Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Capturing Jurors' Attention
Transcript
- 0:03My name is Hilary Johns and today it is my pleasure
- 0:06to introduce three of the best trial lawyers
- 0:09and consultants in the business. First we have
- 0:12Laurie Kuzlanski, PhD. She is an expert jury
- 0:15consultant with over 43 years of experience holding
- 0:18a doctorate in cognitive psychology and a master's
- 0:21in linguistics from Columbia University. She
- 0:25specializes in jury selection, case themes, witness
- 0:27preparation, and trial strategy, having consulted
- 0:30on more than 1 ,200 civil and criminal jury trials
- 0:34nationwide across a broad range of legal matters.
- 0:37Dr. Kucylanski is sought after speaker and published
- 0:41author, who has been recognized by Legal Times,
- 0:45which voted her the number one jury consulting
- 0:47practice in the country for four years in a row.
- 0:49Jay Spillane is a founding shareholder of Spillane
- 0:52Trial Group, a business trial firm representing
- 0:54private companies and individuals in high -stakes
- 0:56litigation for over three decades, with clients
- 0:59ranging from entertainment and sports personalities
- 1:01such as Robert Redford, Harold Ramis, Kelly Slater,
- 1:05and Ken Steffes, to corporations and executives
- 1:08in matters involving intellectual property, technology,
- 1:10real estate, and corporate control. He is known
- 1:13for distilling complex business disputes to the
- 1:16ethical principles of their core. and an approach
- 1:20that drives favorable settlements and strong
- 1:22trial results. Spillane also handles all levels
- 1:25of telework, including his representation of
- 1:28CC Bill LLC and CWI LLC in Perfect 10 Inc. versus
- 1:33CC Bill LLC, one of the most widely cited cases
- 1:37on internet services provider liability for alleging
- 1:40infringing content posted on client websites.
- 1:42He is also American Member of the Invitation
- 1:47Only American Board of Trial Advocates. Neville
- 1:50L. Johnson is a senior partner at Johnson & Johnson.
- 1:54Neville graduated tri -beta Kappa from the University
- 1:57of California, Berkeley in 1971. He received
- 2:00his law degree from Southwestern Law School in
- 2:011975, graduating at the top of his class. He
- 2:04has tried over 28 civil jury trials and over
- 2:0670 civil trials, arbitrations without a jury.
- 2:10He is a member of the invitation -only American
- 2:12Board of Trial Advocates and is on the Board
- 2:14of Governors of the Consumer Attorneys of Los
- 2:16Angeles since 2005, the Board of Directors of
- 2:19the National Organization of Public Justice,
- 2:21and on the Board of Governors of the Beverly
- 2:22Hills Bar Association, 2013 to 2015, 2020 to
- 2:272022. Johnson is a long -time member of the invitation
- 2:31-only Los Angeles Copyright Society on the board
- 2:33of the California Society of Enriching Employers.
- 2:36And now let's get started. Thank you, Hillary.
- 2:39I'll jump right in. Welcome everyone and thank
- 2:42you for joining us. I'm Laurie Kozlanski and
- 2:47I consult on all types of civil and criminal
- 2:51cases. And a very common question really is how
- 2:55do you get jurors attention? How do you keep
- 2:58their attention? And that has become a challenge
- 3:01from the get -go that is only getting harder
- 3:03with all the different changes in our lives.
- 3:07To start with, I'm going to say that this is
- 3:10about attention. So I'm going to start with ADD,
- 3:12which is a pretty common moniker for attention
- 3:14deficit disorder. But today, which is currently
- 3:17now called ADHD, I'm going to call it ADD, how
- 3:21to attract attention, not detract attention or
- 3:25distract attention. So those are kind of the
- 3:27themes right in my wheelhouse. We're now facing
- 3:36people of all different generations in the jury
- 3:39pool. In fact, there are approximately five generations
- 3:43that can serve right now from the age of 18 all
- 3:46the way up to over 80 that cover the gamut of
- 3:49different generations and they speak a different
- 3:51language from one another. So one of the things
- 3:54I say is, well, before you get their attention,
- 3:57you're going to have to know what is it that
- 3:58they pay attention to and what don't they pay
- 4:01attention to an expression. of millennials today,
- 4:05some, is this expression called just put the
- 4:07fries in the bag, bro. Not meaning that it's
- 4:10an insult to people who work lower level jobs
- 4:15at minimum wage, but it means, you know, there's
- 4:18that person sitting at the warmer with the fries
- 4:20and the scooper and the bag, but they're not
- 4:23putting the bag with the fries together. And
- 4:26Usually fast food, people want things to be fast.
- 4:29Well, that's pretty much where we are right now
- 4:31in terms of the jury poll, especially the younger
- 4:33jury poll. It also is a different language, as
- 4:37I mentioned. So for example, what does it mean?
- 4:40Put the fries in the bag? Well, we used to say
- 4:42things like land the plane or get to the point.
- 4:45And that's Silent Generation and Boomers. Millennials
- 4:48and Gen Z, however, don't speak that way. So
- 4:52the first issue is what are some of the blocks
- 4:54to attention that get in the way of getting attention
- 4:57before you can keep it? And why don't people
- 4:59pay attention? Well, one might be because they
- 5:02have negative beliefs. For example, they might
- 5:04feel negatively, especially these days against
- 5:07corporations or banks or insurance companies
- 5:10or certain groups. They might be counterintuitive
- 5:14law. So for example, You may have an oral contract,
- 5:18which we're going to speak about a little bit
- 5:20later today as well. They may think oral contracts
- 5:23don't have any meaning if it's not in writing,
- 5:25especially for a lot of money. They may, for
- 5:28example, think that things like at will can't
- 5:33possibly be true, that you can fire someone for
- 5:35no reason or a reason or any reason, as long
- 5:37as it's not discriminatory. Jurors don't believe
- 5:40that. Or it might be fiduciary duty. It's counterintuitive
- 5:45to think that you're supposed to put somebody
- 5:46else's interest ahead of your own. So before
- 5:49you actually get to persuading them, you have
- 5:51to understand what are the blocks that might
- 5:53be in the way that would stop them from listening
- 5:56and paying attention. In addition, they might
- 5:58be too young or too old to pay attention or remember
- 6:01they have different reasons for not being able
- 6:04to pay attention. Younger people these days are
- 6:07really used to getting a lot of adrenaline hits
- 6:10from their interaction with immediate gratification.
- 6:13I used to say there was delayed gratification
- 6:15and then it became instant. Now it's instantaneous.
- 6:19And so they're used to really fast reactions
- 6:22and fast information, and it's hard for them
- 6:24to pay attention if they don't get that. Older
- 6:27people have other challenges. And then in general,
- 6:30people may not care. So if you don't care to
- 6:33pay attention, you're going to pay attention.
