Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 149: On secondhand fashion & luxury with Parisian entrepreneur Fanny Moizant
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Termuda. When most people think of Paris
- 0:14and fashion, my guess is they think first of runway shows and
- 0:18luxury brands like Louis Vuitton, Hermes and Chanel.
- 0:22They are, for better or worse, part of France's soft power, and
- 0:27they are also among the most counterfeited brands in the
- 0:30world. Earlier this summer, a story I
- 0:33had been reporting for months for Bloomberg Business Week was
- 0:35finally published, and it connects to this very
- 0:38phenomenon. It's about second hand luxury
- 0:40platforms and the issues surrounding authentication.
- 0:44I specifically looked at the French Unicorn Vestier
- 0:47Corrective, whose authentication facility in northern France I
- 0:50was able to visit in December. Now, before reporting the piece,
- 0:54I didn't fully appreciate just how sophisticated and complex
- 0:58counterfeit goods had become to identify and stop.
- 1:02Over several months, I learned how the market for super fakes,
- 1:06which is the name for counterfeits that are nearly
- 1:08indistinguishable from the real thing, has exploded, how brands
- 1:12have been forced to respond, and how platforms like Vestia have
- 1:16become frontline defenders in this battle for authenticity.
- 1:20But there's another story here too, that I wanted to
- 1:22incorporate into this show that was separate from the one I
- 1:25reported. A story about values and access,
- 1:28and how our relationship to luxury products and French
- 1:31savoir faire is evolving. In today's episode I'm joined by
- 1:35Fanny Moison, the Co founder of Vista Corretti to talk about
- 1:39building a sustainable brand from the ground up, why
- 1:42secondhand no longer carries the stigma it used to, and why Paris
- 1:46remains the emotional heart of global fashion.
- 1:51Fanny, welcome to the show. Thank you, my dear Lindsay.
- 1:57There's a, there's a lot I want to talk to you about, but
- 1:59obviously the most obvious starting point I think is the
- 2:03fact that you you created a company that is very tied to the
- 2:09French capital being the fashion capital.
- 2:13So Vestiac Corrective was founded in Paris.
- 2:15And I'm so curious how you find the legacy of couture and the
- 2:21legacy of French fashion, how that influenced your vision for
- 2:25this resale platform? I would go back in time, I mean
- 2:31during I would say my childhood, I was raised by a mum who
- 2:38treasures fashion without being a fashionista per SE.
- 2:42But she really loved and forged my also my love of fashion
- 2:48because she used to buy very little, but at the same time
- 2:52very strong pieces from different houses.
- 2:57I remember and I actually have kept one of her Alaya denim
- 3:02suits, the one from the 80s with the massive shoulders and the
- 3:06very pencil, the very skinny skirt.
- 3:10And I actually claimed it in a, in a meeting room in, in Paris.
- 3:14So I think her own love of fashion, craftsmanship,
- 3:19beautiful things and her culture around it, She was subscribed to
- 3:24many fashion magazines in France and I, I grew up in that spirit.
- 3:29So I think at adult age, I really wanted to reconnect my
- 3:36professional skills with my deep love of what I, I knew as a
- 3:40child. And that's when I, I launched
- 3:43Vestia. So I kind of, yeah, grew up in a
- 3:46non fashion but environment where my eye was literally drawn
- 3:54to beautiful things and and beautiful cuts and materials.
- 3:58Did you have the goal right from the beginning to sort of frame
- 4:03the business as being a sustainable option for fashion?
- 4:06Because that really wasn't, you know, necessarily the buzzword
- 4:10at the time that you launched, but it had quickly became quite
- 4:13obvious that it was a way to go about approaching.
- 4:17Fashion clearly, yes. And because the starting point
- 4:23of Vista was on my side. After worked a couple of years
- 4:27in, in marketing in another industry as in the home
- 4:30decoration industry. I again, I really wanted to work
- 4:34in, in my passion field as in fashion did a fashion school and
- 4:39then couldn't really find a job there.
- 4:42So I started to do a step, a little step to have a, a clearer
- 4:47understanding of what was this industry representing for me and
- 4:53where would I see it's going further.
