Latest / Star Wars Alliance / Star Wars The High Republic Path of Vengeance Review Star Wars Alliance
Transcript
- 0:00Kyle Loo. Everyone, welcome back to another episode of Star war Lines your
- 0:04home on the Key Cultonaliance podcast. Eric for An you know, thanks Star
- 0:08Wars and oh my gosh, I'm so high practiced and I'm out of breath
- 0:12high. Clay Clay is here with me today where we are going to be
- 0:16talking and diving deep into our thoughts on the Path of Vengeance, the last
- 0:22book in the higher public phase. To Clay, how are you doing today?
- 0:26I am doing great. Of course for those listening on the podcast,
- 0:32you have just heard us doing our newscasts. We are in the same recording
- 0:38a little fourth wall breaking, so we have already been recording for about an
- 0:42hour and forty minutes and we are going, like Katie said, going to
- 0:46break down everything there is to know about Path of Vengeance. Katie got two
- 0:52readings in while I were I was only able to get one, and I
- 0:58will I am a little bit of a slacker, but it also has a
- 1:03little bit to do with how I perceived this book, just so we will
- 1:08definitely get into it. Guys. If you haven't read Path of Vengeance and
- 1:15you would like to go read it or listen to it, it is available
- 1:18on Audible currently and then come back and listen to our review or if you're
- 1:23getting our information to actually stay up to date with the High Republic, just
- 1:26go ahead and listen to us. It's totally fine. But like Katie said,
- 1:30this is the last book of Phase two of The High Republic. The
- 1:37epilogue really kind of coinciding with the last three books, really filling in some
- 1:44gaps and leaving us with a lot of questions, as from what I saw
- 1:49on Katie's timeline over on Twitter. But Katie, of course, like I
- 1:57said, conjoining basically into three books. Um, we have, of course
- 2:02the Search for Planet X or the Quest for Planet X, Convergence and the
- 2:08Path of Vengeance. These are all happening simultaneously, and honestly, you can
- 2:16even put in the Battle of Jetta because the events of Convergence. Uh.
- 2:23And of course the manga yes um, which I have not read yet,
- 2:29so um. Well, the good thing is it's a whole buttload of mountain,
- 2:35so you can you can, you can spoil it if you want.
- 2:40Um. I do have it uh in my cart. I recently got a
- 2:47one hundred dollars gift card from my school and from Amazon, and so me
- 2:52and Abby are kind of getting our fingers on a lot of things that we
- 2:55want and then we're gonna make one large order. Um. So that is
- 3:00on the cart and I will be having it soon. But so you told
- 3:09me, because let me get this one out of the way, Okay,
- 3:14because again it's really about load of knock. Basically, the only thing in
- 3:19here is Um, it's basically Marcion Rowe and his team. We're looking for
- 3:27a parcel that was left on whatever the planet Banshee. Left on Banshee,
- 3:34it's basically a droid that says everything that happened during the Battle of Donna.
- 3:39That's it. So they weren't looking for anything special. It's just a retailing
- 3:44of Battle of Donna. Okay, That's that's interesting. Um, That's what
- 3:53I'm like. And this is I'm just gonna go ahead and get straight at
- 3:57the point. This is my whole thing with this phase is I don't well,
- 4:00I feel like they acted like there was a whole lot of questions that
- 4:02were going to be answered with the space and yet there's nothing that was answered.
- 4:10Um. That was my biggest problem here. Um, But you can
- 4:17I think there is some questions that you can get answered by the end of
- 4:23this story. And that is some a question that I really have for you,
- 4:27um when we get to that part. But um, this story is
- 4:31of course told in the perspective of two individuals. This story is about Yanna
- 4:39and it's about Marta. Um. There isn't really any other perspectives being told
- 4:46in this story, which I wanted, But it's not what I wanted.
- 4:56The the the what I assume oomed was going to be the outcome of this
- 5:01book, what I was kind of cheering for, did not happen. There's
- 5:06reveals in this book that I absolutely hated and I'm I'm curious to see what
- 5:15you thought of them. The idea that we knew this from the very start
- 5:26of Phase two, and it's still an argument within the universe, is the
- 5:31Path of the Open Hand a cult? They claim that it's not everybody in
- 5:36existence that believes that. It is My biggest concern with this book, Katie
- 5:44was reading Convergence and then reading this book. There is no point of reference
- 5:51for these two novels to make any sense together on the same timeline overlapping because
- 6:01the character and Convergence Bna is nowhere to be seen in this book, and
- 6:13it seemed like uh binat and oh gosh, I forgot his name. Um
- 6:20um alex um uh uh right is it alex No? No? No?
