Latest / Carbon Weekly News / Why Carbon Removal Should Count Today | CWN EP7
Transcript
- speaker-0: There are no residual mesh then and what is left is what we decide to use carbon moves for. Like carbon removal is something to make net zero faster, cheaper and more achievable. It's gonna be seventy percent by twenty fifty, thirty five percent of that is bi fuel and thirty five percent E fuel. There would be essentially zero demand for carbon removal from the best use case there is, which is aviation. Why should SAP count but not doable CR? Right? I'm quite skeptical about how basalt and hash work cluttering are gonna turn out actually. Only buy a chart that's faster than anything. Like you know everyone else is delayed. speaker-1: Here you see the role of tree planting asking for a friend. speaker-2: Robert's fantastic that you could make it. speaker-0: Yeah, I'm glad you invited me. Quite the setup you have here. speaker-2: Yeah, I'm actually quite excited. We all talked a lot about setups. You're actually a student of Africa, right? And I have an amazing setup and Dan and San Sebastian has catch up to play, but we already established that as Marford. So, but actually we just need to come together for every episode, like in studio. think that's Right. speaker-1: Would be speaker-2: We meet for surfing in Cape Town. speaker-1: Wives and children I'm sure would love that. speaker-0: No. speaker-2: Absolutely fantastic. would be big, big supporters of that idea. our flight, I think, how do I get to San Sebastian? A mess, absolute mess. speaker-1: A lot of carbon offsetting or saf a lot of speaker-2: Saf a lot of staff or not. could talk about that as well. But Robert, fantastic. I I am like, I have one person in my team. She will see that she's like, I love everything that Robert is sharing and around recycling, geo balance, use, and like, she always forwards it to me. And she was like, you have probably that amazing. And she sent me a couple of questions, but Be honest, I had not time to look at it and say sorry to you. speaker-0: Come on, you gotta put them off. speaker-2: Sorry, sorry, sorry. But I think one interesting thing that I always love to talk about because we see some similar things with the customers that we work on is around net zero. So maybe you can give like a really quick intro and like there was some thinking I think it started like a year ago or something that net zero as a concept as it's right now, no one will achieve it. It makes no sense. Why do we setting ourselves up for that and we running towards it and no one is changing anything. So like how, how has your thinking evolved over the last year and maybe you can introduce us to that concept. speaker-0: Great. No, thank you. Yeah, in in my role at MilkyWire, so impact firm ahead of time out there, and I have some other hats if you want them to, for CDR and so on. but there I've been writing about this kind of new way of looking at corporate targets, new Lans on Net Zero. We published a paper in June. It was called Build a World Your Net Zero Target Assumes, arguing that a net zero target is not so much like a smart target as it is a vision. with like one target component, like these are the things that we actually can issue. Like these are the emission reductions. We have agency, there's affordability. We'll set targets for those, identify like where we have a special responsibility, like we're the actual ones that has to pay for this. Like that should be your kind of the unconditional target. Yeah. And then net zero, there's a lot of things that you could be doing to help reach global net zero, kind of creating the conditions like working on policy change, working on your Supply chains in way that may not actually connect your GG inventory, right? Because there's like maybe this R and D, maybe it's coalition building, maybe things that like you won't see your scope free number go down, but it's actually really important. So kind of wanted to contextualize net zero like that. It's it's a commitment, it's to to make the world come true that your target kind of assumes. So we wanna use net zero because thousands of companies have the targets. Yeah. And say that well speaker-2: Like a third or so of the world, think of the big companies, corporates out there, I think have net zero targets or something like that. speaker-0: And saying like, well, you're not gonna use reach this by yourself unless, you know, maybe you're you're a rich company that could use carb removal for all of it, but it's relatively rare. And then you should kind of say what you're doing to to help achieve this. but carb removal still has a really important role. We can get into that as well. speaker-2: So I actually, when I thought about it before this, I was like, I would say almost all of our customers called me when the new SPTI came out and they calculated this 2035 target. And they were like, they can't be serious. That is so much money. If I have