- 6:35You're thinking about your dry cleaning or what
- 6:37you're having for dinner or other things that
- 6:39are more important to you. Or you might care
- 6:42too much if you're a juror that has certain issues
- 6:45on your mind and agendas and that really will
- 6:47hurt one of the parties and help the other. So
- 6:50how do you deal with that? Well, the first job
- 6:52you have is to try to remove jurors that are
- 6:55bad for you, whichever side you may be on. You
- 6:58have to find out who rejects your position. You
- 7:00do that through asking questions of costs, of
- 7:02course, and for dear not in a shotgun approach
- 7:06because that's really not useful. You need apples
- 7:08to apples comparisons to understand what are
- 7:11the real issues that are problematic in your
- 7:13case and the kinds of jurors that will reject
- 7:15it. And what are the targeted questions? If you
- 7:17can only ask a few of everyone. Social media
- 7:22today. It is really important because people
- 7:24present a lot of information about themselves,
- 7:27except for those few that act like Banksy and
- 7:29don't present anything, who are also people of
- 7:31concern. And thirdly, we have the ability now
- 7:34using AI with a sufficient amount of time, which
- 7:36is not a lot, to actually do a very fast scrape
- 7:40of social media and public information about
- 7:43people to find out things like voting records
- 7:45and other things, which turn out to be very important
- 7:48in predicting your orientation to a verdict.
- 7:50And then you have to find out who can't attend,
- 7:54understand, or recall the information. And then,
- 7:57ideally, you want to remove as many of them as
- 7:59you can for cause. You can't control it, but
- 8:02you can certainly attempt it. And so by showing
- 8:05that they just cannot constitutionally remember
- 8:07or pay attention, that should be a reason not
- 8:11to have someone serve on a jury, unless, of course,
- 8:13it's in your benefit for them to miss information.
- 8:16And sometimes that happens. In terms of dealing
- 8:21with counterintuitive law and negative beliefs,
- 8:24you have to, of course, disabuse people of that
- 8:26before you get into the case in chief. So for
- 8:29example, in the 1993 case involving the World
- 8:32Trade Center bombing, the law required the jury
- 8:36to find that the owners of the building had more
- 8:40responsibility than the terrorist for the bombing,
- 8:42which of course makes no sense to your average
- 8:44person in Southern District of New York. And
- 8:47so we had to reframe that as not being about
- 8:50the terrorist responsibility to tenants, but
- 8:53a landlord's responsibility to tenants. So by
- 8:56being able to reframe that in terms of a concept
- 8:59that people could relate to, it made it easier
- 9:03to get past that obstacle to attention and credibility.
- 9:07In terms of non -binding contracts being oral,
- 9:11of course, that's something you need to... refer
- 9:13to the law and other things that we'll show you.
- 9:16Negative beliefs about corporations, for example,
- 9:18being greedy. If you're defending a corporation,
- 9:22what you want to be able to show is not to make
- 9:24them change their mind about corporations being
- 9:26greedy, because that's not going to happen. Instead,
- 9:30what you can do is show, if possible, that actually
- 9:34what the plaintiff said happened would have cost
- 9:37more money than what actually happened. Had we
- 9:40done the right thing, for example, as a corporation,
- 9:42which we did allegedly for the defendant, how
- 9:45that actually was less expensive than the wrong
- 9:50thing. And so it's about knowing how to swim
- 9:55with the tide as opposed to against it. Other
- 9:59reasons that jurors don't pay attention down
- 10:02on the list is that very often attorneys will
- 10:05use too many words, not enough pictures. not
- 10:08enough themes and stories, and use language that
- 10:11no one else outside the courtroom would use,
- 10:14like notwithstanding. People on the street have
- 10:16never heard say that. I've been to a lot of venues.
- 10:19I'm waiting for it to happen, but it hasn't happened.
- 10:21And also because they don't use enough visual
- 10:24support, graphics, and mixed media to garner
- 10:28attention. It's a very visual world we live in
- 10:31and a fast one. So next is... Who's on the jury?
- 10:37Now you've hopefully gotten rid of the worst
- 10:39of the ones that you can spot, and now you have
- 10:41people who are left. Well, as we said, there's
- 10:45a generational difference. We went from an early
- 10:48generation or generations who felt there was
- 10:51hierarchy and authority, I'm the boss, to, well,
- 10:54let's discuss and collab. Any of you who have
- 10:59children and grandchildren that fall into that
- 11:01category know what I'm talking about. It's a
- 11:02lot of collab talk. Also though, there's an interesting
- 11:08shift in the analogies that they refer to. So
- 11:11in our parents' and grandparents' generations,
- 11:13they used a lot of sailing originally, like all
- 11:16hands on deck. They shifted then to sports analogies,
- 11:20to hit it out of the park, or hit a home run,
- 11:23or it's a Hail Mary. This generation, the newer
- 11:27generations, are now referring to things based
- 11:29on being gamers and video game metaphors. So
- 11:32for example, there are terms that you may never
- 11:35have heard, maybe you have. Things like you didn't
- 11:37step up to the plate is now things like, oh well,
- 11:39they play like an NPC, a non -player character.
- 11:43It's fourth and long is now something like just
- 11:46reach the boss battle. They move the goalpost.
- 11:49Now that is they nerfed that feature, nerf meaning
- 11:52to throttle down. And a silver bullet is now
- 11:56a one -shot, meaning that you can get rid of
- 11:58a player in a first -person shooter game, FPS,
- 12:04not that I play them, but I know these things
- 12:05because of the work I do, that you can get rid
- 12:08of one player, particularly with one shot. It
- 12:10won't take multiple shots to knock them out.
- 12:13And other terms that we've talked about that
- 12:16come from the technology world. Also shifts are
- 12:20on the jury that you have to understand is who
- 12:23they think is an expert. Well, it used to be
- 12:25Dr. Spock, and then it became Dr. Google, then
- 12:28Dr. Reddit, then Dr. ChatGPT or Dr. Claude. And
- 12:32so while you may be relying on experts to get
- 12:34attention or to convince people, if they don't
- 12:38see that source anymore as a resource, it will
- 12:41not be persuasive. I can't tell you how many
- 12:44times I've had conversations with people who
- 12:46are lay people. of younger generation and explain,
- 12:51well, the reason I'm explaining the psychological
- 12:52concept and why it matters is that I have a PhD
- 12:56and their reaction is, so what? Next is how to
- 13:04get and garner attention is to understand what
- 13:07is this case about for them? What do they need
- 13:11and expect from you? Very often we see attorneys
- 13:15come into a courtroom with statements like, well,
- 13:17they have to understand X, Y, Z for us to win.
- 13:20And I don't like to start that way because they
- 13:23may not ever do whatever X is. So I like to know
- 13:27rather, what is it that we have to know in order
- 13:30to satisfy what they feel they need? They're
- 13:35not going to change for us. The only control
- 13:38we have is to modify what we're going to do for
- 13:41them. Why should they care? We know why we care,
- 13:44but why should they care? Are you addressing
- 13:46that? Why should they believe you? And how will
- 13:51the outcome impact them? So I would recommend
- 13:54that if you want to get their attention, speak
- 13:57to them as if you care about what their position
- 14:00is in the case or how it impacts them. Now, how
- 14:04do people get information these days and how
- 14:06does that impact what they're paying attention
- 14:10to and what we have to pay attention to. Well,
- 14:12the older generation still sometimes gets its
- 14:15news from the news, meaning cable news or network
- 14:19news. Younger people, on the other hand, get
- 14:22it from social media and we know this. Well,
- 14:25what does that look like? First thing is, it's
- 14:29going to look very visual. The scenic palm tree
- 14:34-lined streets of Beverly Hills offer the perfect
- 14:37SoCal spot to snap some photos, but are sightseers
- 14:39taking the viral trend too far. Some local residents
- 14:43say they're sick of all the shutterbugs. I would
- 14:46just do support LeAnn Sutter joining us live
- 14:48from one of the streets at the heart of this
- 14:49growing controversy. LeAnn. Mark residents here
- 14:54along Cannon Drive say last weekend was the worst
- 14:57they've seen it. Absolute chaos, they say. So
- 15:00many visitors are lining up in the middle of
- 15:02the street here just to get that perfect shot
- 15:05of those palm trees. We got one photo shoot,
- 15:10two photo shoots, three, four. So you get the
- 15:13idea. Well, that's the way that... some of the
- 15:18older jurors may be getting information and paying
- 15:20attention. What I want you to know is that she's
- 15:21very animated and there's switching of the visual
- 15:24scene very frequently and a real variety. Well,
- 15:28how do some of the younger people get information?
