 37:14I completely understand some
- 37:16concerns about local control
- 37:17and making sure that housing is
- 37:20developed where it's
- 37:21appropriate and where it's
- 37:22strategically needed, and that
- 37:23is a lot of the safeguards that
- 37:25we put in the bill is about
- 37:27making sure that it's along
- 37:29main commercial corridors, that
- 37:31it's along state primary
- 37:33highways, that it is a budding
- 37:34commercial areas. So I think it
- 37:36is a very narrow piece of
- 37:39legislation that's just about
- 37:40starting the conversation to
- 37:42increase supply across the
- 37:43across the Commonwealth.
- 37:45>> And if people didn't catch
- 37:46that, you said, in God's
- 37:48backyard, is that what we call
- 37:49it? J.D. Chaney what's your
- 37:51thoughts?
- 37:52>> We're very, very thankful
- 37:54for Representative Pollock's
- 37:56work with us. I think he has a
- 37:58committee substitute tomorrow.
- 37:59It's going to expedite the the
- 38:02planning and zoning process
- 38:05with with, I think, the local
- 38:06government giving consent to to
- 38:08bypass that normal approval
- 38:10process to to kind of expedite
- 38:12that. So we're really thankful
- 38:13for him for working with us on
- 38:15that.
- 38:15>> Mr. Ecklund, I think I may
- 38:17have cut you off there, sir, if
- 38:19you had more to add. You're
- 38:22good. Okay. When you have these
- 38:24distances, it can be hard to
- 38:25judge. Like when I can't see
- 38:26you face to face, I think. Yeah.
- 38:28Go ahead. Wendy Smith.
- 38:29>> Yeah. I just wanted to offer
- 38:31an example. So George talked
- 38:32about an old school building on
- 38:34a religious property. Let's say
- 38:36it's 50 plus years old and it
- 38:38has some historic attributes.
- 38:40Well, that could pair with the
- 38:41changes that Representative
- 38:43Whitten is talking about with
- 38:44the state historic tax credit,
- 38:45so that that could help fund it.
- 38:47They might come to us for
- 38:49affordable housing trust fund
- 38:50dollars to make sure some of
- 38:51the rental units were deeply
- 38:54affordable for poor Kentuckians.
- 38:57Right. And I'm just trying to
- 38:58give an example of how there
- 38:59may be multiple ways different
- 39:02bills go into one project to
- 39:03make it feasible.
- 39:05>> Right? Right. That's a good
- 39:06example. Yes. Representative
- 39:07Watkins.
- 39:07>> I'm a fan of yes, in God's
- 39:09backyard. We talked about this
- 39:11in the task force. I think one
- 39:12of the last times I was on the
- 39:14program, we talked about that.
- 39:16And listen, this is really one
- 39:17of those yes. And issues for me.
- 39:19I want churches that want to
- 39:20get involved as a minister. I
- 39:22think that's near and dear to
- 39:23my heart. But I want to pause
- 39:25right, right now for a moment,
- 39:27just to to speak to some of the
- 39:29people who have been writing in,
- 39:30because I'm hearing something
- 39:31and I'm wondering if everyone
- 39:32else is hearing it. Yes, we
- 39:34know we need supply, but people
- 39:35are concerned about whether or
- 39:37not they can afford it. They
- 39:38are terrified out there. I mean,
- 39:40back in the day when I was
- 39:42growing up, my parents used to
- 39:43say things were sky high and
- 39:45things are sky high. Everything
- 39:47is up from utilities to
- 39:49groceries to health care and
- 39:51housing. And guess what has not
- 39:53increased over the years? Wages.
- 39:55What people are taking home. So
- 39:57that's why I'm saying yes and I
- 39:59love I agree with Wendy. I
- 40:01totally support Senator Mills
- 40:03and Rep Whitten as well, but I.
- 40:30Think we also need to make sure
- 40:31that what we're building people
- 40:33can afford in a way to do that.
