Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Mental Illness and Crime: How Mental Disorders Enter the Criminal Justice System
Transcript
- 0:00You know, usually when you think about a medical
- 0:02diagnosis, there's this expectation of, like,
- 0:05total precision. Oh, absolutely. Like a broken
- 0:08bone. Right. If you break your arm, the doctor
- 0:10puts you in an x -ray machine, the film comes
- 0:12out, and they just point to a jagged white line
- 0:14on the screen. Yeah, they just say, there it
- 0:17is, broken. Exactly. The evidence is objective,
- 0:20it's visible, and it's undeniable. Welcome to
- 0:23the psychology undergrad, by the way. We are
- 0:25really thrilled you decided to join our study
- 0:28session today. Because when you step out of a
- 0:30standard medical clinic and into the world of
- 0:33psychology, I mean, that x -ray machine just
- 0:35completely breaks down. It really does. You are
- 0:37suddenly navigating this diagnostic landscape
- 0:40that is entirely murky. And when that murky landscape
- 0:43collides with the rigid rules of the criminal
- 0:46justice system, well, the stakes become literally
- 0:49life and death. Yeah, which brings us to the
- 0:51case from our notes today. Right. To really grasp
- 0:54those stakes, we need a moral anchor for everything
- 0:56we're going to study today. So let's look at
- 0:59the case of Ethan Saylor. Man, this case is just,
- 1:02it's so heavy. It really is. Ethan was 26 years
- 1:06old, and he had Down syndrome. And by all accounts,
- 1:08he was just a really vibrant guy. Yeah, he loved
- 1:11his church. He loved playing the guitar. And
- 1:13ironically enough, he deeply admired police officers.
- 1:16Which, you know, knowing that detail makes what
- 1:20happened in 2013 just profoundly heartbreaking.
- 1:22Yeah. So Ethan was at a movie theater with his
- 1:26caregiver, and they had just finished watching
- 1:28Zero Dark Thirty. Right, and his caregiver walked
- 1:31out to pull the car around. Ethan, he simply
- 1:35wanted to stay and watch the movie a second time.
- 1:37Yeah, so he just went back inside and sat down
- 1:39in the theater. And the theater manager ended
- 1:41up calling mall security. Right, and it just
- 1:44so happened that mall security was being staffed
- 1:46by three off -duty sheriff's deputies. It's important
- 1:49to note here, looking at our notes, that Ethan
- 1:51hated being touched. Yes, that is a very common
- 1:55sensory reality for many individuals with developmental
- 1:58disabilities. So his caregiver saw what was happening.
- 2:00ran back in, and explicitly begged the deputies
- 2:04not to touch him. She literally asked them to
- 2:07step back and let her handle the situation, which,
- 2:09you know, she was trained to do. But they ignored
- 2:11her completely. They decided to force him out
- 2:13of his seat. And when Ethan verbally resisted
- 2:15the physical contact, they escalated. They pinned
- 2:18a 26 -year -old disabled man to the ground to
- 2:21handcuff him. He was crying out for his mom.
- 2:24And, uh... Underneath the weight of these deputies,
- 2:28he eventually stopped breathing. His death was
- 2:30officially ruled a homicide by asphyxiation with
- 2:33a fractured larynx. It's just a tragedy that
- 2:35never had to happen. Not at all. So, what is
- 2:38our mission for you and us in this study session
- 2:40today? Well, we are going to review our notes
- 2:43on the major categories of mental disorders.
- 2:45Right, we need to understand the mechanics of
- 2:47how these conditions manifest in vulnerable populations.
- 2:51Especially when they enter the criminal justice
- 2:53system. And we want to explore the intense moral
- 2:56implications of how society treats these individuals.
- 2:59Because the foundational question in Ethan's
- 3:01case is how those deputies failed so utterly
- 3:05to recognize the reality of the person sitting
- 3:07right in front of them. Exactly. And to understand
- 3:10that failure, we first have to understand the
- 3:12tools mental health professionals use to define
- 3:15these conditions in the first place. Right. So
- 3:17our baseline rule book in our notes is the DSM
- 3:20-5 -TR. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual
- 3:23of Mental Disorders Text Revision. Yeah, quite
- 3:25a mouthful. But this is the current standard
- 3:28operating manual for psychiatry across the United
- 3:30States. Let me bounce an analogy off you to help
- 3:33conceptualize this for our notes. Think of the
- 3:35DSM like the operating system on your smartphone.