- 4:56And that's where I realized two things.
- 4:59The first one that's we were in an era of big overproduction and
- 5:05big over consumption. And back to my mum example, I
- 5:10remember how she used to shop curating beautiful pieces,
- 5:15treasuring them, spending time into and and thinking about the
- 5:20purchase she's she's going to do and then caring about her pieces
- 5:24for a lifetime almost. And my generation was exactly
- 5:29the opposite. So was buying not one but 2-3
- 5:32times the same type of, I don't know, coat or or whatever per
- 5:38season because of the raise of fast fashion.
- 5:42And that that generation being born almost and raised within
- 5:46this fast fashion era completely changed the way they consumed.
- 5:53And I was able to, to see that first hand because I was raised
- 5:57completely differently. And so I, what I witnessed was
- 6:01this waste. Back then, we were not talking
- 6:04about sustainability, we were talking about waste.
- 6:06So I witnessed the waste that my generation was creating in
- 6:10people's wardrobe in all of us, all of our wardrobes.
- 6:15And I really wanted to, to tackle this and to give a new
- 6:21life to those beautiful items that were sleeping there in, in
- 6:25people's wardrobe. So that was the, the starting
- 6:27point to solve a, a wasteful problem.
- 6:31And the other one was I also understood that the sharing
- 6:35economy was, was bursting with the likes of Uber, Airbnb and so
- 6:40on. And that it was also very
- 6:43inspiring to consume differently per SE.
- 6:46So not to buy from a brand anymore, but to buy from a peer,
- 6:50from someone that inspires you share the same passion and and
- 6:53so on. So I kind of came across those
- 6:57two phenomenons and and merged them to create Vestia basically,
- 7:02which was solving this waste issue and trying to make people
- 7:07consume differently, slower, but definitely better.
- 7:11So in the time that you've launched, we've seen a tonal
- 7:15shift and certainly consumers are more accustomed to second
- 7:20hand, both in, you know, very mainstream items, even HomeGoods
- 7:25and into luxury. Do you think that there's less
- 7:29of a taboo around upcycled or reimagined life for, you know,
- 7:36secondhand luxury goods? And do you think it's
- 7:39successfully disrupting traditional luxury?
- 7:43I mean, I think, you know, that I worked on this story for
- 7:45Bloomberg about secondhand luxury and, you know, looking at
- 7:48a different aspect of the conversation, looking at
- 7:51authentication, of course. But you know, I was so stunned
- 7:54to see that the data suggests that the second hand market is
- 7:58outpacing the original market. And so that makes, you know,
- 8:01luxury brands very nervous, I think.
- 8:03But it also shows maybe a a shift in perspective for
- 8:07consumers. For sure.
- 8:09I mean this market, the the second hand market is projected
- 8:13to be around 350 billion by 2029, outpacing, you're right,
- 8:20the growth of the first hand market.
- 8:22So we'll grow. I mean resale is growing roughly
- 8:253 times faster than the first hand market.
- 8:28And indeed what I'm discussing with the brands because we work
- 8:31hand in hand with them also. But I'm telling them this is not
- 8:35a trend. Resale is here to stay.
- 8:37It's a shift in in people mindsets for good and forever.
- 8:43So yes, and for the best, resale is going to take more and more
- 8:47space in consumer mindset and it's not going to go away.
- 8:51So let's adopt and and let's rebuild this whole industry
- 8:56because there's a room for everyone.
- 8:59We're not saying that first hand should die forever.
- 9:04I was just saying that there's too much out there and we can
- 9:07still capture all the joy and excitement of what fashion is at
- 9:12the end of the day. So yes, now and again, since
- 9:16fast fashion people are completely, I always say drugged
- 9:20by novelties. So they are very excited and and
- 9:24always eager to to have something new.
- 9:27This remains in a beautiful thing in resell.
- 9:32So instead of buying new first hand, you can keep buying new
- 9:36second hand. So have your little excitement
- 9:40moment getting your hands on something beautiful.
- 9:43But it's if it's second hand, by definition, it's way more
- 9:48sustainable because the impact of by buying the same bag second
- 9:54hand, you save 90, so 90 percent of its impact on the planet
- 9:58versus a first hand bag. So there's a dramatic difference
- 10:02between one behaviour and another one.
