Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / POSSIBLE 2026 Day 3: The AI Endgame, Agentic Media, and Rebuilding the Ad Stack
Transcript
- 0:01This is signal and noise bringing Clarity to data Tech
- 0:07and AI. Three of possible at the
- 0:16Fontainebleau in a suite with a nice view of my Army.
- 0:20Beautiful little bit cooler today which I'm kind of liking I
- 0:23can wear this and not overheating along sleeve today.
- 0:27Ian mayor, thank you. Did I pronounce it right now in
- 0:30my from high touch you're the GM of tic at a company which I'm
- 0:35really fascinated by a lot of my time career in the data
- 0:39management space. And so I'm excited to just deep
- 0:43thought a little bit with you. So a few of the themes running
- 0:46through data at the moment. Where is come from?
- 0:48Where is going? First up, I just want to tell me
- 0:51about a little bit about soft your journey and then we'll get
- 0:54into the hi touch business as well.
- 0:56Yeah, myself, it's been an interesting Journey from
- 1:00probably, some of my my first job's were really as a
- 1:04practitioner and running a combination of life cycle and
- 1:07advertising programs for e-commerce.
- 1:10Um, so you know to date myself a little bit.
- 1:14I'm probably the generation who when I started advertising
- 1:18really, it was all about meta and Google and first-party data.
- 1:22And so I kind of actually started in that world first, I
- 1:26then moved into the B2B World, basically bringing to Market and
- 1:31building products that helped people like me that help
- 1:36advertisers do advertising better both on the buy side and
- 1:39the sell side. So how do we you know, curate
- 1:41audiences and and measurement data for these ad platforms and
- 1:45then second how do we use the data that we have as a media
- 1:48seller to monetize a better show, okay?
- 1:50So that would give you a really nice sides of how this ain't
- 1:55coin, right? How that data can actually be
- 1:57used by directionally? Yeah, some people will see you
- 2:01dates which is just it comes from there and goes to their
- 2:03way. Exactly.
- 2:04Right. And it's interesting to see, you
- 2:07know, there's data on both sides and it's being used by both
- 2:10parties. And actually, the application's
- 2:13are pretty similar. Yeah.
- 2:14In some ways functionally but the outcomes are very different.
- 2:17So a lot of what I think about is how do we take solutions that
- 2:21we have and how do we make them work really well.
- 2:23Specifically, for sellers specifically for buyers, okay?
- 2:26And so 90 have been hard for about two and a half years, turn
- 2:30off. Okay, so you got your feet on
- 2:31the table you know you're doing oh cool, he didn't It's just
- 2:34tell me a little bit to give me a high level as to what high
- 2:37touch is who they are. What kind of part they play in
- 2:39this ecosystem. Yeah, so I just were revolving
- 2:42all the time so the answer kind of has changed quickly over
- 2:45time. But we are, I think about, as,
- 2:47as really two things, the first is what we call a composable
- 2:50customer data platform, and that means that we were a CDP.
- 2:53So we can help you build audiences and conversion events
- 2:56measure the performance of your advertising.
- 2:58And that we do all of that without storing any of your
- 3:01data. Okay, the observation there is
- 3:03most all the Enterprise that we work with will realize is They
- 3:07already have a source of Truth. Their first party data that
- 3:10exists in a cloud data warehouse.
- 3:11Sure. Bike snowflake data breaks
- 3:13bigquery AWS and That data one already lives there.
- 3:19It's well governed, it's clean and the real problem is just
- 3:22accessing that data. So what we do is we have a
- 3:25visual interface that allows that just sits on top of their
- 3:28data infrastructure without copying the data.
- 3:30So that a marketer and Advertiser, a media seller can
- 3:33go in build audiences, curate, conversion, API data streams and
- 3:37all of the stuff that they need to get data to where it needs to
- 3:41go. Yeah, right.
- 3:42The second part and part of why we're evolving so quickly as
- 3:46that, we launched our agentic marketing platform, which Builds
- 3:50on top of the foundation that we've created by building AI
- 3:55agents that can specifically build on brand creative for
- 3:59advertisers. That can, you know, do all of
- 4:02the other agentic things that cdp's often do like you know we
- 4:05can write a human prompt and it can generate a basically a media
- 4:09plan and and audiences and set up your conversion fees for you.
- 4:13And what's unique about that? Is that You know, applaud chat,
- 4:18CBT, Etc, actually already really good at doing that stuff.
- 4:21And so, why do you need separate software to do it?
- 4:23The answer is basically that they don't have the context that
- 4:28you need to do it. Well, context generated from the
- 4:30data that, you know, platforms, its over.
- 4:32Exactly. Right.
- 4:33So the, the context that's important there is context about
- 4:36the business about the customer about the, the performance of
- 4:40fast campaigns. If you want to create really
- 4:41good creative, well, if you know what's performed well on the
- 4:44paths and an AI agent in figure out make a hypothesis and say,
- 4:49well, you know it probably has to do with this specific type of
- 4:52messaging. Yeah, I need this specific kind
- 4:54of vibe within the creative itself and then create its own
- 4:58version. So asking the dates are in your
- 5:01own terms and being able to just get more seamless back and forth
- 5:05with it. Exactly.
- 5:06Did you mention creative as well?
- 5:07I don't talk me through that. I didn't expect to hear that.
- 5:10Yeah. It's it's an interesting one
- 5:12because you think a data company is going to just focus on the
- 5:15data? Yeah.
- 5:16Yeah, exactly. Yeah he our observation is we're
- 5:19trying to solve the whole customer problem and the
- 5:22customer problem. That's an Advertiser is if I
- 5:25want to create really high performing advertising.
- 5:28I need really good data and really good creative and we see
- 5:33those as the two Fundamental sort of foundational pieces.
- 5:37And as you know, these AI systems have just gotten really,
- 5:41really good at doing this stuff. We realized that if we want to
- 5:45set, if we want to solve the whole customer problem, then we
- 5:48need to solve the creative side, too.
- 5:49And we think we have a really, really good reason why we can do
- 5:53it better than your standard llm or another company in this case.
- 5:59Yeah, I mean, I just sort of, as you were sort of mentioning it.
- 6:02My mind was wandering is to all the different other ways.
- 6:07You can combine data and created.
- 6:08And if your thesis is that you're going to go to where the
- 6:12source of Truth is, that's kind of a movable, right?
- 6:14You know, you're not going to change that later is which is
- 6:17obviously why your platform does what it does and that then makes
- 6:22sense as to bringing the creative that way as a you know,
- 6:26maybe there's a You know, porting the data over there into
- 6:30the creative platform. That's yeah, that the sort of
- 6:35tagline that I've been. Playing with for a while.
- 6:37And I think resonates with a lot of people, it's this, well you
- 6:40need to bring your media to your data, not bring your data to
- 6:43your media and the closer, you can bring it to the data.
- 6:47Sit better media, you can create.
- 6:49Sure. Yep.
- 6:50I'm not like that. Totally makes sense.
- 6:52If one thing is immovable and the other one is movable.
- 6:54I mean let's So, tell me about the idea that a customer base
- 7:00platform doesn't hold the customer data.
- 7:02Again, that's, maybe obvious to some, but for me, brings a
- 7:06little bit of a surprise or maybe just an
- 7:22Really over the past two plus years.
- 7:25Our strategy. I think he's been validated
- 7:27because now if you look at any CDP they work, they are either
- 7:30trying to go composable or calling himself composable in
- 7:34some way be Sort of, the reason, all of this came about was that
- 7:39our, our Founders actually came from USC.
- 7:42And in that process, what they realized is that the whole
- 7:47promise of the CDP of creating this customer 360 and now being
- 7:50able to create audiences, activated to Identity
- 7:53resolution, all these things that company actually had a
- 7:55really hard time delivering on the promise and delivering on it
- 7:58quickly because there's this core problem of Your customer
- 8:04data is over here and you need to get the customer data into
- 8:07this other. Oh, yeah.
- 8:08And so, now, there's actually this in a lot of cases, they
- 8:12would have six to 12 month. Implementation process is just
- 8:16to build all the data pipelines that someone needs to get it
- 8:19into the separate data source. So, in that way, like that's
- 8:21kind of a big problem and why this whole Evolution started
- 8:27the. I think the adoption of it has
- 8:29been really great and so rapid in large part because of the
- 8:33same time, everyone was moving to this.
- 8:36Modern data stack, just means everyone was trying to
- 8:40centralize the data and the data warehouse for analytics and for,
- 8:43you know, to make good business decision.
- 8:46Well hey if that is already there, it's already clean.
- 8:49We don't have to move the data. We don't have to spend 12
- 8:51months. Trying to get it into another
- 8:54system. Yeah.
- 8:55Right. So we can send audiences.
- 8:57Yeah, I'm not so so Unpacking, the word composable.
- 9:02Is that for you, right? It's, it's just take the bit
- 9:06that you need and speed everything up.
- 9:08Yeah, it's often. We'll talk about composable in
- 9:10two cents. One is composed on the
- 9:11warehouse, so you're composing. The data platform on the
- 9:16warehouse. Yeah, or your composing, you
- 9:18know, your agenda platform on the warehouse, the other is that
- 9:21you really only have to pick and use the parts that you need.
- 9:25Yeah. So hey, we need to be able to
- 9:28hear an audiences and send them somewhere.
- 9:30Great. We have a we have a solution for
- 9:32that. We are if our main goal is to do
- 9:35identity resolution, just Stitch data together better.
- 9:37We have an identity resolution solution, you don't have to buy
- 9:42that they Suite. Yeah, to do all of that we have
- 9:46you know, these individual modules that You can use
- 9:49separately. You can put together.
- 9:51That makes sense. Yeah, I'm not like, you know,
- 9:53modular was always the way I there's a word I always used to
- 9:56use by I guess it's not all right.
- 9:58Yes, I guess. Yeah, the concept makes sense to
- 10:02me. And do you feel like everyone's
- 10:03going that way? Is that how in a world of AI in
- 10:06a world of, you know, lots of different Niche specific
- 10:09technologies that you know, there's going to be a little
- 10:12Microsoft tool for everything in two years time probably.
- 10:15And in that world do you think the composable modular what
- 10:20everyone call it is just An all-encompassing construct from
- 10:24the whole industry? Or does it, do you think it's
- 10:27really specific to how they move around?
- 10:31I do think there's. I do think fundamentally the
- 10:36market and the way that the way that infrastructure is
- 10:39structured in the way that software now interacts with each
- 10:42other kind of makes it so that that will be the case.
- 10:45I can't say that everyone is going to be doing that because
- 10:50even just from a business perspective, if your goal is to
- 10:52grow the businesses, Large. And as quickly as you can, there
- 10:56are going to be Large platforms, whose best strategy is to try
- 11:01and lock you in to all of the things that they did, okay?
- 11:04So I think that'll continue to happen but you know our hope is
- 11:07that that's not actually Yeah, for sure.
- 11:10That makes sense. And so then let's come to, I
- 11:14guess the slightly ambiguous Topic in my head which is an
- 11:18agentic world of everything, right?
- 11:21Well of programmatic agentic. Stuff and we've got the ability
- 11:26for agencies to transact with, you know, or to or to try and
- 11:31act on behalf of a brand with a public show.
- 11:33You know, I'm hearing Rumblings or you know, a lot more thoughts
- 11:36that having agent agentic buying is actually going to maybe be an
- 11:41alternative to data being rich in some instances.
- 11:44I don't know if that's going to happen or not.
- 11:46It's not. It's just like you know, when
- 11:47you talk to Publishers and talk to agencies that that, you know,
- 11:50let's let's try and do a genetic buying.
- 11:53She starts to pop up in as an alternative to data so how I
- 11:57just want to understand how and maybe that's that's something we
- 12:01need to dispel right now or maybe it's I just want to hear
- 12:03your sort of unfair thoughts on. Do you just High touch?
- 12:06Do you feel a softly? See A genetic as all about
- 12:11making the data better? Or do you see it as maybe a
- 12:14parallel track down the line you about what?
- 12:17I mean? It's very much.
- 12:19So I think fundamentally, I don't know that, I agree that
- 12:22agentic can replace the need for data movement, for example, or,
- 12:28or for some form of data sharing or even collaboration, whatever
- 12:31that labor is. And actually in part because of
- 12:35AI. So, really concrete example of
- 12:38this is, you know, every Walled Garden, every DSP, most ad
- 12:42platform. Like a lot of CTV platforms now
- 12:44are starting to release conversion.
- 12:45Apis. Well, why?
- 12:47Because they need data to make really good decisions around
- 12:50which ads to show show whether it's programmatic, whether it's
- 12:54right, even right. Publishers who are now doing
- 12:57direct buyers are trying to do some form of decisioning and you
- 13:00need the feedback from The customers data to say, well,
- 13:05these These are good outcomes. Let's go find more data comes
- 13:08like it. I do think that Agentic media
- 13:11buying. So, you know, figuring out, you
- 13:14know what some, which Publishers should I buy?
- 13:16What placements, you know, how much budget should I allocate to
- 13:19these different line items? That is a really interesting
- 13:21place, where, yeah, any identical to be really good at
- 13:24it, right? Both within within the wall
- 13:26Gardens within the programmatic platforms, within like, direct
- 13:31publisher. Yeah, and so that, like starts
- 13:33to Be really interesting question.
- 13:35Like what happens to all of these?
- 13:38Different methods of buying when there's this other layer, that's
- 13:42kind of coordinating everything. Yeah, yeah.
- 13:43And I just like, just the way the that's really good response
- 13:46and thoughtful one but I mean that's kind of where my I was
- 13:50sort of Moody on the this idea that, you know, in two years
- 13:53time, perhaps first party data is the creme de La Creme like
- 13:56the jewel. The kind of the gold standard
- 13:58for doing all of this stuff and then maybe a sort of more
- 14:04watered down ai-powered. workflow, is there for When the
- 14:10first party data doesn't exist or and I know like there's pros
- 14:14and cons that enables more access to similar kind of
- 14:17mechanisms for those who don't have huge first party data sets,
- 14:20but at the same time, you know, they'll come a point where you
- 14:22need to distinguish what swap because otherwise, we end up
- 14:26diluting first party data again, which is what we've done too
- 14:29much will already. I think there's a great point.
- 14:32I like I'll be the first to recognize that there are a lot
- 14:35of there. A lot of places and advertising
- 14:37where first party isn't as a applicable.
- 14:39So a good example of this would be, you know, broader brand
- 14:43campaigns where there isn't necessarily actually a sales out
- 14:47where someone's exchanging some information with you for money.
- 14:50But your goal is to, you know, increase brand awareness or
- 14:54increase brand affinity. the I think what is actually
- 14:58interesting in terms of Like what could become valuable
- 15:03first-party data is actually the output of that, which is
- 15:06measurement data. So, you know, there's a, there's
- 15:09a big push from a number of dsps ssps again Publishers to make
- 15:15log level measurement data more accessible.
- 15:19And where does that happen to live?
- 15:20Where does that happen to go? Do a warehouse.
- 15:23And so now if you have all this measurement data, even if you
- 15:26don't necessarily have the final outcome, you have some agents
- 15:30who can analyze the data. Maybe you have some external
- 15:33data like your brands that you can an agent could be running,
- 15:37hold out tests and getting exposure data back and comparing
- 15:40it to ya, France studies and now like you are actually using
- 15:44what's become technically your data and to do some really
- 15:48interesting things. Is yeah, that's a really good
- 15:51way of putting actually. It's Accelerating the problem,
- 15:55or reducing the problem in the way.
- 15:57Like, if you don't have first party, then create a better
- 16:00flywheel to yeah, to make that a reality.
- 16:02Exactly. And maybe it's like it's almost
- 16:05It's more about data ownership. Yeah, than it is about, which
- 16:09party originally owned the data, and how can, you know, create
- 16:12this ecosystem of data that you own and that you control?
- 16:15Yeah. So you can make better decisions
- 16:16and drive, better performance. The unheard such as recently,
- 16:20you guys have been in the news a little bit, talk through that
- 16:23little for a sec Dash. I mean, well, I guess today.
- 16:26A good timing. Yeah, got timing.
- 16:28We just announced our series D, raising our 15 million dollars
- 16:33at a. It's a 2.75 billion.
- 16:36Wow, okay. He's a huge numbers.
- 16:39They're huge number. So we've been, I mean we've been
- 16:42on a tear for a while. We've been, you know, we've more
- 16:45than doubled our Revenue, two years in a row.
- 16:49We I think, recently announced that we had 100 100 millionaire
- 16:52and you know, to us, that's a testament to things that One has
- 16:58been the acceptance and really Embrace this composable.
- 17:02Yeah, mentality. Because you know, that's a lot
- 17:06of what is taken us to this place and who has been, you
- 17:10know, a lot of the early success and you know, the fact that
- 17:13these investors really bought into our vision around agents,
- 17:17right? We launched our genetic
- 17:19platform, we have, you know, vegan, exciting Enterprises
- 17:22using it actively today to drive better ad performance.
- 17:26And we think the combination of those two is what why we're here
- 17:29and why we're racing the way that we are, right?
- 17:31Oh congratulations. And like I think the with that,
- 17:34you know, you see certain companies getting investment,
- 17:36you see some companies doing well.
- 17:37But when I unpacked the, the philosophy in mechanics of what
- 17:42you guys do, it does make a lot of sense in an AI Ford world.
- 17:45And I Can Only Imagine that you'll Actually democratize that
- 17:50and make it available for more and more types of customers in
- 17:54the future as well. Yeah, we're really excited in AI
- 17:57together, you know where they on Adeno?
- 17:59Yeah, we're not the first one to say data and AI.
- 18:02So no, but usually better tag, but using it in combination
- 18:06correctly. I think is what you guys are
- 18:08definitely doing so right and thank you so much for joining
- 18:11joining me on the Pod today and we'll see you next time.
- 18:13Thank you so much pleasure. Thank you.
- 18:15He possible Miami 2026. We just saw a beautiful rainbow
- 18:20180 degrees over probably one of the better views of Miami that
- 18:25I've ever seen in from Miami. Yeah Sebastian Penzone.
- 18:29Right. I've never seen you and I live
- 18:32here 10 years. Yeah.
- 18:33And so when you got somebody from Miami coming and looking
- 18:36out, I wish we could show the audience here.
- 18:37It's pretty spectacular because you can see the entire from the,
- 18:41from the beach to the canal. What is Canal?
- 18:44Call? Which yeah, Financial District.
- 18:46You can almost see the ocean and That you can see, they can now
- 18:50basically, is this a metaphor of Miami?
- 18:52The only part. That's not visible.
- 18:54Are here is when we yeah, they'll have a such big
- 18:57buildings. Yeah, but you guys are, I'm
- 19:00impressed. Yeah, this is in, and we're
- 19:02saying thanks to ignition who has this sweet, and we're doing
- 19:07some work with them and they decided to a lot to host signal
- 19:10annoys and so, so guys. Yeah, yeah exactly.
- 19:15So I've just gotten to know Sebastian over the last 15
- 19:19minutes and great guy. I've already getting really good
- 19:22vibes. A Columbiana.
- 19:24Yeah, that did went to school in Canada, you mentioned.
- 19:28Yeah. So right.
- 19:32I finished high school then to Canada, or the Bus 18 and you
- 19:36may not be a small town in British Columbia that must have
- 19:40been a bit of a culture shock crazy, you know, this theorems.
- 19:43Hey, you share with the other people?
- 19:46You never met? Yeah.
- 19:47And funny story. I met some of the guys, one of
- 19:52my best friends in college. She was coming from pundit and
- 19:54it's just now he's out of people.
- 19:56Yeah, so it was really crazy. And did you see all these, that
- 20:00kind of, like, in the time of Vietnam, it ran away from the
- 20:03states and they created they want to read it.
- 20:05Yeah. Yeah.
- 20:06It's something on local communion.
- 20:08Yeah. Can you use a great?
- 20:11I think. I my sister lives in and I'm
- 20:15still. She's the one that selling the
- 20:18catalog 80. Oh, there we go.
- 20:20Yeah, he brought some cacao that we're gonna, you know, make some
- 20:23hot tea this morning with Um, yeah.
- 20:26And so so Avo you were talking a little bit about that.
- 20:29There's a couple different topics that I think we could
- 20:31cover. That will be really interesting
- 20:32for our audience and avo does basically AEO which is, which is
- 20:37a o g o, which is kind of your next Generation, AI driven
- 20:42either answering or generative engine optimization.
- 20:45Tell us a little bit about what what you guys are doing around
- 20:49that. And we can kind of By the
- 20:55abortion marketing knows that word of mouth is where he said,
- 20:58that's what really influenced the Moment of Truth level.
- 21:02Yes. So you're gonna yeah, for the
- 21:04month is evolving. And get out.
- 21:06It's not coming from your friends.
- 21:07Come from a bad. Yeah, exactly.
- 21:09I'm in chatbots in a sense are kind of a word of mouth
- 21:12mechanism where you're getting immediate feedback.
- 21:16Yeah. Which a lot of knowledge in the
- 21:18back. Right.
- 21:19So yeah. Hallucinate.
- 21:20Yes. I like, Miss Beyonds 99% of the
- 21:23time is going to like, I'm better than any of your friends.
- 21:25Yeah. So we help Brands understand
- 21:27Charlie, showing up, if they're showing up.
- 21:30I just showing up with the right things or, yeah, he's making
- 21:33things up. Yeah.
- 21:34And so people don't know how to manage that system and they
- 21:39don't know really where I was pulling stuff and so they could
- 21:42be completely misrepresented, right?
- 21:44Right. Based on some sort of Legacy
- 21:46documentation, or prior information online.
- 21:49So there's basically, you know, Market leaders.
- 21:51Yeah. You watch out for like, they're
- 21:54probably already in AI responses.
- 21:55Are you being shown the way you want?
- 21:57Are you being? You know, like if your prices
- 22:00are there, right prices? Also, for the people that are
- 22:04not as known small brands, are you leaving showing up, right?
- 22:07Yeah. And then what we do is, um,
- 22:09first of all, we spend good time, understanding your
- 22:12business. Two then developers strategy of
- 22:14what to track. The reality is there's a million
- 22:17million companies that do any attractive.
- 22:20Yeah. But what really matters is what
- 22:22you attract, right? Because you can track any
- 22:24questions. But if it's a question that's
- 22:26not related to the business or your objective, you're gonna be
- 22:29wasting money. Yeah.
- 22:30So it's good to like that's the first step.
- 22:31Yeah. And tracking meaning you're
- 22:34tracking the questions that that if you're bdb company, if you're
- 22:37BDC company, you're tracking the questions that people are asking
- 22:39that a resulting in answers, that include your brand, your
- 22:43product, your service. And so, you want to see, you
- 22:46want to optimize around, what's driving the most actions from
- 22:50right? Even exam?
- 22:51Angela say, you're already buying a some people search.
- 22:56Yeah. And you're ready know where the
- 22:58keywords are bringing? You the most sales if you sell
- 23:00not. What we do is we get this
- 23:02keywords and then we transform them into products because we
- 23:05know that the intentionality you want to be.
- 23:08Yeah. On right.
- 23:09It's not like natural language process.
- 23:12We have. So what we do is we leverage the
- 23:14first party data from your current campaigns from your
- 23:16customer service, support, whatever customers asking you
- 23:19less than this, there's not really been the wheel, right?
- 23:22Yeah. Reddit threads and online
- 23:25communities to understand what it was worth tracking, but also
- 23:30understand your marketing Tech, right?
- 23:32Yeah. If you for some reason, had a
- 23:33new rebranding and there's a new thing that won your branch so
- 23:36well, we will track that. Yeah.
- 23:39So you really depends. I think it's very our approach
- 23:43more consultancy that can enable.
- 23:45Yeah, rather than just solution is going to service like you
- 23:49rush or any of those guys. Yeah.
- 23:51Like we we think that the strategy behind it, it really
- 23:55matters technology. It's always going to technology.
- 23:57Yeah, I'm talking to a friend, just the our industry.
- 24:01Although there's a lot of their we love this event because we
- 24:03are we connect with people and that's what really sell.
- 24:06Yeah. I mean, we are connecting with
- 24:07people and we go live. Yeah.
- 24:08Because the IRL in real life, right, which is really come
- 24:11back, right? And it sort of after covid.
- 24:14Yeah. And in people are doing people
- 24:16are amps to be here. There's a lot of interaction,
- 24:18right? So back to that, a the AEO SEO,
- 24:21I mean, you mentioned in our NR, you know, conversation before
- 24:24the the Pod that it really. It's, it's 80% of it is really
- 24:28SEO, right? When you fundamentally from a
- 24:32technical perspective, from a technical perspective?
- 24:34You now we're done as you go, well, you gotta start.
- 24:36Yeah, like that, the way that AI searches actually just similar
- 24:41to Google the difference is that they AI actually, it's only one
- 24:46response is not a list of links. Yeah, it is synthesized like him
- 24:51that he would read the top 10, top 20.
- 24:53Yeah, well and then resistance. Okay, so when I read this is a
- 24:57response. Yeah, so in the first step is
- 25:00Technical College. On SEO.
- 25:01I'm not going to bore people in this.
- 25:02Yeah. It's because you can go and look
- 25:05it up online. Yeah.
- 25:05But I think what it's critical for people to understand that.
- 25:07It's not, it's not something that's wildly new, you know,
- 25:11you're building on the same foundation and your company is
- 25:13taking what is fundamentally a search strategy and then taking
- 25:17that and transforming that transmuting, whatever into a
- 25:21prompt strategy, right? Which is, which is technically
- 25:25speaking. There's one difference and is
- 25:27that every AI engine has its own bot.
- 25:29Yeah. And there's different Bots.
- 25:30There's the training bot, which is a new model that's going to
- 25:33be released. That goes as great stay
- 25:35internet. Yeah.
- 25:36And then, raise the bar, those bosses your publisher, I will
- 25:40block the spots. Yeah, because of publisher, I
- 25:43don't want these guys to train their data on my stuff and then
- 25:46giving our credit no money in nothing.
- 25:48Yeah. So if you're a brand oh you just
- 25:51allow right. Yeah.
- 25:51And then you have the user box which is the most important
- 25:54because it's when you ask the question in real time and I need
- 25:57to go and search the web and look for your content.
- 25:59Yeah, that's the And you want to have allowed because that's the
- 26:03moment that you're gonna be part of the answer.
- 26:04Yeah the way it is and then you've got to have some sort of
- 26:06governance and control over the content that that is going to be
- 26:11surfaced when the user bot is doing this searches, right?
- 26:14So that's Mrs. Similar to as you're right, yeah, you get
- 26:18indexing Google, you gotta submit your sitemap, the type of
- 26:21things you want to allow this. Allow because there's certain
- 26:24things that are like probably private or like their user only
- 26:27or this gated parts of your side or like only login.
- 26:30Like that's the same. Yeah.
- 26:32I was different. Is that you need to have eyes on
- 26:35how your AI Bots are growing your website.
- 26:37Because if you're being pro like, yeah.
- 26:40I mean, that's right. Because that's, that's very much
- 26:44to SEO. The second layer is basically
- 26:47the Evergreen, right? Yeah.
- 26:49And that's content content can be your blog.
- 26:51Yeah, it can be a LinkedIn audible in.
- 26:53And you said this, I think in sort of a theme, which I thought
- 26:56was kind of interesting was was, you know, a relating to content
- 26:59that sort of the rise of PR, which I thought we are now how
- 27:03are you defining PR, and in this context, Are.
- 27:09Opposed to SEO where you have linked building and you need a
- 27:12link back to your site, a lot of your friends need to do it.
- 27:15Yeah. The one part of the deal.
- 27:17Yeah. AI in the usual, your brand.
- 27:20That's that's good enough and think about it so popular
- 27:23article. Yeah.
- 27:24So PR is serving two things get like The credibility and
- 27:28specific industry because Publications too.
- 27:31Yeah. But then even a signal of
- 27:33authority to AI engine. The Authority plays very
- 27:36important because you're you're basically signals from other
- 27:39domains that are trust with the high Authority domains, which is
- 27:42an SEO play, right? It's like when you know like the
- 27:45classic SEO is like, get published in academic websites
- 27:50or journals, get published in government going to because all
- 27:53those have very high Authority and then those links Drive the
- 27:57authority to your own domain, right?
- 28:00It's yeah, what we help them with.
- 28:02Like we are not experiencing VR. Yeah.
- 28:04In terms of what to create out the brand of the connections.
- 28:06We're not doing that. Yeah, but we're partnering with
- 28:09the experts giving them data-driven recommendations
- 28:12because if we already decided, hey, we're gonna try this 100
- 28:15prompts and we track them and we analyze where this the domains
- 28:19are being read to come to a response.
- 28:22And then from there, we see the Publishers.
- 28:24That's a way to justify why it was Publishers?
- 28:27Yeah. Like they are has been a very
- 28:30good feeling, you know? Yeah.
- 28:32Yeah. And I think if I mean I think
- 28:34this is it's it's sort of worth the time to sort of Define
- 28:37because PR this isn't you know your dad's your grandfather's
- 28:40praise but put out a press put out a press release on the on PR
- 28:45newswire, right. That's got some kind of Flowery
- 28:48messaging and language around a particular product because what
- 28:51I've noticed is you know, it's much more than that.
- 28:53It's a full content strategy and then that content strategy
- 28:57becomes technical right? Because because technically The
- 29:01technical elements behind it, you know, build Authority,
- 29:05domain Authority, what I've noticed generally in my
- 29:08background and I've worked in in schools, certainly in PR and
- 29:11Communications. It's not, it's not what I focus
- 29:13on from a core competency perspective, but what I've
- 29:15noticed is that oftentimes you get, you know, the pr people are
- 29:19like the the journalists, the English Majors, the liberal arts
- 29:22majors, and they tend to not be the technical people, right?
- 29:27Right. So, they're very good at sort of
- 29:29understanding, how to deliver a message that's going to have
- 29:32some sort of impact. I'm delivering relationship and
- 29:34so we always don't even bring money.
- 29:36You gotta like feel about relationship.
- 29:37Yeah but Hotel, you gotta do like, yeah.
- 29:40So yeah, it's sort of changes that definition of being like
- 29:44hey, this isn't just about content that running out, but
- 29:46there's a technical component that's going to drive some sort
- 29:50of visibility within llms visibility within Google search.
- 29:55So it's almost like you could fold in SEO and say, hey if
- 29:58you're if your PR that's implement.
- 30:00Inning, Advanced AEO, Advanced SEO.
- 30:03That's where the play is in my mind, much more technical play
- 30:08and it's tied to content. But think about it this way, PR
- 30:12has always been Niche that Trump, you already put.
- 30:15It's for a very, like, a specific audience.
- 30:18It has really ability, but it's not like a mask play.
- 30:21Yeah. But the moment that, that piece
- 30:23of VR is influencing the response that reach roses
- 30:26potentially. Yeah.
- 30:27So that's what we see and like, we'll call a technical PR,
- 30:32right? Yeah.
- 30:33Or that agreement VR. Yeah, imagine.
- 30:35That is programmatic. I'll be right.
- 30:37Yeah, yeah. I'm gonna happen so that anybody
- 30:40that one? Yeah.
- 30:42Yeah. This isn't, you know, there's
- 30:43the publicist PR I was at. I was at a dinner last night at
- 30:47Noble and not, you know, and in a client was uncomfortable
- 30:51because that the client of this particular period, She was
- 30:55sitting next to a journal, a journalist from attic exchanger
- 30:58and in And felt uncomfortable enough where he needed.
- 31:02And this is what a publicist in a sense.
- 31:04Does a traditional PR publicist is needed to be shadowed by.
- 31:09It's almost like having a lawyer with you when you're when you're
- 31:12yeah when you're in a deposition right.
- 31:14So I wanted to be shouted so this is seen very senior guy.
- 31:18So yeah. Well and so that that nothing
- 31:22was being said, I mean obviously controlled what he says.
- 31:26Yeah. But but he wanted to basically
- 31:29set a Chatham House Rules, right?
- 31:32Meaning this this nothing leaves this this group where, you know,
- 31:36that's generally understanding when you're, when you're out for
- 31:38dinner and drinking. Yeah, but it's interesting
- 31:40because I always found that interesting play and I never was
- 31:43quite into doing that myself, but the idea of shadowing
- 31:47someone, that's your role sort of traditional PR like your
- 31:49publicist play. Like, this is gonna be off the
- 31:52record. This is on the record, right?
- 31:54Like you know, journalists you sitting next to Executive you
- 31:57cannot use. This is off the Record, right,
- 31:59in my Having a nation that were you.
- 32:01Yeah. This this is a whole.
- 32:04Another round of it really ties into into almost a brand
- 32:08strategy. Could be.
- 32:09Yeah. Like what continent now?
- 32:12Right about? You got to answer the question
- 32:14that you want to be black? Yeah, but you also have to
- 32:18Provide button because I think the fact that yeah we're writing
- 32:21for Bots doesn't mean that we're not.
- 32:23Right? Yeah.
- 32:24And I think there's a balance between like oh everything is
- 32:27just automated technology and like the human touch does that
- 32:31matters is still really totally, you know, world full AI slope.
- 32:35Yeah, he might have even more. Yeah, so I think that and we
- 32:38talked about that. That's really interesting point
- 32:40is the AI slop play because you were talking about how
- 32:43Publishers, right? Like the changing ecosystem,
- 32:46that Publishers, right? We started a lot about on the
- 32:48Pod about the open web, how there's certainly a Walled
- 32:52Garden sort of take over of a lot of paid media and a lot of
- 32:57content and you've got this open.
- 32:58Well, that's a long tail of Publishers.
- 33:01There's premium Publishers, there's Midtown Publishers and
- 33:03there's a long tail, and they're, they're fighting to
- 33:07stay relevant, but they're also dealing with a lot of like,
- 33:10automated, yeah. Domain creation domain spoofing
- 33:14recipe sites, that are all AI generated.
- 33:17Scraping their side, The pain, we have.
- 33:19No, I think being a publisher is only been challenged because,
- 33:23you know, I had to like, in my Publishers, a one from praying
- 33:26to digital and like it's really changing for them, speed of
- 33:29light, dramatic and like everything.
- 33:31And now with AI is creating a pain.
- 33:34Yeah. And we're talking about how
- 33:36Reddit actually got a really strong part of the pie.
- 33:39Yeah. Underneath a bunch of money
- 33:41licensing. Yeah.
- 33:42Your times did it? Yeah.
- 33:44And, and with Reddit like it kind of almost goes without
- 33:46saying at this point but I remember a period where when you
- 33:49conducted just any sort of search either either an llm
- 33:52interaction or a Google search, you know, I remember days when
- 33:56Reddit was hardly visible, like I'd have to go directly to the
- 34:00domain generally to check out Reddit, you know conversations
- 34:05now it's it's it's it's over Reddit references that you're
- 34:12seeing the automation, something about somebody real, right?
- 34:16That's a really good job. On you know on getting rid of
- 34:21automation some Bots. Yeah, I feel some of it because
- 34:23now people see value on it because they know Reddit is one
- 34:26of not in every industry but in some Industries is shaping their
- 34:30response required just standing right?
- 34:32Well but shipping the response. Yeah they're spamming Reddit in
- 34:35like to talk about that. But Reddit certainly risen from
- 34:39a visibility perspective from from a cultural perspective and
- 34:43graphic perspective. Yeah, I think it's like Wall
- 34:46Street bets. I'm Nathan.
- 34:48Like Reddit was. I mean, it's always been there
- 34:49but this place now. Yeah, like writing started
- 34:52coming to possible since last year.
- 34:54Yeah before they didn't have that.
- 34:56Yeah, right, yeah, yeah. And so what do you think the
- 35:00downside of sort of Reddit being a primary sources?
- 35:04And I've done some analysis to chose, what are the primary
- 35:06sources for for the llms when I was doing some sort of a yoga
- 35:10analysis, right? And in, how do they break up
- 35:13between Wikipedia YouTube Reddit, these kind of key
- 35:16sources of information Where it's pulling from.
- 35:18And I think there's a general distrust that, like, hey, if
- 35:21this, if this information is coming from reddit, reddit is a
- 35:24hearsay. It's a bunch of conversations
- 35:27being happened, you know, it's not, you know, it's not fully
- 35:30validated authoritative content and all cases.
- 35:33Yeah, does that pollute the answers like I don't go and take
- 35:41any action based on a study that ran across a full industry and
- 35:44it tells you ready and Wikipedia number one.
- 35:46Yeah, because that's not your business.
- 35:48The first thing, like go and get the citations that matter for
- 35:51your industry and you'll be surprised because depending on
- 35:54the industry, I seen TripAdvisor icing for us mediums.
- 35:57Yeah, you know, articles. Yeah.
- 35:58So I think there's no suitable, Silver, Bullet, and the AO yo,
- 36:03in space, I'll be honest. It's full of people trying to
- 36:07make money quick. Yeah, it's yeah, anything that's
- 36:10new. Yeah.
- 36:10Yeah. And it's, it's like, there's
- 36:12gonna be a consolidation. There is a lot of smoke in
- 36:14mirrors, right? Where they're really just SEO
- 36:17shops or link building shops, right?
