Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / A Rabbi, a Minister, and a Mediator Walk Into a Room: Resolving Conflict Through a Clergy Lens
Transcript
- 0:03My name is Jeff Kravitz. I am co -chair along
- 0:07with my friend Robert Cohen of the ADR section
- 0:12of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today
- 0:17we have the honor of two guests who bring unique
- 0:22perspective to solving conflict. They are my
- 0:28longtime Rabbi Michael Gottlieb. a thought leader
- 0:31in the community who's had publications many
- 0:35places, including the Wall Street Journal, and
- 0:38Dr. Tim Lane, who has been both a pastor and
- 0:44a counselor. He now has a counseling service
- 0:47in the greater Atlanta area. So good to see both
- 0:53of you and a pleasure for us to be getting together.
- 0:58And I thought I would start with the thought
- 1:03that as a pastor or as a rabbi, you wear many
- 1:09hats. And I would think that one of them over
- 1:13the course of the years has been counseling.
- 1:17And I would turn to the two of you and ask, is
- 1:21that something that you get training on when
- 1:24you go to pastoral school? or whether you go
- 1:28to rabbinical school. And I thought we'd start
- 1:32with Rabbi Michael. Thank you, Jeff. And it's
- 1:36a delight to sit with this August panel. And
- 1:41I hope our conversations continue beyond the
- 1:44format of this Zoom call. So the short answer
- 1:48is yes. And when I was in school, rabbinical
- 1:55school, Was a six -year graduate program the
- 1:59last couple years Well, they still were more
- 2:02than text and history and Bible and philology
- 2:07and philosophy and so on had at least a representative
- 2:13amount of classes in practical rabbinics and
- 2:17most specifically the last year We students studied
- 2:24with psychiatrists in the New York area and our
- 2:29training though untested as we were given the
- 2:34duration of our studies. We're focused on where
- 2:38we professionally should draw boundaries beyond
- 2:43which someone who focuses in counseling ought
- 2:48to resume the interaction. So let me just leave
- 2:52it at that. Yes. And on site within the congregation,
- 3:00in the field, if you will, certainly either enhanced
- 3:04or challenged some of the foundational points
- 3:08that were shared with me and taught to me while
- 3:12I was a student. Interesting. Dr. Lane. master
- 3:21divinity programs in seminary where I was trained
- 3:26they usually are about three years in training
- 3:30and some of us do it in four we take the the
- 3:34fast track and do it in four that was me but
- 3:37they're so filled with Bible, theology, church
- 3:40history, that oftentimes the more interpersonal
- 3:44aspects of ministry, unfortunately, are not dealt
- 3:47with, I think, in ways that they should. It's
- 3:51one of the reasons why after my MDiv, I ended
- 3:54up doing a DEMEN about 10 years later that focused
- 3:59on interpersonal ministry, counseling, things
- 4:01of that nature. But that is... Just the the warp
- 4:07and woof of pastoral ministry you're dealing
- 4:09with people and you're dealing with people's
- 4:12problems They're just like you and you're just
- 4:14like them I always say whenever you get more
- 4:17than two people together things get interesting
- 4:20So and what Dr. Lay what kinds of disputes would
- 4:27come your way over the course of years? Yeah,
- 4:30most of my disputes would be marital Husband
- 4:34and wife obviously not getting along. There'd
- 4:37be issues of infidelity, but just a lack of what
- 4:41they would describe as compatibility. They're
- 4:44arguing a lot, fighting a lot. They want help.
- 4:48That would be probably 80 to 85 % of the types
- 4:51of disputes that I would get involved with as
- 4:54a pastor. And Rabbi Gottlieb, how about you?
- 4:58What's the panoply? of matters that would come
- 5:02your way over the course of years. I would agree
- 5:05with Dr. Lane, but familial relationships between
- 5:11siblings, not uncommon between extended family,
- 5:16in some cases financial spats. But if there's
- 5:22any conflict resolution, more often than not,
- 5:28it's more on an individual basis, dealing with
- 5:31existential angst, meaning in life, existence.
- 5:38I'm throwing around terminologies not to duck
- 5:41under them, but epistemological issues. I find
- 5:47that more than anything has been my experience,
- 5:52but in terms of seeking some resolution, given
- 5:58the nature of a dispute, largely familial, in
- 6:02some cases friendship, in some cases business
- 6:05relationships. And not uncommonly, someone would
- 6:10come to a clergy member, a rabbi, speaking obviously
- 6:15in first person, for moral validation as opposed
- 6:19to necessarily resolution. Well, and Rabbi Gottlieb,
- 6:24you shared with me years ago that oftentimes
- 6:30you deal with anger. And the example that you
- 6:33gave to me was that you have presided over burials
- 6:36where somebody walks in and starts literally
- 6:39shouting it at the corpse. I want to talk with
- 6:45each of you because it's a major part of what
- 6:47Bob and I do. But starting with Michael. What
- 6:51tools do you use to deal with people's anger?