- 10:05So you can still enjoy the beauty of fashion again, the
- 10:09craftsmanship and the novelty aspect while switching to
- 10:13something that is way more sustainable and also way more
- 10:17affordable, which it the key. Driver yes, I was just going to
- 10:21say that because unfortunately many of the luxury houses that
- 10:24people around the world covet and come to Paris even to buy
- 10:28have just skyrocketed in price since 2019.
- 10:31And these are rates of price growth that really exceed any
- 10:37sort of normal gradual progression.
- 10:40And and certainly it's made people very frustrated.
- 10:43Consumers have gotten very, very frustrated.
- 10:45From a global perspective, how do you think French consumers
- 10:49have compared in your experience to those in the US or in Asia in
- 10:53terms of embracing circular fashion and particularly at this
- 10:56level, this category? I think there's a in the French
- 11:00culture, there's this heritage for thrifting, as in Lipus.
- 11:06You've lived in France and you know how we love hanging out in
- 11:11those flea markets, I think you say in English.
- 11:14But at the same time, second hand shops back then when we
- 11:19launched Vestiere were a bit perceived as a bit dusty and not
- 11:23very, very cool. I think what we managed to do in
- 11:2615 years at Vestiere is to really transform the perception
- 11:30of, of French customers towards second hand, make it making it
- 11:36cool as in inspiring and really for people to feel proud when
- 11:42they buy from, from a secondhand platform.
- 11:47So I think that the shift and, and again, the perception of
- 11:50second hand has dramatically changed.
- 11:51And now I think the the share of wardrobes, roughly globally
- 11:58speaking is 1/3 of your wardrobe is composed by second hand
- 12:02items. And there's differences between
- 12:05the different regions. But I would say the French
- 12:09people use second hand to curate their wardrobes and to refine
- 12:15what they have. The Americans are a little bit
- 12:20more transactional in the way they use resell.
- 12:25So it's to make money out of the what they own or to really
- 12:30access amazing deals via resale. And I would say Asia is lagging
- 12:36a little bit behind as in late adopters of resale.
- 12:40And I've been living in Hong Kong for five years.
- 12:44And I, I remember when I arrived in 2017 in Hong Kong, I started
- 12:50the business so literally doing everything and, and anything
- 12:55almost myself. And I was speaking back then for
- 12:59marketing purposes to influencers, local influencers.
- 13:03And I was very surprised to have quite a few no goes as in those
- 13:08women or men were telling me no, no, no, I'm sorry if I yeah, I
- 13:12don't want my image to be associated with second hand.
- 13:16And for me, it was very bizarre because having launched the
- 13:20business in France couple of years before and, and all across
- 13:24Europe, I've never encountered that push back almost.
- 13:29And and for them, the mindset was absolutely not there.
- 13:32And for them, it's, it remained A taboo or something you're not
- 13:36proud of, whereas we were already super adopters of, of
- 13:43resale. So indeed, and I think it's,
- 13:45it's has changed in Asia also, they are slowly and surely
- 13:50jumping into the, the resale wagon because they understand
- 13:53the value. They are very smart shoppers and
- 13:57and sellers. They have amazing, very full
- 14:00wardrobes. So they're eager to offload and
- 14:04also to get their hands on amazing deals.
- 14:05So yes, I think all the different parts of the world
- 14:09have a slightly different behavior to what that's that way
- 14:15of consuming fashion. It's so interesting because, you
- 14:18know, I just remember hearing from family members about the
- 14:23kinds of goods that they wanted to carry down or pass down to
- 14:28their children, and there was a real protection.
- 14:30But I do think it's the generation above ours,
- 14:34specifically in the US that or that came before us, our parents
- 14:38and our grandparents who were a little bit more sensitive to
- 14:40this and remember the cost of things and that.
- 14:44I think people are very disconnected with not only how
- 14:48things are made, which is the whole discussion around
- 14:50sustainability and the impact, but also why you should take an
- 14:55interest in, you know, taking care of your goods to make them
- 14:59last longer. And to jump, sorry to to cut
- 15:01you, but. To go ahead.
