Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Equal Credit Opportunity Act Part 1
Transcript
- 0:05Having different risk based pricing standards for married and unmarried
- 0:11COA applicants based solely on their marital status violates ECOA
- 0:15Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:21I hope you enjoy.
- 0:24Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:28Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the Insider's View on passing
- 0:31your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:34The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:37Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:39If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:42team and receive Support to optimize your results with NCUA.
- 0:46So you save time and money.
- 0:48Visit us@marktrical.com to find out more.
- 0:57Hey everyone, this is Mark TriCal with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 1:01I'm here again with Joe Goldberg.
- 1:03Joe, how are you doing this afternoon?
- 1:05Going well Mark.
- 1:05Hope you are too.
- 1:06Doing well, doing well.
- 1:08Just got my HVAC replaced here and I've got a chill in the air.
- 1:12So life is good.
- 1:14All right.
- 1:14So, Joe, you were, have been an attorney for 40 years.
- 1:18You also taught consumer law and at the, at the, Your last transition to
- 1:24consulting and doing some other things that I know you do, you were at NCUA
- 1:28for eight years where you were in charge of the division that was responsible
- 1:33for HMDA, fair lending, and, you know, consumer compliance in all areas.
- 1:39And that's where I met you.
- 1:40And that's how we got connected here on the other side, now
- 1:43that we're both outside of NCUA.
- 1:46And I'm looking forward today to chat with you.
- 1:50About the ECOA and, and Reg B and the significance and purpose
- 1:55of fair lending and ECOA.
- 1:57So with that, Joe, I'm going to turn the, the, the microphone over to you.
- 2:02Thank you very much, Mark.
- 2:03Appreciate it.
- 2:04I appreciate, appreciate the opportunity to talk about this
- 2:08because being a somewhat of a consumer compliance nerd, you know,
- 2:12this is this is enjoyable for me.
- 2:15I'm going to talk about the equal credit opportunity act.
- 2:19And it's regulation, Reg B, COA is how it's usually abbreviated the acronym.
- 2:25I'm going to go a little bit into the background, why it's important, and then
- 2:31get into some of the meat of the, of the, the law itself and the regulation.
- 2:37Uh, before I start though, I do want to make.
- 2:39Big one statement is, and that is, I know that N.
- 2:42C.
- 2:42U.
- 2:42A.
- 2:43has increased its focus on fair lending in the last several years.
- 2:46They even started when I was there.
- 2:48I left there at the end of 2021, but that's that's still true.
- 2:52And, in fact, the agency is expanding its fair lending examination program.
- 2:58So, having a discussion about eco is probably important for
- 3:03credit unions at this time.
- 3:04Well, and Joe, let's pause there here, right on the front end.
- 3:07So you and I were chatting offline and they added a new supervisor that's
- 3:10responsible essentially for just that.
- 3:13If I, if I remember, right, right.
- 3:15There's now a division for fair lending supervision, a whole
- 3:19separate division within the office of consumer financial protection.
- 3:23So that, that tells you right there that the agency is serious
- 3:26about expanding the program.
- 3:28Yes.
- 3:29And I would even say, and I've said this several other podcasts
- 3:32of different topics that.
- 3:35Chairman Todd Harper is very passionate about consumer compliance, which
- 3:38includes this, and he has been operating as chairman with two Republican board
- 3:44members, and board member Rodney Hood's term is up in August, and in all
- 3:48likelihood, there will, I would envision a relatively quick turnaround there so
- 3:54that this is the only agency that's, that has more, more Has a controlling interest
- 4:00by the party that's not in the president.
- 4:03So, you know, Rodney Hood's done a great job as a board member, but there
- 4:07are things I think that in this arena that chairman Todd Harper may want to
- 4:11do, like expanding it again with this next budget that comes up for 2024.
- 4:15All right.
- 4:16With that, that's my, that's my two cents on it.
- 4:19Again, the microphone is yours, Joe.
- 4:21All right.
- 4:22Thank you.
- 4:22So let's first look at the significance and the purpose of the
- 4:26Fair Lending and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act specifically.