- 15:30Well, it's a combination of Instagram and TikTok.
- 15:34So upcoming FIFA. This is very common right now.
- 15:46So you see, again, now this has got music, it's
- 15:49got color, it's got a lot of motion in it and
- 15:51it happens very quickly. And then on the right
- 15:53-hand side is actually the most, sorry, that's
- 15:57pretty funny. On the right -hand side, you have
- 16:00the most watched TikTok, which is really where
- 16:03a lot of course people live right now. And what
- 16:06does that look like? my gosh yo that's so cool
- 16:18how are you doing that got an nimbus 2000 oh
- 16:21i see here so that's what people are watching
- 16:26are things that are very amusing right musing
- 16:30visual audio changing and so forth and so if
- 16:36i have to tie it all up the answer is think of
- 16:39the audience as very demanding it's experience
- 16:43what we call the drop -down menu syndrome, which
- 16:46is really tailoring seeing and hearing what it
- 16:50wants, when it wants, how it wants, and it has
- 16:53no control over that when it gets to the courtroom
- 16:55and the jury. And so at the end of the day, what
- 16:58they really want is for us to just put the prize
- 17:01in the bag. Thank you. I apologize. I thought
- 17:22you were just going to go in order. I think Jay
- 17:23is next. All right. And you're welcome just to
- 17:27keep speaking and I'll field questions. Thank
- 17:30you. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Hillary.
- 17:34It's very interesting, Lori. So I wanted to mention
- 17:36two cases that I think are exemplary and they
- 17:41touch upon a number of aspects of the case I
- 17:45wanted to mention, including a pretrial mock
- 17:49jury vetting the potential jury pool before they
- 17:55get in their seats, and also some visuals, which
- 17:59I've actually used in closings that are easy
- 18:02to do. I've created them myself on PowerPoint
- 18:05that illustrate how I like to have my words,
- 18:09my themes, and color images all at the same time
- 18:14before the jury's connection. The first exemplary
- 18:18case I wanted to mention was called Plan B versus
- 18:21Diversified Panel Systems. I represented the
- 18:24plaintiff Plan B, Diversified Panel Systems manufactured
- 18:29insulated steel panels for customers think of
- 18:33grocery stores who use these things to create
- 18:36refrigerated spaces to keep the food fresh before
- 18:39it goes out on the shelves. My clients were in
- 18:43the cannabis grow room space, and they had realized
- 18:47that these insulated storage panels had huge
- 18:50advantages over the traditional wood frame construction.
- 18:58They went to diversified panel systems. They
- 19:02proposed a joint venture whereby my clients would
- 19:06introduce the defendants to the cannabis grow
- 19:10room space. which would increase the sales of
- 19:13these storage panels, which had not originally
- 19:16been built for this purpose. And they split the
- 19:18resulting net profits. Now the problem was, classic
- 19:24fashion, they just shook hands and went about
- 19:26doing business. And there was this document that
- 19:30got slow voted around a draft term sheet that
- 19:34had this clause in there that said there will
- 19:36be no agreement unless until there's a signed
- 19:38writing, which never got signed. So one thing
- 19:44we did in the juror selection phase is there
- 19:50is an authorized Judicial Council foreign juror
- 19:53questionnaire, and you can also propose your
- 19:58own custom questions. And we did that here. Let
- 20:04me see if I can share this. So naturally we wanted
- 20:08to know, we being the plaintiffs hoping for a
- 20:10multi -million dollar verdict, we wanted to know
- 20:13if there's any jurors who are just going to negate
- 20:15the case because cannabis can be a divisive issue.
- 20:21So we had these questions. Do you believe working
- 20:24in the cannabis industry is morally or ethically
- 20:26wrong? Do you believe cannabis should be illegal?
- 20:31Basically, we wanted to find out people who were
- 20:33going to nullify the case because they just couldn't
- 20:35stand it was about cannabis. And we actually
- 20:37had quite a few people raise their hands at exit,
- 20:42which was a benefit to us because then we were
- 20:44only getting people who were willing to consider
- 20:47our case and weren't going to be troubled by
- 20:49the fact that it at least indirectly involved
- 20:52growing cannabis. And then I had the I wanted
- 20:58to mention we had a mock jury where I presented
- 21:02Plan B's case. My colleague pretended to be the
- 21:07defense counsel. I played it very conservatively.
- 21:10I talked about how they had a handshake. I showed
- 21:14the jury this draft writing, you know, there's
- 21:17no agreement until you have a signed writing.
- 21:20And then, of course, my colleague in the mock
- 21:23jury really, you know, beat me around the head
- 21:28with that document saying that just pre -explains
- 21:30case. He doesn't have a sign writing and he knows
- 21:33it. And then afterwards we passed out a little
- 21:36short sheet of jury instructions and we got huge
- 21:43feedback. The mock jury said, I lost the case
- 21:46until they got the jury instructions that informed
- 21:50them that you can, California law supports an
- 21:53oral agreement, right? I mean, there's a lot
- 21:55of people I mean, there are some areas where
- 21:57legally, right, the contract has to be in a signed
- 22:01writing. So with that, I front loaded this in
- 22:06front of the jury. Within the first three minutes
- 22:09of my opening statement, I told the jurors, the
- 22:12judge at the end is going to inform you that
- 22:14an oral agreement is enforceable under California
- 22:16law. And naturally, I drew an objection that
- 22:19was sustained. I said, forgive me, Your Honor,
- 22:22but I got that in front of them. And then in
- 22:26the closing, I really needed to repeat that again.
- 22:34So let me see here. Yeah, okay, hang on. The
- 22:45top here. And by the way, before I go to the
- 22:52slide view, I often do these things myself in
- 22:56PowerPoint. You can lay out the slide. If you
- 23:01can see on the upper right, there's a little
- 23:03designer button here. You click that and it reformats
- 23:07in interesting ways. If there's a picture I want
- 23:11to put in, you can add that in. It's easy to
- 23:14do. I'm not a technician and I did this myself.