to take the whole responsibility also for scope free. And this was just scale up over time. you're your emissions will go down and so on over time, but then you have to spend more money on more durable removal and so on. So they literally taught me like, if this comes up, I'm leaving. If I can't share that, so to say that responsibility. So I also feel like, I'm not sure if you think are these other companies at the moment with net zero and the targets that they have set up at the moment, they feel almost like paralyzed. They're like, yeah, I'm not sure what to do, but I'm not going to do this. speaker-0: No, exactly. Yeah, I think there there is a need for kind of more shared language on like what you can do and how you can talk about this. how you can talk about having a target that you're not in control of. And that's okay. Like it's seen it more as a vision. But yeah, I mean, where I see companies with carb removal and their targets, then there's a lot of focus on the near term 2030. Yeah. So operational net zero as a concept. So like cover your scope one, two and other operationals like business travel, I think is really a good case to be using. CDR and SAF for today. Like it's gonna be a green premium forever, basically. It's always gonna cost more than than just burning fossil fuels. And carbon removal is a long term solution, as in staff too. So start paying for that right now. But SPTI has to allow that as near term target fulfillment. Right. so the the companies that that reach operational level net zero or that try to do that, they don't have any blessing from anyone. So if they got some blessing, I think it would be more common. And then that could take this kind of CDR industry through these kind of relatively challenging years. speaker-2: So, I mean, at the moment it's like, there's so many companies always calling me like Adrian. Yeah, I love it just because of LinkedIn. No, I wish. but there's a lot of companies that always like they have this clear divide between reduction and removal, right? So it's like two complete different things for them. But why? speaker-0: Yeah, no, exactly. I think we did ourselves a great disservice, also with as the industry, as kind of always saying that first reduce, then remove, and like remove should never replace reduce. Because like that's true in most cases, but you actually do removals instead of some reductions. And like that's the point. Like carbon removal is something to make net zero faster, cheaper and and more achievable. And for th for example, electrofuels for aviation or for shipping as well. Are very likely much more expensive than permanent carb removal. So like then you would use permanent carbon removal instead of using electric fuels. And that's okay. And that was like controversial. I think it's less controversial now, but in some like two years ago when I said that to like an industry group that sort of should agree, you you would think, they would c they call it greenwashing, like because people have been talking about it as if removals are only for some magical emissions called residual. But there are no residual emissions. Like because Resid that's just like whatever is left. And what is left is what we decide to use carbon removal for. So it's circular, right? Like it's the we don't need carbon removal for any CO two emissions. There's always other alternatives. So unless you allow carbon removal for target fulfillment, including near term target fulfillment, there's no point in using it at all. speaker-1: How does a how does a company draw or how do you draw that line of saying this is something that I mean you talked a little bit about is it is it based on economics? Where is this because also the economics though, there's a little there's a bit of a chicken and an egg problem there too. The more we invest in carbon removal, the cheaper we can make the solutions and then the more continued emissions I can have from other areas because it's cheaper for me to actually offset. So how do we how do we draw that line as a society to say, no, this is kind of where we should say anything above this? Gets removed. speaker-0: Yeah. I think that the market should decide given strict guardrails on quality. So if you use look at the EU ETS now, the proposal from the EU Commission. I think it's great because they make it very clear that carbon removal is mitigation. It's nothing special with it. And they expand the EU ETS. They may include more allowances, more emissions, but they cancel it out with carbon removal. And that's how it's supposed to be used. and then in the long run with EU ETS, the all emissions will be covered by removal. So I think The the market will decide. But when you allow more emissions, like when you're saying we're actually gonna burn more fuel fossil fuels, then it really needs to be permanent. I don't think that you should plant trees to allow more fossil fuels to be used. Planting trees is a very cost