- 6:55Well, in a cemetery, situational sensitivity,
- 6:59of course, is paramount. And what can be done
- 7:03there or what ought to be done there would be
- 7:07different in the context and the privacy of an
- 7:10office. So I just make that comment, which I
- 7:14think is fairly self -evident. but it usually
- 7:22is a foil for something deeper. And again, this
- 7:25is not Psych 101, but unresolved issues with
- 7:30a deceased parent. I remember I was attending
- 7:33a funeral and the son with whom he had held great
- 7:39animosity for now his deceased and being buried
- 7:42father would shovel earth into the grave side.
- 7:46uh as if he were a machine uh with anger and
- 7:50cadence um and it was almost from an outsider's
- 7:55view you sense this catharsis that he was expressing
- 8:00um but it's a deeper dive listen i think anger
- 8:04is very important uh this idea that we have to
- 8:07assuage anger i think is uh a less than sophisticated
- 8:14expression It's important to get angry. It's
- 8:17important to get livid. It depends over what.
- 8:20And that's the issue. So years and years of calcification,
- 8:27of troubled relationships, of toxic upbringing,
- 8:32there is anger. And I think we could all agree
- 8:35to squelch that may not be beneficial. I'm not
- 8:37even talking physiological. It just cordons off
- 8:41or chelates something that is very much a part
- 8:44of the person's psyche. And not that you need
- 8:48a razor to, you know, excise all that pressure
- 8:54that's underlying it. But to discuss it, to discuss
- 8:59it in an environment where there's strict confidence
- 9:02of Assumption of strict confidence where whatever's
- 9:07exchange remains within the room itself. And
- 9:11I think. The biblical text without romanticizing
- 9:16it or without reducing it to a psychological
- 9:18book any more than it should be viewed as a scientific
- 9:22work. Has a host and I mean a host of examples
- 9:26of family dynamic and relationship dynamic. If
- 9:30I were to name the book of Genesis, which comes
- 9:33from the Greek translation, the Septuagint. In
- 9:37Hebrew, it's referred to as brace sheet. and
- 9:40the Masoretes, these groups of scholars that
- 9:42lived around the 6th, 7th century, they're the
- 9:46ones who vocalized and paginated the text. They
- 9:50would name a book by the first salient word in
- 9:54the sentence, the opening sentence. So the Hebrew
- 9:56Bible begins, Bereshit bar Elohim, which is in
- 10:01a beginning or direct object in the beginning.
- 10:06So that's the Hebrew, but there are multiple
- 10:09translations of the Bible. There's the Vulgate
- 10:11in Latin. There's the Septuagint in Greek and
- 10:14we follow the Greek translation as it relates
- 10:18to English and it is Genesis because the framers
- 10:22of the book felt that it dealt with creation.
- 10:24It doesn't deal with creation, not in any astronomical
- 10:29sense. It deals with family. So if I were to
- 10:33name the first book of the Bible, I would name
- 10:36it Family because it's honest and it's raw and
- 10:40it's a yellow amber light that is just flashing
- 10:44as if to say tread lightly. This is a very powerful
- 10:49definitional institution, the family, but it
- 10:53is fraught with all kinds of challenges, many
- 10:56of which are quite painful. So I would draw from
- 11:00certain biblical narratives, selective of course,
- 11:04and I think that can be no magic here, but I
- 11:08think that can be a basis for discussion to explore
- 11:12some of those more in -depth pains that manifest
- 11:15using the example of the funeral that I just
- 11:18did. Thank you. Dr. Lane, how about you? How
- 11:21do you deal with anger when a couple comes to
- 11:24you and You don't want to scoot them out the
- 11:27door, but you do want them to deal with situations.
- 11:30And maybe give us an example or two that would
- 11:32be helpful. Well, I think, one, just the world
- 11:37of emotions oftentimes is downplayed, as Michael
- 11:41was describing, and particularly in spiritual
- 11:44context, and especially negative emotions. So
- 11:47anger would be described as one of the negative
- 11:49emotions, although research by the Gottmans are
- 11:53also saying that it's also a positive emotion
- 11:56because it's the emotion of protest that says,
- 12:00I don't like being disconnected from you. I want
- 12:03to be connected with you. And I think that creating
- 12:09a space where people can openly express their
- 12:16emotions, albeit within a a healthy context,
- 12:20but both positive and negative. And we only have
- 12:24to look to the Psalms to see that that's what's
- 12:26happening. I mean, the wide range of emotions
- 12:30show up in the Psalms and we want to affirm that
- 12:33because that's a significant part of what makes
- 12:36us human. And, you know, I've experienced it
- 12:41when a couple comes in and there's been infidelity.