- 6:27Uh uh Axel's great? Uh sorry not axel Um it's been forever um been
- 6:38on an Axel felt like a big part of the Mother's plans this book,
- 6:46Like there's so many parts of the mother's timeline looking at Phase two where she's
- 6:56in one place where in another book she's in a completely different place. And
- 7:00that's what I would like to see. Somebody break this, break all of
- 7:04these books down into hey, these chapters happen at this point. I think
- 7:10this is like the detriment of especially these last couple books is that they all
- 7:16take place at the exact same time, whereas with Phase one, right,
- 7:21even though we were like, oh, but you could have some overlapping,
- 7:26kind of done it like they all like space themselves out, so nothing truly
- 7:34overlapped. The only thing that I can think of that really overlaps is Into
- 7:41the Dark. The opening chapter kind of overlaps just to kind of give you
- 7:45the introduction to Wreath, and then Daniel jose Older's middle grade book for Wave
- 7:56two overlaps with the adult book. Yes, those are the only overlapping things
- 8:03other than the comic and so I think this really sucks. However, and
- 8:11I wanted to point this out. And maybe this is jump back ahead of
- 8:15things, but I did not put these things together when reading Path of Vengeance.
- 8:20And I'm reading Ryan's review from my knockmanner just because I wanted to,
- 8:24like, he had the summary up. And yes, I know, I
- 8:28just finished the second read of the book, but you know, sometimes the
- 8:31summary in front of you is very helpful. So Saya is helping rewrite the
- 8:41laws of hyperspace on the fly as they leave Planet Acts. Right in the
- 8:48final pages with Yanna, she reveals that her real name is Mary and her
- 8:54child's name is Mary, and she was an engineer from a prominent hyperspace family.
- 9:01Yeah. I didn't put that together at all. It did not put
- 9:07that together. But um, since we're already there, I want to I
- 9:13want to throw something else. Um, what which rod does Markion have?
- 9:22So Markion finds both, he finds Yeah, so which one does he have?
- 9:28First? Though? Okay, hang on, I can love we can
- 9:35wikipedia this, Okay, because at the end of this book, each cousin
- 9:43Janna and Marta have a different rod. And our our biggest question since the
- 9:56beginning of phase two is which one of these individuals is Marcion's grandmother. And
- 10:07I think that there's one specific thing that kind of tells me that it has
- 10:11to be Marta. But I think depending on which rod he had first definitively
- 10:20tells me. Okay, that is his grandmother Rod of Seasons. Okay,
- 10:30he had the Rod of Seasons first. Then I believe via the book,
- 10:37I believe it was Yanna who had the Rod of Seasons. I believe I
- 10:46thought she had the Rod of Daybreak. Correct me if I'm wrong, but
- 10:50but please double check it. It's going to be at the very end she
- 10:54does drop it in front of No Marta has the Rod of Seasons. Uhha.
- 11:01It does make sense because there's something that happens to Yanna that is very
- 11:09significant to her body structure. Um. Her hand gets cleaved off by Marta.
- 11:20Um. Katie, I will be completely honest with you, I am
- 11:24not satisfied with their ending. I wasn't either. I was I wasn't satisfied
- 11:31at all. I don't think. I don't think this gets us to the
- 11:37point because obviously, like Marcion finds the great leveler in Nice. How does
- 11:46he get Nice? As as far as we know, at the very end
- 11:54of the book, there are younger ones. The leveler is with Martha.
- 12:03At the end of the book, they get onto the ship and they fly
- 12:07off um, which is assumingly the electric on the Gay's electric exactly. Um.
- 12:16We see several of these levelers actually die or read not see. This
- 12:24is in a visual um. Janna says, they can be killed. Um.