- 40:35I think Wendy was talking about
- 40:36with with some of the dollars
- 40:37in the Kentucky Housing
- 40:38Corporation, you can make sure
- 40:39that whatever you're building
- 40:40goes to a certain group of
- 40:42people that can actually afford
- 40:43it. And listen, people think
- 40:44affordability, you ask three
- 40:44different people, you're going
- 40:45to get three different answers
- 40:45of what affordability is. But I
- 40:46will tell you what it is not.
- 40:47It is not $1,600 for a one
- 40:47bedroom apartment. That is not
- 40:48what affordability is. And I
- 40:48think we need to start using
- 40:49real numbers when we're talking
- 40:49about that too.
- 40:50>> Yeah. Senator Mill
- 40:50have starter homes to upsize or
- 40:51right size right, to free up
- 40:52the starter home communities?
- 40:52>> Yeah, I think, you know,
- 40:53we've got to figure out how to
- 40:55get people bump people up. And
- 40:58I think we've you've heard it
- 41:00multiple times tonight about
- 41:01the housing continuum. You know,
- 41:04we've we've got some ideas that
- 41:06hopefully we'll be able to
- 41:08release here in the next couple
- 41:09of weeks about first time home
- 41:12buyers, some things that maybe
- 41:13we can do to help them that
- 41:16really doesn't, doesn't have a
- 41:19big effect on our bottom line.
- 41:21Government's bottom line as far
- 41:22as revenue goes. But I think
- 41:24you're going to start seeing
- 41:26we're starting with things that
- 41:28don't cost a lot of money or
- 41:30zero money. The regulatory
- 41:32reforms, tools for local
- 41:33governments to work with
- 41:35developers on. And I think as
- 41:36we get closer to rolling out
- 41:39the budget, I think you're
- 41:39going to see some of these
- 41:41other ideas that I've heard
- 41:42folks talking about tonight,
- 41:44adding money to the Affordable
- 41:46Housing Trust Fund, which is,
- 41:48you know, Wendy can talk about
- 41:49this, but I believe of those
- 41:52206,000 housing units that were
- 41:53short, 60% of those are in
- 41:57workforce housing that we need
- 41:58to do something about. And also
- 42:01this Indiana program of this
- 42:03revolving loan, infrastructure
- 42:05loan program, that's something
- 42:07that we could possibly commit
- 42:09some money to. You know, I'm
- 42:11committed from the work that
- 42:12we've done the last two years
- 42:14to really start asking our
- 42:17leaders, the budget leaders,
- 42:18both the House and the Senate,
- 42:20to put some money toward
- 42:22housing, and hopefully we'll
- 42:24see some of that come to
- 42:25fruition for everybody across
- 42:27the continuum. But I think if
- 42:29we once again, if somebody
- 42:31bumps up out of a starter home
- 42:33into a medium or larger size
- 42:35home, that frees up a starter
- 42:36home for somebody that wants to
- 42:38build equity, move out of their
- 42:40apartment, build equity in that
- 42:42starter home, then that frees
- 42:43up an apartment that might be
- 42:45able to be rented to someone
- 42:47who's homeless right now. So,
- 42:49so important. All the all the
- 42:51pieces of the puzzle fit
- 42:53together. And it's a complex
- 42:54piece. That's why professionals
- 42:58do housing all the time. It's,
- 43:00it's it's always an ever
- 43:02growing situation. But we've
- 43:04just got to get off off of off
- 43:06of stop and get moving forward.
- 43:07And Kentucky I know people have
- 43:09been working on housing for
- 43:11many, many years, but we need
- 43:12to put an extra effort behind
- 43:14it. And that's what this task
- 43:15force was about. And hopefully
- 43:17that's what this program is
- 43:18about tonight to motivate
- 43:20people, maybe to call their
- 43:21legislator and say, hey, we'd
- 43:23like for you to support these
- 43:24ideas.
- 43:25>> Yeah, Wendy, let's pick it
- 43:26up with you again.