efficient solution, but when it's like enabling more fossil fuels, then I think it needs to be permanent. So and and then I think the market can figure it out and companies can use it wherever they see fit, it's kind of expensive with coverable. So they do have a lot of cheaper options. speaker-2: That's the thing, right? I think in a world where a credit costs five euros, they understand how someone says reduce first and then compensate the rest. But in a world where you actually have just a marginal abatement cost curve and you look at the market and you want to enable someone to steer a company, then give them all the options if they're the same. And I think we are unfortunately not there yet. speaker-1: Where do you see the role of tree planting asking for a friend? But I'm just curious, yeah, what what's your perspective on where it should be used and where it shouldn't be used? I mean you give an example of where maybe it doesn't doesn't speaker-0: So one is if you have a set budget and you want to create as much impact as possible, then I think it's a pretty cost effective way of doing that. So if you for example, you know, you're saying we can spend a million dollars, ten million dollars on climate right now, I think it has a pretty given role, like to to do nature solutions, including affrestation and and so on as well. And then secondly, like in a compliance system, I think for other greenhouse gases, like if you want to net out nitrous oxide, for example. from agriculture and say that we want to reach not just net zero CO two, but also net zero like GHGs and or at least for nitrous oxide. Methane is so short lived, so I don't I don't think you need to go net zero there. But like for there I think it it could be plausibly and in the EU I could see that happening, right? Like for for the agriculture emissions, you use the forest sector and so on. Interesting speaker-1: Interesting. You mentioned methane. We we've talked to a few of the recent deals that Google has done in the methane space, both MIDI labs and Teradot, kind of looking at, in one case, just a pure methane avoidance play with alternative wetting and drying and rice, and another one where they're sort of looking at Teradot's case, right? Combining methane avoidance with ERW to have durable CDR. What's your view on on methane? Like, do you think that, you know, should should we be Should we be tracking this? speaker-0: So I think I hate CO two E. You should never use CO2 equivalent. Like I mean there's a worthless concept basically. Like which confuses everyone. Like you should go to net zero CO2 to stop warming and then have a methane reduction target. And like the more you reduce methane, the more carbon budget you have. So like the the less fast we have to reach net zero. Like if we don't do any methane reduction at all, we had we we're already past one point five. Like there's no amount of like reductions we can do. So methane is like needed to to to create a little bit of space for for CO2. But in terms of like is it a cost effective thing to fund? I think if you fund something that's long lasting in terms of like a new practice, for example, or like a the phase out like these refrigerants and so on, and then becomes like a long lasting thing. It's not just like paying every year for this destroying them. Then I think it's basically worthless. but if you're like creating long lasting change, or like this wetting and drying, maybe that I don't know if it leads to long lasting change, but if it does, I think it's really good. And in the specific Google case, I think they they do it also to make like a robust thing where the the the enhanced rock weathering takes they we don't really know, but like maybe decades could be in some cases, right? So making sure that there is like an abatement before that if you're gonna use these credits for some kind of claim. I think that that that can be a robust way of like framing. Yeah. speaker-1: So like a landfill emissions avoidance thing, is that is that up to up or down for you? Like should we be doing those kinds of projects? speaker-0: I think that's probably a policy thing where you should like influence po decision makers to make sure that you shouldn't have any unbent unabated land bill. Like it's not that hard actually to to in have that policy. speaker-2: I think so too. But I'm actually very interested in that whole topic of use and so on, because we work with, as you know, with some of the big airlines and I think they obviously struggling a lot with that, right? On certain perspective on like, is there enough, what is the pricing and so on. Like you also talked about, I think the Oxford Net Zero came up with a new concept. Can you maybe elaborate a little bit on how is there a way forward? Like what can aviation sector expect? Is there like a certain point where we maybe can introduce that and stuff? speaker-0: Thank you for asking. Yeah, they they use the term geologically