- 12:31And the thing, the thing about this whole third, I know we're
- 12:33going backwards here, but I think this is where the this is the meat
- 12:37of potatoes of where my, my, my lack of interest and satisfaction with
- 12:43this book is really hit on um. The mother's fate. It needed to
- 12:52be Yanna, in my humble opinion, it needed to be Yanna for me
- 13:01to feel one satisfied with her demise. The reason that is when it comes
- 13:09to yes, was Marta strung along by the mother the entire time? Yes,
- 13:16And so you could say, well, she was probably more mentally abused
- 13:22than Yanna. But the emotional weight that was carried from how the mother just
- 13:31threw Yanna aside and was basically hey, you're going to this mission to die.
- 13:37Like at the end of Path of Deceit, I like it very much
- 13:45set in stone that Yanna was gonna make a plan to get her revenge on
- 13:50the Mother yep, and it never happened. She tried, and she tried.
- 13:56It's very much how I feel about the end of ted Lassa. But
- 14:01like, and that was the other thing, this, this whole thing with
- 14:07Martha in her descent into madness, she she is lost from There was a
- 14:20there was a moment at the end of Deceit. Yes, she was sad
- 14:24about keV Mo, and you know, she felt like, oh, this
- 14:28is definitely you know, the way I'm supposed to go with the path and
- 14:31everything else. I did feel there could be something there that could bring her
- 14:37back, you know. No, she she dived off the deep end.
- 14:43She she is forever lost so much so, like we said, she's threatening
- 14:50family, cutting off their limbs. UM, and she's ultimately the reason why
- 14:56the mother is dead. She forced the Leveler to kill her UM. One
- 15:01of the biggest things about that is the other revelation that I was actually relation
- 15:09revelation that I was not happy with Um, which was that the mother is
- 15:15for sensitive UM. There was inklings of this UM in every book that she
- 15:22was a part of. UM. We had a discussion about it, about
- 15:28how there's a possibility that she might be for sensitive UM, and I just
- 15:33it didn't feel right. I thought you were talking about the sister revelation.
- 15:39Oh well, we we had assumed that they were mother and daughter, right,
- 15:45it was the big thing that we had discussed UM. That was interesting
- 15:50UM that story like one of them was well developed within their relationship with the
- 15:56fourth while in the forest, while the other one was not, which was
- 16:00of course Alicia, who was the older sister who was not in full control
- 16:06of her forced abilities. And it felt like a Petunia Dursley and Lily Dursley.
- 16:15Yes, And it just like for me, I thought this was a
- 16:23really cool story about a non forced user getting the upper hand on the Jedi
- 16:34and learning that it was a forced user. This is basically a seth without
- 16:41being a seth, Like it's not which and we've learned that though we've learned
- 16:45For me, the forced thing wasn't that big of deal because A we kind
- 16:49of saw it coming. But then b like we've learned about all of these
- 16:53other force sensitive cults whatever you want column, Like on Jetta, we knew
- 17:03the Guardian the Guardians of the Wills back it wrote one they were for sensitive,
- 17:07they were in charge of guarding things. So to me it was I
- 17:12don't mind that she was for sensitive because I think it makes it all the
- 17:18more powerful of like, oh, you didn't choose me, so now I
- 17:19get to go against you. Is it I would have rather had the mother
- 17:26connection mother daughter versus sister sister, Yeah, because I think that makes it
- 17:33like all the more powerful, because it's like I was gonna say, it
- 17:37makes it more compelling to be like, you took my child away from me,
- 17:41and now I'm going to take everything from you. I think I would
- 17:45have liked that a lot more. This just felt like I'm sorry, a
- 17:52cry baby, like, oh you didn't pick me, you didn't pick me,
- 17:55I'm the last one to be picked, a dodgeball, Like it didn't
- 17:57feel right. Um, and I did lie. There was another perspective in
- 18:03this book, which was Maddie. Maddie, who of course is the Jedi
- 18:07that we've been following in the comics. Um, but I it's it's very
- 18:17difficult for me to be able to say I really enjoyed this book. I
- 18:22read sixteen chapters on my iPad and then I just didn't really feel a lot
- 18:30of like, oh, I'm really eager to finish this. Nothing was really
- 18:36pulling me at that point, which is why I waited until the audiobook came
- 18:41out and then I just finished it. From there, I actually enjoyed this
- 18:45one, I think a lot more than Path of Deceit. I think the
- 18:49red that reason though, is primarily because of the cohesive voice, because I
- 18:56felt like with Path of Deceit it was very wish Uashie and like we couldn't
- 19:03balance tessigrattin Jestina Ireland's voice on the page to create one voice. So I
- 19:10think that's why I think I would pick this one above Deceit. I also
- 19:15very much enjoyed the deeper picture into the Planet X. I really enjoyed that
- 19:25and getting so how do you how do you feel about the idea that Planet
- 19:33X exploits your force sensitivity? Because that was like it. I felt like
- 19:45it it unveils exploits like I feel like it's both because, for one,
- 19:51what does the nameless feed off of It's like a really weird symbiotic relationship between
- 19:59the planet and a name list. It's like, oh, you need to
- 20:00feed. Oh, here's people who are for sensitive and like it just calls
- 20:04to them. So I thought of it in that manner. Um. But
- 20:08we we get this this other character, um, which is uh. We
- 20:15find him in the very beginning of this book, UM with the mother and
- 20:21Marta. I can't remember his name such with a b um uh Boder,
- 20:30I can't remember. I can't remember his name off the top of my head.