- 36:20That are sort of repositioning themselves, with kind of the
- 36:23next, the next shiny object. The next wave, Gotta like they
- 36:30get a filter through the crap, right?
- 36:33It feels that they have a silver bullet.
- 36:35Yeah. Right.
- 36:36Yeah. I was.
- 36:38Yeah right. Yeah.
- 36:38And I think that's not it's not just like that.
- 36:41I think. Yeah AI is great.
- 36:42I'm sure every day but I also realized the risks and the
- 36:47Spanish you need behind it. Yeah like I said the thing we
- 36:50write it like we asked humans tend to think that everything
- 36:53has like a one solution. It's not true.
- 36:55And we know this deep inside, we know that it takes hard work.
- 36:59Yeah. And it's on your data.
- 37:01Yeah. That another state, of course,
- 37:03that's yeah. And that's critical.
- 37:04And we've talked a lot about the bunch of different people from,
- 37:07from product leaders, Etc, on the Pod around, how AI
- 37:12fundamentally AI is not doing prompts or having conversations
- 37:15with chat GT, there's an architectural layer right where
- 37:18you're in in, you're really building you're trying to build
- 37:22kind of an AGI and a sense, right?
- 37:24And you're building a memory system, right?
- 37:26And the and what you provided with from a memory system, from
- 37:29a control and management system and a governance system, which
- 37:32is your Worked down files that you're that saves critical in
- 37:36order to get the accuracy in the outputs that you want from it,
- 37:39right. And to have it grow and develop
- 37:41closer to what we think of is intelligence, right?
- 37:45I'll give you my if you might think on AI my experience using
- 37:49it for the last few years one, is that context is scheme?
- 37:53Yeah, 100% opting matters but not as much content.
- 37:56Yeah. If your company wants to really
- 37:59leverage G, it started by organizing your data in markdown
- 38:02files in ways that is connected. Create your own MCB connector.
- 38:06Yeah. So you can actually ask hey go
- 38:08on check out the database and bring this information.
- 38:10Yeah that's for me. The NCP connectors and they
- 38:14connectors in general. Actually that you can actually
- 38:16connect your to notion or Google Drive.
- 38:20Yeah. Or anything.
- 38:21Yeah. Or we make AI powerful because
- 38:23it's just copy pasting to actually have ai.
- 38:27Yeah, things for you. Yeah.
- 38:28And yeah, that's that can be just from an individual agentic
- 38:31workflow perspective. Right?
- 38:32Right. That's, that's Really important
- 38:33for people to understand is like, yeah, projects and prompts
- 38:36that's a very surface level but once you start giving it that
- 38:39instruction booklet which is your markdown files, you know,
- 38:42your repos, your repositories, right?
- 38:45And you start giving a like an instruction booklet, that covers
- 38:49everything on how it should behave, which they call the
- 38:51soul, right? How it should behave.
- 38:53Rules of Engagement guard rails governance and then with
- 38:58writing, it can be narrative structure, you can get, rid of
- 39:01all the slop that we sort of see, if AI the way that will
- 39:05see. It's like the more you use it
- 39:07and that's waste like crazy. How The more you used to charge
- 39:13EPT to switch, its ordered because the memory has been
- 39:15developed. Yeah, with your files are there?
- 39:17Yeah. System has been created, it's
- 39:20not that one model is better than like.
- 39:21Yeah, the office light decreased but like the realities where you
- 39:24put your time and you and you set up your foundations is where
- 39:28you should be. Yes, then that's that's a really
- 39:29critical point. How do you do that?
- 39:31So, I'm gonna call First. Yeah, but every day you claw.
- 39:34Yeah. No.
- 39:35Oh yeah, I I decided not to go with open clock because if
- 39:41you're not technical enough isn't safe.
- 39:42Yeah, yeah. Yeah probably actually, I jumped
- 39:46over to Hermes because of recommendation from one of my
- 39:48technically. Yeah, that's yeah.
- 39:51And I thought so there's this couple things aren't important.
- 39:54It's kills a skills. It gets overlooked by skills is
- 39:58great because you basically teaching cloth to do a
- 40:00particular thing. Yeah.
- 40:01I thought my my whole agent to use it Gemini API to create
- 40:06pictures. Yeah.
- 40:07If you use the 11 laps API to create sound so we just The user
- 40:11at great songs, we talked to 12 Labs yesterday but that's it.
- 40:14They're a little different than 11 hours 11.
- 40:16Yeah, that's about a AI sort of content recognition it like, I'm
- 40:21super micro metadata level. Uh, yeah, yeah, yeah, you should
- 40:25talk to them. It's a really fascinating
- 40:26technology that they have where the AI can start to recognize.
- 40:29Everything's that's happening within a video and the context
- 40:32around around that's outside of sort of the metadata.
- 40:35He's just reading the actual video text because that's yeah,
- 40:39I have a lot of problems we video.
- 40:41I mean yeah exactly there's solving for that problem.
- 40:43That's cool. Yeah.
- 40:45Well like my son's Google home. Yeah, yeah.
- 40:49So you should set up your Cloud skills.
- 40:53Like I've said before, I have the skills that are pretty
- 40:55people are just a way of teaching clock, how to create a
- 40:59presentation. There's a skills are already
- 41:00created. Like yeah.
- 41:01And you, there's actually a skill to create a skills.
- 41:03Yeah. That's about to create this
- 41:05building. You want to create?
- 41:05Yeah. And then you have MC connectors
- 41:08are basically ways that you can connect to your Other platforms
- 41:12like Google Drive notion. It's like, yeah.
- 41:14And cloud makes that really easy GPT does too as well, right?
- 41:18So there's different types of mcps.
- 41:20There's some that are like they work locally in your computer.
- 41:23Yeah. And there's some that are well,
- 41:25I would say start with weapons. You stop man.
- 41:28So one click. Yeah.
- 41:29If you do that, I've done some of the local stuff, which is
- 41:31which, and I generally do that through an open claw or Hermes
- 41:35right, where it's reading your entire drive, but I want to
- 41:37connect it to my source of Truth.
- 41:39So like right what I love for my contacts is notion because
- 41:43notion just like my portable brain, I record everything in
- 41:46notion and if I have to start new session that's not say, hey,
- 41:49go to know, should we buy? Yeah, let's start.
- 41:52Yeah. And then when I do something I
- 41:55would ask him to go. And why don't you know what we
- 41:57did? Yeah, we keep that and I mean,
- 41:59I'm using get get GitHub for that same purpose, right?
- 42:02Yeah. And that's that's one thing that
- 42:04I've learned, is that, like, when I'm doing like, that's I'm
- 42:06creating some sort of template, right?
- 42:07Like I'm creating a proposal template or I'm creating and and
- 42:10I want to codify that and I've run through this whole sort of
- 42:13prompt string to get it right, right?
- 42:15Either GPT or Claude, I'll use either one, right, and I want to
- 42:18get it, right? And once I get it, right, I
- 42:20basically say, now record, everything we just talked about
- 42:23it, converted into a markdown file and you're just telling
- 42:26conversational, you know, right. And then save it and to get hot
- 42:29and it and it folder. I sit into every time you create
- 42:31a proposal from that point forward, it's referencing The
- 42:34Rules of Engagement the structure, the governance, the
- 42:37template. So I sort of automatically and
- 42:38it'll be born again, right? I just from 30s, like, oh, you
- 42:41know, like a fucking book that's the work because that's why you
- 42:45have contacts. So every time you talked to is
- 42:47like if you talk to your best friend because you already knows
- 42:49you. Yeah, that that's where that's
- 42:52where I think that Evolution happening for me is where I
- 42:54realize that like my long prompts sometimes the agent will
- 42:57stop thinking because it just gets totally confused because
- 43:00it's a multi multifaceted prompt I thought.
- 43:03Yeah, I finally started moving away from that and saying you
- 43:07reaches your referencing something already.
- 43:08Yeah you work. Yeah.
- 43:10Hey Go to go to my repo, you know, pull out this particular,
- 43:13you know, and I'm building something based on that and
- 43:16they're like, okay and basically tells you I will review that in,
- 43:18you know, before we create this next proposal or this next extra
- 43:23wide, and I do that around article, generation content,
- 43:25generation commercial, generation, Excel spreadsheets.
- 43:29It's you know, I just and you're it's all conversation.
- 43:32You don't need, you don't need to be a python expert to do
- 43:34this. What you want to switch from
- 43:39Jaggi to Claude? You can do it right away.
- 43:42Exactly. And and that is your memory
- 43:44system that is yours. That is yours.
- 43:46Yeah. Who becomes?
- 43:48Yeah, I think, yeah. And one of our executive
- 43:51contributors, Chris Raja is, he's got a company called
- 43:54mindmaker Ai and it's all built on the idea of capturing in
- 43:58Executives memory system. So it's so it's completely
- 44:01agnostic of model, right? And and it's important because,
- 44:06you know, you can, you can, you can pull out your check GPC
- 44:09projects in prompt history. Yeah, it kind of at the end it
- 44:13and put it into clawed, but it hallucinating and it'll, it'll
- 44:18export something that's very, that's slightly or mean even
- 44:21very different than what you originally had within that with
- 44:25the. Yeah.
- 44:25And so he was like, I saw this issue with bringing stuff over
- 44:29to Claude from GPT or vice versa where it just kind of broke,
- 44:33right. And so so you're losing all of
- 44:36this time and effort that you've put into building structuring
- 44:39and I'm like, It get into GitHub.
- 44:42Yeah, or notion and start building down your way.
- 44:46We have in our company beautiful.
- 44:47It's only between done and me. I'm just a confidential stuff
- 44:50and only the owners have. Yeah, notion we share with the
- 44:53rest of employees. Yes.
- 44:54But it's not about this notion is that is easier to read and
- 44:57edit? Yeah.
- 44:58Feels about. Yeah.
- 45:00It does. Yeah.
- 45:01And you can't really write your own markdown file.
- 45:04You gotta be like I like I always I always mess it up.
- 45:06I'm like, what is the syntax here that?
- 45:08I'm, you know, because it's all text and its lines.
- 45:11So I just, I just have cheap GPS or God created for me.
- 45:14Right? Like, yes.
- 45:15So it doesn't break when it when it gets uploaded.
- 45:17Yeah. Isn't this great like how are we
- 45:19changing this systems that before you have to know again?
- 45:22Yeah you liked and you sassy gonna be like he has to connect
- 45:27to tools and allow you to promise move things and I think
- 45:31this that's funny because a lot of the companies are investing
- 45:34on their own chatbot. Yeah.
- 45:35Investing on how they connect to it.
- 45:37The chat with people actually use.
- 45:39Yeah. Right.
- 45:40Because So I'm not gonna go through like they say hotspot
- 45:43and use your chatbot. Like I'm not gonna hop spot, we
- 45:46try to PT and then play from there.
- 45:48Yeah, yeah. So and so so what do you think
- 45:51organizations have to do? I mean we talked about kind of
- 45:53personally how it's changed our own work lives, right?
- 45:56And how we've set us up and you've leveraged this to help
- 45:59build and I'm how do you think organizations can best role this
- 46:03kind of stuff out? Yeah.
- 46:06Work guys. My career at media come and I
- 46:09watch football this seven years. Yep.
- 46:11The us as well. Yeah.
- 46:13And then I work in depending agency called.
- 46:15Yep. And after that.
- 46:17My finally. Yeah.
- 46:19And look, they the game. And I know this is kind of
- 46:24old-fashion that these days because it's not AI.
- 46:26But he's holding company versus independent.
- 46:29Yeah. Yeah.
- 46:30And it's certainly on topic. I've been diving in a lot
- 46:33recently. Yeah, I think in the age of AI
- 46:36independent. Yeah, because it's about being
- 46:39fast. Yeah.
- 46:40And it's also about that. It's about that architectural
- 46:42layer, they're building out their text at from the ground
- 46:46up. He's here to start something new
- 46:48and took me build something. I know holding company still
- 46:51there at this. Like yeah, I have to be clients
- 46:54and those big clients require more security required for more,
- 46:57there's more rigor, right? Yeah.
- 46:59And there's nobody definition. Yeah, and I think you know, in a
- 47:02moment we're like between you and me next week.
- 47:05I don't know what's gonna Is that yeah.
- 47:06In that in that reality, I think polling companies are meant to
- 47:12fail. If they don't, change
- 47:13drastically are doing because speed matters.
- 47:16Yeah. And speed matters in speed, get
- 47:18in a human slowdown, the complex organizations.
- 47:21Let's put it that way. Complex, Matrix organizations
- 47:23that are, that are sort of human capital based FTE based, right?
- 47:27When you have an independent, they can come in with a much
- 47:30nimbler team, who's, who's ability to execute is compounded
- 47:35because their AI native and technique, right?
- 47:38So, because I think the challenge with Independence
- 47:41before some of some of these capabilities came into play.
- 47:44AI capabilities was, they could not scale quickly enough because
- 47:49they didn't have the FTE, the human capital in order to manage
- 47:52these massive accounts holders had that Advantage now that
- 47:56tablespoon switched, right? You don't need a 3,000 people to
- 48:00run your Commerce media division right through and look, I think
- 48:05Dead. All these companies at the
- 48:08advantage of leveraging negotiation problem.
- 48:11Yeah there's no irritable behind.
- 48:13Yeah, there's no independent agencies that can buy very few
- 48:16videos that holding companies that yeah even on programmatic
- 48:20well it's good deals that yeah and they're leveraging their
- 48:24leveraging debt. They're saying hey we we have
- 48:26the capital in order to invest, you know 18 billion dollars in
- 48:31this entire you know this entire multi-media.
- 48:35Bye for this and then you're dividing that between your
- 48:38clients. That's probably why open doors
- 48:42for things like Sports Marketing.
- 48:43Yeah, exposure sheets for things are outside of the box.
- 48:47Placements are like costume made.
- 48:49I think there's that's the power where they lost the battle of
- 48:52long time ago. Some performance mod
- 48:55Interesting. Depending agencies are in ways.
- 48:57Yes. Yes.
- 48:58And we're talking some right now.
- 49:00Yeah. Oh yeah.
- 49:02And and with this whole notion of moving towards sort of
- 49:05outcomes and drives that how are you actually?
- 49:08Yeah. I want the like, people know
- 49:12you. Yeah, the new shop on the
- 49:15better. True you got to our why?
- 49:17Yeah, the rubber the rubber bands the road?
- 49:19Yeah, yeah. About.
- 49:24Yeah, that's not and inherent that Advantage where it's, like,
- 49:28reach is not good enough anymore, right?
- 49:30Like it like it, like, hey, I get cheap reach to an in an
- 49:34infinite amount of inventory audience, right?
- 49:36You know, certain percentage that mean, it may not be real
- 49:40Independence or like, hey, it's not about, it's not about raw
- 49:44just reach. It's about actually, how do you
- 49:47drive kind of Precision, Precision, and results and
- 49:51results? Now, I think though, Google and
- 49:54man. Oh by the way man, I didn't show
- 49:56up Shane when you possible for those that aren't here has the
- 50:04last three years. Yeah.
- 50:06But and everybody you used to be very ad Tech oriented it's much
- 50:10broader from a tech perspective, but it's also much broader from
- 50:13an agency perspective. There's a lot more holding
- 50:15companies here. I don't know if you are from
- 50:18Seattle. Yep.
- 50:19From you, the last school to meet this guy?
- 50:21Yeah, yeah. Well, hey, this is Been an
- 50:24awesome conversation. I think we could go on forever
- 50:25and I'm getting there. I'm getting the clock here
- 50:27because we've got more podcasts to run.
- 50:29But hey Sebastian, it was great. My man, we should definitely, we
- 50:32should definitely talk, if you're in New York City, we
- 50:35should we should look up. That was a little bit about what
- 50:37we're gonna hear this interview. Oh yeah, yeah.
- 50:40So so we're gonna publish this on on YouTube dot signal, the
- 50:44noise that AI, you know, and then we're gonna publish a
- 50:47collection of these episodes. For each day, we're gonna do the
- 50:51individual episodes. So you and I, um, that'll be
- 50:53pushed out through multiple channels.
- 50:55You know, through, we'll be on, on Apple podcast Spotify.
- 51:00I look, um, before we go, congrats on the beat, man.
- 51:06You guys got something, okay. Thanks everybody.
- 51:09Signaling noise. We're at day, three of possible
- 51:11and I've got Lupine from add Square.
- 51:14He heads up marketing. That's right.
- 51:15Lady could make it. Thanks.
- 51:17I found you. It's a while but I found.
- 51:18Yeah. And he's pretty good.
- 51:20Not too shabby. It's okay.
- 51:21Yeah, I'm glad by from the Sun today there's overcast, which is
- 51:25nice. Yeah, I run to a bunch of people
- 51:27today that were actually wearing like horseback.
- 51:30I can actually do this today. Yeah, with that like melting.
- 51:33So I'm going to a case filled. I have not used.
- 51:35Yeah I brought one and it's Like it's still it's still drying out
- 51:40from last night. Yeah, that way.
- 51:42But then you can make it and maybe you could start out by
- 51:45just telling our viewers a little bit about yourself and
- 51:47your role might be a good place to start.
- 51:50Yeah, sure. So yeah, my name is Luke
- 51:51bennion. I'm a marketer for technology
- 51:55businesses in the advertising. Everybody trade marketing by
- 51:57trade and marketing by Nature, nice.
- 51:59So yeah, I've worked in sort of programmatic space, the past, 10
- 52:03years of various businesses video, intelligence outbrain
- 52:06next and watching that and probably the Common Thread
- 52:10through all of those is data, right?
- 52:12How data gets asked, what days do we have?
- 52:15How is it used and so on. So I've been sort of trying to
- 52:17bring data to life for people for the past as part of the
- 52:21past, decade here, making Data Business is sexy again, right
- 52:23making? Yeah, MDS data.
- 52:26Sexy data is like, very exciting, but I know that like
- 52:29that, you know, that maybe makes me part of my party, but I think
- 52:34that a business is our, you know, certainly crucial to the
- 52:37way advertising. Works today.
- 52:39So we can start out like Taken as the next question.
- 52:43Like you like the company itself location data?
- 52:46Maybe. Tell us a little bit about that.
- 52:48Sure. So, yeah.
- 52:49It's odd square. Is location.
- 52:50Intelligence platform. So, we have a flywheel of ways
- 52:55people can use our data to build audiences like plan in a
- 52:59dashboard where they go in, they see location behaviors where,
- 53:01where people been and what have they been doing and so they can
- 53:04plan their campaigns get insights competitor Intel and so
- 53:07on from the planning perspective, they can build
- 53:09audience segments. So I see these people have been
- 53:12to this store in the past two weeks, let's activate those.
- 53:16And then they can activate them in their DSP or SSP of choice or
- 53:19social platforms as well. And then we have a measurement
- 53:22product and attribution as well. Okay.
- 53:25Actually, Mark your like how do you like how do you take this
- 53:31topic that might and for people in the industry?
- 53:34I think it. They'll understand it, but for
- 53:37people who are maybe not like how would you take this?
- 53:39And it was pretty complex. Write and tell us a story that
- 53:42resonates like, what are some of your secrets or tips as a
- 53:45marketer? Yeah, great question.
- 53:46Well, I guess ultimately the user, the person we want to
- 53:49appeal to is a media agency Persona.
- 53:51So someone in an agency, they've got a brand that wants to run a
- 53:54campaign and planners buyers that were these the Cannabis
- 53:58probably the person on the hands on the keys.
- 54:00Yeah, yeah. And they're gonna go into their
- 54:02programmatic platform and be bombarded with different ways
- 54:05that they can Target people, third party data sources the
- 54:08audience that okay. Exactly.
- 54:09So you need to be appealing to them when they're in that
- 54:12interface. So I think brand is a really
- 54:14important part of that it's being recognizable and having a
- 54:17reputation for quality for trustworthiness of transparency
- 54:21price as well. So they know when they look at
- 54:25that list in the drop-down menu to simplify the way it's done.
- 54:28The ABS where for example is like a trustworthy dates plus
- 54:31then you've got to advocate for your type of data.
- 54:34So we're We use real world data and location data, but they, you
- 54:39could. So so the certain types of
- 54:44Brands we think location data is the best way that they can do
- 54:48targeting. And so you sort of advocating
- 54:51for your brand but also your data type if you like.
- 54:54So, why does real world actions? Create the best way of running
- 54:57marketing campaigns. It worked for a tech company.
- 55:03Last last year, did a stint as I had a commercial for a bit.
- 55:05I mean, I hadn't. Yeah, Our advice the most for a
- 55:09long time but I have a surprise like, and, you know, it's the
- 55:12first time I'd actually like runs specific marketing
- 55:15campaigns like post kind of like AI slop, right?
- 55:18And I was shocked by how Engagement had really Fallen a
- 55:23lot of stuff, just blasting out emails.
- 55:24And we don't want to opens with a single click.
- 55:27You know, we'd run campaigns. We get almost no responses back.
- 55:30It was It was incredible to me, the impact of that I think this
- 55:34information overload that people and how is impacting people and
- 55:39then, you know, this I think B2B or b2c, right?
- 55:41So are you seeing things like that too?
- 55:43And if so, like, how is it impacting the way you go to
- 55:45market how you engage with prospects and customers?
- 55:47Yeah, I mean that's a big question.
- 55:49I think maybe the biggest manifestation of this is in
- 55:52Social organic reach, right? You'll see this at that business
- 55:55as well. You post something on the
- 55:56company, LinkedIn page being like, here's our big
- 55:59announcement. We've been working on for months
- 56:00and get crickets. That's right.
- 56:02Yeah, exactly. But then the CEO or senior
- 56:05leader posts about it, they tell their personal story about the
- 56:09the build that they've been through the Journey they've been
- 56:11on and suddenly they're going viral.
- 56:12So I think it's changed very much from company, pages to
- 56:16personal Stories. The people Town, that's what
- 56:18resonates with people, right? So and the same is true with
- 56:21email. So company email blast
- 56:22newsletters. Yeah, they still get, they still
- 56:25getting engagement but actually, if you're CEO, had the substack
- 56:28or newsletter where they can really dig deep and they're
- 56:31building. Reputation about us really
- 56:33specific Niche. Then that's where they're going
- 56:36to get engagement from the right people and you can't really be
- 56:38too Niche. You can really get deep and the
- 56:41deeper you go and the more specific you go.
- 56:43I think people really appreciate getting that Knowledge from me.
- 56:46Yeah like that. You know we had Joe Zappa on
- 56:48this podcast a couple months ago you have no joke for a few years
- 56:51and that I think it's really cool.
- 56:54What he's doing just kind of like executive lead like
- 56:57evangelism and Communications how I mean, and I think the
- 57:02thesis of that episode ended up being like people, trust people.
- 57:08They don't really trust institutions or Brands as much
- 57:11anymore. And that's so like, I like what
- 57:14you're saying, like, if your leaders can tell a story and
- 57:18communicate directly that'll have a much bigger impact and
- 57:21just like sending out, I'm thinking, but it's a little bit
- 57:24more than that because it's also about adding value to people as
- 57:27well. I think that's where companies
- 57:28often make the mistake. Is they just recite a, you know,
- 57:32their their Mantra if you like, where is there.
- 57:36They're truth. But actually, when you add value
- 57:38to people and tell them something, they didn't know, or
- 57:40teach them something new or give deeper insights into something,
- 57:43and people come away thinking, oh, I've learned something and
- 57:47when you do that you remember and then you engage more and you
- 57:50share and you start telling people about it.
- 57:52So I think Choice absolutely right that the people trust
- 57:55people but people also like Conversations when they learn
- 57:58something and they've got something they can go and tell
- 58:00people the next inner party or conference to their, you know, I
- 58:03think that's a good point, like people.
- 58:04And I think the companies sell the best, and I think, even
- 58:08think in. I've worked in Consulting for a
- 58:09long time, right? I think that even the way people
- 58:12buy that is changing. Like, they're not buying
- 58:14through. Maybe the people they used to,
- 58:17they want thought leadership. Now, they want to be to your
- 58:21point. They want to be told something
- 58:22new and interesting, that makes them think it may provoke some a
- 58:25little bit and then they're going to want to bring in even
- 58:28if they're just lurking and reading in the background.
- 58:30But like, I think seeding those ideas out there, starting
- 58:34conversations, I mean, when I think. like my experience
- 58:38anyway, those are the types of people that You know, when when
- 58:44Brenda who don't want to work with us where they gravitate
- 58:46towards? Yeah, exactly.
- 58:47And that's it. You've got to be building the
- 58:49reputation of your brand over long periods of time.
- 58:51You know this, what's this, the 95 rule, right?
- 58:54So, 95% of the time people are not in Market to buy a product,
- 58:57but you want to be make sure you're there during that period.
- 59:00So that when they are ready to buy your product, you're the one
- 59:03that comes to mind and that's about owning a category as well,
- 59:06it's like being synonymous with the specific thing, you do so
- 59:10that you're an instant, I've even had times where I put
- 59:15content out there and someone I didn't even know engage with it,
- 59:18just apparently read it, right? But they didn't, they didn't
- 59:20like it. They didn't comment in any
- 59:22bringing up later and so I read that thing of yours.
- 59:24Yeah, I really like that. Let's talk about it.
- 59:26Yeah, I think that's always why. I was like, really know that,
- 59:30okay? For every like or comment you
- 59:32get this probably 10 people look at this and lurking.
- 59:35And you know who are still being impacted, right?
- 59:37Yeah. That's a nightmare.
- 59:37When it comes to attribution and marketing, that's stuff, but
- 59:40you're right. It's like you, maybe you can't
- 59:42even Attribute or you can try but is that that doing it over
- 59:45time, right? Yeah.
- 59:46This is really the key. Yeah.
- 59:49I've noticed some leaders and there was a big debate.
- 59:52We got it online if you a few of us the other day like I get
- 59:56really turned off by like, you know, AI, obviously AI generated
- 1:00:00content where it's like, if not but this, if not, but this,
- 1:00:03like, Emoji Emoji Emoji like bullets.
- 1:00:06It's yeah. But I see some leaders, senior
- 1:00:09leaders, posting this stuff. And they still get engagement,
- 1:00:13right? It's shocks me so thoughts on
- 1:00:15that. I mean like, you know, I mean,
- 1:00:17unpacking the way, that's impacting marketing.
- 1:00:20You know, if we talk about this now and you publish this in a
- 1:00:22week's time, it'll probably change that that's what keeps
- 1:00:24happening, right? Like the the speed of change is
- 1:00:27increasing rapidly and so, you know, called Design coming out a
- 1:00:31couple weeks ago, as really impacted marketing collateral,
- 1:00:35for example. And yeah, the ability to create
- 1:00:37written content that sounds a bit like you, but actually, when
- 1:00:42you look at, it looks like it's chat, GT, is a challenge, I
- 1:00:45think everyone's navigating, because it's so easy.
- 1:00:47You know, I my Approach is, if someone didn't have the time to
- 1:00:50write something to himself, I don't have the time to read it,
- 1:00:53but wholly gray. I'm, I don't think everyone
- 1:00:56thinks like that. I think people are maybe just
- 1:00:58accepting that, that's how content is created and and
- 1:01:01engaging with it, but it's frustrating.
- 1:01:03When you spend years crafting, crafting carefully thought
- 1:01:06through opinion pieces or articles, and so on.
- 1:01:10Yeah. Yeah, I don't get it either.
- 1:01:12I mean, if I see stuff looks obviously AI generated with
- 1:01:15someone didn't even take the time or care to just rewrite it,
- 1:01:18alright, to take out like that and and I love em dashes, right?
- 1:01:21Like, you know, but there's a time to place for them, right?
- 1:01:23Or, you know the things that are obviously, I have so much, can't
- 1:01:27take the time. I personally won't take the
- 1:01:29time, but I don't think everyone thinks that I say it's my team,
- 1:01:32you know, well, I'll review something and if the views some
- 1:01:35a chat GPT or Gemini to create it, and it shows throughout,
- 1:01:38excuse me, your, your AI is showing, you know, it's like,
- 1:01:41use it for the research, but if you're AI showing, and it's an
- 1:01:44old saying and advertising strategy, if you're strategy is
- 1:01:47showing you need to put some greats over it.
- 1:01:49And the same is true, is AI, like use it for all for the
- 1:01:52research, 100%, but then do your own research as well.
- 1:01:56Because AI research misses a lot of the interesting things that
- 1:01:59it's it's aggregating. So, but actual nuance and detail
- 1:02:03is not picked up by aggregation. So there's other things to
- 1:02:07discover that AI is not going to as well.
- 1:02:09She marker. How much of what you do is
- 1:02:11already been changed meaningfully by Ai and like
- 1:02:15thoughts on that. I think it's been creeping in
- 1:02:18for longer than we give credit for the last three.
- 1:02:22It's definitely been more front and center but things like, you
- 1:02:25know, Auto automated systems in Social platforms.
- 1:02:28For example, have been around quite a while grammar Checkers
- 1:02:32in 10 years. So yeah, yeah, you've been
- 1:02:34around a long time. AI has actually been in there.
- 1:02:37It's just become very prevalent recently.
- 1:02:39I'd say, you know, where we're tasked with almost any job
- 1:02:43within the department that can be automated or scaled, then we
- 1:02:47should be looking at how AI can do that?
- 1:02:49I think that's fair enough. It's something's a repeatable
- 1:02:51tasks. No one really wants to be doing
- 1:02:53it themselves and if they can help people that most people
- 1:02:56don't, that's true. So that's where where to use it
- 1:02:58really well. But also, you know, We're a
- 1:03:01company full of brilliant insightful, interesting
- 1:03:03individuals. So the value of that human touch
- 1:03:06is also super important to bring that to the surface and automate
- 1:03:10where things were repeatable. That's my approach to it.
- 1:03:13What are some of the AI tools you're using today that you
- 1:03:15really love? And you know for maybe other
- 1:03:18marketers out there you recommend they check out and I
- 1:03:22think it's less about the tools and sells more about how you use
- 1:03:25them, because they're so their platforms, right?
- 1:03:27And they're basically they're there and you say, well, what am
- 1:03:31I gonna do with this thing? So, it's thinking creatively.
- 1:03:33What can I achieve with this technology?
- 1:03:35Whether that's just an llm or whether it's an agent system,
- 1:03:39like, Claude. Claude design is the biggest
- 1:03:41change. I'd say in the ability and
- 1:03:43marketing to create collateral and designs and scaling, that is
- 1:03:47now, it's quite good at it. It's very good.
- 1:03:50And until now nothing has been, but now, it's very good and
- 1:03:53that's gonna supercharge like tailoring content account based
- 1:03:57marketing. So you can just say, give it a
- 1:03:59load of personas, give it a load of individuals and say, adapt
- 1:04:02this content to these people, and it can do it now without it
- 1:04:05looking ridiculous. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 1:04:07Yeah. There's not six fingers anymore.
- 1:04:08You know? It's, it looks really smart,
- 1:04:10right? Even recently, even before this,
- 1:04:12I would like ask it just To create one hero and image and
- 1:04:16give instruction to be totally off, right?
- 1:04:17Like this is like it was really frustrating.
- 1:04:19Yeah. So yeah.
- 1:04:20I mean, the improvements are pretty traumatic.
- 1:04:22Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:04:23It's, you know, we take a human in the loop Approach at Square.
- 1:04:27So we always wanted to be reviewing things.
- 1:04:29I would always want to design it to look at output but yeah, the
- 1:04:32ability to scale and iterate is what's changing. it must be
- 1:04:37changing the speed at which you work too and the speed of which
- 1:04:41you're able because I I know consulting or able to like the
- 1:04:46output of what we're creating so much faster.
- 1:04:49I mean it's we're going like it's or even like I work design
- 1:04:53teams or product teams. Just going to prototype like a
- 1:04:56day or two, it says, yeah. Great is not production, right?
- 1:04:59But just being able to crank out prototypes with the front end
- 1:05:02and some and some five coded. Technology behind it.
- 1:05:06It's incredible. So I imagine for a marketer it's
- 1:05:10made, it's bad things up dramatically.
- 1:05:11Yeah. And then, the challenge is
- 1:05:13adapting as a team fast enough to be able to implement it in
- 1:05:17all the places you want to. Yeah.
- 1:05:18Because, you know, we're just gonna be, I think the real way.
- 1:05:22Marketers operate is fundamentally now changing,
- 1:05:25like, what we're doing today basis is just shifting, its kind
- 1:05:29of make make it way more. We can be way more strategic, we
- 1:05:32would be way more thoughtful because all of the day today,
- 1:05:34difficult stuff is going to be just sped up exactly as you say,
- 1:05:39I've seen some interesting debates recently about like,
- 1:05:41within within marketing like, Communicated like there's a some
- 1:05:47people. So.
- 1:05:48Okay, like your message, like it should be.
- 1:05:50Like, my grandmother should build understand it and some
- 1:05:53people say, you know, actually this is this is AD Tech.
- 1:05:55It's it's really complicated like, no, we're not, you're not
- 1:05:59selling your grandmother, we don't care for girls.
- 1:06:00So yeah. Or do you need to do?
- 1:06:02You need to It's both thoughts on that debate.
- 1:06:06I think quite often people overcomplicate language
- 1:06:09needlessly to seem in sort of intelligence not the right word
- 1:06:13but to seem like that knowledgeable.
- 1:06:15I always again with my team sports certain words drive me
- 1:06:18mad like Leverage and utilize it means use leverage.
- 1:06:23It means you. There's a shorter way to say
- 1:06:25exactly the same word texture. Yeah, so it's always things
- 1:06:28short way. Another thing that lens do is to
- 1:06:30put in a lot of adjectives and adverbs are completely
- 1:06:32unnecessary as well because they not 90% of the time, add nothing
- 1:06:36to the sentence. So stripping that stuff out can
- 1:06:39really simplify your language and my grandma would be more
- 1:06:42able to understand it but it's actually not about that.
- 1:06:45It's about cutting to the Chase and being really clear and not
- 1:06:48over complicating things for people because no one wants to
- 1:06:50wait through messy. Sludgy language you you want to
- 1:06:55understand what something is. But I think that's where I love
- 1:06:58doing is diagrams and flowcharts and that kind of thing, I think
- 1:07:02in our sector in data and Technology.
- 1:07:04And advertising, when you're in a supply chain showing the way
- 1:07:07things move between each other in Groton Graphics is super
- 1:07:11important as well. So it's not just about language
- 1:07:13is about how language and spatial description, interact
- 1:07:17with each other as well. I think that's a super important
- 1:07:19part. article or an article recently about I call the iir L
- 1:07:24in real life rebellion and how like you know there's the trends
- 1:07:27we talked earlier about people being overloaded with content
- 1:07:29that there's just been such a shift back to like Say Back to
- 1:07:33Basics, but back to real life experiences, I was a general
- 1:07:36rehearsal. Last night, I was like a lot of
- 1:07:38what to talk about. Is people like craving these
- 1:07:40things. So here possible.
- 1:07:41How are you? Like folding in real life and
- 1:07:45like in person stuff, I've obviously you're doing because
- 1:07:47you're here. How are you folding it in your
- 1:07:49marketing approach? Have you seen some changes
- 1:07:51recently this area? Well I think you could look at
- 1:07:54possible as a great example because if you go to the main
- 1:07:56inspiration Hall every talk today is on AI paid for Content.
- 1:08:02Yeah. Brands on AI.
- 1:08:03That hole is only 20% full, whereas the 8th gym area is the
- 1:08:08loudest place in my life first and fully 150% full because
- 1:08:12people are just there to talk and network.
- 1:08:13It's definitely. Oh my God.
- 1:08:15Yeah, it needs to be needs to be addressed.
- 1:08:17Let's just say but yeah, people want people Hicks.
- 1:08:20They want that human connection. Not to watch another talk about
- 1:08:22Ai and that's all you need to know about that.
- 1:08:26What we've done at Square here. We had a panel session where we
- 1:08:29invited a dspace is on with us. We discuss the outcomes era
- 1:08:33actually. It's speaking about just
- 1:08:37someone, right? Yeah, they're after me speaking
- 1:08:40about, Joss Aqua lives are very much advocated to the outcomes
- 1:08:44era and I would subscribe to that as well and we were talking
- 1:08:47about the outcomes era we made a time.
- 1:08:49I'll be gone from affiliate Superman to programmatic.
- 1:08:53And how is that all brought us on this journey that we're in
- 1:08:56now. But we also then have like
- 1:08:57laptop stickers, that people can put.
- 1:08:59And and I think the best branding piece here is somebody
- 1:09:02who's branded the lanyard that physical thing or you know, tote
- 1:09:05bags like oh really old school like and it's Swag thing.
- 1:09:09But hey, that's walking advertisements all the way
- 1:09:11around the place and in at a festival where it's very
- 1:09:13difficult to cut through. The noise works, it works.
- 1:09:16And you remember those Brands? Yeah, yeah.