- 43:27>> I just want to, like, take a
- 43:29moment to say, well, I agree
- 43:31with Representative Watkins, I
- 43:32want more. I want to see stuff
- 43:34faster. I'm really eager. We
- 43:37have never seen so much housing
- 43:39legislation proposed last year
- 43:41I thought was the most. And it
- 43:42was in a budget year. This year
- 43:44we have even more. And it
- 43:46sounds like there's more to
- 43:47come before the session closes
- 43:49out. And we have legislators
- 43:52who have committed to a task
- 43:53force who are talking about
- 43:55housing in very rich and
- 43:57intelligent ways and and
- 43:59bringing this array of possible
- 44:01solutions. And so I'm just very
- 44:03hopeful, you know, time will
- 44:04tell what makes it through the
- 44:05whole legislative process. But
- 44:07this is a change in Kentucky
- 44:10that is I'm glad it's happening.
- 44:12You could say it's overdue
- 44:13because many states have been
- 44:15doing really aggressive action
- 44:17on housing, and we don't want
- 44:19them to get too far ahead of us
- 44:21and be the ones that get the
- 44:22jobs and get the population. So
- 44:24I'm very happy to see so much
- 44:26happening in this session.
- 44:28>> So from Ricky and Fayette
- 44:29County, this question, Will the
- 44:31God's backyard bill
- 44:32discriminate against specific
- 44:33religions, or will it be
- 44:35inclusive to all?
- 44:37Representative Whitton, I'll
- 44:39come to you for that.
- 44:43>> I do not believe in any way
- 44:45how it could discriminate
- 44:46against religions. I don't
- 44:48think that it's even part of
- 44:50the bill. I don't think that
- 44:52any religion is even is even
- 44:55qualified in the in the bill.
- 44:56>> Yeah. We we took a look at
- 44:59the concerns around fair
- 45:00housing laws and fair housing
- 45:02protections. So the if the
- 45:04church goes to a market rate
- 45:06like commercial enterprise,
- 45:07like they still have to abide
- 45:08by all fair housing protections,
- 45:10and that includes religion in,
- 45:12in our community. So I
- 45:15appreciate the concern, but we
- 45:16we have really looked at that
- 45:19issue carefully. And you know,
- 45:21I think we are we are good to
- 45:23go on that issue on that part
- 45:24of it.
- 45:25>> I think if the if the
- 45:26religious institution qualifies
- 45:28under the IRS code as a
- 45:29religious tax exempt
- 45:31institution, it could qualify
- 45:33if it met the other criteria.
- 45:34So it does define it as a as a
- 45:37qualifying IRS institution.
- 45:39>> Right. Representative, I
- 45:40want to go back to you, because
- 45:42I know last year you had filed
- 45:43some legislation regarding two
- 45:45evictions. Right. So can you
- 45:46talk to us a little bit more
- 45:48about that? I think
- 45:49Representative Watkins also is
- 45:50a coconspirator in that perhaps,
- 45:52but I'll start with you first,
- 45:53Madam Chair.
- 45:58>> Yes, yes. Thank you. Yes.
- 46:00This year I filed and it's
- 46:01House Bill 338. It involves
- 46:05eviction, expungement and minor
- 46:08protections. It it expunges the
- 46:12evictions when the evictions
- 46:14have been dismissed. So it's
- 46:16really just it prevents it
- 46:19takes down the barriers that
- 46:22thousands of Kentuckians have
- 46:23to deal with every single year.
- 46:26So it's we we talked about it.
- 46:28We were in we were we were able
- 46:30to be in front of the judiciary
- 46:32with this bill during the
- 46:34interim. So we had some really
- 46:35great robust conversations in
- 46:37that committee during the
- 46:39summer. And I'm we're George
- 46:42and I are actually working on
- 46:43that on that together. We've
- 46:45got we've been talking to the
- 46:47clerks about some of their
- 46:49concerns. We've talked about
- 46:50the Apartment Association and
- 46:52we've listened to their
- 46:54concerns. And so we're making
- 46:55some changes. And so we're
- 46:58excited about putting a
- 46:59committee substitute in soon
- 47:01and hopefully hearing it in
- 47:02committee in the next couple of
- 47:04weeks.
