Latest / Elsies Little Pickles’s Podcast / Breaking Down "Isms": A Deep Dive into Marxism, Socialism, and Communism
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:21It's time for another Elsie's Little Pickles, the pickle pod for the people.
- 0:26We are actually very, very lucky. This week we have, even though we've lost
- 0:31kefir because of travels, we picked up Colton as a filler.
- 0:36And what's up? We also have our guest.
- 0:40So it's not always a new pickle. Yeah, we got a new pickle on the pod.
- 0:44So the thing that's been going around, and let me introduce our guest, Noah Mel.
- 0:51He is very, very plugged into Marxism, capitalism, communism,
- 0:57socialism, all the isms, really, just like Colton is as everyone should be at
- 1:02the current time. Right.
- 1:03Well, see, here's the thing is I don't think when people throw these terms around,
- 1:09they actually know what the fuck they're talking about.
- 1:11I don't think that they know what it means. You know, I heard an interesting commentary on that.
- 1:19So not a direct insult at anyone in particular, but most Americans,
- 1:24when it comes to politics, are halfwits.
- 1:28I think that's being generous. Yeah, what you should be afraid of are the midwits,
- 1:37people that have enough knowledge to be dangerous. That's me.
- 1:43Isn't that all of us? Isn't that all of us? Yeah. So, so I guess really kind
- 1:47of what I want to do here is pick both of your brains regarding,
- 1:52communism and socialism specifically, because those are the two that get tossed
- 1:56around as almost pejorative statements.
- 1:59And I don't think that if you really break it down, I don't think that either
- 2:05of those should be dirty words.
- 2:08They should be part of the conversation, but they've been, they've
- 2:11been by my generation and and and
- 2:14you know the generation before us it was
- 2:17always about those are bad words man they
- 2:20they'll be afraid you can't even mention
- 2:24that word yeah the red menace yeah exactly so so i think it's it's really important
- 2:30especially under this new trump 2.0 to understand what these things are because
- 2:36they're the ones that are saying you know everything except what trump says is a bad word.
- 2:42Socialism, communism, Marxism, blah, blah, blah.
- 2:45And I just want to break down what kind of where we're at in this country and
- 2:50globally and what's going on.
- 2:53So one of the things that I think is important to the conversation is the fact
- 2:59that there is a bit of a crisis in capitalism right now.
- 3:03Real quick, before we jump into that, I have a question for you,
- 3:07Noah. so obviously Noah I met you working at Olive Garden primarily we also
- 3:13had a couple classes together.
- 3:15And before knowing you, I considered myself a democratic socialist,
- 3:21kind of in the Bernie vein.
- 3:23And you were the one that introduced me to these ideas and for radicalized you.
- 3:28Yeah. For a better term, I think is the word. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, exactly.
- 3:31How did you come into leftist theory and and specifically communism and socialism?
- 3:37Yeah, great question. It wasn't like I just woke up one day and I was like,
- 3:41I think I'm a Marxist now.
- 3:43I don't think anybody comes to ideas like that. It wasn't the college professors for you?
- 3:47No, you know, I was in college at the time. But if you can believe it,
- 3:51they were actually more anti-communist living in the United States, as most people are.
- 3:55Which I think is important for the listeners to understand,
- 3:59okay, is that this idea that every college is just nothing but professors proclaiming
- 4:07the wonder and beauty of communism and socialism.
- 4:11It's not the reality that you guys are or i
- 4:14have dealt with in the classroom no the
- 4:16closest i ever got and i i think you had
- 4:19this professor as well for his privacy i'm not gonna i'm not
- 4:22gonna say his name but closest i ever got was i had one professor say that he
- 4:27was half liberal half socialist okay yeah i i got a lot of that as well and
- 4:33i mean even taking sociology or political science courses i mean we had a class
- 4:36together called the great political thinkers yeah and And the name Karl Marx was mentioned,
- 4:41we had optional reading from the Communist Manifesto that we were not tested on.
- 4:45And that was the professor that I'm referring to.
- 4:49Yeah, we read Brave New World. And that was something that was actually included
- 4:53in the curriculum, maybe more so than Karl Marx.
- 4:56And especially like John Locke, I think we read probably three times the amount on.
- 5:01So I definitely didn't come to it through college. I had a curiosity in political
- 5:05things, as a lot of people do.
- 5:08And it kind of started from just a genuine curiosity. It was during COVID,
- 5:12which was obviously a large crisis, economically speaking, to mention all the social aspects of it.
- 5:19And, you know, we had the 2020 election around that time. So there were a lot
- 5:22of things that were considered crises of capitalism that were going on around me.
- 5:27And whether I recognize them as that or not is kind of, you know,
- 5:31difficult for me to say in retrospect, but it got me curious.
- 5:34And so I opened up the Communist Manifesto, as most people start off,
- 5:40and I read it and I realized I have not heard a single argument from this little short,
- 5:46I mean, 30 page pamphlet before and had spoken previously as if I had.
- 5:51And so that initial curiosity is kind of what drove me forward.
- 5:54And it turns out to have a lot of explanatory power for everything that's going on around me.
- 6:00See isn't that interesting i think for sorry real quick for me it was similar as far as the
- 6:07communist manifesto because i had already squarely proclaimed
- 6:10myself a bernicrat democratic socialist right and
- 6:14i i was at that point in time i was making
- 6:17claims that i didn't have any education
- 6:21or prior reading to support and when
- 6:24i met you once we kind of you know became
- 6:27friends and you kind of got the
- 6:31lay of the land where i was politically and started introducing
- 6:34me to things one of the i think the second thing you recommended that i read
- 6:39was the communist manifesto and at that point i was like when i read it i was
- 6:44like wow literally there's not a single word that you can like in the entire
- 6:49thing there's not a single word that you can take out.
- 6:52Without it impacting the meaning of it, right?
- 6:56Definitely. Yeah, very, very distilled text.
- 6:59And I mean, it's not like you're going to read the Communist Manifesto.
- 7:02I'd recommend to everybody that they read it at least once.
- 7:04Not to become a communist overnight or anything.
- 7:07Just to know. Just to recognize, yeah, we haven't grown up around these concepts at all.
- 7:13And it kind of puts in perspective a lot of the propaganda that we have become
- 7:18accustomed to over the last, I mean, 150 years since Marxism has really been a thing.
- 7:23And it's completely a misrepresentation. So whether you become a communist,
- 7:27whether you even agree with the ideas at all, you at least have some familiarity
- 7:30with it in a way that you're not going to hear somebody say the word Marxism
- 7:34and immediately have goosebumps.
- 7:36Right. So I guess where I'd like to kind of kick off is all of these theories, political theories.
- 7:45Essentially they all boil down to who gets
- 7:48what and how much how big is your piece of the pie you
- 7:51know and how do we make that fair and equitable yeah and that's one of the one
- 7:56of the crises crises that we're facing now under global capitalism yeah because
- 8:01there's a big big shift currently and you know you see it in the united states
- 8:06but you can see it globally there's this big,
- 8:08big shift of wealth that has happened specifically since,
- 8:13well, I mean, you could go back to probably 2017,
- 8:172018, but I think you really started to see it with the breakout of COVID.
- 8:24You saw a lot of businesses go under.
- 8:27And trillions of dollars filter up instead of down. Exactly.
- 8:31And then on top of that, you saw a lot of businesses get absorbed by the bigger fish.
- 8:36So now we're in a situation
- 8:39where you have people like Elon and and
- 8:42you know Zuck and the list goes on you know
- 8:45Tim Apple you got all these guys who are
- 8:48really just kind of on autopilot collecting the checks I mean when you're yeah
- 8:57their money makes them money yeah I mean when you literally can make more money
- 9:02in the eight hours of sleep that you get per night.
- 9:07Doing nothing but sleeping and you can make more money than most people will
- 9:11make in a year or 10 or their career or their career that's fucked up there's
- 9:19no two ways about it that's just,
- 9:21good on you for figuring it out and getting to where you wanted to be and having
- 9:25but that's not it's not solving problems now this goes back to the idea of trickle-down
- 9:30economics which was the idea that Reagan had.
- 9:33Okay, well, if all the companies and the rich people have as much money as possible,
- 9:39they're going to invest it into businesses.
- 9:42And well, that's not really fucking happening. Yeah, he sampled that CIA crack.
- 9:47Yeah, it's just not happening. So now we have, you know, obviously we've got
- 9:52the global community, whether you're talking the G7 or whether you're talking BRICS.
- 9:56One, I don't want to take time from any of you, but just real quick so people
- 10:01know BRICS is Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa.
- 10:06The reason that's important is because of the fact that they're working together
- 10:11in a way that's kind of starting to put a shadow over the way we're doing things.
- 10:18And it looks like they're becoming a little bit more profitable at it.
- 10:22Yeah, and Noah, you have some numbers on that, don't you? I surely do.
- 10:27So BRICS, meaning Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa,
- 10:30has actually grown in recent years, too.
- 10:32It now includes Egypt, Ethiopia, Iran, the United Arab Emirates,
- 10:36and Indonesia, all together being 60% of the world population and producing
- 10:4235% of the global capital output.
- 10:46So 35% might not sound like a lot. 60% of the world population is certainly a lot.
- 10:51And then you compare that with G7, which is what the United States is a part
- 10:55of, as well as countries like Japan and most of Europe.
- 10:58They produce 28% of the total global output.
- 11:02So Merckx is on pace to beat them by about 10% currently. And looking at larger
- 11:07growth than G7 is projected.
- 11:10So now explain this to me like I'm 10. All right.
- 11:15Why is that important for everyone to know? I have my feelings on it.
- 11:20I have my feelings on why it's important.
- 11:23Because to me. I guess a good way to look at it is essentially we're in a system
- 11:30that that looks at the economy globally as a team sport and for a long time,
- 11:40basically since the fall of the Soviet Union until BRICS came about.
- 11:44What was that a couple of years ago?
- 11:47There was essentially a vacuum where there was only one team, right?
- 11:51And anyone that wasn't on the team was, A, didn't have a team to be on,
- 11:56and they were looked down upon by the team.
- 12:00Yeah, there's even this common term, the end of history after the Soviet Union collapsed,
- 12:05basically saying that the United States and G7 and the West as a whole has such
- 12:09unilateral power over the entire world that there will be no further crisis,
- 12:13there will be no conflict it's just the united states
- 12:16forever and ever amen yeah and realism and
- 12:20that did not that turned into basically the united
- 12:23states sitting with their thumb up their ass and and
- 12:27kind of getting lazy and all
- 12:30of a sudden now you have all these other countries are like okay well if we can't
- 12:33be on that team not only getting lazy but
- 12:36getting lazy to the point that we have been exporting jobs
- 12:39well yeah but that right that's something that
- 12:42goes all the way back i mean yeah it goes
- 12:45to yeah exactly as a concept it goes
- 12:47back very far but the hard practice
- 12:51in reality started under reagan though it has.
- 12:53Never been worse than it has in the last 40 years
- 12:56right and that's part of what has led bricks to grow
- 12:59in the rate that it has is most of our actual production and
- 13:03manufacturing is now in a lot of bricks nations and
- 13:06when we run into issues with like the national debt has became such
- 13:10a big issue since the 90s most of the creditors the
- 13:13united states are these brics countries as well so we're
- 13:16looking at a large growth of eastern capital that is kind of outweighing western
- 13:20capital and going to continue to grow that way and what is capital oh we'll
- 13:25get to that we'll get to that let's let's call it money for now we'll call it
- 13:29you know the total amount of social product that we're producing money resources.
- 13:36Commodities yeah sure but really just the important things we're losing and
- 13:40we're losing pretty bad at the moment the united states had like 2.5 percent
- 13:43growth this last year china had 5 gdp growth india had 7 gdp growth and all
- 13:50of this basically means that like,
- 13:53with international trade occurring with the u.s dollar
- 13:56the united states is losing some of what we call its soft power which means
- 14:00the ability to put sanctions on certain countries and stop them from doing trade
- 14:03unless we do what we want them to do yeah and that's your u.s aid that's your
- 14:08that's your cia interventions that's your which which which currently trump is trying to.
- 14:15Get rid of completely so trying to just eliminate
- 14:18soft power yeah people don't realize
- 14:21the the i in my opinion i don't
- 14:24think people fully recognize that soft
- 14:28power goes a lot further for
- 14:31a lot less money than than just
- 14:34boots on the ground so that's that's the
- 14:37thing is sometimes you can you know like the everyone's holding
- 14:41up pieces of paper in the white house going can you believe that they
- 14:43spent this amount of money on you know you know
- 14:46a lib transgender whatever the
- 14:49fuck play three million dollars for a
- 14:52shrimp treadmill and 20 20 million dollars
- 14:55for iranian sesame street all right
- 14:58well look 20 million dollars for an
- 15:01iranian sesame street does seem a bit much
- 15:04but in comparison to what you know
- 15:07i mean that's one drone strike yeah in a little
- 15:11bit of perspective here people you know like that is
- 15:14literally just one drone strike
- 15:17and exactly and
- 15:21and so the idea that that giving up and and eliminating soft power programs
- 15:27is a good idea it it's that short it's stepping over dollars to pick up dimes
- 15:33in many many ways and and this on the last episode we were talking about the wait,
- 15:39what moment as it collectively starts to happen.
- 15:43And collectively, you're starting to see this now. You're starting to see people go, wait, what?
- 15:48No, that's not what you said. I agreed with you on this, but I didn't think
- 15:53you were going to do that.
- 15:54And he is. So that's why this is important because what you're seeing is whether
- 16:01you like it or you don't like it, whether you agree with it or you don't agree with it,
- 16:05you better learn what these different political systems are about because you
- 16:10might find yourself under one of them.
- 16:13And not not because you chose to. All right. So there are places where these
- 16:19things are done pretty well.
- 16:21You know, socialism, you know what? Denmark and Finland, all that area there.
- 16:26They're fucking doing really well with it.
- 16:28At least they seem to be. I'm sure that they got their problems.
- 16:31There is the distinction that they're social democracies, which means they're
- 16:37about as far left as a capitalist economy can be.
- 16:41Which I don't have a problem with. FDR did. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 16:44So these aren't things that are new or scary. These are things that have actually
- 16:49been put into practice in the United States.
- 16:51And, and, and a perfect example, the simplest example is, do you,
- 16:56do you want to have to pay the firefighters bill while your house is burning
- 17:00down? Or do you like the idea that they're just going to show up and put that shit out for you?