- 1:09:18But I think if, again, comes back to being interesting and
- 1:09:21the most interesting activation here, I think or the most
- 1:09:24useful, sorry I should say, is gums water machines and if you
- 1:09:28see those you can add cucumber flavors, strawberry flavor
- 1:09:31electrolytes Cafe in a little like water container this.
- 1:09:35Branded to that was smart. Yeah and their whole positioning
- 1:09:38is around the mindset Matrix and so they can have that platform
- 1:09:41which they can then apply to really nice activations.
- 1:09:44It just gives them a platform to execute across and so I always
- 1:09:47really admire them for doing things that are Have a smart.
- 1:09:50So, well, listen, really appreciative you coming by and
- 1:09:54Mark it or the market really like this conversation a lot.
- 1:09:56I think there's some good insights for, you know, but how
- 1:09:59marketing works and And your role.
- 1:10:01And, you know, I really appreciate that and I still like
- 1:10:04the rest of the show. Thank you.
- 1:10:04Yes, it's real. Thank you guys.
- 1:10:08We are at day three of possible in Miami and I've got a special
- 1:10:12guest, Anthony Dominguez, who's the senior director of Business
- 1:10:16Development and orange 142? Welcome, thank you so much to be
- 1:10:20here. So love it.
- 1:10:22Anthony if you can maybe tell the viewers a little bit about
- 1:10:26yourself and your background and kind of what brings you to this
- 1:10:29current role. Sure thing.
- 1:10:31So, I'm with orange 142, which is part of our holding company
- 1:10:35at the direct digital Holdings, which owns orange 142.
- 1:10:39And agency and Colossus. Media SSP.
- 1:10:42Our supply side platform for the for good four years.
- 1:10:46I've been with the supplier side, platform sourcing,
- 1:10:50Multicultural Supply over to the SSP and now I've been
- 1:10:54transferred over to Orange 142 our agency.
- 1:10:57It's a help launch our new product called Ignition Plus
- 1:11:01What is ignition plus? It is a we just launched about
- 1:11:05two months ago. It is a unified AI platform.
- 1:11:08That is empowering independent agencies and mid-market
- 1:11:12advertisers, to be able to have a more of a better understanding
- 1:11:19of when it comes to their buying optimizations and, and buying
- 1:11:25optimizations and measure when it comes to everything digital.
- 1:11:28So, we think that the entire ecosystem, right now is a bit
- 1:11:32too fragmented. And that's because programmatic
- 1:11:35has become more complex, which is great because it's become
- 1:11:38more mature, but through that complexity all so drives a
- 1:11:42little bit of inefficiencies, so, understand that a lot of
- 1:11:46Innovations for sure. Yeah, exactly, exactly.
- 1:11:48And one of the things is that who gets exposed to more of
- 1:11:51these inefficiencies is those mid-market Brands and small
- 1:11:55independent agencies that don't have such a that much resources
- 1:11:58out there. And we really feel like they're
- 1:12:01getting a lot of scrutiny, especially with this economic
- 1:12:03climate. So, we wanted to provide a new
- 1:12:06solution out there where we could say, hey, let's use our
- 1:12:08expertise at Orange 142 with the agency.
- 1:12:11Let's enable in Ai and find out how we can help cure for some of
- 1:12:15those inefficiencies. What is the relationship with
- 1:12:19the, with the SSP side of the business studies run separately?
- 1:12:21Or does like the work you do? In the agency directly, relate
- 1:12:24to SSP side of it. Great question.
- 1:12:26I've been asked this quite frequently ignition plus is
- 1:12:29meant to be independent. So we're trying to find out how
- 1:12:32we could I get resolved, those inefficiencies working with
- 1:12:35their current platform where their current setup.
- 1:12:37So they working with a few different dsps.
- 1:12:40We try to work within those dsps and just try and make things a
- 1:12:44little easier for them. If there's an opportunity in
- 1:12:47which we could work, with our SSP in Tam them, to make things
- 1:12:50easier for them, we will, but it's not our, it's not our main
- 1:12:53focus. You, you mentioned midmarket
- 1:12:57brands, are these most like mid caps smbs, your charting for
- 1:13:01this? Or is it going to be Enterprise?
- 1:13:02So 100%, it's one of those small.
- 1:13:05It's a medium sized businesses out there again, we feel like
- 1:13:08when it comes to, the inefficiencies are up there in
- 1:13:11the marketplace right now, they're the ones are getting
- 1:13:13exposed to the most. And they could use the most help
- 1:13:16for it. So, that is where that's where
- 1:13:18our concentration is at the moment.
- 1:13:20I would imagine a lot of them are underserved generally by
- 1:13:22agencies correct. Like they're, you know, that
- 1:13:24because it working with agency, can be expensive.
- 1:13:27And I think for maybe a lot of smaller companies, it might be
- 1:13:29afraid, right? Yeah.
- 1:13:30And this is where we think AI can be a huge Boon for them as
- 1:13:33well, because through AI, as long as we can find these these,
- 1:13:37you know, just measurable efficiencies for them through
- 1:13:40AI. We could save them a sometime
- 1:13:43and, and we can find cost savings.
- 1:13:45There would be wonderful, but it's not only for, for small
- 1:13:49meeting side is Brands. It's also for independent
- 1:13:52agencies as well. I received the, you know, the
- 1:13:54big six agencies already have so much expertise, but some more
- 1:13:58the independent agencies, they could use some more help.
- 1:14:01So we're here to help serve those agencies as well.
- 1:14:05So, their partner, a lot of the ages.
- 1:14:06Everyone knows that their clients are demanding that they
- 1:14:09use AI. Like there's a lot a lot of
- 1:14:11these just expectation. Generally, that agencies will be
- 1:14:14bringing like I mean that's For, for marketers, they're expecting
- 1:14:18their agencies to bring the newest, the best, the brightest,
- 1:14:21they all the coolest ideas, right?
- 1:14:23Including some of the, some of the newest and best text.
- 1:14:25So, but I would imagine for for smaller agencies, I mean ai's,
- 1:14:31The cheaper and faster to adopt than a lot of traditional Tech.
- 1:14:35But it's still, it's still not easy, right?
- 1:14:36No certainly not and not every agency has the resources to do
- 1:14:40it but we've been doing it for quite some time now, and we have
- 1:14:43expertise, and we want to lend out that expertise to the
- 1:14:46marketplace. So that's where we come in and
- 1:14:49that's where our ignition Plus Solution comes in, as well.
- 1:14:52How long have you been with this organization out of curiosity?
- 1:14:54Overall overall, I've been with the company for close to five
- 1:14:58years now. But again, I started more with
- 1:14:59the supply-side platform and I'm happy to say that actually, when
- 1:15:03I was a publisher, I had used the SSP myself.
- 1:15:06So I had a great familiarity with the company, love the
- 1:15:09company and I love her mission statement as well.
- 1:15:12And, and now that I've been transferred over to the agency,
- 1:15:15I feel just as excited to go help out with the agencies and
- 1:15:19for these Brands as well. So, the sounds that you spent
- 1:15:22some time in the world publishing.
- 1:15:24Yeah, right. Okay, what kind of publisher, a
- 1:15:26mostly with multiple show. I worked with Univision now,
- 1:15:29called television, and all worked with Geo media.
- 1:15:33And I actually started my career at Yahoo Okay.
- 1:15:36Yeah, it's fun. Just a bunch of people here.
- 1:15:38Yes I was one of those big Brands like there's so many
- 1:15:42people in The world of advertising, the world of
- 1:15:45digital media that I spent a good portion or at least some of
- 1:15:49their career Yahoo, it's been incredible, like, incubator of
- 1:15:52talent or the industry. Absolutely, we had a joke and
- 1:15:55inside joke, we call it Mother yahoo because she gave birth to
- 1:15:58a lot of ads. Like Executives said, many I was
- 1:16:00able to actually see right here possible.
- 1:16:02I think AOL is another one too, but yeah.
- 1:16:04Who continues on right? In fact their DSP.
- 1:16:08I think it's making a comeback to a certain extent, right?
- 1:16:10Like that. Yeah.
- 1:16:12And you know, talking about the SMB Market, I mean they're seems
- 1:16:15like they're making a big push in terms of gaining market,
- 1:16:18share, SMB Market which I think it's all summer Market is under
- 1:16:21served, right? So it seems pretty strong
- 1:16:24background in Multicultural marketing, too.
- 1:16:26Okay. How like any interesting Trends
- 1:16:29there? Or, I mean, I think it's, I
- 1:16:31mean, it's cool being in Miami seeing like the diversity here,
- 1:16:33baby. I love, welcome by the way.
- 1:16:36Yeah, thank you. I'm native, so yeah, I really
- 1:16:39like this town and it's grown on me.
- 1:16:41I, I guess I came here a little every once in a while I was
- 1:16:43younger. But then, and now that possible
- 1:16:45is here every year and look, if you work in a cruise to cruise
- 1:16:48industry travel Hospitality, this is like the epicenter,
- 1:16:52right? Yeah, as a native Miami.
- 1:16:54I'm very proud to see how much the city has grown.
- 1:16:58And there were quickly, becoming a tech Hub already.
- 1:17:01So I switch on the east coast and possible.
- 1:17:04It's just, you know, just you know, all the evidence, you need
- 1:17:07to see how quickly this is becoming.
- 1:17:09And I think we have to give a students to the local government
- 1:17:13for pushing for it to become more Tech.
- 1:17:16Help as well and a good job. Remember, back in the day, like
- 1:17:18I said, I've been a digital media about 25 years.
- 1:17:20I remember like because of the data laws here.
- 1:17:23There were a lot of the dad, early database, marketers data
- 1:17:25compilers, you know, we're down here and then travel hospitality
- 1:17:28industries been stronger. So it's done.
- 1:17:30Well, but you're right. I mean, the last 10 years it's
- 1:17:32been, I mean, just not only is the skyline change quite a bit,
- 1:17:36but but, you know, marketing, I mean, could possible.
- 1:17:38I mean it was like almost 8,000 people.
- 1:17:40I mean it's been a big success, right?
- 1:17:42And now it's going to exponentially since since its
- 1:17:46initial launch. This is your number four?
- 1:17:48Yes. Yes.
- 1:17:49I, this is my third year here. It's there's more people and
- 1:17:53I've noticed the transition to like, I think, first year here,
- 1:17:57That I was here. So it was number two year for
- 1:17:59possible. It was more heavier, ad Tech.
- 1:18:01And then I think the next year, more or more brand marketers
- 1:18:05here. And then I think this year has
- 1:18:07been cool because I am without common.
- 1:18:08We've got loads about mckown, people around to people, from
- 1:18:11you mentioned, a big six. There are pretty well
- 1:18:13represented here. Now was not the case before.
- 1:18:15So, I mean, it's possible. It's arrived as a temple for
- 1:18:18advertising and absolutely absolutely.
- 1:18:20Um, I've heard a few times has been calling cans of North
- 1:18:24America's so I think that was their goal was to be, I don't
- 1:18:27know compete with Combi be like the North American version or be
- 1:18:30like You know, maybe a warm up for Ken, you know, a couple
- 1:18:34months. So I think they've I think
- 1:18:37they've done a really good job the organizer.
- 1:18:38So I saw an interview with with Christian couple days ago and
- 1:18:42you know, he seemed excited about it.
- 1:18:44So now it's cool. I think it's part of the Miami
- 1:18:46story in everything. Yeah sure.
- 1:18:47And again I want to give kudos to the local Miami government as
- 1:18:51well for bushing for man to be more of a tech cup.
- 1:18:53So I give him I think they give him a lot of flexibility and
- 1:18:57latitude to allow that to happen.
- 1:18:58So what have they done? Has it been taxed since then?
- 1:19:01It has just been like Cheerleading would have been
- 1:19:04some of the things that they've done, everything everything on
- 1:19:06above. I've been hearing, there's a lot
- 1:19:07of cheerleading and there's a certain I can't speak
- 1:19:10proficiently as to what the benefits are from the tax
- 1:19:13perspective. But from what I've heard from
- 1:19:15employers, it sounds like something like that but I could
- 1:19:18say undoubtedly of course Florida is a state is very
- 1:19:21beneficial with more but no city or state taxes.
- 1:19:24Yeah, I mean, no one can taxes huge, right?
- 1:19:26Yeah, I know bunch. I mean, I know bunch of people
- 1:19:28in Tech with moved here, from from the bay area, quite a few
- 1:19:33people. Now, you know, another one from
- 1:19:34New York. I used to live in New York.
- 1:19:37Okay, I'm a New Yorker. Not a native New Yorker, but I
- 1:19:40grew up in New York and I can definitely, I get it.
- 1:19:43I mean, if all plus is, if you're East Coast person, so we
- 1:19:46East Coast, the same time zone and, you know, if you want to go
- 1:19:49back to work as a short flight anyway, right, so I can
- 1:19:52definitely see the attraction and then plus like you mentioned
- 1:19:56Multicultural aspect. This is the gateway to Latin
- 1:19:58America. Yes.
- 1:19:59For many of us Hispanics. We also used to say the Miami is
- 1:20:03the capital of Latin America. Because here in Latin America,
- 1:20:06Inn in Miami. He'll cross so many different
- 1:20:09Latin. Americans, people from Brazil,
- 1:20:10from from Cuba from Venezuela. Absolutely.
- 1:20:13From here, all over, right? Exactly.
- 1:20:16So it's great for marking purposes as well.
- 1:20:19It's just like a firm who wants to just like enter those
- 1:20:22markets. This is a natural place to
- 1:20:25Absolutely. Absolutely.
- 1:20:26I actually happen to know several firms especially for
- 1:20:29Argentina that would have an office here because they could
- 1:20:32lend on the local expertise when it comes to digital marketing
- 1:20:36and then be able to do marketing back in Argentina as well.
- 1:20:40So smart, Okay. So yeah, so, for if from our,
- 1:20:43you know, start here, you can work.
- 1:20:45I mean, if your point, if they have Offices here, right?
- 1:20:48Build those relationships. It's, you know, the natural
- 1:20:50gateway to Latin America or the would actually invest in
- 1:20:53offices, over here to be able to help a market to us, Hispanics,
- 1:20:57and still be able to have a strong connection.
- 1:20:59To one side is Very cool. Very cool.
- 1:21:01So you're background say publishing.
- 1:21:03So we're was that anything before that, it's worth calling.
- 1:21:06So I've always been in business development Revenue operations
- 1:21:10as well for publishing and for a publishing and for obviously,
- 1:21:15for attic for for an SSP and just offer in general.
- 1:21:18And then I certainly love anything when it comes to video
- 1:21:22special for connected television, being able to help
- 1:21:25because actually start off my career in operations.
- 1:21:28So I certainly know how to do on the operational side and then
- 1:21:31some people say have a good personality and help lenses
- 1:21:33sales and so I got into business is about as well.
- 1:21:37Having a likeable personality that helps sales and being on.
- 1:21:41Bilingual also helps especially here.
- 1:21:43I bet he said you moved here from New York, right?
- 1:21:45Yep. I lived in New York originally
- 1:21:46and then oh, because I have family here in Miami.
- 1:21:49I would go from Miami to New York and vice versa, but I did
- 1:21:53most of my career in New York and then during the pandemic,
- 1:21:56like many other, New Yorkers came down to Miami and never
- 1:21:59looked back. He said, okay well nice what's a
- 1:22:02cool story so. Well listen, thank you so much
- 1:22:04for coming by today. It was cool to get to know you a
- 1:22:07little bit here about your story and hear about the newest new
- 1:22:10that kind of existing Company New and whatever you're doing,
- 1:22:13which sounds exciting, and your nickname.
- 1:22:15You're an exciting place. And you know, next year, maybe
- 1:22:19we can check in again and see where things are.
- 1:22:21Yeah, absolutely looking forward to it.
- 1:22:23Thank you. Thank you, pleasure, always.
- 1:22:25We're at Getting close to the end of day.
- 1:22:28Number three, the final day is possible the event down in Miami
- 1:22:32and I've got a really special guest, I'm super excited about
- 1:22:34Crystal Wallace. See you axioms.
- 1:22:37We're coming now. Great to see you, thanks for
- 1:22:39having me back and yes we're calling.
- 1:22:41I'm so excited about this conversation.
- 1:22:43We always have good conversation, not sure how good.
- 1:22:46This one's gonna be? Given to be a great one.
- 1:22:48I know it was. No, it always is day three, it's
- 1:22:51been possible has been great. I mean, it's been a lot of
- 1:22:53activity. A lot of great conversations and
- 1:22:56just strategic conversations, which really to me this is
- 1:22:59usually like the prep work hand but at least for me it's been
- 1:23:03some good connection points a lot.
- 1:23:04He can now. Yeah, I think so.
- 1:23:07Yeah. I mean, I know they really
- 1:23:09wanted to make it like a legit 10 pole, which I think that safe
- 1:23:13to say that it is it was it was cool to see too.
- 1:23:17Like there's so many like people from Oregon stations so many.
- 1:23:21I'm sorry showed up and we did I think he passed.
- 1:23:25Cheers, not so much. I've been here's my third.
- 1:23:27Year. But wrap ran a bunch of people.
- 1:23:29It was great to see. Yeah.
- 1:23:30It was a great, a great Connecting Point and start to
- 1:23:35the summer. I'm definitely felt the heat.
- 1:23:36Oh yeah, being next to this beautiful beach and again, just
- 1:23:41elevate a conversations and it's been really.
- 1:23:44This is my first experience though.
- 1:23:45I've enjoyed it, today's been a little cooler which has been
- 1:23:48nice. It's funny.
- 1:23:48I wore a jacket yesterday. Exactly.
- 1:23:50Go to like, I go to big client dinner and I want to look all
- 1:23:52fancy. It'll still drying out.
- 1:23:54I'm sure it is. I was so and I'm still it was
- 1:23:58definitely cooler but it didn't have the like afternoon, shower
- 1:24:02to kind of clear the humidity. So I'm still hot and sticky and
- 1:24:06yeah probably need to dry out myself.
- 1:24:08So I do love the city but it gets better to do this now than
- 1:24:11July and you compared can't this is actually kind of cool nice so
- 1:24:16that can get a little sticky but great let's get down into it.
- 1:24:20So Data layer just connected. I mean to be maybe good to dig
- 1:24:25into that like, why for a lot of Advertisers just feel and why?
- 1:24:31For a lot of people in in the business does data layer feel
- 1:24:34like just connected from like what's really going on from the
- 1:24:37action? because we have a lot of Data
- 1:24:41layer side. So I think we can we've gotten
- 1:24:44really good in terms of capturing signals and perfecting
- 1:24:48them, but we've essentially built an ecosystem engine that
- 1:24:52it's set for execution versus orchestration across so we can
- 1:24:57only see kind of Vertically down and not across and then
- 1:25:02therefore you could only speak to you.
- 1:25:04Kind of the specific data layer. You know for that specific
- 1:25:08isolation. Yeah it's relationship.
- 1:25:10Um and therefore you can't understand really kind of how
- 1:25:16all that connects to business outcomes and and why this
- 1:25:19matters and how this move in the business you can only speak to
- 1:25:23oh well hey, we know that we drove this channel.
- 1:25:27Drove this versus, here's how we are contributing to drive that
- 1:25:33consumer experience at that. Right moment.
- 1:25:36And that's the whole thing consumers.
- 1:25:39They don't, they don't understand channels.
- 1:25:41They don't care about paid owned and earned.
- 1:25:44It's a relevant to them, right? I mean moments contacts.
- 1:25:47Culture. How do you get there?
- 1:25:50How do you understand that? Well, to me the data layer, the
- 1:25:55data Foundation has to start with identity.
- 1:25:58And and then to further, complicate it identity is
- 1:26:02equality. So much, you know, we had the
- 1:26:05cookie duplication thing that kind of didn't happen.
- 1:26:10But then now you have agents working on behalf of the humans.
- 1:26:14So, not only am I trying to Grapple with you know your
- 1:26:19terrestrial identity, your digital ID based identity you
- 1:26:24know all household around locations and context aware now
- 1:26:29but are not It's a real thing. This was trying to scrape and,
- 1:26:36you know, proliferate and you know leverage or is this a body
- 1:26:41agent acting on behalf of the human IE, their digital twin and
- 1:26:46so I need to understand that, you know, me at my digital twin
- 1:26:48alone. Remember here recently this
- 1:26:50morning I generate content now being produced in the human
- 1:26:53generic content and I think they look at web traffic.
- 1:26:57In many instances of majority of it is actually which is just
- 1:27:00wild thoughts that static. Signals day, is this synthetic
- 1:27:04synthetic? And I says, it's not real but it
- 1:27:07actually is Real, because it's working.
- 1:27:11On behalf of the human. Yeah.
- 1:27:13If it's, yeah, it's good point. It's making a query for you
- 1:27:16obviously, then it's super useful and that you need to be
- 1:27:19counting for that. But also like a lot of it is,
- 1:27:22you know, the Lord. They all of them are just going
- 1:27:24scraping content. Anyway, right?
- 1:27:25So yeah. But you probably want those to
- 1:27:27do that as well, right? And maybe you don't sometimes
- 1:27:29Well, yeah, if it's for the right intention and for a real
- 1:27:35intention so you know, all of the now you can build your kind
- 1:27:40of your genetic swarm to go shop.
- 1:27:43For me, I want to do the research and, and actually,
- 1:27:46here's my credit card. Here are the parameters, and
- 1:27:49which it's like when I tell my daughter, okay, You go grocery
- 1:27:54shopping. I need this list.
- 1:27:55You can buy whatever you want to, but in these parameters, use
- 1:27:58this car don't overspend on this.
- 1:28:01Make sure you check out and get my coupons and that you put my
- 1:28:04loyalty car art in and all that. And she thinking to Commerce
- 1:28:08said, that is the thing that's going to happen.
- 1:28:09Love to get your take 100%. Um, I think some of it is
- 1:28:14forcing functions when you see kind of okay, where, where do
- 1:28:18people go to search First? You see what Google is doing
- 1:28:23this. An agentic recommendation, the
- 1:28:26that the Commerce and shopper. You can't even get to you.
- 1:28:30Gotta click down to pick up, go to your normal experience.
- 1:28:33And now I want, don't give me the AI summary or like, who I
- 1:28:37can buy from and that, you know, that llm response.
- 1:28:39Give me a traditional but Again, this Innovation and even kind of
- 1:28:44the user Behavior Dynamics is changing so rapidly, I'm kind of
- 1:28:50getting used to it now because I'll look and see what they they
- 1:28:53said. I go back to the usual way and
- 1:28:56which I search and find and discover and then buy, and I'm
- 1:29:00like, okay, next time. Well, it was kind of, right and
- 1:29:03then I'll go into my own, you know, gbt llm.
- 1:29:07And then I'll start setting up my own agents with my own
- 1:29:10parameters, so it'll do it itself.
- 1:29:12It's a really good point and I agree with you and I just never
- 1:29:16been a lot of people. People like to honk a lot here.
- 1:29:19It's been a lot of their I've been some people very vocally
- 1:29:23arguing against the concept of Egyptian Commerce thing.
- 1:29:27Eric super was saying it's Mirage.
- 1:29:29I thought about it a lot. I think I grew with your Opinion
- 1:29:34there and I'm way. I'm framing it is like think
- 1:29:38about 25 years ago. Almost no one bought things
- 1:29:40online, right? I remember I heard this great
- 1:29:43podcast about earliest of Amazon and apparently people were so
- 1:29:47worried about giving credit cards, they would email credit
- 1:29:49card numbers or call them in just to Complete the
- 1:29:53transaction, right? So I was a when I was 16, I was
- 1:29:57a credit card Raider, okay? And you know, Anyway, that, yes,
- 1:30:02I remember getting the calls and having don't, don't facts me,
- 1:30:07right? I'll take it over the phone and
- 1:30:10the, the clerk or the sales person that hand the phone over
- 1:30:14to the client. They write.
- 1:30:16Anyway, yeah, so just wild thing that like, people would email
- 1:30:19credit card to tell people, my phone is being ridden down, it's
- 1:30:22like no less. It's probably less secure than
- 1:30:24actually. People just didn't know what
- 1:30:27they could trust it. They hadn't been trained to
- 1:30:29understand this because I think that he looked today, people
- 1:30:32just one click, it's done, right?
- 1:30:33They buy stuff. So, think about how dramatically
- 1:30:36buying behaviors changed in 2530 years.
- 1:30:40So like, is it crazy to think that if agents actually to your
- 1:30:44point, had your credit card information, do your preferences
- 1:30:46new, you what? To buy?
- 1:30:47What not to buy and we have safeguards in?
- 1:30:49Okay, you can return things. Would like what?
- 1:30:54I trust an agent, if it had my frequent flyer information, all
- 1:30:57my information, new one I wanted to fly.
- 1:30:59If I just told it, hey, buy me ticket for Tuesday, that it
- 1:31:01would, if it knew me well enough, he could make an
- 1:31:03informed decision and I 24 hours to exchange it.
- 1:31:05I don't see why not, why not. Why not?
- 1:31:09And is that the trust is definitely a barrier to scaling
- 1:31:14agenda Commerce. for sure, but to me that's where you're trust
- 1:31:20has to be built in that architecture that data layer and
- 1:31:24it has to be identity based because otherwise, then there's
- 1:31:29no grounding of like prostitute, an individual, right?
- 1:31:32Yeah. um, so yeah, those are It's happening.
- 1:31:38And guess what? It may not happen for Our
- 1:31:40Generation, but these kids are It's almost you know guaranteed
- 1:31:46they have no problem with it. This is their digital natives.
- 1:31:49Sure. I think that they speed things
- 1:31:51are changing and advancing and I hope it'll happen for Our
- 1:31:54Generation. But I think you're right.
- 1:31:55Even if the capabilities there, will people actually use it?
- 1:31:59Some people. Well, but maybe maybe not.
- 1:32:02But in the future I agree. I think it's a foregone
- 1:32:04conclusion. We ended up there. um, and if
- 1:32:07you can orchestrate like for And there's different, there's going
- 1:32:12to be different maturity levels and to how agent of Commerce
- 1:32:15evolves, the easiest one is discoverability. you know, and
- 1:32:21then the augmented reality of it.
- 1:32:24So if I'm able to identically like fine things that I've been
- 1:32:29searching for address for can actually I met with a really
- 1:32:34Interesting partner that I'm excited to partner with.
- 1:32:37Okay, cool. And I want to say, yeah.
- 1:32:39Yes. I know I'm not authorized to say
- 1:32:43yeah, but one of those announcements for Cantu that we
- 1:32:46can talk about privately next time.
- 1:32:48But yeah, but You see this dress?
- 1:32:52Oh, that's cute. And then.
- 1:32:54It's connected to my agents, my llm and that's already has my
- 1:32:59picture and they've been thought about it, we put me into what
- 1:33:03I'm looking for in all the various different styles to
- 1:33:06choose from and within one click because I've been searching for
- 1:33:09this dress and it's the perfect dress.
- 1:33:11And now I see myself in that dress.
- 1:33:13So, you know, the augmented reality of all that which um
- 1:33:16between Gemini and now open up, I that video generate like it's
- 1:33:22amazing so much better. It's got like And like three
- 1:33:26months is gotten so much better. Yeah, yeah I mean why not?
- 1:33:33I'm down for it. I was recently me and my husband
- 1:33:37were looking for another property.
- 1:33:41Maybe in town. And I did it all like really,
- 1:33:46okay, all the discoverability. And then all of the comparisons
- 1:33:51on, you know, based on this all the way down to the loan options
- 1:33:55right there and DBT and it was brilliant and I was comparing
- 1:33:59this against what I pulled from Zillow, my realtor was sent to
- 1:34:03me from her bank and it was better.
- 1:34:07Better. It has some some of it was like
- 1:34:10it has still data the data wasn't fresh and so I would go
- 1:34:13to listing and I'm like oh this is no longer here or but it was
- 1:34:18I mean after a while it was like and then we decided not to buy
- 1:34:22because it's so, you know, unintended consequences.
- 1:34:25But that's where, you know, different brands.
- 1:34:28Like if you know, If you are orchestrating first across, I
- 1:34:33didn't, he put in contacts culture where signals in their
- 1:34:37proper place, across that consumer Journey.
- 1:34:41You will win, you will get ahead of it. but trust is a foundation
- 1:34:45that is, I mean, it's it's a must-have, like You talked a lot
- 1:34:52about outcomes, right about like making sure our activities and
- 1:34:56the things we build are driving towards outcomes.
- 1:34:59I mean, how do you do you see progress being made and what do
- 1:35:03you think? We are as minister right now.
- 1:35:05Um, I think we move Beyond the desire, the conceptual, the You
- 1:35:14know. The okay.
- 1:35:16How do we framework this? I think it's still about.
- 1:35:24Organization and coordination and I think we're starting to
- 1:35:27get there the wall guards that come down a little bit, right?
- 1:35:31You have more Cooperative, you know even you know there's a lot
- 1:35:37of coordination around. the consumer, there's, you know, a
- 1:35:43lot of Partnerships that are happening to drive joint.
- 1:35:50Joint joint joint reach and you know and really like the client
- 1:35:55connection. So whether it's for us is Delta
- 1:36:00like what I see them doing and they're very strategic
- 1:36:03Partnerships delivering based on that.
- 1:36:05Customer need based on the time you know started with T-Mobile
- 1:36:09then Uber then you know and They orchestrated as such a way, at
- 1:36:17least for me as a consumer. I'm like, oh man.
- 1:36:21Yeah, I need that. So reminds me of my knee and
- 1:36:26then You know, depending on and it's very you know, Courtney at
- 1:36:310 trust, no data movement type of coordination.
- 1:36:35That I know that they're having Each of these players are able
- 1:36:40to address that consumers need based on where they are in the
- 1:36:44moment based on their needs state.
- 1:36:48To deliver the right message and and kind of drive them closer to
- 1:36:53Annapolis how they want to transact with that consumer.
- 1:36:57And it's in a way that doesn't feel like it's just an ad or the
- 1:37:03sake of an ad and just not feel contrived either, right?
- 1:37:06Yeah. It's, you know, And I think
- 1:37:10that's like, so, we're getting there, we need to do more of
- 1:37:14that, you know, our stance. Axiom Omni know.
- 1:37:19It's a, we need to we need to build an ecosystem.
- 1:37:23This stuff is it is it is is evolving so fast.
- 1:37:27If we are not building a coordinated ecosystem, that's
- 1:37:32trusted and grounded and true. We don't have a chance I love
- 1:37:38what Omni comes doing now. And part of one reason why I
- 1:37:40joined and, you know, now that actually I'm just like, Art of
- 1:37:44Omnicom and we're building this. I mean there's been a lot of
- 1:37:46operating systems, right? But agency is like needing to
- 1:37:49bring. The identity player.
- 1:37:52Yeah, the activation layer orchestration, layer the and and
- 1:37:58then, you know, I think on top of that You know, I think this
- 1:38:03strategy and like the build ideas to drive these, I think,
- 1:38:06you know, I think agency when it works well, as all those things,
- 1:38:08but they just more of an emphasis on operating system.
- 1:38:11I don't know, we are able to share, but I I've heard some
- 1:38:16really cool things about what what's being built right now
- 1:38:18from the integration's and what this is going to deliver for our
- 1:38:21clients, talk about that a little bit.
- 1:38:23Yeah. So we we have and always been.
- 1:38:29We're evolving identity as the consumer's identity evolved.
- 1:38:34And what that means is being an ecosystem player being Federated
- 1:38:39and droppable with our trusted Partners bringing in the
- 1:38:47strategy and that orchestration piece, what OS is in the
- 1:38:51platforms, what has been built to date at I think by, you know,
- 1:38:56a lot of the whole coast and Are again execution.
- 1:39:02Platforms, that speed up kind of the normal flow.
- 1:39:05But what we're doing right now actually goes, that's the past,
- 1:39:07right? Or maybe, that's for like I've
- 1:39:09seen some competitors stitched together different pieces into
- 1:39:12an execution, but we're building seems like a lot more than that,
- 1:39:15right? So much more is it is it is your
- 1:39:18strategic layer that goes all the way from honestly R&D.
- 1:39:23So you know, how can I actually predict the future?
- 1:39:26But what are the signals that are coming in?
- 1:39:28How can I understand kind of the Halo full effect so that I can
- 1:39:32not only understand kind of What outcomes I'm driving now but
- 1:39:38like what outcomes? I'm driving long-term.
- 1:39:41And truly There's a there was a buzzword that I loved but I
- 1:39:49can't teach them right now. So probably was not good, but
- 1:39:52It's that Dynamic funnel. Bringing together you know,
- 1:39:57really a true 360 View and truly we get to incrementality and
- 1:40:03business outcomes. and it's, I don't know, it's just It's, it's
- 1:40:09excited. I am inspired again.
- 1:40:12I was inspired when digital social took off and it became
- 1:40:17you know another area where you can drive off into City.
- 1:40:21But I think where we're going right now and because of
- 1:40:25technology and agentic and all this kind of Rapid building true
- 1:40:31intelligence that, you know, Connects.
- 1:40:35Yeah, it's going to be a bright future for those who get it.
- 1:40:38I think it's an exciting feature.
- 1:40:40I think it's like, most about what were doing. for me it's in
- 1:40:46some of this is probably gonna be a couple years off but I love
- 1:40:49the fact that we're bringing like world class Dad and
- 1:40:53identity layer bringing world-class execution
- 1:40:57orchestration. In the first one, you know,
- 1:40:59we're bringing with Omni it's world class, execution layer,
- 1:41:04and then, we're layering on top of, I think an AI enables this
- 1:41:10Us to build this control pain on top of that.
- 1:41:13And then we're going to be able to build.
- 1:41:14I mean By understanding of it. And what I kind of see emerging
- 1:41:20is like We're going to be able to build or imagine a few
- 1:41:23clients can bring their own age. Those agents can Well, identity
- 1:41:29and audience data for maximum. They can use our tools.
- 1:41:33So then identify which channels one activated on, like I can
- 1:41:38They can, they can activate a different channels.
- 1:41:40They can pull. Look at the results and
- 1:41:41immediately, pull them back into planning and adjustment and
- 1:41:44optimization in a way that's quicker.
- 1:41:46More Dynamic, I mean, we talked about this before, how I think
- 1:41:49it's been a lot of these analogies historically, you
- 1:41:53could look at stuff, but okay, but the time you've gone through
- 1:41:55the pain of looking at it and understanding it seeing what's
- 1:41:58working like it's weeks go by and like this too late, right?
- 1:42:03So, I think being able to do those things, do those things in
- 1:42:06closer to real time and having like closing, finally closing
- 1:42:09that Loop between Results analysis measurement and then
- 1:42:14back into planning and optimization is going to be a
- 1:42:17huge. I think the Omnicom operating
- 1:42:20system will enable that. Yeah.
- 1:42:22When you close the exposure to conversion, you get outcomes and
- 1:42:28we make that Dynamic and faster to the signals as they come in
- 1:42:32and then you can experiment all. So, along the way because that's
- 1:42:37what technology, you could create synthetic, you can
- 1:42:39literally create synthetic data. That's so close the real world.
- 1:42:42And what's happening, you get there a lot faster.
- 1:42:44And then the geek in me goes down to the infrastructure
- 1:42:48layer, where your pipeline and becomes Dynamic based on what's
- 1:42:52happening in the, you know, the data that's coming in and so and
- 1:42:55you do it with AI, you could not do that before.
- 1:42:57No. Wait not The scary thing.
- 1:43:00The scary thing to me. If?
- 1:43:04it's some reason like we lose, you know, Wi-Fi connectivity,
- 1:43:08sometimes these models, you know, they're in two Sprint
- 1:43:12cycles and I can tell like when a model is off and I'm like off
- 1:43:17and I know what that shit for a week when they go and fix it.
- 1:43:20And so The dependency and and there's nothing new Under, it's
- 1:43:26not always say that that's my Mantra.
- 1:43:28So like making sure that you have these like locally too on
- 1:43:33edge, like it's actually you know, it's like 40, you know,
- 1:43:39we're almost 60 year old company and we have a data center like
- 1:43:44yeah, we have a data center like that's that's not old, that's
- 1:43:48not know. It is planning for the future
- 1:43:51and all of those, you know, fail your points and fell safe that
- 1:43:56you need to that honestly, because there was this rapid
- 1:43:59migration to the cloud. Those companies that, you know,
- 1:44:03and that were less regulated and, you know, could kind of be
- 1:44:07free to just kind of go there, they're gonna have to start
- 1:44:11thinking back on, just like when we had to go back to as 400
- 1:44:15stuff and like, all they know the, the clients in that I some
- 1:44:20probably still are, but I remember that.
- 1:44:21Yeah. so, um, and I think on the We're, we're ahead of that game.
- 1:44:30Um, One of the, one of the great, like interesting things
- 1:44:35when we were, you know, bringing in assessing kind of what parts
- 1:44:39and pieces to really bring together. it was so
- 1:44:44complimentary like, we and there is a sea of sameness but like
- 1:44:47the uniqueness and in Brain, Trust that you all brought, it
- 1:44:53was so kind of similar in like a line to like, The the Wizards,
- 1:45:00the experts, you know, on our side.