- 47:04>> Before we go to George, I
- 47:05want to ask Representative
- 47:06Watkins, what's your take on
- 47:08this? You on board with this
- 47:09version or you want to wait for
- 47:11the committee substitute before
- 47:12you?
- 47:12>> I always love to see a
- 47:14committee substitute, but I
- 47:15really have to celebrate
- 47:18Representative Whitten on this
- 47:19important piece of legislation.
- 47:20And she knows this. I've told
- 47:21her this privately as well. But
- 47:22for those at home, I've been in
- 47:25real estate since 2009. I've
- 47:26been a former property manager,
- 47:28whatnot. I want to make this
- 47:29real. If you have an eviction
- 47:31sometimes and you are applying
- 47:33for an apartment and you get,
- 47:35you know, a credit check and
- 47:37whatnot, if if a company or a
- 47:39landlord sees that you have an
- 47:40eviction on your record, they
- 47:42can up your security deposit.
- 47:44Sometimes we know we pay one
- 47:45month as a security deposit.
- 47:47Sometimes landlords are
- 47:48charging or companies are
- 47:49charging 2 or 3 months upfront
- 47:52simply because that's there.
- 47:54And removing that, especially
- 47:55if it's been dismissed, is
- 47:57going to change the lives for
- 47:58so many different Kentuckians.
- 48:00And I'm really happy to be a
- 48:02supporter of it. Of course, I
- 48:03want to see the substitute, but
- 48:04I really want to celebrate this
- 48:06important piece.
- 48:06>> And Representative Whitten
- 48:07mentioned about expungement,
- 48:08eviction, expungement and minor
- 48:11protections. What does that
- 48:12last piece mean? Representative,
- 48:15we need to go to you for that.
- 48:17>> Simply that. Yeah. Yes. It's
- 48:23simply that when when
- 48:25individuals are are writing a
- 48:26lease, a lot of times they are
- 48:28simply putting the individuals
- 48:30that live in that unit. And a
- 48:34lot of times those are minors.
- 48:36And so, you know, they're not
- 48:38thinking about if if they might
- 48:40go to, to eviction proceedings.
- 48:43Well, unfortunately, if they go
- 48:44to eviction proceedings, the
- 48:46names of those minors are
- 48:48included in the legal document.
- 48:50And that is not something that
- 48:52that we want. We we never want
- 48:54to include minors in, in this
- 48:57type of thing. So this would
- 48:58simply strike the minors name
- 49:02from, from the original record.
- 49:04And that is part of the
- 49:06committee substitute that that
- 49:07George and I have been working
- 49:09on.
- 49:09>> Yeah. And I want to go to
- 49:11you, Mr. Eckland, to give you a
- 49:12chance to really talk about
- 49:13this a little bit more and what
- 49:15you hope the final version will
- 49:16look like.
- 49:20>> Yeah. I mean, Renee, I'm so
- 49:22glad that you brought this up.
- 49:23Like, this has been five years
- 49:24in the making. We look at other
- 49:26states like Utah. We look at
- 49:27states like South Dakota and
- 49:29Indiana who have done this
- 49:31measure as well. And we you
- 49:34know, from my point of view, I
- 49:36hear this all the time talking
- 49:37about the barriers that they're
- 49:39navigating security deposits,
- 49:41application fees and evictions
- 49:43on people's records. This is
- 49:44about giving people a chance to
- 49:47focus on what's in front of
- 49:48them, not what's in the past.
- 49:50So this is really focusing on
- 49:51those cases that got dismissed
- 49:53by either the home renter
- 49:55moving out or paying up, or
- 49:57that the case was just dropped.
- 49:59All parties agreed to that. And
- 50:01this is about, again, just
- 50:03removing one of those barriers
- 50:05so that people can move and
- 50:06focus on what's what's in their
- 50:08future. You know, we have
- 50:1040,000 evictions in Kentucky,
- 50:12and that's a huge number.
