Latest / AEC GrowthCast / How Kimley-Horn Keeps Its Culture While Growing (Ep. 9)
Transcript
- Aaron Nathan: I I don't really like the title (COO) because it it implies executive authority that I I guess I have, but I don't feel like in our organization I really utilize. Our chairman now when when we were talking about this, he said, "Aaron, you're really kind of like a janitor." I mean, it's it's a custodial capacity. I feel blessed that that folks have asked me to do this, but I never aspired to this. So now I live vicariously through, you know, a couple thousand practice builders. So when I see a practice builder, "Tell me what you're working on. What's cooking with your client's business?" Because Gregory Hart: Hello and welcome to the AEC GrowthCast. My name is Greg Hart, president here at PSMJ. Thanks for joining us. The AC GrowthCast is the show for AEC firm leaders where we talk about the data, the stories, and the insight behind high performance in architecture, engineering, construction organizations. In this episode, we're getting into what has gotten an 11,000-person engineering firm on Fortune's Best Places to Work, currently 19 times. We're digging into some of the data and stories and trends coming out of PSMJ's latest AE financial performance benchmark survey. And we're figuring out how to bridge a valuation gap and a potential acquisition, an issue that comes up quite a bit. So lots of firms are getting bigger out there these days, but what really are the secrets to getting better? Stay tuned to find out. And I want to get right into my discussion with Aaron Nathan. Aaron's the chief operating officer at Kimley-Horn, one of the nation's leading engineering, planning, and design consulting firms. Many of you are probably familiar with Kimley-Horn. If not, you will be after this episode. Aaron is a professional engineer with more than 25 years of experience at Kimley-Horn. He's held a variety of roles and became the COO, though you'll hear how he doesn't necessarily like that title, in 2024. Why is this discussion important? Like I said, 19 times in Fortune's Best Places to Work is nothing to sneeze at. Kimley-Horn is also frequently in PSMJ's Circle of Excellence, which are the top performers in that financial benchmark survey that I mentioned earlier. And they really are a case study in staying true to a set of core principles. during an extended period of of fairly robust growth. So lots of good takeaways. And I think it's an important discussion for all of us to kind of absorb. So let's take a listen and jump right into that. We have Aaron Nathan with us today, Chief Operating Officer at Kimley-Horn. Thanks for joining me, Aaron. Aaron Nathan: Thanks, Greg. Gregory Hart: Tell me a little bit about Kimley-Horn, maybe to get things started here. Give us a little bit of a description and background. Aaron Nathan: I feel like when I'm talking to folks familiar with the AEC industry, I can skip a few steps on some of the background. If I'm sitting next to someone on the plane, perhaps. I like to describe us as a built environment consulting firm. And then people inevitably will say, "Well, what is the built environment?" which allows you to talk about engineering, planning, survey. You know, if you're on a plane, "Hey, the runway that we just took off from, or that Gregory Hart: Yeah, yeah. Aaron Nathan: terminal," or the water line, the chicken restaurant, whatever the thing might be, we we may have been involved with that. So definitely started as engineering, but have grown quite a bit. And now I think it's around eleven thousand five hundred. I'd like to think that's an outcome on headcount, not a goal. But that's kind of the zip code of of number of employees we have today. Gregory Hart: And how many offices? Aaron Nathan: I I probably should know the answer better than this, but I'll say one hundred seventy five ish. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I can give you a better update if I study the weekly message, but yeah, in that zip code. Gregory Hart: It's growing, that's for sure. Yeah, it's funny. We've— I think one of the things that we often think of Kimley-Horn for is the Fortune Best Companies to Work for. Is it something like nineteen years that you've been on Fortune's best companies work? Aaron Nathan: Yeah, nineteen years and And we put it in our email signature. So that's probably the way I keep up with it. We get the annual Gregory Hart: That's Aaron Nathan: note to reminder to update your email signature. Gregory Hart: So take me through that a little bit. what are some of the core principles or sort of the secret sauce that's led to that kind of sustained success? Aaron Nathan: We're very appreciative of the external recognition. But it's definitely the outcome of a lot of things we do, not necessarily a goal. Our growth is really sustainable and we really see it as sustainable, not remarkable or outsized. It's been very consistent for us. So next year we'll be happening to celebrating our 60th anniversary as a firm. but it's been a very smooth growth model through that time. A few things that I think are noteworthy... Any time someone asks me about core principles, we have something we call our core values and core purpose that are really true to us. We actually documented them in 2000. And for context, I joined Kimley-Horn in 2001 when we were about a thousand employees. They weren't written to be aspirational. They were a reflection of who we were at that time. And if you think about all the things that have happened in the world since 2000, we haven't changed one word in our core value and core purpose over 26 years. We've continued to rely on those as guiding principles for our culture. Our core purpose is a statement to provide an environment for our people to flourish. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: And that truly is a guiding light for a lot of things we do, whether we're doing exceptionally well in the market or whether we're struggling with something, we truly do look at that to say how how do we live up to our core purpose? We first were recognized by Fortune I believe in '04. I'd have to kind of go back in the annals to know this with certainty, but I recall being at Kimley-Horn for a number of years and we got this recognition. And (I'm) very proud of that recognition. And it's interesting over time, Fortune relies heavily on a couple different sources for their ranking. And one of them is employee surveys, is certainly a place they ask employees how how are we doing on different things. The things that they pick up on to me are small items, but they're really important cultural things to me that feel very normal. We have these things called teamwork awards. You can give anybody a $75 award for doing anything. There's very little approval to those. And so that's something that always gets picked up on. And these little cultural nuggets that to me, Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: coming here out of college, they just feel like they're normal part of our culture. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I don't think we're that different than we Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: were in 2000 or 2001. There's just to your questions earlier, there's more dots on the map, there's more people, but we still live those core principles every day. Gregory Hart: Yeah. It seems important to note too that core principle of kind of creating an environment for our people to flourish. That doesn't mean creating an environment for everyone to flourish. It means creating an environment for people that really subscribe to that culture and, you know, are really want to grow with the firm. Seems to me the opportunities are endless. Even yourself is probably a great example over twenty five years, rising up to be COO of the firm. And it's it's kind of awesome to hear even you say, "I don't think the company's that different culturally." You know, so many times, there are firms that have kind of lost their identity, become slower, become more inwardly focused, become more kind of bureaucratic. But it's kinda awesome to hear you say, like, "We still kind of operate the Aaron Nathan: Please. Gregory Hart: same way we did back then." Aaron Nathan: There's a lot more consistency over time than there are differences. I started with Kimley-Horn as a traffic engineer, transportation planner. That's how I sort of found Kimley-Horn. We've always been organized around practice. We've always been structured to support our practice builders. That model allows us to continue to scale. You said the words rise up. I had sort of a a reaction to that because I feel like I've had the opportunity to move down on the org chart, not move up. I moved down because I'm there to support others. I joke with folks I I work down in the basement sometimes of the firm because the practice builders are the ones serving clients and doing things on the front line. So those things have led us to grow. And I think it's one of the things that's attractive to us for recruits, college grads, and clients who want to be served. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, ultimately creating an environment for people to flourish kind of falls on you, right? Yeah. So you're behind the scenes doing everything you can to make sure you're knocking down obstacles in supporting that environment, right? I mean, that's probably job number one for you to keep that kind of core value intact. Aaron Nathan: Yeah. There's oftentimes if I'm joining practice builders, I happen to be a with a group of our power delivery practice builders last week. And really it was "Tell me what y'all need. Tell me where there's friction, tell me where there's challenges, because I'm I'm here to support you." And certainly we might nudge, we want to keep things culturally aligned. We want to have a strong reputation in the industry, deliver with quality, all the things that any firm will try and do, but try to think about what is it that I need to be aware of to help provide that support from the bottom. Gregory Hart: Yeah. One of the things I love about talking to you, and even when we talked earlier, it's sort of like "We run the firm the way we think every firm should be run. So it doesn't seem like we're doing all that much different." But the phrase practice builder, you know, a lot of firms would use some typical kind of org structure, principal, director, vice president, something like that. But practice builder is a much more kind of specific phrase. It's more than just a title, right? That's a sense of empowerment. Tell me a little bit of what a practice builder is. Aaron Nathan: It's an interesting question. And we don't actually even anoint someone with the title. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: Sometimes folks will say "A practice builder... Oh, that's a seller-doer. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I know what that is." We believe there's a few more rungs to that conversation. And we actually have a term that we'll use called the well-rounded practice builder, who have a high-level responsibility for the success of their team, for their clients; win work, produce work, produce it with quality, collect the invoice. You know, they do all the things you need to do to run a business successfully. And we also acknowledge that nobody's perfect and nobody's perfect at all those things. So, how do we support people along the way in sort of running their own small business? The other factors that come into play are other cultural items: we're one profit center as a firm. So you're encouraged to share resources and partner with the practice builder down the hall versus compete with a practice builder down the hall. We're also privately held by active employees. So the majority of our owners of the firm are also active practice builders in the firm. I'd say roughly 80% of our owners are practice builders as well. It's a unique to Kimley-Horn structure. I've learned that over time. For me, it was normal when I started. I've realized we've become maybe special in our own way. One of the things I like to describe as we grow is I want to be Kimley-Horn only more so. Like let's aspire to be a better version of ourselves as we grow and Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: evolve. And I I think we believe with confidence that we can continue to scale and continue to be a just a better version of Kimley-Horn. Gregory Hart: It seems like that all ties back to that core principle too. It's like everything from the seventy five dollar spot bonuses to the one profit center, which you know, profit centers can be hugely divisive, right, in any company, not just in our industry. So that allows for much better collaboration, across business units. Is there an alternative way that you're tracking office, division, discipline, performance, is it purely based on revenue or how else do you know as one profit center what's working and what's not? Aaron Nathan: Yeah, We certainly have a lot of tools at our disposal, which I think are consistent. you know, with peers of mine or other people in the industry that are tracking performance. So we have those things. It's interesting, Greg, because it's hard to point to one metric as the metric or the answer, the thing you look at. I've sometimes used the analogy of it's sort of like the weather. If all I tell you is the temperature, that's not enough information. Is that the high? Is that the low? Is it raining? You know, what are the conditions around it? So there's always a bunch of variables you need to look at. I think ultimately we know it takes a lot of partnership to serve our clients, and we benefit from those who came before us with client relationships. So many stories around "How did we end up serving that client?" "Oh they used to work at that place, and that place used, and so that was so and so in another office." People are proud of where they work. I have a Kimley-Horn shirt on today. People are proud of the brand, proud of the logo, and want to have a strong reputation. I have found myself recently enjoying some Charlie Munger quotes. Our president CEO quotes Charlie from time to time too. So it probably helps and put it in my head. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: "Show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome." Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: So when the incentive is to to be a better version of Kimley-Horn, we have plenty of competition outside our walls. So we try to cut it down into inside our walls. Gregory Hart: The recruiting at Kimley-Horn, to be sustaining this kind of growth, must be pretty intense and it must be pretty widespread. And certainly having that designation must help. And I think you guys do a lot of recruiting at the entry, if not intern, level, right? To kind of keep that culture building and the firm growing. Aaron Nathan: Yeah, and that's always been the case. I I'll Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: get my numbers wrong, but it's north of a thousand college grads that we'll hire this year. Similar volume of interns, because where does the college grads come from? A lot of them come from the intern program before. I have two teenagers now. So knowing what someone on a college campus thinks about and how they find the company of choice... something I go ask our college recruiters about because they spend a lot more time on campuses than I do. But I I have to think that that brand reputation makes our booth or our virtual booth, however it's done now, an attractive place for people to go explore. And without a doubt, it's a talent war. I mean, I know technology will be a disruptor of how talent works and what we ask people to do, but absolutely you're trying to attract the best and brightest to come to your booth. And so it's clearly the Fortune ranking, I think, has to be a helpful, "Hey, it's it's worth me kicking tires over here at this Kimley-Horn place. Let me see what they're about." Gregory Hart: Yeah. There's a lot of firms that are gonna chase revenue growth, right? And a lot of firms that are gonna chase other elements of kind of the financial growth piece. But what else do you do to make sure growth doesn't come at the expense of culture? How do you continue to sustain that as you as you grow more and more and more? Aaron Nathan: My mind is going maybe two two different directions on it. One is, you start with why why do we grow? You know, sometimes I'll say, you know, hey, we're 11,500. That's it. Like we've reached the number that we were Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: trying to get to. Like is there some number? And I think there's realization that we ultimately fulfill our core purpose when we grow. You know, how do you provide an environment people to flourish? When you grow, you create opportunity for whether it's the young professional to step into a new opportunity, the senior person to get to do something a little different, to serve a different client. If the why you grow fulfills your core purpose, it's the culture arguably strengthens. You're fulfilling those things. I acknowledge that's sort of a kind of a philosophy mindset, but I think over time many of us have an opportunity to think about our growth and why do we do that? Now, you want to right-size it. You got to be cautious about erosion of culture along the way. And so, how do you maintain it one person at a time? You know, you can't skip steps, you can't integrate in bulk. When I started and I walked in, another young professional who had been here a year helped me out with something. You know, that needs to be the same experience in