- 15:03To the affordability topic indeed, I mean we are going to
- 15:06maybe I give you a preview of a survey we're going to launch in
- 15:11in full. Affordability has always been
- 15:14the main and the first driver towards second hand ahead of
- 15:18sustainability, ahead of the choice, as in the large choice
- 15:23and the last one being the experience, the thrill of the
- 15:25hunt. And we've seen a massive spike
- 15:30of these criteria. So we were around 50 ish percent
- 15:33of people saying, yes, I buy second hand because it's more
- 15:36affordable. And the the survey we're going
- 15:38to unveil is around 80 ish percent.
- 15:41So indeed the the the rising price of the first hand goods
- 15:48are really driving people more and more towards second hand
- 15:52because it's very, very difficult today to afford
- 15:54something you really want to have.
- 15:58So second hand remains the best option.
- 16:02So interesting. And was that a a, a, a survey
- 16:05that looked at just Americans or sort of a pool of global
- 16:08shoppers? No, it's a pool of global
- 16:10shoppers and indeed we have a sensitivity that is slightly
- 16:14different from region to region, but I'll let you discover it
- 16:18later in in October. OK, well, I look forward to
- 16:22reading that because that's a that's quite a staggering
- 16:24figure. Now that you bring up also this,
- 16:27this like, you know, surge in interest in affordable or
- 16:31because of the affordability, it raises another question, which
- 16:34is OK, you have so many products now listed on the app and on the
- 16:39website, which raises the question, how can you guarantee
- 16:44obviously the authenticity of these goods?
- 16:46And so you have a, an authentication Academy and
- 16:49several sort of headquarters dedicated to this question.
- 16:53And counterfeit represents a huge, you know, almost trillion
- 16:57dollar problem globally and not only in the luxury sector.
- 17:01I'm curious, beyond the issues of IP intellectual property with
- 17:05regards to the authenticity of a of a luxury good, what are the
- 17:10what are the major issues related to counterfeit that
- 17:14people need to care about? I mean, I feel like I grew up
- 17:16understanding why fakes were bad and so many people I think need
- 17:20a reminder. Yeah, I think, I mean for many
- 17:23reasons, counterfeiting industries usually are linked
- 17:28with dirty money. So you don't really know where
- 17:33those that money is going and and flying from, but it's also
- 17:38how and how are they produced and made of being very hazardous
- 17:44materials, cheap materials, hazardous materials that could
- 17:49have an impact on your health. And I mean, of course, a handbag
- 17:53is not, you're not wearing the handbags on your skin properly,
- 17:57but very cheap materials with floated with chemicals and a lot
- 18:05of bad substances can literally harm your, your health.
- 18:10So, and, and I don't know if you saw that when you visited the
- 18:15warehouse and the way we do the authentication and so on, one of
- 18:18the best way to spot a counterfeit issue, yes, a
- 18:21product is to smell it. So our authenticators when they
- 18:27are inspecting A handbag, for example, a pair of shoe, if you
- 18:31smell glue as in very chemicals, heavy chemicals glue, there's a
- 18:38very high chance that you're facing a counterfeited item.
- 18:42So it is not a material that the houses are are are using.
- 18:47So yeah, stay away for those numerous reasons from those
- 18:52items. And if you have a doubt, the
- 18:56only thing I would say is shop from a, a place you trust and
- 19:00make sure they have what it takes to do that authentication
- 19:04because there's a lot of claims also out there and very little
- 19:10is. And I think since, I mean since
- 19:12day one, literally we launched the business in two O 9 in two O
- 19:1710, we signed an antique counterfeiting shelter with the
- 19:21French government and all the luxury houses.
- 19:25Then we sign the equivalent in Italy.
- 19:27So we are working behind the scenes hand in hand with the
- 19:30houses. We're using their for some of
- 19:34them, their technology to check also the provenance of every
- 19:40single item. So there's a very, very deep, it
- 19:44is a very deep component of this year.
- 19:47Doesn't mean that we are 100% perfect because counterfeits are
- 19:52very, very, very difficult to to spot.