balanced fuels. I like it. You know, sometimes you have to come up with a new name for the same concept to get more buy-in. I am I'm okay with that. You know, that's GBF. Yeah. speaker-1: Super pollutants. speaker-0: Exactly. Exactly. You know, that's that that's taking on, like people like TV. So I think right now the refuel EU legislation, I don't know if you're probably familiar with it. Maybe all not not everyone who listens to this will be, so I'll just explain quickly that companies airlines have to That do fuel uplift, like put fuel in the plane in the EU has to put more and more staff, it's gonna be seventy percent by twenty fifty, thirty-five percent of that is biofuel and thirty five percent e fuels. So that's legislation. And that's like it's policy stacking, it's on top of EU ETS. So if companies actually comply with that eSAf and biosap legislation, they don't need any ETS credits at all. So which means that there will be essentially zero demand for cover removal from the best use case there is, which is aviation. Where it's the best use case. And right now Refuel is up for review and the commission is gonna publish a report first of January. So now we have to start influencing that. Or it's already late, but we gotta do it now. I'll I'm I'm trying to pull some strings there. but like, you know, and and then there'll more. and also in other places, SPTI, etc. Why should SAF count but not durable CDR? Right? so that's we have to make the case over and over again. And I think I felt relatively lonely. I'm not the only person talking that, but like Now Oxford Netero is doing great, the researchers are still doing it, but I think we need more voices. speaker-2: I actually, I'm still sharing that with aviation companies. It's the one post, I think it was in two years ago, the comparison with E-Fuel is to CDR and the pricing and so on. Where it was basically, I think in the end you would be able to buy two CDR speaker-0: Yeah, basically. speaker-2: credits for every E-Fuel ton of CO2. It feels like a fast little bit where it's like, look guys, let's just figure out the best way and let's not talk around. Now I think it's crazy. now that's great, but I'm thinking like, is there anything else? Like, I mean, you and a lot of conversation, is there like some crazy concept where you say like, well, this actually could change a lot in five years and no one knows about it. speaker-0: well then I'll then I'll say that we're working on the kind of connected to your first question, like a capabilities first approach. Yeah. Right. Looking at what can we do as a company, what are our unique capabilities? And then like setting targets downstream of that. and for companies that are relatively rich, like they they could do a lot with money actually and and kind of support different things. For those that have like ordering manufacturing, they have a lot of capabilities and kind of looking at what what kind of goes into a product and so on. But it that targets are not one size fits all. that it's something that sort of needs to be tailor made a little bit to to companies. So you just like mentioning concepts, that's maybe one concept. speaker-2: No, that sounds good. with Mickey way, you also supporting a lot of projects, which I absolutely love. And I'm wondering, is there any kind of pathway methodology project type where you were like, this is going to be it. But now after like one or two years, you're like, no, this is it. speaker-0: Not not going well. No. speaker-2: We're not gonna work out. speaker-0: Well, the easy one to answer is like macroaldiosyncing. but you know, that doesn't look like it's gonna be going economical. I'm quite skeptical about how basalt and hash rock ordering are gonna turn out actually. Like it's gonna it's hard to measure and it may take a long time. is it then gonna be economical? Like so you can get a good price per per ton for the speaker-2: We were talking about price per ton of enhanced rock weathering where I'm not a project developer, but obviously sometimes from corporates I'm asked like, what is the price? Can you give me a price for the next 15 years? everyone gives me completely different price. The one is 150 in the end, the other one is 400. So I'm still, I feel like I'm in a black box from the outside. You know way more about it. But for me, it feels something. speaker-0: It's also depending on what you accept as evidence and also like where there's no scientific real consensus on how to measure it right now. Yeah. Like so there's a bit of a debate. I think for limestone it's it's easier to measure. Yeah, because you can look at the water and it's getting flushed out all the time. So there you could get it more cheaply today already without much like controversy on like how it was measured. speaker-1: Yeah, limestone does seem like a really interesting spot. And it I mean it's it's tricky because the the big benefit of ERW a few years ago, as we all thought, was