- 20:33Um. But he is the love interest for Marta in this book.
- 20:41Um. This felt wrong to begin with, but then it made me think,
- 20:51oh, this is this is MARTA's way out, Like she's gonna see
- 20:56how much this guy is like in thell into the path, and she's not
- 21:00going to feel right with it, and she's going to convince him to leave
- 21:04and they both leave. That's where I thought this book was going. And
- 21:07that was totally wrong. And how did you feel about these uh voices in
- 21:18Marta and Janna's head. There was a throw a line in this book from
- 21:23a completely separate character that were like, oh, you know, one thing
- 21:29I've heard about the ever renny is that they the dead speak to them.
- 21:33And a big part of this book was that KEVMO was looming over MARTA's shoulder
- 21:44and then yeah, so how do you feel about that relationship throughout the book?
- 21:51I really enjoyed it. Um. I thought it gave them a different
- 21:56picture um of kind of like what was going on, because like everybody knows,
- 22:00the voice in your head is your worst enemy, and that was literally
- 22:04what was coming out. There was no support from them. It was like,
- 22:07no, you're literally screwed like kind of thing. So I thought it
- 22:12was a good perspective to have. It makes me enjoy path of to see
- 22:18more because again the dual voices kind of thing threw me off. But yeah,
- 22:26I enjoyed it. What about you, I really enjoyed it because it
- 22:32gave, like you said, this perspective about for Yanna. I did feel
- 22:38that Core had some moments of softness towards Yanna, whereas KEVMO was really beating
- 22:47down on Martha the entire time, like, oh, you're not good enough.
- 22:52Oh you know you could have done this and you couldn't have done that,
- 22:56but you know it's over now, reminding her, oh, you're the
- 23:00reason why I'm dead. The mother is the reason why I'm dead, Like
- 23:03you should be going down this path, which brings I think for Yanna and
- 23:10Core, the softness was actually speaking against Yanna because I think Yanna's used to
- 23:17a hard edge and so the softness threw her off and was not she was
- 23:22not capable of maintaining a response to that. Yeah, I can see that,
- 23:27Um. But one of the biggest I feel like reveals of this book
- 23:33also UM, because in Convergence we find out that they are no longer the
- 23:41path of the open hand um Binn and the people that follow him yell during
- 23:48the battle that they are the path of the closed fiss and that very much
- 23:56felt like a binnot thing is the aggressiveness of it, and it just like,
- 24:03oh, that is definitely his creation. Now that the Mother is off
- 24:08planet and all of this stuff, because that's how it felt. That's the
- 24:11way they portrayed that she had gone. She was not on Dolna anymore.
- 24:18And we find out in this book that Martha was the one that created the
- 24:26path of the closed Fist, which again just shows how far gone she was
- 24:33at the end of this book. And it's weird that even after killing the
- 24:41Mother, she is still devoted to destroying the Jedi and keeping the Force free,
- 24:51which is kind of like now in retrospect of seeing Marcion Row and the
- 25:00storms and all of that, like it all makes sense, Like, yes,
- 25:07you can connect the dots here. It may not be my favorite book
- 25:11out of all of these, but it does make sense. Like you look
- 25:15at what Marta went through, what she teaches her offspring, and what their
- 25:22family goes through after that, Like there's there's a reason why it evolves to
- 25:30what they become us as the Night Hill. Um. So I do like
- 25:38that. Um very very crazy to see that evolution from this sweet, peaceful
- 25:47person that Marta was at the beginning of this phase to this very hardened individual
- 25:53that is now on this crusade to what she believes is for the greater good
- 26:02of the galaxy. You know. Yeah, And it'll be interesting to see
- 26:08how it plays out because obviously Marie Santeca, both of them are with Yanna,
- 26:14So how does Mari end up with and Mark Yon kind of thing.