- 19:56But I think we have from far the best knowledge in the market
- 20:00because it's been 15 years compounding efforts and and
- 20:05trainings and expertise from. The best people in this
- 20:10industry. Yeah, it's wild.
- 20:12I saw one of the authenticators smelling the bag and looking at
- 20:17it closely with a magnifying glass.
- 20:19I mean, it really is, you know, it's a technique.
- 20:22It relies also on a lot of fashion knowledge, it, you know,
- 20:25understanding what era the item came from, what collection.
- 20:29I mean, it really demands staying up to date, updating
- 20:34skills. It's really fascinating.
- 20:36And it's true that there are, when you say dirty money, I
- 20:39mean, I almost think that's a nice way of putting the kinds of
- 20:42criminal plus activities that counterfeiting really funds.
- 20:47So I think if you're sensitive to that and the public health
- 20:50issue, it's really important to pay close attention.
- 20:53I'm glad you brought up the policy or the charter that
- 20:56you're involved in because I also know you've been active in
- 20:59policy at an EU and national level.
- 21:02There's the anti fast fashion legislation in France and this
- 21:05sort of circular messaging that you've put forward on different
- 21:09Vestia advertisements. What does effective change look
- 21:13like going forward about legislation and how to make
- 21:18fashion as a general industry held to better, better
- 21:25regulation, held to better rules to try to minimize the impact of
- 21:29fashion? What changes do you think still
- 21:32need to happen and how can you be involved in that?
- 21:37Indeed, it's a very important topic.
- 21:39I think regulation needs to evolve.
- 21:43I'm very proud in that respect to be French because as you, as
- 21:46you know, the Senate has voted the Antifas fashion law, which
- 21:52still needs to be fully approved and rolled out.
- 21:55But it's, it's a massive win to answer your question.
- 22:00I think going further and forward, I think we owe
- 22:05consumers, but also the whole industry more transparency.
- 22:09I think there's still very little we have, as I said in the
- 22:13very beginning of of your questions, we have an
- 22:17overproduction problem. So bare minimum I would say is
- 22:21for brands to disclose their volumes.
- 22:24I would really almost force them to to do so and to start
- 22:29tackling the problems from a volume perspective, but also
- 22:34full transparency in terms of supply chain work ethics and and
- 22:41and so on. So I think that's one area where
- 22:45we need to push for further improvements.
- 22:50The second one I would say is Advesia.
- 22:53We are pushing forward for a positive regulation on VAT, for
- 23:00example. So how can we, we as in the
- 23:04circular businesses benefit from lower taxes that will enable the
- 23:11prices of second hand to come even lower, benefiting the
- 23:15consumer, growing the pie of that resale for the benefit of
- 23:20all the planets, the consumers and so on.
- 23:24So I would say that's the second big piece of the puzzle that
- 23:28needs to happen. And the last one I would say
- 23:31which is more long term, we are fighting and and I would say
- 23:36lobbying for the implementation of the DPP digital product
- 23:42passport, which for me is the key towards clothing that
- 23:49circle, that virtuous circle between first hand and second
- 23:53hand. So imagine I am a consumer.
- 23:56I go to a store, I buy a bag and I would, when I check out, so
- 24:02when I pay my bag, I would receive my certificate of
- 24:07authenticity and ownership, for example, on my wallet, on my
- 24:12Apple Wallet. That's my dream.
- 24:14And I would store all my assets and my possessions on this
- 24:18wallet. And in one click I would be.
- 24:21So going back to my wallet, as I check my train tickets or I
- 24:26would check my assets, I would be able to see where my bag has
- 24:31been made, which are the materials and so on.
- 24:33So all the transparency part. But I will also be able in one
- 24:37Click to very simply be able to sell it on collective but other
- 24:44platforms also. So it's enabling consumers and
- 24:48those two industries again to be connected technically speaking.
- 24:53And I think if we do that and if we push for that DPP regulation
- 24:59to happen, that will mutually enable second hand to scale.
- 25:06And we can even imagine again to respect the work that is done in
- 25:12the houses in terms of of creativity and craftsmanship.