- 23:22This was the, beyond the cover page, this was
- 23:25my first slide. I mean, I wanted these words
- 23:28in these colors right in front of the jury's
- 23:30eyes to remind them under the principle of primacy,
- 23:34make sure you're saying your most important things
- 23:36first and last, that they could enforce an oral
- 23:40agreement. And we had good evidence that the
- 23:44parties had in fact performed and shared. the
- 23:49net profits for a good while before the defendant
- 23:52claimed that it wasn't a deal for lack of the
- 23:54writing. I had this here, and again, I may be
- 24:00begging Lori's issue. I'm not sure if this is
- 24:04an image that appeals to young people. But to
- 24:07me, you shake hands, you have my word. It's just
- 24:11an image I wanted to get in front of the jury,
- 24:13respecting an oral And here I quote that even
- 24:21the defendant said in their pleadings alleged
- 24:23that there was an oral agreement. So that was
- 24:26important to get to the jury in front. And at
- 24:31the very end, there was an exhibit I wanted to
- 24:35show them, which we used to great impact. I had
- 24:41the CEO of the defendant up on the stands. He
- 24:46had presented these financials showing what business
- 24:50they've been doing to the so -called cold storage
- 24:53industry, Trader Joe's or Ralph's, right, keeping
- 24:57the food cold, versus the so -called non -cold
- 25:01storage business, which was these warm room temperature
- 25:05cannabis row rooms. So we had created this chart.
- 25:09from boring looking financials, which would look
- 25:12visually interesting and all. But we created
- 25:13this chart, including the color, which he validated
- 25:17on the stand. And you can see, just look at it.
- 25:20After my clients had introduced the cannabis
- 25:23market to them, it blew their revenue to the
- 25:27moon. And by 2022, it was 90 % of their revenues.
- 25:31Instead of doing 3 million, they were doing 30
- 25:33million. So that really showed the jury that
- 25:36what my clients had brought to the table really
- 25:40had impact and we got a unanimous eight figure
- 25:43verdict at the end. The other case I wanted to
- 25:49share, which is called the Schiller versus Guo
- 25:53case, I represented Dr. Kong and it was a vascular
- 25:58surgery practice. There were four partners and
- 26:02partners three and four, were a little jealous
- 26:06and curious about why partner number one was
- 26:08consistently the highest biller in the surgery
- 26:11practice by far. So they decided to do a surreptitious
- 26:15review of his cases and came to the conclusion
- 26:18that he was spiking his revenues by subjecting
- 26:21patients to surgeries they didn't need, which
- 26:23is a very provocative accusation. They went to
- 26:27my client, Dr. Kong, who was number two, pressed
- 26:31him to expel the first doctor, number one. My
- 26:36client initially voted to do that under the pressure
- 26:38of being confronted with this finding. Later,
- 26:43acquired some doubts that his fellow partners
- 26:46had been dealing with him honestly. And in the
- 26:49discovery, we got these horrifying conversations
- 26:53in text where the parties who leveled this accusation
- 26:59were texting one another about being whistleblowers
- 27:01and making millions and buying the assets of
- 27:06the partnership at a fire sale after we blew
- 27:09them up. So the case involved days of just kind
- 27:14of mind numbing testimony from these medical
- 27:17experts about whether or not if you see this
- 27:21or see that in somebody's veins or arteries,
- 27:23whether you're really subjecting to the surgery.
- 27:25But from our standpoint, Dr. Kong was defending
- 27:30himself and asserted theories that this was inconsistent
- 27:33with the partnership agreement. I mean, you're
- 27:35supposed to be honest with your partners, right?
- 27:38And I just wanted to convey to the jury that
- 27:40they used this theme of subjecting patients to
- 27:44surgeries they don't need dishonestly for a craven
- 27:51purpose. stabbing their partner in the back.
- 27:59So let me see. So after the opening slide here,
- 28:14I wanted to show my client and just have an image
- 28:17here of surgeons taking care of people. I mean,
- 28:21he and partner number one had had built this
- 28:25vascular surgery practice that was saving lives
- 28:27throughout the Ventura and Santa Barbara area.
- 28:33And again, maybe I overuse this image, but I
- 28:38wanted to convey this image to the jury that
- 28:40partners are honest with one another, they have
- 28:43duty to disclose important facts to one another,
- 28:45exercise their best vision, judge to be loyal
- 28:47to one another, not parlay an accusation into
- 28:52into financial gain. And here was this image
- 28:58here where I took a couple of the most heinous
- 29:03statements that were in these text chains. Let's
- 29:07blow this popsicle stand to the moon, which is
- 29:09in a text thread about, you know, the popsicle
- 29:12here was the vascular surgery partnership. And
- 29:16then... There was cackling and a text thread
- 29:18about buying the assets of the partnership after
- 29:21they blew it up at a fire sale, which I thought
- 29:25was heinous. I had thought that there were some
- 29:33important lies, so I had this slide here. Now,
- 29:39I suppose this begs the question. Unfortunately,
- 29:41I'm old enough to remember having seen Pinocchio
- 29:43as a kid, and I'd be Curious, Laura, if there's
- 29:46time later, if you think that a 20 -year -old
- 29:49would recognize this thematic. But of course,
- 29:53those of us who are old enough remember Pinocchio's
- 29:55nose growing every time he lied. So I wanted
- 29:58to give that visual next to my summation here
- 30:02about how I thought that the parties who had
- 30:07initiated this problem were telling the truth.
- 30:11And then I got some of these texts in front of
- 30:16the jury. Here, let's see. And while I'm getting
- 30:22this up, let me just remark a moment about discovery
- 30:27of electronically stored information. I'm always
- 30:32amazed that people produce emails as a PDF image.
- 30:36Maybe it's faded. You need to get those in native
- 30:39format. for among other reasons, you get the
- 30:43metadata plus it just looks better on the screen.
- 30:46I've seen terrible productions of text threads
- 30:49where it's a little screen cap or I've seen exports
- 30:54that read like a computer program and you don't
- 30:57see the conversations like you see it on the
- 31:00phone, right? Where there's speech balloons and
- 31:02they're justified left and right and the color.
- 31:07We actually went to court over this and forced
- 31:09the other side to export their text threads in
- 31:14a fashion that you could scroll through the whole
- 31:17thing, and the jury could see the text thread
- 31:20rolling as though they were looking at it on
- 31:22their phone. So here was an exchange here where
- 31:27somebody's talking about my client as though
- 31:29I'm being a terrible partner. And they say, let's
- 31:33leave and find that qui tam, which is a whistleblower
- 31:35action. And this is the reference to blowing
- 31:37this popsicle stand, namely the vascular surgery
- 31:41of partnership to the moon. And then we had this
- 31:46text image here. This was a reference to negotiating
- 31:53a deal to buy the assets of the practice at a
- 31:56fire sale after they'd blown it up. And towards
- 32:04the end, I wanted to have another image of people
- 32:08being honest with one another. I wanted to come
- 32:11up with an analogy for a relationship that's
- 32:14important where people need to treat one another
- 32:16correctly. I said, keeping a partnership together
- 32:19is like keeping a family together. And I found
- 32:22some picture just on, I grabbed on the internet
- 32:26of a husband and wife looking like they're having
- 32:29a difficult time in a therapy session. to convey
- 32:32that image. And then finally, I had some criticism
- 32:37of their damages, which I thought were nonexistent.
