Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Mega Edition: Judge Berman's Opinion And Order Denying Jeffrey Epstein's Bail Attempt (Part 1-2) (7/4/26)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to begin taking
- 0:06a look at Judge Berman's order and opinion denying Jeffrey
- 0:10Epstein's bell request. So let's dive in case number one
- 0:16nineteen DASH cr DASH zero zero four to nine zero
- 0:20DASH RMB United States of America Government against Jeffrey Epstein.
- 0:26Decision and order remanding defendant. Now would the judge remand
- 0:30a defendant that did nothing wrong? Would Judge Berman remand
- 0:34a defendant to the custody and care of the state
- 0:38if that person wasn't a danger to the community. I'll
- 0:41leave that up to you to decide. Background. This ruling
- 0:46follows the court's bell hearing held on July fifteenth, twenty nineteen.
- 0:50The issue before the court is whether the defendant should
- 0:53continue to be remanded pending trial or whether he should
- 0:56be granted release while the case proceeds. No matter the
- 1:00answer to this question, and no matter what has been
- 1:02said in court in analyzing the matter, this is a
- 1:05criminal case and the defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, is innocent of
- 1:09the federal charges alleged against him now and until such
- 1:13time if it comes that a jury or the court finds,
- 1:16after fair and thorough consideration of the facts in the law,
- 1:20that he's guilty. It should also be borne in mind
- 1:23that the court has not yet been presented with a
- 1:25motion to dismiss the indictment. This is a federal as
- 1:28opposed to a state case. We proceed under federal law
- 1:32and federal rules. The federal statute that applies here is
- 1:36US Code eighteen, section fifteen ninety one, which sets forth
- 1:40the crime of sex trafficking with which mister Epstein is charged.
- 1:44Mister Epstein is also charged with conspiring with others to
- 1:47commit sex trafficking under US Code eighteen, section three seventy one.
- 1:53Sure sounds like he was doing it alone. Huh, I
- 1:55guess the judge is lying to. With respect to the
- 1:58issue of roman versus release, US Code eighteen, section thirty
- 2:02one forty two applies. It sets forth a presumption in
- 2:06favor of remand an exception to the presumption in most
- 2:10cases which favors pre trial release. Section thirty one forty
- 2:14two states that if there is probable cause to believe
- 2:17that the person committed an offense involving a minor victim
- 2:20under section fifteen ninety one. Then it shall be presumed
- 2:24that no condition or combination of conditions will reasonably assure
- 2:28the appearance of the person as required and the safety
- 2:32of the community. The indictment in this case was returned
- 2:36by a grand jury, thus establishing probable cause that the
- 2:39defendant committed the crimes of sex trafficking and sex trafficking
- 2:43conspiracy see United States vers. Contreras, Second Circuit, nineteen eighty five.
- 2:48An indictment returned by a duly constituted grand jury conclusively
- 2:52established the existence of probable cause for the purpose of
- 2:56triggering the rebuttal presumption set forth in thirty one to
- 2:59forty six two. In most federal cases, the rebuttable presumption
- 3:05that applies favors pre trial release, not remand there is
- 3:09another very important issue to be considered in the case.
- 3:12It has to do with victims of the crimes charged
- 3:15in the indictment. Victims refer to the minor girls who
- 3:18are alleged to have been sexually trafficked by the defendant.
- 3:21Under US Code Section thirty seven thirty one, victims are
- 3:25entitled to be heard in court, including on the question
- 3:28of whether the defendant is to be released or remanded
- 3:31victims have, among other things, been given the opportunity to
- 3:34testify at the bail hearing Council submissions. The government letter
- 3:39application dated July eighth, twenty nineteen, requests that the court
- 3:43remand mister Epstein. It argues that mister Epstein poses an
- 3:46acute danger to the community and grounded in past experience
- 3:50with this defendant, that if mister Epstein is allowed to
- 3:54remain out on bill, the defendant could attempt a pressure
- 3:57and intimidate witnesses and potential witnesses in this case, including
- 4:01victims and their families, and otherwise attempt to obstruct justice.
