Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Why are British Columbians leaving the province? (Steve Saretsky)
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. If folks, my name is Mohameir and this is Van Keller,
- 0:20British Columbia's bona fide culture and politics TV talk show. We got a
- 0:24jam packed show tonight, including a Grand Prix World Champion of magic based right
- 0:30here in BC. But first, Over the last four to five years,
- 0:35I've had a lot of friends move out of BC. In fact, nearly
- 0:39seventy thousand people left BC last year, with more than half relocating just next
- 0:44door to Alberta. So what's going on? Am I going to lose more
- 0:47friends here? To comfort me? Or be the bearer of bad news?
- 0:51Is a real estate agent, analyst, commentator and advisor to policymakers. His
- 0:56business is, in fact, is among the top one percent Greater Vancouver realtors,
- 1:02and his weekly newsletter reaches several thousand readers. The founder of the Siretsky
- 1:06Group, he is Steve Siretsky. Thanks for having Steve, so nice to
- 1:10see you. Why are all my friends leaving the province? What's going on
- 1:14there? Maybe they're trying to get away from you. I don't know.
- 1:15I din't blame them, to be honest, I mean, yeah, I
- 1:18think it's cost of living. I think it's just continued to kind of ratchet
- 1:21up. I mean, truthfully, I'm kind of surprised it took as long
- 1:23as it did. I think I've been involved in Calgary real estate myself,
- 1:29just on the personal side, and that was kind of one of my core
- 1:32THECS you know, four or five years ago, was if Vancouver continues to
- 1:36run at the pace that everybody believes it's going to, which is basically double
- 1:38digit price appreciation, eventually people will leave. And I think we're finally starting
- 1:42to see that in the data. And it's not just Vancouver. If you
- 1:47look at the you know, there's a good chart out recently from BEMO on
- 1:49the research side which showed you know, Vancouver, Toronto, Montreal seeing a
- 1:55mass exodus interprovincially basically leaving those provinces going to more more affordable places. There
- 2:00almost seems to be like a nesting doll effect though, right like people are
- 2:04leaving big cities, or in the case of BC, people are leaving BC
- 2:07and going somewhere else. And then I've also seen that there's a lot of
- 2:10migration out of Canada right like this this is a trend on multi levels.
- 2:15Yeah, I think it's just reaching sort of a tipping point. Right.
- 2:19It's like, if I think what people do in Vancouver is they get sort
- 2:21of priced out, they go to the island or they go to Kelowna.
- 2:23Those those two areas have gotten really expensive. So now I'm finding that it's
- 2:27starting to migrate to Calgary. Like I never had those conversations three or four
- 2:30years, five years ago with clients prospects. Now it's all, hey,
- 2:35you know, tell me a bit more about Calgary and so. And we've
- 2:38had a bunch of our clients personally relocate, so you know, you're starting
- 2:42to see it again. This is a lot of this is anecdotical, but
- 2:44you can see it in some of the data as well. It is happening.
- 2:46When we think of who is moving out of province, out of BC
- 2:50in particular, aside from being my friends, who else is moving out?
- 2:53In terms of demographics, I mean, it tends to obviously be you know,
- 2:57millennials, people that are trying to our families, right, And I
- 3:00think if you look at Vancouver, you know you always talk about all the
- 3:02missing middle, the missing middle. I mean, it is true we do
- 3:06have that missing middle housing. Right. It's either you're in a two bedroom
- 3:08condo for let's call it a million bucks, or you're going into a single
- 3:12family house at two right, there is no sort of in between, you
- 3:15know, duplex, triplex, townhouse. I mean, we're starting to slowly
- 3:19build that. But so this is hitting millennials the hardest. Yeah, it
- 3:23is. I mean you think about a millennial that's you know, is trying
- 3:25to get started in life and wants to start a family. I mean,
- 3:29it's it's tough. It's tough to do in this city. And I think
- 3:31you know, you're certainly seeing fewer and fewer people having kids. But if
- 3:37you do want to have kids, and you know, you grew up with
- 3:38the yard and you want to you know, offer that experience to your children,
- 3:44I mean it's it's tough to do that in Vancouver. So is that
- 3:46where you're hearing from clients that you know, they're maybe willing to even sacrifice
- 3:50their careers here or their network that they've built up, you know, their
- 3:53friendship with me, perhaps in order to have a lifestyle that is more family
- 3:57orientated. Yeah. And I think people are just moving further and further out
- 4:00right. And I think we saw that during the pandemic, and I feel
- 4:03like that trend hasn't really reversed, Like we're not really seeing we're still seeing
- 4:08like a hybrid model from a work from home perspective, and we're still seeing
- 4:13a lot of people moving out to Langley to Abbotsford, to Surrey to you
- 4:18know, to drab more space. If you only have to commute two three
- 4:21times a week, all of a sudden that commute isn't that bad. And
- 4:25so you know, we saw a little bit of a price correction, but