- 17:06You know, that's a socialist program. An important thing to note there,
- 17:10too, is, I mean, that's one of those things that are commonly called socialists
- 17:13and may not always be what a Marxist like myself would consider actually socialists.
- 17:17We generally consider that something like a social welfare program.
- 17:20And what this actually does in the long term, it prevents capitalism from having more issues.
- 17:25If we didn't have a lot of these social welfare policies, we'd be seeing a lot
- 17:29more issues on the social scale with a largely uneducated populace, people.
- 17:33I mean, the health care situation is already in tatters. Well,
- 17:37I mean, it's like a concession, right?
- 17:40Exactly. Social welfare is more of a concession. We know you want more,
- 17:44but this is as much as we're willing to give you.
- 17:47And the places that have had the least concessions, like pre-Soviet Russia,
- 17:52that's exactly why we ended up with a Soviet Russia.
- 17:56Yeah, because they were not given any concessions. So this is the reason why
- 18:02I wanted to have the conversation.
- 18:03So with that, one of the things that's real important to me is the wealth distribution
- 18:10in the United States and globally, but let's just go with the United States right now.
- 18:15This accumulation of wealth, it does have a teeter-totter effect.
- 18:21You can't put $300 billion on one side of the seesaw and put a feather on the
- 18:30other side and expect that that's going to balance out.
- 18:33It's not. No matter how much you slide that cash over towards the middle,
- 18:38it's still going to always be on that side, Elon's side.
- 18:43So as that system of capitalism is breaking down, you're starting to see these other systems rise up.
- 18:54And I think when, when you get into AI,
- 18:57when you get into where the workforce is going to go, I mean,
- 19:01there's going to be some jobs, obviously you can never replace with,
- 19:05with AI, but it doesn't mean that you can't replace them with a robot with AI.
- 19:10You know what I mean? So like I was watching this thing today where guy was
- 19:12installing cabinets into a house and they're like, this is something that AI can't do.
- 19:18Give it a, give it a five years. I guarantee you, you're going to have,
- 19:22you know, robot AI dedicated machines that are going to do nothing but hang cabinets perfectly.
- 19:32You know, they're going to be able to scan the lasers out of their eyes to make
- 19:36sure everything's straight.
- 19:37They're going to be able to lift no matter how much the weight is.
- 19:40They're going to have a little fucking drill in their finger,
- 19:42whatever the fuck it's going to be.
- 19:44You're going to be out of a job, you know, and it's interesting because right
- 19:47now, even you're starting to see.
- 19:50There was a huge, huge layoffs that went on in Silicon Valley this week, right?
- 19:55Because they're all on the same fiscal calendar. So you saw huge layoffs from
- 20:00many of the large tech companies.
- 20:02And essentially what's going on is people are working at these tech companies
- 20:07and they are building their replacement with AI.
- 20:11Yeah, and that's an important aspect as well, especially when you're talking
- 20:16about, in Marxist terminology, that would be called labor-saving machinery, right?
- 20:23So, other examples of this would be, in the modern time, most Ford factories
- 20:28are almost fully automated.
- 20:31What else? Most food production is automated by machines, right? Yeah, yeah.
- 20:37Well, the reason why I wanted to set that up— saving machinery and all of that
- 20:40money does not go back to the people who are now out of a job right and that's
- 20:44the reason why i wanted to set it up that way because when you talk about,
- 20:48socialism or communism you could even you know like even the the talk of a basic wage right,
- 20:57yeah you would think that that would make sense given what the future seems to hold right Right.
- 21:05And it's not meant to be scary that, I mean, to me,
- 21:09the idea of having companies that, that have, you know, AI and robotic workers
- 21:15and putting us in a position where we don't have to work, we can pursue other
- 21:20endeavors, whatever those may be.
- 21:23I think that's, that's a pretty good fucking idea.
- 21:27You know what I mean? Like we shouldn't live to work.
- 21:31Yeah. You know what I mean? I agree. And we're going to get our first Marx quote
- 21:35here because I think you've hit something.
- 21:37All right. Lay it on me, brother. Before we get into that, Sam Altman,
- 21:41who is the OpenAI CEO. Very familiar.
- 21:44Just recently had a quote, AI may require changes to the social contract.
- 21:49It may. And this echoes. Yeah, it may. Right.
- 21:52This echoes a certain economist from the 19th century by the name of Karl Marx,
- 21:57who said, the hand mill gives you society with the feudal lord.
- 22:00The steam mill gives you society with the industrial capitalist and now we can
- 22:04adjust this to modern day and think about ai and computers as labor saving technology what is next,
- 22:11yeah because it certainly can't be the same thing it's always been right
- 22:14especially when at at the center of marxism
- 22:17socialism and communism this the core component
- 22:21is labor right well it is
- 22:24and this this gets to it all right i was explaining to
- 22:27friend of the show kirk nolan we were having conversation about this
- 22:30and i was explaining to him look you you have to
- 22:33understand that like trump with all these layoffs and all
- 22:35these departments and whatnot trump is a businessman so
- 22:38is elon and it's ingrained in businessmen that your most expensive resource
- 22:45is your human resources so if you can eliminate as many actual people from doing
- 22:51a job you're going to be that much more profitable, right?
- 22:56So the reason why I think that this conversation is so important is not just
- 23:00what's going on globally, but what's going on with AI and what's going on with
- 23:06what's going to happen with our workforce, all right?
- 23:09So when you see these things and you know that there has to be a new solution,
- 23:14but everyone's afraid to say, you know, socialist or communist is the solution
- 23:22for this particular problem.
- 23:24That's, to me, a lack of understanding.
- 23:28And maybe, you know, maybe I'm wrong. You know, it doesn't mean that Marxism
- 23:33or communism or socialism is the answer to it.
- 23:36But I would think that that would probably have to be at least a little bit in the conversation.
- 23:41Yeah, and the reason why you're seeing, you're seeing like so many left movements
- 23:48kind of rising up and getting gaining popularity gaining traction it really
- 23:53comes down to two things one.
- 23:56Old power structures are dying. So old power structures in the sense of like
- 24:02misogyny or racism or classism, right?
- 24:08Those, those are kind of, kind of falling by the wayside and the people that
- 24:11are still holding onto it are instituting a, like a neo-fascist program, right?
- 24:17So that's what you see in Italy and with the AFD in Germany and with Trump and,
- 24:23you know, millions of examples across the world.
- 24:26And that's always what we've seen with crisis, is that it spawns two things.
- 24:31Harsher criticism of capitalism, which we can call socialism,
- 24:35communism, whatever we want to call these left-wing movements.
- 24:38And there's a counteracting right-wing movement that seeks to preserve the existing
- 24:42system. And typically, this has been fascism.
- 24:45And an excellent example of this would be post-World War I Germany,
- 24:48amidst all the economic crisis that they were experiencing.
- 24:52Coinciding with that was a very rapidly growing communist movement that ended
- 24:57up being, through assassinations and other means, completely suppressed that
- 25:02gave rise to Hitler's Germany.
- 25:04Yeah, and on top of that, you have one of the earliest modern examples of a
- 25:11social democracy in the Weimar Republic, right? Right.
- 25:15So you you see kind of the the the inkling of like, OK, so clearly what has
- 25:23historically been the situation is not the situation anymore.
- 25:27Right. Monarchs are falling.
- 25:30Power structures are falling. So how do we make a more equitable system for
- 25:35people in the modern era?
- 25:38Right. Well, how do you do that without them going? Oh, my God,
- 25:40you're woke. Oh, my God, you're woke.
- 25:42Whatever the fuck that means anymore. I mean, like, it's cool to be woke.
- 25:46Hitler was very anti-woke.
- 25:48Yeah. You could say that.
- 25:51That's putting it lightly. Yeah.
- 25:57Fucking little Charlie Chaplin mustache.
- 26:02Yeah, it was wound a little tight. It was definitely anti-woke.
- 26:08In my good Christian Florida. Yeah, exactly.
- 26:11All right, so that's kind of how I wanted to start the conversation and frame
- 26:16what it is we're talking about.
- 26:18Because right out of the gate, just if I put communism explained or communism
- 26:25and socialism and Marxism explained on the title, people probably wouldn't even fucking bother.
- 26:32But you've got to understand that this is not necessarily the direction that we have to go.
- 26:39But at some point, our technology is going to displace us from the workforce.
- 26:46Yeah, it's pushing us in that direction, whether we want that direction or not.
- 26:50Yeah, we don't need a boogeyman.
- 26:52We don't need, you know, a Hitler or even a Trump.
- 26:55You know what I mean? Like, it's not about the boogeyman here.
- 26:58It's about this is just the way things are moving forward.
- 27:01And with this move forward in in AI and robotics and and how it's going to be
- 27:08used in the workforce to eliminate as many human resource positions as possible.
- 27:16In order to create that, that increase in profit, we do need to look at the
- 27:21system and go, okay, well, wait a minute.
- 27:23If you're not going to have any employees, you're going to have to pay into some sort of.
- 27:30Fund here yeah because we're not we're not the
- 27:3390 the 99 we're not
- 27:36going to just sit sit back and let you take all the money
- 27:39while we're exactly and it wouldn't be in there it wouldn't be in their best
- 27:43interest anyway because at some point you are now making products that no one
- 27:48can afford because they don't have jobs yeah and so at that point you are guaranteeing
- 27:53some level of revolt or at bare minimum, just push back. Exactly.
- 27:58Yeah, this is why crisis is a cyclical issue in capitalist societies,
- 28:01is we constantly are kind of milking more profit out of the working class by
- 28:05reducing wages, by increasing profit rates to compensate for losses in profit
- 28:09rates, all of these issues.
- 28:11And in the process of doing so, when wages go down, people don't have the money
- 28:15to buy the now inflated goods that are on the market.
- 28:18Yeah, and on top of that- Couldn't have said it better, that's awesome.
- 28:22And what what summing up that sentiment, it's it's the idea that capitalism
- 28:27is a system of infinite growth on a planet of finite resources.
- 28:32Right. So capitalism requires the line to go up.
- 28:36Well, at a certain point, there's nothing you can feed in to continue growing
- 28:41that line. So I'll give you an example, a real world example.
- 28:44Right. I was running a used department for motorcycles at a dealership.
- 28:51And the, it came to that point of, you know, right around this time of year.
- 28:55And the owner comes to all of the managers and says, I want you to put together
- 28:58your budgets and your expectations and forecast for the following year, which I did.
- 29:04And I actually spent more time on it than anyone else.
- 29:08I took into consideration that at that point we were going into a political
- 29:11year, it was going to be a presidential election that historically for those,
- 29:15you know, at least three months out of Although out of a political year like
- 29:18that, you're going to see, depending on how the economy is and how popular the
- 29:23incumbent is, you're going to see a shrinkage.
- 29:25And even if it's not a lot, you're still going to see some.
- 29:29And I was trying to explain to him that all these economic indicators,
- 29:33the best you could hope for would be one and a half to 2% increase.
- 29:38And I said, that's being generous.
- 29:40And he goes, well, that doesn't work for me.
- 29:43And I go, OK, well, I'm sorry it doesn't work for you. He goes,
- 29:46do it again. I go, well, the answer is still the same.
- 29:50This is the correct answer. If you don't want the correct answer,
- 29:53why don't you just do it yourself and put down whatever imaginary number you
- 29:57want to fucking put down on there.
- 29:59But I'm not going to be held accountable to imaginary numbers that are not attainable.
- 30:05You know, I'm not going to let you might not be happy with my answer,
- 30:08but I'm not going to risk my job by giving you.
- 30:12Well, what I ended up doing was I ended up resigning from that particular position.
- 30:17And guess what? That year they had one and a half percent growth.
- 30:22So, like, I was calling it for what it was, not what he wanted to hear.
- 30:27But that that's the way business works. And that's the way Wall Street works.
- 30:30We don't care, but you better, you know, we don't care how you do it,
- 30:35but you better give us 3% at least increase year after year after year and preferably five to 8%.
- 30:42But the bare minimum that they're taking is 3%. All right.
- 30:45Well, when you don't have any more human resources to lay off, right?
- 30:52When, when literally you're on, you're running a business on your own,
- 30:56because at a certain point, it's just you turning out.
- 31:00And unplugging the robots and flicking the switch so that they go to work,
- 31:07when that's literally all that's left, who's buying that product?
- 31:14Absolutely. And that's why I say this is so important.
- 31:17Most used motorcycle dealers don't exactly have the money to completely automate
- 31:22their workforce. That tends to be a pretty expensive thing.
- 31:25That's another thing that drives a concentration into bigger dealers that have
- 31:29the type of money to be able to afford some layoffs still and be able to afford
- 31:33some new labor-saving technology that might help them increase their profit
- 31:36rates. And so they're able to out-compete. Yeah.
- 31:38And that's what I'm saying is that we're seeing this happen.
- 31:42We may not be able to put our thumbs on it or directly say this is the word
- 31:48for what's going on, but this is what's going on.
- 31:52And if as a listener, you're not paying attention to what the other,
- 31:56and again, you don't have to agree with any of this.
- 31:58You don't have to agree with communism. You don't have to agree with capitalism.
- 32:01You don't have to agree with social, any of the isms.
- 32:03You don't have to agree with them. but you should understand what
- 32:06it means because things are happening
- 32:09because it's happening and it's going to affect you one way
- 32:12or the other and whether you call it woke or whether you call it broke or a
- 32:16joke or whatever the fuck you want to call it the reality tomorrow is coming
- 32:21whether you want whether you participate in it or not so i want to get i want
- 32:28to get to marxism we'll get to that in just a minute.
- 32:33All right. So for, for all the listeners, one of the things that I want to do
- 32:38here is it's not that we're promoting or condoning or condemning any system.
- 32:45We're saying that they all have pros and cons.
- 32:49And if you don't understand what those systems are, you can't make a decision
- 32:54that is in your best interest, you know?
- 32:58So it's, it's, it's one of those things where like, all right,
- 33:02I'll give you an example, right?
- 33:04Putting faith into something. Okay, great. I like to be able to put faith in
- 33:08things, but I also like to be able to confirm that I'm going to get what I'm paying for here.
- 33:13You know what I mean? So like, I don't, I don't put faith into my investments.
- 33:19I put research into my investments, you know, and I'll just go,
- 33:23oh, look, that sounds fun.