- 32:42I came up with this cute little ghost thing again,
- 32:45which conveyed an image I wanted the jury to
- 32:50see. So these are just a couple of examples of
- 32:53how I used primacy and recency, saying the most
- 32:58important thing first, saying the most important
- 33:00thing last. removing jurors who are going to
- 33:03have an animus to my part of the case and making
- 33:07sure that my words and themes are conveyed with
- 33:10images that I felt would capture the jury's visual
- 33:16attention and keep them awake and interested
- 33:19while I was conveying orally what I thought the
- 33:22evidence had shown. Again, we got an anonymous
- 33:25verdict in favor of Dr. Kong after making that
- 33:27presentation. So thanks so much and I'll turn
- 33:31the microphone over to to know Hi everybody Jury
- 33:40selection is the most important part of a case
- 33:44These are your judges You need to win them over
- 33:48First thing to be considering is that you are
- 33:55am I on the screen? Okay. First thing you need
- 34:01to be aware of is that you are on duty two miles
- 34:03from the courthouse. So be careful. Whether it's
- 34:09in the cafeteria or the hallway, they're looking
- 34:13at you. They're looking at how you're dressing,
- 34:15how you're interacting with everybody. I know
- 34:18a friend of mine who's a big hitter on his first
- 34:20day having a jury trial showed up in his Porsche.
- 34:26He was late and he... He didn't know it, but
- 34:30he cut off a juror. And somebody saw that. And
- 34:33he lost the case when he talked to the jurors
- 34:34afterwards. They said, you cut me off. And I
- 34:36saw you do it. I saw the public defender of the
- 34:44city of Chicago give a talk on jury instructions.
- 34:47He said, most important thing is to get the jury
- 34:49to like you. That's the most important thing.
- 34:52I saw another big hitter who he just said, I
- 34:55want to bond with the jury. I have a friend of
- 34:59mine who's a very, very successful lawyer. And
- 35:04he says, I went to the Jerry Spence School. I
- 35:08totally followed that. We spent five days in
- 35:10psychodrama, whatever it is. But I said, how
- 35:13do you do this? He says, I become one with these
- 35:18people. I learn who they are, and I can feel
- 35:23them. No joking. It's not a time for that. What
- 35:28you want to do is learn their names, if you can,
- 35:32on the jury, saying, well, Mr. Bennett or Mr.
- 35:35Smith, whenever it is. Do you agree with Ms.
- 35:38Jones on what she has to say? That shows that
- 35:40you're on top of it, although it's very difficult.
- 35:43The way they're picking juries these days is
- 35:45you have 75 people, and you're supposed to query
- 35:48them all at the same time. Don't be flashy. No
- 35:53jewelry, no monogram shirts. Wear white shirts
- 35:56if you can. Use visuals. I've seen the Pinocchio
- 35:59example in the past. You want to use videotape
- 36:04when you can. There's nothing more powerful than
- 36:07to show a witness 20 times on video saying, I
- 36:12don't recall. And then you say, what's the number
- 36:14one way people lie? They don't recall. And you've
- 36:18already asked them the question. You remember
- 36:19things that are important in your life, and was
- 36:21this important? Oh, you don't recall? Okay. You
- 36:25want to use video to impeach. There's nothing
- 36:27more powerful than asking a witness a question
- 36:31saying, oh, really? And then, boom, you hit them
- 36:34with that. You do that two times, that witness
- 36:35is blown out of the water. Jury questionnaires
- 36:39are very useful if the court will let you do
- 36:42it. We use jury consultants, and they're very,
- 36:45very helpful. We recommend them because they
- 36:48can see things that you're not going to pick
- 36:50up as well. We have used mock juries and you
- 36:55can pay plenty to go to an office and where they
- 37:00don't have a mock courtroom. We use Craigslist
- 37:05and pay them 50 bucks and give them lunch. They'll
- 37:09spend three or four hours with you and help you
- 37:13figure out what it's going to take to to get
- 37:17your ball over the plate. Wadair. Absolutely
- 37:22use artificial intelligence. I was supposed to
- 37:26start a trial two weeks ago, it got continued,
- 37:28but my friend Claude, I said, here's what the
- 37:32complaint is. Here's some of the issues in the
- 37:34case. Here's the kinds of people that I'm expecting
- 37:40to have. I've got 90 questions, 70 of which were
- 37:46perfect overall. You want to find out, your key
- 37:50is to find out their biases. Anybody who's biased
- 37:54against your journey, you want them off. And
- 37:56how do you do that? You get them talking amongst
- 37:59themselves and you tell them there's no wrong
- 38:01answer. How many people think there's too many
- 38:05trials, too many cases, et cetera, and you raise
- 38:08your hand along with them as well. And you talk
- 38:13to them in an interesting, nice way, like it's
- 38:16a talk show or whatever it may be, to say, okay,
- 38:19I agree or I understand. You don't have to say
- 38:21I agree, say I understand. And who agrees with
- 38:25what so -and -so has said in this particular
- 38:27case? I've seen one lawyer I know, he just says,
- 38:33I want brutal honesty out of you people. If you
- 38:36don't like me, you tell me. And I actually did
- 38:39that in a trial, and they said, yeah, I like
- 38:41you so much. I won a lot of money. And I think
- 38:46I got rid of that jury. But one of the other
- 38:51questions is, do you believe that people who
- 38:54are bringing lawsuits start behind the starting
- 38:58line if this was a race? In other words, they
- 39:00have to catch up for other people. Can you award
- 39:04substantial damages if the facts and law warrant
- 39:07them? I always ask, what are your hobbies? What
- 39:11do you do for fun? What programs do you watch?
- 39:15What do you subscribe to? Is there something
- 39:17I should know about you that you haven't revealed?
- 39:22Is there anything about anybody in this courtroom
- 39:25or this case that bothers you? How did you know
- 39:29about similar cases? Have you been involved in
- 39:31anything like that? types of jurors Everybody
- 39:36has says and I don't know How scientific it is
- 39:41but we don't want accountants engineers and scientists
- 39:44because they don't have as big a heart as the
- 39:47rest of the public Others have said I don't want
- 39:50any immigrants people from other countries are
- 39:52not in them Used to awarding large amounts of
- 39:56money and I want to make that clear at the very
- 39:58beginning if my facts and law show you that There's
- 40:03a it could be millions of dollars. Are you willing
- 40:05to award that? Are you willing to award? punitive
- 40:09damages overall If they don't want to be on the
- 40:13jury They I don't want them on either I was doing
- 40:18picking a juror one time and the second day of
- 40:21jury selections This dude stands up in the middle
- 40:24and says why am I still here? Okay, you gotta
- 40:27go The lawyer and we heard this from The lawyer
- 40:34is not the star, the client is. The lawyer is
- 40:38calm and organized, but he can be passionate
- 40:41in closing. I have a friend of mine, a big hitter,
- 40:44somebody once made a motion in Lemonade that
- 40:46said, Your Honor, tell him he's not allowed to
- 40:49cry in closing argument. I know some lawyers
- 40:54who take improv classes, there's an improv class
- 40:58available for lawyers to help you during trial
- 41:01over all. I highly recommend seminars that you
- 41:05attend to where you can learn other, I'm not
- 41:09gonna call them tricks of the trade, other techniques.