- 4:06The government also contends that in light of the strength
- 4:09of the government's evidence and the substantial incarceratory term the
- 4:13defendant would face upon conviction forty five years, there is
- 4:16an extraordinary risk of flight, particularly given the defendant exorbitant wealth,
- 4:21his ownership of and access to private planes capable of
- 4:25international travel, and a significant international ties. Wait a minute,
- 4:30I thought the government told us there is no substantial evidence.
- 4:33I thought they didn't have anything to share with us.
- 4:35That's weird. The government also provides the following background information
- 4:40in our about two thousand and five, the defendant was
- 4:42investigated by local police and in Pombeach, Florida, in connection
- 4:46with allegations that he committed similar sex offenses against minor girls.
- 4:51The investigation ultimately also involved federal authorities, namely the U. S.
- 4:56Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida and the
- 4:59FBI's my Office, and included interviews with victims based in
- 5:03the Pombeach area, including some of the alleged victims relevant
- 5:06to count one of the instant indictment. In the fall
- 5:10of two thousand and seven, the defendant entered into a
- 5:12non prosecution agreement with the Southern District of Florida in
- 5:16connection with the conduct that issue in that investigation, which
- 5:20the non prosecution agreement identified as including investigations into the
- 5:24defendant's abuse of minor girls in the Pombeach area. In
- 5:28June two thousand and eight, the defendant pled guilty in
- 5:31Florida State Court to one count of procuring a person
- 5:35under the age of eighteen for a prostitution, a felony,
- 5:38and one count de solicitation a prostitution, also a felony.
- 5:42As a result, the defendant was designated a sex offender
- 5:45with registration requirements under the National Sex Offender Registration and
- 5:50Notification Act. The Defense moved on July eleventh, twenty nineteen,
- 5:55for a pre trial release of mister Epstein, arguing that
- 5:58mister epstein stricken appliance with the various monitoring requirements associated
- 6:03with his sex offender registration actually decrease any danger that
- 6:07he might otherwise pose, and also that mister Epstein has
- 6:11never once attempted to flee. The United States Defense proposes
- 6:16that they describe as a stringent set of fourteen conditions
- 6:19that will effectively guarantee mister Epstein's appearance and debate any
- 6:23conceivable danger He's claimed to present. Id at one. The
- 6:28fourteen conditions do not include private security guards twenty four
- 6:31to seven. The fourteen conditions do include one home detention
- 6:35in mister Epstein's Manhattan residence, with permission to leave only
- 6:40for medical appointments as approved by pre trial services, including
- 6:44at the court's discretion. The installment of surveillance cameras at
- 6:48the front and rear entrances to ensure compliance as if
- 6:51those weren't there already, electronic monitoring with a global positioning system,
- 6:56an agreement not to seek or obtain any new pass
- 6:59past during the pendency of this matter, can sent a
- 7:03US extradition from any country and waiver of all rights
- 7:06against such extradition. A substantial unspecified personal recognissance bond in
- 7:13an amount set by the Court after reviewing additional information
- 7:17regarding mister Epstein's finances. The bond shall be secured by
- 7:22a mortgage on the Manhattan residents valued at roughly seventy
- 7:25seven million dollars. Mister Apstein's private jet can be pledged
- 7:29as further collateral. Mister Epstein's brother Mark will serve as
- 7:33a kosherty of the bond, which shall be further as
- 7:36secured by a mortgage on Mark's home in West pom Beach, Florida.
- 7:40Mister Apstein's friend David Mitchell, will also serve as a
- 7:44kosherty and pledge his investment interest into properties to secure
- 7:48the bond. Mister Apstein shall de register or otherwise ground
- 7:52as private jet. Mister Apstein shall demobilize ground and lord
- 7:57register all vehicles or any other means of transport to
- 8:00in the New York area, providing particularized information as to
- 8:04each vehicle's location. Mister Epstein will provide pre trial service
- 8:09and or the government random access to his residence. No
- 8:12person shall enter the residents other than mister Epstein and
- 8:16his attorneys without prior approval from pre Trial Services and
- 8:19or the Court. Mister Epstein will report daily by telephone
- 8:24to pre Trial Service or any other schedule the court
- 8:27deems appropriate. A trustee or trustees will be appointed to
- 8:32live in mister Epstein's residence, and a report any violation
- 8:36to pre Trial Services and or the Court any other
- 8:40condition the Court deems necessary to reasonably assure mister Epstein's appearance.