- 33:25I'm gonna buy a piece of that company no that's fucking stupid so that's how
- 33:29you that's how you end up in the bottom you know the bottom 10 that's how you
- 33:34end up with a bunch of trump coin.
- 33:37People lost their asses like their entire life savings there was it was pretty
- 33:42good one millions though if i was paying attention just a little more yeah yeah all right so so,
- 33:49let's break it down let's start with marxism give me a little bit of a history
- 33:53on that kind of if you could, Noah,
- 33:55and kind of like I said, explain to me some of the pros and cons and how it's
- 34:00been used right and how it's been used wrong.
- 34:03Absolutely. Yeah. I think, you know, with any system that we're going to talk
- 34:07about, there are advocates of systems that are going to be dogmatic about it
- 34:10and tell you there's nothing that's wrong with it.
- 34:12I am not one of those people. And I think it's especially important when talking
- 34:16about Marxism to assess the flaws that we saw in 20th century Marxism,
- 34:21for example, in places like the Soviet Union, in China, North Korea,
- 34:26the list goes on and on. Half the world was Marxist.
- 34:29But at the same time there's a lot of fear mongering that goes
- 34:32into talking about these things it's very hard to separate what
- 34:35was essentially red scare cold war propaganda and
- 34:39what actually occurred and what we should really think about
- 34:42it in the year 2025 well and
- 34:45i so marxism sorry to interrupt i would just
- 34:47like to add we're going to get into this once we
- 34:50kind of get into kind of what the what
- 34:53the basis of marx's philosophy is right
- 34:57but kind of at the core of it is critique
- 35:01self-critique and and
- 35:04learning from prior mistakes right absolutely
- 35:08that's that's that's a core part of
- 35:11the the philosophy not necessarily
- 35:15the ideology in certain applications i was gonna say because the application
- 35:19of that does not seem to be yeah application dependent but a core component
- 35:25of the philosophy of it is critique self-critique and learning from mistakes
- 35:30okay all right i got that yeah.
- 35:34So it's it's kind of hard to pin down exactly what marxism is because there
- 35:37is such a long history of deviations to marxism a lot of the time what we're
- 35:43talking about when we talk about communism in the Soviet Union and China is
- 35:46what's called Marxism-Leninism,
- 35:48or sometimes Maoism.
- 35:49And that's only one specific type of Marxism out of a myriad of options that
- 35:53developed over the course of the 20th century.
- 35:55I don't think we really need to get into all the specifics of these to really
- 35:58understand what Marxism is, though, because Marxism came out of very definite
- 36:02historical trend of socialism all throughout Europe at the time.
- 36:06Marxism, basically, I would say, is a political doctrine that has its basis
- 36:11in economics, sociology, political theory, and a bunch of other fields of study.
- 36:19Vladimir Lenin, chill's running up your arms right now. Oh, God. Summarized it.
- 36:25As basically being broken into... Ivan, your means of production.
- 36:31Yeah, right. Yeah, that's how he broke it.
- 36:34Broke it down to philosophy, political economy, or economics,
- 36:39and what he called scientific socialism.
- 36:42And that might sound like a difficult thing to pin down, especially.
- 36:45But once you look at the history of where Marxism came from,
- 36:49scientific socialism makes a little more sense.
- 36:51As long as capitalism has been around, there's been criticism of capitalism.
- 36:56And early on in capitalism's development, there were a lot of what we would
- 37:00call utopian socialists.
- 37:01These are people that would look around themselves and say, there's a lot of things wrong here.
- 37:06The promises of liberty, egality, fraternity weren't exactly met after,
- 37:12let's say, the French Revolution.
- 37:14And so utopian socialists said, I think this should happen. I think that's a
- 37:18long history of utopian socialism in Ireland.
- 37:23Okay, definitely. Yeah, because at the time when utopian socialism was happening,
- 37:28we're talking like late 1600s, 1700s, right?
- 37:32And that's when this idea of utopian socialism kind of comes about in force.
- 37:40And at that time, Ireland was firmly under the boot of England.
- 37:46Essentially all of the colonialism and slavery that
- 37:50that the english exported around
- 37:53the world their testing ground for it was
- 37:55ireland okay so some of some
- 37:58of the some of the landlords in ireland who were english
- 38:01kind of got this kind of got this this ultimatum
- 38:04from some of their some of their essentially slaves
- 38:08who were irish and serfs
- 38:11yeah serfs whatever you want to like pin
- 38:15pin them to but essentially serve slaves and
- 38:18something i found really interesting is so
- 38:21like the the irish the the peasants they would essentially petition their landlord
- 38:27to be like hey we want to set things up this way in a utopian socialist way
- 38:32because we think that'll work better for us most of the time they got stomped
- 38:36out sometimes they didn't and of those that didn't.
- 38:41They were also heavily Catholic, right? In Ireland then and now.
- 38:47The Vatican City sent bishops out to Ireland on essentially like humanitarian missions, right?
- 38:55And those bishops came back and said, of the utopian socialist farms,
- 39:00we have not seen a more Christ-like group of people.
- 39:05We have not seen a better representation of what Christianity means than the
- 39:11Irish peasants under these utopian socialists.
- 39:15I mean, that makes sense because the idea, you know, from where I'm coming from,
- 39:20at least, is that utopian view of socialism is everyone gets enough to eat.
- 39:28You don't need more than you need, but you'll have at least enough.
- 39:33You'll have some leftovers.
- 39:35You know what I mean? Like you should be able to, you know, you should be able
- 39:38to have food, a roof over your head, medical care, which I'm sure wasn't great at that time.
- 39:46But these are, these are simple things like you should be able to survive.
- 39:53And I don't think that that's utopian. I think that that's common sense.
- 39:58You know, the guy that doesn't. Yeah, I mean, it's a lot of shoulds based on what they don't have.
- 40:02Yeah, I mean, I think it's understandable why people would want it to be a certain way.
- 40:06The guy with the loaf of bread doesn't steal another loaf of bread unless he needs it.
- 40:10I mean, that's really what it boils down to, you know? Yeah.
- 40:14All right, so you got the utopian view of it, which, from what I'm gathering,
- 40:20was very much along the lines of biblical teachings of Jesus. Yeah.
- 40:27And the reason it's it's correct me if I'm wrong, Noah, but from what I understand,
- 40:31the reason it's called utopian socialism is because the the common idea in that movement was. Yeah.
- 40:39What we would now call kind of a democratic socialist view, which is if we just
- 40:44ask really nicely, maybe the capital owners will allow us to do this.
- 40:50Maybe they'll give in willingly if we just ask nicely enough.
- 40:53Sure. Yeah. I mean, that was definitely some of the utopian socialist position
- 40:57is that, well, we can make things better for ourselves so it'll be comfortable
- 41:00and not really thinking about what the interest of the capitalist is or the
- 41:05interest of the worker is, thinking about, I want this.
- 41:08And so I think it would be really great if we were able to petition and get
- 41:12a hold of these resources that we need to make our lives objectively better.
- 41:15Pretty pleased with a cherry on top, Mr. Capital Owner.
- 41:18Yeah, absolutely. And actually, sometimes specific utopian socialists were capitalists
- 41:23themselves, which seems like a contradiction.
- 41:25But one notable example was this man named Robert Owen, who put together his
- 41:31utopian socialist vision in the form of a factory in which he.
- 41:37Educated children throughout their lives, gave them a ton of benefits that were
- 41:42not accessible anywhere else at any factory all throughout England,
- 41:46France, Germany, any of these capitalist centers of Europe at the time.
- 41:49Treated them like humans. Basically, treated them like humans.
- 41:52And when he got later through this process, he kind of looked down and said,
- 41:56this is great. you know, I've given these people a lot, but at the same time,
- 42:00these are all still people that are subservient to me.
- 42:03And so out of this, Mark studied Robert Owen in his experiment,
- 42:07or his experiment, and a lot of people that kind of followed suit with that called the Owenites.
- 42:13And he developed a critique as to why did this not lead to this perfect ideal
- 42:19situation as it should have?
- 42:22I mean, the aims were all there. The aims were positive.
- 42:25It's not like they were trying to keep people subservient to them,
- 42:28but they still couldn't make it past a lot of these barriers that seemed to
- 42:32be kind of cooked into the capitalist system.
- 42:35Yeah, because while his factory may have been utopian socialist,
- 42:39the rest of the world was not.
- 42:41So, yeah, it was also just an isolated little bubble. Yeah.
- 42:44And I think they were largely like they were largely subjugated in the sense
- 42:49of not necessarily like a slave sense.
- 42:52No, but they knew who was buttering their bread.
- 42:55Yeah. We can't get any better than this. So why would we do anything other than this?
- 42:59Exactly. And that's that's that's where you always see the problem with,
- 43:03you know, any arguments against capitalism.
- 43:06Right. is, well, what's the point if I can't get obscenely wealthy?
- 43:13You know what I mean? Or if I can't have obscene levels of success,
- 43:17why would I work harder than I have to?
- 43:20Which is most often said by people who are about two paychecks away from living on the street.
- 43:26And that may be true, but I guess there is a bit of, it is baked into human
- 43:32nature that, as an example with that,
- 43:37if you know who's buttering your bread and you're not unhappy with that guy,
- 43:42why wouldn't you just continuously worship him?
- 43:46You know, he's the guy that's making this all happen. I'm going to do whatever he wants.
- 43:50You know, I'm counting my blessings and I'm willing to give back to him.
- 43:54So I think that, yeah. And I don't say that in a negative way.
- 43:58I say that it just might be part of human nature.
- 44:03And that's the thing that I wonder if any of these systems can really fully
- 44:07wrap their hands around is that you're dealing with,
- 44:12human nature you're dealing with squishy little fat
- 44:15fucking people that want to have a
- 44:18great time but also are willing to
- 44:21be loyal because they don't want to make a decision they want to follow the
- 44:25leader you've fallen you've fallen right into our trap good that's exactly what
- 44:29i hope for our evil communist trap yes so so enter scientific socialism noah
- 44:35yes so oh there is this idea of human nature,
- 44:39and that was actually a crucial part of the utopian socialist vision as well,
- 44:43is this is completely compliant with human nature.
- 44:46The issue is human nature changes based on what we call modes of production.
- 44:51Human nature under slavery is different than human nature under feudalism,
- 44:55is different than human nature under capitalism.
- 44:57And so if we look at the behavior of a capitalist or the behavior of a worker,
- 45:01we notice these are specifically tied to their class position in society.
- 45:06The capitalist is the personification of the capitalist system.
- 45:11He has to do these things because it is his position as the capitalist to do so.
- 45:16And same with the workers who have to work to earn a wage to feed themselves.
- 45:21These are necessary social conditions that the utopian socialists didn't historically evaluate.
- 45:27And so Marx's theory of scientific socialism takes a
- 45:30step back looks at the entire course of
- 45:33human history and says that there are
- 45:36definitive changes in the way that we interact
- 45:39with nature that lead to definitive changes
- 45:43in our arrangement as a society and
- 45:46the classes that then conflict with each other
- 45:49and that leads us into the next
- 45:52stage of society which is in
- 45:56our case socialism okay so that's the
- 45:59marxist argument so basically marxism leads
- 46:03us into socialism no capitalism leads us into socialism capitalism leads us
- 46:09into socialism socialism leads us into communism yes and marxism is just kind
- 46:14of marxism is just kind of like floating over the top going i like that idea
- 46:19I like that idea. I like that idea.
- 46:21Right. I mean, it's the mode of analysis that kind of.
- 46:24So really, yeah. So, I mean, really the way we should be looking at, well, hold on a second.
- 46:29The way we should be looking at it is if we had, you know, the little spyglass, right.
- 46:36And pull it out. And we're looking at, you know, across the ocean. Yeah.
- 46:41That spyglass is Marxism. It's the way of interpreting.
- 46:46It's a lens of interpreting all of this through. Okay. Absolutely.
- 46:50Yeah. And so it's not so much that we are this hand over society that's moving
- 46:55the pawns in this specific way to get us to the communist vision.
- 46:59It's more so, and I'm going to read from the Communist Manifesto here so that
- 47:03it's directly from Marx himself. Yeah.
- 47:06Citation needed, please. Yep. So the weapons with which the bourgeoisie felled
- 47:11feudalism to the ground are now turned against the bourgeoisie itself.
- 47:15But not only has the bourgeoisie forged the weapons that bring death to itself,
- 47:18it has also called into existence the men who are to wield those weapons,
- 47:22the modern working class, the proletarians.
- 47:25And basically what this is trying to say is that the capitalist class can't
- 47:30exist without a working class, the proletarians, who do the labor that actually produces the capital.
- 47:36And similarly, since the workers don't have the means of production themselves,
- 47:40they have to sell themselves to the capitalist in order to, you know, live.
- 47:46Now, define for the listeners, bourgeois or bourgeoisie, means of production,
- 47:52proletariat, because those, you didn't say proletariat, but we're getting there.
- 47:56Those are some core definitions that we need for this conversation.
- 48:00Yeah, absolutely. So means of production, we'll start there,
- 48:03because the classes that are in each means of production, or within like the
- 48:07means of production, change given the historical stage.
- 48:10Means of production are basically the things that you use to transform nature
- 48:14to end up with a certain product.
- 48:17In capitalism, the means of production you can think of as a factor of production.
- 48:21We produce commodities. That is what capitalism is all about.
- 48:25We sell these commodities on the market.
- 48:27And if you really get down into it, workers themselves are reproduced as commodities.
- 48:31We receive a wage. We sell ourselves back after we've been replenished through
- 48:36this wage, maintaining ourselves on the market to capitalists,
- 48:39just as commodities are also bought and sold.
- 48:41Labor itself is a means of production.
- 48:44Yes, in a sense. and so if we
- 48:47look at the means of production of capitalist society there
- 48:51are two classes necessary to make it happen and
- 48:55those are the capitalist class the bourgeoisie and the
- 48:58working class the proletariat i'm not going to get into like the etymology of
- 49:02what these specific french terms mean or anything but basically the the idea
- 49:07here is that the capitalist is the one that owns the means of production they've
- 49:12come to this position in society through a long historical process.
- 49:16Or sometimes, you know, you have that American success story where somebody
- 49:20moves their way up from the working class to the capitalist class,
- 49:23although this is happening less and less every day.
- 49:26And they own the means of production, but they have nobody to work it.