- 4:29So what ECOA does is it requires creditors to make decisions related
- 4:35to providing credit and the terms of credit based, they would base them
- 4:40solely on credit related factors.
- 4:43That's in a nutshell, that's the purpose of ECOA.
- 4:47Because, as we'll talk about, there are other factors that are discriminatory
- 4:52in nature and therefore illegal.
- 4:55So, Congress passed the Equal Credit Opportunity Act in 1974, and as Congress
- 5:03sometimes does, not always, But they did with respect to ECOA, they put right in
- 5:09the law findings and purpose, and I'm, I'm going to read it to you so you see
- 5:15exactly what it is that Congress intended when they did this, the Congress finds
- 5:21that there is a need to ensure that the various financial institutions and other
- 5:26firms engaged in the extension of credit exercise their responsibility to make
- 5:31credit available with fairness, Bye bye.
- 5:34Bye.
- 5:34Impartiality, excuse me, impartiality and without discrimination on the
- 5:40basis of sex or marital status.
- 5:44Economic stabilization would be enhanced and competition among the various
- 5:49financial institutions and other firms engaged in the extension of credit
- 5:53would be strengthened by an absence of discrimination on the basis of sex
- 5:57or marital status, as well as by the informed use of credit, which Congress
- 6:02has heretofore sought to promote.
- 6:05It is the purpose of this act to require that financial institutions.
- 6:10And other firms engaged in the extension of credit, make that credit equally
- 6:15available to all credit worthy customers without regard to sex or marital status.
- 6:22Well, that that's that's it.
- 6:24That's the purpose of of this and what.
- 6:27Congress intended when they wrote this law.
- 6:30Now you'll notice it repeatedly refers to sex or marital status.
- 6:35Two years after this was passed in 1976, Congress added the
- 6:40other seven prohibited bases.
- 6:42That's the term used for what, if that particular term or quality
- 6:51was used in the, Decision process would constitute discrimination.
- 6:57So, there are 9 of them, even though the original purpose and
- 7:01the original act is only with respect to sex or marital status.
- 7:05So, what it does is, if you have the written purpose that I read in front
- 7:15of you, you would see it does 2 things.
- 7:18Prohibited discrimination in credit transactions.
- 7:22And then require disclosure of why credit was denied or changed that has
- 7:29to do with the informed use of credit.
- 7:31That was in that purpose.
- 7:33You may be familiar with the term adverse action notices and that's
- 7:37what I'm referring to about the disclosure of the reasons for credit
- 7:41being denied or terms being changed.
- 7:44You know, there's now good to point that out.
- 7:47Yeah, there's, there's now a 3rd primary purpose.
- 7:51Congress amended ECOA in the Dodd Frank Act, and because of a regulation recently
- 7:57released by the CFPB, creditors who make credit available to small businesses.
- 8:06And there's a threshold amount to come under this provision, but
- 8:10those who do must collect and report data with regards to those small
- 8:16business transactions to the CFPB.
- 8:20I'm not really going to talk about that in this podcast because it's,
- 8:25it would take up too much time and we have, we'll do that in another podcast.
- 8:31You got it.
- 8:31You got it.
- 8:32All right, now, then there are some other smaller provisions of lesser importance.
- 8:37I would characterize that as, but I'll talk about those very briefly
- 8:42toward the end of the presentation.
- 8:44All right.
- 8:45Now, one thing before I dive into the details.
- 8:48I just want to review.
- 8:50The difference between a law and a regulation, because we do talk
- 8:54about a, which is a, an act.
- 8:57It's a law passed by Congress and also the regulation laws that laws are
- 9:03enacted by Congress regulations are promulgated by somebody that's appointed
- 9:09by Congress to promulgate the regulations.
- 9:12Usually it's an agency.
- 9:14Sometimes it refers to an individual, such as the secretary of, but the purpose is.
- 9:20To allow the entity that has expertise in a certain matter to come up
- 9:27with the fine details and the rules and regulations that Congress.
- 9:32Requires in a wall.
- 9:34That's a, that's a, that's a great point.
- 9:36Let's let me just kind of pause there.