- 1:45:03And so we ended up not which just compliments but Innovation
- 1:45:08that now, you know, for a couple years but like iteration um,
- 1:45:14we're I think we're bringing something really unique to bear.
- 1:45:18This differentiated everyone's I like to think.
- 1:45:22Yeah. I mean I grew like I was
- 1:45:23agreeing with you. Like I think that like what I'm
- 1:45:25seeing is potential for like the whole to be much better bigger
- 1:45:28than someone's that now gonna be a little selfish here too.
- 1:45:31So like I'm part of Corral's systems, integrator consulting
- 1:45:37firm and you know, we've, you know, Harris been off for about
- 1:45:3920 years, was quite, I'm in 2018, so trying to find, but I
- 1:45:43think what's really cool now is just to see, okay?
- 1:45:45This like an impression I get right is I'm he comes
- 1:45:49acknowledging, our clients need Engineering.
- 1:45:54Engineering prowess. Knowledge of the big
- 1:45:58hyperscalers possibility to like rapidly build.
- 1:46:03Advertising Marketing Solutions using this technology.
- 1:46:07That can sit on top of omni and things.
- 1:46:10I've seen as a big difference between two here, and
- 1:46:13absolutely, even even in ipg like acting like our our biggest
- 1:46:20part of our business is not the agency business.
- 1:46:25And now there's just a pull through us come together.
- 1:46:28And I think our place a huge role and I'm excited about like
- 1:46:31how we become symbiotic, because you all have the strategist.
- 1:46:35You all have, who can who can bring it all together.
- 1:46:38These fit for purpose and so we're not approaching a client
- 1:46:41with another Point solution. Another platform that you need
- 1:46:44to slap on and here's how we're going to power up and make an
- 1:46:48augment and make your what you have work harder because what we
- 1:46:53know where this sits that says and how you kind of bring all
- 1:46:56those things together and I'm more orchestrated way, I love
- 1:46:59that. Now having really cool
- 1:47:00conversations but people from my PG&E and for mother's another
- 1:47:04places across both the legacy ipg is well as Omnicom now say
- 1:47:08well guess what is one pattern where we're taking first party
- 1:47:12data? Maybe where you know onboarding
- 1:47:15with actually you know activating on me or work guess
- 1:47:18what? We're taking you know we're
- 1:47:20taking you putting in a clean room and you're bringing tonight
- 1:47:23I see identity service and then guess what?
- 1:47:25She didn't do that. So we're looking at these
- 1:47:29patterns bringing Bringing to Bear the latest Technologies and
- 1:47:34the knowledge of his stuff ups. And plus the ability how to work
- 1:47:37with these platforms, you know, how to work with AWS.
- 1:47:39We have not only AWS Engineers but we know how to navigate to
- 1:47:43unlock funds. Exactly.
- 1:47:44It's just I see clients get so excited about that just in
- 1:47:48benefit our clients, 100%. And look, that's what being an
- 1:47:52agent and advisor, you know, and you know having agency is about.
- 1:47:56That's that's my hope of these form.
- 1:47:58You get that scale observability across the market so that if
- 1:48:05that's not your core business, you never can get that.
- 1:48:07That we have brilliant clients. I mean it's very data clients
- 1:48:10but focus on your core powering up your Enterprise and we can
- 1:48:13help you and be your strategic advisors and so we're getting
- 1:48:17back. I feel like There's a my my
- 1:48:22colleague who's a brilliant PhD and AI. just really got He
- 1:48:30always talks about Conway's law the way you organize the way.
- 1:48:32Um, yeah. And I think that, Not saying
- 1:48:36when messy because it's a freaking.
- 1:48:39Height of the industry that you're now integrating these two
- 1:48:43things but the way we're organizing now feels like a new
- 1:48:48Modern Way, agency industry operate, you know, form
- 1:48:54together. You know, going back instead of
- 1:48:56just being execution, really kind of being that orchestration
- 1:49:02layer. If it's a client and actually
- 1:49:04looking at a client and actually, you should take these
- 1:49:06pieces and house. Your data is the most valuable
- 1:49:09asset that you have is what I like that.
- 1:49:14A lot funny. I talked to the CMO of the large
- 1:49:16bank today in conversation like this, and that's kind of that's
- 1:49:19really where we landed using. Like it's not a question of do I
- 1:49:23in-house or do I have agency model?
- 1:49:26That you his opinion is the future is like maybe some things
- 1:49:29for some. For some brands should be
- 1:49:31announced. But I think for me, I mean it A
- 1:49:35media Remains the front door for hscs.
- 1:49:37I think there's more pressure for transparency and I think as
- 1:49:41Brands began to go some, I think that's gonna put a little
- 1:49:44pressure in the media business but still gonna be the front
- 1:49:46door. But all these other things we
- 1:49:47can do, you know, bringing in AI engineering, bringing in systems
- 1:49:51integration and our data and identity assets, specific things
- 1:49:55that we can bring to the brand. That make a huge difference.
- 1:49:58Yeah. And then let Media be that
- 1:50:01celebrated to your most valuable asset data because it's going to
- 1:50:04create more data more signals and the orchestra together
- 1:50:07that's where you get to outcomes and I'm excited.
- 1:50:11The interesting thing. You say the there is a call for
- 1:50:15transparency and out the black box but isn't always the case
- 1:50:19where we're at a inflection and kind of change.
- 1:50:23And so, Like I think that is fundamental and like that, that
- 1:50:29would be the measure of success and I think you can't just not
- 1:50:32want to play that can do it has to be a Consortium.
- 1:50:34We have to you know, we have to cooperate and coordinate.
- 1:50:39Some of our biggest competitor or some of our biggest, you
- 1:50:44know, partners and clients, you know, permanent enemies.
- 1:50:46They're only. Permanent interests, right?
- 1:50:49I love that. Oh, And you think about it, too?
- 1:50:52Like and I grew with what you just said about like you know
- 1:50:54like okay who work like maybe someones competitor one day but
- 1:50:57maybe they're another day or maybe.
- 1:50:59So I think that's really interesting and also think that
- 1:51:03Like the the push for more transparency, I think it's a
- 1:51:06good thing. I read the other day by the way
- 1:51:08that I'm a con is going to be looking into like as we shift
- 1:51:11to, I mean, more gently trading model where like scale demand in
- 1:51:15our side and then, you know, the Publishers, they've they've
- 1:51:18scaled supply high quality inventory at some point.
- 1:51:21Like I, I read the other day that we're trying to like move
- 1:51:25or to get to trading. I think this is a cool
- 1:51:27experimentation going on. And I and like one of the goals
- 1:51:30of that is are there opportunities to streamline, the
- 1:51:33path, the connection between demand and Supply.
- 1:51:36Now, there's a lot of total taking and people like or
- 1:51:40entities just skim off the top. There is an opportunity to build
- 1:51:44a cleaner path that has provides better outcomes and more
- 1:51:46transparency. I think so.
- 1:51:47All right I think so and I don't be too God but I feel like I
- 1:51:52know so I Yes. And I think that's human.
- 1:51:58Um, some of what there's all innovative New ways.
- 1:52:06Of clearing out that supply chain that are happening.
- 1:52:11In that our leading what transparency?
- 1:52:14Even that's a p Partners. Yeah, you know, they are willing
- 1:52:17to work with us from that standpoint.
- 1:52:20I think they think to the great SSP is they want to have this
- 1:52:23discussion. They're sick of all the
- 1:52:25nonsense, right? You know they know that they're
- 1:52:26doing things the right way and they know they can win by by
- 1:52:30just providing a better service, not by yeah not by like allowing
- 1:52:33Shady Behavior to happen. It's funny.
- 1:52:35I was that up some friends and clients from Hearst great
- 1:52:39legacy. you know, publisher media player, they own
- 1:52:43incredible like property, spanning magazines to look,
- 1:52:46local TV stations, radio, stations, Etc, and it was And
- 1:52:50asked me like we're going around the room.
- 1:52:51It was. I mean, it's just that lovely
- 1:52:54people and they asked everyone in the room like what do you
- 1:52:57predict in five years? That was my prediction.
- 1:52:59I said, I think in five years I'm not saying all everything's
- 1:53:01gonna be cleaned up. I said, I think if five minutes
- 1:53:03we're gonna have made significant progress towards
- 1:53:06cleaning up the supply path, building a connection between
- 1:53:09demand and supply and, you know, getting better outcomes to
- 1:53:14Brands but also like Better monetization for the best
- 1:53:18Publishers in the world. Absolutely.
- 1:53:19Wonderful. And I think you know modeling at
- 1:53:22kind of the three bit level and this is, this is probably a
- 1:53:26tangent, but a lot of times Now, people are they know enough
- 1:53:31about like data and like targeting to be dangerous and in
- 1:53:35their like, okay, real time. Is it real time?
- 1:53:38You know, is it bad? Is it?
- 1:53:39You know if I could depends on the use case, but what I can
- 1:53:42talk, I need real time for certain things.
- 1:53:44I can actually talk therefore less integration less need to
- 1:53:49like pipe versus having kind of more of this you know, data
- 1:53:53collaboration and bring your own model type of thing and so less
- 1:53:58technical overhead. Easier integration bastard kind
- 1:54:03of unless compliance first because you're not copying
- 1:54:06shipping things all over the place.
- 1:54:08Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:54:08Let's eat grass and data leakage.
- 1:54:10So yeah. Five years.
- 1:54:13Oh, Seeing everything will be solved but I, I guess.
- 1:54:18Yeah, that should be the next podcast.
- 1:54:21I'm your prediction five years. I mean more, you know,
- 1:54:24everything that's been enjoying is proven out like, and we've
- 1:54:29seen the progress and just even six months, more or less than a
- 1:54:33year. Like, what does that look like
- 1:54:34in five? It's hard to say that's a pretty
- 1:54:37curious months, but looking at just like, Month or two.
- 1:54:41So, can is coming up. I'm excited to see you there.
- 1:54:43I think we're gonna, we can create some great content there
- 1:54:46and it's gonna be, you know, it's going to be so many great
- 1:54:48partners and clients there and colleagues and friends from the
- 1:54:50industry and first can too, so, okay, you'll have to handicap
- 1:54:55year round if you don't mind. I don't mind at all.
- 1:54:58You you're going to love it. I'm gonna be.
- 1:55:00Yeah, I think for public. Oh yeah it's gonna be.
- 1:55:03So I kind of previews but this is like a big excited people.
- 1:55:06I just so it's like if you see as I'm starting to build
- 1:55:11Anything you're looking forward to in a run up to that beside
- 1:55:14me. I mean, it sounds like just
- 1:55:15going to be amazing. So and so, besides that
- 1:55:18anything, that's back in the lab like, getting ready for what
- 1:55:21we're gonna show, you know, the the plane is landed.
- 1:55:26And I'm, I'm a tinkerer and I'm just really excited to like
- 1:55:31continue building and, and showcase that we have so cool.
- 1:55:35I won't ask you to give away anything.
- 1:55:37I'm super excited to see what what you gonna showcase.
- 1:55:40You know, I'll be there trying to get a front row seat.
- 1:55:44I think everyone should be excited about it, but thanks
- 1:55:47crystals. Really cool to see.
- 1:55:48Thanks an opportunity, wonderful to spend time with you, and Over
- 1:55:54now. Hey, what six, Miami into the
- 1:55:57day, still absolutely beautiful. Here, I've got Michael Ackerman
- 1:56:01Chief business officer of digital turbine, right?
- 1:56:05Thanks, I just met you but it's one of them about these
- 1:56:08conversations is like you do a little bit of exchange and you
- 1:56:11feel like you're getting to know size pretty quickly.
- 1:56:13But it might be because we both live near City.
- 1:56:16Yeah, right. Yeah, right.
- 1:56:19And there's something about New Yorkers or people that have
- 1:56:22lived in Europe for a while and small Australia originally.
- 1:56:24Right, did you? Yeah.
- 1:56:26Is is there is a little bit of like hey we're just table.
- 1:56:30Oh yeah. And we're gonna get to know each
- 1:56:32other really quickly there's not a whole lot of opposition.
- 1:56:34Yeah. Cuz it's it's communal.
- 1:56:36Trauma of living in like we instantly bond with one another.
- 1:56:40Yeah, the communal trauma. That's a really interesting.
- 1:56:42I call it forced adaptation, right?
- 1:56:44You're constantly. Like and I was actually talking
- 1:56:46to a Brit last night from London.
- 1:56:49I said, well, what did you think?
- 1:56:50When you first she goes, I was like an assault on her senses
- 1:56:53that she described it was. Like, yeah, you're forced to
- 1:56:56consolidate that to something new the street culture.
- 1:56:58The noise that the dynamic sort of multiculturalism.
- 1:57:02It's a really interesting place, really?
- 1:57:04I say very different city very much.
- 1:57:07So yeah. Also without a beach, which is
- 1:57:09why I film Miami right now. It's kind of combining the
- 1:57:12twice. The beach there.
- 1:57:13I see traffic and honking like yeah, it was like nice combo.
- 1:57:16But yeah, you know, I kind, I can't wait.
- 1:57:18Because I'm so used to a city background.
- 1:57:21Yeah, you the city. Yeah, move.
- 1:57:23That's the purpose. We don't have as much noise but
- 1:57:25yeah, it's it. I certainly got that one.
- 1:57:27I looked at Brooklyn. Yeah.
- 1:57:28And so there's always a good. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:57:30So sort of air filter generally, right?
- 1:57:33Like is the air quality when you get like the on the windowsill
- 1:57:36and new city or Brooklyn, you're just like wow.
- 1:57:38They are dust. I'm happy it set a white
- 1:57:43anyways. So digital turbine you.
- 1:57:45We had a lot of conversation before like before around and I
- 1:57:48thought one of the most interesting parts of this book,
- 1:57:50what kind of start with your your background?
- 1:57:52Because we talked about sort of your two, Are competencies,
- 1:57:55right? And we talked about how my
- 1:57:57brothers is a CEO, but a couple of elastic path.
- 1:57:59I was talking about sort of this superpower of being having the
- 1:58:03deep subject matter expertise for product leader, right?
- 1:58:06Where you understand how things are built and engineered, and
- 1:58:09architected and delivered. But also understanding the
- 1:58:12commercial use cases, which is really how do you translate this
- 1:58:15in a way that's meaningful for someone that doesn't have to.
- 1:58:18Yeah. And and have no real
- 1:58:20dependencies on someone else for the knowledge because you've got
- 1:58:24the knowledge for product perspective.
- 1:58:25So it sounds like you just kind of thinking back and forth
- 1:58:27between sort of that cheat that that head of product, you
- 1:58:30product officer pretty soon distinguished career right,
- 1:58:33across Pinterest and Uber advertising and not digital and
- 1:58:37much more. I'm leaving some out and
- 1:58:39Commercial jobs. Yeah.
- 1:58:40Right. So tell me about like you're
- 1:58:42because I think that was fascinating, you know, in your
- 1:58:45super interesting, guys. How did you kind of
- 1:58:47differentiate from a personal perspective?
- 1:58:51Yeah, you know I I think it's a great question.
- 1:58:53When I look back On the Arc of my career, you can be like, oh,
- 1:58:57that makes sense. Because, you know, he was
- 1:58:59really, I don't know. Yeah, I like to know how things
- 1:59:02work. So I studied software design and
- 1:59:05development. I realized very quickly though
- 1:59:08that I wasn't a good engineer. Yeah.
- 1:59:10And but my my desire and my curiosity to build to break
- 1:59:14things like, um, and as I was progressing, like, is the this
- 1:59:19realization that if I can build something else you take the
- 1:59:22market. Yeah, I said to you earlier, you
- 1:59:24know, no one wants to build a house and No One's Gonna live
- 1:59:26in. Yeah.
- 1:59:26And so, being able to Think Through how do I, how do I
- 1:59:30actually create something from nothing but also then, how do I
- 1:59:34just think a fun creative process one?
- 1:59:36Yeah, but you know, that's a diamond, does it?
- 1:59:39A lot of people can create a lot of great ideas out there.
- 1:59:41The ones that stick the one who understand them values.
- 1:59:44Cannot articulate that down you. Yeah.
- 1:59:46And hopefully do a value exchange or like all that sort
- 1:59:50of like it's not product Market that it's probably Market set.
- 1:59:53Like how do you actually Thinking kind of outside in
- 1:59:56versus inside out and I can be the sort of death.
- 1:59:59Now of that product leaders is the ones that don't, they think
- 2:00:03they'll build it and people will come.
- 2:00:05Yeah, and that's just not the right way to think about it,
- 2:00:07right? And I think there's a lot of,
- 2:00:08you know, there's a lot of hammers out there and so much of
- 2:00:10a nail. Yeah, I think the some of the
- 2:00:12best Products and solutions that come from something, you feel
- 2:00:17and experience yourself. So, you know, I worked at
- 2:00:19Pinterest and I was there early days, I loved it.
- 2:00:22We were changing the world. Yeah, creating a better
- 2:00:25internet, but that was your mission is just like that early
- 2:00:29days of pizza is where it started.
- 2:00:30It was because our co-founded Ben and Evan.
- 2:00:32They wanted a website where they could share their and so they
- 2:00:37created Pinterest to solve something between the two.
- 2:00:39Yeah, very simple. Yes, exactly.
- 2:00:41It's amazing. How you can just simplify things
- 2:00:43out. It's almost like an essential
- 2:00:45thing. And, as simple, it's the player
- 2:00:49that that book, that there's almost like a lightning strike
- 2:00:53one, right? It's, it's like, you figure out
- 2:00:55a category and like it maybe seemed super narrow for people
- 2:00:58looking in the outside but then you expanded that's got broader
- 2:01:01applications to kind of the scene problem, right?
- 2:01:03But it's one of my oh yeah. So yeah, that's an online
- 2:01:08digital world and people were playing in the game was fine.
- 2:01:10And why not? But really, what everyone fell
- 2:01:12in love with was the chat function.
- 2:01:14Yeah they could talk it was like tripping.
- 2:01:17Yeah. And so what happened was the
- 2:01:19game to do? Well, they saw all of the
- 2:01:22engagement on the slack Channel. Yeah, on the sorry on the chat
- 2:01:25bowed out and they spun that out into slack.
- 2:01:30This the chat function within a different product by Going and
- 2:01:35listening and actually seeing Oh I thought I was solving this
- 2:01:37problem. People want to play this online,
- 2:01:39multiplayer game, but it was actually, this problem, people
- 2:01:42wanted a better way to communicate online in different
- 2:01:45channels in different direct messages.
- 2:01:47Go, that's the problem. We need to solve.
- 2:01:49Yes, we really have a solution for that.
- 2:01:51People are using and engaging with lit scale that up.
- 2:01:53That's a classic example sort of like a of a tech pivot where you
- 2:01:58are solving for something different.
- 2:01:59And you realize that lightning strike like, oh, this is
- 2:02:02Meaningful. And remember, multiplayer games,
- 2:02:04these to talk about outside of like fortnite that world they
- 2:02:07talked about. I've been like a business, just
- 2:02:10walk up to like a bar. You're a little Avatar.
- 2:02:13You like tap, the person next to you will search like, hi.
- 2:02:16I'm actually somebody at the crazy that would replace
- 2:02:20something like it's IRL in real life, right?
- 2:02:22Like something. Like, and that's it for about 10
- 2:02:25minutes, Facebook, or the only notice Facebook rebranded, his
- 2:02:29meta because they were betting very heavily on the bed of us.
- 2:02:32Yeah. Yeah, never was all the rage.
- 2:02:35Right, and it's just like, they're conferences on, right?
- 2:02:37Oh, yeah. It sounds like, you know, but
- 2:02:41like actual physical governance about the metaverse of the
- 2:02:44metaverse. So, we get an idea of like,
- 2:02:45you're sort of product leader commercial leader.
- 2:02:48You, how do you actually help organizations bridge that down?
- 2:02:51Yeah, so I I think it's really important and you know, it's a
- 2:02:55registered Democrats like. Yeah, you can be I can be a
- 2:03:00conventionally driven quite later or a technically minded
- 2:03:03commercial leader. Like yeah, you can you can bring
- 2:03:06together. Yeah, I think for me like the
- 2:03:09the focus is to say what what is it that we are trying to solve
- 2:03:13for what do we build and what grade and then what value does
- 2:03:16it does it bring to the market? Yeah.
- 2:03:18So for me it's a Digital turbine.
- 2:03:22I think the most interesting thing is we have multiple
- 2:03:24constituents that we serve, we serve advertisers agencies at
- 2:03:28developers to help them, get reached and distribution
- 2:03:31throughout massive ecosystem and network of hundreds of thousands
- 2:03:34of apps that all have our SDK embedded.
- 2:03:36We seek 2 billion unique users, every single month but then we
- 2:03:39also serve the publisher Community because people who are
- 2:03:41looking to monetize, sometimes that's the same app.
- 2:03:43Yeah, sometimes they're separate and then we also carry is
- 2:03:46looking to create really engaging Discovery experiences
- 2:03:48on their within their devices. So for us, the goal, is to say,
- 2:03:53okay sort of app modernization in an application, adoption
- 2:03:56acquisition, right? And the acquisition happened to
- 2:03:59sort of operating platform level, right at the device
- 2:04:02level, or the carrier level where it's called.
- 2:04:04As you described in the, in the monetization level is like, hey,
- 2:04:08we've we're gonna help you. Actually, we're going to bring
- 2:04:11advertisers to your app for appropriate for those apps that
- 2:04:14needs. There's a trial of new apps
- 2:04:17coming out, right? And a lot of these need help.
- 2:04:19So, I say to My wife can't explain what I do and I'm like,
- 2:04:22I'm just I'm keeping the internet free.
- 2:04:24Yeah. And and so there is a tsunami of
- 2:04:27all of these apps just there that you do like surveillance
- 2:04:29marketing or anything like maybe MSA.
- 2:04:32But yeah, if the city though touch upon it in q1 alone, there
- 2:04:36was I think it was 80 or 84% increase in app submissions to
- 2:04:40the App Store. Everyone's buying on the
- 2:04:42weekend. Yeah.
- 2:04:42Helping them create really like I I love that.
- 2:04:45Like what are applied? Yeah.
- 2:04:47So that's really all of creativity that didn't which is
- 2:04:52really exciting. Yeah.
- 2:04:53But great you created it how do I get it to the world?
- 2:04:56How do I distribute it? And that's what we come in like
- 2:04:59we threw out deep Partnerships and relationships with oems and
- 2:05:03carries a surprise and Motorola Samsung.
- 2:05:05We help you get on the device. We bring Discovery experiences
- 2:05:09or apps to the consumer and we allow them to go and choose what
- 2:05:14they want to engage with on a new phone.
- 2:05:15Yeah, and then once they have that within specific cops that
- 2:05:19want to remain In free for their consumers.
- 2:05:21So they need to find other ways to monetize.
- 2:05:23Yep. We help them as well.
- 2:05:25So we have our Ester game better in 100,000 apps and they're all
- 2:05:29leveraging Us. In order to go and bring those
- 2:05:30advertising agencies. Again, those Brands to a large
- 2:05:34ecosystem of consumers that have a high propensity to want their
- 2:05:37brand product or service. Yeah.
- 2:05:38And so, in sort of Market places, right?
- 2:05:41Where a brand can come in say, hey, I'm looking for this
- 2:05:43specifically. I'm assuming it will say like
- 2:05:46this is total supposition, right?
- 2:05:47Because you haven't told it this yet, but I'm assuming that
- 2:05:49that's what they're doing. And it's like the apps that have
- 2:05:53the audience, that's their fundamental retarded.
- 2:05:56Right in the, you can figure out reach metrics, how many people
- 2:05:59can I reach within this apple or installs?
- 2:06:01All that sort of stuff. They set it up and then and then
- 2:06:04how are they actually paying for?
- 2:06:05Is it a CPM? So sometimes it's a CPM.
- 2:06:08If the action is very like up a final round.
- 2:06:12Yeah. Sometimes it's a CPI.
- 2:06:14If it's about hey I want it. I have an app.
- 2:06:16I want to get my app installed. Yeah.
- 2:06:17So it is very much dependent on what is the That high agency.
- 2:06:21I think, you know, you, you walk out here impossible, and you can
- 2:06:25say very quickly, like, does anyone have any data to sell and
- 2:06:29everyone? Exactly.
- 2:06:30But they have the audience. Yeah, but what they're missing
- 2:06:34is like one is a consumer over here, and there's a brand over
- 2:06:38there and like there's a lot in the middle.
- 2:06:39Yeah. How do we actually buddies?
- 2:06:41That ultimately why we all exist if they want to have a
- 2:06:44conversation? Yeah.
- 2:06:45And I'm a real believer. I think.
- 2:06:47Historically, there's a concept that adds their attacks on
- 2:06:50people's attention. Yeah, that's an interesting
- 2:06:53point. Yeah.
- 2:06:53And we're like the attention economy right about that.
- 2:06:56Well, I spend my career trying to be the opposite, trying to
- 2:06:59make sure they add a creative to the experience.
- 2:07:03Yeah. And it's kind of like the right
- 2:07:05attention. Yeah, it's sort of elimination
- 2:07:07eliminate distraction. And distraction is a type of
- 2:07:10attention and focus on on, like, like the right type of potential
- 2:07:13because through the noise, right?
- 2:07:16I I have a real belief, you know, when I started at Rows at
- 2:07:21just very, very early stage. And so there was maybe on our
- 2:07:24core product, in some amazing people, but definitely purists
- 2:07:28like no, you cannot Sully this user experience by bringing ads
- 2:07:33and it was such a Negative view out of it.
- 2:07:35And we're seeing that same thing replay with llms, right?
- 2:07:37But it doesn't need to be that way.
- 2:07:40Yeah, we just need to be interrupted necessarily like if
- 2:07:44I will targeted ad that knows who you are knows what you're
- 2:07:48looking for. An example to keep you something
- 2:07:50bigger, you're trying to find it's phenomenal.
- 2:07:52I started my career and paid search, you know?
- 2:07:55There is a reason Google and being a bit because they're add
- 2:08:00business in sem, in paid, search knew exactly what I wanted and
- 2:08:04brought it to me. I wasn't looking for 10 minutes,
- 2:08:07actually, that anyway. And I think what she look like
- 2:08:12that. Yeah.
- 2:08:13That's what, what chat GT or anything.
- 2:08:16I'm going very deep with Claude, right?
- 2:08:17Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:08:19He made like, what I think is really interesting in that drive
- 2:08:24is It's even figured out more. We weren't even looking to a
- 2:08:29certain results. We need to click into a web
- 2:08:31page. We just wanted an answer to our
- 2:08:33question. Yeah.
- 2:08:33And so that was probably with Google was trying to solve the
- 2:08:36very instant world world information, you knowledge,
- 2:08:39right? So it's easy in the easy,
- 2:08:41indexed, and findable, that's what they were solving for
- 2:08:44before they had to find a modernization model, right?
- 2:08:46So, let's just forget and some people argue that that's the
- 2:08:49only thing that Google or organically has succeeded in
- 2:08:52their entire history of organization is the search
- 2:08:55business. Everything else has been through
- 2:08:56acquisition and anything else they have tested?
- 2:08:58It was critical and it was a court.
- 2:09:01It was a core competency that they have, right?
- 2:09:03Well, I I used the example of Google on search specifically a
- 2:09:08lot to say, you know, in the lane 90s there was his little
- 2:09:11company equals Yahoo, which was the dominant such player.
- 2:09:13Yeah. And the thing was how to stop
- 2:09:15the rankings search of web pages when you when you saw in your
- 2:09:19search engine results page, it was specifically based upon the
- 2:09:22amount of traffic each one God. So the website that Had the most
- 2:09:26people that goes a popularity contest that was at the top.
- 2:09:30Google had the exact same as data at the same amount of
- 2:09:32visiting new in new. All the same information as
- 2:09:35Yahoo and they said, we can be better.
- 2:09:37I'm gonna create a quality score.
- 2:09:39Yeah, I'm gonna figure out like indicator to say, this isn't
- 2:09:42just popular, but this is relevant, it's about sure.
- 2:09:45And they can an authority score. How much can this how inequality
- 2:09:49Authority are tied? Because, how much can this site
- 2:09:50this page be trusted. And then there's a whole bunch
- 2:09:53of other stuff like the leak link ecosystem, right?
- 2:09:56That are that are that are defining like how trustworthy
- 2:09:59this say so that just couldn't be duplicated.
- 2:10:01Exactly. Now, and even though, we do see
- 2:10:03a lot of spoofing pictures of that, that was very, that was a
- 2:10:07critical decision. A critical point in time and
- 2:10:09that had them take over the app world.
- 2:10:11And so yeah I think like the the point there and I say it a lot
- 2:10:16to my organization is the goalies of relevancy.
- 2:10:19Yeah. So what drives relevancy?
- 2:10:22That's like Asian that drives and engagement that drives
- 2:10:25great. Yeah.
- 2:10:26Like revenue is a, it's a lagging indicator.
- 2:10:29Yeah. That's like you need to get her
- 2:10:31relevancy. If you're relevant at the right
- 2:10:33in the right time in space, you're going to have an impact
- 2:10:36on somebody's Behavior at some point.
- 2:10:38Exactly. And so coming back, full circle
- 2:10:40it to create relevant outs. In the audience were up, they
- 2:10:45are solving a problem was actually looking for that
- 2:10:48product. Oh, I actually want to go on
- 2:10:50that patient. Like that is so timely in order
- 2:10:53to come and solve that problem. Yes.
- 2:10:55So why is CTV fucked up so bad? That's that's my question and
- 2:11:00just do you agree with this? So what for independent right?
- 2:11:04Yeah, no, but but I mean, like I do feel that I had this hope
- 2:11:07that CTV wasn't going to follow the same path and we didn't even
- 2:11:11talk about this beforehand, but I think it's an interesting
- 2:11:12topic. It's like that it wasn't gonna
- 2:11:14follow the same kind of path that sort of need to default.
- 2:11:17Like you have aligned advertising spots across time
- 2:11:21across channels, you can't escape the advertising, right?
- 2:11:25And I found that, it's almost gotten worse with CTV and
- 2:11:28there's a little less frequency capping, then I see right where
- 2:11:32I'm getting the same Edge over and over again.
- 2:11:33I know they got it. They've got like they don't have
- 2:11:35the I'm like, why can't they feel for sports when you're when
- 2:11:39you're having to log into Amazon Prime or Netflix to watch
- 2:11:42sports? Yeah, you like no longer.
- 2:11:44Can I even flip channels? Like I'm kind of a total cap of
- 2:11:48audience, right? Do you agree with that same?
- 2:11:51Do you think they've got right? It just seems relevant either.
- 2:11:54So a lot of cases, I love friends, I know.
- 2:11:56And I, I love them a lot, but whenever I watch Word.
- 2:11:59I see the same ad every break. Yeah, for two hours.
- 2:12:02Yeah. Like and I'm not gonna loyalist,
- 2:12:04I'm just showing me this and it's like, right all this
- 2:12:07function in and diabetes, you know, something that I don't
- 2:12:10know, but I should be worried or or like, do you have frequency
- 2:12:13being like those? That is the experience where
- 2:12:15people like I got and that's when they be caught.
- 2:12:17There's that by telling you something, it is not relevant to
- 2:12:21me. And I think that the big problem
- 2:12:22there is. I questioned sometimes if it's a
- 2:12:25density of demand problem. Yeah.
- 2:12:26Or if it you know, on linear television it's often more
- 2:12:30efficient and keep it to buy and National spot.
- 2:12:32Yeah, I said living in New York. I would see at Sonic.
- 2:12:36I don't know where Sonic and so I've never seen one side.
- 2:12:39I gotta go to the next to find that, right?
- 2:12:41I didn't realize it's not worth it.
- 2:12:43Yeah, right. Yeah, the view isn't worth the
- 2:12:46hot but with that, it's cheaper for them to buy nationally and
- 2:12:50just hit everyone bother then be specifically.
- 2:12:52Yeah. And I think CTB has taken that
- 2:12:54same approach and and I agree. There's a company that called
- 2:12:58Tilly that I actually need is doing really, really interesting
- 2:13:01things. Yeah.
- 2:13:02So it's a beautifully made. I know this is, this is where
- 2:13:06they build it into exactly television.
- 2:13:08That that's like an operating system.
- 2:13:10It sounds like a television. Exactly.
- 2:13:12Yes, it has a second screen at the bottom like this rectangular
- 2:13:16where it's able to show you the weather any news up.
- 2:13:20Yeah. And and it makes your television
- 2:13:23much more than just a viewing telling that he is, it's much
- 2:13:28more of a multi multi-app multi-functionality system,
- 2:13:31right? And you look at that and you're
- 2:13:33like, I don't know if that is the future, but at least you're
- 2:13:38trying to pick the Paradigm. Yeah.
- 2:13:40Of what city is trying and they give away the first people that
- 2:13:43don't tell it, they give away the TVs for free.
- 2:13:45Yeah, right. My concern and like, I just
- 2:13:48think of it from a consumer perspective for the business
- 2:13:50perspective. So I kind of get what you're
- 2:13:51saying. Yeah.
- 2:13:52Hey, let's change our view and think about TVs, right?
- 2:13:55You don't even think about, I mean, is this really your phone?
- 2:13:58Is this a phone? I mean, I rarely use my iPhone
- 2:14:01as a fundament sometimes, you know that it's usually, you
- 2:14:04know, it's more of a computer that, right?
- 2:14:06And so it's a changing the Paradigm of how people think
- 2:14:09about television as just a device.
- 2:14:12Right. I think that's a I think it was
- 2:14:14free that's supported for people that.
- 2:14:15You know you could certainly hit demographics that couldn't
- 2:14:17afford this big expensive piece of tech.
- 2:14:19Yeah. Right.
- 2:14:19Um, my problem is, are they showing at that?
- 2:14:22I've asked to Telly guys? This they're showing ads and his
- 2:14:25bar that are that's persistent on top of the ads that are
- 2:14:29happening through your streaming content.
- 2:14:31And then you're getting me. Not be aligned.
- 2:14:34To that because they're probably OEM oriented.
- 2:14:37Some, they're coming from a different Source, they're being
- 2:14:39searched here. So I'm getting like, probably
- 2:14:41don't even more. Yeah.
- 2:14:43Right. So, but again, you gotta, let me
- 2:14:46tell you guys, coming on the comments.
- 2:14:47Yeah, exactly. Yeah, exactly.
- 2:14:49Like, like, a be improved the ad experience the relevancy, the ad
- 2:14:53experience, and also the, the ability to kind of actually just
- 2:14:56that information when you get over all different angles
- 2:14:59without advertising. I'm assuming your recall and
- 2:15:03your ability to absorb and compute that information, just
- 2:15:05go to the trouble. I Think Through Time Square.
- 2:15:07Yeah. I just like, you know, you just
- 2:15:09like that doesn't stop people putting on billboards.
- 2:15:11Yeah. And so, I need a great question.
- 2:15:13I don't know what I appreciate. Is people looking to say, what
- 2:15:18do something? Hasn't really?
- 2:15:217080 different way. Yeah, and we beat again, the
- 2:15:26contract, the experience with the consumer to give them
- 2:15:29something that could be of a different type of value.
- 2:15:31Yeah, yeah. And I like the value that I like
- 2:15:33the idea of the quid pro like it's like if I'm not willing to
- 2:15:37maybe secretary that's wrong, we're an expression.
- 2:15:39But if I'm willing to try and pay and up level my like I will
- 2:15:43be either supposed to know ads or a certain number of ads or a
- 2:15:46ton of ads based on my tier, you know, I think that is it gives a
- 2:15:50lot of, it gives an entry point for a lot of different.
- 2:15:53So it's economic types, right? Or people that you have multiple
- 2:15:56apps, you don't want to invest in every single one of them, so
- 2:15:59I think that's good. But the problem is, I think
- 2:16:01that, I think they've actually, it's kind of spin for content,
- 2:16:05right? It's not just one cable
- 2:16:07subscription, right? It's subscription so multiple or
- 2:16:10something, you know, 750. You know, it's it's a similar
- 2:16:15concept. What interesting is like, the
- 2:16:17cable networks bundled together all of these IND And then
- 2:16:21fragmented television network. Yeah.
- 2:16:24And then we're like, we don't like that.
- 2:16:25So, we're gonna go and, and do streaming and go to Netflix and
- 2:16:28cut out chords and whatnot. But now we have 27 different
- 2:16:31streaming services that I do. Now we're getting back to
- 2:16:35rebundling. Yeah.
- 2:16:36Like it's just the keyboard. It's a question and I think this
- 2:16:40would be a good topic then on because it kind of goes back to
- 2:16:42where you are now and how you've set up this sort of SDK in this
- 2:16:46Marketplace for advertisers to go and advertise against apps as
- 2:16:50innocence media channels. And that's audience plays,
- 2:16:52right? And to that easily.
- 2:16:54Um, I'd love to hear like how from a success metrics
- 2:16:57perspective because then I look at this.