- 26:21That'll be interesting to see how that plays out. There is a Martyr Row
- 26:26story post phase two coming in the Tales of Light in Life as one of
- 26:33the short stories, so that could be interesting to see. Maybe she sticks
- 26:37the level or an ice there who knows um, Because because one of the
- 26:42things that she references are that she makes very clear in the in the book
- 26:52is that she is forcibly having to think, hey, don't kill these individuals
- 26:59yep uh, in order to keep the leveler at bay. So it may
- 27:03be that this is straining on her and that she may have to put him
- 27:11on ice just to be able to live at least somewhat of a normal life.
- 27:15All right, y'all, we are going to hit our first ad break
- 27:17and we will be right back in three two one. I think it'll be
- 27:22interesting to see and obviously, like just because phase two is over doesn't mean
- 27:29we couldn't see another Yanna and Marta story come to fruition at some point.
- 27:34Us. Okay, um, what did you think about as Lin Rell in
- 27:45this So Aslin, if I remember correctly, is the one at the end
- 27:51of Pata deceit correct. Yes, he comes in looking for um keV Mo
- 27:59and his master. Yes. Now, this is something that I brought up
- 28:04in one of our other reviews. We looked it up and before this book
- 28:11came out. I think it was the Wikipedia that had him deceased at this
- 28:18battle now it could have just have been an assumption, but when we talked
- 28:22about it, they had him deceased in this battle. He is not.
- 28:30He is slowly going into madness due to the leveler. He is the one
- 28:38that is that keeps reciting the what we deemed as the nursery rhyme that is
- 28:48attached to the nameless shriek Karai Karai. And I think from just assumption,
- 29:02this is where we're going to be getting those like writings and temples from from
- 29:07what we've seen in the first phase of the High Republic right like we're going.
- 29:15Yeah, I think that he eventually this is just me headcanon. Of
- 29:22course that's nothing has been written so far to my knowledge. I think that
- 29:27he will get his head on straight to a certain point. But he will
- 29:33be obsessed with this and he will research this, and he is going to
- 29:37be the one leaving all these clues for our original heroes in phase one that
- 29:42that are events that end up following all of this, Like, I think
- 29:48that's what's going to happen. Um had had something here on Nividi in Prime's
- 29:56website a hand okay, because I sorry, go ahead, Well, I
- 30:04was gonna say because I believe it was at the end of Trail Trial of
- 30:08Shadows where we see one of the temples that have the markings of the nursery
- 30:17rhyme and kind of leading to like the origins of the Nameless or whatever.
- 30:21Of course, we now know what those origins are with Planet X, but
- 30:26it's still very interesting. Like we we have seen and heard uh with with
- 30:33these novels and audio dramas and whatnot. Yoda knows about all of this stuff
- 30:41and inklings of it. And at the end of Battle of Jetta, they
- 30:45decided, oh, nobody can know about this. Let's keep all of this
- 30:48a secret, like at the Battle of Donna, is what they Yeah,
- 30:52that's right, that's right. And it's just I'm I'm very curious as of
- 30:59why they felt like there I need answers from from Phase two to Phase one
- 31:06the fifty years, Like I feel like there should be answers to why the
- 31:15Nameless are still so unknown to our heroes in Phase one, Right, So
- 31:27the answer to Aslin will come in this guy, I'll just tell you that,
- 31:33okay, um And the last thing, Okay, So the lullaby that
- 31:41was found um By in the Trail of Shadows by Emeric was on the planet
- 31:47rant Urnam, which um is where Marcion actually found the Rod of Daybreak that
- 32:01actually takes place, and one of those guys um the Star Wars Adventures books
- 32:09by IDW there is like a villains in there, and I have not read
- 32:15it, but I have it, and somebody has said, oh, this