our 175 offices today. So I think growth for us is fulfilling our core purpose. We're working on our business plan for 2027. We'll have growth goals, but we have to remind ourselves that growth is the outcome, not the goal in and of itself. So it's an interesting paradigm. There are points in time where maybe we need to slow down the pace of growth in a particular area, particular market to make sure it's happening in a healthy way. But you also sometimes want to take advantage of market opportunities. And so you might be willing to have a little outsized growth in one area to support it well. It's the topic de jour all the time, which I think is healthy. Gregory Hart: It seems like a big piece of that. So one of the most common bottlenecks, for a lot of firms, especially smaller to mid-sized firms, because they don't have the infrastructure is developing future leaders, right? Take us inside that a little bit. What does leadership development inside Kimley-Horn look like? What advice would you have maybe for firms that are struggling with that piece a little bit? Aaron Nathan: I'll let you be the judge on the value of the advice Gregory Hart: Ha ha. Aaron Nathan: and endeavor to to try to share with you how we think about this topic. We are proud of giving responsibilities early. We definitely see the most leadership opportunities with our clients in practice, in projects. So encouraging Gregory Hart: Uh-huh. Aaron Nathan: young professionals, "Hey, go go to that client meeting. Go to that planning and zoning commission meeting." Even if you're just there to take notes, we think that becomes the ground for development, not in conference rooms, internal meetings. I mean, you might learn a little bit about some operations or things like that by sitting in an internal meeting, but our internal meetings aren't very exciting. Serving clients is the training ground for the Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: vast, vast majority of our leaders. I can think of a couple things as I was growing up in the firm in the spirit of storytelling. I remember early in my career, my supervisor who's still with Kimley-Horn, kind of my Kimley-Horn parent, he would go to client meetings and he wasn't the best note taker. He'd come back and the guidance wasn't clear. And I said, "I'm going to the next meeting to take notes because your notes aren't good." And he's like, "Thank you. I acknowledge that!" He's fantastic with clients and just doesn't necessarily document everything well. So he invites me in and I'm out of my league. I'm Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I'm taking notes on things I don't really understand. And then I'll never forget a week or two later, client calls the office, can't get a hold of my supervisor. "Hey, Aaron, you were there. Can you help with this?" Greg, I don't even remember- I didn't understand what they were asking for. Gregory Hart: Ha ha ha. Aaron Nathan: And my supervisor's name was Brian. Brian says, "Sounds like you need to figure it out then. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: He called you." So that was Gregory Hart: That's awesome. Aaron Nathan: I was probably been in Kimley-Horn for nine months. I was Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: probably 24 years old. And so that leadership opportunity, sort of, "Well, I guess I need to figure out how to write a proposal. How do I do that?" So clearly the client side, that's where I feel like in hindsight, folks say, "Oh Aaron worked to figure that out." So I look at it, I saw it as job security. My supervisor told me to figure something out. And so, fast Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: forward that to today and think about leadership, I don't know who to attribute this statement to when we talk about who leads Kimley-Horn. You heard me say earlier we're organized around practice. I said I support practice builders. So who leads Kimley-Horn? We'll say in conversation, we are leader-led. "Well, Aaron, what does that mean? Of course leaders lead." We don't emphasize titles. And we'll still say we don't put titles on business cards, even though business cards are sort of going the wayside. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: We don't put titles on them. We haven't for decades. Most people's email signature doesn't have a title on it. We empower practice builders to serve their clients. So the vast, vast, vast majority of our leaders are practice builders who lead their teams and serve their clients. So the people we identify for titles with leader in the title who moved down on the org chart, they come out of, "Hey, you were pretty good over here and you've shown some acumen for these other things. Maybe we'll grab you." So the noteworthy thing about it is it becomes a bigger ground of people from which to pull from for leadership. Gregory Hart: Your story is awesome about kind of the note taker and suddenly you're getting thrust into a client role. Number one, I I think that's one of the best ways to not only develop somebody as a leader, but identify who doesn't like run and hide when given that opportunity. But number two, so many times when I talk to kind of next generation professionals, and they're just like, "When are they gonna get out of the way? When are they gonna give us an opportunity to take on more responsibility? You've just made it a real priority to, you know, with guardrails, right? But but give people an opportunity to to get involved little stretch goals, stretch projects to to to see what they can do. Aaron Nathan: Prior to my current role, I served in a role focused on our Texas region. And I'll I'll never forget we were in a fall planning meeting, 70 people in a room. We were talking about this need to develop more practice builders and more people willing to grab opportunities. And we were fortunate, sitting in Texas, I mean one of the strongest economies in the world, not just in America. And so more opportunities than we had people to lead. And I would guess at the time he probably had seven or eight years of experience. And in the meeting, so we invited a mixture of senior folks and emerging professionals. And he used this term hug and shove. And I don't know where he got it from. I'm not saying he made it up. He said, "Sometimes I need a shove. You need to push me out there and make me uncomfortable. But there's other times, can you come give me a hug? Because it's a little scary out there by myself." Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I've more now adopted this hug and shove mindset of Gregory Hart: I like that. Aaron Nathan: knowing when to push somebody and knowing when to say, "Hey, I'll help you," is an interesting balance because it doesn't come from years of experience. So you gotta know your folks, you gotta know your team, you gotta be a strong leader to know when to push so that's a delicate balance. And it's hard to do a math equation around the hug and shove, you know, metric. But I think we try absolutely to appropriately shove. You know, how do you do that in the right way and encourage people to to take ownership? And we're here to help. We want to help. So how do you find that balance? That's and the the people who want to grow, the people want to lead. There's a place for people who aren't ready for the shove. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: But you can grow at a faster rate. We'll put you in front of opportunities and then ultimately it's up to the clients to decide if they trust you or not. Gregory Hart: And that's so true, Aaron, as well, that, you know, that internal meetings are one thing and that's a great opportunity to, you know, learn some of the business KPIs and and sort of internal operations. But getting out in front of clients is where you really have an opportunity to grow and develop and push yourself. Aaron Nathan: I grew up in our Fort Worth office and I remember really wanting to be in this Monday morning PM project managers meeting. And then once I got invited, I thought to myself, "This is a waste of time. I need to be out with my team Gregory Hart: Ha ha. Aaron Nathan: and clients. Can I skip the meeting? I mean, these are important Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: metrics, but this isn't where the magic happens." Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: Office leader at that time was sort of like, "Aaron, you're missing a lot of these meetings." You know, I said, "Yeah, I know. Aren't you proud of me?" So finding Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: that balance is important too. Gregory Hart: You're the COO, eleven thousand person firm. What's an operational metric you look at every week? Aaron Nathan: Our president has shared with me is he's used this analogy of what instrument in the orchestra do you listen to? Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: You know, my son's in band in high school, and so my wife's like, "Oh you can hear him playing!" I don't know, I'm hearing the blend of things. I can't pick out his instrument. So I think if you overfocus on a singular metric, you're kind of indicating to your teams that the other ones aren't as critical. So I really find myself exploring different metrics from time to time, they interrelate with each other. Clearly there's profitability things and backlog and workload, retention. I mean, there's all sorts of stuff that you can dive into. I have a lot of dashboards. But you gotta understand the story behind the metric, which requires you to listen to your practice builders. We have tremendous tools, but I feel like I work to connect with what we're hearing from the quote front lines, because that's where the magic is. I mean, I I watch the news, but I think my intel from practice builders, that's the real story about what's happening. To be clear, we have so many tools and dashboards, and then we have summary charts for those dashboards. So I I think Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: from the standpoint of confidence about our business and our operations and how we run, I feel you know, we check, check, check. You know, that stuff we absolutely do. But I think what I share with people is that I absolutely look at those things, but that's a glance. That's a awareness. And it's really easy to look backwards on performance. It's really hard to see the future. And so that's what you're really trying to study is what dials do we need to turn differently now? One of my partners always kind of talks with these modulators and dials, and do you handle those in a way that makes sense for what you're hearing? And you got to listen and practice to do that. Gregory Hart: It's hard to see it in the moment, but it seems like twenty-five years from now we're probably gonna look back at this time and see, "That was a bit of an inflection point that you know, there's AI and other stuff like that." Generational change is certainly not just in architecture engineering firms, but in clients and everywhere else. More projects are happening faster, things are moving at a different pace, maybe, than they had 15, 20 years ago. Take me through your take on that a little bit. So let's go outside Kimley-Horn, just on kind of the client expectation piece. What's changing? What's evolving? What are you seeing compared to like 10 years ago? How is the world you're operating in changing? Aaron Nathan: If I could tell the future, I you know, I would I'm not into investing in stock market stuff. I feel like if I knew that I could be, you know, I could foresee things. One of the things and and a lot of partners in Kimley-Horn know I'm super passionate about this. We've run a quality call program in Kimley-Horn for going back to the nineties. I mean, it's 30 years of asking clients a set of questions. "How are we doing? How can we serve you better? What should we be aware of?" And we ask thousands of clients each year what's going on. Now we have the power of some some data analysis tools where it used to be handwritten notes on each call, and now obviously you can sort of summarize these in a way and pull themes, pull trends. Clearly, regardless of market sector, regardless of client type, availability and responsiveness is so critical. I think it's always been a variable, but now when are you really off the grid? And so that expectation of availability and responsiveness, clients want to know the status of their project, the data, the files, the report, the map, the chart, at their fingertips. Because they're relying on us to make decisions, to inform their leadership about the directional project. Many of our clients, they might have a thousand projects going on at any one time. So how do they know which ones to look at? So they're relying on us, whether it's a publicly traded mega client or a small city. They're trusting us with those things. It puts pressure on our teams to be available at all times, which is impossible. Right? So if you're serving multiple clients, you can't be available to every client every moment all the time. And that's just not healthy. So it's impossible for one person to be a backstep for a project. So going back to your question about okay, clients' expectations are evolving. It relates back to some of the leadership development that we have. I think it used to be a little more client needed the principal in charge. I need my one point of contact. Our clients, I think, are best served when they see the depth of our team and they know who to go to for that availability and responsiveness. Certainly if they desire to have one point of contact, we can navigate, but you realize when you call that one person, they're just going to reach out to the other. You know, how how can you know everything about an entire program? We're gonna continue to see that availability and responsiveness translate into things even more. "I wanna see live action where this project is at. I need to know as you're designing it, what's happening with my cost, you know, information. What's my cost estimate now? Live action in CAD! I want to know like are Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: you just drew a line and so what does that do?" So I think this expectation of awareness of what you're doing because the bar for them is changing as well of availability and responsiveness and the tools are there to do it now. Gregory Hart: We often call those zipper relationships where yeah, at each level in the organization on the Kimley-Horn side and on the client side, it's much more integrated. And that's better for everybody too. Aaron Nathan: The people side of this, I think, is so powerful too. It's nice to be able to either check out for the day or go on vacation and know that the organization can still function. There was a Mr. Kimley and Mr. Horn. They were around. They were the founders of company. They're not around anymore. My name is not on the door, and I'm okay with that. You know, because sometimes I I trust my partners to handle things. Now, if you need to get a hold of me, you can. But there's also this empowerment around like trust you to run things. How can we Kimley-Horn be available and respond to our clients all the time? That's what I think we're gonna continue to see pressure. And so as an organization, I think to create an environment where we can create that for our clients, they trust us. Whether it's because things are going fast or because something's going wrong, we're here. Let us know what you need. Gregory Hart: If you were talking to a bunch of Aarons from 25 years ago, you know, and and talking to a bunch of people who may have potential aspirations or don't even know yet where their career might take them. What's some advice you might have to somebody who's just sort of, you know, been in it for a few years, just sort of starting out in the industry and wants to kind of figure out what they can do to be more valuable or to develop in the organization? Aaron Nathan: This might be the sort of question, you know, when we do training, we have open forum type settings. It's a common question of what advice do you have for someone in my role or someone in my practice or someone in this world. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: And I actually find myself oftentimes we're on a panel and I'm taking in the answers from others on the panel just a bunch of, "Oh that's good advice. That's good advice! That's good advice." There's so much out there now to inform a young professional on what works for them, whether it's related to professional development or work life balance or or whatever the the technical development, whatever the topic du jour is. When you're growing up, everything's very milestone driven in points in time. And every six months there's a thing. And then you enter the workforce and maybe licensure at four years becomes a thing. So there's something out there, but things get really hazy. I think finding things that you truly enjoy, As I say this, I think about Kimley-Horn of, "Hey, what do you want to work on? What kind of projects do you like working on?" So clearly you're gonna spend a lot of time at work. So you gotta kind of enjoy what you do. What are you passionate about? When you go home, what are you actually willing to read a little about that you might or maybe I would have said Discovery Channel or History Channel in the past, now it might be what YouTube video might you watch Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: that's a little kind of what might you nerd out on? Like embrace that thing and the understanding. I think understanding our clients' businesses is tremendously powerful. So seeking to understand what is my client's motivation? So package these things together. You're doing something you like to do. This is an interesting thing. You're probably in the AEC world because you like built environment. Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Aaron Nathan: You care about the community, whether it's water or transportation or development, you care about these things. And then you find something that, "Hey, that client needs to get that thing done!" There's this alignment of what are you passionate about? What does your client appreciate you doing that you're passionate about? And then go find a firm that'll reward you and encourage you to go do those things. And then the time goes by pretty fast along the way. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I can think of a couple different stories along the way of like points in time where I don't think I realized it. It was talking to friends from college about what they were doing. They had a job. They were telling me how many hours a week they're working. I was describing, and I think we worked the same number of hours. So full disclosure, it wasn't that I worked more. I just felt differently about it. I felt like I was getting opportunity. I was growing. I was getting to do, you know, quote, fun stuff. Now, I think back on some of the stuff that I thought was fun as a young version of me. I would go to council meetings and just sit in the room and meet people. Now I think of that as just how what was wrong with me? Why did I -but Gregory Hart: Ha ha. Aaron Nathan: after you've been at a couple hundred, you sort of like, okay, I don't need to go to another public meeting. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: But I think my advice is go find something you enjoy. Go work for a firm that's going to reward you for that. Go find people that are gonna hug you and shove you. And you'll find your path. And it might require you to change along the way. I feel fortunate that I ended up at Kimley-Horn at the beginning. I'd like to think I would have found Kimley-Horn eventually because there was alignment in in things I enjoy, but yeah. And maybe the last piece of advice that I give somebody, and I say this often, I think it's on my KHNet profile or something like that too. Do the right things today and good things will happen tomorrow. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: Like you can only control what you can control. And so if you become kind of like, "Hey, Aaron will help you." You develop a reputation. And that doesn't mean you're gonna do everything perfectly, but you know, I think I've always you care, you try, wanna learn, and man, it's amazing how the world rewards you for that. Gregory Hart: Always be helping, right? That's a that's a big part of it. Look over and and the good thing is, especially in a firm like Kimley-Horn, but there's lots of others too, that even in this industry, you it doesn't have to be a technical track. You know, there's so many opportunities to find your passion and then pursue that. I like your point about yeah, like what stuff would you want to like watch YouTube videos about after work? Like that that's kind of a good indication of kind of where your passions lie. Aaron Nathan: Yeah. Growing up, I I think I told my high school guidance counselor I wanted to be an architect. And she said, "Aaron, you you're really bad at art. Your math scores are good. You know what this civil engineering thing is? You should check that out." I don't even remember who it was. I feel like I owe this lady so much in my life. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: She's the one who told me about civil engineering. But yeah, she there's also and also you tend to be good at something too. So Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: "Hey, you're not good at drawing, but you get a ruler out and you might be a little better." Gregory Hart: Well, I think there's an important point there too in like not necessarily getting so hung up on this long-term vision, but more kind of looking at the opportunities that are in front of you and finding your passions there. I don't want to put words in your mouth, but I bet twenty five years ago or thirty years ago or forty years ago, you weren't like, "I'm gonna be the COO of a ten thousand person engineering firm someday. That's my destiny." Right. You probably never once crossed your mind. Aaron Nathan: And I and full disclosure I share with people, I I don't really like the title (COO) Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: because it it implies executive authority that I I guess I have, but I don't feel like in our organization I really utilize. Our chairman now when when we were talking about this, he said, "Aaron, you're really kind of like a janitor." I mean, it's it's a custodial capacity. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I feel blessed that that folks have asked me to do this, but I never aspired to this. So now I I live vicariously through, you know, a couple thousand practice builders. So when I see a practice builder, "Tell me what you're working on. Hey, What's cooking with your client's business?" Because that's the magic. You know, Gregory Hart: Yep. Yep. Aaron Nathan: I'm down in the basement. You don't really it you know, Everything's working fine. So tell me what your client needs. That's what Gregory Hart: Yeah. Aaron Nathan: I want to know. Gregory Hart: Many years ago, I was talking to a CEO of a firm that had gone public, they were publicly traded at the time. And he had said, "We never want to be a leadership team that's a bunch of highly paid administrators. We want to have a culture that's very much focused on kind of hands on, client focused, and creating a lot of opportunities for everybody." So yeah, it seems like that at Kimley-Horn as well. That that title, right, especially in other industries, would imply it would seem like more mahogany on your walls or like a leather and all that kind of stuff, Aaron Nathan: That is not us. Gregory Hart: Aaron Nathan, COO, even though he doesn't like the title, of Kimley-Horn, thanks so much for joining me. Lotta lot of good stuff in there, really appreciate it. Yep Aaron Nathan: Thanks, Greg. Thanks for letting me take some of your time. Gregory Hart: We're doing a deep dive on some of the survey data and other data with the one and only Dave Burstein at PSMJ. For those of you who don't know Dave, I'll introduce him in a little bit. But Dave is bringing a whole bunch of data to the show. We're gonna have metrics plural of the month. Alright I'm thrilled to have with me today David Burstein of PSMJ Resources, senior consultant, Brainiac, knowledge of all things AEC business, probably a whole bunch of other stuff too. A lot of you may know Dave from your interactions in strategic planning or hearing him speak at our events over the years or or other places outside of PSMJ. In fact, what we're going to talk about today, that is some of the financial, operational, and broader trends impacting the industry. is what Dave will be cover covering at our AEC THRIVE conference in October, this and I think a whole lot more. So if you like what you hear in our conversation today, be sure to to catch up with us in October at AEC THRIVE. We'll put a link to it in the show notes. You can get more information on that. The other thing I just wanted to mention in our discussion with Dave, because we're going to be talking a bit about data and some of the trends that we're seeing both with PSMJ data and broader economic data. We are sharing slides. So we'll try to make sure in our conversation, if you're not looking at the slides, no problem. You'll still get a lot of value out of our conversation. But we'll include a link to the sh in the show notes where you can download the PDF of the slides. So with that, Dave, thanks for joining me here. Dave Burstein: My pleasure. Glad to do it, Greg. Gregory Hart: I've got a little bit of stage fright here. Your inaugural presentation, your inaugural visit to the to the AEC GrowthCast This is going to be exciting. Dave Burstein: Yep, first time. Gregory Hart: It's first time, first time call a longtime listener. So earlier this year we published our annual AE Financial Performance Benchmark Survey Report, which of course includes a whole lot of data on financial and operational performance. You've had a chance to dig into that. We've talked about it kind of superficially here, just at a real high level. several metrics setting records, but you've had a chance to really dig into it. And I'm gonna hand it over to you to kind of take us through some of the observations that you're seeing, what you like, what you don't like, and what's changing. So with that, why don't you want to just kind of jump into it here, Dave! Dave Burstein: Like you said, I I've gone through the 2026 survey