- 9:38So putting that in, like, in terms, the federal credit union
- 9:41act is a fact approved by Congress.
- 9:45And then that would require in some instances, or other actions would require
- 9:50promulgate regulations as you describe.
- 9:53Which allows the kind of the mission and the principles, I guess, to be put in
- 9:57place in the law, and then it gives the regulators some authority to make it a
- 10:02little bit more nimble, so they don't have to run back to Congress if a change on
- 10:07how it might be implemented or whatever was delegated to the, uh, To the agency
- 10:13to regulate any thoughts on what I just said, no, that that's exactly right.
- 10:18The, to some extent, the law is often the outline and then the regulation is
- 10:24the details that fills in the outline the regulation will do such things as define.
- 10:30Parts of the law, it may explain what certain things in
- 10:34the law are supposed to mean.
- 10:36It will create the rules.
- 10:38And by regulation, but those are the rules by which those who are
- 10:43covered under that law must must act.
- 10:47And, yeah, it's, it's the, the whole purpose is to recognize that
- 10:51there are those with expertise, more expertise in Congress in a specific
- 10:56area, and they are more capable of providing the details than Congress.
- 11:01This is the way the government is intended to work anyway.
- 11:05Right, and there are restrictions and agency cannot
- 11:08go beyond what a law provides.
- 11:11It can, as I said, it can define certain things.
- 11:13It can create the rules, but it can't add.
- 11:17To the law, unless Congress specifically says this agency shall say.
- 11:23Who this affects, and it does that in some respects with the consumer
- 11:27protection laws, it does give now the CFPB the authority to determine whether
- 11:33there should be any exceptions to those who are covered under the law.
- 11:37Sometimes that's in the law, but a lot of times that's left up
- 11:41to the agency and you'll, you'll find that there are exceptions.
- 11:45We know that with a number of, a number of consumer protection laws.
- 11:50Anyway, so generally speaking, we'll talk about the law and talk about a COA.
- 11:56I'm not really going to differentiate between the origin, whether it's in
- 12:01the law or the regulation, because I think it's more important that you
- 12:03hear what it is you have to comply with, regardless of where it came from.
- 12:07And you can always go look them up if you're, you're that interested.
- 12:11You got it.
- 12:12All right.
- 12:13So now first, first thing is the coverage of ECOA.
- 12:18What does it cover?
- 12:19Well, it covers all forms of credit, not just mortgage
- 12:23loans, but all sorts of loans.
- 12:26And it covers consumer credit, but also small business lending.
- 12:31And as I said, there is a new provision that we aren't going to get into the
- 12:35details, but essentially Congress decided that just because somebody is
- 12:39seeking credit as a business, that they should not be victims of discrimination.
- 12:45So there are provisions that apply to business lending as well.
- 12:51All right, now the 1st general purpose or primary purpose of ECOA, as I
- 12:56said, is to prohibit discrimination in any aspect of a credit transaction.
- 13:03And that's in quotes, any aspect of a credit transaction.
- 13:07That term is defined in Regulation B, and applicant's dealings with a
- 13:14creditor regarding the application.
- 13:18And that's pretty much from beginning.
- 13:22Of the application process, even before that, because we do, there is marketing
- 13:26involved that can be discriminatory.
- 13:30And then there are also provisions that apply to when the credit has already been.
- 13:36Provided to a borrower and what happens down the line.
- 13:41Uh, and 1, I want to point that out because a couple of years ago, there was
- 13:44a court case in which the court decided.
- 13:48That apparently, without reading the regulation that, because so much of a
- 13:54refers to applications and applicants that it only apply to the application
- 14:00process and nothing after that eventually higher courts corrected that
- 14:06because there are provisions defining.
- 14:10The different terms and application does actually for purposes refer
- 14:16also to what happens after the application has been approved.
- 14:20So, Joe, yeah, I just learned something.
- 14:23So on the advertising side, every aspect, it could be advertising
- 14:27and that I guess that would be.
- 14:29Like, a redlining situation where someone chooses not to market
- 14:32in a particular area if they're.
- 14:35If there are reasons for that were flawed because they were trying to discriminate
- 14:39that would apply to this, right?
