Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Dirty John (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07So, Burdo, have you listened to that new podcast called Dirty John?
- 0:12I did, Yes. What do you think of the title of that podcast
- 0:15called It's Dirty John. It's a provocative title. Yeah, I had some
- 0:20other podcasts I listened to was advertising for it, and they played a little
- 0:26bit of it and I and I just said, I think I've had enough
- 0:30of these kinds of podcasts where there's some psychopath does something horrible, sure,
- 0:37and the way they're presenting it, it's like, oh scary, you know,
- 0:41there's I feel like there's this huge trend on podcast in the podcast world
- 0:46right now where everything has to be scary. Sure, like in the in
- 0:51the in the mid two thousands. When I when we came on the scene
- 0:56in two thousand and eight, they were mainly educational, Yeah, very topic
- 1:00driven, Like I listened to some that were video game related and stuff like
- 1:04that. Right, and then it seemed like there were like science y kinds
- 1:08of podcasts, you know, like like Radio Lab and this sort of thing.
- 1:15And then all of a sudden, it seemed like overnight every popular podcast
- 1:22now is It's About It's about Like is are basically many documentaries on the scariest
- 1:30human stuff that's ever, you know, whereas I thought when I heard the
- 1:33title, I thought it was about prostitution. That's funny. It didn't even
- 1:38occur to me. So at first I was like, yeah, I think
- 1:42I've had enough of this sort of thing. And there's so many other great
- 1:44podcasts out there that I'm behind on listening to. So but then you reached
- 1:49out to me and you're like, hey, have you heard this Dirty John
- 1:53podcast? We should do it. We should do an episode on it.
- 1:56And I looked at it and it's only like seven episodes. I think,
- 2:00yeah, okay, and it's not very doesn't take very long to listen.
- 2:02No, it's not a huge investment. It's probably like what four hours,
- 2:07three hours or something, right, and so, man, it has an
- 2:10ending. There's it's not like an open ended thing. It's it's basically one
- 2:15story in about three hours of listening, right, and when one thing I
- 2:17liked about we haven't even started. This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast.
- 2:23I'm your host, doctor Kirk Kanda. I'm a therapist and a professor.
- 2:25Who are you, beto? My name is Umberto Casana, and I trained
- 2:30people on how to use fidget spinners correctly. So what were you going to
- 2:34say? Well, I was gonna say that, like, you know.
- 2:37I first, I literally did think it was about prostitution because I thought,
- 2:40you know, John, dirty John. You know. And the only reason
- 2:45I started listening to it is because I was scrolling through dig and I saw
- 2:50this thing. I was like, oh, dirty John, but I didn't
- 2:52I didn't like think about it. I thought, oh, it must be
- 2:53about prostitution. And then it came up again and I saw something about like
- 2:58like the picture of the guy and it's said something about like you know this.
- 3:01It did make it sound like sort of scary, and I was like
- 3:04okay, and I started listening. But I actually found that what was fascinating
- 3:10to me is that I was expecting it to be like and here it was
- 3:15his first murder, and here was a second murder, right, But what
- 3:19was so much real and more relatable on everyday life was that, yeah,
- 3:23this was a psychopath type person, but but sort of a person you could
- 3:29run into. Yeah, so we're going to spoil the whole thing spoiler alerts
- 3:32because we hate having to edit ourselves. So and it does have a surprise
- 3:39ending that isn't like if it was spoiled for you. If it was spoiled
- 3:45for me, it wouldn't. It wouldn't completely ruin it for me, No
- 3:49if, but it is. It is a twist at the end. But
- 3:53really the big appeal of this podcast is just hearing about the story and so
- 3:58it can't really be spoiled in my view. But basically, it's about a
- 4:01woman, Deborah. She's a successful interior designer. You know. She's a
- 4:08woman who's I think it's been married like three other times or something. And
- 4:12she's wealthy, and she's in her fifties or something. And she meets a
- 4:16guy named John, and he's a hands on on like match dot com or
- 4:21something. And he's a handsome man who seems to have it all. He's
- 4:28attractive, he's single. He he's a doctor with doctors without borders. He's
- 4:35done all these dashing things like jumped out of helicopters in Iraq and everything.
- 4:40And he's an asiologist. How do you say an esthetiologist, an esthetician?
- 4:45An esthetician Wait, no, anesthesiologist an a stesiologist. Esthetician is something else.
- 4:51I don't know. It's so hard well I don't know either. But
- 4:55he makes people fall asleep, so they so you can be cut into a
- 4:59surgery. But so, you know, she meets this guy in match and
- 5:03she starts dating him, and her family, her kids, her two daughters
- 5:08in particular, hate this guy immediately. Yeah, right away, they're just
- 5:11like, something's wrong with this guy. Which, which, by the way,
- 5:14that right off the bat was so interesting to me because this person,
- 5:20the same person right is able to come off so well to her and so
- 5:29bad to very close people to her, and presumably she was observing him,
- 5:34because it didn't indicate like you know, it's the one thing of initially he
- 5:39pulled them aside and it's like, ah, I'm actually evil and I want
- 5:42all your guys' money. But that's not the case. It's just they saw
- 5:45his interactions with her and with them, and they concluded, Okay, there's
- 5:48something wrong with this guy. Right. So the reason why I think it's
- 5:53a worthy episode for our podcast is the whole story is a case study in
- 6:01a family as it faces a new member of the family who has massive psychological
- 6:10issues, and how that all plays out and how to see it, I
- 6:16think is interesting. And so maybe since you introduced that, I think maybe
- 6:20we should go into that a little bit in terms of why do you think
- 6:24that is and how do we see it and how do you think the podcast?