- 12:46And, you know, Anger is an appropriate emotion
- 12:50for the spouse that's been betrayed because it
- 12:54says, this is wrong, this is not good, I don't
- 12:57like this, this hurt me. That's what I want to
- 13:02hear. I don't want to hear, oh that's fine, no
- 13:05problem, you go ahead and continue with your...
- 13:08you know, adulterous relationship. So creating
- 13:11a space where the person who's been betrayed
- 13:14can talk about how they've been impacted by that
- 13:17betrayal and then walking a couple through the
- 13:19process of reconciliation and healing. I can't
- 13:26believe how many couples I've dealt with, religious
- 13:31people who hold marriage in high esteem, where
- 13:35there has been some type of infidelity and betrayal
- 13:39and helping them walk through that wisely and
- 13:43carefully in a way that doesn't just overlay
- 13:49some simplistic solution to that serious problem.
- 13:54It's difficult but it's also for me quite rewarding
- 13:58to walk with a couple in that context, surprisingly.
- 14:03Fascinating. And Bob, Bob, I do have a follow
- 14:08up question. Yeah, sure. Thanks. This is for
- 14:11both Dr. Lane and Rabbi Galli. When you are dealing
- 14:16perhaps with a marriage situation and there's
- 14:19intense anger on one or both sides and either
- 14:23one or both of the parties can't get beyond that
- 14:26to get to the point of reconciliation, what do
- 14:29you do in those situations? I'm sure that happens
- 14:32occasionally. Yeah. Dr. Lane? Well, thankfully,
- 14:40in the majority of my experiences with couples,
- 14:43hundreds of couples where there's been infidelity,
- 14:45I see a desire to heal and go through that process,
- 14:50which is quite amazing. And it actually, the
- 14:55infidelity, the betrayal actually serves as kind
- 14:59of smelling salts, if you will, to the couple.
- 15:02And they often have a better marriage after the
- 15:07infidelity if they are, you know, cared for and
- 15:12they walk through that process wisely. But certainly
- 15:16there are those situations where, you know, one
- 15:19spouse cannot get beyond, can't get past what
- 15:21has happened to them and all the pleading and
- 15:25encouraging that you might do still does not
- 15:29dissuade them from from ending the relationship.
- 15:32Sometimes the relationship needs to end because
- 15:37it's so broken. But often, often again, just
- 15:41providing a context for them to to process all
- 15:46the wide range of emotions that someone who has
- 15:50been betrayed and someone who has betrayed their
- 15:52spouse. Do you ever refer them out for to a psychologist
- 15:58or psychiatrist or someone who does that type
- 16:03of work full -time 24 -7. So when I was a pastor,
- 16:08I always told myself I need at least three experts
- 16:11that I can call. One would be a lawyer, another
- 16:16a doctor, and another a professional counselor.
- 16:20And so those would be situations when I was a
- 16:23pastor where I would definitely resource people
- 16:27who have training in that. After I was a pastor
- 16:30and went to school and got a degree in counseling,
- 16:33I do a lot of that myself now, but I'm not serving
- 16:38in a pastoral role. So I'm in a more professional
- 16:40counselor role now. You know, it's fascinating.
- 16:45I will take on any kind of mediation except family
- 16:50law. And the reason is I've been married for
- 16:5545 years. Each of our parents were married for
- 16:5850 years. And I just don't bring enough context
- 17:01to the situation. But having said that, I had
- 17:04a former client. And when I worked with him,
- 17:09he was very high up in the Hollywood community,
- 17:11and he was accused of inappropriate behavior,
- 17:15which turned out to be an absolute false claim.
- 17:18I told him before I could try his case, I had
- 17:21to meet his wife. because I needed the full context
- 17:26before I could go to trial in this situation.
- 17:29We ended up convincing the plaintiff to drop
- 17:32the charge and years later he came to me and
- 17:36he said, I need a good divorce lawyer. I said,
- 17:38no, you're kidding me. And I said, let me talk
- 17:44to you and your wife I got involuntarily brought
- 17:47into the situation and I hate to use the expression
- 17:51but thank God they ended up together again it
- 17:54was maybe the most gratifying quote mediation
- 17:57that I've ever done so it can be very. I think
- 18:02Sally and to deal with with with family law situations
- 18:05and Michael does that come to you as well these
- 18:08family law where where there's a charge of infidelity
- 18:11have you had that come to you. I don't want to
- 18:14be glib by saying, of course, over an arc of
- 18:1731 years, but most definitely. I wanted to very
- 18:20briefly pick up on what Dr. Lane had said. Within
- 18:26the broader context of Jewish law, Jewish thought,
- 18:31Jews never marry till death do us part. It's
- 18:34never said at a conventional Jewish wedding.