- 32:21is where that happens. So he finds it there and so the lullaby is
- 32:29found carved into that cave, and the night Hiler said to have reverence for
- 32:34that cave. So there's that. UM. Yoda and Elder Trumac visited rant
- 32:43Turnam in the Higher Republic Adventures only to be shot out of the sky by
- 32:47automated defense systems. So my thought process is is that's not done by Aslin,
- 32:54That m is done maybe by Marta or Jana and an attempt to keep
- 33:01the yeah interesting, okay, UM, So that there is UM. If
- 33:16you go look at Numidian Primes, the seeds for the Higher Public Phase two,
- 33:21it kind of sums up a lot of the things actually that UM we
- 33:25find out that they wrote that before Phase two came out, kind of going
- 33:30Okay, this is what I'm expecting to happen, and we did get a
- 33:32lot of that information, so um for me, I as much as like,
- 33:39I don't like the ending, and again like I went in with expectations,
- 33:44but I think my expectations were kind of addressed, Like I resolved my
- 33:50expectations for the second read through, so that I and that's what I did
- 33:54for Rise of Skywalker was I went in and I said, Okay, that's
- 33:58not what I was expecting. But then I watched it again and I was
- 34:00like, Okay, I can get it now. I still don't think I
- 34:05like what happened in this book, and I hate to say that because I
- 34:09really enjoyed Raising Storm and I was like, oh, Cavin, Cavin's gonna
- 34:15bring it home right here, and he did bring it home. But I
- 34:16also think that maybe they failed in planning this story wise, and I hate
- 34:27it, I really do, because they've done such a phenomenal job with it.
- 34:30They've just taken a huge step back, I think with phase two.
- 34:34So I'm looking forward to phase three and I still sticking with this book.
- 34:39I really liked the perspectives that we got. I liked getting to hear more
- 34:45from Yanna and Martha, but I also think getting Maddie's perspective made this book
- 34:53better. I don't. I think if you don't have Maddie's perspective, that
- 35:00ruins the book a lot. And Maddie brings a breath of fresh air.
- 35:04She's still in the same situations, but it helps bring some levity because she's
- 35:09a padawine and she's a chatterbox, so it kind of helps alleviate some things
- 35:16that are going on and not necessarily in a she makes jokes all the time.
- 35:22It's just a different perspective because Janna and Martha are just so everything's terrible.
- 35:30It life sucks kind of feeling, yes, but like it also helps
- 35:36with the like you you're starting to get more information from Olivia, which is
- 35:43something that is very important for this story. And Olivia plays a more minor
- 35:50role than I would have thought she would have played. Getting introduced to her
- 35:54at some of the conventions that we got yeah, yeah, like the break
- 36:00down of like the introduction of phase two, like, oh, this is
- 36:06Olivia, this is the mother, and like all the fans connecting the dots
- 36:10immediately were like, oh, how is this going to play out? You
- 36:15know? Well, And I don't think I think people said, oh,
- 36:19they kind of look alike. But I think what really screwed this phase was
- 36:24releasing the mother video on YouTube and saying, oh, she's Alicia Zevern.
- 36:32I think that was a huge mistake because they didn't even say her name in
- 36:38the video. They said it in the captions, and it's like, why
- 36:43would you put her name in the captions and like cause all the spiraling.
- 36:47That's my opinion. Yeah, I think that it was a little bit too
- 36:53much of a hiccup on their part that kind of ruined quote unquote ruined the
- 36:59surprise. But like surprisingly also like I never thought I was going to be
- 37:06rooting for the Herald at one point, and I was near the tail end
- 37:10with him being so aggressive towards the Mother. It. He has been a
- 37:20rollercoaster of a character since the beginning. You saw him very solemn but very
- 37:24stern, and you're just like, Okay, he's just playing a role.