- 50:14That's largely because of our
- 50:15lack of housing. It's not
- 50:17because somebody is deciding
- 50:19willfully not to pay. It's we
- 50:23have a housing issue. And
- 50:24unfortunately, those that are
- 50:25the least resources in our
- 50:27communities are the ones that
- 50:28are going through eviction
- 50:29court that are getting
- 50:30displaced and ending up
- 50:32homeless. So I see this as
- 50:33really a as much as an eviction
- 50:37expungement bill as a homeless
- 50:39prevention bill, like we are
- 50:40trying to move people up that
- 50:42continuum that we keep on
- 50:43talking about. And just
- 50:44removing this barrier is one of
- 50:45the most important pieces that
- 50:46we can do. So I'm incredibly
- 50:48hopeful for House Bill. 338 I
- 50:50think it is a huge step for us
- 50:53and in the state to just make
- 50:54sure that we're focusing on
- 50:56giving people the tools and
- 50:57giving them the foundation
- 50:58stone that they can build their
- 51:00lives upon.
- 51:00>> And, George, what we have
- 51:02you what is it that's missing
- 51:03or that we haven't discussed
- 51:04tonight or that perhaps is
- 51:06forthcoming to be filed that
- 51:08really would help the homeless
- 51:09population, in your view? Maybe.
- 51:13>> Yeah. I think another piece
- 51:15out there is House Bill 411. So
- 51:17this is about modernizing the
- 51:19State Affordable Housing Trust
- 51:21Fund. The State Affordable
- 51:22Housing Trust Fund is geared
- 51:23for those that are earning 60,
- 51:24or those people that are
- 51:25earning 60% Ami and below,
- 51:27which is a really fancy way of
- 51:28saying, you know, workforce,
- 51:30people that are working, people
- 51:31that are pre-K, teachers,
- 51:33waitresses, customer service
- 51:36reps. You know, there's a bill
- 51:37out there that would adjust the
- 51:39deed recording fee and the
- 51:40mortgage recording fee so that
- 51:42we're giving an additional $10
- 51:44million every year to the
- 51:46Kentucky housing, to Kentucky
- 51:48housing to build homeownership
- 51:51opportunities and rental
- 51:52opportunities. So that is
- 51:53another bill that's out there
- 51:54that I'm excited about this
- 51:55session, and I really
- 51:58appreciate the work of the task
- 51:59force. I've it is heartening.
- 52:01And I think Wendy said it like
- 52:03the the expertise that has been
- 52:06shown on this panel and in the
- 52:07General Assembly right now is
- 52:09incredibly heartening.
- 52:10>> Yeah. J.D. Chaney, I want to
- 52:11come to you. What what does
- 52:13city governments want from this
- 52:16perspective? You all have lots
- 52:17of perspectives.
- 52:18>> Lots of perspective. There
- 52:19are a lot of good pieces of
- 52:21legislation. I think it's
- 52:22extremely important that we not
- 52:24take steps forward and at the
- 52:25same time enact legislation
- 52:27that takes us backwards. For
- 52:29example, we got to recognize
- 52:30that housing has shifted from
- 52:32just being purely shelter to
- 52:33being financial assets. We've
- 52:35got investor owned, and the
- 52:38short term rental market
- 52:39certainly plays into that. And
- 52:40we're considering legislation
- 52:42for the General Assembly is
- 52:44considering legislation that
- 52:45would allow for the
- 52:47proliferation without any local
- 52:49government regulation. And it
- 52:50does impact the affordability
- 52:53of for for the working class to
- 52:55be able to afford homes that.
- 52:56>> You're talking about. Airbnb.
- 52:58>> Well, it's Airbnb
- 52:59legislation. It's the only
- 53:01short term rental company here
- 53:02playing in the in the
- 53:04legislative game. And it takes
- 53:06it takes a long term rentals
- 53:08out of the market. And it takes
- 53:09a single family residential
- 53:11property out of the market. So
- 53:13we're extremely concerned about
- 53:14that legislation that would
- 53:16completely give a give a all,
- 53:21all, all access to, to short
- 53:25term rentals to without any
- 53:27kind of oversight or regulation
- 53:28from the, from the local
- 53:29government.