- 6:28The other thing I should say before I forget is that so the podcast
- 6:30was made by Christopher Gofford for the La Times. Apparently now publications are making
- 6:39podcasts like there was that one that was made by I think it was like
- 6:45the Des Moines and Inquirer something or the Ohio and some Midwest that's called the
- 6:50Inquirer, which I find to be a very unfortunate name because the whole podcast
- 6:56was about they're investigating the murder of this one woman. I think it is
- 7:00a pretty interesting episode. And she kept saying, I'm so and so from
- 7:02the Inquirer, and I'm like, really the Inquirer, but that's the National
- 7:06Inquiry. Apparently there's like, you know, the Springfield Enquirer. But anyways,
- 7:13but it's interesting that a lot of these traditional publications are now sponsoring podcasts,
- 7:23which makes total sense because you have a team of reporters, you have
- 7:27an editorial staff, you have advertisers, you know how to put a story
- 7:32together, you have writers, you know, and and so that's what this
- 7:35is, is this Christopher Gofford. I think that's how you pronounce this name?
- 7:40For the La Times has been doing stories like this all the time,
- 7:44and then he just then they just decided to record all of his conversations with
- 7:49all these people, which is is it's and the way it's all put together,
- 7:54and the way he asked questions, and the the kind of journey that
- 7:57they take you on. It's pretty interesting. And again it's you know,
- 7:59it doesn't too long. But anyway, so why what is our conceptualization of
- 8:05this guy psychologically? Because basically right from the start, so let's just go
- 8:11on this fact. Let's just summarize the facts. He starts dating, well,
- 8:16let's spoil the whole thing and go back back in time. I mean,
- 8:18when he starts dating her, the facade he's putting for her is almost
- 8:22one hundred percent fabricated. You know, he's not a certain or not a
- 8:28true doctor. He's a nurse and he doesn't hasn't flown in these missions and
- 8:33things like that. He is actually homeless. He's currently un he's currently unemployed,
- 8:39and he just got out of prison. God, out of prison.
- 8:43He went into prison for what again, Like was it money fraud or something
- 8:48or yeah, yeah, it was because that was the other thing is he
- 8:52comes from a family of basically sort of at least friendly to crime, sort
- 8:56of back. Right, So let's just briefly summarize this life. He grows
- 9:01up in a family in which his father was was actively encouraging his kids to
- 9:07involve themselves in scams and criminal activity and intimidation. His dad, like they
- 9:15talked to Dirty John's sister, I think, and the sister is saying things
- 9:20like our parents were awful, awful people, I think is what she was
- 9:24saying. And they were uh, terrible parents and taught terrible lessons. And
- 9:31it sounds like Dirty John's father was kind of a con man himself and an
- 9:37aggressive person, and and and would say and was like would tell people that
- 9:41he was involved with with the with the mob, even though it's questionable whether
- 9:45or not that's true. And and then Dirty John adapted that. Right,
- 9:48It's like Dirty John's just like his dad, or a worse version of his
- 9:52dad or something. And then and then he Dirty John grows up. The
- 9:56reason why they called him dirty John is because he he was so shady in
- 10:01college and in his twenties that his friends started calling him dirty John because they
- 10:05just observed his behavior was. He was always trying to figure out a scam.
- 10:11He was always working an angle, and he was exploitative of women.
- 10:16And yeah, he got the sense that a lot of it had to do
- 10:18with his behavior around women. And they said in that Bouchelor party interview,
- 10:24they were like, oh, well, you know what I mean. We
- 10:26call him like filthy John or whatever, but we can't really talk about why
- 10:31right now. And so he goes to college and he becomes a nurse and
- 10:37he specializes in anesthesiology and he starts to work. He gets married and he
- 10:46doesn't invite any of his family to the wedding. He just totally wants to
- 10:50get away from his family because his family has issues. And also he's already
- 10:56starting to kind of lie about his past, like the weird lies really instead
- 11:01of saying because his real name is John, his born name is John,
- 11:05but he starts calling himself Jonathan, and he lies about his age. He
- 11:11says he's younger. He says he's five years younger. Yeah, to his
- 11:16wife. And then he in the marriage, something goes wrong and the wife
- 11:22wants to divorce him, and that's when he turns on her. Why did
- 11:26she want to divorce him. Well, remember there was something about like he
- 11:28immediately starts having like affairs and like just sleeping around and stuff like that.