- 3:39Oh, I like that. Yeah, it provides the entire
- 3:41framework for how the mental health system runs.
- 3:43But just like iOS or Android, it constantly requires
- 3:47software updates to fix bugs. And we aren't just
- 3:49talking about scientific bugs here. No, we are
- 3:51talking about massive bugs in societal morality.
- 3:55Like, if you look back at older versions of the
- 3:57DSM, the psychiatric establishment literally
- 4:00classified being gay as a mental disorder. all
- 4:03the way until 1987, which is wild to think about.
- 4:06Right. The recent updates to the manual have
- 4:08finally started scrubbing highly stigmatizing
- 4:11language, replacing it with more objective humanizing
- 4:14terms. Like using the phrase experienced gender
- 4:16instead of pathologizing someone's identity.
- 4:19Exactly. The operating system metaphor works
- 4:21perfectly because, you know, even if you have
- 4:24the newest update installed, the software is
- 4:27only as good as the person holding the device.
- 4:29Yeah, what our notes call cultural humility.
- 4:32Right. A rigid adherence to the rule book is
- 4:35dangerous without an understanding of the patient's
- 4:38cultural context. Our texts use indigenous and
- 4:42native communities as a prime example of this
- 4:44failure. Because those communities carry immense
- 4:47generational trauma linked to systemic violence
- 4:50and colonization. Exactly. Yet the Western mental
- 4:53health model often completely fails to treat
- 4:56them. Well, beyond chronic underfunding and a
- 4:59deeply justified historical mistrust of government
- 5:01medical institutions, there are, like, profound
- 5:04linguistic barriers, too. Yeah, in several native
- 5:07languages, there isn't even a direct conceptual
- 5:10translation for the English word depressed. Sadness
- 5:13and trauma are understood through an entirely
- 5:15different communal and spiritual framework. They
- 5:17are. But wait, if our primary diagnostic tool
- 5:20was built almost exclusively by and for one specific
- 5:23Western culture, Isn't it kind of a fundamental
- 5:26moral failing to apply it rigidly to marginalized
- 5:30groups? It's a huge question. Especially if we
- 5:33are talking about a legal setting where a judge
- 5:35is using that exact tool to determine if someone
- 5:38should lose their freedom or their life. Yeah.
- 5:40The field of forensic psychology wrestles with
- 5:43that exact contradiction every single day. I
- 5:45can imagine. When an evaluator lacks cultural
- 5:48competence, they risk pathologizing a completely
- 5:52normal cultural response. Or, conversely, they
- 5:55miss a severe underlying psychiatric crisis simply
- 5:58because the patient's presentation doesn't perfectly
- 6:00match the textbook definition. Exactly. A definition
- 6:03written in a completely different cultural context.
- 6:06It fundamentally alters how a court views an
- 6:08individual's intent and culpability. And that
- 6:11concept of culpability shifting because of an
- 6:14underlying crisis leads us directly into our
- 6:16next section in our notes trauma. Right, because
- 6:19severe sustained stress doesn't just result in
- 6:21someone feeling sad. No, it physically chemically
- 6:24alters the architecture of the brain. completely
- 6:27fracturing a person's baseline reality. Post
- 6:30-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD, is, I mean,
- 6:33it's basically an epidemic within the justice
- 6:35system. The statistics we have in our notes are
- 6:38staggering. They really are. Over 20 % of incarcerated
- 6:41women meet the diagnostic criteria for PTSD.
- 6:43Wow. And we also track disproportionately massive
- 6:47rates among incarcerated black men, which our
- 6:50texts link heavily to a lifelong exposure to
- 6:53violent victimization. Right. The mechanism of
- 6:56trauma essentially hijacks the brain's alarm
- 7:00system. It physically changes how the amygdala
- 7:03processes danger. Locking the individual's nervous
- 7:06system in this perpetual state of hyperarousal.