- 14:41I right.
- 14:42Okay.
- 14:42Great.
- 14:42Yeah.
- 14:42I hadn't I the advertising piece of it.
- 14:44It just never clicked with me.
- 14:45But the way you described it there, I was very helpful.
- 14:48Yeah, there are exceptions for some types of credit, but generally speaking,
- 14:53especially for consumers, it's pretty much all credit 1 thing that I will
- 14:56talk about at some point is what's called a special purpose credit program.
- 15:02And there are, there's some other.
- 15:05Provisions that allow disparate treatment, if you will, if the party involved
- 15:12is in an economically disadvantaged class, and that treatment is beneficial
- 15:17to that person and others that are in the economically disadvantaged class.
- 15:22Well, I'll talk about that along the way, because it actually applies to a
- 15:25couple of different provisions here.
- 15:28So that's, that's essentially what is covered by ACOA.
- 15:33And the term that's used in the act of the regulation is prohibited basis
- 15:39or prohibited bases is the plural.
- 15:42The act itself ECOA contains all the prohibited bases that are
- 15:50covered by the provisions of ECOA.
- 15:53They are race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status, age.
- 16:02Whether an applicant's income derives from any public assistance program, and
- 16:07whether an applicant has in good faith exercised any right under this chapter.
- 16:14Now, this chapter is a group of laws that are considered to be
- 16:17the consumer protection laws, federal consumer protection laws.
- 16:22And I'm going to talk about each one of these specifically, so you'll get some
- 16:25idea of what is meant by these terms.
- 16:29And
- 16:321 of the 1 of the items that you also have to realize is that the prohibitions can
- 16:37extend beyond just who the applicant is.
- 16:42For example, a creditor cannot discriminate against an applicant
- 16:47because that applicant does business with somebody of a particular
- 16:50race, religion, or national origin.
- 16:53So it's, it's, it's broader than it sounds, but it's done
- 17:00to prevent discrimination.
- 17:02I mean, it still satisfies that purpose.
- 17:05Let's take a look at what these terms mean.
- 17:08Race and color mean exactly what you think they mean.
- 17:11I don't think there's any need to go into what, what the definitions are.
- 17:14They're self explanatory.
- 17:16A national origin, uh, probably also falls into that category, but under
- 17:22the official interpretation of Reg B, a creditor can consider a person's
- 17:29citizenship in some circumstances.
- 17:33They would still have to be related to the credit evaluation
- 17:36process, but here's an example.
- 17:40If the applicant would be required to provide security for the loan,
- 17:44Let's say it's a motor vehicle loan.
- 17:46The car is going to be security.
- 17:48The creditor consider can consider whether that security would be available to
- 17:52the creditor in the event of a default.
- 17:55So somebody from Europe is in the United States legitimately here,
- 18:01buys a car, gets a loan for it, but has the capacity to take that car.
- 18:08Across the Atlantic and use it there.
- 18:10The creditor who's considering the application can make the determination
- 18:18that the risk of not having the security there could be a reason to deny the loan.
- 18:23That's a great example.
- 18:25Yeah, no, that, that makes perfect sense.
- 18:27Yeah, I mean, and it does make sense.
- 18:29I mean, it's not, you know, the creditor should not be put in a position
- 18:32where it's really just, you know, a risky loan that shouldn't be made.
- 18:37Right.
- 18:39All right.
- 18:40The term sex refers to gender, at least originally referred to gender, but
- 18:46also prohibits discrimination based on sexual preference and gender identity.
- 18:51So it's kind of a broader term than it first appears and marital status.
- 18:58Was originally included here.
- 19:00In fact, the, the, the original ECOA, I think, grew out of the practice of
- 19:10mostly wives, not being able to get credit on their own because they needed
- 19:17either the creditor would require a husband to be a co signer or guarantor
- 19:21or be involved in the credit transaction because, you know, wives weren't
- 19:26considered to be a good credit risk.
- 19:27Right.
- 19:28And obviously, even even back in 1974, it was pretty obvious that
- 19:33was just purely discriminatory.
- 19:35And there was real the real basis for that kind of analysis.