- 8:45The defense also proposes as a fallback, round the clock
- 8:49privately funded security guards, which will virtually guarantee, not just
- 8:53reasonably assure mister Epstein's presence in the circumstances of this case.
- 8:58The bell package originally was not accompanied by a financial
- 9:02statement reflecting mister Epstein's finances. However, on July twelfth, twenty nineteen,
- 9:07the defense filed a one page document which included five
- 9:11groups assets owned by mister Epstein, totaling five hundred and
- 9:15fifty nine million, one hundred and twenty thousand, nine hundred
- 9:18and fifty four dollars. The government responded to the defense
- 9:22motion on July twelfth, twenty nineteen, arguing, among other things,
- 9:27that mister Epstein has a history of obstruction and manipulation
- 9:31of witnesses, including as recently as within the past year,
- 9:35when media reports about his conduct in Florida re emerged.
- 9:39The government filing was made against a backdrop of significant
- 9:42and rapidly expanding evidence, serious charges, and the prospects of
- 9:47a lengthy prison sentence. It contends that the defendants proposed
- 9:51conditions of release are woefully inadequate. The court also received
- 9:55a letter from the government dated July sixteenth, twenty nineteen,
- 9:59providing a, among other things, details about allegedly suspicious payments
- 10:03made by the defendant in twenty eighteen upon Beach, Florida
- 10:08police report mister Epstein's expired Austrian passport in another name,
- 10:13but with mister Epstein's photo, and a pile of cash
- 10:15and diamonds found in mister Epstein's safe, for example. The
- 10:19government says records from Institution One show that Honor about
- 10:23November thirtieth, twenty eighteen, or two days after the series
- 10:27and the Miami Herald began, the defendant wired one hundred
- 10:31thousand dollars from a trust account he controlled to an
- 10:34individual named as a potential co conspirator and honor. About
- 10:38December third, twenty eighteen, the defendant wired two hundred and
- 10:42fifty thousand dollars from the same trust account to an
- 10:45individual who has also been named as a co conspirator.
- 10:49According to the government, the second individual is also one
- 10:52of the employees identified in the indictment, which alleges that
- 10:55she and two other identified employees facilitated the defendant and
- 11:00its trafficking of miners by, among other things, contacting victims
- 11:04and scheduling their sexual encounters with defendant at his residences
- 11:08in Manhattan and pom Beach, Florida. By letter dated July sixteenth,
- 11:13twenty nineteen, Defense Council states, among other things, that the
- 11:17court should reject the idea that there's literally nothing a
- 11:20person of Epstein's means could say, do, or pledge to
- 11:24rebut the operative presumption and make himself eligible for release.
- 11:29Epstein contends that Section fifteen ninety one and the remand
- 11:33presumption do not contemplate or cover the core conduct that
- 11:37issue here performing sexual massages for money. Defense Council also
- 11:41states that Epstein certainly recognizes the Court's request for further
- 11:45transparency and is committed to providing a complete and accurate disclosure. Accordingly,
- 11:51we propose that the courts preliminarily accept the initial financial
- 11:55disclosure proffered last Friday, and, if intending to grant bail,
- 12:00include a release condition directing Epstein to tender a comprehensive
- 12:04forensic accounting of his finances as expeditiously as practicable. By
- 12:10letters dated July sixteenth and July seventeenth, twenty nineteen. Defense
- 12:15Council also submitted information regarding Epstein's new Mexico sex offender
- 12:20registration status. Defense Council also stated that Epstein traveled extensively
- 12:25over the last eight months and invariably returned to the
- 12:29United States, that inescapable reality emphatically proves he won't flee
- 12:34and entitles him to release on any and all conditions
- 12:38of the court deems appropriate. All right, folks, we're going
- 12:41to wrap up right here, and in the next episode,
- 12:43we're going to pick up where we left off, and
- 12:46that's the indictment. All of the information that goes with
- 12:49this episode can be found in the description box. What's up, everyone,
- 12:53and welcome to another episode of the Epstein Chronicles. In
- 12:57this episode, We're picking up where we left off with
- 12:59Judge Berman's opinion and order denying Jeffrey Epstein's request for bell.
