Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #16: Week 2 Review, auditing the AP Voters and Week 3 high leverage games
Transcript
- 0:17Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Cents Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume, not the expectations.
- 0:24This is episode number 16, where we will be recapping week two.
- 0:28We'll be going over the new conference pecking order in college football.
- 0:32We have a brand-new top 25 to discuss.
- 0:35We'll audit the AP poll for this week, and then we'll talk about the highest leverage games of week three.
- 0:42Nearly every FBS team played in week two.
- 0:45Northwestern is about to go 11 straight weeks with football, while Florida State and Stanford get the benefit of two byes this season after playing in both week zero and week one.
- 0:5537 teams matched up against an FCS school, including 10 of last week's CSR top 25, meaning a lot of turnover is about to happen between weeks.
- 1:04If we're looking to rank teams early in the season, especially before conference play really takes off, we have to look at head-to-head match-ups between conferences to determine which is best and consequently, which will be giving victors more points.
- 1:18Uh, at the top of our conference rankings for the second straight week is the Southeastern Conference.
- 1:23They went into week two with a winning record head-to-head against eight of the other nine conferences, with the one missing being the Big Ten.
- 1:29Fortunately, three match-ups between the SEC and Big Ten in week two would settle the score quickly.
- 1:35First, Michigan gave the Big Ten the edge in their win over Oklahoma as Jordan Marshall put Big Blue ahead for good with about eight minutes to go.
- 1:44Mississippi State traveled up to Minnesota to take on the Golden Gophers in game number two, where the Bulldogs trounced the home team 38-13.
- 1:51The SEC-Big Ten battle then would all come down to the biggest game of the week, Ohio State taking on Texas.
- 1:58Ohio State took a 20-point lead into the fourth quarter, but Texas converted several key third and fourth downs throughout the last 15 minutes and completed the comeback with less than 30 seconds remaining to give the Longhorns the win and the SEC a two-one victory over the Big Ten this season.
- 2:13Following week two, it's going to be tough for any other conference to catch the SEC.
- 2:18The SEC is guaranteed a winning record against seven conferences at the end of the season, with the only two left to be decided against the ACC, which it could clinch this week, and the Mountain West, which Oklahoma looks to finish off this week in their tilt with New Mexico.
- 2:31If we're talking 2026 exclusively, no conference can claim superiority over the SEC.
- 2:37So what does this mean?
- 2:38It means an SEC win, whether it's a team inside or outside the conference, is going to be worth the most compared to wins to other conferences.
- 2:46For comparison's sake, a win over an SEC school is currently worth double that of a win over a MAC or a Conference USA school Next, you would think we'd be talking about the Big 10, however, they were second among the conferences last week, but ACC took that spot this week, having a winning record against six other conferences.
- 3:06The Big 10 went one and O against the ACC in week one, but in week two, Boston College beat Rutgers Friday night, Wake Forest beat Purdue early Saturday, and Duke beat Illinois to flip the script.
- 3:18In just one week of games, the ACC secured a winning record head-to-head against the Big 10 for the duration of the season.
- 3:25That gives them a sixth conference against which they are winning head-to-head and put them second in the CSR conference rankings.
- 3:32The pivotal game moving forward for the ACC will be Virginia's matchup with West Virginia in week three.
- 3:37That will give the opportunity for the ACC to go to a winning record against the Big 12 as well, getting closer to the SEC and the CSR.
- 3:45Fortunately for the Big Ten, they didn't fall far, losing just a spot to the ACC and moving to third in the common sense rankings.
- 3:52Losing two of three to the SEC hurt, but losing all three week two games against the ACC was unexpected, and will leave the Big Ten trying to catch up the rest of the season.
- 4:03They do have the benefit of getting their one game against Conference USA coming up in week three.
- 4:07So if Indiana can beat Western Kentucky at home, they would secure a sixth conference at the end of the coming week.
- 4:13They also have their final game against the Big 12, giving them another opportunity to improve in the CSR The American Conference has a winning record against four conferences, putting them slightly behind the Big Ten so far this season.
- 4:26The Tulsa win over Oklahoma State is proving monumental in the common sense rankings, as it was the first of just two matchups between the American and Big 12.
- 4:35Courtesy of Tulsa's win, the American currently sports a winning head-to-head over the Big 12.
- 4:40With just one game between the American and Big 12 remaining, the Big 12 can't fully reverse the script, but they can take the American Conference down a peg if Kansas State can beat Tulane.