- 49:30You can look at some small cases of like a mom and pop shop where the person
- 49:34is doing their own labor with their own means of production.
- 49:38And we would call them petty bourgeoisie or small bourgeoisie.
- 49:43Tiny bit bougie that is where the term bougie comes from little bit bougie that
- 49:51is where the term bougie comes from is bourgeoisie.
- 49:55So the vast majority of these cases are a capitalist who has a ton of means
- 50:01of production, far more than they could ever operate themselves,
- 50:04and they need to produce a ton of product, and they need people to be able to do that.
- 50:09And so historically how this happened is we had things called the enclosures of the commons,
- 50:14the expropriation of agricultural laborers from their land under feudalism,
- 50:19that basically created this whole mass of people that had nothing to do to fulfill
- 50:23their own needs because all this common land was closed off.
- 50:26And so they decided to sell themselves to capitalists who had the productive
- 50:32facilities in order to produce commodities.
- 50:35And so that's kind of the genesis of capitalism. That's where it starts.
- 50:39And that's where those classes come from. So I guess the question then,
- 50:43and maybe this is a question for later,
- 50:47okay, but when you remove the worker from the equation and replace them with AI, robotics.
- 50:57Etc., what system is that going to be?
- 51:03You know what i mean like because i don't think it's been defined yet like
- 51:07there is going to become this shift and that's why like i said i wanted to to
- 51:11get the definitions of marxism capitalism socialism and and the the ups and
- 51:16downs of it so keep that question in mind because i want to actually save that
- 51:21for the end of the show is when you remove when you remove the worker However.
- 51:27Where, what, what is the system that makes society continue to function?
- 51:32All right. So, so we've kind of handled Marxism, I think, unless you had anything
- 51:37more you wanted to add to that.
- 51:38Well, let's, let's go into dialectical materialism real quick,
- 51:42because I think that is an important, an important aspect of.
- 51:45Of the method of critique that Marx puts forward. Lay it on me,
- 51:49because like I said, I'm here for the education.
- 51:52So go ahead. Yeah, so dialectical materialism, you can kind of break it down
- 51:56into two different pieces, right?
- 51:58So there's the dialectic, and then there's the materialism.
- 52:03The easiest piece of that to understand first is materialism.
- 52:09Materialism is a philosophy or a school of thought,
- 52:13I guess would be a better way of putting it that stands
- 52:16opposed to idealism so i
- 52:19guess for an example idealism is the
- 52:22is the concept that history is driven forward
- 52:25by by ideas
- 52:28or by by thoughts right another way
- 52:32of thinking of it might be like the great man theory the sense
- 52:36that history is pushed forward by one great man
- 52:39with great ambitions you're napoleon you're you
- 52:42know alexander alexander the great alexander the great yeah your great man theory
- 52:47that's they have these visions that are beyond our comprehension beyond anyone's
- 52:53comprehension and they are the people that that move history forward materialism on the other hand.
- 53:02Rejects that idea and recognizes that material circumstances,
- 53:07so how much money a worker is getting paid, how much capital the capitalist has.
- 53:14Material circumstances, real things, are what move history forward, right?
- 53:20Yeah, I think I land more on the
- 53:24idea that you have visionaries that come around
- 53:27every you know every generation or so
- 53:30you know your einsteins and and and the like your
- 53:34your socrates your plato your great thinkers
- 53:38that that do push but would society forward in ways that society couldn't have
- 53:43even thought of that's fair but would einstein have been einstein if he was
- 53:49not well off enough to attend school ah it's a good point or even even beyond that i mean.
- 53:57The reason for so long we have had an idealist conception of history is it's
- 54:01easy to look at these big figures that actually are doing the things that are changing society.
- 54:06That's not what we're saying is not happening, but that there are specific social
- 54:10circumstances that give rise to individuals that are like that.
- 54:13Especially when we're considering political ideas, there are specific political
- 54:17circumstances that these people find themselves in where their actions are determined
- 54:22by these circumstances.
- 54:24No, I would agree with you on that. I would absolutely agree with you.
- 54:27Because if you don't have the education, or if you're not in the situation where
- 54:30you could have gotten the education to expose you to the thing that you found
- 54:33most fascinating, in his case, physics, and mathematics,
- 54:37had he not had the data available to him, he may have never discovered it.
- 54:42And he might have just been a patent clerk.
- 54:45So yeah, I get that. If we adapt that to political theorists,
- 54:49if we think about somebody like Lenin who led the Soviet Revolution in Russia...
- 54:54This would have never happened if the situation already in Russia was not one
- 54:59where people were split up between proletarian and bourgeoisie,
- 55:04where this specific social relation existed to give rise to this broader social
- 55:08change through the ideas of one specific person.
- 55:12And I mean, it's not like the whole revolution happened because Vladimir Lenin pointed his finger.
- 55:17There were actual people who supported the revolution and made it happen.
- 55:22Yeah, he wouldn't. He wouldn't.
- 55:25Lenin wouldn't be Lenin if it weren't for millions of like-minded people.
- 55:31Well, yeah, I think that that goes with any large political movement.
- 55:34You could say the same for MAGA, you
- 55:36know, I mean, just because they don't understand what it is that they're.
- 55:41And it's their material circumstances that brought them to that belief.
- 55:45Again, I would absolutely agree with that statement.
- 55:48So you're not losing me yet, guys.
- 55:52So then the other side of dialectical materialism is the dialectic,
- 55:56which goes back as far as Plato, kind of went away for a little bit.
- 56:01There was a revival in, what would that have been, like the early 1800s?
- 56:08With philosophers like Hegel, right? And Hegel was a huge inspiration on Marx.
- 56:15We don't get Marxism without Hegel's dialectic.
- 56:20Now, this is an area that I have an elementary grasp on, so I'm going to kick
- 56:27this over to you, Noah, to kind of explain what the dialectic is and how it
- 56:32plays into dialectical materialism.
- 56:34Yeah, and I'll preface by saying I'm no master either. I mean,
- 56:38Hegel's nickname is the master master.
- 56:40I'm not a Hegel, all right? But basically, the dialectical idea is that things
- 56:46are constantly in change.
- 56:48They change through what we call contradiction, or in the negation of themselves,
- 56:53and we'll get into what that means exactly, and that this is applicable to both
- 56:57social, natural, ideal, and basically everything.
- 57:02So Hegel's dialectic was an idealist dialectic, meaning it pertains to the field
- 57:08of ideas, meaning ideas through constant change give rise to higher ideas.
- 57:12And this is how he kind of viewed history.
- 57:14Now, with the materialist's turn, with Marx coming along, and there's a phrase,
- 57:20turns Hegel on his head, he put primary materialism over the idealism that Hegel had in his dialectic.
- 57:28And so we can basically break down dialectics to make it a little bit easier
- 57:32into three primary laws.
- 57:34And this is how we analyze change in society, which if we're going to have a
- 57:38political historical theory like Marxism is, it's pretty important that we understand
- 57:42the actual motor to how this works.
- 57:45So just a real quick overview of these laws.
- 57:48There's the law of the negation of the negation, which basically states that
- 57:52in the full course of the development of something, things run into their opposites.
- 57:56And so there are a million examples we can think of, one being life and death.
- 58:01Life and death are opposites, but in the full course of development of life,
- 58:04you eventually reach death.
- 58:06And there is nothing alive that is incapable of death.
- 58:13I guess, theoretically, the lobsters, but... Okay, Jordan Peterson,
- 58:19back off a little bit here. The lobsters.
- 58:23Theoretically, lobsters can live forever, but typically they don't. No.
- 58:27Yeah. So I think most people would agree with that law. It's pretty straightforward.
- 58:31Things run into their opposites over the course of time. So if we think about
- 58:34capitalism here, there's a contradiction between the working class and the capitalist class.
- 58:39And if we think about things running into their opposites, they're kind of getting
- 58:42ahead of ourselves. But you can predict what the theory basically is as far as that goes.
- 58:47Especially when the working class is the 98% and the capitalist class is the
- 58:532%. Yeah, there's going to be a problem.
- 58:55That disparity is only growing every day. Yeah, and there's going to be a problem.
- 58:59Right now, I think that we're on the brink of a problem as far as like all of this.
- 59:06I can see that divide.
- 59:09A breaking point. Yeah, there's a breaking point coming. There's this definitive
- 59:12divide between employers and employees.
- 59:15Yeah, and that is one of the points of dialectical materialism.
- 59:20We'll get to that in just a second.
- 59:22We'll actually get to that in this next law that I'm about to talk about.
- 59:25The next law is the unity of opposites.
- 59:27And this basically states that everything contains two contradictory aspects in unity.
- 59:32There's a principal aspect and a secondary aspect. And you can extend that into
- 59:36more than just two, but the point is that there are two primary aspects to everything.
- 59:40And so thinking about capitalism like we are right now, these aspects would
- 59:45be the working class and the capitalist class.
- 59:47And so these two things are in contradiction to each other because they both
- 59:52have their own interests separate from each other. And this creates a lot of conflict.
- 59:56But at the same time, they are a unity because capitalism cannot exist unless
- 1:00:01both of these classes exist.
- 1:00:03We can't just do with capitalists because they aren't the ones doing the labor
- 1:00:07with all of the means of production.
- 1:00:09And we can't just make do. It's not capitalism if there's only a working class.
- 1:00:14Right. Right. Exactly. If there's just a working class, then where did the means
- 1:00:18of production go? Because the capitalists had that, historically speaking.
- 1:00:22So you can kind of see there these two
- 1:00:25things in everyday society are visible they're
- 1:00:29contradictory contradictory to each other but if we talk about
- 1:00:31capitalist systems or society as a whole it's
- 1:00:35a unity it is a system but see
- 1:00:37the thing that i find interesting is even when you have you
- 1:00:40know quote-unquote company run by the employees i
- 1:00:44believe harley davidson tried this for a little bit i don't know
- 1:00:47if it's still the same but there was a
- 1:00:49period of time where essentially the employees
- 1:00:52were running the show and that was
- 1:00:55when they had a resurgence that was
- 1:00:58when they were making more money than they ever made that was
- 1:01:01when their products were better built than they'd been
- 1:01:05historically ever since the 50s yeah
- 1:01:08no before that even like ever right yeah
- 1:01:12so now i don't think that's the case anymore
- 1:01:15but that's how does that fall into like it's
- 1:01:18you know it's a business where essentially as.
- 1:01:22An employee you're buying into ownership you
- 1:01:26know yeah well i mean you're yes you're describing a co-op essentially
- 1:01:30essentially yeah which in in a capitalist economy
- 1:01:33right so the entire world essentially a
- 1:01:38co-op is still a capitalist venture there's just not the one person at the top
- 1:01:46or the group of people at the top that are you know essentially skimming off
- 1:01:51what in marxist terminology would be called.
- 1:01:55Labor surplus value from, from your labor. Well, see, I mean,
- 1:01:59that's the other thing I think that you're seeing a lot of pushback on nowadays
- 1:02:03is people are starting to go,
- 1:02:04okay, well explain to me why as the CEO, you're making over a hundred times
- 1:02:12the amount of the janitor.
- 1:02:14Like it used to be 10, 11% above your lowest paid employee, right?
- 1:02:22Now you're talking hundreds of percent.
- 1:02:25That was also at the time when we had a 94% top-tier tax bracket. Yeah.
- 1:02:33Right. Just putting that out there. Which, oddly, was during the most productive
- 1:02:39time in this country right after World War II.
- 1:02:43Yeah, which universally, obviously, there were many issues socially at the time.
- 1:02:50But in the general zeitgeist of American thought, post-World War II is considered
- 1:02:56the golden age of America.
- 1:02:58Right. That's my point. Yeah. I mean, obviously, you have to take all the social bullshit out of it.
- 1:03:03But just from a post-war profit GDP... Yeah.
- 1:03:10If you're just looking purely at economic indicators... Indicators, yeah.
- 1:03:14Post-World War II, America was the number one country. Yeah, it was the shit.
- 1:03:20For some reason, MAGA doesn't want that 94% top tax rate anyway. I don't understand.
- 1:03:26No, no, they want to return to the 50s, but not for the tax rate.
- 1:03:30I wonder what they might want to be doing.
- 1:03:33Yeah, if you're not going for the tax rate, what are you going for?
- 1:03:36Oh, oh, oh, you're going for that. Something about the back of the bus? Yeah, I see. I gotcha.
- 1:03:43All right, so now moving forward here, unless there's more that I need to.
- 1:03:48To be educated on regarding well there's also the the distinction within dialectical
- 1:03:55materialism of the quantitative and qualitative change right so there's there's
- 1:03:59a difference between those two quantitative in the sense of you take a little
- 1:04:03piece at a time essentially gradual change right.
- 1:04:08At a certain point you you kind of reach a breaking point with gradual change think of Water boiling.
- 1:04:16Okay. Yeah, exactly. It gradually increases in temperature until there's a qualitative
- 1:04:22change, which is it's now being converted into gas because it's boiling.
- 1:04:28In a capitalist system, I guess the way you could view that is let's just take...
- 1:04:36The past 20 years or so capital capitalist
- 1:04:40profit was kind of slowly but
- 1:04:44surely increasing it was steadily increasing and
- 1:04:46then we get the 2008 craft and wages
- 1:04:50drop but profits shoot through the roof right and
- 1:04:54then they kind of like they kind of plateau but they're
- 1:04:57still on the rise people are people at
- 1:05:00the bottom are still struggling but like the capitalist
- 1:05:03profit it's still steadily increasing
- 1:05:07until we get covid and then everyone everyone
- 1:05:11that isn't a capitalist is suffering
- 1:05:15even more and even some of the capital profit oh
- 1:05:18wait a minute shoots through the roof to be fair to be fair there were a lot
- 1:05:22of you know restaurant owners right who who i mean when you say capitalist It
- 1:05:29does seem to almost kind of come across as painting capitalist bad, worker good.
- 1:05:36And I get that. But I mean, you also have like these small restaurants or small
- 1:05:42bars, you know what I mean, where it's just a family who owns it and runs it
- 1:05:45and they couldn't make it through that.
- 1:05:48When I say capitalist in this sense, I'm talking about.
- 1:05:53You know, your, your multinational conglomerate CEOs.
- 1:05:57Okay. That's why I say you gotta, you gotta be a little bit more specific on
- 1:06:01that one because I totally agree with you on that point of view.
- 1:06:05There is, there is something to be said about the, the small business owner
- 1:06:09and there is both praise and critique that can be levied there.