- 41:14Make sure that in your opening statement, you
- 41:17stay, you say fundamentally what the case is
- 41:20about because that's a rule. that you have to
- 41:23do that. And it happened to me once. I was not
- 41:25aware of the rule. I had to go back and repeat
- 41:28my opening statement, and it didn't make me look
- 41:30so good. Another thing is that I did a jury trial
- 41:34one time, and we won. But the juror said, you
- 41:38know, we're not stupid. You don't have to say
- 41:40the same thing five times over and over again.
- 41:46So that's kind of the bottom line for me is what
- 41:50I'm saying of my my tips overall, and I guess
- 41:53now we can have an agreement to talk amongst
- 41:56ourselves or answer questions if people have
- 41:59any that they want to ask. I do have a few questions
- 42:06that I would like to add, and since I'm so fortunate
- 42:09to have the three of you here, I have a list,
- 42:12and I don't think we have any current ones. How
- 42:16do you approach... I didn't work for the... I
- 42:20never worked for the public defender. I didn't
- 42:22work for the public defender at the DA, but I
- 42:24was on the court appointed attorney of defense
- 42:25panel, because we did a lot of criminal defense
- 42:27early on in my career. And we had fast trials,
- 42:31where I know Jay explained where he was successful
- 42:34in a trial, but it was a lot of testimony. And
- 42:37Neville, I know you've been involved as, Laurie,
- 42:38you certainly have. How do you capture a juror's
- 42:42attention and maintain it quickly? when you have
- 42:44to grab it, when the trial's, you know, we've
- 42:47all seen these situations where it's like, get
- 42:48a jury in here now, we're going to pick a jury,
- 42:50I don't want it, I don't want this case to drag
- 42:52out all week, I've got a full calendar. Does
- 42:54your approach change when you're dealing with
- 42:57a fast trial as opposed to a long trial, besides
- 43:00the obvious? I always want to keep it moving
- 43:03as fast as possible. I mean, people get bored
- 43:06and they get angry, and you don't want to keep
- 43:08them waiting around at all. And I want to say
- 43:11one other thing, which is why it's helpful to
- 43:13have jury consultants, et cetera. I mean, I almost
- 43:16got burned. I won a big case. But the 20 -year
- 43:20-old, two 20 -year -olds, they were going to
- 43:22stick it to me. I won, like, I think it was 9
- 43:25-3 overall. They were not on my side overall.
- 43:28So don't think that just because they're college
- 43:32students or whatever that they're liberal or
- 43:34anything like that. You can't always tell. And
- 43:38the other thing is for cause is what it's all
- 43:42about. I'm trying to get rid of people for cause.
- 43:44And sometimes a jury selection can go on for
- 43:46four days and you get rid of 53 people overall.
- 43:50And one other thing I want to say is respect
- 43:52at all times for the court, the clerks, the jurors,
- 43:57opposing counsel, your client, et cetera, at
- 44:01all times. And you don't want to be arguing in
- 44:07front of the jury with opposing counsel. Judges
- 44:11hate that. You want to win, but you need to control
- 44:18your emotion overall so that you're not over
- 44:21the top. I mean, you're supposed to be articulate
- 44:23and measured is the goal. But you can, as I said
- 44:29in closing argument, no problem. Be passionate
- 44:32in your way all you can. And people always say,
- 44:35get out. Get away from that podium. Get in front
- 44:38of the jury. You know, have your jacket open,
- 44:41and there you are connecting with them, looking
- 44:45them in the eye overall. You know, Hillary, there's
- 44:51a phenomenon I try to focus on, which is trial
- 44:56estimates, right? I mean, yes, I want to get
- 44:59my point out there, get focused, show my images,
- 45:02get my main thing, you know, sit down. What I
- 45:07find so many practitioners don't focus on is
- 45:09I hear these trial estimates and they just seem
- 45:13totally unrealistic. And in Los Angeles Superior
- 45:16Court, unless you get in the complex department
- 45:19where there's no morning calendar, if you're
- 45:21in one of the departments where there's a morning
- 45:23calendar, you're gonna get four and a quarter,
- 45:26four and a half hours of testimony soaking wet
- 45:30in one day, right? What I see, especially if
- 45:37I get colleagues maybe at bigger firms who haven't
- 45:41tried as many cases, you know, they list 400
- 45:44exhibits and they've given us six or seven day
- 45:48trial estimate. And then if you break it down,
- 45:51some of the judges require a list of the witnesses
- 45:53with how many hours you're gonna go on cross,
- 45:56direct, cross and redirect. they've estimated
- 46:00100 hours of testimony. So it's gonna take us
- 46:02a month to do that. So I often have to fight
- 46:05against unrealistic trial estimates. In the vascular
- 46:12surgery case, that judge handed off her morning
- 46:18calendar. She took the kind of the biggest courtroom
- 46:21in the Ventura County court. And so we were getting
- 46:24closer to six and a half, seven hours. which
- 46:28compressed it, but we had a hard time keeping
- 46:31the jury's attention there because there was
- 46:34so much medical testimony. It was important,
- 46:37but a little mind -numbing, which is, I just
- 46:41try to get up there and say, look, I don't know
- 46:42what you think about the medical testimony, but
- 46:44you got to be honest with your partners, not
- 46:46stab them in the back. It had my little punch
- 46:49points during a very long trial. I would add
- 46:54one quick thing to that, Hillary, which is, you
- 46:57know, Pixar and trailers for movies do exactly
- 47:02what you're asking, right? So how do you get
- 47:04somebody's attention quickly and it motivate
- 47:07them? to be there for the longer story, right?
- 47:11I would say you look into Pixar and how it goes
- 47:13about storytelling. You can find it online, it's
- 47:15free. They obviously do that very well, Ken Burns.
- 47:19Other people do it very well. So you wanna be
- 47:21able to get their attention quickly. You wanna
- 47:23be able to tell a story. You don't want just
- 47:25to ram a bunch of facts down their throats. And
- 47:29what Jason is very important also, which is you
- 47:32wanna be thematic in terms of there's all this
- 47:35talk and detail, but here's the point. And so
- 47:38what you want to do is create audio tabs of the
- 47:41chapters to say, here's where we're going next.
- 47:43This is what we're doing. This is why I'm telling
- 47:45you. One of the articles that I'm sharing with
- 47:47the audience and they're welcome to see is called,
- 47:49why are you telling me that? It's the only documentary,
- 47:52a trial is the only documentary that doesn't
- 47:54give you the real title until it's over. So,
- 47:57you know, you're getting all these facts and
- 47:58no one puts the story together for you typically
- 48:00until it's kind of too late. And so you want
- 48:03to be able to front that. so that you can motivate
- 48:05them into paying attention to it, whether it's
- 48:08short or long. You know, another issue that you
- 48:11have is how much time are you going to have?
- 48:13And you should have as much as you want, but
- 48:16some judges say, I'm going to give you an hour.
- 48:19And that's the way it is. And how about federal
- 48:21court, where you don't get to pick, you don't
- 48:24get voir dire, although some judges will allow
- 48:27you to do it. So what are you doing then? You're
- 48:29saying, can I have jury questionnaire? Can you
- 48:31ask them these questions, please, Your Honor?
- 48:33I need to know overall. But I mean, they can
- 48:35do jury selection. I mean, I've had it in like
- 48:38an hour. Yes. You know, they just basically ask
- 48:41your name and where do you live? Thanks a lot.