- 18:38In fact, there was a medieval biblical and legalist
- 18:44who popularly was known as Arashi. That was an
- 18:51abbreviation of his actual name. And he writes
- 18:55that divorce is a mitzvah. Mitzvah is a commandment.
- 19:00It's not a good deed. It's often misconstrued
- 19:03and even more frequently mistranslated as if
- 19:08to say, and he did say, do everything possible
- 19:12to resolve the differences that may break about
- 19:16a marriage. But if everything was exhausted within
- 19:24reason, it literally is a commandment to dissolve
- 19:27the marriage. A ketubah is a wedding document,
- 19:33but what it is in its most... Accessible vernacular
- 19:37is an insurance policy for the woman. And I know
- 19:40that sounds funny, but it's not meant to be.
- 19:43And I think it's a quite accurate definition.
- 19:46Ketubah is an Aramaic word, which literally means
- 19:50writing, the Hebrew equivalent with ketivas,
- 19:53not a language discourse here. But what the ketubah
- 19:57says in its essence is, should this marriage
- 20:00dissolve, We hope it doesn't. Here's sufficient
- 20:06funds for the woman to go ahead with her life
- 20:09to jumpstart it. And with regard to Jeff, your
- 20:15comment as far as having the background, I don't
- 20:20know at what point the background is sufficient.
- 20:24I would argue perhaps someone who has endured
- 20:27divorce might be a more capable counselor. I
- 20:31don't know. I do know I never visited Russia
- 20:35and I certainly never visited the Soviet Union.
- 20:38to know that the architecture of that country,
- 20:43its leadership, its political ideology, along
- 20:47with its history, is less than desirable. So
- 20:50there are things we know never having experienced,
- 20:53never touched down on the soil. And again, I
- 20:56know that's a bit of a platitude, but too often
- 20:58we lose sight of that. Well, I'm not an expert.
- 21:03That becomes almost a deflection point. um not
- 21:10only the experts know the so -called experts
- 21:13of which they can be often very soundly um uh
- 21:17flat out wrong um as we know all too well um
- 21:22and as far as what social accountability they're
- 21:25held to is a separate issue though i do think
- 21:29when it comes to resolving disputes not uncommonly
- 21:35uh if there is such An unbridgeable impasse.
- 21:40I do think there's value in clarification over
- 21:44agreement, clarification over agreement, and
- 21:49I think as far as any type of adjudication, any
- 21:53type of counseling session that may not have
- 21:56immediate benefit as far as when one exits the
- 22:00office. But if the seeds are planted and if the
- 22:03person is sufficiently self -scrutinizing, allowing
- 22:07for perhaps some of the emotion to tamp down,
- 22:11that very notion of clarification over agreement
- 22:14may be a very soothing and very helpful retrospective
- 22:21of what occurred and what was discussed. That's
- 22:25super. Dr. Lane, to you. Yeah, just a story.
- 22:30you wanted stories. So I was a young pastor 30
- 22:34plus years ago in my early 30s and a husband,
- 22:39a congregant came to me and said, I developed
- 22:44a relationship with a woman on the internet.
- 22:47We've developed a very intimate relationship
- 22:50and this has been going on for six months to
- 22:54a year. And he began to describe to me how all
- 22:58this came about. And then he said something quite
- 23:02interesting. He said, and I don't know why I'm
- 23:05here telling you. But it was an honest kind of,
- 23:11I'm opening up and I'm being vulnerable about
- 23:15something that I've done that's horrible. And
- 23:17I had the opportunity, I think Michael, you're
- 23:20referring to this, I had the opportunity to assure
- 23:23that husband. I said, no, you've come to the
- 23:25right place. And in our Christian tradition,
- 23:29I said, this is exactly why Jesus has come to
- 23:32bring hope and healing, the experience of forgiveness
- 23:36and potential reconciliation with your wife.
- 23:40And it was there that I started a... pastoral
- 23:45counseling relationship with this husband and
- 23:48wife and walk them through that infidelity and
- 23:51saw them reconcile and stay together as a couple.
- 23:57So you provide that safe space for people to...