- 1:06:13But when I say capitalist and I think Noah, you would agree when I'm in this
- 1:06:17conversation saying capitalist, I'm talking about Elon, I'm talking about Zuckerberg.
- 1:06:22I'm talking about that's the primary target for sure yeah okay
- 1:06:25yeah and in all of these forms I mean it's important to
- 1:06:28recognize that like it doesn't necessarily imply that
- 1:06:31there's malintent here it's not that they're wanting
- 1:06:34to be evil and licking their fingers together in a
- 1:06:36dark room somewhere it just so happens that they do do that
- 1:06:39yeah oddly oddly it's still it's
- 1:06:43their hobby sure that there's just that tiddly
- 1:06:46links of how our economy works
- 1:06:48that drives them to do these thing and i think with marxism
- 1:06:52being a structural systemic critique it's important
- 1:06:54to understand that like you don't really have to think
- 1:06:57about the concept of evil people to recognize that
- 1:07:00there's a problem here the problem is internal to the system and
- 1:07:03it's driving us quantitatively right now little
- 1:07:06by little or the next big crisis and
- 1:07:09we see crisis every you know seven to ten years
- 1:07:12in the form of a recession that's not necessarily because one
- 1:07:15person did something bad but because there's something structural going
- 1:07:18on well i mean that's on top of that every 20 to.
- 1:07:2150 years in the form of a mass a mass
- 1:07:24depression right yeah or war yeah or
- 1:07:27so so your colton your
- 1:07:31grandmother was an executive secretary at
- 1:07:34a corporation large corporation in the
- 1:07:37detroit area and her boss was basically
- 1:07:42the head of the michigan republican party so even
- 1:07:45though she was absolutely democrat and
- 1:07:49hated it the fact blue is the ocean yeah she
- 1:07:52would be serving coffee and taking notes and whatever as a young lady yeah listening
- 1:08:01to all these really big wig republican party leaders and they at that time were very very clear,
- 1:08:10Military industrial complex is the way to go.
- 1:08:12It was not only good for their businesses, it was good for their bottom line.
- 1:08:17And in their opinion, it was good for the economy because a dead guy can't flip a burger.
- 1:08:24So I think that's something that, that people don't understand is,
- 1:08:28is that really, if you took, if you took the military industrial complex out
- 1:08:33of civilization globally, a lot of these things probably wouldn't be happening.
- 1:08:39A lot of these bad things, you know, whether it's, you know. Well, yeah.
- 1:08:42I mean, it's also important to understand why though. Why do that? Exactly.
- 1:08:46Yeah. Yeah. At this point, war wouldn't, wouldn't be on the table if it wasn't profitable.
- 1:08:51Right. And that's my point. Is it's very profitable, especially for the United States.
- 1:08:56And that's why I think that we've got a problem moving forward is because we're
- 1:08:59always jumping from one financial crisis or bubble, whether that's a housing
- 1:09:04bubble, the tech bubble.
- 1:09:06We fix it with a war. We fix it with a war. And then a little bit more goes on to the national debt.
- 1:09:12I say fix it. I should say we put a bandaid over the recession or the crisis. Right. Exactly.
- 1:09:19Exactly. It's it's a war of distraction more than anything else.
- 1:09:24All right. So let's get to let's get to socialism. This is the one I'm most
- 1:09:28excited about because it's the one that I can I relate to.
- 1:09:31I think the most, though, I have had you tell me, Colton, that that I lean more
- 1:09:36communist than I do socialist.
- 1:09:38But I do think you always confuse me because you will tell me I'm a classical
- 1:09:45liberal and then you'll say something. And I'll be like, okay, that's communist.
- 1:09:49And then I'll explain something about socialism or communism.
- 1:09:52And you'd be like, yeah, yeah, that makes sense. I can get behind that.
- 1:09:55Yeah. There's a reason here to mediate this little father-son thing that's happening.
- 1:10:00Yeah. I think that that's the case with most people, honestly.
- 1:10:04And that's why I think it's so important that people learn for themselves what this actually means.
- 1:10:08Which is exactly the reason why I want.
- 1:10:11Yeah, this is... So, unlike a lot of people, I'm not so stuck in my ways that
- 1:10:17I can't see if I've been wrong. And I'm not so...
- 1:10:22Egotistical that i can't a high threshold of evidence i
- 1:10:25yeah i do need a high threshold of evidence but
- 1:10:28once i've that's been once that's
- 1:10:31been given i i'm not going to go oh well
- 1:10:34i'm not going to admit to it but okay but that's socialism
- 1:10:37yeah you know i don't care what the words are that are put to it i just want
- 1:10:41to make sure that we're all on the same page and it's those very arguments that
- 1:10:46you and i have had or discussions or however you want to look at it those very
- 1:10:51things are the reason why I wanted to have this conversation because I do believe that when,
- 1:10:57when you take away necessary,
- 1:11:00you take away like the, the scary part of it and you go, okay,
- 1:11:03well, we're not going to call it socialism. We're not going to call it communism.
- 1:11:06Do you agree with a B and C you do? Okay. That's all communist.
- 1:11:13Yeah. Well, the problem is at this point, the, the dogma of American capitalism
- 1:11:18is so ingrained in so many people. It is.
- 1:11:21It is. As soon as they hear something that even, that even sparks the question,
- 1:11:27is this socialist? They call it communist, right?
- 1:11:30Right. They don't know the difference. So that's why I wanted to get a definition from you guys.
- 1:11:35Let's start with socialism. I'll give you an even more direct definition right
- 1:11:39now to kind of get ahead of it a little bit.
- 1:11:41Because I think when you hear this, It's not as much this set of things to be
- 1:11:47prescribed to a society, and we'll see how it goes from there.
- 1:11:51And going back to people agreeing with this more than they think they would,
- 1:11:55it's easy to understand once you hear the definitions that Karl Marx and his
- 1:12:00collaborator Friedrich Engels actually put out there.
- 1:12:02Because they didn't write a whole lot about what communism actually is,
- 1:12:05but the definitions that we do have, I'll just read a few here.
- 1:12:10Communism is the riddle of history solved And it knows itself to be this solution,
- 1:12:14There's one definition Basically saying whatever comes after capitalism So not
- 1:12:19very distinct No Second definition We call communism the real movement which
- 1:12:23abolishes the present state of things The conditions of this movement result
- 1:12:27from the premises now in existence.
- 1:12:29Also not too distinct Yeah, this is kind of as clear as mud Yeah,
- 1:12:34right And I think we can get a little closer here Friedrich Engels said Communism
- 1:12:39is the doctrine of the conditions of the liberation of the proletariat.
- 1:12:43So basically, whatever results in the political success of the working class,
- 1:12:47long-term is what we would call communism.
- 1:12:51A little more clear, but I mean, it's still incredibly vague. But importantly,
- 1:12:55an important caveat to why those definitions aren't very clear is because without
- 1:13:03moving past the current, what in leftist circles is called an epoch,
- 1:13:10without moving past the current epoch, you don't know what the next epoch is going to be.
- 1:13:16So an epoch, we are in the capitalist epoch.
- 1:13:20Before the capitalist epoch, we had the feudal epoch.
- 1:13:23And before that, we had the slave society epoch. And then before that was a
- 1:13:29primitive communalism, right?
- 1:13:31Right. And so Karl Marx, the important part of his scientific socialism,
- 1:13:35or it's also called the theory of historical materialism, is that using all
- 1:13:41of the dialectical materialism, that philosophy that we talked about earlier,
- 1:13:44it makes these definitions a little more clear as to what they're referring to.
- 1:13:47Because if we think about the conditions of this movement result from the premises
- 1:13:51now in existence, if we follow those laws of change relating to the class contradictions
- 1:13:57that capitalism has, you're able to see kind of where it's leading.
- 1:14:02We now have a largely socialized production, but the ownership of this production
- 1:14:07is still private. And this is changing.
- 1:14:10If we were to move past a capitalist framework, we're going to see socialized
- 1:14:15ownership as well as production.
- 1:14:17And so this is how we kind of arrive at a more specific definition
- 1:14:20that marx gives and this is perhaps the most specific
- 1:14:24that you're going to get if you read directly from carl marx or friedrich
- 1:14:27engels they say that after labor has become not
- 1:14:30only a means of life but life's prime want after the
- 1:14:33productive forces have also increased with the all-around development of the
- 1:14:36individual and all the springs of cooperative wealth flow more abundantly only
- 1:14:41then in the narrow horizon of bourgeois right be crossed in its entirety and
- 1:14:46society inscribed on its banners from each according to his ability to each according to his needs.
- 1:14:52So they get something important here where like capitalism has to reach a certain
- 1:14:55point of growth where it's able to provide for people and then we don't have
- 1:14:59a reason anymore to appropriate things privately.
- 1:15:01People are able to decide for themselves democratically what we should do as
- 1:15:07a society to allocate all of these
- 1:15:09goods that we're now able to produce so easily with such little labor.
- 1:15:12Yeah, and again, it's not a disagreement on...
- 1:15:20On its face. It's the gap between where we are and where that would,
- 1:15:29where we would need to go.
- 1:15:31That just seems like a very, very big gap.
- 1:15:35It's not so, so big a gap though, when you think about it, because one thing I know is.
- 1:15:41Even if all you're talking about is the logistics of making that a reality,
- 1:15:47forget people's opinions.
- 1:15:50So forget the idea of like, oh, I don't like this.
- 1:15:52Like you're going to deal with that no matter what. But when you get to the
- 1:15:56point of actually executing that plan, that just seems like a big fucking bridge to build.
- 1:16:05So to me, it's not so big a bridge because of a couple of things that Noah touched on. Right.
- 1:16:10So first, we already live in a system of socialized labor.
- 1:16:15Right. So that's the sense of everyone has to work to some extent in order to
- 1:16:22produce all of the needs of society, right?
- 1:16:26You don't have enough food if you don't have enough people working the farms, for example.
- 1:16:33You don't have enough cars if you don't have enough people working to build the cars, right? Yeah.
- 1:16:39But the only the problem is we've now reached we've reached a point and very
- 1:16:45early in capitalism, we reached a point where capitalism could no longer justify its existence. Right.
- 1:16:53It has maintained its existence through force, violence and repression,
- 1:16:59but it has not justified its continued existence.
- 1:17:04That becomes more so a problem, yeah.
- 1:17:06I mean, doing away with the way that things are now seems crazy until you realize
- 1:17:11that, really, for communism to be the emancipation of the proletariat.
- 1:17:17Every day, capital is accumulated into fewer and fewer capitalists through competition.
- 1:17:22There are less and less companies with one or a board of people sitting at the
- 1:17:26top that we would consider a capitalist.
- 1:17:29And so to do away with something like private property, meaning individual ownership
- 1:17:33of production, production that's already happened for, I mean,
- 1:17:37we're regressing toward 99% right now.
- 1:17:40And just to, just to put a, put a stop to the, the most common argument before you get it.
- 1:17:46Cause I know you will private property does not mean your toothbrush.
- 1:17:50It doesn't mean your house.
- 1:17:51Private property is the means of production and capital, right?
- 1:17:56Factories. Right. Yeah. We actually produce things. Yeah.
- 1:18:00Personal property is your toothbrush, your house, your bed, your car.
- 1:18:04No one wants it. Which is fine. Yep. No, no one wants to take that away from you.
- 1:18:08Well, and even if they did, you know what I mean? Like, that's really not the
- 1:18:12argument, I guess. You know, I mean, that, that's, well, is, is it an argument?
- 1:18:16Yeah. But it seems to me like the people who would be.
- 1:18:20Putting that argument forward are thinking small.
- 1:18:24Yeah. And that, that is, that is one problem with it, but that is an overwhelmingly common argument.
- 1:18:31Yeah. I mean, cause as soon as you said private property, I went,
- 1:18:35eh, okay, where's this going?
- 1:18:37You know what I mean? And, and that shuts a lot of people off,
- 1:18:40especially people that are of my age and older, you know, like there's,
- 1:18:45we, we, you know, I think that you guys make really good arguments.
- 1:18:50As to some of the benefits of it, okay?
- 1:18:55And I'm not even arguing or resisting those points of view.
- 1:19:01What I find difficult, though, is getting people to open their mind and hear what that option is.
- 1:19:11It's like the person who goes to a restaurant and never orders anything other
- 1:19:17than the salad. They just don't want to even hear what's, you know,
- 1:19:21no, I don't want to hear what the special of the day is. I don't care. I want my salad.
- 1:19:25All right. Well, that's a closed-minded and boring existence.
- 1:19:29And that's where I think most of us are, is in the closed-minded, boring existence.
- 1:19:34And you could take that analogy and put it across the board.
- 1:19:38The person, there was a guy that I used to work for who, at one point he said
- 1:19:44to me, he goes, you know, Steve, your problem is you need to get yourself into a rut.
- 1:19:50And I was like, what? I was 27. Right.
- 1:19:54And he goes, you need to get yourself into a rut. He goes, you got too much
- 1:19:57going on. You got too many things distracting you. You need to get boring.
- 1:20:02He goes, you need to wake up every day, have the same breakfast,
- 1:20:05come to work, do the same job, have the same lunch, and then mix it up with
- 1:20:12what you have for dinner.
- 1:20:13And I'm like, you're fucking joking, right? He's like, no, I'm dead serious.
- 1:20:18And that's where we are. The vast majority of the country that's over 40, I would say...
- 1:20:26Comfortable in their rut. They're comfortable in their rut. And there's a Marx quote...
- 1:20:33That to me gives a little encouragement as to what could be possible.
- 1:20:40And Noah, I'm wondering if you are thinking of the same quote that I am.
- 1:20:44I could be. Start it off. So I'm going to butcher it. I can promise you.
- 1:20:50But it's something to the effect of every man ought to be able to hunt in the
- 1:20:55morning, work the fields in the afternoon, farm in the evening,
- 1:21:00and still have time to enjoy life.
- 1:21:03Sure, yeah. I mean, the basic idea there, and I mean, it sounds ridiculous hearing it.
- 1:21:08Like people will often read that quote and go, okay, so this is his idea of
- 1:21:11communism is everybody's just kind of hanging out.