- 48:44Goodbye. And again, of course, I echo what people
- 48:47have been saying is themes. You really should
- 48:49be developing a theme all the way through to
- 48:53the time when it's time to bring it home overall.
- 48:58But the bottom line is don't bore the jury and
- 49:00just get to the point. And two follow -up questions.
- 49:05Don't bore the jury. Perfect segue. Lori, I know
- 49:09all of you are great. Jay and Neville are both
- 49:11great at this, and Lori, you're a pro, too. Observing
- 49:15the jury, I've seen this happen. I've seen it
- 49:18in hearings. I've seen it in trials that I've
- 49:20observed. And I've seen it when it's been in
- 49:22trials. You're like, you're losing the jury.
- 49:24We've all seen the situation where the judge
- 49:26is really annoyed, and you can tell they're annoyed,
- 49:29and the person's not reading the room. And we've
- 49:31seen attorneys go in and, spit up all this information,
- 49:36and the jury could care less. What is some of
- 49:40the tips or practices that all of you use to
- 49:43observe the jury when you're in trial? I'm not
- 49:46talking about four -year or things like that,
- 49:47or you look at them and you go, yeah, they're
- 49:49not liking this. Sometimes you can tell they'd
- 49:52like, Neville mentioned it. Well, if they're
- 49:54sleeping, you got a problem. But I had a judge
- 49:59in one case that I had, and it was a long trial,
- 50:01like six weeks. And the judge, and we were creaming
- 50:06a witness, and the judge after the day ended
- 50:11said, I really don't think you ought to continue
- 50:14with this witness anymore. The jury has got it
- 50:17overall. So that's I think a tendency is, you
- 50:20know, you wanted to throw everything in, but
- 50:23you don't need to. It's just make your point
- 50:25and move on. If you can destroy the credibility
- 50:27of a witness in... and one or two questions,
- 50:31why spend 10? I've seen lawyers in court examine
- 50:39a witness while seated looking at their laptop
- 50:45on which they have their questions. I've seen
- 50:49lawyers ask questions and they're turning their
- 50:53backs on the jury. When the other side is grilling
- 51:00my witnesses or putting theirs on, I can turn
- 51:03and look at the jury just to see, is the jury
- 51:07nodding? Are they shaking their heads? Are they
- 51:09falling asleep? And if I'm an examining witness,
- 51:14I always go to the podium. I always ask the judge,
- 51:19what is the territory within which I can move
- 51:23without being admonished by your honor? Medical
- 51:27thing is okay. You have to be able to touch the
- 51:29podium. So So I I'm about I've got like one fingertip
- 51:33on the podium and I asked I'm looking at the
- 51:39witness for the question, but then when it's
- 51:41the answer I turn to the jury sometimes to see
- 51:44how they're reacting You'll make eye contact.
- 51:47It just makes it a little more You're getting
- 51:51a little more chance to get people's reactions
- 51:53than if you're just you know, sitting there with
- 51:56your outline, going through all your questions
- 51:58like this, and you're just not experiencing what's
- 52:01happening in the room. Okay, a couple of other
- 52:05things you can do. One is I find that the way
- 52:08that questions, whether it's direct or cross,
- 52:12get asked is not the way anybody speaks in real
- 52:15life, typically. It's sort of depo speak. So
- 52:18the first thing I would say is don't do that.
- 52:21Speak like a person. that's having a conversation,
- 52:24whether it's friendly or hostile or whatever
- 52:25it may be. And don't forget to use intonation.
- 52:29So, you know, really, did you did that happen?
- 52:32You know, you want to be able to get people to
- 52:34pay attention because it's the way people actually
- 52:36communicate. That's one thing. The second thing
- 52:38is shake up some of the media. Don't just use
- 52:41blow ups of documents. Use other types of media.
- 52:45Make sure that you're using different types of
- 52:48visuals. Thirdly, if it's a very important witness,
- 52:52good or bad, fill the courtroom. Let the signal
- 52:55be that this is important to pay attention to.
- 52:58So bring an audience in on your side, on the
- 53:00bride's side, so to speak. On the other hand,
- 53:04if it's really someone you don't want them to
- 53:05pay attention to because it's very damaging or
- 53:08maybe not such a good witness, Maybe empty your
- 53:11people out of the courtroom, like, don't worry
- 53:13about this, you can take a nap now. So you can
- 53:15send signals to people to pay attention or not
- 53:19pay attention and absolutely be able to shift
- 53:23on your feet. If you see that you're losing them,
- 53:25there's no point to keep going in the same way
- 53:28that you're doing it. Which brings me to my next
- 53:32question. I mean, they're war story or a time
- 53:36or a tactic that you've used when sometimes,
- 53:39and I've had this in hearings and trials and
- 53:42a lot of lawyers have, what you're doing is not
- 53:44working. Either it's the graphics are not persuasive
- 53:48and you're putting these people to sleep, you've
- 53:51lost them, you have other options. I mean, sometimes
- 53:54if you have no other choice, there's like, I
- 53:56know Jay, you were discussing, there was a lot
- 53:58of medical testimony. You had to get that in
- 54:00and you very clearly stated that you could you
- 54:04know, get the sound bite in and get the point
- 54:06of the, crystallize the point of that you were
- 54:09trying to make. But sometimes, well, hearing
- 54:11certainly and in trials, what you're doing is
- 54:14not working. And you may have to change course,
- 54:18maybe not throughout everything. But can you
- 54:21think of times that's happened and how you handled
- 54:23it or tips to manage that? if you have to make
- 54:27the course correction that, you know, these things
- 54:30happen. It happened to me one time where a witness
- 54:34I had brought his notes with him to the stand
- 54:40and the opposing counsel was able to see them.
- 54:43And the questions we were going to go over, I
- 54:46wasn't too happy about that. So leave it in the
- 54:49seat when your witness is there. That's a good
- 54:55point. I've had that happen to me. Also, I'll
- 54:57tell you, another time I had a client, one of
- 55:00my earlier cases, and he got up in the middle
- 55:05of his testimony and pointed at the defendant
- 55:08and said, you know, you guys cheated me. It was
- 55:11like he pissed the judge off. You know, he was
- 55:13showboating is what he was doing. Now, I had
- 55:16no idea who was going to do that, but you got
- 55:18to learn to keep them under control overall.
- 55:23Although there was an amusing moment one time
- 55:25when I asked my client on the stand, why did
- 55:29you call someone so eroding that he said, just
- 55:31look at him? Best visual you could get. Or another
- 55:37time I had a guy who was an expert witness on
- 55:39the valuation of something and the closing counsel
- 55:42said, have you been paid yet by Mr. Johnson?
- 55:45No. How do you know you're going to get paid?
- 55:47And the witness said, how do you know you're
- 55:49going to get paid? So anyway. There is humor,
- 55:52occasionally. I've trimmed my witness list. I
- 56:01think we got this point. Maybe we'll drop a witness
- 56:05I was thinking of bringing. I've trimmed or adjusted
- 56:10my outline, particularly if we get a lunch break
- 56:13or a morning or afternoon recess. Why don't we
- 56:18scratch this topic and just move to the last
- 56:21point. So I've tried to make those real -time
- 56:26adjustments. And in some cases, there's just
- 56:29not much you can do. I actually, my side in the
- 56:33vascular surgery case wasn't, my client wasn't
- 56:36dependent on whether the surgeries were necessary,
- 56:40but sometimes, I don't know, sometimes you just
- 56:43gotta get through a lot of material. My impression
- 56:46was the jury was to get lost on this. which is
- 56:49why I wanted to stay with just simple things.