- 25:16We could imagine giving royalties every time an A second
- 25:20hand item is sold. We could pay to the brands a
- 25:25fraction of of the sale price for them to make money out of
- 25:30second hand. Exactly as I don't know, an
- 25:33artist makes money every time it's song is aired or something
- 25:38like this. So indeed it will create value
- 25:42for the brands, will create value for the consumers and the
- 25:45whole industry would benefit from such a, a tool which is the
- 25:51GPP. So this for me is the the, the
- 25:54long term vision that we we need to hope for and to lobby for.
- 25:59Well, it sounds like you're you're doing a good job of that.
- 26:02There's also King Charles's initiative, the Sustainability
- 26:06Initiative, or it's called the Sustainability Market
- 26:09Initiative. Right.
- 26:10Yes, SMI, correct. SMI that is, is really pushing
- 26:15for this. And so there are things, there
- 26:16are things happening. I think what's interesting is
- 26:19that some of these houses don't actually want all these people
- 26:22to be wearing their their goods and that this becomes sort of an
- 26:25image issue. And so they're, they're not in
- 26:27control. They're not in control over who
- 26:29gets to wear and walk around whatever city that they live in,
- 26:33you know, with a Louis Vuitton bag or or a carte watch or
- 26:37whatever. But I like this thinking that I
- 26:40hadn't, I hadn't actually come across that of giving some
- 26:44royalties back to the back to the brands.
- 26:46That's really interesting. My my last question is involving
- 26:50obviously Vestia codective is, is you don't need to be based in
- 26:54Paris to use that. You can literally be anywhere in
- 26:57the world. But certainly people who come to
- 26:59Paris and are interested in shopping, what would you
- 27:02recommend they do instead of, if they're just visiting Paris,
- 27:06instead of buying something new, can they get it delivered to
- 27:11their hotel? Do you have any sort of
- 27:13partnerships or ideas that could be geared toward, you know,
- 27:17someone who's just passing through Paris but want to take
- 27:20home something that feels very Parisian?
- 27:23Yes, I would say first and foremost check Vestia Collective
- 27:27while you're in the USI mean we have actually the US is the
- 27:31first business of Vestia. So the biggest market of Vestia
- 27:35is the US. So you're all very welcome to
- 27:39check out the, the amazing supply we have on the platform
- 27:44and that is coming from US sellers or sell directly your
- 27:49your goods. We also have AVIP service if
- 27:52you're interested, we can come to your place, clear out your
- 27:55wardrobe in the US. So very hassle free and and
- 28:00white glove service. But if you prefer travelling and
- 28:02if you're travelling to Paris, yes, we can deliver anything to
- 28:06your hotel, your Airbnb. We don't have a physical space
- 28:12because not that we don't want to, but I think we are.
- 28:16We're so busy in building the experience on the platform that
- 28:19it's not retail and and physical is not the the the priority nor
- 28:26in the books for for the next years to come.
- 28:30But otherwise you have plenty of amazing options of second hand
- 28:36stores in Paris that you can really enjoy.
- 28:39And actually last weekend my daughter, my 19 years old
- 28:43daughter, took me to the Mahe and she made me a tour of her
- 28:49favorite places and discovering amazing vintage treasures.
- 28:54So yeah, Paris is a is a wonderful destination for
- 28:58shopping sustainably. Well, Fannie, I'm, I'm so
- 29:01grateful you could take the time.
- 29:03I think there's a lot that is being done that goes well
- 29:06beyond, you know, the luxury industry and, and is, is about
- 29:10changing our consciousness around fashion and how much
- 29:14there's an overproduction problem.
- 29:16And I think it's it's important to know that there are companies
- 29:20lobbying for change and that it's, you know, something that
- 29:23people can get behind. So thank you so much.
- 29:26And I look forward to that report that will come out or
- 29:28that survey that will come out in in October.
- 29:31Thank you Lindsay for having me. It was a real pleasure.
- 29:35That's the show for today. If you're listening on Spotify,
- 29:38be sure to check out the poll related to this episode by
- 29:41scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 29:43conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 29:46subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 29:49what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 29:52from me at lindsaytremuta.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 29:56Sub Stack at Cadiento.