- 24:02to open up and talk about where they've aired
- 24:05and where they've fallen and where they've made
- 24:09egregious mistakes and hurt others, but then
- 24:12invite them into that place of change and growth
- 24:16and healing and reconciliation. Tim, it's been
- 24:20often said it's very easy to get a divorce. I
- 24:24would challenge that. I think it's too easy to
- 24:26get married. It's very true. Do we sit with couples
- 24:32prior and and even then I acknowledge with with
- 24:38proven amounts of crow of which I've eaten that
- 24:43of course we don't ultimately know you know what
- 24:46what what are some of the ingredients as it were
- 24:49the prerequisites that at least would give a
- 24:54priest, a minister, a rabbi, a religious -based
- 24:59counselor, a sense of grounded optimism that
- 25:03this relationship will not merely be a testament
- 25:07to time, but more importantly, a testament to
- 25:10depth and a true intimacy that even transcends
- 25:14the physical. Yeah. Dr. Lane, do people come
- 25:18to you who are not believers? And is your approach
- 25:22with them different? And if so, how is it different?
- 25:28So in a pastoral counselor, more professional
- 25:31context, the way I market myself is a Christian
- 25:36counselor. So that's obviously going to, you
- 25:39know, call certain people to say yes or no. But
- 25:44I have had people come and they'll say, I'm not
- 25:47really interested in matters of faith, but I
- 25:50do want you to help me with this. And obviously
- 25:53I will work with them and definitely invite opportunities
- 25:59like that. Sometimes it will lead to deeper questions
- 26:04of meaning and purpose that we can get into.
- 26:07And I can say, well, here's where I'm coming
- 26:09from. Are you open to hearing that? There are
- 26:16other perspectives on meaning and purpose and
- 26:20things of that nature that you can investigate,
- 26:22but here's where I'm coming from. So yeah, I
- 26:25welcome those situations. When anybody's asking
- 26:28the deeper questions, right? Why do I exist and
- 26:31what does... true and fulfilling and flourishing
- 26:35existence look like. They may not be putting
- 26:37it that way. Whenever someone's asking those
- 26:39kinds of questions, you're heartened by that.
- 26:43And do you have situations where, let's take
- 26:46a couple, OK, or business partners, where one
- 26:49is, let's make it business partners just to change
- 26:51the tape a little bit, OK? Somebody comes to
- 26:55you and she's a believer, and she's in a business
- 26:59partnership with her longtime friend, who doesn't
- 27:03believe in Moses, Buddha, Ahab, anything, right?
- 27:10How do you deal with that given the path that
- 27:14you have chosen? Is that to me? Yes, please.
- 27:20Well, I mean, we're called to live in the world
- 27:22with people of all different beliefs and persuasions
- 27:26and to be compassionate. But at the same time,
- 27:32if that relationship is troubled and there are
- 27:34things that are happening that are breaking down
- 27:37that relationship, I might say, have you considered
- 27:40a career change? Or do you want to look for another
- 27:43role in the company? Those are appropriate decisions
- 27:48that you can help people make. along with encouraging
- 27:53them to pursue deeper conversations with that
- 27:57coworker with whom they are in disagreement,
- 27:59teaching them how to do conflict well in the
- 28:01workplace with whom they disagree. I would also
- 28:06add, if I may please, I would want to know something
- 28:11about each person's background. Are they a born
- 28:18-again Jew? or born -again Christian, and I think
- 28:22that's an operative consideration because much
- 28:26like marriage or a business relationship or a
- 28:30partnership of ownership and direction within
- 28:33business, if one partner changes his or her theological
- 28:39foundation midstream, shall we say, I think that
- 28:43has to be taken into consideration. I see that
- 28:48more or I have seen that more in the context
- 28:52of marriages, both among Jew and non -Jew, that's
- 28:58really secondary. But is this essentially the
- 29:02person with whom you started a business? Of course
- 29:06we change, and God willing, that should be the
- 29:08course of our life. And with that change, we
- 29:13all hope there's new perspective and greater
- 29:15maturity. But if there's a foundational almost
- 29:19sea change within a person's worldview midway
- 29:23into a relationship, or certainly after the relationship
- 29:27has begun without putting a particular point
- 29:31in time, that changes really the discourse. It
- 29:36changes what might be a suitable outcome. And
- 29:40it's challenging unto its own. It's challenging
- 29:43by itself. Yeah, I have a question for Rabbi
- 29:47Galli. Sometimes I know that congregants get
- 29:54angry with each other, and sometimes serious
- 29:57disputes happen. And I'm curious, and this could
- 30:00apply to Dr. Lane too, how do you deal with parishioners
- 30:05or congregants that are so angry they're becoming
- 30:09disruptive? to the church or synagogue, and also
- 30:15destructive. Have you ever counseled and mediated
- 30:20disputes between congregants? I would think that
- 30:22comes up at times. Yes, and I think there's almost
- 30:30inseparable similarity to a family. Congregations
- 30:35are families, particularly among members who
- 30:38are frequent attenders of the service or perhaps
- 30:42serve on the board. What I am particularly vigilant
- 30:48is not speaking about other congregants in their
- 30:52context in among them, or for that matter, any
- 30:57other congregant. As a typical rule, I do not.