- 11:35And and I don't know if that was the entirety of it, but and
- 11:41and remember they were saying that during the wedding, there was a sense of
- 11:46like there these weren't people that he's known all his life where you're like,
- 11:50oh, we grew up together. It was all like people that knew him
- 11:52for like a year in call and you like really superficial acquaintances. And in
- 11:58fact I forget, but it was a common of like I can't believe he's
- 12:01getting married, like you know, stuff like that. Yeah, and then
- 12:03she reached out. She found his parents and his siblings and started talking with
- 12:09them, and they started telling her information and she's like, wait, so
- 12:11he's been lying to me about his birthday and his name and what you know,
- 12:16what else is he lying to me about? And then she divorces him.
- 12:20And it should be noted that these are very attractive people. Dirty John
- 12:26is a is an attractive guy. He kind of reminds me of like a
- 12:31like a pudgy Tom Selleck or something. And anyway, so she divorces him
- 12:37and he turns on her and becomes very threatening, right. And by the
- 12:41way he's they make a point of saying that in his quote unquote prime he
- 12:45was very physically imposing because he was like six foot two, did heavy steroids
- 12:50and weights and stuff, so he was a big guy. Yeah, so
- 12:54physically imposing. Yeah. And so he starts to threaten her, and then
- 12:58she starts to they have kids together, and she starts to record these conversations
- 13:05because she's gone to the police, and they play those some of those tapes
- 13:11on the podcast and it's pretty interesting. He's like, he's like, you
- 13:13know, when when you get yours, I'm gonna you'll know it was me.
- 13:18And she's like, what are you talking about? What are you threatening
- 13:20me? Yeah? Are you saying because she's trying to get him to say
- 13:22something on tape, and he's like, well, you'll know, believe me,
- 13:26one day, when you least expect it, something's gonna happen to you.
- 13:31And it's gonna be because I made it happen. Yeah, you know.
- 13:33And he says, you know, I've been reacquainting myself with part of
- 13:37my family that and he implies it's the mob, and uh, just something
- 13:43very bad can happen, you know, right? And so yeah, so
- 13:50then somehow is that what lends him in prison because he no, there was
- 13:54that actual Uh, he broke the law with some scammer something like I can't
- 13:58remember that, some sort of other scam and he goes to jail. How
- 14:03long did you go to prison for? It was? It was years?
- 14:07Like he was in jail for several years. Yeah, like like ten years
- 14:09or something. I don't know if it's that long. But anyway, while
- 14:13so he emerges from prison and immediately and his sister is trying to help him
- 14:16right and trying to get him back on his feet. He's like, Okay,
- 14:20you need to get a job. You need to live an honest life,
- 14:22John. You know, let's let's put aside that bullshit in the past.
- 14:26Let's live an honest life. Get a job. And she looks over
- 14:30at the computer screen, hoping he's looking for jobs, and he's actually on
- 14:33match dot com or something like that, and she just looks at him.
- 14:35She's like, really, like, the day you get out of prison and
- 14:41we're talking about how to build your life, and this is what you want
- 14:45to do with your time, and she just she said she kind of gave
- 14:48up on him at that point. And that's actually when he meets Deborah right,
- 14:54the star of this podcast, and proceeds to date her, and they
- 15:00fall in love and they get secretly married and yeah, and Deborah is in
- 15:03this weird position because all of her family hates him, or many of them
- 15:07do. Yeah, in some cases he starts threatening them right well. And
- 15:11it's also interesting because she describes how when she starts trying to date online,
- 15:16she was continuously disappointed. You know, she'd meet with these guys and they
- 15:20didn't look as good as in their picture and they were sort of boring,
- 15:24they didn't get along. And then she goes out with John and in their
- 15:28date, initially she's like, oh, this seems really interesting and everything.
- 15:33But when they go to her house and it should be noticed, it should
- 15:37be noted he's always wearing his scrubs. Oh right, Yeah, he's always
- 15:41well, oh are they But then when they go to her house or whatever,
- 15:46he tries to get more physical than she wants. And she made it
- 15:50sound like it got intense, like she had to push him off to the
- 15:54point where he had to apologize later. Yeah, I was it push off.
- 15:58It was some I got the impression that it was aggressive talk like come
- 16:03on, like come on, let you know, come on, let's do
- 16:07it. If you if you hear it again, I'm pretty sure she she
- 16:11indicated that he that like he tried to uh to. That's not to say
- 16:15like, oh, he raped me or anything. It's just I think he
- 16:17tried to make moves She was definitely not comfortable with, to the point where
- 16:21he had to apologize, right to the point where she went to like her
- 16:26daughter and said like, yeah, I thought this guy was gonna be great,
- 16:29but he ended up being I ended up having to kick him out of
- 16:30the house so that red flag didn't kick in for her. Well geez,
- 16:34so we can get into that whole thing. Yeah, So, so what's
- 16:38the diagnosis Berto, Like, how do we label him psychologically? Well,
- 16:42so far, because he he seems to lie kind of compulsively about his who
- 16:49he is, what he is doing, who he is, et cetera.
- 16:52Because he has been fairly dysfunctional and you know, had to go to jail
- 16:56and messed up, you know, his marriage all. He seems pretty unempathetic
- 17:02in his interactions in those recordings that you hear, and in fact, you
- 17:04know threatening and violent even and stuff like that. Like my layman thing would
- 17:10be to say, I think he's like a psychopath. Right, so let's
- 17:14go down the symptoms. Long story, Shirt, he is a quintessential psychopath.