- 13:06See indictment. O Grand Jerry voted to indict mister Epstein
- 13:11on or about July second, twenty nineteen. The indictment charges
- 13:15mister Epstein with two felonies involving minor girls, some as
- 13:19young as fourteen. Count one includes conspiracy to commit sex
- 13:22trafficking of minor girls in violation of US Code eighteen,
- 13:26section three seventy one, and Count two includes sex trafficking
- 13:30of minor girls in violation of US Code eighteen, section
- 13:34fifteen ninety one. It states, from at least in or
- 13:37about two thousand and two up to and including at
- 13:40least in or about two thousand and five, Jeffrey Epstein
- 13:43entysed and recruited and caused to be enticed and recruited
- 13:47minor girls to visit his mansion in Manhattan, New York,
- 13:50and to the state in Pombech, Florida, to engage in
- 13:53sex acts with them, after which he would give the
- 13:55victims hundreds of dollars in cash. Indictment dated July second,
- 13:59twenty nineteen. Moreover, and in order to maintain an increase
- 14:04his supply of victims, Epstein also paid certain of his
- 14:07victims to recruit additional girls to be similarly abused by Epstein.
- 14:12In this way, Epstein created a vast network of underage
- 14:15victims for him to sexually exploit in locations including New
- 14:20York and Palm Beach. The indictment also charges the victims
- 14:24where as young as fourteen years old at the time
- 14:27they were abused by mister Epstein, and were, for various reasons,
- 14:30often particularly vulnerable to exploitation. Mister Epstein intentionally sought out miners.
- 14:37He knew that many of his victims were, in fact
- 14:39under the age of eighteen, because in some instances, minor
- 14:43victims expressly told them their age. Following his arrest on Monday,
- 14:48July eighth, twenty nineteen, mister Epstein was arraigned and presented
- 14:52with the indictment by Magistrate Judge Henry Pittman. Legal principles
- 14:58governing release versus remand under the Bell Reform Act US
- 15:02Code eighteen, Section thirty one forty two, a court can
- 15:05order a defendant's detention if it determines that the defendant
- 15:09is either one a danger to the community or two
- 15:12a risk of flight US Code eighteen, Section thirty one
- 15:15forty two E. A court does not need to find
- 15:18both bases are proven to order a defendant's detention United
- 15:22States versus Blanco, second Circuit, twenty fourteen. Dangerousness means that
- 15:28the defendant is a danger to the safety of any
- 15:30other person or the community. US Code Section thirty one
- 15:35forty two. A finding of dangerousness must be supported by
- 15:39clear and convincing evidence see United States versus Ferranti, second Circuit,
- 15:43nineteen ninety five. Where there is a strong probability that
- 15:47a person will commit additional crimes if released, the need
- 15:50to protect the community becomes sufficiently compelling that detention is
- 15:55on balance appropriate US First Chimacharanga, second Circuit, nineteen eighty five.
- 16:03Even a single indictment of witness tampering may be sufficient
- 16:06to revoke Belle Lafontaine at one thirty four. To order
- 16:10detention based upon risk of flight, the court must find,
- 16:13by a preponderance of the evidence that no conditions could
- 16:16reasonably assure the defendant's presence at trial. See United States
- 16:21versus Jackson, second Circuit, nineteen eighty seven. US Code eighteen,
- 16:26Section thirty one forty two. The constitutional limits on a
- 16:30detention period based on dangerousness to the community may be
- 16:34looser than the limits on detention period based solely on
- 16:37the risk of flight. In the former case, release risks
- 16:40injury to others, while the latter case release risks only
- 16:44the loss of a conviction. US versus Milan, Second Circuit.
- 16:48Nineteen ninety three, courting the United States ver. Sorena, nineteen
- 16:51eighty six, Second Circuit. A Bell package that may reasonably
- 16:56assure the appearance of the defendant at trial will not
- 16:59necessarily a sure the safety of the community United States versus. Rodriguez,
- 17:04Second Circuit, nineteen ninety one. The Bell REFORMAC sets forth
- 17:08the following four factors to be considered in the release
- 17:11remand analysis. One the nature and circumstances of the crimes charged.