- 7:08Exactly. You know, if you're taking notes along
- 7:10with us, I like to use the four buckets as a
- 7:12memory aid for PTSD criteria. The four buckets,
- 7:15yeah, that's a great way to break it down. Yeah.
- 7:17Bucket one is re -experiencing. This is where
- 7:19the brain replays the trauma through vivid flashbacks
- 7:22or nightmares. Right. Bucket two is avoidance.
- 7:25The intense, active effort to stay far away from
- 7:28any triggers or reminders. Bucket three is reactivity
- 7:32being easily startled, prone to outbursts, or
- 7:36constantly on edge because, well, that alarm
- 7:38system is broken. And bucket four is thinking
- 7:41and mood, which covers the cognitive side, like
- 7:45significant memory gaps and persistent, crushing,
- 7:48negative beliefs about the world. When you look
- 7:50at those four buckets, you can start to see how
- 7:53an individual operating in that state of hyperarousal
- 7:56might react aggressively to a guard's sudden
- 7:58command. Oh, totally. Now, if trauma is severe
- 8:01enough, and particularly if it occurs repeatedly
- 8:04during early childhood development, it can push
- 8:07the brain beyond PTSD into dissociative disorders.
- 8:10Which is a profound defense mechanism where the
- 8:12core sense of self splinters to survive the unbearable
- 8:15stress. Right, resulting in deep memory and identity
- 8:18disturbances, and the most The infamous condition
- 8:20in this category is dissociative identity disorder,
- 8:23or DD. But anyone studying psychology has to
- 8:26navigate DD very carefully, because public perception
- 8:29has been entirely warped by pop culture. Oh,
- 8:32completely warped. You were talking about the
- 8:34Sybil myth from our reading. It's wild to look
- 8:36back at the history here. It really is. In 1973,
- 8:40this book called Sybil was published. It detailed
- 8:43the story of a woman who supposedly had 16 distinct
- 8:46personalities, and it became an absolute cultural
- 8:49phenomenon. Everyone was talking about it. And
- 8:52the fallout from that media frenzy caused immense
- 8:54collateral damage to the practice of clinical
- 8:57psychology. How so? Well, to put it in perspective,
- 9:00prior to the publication of Sibyl, there were
- 9:02roughly 100 documented cases of multiple personality
- 9:06disorder in the entire history of modern medicine.
- 9:09A hundred. Ever. But in the single decade following
- 9:12the book's release, thousands upon thousands
- 9:15of people were suddenly diagnosed. Wow. It was
- 9:17a massive psychological contagion. Exactly. The
- 9:20media fascination literally manufactured symptoms
- 9:23in the public. Dayt is a legitimate condition,
- 9:26but it is exceedingly rare. And later investigations
- 9:28revealed that much of Sybil's narrative was heavily
- 9:31embellished, if not entirely fabricated, by her
- 9:34psychiatrist. Yeah, it's terrifying how easily
- 9:36our shared perception of reality can be manipulated
- 9:39by a trend. Which brings us to the individuals
- 9:41whose brains lose their connection to reality
- 9:43entirely without any media influence. Let's look
- 9:47at psychotic disorders. Right, with schizophrenia
- 9:50being the primary diagnosis we need to cover
- 9:52in our notes. Schizophrenia is generally categorized
- 9:54by three types of symptoms, right? Yes. You have
- 9:57positive symptoms, which are things added to
- 9:59reality, like auditory hallucinations or fixed
- 10:02delusions. Then you have negative symptoms, which
- 10:05are things taken away from a normal baseline,
- 10:07like a completely flat emotional affect, or a
- 10:10severe lack of motivation. And finally, there
- 10:13are cognitive symptoms that impair memory and
- 10:15executive focus. But if there is one clinical
- 10:18concept you take away from this entire study
- 10:20session, it needs to be anasognosia. Anasognosia.
