Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When the Company Says No Budget
Transcript
- Lucas: Listener question this week, and it's one I hear constantly: 'My boss says I deserve a raise, but the company has no budget. What do I do now?' Luna: That 'no budget' line is brutal because it sounds final. But it's often not as final as it seems. Lucas: Right. And I want to start with a specific example. A friend of mine — mid-level marketing manager at a regional bank — got told exactly that last year. She was due for a promotion-adjacent raise, maybe 15 percent. Her boss said, 'You're killing it, but we're in a hiring freeze, no salary budget until Q4.' Luna: So she just waited? Or did she push back? Lucas: She did something smarter. She said, 'I understand the budget constraint. Can we document the raise I've earned, and set a review date in six months, with a written commitment to fund it then?' Luna: And they agreed? Lucas: They did. But here's the kicker — she also asked for something immediate that wasn't salary. A one-time professional development stipend, five thousand dollars, to attend a leadership program. That didn't hit the salary budget. It came from a different pool. Luna: Interesting. So she got something tangible right away, and locked in the raise later. Lucas: Exactly. And if today was actually useful to you, the way these episodes stay ad-free is listener support. You can find that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to keep this going. We appreciate it. Lucas: So back to that framework. She did three things I think are worth unpacking. First, she reframed the ask from a cost to a retention investment. She brought data: her exit would cost the bank roughly 1.5 times her salary in recruiting and training. Luna: That's a strong number to have ready. Most people just say 'I deserve it,' not 'here's what you lose if I walk.' Lucas: Right. And second, she timed her ask to a real business win. She had just led a campaign that increased digital account openings by 18 percent. That's not 'I've been here a year.' That's 'I just delivered measurable value.' Luna: So the 'no budget' line becomes harder to lean on when you're pointing at a specific result. Lucas: Exactly. Third — and this is the part most people skip — she proposed non-salary trade-offs. Besides the stipend, she asked for an extra week of vacation, pro-rated for the year. That cost the company almost nothing in cash, but it moved her total compensation noticeably. Luna: And it signals she's thinking creatively, not just demanding more money. Lucas: Yeah. Now, there's research on this too. A Willis Towers Watson survey from 2024 found that about 40 percent of companies that said 'no budget' for a raise actually had funds available — they just hadn't prioritized that person's role in the current cycle. Luna: So 'no budget' often means 'not budgeted for you right now.' Lucas: Exactly. And that's a very different problem. It's a persuasion problem, not a math problem. So the move is to make your case undeniable and to give them a path to say yes that doesn't blow up their quarterly planning. Luna: What about the one thing you should never say in that conversation? I've heard you mention that before. Lucas: Never say 'I'll leave if I don't get it.' Unless you already have an offer in hand and you're genuinely willing to walk — and even then, it's a high-risk move. Once you threaten, the relationship changes. Better to let your leverage be implied: 'I love this team, I want to stay, and I want to make sure we find a solution that works for both of us.' Luna: That's diplomatic. But what if the budget truly is frozen? Like, the company is in a downturn? Lucas: Then you pivot to non-salary compensation entirely. Stock options if they have them, or a future-promotion track with a written timeline. I had a listener who got a title change to 'Senior Analyst' with no raise, but with a documented commitment that the next review cycle would include a 10 percent adjustment. She got it six months later. Luna: So the paper trail matters. Without documentation, the promise can evaporate. Lucas: Absolutely. Send a follow-up email after the conversation: 'Thanks for the discussion. To confirm, we agreed to revisit compensation in January, with a target of X percent, contingent on continued performance.' That's not pushy — it's professional. Luna: I think a lot of people worry that asking for documentation signals distrust. But it's actually just good business. Lucas: It is. And the best bosses appreciate it because it makes their job easier — they can forward that email to HR and say 'we have an agreement.' Luna: Let's talk about the timing. You mentioned she timed her ask to a business win. How soon after a win should you bring it up? Lucas: Within two weeks, ideally. The data is fresh, your boss is still feeling good about the result, and the correlation between your effort and the outcome is obvious. If you wait a month, it starts to feel like 'remember that thing I did?' Luna: And the actual meeting — how do you open the conversation without sounding entitled? Lucas: Start with gratitude and context. 'I really appreciate the opportunities I've had here, and I want to make sure I'm building a long-term future. Given the results we just saw on the campaign, I'd like to discuss how my compensation can reflect that.' Then pause. Let them respond. Luna: That's calm and confident. Not demanding, but clear. Lucas: Right. And if they hit you with 'no budget,' you have your next move ready: 'I understand. Could we talk about alternatives that don't hit the salary line, and also set a firm date to revisit the raise?' Luna: So the script is: acknowledge, pivot to non-salary, lock in a future date. Lucas: Exactly. And the key detail is 'firm date.' Not 'sometime next year.' Say 'Can we put a review on the calendar for January 15?' That's concrete. Luna: What about people who work at smaller companies, where there really isn't a separate budget for stipends or training? Lucas: Then get creative. Ask for a paid certification. Or a conference ticket. Or even a title change that positions you better for your next job — that costs them nothing but can boost your earnings down the line. One listener got 'Lead' added to her title and used it to land a 20 percent raise at another company six months later. Luna: So the title itself becomes a form of compensation. Lucas: Exactly. And for people who stay, the title can also justify a higher band in the next compensation cycle. HR looks at titles, not just tenure. Luna: I want to circle back to the retention argument you mentioned. How do you find that data — the cost of replacing yourself? Lucas: Start with your salary. The Society for Human Resource Management publishes benchmarks: replacement cost is typically 1.5 to 2 times annual salary for mid-level roles, higher for senior. You can say 'Industry data suggests replacing someone at my level costs the company roughly X dollars.' That's credible and not self-serving. Luna: And it frames you as someone who thinks about the company's interest, not just your own. Lucas: Right. And that's the whole game. The person who gets the raise isn't always the one who deserves it most — it's the one who makes it easiest for their boss to say yes. Luna: So making it easy means having a specific number, a specific alternative, and a specific timeline. Lucas: And a written follow-up. That's four things. Do those four, and you've probably done more preparation than 90 percent of people who ask for a raise. Luna: I think that's a good place to leave it. Next episode, we'll talk about something I've been getting a lot of questions about: how to navigate a return to office mandate when your team is distributed. Lucas: That's a good one. See you next time.