- 2:16:59It's really the question is I want to get your perspectives on
- 2:17:02that and I don't think by Coast Rios a great couple of articles
- 2:17:06on Apple because they certainly attracted some attention and
- 2:17:10talk a little bit about circular economics where you know, their
- 2:17:13advertising and games to the game players and they're not
- 2:17:16already apps and games listening, they were their own
- 2:17:20apps and games. And So in your treatment system,
- 2:17:22like you're selling to yourself to kind of boost your economic
- 2:17:26model, now circular economics, whether it's in an open Ai and
- 2:17:29the LMS and programmatic. It's part of economic, it's not
- 2:17:34really fraudulent or corrupt, but, but app loving people
- 2:17:37thought like, hey, is this are they've mastered the art of
- 2:17:40direct response marketing for a specific type of game, or that
- 2:17:44once other games, or once being incentivized to with points, to
- 2:17:48be able to go further on in a game.
- 2:17:50So they're incentivized to purchase and now they're trying
- 2:17:53to hit any of you where they've gone to deep into like, hey, we
- 2:17:57can we can apply this direct response knowledge.
- 2:17:59This ecosystem that we build this ad delivery model to Brands
- 2:18:04and I'm a bit skeptical. That that model will translate
- 2:18:08to on Coca-Cola. Right.
- 2:18:09There's a bunch of boys that can happen, although it's very small
- 2:18:12it's like 5% of global media but now or in-app, right?
- 2:18:16Like is that the best mechanism? Is it going to provide me with
- 2:18:19what you need is a brand advertised?
- 2:18:21Her versus what you're doing. You just so So if you think they
- 2:18:27actually don't go after brand dollars, they're much more
- 2:18:31focused on like the app developer Community.
- 2:18:33Yeah. Where they have moved is
- 2:18:35e-commerce and they believe that the same sort of distribution
- 2:18:38and user acquisition that they've done.
- 2:18:39Or are they just related types? Exactly.
- 2:18:44Yeah. So this I've done it all.
- 2:18:45So it's funny. I would actually say we are the
- 2:18:48Apple, 11 brand. Okay.
- 2:18:49And I'll answer your question like the success metrics are
- 2:18:52exceptional because I think people think of in-app and we're
- 2:18:56not, we're not just games, we have a lot of gaming.
- 2:18:58Yeah, you know it's around a 50/50 split of gaming and
- 2:19:02non-gaming so we have weather apps.
- 2:19:03We have dating apps, we have soccer scores.
- 2:19:06We have you know old every day. You tell the shop soccer, we
- 2:19:13have all like utility every day apps as well as games for Brands
- 2:19:18to show up in and they can be very specific about where they
- 2:19:20want to do. The thing is, I use apps.
- 2:19:23All that is like, there are two fundamental Things that I think
- 2:19:26you should know about this and then I'll speak about to
- 2:19:29integrate. I love them.
- 2:19:30But one About the time. Only 25% of that time.
- 2:19:34I'd awareness is actually in wall Gardens on YouTube.
- 2:19:37The other student by percent are on other apps.
- 2:19:39Yep. 5% of media. Or more goes to that only 25% of
- 2:19:44people, where they're in their time.
- 2:19:45We represent that unwal Garden. That other 75%.
- 2:19:49Yeah. People spending all of those
- 2:19:50other apps that you go through every single day and most people
- 2:19:53are there they're doing, they pick up their phone and they're
- 2:19:56doing at least 20 minutes per session eight times a day into
- 2:19:59all of the apps that run your life.
- 2:20:00Yeah, and some of them are free and add supporters are not.
- 2:20:03We are there to help them monetize.
- 2:20:06And again, bring those brands in the consumers closer together.
- 2:20:08Additionally, from a brand perspective, an agency
- 2:20:11perspective. Open web is Contracting.
- 2:20:14Yeah, each we have a lot of pressure put on on a web.
- 2:20:18Now you really premium within sort of brand awareness or brand
- 2:20:22that's actually is is sort of here to stay.
- 2:20:25But what happens to the mid and long tail?
- 2:20:27And so write these big know, there's a problem now, a
- 2:20:31solution. Be okay.
- 2:20:32I'll just put more of my budget into the wall Gardens into
- 2:20:36social and that's a path. Yeah.
- 2:20:39Or and I think what the point of a conference like possible is is
- 2:20:43to say there are actually other meteor Avenue.
- 2:20:46Yeah. This is not all programmatic
- 2:20:47media, it's not all display advertising and it's not all
- 2:20:50only like Google or meta or Amazon.
- 2:20:53Like, we are that very Bible Channel.
- 2:20:57And so for us specifically, when you think about, when you think
- 2:21:00about it, you know, drinking like what apps that's for sure.
- 2:21:04Just for your own kitchen, and consumer.
- 2:21:06Exactly. And, and, but even from like,
- 2:21:08again, as I said earlier, like 8 + 150 to the app.
- 2:21:12So they're more apps is more proliferation apps because many
- 2:21:16more time in these apps. Yeah, and so fast like, that's
- 2:21:19where a brand should be. Yeah, that's where you need to
- 2:21:22find. It seems like an unboxed
- 2:21:24underutilized in. Where is that the media by
- 2:21:26process Foreigner age and agency?
- 2:21:28Do they clear space for this? You know, he That updates.
- 2:21:32The biggest blocker. Exactly.
- 2:21:33And that is the same thing but he's very kind of hard hard to
- 2:21:39find categories of like linear digital TV.
- 2:21:41You know, like if you know search social you know, but it's
- 2:21:43like where does this stuff fit in?
- 2:21:45So as I was saying earlier, like when I was in search in like
- 2:21:482000 and now that we make a bet on integrating with Facebook at
- 2:21:54the time and I remember going to the search and it's like, I
- 2:21:57don't have a social budget that doesn't exist.
- 2:21:58I don't believe in these fans and followers things going away.
- 2:22:02Yeah. Then a few years later, I was at
- 2:22:04Pinterest and I went, hey, this is like discovery of brand.
- 2:22:07It says, like I don't have a discovery budget.
- 2:22:09I'm only gonna buy Facebook. Yeah, a few years ago, you said
- 2:22:12Facebook was a note box and so what me and my team does is
- 2:22:17really helped agents season. Yeah, the simile, like, in app
- 2:22:21is not a scary type of music where people spend 75% of their
- 2:22:25time, on their phones, it is where a brand should be and
- 2:22:28needs to be. It is completely verified.
- 2:22:30All It is completely addressable.
- 2:22:32Yeah limited fraud like we are the platform digital turbine or
- 2:22:37DT is the mechanism that allows people when the open web
- 2:22:41shrinking when they don't want to be yeah, more into just
- 2:22:43competing with everyone else. On this part with Brands can go
- 2:22:47and connected. So you talked about Coca-Cola
- 2:22:48and they I'll share with you. We have an amazing set of
- 2:22:52activations. With Coca-Cola was Sprite with
- 2:22:54vitamin water, all under the coke umbrella, who are finding
- 2:22:58Their audience, who want to engage their people in our
- 2:23:02ecosystem. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:23:03And then you can make adjacencies.
- 2:23:05You could be confident, Jason seeds.
- 2:23:06You can. Yeah.
- 2:23:07You can just use audiences. All, it's all sort of you can
- 2:23:10break down just to me what marketing is.
- 2:23:13So one of the formats that we have a playable games and so
- 2:23:16Coca-Cola together with us, it's literally game where you're
- 2:23:20stacking Coke cans and the second you get it above a
- 2:23:24certain line. You win the game.
- 2:23:25Yeah, to me, that is what marketing is.
- 2:23:28It's fun. It's whimsical to get into a
- 2:23:30KitchenAid. It has a lot.
- 2:23:31Asking impression, surprise, and Delight that.
- 2:23:33Yeah, and it increases intent to buy.
- 2:23:35So we run brand lift studies, or we have our own.
- 2:23:38We use third parties. We work with Nelson.
- 2:23:39We have all of this and the results that lasting our
- 2:23:42ecosystem. Our supply, our inventory.
- 2:23:46When they are working with us, it's economically across brand
- 2:23:49recall brand awareness, brand affinity and intent to buy.
- 2:23:53You know, why all here that actually helped create that
- 2:23:56moment of conversion. Yeah, into the relevant.
- 2:23:58Way, that's not interrupted. And well, this is this has been
- 2:24:01an awesome conversation. It's been great getting to know.
- 2:24:02Yeah. It's a half hour, 45 minutes,
- 2:24:04someone and in it's it's just it's eye-opening and interesting
- 2:24:08and there's just a lot of really good sharing possible to finding
- 2:24:11a lot of really smart people. So that's been a pleasure,
- 2:24:12thanks for joining us and I think we got you on the full
- 2:24:15pot, right? I would love, I think we could
- 2:24:17do like a full show. I don't have like power session.
- 2:24:18I'm totally man. Hey, thanks for joining us, and
- 2:24:20we'll talk to you guys soon. Awesome.
- 2:24:22Thank you possible. 2026 is a signal and noise podcast, and we
- 2:24:28are close to the end of the event.
- 2:24:31We've got to 322. So we've got no technically,
- 2:24:34it's an over. We're like yeah, people here.
- 2:24:36But, you know, people still Milling about so good.
- 2:24:38Special guests here. Laura Foster SVP marketing.
- 2:24:41I come. Yeah, thank you so much.
- 2:24:44Happy to be here and make it. Yeah, it could help us close out
- 2:24:46the show. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:24:47Hopefully it's a banger. A little tpd.
- 2:24:50I'm not. Well, tell us about yourself.
- 2:24:54Yeah. Where do I start?
- 2:24:55Where do you start? I will probably talk about gum
- 2:24:57gum for a moment, right? Because I'll give that a little
- 2:25:00bit of a plug, right? And I get to work for a company
- 2:25:04and use technology and be a human being at the same time and
- 2:25:10that makes me so grateful, every single day, when I wake up, and
- 2:25:14I get to be a human being and whatever context that means, Gum
- 2:25:19gum started with contextual advertising.
- 2:25:22It was kind of our fundamental belief from the beginning that
- 2:25:25what you're reading or watching is likely in the most important
- 2:25:29signal to determine whether or not it's time for an act, right?
- 2:25:33But when you think about the way you brief someone, or when you
- 2:25:38think about the targeting parameters, it always starts
- 2:25:41with Asian gender. And I think that's right because
- 2:25:44you need, I always like, I like to say that you need a box for a
- 2:25:48brief because then you know how to break out of it as part of
- 2:25:50identity. Right, exactly.
- 2:25:51Exactly, you need to understand those things but Asian, gender
- 2:25:55and 2026. Not as easy as it was in the
- 2:25:581950s. That's true.
- 2:26:00And I'm a new mom. I had a little thank you.
- 2:26:04Six months ago. And there are moments in which
- 2:26:08it's the right time to serve me a diaper.
- 2:26:11Add and there are many moments in which it is not.
- 2:26:14So we don't want to think about everything also.
- 2:26:16I think about neighbors once every hour, no matter what.
- 2:26:20But do I fall in the age and gender and demo, and probably
- 2:26:24diaper and tender category from the third party segment?
- 2:26:28Yes, absolutely. But the most important part is
- 2:26:31the moment. Of receptivity.
- 2:26:35And finding that is difficult, and we're contextual signals
- 2:26:40coming. That's where the contextual
- 2:26:41comes in, but that's still the base.
- 2:26:43So gum gum, founded on that grew up in that believes in that
- 2:26:48stealth, an entire business on that the reality is context.
- 2:26:51What I'm watching or reading only goes so far.
- 2:26:55There's all. So, have I previously engaged
- 2:26:57with the brand? There's all.
- 2:26:59So, am I in the right mindset to actually be opened that add to
- 2:27:05view it to watch it? There are great moments in
- 2:27:08which, to serve me spots. Can I have more of those?
- 2:27:10I don't get them that often, though.
- 2:27:13And there are a lot of times when it might be, actually the
- 2:27:17perfect time to serve me an ad for diapers.
- 2:27:20But how do you tell us an Advertiser?
- 2:27:22It's not what I'm reading about. Diapers.
- 2:27:24Which I think is what everybody thinks when they hear.
- 2:27:26Contextual advertising, they think, oh, she's researching
- 2:27:30best parenting tips. This is a great time to serve
- 2:27:32her diaper advertising. Know, it's already in my cart.
- 2:27:35I'm just waiting for that other product, add to my cart and then
- 2:27:39it'll make sense to check out so that I don't have Amazon back.
- 2:27:42Should be the worst time. Just to serve you up that ad,
- 2:27:44right? You completely waste of
- 2:27:46impression and that is the biggest thing.
- 2:27:48Like, We still in this industry want to find these perfect
- 2:27:54little contracts of age and gender and context and I think
- 2:27:58is easy because there's buckets of money there. but the reality
- 2:28:01is, is we're all human beings at the end of the day and my mood,
- 2:28:05my moment, what I want to do shifts every every micro
- 2:28:10millisecond can sexual signals me.
- 2:28:13I agree. It's like funny to remember
- 2:28:16there was a big push when cookie started going away as big push
- 2:28:18for contextual she's just kind of fell off right?
- 2:28:21Yeah yeah and I you know I think it was framed around oh you
- 2:28:26don't want to Target people anymore identities you know
- 2:28:28sacred and come in. A lot of money in that I was
- 2:28:33really good business for a couple of years.
- 2:28:37I've spent too long in ad Tech and not been on both ends of
- 2:28:41that cookie conversation. Will they won't, they will, they
- 2:28:44won't, they written thousands? Yeah, you Google right?
- 2:28:46Yeah, thousands of povs that have wrecked, whatever.
- 2:28:49I was working on that day, they just did so many battles about
- 2:28:52it. It's so far at the end of the
- 2:28:55day, it actually really didn't freaking matter because everyone
- 2:28:57forgot that 50% of the internet. At least in the states uses
- 2:29:00Safari and uses the iPhone, I think 70% up to 70% of traffic.
- 2:29:05When you factoring in Mobile people, instead, Safari plus
- 2:29:07people who have you don't have cookies or, you know, don't
- 2:29:10accept them just run up to 70% of traffic does not have them.
- 2:29:13Anyway, exactly. So we hyper obsessed on
- 2:29:15something and and rightly used it as a way to suck, contextual
- 2:29:19and then it fell off. The reality is, is It's
- 2:29:22additive, it's not, or it's an and it's sure my Asian gender,
- 2:29:28great, sure, the geolocation of where your product is available.
- 2:29:32Of course, maybe those are hard for parameters are hard rules
- 2:29:36but then it's the moment. It's what I'm reading, what I'm
- 2:29:40watching, where I'm at my day, the time of day, the weather,
- 2:29:44all of these things are all so signals that come through on the
- 2:29:47add call, most of the time we ignore him but they have the
- 2:29:51largest impacts on what I'm going to do.
- 2:29:54The way dsps work, they prioritize IDs, right?
- 2:29:57And you know, I get why they do that but like there's a lot of
- 2:30:02signal there, that's just being missed that.
- 2:30:04Yeah, coming from Supply is incredibly valuable, right?
- 2:30:08Yeah. Yeah, there's that if you really
- 2:30:10think about it, it's probably thousands of signals that come
- 2:30:13through on the impression call because you can tie it to an IP
- 2:30:15address which means you can tie it to a Geo, which means you can
- 2:30:17tie it to census data. Which means you can and in, and
- 2:30:20if a human being, which is usually on the other end, at
- 2:30:24least, so far of most of these buys has to think about it.
- 2:30:28They think about it as layers. So they think Laura Foster in
- 2:30:34Los Angeles, new mother. Let's find more hers and then
- 2:30:39they add those targeting layers. And at some point you've
- 2:30:43narrowed and narrowed and narrowed, you're paying a
- 2:30:45thousand dollars to find the Laura look alike.
- 2:30:48And at the end of the day, Laura looked like might be the exact
- 2:30:52person you need to hit but if you're hitting them in the wrong
- 2:30:54moment, doesn't matter. It's completely wasted.
- 2:30:56So there's ways to let technology do.
- 2:31:00What technology does best take a look at all of these signals
- 2:31:03model, all of them, the likelihood of them to matter in
- 2:31:07real time and then use that as logic to bid or not.
- 2:31:10And it's not just contextual. That's what's really cool about
- 2:31:13it. It's, you know, there's clear
- 2:31:15ones like oh if it's hot and sunny, maybe my makeup is
- 2:31:19melting off and maybe it's a great time to remind me that
- 2:31:21Sephora is having a sale, right? There's also ones that are maybe
- 2:31:25less. Apparent immediately on its
- 2:31:29face. And if we really nerd out and go
- 2:31:32deep into it, Vector modeling and Game Theory, Etc, and
- 2:31:36predicted likelihood of an outcome.
- 2:31:37I think people love to know and I think a lot of our audience is
- 2:31:41I don't want to say they're probably like I am also not
- 2:31:47embarrassed to say I'm a weirdo. It's fine.
- 2:31:49That's how you survive in this business.
- 2:31:51Correct. Survive?
- 2:31:53Any length of time? Let's just totally my
- 2:31:56six-month-old. I'm praying for her to be weird.
- 2:31:59It's funny just like this. This podcast my daughter's 12,
- 2:32:02I'm like, I'm I've tried to get to listen to it.
- 2:32:06Yeah. I mean, I get like I showed this
- 2:32:07to like my hairdresser like found out.
- 2:32:10I do a podcast, dude. I want to listen, I gave it to
- 2:32:13in the next time I saw me said, you know, I didn't understand
- 2:32:15anything He said I just I'm not gonna listen your podcast
- 2:32:19anymore so I get it. It's for people like you are in
- 2:32:21this industry like to know that on like big stream and stuff
- 2:32:24like that. So I think there's stuff for
- 2:32:26everyone. Yeah.
- 2:32:27But yeah I mean go go nerds. So looking back at this.
- 2:32:31I mean there's there's this debate over the last couple
- 2:32:34years about resellers versus not being resellers like the SSP
- 2:32:40space. Love your comments on that.
- 2:32:41Yeah, the first thing that popped in my head is like I
- 2:32:43don't care. Because that's us speak, that's
- 2:32:47not human beings speak. And when I go back to like, when
- 2:32:50I started my career and AOL and Yahoo and MSN were all
- 2:32:57separated. So I'm gonna meet with them.
- 2:33:00Still love them. Right.
- 2:33:01But they make it a comeback which is pretty.
- 2:33:03It was all about. Hi.
- 2:33:04It was all about the audience specifically that they could
- 2:33:08acquire. That no one else could acquire.
- 2:33:10And the reality is is I was checking AOL and Yahoo and MSN
- 2:33:14every single day and it's the same debate in streaming now
- 2:33:18with the premiums out there like oh our audience is so nice.
- 2:33:22Our data is so Niche, blah blah blah.
- 2:33:24No it's not I'm gonna watch Netflix and then I'm going to
- 2:33:27switch to Hulu because you have another show that I like right
- 2:33:30and maybe I'm gonna light up a subscription one day and then
- 2:33:34cancel the next day cuz I got all of the content I want out of
- 2:33:37it. So resellers is not resellers, I
- 2:33:41think, you know, transparency of fees but you need to remember
- 2:33:44that you're trying to talk to a human being on the other end and
- 2:33:48where is less important than when and why.
- 2:33:51And how? That's a good point.
- 2:33:54I think there are Some ssps that you could definitely say are
- 2:33:59back. Mostly is resellers, right?
- 2:34:01And I don't think they're adding tons of value.
- 2:34:02Yeah, what I've seen, and I've seen I've seen, but, you know,
- 2:34:04but clearly like an SSP, like the fact they're sitting closest
- 2:34:08to supply. I mean now I was having dinner
- 2:34:11with with her. She's been a client of mine and
- 2:34:13partner mine for many years and like they they love their
- 2:34:16relationship with ssps right and like it's so they acknowledge
- 2:34:19how critical it is to have these Partners who can help you bring
- 2:34:22to Market. So I think everyone's trying to
- 2:34:24figure out like What is the right balance?
- 2:34:26And where maybe can you edge some of those steps out?
- 2:34:29Because every single Tech layer you add of course, there's
- 2:34:32there's fees, right? And then there's data pass and,
- 2:34:34you know, don't even get me into like the state is sustainability
- 2:34:37of all those passes. But at the end of the day, you
- 2:34:40need to work with partners that drive your outcomes and that
- 2:34:43should be the most important thing.
- 2:34:44It's also branding to understand too.
- 2:34:47Like if you're if that's a publisher like like it's not
- 2:34:49about you know having bazillion as many relationships as
- 2:34:52possible, right? And ultimately if you're at
- 2:34:55you're connected to these as peas and you know in I've got
- 2:34:58everyone with header bidding, like at some point, it does slow
- 2:35:01down. Page load, add loaded, you know
- 2:35:05that user experience is got to be part of that, right?
- 2:35:07So I think finding a right Partners in Supply size has to
- 2:35:10be about the human on the other end and even has here all
- 2:35:15investing. So heavily and figuring out the
- 2:35:18role that it should play. And all of our Lives, both at
- 2:35:21home and at work, It comes back to If it creates a human
- 2:35:25connection. Good.
- 2:35:27If it doesn't bad and it's just that simple.
- 2:35:30But I think we forget when we, you know, when we nerd out what
- 2:35:34are some, what are some things you're working on right now?
- 2:35:36I think there's actually a lot of really cool Innovation on
- 2:35:39this on the supply side of things.
- 2:35:40And I think they just pendulum kind of swings, right?
- 2:35:43I think. For wild dsps were I think
- 2:35:46making some interesting with and they still are but yeah like
- 2:35:49right, I think like working with people on the supply side like
- 2:35:53chalice was in here yesterday for yeah.
- 2:35:55Only with Adam about stuff. They're doing.
- 2:35:57There's just I think As some capabilities and functionality
- 2:36:01migrates. Let's say from Demand and just
- 2:36:05apply. So, open up some really
- 2:36:06interesting opportunities and, and some cool, Innovation, on
- 2:36:09supplies side of love to hear what you're like.
- 2:36:11If you're able to start making a road map.
- 2:36:13Yeah, I think we're actually gonna do a whole webinar.
- 2:36:15I'm a big believer in transparency because
- 2:36:18transparency is how you get feedback and feedback is how you
- 2:36:21get a good map. So one of the biggest things I'm
- 2:36:24super interested in is how do we connect signals and how do we
- 2:36:30give our supply Partners a data Edge because they are all again?
- 2:36:36Selling the same audience. And the differentiator then
- 2:36:39comes the data, how do we give them insights about Their
- 2:36:42audience? That maybe they didn't know that
- 2:36:44they can then put into their materials, their decks Etc?
- 2:36:48And then how do those things change?
- 2:36:50You know, one of the things with mindset and huge on our roads
- 2:36:55app is something we're calling snapshots.
- 2:36:56It's it's basically a summary of every signal and the level of an
- 2:37:00importance that that signal has on every bit.
- 2:37:03And every impression and every single snapshot is directly tied
- 2:37:08one to one to an impression but not directly tied one to one
- 2:37:11person necessarily. So my Snapshot at 7 in the
- 2:37:14morning is going to look totally different from my Snapchat right
- 2:37:17now because I'm going to different mindset and a
- 2:37:20different mode but you know there's really cool insights for
- 2:37:22Publishers in that too. Like If you think about
- 2:37:25streaming specifically and you think about something like pod
- 2:37:28position, well, everyone's like oh I want to be first, it's like
- 2:37:31well, first is right after the content ended so as a human
- 2:37:35being, I know. That's the moment I can run in
- 2:37:37the bathroom, right. Maybe the first is not, so,
- 2:37:39maybe first is not the best, right?
- 2:37:41There's other things to like time of day and how that
- 2:37:45influences and that's like pod position, but in your life, we
- 2:37:50think about prime time but prime time is not the same as it used
- 2:37:55to be because now I record it or I stream it and I can watch it
- 2:37:58whenever I want to watch a good point.
- 2:37:59They look at like linear like gay parts or such a big part of.
- 2:38:02Yeah, you're planning and buying but you're right.
- 2:38:04I think we see TV. I'm not saying it has no role
- 2:38:07but like it's clearly people can stream anytime and you look at a
- 2:38:10ctd. Stats is, a lot of people too.
- 2:38:13Watch late at night. Oh yes.
- 2:38:16A surprise number I was upstairs yesterday.
- 2:38:19Listening to a panel that ad we putting on your buying CTV, but
- 2:38:23are you buying it, right? Right, rebank CTV at all right?
- 2:38:27Well yeah, hopefully everybody is.
- 2:38:29I don't know. Maybe not.
- 2:38:30That's how you define CTV. That's that's the whole other.
- 2:38:34But we don't need to go there because the Nerds are they know
- 2:38:36that? That would be a whole nerds, you
- 2:38:38know. We'll do it.
- 2:38:38We'll do another episode on that.
- 2:38:39We had to be a doctor fuel in a couple weeks ago.
- 2:38:42Whoa, yeah. And we were pretty deep on that
- 2:38:44but keep going, okay, so, yesterday upstairs, they were
- 2:38:47talking about how a lot of money is set with YouTube like 40
- 2:38:52billion dollars. Like the most streaming money is
- 2:38:55spent, oh YouTube is TV, right? But a lot of those are at 2 a.m.
- 2:39:01So what is the value of its 2 a.m. cat video versus a 4 p.m.
- 2:39:07I'm going to say Spa again because I'm ready to leave the
- 2:39:10conference and go to a spa really, I'm feeling the spot
- 2:39:14today. But you know if 4 p.m. there's a
- 2:39:16different value there and is that something that Can help
- 2:39:21others juice. Bye. actually have A couple
- 2:39:29cigars. I'm gonna have skunk and a
- 2:39:31bourbon in about an hour but in Miami so I have it is right
- 2:39:39manager. Yeah but I guess the back to
- 2:39:44this so A lot of changes these days with AI, right?
- 2:39:48I mean it's, you know, we do have to talk a fashion.
- 2:39:50I think a little bit like not so fortunately, because at this
- 2:39:53point if you aren't using it, I'm Confused by you?
- 2:39:58How whoa, what is that like um It's like living life in analog.
- 2:40:05Say anything to call an AI space.
- 2:40:06You're working on. I mean, I know you can probably
- 2:40:08just with your product roadmap and love the whole thing at the
- 2:40:11eye. So I'm gonna completely powered
- 2:40:13and has been since the beginning by using AI to identify things
- 2:40:18within images. That's actually where we started
- 2:40:20and understand the context that images.
- 2:40:23Yes to figure like he's able to that.
- 2:40:25Yeah, it's frame by frame to understand all the right moment
- 2:40:28and then we also have technology where you can actually sort of
- 2:40:31insert and add on top of the context as it's live or the
- 2:40:35content as it's live as well that we have some Supply
- 2:40:38Partners running with us and some advertisers.
- 2:40:40It's almost that product placement taking like, yeah,
- 2:40:42exactly. I I compare it definitely
- 2:40:45wrongly. So, but to pop up video, back in
- 2:40:49the MTV days when you would watch the music video and you
- 2:40:51get the facts popping up over it, but obviously there's major
- 2:40:56applications especially in sports and sports tonight.
- 2:40:59Like we actually worked together 25 years ago that company that
- 2:41:04was trying to just funny. You mentioned a pop-up box.
- 2:41:06It was called pop-up Technologies.
- 2:41:09And really an agency that its own technology was trying to.
- 2:41:11It never worked, by the way, it was like a pop-up box, it would
- 2:41:15pop up and then you could complete the transaction box
- 2:41:17attack. I mean, it can work, it works
- 2:41:20now like to do that. Now like there's no payment
- 2:41:22system back that just didn't work.
- 2:41:24Yeah. Yeah, but it was, it was the QR
- 2:41:27code was idea before its time. So exactly exactly.
- 2:41:30It came back around. But you know, if we're talking
- 2:41:32about contextual that's the base, but then every other
- 2:41:34signal. Okay, well first of all, you
- 2:41:36need to capture them which means you some pretty powerful
- 2:41:39technology. Then you need to look at all of
- 2:41:41them and not just individually but in combinations and compare
- 2:41:46the likelihood of each one of those in influences.
- 2:41:49No human being can do that that and to do that all.
- 2:41:53So, in two milliseconds, yes to do that as quickly, you would
- 2:41:56need like months and even then it would be wrong because the
- 2:41:59moment changed, right? So, it's all bills on on AI.
- 2:42:05That's that's the only way it can work and it feels like, I
- 2:42:09was saying this with my marketing team, like it feels
- 2:42:12like we planned it, and the tech finally caught up to what we
- 2:42:15originally wanted which was context, is so much broader than
- 2:42:19what you're reading and watching is the context of your
- 2:42:21environment. It's the context of your
- 2:42:22relationships, the context of your past experience with the
- 2:42:26brand, and all of those things matter.
- 2:42:28And my hope is that as an industry, we stop thinking of
- 2:42:32contextual as keywords because it's not and it hasn't been and
- 2:42:36we start thinking about contextual more as how we treat
- 2:42:38the word context in people's everyday lives.
- 2:42:42I love that. I think there's a lot of
- 2:42:43misconception or let's say simplification and actual what
- 2:42:46it is. Obviously, that's part of it,
- 2:42:48right? And that's why we had to choose
- 2:42:49a new word. Like we had to choose the word
- 2:42:51mindset because we're not just looking at keywords.
- 2:42:54We haven't been for over 10 years, maybe in the past, we had
- 2:42:58to yes. Oh yeah.
- 2:42:59That's all we had. But now we have is now we have
- 2:43:01more and now we have a very powerful brain in AI that can
- 2:43:05look at it and understand all of it and predict the likelihood
- 2:43:08that it's gonna convert or make someone remember you, which, you
- 2:43:12know, is also good. It doesn't always have to just
- 2:43:15drive a sale. Very cool.
- 2:43:17So is this. You fly home later today.
- 2:43:19I am going to enjoy a dinner, just with my marketing team
- 2:43:25tonight. All right.
- 2:43:25Yeah, and not know. We're gonna talk about work.
- 2:43:28We probably are but it'll be with a cocktail and so then fly
- 2:43:32home tomorrow, it's funny. I think last year, I had my
- 2:43:36favorite night of possible was actually the last night.
- 2:43:38So when it yeah we had a little CMO dinner at a couple, you
- 2:43:42know, old friends. And then the organizer was, you
- 2:43:44know, it was great and it was so good. we didn't really talk
- 2:43:48about work for him, he was just more good to see you.
- 2:43:51And it was so chill and like, you know, the weather was
- 2:43:54perfect. So I hope you, I hope you have
- 2:43:56the same experience low pressure.
- 2:43:57Everybody just hang out. I mean, yeah.
- 2:44:00So this is now like, I think number 38 of one of these.
- 2:44:03I'm definitely a little over getting his best.
- 2:44:06Yeah, well, I have a lot of practice, right?
- 2:44:08That's true. That is.
- 2:44:09So, this is been a really cool conversation.
- 2:44:11Yeah, appreciate you. You putting up with our schedule
- 2:44:15and no, not and maybe location changing, but it was a great
- 2:44:20conversation. Good to get to know that was up
- 2:44:21in the penthouse. They brought me down at the
- 2:44:22basement. Yeah.
- 2:44:23Well Facebook, but we have coffee here.
- 2:44:25It's true and a dog and a dog. That's pretty awesome.
- 2:44:28It's awesome. It was great to see you.
- 2:44:30Yeah. Thank you so much, safe travels
- 2:44:33home and you can touch cheers. Signal and noise D3, nearly our
- 2:44:39last interview and I still have energy.
- 2:44:41Thankfully, even though I've been eaten all day of high,
- 2:44:45symmetrics the CEO and co-founder of the Pod about
- 2:44:49measurement. Hyper metrics, is really deeply
- 2:44:51involved in sort of kind of next-generation household and
- 2:44:55person specific measurement within households across
- 2:44:58channels and and I really loved how we started talking about in
- 2:45:02Seattle, you're out of Seattle. But you're not a Seattle native.
- 2:45:04Now, former New Yorker former New Yorker, consider myself in
- 2:45:08New Yorker for life that great. Are you like in your like New
- 2:45:10York City? One of the race?
- 2:45:12I lived in Brooklyn, but I just loved living and working.
- 2:45:16There was, yeah, yeah. And you were born in raised
- 2:45:18know. I'm from DC.
- 2:45:20Oh, you see? Okay, yeah.
- 2:45:21But enough of me enough of time in New York over a decade.
- 2:45:24So yeah, that's loud. Yeah.
- 2:45:25And I think there's some there's some and so have you had some
- 2:45:28culture shock moving to Seattle? I mean like or is it something
- 2:45:31that you just adopted and embraced?
- 2:45:32And didn't like I mean cultural I think it's super interesting,
- 2:45:34I was always into the The music, the whole underground music,
- 2:45:37scene of Seattle was like, kind of what I grew up with.
- 2:45:40Yeah, I won't say grunge but it was like a lot of that like,
- 2:45:43really deep stuff and that music scene.
- 2:45:45Yeah, yeah, I mean, I think Seattle culturally is very
- 2:45:49interesting. The summers are fantastic.
- 2:45:51Yeah, so the outdoors are just absolutely stunning.
- 2:45:54I think it could use a little, a little more like Pizzazz here.
- 2:45:59A little like the raw like in your face Street culture of New
- 2:46:04York City. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:46:05Just like a busy restaurant and everyone's like laughing.
- 2:46:08Yeah being laughing. Why it's on the quieter side?
- 2:46:12Yeah you know there's a lot of pluses with that.
- 2:46:14Yeah yeah I was talking about the same way earlier Parts I
- 2:46:17call I talked about New York is sort of like for statistically
- 2:46:22challenged by your environment and I actually comes down.
- 2:46:25There's a lot of that street culture, which is sometimes in
- 2:46:28restaurants or in places, but it's also out on the streets and
- 2:46:31not every city has that. But anyway, yeah.
- 2:46:32That's that's the that's a little bit about us New Yorker,
- 2:46:35love. Like I'm not a New Yorker by
- 2:46:37heart. I'm the Boston region, but but
- 2:46:39I've been there for 26 years so I guess I am and yeah, by heart.
- 2:46:43I technically consider myself that even though I live in New
- 2:46:45Jersey, I read in New York Magazine ones that you have to
- 2:46:47live in New York for 11 years before you can say you're in New
- 2:46:50York. Yes, we're good.
- 2:46:53Yeah, so so high for metrics to me.
- 2:46:55You do is you're doing some really interesting stuff and and
- 2:46:57I was asking you a ton of questions at a time in terms of
- 2:46:59how you are really kind of challenging, we won't call
- 2:47:02current call current currency. Yeah.
- 2:47:03Um, but how your challenging sort of like personal level
- 2:47:07household measurement models, which are currently or in the
- 2:47:11past have been really controlled and Particularly monopolized by
- 2:47:15companies like Nielsen. And I was at Nielsen for a few
- 2:47:18years, I was not on the TV measurement side.
- 2:47:19It was more on the ad Tech martech side but tell me some of
- 2:47:22the just just so the audience knows who high for metrics is
- 2:47:25because I think you're doing some great Innovative stuff and
- 2:47:27this was 10 minutes of talking to him.
- 2:47:28Like, this is really interesting, let's get into it.
- 2:47:30So, tell the audience a little bit of what you guys are doing
- 2:47:33at the household level, that allows you to sort of take
- 2:47:36panels. Yeah.
- 2:47:37And the traditional sense to kind of another level of
- 2:47:40fidelity. And yeah, so first and foremost,
- 2:47:43we're a technology company. Yeah.
- 2:47:45So we one of our Central tenants in chords is that we'll never
- 2:47:48build a tech that already exists because we believe that's adding
- 2:47:51more to the problem that are existing accumulated over dates
- 2:47:55at the point. Another way that we position
- 2:47:58ourselves is that we say we are not ACR and we measure
- 2:48:01everything that ACR measures and everything.
- 2:48:03It does not. Yeah.
- 2:48:04And there's a little factor that you get a share that you even
- 2:48:07though you don't use a CCR. You've been accused by the Big
- 2:48:12Brother, the the Nielsen you've been sued, a handful of times
- 2:48:15and you've won in every case because you're using a
- 2:48:17fundamentally different technology.
- 2:48:18Absolutely different. When the first things we did,
- 2:48:20when we started the company was file, our patents.
- 2:48:23We have a very large and robust patent portfolio.
- 2:48:25All of our Technologies, proprietary and we wouldn't, we
- 2:48:29wouldn't have started the company if it wasn't for that.
- 2:48:30So, I myself have built an audio Acer panel in the past, prior to
- 2:48:34starting high five, so and my co-founder did as well.
- 2:48:37So, we're very familiar with the ins and outs of how ACR works,
- 2:48:40and we truly this company because we wanted to build
- 2:48:43something that measured everything ACR.
- 2:48:45Does everything and he started for this automated content
- 2:48:48recognition, and audio and audio.
- 2:48:52Yeah, yeah. And it's at the, the device
- 2:48:55level, like, the television, it can be.
- 2:48:57Yeah, in the case of CTV, it's embedded in the TV, in the case
- 2:49:01of panels, it usually sits next to a TV on a tablet and
- 2:49:04continuously listening. Yeah, thank Shazam for content
- 2:49:07and advertise. Oh, she's there we go.