- 4:49If you thought the Big 12 would come next, you would be wrong, because next up is the rebuilt Pac-12.
- 4:54They came out of week one praising the Colorado State Rams as they beat Wyoming from the Mountain West to give them a little bump in the CSR.
- 5:01But in week two, Fresno State beat Sacramento State, and Boise State beat Memphis on the Smurf Turf to give them three total conferences against which they are above.500.
- 5:10Here with two conference head-to-heads to their name is the Big 12, who is currently tied with the Mountain West in s- at sixth in the common sense rankings.
- 5:18The Big 12 has the most to gain from the rest of non-conference schedules since they have yet to play either of their two matchups against Conference USA, MAC, or Mountain West.
- 5:27They'll need to win both games against all three conferences to have a hope of catching the rest of the traditional Power Four.
- 5:33The Mountain West had a discouraging week two with two teams losing to FCS schools.
- 5:38However, they're undefeated against the MAC and Conference USA, so they get credit for those records against FBS conferences.
- 5:43As mentioned previously, they have yet to play against the Big 12, but they're also waiting the lone matchup the Mountain West has with the Sun Belt this season, so they do have an outside chance of improving in the next couple weeks.
- 5:54Our final three conferences in order are the Sun Belt, who has yet to play the MAC or Mountain West, and then the MAC and Conference USA falling to the bottom of the common sense conference rankings.
- 6:06So based on these conference strength rankings, a win over an SEC team is currently maxed out in the CSR formula.
- 6:12A win over an ACC school will count second most, followed by a Big Ten third most.
- 6:17On the flip side, a loss to an SEC school will hurt you as little as a loss can in the CSR formulas.
- 6:24Before we launch into what the top 25 looks like, I wanna give some side-by-side resumes to see how the AP voters did in their evaluations this week.
- 6:32So first, Team A has wins over an ACC and Pac-12 team.
- 6:36One of their opponents also has an FBS win.
- 6:39Team B has a win over a Big 12 team and an FCS team, and that Big 12 w- team does not have another FBS victory.
- 6:47So which team do you think would be ranked?
- 6:50If you're paying attention to what I'm saying, you'd hopefully agree that it should be Team A, which is UCLA in this scenario.
- 6:55UCLA got nine AP votes while Team B, BYU, is ranked 11th in the AP.
- 7:02Let's do another one.
- 7:03Team A's only win is against a Mountain West school, and they lost their other game to a Big Ten team.
- 7:08That Mountain West school they beat does not yet have an FBS win.
- 7:12Team B has wins over both the Big 12 and Conference USA, and that Big 12 team they beat also has a Big Ten team beat this season.
- 7:19Team B you'd think would have a better resume.
- 7:21Well, and that team would be Tulsa, who scraped just 18 votes this week while Team A, Oklahoma, ranks 24th after their loss to Michigan.
- 7:30Last one.
- 7:31Team A has wins over an American team that has a further FBS win and a Big T- Ten team who also has an FBS win, so they've proven they're better than four teams so far this season.
- 7:41Team B has an FCS win and a victory over an 0-2 Conference USA team.
- 7:45So who deserves the number next to their name?
- 7:48You would think it'd be Team A, which would be Duke, but they have zero votes in the AP poll.
- 7:53Meanwhile, Team B is the University of Georgia, who is ranked second and actually received three first place votes following week two.
- 8:01So moving on to the Common Sense Rankings top 25, the number one team in the land is Southern Cal.
- 8:08They were one of two teams that had the opportunity to go to 3-0 this season, but the only one to accomplish the feat.
- 8:14They have wins against San Jose State from the Mountain West, Fresno State from the Pac-12, and Louisiana from the Sun Belt, giving them wins against three other conferences.
- 8:22They also have 50% more wins than any other team in the country, and each of them is against FBS competition.
- 8:28Since so few games have been played, that carries enough weight to make the Trojans number one.
- 8:33At number two is a team that got no AP votes.
- 8:35That is the Duke Blue Devils.
- 8:37While their wins don't carry as much weight as a couple other teams, the fact that Illinois and Tulane both have wins against FBS competition boosts their stock in the CSR and gives them that number two slot.
- 8:50At number three is a team you either love or love to hate, the Alabama Crimson Tide.
- 8:54Their win over Kentucky is amongst the best in the country currently, given an SEC win means as much as it possibly can in the CSR formula.
- 9:02They also picked up a win against the fourth best conference in week one, beating East Carolina to kick off the season.