- 10:24This concept absolutely blew my mind when I first
- 10:27read about it. It's so important. It is the neurological
- 10:30inability to recognize one's own illness. Think
- 10:32about how the public reacts to a person experiencing
- 10:35severe schizophrenia on the street who refuses
- 10:37medication. The common assumption is that the
- 10:40person is just being stubborn or deeply in denial.
- 10:43Right, but anasognosia means that the specific
- 10:46physiological region of the brain responsible
- 10:48for self -reflection and insight is physically
- 10:51damaged or impaired. Okay, let me use another
- 10:53analogy here because this is crucial for our
- 10:55notes. Think of anasognosia like a driver having
- 10:59a literal blind spot in their car mirrors. Oh,
- 11:02yeah. If an 18 -wheeler is riding in your blind
- 11:05spot, you don't refuse to see the truck. You
- 11:08are not stubbornly ignoring the truck. You genuinely,
- 11:11physically cannot see it. Right. It is not a
- 11:14moral failing on the part of the driver. It is
- 11:16a physical deficit of the vehicle. Now, translate
- 11:19that to the criminal justice system. Imagine
- 11:21how lethal that physical deficit becomes when
- 11:24someone with anasognosia interacts with a police
- 11:26officer. An officer who is aggressively demanding
- 11:29immediate compliance from someone who literally
- 11:31cannot see the reality the officer sees. That
- 11:34analogy captures the danger perfectly. It does.
- 11:36And that total loss of insight bridges us directly
- 11:39into our next major category, mood disorders.
- 11:43Because even if someone doesn't have a psychotic
- 11:45condition, extreme sustained shifts in emotion
- 11:49can also detach them from their baseline reality.
- 11:52frequently leading to a desperate need to self
- 11:54-medicate just to survive the day. Let's break
- 11:56down the mechanics of bipolar disorder and major
- 11:59depressive disorder based on our notes. Bipolar
- 12:01involves those massive pendulum swings between
- 12:04manic highs where risk assessment often vanishes
- 12:07and crushing depressive lows. Right, and the
- 12:09clinical context surrounding depression is vital
- 12:11for our understanding of how it impacts society.
- 12:14Take perinatal depression. Oh, right. We use
- 12:16that specific terminology now to clarify that
- 12:19the onset of severe depression often begins during
- 12:22pregnancy, not just postpartum. Exactly. And
- 12:24it impacts roughly one in seven women. We also
- 12:27see incredibly high risks of severe depression
- 12:29among LGBTQIA plus youth. And the research in
- 12:33our source material doesn't link this to the
- 12:35identity itself, but directly to the daily friction
- 12:38of societal stigma. Yeah. Our notes impartially
- 12:41report that when simple existence requires navigating
- 12:43aggressive legislative barriers, like a teenager
- 12:47fighting just to use a public bathroom safely,
- 12:49the psychological toll is immense. Fortunately,
- 12:52we have a section on treatments. Our notes highlight
- 12:54cognitive behavioral therapy, or CBT, which essentially
- 12:57works by identifying and manually rewriting negative
- 13:01looping thought patterns. We also have dialectical
- 13:03behavior therapy, DBT. This one is huge for the
- 13:07justice system because it focuses on building
- 13:09distress tolerance. Right, teaching an impulsive
- 13:12brain how to build a shock absorber for intense
- 13:14emotion rather than acting out dangerously. And
- 13:17for severe treatment -resistant cases, there
- 13:20is modern electroconvulsive therapy, ECT. Which
- 13:23is not the torture device shown in old movies,
- 13:25but a highly controlled, medically induced neural
- 13:29reset used as a last resort. But here's the tragedy.
- 13:32When vulnerable people don't have access to CBT
- 13:35or DBT or a supportive medical system, they turn
- 13:38to whatever is cheap and available. Yeah, that
- 13:41reality feeds directly into substance use disorders.
- 13:44Which are currently monopolizing public health
- 13:46discussions due to the sheer lethality of the
- 13:48fentanyl crisis. Absolutely. But for our focus
- 13:51today, the critical concept is the dual diagnosis.
- 13:54Almost 40 % of individuals with a substance use
- 13:57disorder are concurrently battling another distinct
- 13:59mental illness. I use a check engine like analogy
- 14:02to understand dual diagnosis. Let's hear it.