data, both the compensation as well as the financial performance. I've been looking at these things for many, many years, so a lot of this is just putting in perspective going back quite a few years. So the first thing is revenue. And if you go back to 1995, which is what this graph shows, you can see that there's been ups and downs pretty much along with the general economy. We were in kind of a downward cycle in terms of a revenue change, particularly after the Great Recession of 2008 and 2009. You can see that firms went negative in 2011, started back positive in 2012, and it's been pretty positive since then. Revenue growth has generally been in the five to ten percent range, maybe even closer to ten than to five. So it's been pretty solid. If you look at the revenue growth by engineering versus architecture, you get a little bit of a different picture. Engineering firms have grown really steadily. You can see revenue has gone from around 65, 64, 65,000 in 2020. In the last couple of years, last five years to 2026, it's gone from 64,000 all the way up to about 97,000. So that's a big increase in just a few years. Architecture, on the other hand, has really seen a very different picture. There was good revenue growth from 2020 till about 2024, maybe 2025, and then it kind of leveled off. And actually, the last quarter or so it's it's been going down. And so architecture firms, you can see, have been struggling a lot more than engineering firms. When you look at backlog, you can see that there's a very big difference in the backlog depending on which sector firms specialize in. Most of the sectors have been pretty solid. Transportation, water/wastewater, energy utilities, commercial, education, housing, have all been positive to varying degrees, some more than others. The biggest positives have been commercial and housing, interestingly enough, in terms of change from last year. The ones that have been a little bit negative, a bit surprisingly actually, have been industrial and healthcare. The overall median is a little bit over three percent in terms of backlog growth, but you can see that it definitely varies sector to sector, all the way from minus five percent up to plus eight percent. Gregory Hart: You know, if you look at that kind of revenue of architecture versus engineering, how architecture is kind of in a pretty steep, steep descent. But it's kind of, I mean, you know, broad brush, you kind of figure okay, architecture is a bit more vertical projects, engineering a bit more flat infrastructure. You look at the backlog change, and it's on the one hand, it's interesting, commercial developers and housing are the two biggest increases. So seven and eight percent respectively net revenue backlog change year over year. My guess would be, it's a big positive number, but that's from a very low you know, like a number, right? Or something. It just seems like maybe those markets have found the bottom, I guess, is the story there. Dave Burstein: Yeah, I think there's another factor in here too. So take commercial sector, for example. A lot of those clients really don't even hire architects. You Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Dave Burstein: know, they just, you know, put up plain vanilla buildings with very little or even no architecture involvement at all. And so a lot of those really go into the engineering side, not so much into the architecture side. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Yeah, good point. Dave Burstein: Healthcare, on the other hand, is very heavily architecture focused and and it's negative. If we look at employment and separate it by engineering versus architecture, the engineering employment has actually gone up pretty dramatically. You can see that during COVID it took a little bit of a dip, but then it recovered pretty quickly and it's been going up pretty steadily since then. Architecture took a much bigger dip during COVID. It recovered pretty well until about the middle of 2023, and then it's actually been on a gradual decline in employment since mid-2023, continuing to now. Again a big difference between engineering and architecture firms. If we look at what kinds of salary increases they saw in 2025. Just about across the board, it was 4%. The one exception is architecture interior firms, which were a little bit lower, 3%. Again, that points out some of the differences between the strengths of engineering firms versus some of the weaknesses in architecture firms. When we asked people their projected salaries, we saw a little bit more modest projections than we saw actual increases last year. We saw pretty much split between three percent, which is mostly on the architecture side, and four percent, which is more on the engineering side. When we look at actual changes in hourly wages, and this isn't exactly the same as wage increases because there's also a a factor of any changes in average experience level, but but they're pretty close. Engineering firms increase by almost five percent, whereas architecture firms increase by a little bit more than three percent. And in the past we've seen more of an of a change due to the median age of employees. As the baby boomers have been retiring, we've been seeing the median age going down because the baby boomers being replaced by college graduates. We've kind of seen an end to that. In fact, since twenty twenty one, the median age of A and E employees has actually remained stable. So I think that demographic change has pretty much come to an end. Going back to 2001, the median turnover in the industry was around eighteen percent. In fact, if you go back farther than that, it was actually around twenty percent. And now moving forward, it's closer to thirteen percent. So this is really contrary to what a lot of people have been saying, and that you know the younger generation changes jobs more frequently. That may be true in the general economy, it's not true in this industry. We're seeing actually almost historic lows. We got down to about 11.5% median, and now we're at 13, so it's not quite historic lows, but pretty close. When we look at the source of that turnover, in most recent survey, which is for 2025, the vast majority of it was voluntary turnover: 9.6% versus 2.5% involuntary. So looking at the balance sheet, one of the big issues is how fast we get the bills out. And some good news here. Back in 2000, it took about 27 days on average to get the invoices out. Fast forward to 2025, and it's down to 15 days. That's a pretty big decrease, and it indicates that that firms are doing better, not just at getting the bills out more quickly, but other things that reduce WIP. So for example, getting retainers up front firms are doing better in that. Doing more work lump sum and billing ahead of expenses, firms are doing better at that. All those things drive down WIP days. When we look at AR days, we see a pretty similar pattern. Actually from 2000 to about 2023, we really saw very little change. You know, it kind of went up and it went down. But since 2023, we've seen some pretty dramatic reductions in AR days. So firms are are not only billing quicker, they're collecting their accounts quicker. Gregory Hart: The only rational explanation is they're just implementing some best practices, right? I mean to track WIP first of all, but to shrink it. Do you see anything else besides they're just getting more diligent and more focused on it? Dave Burstein: Yeah, I think that's right. And and you know, if you were to show these graphs to a banker and say, you know, "What do you think about this firm?" They would be horrified. You know, they'd say, You know, Gregory Hart: Mm-hmm. Dave Burstein: "Oh my God, why is it taking so so long to get bills out? Why is it taking you so long to get paid?" You know, compared to just about any other industry, our industry is pretty bad at both billing and collecting accounts. Maybe we're moving more toward what what the norm is and and really should be. And some of this may be driven by private equity. A lot of firms in the last few years have gotten an infusion of private equity money and that may be driving some of this improvement as well. If we look up a balance sheet, there's an interesting thing that happened between 1995 and and about 2011-2012, we saw very little change in the equity per total staff. And then all of a sudden, in starting in around 2012-2013, we saw it really increase dramatically from around $20,000 per employee to about sixty thousand dollars per employee. That's triple since 2012. And I think the reason for that is that the Great Recession of 08 and 09 really created a lot of problems with firms that had very skinny balance sheets, and they had to go back to their partners and do a capital call and say, "Hey guys, remember those bonuses we gave out? Well, we need that money back." Well, that's not a very pleasant conversation. So I think a lot of firms swore that they didn't want to have that conversation again. And so they've been increasing the strength of their balance sheet ever since then. Gregory Hart: Do you think that just keeps going up, Dave, from here? Dave Burstein: It's kind of l it kind of leveled off from 2021 to 2025. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Dave Burstein: We saw a little bit of an increase, not really that much though. I I think the big the big change was from 2012 to 2021. And then once people got a much more conservative balance sheet, I think people are starting to to feel like, "Okay, we're good shape now. We don't need to keep increasing our balance sheet." Gregory Hart: Yeah, makes sense. Dave Burstein: So let's look at profitability. One of the the ways you can calculate profitability is pretty straightforward. You look at what's your direct labor multiplier minus what's your break-even multiplier, which is one plus your operating overhead rate, and not your far overhead rate, and then divide that by the direct labor multiplier. Pretty standard way of measuring profitability. Just as an example, let's say your actual direct labor multiplier is 3.5, your overhead rate's 170%. So you do the calculation and you get a 23% profitability. So let's just look at some of the components of that and see what's happened. The old business model, which has been around forever, is sell more work, hire more people, bill more hours. And that's how you increase profits. The metrics have traditionally been headcount and utilization. A lot of focus on that. And some firms are still operating under the old business model. But we're finding that it's not working anymore. And here's why. Back in the day, there were places that were called drafting rooms. And there were people in those places that were called draftsmen. They called draftsmen because there was no women there. They were all men. And they charged 40 or more hours every week, all to projects, virtually none to overhead. And there was a lot of hours that went into direct labor. Fast forward and they've been replaced by engineers and architects who basically do their own CAD work, so they don't need all those drafters. And they've also been replaced by IT departments that didn't even exist back in the old days, but now it's not only an IT person, in most firms it's an IT department, and they charge almost all their time to overhead. So you have a decrease in direct labor and an increase in indirect labor. And that basically has been a downward trend on labor utilization. So for firms that are focusing on labor utilization, it's gotten harder and harder to get utilization, largely because of the effects of technology: CAD. And if you look at the cost of technology, they've increased dramatically. Back in 2004, the median firm spent 3.3% of direct labor on technology costs, not including labor, that's just non-labor costs. Well, fast forward to 2025, and it's two and a half times that. It's gone from 3.3% to 10.8%. So firms as a percent of direct labor are spending way more money on technology. And in fact the trends seem to be accelerating as new technologies are coming in. You know, we're we're seeing a lot more interest in drones and in reducing survey crews by using technology there, by AI, just all kinds of things. So I expect this trend to continue. So that's a whole nother factor that's driving up indirect costs. And so when you combine those factors, what you're seeing is a long term increase in overhead rate. And so that means that the break even multiplier has been going up. So, what we're finding is the firms that are still sticking by the old model just aren't doing very well anymore. The firms that are doing well have adopted a new model. And the new model is starts out with finding out what it is your clients really want. Yeah, they're gonna hire you to do a building or to design a treatment plant or whatever, but what is it they really want? What are their critical success factors? Then once you figure that out, what can you do to add more value? What is it really that's going to affect their lives? And once you figured that out, now you can leverage your hours and charge a higher multiplier. And so the metrics have changed from headcount utilization to the direct labor multiplier and profit per employee. Firms moving from cost-based pricing to value-based pricing. And what that's done is the target multiplier, which for years between in the 1990s and early 2000s, was kind of stuck at a 3.0 median. Between 2005 and about 2018, it jumped up to about a 3.1 median. And then from 2019 to 2024, we saw it jump up again from 3.1 to 3.2. In the most recent survey, we're seeing it closer to 3.3. So you can see that as the firms have adopted this new model, they really are increasing their target multiplier. The other thing that affects multiplier, looking back in the day, is just project management. And back in the old days, job cost accounting systems were either non-existent, or if they were existent, they were very primitive. PM training was almost always on the job. In fact, I remember back when Frank Stasiowski and I first started doing (AEC) Project Management Bootcamp It was 1980. We were the only people doing PM training in this industry at all. So the total amount of formal training was like 75 people! And then the other thing is the way people track projects was "Well, we did the project, and if there was money left over, it was great." And that was it. We targeted a 3.0 multiplier. We never got there. You know, we always achieved a multiplier of maybe 2.6 or 2.7 or 2.8, but we never got up to three. That we call net revenue deficit. Well, today it's a whole lot different. We have way better job cost accounting systems. Everybody complains about their job cost accounting system, but trust me, it's way better than they used to be. People are investing way more in project management training. PSMJ trains thousands of project managers every year, and there's other people that do it as well. And they're implementing a lot better project management practices. As a result of that, regardless of which sector you're in, just about, we're seeing not just the disappearance of net revenue deficits, we're now seeing the appearance of net revenue surpluses. And so even though people have raised their target multiplier, their achieved multipliers actually exceeded their targets, whereas it used to just fall short. Not only are people charging more, they're actually taking more of that to the bottom line. And so when you look at the achieved direct labor multiplier, it's gone from about two point eight in the 1990s up to over three point four today. Huge increase. That means that we're leveraging our staff a whole lot better. We're getting more revenue per staff. In fact, if you go back to 2011, there's been about a sixty two percent increase in net revenue per total staff. The d increase in profit per staff has been a six hundred percent increase in that same period of time, which is amazing. If you look at profitability, back in 1986, it was a little over ten percent. Today, it's over twenty percent. So we basically doubled our profitability as a percent of net revenue. We also are seeing that some firms have are doing better than others. Back in 2000, the bottom quartile was getting 8% profitability as a percent of net revenue. Well, it increased some to 2025. In 25 years, it went from 8% to 11%. But if you look at the upper quartile, they went all the way up to 29%. And the difference between the lower quartile and the upper quartile has really increased in the last 25 years. Looking forward, as technology becomes more and more important, people who charge by the hour are gonna be left behind because technology is reducing the number of hours that it takes to do a project. And if you just charge by the hour, all it's gonna do is reduce your fee. And so we really need to move completely into a lump sum environment. The good news is that trend has already begun. We've gone from about forty percent of revenue being lump sum back in the early 1990s to closer to sixty percent today, but it's gonna have to be a hundred percent if we're really gonna succeed as an industry. Gregory Hart: Awesome. Dave Burstein: That's kinda how I see things. Gregory Hart: There's so much kind of converging at once. I should also preface all the data we're talking about is kind of median overall for the industry, right? I used to have a statistics professor who said if I had one foot in a bucket of ice and the other foot on fire, on average I'm pretty comfortable. And that's kind of there's extremes on either end here, but overall, we would you say this feels a little different this time with these records that are getting set, firms that are crushing it, tons of cash on