- 9:07What puts them behind Duke is neither Kentucky nor East Carolina has beat another FBS team so far, so opponent win points are still at zero.
- 9:15That will change as the season continues and both ECU and UK pick up wins.
- 9:20Fourth is a little controversial because it is the AP number one.
- 9:23That is the Texas Longhorns.
- 9:25I understand why the voters put them number one.
- 9:27They beat the previous number one team and were already ranked fourth in the previous poll.
- 9:31The Longhorns get the benefit of that Big Ten win, plus some additional points for the Ohio State's MAC win, and the Longhorns get a Pac-12 win after beating Texas State in week one, and they get additional points for Texas State's win over UTSA in week two.
- 9:45That puts them firmly in the fourth position after two weeks.
- 9:49Fifth is the UCLA Bruins.
- 9:50Similar to the Duke Blue Devils, they are unranked in the AP poll, but at least received nine votes.
- 9:55Small victories, we'll, we'll take them.
- 9:57The Bruins have picked up wins against an ACC and Pac-12 opponent, but the quality of wins from those teams doesn't quite bump them up higher than fifth.
- 10:04A win over Purdue in week three, however, could move the needle for UCLA, especially if the Big Ten can win their key match-ups this week Continuing down the top 25, we have five teams to round out the top 10 that all made an appearance in the AP poll.
- 10:17You have Michigan with their win over Oklahoma and another team from the MAC, plus they get credit for Oklahoma's week one win.
- 10:24The Ole Miss Rebels are in number seven.
- 10:26They have wins over both the ACC and American conferences.
- 10:29Number eight is Notre Dame with a win over Big Ten and American.
- 10:33LSU is at nine, and then Penn State is at number 10.
- 10:38Quickly listing off the rest of the top 25, you got 11 Mississippi State, Washington at 12, and yes, I know they only beat Utah State by a couple, but a win is a win in the CSR.
- 10:49Number 13 is South Florida who would take a spot in the hypothetical college football playoff bracket as the group of six representative.
- 10:5614, Wake Forest, 15, Tulsa, 16, Iowa, 17, Auburn, 18, Texas A&M, 19, Pitt, number 20, North Dakota State, FBS newcomer, 21 is Nebraska, 22 is Michigan State, 23, Utah, 24, Cincinnati, and 25, Miami.
- 11:13Both the 24th and 25th ranked teams, Cincinnati and Miami, are the highest ranked teams that have just one FBS win after beating an FCS school in week two.
- 11:23Although half the Big Ten had a bad week, the other half beat quality opponents giving the Big Ten eight schools in the CSR top 25.
- 11:30The SEC then has seven, the ACC four, the American and Big 12 each have two, then the last two spots are NDSU from the Mountain West and Notre Dame.
- 11:39If I haven't mentioned your favorite team and you wanna see where they shake out in the CSR, visit commonsenserankings.com to see the full list of FBS programs.
- 11:48As we piece together our college football playoff bracket according to this week's Common Sense rankings, we see USC, Duke, Alabama, and Texas earning the byes to the quarterfinals.
- 11:58The first-round games would include UCLA hosting South Florida in LA.
- 12:02Although South Florida is ranked 13th in the CSR, they would get the last spot as the highest-ranked group of 16, taking the place of Washington.
- 12:10Number six Michigan would host number 11 Mississippi State.
- 12:14Number seven Ole Miss would be playing Penn State, and number eight Notre Dame would welcome number nine LSU to South Bend.
- 12:21The top three teams not in the bracket this week are Washington, Wake Forest, and Tulsa.
- 12:28Let's talk a little bit about the curious case of Ohio State.
- 12:31They dropped from number one to number six in the AP poll, which isn't significant, but they're nowhere to be found in the Common Sense rankings.
- 12:38It's here where I remind you that the CSR ranks the resume with no assumptions made about future performance.
- 12:44So what do we know about the Buckeyes?
- 12:45They lost to Texas and beat Ball State.
- 12:48So with the information we have so far this season, those teams provide the upper and lower limit for the Buckeyes ranking.
- 12:55What do we know about Texas, the team to which they lost?
- 12:57We know they're better than Ohio State, we know they're better than Texas State, and through those teams, we know they're better than UTSA and Ball State.
- 13:04We know the Ball State Cardinals are worse than the Buckeyes and better than an FCS school.
- 13:08There isn't a world where we can confidently conclude the Buckeyes have the sixth best resume in the sport.