- 31:01And I do feel I have. some friends, and I would
- 31:06really define what I mean by friendship in the
- 31:10truest most, I think, embracing way with a number
- 31:14of my congregants, certainly after 31 years.
- 31:19But in direct response to your question, I think
- 31:24in many ways, there are similarities to a family
- 31:28discord. And that's largely how I approach it.
- 31:33Again, not uncommonly in this case, unlike say
- 31:37within my own family, but family members who
- 31:42are at an impasse and have a lot of just enmity
- 31:48between them. They're often coming to me for
- 31:51a moral judgment. Unlike the therapist who might
- 31:55want to speak in terms of what's functional or
- 31:57dysfunctional or unlike the lawyer that would
- 32:01perhaps entertain what is legal and what is not.
- 32:05Coming to a clergy member. uh tell me rabbi uh
- 32:10you know tell me pastor um what is right or wrong
- 32:14in this case and in that sense i think and jeff
- 32:18you alluded to this but just to tease it out
- 32:20a little bit um they're there too i think there's
- 32:26a a representative percentage of their emotion
- 32:31uh that wants to be self -critical also uh teach
- 32:35me rabbi tell me Am I wrong? And if I am, I want
- 32:40to hear it, not merely I want to defend myself
- 32:42even to you. And Dr. Lane, to you on that, that's
- 32:47an interesting question. Well, you know, we haven't
- 32:51talked about group conflict and things get interesting
- 32:57with two people. Things get even more interesting
- 32:59with 50, 100, 500, 1000, right? and we've seen
- 33:06world wars at that level, but certainly in churches.
- 33:11In my circle, we often talk about a church splant,
- 33:17so it's not a church plant, but they don't want
- 33:20to call it a church split, so it's a church splant.
- 33:24Two groups differ with one another, oftentimes
- 33:28over tertiary, sometimes secondary matters, not
- 33:34primary matters that will leave and start a new
- 33:38church, and it's often done, you know, with acrimony
- 33:41and hostility, which is just sad. But maintaining
- 33:46unity in the body of Christ, as I would describe
- 33:49it, Paul talks about unity in Ephesians 4, and
- 33:54maintaining that unity while also, in the latter
- 33:57part of that chapter 4, talking about appreciating
- 34:00the diversity of gifts that are in the body of
- 34:04Christ and helping people live in that space
- 34:07of we are one but we are different and that's
- 34:10similar to marriage, right? We're one flesh but
- 34:13we are two very different distinct people and
- 34:17helping people grapple with that diversity and
- 34:20appreciate that diversity in such a way that
- 34:22it strengthens the unity rather than hinders
- 34:25the unity I think is really a a calling of the
- 34:29pastor, which means, and Michael can appreciate
- 34:32this, we have to be comfortable with conflict.
- 34:37And so often, so often, you know, we just want
- 34:41everybody to like us. And that's just not that's
- 34:44just not the way the world works. And we have
- 34:46to be willing to get in the fray and get a little
- 34:49bit messy and get dirty ourselves and working
- 34:53with people. And sometimes people come out of
- 34:56experience and they don't like me. That's part
- 35:00of the role of being a leader that comes with
- 35:03the territory. That's so important because as
- 35:07mediators, Bob and I have situations where there's
- 35:12reasons they call us neutral or neutrals. But
- 35:16having said that, there are situations that we
- 35:19each have that cry out for us to weigh in on
- 35:24the circumstance. I mediated a civil rights case
- 35:28the other day. The underlying allegation was
- 35:32that the plaintiff had beaten his wife, which
- 35:37he vociferously denied. I won't go into the merits
- 35:41or the demerits, but I will simply say that my
- 35:44emotional reaction was to say to the plaintiff,
- 35:48you know, buddy, you're lucky to be out of jail.
- 35:50not to be suing the city for your civil rights
- 35:53violation. And I knew that would draw the ire
- 35:57of the plaintiff's lawyer, who was a very, very
- 36:00skilled practitioner and who is there, frankly,
- 36:03to be the advocate for this person who either
- 36:05did or did not do something bad to his spouse.
- 36:11But it does become a matter as a neutral that,
- 36:14in a sense, you have to be immune to people not
- 36:18necessarily liking you. You're not there to win
- 36:21a popularity contest. Right. Yeah. And you won't
- 36:25with a good number of people. I would think.