- 14:05When you see someone completely consumed by addiction,
- 14:08you have to ask is the chemical substance the
- 14:11root cause of the broken engine? Or is the substance
- 14:15use just the driver's desperate attempt to slap
- 14:19a piece of black tape over a flashing check engine
- 14:21light? Like a severe undiagnosed mood disorder
- 14:24they can't afford to treat. Framing it that way
- 14:26highlights the agonizing chicken or the egg dilemma
- 14:29that clinicians and judges face. Because while
- 14:32self -medication is incredibly common, the biochemistry
- 14:35is a two -way street. Right. We know definitively
- 14:39from our notes that substances like high -potency
- 14:41cannabis or amphetamines can actively trigger
- 14:44early psychosis in susceptible brains. Or wildly
- 14:47exacerbate an underlying psychotic disorder.
- 14:51Disentangling the origin, figuring out if the
- 14:53trauma caused the addiction or if the addiction
- 14:54induced the psychosis is a nearly impossible
- 14:58task for a court trying to determine legal accountability.
- 15:01Which brings us to a really uncomfortable boundary.
- 15:03We've established that a mood disorder or a psychotic
- 15:06break can sometimes mitigate criminal behavior
- 15:09in the eyes of the law. But where does the justice
- 15:11system draw the line and say, no, your psychiatric
- 15:13state does not excuse you? Well, the legal system
- 15:16draws a very hard line at personality disorders
- 15:19and paraphilic disorders. Let's look at antisocial
- 15:21personality disorder first. The diagnostic criteria
- 15:25require a pervasive long -term pattern of manipulating,
- 15:29exploiting, and callously violating the rights
- 15:30of others. In the general public, this might
- 15:33affect around 5 % of the population, but in populations
- 15:37of incarcerated men, prevalence estimates skyrocket
- 15:40up to 75%. That's a massive jump. Then you have
- 15:43narcissistic personality disorder driven by grandiosity
- 15:46and a profound lack of empathy. And borderline
- 15:49personality disorder, which is characterized
- 15:52by a terrifying fear of abandonment and explosive
- 15:55emotional instability. We also need to define
- 15:58paraphilic disorders, such as pedophilic disorder.
- 16:01The DSM draws a very fascinating specific moral
- 16:04boundary here. It does. Simply experiencing atypical
- 16:07sexual urges does not constitute a mental disorder
- 16:10on its own. the manual explicitly states it only
- 16:13crosses the threshold into a diagnosable disorder
- 16:16if those urges cause significant distress to
- 16:19the individual or if they result in harm to others.
- 16:23The distinction between having a thought and
- 16:25acting on a compulsion is foundational to the
- 16:27DSM. But legally speaking, states are incredibly
- 16:30rigid about these specific categories. Like Oregon,
- 16:33for example. Yeah, Oregon is a prime example.
- 16:35Their statutes explicitly exclude personality
- 16:38disorders and paraphilic disorders from being
- 16:41utilized as the basis for an insanity defense.
- 16:44The legal framework essentially dictates, even
- 16:47if a psychiatrist diagnoses you with this recognized
- 16:50disorder, you retain full agency and are fully
- 16:54responsible for your actions. Right. I have to
- 16:57stop and push back on the morality of that legal
- 16:59framework. Go for it. Our textbooks and our notes
- 17:01clearly establish that conditions like borderline
- 17:04and antisocial personality disorders are heavily
- 17:06forged by a combination of genetics and severe
- 17:09repeated childhood abuse. That's true. So if
- 17:11we know that as scientific fact, isn't it a massive
- 17:14moral contradiction for the justice system to
- 17:17look at a defendant and say, We fully acknowledge
- 17:21that your brain's architecture was physically
- 17:23miswired by horrific trauma when you were a three
- 17:26-year -old, but we are still going to hold you
- 17:28100 % culpable for the way that brain operates
- 17:31today. You know, you are hitting on the ultimate
- 17:34philosophical tension in forensic psychology,
- 17:37the war between determinism and free will. Right.