- 17:19He's a classic case. Actually, he's why Hair even developed the measure
- 17:26interest as a way of and you'll get the picture. As we go through
- 17:30the different symptoms, it's like, oh wow, yeah, this is exactly
- 17:36what this diagnosed, what this label was developed for. It was a guy
- 17:38like this. Well, in fact, what's funny is, before we did
- 17:41our podcasts and before we've talked about this topic, if you had asked me
- 17:45this, I don't know, ten years ago or something, I would have
- 17:48probably said, oh, I don't know. He seems like a crook,
- 17:51but he's not a psychopath, you know, like with the knife and the
- 17:53killing, which is funny because it will come. But but that was sink
- 18:00is through our conversations about this, I was able to pick up some of
- 18:03those things. I'm like, oh, yeah, right, right, so
- 18:06you're learning that's good. So symptom number one super is he superficially charming and
- 18:11glib? Oh yes, how so? Well that is basically what attracted her
- 18:17to him as he was able to put on the charm, and then he
- 18:19was described alternatively as either you know, really odd or charming, you know,
- 18:27So that to me indicates that it's something that he could turn on but
- 18:33wasn't like just part of his normal character. Right. There are people in
- 18:36her family, including Deborah herself, who were you know, reported to on
- 18:41this podcast that they thought John dirty. John was this really nice guy charming
- 18:48listened to you, was nice and funny and just a great guy, and
- 18:53then alternatively was a terrible person. Yeah, all right, inflated sense of
- 18:59self war Yeah, I mean, first of all, in the stories he
- 19:03tells, whether he is fully aware of how much he's exaggerating. He could
- 19:08have gone for a more normal narrative and still be lying, but instead it's
- 19:12like these like hero narratives. And then he also in his conversations he seems
- 19:19so self entitled. Yeah, like he's entitled to all the money, he's
- 19:23entitled to all all the rights of the family. Like he's just entitled,
- 19:29you know, right, right, So the phrase self worth is a little
- 19:33weird to me. The way that you phrased it is evidence of what I
- 19:41would say, a inflated sort of presentation of self worth or something. But
- 19:48whether or not he deep down actually felt that way about himself is hard to
- 19:52know. Sure, so that's a that's a little bit of a question mark
- 19:56for me. There's there's really only three questions marks, and that's one of
- 20:00them. I might as evidenced in that bucket. Then I might also throw
- 20:04in the whole Oh I come from this family of the mob. Seems odd,
- 20:11like it's just a bragging thing. But he's so proud of it.
- 20:14Yeah, like oh he's he's connected and that's his background, and it's like,
- 20:18really you would be proud of that, Like, yeah, a constant
- 20:23need for stimulation this is actually one of my question marks. But but is
- 20:29there evidence for a constant need for stimulation? Well, it was the thing
- 20:32of like he did didn't any like he liked water stuff, you know,
- 20:37boating things like that. He also when I when I hear constant need for
- 20:42stimulation, I here, I think about people who drink a lot, use
- 20:48drugs a lot, who do a lot of extreme sports, maybe who get
- 20:55bored like really easily. Yeah, whereas he didn't present like that. I
- 21:00would talk about him like he would he would get up and he'd act like
- 21:03he went to work or he'd just stay home. Yeah, actually that's a
- 21:07good point. I played a lot of call of duty. You know.
- 21:10No, maybe that's maybe that's the outlet. But that's not like simla.
- 21:14But it's not like a lot of stimulation, you know what I mean.
- 21:15It's like it again when I think, when I know when I apply this
- 21:21label to people that I'm diagnosing the constant need for stimulation. It's usually like
- 21:26an excessive activity in things that often result in self destruction, you know,
- 21:34lots of sex, lots of masturbation, actually, lots of drugs and alcohol,
- 21:41lots of Now, but he didn't apparently cheat on her while they were
- 21:48while they were together. Now, the other thing is is he's in his
- 21:52fifties at this point, right, and psychopathy tends to decrease over the years,
- 21:59or at least the manifestation of the bad behaviors, the annoying behaviors.
- 22:03And so we could say that when he was in college and young, that
- 22:07he probably did have that presentation as a drinker and a sexor and all that
- 22:12kind of stuff. And I mean, like, okay, the guys they
- 22:15interviewed at the party, to me and maybe this is unfair, but they
- 22:18seem like very stereotypical, like frank guys. Right yeah, and they were
- 22:23calling him, oh, that's dirty John, So you can kind of maybe
- 22:29imagine he was a party wreck in college, right yeah? Yeah? What
- 22:33about lying pathologically? That absolutely, like NonStop? Yeah, just which is
- 22:38an interesting thing because when I thought about it later, I thought that is
- 22:45that is pathological lying in that he didn't need to lie. No, why
- 22:49did he name his Why did he call himself Jonathan instead of John? Why
- 22:53did he make his birthday five years earlier? Like to his wife, It's
- 23:00like she's gonna find out eventually, she's your wife. Yeah. Actually,
- 23:04lies that not only are unnecessary, but could destroy your whole point of lying
- 23:10in the first place. Right. It's the same thing with the exaggerations.