- 1:21:14But the point is, past a certain point, and this is perhaps tying us into,
- 1:21:20you know, most people being the working class now and the daunting reality of
- 1:21:25computers and AI kind of pushing people out of their jobs is that it won't be
- 1:21:31necessary if we're able to reduce the amount of labor time necessary to such
- 1:21:35an extent to where people don't have to spend 40 hours of their week,
- 1:21:39five days a week, six days a week doing these things. Nobody wants to do it. No.
- 1:21:43And that's the thing is, is that again, you might be comfortable in your rut,
- 1:21:47but I guarantee you, you fucking hate your job.
- 1:21:49Right. And that's my point is, is that there's no quality of life for most people,
- 1:21:53because if you only were working 40 hours a week, you're pretty lucky.
- 1:21:58Nowadays, it's 50, 55 hours a week.
- 1:22:01Plus, on the weekend, you got to check your emails and make sure that there's
- 1:22:05no surprises for you on Monday.
- 1:22:07It's ridiculous. Now, the downside is, while that's all horrible,
- 1:22:14when you remove that from people.
- 1:22:17There is a major level of adjustment that's going to have to happen in the country
- 1:22:21because you don't. I mean, your first week.
- 1:22:25Sorry to interrupt, but we're already marching towards it with AI. Oh, I agree.
- 1:22:29Yeah. Whether we want to or not. But what I'm saying is,
- 1:22:32is just as I've said that social media was a horrible idea because it's a psychological
- 1:22:39experiment on everyone with no controls in place. Right.
- 1:22:47I don't have a problem with social media. I have a problem with the fact that
- 1:22:49there's no real controls in place.
- 1:22:51And the fact is, is that it does do damage to people of all ages, right?
- 1:22:57Some people just cannot, they cannot handle somebody criticizing them.
- 1:23:02They internalize it too much. And it's the same thing when you,
- 1:23:05you have spent, you know, 10, 15, 20 years.
- 1:23:09I mean, look at you guys, you, you, you've gone through school and worked, right?
- 1:23:15Yeah. So your school week, work week is probably 40, 50 hours,
- 1:23:2060 hours total, maybe more.
- 1:23:23And then you go into a job. When I was with CADC, it was a 48 hour work week.
- 1:23:27And then I was coming home and doing homework.
- 1:23:29Right. And you were taking what, two or three classes at the time?
- 1:23:32When I was working with CADC, three classes. Yeah.
- 1:23:35So now you're talking, that's a second job right there. That's 30 hours additional a week.
- 1:23:41So you're putting in like an 80 hour a week. Like when you get used to that,
- 1:23:46even though it's not healthy, even though it sucks, all those things,
- 1:23:49when you get used to that and then all of a sudden it stops.
- 1:23:54There's an adjustment that mentally, you know, not just an adjustment.
- 1:23:59Sure. But to me, it's an opportunity for self-actualization. Right.
- 1:24:04Well, I would say that I agree with you in theory, but I also know I've seen
- 1:24:09people who have gotten laid off and within six months, they've turned into a
- 1:24:14fucking collapsed ashtray of who they were.
- 1:24:17You know what I mean? Like they're, they're just broken. They're not they they
- 1:24:20don't have a sense of that they needed to be told what to do and and have some
- 1:24:28sort of feeling like what they were doing was important.
- 1:24:31Right. And I think that that goes for everyone. So that's the danger in this, in my opinion.
- 1:24:38I think that's a danger if we don't change the way that we organize society
- 1:24:41and we kind of I agree happened to us. Yeah, I agree.
- 1:24:44And so such an important concept with what past socialist states have done is
- 1:24:50they've guaranteed the right to work wherever there is work for all people.
- 1:24:54I mean, you can look at the Constitution of the USSR, and it was a guarantee that you can get a job.
- 1:24:59You can leave that job whenever you would like. That's also in the Constitution.
- 1:25:02And there were very specific grounds for firing.
- 1:25:05You might not be happy digging coal, but at the same time, you have the right
- 1:25:09to leave that job and find something that you prefer. And I think that that's a good idea.
- 1:25:14But on top of that, I would say that one of my biggest critiques of specifically
- 1:25:19the United States and in both parties is the fact that education on every level
- 1:25:26should be free and encouraged.
- 1:25:30Because if you want your country to be successful, it is not going to happen with stupid people.
- 1:25:37You got to have. And I think you got to have that stimulation.
- 1:25:41But the current way things are arranged where people have to work is,
- 1:25:44for a lot of people, it's not an option. Right.
- 1:25:47Yeah, it's very coercive. That's the problem. It's very coercive.
- 1:25:51And if you're living, you know, 30 to 50% of American households are living
- 1:25:56paycheck to paycheck, the only
- 1:25:58option for people if they do want to become educated is taking out loans.
- 1:26:02And this is how we've gotten to this massive student debt crisis.
- 1:26:04Exactly. Exactly. If we look back again at the USSR, education was also guaranteed
- 1:26:08as a basic right, where people could at any point in their life go back to a
- 1:26:13university and further their education.
- 1:26:15They had the highest rate out of any country in the world of adults furthering
- 1:26:19their education because it was accessible to them.
- 1:26:22Even continued to other socialist experiments, namely Cuba.
- 1:26:27Some of the most educated, despite being a very poor nation,
- 1:26:31all considered. An island.
- 1:26:33Yeah. Yeah, despite being sanctioned by the by the the global dominant country,
- 1:26:39despite being relatively poor, they export the most doctors out of any country in the world.
- 1:26:46You can't do that unless you have a real education system. Right.
- 1:26:51Hold that thought for a second. But yeah, so for me, I look at education as
- 1:26:55the number one thing that every country should be investing in.
- 1:27:00I don't see how that is ever. Yeah, I mean, you can't have a functioning society
- 1:27:06without people competent in running it.
- 1:27:08Yeah, but see, that's the thing is, and this is the argument that I think,
- 1:27:11they won't make this argument, but it's clearly what their goal is.
- 1:27:17We want you smart enough to be able to contribute to society,
- 1:27:23but not so smart that we have to worry about whether or not you're going to overthrow us.
- 1:27:27Smart enough to do your job, not smart enough to notice you're getting fucked.
- 1:27:31Right. And I think that you see that specifically in just the schools.
- 1:27:36All right. Just specifically your high schools.
- 1:27:41Yeah, they're designed to prepare you for an office job. And more importantly,
- 1:27:47very few windows, very, very prison-like.
- 1:27:51I mean, my high school was built by a guy that built prisons.
- 1:27:55Yeah. It was designed and built by a prison architect.
- 1:27:58Right. And that's my point is that they're telling us what they're doing to us.
- 1:28:02We're imprisoning you for the rest of your life in a job that you may or may not want.
- 1:28:09Okay. But you have to have, otherwise you can't eat. Right.
- 1:28:15And to me, that's that's the the distinguished distinguishing factor of socialism.
- 1:28:21Right. So to me, I view it as I kind of split socialism,
- 1:28:26communism, Marxism into maybe a slightly different slightly different category
- 1:28:33as generally communists tend to or leftists tend to.
- 1:28:38To me, Marxism is the philosophy of.
- 1:28:42Socialism is the economic principle, and communism is the society that grows
- 1:28:48out of the combination of those two.
- 1:28:50Okay. Right? So to me, socialism really comes down to the Angle's quote,
- 1:28:57from each according to their ability to each according to their need, right?
- 1:29:02So what does that mean to me? To
- 1:29:04me, that means, A, everyone is able to contribute to society in some way.
- 1:29:13Some people are able to contribute to society more than others,
- 1:29:18but that doesn't mean that the people that aren't able to don't contribute to society, right?
- 1:29:24So even as far back as Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, we see a recognition
- 1:29:32that there are people of different abilities.
- 1:29:35And just because someone has less ability than someone else does not mean that
- 1:29:40they are not worthy of being taken care of. Right?
- 1:29:45Well, I mean, it's important to say, I mean, we don't want everybody to like
- 1:29:48be paid equally and everybody has to be exactly the same in society.
- 1:29:52Yeah, that doesn't work.
- 1:29:54That's not at all what we're saying. Yeah, no, it's not an equal outcome thing. It's not.
- 1:29:58Right. But when we live in a class society where some people have and others do not,
- 1:30:05you're fundamentally going to run into some problems, economically speaking,
- 1:30:08socially speaking, and we're starting to see a lot of those problems just because
- 1:30:12of that type of arrangement.
- 1:30:14Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And then the other end of from each according to their ability
- 1:30:18to each according to their need is that there are people who have different levels of need. And.
- 1:30:25That's not to say that there aren't people that could abuse the system.
- 1:30:30Sure. I don't care what the system is. There's going to be waste,
- 1:30:33fraud, and abuse in every system.
- 1:30:35You just have to accept that that's baked into every one of these cakes.
- 1:30:38Yeah. Having multiple hundred billionaires soon to be the world's first trillionaire,
- 1:30:45to me, is just as much of an abuse of the system as Reagan's welfare queen. Yeah.
- 1:30:52No, I agree. it's just if not more an abuse of the system corporate welfare
- 1:30:58in my opinion is far worse than any welfare that you're seeing on the street
- 1:31:03and that's another point we already have socialism it's just only socialism for the rich.
- 1:31:11Socialism for we and not for the yeah if we
- 1:31:15really had such a big problem with giving handouts our
- 1:31:18economy basically would have collapsed by now I mean 2008 is a
- 1:31:21perfect example with you know the bank bailouts oh yeah if that didn't happen
- 1:31:25who knows what would have happened in place of that so i mean we really don't
- 1:31:29have a problem with like massive welfare so long as it's to preserve the system
- 1:31:33that currently exists right rather than helping people out that is going to
- 1:31:37move us past something that is benefiting those people,
- 1:31:40yeah it does seem it does seem to be a a
- 1:31:44rigged system in that sense when when
- 1:31:47you have anything that's too big to fail then you
- 1:31:50maybe you need to let that fucking thing fail and yeah
- 1:31:54start over and do something different you know
- 1:31:57yeah which which i mean that's a core principle of
- 1:32:00marx's what we spent yeah what did they say though that that what we spent on
- 1:32:05the bailout in 08 09 10 wasn't it like that would have bought and paid off every
- 1:32:12closed and and educated every person in the country. And paid off every mortgage.
- 1:32:19Yeah. Yeah. I think the estimate, I think is like somewhere around the figure of $700 billion.
- 1:32:25It's ridiculous. Which is just a preposterous amount of money.
- 1:32:27If I'm not mistaken, is like two or three times as much medical debt as there is in this country.
- 1:32:35Right. Well, again, regardless, all right, let's get back to,
- 1:32:40to the meat and potatoes of this.
- 1:32:43Moving forward into more of the communist views and, and, and,
- 1:32:48and, the criticisms as well.
- 1:32:51Yeah. So what can you tell me about that?
- 1:32:54No, you want to take the critique of capitalism as presented by Marx?
- 1:33:00For sure. Yeah, I love talking about what the communist views are and everything,
- 1:33:03but I think that it's really important that we root this in criticizing what is right now.
- 1:33:07Because like we said earlier, communism is what grows out of right now in Marxist theory.
- 1:33:12And so we have to be able to look at what's happening right now,
- 1:33:15understand why this causes problems and how that leads us to,
- 1:33:19you know, fixing issues in the way that something like the Soviet Union did
- 1:33:22or China did or Cuba did, like we were just talking about with education, for example.
- 1:33:26Yeah. Not that they are above critique, which we will get to briefly.
- 1:33:32Yes. Yeah. I'll hold my breath till then. I might pass out. This might take
- 1:33:36a minute, but we will get to it.
- 1:33:39So like we were saying earlier, Marxism is primarily a critique of capitalism.
- 1:33:44Socialism has always been the shadow of capitalism.
- 1:33:47And so when we look at how Marx criticized capitalism, and we talked earlier
- 1:33:53about how social systems are defined by the relations that people have to the
- 1:33:59means of production and how these modes of production move us forward,
- 1:34:02we got to start with an analysis of what we live in right now.
- 1:34:06And so Marx did that by analyzing exactly what happens in production.
- 1:34:11He wrote a book called Capital. It's three volumes.
- 1:34:15That's my next read. Yeah, I think all in all, like 3,000 pages or so.
- 1:34:20It's a tough read, but it's very important. It's not where I'd recommend people
- 1:34:23get into it, but I hope that I can kind of make it a little more concise here
- 1:34:27so we can at least see what some of these dynamics are.
- 1:34:30So he starts by looking at how we change nature in any specific form of society.
- 1:34:36And he looks at all the previous economists of his time, people like Adam Smith,
- 1:34:40who most people have heard of.
- 1:34:42And he notices, yep, well, liberal too, but I mean, what's the difference?
- 1:34:48He noticed that all these economists were starting from the same grounds and
- 1:34:53ending up with the same errors and that's they started with assuming private
- 1:34:57property private property was not a historical feature of capitalism it is just
- 1:35:01what it was and so they started from that and ran with it there,
- 1:35:05so Karl Marx didn't take this for granted.
- 1:35:09He noticed how relations from private property can generate things like inequality
- 1:35:13and exploitation and all these issues that we'd like to talk about as socialists.
- 1:35:19But that kind of starts with looking at where private property came from and
- 1:35:24how it operates in capitalist society.
- 1:35:26So we were talking earlier about how capitalists are the one that own private
- 1:35:29property. They own the factories. They have the means of production.
- 1:35:33And it's proletarians, the working class, that need
- 1:35:36to sell their labor to be able to produce commodities in
- 1:35:39a capitalist society so labor is a commodity that
- 1:35:42is bought and sold hasn't always been a commodity i
- 1:35:46mean people used to do private work but now
- 1:35:48with the scale of production that we have it takes a
- 1:35:51lot of laborers as most people are and so
- 1:35:54we buy and sell them on a market just like we do any other commodity
- 1:35:57both physical and intellectual labor i
- 1:36:00i would like to interject yeah yeah and
- 1:36:04and let me let me just interrupt real quick
- 1:36:06the easiest way i think for the
- 1:36:09listeners to understand kind of what you're
- 1:36:12talking about right now is no matter
- 1:36:15what your views are on china china is
- 1:36:18actually almost that well
- 1:36:21they're they're that at least they're doing the state
- 1:36:26owns the business yeah so
- 1:36:29china as it exists right now is best described
- 1:36:32at least to me as state capitalist so right
- 1:36:35there's elements there's elements of socialism from their.