- 17:16Two the weight of the evidence against the person. Three
- 17:20the history and characteristics of the defendant, including the person's
- 17:24character and financial resources. And four the seriousness of the
- 17:28danger posed by the defendant's release. US Code eighteen, Section
- 17:33thirty one forty two G. The weight afforded to each
- 17:36factor under section thirty one forty two G is within
- 17:40the special province of the district court. United States versus Pallino,
- 17:44three thirty five SDNY twenty eighteen. The rules concerning admissibility
- 17:50of evidence in criminal trials do not apply to the
- 17:53presentation and consideration of information at the release remandeering US
- 17:58Code eighteen, section three thirty one forty two F two.
- 18:01For example, the government is entitled to present evidence supporting
- 18:05remand by way of proffer, among other means. US Code eighteen,
- 18:09section thirty one forty two F two. See also US
- 18:12First La Fontaine, Second Circuit, two thousand. Bail hearings are
- 18:16typically informal affairs, not substitutes for trial or even for discovery.
- 18:23US Code Section thirty one forty two F two b
- 18:25expressly states that the federal rules of evidence do not
- 18:29apply at bail hearings. Thus, courts often based attention decisions
- 18:33on hearsay evidence. United States versus Abuhama three ZHO nine,
- 18:38Second Circuit, two thousand and four. District courts are afforded
- 18:41wide discretion regarding the scope of such hearings. US versus Bartalk,
- 18:45Second Circuit twenty twelve. E. The presumption of remand in
- 18:51US Code Section fifteen ninety one cases. A US Code eighteen,
- 18:56section fifteen ninety one case involving sexual victimization of a
- 19:00minor is unusual in that it includes a presumption in
- 19:03favor of pre trial detention, reflecting the significant harm caused
- 19:08by such a crime. The presumption is that no condition
- 19:11or combination of conditions will reasonably assure against flight or
- 19:15danger to the community. United States Verse English, Second Circuit
- 19:20twenty eleven, quoting US Code eighteen, section thirty one forty
- 19:24two E three E. Mister Epstein may rebuct presumption by
- 19:30coming forward with evidence that he does not pose a
- 19:32danger to the community or a flight risk. US first
- 19:35mercedes the government retains the ultimate burden of persuasion that
- 19:40mister Epstein presents a danger to the community by clear
- 19:44and convincing evidence. Even if rebuttal evidence is presented, The
- 19:48presumption favoring detention does not disappear entirely idea. At four
- 19:52thirty six. It remains a factor to be considered among
- 19:56those weighed by the district Court. F mister Epstein poses
- 20:01a danger to others and to the community, the court
- 20:05begins with dangerousness because that concept is at the heart
- 20:09of the case. It finds that the Government is shown
- 20:12by clear and convincing evidence that mister Epstein threatens the
- 20:15safety of another person and or the community, as follows
- 20:19on pages ten through twenty one, victims had advised the
- 20:23court that they would fear for their safety if mister
- 20:26Epstein was released. Victims have specifically conveyed to the government
- 20:31that any former release by the defendant, including home detention
- 20:35with full time private guards, could result in their harassment
- 20:39and abuse. At a bail hearing on July fifteenth, twenty nineteen,
- 20:43two victims movingly testified about their past sexual encounters with
- 20:48mister Epstein when they were reminders age fourteen and sixteen, respectively.
- 20:53In enacting the CVRA, Congress stated that victims deserve the
- 20:57right to be heard at specific points in a criminal
- 21:01justice process, including bell hearings. Giving victims a voice not
- 21:06only improve the quality of the process, but can also
- 21:09be expected to often provide important benefits to the victims.
- 21:13Miss Annie Farmer was introduced by her counsel, David Boyce,
- 21:16and stated that she was sixteen years old when she
- 21:19had the misfortune of meeting Jeffrey Epstein in New York.