- 23:15Okay, I could see in this case, if someone's trying to pass off
- 23:18as more legits, it's say, like, I do have a job,
- 23:21I'm employed, right, Because if he's unemployed and he's embarrassed about it and
- 23:23stuff, but he's not employed. He's a doctor and an anesthesia doctor.
- 23:29You know, it's like hardcore. They get paid tons of money, they're
- 23:32very well respected. It's a hard profession. And he's been in doctors without
- 23:37borders. It's like ten x the lies right right that, you know,
- 23:42being a nurse as anesthesiologist and say it again, anstesiology and is theesiologist and
- 23:52it is theologists is a badass profession, you know. And on the scale
- 23:59of yeah, of course that's you know, on the that's on one side
- 24:04of the bell curve. Let's just put it that way. So why not
- 24:07just keep it at that? Yeah, that wasn't good enough? Yeah,
- 24:10Or why not go back to school and become a physician if that's what you
- 24:14want to do. I don't know. Yeah, there's just all these weird
- 24:17little lies that he would do, you know. And and that's the definition
- 24:22of pathological lying. Now, the typical way of seeing pathological lying for Layman
- 24:30and among many clinicians in my experience, is basically at the core of one's
- 24:37personality is this is something dirty, is something there's something manipulative and evil almost
- 24:47about someone someone who wants to trick people because they like it, or they
- 24:52want to trick people for their own means or something. See. But the
- 24:57development, I mean, I'm going to cut to the chase and say that
- 25:02My thesis about this guy is he's a tragic figure. He was, he
- 25:07created tragedy around him, but he clearly, in my view, wanted to
- 25:14live a normal, good life. When he got out of prison, he
- 25:18meets Deborah and he was at initially for a while anyway, this really nice
- 25:23guy. Now the sense you get from the story tellers and particularly the people
- 25:32in the family and whatnot, is like, he's evil and he's out to
- 25:36manipulate, and he's out to get her money or something. And that's one
- 25:41way of looking at it, and we'll never be able to answer these questions
- 25:44like what really motivates any particular human. But the part of it that I
- 25:48didn't think was being talked about was he was, in my view, desperate
- 25:52for attachment. He gets out of prison and he wants a stable relationship,
- 25:57as anyone does, and so he goes on a match. He meets us
- 26:03woman. Maybe he's like, wouldn't it be nice if she actually made a
- 26:07lot of money, you know what I mean? And then he ends up
- 26:11in the relationship with her, and for a while he's trying to be nice,
- 26:17he's trying to hold together. These other people are starting to threaten his
- 26:21relationship with her, and he gets upset because he really wants to be with
- 26:26Deborah. He reacts in this really dysfunctional way because that's what he was taught
- 26:30and because he has a psychological condition that makes it so that he can't really
- 26:37think straight in situations like that. You know, he jumps to intimidation too
- 26:41quickly, he's threatened too easily, he has too much he doesn't have enough
- 26:48empathy. It's like he needs to think about, like, well, you
- 26:52know, if I was there with him in those moments, and he's like,
- 26:56so I'm getting the vibe that you know, and he came to me
- 26:59for therapy, I'm getting the vibe that these people are against me, and
- 27:02so I'm going to really let them have it. And so I would talk
- 27:04with him about, well, what do you want out of the situation.
- 27:08Well, I want to be with Deborah. Well, how do you think
- 27:11this is going to play out? Yeah, if you end up alienating her,
- 27:15you know, there's a I get that you're worried that you're going to
- 27:18lose Deborah, but there's a there's a better way. And I've talked with
- 27:22people in this similar not not exactly like this guy, but but other people
- 27:27in similar situations. You know, there's a lot of notions in our society,
- 27:30particularly around masculinity, that you need to assert yourself, you know,
- 27:33and you need to you need to grab the woman, and you need to
- 27:37make it happen, and you need to put down your enemies. And you
- 27:41know, you know, just look at Jerry Springer. Everyone's screaming at each
- 27:45other. You know, there's clear messages in our society that say, if
- 27:48someone gets in your way, you know, you got to put that down.
- 27:51You've got to intimidate that person. And so I think that his pathological
- 27:57line was his desperation for attachment, his desperation for closeness and stability, because
- 28:07there's so many other ways one can scam money, you know, other than
- 28:11other than just dealing with a woman and all of her family members. Yeah,
- 28:18well, he could have made it a much quicker scam in that case,
- 28:21right, He could have like defrauded her by taking all her bank account
- 28:23money or something like that. And that's what they were kind of implying,
- 28:26was like he would go from woman to woman, yeah, and take their
- 28:30money, and he did sometimes do that, and that I don't have any
- 28:33sympathy for this man, and I don't have any sympathy for what he did.