- 1:36:39And past and elements of communism but
- 1:36:43their past but there's also this other aspect somewhere
- 1:36:47in what the 80s or 90s they went through what in the left we call capitalist
- 1:36:51restoration which is essentially they they brought more capitalism back into
- 1:36:58the country as a way to kind of bail them out of the situation that they were in. Mm-hmm.
- 1:37:05And they seem to be doing all right. Well. More than all right.
- 1:37:08Yeah. They're kind of kicking ass.
- 1:37:10Yeah. They have a lot of issues like most capitalist economies will have.
- 1:37:14Including the Uyghur genocide and the event that shall not be named of 1989. Yeah.
- 1:37:21Which one are we talking about? No. So, yeah.
- 1:37:25I mean, like, we have to also recognize that China has had insane growth since the 80s.
- 1:37:31And that's what's leading them now as part of BRICS to be,
- 1:37:35soon to be perhaps the world's leading superpower but they also started off
- 1:37:39as a communist country as well,
- 1:37:41but today they more or less operate under the same principles that we're talking
- 1:37:45about now as most other capitalist societies do with workers being proletarian
- 1:37:50they'll just rein in the capitalists every so often and be like hey look you're
- 1:37:56getting a little crazy on this,
- 1:37:58but at the end of the day it's time to be executed,
- 1:38:00Doesn't the government, Chinese government, basically own everything?
- 1:38:04I mean, as far as like, more or less. You've got the building. Great.
- 1:38:09You've got the company. But we own the patent.
- 1:38:12Yeah. Companies are subordinated to the government. Yeah, it rules China.
- 1:38:17And the ruling party is still the Communist Party of China.
- 1:38:20And so there's a lot of argument to be had there about whether or not they're
- 1:38:25socialist because it's still ruled by the Socialist Party. but a lot of the
- 1:38:29production that's actually happening is capitalist, right? Like,
- 1:38:32they still do things like we do now.
- 1:38:34But that's what I'm saying is that like them or dislike them,
- 1:38:37a lot of what they seem to be doing is at least attempting to do is,
- 1:38:44what's the best little piece of this?
- 1:38:45What's the best piece of that? And they're trying to make it all work.
- 1:38:50Under one system, but they're, they're kind of doing it almost buffet style or am I?
- 1:38:58Yeah. They kind of opened it up so you can do pretty much whatever.
- 1:39:02But just so long as at the end of the day, you understand that we still own you, you know? Yeah.
- 1:39:07As long as it's in the national interest air quotes. Yeah.
- 1:39:11Okay. I just want to make sure that I was on the same page and I was understanding this correctly.
- 1:39:15All right. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Yeah, no, that's fine. So as I,
- 1:39:18as I keep talking about this, China is also an example of this kind of happening.
- 1:39:22They just happen to be able to do it a little better because of a whole list of reasons.
- 1:39:27But the important part to understand with China, with any capitalist society,
- 1:39:32is that there's a process going on, which Marx described as exploitation,
- 1:39:36and is what kind of characterizes capitalism in a lot of ways.
- 1:39:41And basically so going back to what i was saying with laborers being
- 1:39:45bought and sold on the market as any other commodity they have
- 1:39:48to do this they don't have any way to live otherwise and so that leaves them
- 1:39:53to be compelled to sell themselves for something that might not be their preferred
- 1:39:56wage i mean if we all could work for what we really really wanted we'd be making
- 1:40:00a lot more money than we do but we're offered a certain wage when you hire in
- 1:40:03a company and this wage is decided upon a lot of factors.
- 1:40:08And most importantly, there's a calculation that can happen where we have to
- 1:40:13determine what is the necessary amount of labor that it takes to produce this
- 1:40:18certain amount of goods.
- 1:40:20Necessary average, right? Yes. On an average between, you know,
- 1:40:25if we take every company that produces this type of good and average them all
- 1:40:28out, because we're talking about a whole social system where things happen to
- 1:40:31sell and compete on the market.
- 1:40:33But for sake of simplicity, we're talking about the average here.
- 1:40:37So we have to look at the necessary amount of labor that it takes to produce this good.
- 1:40:42We have to look at maintenance and providing all of the materials necessary
- 1:40:47to continue to produce this good.
- 1:40:49But then additional to that, we produce more than what it takes to just replenish those two things.
- 1:40:56We could stop at a certain point in the working day and say,
- 1:41:00great, we have enough money now to pay out all the workers for the labor that
- 1:41:03they did directly, exactly what they produce.
- 1:41:05And we have enough money to also continue this process, doing maintenance on
- 1:41:09the machines, buying new machines, whatever it takes to continue that process.
- 1:41:13Additional to this is what we call surplus labor. It is whatever the amount
- 1:41:18of labor that is performed additional to what is necessary.
- 1:41:22And out of this is where we get profits.
- 1:41:25You wouldn't have profits if there wasn't work being done additional to the
- 1:41:29original investment. And if you're going to continue working as a capitalist
- 1:41:33company, you have to have profits. You have to expand.
- 1:41:36You have to fight it out on the market. The line has to go otherwise.
- 1:41:40Exactly. The line has to go up. And so earlier when we were talking about,
- 1:41:44you know, the estimated growth for a quarter, you have to have a target.
- 1:41:48You have to be able to grow to stay competitive in that market.
- 1:41:51You have to be able to stay open and you have to be able to compete with the others.
- 1:41:56What I find interesting about that, though, is these are all just imaginary
- 1:42:00numbers, really, at the end of the day.
- 1:42:03You know what I mean? But they also, they relate to something that is real.
- 1:42:07Every commodity that we have has a price, and I mean, we can talk about supply
- 1:42:11and demand, but when those two things are equal, there's a reason that that price is where it is.
- 1:42:16And that is the cost that goes into it at production, plus this surplus. Mm-hmm.
- 1:42:22Yeah, we need to get enough out of this car, let's say.
- 1:42:25We need to sell this car at the right price that it covers the raw materials
- 1:42:32that went into it, the labor that went into it.
- 1:42:35And there's a little bit on top that the 1% can skim off.
- 1:42:41Right. And so socialists look at this and say, this is exploitation.
- 1:42:45Capitalists look at this and say, well, you agreed to the wage.
- 1:42:48And socialists can simply reply, we had to.
- 1:42:52The workers had to agree to that wage. We don't get to determine how much money we want to make.
- 1:42:56That is decided in part by the market and more specifically by the capitalist
- 1:43:01that offers the position to the laborers so long as if they give them that wage,
- 1:43:05they're able to still maintain a certain rate of profit.
- 1:43:07This is a good point that I would like to interject.
- 1:43:13This reminds me a lot of the Coconut Island example. Have you heard this thought experiment, Noah?
- 1:43:18Oh, yeah. Plenty of Robinson Crusoe type of stories. Yes. Yeah.
- 1:43:22Dad, have you heard the Coconut Island example? No, I don't think so.
- 1:43:26So, okay. So let's say you're on a plane going over the ocean and it goes down.
- 1:43:33There are two survivors. You are one of them.
- 1:43:35You wash up on a deserted island where it just so happens the other survivor washed up on.
- 1:43:43You wake up you look around and
- 1:43:46you realize hmm i'm on a desert island that sucks
- 1:43:49right you start walking around you look around
- 1:43:52you see the other survivor you walk up to them you they say hi how you doing
- 1:43:56you just woke up yeah i just woke up cool i've been awake for two days now i
- 1:44:02have collected all of the coconuts the only food source on this island i would
- 1:44:07be happy to share some of my coconuts, not all of them,
- 1:44:11but some of them with you in exchange. You have to suck my dick.
- 1:44:16That's an exploitative relationship. I guess, you know, it depends on whether or not you like coconut.
- 1:44:24It's an exploitative. How much you want. And coercive system.
- 1:44:30And in the same way, we as the proletariat, as working people,
- 1:44:36have to sell our labor in exchange for a wage that is not worth the work that we're actually giving.
- 1:44:44You've heard me say for years, we're all whores. It's just what level?
- 1:44:50Exactly. Well, you'd hear a lot of people respond to this by saying,
- 1:44:54well, I took the risk. I'm the one that invested this capital initially to make this all happen.
- 1:44:59But the issue is, after a certain sales period, though, the only money that
- 1:45:05you're working off of is money that was generated through this surplus by exploiting these workers.
- 1:45:11Essentially over the course of running this company, you run out of that original
- 1:45:15sum of money that you started with.
- 1:45:17And you're basically floating on an island of the money that was made for you
- 1:45:21by other people that you employed who agreed to a wage that they didn't necessarily
- 1:45:25want, but they had to agree with if they are going to sell their labor and survive. Right.
- 1:45:31I can't buy food unless I whore myself out for a wage that is half of what I'm
- 1:45:39actually worth in this position.
- 1:45:40So we're coming up on two hours and which is twice the amount of time we normally do.
- 1:45:46With that, I kind of, I kind of want to, you know, start wrapping it up and
- 1:45:49getting to what do you each see as where we are and where we need to be?
- 1:45:56Not necessarily a utopia, you know what I mean? But what I look at that,
- 1:46:01you know, that bridge and I go, that's a big chasm.
- 1:46:04You know, that's, that's a lot of, a lot of space from here to there.
- 1:46:08And you guys seem to have a little bit more positive view on that than I do. So I'm just curious.
- 1:46:13Well, I think it's important to start with the main prescriptive points given
- 1:46:20by the Communist Manifesto and then compare that to historical cases of socialism, where they failed,
- 1:46:27why they failed, and kind of where we can go from there.
- 1:46:31Right because everyone when you say communism in America everyone thinks,
- 1:46:35either the killing fields in Cambodia or the cultural revolution in China or
- 1:46:42Stalin's reign of terror or you know so on and so forth yeah I'll be honest
- 1:46:47with you it doesn't have it doesn't have a good.
- 1:46:50Publicist you know what I mean like you know not not criticizing it but if all you did was go off of,
- 1:46:59past publicity of communism and it's
- 1:47:02not looking great yeah okay so let's
- 1:47:05let's start just rapid fire the 10 points of the
- 1:47:08communist manifesto if you have any
- 1:47:11questions feel free to to shout them out yeah i will so number one is the abolition
- 1:47:17of property in land and application of all rents of land to public purposes
- 1:47:24right so what that's talking about is land should be held in common,
- 1:47:29instead of saying, you know, this is private property.
- 1:47:33This is specifically for my capitalist venture.
- 1:47:36Nah, fuck that. It should be held in common. Okay, but that is separate.
- 1:47:40Which is in the interest of the working class that doesn't have land, you know.
- 1:47:43But that is separate from, yeah, that is separate from you buy a house, you own that land.
- 1:47:49Yeah, this is not, this is not, oh, I can occupy your front yard.
- 1:47:54Yeah. That's a different situation. No, so the definition of this is specifically corporate.
- 1:48:02Yeah, land you're using to exploit other people. So if you have a factory,
- 1:48:06like we just talked about the definition of exploitation, the Marxist sense,
- 1:48:09that's abolished per point one of the Communist Manifesto.
- 1:48:14And with a socialized workforce, you don't need to do it that way.
- 1:48:19Okay. Next is a heavy progressive and graduated income tax, right?
- 1:48:24So this is your standard lefty talking point of tax the rich.
- 1:48:30I say tax the fucking church, but go on.
- 1:48:33Yeah, tax them too. I don't give a fuck. Fuck them. Marx even said religion
- 1:48:38is the opiate of the masses.
- 1:48:39And most people hear that and think, oh, that's because he wanted to control
- 1:48:44everyone's minds and this and that.
- 1:48:46And that's why religion. No, he was saying individual religious practice is
- 1:48:53fine, but as an institution.
- 1:48:57Oh, it's fucking horrible. As an institution, it is a means of control.
- 1:49:01Yeah. Yeah. It keeps people complacent as well. Yeah.
- 1:49:05Next is the abolition of all rights of inheritance.
- 1:49:10No more Rockefeller family. Yeah. This is a hard sell for some people.
- 1:49:17In America specifically, because the whole point of the American system is I
- 1:49:23made it so my kids don't have to fight for it.
- 1:49:26Right. But in a system where you don't have to fight for it,
- 1:49:30it doesn't really matter.
- 1:49:32It doesn't come down to I made it. Right. You know, if you don't have to fight
- 1:49:37for it, it's not an issue of, oh, if there's no inheritance,
- 1:49:41then my children will be dirt poor. That's not the case, right?
- 1:49:46No, I got you. I follow. I don't know that I fully agree with that, but I'm with you.
- 1:49:50Fourth is confiscation of all property of immigrants and rebels.
- 1:49:55So essentially, if you leave the country and you leave your house,
- 1:49:59that is now property which can be allocated to someone in need,
- 1:50:05right? And same thing with rebels.
- 1:50:07If you, let's say socialism is
- 1:50:10widely instituted in the united states and there's a little cell in idaho.
- 1:50:17That after it has been established as, as the new, the new system and everything
- 1:50:22is working just fine everywhere else, but this little cell in Idaho is rebelling
- 1:50:27and trying to maintain their,
- 1:50:29their exploitative control over, you know, so on and so forth. Right.
- 1:50:34Once those rebels are quashed, their property then becomes public property. Okay.
- 1:50:40In the same way that, you know, if I were, you know, a single person paying
- 1:50:47my own rent on my own 100% and I were to go to jail,
- 1:50:52that property is now up for grabs, right? Okay.
- 1:50:56So not dissimilar to what is already the case. Okay.
- 1:50:59I don't know how I feel about that completely, but I would say that,
- 1:51:04you know, there would have to be some sort of, you know, aspect of freedom of
- 1:51:09speech that was allowed within that specifically regarding politics.
- 1:51:14Well, freedom of speech is very well respected within the Marxist tradition.
- 1:51:20Okay, that's what I wanted to verify.
- 1:51:22That's not the issue here. By rebels, what they mean, what Marx means is like.
- 1:51:27Openly militant or holding out against this chain i mean it's no different than
- 1:51:31if i were to walk out into the woods here in michigan and decide i'm on sovereign
- 1:51:36territory yeah no i yeah of noah yeah yeah uh next is no i better watch out
- 1:51:45i want to get elon is going after noah.
- 1:51:49We got to get there's this there's this guy that lives out in the in the desert utah you can look
- 1:51:53up his name is zach and he is he has founded the
- 1:51:56republic of zachistan which he claims is a
- 1:51:59sovereign territory does he have a flag if you
- 1:52:02can find him you can visit for free but you
- 1:52:05got to find him first so does he sell flags he does yeah there's an embassy
- 1:52:09i think in argentina oh perfect that's our next vacation next we have the centralization
- 1:52:16of credit into the hands of the state by means of a national bank with state
- 1:52:20capital as an exclusive monopoly.