- 4:27you still see a lot of young people are moving out there, and it's
- 4:30just it's it's out of necessity. Within Canada, are there better job opportunities
- 4:34than what you can find in Metro Vancouver or British Columbia? Like are people
- 4:39actually leaving for economic reasons as well? I mean, I think if you
- 4:41look at statistically a highest incomes or in Alberta really which is like yeah,
- 4:46exactly. I mean obviously, like I said, I'm surprised it took as
- 4:48long as it did. Wow, lower taxes, you know, higher incomes,
- 4:53cheaper housing. Again, you're dealing with the weather. So there's obviously
- 4:57a lot of people I'd call them maybe a little bit snob at times,
- 5:00but people spend like a you know, We've had stories with clients that have
- 5:04relocated back where it's like, hey, we spent two years in Calgary,
- 5:06couldn't deal with the weather. We move back and we're gonna We're gonna stomach
- 5:10these very high housing prices and just deal with it because that's the lifestyle that
- 5:15we want to have. So everybody kind of moves for different reasons. But
- 5:17I would just say in general, we are certainly seeing I think more people
- 5:21are are just dealing with cost of living, saying how am I ever going
- 5:25to get ahead, and whether that's relocating to Alberta or different parts of Canada
- 5:28or even the US. I think it has kind of reached that tipping point
- 5:32when I think about all the issues that we face here in British Columbia in
- 5:35particular, does it all boil down to the cost of land? Like I'm
- 5:40thinking, if you're an entrepreneur and you want to start, especially a storefront
- 5:44business or something that requires some industrial land, there's a heavy cost not only
- 5:47purchasing that land, but even if you want to lease it getting into the
- 5:50market. Right now, I think about, you know, this idea of
- 5:53building communities and building schools or even building social housing. Like the cost of
- 5:58land seems to just be this anchor that it really prevents growth from happenings.
- 6:01Do you feel the same way or is there something else that I'm missing.
- 6:03I think, yeah, I think that's very accurate. I mean I always
- 6:06tell people like, listen, if you know well, I mean, I
- 6:10think the cost of construction is also up there now too, especially in Vancouver.
- 6:13I always say like, okay, listen, let's just pretend I'll give
- 6:15you a piece of dirt in East Vancouver. I'll give it to you for
- 6:18free. So normally that's two million dollars. Yeah, very prohibitive, but
- 6:21I'll give you the I'll give the dirt for free. All you have to
- 6:25do is go and build a house. I mean, for you to build
- 6:27that house, it's going to cost you minimum minimum a million dollars. Really,
- 6:31so like, can I sell that house for four million dollars? Though
- 6:33you probably get you probably get at least three and a half for us.
- 6:39But I mean, so I think it's and I think ultimately though, why
- 6:42is the cost of construction so expensive? It does come back to house prices,
- 6:46right, People need incomes to support the cost of living here, right,
- 6:50and so like you know, if your trade is coming in from Abbotsford
- 6:54and driving in and their rent has gone up by you know, thirty percent
- 6:59over the last two years, or their mortgage has gone up, and it
- 7:01all gets filtered through at the end of the day. It's amazing because I
- 7:05personally have built properties in Calgary and the cost of construction is materially cheaper there.
- 7:13Interesting, and well, why is that the case? I just I
- 7:16mean, I I don't I think that for whatever reason, the trades seem
- 7:19to charge a little bit less. I find maybe the materials seem to be
- 7:25slightly cheaper. I think there's less less taxation on those. It's very strange,
- 7:28honestly, it's I don't really have a perfect answer for you other than
- 7:30there's like a noticeable difference in the cost of construction. And I'll end it
- 7:33on this note. If there was a severe correction in the cost of land,
- 7:39it might put our whole financial system at risk, right, So we're
- 7:41kind of caught. Yeah, I mean, it's uh. And I look
- 7:43at like governments and I think every government today, whether you're at the municipal,
- 7:46financial, federal level, they're all looking for revenues, and I think
- 7:50that real estate has been that golden goose that has brought on those those revenues
- 7:55through capital gains, increases, through property transfer taxes, through development charges.
- 8:01So real estate it's tough because you're kind of walking that fine line of trying
- 8:05to keep the system going but at the same time knowing the system is kind
- 8:09of crumbling a little bit under us, to the point where now we are
- 8:11seeing people leaving. Yeah, mostly my friends. Yeah, you're gonna have
- 8:16that. I'm gonna be the only one left for you. Just suit me.
- 8:18But Steve, thank you so much. I appreciate your time. Thanks.
- 8:20Yeah, thanks for having me. Folks follow him on social media.
- 8:24He's a wealth of knowledge and analysis. He is, of course, real
- 8:28estate officionado. Steve Saretzky, now one of the world's best magicians, is
- 8:33here in studio. He fooled Penn and Teller twice, so he might make
- 8:37my head explode. Sean Farquhar is up next.