- 28:37But I think that the part of the line of thinking that I think
- 28:42wasn't really presented in this podcast is just really typical, is the kind of
- 28:47the vibe I'm talking about. Do you know what I'm saying? Yes,
- 28:49Yeah, that makes sense. I think I think you're right in that,
- 28:53at least from what's been percented, because you know, we don't know did
- 28:57he the extend of the other people he actually hurt in his life and stuff
- 29:03like that, But from what's been presented, it did seem like at like
- 29:07Deborah wasn't being physically abused, right, Like, there was no indication that
- 29:12he was like hitting her or things like that, and she seemed to want
- 29:17to be in the relationship. And so maybe it was him not being able
- 29:22to deal with what you're calling what he perceived as threats and that spiral out
- 29:27of control for him, right exactly. And he was taught a certain thing
- 29:32as a child, and he probably had a biological disposition for psychopathy anyway,
- 29:36for lack of empathy and a lack of fear. There's there's associations with like
- 29:41a lack of fear with psychopathy, which is interesting because when you're when you're
- 29:45a young child and you're developing, and your parents look at you with a
- 29:51face of like anger or a face of disapproval, that activates a young child's
- 29:56fear response like, oh my god, my parents are upset at me.
- 30:00Well, imagine if you don't have that fear response in the way that other
- 30:03people do. And because the primary way to modify a child's behavior is too
- 30:11sorry, my alarms going on, that's us telling us, so we have
- 30:14to take a break. But let me finish this point. Is that you
- 30:19know when you when you look, the primary way of modifying a child's behavior
- 30:23is to look at them and be like no, no, stop it,
- 30:27you know, or like you know, you get an angry face and you
- 30:32say no, and you know, and and imagine if as a three year
- 30:36old, you're just you're just unaffected by that. You're just like, huh,
- 30:38they're putting on that face, that face, Yeah, that isn't that
- 30:41funny that they're trying to scare me. I'm not scared. I have no
- 30:47fear because you see two year olds, three year four year olds when you
- 30:51do that to them and they're not ready for it. They freak out,
- 30:53you know, they jump, They're like, oh my god, you know,
- 30:56like Mom's upset at me, and wait what am I doing? You
- 31:00know, you see them have a physiological autonomic response to that, right,
- 31:06And and that's an important element in modifying the child's behavior and and and helping
- 31:12them to understand empathy, because you know, two year olds have very little
- 31:15empathy in the way that we hope adults will have. You know, mine,
- 31:21me, give me, this is my I you know, uh,
- 31:23a friend comes for a playdate and has a stuffed animal, and you know,
- 31:29little Jenny is just like, that is now mine, that's my stuff.
- 31:32That's mine. Now I see that, I see that stuffed animal.
- 31:34I want it. That's mine. That's psychopathic behavior, right, And and
- 31:38you're like, you know, hey, have empathy for your play date.
- 31:42It's like no, this is mine, and and hey, we're gonna have
- 31:45to give this back to you know, to to Jane, and and Jenny's
- 31:49just like, no, my, you know, like you know, every
- 31:53kid goes through that kind of stuff. And the way you modify psychopathic child
- 31:57behavior is to essentially one of the ways is to essentially make them afraid.
- 32:04You're not You're not abusing them. But but you're like, you're you're you're
- 32:07saying sternly, no, this is not okay. And the child's like,
- 32:12oh my god, mom and dad or what my parents upset at me there,
- 32:16you know, and and so that, and no one likes to be
- 32:19afraid, right, and so you're like, Okay, Well, to avoid
- 32:22being made afraid in the future, I am now going to not take Jane's
- 32:29stuffed animal because when I did that, I something the series of things happened
- 32:35that made me feel terrible. So I'm gonna avoid that. Well, imagine
- 32:37if you don't have that brain, you have an incentive to avoid that.
- 32:42Yeah, you're just like, huh, You're you're more calm as a three
- 32:45year old thinking through this. You're just like, Okay, well, I
- 32:47want that stuffed animal, and my parents are saying these things to me,
- 32:54and I don't really care. There's no downside. Yeah, And and Jane
- 33:00is upstate because that's the other thing is now Jane's upset. And if you
- 33:02don't have that fear response to someone else being upset them, you know,
- 33:08them retaliating against You're just like, you know, I'm not afraid of that.
- 33:13Yeah, maybe they'll try to smack me around. I don't really care.
- 33:16Then then you just don't develop That's this is one hypothesis as to why
- 33:21there are psychopaths. Interesting. It's not that they don't have empathy, it's
- 33:24that they don't have fear. And it's a weird hypothesis of the development of
- 33:30empathy, right, is that we develop empathy partially because we were trying to
- 33:35avoid the fear of what it feels like when we actually harm other people and
- 33:42their response to us, and the fact that they might actually get revenge on
- 33:45us. You know, if I take Jane's thing, and I worry that
- 33:50she's going to punch me in the face, or I worry that she's going
- 33:52to take one of my things, or I worry that she's going to tell
- 33:55my mom, and then my mom is going to chastise me or spink me
- 34:00or take away something, and that, you know, it's all kind of
- 34:02a fear system. Yeah, and and so anyway, so as he is
- 34:12is lying, he so you develop this sense of lying because when you lie,
- 34:19you just don't. You don't you're not worried about the consequences of lying.