- 19:40So, you know, now a spouse who applies for credit cannot be denied credit.
- 19:46If he or she qualifies on his or her own without the need to have a spouse.
- 19:54Now, couple of things.
- 19:57Number one, if that person does not qualify to get credit on their own, and
- 20:05a guarantor or co-signer is required,
- 20:10creditor cannot require the guarantor or co borrower to be the spouse
- 20:17'cause that would just be a way to get around this prohibition.
- 20:20Secondly, there is an exception to this, similar to the citizenship
- 20:25issue that I mentioned.
- 20:27And that is, there are some states where their property laws would make it so that
- 20:37if one individual applies for credit.
- 20:41That could involve security that could be impaired without the other spouse
- 20:48being part of the transaction, right?
- 20:52Generally, it's a domestic relations type of matter.
- 20:55Usually what is what happens, but the creditor can take into account
- 20:59whether the state law gives that applicant spouse an interest.
- 21:04In the property being offered as collateral again, it's
- 21:07the same same analysis.
- 21:10Would that create an undue risk?
- 21:12That would make the transaction 1 that the creditor would not approve.
- 21:17Sure.
- 21:17That makes sense to, you know, right?
- 21:19Right.
- 21:20So, you know, sometimes the laws do make sense.
- 21:23Yeah, that's good.
- 21:25It's good.
- 21:25It's good.
- 21:26When we can, we can, when we can conclude that that's true.
- 21:30Yeah.
- 21:30All right.
- 21:31Also, I do want to mention this credit unions and all other
- 21:34creditors and not evaluate
- 21:40unmarried co applicants differently than married co applicants.
- 21:47And I want to refer to a letter to credit unions that NCUA sent in February of 2022.
- 21:52The letter is 22 CU 04.
- 21:57And in that letter, the agency pointed
- 22:00out that having different risk based pricing standards for married and
- 22:05unmarried COA applicants based solely on their marital status violates ECOA.
- 22:12And the letter mentions that a common violation that NCOA examiners were
- 22:18seeing, and I believe they are still seeing, is when married co applicants
- 22:23apply for credit, the credit union will use the higher of the two credit scores.
- 22:30But when the co applicants are unmarried, the credit union will
- 22:35use the score of what it considers to be the primary applicant.
- 22:40Sometimes we ask how they determine that and we would get the answer.
- 22:44It's the one who signs the contract first, but signs the application first,
- 22:50you know, but the point is that it's marital status is what's dictating
- 22:55how the, the creditor is evaluating the applicants and that's improper.
- 23:01You're getting treated better if you're married than if not.
- 23:04And the reality is the risk is the same and it's a violation
- 23:09to discriminate against the.
- 23:12In this example, you gave choosing the lower credit score because because they
- 23:17weren't married is a clear violation.
- 23:19And unfortunately, for a lot of credit unions, that's right in there.
- 23:21It was right in their policies and procedures.
- 23:24And, in fact, I'm going to talk about this a little bit at some point down the
- 23:28line in this presentation that requires.
- 23:33The regulatory agency to refer the matter to the Department of justice to
- 23:39see if it wants to take over the case.
- 23:43So, you know, words of the wise, if if there's anything like that.
- 23:47In your policies or procedures, you need to evaluate them to make sure
- 23:51that you're not in violation of the.
- 23:54And I'm just kind of dovetails into the next one, which is age discrimination
- 23:59based on age is a violation.
- 24:01But there's a few caveats to that.
- 24:05Number 1, if the applicant is below the age.
- 24:10That.
- 24:11Of majority where the person can be bound to a contract.
- 24:16Usually, it's under the age of 18, 18 is a magic age down almost every state.
- 24:20I believe if the person is under that age of majority age can be considered
- 24:26a factor because again, you get into security because if that person can person
- 24:32can essentially renounce the contract, it becomes a problem for the creditor.
- 24:39Other than that, credit related factors are the only way to judge whether that
- 24:44a young person is entitled to credit.
- 24:47And I'll talk about that in a second.
- 24:50Well, let me just talk about it now.
- 24:53There are standards that a creditor consider, that can, the creditor can
- 24:59consider, such as length of employment.