- 1:52:24So instead of having all these individual big banks that gamble with our money
- 1:52:27and fuck us out of our money.
- 1:52:31Instead, that is put in the hands of a democratically controlled state.
- 1:52:34Again, that's one of those things where it's like, I'm not big on any kind of monopoly or ooglopoly.
- 1:52:41However, the loan sharking that's being done at 25% with the credit card companies
- 1:52:46nowadays is fucking disgusting.
- 1:52:49There's no need for it. You don't have 2008.
- 1:52:53You don't have the financial crisis of 2008 if the state is the sole proprietor of banking.
- 1:53:01Well, it's also worth noting that socialist states, I mean, you can go ahead
- 1:53:04and look at the history of their interest rates.
- 1:53:07There's absolutely zero comparison to anything in the West.
- 1:53:11I mean, like you said, like this 25 percent, any like predatory loaning does
- 1:53:14not occur in a socialist state because they have no reason to accrue that kind
- 1:53:18of interest. Well, it doesn't benefit them.
- 1:53:20Exactly. It actually goes against their benefit. So, yeah, that would make total sense.
- 1:53:25Yeah, because then then you're sowing discontent within the population.
- 1:53:28It's the same reason I've said that they shouldn't have any interest.
- 1:53:31It should be a zero interest loan for student loans.
- 1:53:34There's no benefit in fucking over your next generation and saddling them.
- 1:53:39It should just be free. There shouldn't have to be loans.
- 1:53:42Yeah, there shouldn't be loans. It should be free, but shy of being free,
- 1:53:46you shouldn't. There should be no interest. There should be no interest on that.
- 1:53:49You know what I mean? Profit off that. Yeah, I mean, it doesn't make any sense.
- 1:53:53So you're saddling, you're saddling a generation coming out of school with.
- 1:53:59And there are hundreds of thousands of dollars. Yeah. You're talking. Yeah.
- 1:54:02The, the, the, no wonder no one can buy a fucking home when you're already a
- 1:54:06hundred thousand dollars in debt with your fucking education.
- 1:54:09Yeah. Big surprise, right? Yeah.
- 1:54:11So, so next, next would be the centralization of
- 1:54:14means of communication and transport in
- 1:54:18the hands of the state which this this
- 1:54:22point i guess could could best be
- 1:54:25recognized as like amtrak right
- 1:54:29and the usps right so
- 1:54:33obviously now that now that we're so technologically advanced that we have social
- 1:54:38media and we're on a zoom call and we're doing a podcast and there's there's
- 1:54:42a little obsolete sure yeah there's there's some caveats to be to be inserted
- 1:54:46there for application in a modern context,
- 1:54:49but what the point is getting at is USPS,
- 1:54:55Amtrak, things like that, taxi services should all be controlled solely by the
- 1:55:01state and should be, I guess, essentially run by the state.
- 1:55:07For the benefit of the service itself, right?
- 1:55:11I think before we keep going with what we mean by control by the state,
- 1:55:16we're not talking about the state in the capitalist sense, because I know a
- 1:55:18lot of people will hear that and think, well, I don't want Trump's government
- 1:55:21controlling the means of communication, transportation, and all these things.
- 1:55:25Under socialism, the state kind of refers to something different.
- 1:55:28The Marxist conception of the state is that it's basically something meant to
- 1:55:32deal with the fact that contradictions between the working class and capitalist
- 1:55:36class are irreconcilable.
- 1:55:39And so because these things can't be mediated 100%, the state kind of steps
- 1:55:43in, and that's why you see concessions given out to the working class.
- 1:55:46That's why you see things kind of reeled back where right now in the Trump administration,
- 1:55:49we're seeing, I mean, bills put into Congress for repealing OSHA and things
- 1:55:54like that to allow capitalists to kind of make more money and deregulate.
- 1:55:58Yeah, he's doing exactly the opposite.
- 1:56:01Right, and so when we talk about the state in a socialist sense,
- 1:56:04I'm not even necessarily referring to what the state looked like in the Soviet
- 1:56:06Union, which a lot of people would consider state capitalist.
- 1:56:10The state is more so here less interested in specific class interests like it is now.
- 1:56:16And it's more so interested in becoming an administrative body that is democratically
- 1:56:21controlled by the class, which is the working class.
- 1:56:25Making things work the way they should for the people that need it.
- 1:56:30Yeah it is it is by definition a class
- 1:56:33right a working class state so that operates in
- 1:56:36the interest of the working class so i mean really at the
- 1:56:39end of the day and we could probably stick a pin in it right here because it
- 1:56:44seems like this all boils down to one thing which is we want to create a system
- 1:56:52of the people for the people and by the people now there was that one.
- 1:57:00Yogi or whatever who goes the problem is
- 1:57:03the people are fucking stupid right so
- 1:57:07i don't know if he was a yogi or if it was a shah or whatever but anyways he
- 1:57:10goes you know he was explaining the u.s government he goes problem is the people
- 1:57:14are fucking stupid and that may be true but i think that you know one of the
- 1:57:21things that i've taken from this is is that a lot of those scary terms that, you know,
- 1:57:26immediately you just close your ears to and turn your head and look away.
- 1:57:31It really is about trying to figure out the most equitable way for people to be able to exist.
- 1:57:41Yeah. And removing the predatory aspect as much as possible,
- 1:57:47though not 100% possible because everything's run by people.
- 1:57:51But the idea being that we want to remove as much of the predatory aspects and
- 1:57:56the gouging and the price fixing and the fuck you,
- 1:58:01you're only going to get this amount per hour and good luck living on 750 an hour.
- 1:58:07And I mean, it does also come down to like, you know, people can certainly be stupid.
- 1:58:12But if we do, like we were talking about earlier, make more of an investment
- 1:58:16into educating the people so that we're not just producing workers just to work.
- 1:58:20Which is uh 10 sure yeah which people do kind of choose to behave in their best
- 1:58:27interest and when the the only class left in a society is the working class
- 1:58:32as is the case with socialism.
- 1:58:35There's a there's a sort of common good that comes with that class standing
- 1:58:38that i think is much more easily put into practice in a socialist democratic
- 1:58:43state than it would be in a more confusing capitalist state where you have a
- 1:58:47lot of people that are working people, but
- 1:58:50also rely on the capitalist system and whatever benefits the capitalist,
- 1:58:55because indirectly it kind of ends up benefiting them as well.
- 1:58:58Right. Yeah. And I would like to just, I know we're running pretty long and
- 1:59:02you want to put a pin in it.
- 1:59:03I do want to just rapid fire this because I think it's important to fully explain.
- 1:59:08And then also I would like a brief discussion on previous socialism.
- 1:59:12Yeah. No, go. So next, after means of communication and transport,
- 1:59:17we extend extend factories and instruments of production to the ownership of the state.
- 1:59:22And again, this is a state of the people by the people for the people,
- 1:59:26not a state as it exists today, which is mostly benefiting the capitalist, right? Mm hmm.
- 1:59:35Equal liability of all labor and the establishment of industrial armies,
- 1:59:39especially for agriculture.
- 1:59:42So for this, what Marx is really kind of getting at is there needs to be enough
- 1:59:50labor to fill all of the primary needs of society, right?
- 1:59:55It changes with AI and machinery as well. And, you know, that will become less important.
- 2:00:00Yeah, I think that that will definitely become less of a mitigating factor.
- 2:00:04I think what, like I said, I think what you're going to see is you're going
- 2:00:07to see within five years between AI and the level of robotics and the dexterity
- 2:00:12that's, that is being created in new robotics.
- 2:00:17I don't think you're going to, you're going to see very many human laborers.
- 2:00:21I think. Yeah. And if all of that value is going to the 1% instead of the 99%,
- 2:00:26it won't be long after that point that you see massive revolts.
- 2:00:31Right. And that's my, yeah, exactly. Right.
- 2:00:33People alone. Yeah, they're not going to put up with that. Next,
- 2:00:36we have combination of agriculture with manufacturing industries,
- 2:00:39the gradual abolition of the distinction between town and country to establish
- 2:00:46a more equitable distribution of the population over the country.
- 2:00:50So it's essentially, that's getting at, obviously, population centers are in
- 2:00:56cities, and that's where manufacturing is done.
- 2:00:59But that also encourages people to move away from where our food is grown.
- 2:01:06And we're already kind of seeing a change like this in the natural course of capitalism anyway.
- 2:01:11I mean, the distinction between town and country has kind of become less.
- 2:01:15Yeah, it's very blurred at this point, I think.
- 2:01:17I mean, there was a point, I think, in every country's existence where there
- 2:01:22was a definitive town and definitive country. And you knew when you crossed
- 2:01:27that little borderline.
- 2:01:29Yeah, and now it's urban, suburban, semi-suburban, and then country.
- 2:01:33And it's kind of all free-flowing.
- 2:01:36Look, when, you know, when every country home has a McDonald's within 10 minutes
- 2:01:44of it, it's not very country, you know what I mean?
- 2:01:47So, so I, I do think that that, you know, you got Walmarts, you've got,
- 2:01:51you know, you got grocery stores.
- 2:01:53It's not like it used to be that, which quite frankly, I don't care for.
- 2:01:59I mean, I remember being on the road and every town I would go to when I started,
- 2:02:04I could find the local best steakhouse or the local best barbecue joint or whatever.
- 2:02:11And now every town's best steakhouse is a Texas roadhouse. It's a Texas roadhouse.
- 2:02:15Right. Yeah. And there was no mom and pop.
- 2:02:19I know it sounds silly, but I would get a kick out of these mom and pop hardware
- 2:02:24stores because they would just have unique, weird shit.
- 2:02:27You know and even if i wasn't buying it it
- 2:02:30was just interesting to to you know
- 2:02:33window shop there yeah that went away if
- 2:02:35there wasn't a need in the area exactly and then i'll win able to compete they
- 2:02:41weren't and that so i would prefer that there was more definitive between town
- 2:02:46and country i think that that would actually benefit a lot of small businesses
- 2:02:50and mom and pop shops but i don't think that that's,
- 2:02:54I don't think we're going back to that, at least not anytime soon.
- 2:02:57The last point from the, from the manifesto is free education,
- 2:03:02abolition of child labor and the combination of education with industrial production.
- 2:03:08Which gives you a sense of when this was written, too. I mean,
- 2:03:10calling for the abolition of children's factory labor, which to an extent does still exist in a way.
- 2:03:14It does. I was going to say. And is coming back. It's coming back.
- 2:03:17It's making a comeback. It's making a comeback this Sunday, Sunday, Sunday. Yeah.
- 2:03:22Yeah. It's very much. It's less so now because children could reach into machines
- 2:03:25where adults could, and more so because, well, we can pay a 15-year-old at Burger
- 2:03:30King a lot less than we can pay an adult that has bills to pay.
- 2:03:33Exactly. That's another way that we can exploit people for more and maintain
- 2:03:36our rates of profit and increase them because we're running out of ways to do that
- 2:03:38look i'll be honest with you i was of children on the
- 2:03:41same level to it yeah maybe not the
- 2:03:44same level as like pedophilia to me it's as predatory as pedophilia well i i
- 2:03:52had my first job at 11 and i can tell you that being a caddy and getting fucked
- 2:03:57in the ass are two different things so that's all the time though or just some Well,
- 2:04:03you know, it depended on how big the tip was going to be.
- 2:04:08And the last thing that I just kind of want to briefly touch on,
- 2:04:12probably what most people were waiting for, is critique of previous socialist countries.
- 2:04:18Okay. So the first one that ever popped up after Marx kind of established himself
- 2:04:24was the Paris Commune. It lasted for what, like three months?
- 2:04:28It lasted for about a month, actually. One month. Yeah, so...
- 2:04:32Important to note here, too, is that, like we were talking about earlier,
- 2:04:36it's important to not consider Marxism as this hand over society that's moving things around.
- 2:04:40The Paris Commune was a case of historical socialism that actually happened
- 2:04:44in part before Marx was really popular at all.
- 2:04:48And he wrote a lot to the workers of the Paris Commune and kind of advised them
- 2:04:52about the best way to go about things.
- 2:04:54But this is something that popped up because of the way that capitalism works
- 2:04:58and because its crises necessarily lead to this sort of thing happening.
- 2:05:02But yeah, it only lasted a month until the Russian Revolution took place in 1917.
- 2:05:10Which, fun fact, when Lenin, past the date that the Paris Commune survived to,
- 2:05:18went out in the street and danced because he was so excited that the USSR became
- 2:05:22the new longest-lasting socialist state in history.
- 2:05:25And it ended up lasting almost to the entirety of the 20th century.
- 2:05:29That, too, now is defunct. And there are a lot of reasons as to that.
- 2:05:33Well, I think it's what you see, and I've said this on previous podcasts,
- 2:05:38but what you're seeing is we've taken in the first 25 years of the 21st century,
- 2:05:44and we've literally tried to compress everything good and bad,
- 2:05:49but more so bad, it seems like,
- 2:05:52that happened in the 20th century.
- 2:05:54So you can draw direct lines, whether it's, you know, wars or whether it's financial,
- 2:06:00whether it's, you know, civil, it doesn't matter.
- 2:06:03Like you're seeing whether it's race riots and the whole thing,
- 2:06:08we're just compressing it.
- 2:06:10And that's why I've got a lot of faith that it's going to get better because
- 2:06:15we've already in the first 25 years, pretty much done all the stupid and bad
- 2:06:20bullshit we did in the, in the, in the previous hundred years.
- 2:06:23So I have a feeling that there's something to be hopeful for.
- 2:06:27What that is, I'm not sure.
- 2:06:29As long as we don't just do it again. As long as we just don't continue on this
- 2:06:33repetitive treadmill of stupidity. History doesn't repeat itself.
- 2:06:38History doesn't repeat itself, but it often rhymes. Yes, exactly.
- 2:06:42All right. With that, I'd like to say thank you to our guest, Noah.
- 2:06:46You were phenomenal. I appreciate you, brother. You're welcome back on anytime you like.
- 2:06:51Colton. Thank you so much for having me on. Always a pleasure to have you on.
- 2:06:55And with that. Always great to be here.
- 2:06:56That's another Elsie's Little Pickles.
- 2:07:00Music.