- 34:25Yeah, and so you just developed this habit of just like, well,
- 34:29you know, when in doubt, I'll inflate this, and I'll inflate
- 34:34that, and I'm not even if I get caught, I don't really worry
- 34:37about it. That's what's so strange about psychopaths, is like, like,
- 34:40and that's why I love this podcast so much, because if you really look
- 34:44at Dirty John, his life is a mess. He's not like this calculated
- 34:49mastermind, which is how often they're presented. And if you don't really listen
- 34:52carefully, I feel like this podcast presents him as a mastermind. You know,
- 34:57he's like a con man. He's always like figuring out how to manipulate
- 35:00people, blah blahlah blah. And it's and it's like, Debian, did
- 35:04you get that sense? Well, I got more of the sense that he
- 35:06he's always trying to forcefully manipulate, But I didn't get the sense that he
- 35:12was often as successful good because he was not successful. This man, when
- 35:17he meets Deborah is coming out of prison. He's homeless, he doesn't have
- 35:21a job, and he doesn't even have any clothes. Yeah, and it's
- 35:25you know, because psychopaths are often presented in the media, they're rich,
- 35:30they live in a castle, yeah, yeah, because you're smart. Yeah,
- 35:34they're always like really good at manipulating. They're playing six chess games at
- 35:37the same time, right, Whereas you look at this guy's life and stupid
- 35:42choice after stupid choice. Yeah, you know, like, what do you
- 35:45want out of life? John? Do you want to end up in prison
- 35:49again? Do you want to end up dead as what happened in the case,
- 35:52or would you rather just have a fun, good life. Well,
- 35:55here's the normal path to a fun, good life. You know, get
- 35:59a job, be a normal human being. Uh, don't threaten people,
- 36:04don't lie, don't don't give people a reason to look into your past,
- 36:08because that's the whole thing. Like, he kept pushing people and kept pushing
- 36:12people. Eventually they're just like, I'm gonna I'm gonna look at this guy's
- 36:15path. I'm gonna get a lawyer. Yeah, what is wrong with this
- 36:17guy? And like when he's when he's on that phone call with is it
- 36:22the the son in law of her like Deborah's son in law I think or
- 36:28something that Well, a major character is Deborah's nephew, nephew nephew. Yeah,
- 36:32and he you know, they're having this heated conversation and the nephew keeps
- 36:37trying to draw these lines in the sandal, like I'm not gonna let you
- 36:39do that to her family or something, and John like doesn't care. It's
- 36:43like, why didn't you come here? Come come here, tell me just
- 36:45come here, you know, and and and you know clearly John won't back
- 36:52down. He's like, I don't care. I'm gonna take it to the
- 36:53limit. He pushes and pushes and pushes, right, and it's like to
- 36:59what, Dirty John, Like, what is your goal here? Right?
- 37:02If your goal is to have a good life? And to you know,
- 37:07that's the thing about psychopathology is that, such as personality disorders, is that
- 37:14it's it's not a it's not a well thought out approach to life, right
- 37:20and it and it ends up you end up shooting yourself in the foot.
- 37:22Which is why this podcast, you know, Dirty John is a good presentation
- 37:28of that and really lays that out well. And I and I really hope
- 37:30that listeners when they listen to this, Oh I get it. Psychopaths are
- 37:36tragic individuals who create a wake of tragedy around them, But the most tragic
- 37:42figures often the individual doing these things. Like I don't get the sense this
- 37:46guy was a happy individual, do you know what I mean? Pockets of
- 37:50happiness, but overall no, I doubt it. I got the sense like
- 37:53this guy was in a daily basis feeling like crap. Because that's often the
- 38:00case. You're just in a constant state of worry about losing your attachments.
- 38:04You're in a constant state of the traumise he went through when he was a
- 38:07kid that he didn't process, in a constant state of remembering like all the
- 38:12disappointment that he's been through in life and trying to deny that and everything.
- 38:15Anyway, let's take a break. What do you say? Let's do it
- 38:22all right, we're back from the break. If you haven't become a patron
- 38:25of the podcast, do so now by going to patreon dot com. Once
- 38:30you become a patron, you get access to a lot of our patron only
- 38:34episodes. Okay, let's continue with the psychopathic symptoms. So we got superficial
- 38:38charm, inflated sense of self worth, constant need for stimulation, lying pathologically.
- 38:44What about conning others and being manipulative? Oh right, yeah, I
- 38:47mean he was emotionally manipulative in what I heard in the podcast, and he
- 38:54was definitely always trying to sort of get the the edge, but using like,
- 39:01uh threats, Yeah, a lot of them violent threats. But he
- 39:05also I think in line with this symptom is the lying about doctors of that
- 39:09border. Oh sure, yeah, it's very comming. You're trying to you're
- 39:14trying to manipulate. He's trying to manipulate Debra and other women to respect him
- 39:19more and stuff. And like the scrubs thing, yeah, like what was
- 39:22it that he didn't have any other clothes? I didn't think. So that's
- 39:24the thing, Like the scrubs alone, so people don't listen, he would
- 39:30wear this these dirty scrubs all the time. And other people in the family
- 39:35who know physicians know that you don't wear your scrubs to like a like a
- 39:42Thanksgiving dinner, no, and and so, and if your scrubs are dirty
- 39:45from the street, you can't use them in the hospital, right, So,
- 39:51so you know, the the fact that he's that that's why this is
- 39:58the ninety nine point nine percent of cycle has are like this. They they're
- 40:01stupid, They they don't they're trying so hard it becomes obvious. And that's
- 40:07why his that so Deborah's in love with dirty John. She's just like,
- 40:12oh he's dashing, I want love, and so, as anyone, you'll
- 40:15get clouded to to reality. But the family members, you know, her,
- 40:21her kids and other people, they're not in love with him. So
- 40:23they're looking at him, you know, with with without rose colored classes.