- 17:41Where exactly does the childhood trauma end and
- 17:44the adult's free will begin? The justice system
- 17:47relies almost entirely on the premise of free
- 17:49will, because the alternative absolving violent
- 17:52or destructive behavior because of a tragic background
- 17:55is a reality society refuses to accept for the
- 17:57sake of public safety. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 17:59And frankly, this strict legal boundary exists
- 18:02largely because of the fear of malingering. Malingering,
- 18:05faking it. Exactly. Deliberately exaggerating
- 18:07or entirely fabricating psychological symptoms
- 18:10to escape justice. Oh, like Kenneth Bianchi from
- 18:12our reading. Yes, the hillside strangler. He
- 18:15is the textbook cautionary tale. In the late
- 18:1870s, he brutally tortured and murdered at least
- 18:2110 women. And when he was finally cornered by
- 18:24law enforcement, he attempted to fake dissociative
- 18:26identity disorder. Right. He claimed a hidden
- 18:29alternate personality was the one committing
- 18:31the murders. It took skeptical psychiatrists
- 18:33and rigorous interrogation to eventually expose
- 18:37the lie. Cases like Bianchi's forced the legal
- 18:39system to remain hyper vigilant and deeply suspicious
- 18:43of psychiatric defenses. That suspicion is exactly
- 18:46why we have to discuss psychopathy. It is. And
- 18:48we need to clarify that psychopathy is not an
- 18:50official diagnosis in the DSM, right? Correct.
- 18:53It is a clinical construct, a specific cluster
- 18:56of traits. Dr. Robert Hare developed the Psychopathy
- 18:59Checklist Revised, or PCLR. To measure traits
- 19:01like superficial charm, profound callousness,
- 19:04pathological lying, and a total lack of remorse.
- 19:07And while only about 1 % of men in the general
- 19:09population score high enough to be considered
- 19:11psychopathic, 15 to 25 % of prison inmates exhibit
- 19:16these traits. Wow. So it has become a highly
- 19:19controversial but critical tool for courts. when
- 19:22assessing the risk of recidivism. It really has.
- 19:25Okay, we have just waded through the darkest,
- 19:27most manipulative behavioral profiles. But as
- 19:31we start to bring this study session to a close...
- 19:33We have to return full circle. Yeah, we have
- 19:35to look at the people who, much like Ethan Saylor,
- 19:38are fed into this brutal system fundamentally
- 19:41unequipped to defend themselves. We must address
- 19:43childhood and neurodevelopmental disorders. This
- 19:46includes disruptive conditions like oppositional
- 19:49defiant disorder or ODD and conduct disorder.
- 19:52And you cannot look at these diagnoses without
- 19:54confronting the staggering racial bias and how
- 19:57they are applied. Our sources are very clear
- 19:59on this. Studies consistently show that white
- 20:02children exhibiting disruptive behaviors in school
- 20:04are frequently diagnosed with ADHD. Right, and
- 20:07ADHD is framed as a medical or neurological issue
- 20:09that requires patients, medication, and academic
- 20:12support. However, black children exhibiting the
- 20:15exact same behavioral patterns are disproportionately
- 20:17labeled with conduct disorder. Which the system
- 20:20views not as a medical need but as an inherent
- 20:23behavioral threat. That bias is infuriating because
- 20:27it completely misses the underlying trauma those
- 20:30marginalized kids might be reacting to. It effectively
- 20:33criminalizes them before they even reach adulthood.
- 20:36It really does. We also see catastrophic systemic
- 20:39failures when dealing with autism and intellectual
- 20:42developmental disorders. Now the modern neurodiversity
- 20:45movement is doing incredible work here. They
- 20:47are rightfully reframing autistic traits like
- 20:50hyper focus deep passion and direct communication
- 20:53as strengths rather than clinical deficits But
- 20:57when those behavioral differences intersect with
- 20:59the criminal justice system the lack of understanding
- 21:01can be deadly Which brings us to the profound
- 21:04moral crisis of false confessions. Yeah Individuals
- 21:07with intellectual disabilities are vastly overrepresented
- 21:10in our prisons. To survive in a world not built
- 21:13for them, many have adaptively learned that pleasing
- 21:15authority figures is the safest route. So imagine
- 21:18an individual with a cognitive disability sitting
- 21:20in an interrogation room with a detective for
- 21:23six hours. They aren't stubbornly resisting.