- 2:49:08She's Used to them as a Shameless is here doing them all
- 2:49:13the time in places, right? And for people that don't know
- 2:49:15how the Nielsen panel. Take that traditionally worked
- 2:49:17not to spend too much time on that.
- 2:49:18But because we're gonna talk about the puck.
- 2:49:20I like these are your words right there panel?
- 2:49:22Yeah. Mine is.
- 2:49:23No, you literally come into the house and you've got like a
- 2:49:25controller and you select traditionally, you would select
- 2:49:28you'd be recruited to become part of the panel.
- 2:49:30Like, there was a Simpsons episode.
- 2:49:32Yeah, on the books and you push the button identify who you are
- 2:49:35person a person, B person C and then then they would track
- 2:49:38what's happening with Watermark technology?
- 2:49:41What's happening on the television screen, etc, etc for
- 2:49:44and for basically, reach and frequency assessment in
- 2:49:48analysis, so that they could then bring that back to the
- 2:49:50advertisers, to say, you're trading against this free reach
- 2:49:54and frequency, right at a very basic level, it's agent
- 2:49:56demographics, right? What do you guys doing?
- 2:49:58That's the, that was pretty good.
- 2:50:00I haven't done that. Like a panel live before so
- 2:50:05riffing here. No.
- 2:50:06But how do you guys doing? It's different in Intel, Look at
- 2:50:10puc so that this is pretty interesting.
- 2:50:11Well, first and foremost, our technology is completely
- 2:50:14different so we have a proprietary blend of computer
- 2:50:16vision machine learning and AI. We started her model seven years
- 2:50:20ago. So it's deep Tech.
- 2:50:22We're not, you know, using AI the way it's used today
- 2:50:26necessarily and we the households are fully consented.
- 2:50:29It's a panel. Yeah.
- 2:50:30But the technology is what allows us to measure absolutely
- 2:50:33everything. Yeah, so we send the households.
- 2:50:35A piece of Hardware that Hardware is installed with
- 2:50:37everything within. Yeah.
- 2:50:39Yeah. So we measure every physical
- 2:50:41like just shape of you. It looks like an Apple TV.
- 2:50:44Yeah. And you HDMI.
- 2:50:46Yeah, yeah. And that proprietary blend of
- 2:50:49our technology essentially is acting like a media brain.
- 2:50:53It's looking for very specific information throughout the
- 2:50:56stream and dependent on. Whether you're streaming
- 2:50:59something. Playing a video game watching a
- 2:51:02fast Channel, using your set top box, there's a different set of
- 2:51:05rules within the algorithm that kicks in to decide for all of
- 2:51:08that information. Yes, because the signals
- 2:51:11probably solely different based on whether you're an app
- 2:51:13environment, whether it's cable television environment or PS4 or
- 2:51:16PS5. Whatever.
- 2:51:17Exactly. Yeah.
- 2:51:18So each one of those that within an algorithm in order to address
- 2:51:22exactly how to measure content and advertising correctly,
- 2:51:24including brand sponsorships and product placements and did you
- 2:51:28and your co-founder are you the data science algorithmic.
- 2:51:32Screws behind this. Did you build this?
- 2:51:34We are. Yeah, that's the engineer, the
- 2:51:37relationship. I'm the product Corp Dev person
- 2:51:39in the relationship. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:51:40So he's came to, this is the math, guys see this?
- 2:51:44Yeah, he came to me and he was like, you know, Joanna?
- 2:51:46What if like, we didn't use ACR in our industry and and started
- 2:51:50using something else and his background includes building the
- 2:51:53currency and in Mexico. So he's based in Mexico City.
- 2:51:56Oh okay and me. Yeah and we conference I've
- 2:52:00heard nothing but great things about Mexico.
- 2:52:02Me when you do go get these on planet Earth London Mexico
- 2:52:07Casino? Yeah maybe Tokyo Tokyo.
- 2:52:10I put Mexico City number one. Wow.
- 2:52:12You're that you're here first and that is I really have to go.
- 2:52:16She's yeah. Um so yes, so he came to me and
- 2:52:20he said, you know what, if we didn't use ACR, what if we
- 2:52:22started using consumer grade technology and applying it to
- 2:52:25the measurement space and things like me more, that's an
- 2:52:29important Point. Yeah, yeah, so it is An
- 2:52:32important point because going back to the fact that we will
- 2:52:35never build technology that has already existent.
- 2:52:37A lot of the technology in our space.
- 2:52:39It's pretty old. Yeah and no he's your goes back
- 2:52:42but 30 years. Yeah.
- 2:52:45Yeah watermarking goes back further and That technology
- 2:52:49worked great 30 years ago and the basis of that technology is
- 2:52:54to connect back to schedule data.
- 2:52:56Yeah, well, anything Dynamic. You can't connect it back to
- 2:53:00schedule data. So we found, you know, we got
- 2:53:02focused on this problem, seven years ago and seven years ago,
- 2:53:05we were streaming as consumers but not nearly as much as we are
- 2:53:08today, right? So we're like, hey, this is just
- 2:53:11only gonna get worse and we have a solution to solve for it
- 2:53:15today. Yeah.
- 2:53:15So are we started the company seven years ago, we have a
- 2:53:18robust patent portfolio, our Technologies, completely
- 2:53:21proprietary. And let me ask you this does it
- 2:53:24let you read into, I mean you know because just what is the
- 2:53:26specificity? The granularity of right content
- 2:53:30recognition, right? So I'm assuming it goes down to
- 2:53:32its the app or the channel or the game level.
- 2:53:35Right? And then it's the specific
- 2:53:37content underneath that like, what am I?
- 2:53:38Oh, I'm watching Netflix. What am I streaming?
- 2:53:41That's the actual show. Level content.
- 2:53:42It's the show. It's the program.
- 2:53:44It's the season. It's the episode.
- 2:53:45It's the product placement and brand sponsorship.
- 2:53:49Yeah, so so we can measure user-generated content, we can
- 2:53:52measure product placement. That's interesting too.
- 2:53:53Yeah. How does that work?
- 2:53:55How do you use? How are you guys capturing
- 2:53:56product placement within within a streaming environment, for
- 2:53:59example? Yep.
- 2:54:00So that same proprietary blend of AI and machine learning and
- 2:54:03computer vision. It's picking up, all the logos
- 2:54:06throughout your street throughout your experience,
- 2:54:08right? So I like to use stranger
- 2:54:10stranger things. As an example where, you know,
- 2:54:12the agios are constantly shown our algorithms pick that up and
- 2:54:16and call it up. Wow, that's great.
- 2:54:18And so, and so you're selling this, how are you selling this?
- 2:54:22I mean, how are you selling this in?
- 2:54:23Is it a publisher Beast sale? Or is it like this outside or
- 2:54:28more of the buyers or was it a bridge between two?
- 2:54:30So we have a great relationship with comscore their customer of
- 2:54:34ours as is nbcu. Yeah.
- 2:54:35However we're not a rating or a currency.
- 2:54:37Yeah we never make that very clear.
- 2:54:40We absolutely do not want to screaming on this.
- 2:54:44No. But you're gonna be piping this
- 2:54:45in into other analytics applications like like Score.
- 2:54:49But potentially I'm assuming you have a lot of mmm relationship.
- 2:54:52I have a lot of relationships with Brands.
- 2:54:54Yes, modeling or marketing mix modeling for those that go
- 2:54:58broader than just media. But yes, we're essentially the
- 2:55:01way to think about as is where the Gap filler.
- 2:55:03So as whether you're a brand or a publisher, or an ad tech
- 2:55:08company, you have a proprietary blend of data sets, right?
- 2:55:11And that's how everyone is trying to figure out their own
- 2:55:14magic. Yeah.
- 2:55:15But across those data sets, there's a ton of holes.
- 2:55:18Yeah, right. You might have this CTV data set
- 2:55:21and this linear data set and this mobile set but it's a
- 2:55:24fraction of The Full Experience. Yeah, we measure the full
- 2:55:27experience you license our API or data as a service.
- 2:55:31You are not allowed to take our API and relight.
- 2:55:34I'm glad you didn't create another as a service term,
- 2:55:36right? Yeah.
- 2:55:37I was a service the other day. Like, open clock, Claus data
- 2:55:41service. Everything's a service, it
- 2:55:43seems. Yeah.
- 2:55:43But yeah. Well, and what, how does this
- 2:55:46extend to you? Get to television glass, right?
- 2:55:48It seems like it's everything but you've also got connection
- 2:55:51to device level data, right? So that's your your iPhone, your
- 2:55:54iPad. Any other sort of device and so
- 2:55:57that can track really, any type of advertising exposure, right?
- 2:56:01So correct, any programmatic display.
- 2:56:03It could be searched. I mean, I'm assuming, would you
- 2:56:06what about chatbot and llm? Like, how does all this stuff?
- 2:56:08Get into going back to being the Gap filler?
- 2:56:10They are the answer for clothes Loop analytics.
- 2:56:13So here that the answer for close-up.
- 2:56:15Yes, you are commercials, are you so other than the
- 2:56:20proprietary blend of machine learning and AI, which we call
- 2:56:24unni? The unified Nuremberg media
- 2:56:25identification? Yeah, it's one of my favorite
- 2:56:27foods too. I love the Briny.
- 2:56:30Yeah. The Taste Of The Sea.
- 2:56:32Yeah, so he came up with that. I was like, absolutely.
- 2:56:35Yeah. No break.
- 2:56:37Ya know. So uni is what measures the
- 2:56:40entire Omni Channel experience on the TV?
- 2:56:42Yeah, it's a software. So we also put it on people's
- 2:56:44phones and tablets. Yeah.
- 2:56:46We also measure all the activity there.
- 2:56:47Yeah. But separately.
- 2:56:48Lee. We have a router approach, where
- 2:56:50we become the home's mesh Network.
- 2:56:52Yes, and that's where we collect all the URL, https traffic.
- 2:56:56We see all the ad calls, so, in the case of the TV, especially
- 2:56:59we can see what was actually shown on the TV and then what
- 2:57:03add calls are behind it because as you know, that doesn't always
- 2:57:05match up. Yeah.
- 2:57:06So we see absolutely everything down to the individual.
- 2:57:09Yeah, people are measured using Bluetooth and Wi-Fi beacons,
- 2:57:13that act like sonar and we'd be able to pick up your Smartwatch,
- 2:57:16my SmartWatch, my phone so we know would be the two of us in
- 2:57:19front of the TV and then all the activity on our phones as well.
- 2:57:22Wow. Which can lead to a lot of like
- 2:57:24I was exposed to something here in this device, like online and
- 2:57:27then I went and committed this action on iPad, so I watch
- 2:57:31right? And one, which I don't think was
- 2:57:33salt while I was there like Nielsen marketing cloud and
- 2:57:35Nielsen was, they had all this panel data, you know, in in TV
- 2:57:39viewership and reaching frequency.
- 2:57:41But it was all at the household level, they really couldn't get
- 2:57:44it down to the person's level, right?
- 2:57:46They used persons plural for some Reason, I think that's
- 2:57:49dramatically correct. And, and the person level, the
- 2:57:52person's level, and they were always trying to match that to
- 2:57:55like this basically data. And identity graph, that
- 2:57:58actually the sort of building, right?
- 2:57:59It was the early days of, sort of you take a cookie pool, you
- 2:58:02start to match it to mobilize IDs, you know, this whole world,
- 2:58:06right? And you're trying to create a
- 2:58:08graph that's crossed device that can be predictive of an
- 2:58:11individual's actions, right? Right?
- 2:58:13Based on what, they're what they're consuming, right?
- 2:58:16Domains are going to all that sort of stuff.
- 2:58:18And I just found that the bridging what we saw was the
- 2:58:21bridging of the, two, super difficult, right?
- 2:58:25Yeah. It was very hard to, you know,
- 2:58:27combine the two and I think that was the promise that was never
- 2:58:30fully lived up to. It sounds like you guys.
- 2:58:31Just had that almost as a native architecture its native exactly.
- 2:58:35But separately that difficulty and within the bridging is
- 2:58:39because there is no data set other than if that measures
- 2:58:42absolutely everything. Yeah.
- 2:58:43So if you're bridging, you know, let's say YouTube data to nbcu
- 2:58:47data. If you don't have a data set
- 2:58:50that shows you how to bridge it or what else people are doing on
- 2:58:53other devices and otherwise those connection points are
- 2:58:56become assumptions. Yeah.
- 2:58:59And they're not exactly. Yeah.
- 2:59:00You turn the people love to say, probable.
- 2:59:03I think, right? Yeah.
- 2:59:04You get probabilistic matching saying that like, from an
- 2:59:07algorithmic perspective or predicting that like X percent
- 2:59:10confidence that this is this person, but it becomes very
- 2:59:14hard. Once you start to get down to
- 2:59:15the device level because, you know, how do you really know?
- 2:59:18It could be a child, whereas, you guys are self identify your
- 2:59:21household level, but those probability models become easier
- 2:59:24when you use our data. Yeah.
- 2:59:26So it is in, you know, probability because people are
- 2:59:30so I didn't think they're like authenticating device one device
- 2:59:33to device three person. One, if I want to, you know,
- 2:59:36person too. And so you have a deterministic
- 2:59:39signal of exactly what. Now, if device one is being used
- 2:59:43by Mom and said a daughter or son, that is a problem because
- 2:59:47it's still gonna be aligned To the person, right?
- 2:59:50So it kind of hard to control for that, unless you can control
- 2:59:53that. Can you is it hard?
- 2:59:54You can, you know, that's that comes down to panelists
- 2:59:56compliance. Yeah, making sure that they
- 2:59:58share that kind of information. So, there's an agreement here.
- 3:00:01There is an agreement. Yeah, that's our fully, you
- 3:00:03know, once you sign up to become part of a panel, you fully
- 3:00:06understand what you're signing up for and why.
- 3:00:07Yeah. And why it matters to be
- 3:00:10compliant? Yeah, and we asked we as we were
- 3:00:11kind of playing around with this question is, who are the people?
- 3:00:15It's like The Simpsons episode, right?
- 3:00:16The Simpsons family became like a Nielsen family is, who are the
- 3:00:21people that sign up for the panel?
- 3:00:22And why are they incentive? How are they incentivized to do
- 3:00:26it? Yeah, well so it's a cash
- 3:00:27incentive which is common with girls.
- 3:00:29However, we are representative of the US population.
- 3:00:32So to answer your question on who we're making sure that we
- 3:00:35have the right mix of people that matches.
- 3:00:37The US Census as well as the ARF Dash survey which serves as our
- 3:00:41universe, and then separately, you know, you have to think
- 3:00:44about a couple things one is the general consumer today, fully
- 3:00:47understand that That understands that the data is being used,
- 3:00:50they also are not enjoying their media experiences and the idea
- 3:00:55that they can help provide their data to improve their media
- 3:00:58experiences, is actually something that people are
- 3:01:01excited about. Yeah.
- 3:01:02And then separately, our media SAC at home is becoming
- 3:01:06incredibly expensive. Yeah.
- 3:01:07And you have to think about your average family and I encourage
- 3:01:11everyone to look at US, Census Data and see what the average
- 3:01:14family looks like, and what our household incomes look like and
- 3:01:17later on a couple of kids and otherwise and it gets even more
- 3:01:20expensive and harder, right? So we do not, we don't
- 3:01:23supplement your media stack, but our households do I think, you
- 3:01:28know, when we compare people that subscribe to just a cable
- 3:01:32stack, like back in the back in the day, you know, versus now
- 3:01:35that we've got multiple subscriptions across multiple
- 3:01:38streaming providers, a lot of cases, I think that they've done
- 3:01:41a pretty good job of getting us to spend more money for, oh yes.
- 3:01:44Yeah, to this content it's probably an order of magnitude.
- 3:01:48Larger, maybe two, three x, what we were spending previously,
- 3:01:51you're spending $200. You might be spending 600
- 3:01:52dollars, right? I'd love to see if there's stats
- 3:01:54on that, on that fact. Now, one other topic that I
- 3:01:56wanted to, I thought was important that we cover was MRC
- 3:01:59accreditation. It was all the hype and Nielsen
- 3:02:01lost it, did they regain it? I know they lost MRC
- 3:02:04accreditation and during covid and they regained it.
- 3:02:07And that was always a large topic of controversy and, and,
- 3:02:11you know, be basically the governance around measurement so
- 3:02:14that you're not, you're not sort of you.
- 3:02:16They're controlling for the for Nielsen, not being part of the
- 3:02:19selling of media so they can play that neutral Arbiter, roll
- 3:02:24the referee. Right?
- 3:02:25It's it. I get it from a from a
- 3:02:27regulatory perspective. But what do you think the role
- 3:02:29of MRC and MRC accreditation? That's the media rating sound.
- 3:02:33So for those that don't know plays in today's world today
- 3:02:36right now it's kind of like the are secrets.
- 3:02:38Like what do you think? I think that their role in
- 3:02:40function should remain as it always been which is to audit
- 3:02:43all of these companies and make sure that they're doing what
- 3:02:46they say they do. And that's where It's not that's
- 3:02:49where it starts and that's where it ends and nothing else.
- 3:02:51I think that they have an incredibly important role in
- 3:02:54function within our ecosystem. And you know, one of the amazing
- 3:02:57things about being here at possible is all these new
- 3:03:00companies and AI is obviously fueling all of that.
- 3:03:03Yeah but what we also are learning even beyond our
- 3:03:06industry is about AI slot, right?
- 3:03:07Yeah. And being audited, I think about
- 3:03:10is gonna become even more important as time goes on so
- 3:03:14that function of making sure that companies are doing what
- 3:03:17they're saying they're doing. Yeah, it's incredibly important.
- 3:03:20Anything beyond that, I don't think that's their role or
- 3:03:24anybody, you know, providing accreditation.
- 3:03:26So you don't think it's like, sort of hit a point where it's
- 3:03:29like, hey, this is no longer relevant in the current
- 3:03:31ecosystem, right? I don't believe that, I think,
- 3:03:34you know, it evokes a certain confidence for for Traders.
- 3:03:37I mean, you know, working in this industry, we get
- 3:03:39comfortable talking about advertising in otherwise, but
- 3:03:41it's important, it's attention economy.
- 3:03:43It's how people get their information.
- 3:03:44It's how I just get allocated, you know, we just talked about,
- 3:03:48you sort of governance body, right?
- 3:03:50Just like some of the controversy can be gamed to a
- 3:03:54certain degree in that there's influence of with Nielsen
- 3:03:56rights. Like that, I hope that I'm not
- 3:03:58getting sued for this, but like, in terms of how do you actually
- 3:04:00influence the decisions that the governing body, right?
- 3:04:03It's sort of like The Regulators controlling the regular the or
- 3:04:06the the providers controlling The Regulators, right?
- 3:04:09Like there has been some controversy on that, but it
- 3:04:11sounds like it does. Play a good role Made Me Do
- 3:04:13adapt an optimized but just in terms of governance of the
- 3:04:16entire measurement, ecosystem right now and I think we'll
- 3:04:19finish with this. Is that That you talked about
- 3:04:20and I think there's a theme that I'm hearing from you.
- 3:04:23I told you, I talked to Mike Senator, the US, president of
- 3:04:26mutant necks nothing. You sent next about the rise of
- 3:04:29the rise of. Mmm.
- 3:04:32Yeah. And I I've heard this ad nauseam
- 3:04:34for like, last 10 years of my life and I was involved heavily
- 3:04:36and at new star and, you know, people talked about the death of
- 3:04:39mmm and it was too slow, was it actionable?
- 3:04:41There was the rise of MTA for like quick.
- 3:04:44Like we can make, you know, minute to minute decisions on
- 3:04:48our media allocation and our Dollar location to affect
- 3:04:51outcome. Yeah.
- 3:04:52And but that's changing now, it's like mmm is getting a lot
- 3:04:55faster, a lot more, a gently driven so that it's not as much
- 3:04:59of a managed service. Yeah.
- 3:05:01What do you what role? Do you guys play?
- 3:05:03Yeah, it seems like it's pretty critical, right?
- 3:05:05Yeah. These mmm providers for all
- 3:05:07those out there that haven't heard of.
- 3:05:08Yeah, it's incredibly important for us as an industry to just
- 3:05:12get the counting right level. Yeah.
- 3:05:15And that's what life is here to do.
- 3:05:17Yeah, we put this in ourselves at 0 party data.
- 3:05:20Yeah, because we're in the household and we're just at the
- 3:05:22root measuring. This is true for any data like
- 3:05:27having to Define it in some complex way.
- 3:05:29We don't license data sets we don't merge data sets.
- 3:05:31Its true, zero party data. A person is exposed to media and
- 3:05:35we report on that, and that's it.
- 3:05:37Yeah. And that is foundational to our
- 3:05:39entire ecosystem. Yeah.
- 3:05:40And as I mentioned, we're not a rating or currency, but instead,
- 3:05:43we're here to help facilitate all types of trading whether
- 3:05:47your outcome based, mmm currency.
- 3:05:49It really truly doesn't matter, and it shouldn't.
- 3:05:51Yeah. You know.
- 3:05:52CMOS should be the one making the decision for their business
- 3:05:56and what makes sense for them. And they're, you know, they
- 3:05:59can't even make those decisions decisions without knowing where
- 3:06:02we're spending our time and we fundamentally believe that we
- 3:06:05need to get that right first. And then let the industry do
- 3:06:08what it needs to do in order to match media, buys to Consumer
- 3:06:13Behavior. Yes, right now, I'm pretty sure
- 3:06:15we can all agree. They're not matched.
- 3:06:16Yeah, yeah. And we're not here to really
- 3:06:18hide, you know, and people that listen.
- 3:06:20Signal in, those were not cheerleaders, we're not
- 3:06:22cheerleading the next, you know, tech company.
- 3:06:24That's, that's changed the universe, but I'm actually
- 3:06:26buying your story here, right? And and if you've been
- 3:06:29impossible, you know that everybody's Hawking data and
- 3:06:32everybody's trying to sell data. If you say, if you ask who's
- 3:06:34trying to sell data in a room and a possible, then half the
- 3:06:38audience is going to raise their hands.
- 3:06:39But this is the, this is honestly a super compelling
- 3:06:41story knowing the space and seeing kind of the mechanics of
- 3:06:45how it works in my career and and it's super exciting.
- 3:06:49I'm excited for you and congratulations on launching
- 3:06:52this. So it's a hard painful process.
- 3:06:54Yeah. Found the business.
- 3:06:56Believe me, I'm in the middle of it and wish you the best of
- 3:06:59luck. It was great.
- 3:07:00Yeah. And thanks everybody.
- 3:07:01Thank you. Signaling noise podcast.
- 3:07:05We got a friend here. Singing, those podcasts.
- 3:07:08This is our near me end here in the end and wrap up in the
- 3:07:13pressroom of possible 2026. I've got a special guest we've
- 3:07:16been waiting, you know, waiting a couple hours here to get this.
- 3:07:19A really appreciate your patience here.
- 3:07:20Joshua, John had a DSP strategy, Yahoo DSP, that's here, but have
- 3:07:27you. So there's a lot to talk about I
- 3:07:28mean I know you made you be Yahoo made some really cool
- 3:07:31announcements this week about Oh hello, I'm sorry.
- 3:07:34You made some announcements about, I think SMB segments
- 3:07:39Chantix stuff. So maybe we start out by just,
- 3:07:41you know, let's talk a little bit about yourself and your role
- 3:07:43and how long you've been doing this?
- 3:07:45And I can dig into some product stuff after that.
- 3:07:47Yeah, that'd be great. So I've been at Yahoo for almost
- 3:07:50four years now, I lead our strategy and solutions team.
- 3:07:52So basically my team Works across our product and
- 3:07:55Engineering teams to better understand what we're going to
- 3:07:57build and what we're prioritizing over the next six,
- 3:07:5912, 18, 24 months. Yeah, I think from a Yahoo
- 3:08:03perspective, we've been on a really good journey over the
- 3:08:05last couple of years. I would say we've done a lot of
- 3:08:08transformation over three years. Really, focusing our product and
- 3:08:11kind of transitioning from a sales letter organization to our
- 3:08:14project organization and with that better understanding where
- 3:08:18our customers are and then meeting those needs.
- 3:08:19Whether that is through new segmentation, new products that
- 3:08:22we're developing their tools that are features One.
- 3:08:26They always so fascinating about Yahoo it's like it's been around
- 3:08:29for really as long as the modern web write a company and been
- 3:08:33through lots of different turns and twists and through it all
- 3:08:37has been like the Has launched like a 1000 careers in
- 3:08:42advertising and AD Tech. It was just something maybe more
- 3:08:44than any other passage. I probably like at least half
- 3:08:47the people are possible. I've worked at AOL Yahoo from
- 3:08:52entity within that. Yeah, it's an OG, a brand in
- 3:08:56that Tech and advertising. So yeah, definitely I think a
- 3:08:58badge of honor and it's been cool to watch this, like, just
- 3:09:01come back over the last couple years.
- 3:09:02Yeah, totally. And I think it's something that
- 3:09:04we are really proud of. I think, you know, when I told
- 3:09:07my parents that I was going to go to Yahoo a couple years ago,
- 3:09:10they're like, what is that? Why are you?
- 3:09:11So you explained to them what we actually do and where we are in
- 3:09:14size of actually what we're bringing consumer standpoint,
- 3:09:16there's a ton of opportunity that we've been able to bring
- 3:09:18together and kind of reinvent. The Brent, what do you think
- 3:09:22makes Yahoo DSP me? A lot of dsps out there, right.
- 3:09:25What do you think makes Yahoo DSP?
- 3:09:26A little different? Gives you a competitive
- 3:09:28Advantage? Yeah, so I think the kind of
- 3:09:31core competitive advantage that we have is Yahoo's belt on a
- 3:09:34very large consumer ecosystem. So yeah, Sports Yahoo finance,
- 3:09:37Yahoo mail. All your own and operator, all
- 3:09:40of our own Opera properties. And because of that, we have a
- 3:09:43really great consented audience and that gives us a really
- 3:09:46holistic Bureau of whole picture of you of this audience that we
- 3:09:49have, and we could take that view and bring it across the
- 3:09:51open. And so, you know, we don't
- 3:09:53believe in this concept of buying identity.
- 3:09:55You should be really owning your identity owning those audiences.
- 3:09:58And what you have a really good spine, building features that
- 3:10:00enhance that across the open. Web is really kind of what we
- 3:10:03have your own spine. Yes.
- 3:10:06So connect ideas are full on spine with 232 million logged in
- 3:10:10users. So, that's what we've seen.
- 3:10:11This, the US 80 million monthly active male users, for example.
- 3:10:14So we see trillions of dollars and terms of purchase receipt.
- 3:10:17There were able to use. There's a really holistic view
- 3:10:19that we can start to bring together for planning targeting
- 3:10:22and not measurement alternative to You were an early mover in
- 3:10:26the CTV space as well. Yes, we were a very early in the
- 3:10:29CTV space in terms of Investments that we made to make
- 3:10:32sure that we can bring in holistic measurement bringing
- 3:10:34audiences into the households directly for targeting and then
- 3:10:36working really great Partners like a video for example, to
- 3:10:39provide that linear, reach numbers as well within the
- 3:10:41platform. I saw the recent announcements
- 3:10:43about like, like really trying to take the DS.
- 3:10:46Like look at the DSP Market in. Let's say small and midsize
- 3:10:50businesses. I thought that was really
- 3:10:51interesting. I think it's a great idea by the
- 3:10:53way and I know you look at some of the things like Amazon DSP is
- 3:10:57done in terms of like creating tools, you know, for smaller for
- 3:11:01smaller brands or smaller advertisers.
- 3:11:02I love to hear if whatever, you're able to share about the
- 3:11:05strategy is pretty cool. Yeah, so, you know, our eat this
- 3:11:08is always been, we want to meet The Advertiser where they are
- 3:11:10and whether it's right or wrong. Kind of dsps, have become more
- 3:11:14complex because media plans are complex and so are there ways we
- 3:11:17can make it a lot easier for users to use their platform.
- 3:11:19And so that's what we've been thinking about how we start to
- 3:11:21address these new segments. That maybe wants something that
- 3:11:24is a little bit more fine tuned for their needs.
- 3:11:26And basically, what we want to go for them is a little bit of a
- 3:11:30simpler version of how we kind of approached current workflows.
- 3:11:33And so that's how we're thinking about different ways around
- 3:11:34those advertisers. What are some things in terms
- 3:11:37like workflow, automations content generation that you
- 3:11:40either are already baked in or you're going to you think would
- 3:11:43be good for the market. Yeah, I think in general, we
- 3:11:45have made a very large push into it.
- 3:11:46Obviously AI is like the buzz word and everyone is talking
- 3:11:49about it the way that we think about it is written standpoint.
- 3:11:52And so, as we look at our DSP, we do a couple of things really.
- 3:11:55Well right, we do audience planning really well.
- 3:11:57We do insights really. Well, we do optimization and
- 3:11:59measure but we also know that our advertisers and our agency
- 3:12:03partners do things really well too.
- 3:12:04They have really great secret sauce on strategy.
- 3:12:06And so, they want us to be able to pipe in our insights directly
- 3:12:09into their platforms. And that's where we think it is
- 3:12:11really interesting workflow. And so, how can we start to make
- 3:12:14a lot easier for these tools than that their data and their
- 3:12:16own secret sauce to it as well allows us to kind of decouple
- 3:12:19the DSP for variety in terms of how we want to surface?
- 3:12:22Iterations of the UI whether that's through our platform or
- 3:12:24through other partners that other on version as well.
- 3:12:26So you really doesn't matter, like what the UI looks like.
- 3:12:29You'll have one obviously continue to but like if someone
- 3:12:31wants to just build the throne enchant workflows or have their
- 3:12:34agents, you Go cross another UI. They can just connect to you and
- 3:12:39this point, right? Like what is a UI and future
- 3:12:42workflow, it's going to be drastically different you guys
- 3:12:44to humans, right? Exactly.
- 3:12:45I mean in the last couple About co-work that is dressed with
- 3:12:49changed. How you read your email and so
- 3:12:50that's in concept of do you need to go in and actually set up a
- 3:12:53campaign by clicking these Bots? You know, we've gone from Excel
- 3:12:56workflows to now trying to do you know different types of
- 3:13:00events workflows. And now do we just want to do
- 3:13:01this in a natural lens ends up? But I think you're right.
- 3:13:04Like trying to pretend anyone like his nailed.
- 3:13:07It is crazy. So what you're saying is we'll
- 3:13:08just build go ahead. Let's we'll build so you'll have
- 3:13:11it so you can build on top, we have a great infrastructure and
- 3:13:14then how you want to tap into that infrastructure is up to
- 3:13:17you. And I think that flexibility is
- 3:13:18really important and that's something that we also think is
- 3:13:21going to be differentiated, right?
- 3:13:22Again, we don't have a existing data environment where you move
- 3:13:25your data to. We want to meet you where you
- 3:13:27are, if you're using snowflake, we'll meet you there if you're
- 3:13:29using signal you. So really depends on what the
- 3:13:32needs at. Then you can pick and choose
- 3:13:34what makes the most size for you.
- 3:13:35You might not know the answer to.
- 3:13:38This is just kind of one of these, you know, some are
- 3:13:40questions. Like what do you think?
- 3:13:41Like who do you think is going to be like, will a lot of media?
- 3:13:44I mean obviously people plan to meet here is usually one thing
- 3:13:47That people who buy the meat. They usually young, or people
- 3:13:49who are in platform, you know, doing all of the things, you
- 3:13:52know, we've trained yourself to do whether it's pushing knobs
- 3:13:55adjusting pacing, uploading, you know, picking things drop downs,
- 3:13:59Who do you think it's the same people to do that?
- 3:14:02Do you think it's different people who end up like doing
- 3:14:04everything? Maybe just all most people comes
- 3:14:07done automated and done by agents in the future.
- 3:14:10Like, any thoughts on that? Yeah, I was a Trader, right?
- 3:14:13Okay, I worked in an agency. That's why I started here.
- 3:14:16I did it. I did adopts.
- 3:14:17I had to go in. I make this joke a lot, but I
- 3:14:20worked in Auto and tier two Auto was his own Beast, right?
- 3:14:23Oh yeah, millions and millions of lines are putting into
- 3:14:25Prisma. You have to then traffic, you
- 3:14:27push them out of DC. I'm gonna upload into your
- 3:14:29campaigns, they make them very Geo, specific tons of tags and
- 3:14:32stuff. Yeah, it's right.
- 3:14:33And how many times at the end of year in December, was everyone's
- 3:14:36scrambling to make sure that everything set up for January
- 3:14:391st and you're working till 2:00 in the morning, right?
- 3:14:41Yeah. And so with that, you know, I
- 3:14:43did that for a year and I don't want to do this anymore.
- 3:14:45I only just thank you and it's a very important but there's got
- 3:14:50totally. Yeah.
- 3:14:52But there's better ways you can do this because in immediately I
- 3:14:55wanted to be more focused on strategy.
- 3:14:56What are the channels that make the most sense for the partners
- 3:14:59of published that we Is one of the audiences.
- 3:15:00And so what we're looking to do is figure out how we can have a
- 3:15:04genetic workflows and different types of agents and tools within
- 3:15:07our platform for U of our perspective, and then outside of
- 3:15:10the platform to actually start to automate it.
- 3:15:11And I think we're seeing a lot of this already, right?
- 3:15:13Whether that is, you know, integrated trafficking from an
- 3:15:16ad server directly into the DSP platform or us being able to
- 3:15:18send exposure files and measurement to reply to another
- 3:15:20environment on the click of a button.
- 3:15:22We are starting to see that collapse, we have been really
- 3:15:25focused on troubleshooting within the platform.
- 3:15:27There's two issues that everyone runs into from ideas per
- 3:15:31perspective and I'm going like, in the wheels on this.
- 3:15:33It's good people like we nerd at.
- 3:15:37Yeah, we should like, everyone's like my pixels not working.
- 3:15:40So, it's really enjoying yourself and She loves pixels.
- 3:15:46Yeah. And so you know, my pixel is not
- 3:15:48working. How do I troubleshoot it?
- 3:15:50What do I need to do? And that process was insane that
- 3:15:52the go into your site, you manually scrub the pictures.
- 3:15:54You have to see what matters. What are not fired.
- 3:15:56We've been able to automate. I've been there done that again
- 3:15:58that right or the other one. That's just a really interesting
- 3:16:01one is why am I not scaling and I'm running on a PMP and nine
- 3:16:05times at a time, the problem is that you're bidding below the
- 3:16:08forks. Right now, to identify that,
- 3:16:09somebody usually emails somebody on our client services team to
- 3:16:13say, why is my campaign that's going on?
- 3:16:14That's scaling. Someone they don't publish your
- 3:16:17team, the publisher team reaches up to the publisher.
- 3:16:19The publisher comes back, says you guys just below the floor
- 3:16:22that's like 10 emails. It takes about two days and
- 3:16:25that's chaos. We just created an agent, the
- 3:16:26baseball is able to identify very quickly, they could go to
- 3:16:29the Floyd just pops up and tells you hey, you didn't below the
- 3:16:31401K. You cut all the emails.
- 3:16:33You cut her all the time. He just happens exactly.
- 3:16:35And it's just like how do you these are like little things
- 3:16:37that are very practical and I know it's not sexy but these are
- 3:16:39the things that actually make the platform better and that's
- 3:16:41what we want to and eventually agents will just do that
- 3:16:43proactively, right? I mean It obviously if you know
- 3:16:46it like you can tell them but after why you train them to get
- 3:16:48smarter, they'll probably notice these things and maybe flag them
- 3:16:50for you. Right?
- 3:16:50I mean, you know, we shouldn't we don't want to encourage this,
- 3:16:54but the first thing I did when Comet came out, the browser was
- 3:16:57I went to the DSP and I wanted to see how much I can do.
- 3:16:59Just some browser history, right within three pages.
- 3:17:02I couldn't build a case. We just did three pages to look
- 3:17:05at from URL standpoint, on our site.
- 3:17:06And I was able to set up campaign within a experiments,
- 3:17:09right? And see like Jurassic changes
- 3:17:11how we think about agents, and what we're doing, what we're
- 3:17:13trying to do. So yeah that's all stuff people
- 3:17:15would have been doing right? Yeah.
- 3:17:16And so and then that removes the need for you to do the Tactical
- 3:17:19work and then focus on strive doing the things that are
- 3:17:21actually differentiated when it comes to Media.
- 3:17:23Bye. So right.
- 3:17:24I mean it it's still some but it's a lot of the You know, the
- 3:17:28emailing back and forth for looking at things, you know, the
- 3:17:31swiveling between tools that you know, that gets minimized.
- 3:17:33That was fun more efficiency, right?
- 3:17:35And so we, we should be using another part of her brain.
- 3:17:38Those manual tests to get him again. so that's a DSP strategy
- 3:17:42just like the there's been a lot of talk about Different things
- 3:17:46that dsps do now? Like like do they migrate out of
- 3:17:49DSP is like decisioning for example, something that
- 3:17:51obviously, you know, core functionality, okay?