- 25:02Now, length of employment would have to be a reasonable amount of time.
- 25:07It could not just be a proxy for age.
- 25:09Thank you.
- 25:10Uh, it can't be such a long period of time that somebody, let's say 21, you
- 25:14know, could never qualify because they hadn't been working since they were
- 25:19age 10 or something along those lines.
- 25:20That's an extreme example, but that's that's the idea is that it has to be
- 25:25a legitimate consideration and not 1 just because the creditor doesn't
- 25:29want to loan to really young people.
- 25:32Joe, when you're, when you're, when you're talking through that,
- 25:35I'm thinking about the Columbia.
- 25:37Record thing that you could join back in the day where you'd get, you'd get 12,
- 25:4212 or 13 tapes or record albums for a penny and you'd tape your penny on it.
- 25:48And then after that, you'd have to, you'd have to buy six or
- 25:51eight, six or eight albums that, you know, at an inflated price.
- 25:56And I remember at my school there, there was.
- 25:59An understanding that if you were under 18, you could do that.
- 26:02You could get those 15 record albums for a penny.
- 26:04And then when they, when they told you that they, that you needed
- 26:07to live up to the terms of the contract, you weren't 18 yet.
- 26:10So you couldn't, they couldn't demand that you then buy those next overpriced.
- 26:16Absolutely.
- 26:18So, yeah, I do.
- 26:20I'm older than you.
- 26:21I remember that.
- 26:23So, all right.
- 26:24But a couple of things.
- 26:25First, it is permissible for a creditor to use age to provide a
- 26:30benefit to an elderly applicant.
- 26:32That's a term that's used.
- 26:33I'm not using any kind of disparaging term.
- 26:36It says right in there, elderly applicant, and maybe it is disparaging
- 26:40because elderly for a code means 62 years or older, which I'm not.
- 26:44I'm not sure that qualifies as elderly these days, but that's what exactly.
- 26:49Yeah, so if it's a benefit to somebody in that age category, 60 to 62 or
- 26:54older, then age can be considered.
- 26:57And now there's another provision that allows a creditor to use a
- 27:01system that does consider age, but under very narrow circumstances.
- 27:06It can't be a negative value or factor for an elderly applicant using that same
- 27:12definition and the creditor has to use.
- 27:15I'm using terms now directly from the regulation and empirically
- 27:19derived credit system, which considers age that is demonstrably
- 27:24and statistically sound in accordance with the rest of regulation being.
- 27:30I don't want to get into too much discussion about this, but I
- 27:35can tell you in my time at NCUA.
- 27:37Okay.
- 27:37I never saw such a system.
- 27:39There were no, there were, there were credit unions who
- 27:42had standards where there was a minimum age for certain things.
- 27:47They did not have a way to prove that they, the system was statistically
- 27:53or demonstrably sound, demonstrably easy for me to say sound.
- 27:58So I would, I would exercise caution if you're thinking
- 28:02about doing something like that.
- 28:04And finally.
- 28:06Age can be considered if there's an inquiry for the purpose of determining
- 28:12the amount and probable continuance of income levels, credit history or other
- 28:18pertinent element of credit worthiness.
- 28:20And there's some, some further fleshing out of that in the regulations.
- 28:25And that same 2022 letter to credit unions that I mentioned with respect
- 28:30to marital status does talk about the age discrimination issue.
- 28:36And what it specifically refers to is this.
- 28:40These are again, things that examiners were finding on a regular basis, and I
- 28:44think they still are and that is where there were automated underwriting systems.
- 28:50That were set to kick out from the automated underwriting system.
- 28:54Those who are under a specified age.
- 28:56I remember 1 credit union has 3 or 4 different ages, depending on the product.
- 29:03They, they were sent to manual underwriting and what we heard almost
- 29:09in every credit union where we found these was, well, we send them the
- 29:13manual underwriting, but we weren't denying them for for those reasons.
- 29:19The mere fact that someone was being evaluated by a different system because
- 29:25of a prohibited basis was the violation.
- 29:29And again, the N.
- 29:30C.