wow, I can I can start generating revenue in year one, two, three from these projects because I can measure this and I see what's happening. And you know, and if that starts to change, then the economics as the economics erode, yes, you could technically just wait and measure much later. And that's what we're seeing in some of these concepts of okay. You know, if I don't know what's but then you really have to do something like this combined methane approach. So a traditional ERW only project just doesn't really work in that sense, right? In addition to the questions of there's still a lot of scientific questions. It seems like more and more every year on on whether this you know works and how speaker-0: There was more questions raised than answered, I think. Yeah. Unfortunately. Yeah, over the last five years. speaker-1: A lot of buyers are pulling back as a result of that, which, you know, and in addition to that, you're still seeing even with the current scientific understanding, a lot of developers really struggling to bring credits on. speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: I was curious as well, maybe along the same lines and these some of these new projects that you're what's a rising star that you're seeing who has made it faster to first deliveries than you had originally expected? speaker-0: Only Bioshar that's faster than you think. Like you know, everyone else is delayed. so it's you should expect delays like as a buyer as well. Like you have to be realistic, like when you're making off takes and so on. Like you if you don't want to screw the product over, you sort of have to may build in that they don't know how fast this this is gonna be unless they're already like delivering at scale. And it's basically only Bioshar that is delivering at scale. So some Bioshar products have been faster, but also many of them are delayed actually. So speaker-1: Hear mixed reviews from a lot of buyers about biochar because we've often said, Hey, we got all this forest, we got forest biomass, we could potentially have waste biomass. We should be using it in biochar. And a lot of buyers say, but the biochar is risky. There's a lot of, you know, there's huge range in quality and pricing. What's your perspective on that category? Like you think it is a a category that's here to stay and we can find a way to kind of speaker-0: I think it's here to stay, but the difficult thing is that we're not gonna reach consensus there either on exactly how durable it is. Because there's a inner inertinite camp that sort of p points to being thousands of years. It's coal like. Yes, it is. But if you grind up coal and put it in active soil, we don't exactly know what's gonna happen to that coal either. So like there is a live it's it's hundreds of years probably, right? So it it's not like it doesn't go away quickly. We're pretty sure it stays there for for quite some time. But is it like a thousand years? it's gonna be hard. It's gonna be really hard to figure out if it's thousand years not. That that may be okay. but that's why it sort of puts it in a little bit of like middle careg category. But if you're gonna remove carbon now, that's basically what you can do this year, right? Yeah. speaker-2: And is there like maybe to wrap it up, there like, I actually always love to ask my candidates when I hire people, but I think in general, it's a good question. Is there like one thesis or like one thing out there where you stand really strongly behind where everyone else is like, I'm not sure if this is going to be a thing, like some pathway or some thesis around net zero targets. speaker-0: Well I I I think I said a lot of stuff that that could qualify as that answer already. Yeah. speaker-2: Fair. speaker-0: but yeah that that carbon removal is mitigation that is used right away for near term target fulfillment. Like that's what I'm really trying to hammer in now. So I'll say one more time. to you know, yeah get it that long list. speaker-2: I mean, I love that. I think if we want to enable like real carbon management in companies, which at the moment it's not, like I don't feel like I feel like there's a sustainability manager that basically has to translate certain things into different apartments, but they're never really almost a controller. why? Because we don't enable them. How the standards are set up and then they're also different from each other. I think they're not enabled to go on like almost like a cockpit perspective. they're like, look, these are the things this will cost us. This will cost us and this we can do achieve in five years, but we will not. That's the reason I can do this and so on and so forth. They're not in the seat at the moment. So I'm, I'm, I'm all up for that. speaker-0: Mm. That's good. speaker-2: right, Robert, thanks so much for coming over and speaker-0: Thank you. speaker-2: wishing you a good climate week. speaker-0: Likewise. speaker-1: Yeah, this was fun. Thanks.