the balance sheet, adapting to AI and tech, value based pricing, so on and so forth. What's your take compared to- Dave Burstein: Well again Again to your point, you know, i if you look beyond the medians and you look at the differences between the lower quartile firms and the upper quartile firms, you're seeing some big differences. And so I I don't think everybody is moving in lockstep here. There's a lot of difference in how well people are adapting to the new world that we're living in today. Those who are adapting well are doing well, those who are not adapting well are doing less well. Gregory Hart: It does seem like things are changing a bit. So I would ask you this, Dave. Because there are firms sitting on a bunch of cash that could probably be putting that cash to work, And then there are other firms. You know, we had one recently, twelve person architecture firm called us that they're now down to three people and really, really struggling. What's your advice for both of those scenarios? Crushing it off the charts and struggling and wondering if they can meet payroll? Dave Burstein: Clearly there is a difference in the market between architecture and engineering firms. Your firm that had to downsize their architecture practice. I I mean they're not alone. The whole architecture industry has been downsizing a little bit. I really think that's gonna change. One of the things that I'll really focus on in my presentation at THRIVE is is you know what do the markets look like. A lot of the the markets that that architects have traditionally relied on, things like office buildings, retail, those seem to be bottoming out. And I think architecture firms are going to start to to do better in the coming years. Similarly, a lot of firms that have been doing very well on transportation engineering projects. They may slow down a little bit as the IIJA money starts to be spent. There may be some more transportation bills, but they probably aren't going to be as big. So I think we're gonna start to see more of a normalization between architecture firms and engineering firms in terms of the overall market impact. But regardless of the market, firms that are managing themselves well and and really positioning themselves well, whether architecture or engineering, continue to thrive. We we continue to see architecture firms in our Circle of Excellence, for example. Gregory Hart: Yeah. Dave Burstein: A lot of it has to do with just how well you run your firm. Gregory Hart: Yeah, you bet. Dave, thanks so much. So dburstein@psmj.com if you want to reach out to Dave, we'll include that in the show notes as well. Thanks so much, Dave. Dave Burstein: Thank very much, Greg. And if anybody has any individual questions for me, shoot me an email, I'll be glad to have a discussion with you. Gregory Hart: You bet. So there you go, not just one metric of the month, but many, many, many metrics of the month. Dave always brings the data. And if you want more of it, I hope to see you at AEC THRIVE in October, which will be here before you know it. Okay, moving on to the five-minute fix. This is a segment where we cover one of your real actual questions and take five minutes to share some tips, insight, and perspective on said question. If you have a question you want us to cover in the five-minute fix, Email us at AECgrowthcast at psmj.com. This is an MA question, merger and acquisition question, which we get a lot of these lately. And we're going to jump right into one right here. "We have made a few small acquisitions over the years that were really just group hires and are now looking to make our first real one, a 50-person MEP engineering firm. We seem pretty far apart on valuation, about 40%. Aren't sure how to proceed. We really do like the company. What should we do?" So, first I would say yes, a 40% valuation gap is quite large, not one that you're simply gonna split the difference. For the sake of this discussion here, let's just say buyer is somewhere around 10 million, seller something like 14 million, so you get a four million dollar valuation gap. What do you do? Number one, make sure that you as a buyer are assigning a reasonable valuation here, right? If you're used to a couple group hires, you might be used to paying three or four times EBITDA. When you're getting into a firm of this size, it could be five, six, seven, maybe eight times EBITDA. Right out of the gate, you know, firm value, if nothing else, scales with size, right? So you want to make sure you're attaching a reasonable multiple to the EBITDA. You also want to make sure you're using a reasonable level of earnings, the earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. Are you using this year's, last year's, next year's, a three-year average? How are you adjusting for owner compensation? What is your normalized EBITDA? And what does the seller see as a normalized EBITDA? Let's make sure first, are we off on kind of what a representative level of earnings is, or are we off on the multiple that we're attaching to that level of earnings? Once you know that, you can start to dig into okay, what are the assumptions that we're applying differently. Is it a different assumptions on growth potential, synergy, backlog quality? Isolate and get into a much more specific discussion about where the difference is, not just, "Oh well, we're off, what do we do? Let's just kind of see which one caves first." So you can really get pretty scientific on that. Number two, you can put some of that at risk. Okay. Well, you can put the whole four million at risk, but I wouldn't do the whole four million at risk purely as an earnout. Earnouts are a effectively pay for performance provisions that say, "Look, we are at X, you are at Y. If you hit certain targets, we'll pay out the delta between X and Y. So over the course of two or three years. If we hit certain revenue targets or profitability," but I really don't like earnouts based on profitability because they're kind of counterintuitive to integration in the firm. But "if we hit some growth or expansion or whatever target is, we'll pay out that remaining. If we don't hit it, we don't pay it out." Again, those are good to bridge a smaller gap. So maybe you're going to cover 2 million, let's say, of the difference. Now you're at 12 million, okay? And now you've closed a little bit. Now how do we close the other two million? Well, if it's a seller that's sticking around for a little bit, there's a way you could use effectively buy or stock, right, as currency in the transaction. That not only bridges that gap because buyer stock and your company has real value, it also gives them a second bite of the apple. It's an earnout without the downside of an earnout, right? It motivates them to continue to contribute to the organization collectively, but it does so in a way that I think is more synergistic. Now, you have to be careful though, because if you value your own stock internally at say book value, you're gonna have to kind of overcompensate. You're gonna have to give away a lot more stock than you otherwise would if you were valuing your company stock, your buyer stock at market value. So if you're valuing it at market value, you could also bridge the gap a little bit with buyer stock. That should close most of that gap, depending you know on several different variables. There's other little things you can do too, right? We could look at more cash versus seller financing, right? A big portion of the 10 million, I would assume, is promissory notes from the seller. All things being equal, a seller who's getting a deal that's more cash, fewer notes or smaller notes is gonna assign a higher value to that, right? Time value of money. And then there's some other little things you can do on working capital requirements and such to try to close that gap. But by and large, I think the key to remember here is when you're looking at a valuation gap, get curious, don't get furious, dig in why is there a gap? And then specifically what are some tools we can do to bridge that gap? There's almost always going to be a gap, right? It's hardly ever you're gonna have a transaction with buyer and seller immediately right on the same page. But once you know why, then you can look at some of these tools, whether it's buyer stock, earnouts, other creative little mini solutions, if you will, to tighten that up. With that, that's our five minute fix. And with that, that is the end of our AEC GrowthCast episode. We covered hugs and shoves and so much more. If you like what you heard, go out and implement some of these ideas in your firm. But first be sure to like and subscribe to AEC GrowthCast wherever you get your podcasts. If you have questions, ideas, comments, be sure to share those with us at aecgrowthcast@psmj.com. That's it. Thanks so much for joining us. We'll see you next time.