- 3:17:54We're seeing a lot of innovation on Supply now, like pulling in
- 3:17:58and say deeper richer broader signals from, you know, from
- 3:18:04From from bidstream using that to inform.
- 3:18:06Like where do you see? Like if there's even been some
- 3:18:10debates, I don't think this is gonna happen.
- 3:18:12I can do these peas in their current form, even exists in
- 3:18:15five years, right? Thoughts on that.
- 3:18:17Like yeah, so I think At the end of the day, media plans are
- 3:18:21complex. And I think there's this
- 3:18:23rhetoric that they should be less complex.
- 3:18:25I disagree. I think there should be more
- 3:18:26complex. We should be more complex,
- 3:18:28right? I think that eliminating factors
- 3:18:30people now in time. Well, the people is a time in
- 3:18:33the software that's allowing us to do that, but like you know,
- 3:18:35something as simple as frequency camping was complex a couple
- 3:18:38years ago when I used to work in that Network.
- 3:18:40And then we moved to do is to be environment to start to do that.
- 3:18:42You know, it's hard to do before.
- 3:18:43Yeah, exactly. And so, when we start to layer
- 3:18:45on all these different layers of complexity, you need a tool
- 3:18:48that's able to make sure you can orchestrate that process.
- 3:18:50And so that's always going to do the DSP.
- 3:18:52I think there's gonna be benefits and advantages of,
- 3:18:55whether that is being closer to supply or different types of
- 3:18:57algorithms that might be custom, but that's still lives within
- 3:19:00the single orchestration lawyer, whether that is in our you or
- 3:19:03somebody else. And we're just the tools of
- 3:19:05power I think is Up For Debate, but you need a way to start to
- 3:19:08organize that complexity. Yeah, makes sense and I guess we
- 3:19:12say something matter, like he's gonna live somewhere.
- 3:19:15I think in many instances, will be still being the DSP for
- 3:19:17Microsoft Word, for others, fine, right.
- 3:19:21What are some like? Other partners that you're
- 3:19:24having a lot of success, you know, working with now like who
- 3:19:27you like as you build up some of these new capabilities.
- 3:19:30So one of the things that we have been pretty focused on is
- 3:19:33what we call inflight outcomes. And so that is really how do you
- 3:19:35start to do better optimization? I think we are so focused on
- 3:19:38targeting from an audience perspective, but at the end of
- 3:19:41the day, that's a static targeting.
- 3:19:42Your audience is only as good as the optimization and measurement
- 3:19:44that you can use to make sure you're driving that outcome.
- 3:19:46So we've been really rolling out some interesting Partners into
- 3:19:49that. I have tool that we had.
- 3:19:51We just want it and Mark it actually where we can do some
- 3:19:53really interesting. I focus in the Geo filters that
- 3:19:55they're able to provide so you have a qsr client that's looking
- 3:19:57to do some type of lift. Instead of just having static
- 3:20:00audience, that is somebody that's interested in a
- 3:20:01cheeseburger. You can apply that plus take the
- 3:20:04Insight. So we're getting from a Geo
- 3:20:05perspective and optimized in real time against that segment
- 3:20:08similar work that we're doing with like, Cuba or sarkana.
- 3:20:10So, really starts to go beyond just the standard audience that
- 3:20:13we want to Target against that standard measurement and add a
- 3:20:16player to it. Oh, some of these changes like,
- 3:20:19impacting the way you work with Asians and like, you know, maybe
- 3:20:22not even changes. To your platform, just changes
- 3:20:24generally industry. Is that is a shifting at all.
- 3:20:27Are you seeing like how you interact with them?
- 3:20:29People like is Or something. Maybe migrating, it has to
- 3:20:34Branch. You have to work truck with
- 3:20:35Brands more Curious to hear about that.
- 3:20:36Yeah, so everyone has a different flavor depending on
- 3:20:38the sophistication. The advertising.
- 3:20:40If you're a very sophisticated and Advertiser and you can
- 3:20:43support and then us model, that's one way you're going to
- 3:20:45go. But then you quickly realize
- 3:20:47that I need to make sure I have a DMP infrastructure, I need to
- 3:20:49assume infrastructure, I need to have some type of strategy
- 3:20:52thing, I need to send somebody to possible to meet with all the
- 3:20:54different partners that are coming, right?
- 3:20:55Like, I mean, I met with six measurement properties this
- 3:20:58morning, like and so there's so many different people coming, so
- 3:21:00that's one side of it, from an agency side.
- 3:21:03I'm fairly bullish. You know, I worked at agencies
- 3:21:05for a long time and every couple years there's the concept of the
- 3:21:08meta DSP that comes up, right? And I've been asked to build
- 3:21:12them so much, right? And so, and so that concept
- 3:21:15keeps coming up. There's always some hiccups, but
- 3:21:17we're at a point now, with technology is not a limited
- 3:21:20factor, right? And so the ability for us to
- 3:21:22access these things, and many people maybe now, as possible
- 3:21:25with us within this again, I mean, like the work that Newton
- 3:21:28research example creates it a So cool.
- 3:21:32They're doing this out. We didn't awesome case study we
- 3:21:34do and we worked with RPA and basically, we're creating agent
- 3:21:37and then set up a full campaign from A CTV perspective within
- 3:21:39that agent, interface directly plugged into the Yahoo DSP,
- 3:21:42active traffic, the agent activated, and then get the
- 3:21:45measurement right there and we did it over winter break the
- 3:21:47announcement at CS. We did it within a week and a
- 3:21:49half. Yeah, I appeared that with this
- 3:21:51shot. Here's my file, just everything
- 3:21:54just gets a pretty, it's amazing, right?
- 3:21:56It creates so much more sophistication in terms of what
- 3:22:00we're able to do. And it's simplifies a lot of the
- 3:22:01work that we can do too far away.
- 3:22:03Are we from that before? That's like obviously you can do
- 3:22:06it like in one instance if before that actually happens at
- 3:22:08any scale. Yeah, I got in trouble when I
- 3:22:10start to say some of these answers but I think it's gonna
- 3:22:12happen next year. Like, I Really Gonna Start, I
- 3:22:15think she's gonna be up. There's a couple of agencies
- 3:22:17that we have been working with and talking to that are quite
- 3:22:19sophisticated, specifically among the independent agency
- 3:22:22groups. There are already moving in this
- 3:22:24direction where they want to create these uis and these tools
- 3:22:25for their team because they're being strapped, right, for
- 3:22:27resources and time. And so how can they make a lot
- 3:22:30easier for their teams to focus? Strategy unless someone
- 3:22:33execution and so we'll see you slow shift.
- 3:22:35Some of the larger hold codes are doing some really
- 3:22:37interesting Innovation as well working with Partners like
- 3:22:40Newton and Ikea. So I think we'll start to be
- 3:22:42sooner rather than later especially when you're looking
- 3:22:44at data orchestration that you need to do from an agent's
- 3:22:46perspective, putting it within your eyes showing the secret
- 3:22:49sauce, you're able to do. And then using tools that you
- 3:22:51just sort of sit in their environment is something that I
- 3:22:54think is going to happen sooner rather than later.
- 3:22:55So aggressive timeline. Yeah, it's not crazy with that
- 3:22:57crazy speed things. You're going again, if you're
- 3:22:59playing quadco work do it three months ago.
- 3:23:02Four months ago, no one was talking about it and not just a
- 3:23:06single Enterprise is approved that you're always just being
- 3:23:08able to spin a pageants and have them do things.
- 3:23:10That was like a year ago. Yeah.
- 3:23:11Right. Yeah, it's wild.
- 3:23:13So what gets you excited about like the next and maybe it's
- 3:23:16that, right? But like the next like you know
- 3:23:18you're you're too like that stuff you're working on just
- 3:23:21stuff in Industry generally. Yeah, I mean, I am very bullish
- 3:23:24on this idea of how could we start to be an orchestration
- 3:23:27platform that is also decoupled, right?
- 3:23:29So mentioning all the different partners that we're working with
- 3:23:31tapping to the identity spine and then taking those features
- 3:23:33and products and pushing them out to different.
- 3:23:35Environments is probably the most exciting thing that I think
- 3:23:38we have on the horizon. We are doing a lot more with
- 3:23:41ifo, as I mentioned, which I think is also something really
- 3:23:43unique is this idea of getting people to actually optimize
- 3:23:46their audiences? I was on a panel for Commerce
- 3:23:48meeting yesterday. I think Commerce Media Partners
- 3:23:52are starting to understand that. Yes, I may have a really rich
- 3:23:54static environment. I may have some interesting
- 3:23:56inventory and then I have some type of measurement but it
- 3:23:59doesn't really drive a lot of performance besides just a shop
- 3:24:02for dollars and it to get. And so, how can I start to use
- 3:24:04optimization to go after both endemic and not endemic?
- 3:24:06And so in those altogether as another research?
- 3:24:09Yeah, there's explosion of retelling Commerce, media, Sites
- 3:24:14and some are doing really well. But I think, you know, still
- 3:24:16almost like 80% is Amazon. Yeah, at Walmart and Kroger for
- 3:24:21the big ones. It's pretty much.
- 3:24:22So I mean again I don't think you should at this right now.
- 3:24:242026, you should not be buying identity and so if somebody has
- 3:24:29consented identity, whether it's a retail partner or whether
- 3:24:31they're somebody that has a really great owning the property
- 3:24:33system, like, that's the way that you should go, and your
- 3:24:36identity belt off of that. If you're buying it or
- 3:24:38licensing, it inherently, you're not a way too far from that
- 3:24:41consumer. So how do you actually create
- 3:24:42about it? What did you get the events so
- 3:24:46far if possible? This is an amazing.
- 3:24:48Yeah. If you really hot, it was a but,
- 3:24:53you know, I love coming to these things because I they're just so
- 3:24:55many different companies to make.
- 3:24:56I This may sound a little pretentious.
- 3:24:59One of the things I wanted to do this.
- 3:25:00This time was take five LinkedIn meetings right?
- 3:25:03We all get different LinkedIn requests all the time.
- 3:25:05Most of us just try to ignore them and I wanted to fight all
- 3:25:08five were great. All you need companies and not
- 3:25:10worked with before we're all really different, interesting,
- 3:25:13audiences or measurement providers that we can start to
- 3:25:16bring together. And so just come into these
- 3:25:18things, making sure that you don't need to talk to the same
- 3:25:19partner that you already work with every single day and
- 3:25:22meeting somebody, there was always the best part we ended up
- 3:25:24over 40 of these sessions, which If you.
- 3:25:31Hold me a couple weeks ago that we would have had this minute.
- 3:25:33I wouldn't have believed you because it's It's hard to get
- 3:25:37them and it's hard to get good ones.
- 3:25:39We had 40 to, I think incredible discussions like this one with
- 3:25:43people who we wanted to talk to who had great points of views.
- 3:25:45And I that's hard to do, and Something about the event this
- 3:25:52year was I was very successful. Yeah, I mean for us but because
- 3:25:56some of the way it was set up I did get a bunch of just random
- 3:25:59LinkedIn requests and I took a couple of them and they were
- 3:26:01good meetings. Yeah.
- 3:26:02I mean like what may out of the three I took you on one one I
- 3:26:06cried her done without but it was but it was good to meet
- 3:26:08someone new and the other two were fantastic.
- 3:26:10And then and we definitely got business done here.
- 3:26:13And I got some incredible meetings with clients, both
- 3:26:16publisher clients as well as Advertiser clients here.
- 3:26:19So, I think it was definitely heavier agency presidents, very
- 3:26:23heavy brand and publisher presence that.
- 3:26:25I, I don't know if I saw that last year but I had outstanding
- 3:26:28meetings. Yeah.
- 3:26:29And they're all really good, some good dinners as well, but
- 3:26:32yeah, it is good. Yeah, and then but it's, it's a
- 3:26:36grinder, right? It's a, it's a crime, it's a
- 3:26:38crime, but it's good. I mean, that's what we're here.
- 3:26:39That's what I'm here for, right? I mean explain to my wife so I'm
- 3:26:42gonna Miami for four days, it's gonna be great.
- 3:26:45I'm not enough right? Like that gonna be what I mean?
- 3:26:48Yeah, you gonna be meetings back to back?
- 3:26:51I mean, I told my wife this morning yesterday I had my first
- 3:26:56meeting at, like, 8 breakfast meeting and then we're, yeah, I
- 3:27:01had a bunch, a bunch of stuff for Omnicom that I had a couple
- 3:27:03of these I hosted and then my dinner ended at 1 a.m.
- 3:27:08So he was a long day and I was, I was really tired by the time I
- 3:27:11got back and you know, I was so hot.
- 3:27:14I was suit jacket. It was still drying out the end
- 3:27:18of the room but I do. But yeah, I was but this is a
- 3:27:20fun event and like you know, it's it's gotten better every
- 3:27:23year and next year I'll be sure. You'll be a can I'm guessing
- 3:27:26too, right? Yeah cool.
- 3:27:28So we're starting we're trying to find a deal with Publisher
- 3:27:31partner to do some podcasting there.
- 3:27:34So I'll let you know if we finalized things and it'd be
- 3:27:38cool and maybe show, you have some big announcements for
- 3:27:41Canada. I know we do.
- 3:27:41Yeah, we asked, well, really house stuff coming up, so I'm
- 3:27:44free. Well, no, we can cover so those.
- 3:27:46Yeah, that'd be great. I know, I, I have to say, this
- 3:27:49is the only I took podcast that I listened to, in my car.
- 3:27:52Because I can't listen to people's voice is in the car.
- 3:27:56But you guys have great forces of a very car and so I'm totally
- 3:28:00fine listening to its really great for me.
- 3:28:02Yeah, I appreciate that. Looks like I don't like think
- 3:28:05too. It's in fact we have long These
- 3:28:07are caught these are detailed discussions about things too.
- 3:28:10Yeah, actually listen to my own podcast.
- 3:28:13I mean I try to write there's a lot of information that's Bill
- 3:28:17Simmons and then you guys so just well we'll help us spread
- 3:28:20the word. If you know anyone else, you
- 3:28:22might be interested in and nerdy ad Tech, long-form content.
- 3:28:25But thanks again for spending time with us here and we will
- 3:28:28definitely be in touch soon. Hopefully, see you in a couple
- 3:28:30weeks. I can appreciate.
- 3:28:31Thank you for dealing with my dog as well.
- 3:28:32It's great. Thanks so much.
- 3:28:37Hello, everybody. This is Brad house from signal
- 3:28:39annoys beaming into you for day one of possible in a beautiful,
- 3:28:45beautiful, mad connect mansion on 1374 South Venetian, Way on a
- 3:28:50little island overlooking Miami. It's quite beautiful.
- 3:28:52And I've got George music with me who we've had on the podcast
- 3:28:55recently who's a phenomenal guest.
- 3:28:59You were a phenomenal guest, by the way that an hour and a half.
- 3:29:02Episode did we went like full Joe Rogan on that?
- 3:29:05That's right. Um, and we talked a lot about a
- 3:29:07lot of things and I thought, well, rehashed, some of that,
- 3:29:09but you've had a recent experience in Horizon, Commerce
- 3:29:13is an EVP which Chief business officer, right?
- 3:29:16You've had a ton of experience in retail media, just Commerce
- 3:29:19media, right? And now you're here at this show
- 3:29:22on behalf of mad sense, right? As the sort of fractional Chief
- 3:29:27strategy job, but it right. Um so what do we start with your
- 3:29:31your Commerce you know you made some comments on back and forth
- 3:29:34on email around Commerce media and Retail Media.
- 3:29:37It's been a, you know, with retail media.
- 3:29:39It's been a rapidly growing ecosystem.
- 3:29:41I've done some research recently on it.
- 3:29:43Um it's it's gotten kind of messy, even though there's
- 3:29:46there's a lot of concentration at the top between the Walmarts
- 3:29:49and the Amazons. There's 200 other retail, media
- 3:29:51networks, all competing, and grow it and growing all of them
- 3:29:55may be middle, you know, in a way walled Gardens.
- 3:29:58Um, it's, it's kind of a messy ecosystem.
- 3:30:00How to Brands? Think about that.
- 3:30:02Do you think that there's room for improvement in and how does
- 3:30:06that tie in to Commerce media as a whole?
- 3:30:08Yeah, so um, we've seen We've seen kind of this this book
- 3:30:14already, right? It's kind of the same process
- 3:30:17when programmatic first came out right?
- 3:30:19Or and more specifically when the DSP first came out.
- 3:30:22Yeah. And then so, the first one was
- 3:30:23like, wow, this is great. What can I exactly?
- 3:30:26I can do this in this at the same time.
- 3:30:27Great. The next 20 came out.
- 3:30:29Oh, that's great. That's choice right?
- 3:30:31I don't have to be and then the next thousand came out and never
- 3:30:34was like what the hell? Yeah right.
- 3:30:36And so end up with five. Mentation will you you have a
- 3:30:39fragmentation? You end up with dilution?
- 3:30:41Yeah. Because everybody's has to say
- 3:30:44something different. Yeah, we do something completely
- 3:30:47different and yeah it's impossible.
- 3:30:49It's already been done. Yeah.
- 3:30:50And you're seeing the same story told and 50 different ways when
- 3:30:55they're all fundamentally doing the same thing and and have some
- 3:30:57point you you've reached the point of diminishing.
- 3:31:00Yeah, right. Adding another retail media
- 3:31:03Network It doesn't add any more value.
- 3:31:06Yeah. It distracts away from the value
- 3:31:09that brands are looking to get you tell media.
- 3:31:12We've had it, it was been called Chopper marketing.
- 3:31:15Yeah, only different and that was the offline world, so you'd
- 3:31:18see in caps and to see you very successful.
- 3:31:20Yeah, very successful, right? People build post strategies
- 3:31:23around the Shelf placement. The place the place that people
- 3:31:27ultimately purchase the product, right?
- 3:31:28Yeah, I've heard some people call that the white glove Mafia.
- 3:31:31That's right. Right.
- 3:31:32Where that I think it was of marketing spin for Skippy G.
- 3:31:35The number that I've heard was that 75 cents of every dollar
- 3:31:38was going towards Chopper marketing and the digital, the
- 3:31:42media space, they're all competing for the ring sets,
- 3:31:44right? So you get digital media, linear
- 3:31:46media all competing for this much smaller share.
- 3:31:49So that's where that's, that's why the brand media dollars.
- 3:31:52Yeah, starting becoming more more because they needed the way
- 3:31:55to get more media spent to get more.
- 3:31:58Yeah. Because Shopper marketing people
- 3:32:01was not agree to this or they will, they will pick the reason
- 3:32:05to disagree, but shop for marketing, was the purest
- 3:32:08performance. Yeah.
- 3:32:09Right Point purchased that was the whole idea.
- 3:32:12Impulse purchase which is Paul cash.
- 3:32:14We Now call lower lower funnel. Yeah, yeah.
- 3:32:16And you could track back with like, hey, we were Nabisco,
- 3:32:20we've made this change or in cap strategy and you know strategy
- 3:32:24and you see the, you know, Consulting increase.
- 3:32:26Not even to the day, you can actually see the skus?
- 3:32:28Yeah. Because you have POS data,
- 3:32:30right? Yeah.
- 3:32:31Somebody scans, it, it goes through.
- 3:32:32You can't live about that, right?
- 3:32:34Yeah. So, that was the purest way of
- 3:32:35doing it now. We've just done that same thing.
- 3:32:39It's called digital storefront. Yeah, still store.
- 3:32:41Yeah, right. You only difference is instead
- 3:32:44of paying Walmart. You are paying Amazon?
- 3:32:46Yeah, and you think there's a fundamental because I've talked
- 3:32:49to some CEOs in the past that had some issues within this.
- 3:32:52Was it by my former company media, radar maps, I had some
- 3:32:55issues with with kind of retail media saying, hey, once you go
- 3:32:59out side of the environment of the e-commerce shop, right?
- 3:33:03You're just doing an extension on it and it's an audience
- 3:33:06extension play. It's pretty great, in the open
- 3:33:08web versus the what you're doing in Commerce.
- 3:33:11Environment is really just Shopper Market.
- 3:33:13That's right, digitized, that's it.
- 3:33:15So, so because remember, it's not just people to me, it's just
- 3:33:18media. Yeah.
- 3:33:19When you go to Amazon, it's just media.
- 3:33:21Yeah, it's product. It's like you go to store
- 3:33:23product placement. Yep.
- 3:33:25Search. It's all the same exact things
- 3:33:27emotion pricing. So, all the same.
- 3:33:29Exactly, the only difference is, you can activate media digitally
- 3:33:33and understand how that it's impacting from Discovery to to
- 3:33:37decisioning in the same environment.
- 3:33:39Yeah, well, yeah, you have a lot more intelligence around what
- 3:33:42the consumers doing, what they might potentially, they're
- 3:33:44preventing to buy something next.
- 3:33:45After they've bought something, which you can't do dynamically,
- 3:33:48and insurance, and plus, and plus your wall, you're in the
- 3:33:52home of Amazon, so Amazon can see everything.
- 3:33:54Yeah. Right.
- 3:33:55So they can calibrate and distribute and be assessed on
- 3:33:59the stand. Right to ensure that you're
- 3:34:02hopefully, getting the best value for your dollar, want you
- 3:34:05expand outside of We call it Commerce media because it's not
- 3:34:09endemic anymore. Yeah, it's not endemic.
- 3:34:11That's not a limit to the, to the, to the retailer.
- 3:34:14Could you sort of financial transaction event?
- 3:34:16You still write first party there?
- 3:34:18Yeah. Well you're absolutely right.
- 3:34:20When people talk about Commerce media, they label the Commerce
- 3:34:24meet you like, okay, what are you using?
- 3:34:26Well CTV. I'm doing some video, I'm doing
- 3:34:28some social, I'm doing some audio.
- 3:34:29So you just doing media. Yeah.
- 3:34:30But they're targeting him off of some sort of ID.
- 3:34:33That's tied. Back to some Behavior within a
- 3:34:35Commerce environment but we've been like we don't do that.
- 3:34:38Any? Yeah, the first party played
- 3:34:42within using somebody's first party data or using some proxy
- 3:34:45of understanding who you should go after verse, that's not new.
- 3:34:48Yeah, what was been what's, what was been really, really
- 3:34:51impactful? Was this notion that you have
- 3:34:53and environment purely focused on retail?
- 3:34:57Yeah. Which was Amazon?
- 3:34:58Yeah, it was Walmart or could be Target too, right.
- 3:35:00But now you have all these other players, you know, Chase which
- 3:35:04is interesting those, those are what I would call Commerce.
- 3:35:07Media players. Yeah.
- 3:35:08What is a bank have to do with with placing company?
- 3:35:13Yeah. So so they have they have a
- 3:35:16Commerce Media or from Chase Media Solutions?
- 3:35:18Yeah. So does it feel?
- 3:35:19But they're not selling anything.
- 3:35:21Yeah, you still? I mean, so I looked at I looked
- 3:35:23at what other than targetable sort of sit atomized data,
- 3:35:27right? So you can Target these people
- 3:35:29based on their purchase Behavior, without tying it back
- 3:35:31to pii which is an advantage, right?
- 3:35:34Which is and she says that's true Commerce media.
- 3:35:37So I would say that that to me, true retail I Define commerce
- 3:35:41media as transaction. Yeah, that's the way it is,
- 3:35:44right? It was always, it was always
- 3:35:45this notion of communication to Commerce.
- 3:35:46Yeah. I communicate, I can see it.
- 3:35:48That was always been the goal that was always be the goal of
- 3:35:51what we do in marketing. Yeah.
- 3:35:52Incrementality in driving commercial transaction.
- 3:35:55Yeah, right. Yeah, I can understand the
- 3:35:57Amazon store. I can understand Walmart story.
- 3:36:00And then the target, hey, I can even send the Home Depot store.
- 3:36:02Yeah, I get it, cuz they, yeah. And you're talking about from a
- 3:36:06attribution perspective, as well, right?
- 3:36:07They've been exposed X. They know what we control.
- 3:36:09The point that we try that entire flow.
- 3:36:12So all the way through the point.
- 3:36:13Yeah. Somebody like you got something
- 3:36:15like a Chase or Delta. Yeah.
- 3:36:16What did they sell? Just not selling anything.
- 3:36:19Yes. As far as I know, Yeah, but but
- 3:36:20they become an ableism. Now what Commerce media has
- 3:36:23become is this notion is a, I have all these audiences.
- 3:36:27Yeah, right. That are coming to my business.
- 3:36:29I'm a Chase, customer go in, but I have this understanding.
- 3:36:32So if you want to sell Financial products or you want to sell
- 3:36:36automobiles or you want to whatever, right?
- 3:36:39We have this great piece of information which are you should
- 3:36:43drive that outcomes from a targeting perspective and an
- 3:36:46intent and engagement perspective.
- 3:36:47But is it a tributable like, like retail idiots?
- 3:36:51Um, if you have the right way to if you were having the right,
- 3:36:56Connecting mechanism. Yes.
- 3:36:58Yes. So you're going to have to have
- 3:36:59something that enables you to take multiple data sets that are
- 3:37:03not necessarily common and you figure out a comment in this day
- 3:37:07and age that's a hard clean room with something like that.
- 3:37:10Yeah I say something like that because the clean rooms are
- 3:37:13starting to kind of not really do what they were.
- 3:37:16What they were supposed to be. Yeah.
- 3:37:17So but you need something like that, where you're not
- 3:37:20disclosing information. Yeah.
- 3:37:22Because you don't want to chase to say, look, look at all the
- 3:37:25stuff that you know, about our customers.
- 3:37:26Yeah, right. Or prospects the other one
- 3:37:28doesn't want to do the same thing but they want to
- 3:37:30understand that their data plus this data actually created a
- 3:37:32better relationship. Yeah.
- 3:37:33So you need something like that, that's unbiased.
- 3:37:35Yeah, and it because I've heard some Commerce media people.
- 3:37:38It was it at a beet Retreat of the Berkshires.
- 3:37:40For example, they were coming at one of the big advantages of
- 3:37:43Commerce. Meaning it was, this sort of,
- 3:37:44kind of a persistent, um, purchase ID, right related to
- 3:37:50some sort of financial transaction, right, let's say
- 3:37:53it's a big door Dash or whatever it might be.
- 3:37:56That gives them a greater view through the path to purchase,
- 3:37:59right? And I would say that to me is an
- 3:38:01argument for retail me, right? But not necessarily for Commerce
- 3:38:05me without some pretty hefty data science, right?
- 3:38:08And some kind of a trap a whether or not it droves
- 3:38:11correct. Any sort of lift during the idea
- 3:38:14is if you're trying to find, A certain type of population,
- 3:38:21right? Higher household income is or
- 3:38:25you're trying to steal, sort of be a vase trying, which is
- 3:38:28weird, right? So Bank of America is trying to
- 3:38:30take take customers They can use Chase.
- 3:38:35Media. Yeah.
- 3:38:36Right to Target, right? Yeah.
- 3:38:37It's weird thing, right? You like, so that I understand
- 3:38:40when you're trying to go specifically to a vertical.
- 3:38:42Yeah, Delta whoever it is, right?
- 3:38:44It has this capability to say, look, You can Target these
- 3:38:50people inside Amazon. Yeah.
- 3:38:52Okay. And you don't necessarily have
- 3:38:55to get them to buy something, the idea is to have them
- 3:38:58purchase something. Yeah, right somewhere else.
- 3:39:00So if you're Target population has these types of Profile.
- 3:39:05Yeah. And which is the purchase
- 3:39:07propensity of some sort. It's not.
- 3:39:08So you and I are not just one dimension.
- 3:39:10Yeah, he's customized. This type of car I tried.
- 3:39:13I love this, right. So we're all very
- 3:39:14multi-dimensional on it. Yeah.
- 3:39:16The whole idea of what Commerce media was is to say this data
- 3:39:20exists. Yeah.
- 3:39:21In places. Now they have have realized that
- 3:39:24they are sitting on valuable information.
- 3:39:27Yeah. That might be predictive of
- 3:39:31intent of purchase. And so now, let's I think this
- 3:39:34is a good to AI, like in you've had a lot of you are on our
- 3:39:37podcast, and if you haven't listened to the podcast George,
- 3:39:40it's phenomenal. It was released a couple of
- 3:39:42weeks ago. Um, you've had some issue with a
- 3:39:45lot of the height, a lot of the smoke and mirrors around High,
- 3:39:48you know, coming from data, science background, right?
- 3:39:50You know, how machine learning work 20 years ago and how it's
- 3:39:54working today. Um, you know, like how much
- 3:39:57better we getting it applying AI in a way that is predictive of
- 3:40:02intent of purchase Behavior to Ensure that we're not being
- 3:40:05followed around the web with something that you already
- 3:40:07purchased with things to be persistent problem.
- 3:40:09Retargeting sort of created it but it doesn't seem to have
- 3:40:12cured itself. Yeah, where do you see that us
- 3:40:15now the story, The propensity modeling aspect, right?
- 3:40:20Look at behavioral modeling, look at psychographic modeling.
- 3:40:25Look at all those types of things that give you a better
- 3:40:27sense that this person is in the Market at some point.
- 3:40:31Yeah timing. Yeah, right.
- 3:40:34And you should, you should communicate to them.
- 3:40:36Yeah. We've been doing a long time.
- 3:40:39Yeah. Even we did that even before.
- 3:40:41Digital APG was was exactly on that premise.
- 3:40:44Yeah, right. Zero to one, one to two to
- 3:40:47three. Yeah, those those are called
- 3:40:50propensity models. Yeah.
- 3:40:51Trial conversion loyalty. Yeah.
- 3:40:54So so yeah, tremendous amount of history on the standing, how to
- 3:40:58do that, digital came and said, well, we can do that better.
- 3:41:01Yeah. Okay, great because we have more
- 3:41:02signals, we have more Rick. So then it became well we can do
- 3:41:05that in real time and the reality is most of that shit is
- 3:41:08not sense. Yeah.
- 3:41:08Yeah. It's not.
- 3:41:09And that was, that's been a clean and sort of AD tech
- 3:41:12martech for a very long time. So it's real time x, you can
- 3:41:14Instantly respond to Consumer, but I'm still being followed
- 3:41:17around with an ad for a product that I purchased already.
- 3:41:20So means underlying data. So by definition, by definition,
- 3:41:24that is for right? So I am and it still happens to
- 3:41:27this day right? When you buy a product and then
- 3:41:30that same company communicates trying to Value the same exact
- 3:41:32product. You just bought.
- 3:41:33Yeah. And you're like I don't
- 3:41:34understand. Yeah.
- 3:41:35I'm not gonna buy the same thing.
- 3:41:36I just bought two days. Yeah I'm gonna do that.
- 3:41:37So that tells you inherently that that there is no such thing
- 3:41:41yet. Maybe they are pockets of it.
- 3:41:43No. Such thing as truly.
- 3:41:46Seeing on the stand we calibrating and then adjust it.
- 3:41:49Yeah. Now ai has the ability to
- 3:41:54address that. In in going.
- 3:41:57And then the ongoing. Yeah, has it to date.
- 3:42:01So the hype of what people say they're using and say they're
- 3:42:06doing is a lot of smoke and mirrors.
- 3:42:09Yeah. Right.
- 3:42:09Because that was the point. You made, you made that, right?
- 3:42:11That it's not. There.
- 3:42:12There are a lot of broken use cases.
- 3:42:14A lot of like almost prototype tanker use cases.
- 3:42:16Which exactly. That there are a lot of
- 3:42:17prototypical things that people are doing that are trying to
- 3:42:22extrapolate out that they were successful and the reality that
- 3:42:24they're not. Yeah, there's only I've in the
- 3:42:27years that I've been doing this and probably in the last two or
- 3:42:30three years. I've been focused on trying to
- 3:42:31identify true applications of AI true apply.
- 3:42:34Yeah, when I buy that is, it has been vetted.
- 3:42:38It has been implemented in real world and I can see it and trace
- 3:42:42it on the standing with the statistically significant
- 3:42:45sample, you know, this is so and I've, yeah, maybe I have come
- 3:42:49across A handful of companies, right?
- 3:42:52Yeah, I can say, have our truly applications of AI.
- 3:42:56Yeah, Matt says, is one of them right?
- 3:42:58Which is, which is why I am Um I Have No Reservations about
- 3:43:03attaching my name to a company because I do.
- 3:43:06Yeah, the vast majority of time to an AI company doing here, you
- 3:43:09think is in. And so let's let's pivot to
- 3:43:11that. That's a good pivot and not to
- 3:43:12shill a mad sense, but you are here on the, on the back, but
- 3:43:15know what you described, which really stuck with me.
- 3:43:17And I started sort of incorporating into my own
- 3:43:20thinking, was this notion of temporal intelligence, correct
- 3:43:24of how Brands to properly use AI.
- 3:43:27I should be using it as sort of a Memory Center that spans time,
- 3:43:31right? So that you can, you know, it's
- 3:43:33been, it's time. And it also spans people because
- 3:43:35if a person leaves an organization, there's not in
- 3:43:39today's world or in yesterday's world, there's a brain drain.
- 3:43:42That's right. And they're Intel, they're all
- 3:43:44spread out in a 1000 different places email chains folder
- 3:43:48systems, none of which is actionable or usable, right?
- 3:43:52Not into the extent that organization's when they
- 3:43:55entered, you look at them like you gotta be kidding.
- 3:43:58Yeah, so it kind of brings up the notion of organizations
- 3:44:03Enterprise is using AI to build IP that stands the test of time,
- 3:44:08right? And they can point use it to
- 3:44:10point back to decisions. They've made in the past.
- 3:44:12Yeah, traceability. So tell me about that because
- 3:44:15that's doing some really interesting things in terms of
- 3:44:17what's going on in the comments, the application.
- 3:44:19So I will tell you that if everybody has access to the same
- 3:44:23AI, Right. What's the competitive
- 3:44:25differentiation? Yeah, it's not Oddity, right?
- 3:44:28Yeah, so no. So people will say, no, I have
- 3:44:30everybody's access the same. Yeah.
- 3:44:32Everybody's using the same AI called?
- 3:44:35Yeah. Open are everybody's using that,
- 3:44:37right? So, they're giving up their most
- 3:44:39important thing which is IP. Yeah, choose something that they
- 3:44:42will never give a back to them. Yeah, that's true.
- 3:44:44Okay. And you're in your trade, you
- 3:44:45know, and if it's publicly available publicly available
- 3:44:47your training the model. Yeah.
- 3:44:50But they call World models. Yeah.
- 3:44:51And it's not cool your model. Yeah.
- 3:44:53Right. That's the big difference right?
- 3:44:54Yeah. Well it's a world model in that
- 3:44:56doesn't frighten. You you're giving your data with
- 3:44:58somebody else's data. Right?
- 3:45:00Did I looting it? Connect your learning more about
- 3:45:02you you will never learn. Yeah, you should never do it.
- 3:45:05Why would you do that? Because you have, you have an
- 3:45:07ability to actually do it the right way.
- 3:45:09Yeah, so when you look at What is the right way?
- 3:45:13So if that is the truth, the thesis saying, if everybody had
- 3:45:16access the same AI, what is true competitive from intuition?
- 3:45:19Yeah, it has to be cognitive capital.
- 3:45:22That is the most unbeatable last asset.
- 3:45:24Well, it is the most critically important in modern marketing
- 3:45:28today. Yeah, right.
- 3:45:30Cognitive Capital. Yeah.
- 3:45:31What sits which are the brain power behind the organization?
- 3:45:35So people say well, I give it data.
- 3:45:38Here. But that's not the point.
- 3:45:40The data is not the important is the context of that data.
- 3:45:43Yeah. Which the only way you have
- 3:45:45meaning context is meaning. Yeah.
- 3:45:46Right is from people's heads. Yeah.
- 3:45:49Right. So if you're not encoding that
- 3:45:52into something. Yeah.
- 3:45:53Right. That is yours your and all yours
- 3:45:56that you have. No AI.
- 3:45:58It's an awesome. Because how do you get
- 3:46:00artificial intelligence? The only way you can craft
- 3:46:02intelligence is when you've already encoded your human
- 3:46:05expertise and institutional knowledge.
- 3:46:07Yeah. In a system.
- 3:46:08Yeah. That has learned over time how
- 3:46:10you think, how you behave? How you learn how you reason?
- 3:46:13Yeah, make decisions how you trade off.
- 3:46:15Yeah, and it's how human beings evolved right now.
- 3:46:17Not only culturally learning and what's being passed down from
- 3:46:20Generations but at the genomic, correct.
- 3:46:22Right. Which is which stuff that's
- 3:46:24encoded in the brains from generation paths.
- 3:46:27They're not like, yeah, it's almost like if you ever want to
- 3:46:29get to AGI which sounds like today, nobody's even close
- 3:46:33people say they are too, in coding.
- 3:46:35This type of cognitive sort of, you know, Intelligence.