- 21:24Miss Farmer said that mister Epstein flew her to New
- 21:26Mexico and was inappropriate with her. She was reluctant to
- 21:30go into details about her experience with mister Epstein. Miss
- 21:34Farmer opposes mister Epstein's pre trial release because she believes
- 21:38other Epstein victims would continue to be victimized and that
- 21:42mister Epstein's wealth and privilege and notoriety would make it
- 21:46difficult for other victims to come forward. Miss Courtney Wilde,
- 21:51introduced by her counsel Brad Edwards, and said she was
- 21:55sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein starting at the age of fourteen.
- 21:59She asked the court to get mister Epstein in detention
- 22:01for the safety of any other girls out there that
- 22:04are going through what she was going through. Miss Wilde
- 22:07said that mister Epstein is a scary person to have
- 22:10walking the streets. Mister Epstein poses a threat to additional
- 22:14young girls if he's released. At the remand release hearing
- 22:19on Monday, July fifteenth, twenty nineteen, as noted, the court
- 22:23heard poignant testimony from two of mister Epstein's alleged victims
- 22:27about their fears and anxiety over his potential release. Even
- 22:31if under strict conditions of home confinement. The court is
- 22:35also concerned for new victims. Mister Epstein's alleged excessive attraction
- 22:41to sexual conduct with or in the presence of minor girls,
- 22:45which is said to include his soliciting and receiving massages
- 22:49from young girls and young women, perhaps as many as
- 22:52four times a day, appears likely to be uncontrollable. Defendants
- 22:57alleged sex crimes were of an addictive sexual nature that
- 23:01cannot be suppressed simply by a restrictive set of bell conditions. Accordingly,
- 23:06mister Epstein's past sexual conduct is not likely to have
- 23:09abated or been successfully suppressed by fierce determination, as his
- 23:14defense counsel suggests. Defense counsel contends that he wasn't a
- 23:19predator that couldn't control his conduct. He disciplined himself. Defense
- 23:23counsel also argues that appreciating the gravity of these charges,
- 23:28putting aside the age of these witnesses, and putting the
- 23:30consent issue aside, it's not like Epstein's and out of
- 23:33control rapist, it seems fair to say that mister Epstein's
- 23:38future behavior will be consistent with past behavior, including a
- 23:41trove of lewd photographs of young looking women and girls
- 23:45which were recently uncovered during the July twenty nineteen search
- 23:49of mister Epstein's seventy first Street mentioned. The search results
- 23:53suggests that possibly the defendant could target another vulnerable victim
- 24:00States First Baker three forty nine f. Dot supp. Where
- 24:04the defendant was alleged to specifically target vulnerable women, and
- 24:07where he attempted to contact an alleged victim, The court
- 24:11was persuaded that the defendant would be a danger to
- 24:13society if released. Despite having been convicted of the above
- 24:18mentioned to Florida sex crimes in two thousand and eight
- 24:21involving an underage girl, mister Epstein, as noted, maintained his
- 24:26New York residence of vast trove of sexually suggestive photographs
- 24:30of nude underage and adult girls doc at eleven example
- 24:34one at nine. That is, during July six and seventh,
- 24:37twenty nineteen, the authorized search of mister Epstein's NYC residents,
- 24:43the FBI found a substantial collection of photographic trophies of
- 24:47his victims and other young females. This evidence includes compact
- 24:51discs labeled young redacted names, miscellaneous nudes, one girl, picked nudes,
- 24:57and the government contends that this evidence includes hundreds or
- 25:01perhaps thousands of sexually suggestive photographs of nude underage girls
- 25:05and women, and that it's corroborative in nature and it's
- 25:09consistent with the victim recollections of inside mister Epstein's residence.
- 25:14This newly discovered evidence also suggests that mister Epstein poses
- 25:18an ongoing and forward looking danger see doc at eleven
- 25:22at ten. See also Baker us First good Win two
- 25:26fifteen WL six three eight six five six eight at three, Kentucky,
- 25:32October twenty first, twenty fifteen. All Right, we're gonna wrap
- 25:36up right here, and in the next episode, we're gonna
- 25:39pick up where we left off, and that's with the
- 25:41section fifteen ninety one presumption of pre trial remand reflects
- 25:46the seriousness of mister Epstein's alleged crimes. All of the
- 25:51information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 25:54the description box.