- 29:30U.
- 29:31A.
- 29:31was required to refer several credit unions to the Department of justice.
- 29:36Because of those violations, so I would caution you haven't done this recently.
- 29:41Take a look at your policies and procedures and see if there's
- 29:45anything like that in them, because it's a potential problem.
- 29:50Very good.
- 29:50You have a referral to the Department of Justice.
- 29:52It's not something that NCOA does lightly and it's not something if you're out
- 29:56there in credit union land, you want to have on your resume if you were exactly
- 30:01now, the the referrals themselves.
- 30:04Are not a matter of public record.
- 30:07They do become public if the Department of Justice decides to keep that referral.
- 30:12And handle a case, they will, they will make it public, but until.
- 30:17Unless that is done, it doesn't, doesn't do that.
- 30:20The, the agency does.
- 30:23Provide the number of referrals per year to other agencies as required by law, but
- 30:29the names are not are not made public.
- 30:31However, you run the risk of D.
- 30:34O.
- 30:34J.
- 30:35keeping 1 of those and.
- 30:37This just as Mark said, it's not something you want.
- 30:40So, all right now, the last 2 prohibited bases 1 is income derived
- 30:46from a public assistance program.
- 30:48Somewhat somewhat obvious if somebody has income from, let's say, disability.
- 30:54You have a permanent disability or something along those lines, social
- 30:58security income, just the mere fact that the income is not from an occupation,
- 31:04but it's from public assistance of some sort is not enough to deny a
- 31:09person if they're otherwise qualified.
- 31:12However, same as with age.
- 31:15There can be an inquiry, inquiry made to determine the amount and
- 31:19probable continuance of income levels.
- 31:22If somebody is receiving benefits that have an end date, that can be
- 31:26considered when deciding whether the person has the requisite
- 31:32qualifications credit for a credit, they're going to be able to continue
- 31:37to pay for the duration of whatever the credit is it's being considered.
- 31:41But that's the only reason.
- 31:43And then finally, the prohibited basis of denying somebody credit or the terms of
- 31:50the credit, not being the same as other people, based on the fact that somebody
- 31:56exercised rights under certain laws.
- 32:01As I mentioned, it's the Consumer Credit Protection Act is the name of the section.
- 32:08Of the federal laws that contain a co and a number of other laws, such
- 32:12as a fair credit reporting act, a fair debt collection practices act
- 32:16or electronic fund transfer act and also the truth and lending act.
- 32:20So, let's suppose somebody, um, ends up suing the credit union because
- 32:26there is a truth and lending violation.
- 32:28And they lost some money from it somehow or other, uh, and then a couple of
- 32:32years later applies for credit with the credit union, the credit union.
- 32:36Cannot deny the application or change the terms that are being applied for
- 32:44solely because that person sued the credit union under one of these laws.
- 32:49Got it.
- 32:49Yeah, you can't you can't discriminate against me for pursuing my rights.
- 32:54Exactly.
- 32:55Okay.
- 32:56Well, you know, Joe, there's been a lot to.
- 32:59We've talked about a lot already.
- 33:00I know we got more that we want to talk about, including a second primary
- 33:04function and, you know, special, I think some, some other provisions like
- 33:08the special purpose credit program.
- 33:11And then I think we're going to do a little bit more of a discussion on the
- 33:15referral program to the department of judge department of justice, but this is
- 33:19a good spot to kind of break this one.
- 33:23If not in two, break it in two thirds on the front end
- 33:25and one third on the back end.
- 33:27So John, I want to thank you.
- 33:28For what you've already said, and let's start back up with a, with a
- 33:33second take on this topic here shortly.
- 33:36Thanks, Jim.
- 33:37Thank you, Mark.
- 33:38You got it.
- 33:39And listeners, I want to thank you for listening to this
- 33:41episode of With Flying Colors.
- 33:43There'll be the next episode in queue will be part two of this topic.
- 33:48I want to thank you for listening and this is Mark Treichel
- 33:51signing off with Flying Colors.
- 34:02for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 34:05Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 34:09experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 34:14If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 34:17out our services at marktreichel.
- 34:19com.