- 13:13Until they beat more teams, especially teams with other wins, Ohio State will likely stay below several, quote-unquote,"less deserving" undefeated teams.
- 13:22Let's now turn our attention to the AP poll, which did not show much improvement from the previous week.
- 13:28A reminder that the Associated Press, who sponsors the poll, gives its voters very clear instructions for voting.
- 13:34They are meant to base their votes on performance on the field, ignoring preseason expectations or brand name recognition.
- 13:40They are asked to make weekly changes based on game outcomes and consider head-to-head results.
- 13:44So let's see where they erred.
- 13:46First off, somebody missed the deadline to send in their AP vote, so we only had sixty-eight of the sixty-nine ballots returned this week.
- 13:53I gotta call out Sean Reiter from the Albuquerque Journal for missing his wake-up alarm.
- 13:58They stayed stagnant by ranking twelve of the top twenty-five most deserving resumes this week.
- 14:03On the field, Tulsa beat Oklahoma State, who beat Oregon, but in the poll, Oregon is above Oklahoma State, who is above Tulsa.
- 14:12Eleven of the AP ranked teams have half their, of two wins against FCS competition, and one more, Louisville, can only claim a win against an FCS team so far this season.
- 14:22Lastly, the biggest miss was Duke.
- 14:24Two wins over FBS opponents and not a single voter threw a spot on their ballot to the Blue Devils.
- 14:28I can't quite understand that one.
- 14:32So which voters did well?
- 14:33David Jablonsky gets his second shout-out in as many weeks.
- 14:35He's joined by Ralph Russo, who's also taking on-the-field results seriously.
- 14:40Of all the voters, I believe they are the only two to have Tulsa above Oklahoma State above Oregon.
- 14:46Russo has them one right after another at twenty, twenty-one, and twenty-two, while Jablonsky has Tulsa at twenty-three, OK State at twenty-four, and Oregon unranked.
- 14:56There are two more, Dylan Sinn, who also got a shout-out last week, and David Briggs, who had Tulsa on their ballot, but neither Oregon nor Oklahoma State.
- 15:03Next, I want to shout out the six voters that had Mississippi State on their ballots.
- 15:07The Bulldogs are the CSR number eleven and deserved more love than they got, after beating UL Monroe and Minnesota to start the season.
- 15:14Those six voters were Adam Lichtenstein, Bob Balogh, Dylan Sinn again, Cokie Riley, Reese Davis, and Steven Means So who deserves to be audited?
- 15:24I believe John Wilner tied for the most one-loss teams ranked in his ballots this week, which is a cardinal sin in the CSR.
- 15:30He has Ohio State at number two, Louisville, Western Michigan, Oklahoma, Oregon, and Boise State all in his top 25.
- 15:37He's one of two voters with six one-loss teams on his ballot, and I called out the other last week, so I want to make sure I'm criticizing equally amongst the voters.
- 15:45We had three voters put UGA first, Nick Jacobs, Kirk Kenny, and David Pascal.
- 15:49While I have no doubt UGA will continue to win following their offensive explosion so far this season, their resume right now includes just a win over an FCS team and an 0-2 CUSA team.
- 16:00That resume is unequivocally not the best in the sport.
- 16:04I want to specifically mention Dylan Sinigan.
- 16:06He continues to fascinate me with his ballots.
- 16:09He is the only person to put UCLA on his ballot, giving them all nine points that they accrued this week.
- 16:15He was also one of six voters with Mississippi State on their ballot, which is a good call.
- 16:18But then on the flip side, he was the other voter that had six one-loss teams among his top 25, and he has Miami as his number one team, even with just one FBS win to their name.
- 16:29I'm dying to interview this guy if anybody listening happens to have an in in interviewing with Dylan.
- 16:34So he is-- his ballot is one I'm looking forward to every week moving forward So what games carry the highest leverage in week three?
- 16:43We have our highest ranked game in both the CSR and the AP poll in LSU at Ole Miss.
- 16:48If you've been living under a rock, former h- Ole Miss head coach Lane Kiffin left to lead LSU in the off-season, abandoning the Rebels for their shot at the national championship.
- 16:58It was ugly, and now he's going back.
- 17:00They'll also be the highest ranked matchup of the week, and whichever team wins will likely be near the top of next week's Common Sense rankings.
- 17:07The other CSR-ranked matchups are Wake Forest, Miami, Notre Dame, Michigan State, and then the CSR number 17 Auburn plays Florida this week who is just outside the top 25.