- 56:52If you're a partner, you got to be honest, you
- 56:53got to be true, and you want to stab your partners
- 56:56in the back for financial gain. Laurie? Yeah,
- 57:01I would say, I mean, I agree with all that. I
- 57:03think, you know, what I say to clients is, I
- 57:06think of Juror time like jury years like dog
- 57:10years like a minute of an attorney's lifetime
- 57:13is feels like seven out of the jurors So you
- 57:16really have to understand that while you may
- 57:18think it's all pearls. They don't so in any case
- 57:22That's going to be the case that they feel that
- 57:24their time is not necessarily being used optimally
- 57:27that a lot of time is wasted it's disorganized
- 57:29so first of all certainly be organized be prepared
- 57:31they don't want to see you shuffling your papers
- 57:33up at the podium things of that nature but in
- 57:36addition what i recommend is it's not working
- 57:38and that can happen to anybody for variety of
- 57:41reasons. Is i think for each key witness you
- 57:45should have one summary graphic that sort of
- 57:48the kill shot. that says here's why i'm here
- 57:51here's the point that i'm going to be making
- 57:53with this person whether it's affirmative or
- 57:56defensive and so that if you need to almost at
- 58:00any time you can jump to that and just go so
- 58:03does this summarize you know your testimony or
- 58:06your position or or what you've you know testified
- 58:09to and if it's your witnesses you want to make
- 58:11sure that all of your witnesses knows know their
- 58:15summary slide and then of course that you're
- 58:18opposing Don't. But that's always a go -to, which
- 58:22is like, let's cut to the chase type of slide.
- 58:27What about the classic situation where either
- 58:29you don't like your client or your client is
- 58:33not likable? We've all had these. Laurie's smiling.
- 58:37Laurie, why don't you start us off there? Oh,
- 58:39no. Well, I'm not a fan of saying to the jury,
- 58:44look, you don't have to like my client, but.
- 58:47I don't think that's a really good way to go.
- 58:50I think what you want to be able to do is talk
- 58:53about the values that matter that do align with
- 58:55where your client is at. But what I often do
- 58:57if a client is not likable is I will tell them
- 59:00that. I'm very often hired to be bad cop, okay?
- 59:03It's easier for me than the advocate who's got
- 59:06to be their kind of as a cheerleader. I don't.
- 59:08I'm there and I'm a truth teller, and I have
- 59:11some psychological training to be able to deliver
- 59:14a poison pill, which is, look, if I don't like
- 59:17you and I get paid a lot more than the jury,
- 59:19why would they be motivated to like you? So I
- 59:22want to align with them to let them understand,
- 59:24first of all, what they do that is not likable,
- 59:27to see what it is that they can do to deal with
- 59:29that, because if they have ego, and they typically
- 59:31do, see that they're working against their own
- 59:34best interests. And I work with a lot of celebrities
- 59:36and that's an issue there too. And I can tell
- 59:39you that research shows that likability is 50
- 59:42% of credibility. So that they can actually shoot
- 59:46themselves in the foot very easily if they don't
- 59:49take care of the fact that they're not being
- 59:50likable. And there's a lot of studies about what
- 59:53makes people likable and unlikable, but most
- 59:55of people have a good gut about it. Yeah, when
- 59:58it comes to that also is you you have existed
- 1:00:01you've gone through the testimony with your witnesses
- 1:00:03before so they know what's coming and You know
- 1:00:07the the kinds of answers that you're looking
- 1:00:09for, you know, they're truthful overall brevity
- 1:00:14conciseness organization I had a I had a pro
- 1:00:21bono case where I represented a fellow who was
- 1:00:25a It was a civil commitment for pedophilia, which
- 1:00:30is loathsome, of course. And we had a Fourth
- 1:00:35Amendment or section, whatever it's called, case
- 1:00:37where they were going to search him. And he wanted
- 1:00:41to be searched by a psychiatric technician who
- 1:00:45was familiar with his ailment. But instead, the
- 1:00:47guard slams him to the hot, paved 100 -degree
- 1:00:51heat and beats him up, and he was all injured.
- 1:00:53I got an eliminate ruling from the judge saying
- 1:00:57that the only reference people could make that
- 1:00:59he was committed for being a danger to himself
- 1:01:02or society. So the jury didn't know his particular
- 1:01:06element and just told him, look, maybe you're
- 1:01:09glad that my client isn't living in your neighborhood.
- 1:01:12But the reason we're different from other countries
- 1:01:15is because we have a constitution which we should
- 1:01:18all honor and applies to everyone, even people
- 1:01:21who are committed to an institution. And what
- 1:01:23happened wasn't right. And you should stand up
- 1:01:27for what's right. And the jury returned a verdict
- 1:01:29that the institution, through the guard, violated
- 1:01:34his Fourth Amendment rights. One last question,
- 1:01:38and I think we're about out of time. I know it's
- 1:01:40important to thank the judge and the jury. Do
- 1:01:43you do anything special when you thank the jury?
- 1:01:45I know it depends on the case. Jay, what do you
- 1:01:48do? I just thank the judge and jury for the time.
- 1:01:53We sure appreciate it. We know you spent time
- 1:01:58away from your work and your families, but this
- 1:02:00is why the justice system works, that we have
- 1:02:03citizens who are willing to volunteer for this,
- 1:02:05and it means a lot. I say that Abraham Lincoln
- 1:02:09said, after being a soldier, the most important
- 1:02:13thing a citizen can do is be on a jury. And we
- 1:02:17appreciate it. And that's what keeps our country
- 1:02:19running. Laurie, do you find in your consulting
- 1:02:24work that being thanking the jury and doing things
- 1:02:27other than thank you for being here today? I'm
- 1:02:29like, Jay and Neville are both getting great
- 1:02:30examples of something a little more personal,
- 1:02:33like they're making it personal to the jury.
- 1:02:35You're not saying, hey, thanks for coming by.
- 1:02:37You're saying, hey, you really contributed here
- 1:02:39today. And this is part of our system. And this
- 1:02:41is why it's so important. Laurie, do you find
- 1:02:43that helps? I think it helps, but it also helps
- 1:02:46to add to that, to remind them the promises they
- 1:02:49made in jury selection and when they were sworn
- 1:02:51in, to the extent that you've asked for certain
- 1:02:54commitments for them to now uphold them. This
- 1:03:00was great, and I'm always, Laurie, I was thrilled
- 1:03:03to meet you, and I know I've worked with Day
- 1:03:06& Neville before, and I so appreciated your insights
- 1:03:09and things like that. I'm taking my own little
- 1:03:11notes here, and thank you. And for those of you
- 1:03:13who are viewing today, we're going to have another
- 1:03:15presentation that all three of these fantastic
- 1:03:17speakers have generously agreed to speak at,
- 1:03:19which is appealing to cross -generational jurors.
- 1:03:23So stay tuned, and thank you so much. Thank you.
- 1:03:26Thank you. Bye -bye. Thank you. I know.