- 37:28Then his role really exploded in the Battle of Jetta. You know, the
- 37:34Mother playing him out to be this outcast that kind of went rogue and all
- 37:38of that, and that was interesting. But for him to like be like,
- 37:44oh, she is just doing this for her own greed, in her
- 37:47own good I was glad that he somewhat woke up. But then again,
- 37:54like even Yanna was was so surprised when he was like, oh, we
- 38:00have a new leader, Marta. She's the one that's you know, giving
- 38:04us guidance, you know, and he's like, the Force will be free,
- 38:07The Force will be free. It absolutely is mind boggling. Of course
- 38:12this is all a work of fiction, but like it's absolutely mind boggling to
- 38:15see somebody who is so lost in this cult that they like it's right in
- 38:22front of them, like, hey, this is bad, Like you were
- 38:27starting to see it, and now just because somebody gave a somewhat great speech
- 38:31on the side of a cult, you're okay with it. Like it's absolutely
- 38:35maddening. Yeah, and that's why I'm interested to see how the Higher Republic,
- 38:45how like what has been done in the Higher Republic comes to fruition for
- 38:51later parts of Star Wars in general, because um, there is another cult,
- 38:57not the same cult in Um Alphabet Squadron book two. Yeah, so
- 39:02it's very different perspectives and obviously, like some of them take real world experience
- 39:08that we have right here, because there's hundreds of cults in modern day US,
- 39:16so and there is Again, we will definitely be planning this review later
- 39:25on. But a big part of Jedi Survivor Star Wars Jedi Survivor the video
- 39:32game was that there were implementing parts of the High Republic in that game,
- 39:38and it's a pretty big revelation. And where that game ends leaves a lot
- 39:45of questions for like the OG trilogy timeline and how things play out there.
- 39:52So it's it's going to be very interesting on how Lucasfilm and Star Wars really
- 39:58decide where this is all going because there's no nameless in the prequels, there's
- 40:07no nameless in the Rhythm trilogy. Is Ray gonna have to fight against the
- 40:12nameless? Like? And then we find out like, Okay, how did
- 40:16this happen? Like we I would like to get some concrete answers to why.
- 40:23And again the simple answer is this stuff wasn't written when the trilogy was
- 40:30taking place. But you need to make it make sense. That's the biggest
- 40:35problem. If you're gonna put it in this universe, you need to make
- 40:37it make sense. Yeah, and ultimately we'll see what happens. I mean,
- 40:43we know the end date for the Higher Republic Um twenty twenty five is
- 40:47coming and it's not going to be delayed by writers drink. So that's true,
- 40:58And especially with some of the tie ins that happened with the High Republic
- 41:02and Jedi Survivor. I'll be interested to see because I did, I promise,
- 41:07I did read like some of the Wikipedia is related to the game,
- 41:10So it'll be interesting to see how they go about choosing to tie stuff in
- 41:16into Phase three. But I definitely think Phase two for the Higher Republic can
- 41:25be saved with some later addictions. It all kind of depends. And I
- 41:31don't again, like we say, I don't consider if you write something in
- 41:37the future that helps the perspective of something written previously. I don't consider that
- 41:44a recond it's just improving on what you have. Yeah. So with that,
- 41:52based on everything you read in Phase two, how would you rank everything
- 41:58so far on a scale one to ten or one to five? Like,
- 42:04what what was your favorite book? What was your least favorite book? Oh?
- 42:07I said this, Um. I I since a text to you saying
- 42:13this, I feel like Convergence should have been the ending. UM doesn't yeah,
- 42:19sorry not converted Cataclysm should have been the ending UM And you said,
- 42:24oh, well, you haven't read the entire book yet, which in retrospective
- 42:29it wouldn't really make sense if if Cataclysm was the ending. I do give
- 42:32you that, UM, but that was peak fiction. In my mind.
- 42:39It was just so so good. Um I I would give that, um
- 42:46the the s tier of this uh of this phase. UM. Of course
- 42:54there was also UM. Oh shoot, I need to get the titles of
- 42:59the books. UM Convergence, Cataclysm, Path of Deceit, UH, Path
- 43:07of Vengeance. I have us for the Hidden City and UM question Yeah,
- 43:15Battle of Data. UM. I think uh question for the Hidden City and
- 43:21the Quest for Planet x UM they were fun editions. UM. I think
- 43:27that um. They they both had really important stories to be told. UM.
- 43:32I really like uh Quest for the Hidden City just for the fact of
- 43:37like the horror esque aspect in the in the novel. UM really enjoyed that.