- 3:46:38That's what you need to get to. Yeah, so this is again, I the
- 3:46:43reason I got excited in the attracted to Madison is the
- 3:46:47their focus was exactly on this, right?
- 3:46:50Yeah, is encoding. What makes a business unique,
- 3:46:55the business genome the intellectual DNA of an
- 3:46:57organization. Yeah, that is true, IP.
- 3:47:00Yeah. That is once you have that
- 3:47:01inside a system and that the organization has reconditioned
- 3:47:06themselves to work, In a system like that.
- 3:47:09Yeah, there is no amount of money that exists in the world
- 3:47:12can replicate that. Yes.
- 3:47:13Unrequited that it's impossible to copy.
- 3:47:16Yeah. That is true differentiate,
- 3:47:18right? Well, how do you get people to
- 3:47:19buy into this? I mean people using it and
- 3:47:22putting their information into it.
- 3:47:24How does how does meds and sort of manage that?
- 3:47:26The interesting part is the industry has done the hard work
- 3:47:29for a company like yeah because every older Reports say the same
- 3:47:33exact thing everybody spends. It's not a question of spending
- 3:47:36money. Free 4850 billion dollars.
- 3:47:38Have been spent already into AI. Yeah, Enterprise 97% people will
- 3:47:43say, it's like Over 95%. Probably close at the 98% half
- 3:47:47fail. Yeah.
- 3:47:48Why. Because they're trying to do
- 3:47:51what I just described. What?
- 3:47:53What open? Models.
- 3:47:55Yeah. Horizontal models Which models
- 3:47:57by Design are meant to be consumer-facing, not business.
- 3:48:01Yeah. Right.
- 3:48:02And then it doesn't work. Exactly.
- 3:48:04So you just proved the thesis, it doesn't work because they're
- 3:48:07not meant to do what you're trying to get them through.
- 3:48:09Yeah, there is no amount of money that you're going to give
- 3:48:11these guys. By the way.
- 3:48:12It will require tens of millions of dollars to get open AI to try
- 3:48:16to build something. That would be spoke to you, but
- 3:48:18don't want to do that. Yeah, that's not their business.
- 3:48:20Yeah, it seems like the whole industry is moving towards
- 3:48:22multi-model and and developing sort of proprietary agent, super
- 3:48:27agents, the Hermes the open Clause to be able to, hey we're
- 3:48:30gonna use models for compute and for decision and for problem
- 3:48:33solving, but we're gonna have this independent thing, that's
- 3:48:35building a memory system. That's building a soul.
- 3:48:38That's an interesting turn that came up relatively recently and
- 3:48:41I was like, what is the soul? And you ask a tech person.
- 3:48:44And and what they're saying it's really you're you're sort of how
- 3:48:47this this AI should be. That's right.
- 3:48:49And the rules and sort of the the guide book.
- 3:48:52It's not the semantic layer person but It's not know.
- 3:48:55So when you have in an AI system, a true specialized AI
- 3:48:59system built on the DNA of organization, right?
- 3:49:03The DNA of an organization? It takes time think about an
- 3:49:07organization has been around 50 years.
- 3:49:09Yeah, 100 years You think you're going to take an off-the-shelf
- 3:49:13AI or an agent and say we're an AI company?
- 3:49:15Yeah, it doesn't work. Yeah.
- 3:49:16And suddenly yeah, yeah, design their category design.
- 3:49:19They're sort of competitors. Who is that price?
- 3:49:22Yeah it you know to do 50 to 100 years worth of knowledge.
- 3:49:25Yeah in a week that's impossible.
- 3:49:27It's that notion of like over the course of time.
- 3:49:31Yeah it has a compounding effect.
- 3:49:33It has well that that's the beauty, right?
- 3:49:35So once you once you've trained and fine-tuned the AI To your
- 3:49:41organization. Yeah, right.
- 3:49:43The soul aspect, what makes you you right?
- 3:49:45Yeah. Because remember the
- 3:49:46organization that can be company values, Rules of Engagement.
- 3:49:49So it's all the business physics.
- 3:49:53Yeah. So remember it's human expertise
- 3:49:55institution on knowledge but also all the other things,
- 3:49:58right? What you can say, what you can't
- 3:50:00say when you can say it. Like product pricing, all.
- 3:50:02Yes, things. That's all proprietary.
- 3:50:04Yeah. Right so we have what matters
- 3:50:07has to build to do is extract all that Build the initial
- 3:50:12Foundation. Work with the teams because
- 3:50:16that's the other thing where companies like mad sense, has
- 3:50:18figured out is, it should never be a SAS business.
- 3:50:20Yeah, right. Most of these companies.
- 3:50:22Good luck. Here you go.
- 3:50:23Good luck. And you're like, what am I gonna
- 3:50:26do this? So education and knowledge as
- 3:50:28you as you know, right are probably the biggest barriers,
- 3:50:31the true AI application. Yeah.
- 3:50:34So mad. Since works.
- 3:50:35These companies to really recondition them how to think
- 3:50:39about AI, how to institutionalize, a, how do you
- 3:50:41retrain your people to work and think and reason in a system.
- 3:50:46Yep, right. Yeah.
- 3:50:47And it's not just a tool, it's IP.
- 3:50:50It's fundamentally. It's gotta be more operating
- 3:50:53model. Yeah.
- 3:50:53For right. Yeah.
- 3:50:54After time, Right. It learns it on the stands.
- 3:50:58It starts making connections. It starts reinforcing it starts.
- 3:51:01The siding, it starts challenging you and it's getting
- 3:51:04more and more accurate as accuracy 100%, right?
- 3:51:07You have less less error rate. I say over pureed time, then I
- 3:51:14would make the claim they have artificial intelligence because
- 3:51:18now, so the business has artificial intelligence because
- 3:51:21yeah, the AI has learned, right? This thing that makes the
- 3:51:24business. The salt the business.
- 3:51:26Yeah. And you're seeing the exact
- 3:51:28attracted to say, I use co-pilot, I use XYZ, right?
- 3:51:31That's not artificial. Intelligence in the true sense.
- 3:51:34No. So when people claim that people
- 3:51:36don't realize what it takes to create artificial intense,
- 3:51:40right? That will immersive building a
- 3:51:43soul, it's building, but it's a judgment capture all that.
- 3:51:45Yeah, that information. That makes who you are, you?
- 3:51:48Alright? And then realize that you're
- 3:51:50going to be transitory employees, that transitory, you
- 3:51:54gonna have more employees, come in and out.
- 3:51:56Yeah? Right?
- 3:51:56Yeah. When you have a system like
- 3:51:58this, that is no longer, um, things that will hurt your
- 3:52:02business. Yeah, you have no memory.
- 3:52:03It's, it's risk reduction. That's from an organizational.
- 3:52:05That's right. So now you have the uniqueness
- 3:52:08of being a true. Enterprise intelligence
- 3:52:11organization, where the Enterprise benefits from the
- 3:52:14collective. Yeah.
- 3:52:15Well, you've heard it here. I mean we've been we've been
- 3:52:17talking for a while but I think George just redefined artificial
- 3:52:21intelligence for organizations. Don't give a true definition and
- 3:52:24I honestly agree with that. 100% that that's how you have to
- 3:52:27think about this. You're building memory system,
- 3:52:29You're Building IP and it stands the test of time, but thank you
- 3:52:33for joining it. It's a little warm out here.
- 3:52:35We're up on top of roof deck, with an infinity pool, a little
- 3:52:39far away from us but this has been a pleasure.
- 3:52:43George It's day two possible, Miami 2026 with Adam Woods, the
- 3:52:52new Chief product officer of incubator right?
- 3:52:54Which is an international agency.
- 3:52:56Independent agency is but not for a while performance in the
- 3:53:00agency been around for many years.
- 3:53:01Yeah and we were both just commenting on how neither one of
- 3:53:04us has been doing single piece of content.
- 3:53:06I've been producing a lot of cuts, yes, but I have been to
- 3:53:10any content. Nowhere to go.
- 3:53:12I've walked by another car. There's a conference now.
- 3:53:14Yeah, there's a conference down there but we're up on a
- 3:53:17beautiful about you and Adam and I have gotten to know each other
- 3:53:20a little bit of the last couple of weeks.
- 3:53:21And you know what I kind of was thinking about, as I was
- 3:53:23walking, halfway across the possibly Universe, the
- 3:53:26Fontainebleau University to get coffee for us, was that you've
- 3:53:29just shared a lot of really interesting input around the
- 3:53:34product life cycle, and building in how it's transformed.
- 3:53:36You is sort of a product leader. Yeah?
- 3:53:39Right. And maybe give the audience a
- 3:53:41little background of where you kind of came from.
- 3:53:43But I think that'll lead into this the story that you've told
- 3:53:46me about its News story. It's not like something you've
- 3:53:49been working on for five years old Brenda.
- 3:53:51Yeah and that you've done, add incubated in terms of kind of
- 3:53:54completely re-platforming, new organization building, an
- 3:53:57operating system kind of from the ground up, right?
- 3:54:00Integrating Point solutions, architecting from the ground up
- 3:54:03and doing it in this incredible short period of time which you
- 3:54:06know, not just prototype. But actual stuff that can be
- 3:54:09delivered to clients in production in production
- 3:54:11production. Which is a big difference.
- 3:54:13Yeah, yeah. So so I guess give the audience
- 3:54:16a little bit of your background, right?
- 3:54:18And then and then I think let's talk about that because I think
- 3:54:21you get some real interesting insights to see from a few
- 3:54:23technical. Person know.
- 3:54:25Yes. So it's been about 10 years wpp.
- 3:54:28Did the holding company kind of the the tour that you must
- 3:54:32absolutely love to get to build some really amazing things.
- 3:54:34I was wondering about Thompson data so, you know, normal title
- 3:54:38a normal title. Yeah.
- 3:54:39Like a certain way, right? Like I build a date and identity
- 3:54:46spine, the At the peak of it was projected across like a good
- 3:54:50chunk of the world. Yeah.
- 3:54:51And and, you know, like, I think about those times with building
- 3:54:55that and it was, you know, a significantly different
- 3:54:58approach. Yeah.
- 3:54:59Like we had to kind of design things and then prototype and it
- 3:55:03was you know, once you got to the place where you're like,
- 3:55:05okay now I've got an engineer it and really take it all the way
- 3:55:08through. You know, you start hiring
- 3:55:10developers and you have to do UI and and yeah you make really
- 3:55:13considered moves, right? Yeah.
- 3:55:15And and there's always been this kind of like the there's a
- 3:55:18moment in time when when the size of your bet dictates your
- 3:55:21action. Yeah, right.
- 3:55:22That's a really good point. So yeah.
- 3:55:24So you know, when I hear the group early on it was like, you
- 3:55:27know, if I have to make a million two million dollar bet
- 3:55:30on something, I have to really think about it.
- 3:55:32Yeah and and so then you know what's really fascinating in the
- 3:55:36world today is we can build things at a place that like has
- 3:55:40never been acceptable to us. Like it's, it's literally brand
- 3:55:43new. Yeah.
- 3:55:44Like it doesn't, you know, this isn't something that existed.
- 3:55:47Six months, 12 months. Yeah.
- 3:55:49A few months ago like which is when you think about those that
- 3:55:51time, Months ago. Yes.
- 3:55:54Yeah, exactly. Like like six months ago I could
- 3:55:57Vibe code something pretty interesting.
- 3:55:59Yeah, right. Yeah, the the would fall down as
- 3:56:03soon as it was really ready to start scaling.
- 3:56:05Yeah. Right.
- 3:56:06That's a classic sort of prototype model.
- 3:56:07They really need to bring in a team of Engineers to sort of
- 3:56:10build out like hard coat this. And, and, and you could, you
- 3:56:14know, it's, it was already an interesting unlocked as a
- 3:56:16product person because now you can prototype things that are
- 3:56:19more real, right? Yeah.
- 3:56:20So, it's like, I'm less than figma.
- 3:56:22I'm more just actually working an idea.
- 3:56:24Yeah. An MVP, exactly right.
- 3:56:28Maybe not quite beta, or would you even say that what we were
- 3:56:34doing, you know, call it like, a year ago?
- 3:56:36Yeah, right. And, and so, then, you know, I
- 3:56:40was kind of in between and really wanted to push how far
- 3:56:44personally I could take AI, right?
- 3:56:47And so, it was all the kind of things you hear people talking
- 3:56:49about the knowledge graph, get your, you know, you're, you're
- 3:56:54Twin right, like you and and you know, like start really getting
- 3:57:00to place the the, you know, like I used it in every aspect of the
- 3:57:04business that I was doing. Right.
- 3:57:05So I just did a consultant. Physical says the consultant.
- 3:57:08Yeah, and that's when you really started.
- 3:57:09Kind of getting how do I build like yeah he product level
- 3:57:13stuff. Exactly.
- 3:57:14What is very new stuff. Exactly.
- 3:57:16And so yeah walk us through that like to hear it because I'm
- 3:57:19certainly experiment. You're more of a tech.
- 3:57:21Yeah. So from birth?
- 3:57:24Yeah, I'm getting I don't suppose democratized.
- 3:57:27Yeah, like me, right? I don't get involved and
- 3:57:30actually start to productionize stuff it's just but it's more a
- 3:57:33ginger workflows and advanced. It flows tell me how you started
- 3:57:36thinking, so what starts to get interesting.
- 3:57:39And I think less about what I was doing in dependently and
- 3:57:41more as a commanding, you yeah. Is so we've been able to
- 3:57:47essentially build a new version of our platform.
- 3:57:51From like, from the ground up. Yeah, right.
- 3:57:54Like like, we took all of the interesting points solutions
- 3:57:57that we have and all of the great like data science and
- 3:58:00algorithms and bidding and optimization that we can do that
- 3:58:04provide a ton of value, right? Like and these all lived in
- 3:58:07different blue eyes, they look like, yes, right?
- 3:58:10So the data was, you know, each solution was kind of
- 3:58:14self-contained. Yeah, right.
- 3:58:15Yeah. And so you know, you look at
- 3:58:17that, you say, okay, actually, what I really want is, I want a
- 3:58:21essentially like a data architecture that allows a brand
- 3:58:26to unify all of their data. Yep.
- 3:58:28Alright. Bring all of your marketing
- 3:58:30data, your inventory or you know, supply chain data.
- 3:58:33Yeah. Yeah.
- 3:58:34And then Infuse that with you know your Frameworks and the
- 3:58:39things that make your business. Distinct.
- 3:58:40Yeah. And then have that as the basis
- 3:58:43of the platform. Yeah.
- 3:58:45And the Frameworks would give it sort of the that's like, almost
- 3:58:48like it's like, it's Is it the soul?
- 3:58:53Is it the is it say? Yeah.
- 3:58:54It's it's it's a combination of like markdown files and rag
- 3:58:58architecture and being able to do things inside of bigquery and
- 3:59:03and there's, you know, there's more to it than just markdown
- 3:59:05files. Yeah.
- 3:59:06But at the end of the day it's it's infusing what we're doing
- 3:59:10with marketing and advertising with all of the interesting body
- 3:59:14of work that exists inside of any organization.
- 3:59:16So like yeah how do they talk about themselves?
- 3:59:18What is their voice look like what are the rfps they've done
- 3:59:21with it. So like temporal intelligence,
- 3:59:24right? That's like this over course of
- 3:59:26time. Yeah, it client might be 50
- 3:59:28years old. 100 years old. How do you actually capture that
- 3:59:31stuff as part of like the memory training system, right?
- 3:59:33Yeah, yeah. And then use that to be able to
- 3:59:36power experiences that are, you know, a gentle in nature but
- 3:59:41also more about like, how do you actually help somebody solve
- 3:59:45their true business challenge? Right?
- 3:59:47I mean, yeah, the end of the day like at the end of the day, it's
- 3:59:50you know, like like When we look at marketing, when we look at
- 3:59:52advertising, it is, you know, almost always, if not always in
- 3:59:57service of breadth, right? Like ambitious Brands, come to
- 4:00:00us and are looking for ways to grow to find in your mentality
- 4:00:03to find an edge. Yeah.
- 4:00:05And and so, you know, part of that edge lives outside of that
- 4:00:09system, but a lot of that edge is inside of the, you know, the
- 4:00:13like amazing work that they've done.
- 4:00:15Yeah. And the incredibly smart people
- 4:00:16that they work with and have inside of their organization and
- 4:00:19so, and so, are you bringing that within the within the
- 4:00:22agency, because isn't that the fundamental IP that lives within
- 4:00:26the brand itself and they just not collected in a master's in a
- 4:00:30way that centralized it's on the back, right?
- 4:00:33But and this is where you have to be brand where they're at,
- 4:00:36right? Some of them are really far
- 4:00:38along. Yeah.
- 4:00:38And some of them are very early in the journey.
- 4:00:40Yeah. And then they need wildly
- 4:00:42different things. And, you know, the other thing
- 4:00:44that I think that is is interesting that we've really
- 4:00:48unlocked and again, this the speed that we can move at Is
- 4:00:52when we can bring applications to their data, then I don't have
- 4:00:55to go to a brand and ask them. Hey, I'm gonna like do APA with
- 4:01:00you and you're gonna process all of your stuff through yacht,
- 4:01:03right? Which is sort of a data movement
- 4:01:05problems that problem. They've got to bring data out of
- 4:01:08their platform because, yeah, I know, the wise, right?
- 4:01:11You want to be able to plug into drinking system that can be
- 4:01:13their native Cloud ecosystem. It could be any of that.
- 4:01:16Yeah, 100%. So if you build this this in,
- 4:01:19and I'd love to describe sort of how you platformed you
- 4:01:22architected this platform and what it does.
- 4:01:24But if you build it for kind of modularization shows.
- 4:01:27Absolutely right. So it can be used in plugged
- 4:01:29into almost like composable. Yeah, but but we'll probably for
- 4:01:37the brand. Okay.
- 4:01:38Right. So like you know, less about
- 4:01:41forcing them into my work. Yeah.
- 4:01:43You have to adapt to another Point solution, right?
- 4:01:46Relax. Exactly.
- 4:01:47Exactly like like this business and turn it on his head.
- 4:01:51Right. Yeah.
- 4:01:51It's like I actually don't want you to adapt to my model.
- 4:01:55I want to take my infrastructure in our approach and then adapted
- 4:02:00to your unique business challenge.
- 4:02:02Yeah. And it seems like composable is
- 4:02:03sort of the start of the right. Like, it was pushing in that
- 4:02:06direction, you know, like, in advance of what we've seen in
- 4:02:09terms of the rapid gentrification of technology.
- 4:02:11And and I think you make a really good point about SAS is
- 4:02:14that is, it is sort of it's a paradigm shift for those and and
- 4:02:17SAS companies are under threat and challenge because they have
- 4:02:20to, they have to reflect for just, just throw them on all the
- 4:02:24success platform off the guy and re-architect and rebuild and so
- 4:02:27it sounds like you, you kind of rebuilt the architecture from
- 4:02:30scratches that with help with help just with the Gypsy Outlets
- 4:02:35but a jumps are open architectural help, right?
- 4:02:37Like there's there's still a very strong need for engineering
- 4:02:41for designs. Yes.
- 4:02:42For you know, the ability to look at something and say, yeah,
- 4:02:45it's good, it's designed it, right?
- 4:02:49But but you know, When you start to get to a place that you're
- 4:02:53looking at, like, okay, now, how am I going to scale this?
- 4:02:55Yeah. Like, does it really stand up
- 4:02:57and is it, you know, is it secure and can I audit it for
- 4:03:01security, right? Like these are the things where,
- 4:03:03where what you really want to find is like, you are, you know,
- 4:03:06the subject matter experts getting them paired with really
- 4:03:10high quality, engineering and architecture.
- 4:03:12Yep. And and then using a Gentech for
- 4:03:15Speed, right? Yeah, it doesn't replace either
- 4:03:17of the two of like the knowledge of what we do and the knowledge
- 4:03:22of how to make things, scalable and secure.
- 4:03:24Yeah, it just lets you go that much faster and and move things
- 4:03:29with you, right? And as long as you've got right
- 4:03:32when and you know if you're people has different
- 4:03:35applications right here, are people made mean that I can do
- 4:03:39the same job in, you know, half the time.
- 4:03:42And then I'm gonna just take on more work because we're gonna
- 4:03:45grow that much faster. Yeah.
- 4:03:46Right by. Yeah.
- 4:03:47So it's a really positioning Where you're applying you're
- 4:03:52doing. Like it's how do you innovate in
- 4:03:55the you know take your organization. 2x 3x.
- 4:03:59Yes the page. Yes and income.
- 4:04:02The value becomes the ultimate calculation like like yeah we
- 4:04:04don't need to go through these. Remember there's that it was the
- 4:04:06waterfall life cycle so that it was a job Sprints.
- 4:04:09And oftentimes I bumped all those you know I remember I
- 4:04:12remember when I first worked for March 28th job, not really pure.
- 4:04:17I was in which media for that but and I remember I'm saying
- 4:04:20I'm like he is now is the time when I interviewed with them.
- 4:04:22He's like he's like we've got to get out of build mode.
- 4:04:25Yeah. Like now is the time they were
- 4:04:26going from like data Marketplace to data management platform and
- 4:04:30making this transformation into into a space.
- 4:04:32That was now seems old right. But but that it was like
- 4:04:37everybody was just talking audience and and collecting
- 4:04:40cookies, right? And so they were rolling this
- 4:04:42out he's like Now's the Time to act like we can't have any more
- 4:04:45Cycles because we were still in that old software model that
- 4:04:48that's too slow. It just took two years of the
- 4:04:51best engineering talent that it is real to develop this shit.
- 4:04:54Yeah. And and I think that there's,
- 4:04:57you know, there's the moment Right now where, you know, a lot
- 4:05:00of companies and a lot of companies that have, you know,
- 4:05:03like very deep backgrounds of things that they build that
- 4:05:07they've scaled for years. That, you know, at some level
- 4:05:10that actually becomes more of a boat anchor yet, then an
- 4:05:14advantage. Yeah.
- 4:05:14It's holding you back and my last game but I work for.
- 4:05:17I went Independent Media. Radar was facing that same
- 4:05:20problem and they they made a massive Act.
- 4:05:22Was a couple of actors just are, but their SAS platform, they
- 4:05:25quickly. Learned was a monolithic SAS
- 4:05:28platform. Yeah, that was, it would take
- 4:05:29more time and effort to re-architect that and work
- 4:05:32within that it just was out completely.
- 4:05:34Yeah. So they're like scrap the thing.
- 4:05:36All together and rebuild from the ground up and that type of
- 4:05:39decision probably couldn't have been made five years ago,
- 4:05:42because it would take too much time, right?
- 4:05:44Like, a lot of people will even struggle today, right now.
- 4:05:49With with making that decision, right?
- 4:05:52Like, you know, you think about I've put millions of dollars
- 4:05:55into something. I'm very proud of it.
- 4:05:57I'm cost, it's all the cost problem, right?
- 4:06:00And and so you know, you look at that and you say like, you know
- 4:06:03sure yes like a lot of people will have the will to go do
- 4:06:07this. Yeah, some people will not write
- 4:06:10and the people that have said that hold it close to see that.
- 4:06:14Yeah. Dedicated times of their life,
- 4:06:16they're almost like and and even like, you know, one of the
- 4:06:20things and I talked about this a little bit.
- 4:06:22It's like I've had to adopt like very different ways of working.
- 4:06:25Yeah. So to do these things and
- 4:06:27that's, and it's, you know, it's challenge, it's transforming
- 4:06:30yourself. But it's also it's you can't
- 4:06:32have amped up for it because you yourself adapted to this change.
- 4:06:35So, but it also took time, right?
- 4:06:37Like, you know, there there were specific about that but he so,
- 4:06:41you know, when when traffic to come out like I could see the
- 4:06:44implications of what this was going to do.
- 4:06:46Yeah. And and there were moments that
- 4:06:49Were as much. But like building, like hoping
- 4:06:51excitement but there was also like a ton of anxiety, right?
- 4:06:54And I think like, it's out there and it's real and people talk
- 4:06:58about it a bit, but I don't know that they talk about it enough,
- 4:07:00which is an exciting from you meeting.
- 4:07:02Like, I need to adapt quickly or anxiety.
- 4:07:04Just for for, for, for me, for my team.
- 4:07:08Yeah. For my family.
- 4:07:09Yeah. Or, you know, the economy for
- 4:07:12the country for the world. But yeah, but it's like 10,000.
- 4:07:17Yeah level of like like these we're going through this massive
- 4:07:22Industrial Level transformation. It's probably the greatest
- 4:07:24transformation industrial transformation in the history of
- 4:07:26humanity. I think it's bigger.
- 4:07:29It's to see when you're it's even beings right here than the
- 4:07:32internet. But yeah, I mean and so I
- 4:07:35thought some of that same pressure.
- 4:07:36It's like maybe not being a technical leader in the past but
- 4:07:39like, say I need to transform myself, right?
- 4:07:42Yes. And then I got involved and I'm
- 4:07:44like, yeah, it's hard, but it's but I, but I'm actually enjoying
- 4:07:47this because it's empowering like you can build stuff, much
- 4:07:50faster. And, and with less dependency
- 4:07:53on, I'd always have to go to other people to build this or
- 4:07:56could we call that? And now I'm like getting my
- 4:07:59hands and dirty, and it's a fascinating transformation
- 4:08:02process. And I think like, you know, the,
- 4:08:04the biggest thing for me is How do you make it?
- 4:08:08Like actually less about me. Yeah.
- 4:08:11Like like it's so like I've had those transformation for myself
- 4:08:15and I know the pace of what I can do.
- 4:08:17Yeah and it's like okay great. I'm locked myself.
- 4:08:20Now, I want to talk about, you know, the next 10 people.
- 4:08:23Yeah. And then how do I take those 10
- 4:08:25people and have them unlock the next hundred and think about,
- 4:08:29like, think about that. That's like the, that's the
- 4:08:32hard, right? I think unlocking yourself.
- 4:08:34Well, you've said a blue? Yeah.
- 4:08:36It's kind of like you're, you're a trainer and it's like, I've
- 4:08:38learned how to physically manage myself.
- 4:08:40Now, I can train other people know how to physically manage
- 4:08:42their lives. Right?
- 4:08:43You know, it's the same sort of thing, so.
- 4:08:45So, as a force multiplier, how, what are your secrets to the,
- 4:08:48what have you had to do within your own teams to?
- 4:08:52Not only unlock and I'll just see where people are lagging or
- 4:08:55resistant to the change. And I think that it's, you know,
- 4:08:58I think the biggest thing is just getting people to work with
- 4:09:02it, showing them a little bit of how to do it.
- 4:09:04Yeah. And how to do it in a more
- 4:09:06structured way, right? Yeah.
- 4:09:07There's and there's a lot of kind of like things that you
- 4:09:10know anybody listening like you should go learn about quad and
- 4:09:13Gemini and extra plugins and like there's there's a
- 4:09:16difference between just doing it and doing it.
- 4:09:18Well yeah and and those are where the Real edges of
- 4:09:21Advantage lie. Yeah but it's it's finding the
- 4:09:24you know finding people that have always felt blocked by
- 4:09:27something. Yeah giving them a tool to go
- 4:09:30explore to see what they could do if they got on blocked and
- 4:09:33then and then you know helping them through those moments of
- 4:09:37learning and then doing that in a like secure way.
- 4:09:41So it's like go do your prototype and you don't have
- 4:09:44access to customer data yet, right?
- 4:09:46Yeah. Like don't get your agent
- 4:09:48anywhere near a production environment.
- 4:09:50Yeah. Right.
- 4:09:52But there's because you can build synthetic data for a brand
- 4:09:57now and minutes, right? So it's like, so it's like
- 4:10:01developing a and figure all the stuff out and say way.
- 4:10:04And then turn to the people that you can trust that really
- 4:10:08understand the steeply and and use them to help you go do
- 4:10:14things that are that are like truly industrial grade.
- 4:10:16Yeah. And and that's where you know,
- 4:10:18like in and that is where a lot of Our competitive Advantage.
- 4:10:21Flies is because we know the ways to make this industrial
- 4:10:26because we've got a team of people that have built these
- 4:10:29systems that, you know, that our world spanning, that are, that
- 4:10:34are very large, these things, that's the positive part.
- 4:10:35You've got champagne, you've got people that have leaned in,
- 4:10:38where have you seen other change management that around people
- 4:10:41that weren't able to sort of adapt to that?
- 4:10:43That either held on to things that were able to tightly or, or
- 4:10:47engineering teams. Like, you talked about how you
- 4:10:49have an engineering teams, and a whole bunch of different places,
- 4:10:51but you don't necessarily need the FTE low that you had at the
- 4:10:55past. I think that's where and again,
- 4:10:58like I'm too early into this to have the final answer.
- 4:11:01Yeah. They're, you know, do we need
- 4:11:04the same skills? No.
- 4:11:05Right. Like that's clear.
- 4:11:07And so I think that anybody, you know, like anybody that's trying
- 4:11:11to hold on to the way that an engineering job was wrong.
- 4:11:13Yeah. Like five years ago?
- 4:11:15Yeah. It's like you.
- 4:11:17You need to adapt. Yeah.
- 4:11:19Like the Competencies you might understand python or whatever.
- 4:11:23And now just how you app, you implement this to just work for
- 4:11:29sure, thinking security scalability.
- 4:11:30Yeah, yeah, and systems thinking.
- 4:11:33Yes, yeah. I think I think that's good.
- 4:11:35I think you made that point earlier is like, is like the
- 4:11:37Strategic systems thinking oriented roles.
- 4:11:39And we talked about this. A lot of the Pod are sort of
- 4:11:41best Advantage which is unfortunate for the people like
- 4:11:44my kids that's gonna come right out of college, right?
- 4:11:47That doesn't really have the younger people earlier, but
- 4:11:50where if you're bumping in agentic, Workforce under you and
- 4:11:54they're spawning teens and you've got different functions,
- 4:11:57right? You have to kind of know how
- 4:11:59that works. You know how that architected
- 4:12:01from almost a business strategy and functional strategy
- 4:12:04perspective. Yeah, right.
- 4:12:05And when it goes off, the rails you need to be able to see that.
- 4:12:08Yeah. Like and ask the questions and
- 4:12:10interrogate it the right way, put in the wake of government.
- 4:12:12So how do you thought about? Like speaking of I think that's
- 4:12:15how have you thought about governance Frameworks and
- 4:12:17setting up, you know, reducing hallucination.
- 4:12:20And reducing a failure rates, or healthier aerated.
- 4:12:24But it's also, those are, you know, some of the ways that I,
- 4:12:28you know, there there's a difference between just using
- 4:12:31something like Gemini CLI and using it.
- 4:12:33Well, yeah, right. There's a difference between
- 4:12:35quad code and using it at the highest end you possibly can.
- 4:12:38Yeah. And it is the difference of
- 4:12:41pace, right? Like if you're doing really
- 4:12:42structured design that leads you into, you know, good plans that
- 4:12:46you implement with multi-agent kind of like activities inside
- 4:12:50of the way that it's building. Yeah.
- 4:12:51It works a incredibly well and if you're kind of just again
- 4:12:56like Vibe code and you like your 18 that's doing some shit.
- 4:12:59Yeah like turn it around a couple of times.
- 4:13:01Like like that's not where you get to the stuff that I'm
- 4:13:04parked. Yeah yeah.
- 4:13:06So how do you get to the stuff that you're talking to learn?
- 4:13:09You learn. and so, what do you What were this particular
- 4:13:13platform? What is it?
- 4:13:14What do you calling the platform?
- 4:13:15Those famous sweet, this seamless Suite.
- 4:13:17How are you getting? How are you thinking about this
- 4:13:19platform in the larger system of agency people?
- 4:13:22And other Independents platforms operating systems, I know we've
- 4:13:26talked about this I've heard perspectives where from pretty
- 4:13:29senior agency, that's George, can you see who's the guy that
- 4:13:32we had on the spot? A couple of times here as well
- 4:13:34as before he said that there's a lot of operating systems out
- 4:13:37there that are honestly. Point Solutions which you've
- 4:13:40addressed straight with like an AI wrapper.
- 4:13:42They have the true data, integration Tech integration
- 4:13:46memory System rate that starts to capture and encode all of
- 4:13:51that stuff, right? So for better decision and you
- 4:13:54can track it up. Like are you seeing that you
- 4:13:57guys have a role to play in terms of differentiating?
- 4:13:59Those absolutely true. Artificial intelligence supposed
- 4:14:02to sort of, yeah, you know, thank you having built and
- 4:14:06rebuilding it from scratch, right?
- 4:14:08Using all of the great learning that we've got over so many
- 4:14:12years of research write custom making it for the type of
- 4:14:16problems that we see every single day.
- 4:14:18And then and then really leaning into, you know, part of what the
- 4:14:22differentiation of incubated is is, you know?
- 4:14:25It's the service, right? Like we're not out there
- 4:14:28building a self-service platform for you to use.
- 4:14:30Yeah. And they're hoping Brands grow
- 4:14:33their businesses with Ali. Consultative partner?
- 4:14:36Yeah, that works across, you know, across the Entirety of
- 4:14:40their agency staff. Yeah yeah and and I think the
- 4:14:43key part is that from a tech perspective counseling a partner
- 4:14:45but we're actually enabling this within your own ecosystem which
- 4:14:49is going to help you preserve that IP to build it to manage to
- 4:14:52capabilities built, right? So that they've got a mask
- 4:14:55because that's what these companies need.
- 4:14:57They can't, they can't have this fragmented process with multiple
- 4:15:01data warehouses, you know, and you say in-house and I like, I
- 4:15:04don't even know that. That's the right construct,
- 4:15:06right? Like somebody's one of the
- 4:15:08in-house, some Brands want to work with agencies.
- 4:15:10Yeah. Around a work with us as an
- 4:15:12agency. Some Brands actually work with
- 4:15:15us as one of many agencies. Yeah.
- 4:15:17So it's like it's like find where you produce value and go
- 4:15:21back to myself that. Yeah right.
- 4:15:23And thinking more of like like plugging into their architecture
- 4:15:26as a rip and release on. Yeah versus or forcing them to
- 4:15:31come into your environment to do everything right?
- 4:15:34Which is just another platform that might be 50 or 60.
- 4:15:37They kind of use that. Log into and learn.
- 4:15:40It's like let them operate where they're gonna sew.
- 4:15:43So, what else, what like, what have you heard here at possible?
- 4:15:46And I know we're baking. And we're son.
- 4:15:48Yeah, we're probably gonna have to retire to come up, but we'll
- 4:15:54finish this with, like, final. Thoughts of you've had a lot of
- 4:15:56conversations here, obviously, there's a ton of talk about AI,
- 4:15:59you are on the front lines of something that's super
- 4:16:02Innovative and it sounds like you're amped up and excited.
- 4:16:04Probably more so than anybody in your career actually.
- 4:16:07It's a transfer that's personal trainers to transform
- 4:16:10technology. Yeah, like I'm learning more
- 4:16:13that I have in a very long time. Yeah.
- 4:16:16And I love it. Yeah.
- 4:16:17And it's like that's kind of why we get up and go to work.
- 4:16:19Yeah. Right.
- 4:16:21And like that. That's why I went into.
- 4:16:23It was like, that's what I want and I feel like I'm in a box so
- 4:16:26where I currently, yeah, I want to build and I want to learn and
- 4:16:30develop and I realized that we were facing just a
- 4:16:33transformative moment that I'm like there's no other time
- 4:16:35better than now to jump into that.
- 4:16:37Absolutely. So what, You heard it possible?
- 4:16:40Just to sum it up. It like, like, you know, are you
- 4:16:44seeing a lot of smoke and mirrors?
- 4:16:45And then, if you've gotten in place in this, I think that
- 4:16:49it's, you know, that a lot of it is real.
- 4:16:51Yeah. Like in in a way that maybe a
- 4:16:55year or two ago was not quite there, so I think it's really
- 4:16:58that transformation about like, you know, more and more
- 4:17:01companies are doing interesting Innovative things coming from a
- 4:17:05lot of Direction. Yeah.
- 4:17:06And doing it to enterprise-grade, but doing it
- 4:17:10incredibly fast. Yeah, but and I think in the,
- 4:17:13the last year, I agree with you, you've seen from what was sort
- 4:17:17of theory, you know that hypothesis to sit where you're
- 4:17:21actually seeing like prototype showing demo Solutions and that
- 4:17:24are living up to the real us. Yeah, and now we'll just see if
- 4:17:27they actually delivered the outcome.
- 4:17:28So I mean that's that's going to be this sort of next battles
- 4:17:30like she's your implemented on the client site.
- 4:17:32Are they showing efficiency performance?
- 4:17:35Gains outcome game, right? Like yeah, I think that's going
- 4:17:39to be where the rubber boots, the road of like, it is worth
- 4:17:41the investment on purpose, right?
- 4:17:42Hey, well, thanks everybody for joining us.
- 4:17:44Thank you out and that was great book.
- 4:17:46Get back into the air conditioning.
- 4:17:47It's about 95 degrees and we'll talk soon.
- 4:17:52Okay?