- 36:28I would differentiate that being a congregational
- 36:32rabbi serving a congregation, it's just different
- 36:36than being a therapist where there are set hours
- 36:40and you're not engrossed in the community or
- 36:46titular to the community. And I would say that
- 36:51of other professions. The lawyer has a liminal
- 36:56period of time with his or her client and not
- 37:00so with the rabbi. So if there is a spat, more
- 37:05than a spat, You know a grievance between congregants
- 37:09Invariably people talk and they gossip and it
- 37:13becomes this ring of concentric circles that
- 37:17just pulsates outward and What should be contained?
- 37:23and confidential unfortunately not uncommonly
- 37:28unravels and becomes somewhat of a public spectacle
- 37:31and It breaks apart a community. It certainly
- 37:35challenges its integrity. How do you each deal
- 37:39with pastoral privilege? There's a little bit
- 37:51more informality in a pastoral role than there
- 37:55is in the other role that I serve in now, which
- 37:58is a more professional role, confidentiality.
- 38:02You also mentioned the dual relationships. But
- 38:06I would always err on the side of sharing someone
- 38:11what my limitations of confidentiality are. and
- 38:18then say, you know, my goal if you share something
- 38:21with me that's personal, if it's not illegal
- 38:25or you're not in harm's way, my goal would be
- 38:28to get you to have a place where you can bring
- 38:31that issue up with that individual. So it's not
- 38:35you and me having secrets about this other person,
- 38:40but it's me helping you broker a conversation
- 38:43and provide a context so that you can have that
- 38:47conversation and bring up that issue with this
- 38:50other person in the congregation with whom you're
- 38:52in conflict. I believe in the ultimate analysis
- 38:59that there's an objective standard of good and
- 39:02evil. I don't think it's reduced simply to subjective
- 39:05personal views and I would add to what the Reverend
- 39:10said, what Dr. Lane said, I think it depends
- 39:14on the context. And in that regard, I don't see
- 39:18myself as an adversary or an advocate. And not
- 39:22that I am somewhere soundly in the middle. I
- 39:27am an emotional creature. I'm a flawed man and
- 39:30all of the rest. But if there's something that
- 39:33is a deep cause for concern, of what might unfold
- 39:40as a future, a nefarious behavior. And let me
- 39:44be specific, one that would cause harm to another
- 39:47human being, physical harm, let alone emotional
- 39:51harm, but primarily physical. Or if there was
- 39:56something done in the past along the lines of
- 39:59very criminal behavior. I want to respect confidentiality.
- 40:05But again, if I do feel not in a holier than
- 40:10thou way, and please God, I hope that is not
- 40:14my motivation, but still in all serving something
- 40:18that I hold as ethereal and transcendent, eternal,
- 40:24timeless, and moral in at least the theoretical
- 40:28sense of an objective morality, not merely what
- 40:31I think or feel. I would go to authorities and
- 40:36I most forthrightedly would tell of my counseling
- 40:42experience or a personal conversation with an
- 40:45individual in my office. I'm not a therapist
- 40:49and I don't say that in any way to slight therapy.
- 40:52I'm very pro -therapy. I told you I studied with
- 40:55psychiatrists, one of whom was quite prominent
- 40:59in New York. But I want to see myself not as
- 41:08flawless, not as a paragon of virtue in that
- 41:11sense, because I just, I don't feel worthy and
- 41:16that's a psychological dive of a different sort.
- 41:19But I do see myself as an exemplar, not me personally
- 41:24per se, though I strive to be, but the position
- 41:29that I hold. And it is different. It is qualitatively
- 41:34different than sitting in the office of a lawyer,
- 41:39sitting in the office of a physician or a therapist.
- 41:44And I think that's when I talked about limits
- 41:46to confidentiality. If you're telling me you're
- 41:49going to do harm to yourself, I'm going to find
- 41:51a way to get you to. the hospital or if you're
- 41:56telling me you're going to do harm to another
- 41:57person or you're confessing to allegations, criminal
- 42:01allegations in the past, I have a responsibility
- 42:04just like a therapist would to report that. But
- 42:09when it comes to, you know, more personal matters,
- 42:14where there's not criminal behavior, there's
- 42:16not self -harm or other harm that's in the mix.
- 42:19I'm also still saying, look, I'm willing to hold
- 42:22this in confidence, but my ideal goal would be
- 42:25that if this is something that you have between
- 42:27you and another person, how can I help broker
- 42:30that conversation? That happens a lot of times
- 42:33when I'm doing marriage counseling. I'll meet
- 42:35individually with the husband and wife early
- 42:37on. Give me your perspective. I just want you
- 42:39to have an opportunity to talk about some of
- 42:42your concerns, goals. And I always preface that
- 42:46by saying these individual meetings I'm having
- 42:48with the two of you are not for you and me to
- 42:50have secrets between you and me and your spouse.