- 43:43UM. But I would still rank them a little bit lower than the
- 43:47adult novels. UH. Convergence, right is right? Yeah, Convergence was
- 43:54the first one. Yeah. Convergence UH would probably be right below Cataclysm,
- 44:02and then it's the Battle Battle of Jetta would be after that, and then
- 44:09Path of Deceit and then Path of Vengeance would be after that. And then
- 44:17the comics. I think they have been a nice addition, just kind of
- 44:21putting in information for all of us reading everything is really really nice. I
- 44:28need to catch up on Adventures. I have not been keeping up with that,
- 44:30but I know that they have also been kind of crazy with the release
- 44:35schedules on that. But overall, besides my ranking of it, it was
- 44:44a nice addition that lacked connective tissue other than them all kind of using the
- 44:52catalysts of the Battle of Jetta as like a focal point. Other than that,
- 45:00it really needed some more planning. Um. But I love the characters
- 45:06that we that we got to meet, um axel Um freaking uh the the
- 45:14Prince and Princess of uh Erino and uh Iron like those were awesome stories.
- 45:23I really did enjoy those, um and the the the Jedi that we that
- 45:31we got to really get attached to, and then all of a sudden,
- 45:35you know, they they die. Um. I've I've said it's so many
- 45:39times. I want a happy ending for Jedi. I really do. UM.
- 45:45One that we didn't really get any ending too was Cilandra, Like where
- 45:52did she end up, you know, with with her pass and I think
- 45:54that's another good answer. Ruper and Cilandra have a post Face two story in
- 46:00Tales of of Latin Life, so um, those are really the main stories.
- 46:07We're going to get intings too from Phase two, so it'll be interesting
- 46:13to see that comes out September fifth, and I imagine we will get it
- 46:17around the same time, so um, just kind of be prepared for that.
- 46:23Obviously will be in the middle of a soaker reviews at the same time.
- 46:28So Yeah, for me my ranking for Phase two stuff, I would
- 46:34definitely have to say Convergence, Cataclysm, Quest for Planet X, and then
- 46:40I would probably put Path of Vengeance, Quest for the Hidden City, Path
- 46:45of the Seat. And I'm not saying like it's really hard for me to
- 46:51go I hate this book, like I didn't hate Path of the Seat.
- 46:54It's just like putting them in order. I definitely think if you're going to
- 46:59pick anything from this book from this series to read and you're not concerned about
- 47:05what the name, if you're concerned about what the nameless are in Phase one,
- 47:09you need to read the young adult duo. Yeah. If you're like
- 47:13I just want to read a good story, Cataclysm and Convergence or Convergence and
- 47:19Cataclysm, no doubt about it. Like phenomenal story, right, there too
- 47:22many perspectives in the second book, but like otherwise even still, you read
- 47:28those two books back to back, it is amazing. Yep, So that
- 47:35would be my pick, especially if you're a romance person. Yeah, romance
- 47:42version. So yeah, I think that about concludes everything. Um, I
- 47:46think I think we touched the high points. I don't think we needed in
- 47:51a degree. This is a month after at least, so everybody else has
- 47:57already talked about it. But obviously if you've read the book and you're like,
- 48:00hey, you missed this really big part and I want you to talk,
- 48:04please let us out. We'd be happy to talk more about it,
- 48:07of course, But as Katie said, we have covered everything tonight, so
- 48:13I want to think everybody who has lasted this long and uh, you know,
- 48:19just talking your ear off about our favorite books. But of course you
- 48:22can always find me at fanboy late on Twitter. I do have a masset
- 48:28on you. It's uh somewhere in my Twitter account. You can definitely find
- 48:31it. But I also of course host Ranger Alliance, which is coming back
- 48:37next week, and of course over not on the network Batman News Weekly.
- 48:44We have already reviewed the Flash because we were at a fan event this week,
- 48:49and that actually drops in the next two days. So go watch the
- 48:52Flash and then listen to our review. But yeah, Katie, what about
- 48:57you? Don You can find me on Twitter and Instagram. It's at Slice
- 49:00of Katie. This show you can find on Twitter. It's at starge Lens.
- 49:05That the eight and the War is very important. Don't forget it.
- 49:07That is the same user name without the at sign obviously that you can contact
- 49:12us at gmail dot com. If you have questions and don't really want to
- 49:17root and you're not a social media person, obviously reach out to us.
- 49:22I'm typically going to be the one to check email. Clay is going to
- 49:24be checking our phone for any text or voicemails or voice messages you'd like to
- 49:30leave us. Remember to leave us your name so we can credit you.
- 49:36And that number is eight three zero five three eight four eight to eight.
- 49:39I want to wish everyone a great day or night, whatever tim day you
- 49:43are listening, are watching, and we will see you all next time.
- 49:45May the voice to be with you