- 53:30>> And they're not taxed. Right?
- 53:31>> Are they? Well.
- 53:32>> What kind of tax.
- 53:33>> That's in litigation. And
- 53:34it's in litigation with us. In
- 53:36fact, in the Kentucky Supreme
- 53:38Court. And I think they pay in
- 53:40some places and they don't in
- 53:43others, is what we've seen,
- 53:45even though these other short
- 53:46term rental platforms are are
- 53:47in compliance.
- 53:48>> Yeah. Senator Mills, real
- 53:50quick, we'll come back to you.
- 53:51What's another bill perhaps
- 53:53that we're going to see coming
- 53:54from, from your caucus or from
- 53:55you when it concerns housing?
- 53:59>> I really think that, you
- 54:01know, we've here here is an
- 54:04idea that that I was given
- 54:07actually by a developer that I
- 54:08think we'll see me file here in
- 54:11the next week or so is the
- 54:14assessment process, you know,
- 54:15when people are developing,
- 54:17like taking a larger piece of
- 54:19agricultural land and
- 54:21developing a neighborhood that
- 54:23those that lot would not be
- 54:26reassessed until a house is
- 54:27actually built on it and
- 54:28somebody actually moves into it.
- 54:31Sometimes one of the costs of
- 54:33developing a neighborhood, a
- 54:35new development, is actually
- 54:36the increased property tax that
- 54:39the that the developer would
- 54:41have to carry that for five or
- 54:446 or 7 years. That becomes an
- 54:46ongoing cost to that developer.
- 54:48So you'll probably see that
- 54:50bill filed. But I really just
- 54:51want to point everybody to the
- 54:53budget document. I'm hopeful in
- 54:55the budget document that we're
- 54:56going to see several different
- 54:59infusions. You know, it may not
- 55:00be the large number that maybe
- 55:03represent Watkins has in his
- 55:04bill, but we're going to see
- 55:06multiple. We're going to see
- 55:07multiple streams of investment
- 55:10going in to housing all across
- 55:12the spectrum.
- 55:13>> And so that's House Bill 500.
- 55:15Right. So we'll keep our eye on
- 55:16that. And any supplemental bill
- 55:17that deals with one time money,
- 55:20perhaps it could come out. And
- 55:21we'll be on top of that. Of
- 55:22course, each weeknight here on
- 55:25KET with our program Kentucky
- 55:27Edition. Just final word.
- 55:29Representative Watkins, real
- 55:30quickly 30s on an idea we
- 55:31didn't discuss.
- 55:32>> Sure. Well, we're talking
- 55:33about building more housing. I
- 55:34want to make sure that housing
- 55:35is safer. So I believe that
- 55:37every new home and every new
- 55:38rental unit should have a smoke
- 55:40alarm. So House Bill 326 does
- 55:42that.
- 55:42>> Okay. All right. We'll be
- 55:43looking. We've got a lot of
- 55:45notes that we've taken on all
- 55:46the bills and the bill numbers.
- 55:47We're going to be tracking
- 55:49those. And you can follow along
- 55:50because we'll do that on
- 55:51Kentucky Edition at 630 eastern,
- 55:52530 central right here on KET.
- 55:55And next Monday night we will
- 55:56talk about public education
- 55:58legislation. Several bills are
- 55:59flying through the General
- 56:01Assembly. Senate measures that
- 56:02deal with JCPS Jefferson County
- 56:04Public Schools and Fayette
- 56:05County Public schools. And and
- 56:07we're going to talk about all
- 56:09of that next Monday night. And
- 56:10then the meantime, on Friday
- 56:11night, you can make sure you
- 56:12turn back here. You'll see Bill
- 56:14Bryant and a panel of working
- 56:15journalists talk about the news
- 56:16of the week, and they'll break
- 56:18down all of these issues before
- 56:19the Kentucky General Assembly.
- 56:20Thanks for watching tonight.
- 56:21I'm Renee Shaw and I will see
- 56:23you tomorrow night on Kentucky
- 56:25Edition. Take good care.
- 56:25[MUSIC]