- 42:53It's for me to find things that we need to address
- 42:57together. And then it does also give me an opportunity.
- 43:01So if one says, hey, my spouse is beating me.
- 43:05that gives them the freedom to articulate that
- 43:08and then I have to take the appropriate steps
- 43:10to determine what kind of domestic violence am
- 43:13I dealing with here and what are my appropriate
- 43:16and godly responses to have this person protected.
- 43:21Here's a supposition under which I am guided.
- 43:25I hold as an axiom that words are actions. My
- 43:29tradition teaches me that. Again, what do I bring
- 43:32that a therapist would nod or a compliment to
- 43:35a therapist or a legal session or a medical session?
- 43:40I don't believe we're just biological creatures.
- 43:42I'm a stalwart believer in a firm natural law,
- 43:48but I don't think we're an oops of the universe.
- 43:51And I remember I was called a number of years
- 43:54ago by I think a district attorney asking me
- 44:03to, sorry, I just had something pop up, asking
- 44:08me to offer an understanding of a section in
- 44:13the book of Daniel because he understood that
- 44:21the defendant used a quote from the book of Daniel
- 44:25as a life -threatening action. Now that's a written
- 44:30word, but my point is I believe words are actions.
- 44:34You can read a book and it can accelerate your
- 44:39heart rate or it could bring tears to your eyes
- 44:43and it's just ink on a page. and it has as much
- 44:48force in many cases than an action, a physical
- 44:54action itself. So when words are spoken in the
- 44:58manner in which we're at least addressing here,
- 45:03I take them seriously and my tradition tells
- 45:06me to do so. The book of Proverbs is just filled
- 45:10with hurtful and helpful speech, right? how it
- 45:14impacts others. So absolutely. The writer James,
- 45:20the New Testament epistle, which is really connected
- 45:23to wisdom literature in the Hebrew scriptures,
- 45:27he talks about how with our mouth we praise our
- 45:30father, but we also with that same mouth curse
- 45:33our brother who is made in the image of God.
- 45:38That's powerful. And there's a lot in James about
- 45:41the power of the tongue. And as you're describing,
- 45:45Michael, just the weight that our words have
- 45:50and how they impact others. ethnocentric comment,
- 45:58the founders of Christianity were knowledgeable
- 46:01Jews, that they just were. Between James and
- 46:04Paul, they gave rise to an antinomial Christianity
- 46:08that was an internal debate within the formulation
- 46:12of Christianity, but echoes very soundly certain
- 46:17key Jewish foundational principles. Not that
- 46:21it's the same as gravity that you folks are talking
- 46:24about. But I had a client who would come to me
- 46:27on other things, and he came to me and he says,
- 46:29I need you to file a lawsuit involving my daughter's
- 46:34bat mitzvah. And I said, that's antithetical
- 46:37to everything that a bat mitzvah should be. The
- 46:40long and the short of it was that they were new
- 46:42people to the... area they thought they had an
- 46:46agreement with another family regarding dates
- 46:48they felt that the agreement had been broken
- 46:51and and the little girl was most concerned that
- 46:54nobody would go to her. But that's when everybody
- 46:57would go to let's call it her rival and I said
- 47:01I want to wave the turning client privilege and
- 47:04be able to talk with the other family and and
- 47:07they can you know to do so. And when I went to
- 47:11the other family, I said, look, I want to get
- 47:13the two girls together in a room. OK, and I got
- 47:18the two girls together in a room. They were most
- 47:21chagrined that their parents were at odds with
- 47:23each other. And they, of course, came up with
- 47:26the perfect solution, which was that each of
- 47:28them would have a separate ceremony, but that
- 47:31they would share the but minutes for party together.
- 47:35And they, of course, became fast friends, which
- 47:38was, you know, You feel like a Boy Scout when
- 47:41something like that happens. Bob, to you, anything
- 47:44further? No, I think it's been a wonderful discussion
- 47:48of philosophy and religion and problem solving.
- 47:52And I think that this could go on for a lot longer.
- 47:54But I think it's been very, very informative
- 47:58and educational to me. I've enjoyed it very much.
- 48:02And I want to thank the two of you. You're busy.
- 48:05folks, which is important, and you're busy because
- 48:08you do a lot of good works. So on behalf of the
- 48:12Beverly Hills Bar Association, thank you so much
- 48:15for participating in this. And I will be looking
- 48:20forward to giving you feedback in terms of the
- 48:24airing of the program. Take care. Great. Thank
- 48:27you all. A pleasure. Bye -bye.