- 17:18By conference, the Big Ten will look to steady the ship as they took some blows in week two.
- 17:23Week three will feature the Big Ten's only matchup against Conference USA when Indiana hosts Western Kentucky at four o'clock Eastern on Peacock The Big Ten will also have must-win game against the Big 12 as Northwestern battles Coach Prime's Colorado Buffaloes in Evanston at 7:30 Eastern on Fox.
- 17:40The Big Ten and Big 12 are currently tied one-one head-to-head so far this season, so a Wildcats win would get the Big Ten a little closer to the SEC and likely ahead of the ACC.
- 17:50But the Buffaloes win would close the gap between the Big 12 and the Big Ten in the CSR.
- 17:55Lastly, the Big Ten would appreciate a Michigan win over UTEP to solidify a winning record in 2026 against the Mountain West.
- 18:02The SEC has one game that'll have their attention for conference superiority in week three.
- 18:06That'll be the Oklahoma Sooners game against the New Mexico Lobos.
- 18:10A New Mexico upset would put the SEC and Mountain West at one and one, lowering the SEC in the eyes of the CSR.
- 18:16But a Sooner win would all but guarantee the SEC's second straight year with a winning record against every other conference.
- 18:23If the SEC can also win both matchups against the ACC this week, they will lock up winning records against all nine other conferences.
- 18:30Those games are Alabama-Florida State at 3:30 on ABC, and Vanderbilt then hosts NC State at 12:45 on SEC Network.
- 18:39The Big Twelve has their rubber match with the Big Ten with Colorado playing Northwestern, but they're also tied two-two against the ACC this year.
- 18:46The fifth matchup there is Virginia versus West Virginia, which is seven-thirty p.m.
- 18:50Eastern on ACC Network.
- 18:52If Colorado and West Virginia both win, it'd pull the Big Twelve back into range of the other Power Four conferences.
- 18:58The Big Twelve will also play their first games against three new conferences this season.
- 19:02Cincinnati hosts Miami, Ohio from the MAC, and Iowa State hosts Bowling Green in another Big Twelve-MAC matchup.
- 19:08Arizona hosts Northern Illinois from the Mountain West.
- 19:11If the Big Twelve can win all five of those games, it'll move from having a plus-five-hundred record against two conferences all the way up to six, likely putting it level with the ACC and Big Ten if favorites win elsewhere.
- 19:23The biggest games for the ACC have already been mentioned, as several teams will play in-conference in week three.
- 19:28FSU's game with Alabama and NC State's game at Vandy are must-wins if the ACC has any chance of pulling off a comeback against the SEC this season.
- 19:37Virginia's matchup with West Virginia will decide the head-to-head between the ACC and Big Twelve.
- 19:41Virginia Tech-Maryland, which still a game the Hokies want to win, holds less importance as the ACC has already locked up a head-to-head victory over the Big Ten in twenty twenty-six.
- 19:52Amongst the group of six conferences, the American kicks off the first two of four matchups with the MAC this season.
- 19:57Temple plays Toledo, and Rice plays Western Michigan.
- 20:00If the American wins both, they'll move up the CSR conference rankings, going from four conferences to five conferences against which they have winning records.
- 20:08The American will also need to win its final three matchups with the Pac-12, with the next being North Texas' game against Texas State on Saturday.
- 20:16The Sun Belt and MAC will play their only game all season when Ohio kicks off with South Alabama at seven o'clock on ESPN+.
- 20:22The MAC is still bottom of the pile in the CSR, so a Bobcats win would get them out of the basement.
- 20:28The Sun Belt plays the Pac-12 for the first and only time on Saturday when James Madison heads to San Diego State for a ten o'clock kickoff on the CW.
- 20:35Those games give the Sun Belt an opportunity to get themselves a better conference rank in the CSR.
- 20:42Through two weeks of games, the Big Ten and Big Twelve are the conferences in the most need of finishing non-conference play strong, while the ACC has likely overperformed so far this season.
- 20:51The Big Twelve has the biggest opportunity in week three to increase their spot in the twenty twenty-six rankings, while the Sun Belt also has a good chance to pick up some key wins this week.
- 21:00There will be fewer updates throughout the coming week and no podcast next week as the family and I are taking some much-needed vacation.
- 21:06Expect the website to be delayed as well, but I'll likely cover multiple weeks of games on the next podcast.
- 21:11Thank you for joining me for another CSR podcast where we rank resumes, not expectations.
- 21:17As you go about your day-to-day, please use some common sense