- 21:25Their brain simply realizes the detective wants
- 21:28them to say yes. So they will frequently offer
- 21:31a full false confession to a horrific crime.
- 21:34Simply because they want to be agreeable and
- 21:37they think agreeing means they get to go home
- 21:38It's a horrific exploitation of a survival mechanism
- 21:41It really is and finally we have to touch on
- 21:44neurocognitive disorders in our notes specifically
- 21:47traumatic brain injuries or TV eyes and dementia
- 21:51The statistics we have here are almost unbelievable.
- 21:54Research indicates that up to 87 % of jail and
- 21:57prison inmates report having suffered a traumatic
- 21:59brain injury. 87%. That is wild. Yeah. A TBI
- 22:04often devastates the prefrontal cortex. It severely
- 22:07impairs impulse control, sparks sudden aggression,
- 22:10and hinders the ability to process complex instructions.
- 22:13So when an inmate with an untreated TBI fails
- 22:15to quickly process a guard's order, the guard
- 22:18almost always misinterprets that neurological
- 22:20as deliberate defiance. Exactly. This leads to
- 22:23the inmate being thrown into solitary confinement
- 22:25or facing extended sentences, essentially punishing
- 22:28a brain injury with isolation. And you compound
- 22:31that with the looming epidemic of dementia. We
- 22:34have an aging, highly marginalized inmate population
- 22:37that is rapidly losing its cognitive function.
- 22:39It's a crisis. Let me ask you this because looking
- 22:43at these notes is incredibly bleak. If our state
- 22:47prisons are literally being forced to construct
- 22:49memory care wards, and we have inmates whose
- 22:52daily job is to change the bedpans of other elderly
- 22:55inmates dying of Alzheimer's, haven't our prisons
- 22:58just become morally bankrupt? deeply unequipped
- 23:01nursing homes? Honestly, when you analyze the
- 23:04demographic data and the daily operations of
- 23:06these facilities from our readings, it is very
- 23:08hard to argue otherwise. We are essentially warehousing
- 23:11cognitive decline. In the absence of a functional
- 23:13mental health infrastructure, the penal system
- 23:16is operating as the ultimate, albeit incredibly
- 23:18punitive, social safety net for human beings
- 23:21whose minds are simply failing them. Well, that
- 23:23is a remarkably heavy realization, but it's vital.
- 23:26Thank you for joining us on The Psychology Undergrad
- 23:28to review these notes today. Yes, thank you.
- 23:30Understanding the mechanics behind these disorders
- 23:32and critically examining the biases in how our
- 23:35society diagnoses and punishes them is the very
- 23:39first step toward treating people with the dignity
- 23:41they inherently deserve. It is the only way we
- 23:44begin to prevent avoidable, devastating tragedies
- 23:47like what happened to Ethan Saylor. Because a
- 23:49thorough, compassionate understanding of the
- 23:51mind is the absolute best defense against systemic
- 23:54failure. Before we close our textbooks for the
- 23:57day, I want to leave you with one final thought
- 23:59to meld over on your own. Oh, I'm ready. We started
- 24:02this session by comparing a psychiatric diagnosis
- 24:04to an x -ray, pointing out how messy, murky,
- 24:07and complex the reality of the human brain actually
- 24:10is. But take a step back and think about the
- 24:12criminal justice system itself. Okay. If our
- 24:15justice system was originally designed centuries
- 24:17ago on a moral framework of punishing the wicked
- 24:20or isolating the evil, how must society radically
- 24:23redesign that entire system now that we can finally
- 24:26see inside that murky x -ray? Now that the science
- 24:29proves the vast majority of people locked inside
- 24:31those walls aren't wicked at all, but are actually
- 24:34just human beings navigating severe neurological
- 24:36injuries. untreated childhood trauma, and terrifying
- 24:40cognitive decline.