- 40:29Yeah, and so, and it's immediately apparent upon meeting him that something's up
- 40:35with this guy. And that's the thing about psychopathy is like the these are
- 40:39not geniuses. They're not good at manipulating other people. They're quite obvious.
- 40:44Like when you interact with them, you'll pretty quickly realize, ah, sums
- 40:50up with this guy. You'll you'll feel it. Like the daughter meets him
- 40:52and she's immediately like he's a slob. He's just like moping around the house,
- 40:58you know, and she's immediately turned off by it. Yeah. I
- 41:04was interpreting all of that initial reactivity from the two daughters as them picking up
- 41:09on something. When you interact with someone who doesn't have empathy, you feel
- 41:16it in your bones. I do when I interact with someone who has a
- 41:22personality disorder that has an element of a lack of empathy, I feel it
- 41:24in my bones right away. There's something unnerving about someone without empathy, even
- 41:32if you don't have evidence that they don't have empathy. There's something about facial
- 41:37expressions. It's it's weird, like they'll you know, they might be saying
- 41:43things like, oh, that's interesting, but you get a sense like they're
- 41:47not sincere, oh that's interesting. And so you in your bones, in
- 41:54your all of your brain power that's spent on picking up on facial cues and
- 42:00and you know, nonverbal cues is alarm bells are going off, like something's
- 42:07incongruent here. I'm not. I don't know what. You know. Your
- 42:10brain doesn't know psychopath but your brain is like, something's kind of off in
- 42:16this situation. You know, it's all the usual back and forth I get
- 42:20to do with people. It's not right. Yeah, there's something different here.
- 42:23And we're i think programmed or evolved to when we pick up on incongruencies
- 42:30and something's off, we tend to get a little afraid because we like things
- 42:37to feel familiar, and so something doesn't feel familiar, we get a little
- 42:43afraid. And so I think that was my you know, it's reading into
- 42:45it quite a bit, but that was my guess that's what was happening.
- 42:49So the next symptom here lack of remorse or guilt. Did he exhibit that
- 42:53lack of remorse? Well, I don't think he ever felt anything was his
- 43:00fault. No, no, nothing, No he did. He did empirically
- 43:04horrible things that we heard about. Yeah, No, no evidence of remorse
- 43:07or guilt. He was always a victim. Yeah, I mean, you
- 43:12know the things that he would do and say, It's like, how about
- 43:15just say you're sorry, you know, or how about just sort of say
- 43:20m he he he. He just relentlessly was aggressive verbally with people. Yeah,
- 43:28just at the drop of a hat. Even again, as it started
- 43:30to escalate with Deborah's family, he just just just kept at it, you
- 43:36know. Yeah. So what about shallow emotions? Well, that one,
- 43:40it's a little hard because I'm assuming, yes, I am still intrigued.
- 43:47What was the deal with that? Because Deborah had lost her sister, right,
- 43:52right, So Deborah's back sister was murdered by by the sister's husband,
- 44:00and then there was also something else which is maybe not a thing, but
- 44:06Debrah's remind me who was the person in the end who he fights with Deb's
- 44:14daughter? Something in her voice that I found interesting. She had that sort
- 44:21of voice like she went through some maybe some tough times young. It could
- 44:23be yeah, it could be nothing, but there was something in her voice.
- 44:28So I sort of had this sense like maybe we don't know the whole
- 44:31story about Debra's past in the sense of why she might find it irresistible to
- 44:38be attracted to someone like John, and that that we don't necessarily have all
- 44:44the pieces, but there must be something there because because just because you like
- 44:49someone, he wasn't in her life for ten years, you know, it
- 44:52was it was a fairly quick, strong, intense attachment that developed for someone
- 44:58who was not a teen. She was fifty, you know, fifties.
- 45:01Age has nothing to do with that, well, I guess, but age
- 45:05does give you experience, you know, like, no, not in you
- 45:08would like to think. And that's the cultural notion that somehow adults are better
- 45:15able to manage love relationships. And I'm here to tell you that is just
- 45:19not my experience. I mean, certainly fifteen year olds might have a little
- 45:23bit more of a deficit, but the propensity to fall in love quickly and
- 45:30be I guess what I was trying to say was if she was on the
- 45:35level, then he must have had enough actual emotions that she could work with.
- 45:44Otherwise, why would she have been so attached to him? Well,
- 45:46so, good question. Yeah, this is the other question mark for me,
- 45:51is the emotion part you and you're good to sort of wonder maybe when
- 45:58it was just the two of them and there wasn't any threats that were happening
- 46:01on the outside, that there was a depth of emotion that Debora was picking
- 46:07up on that she appreciated. Right, Yeah, totally. I didn't see.
- 46:12There's no evidence to me in terms of what they presented that he had
- 46:15shallow emotions. So, but he might have. It's hard to know.
- 46:22I guess part of what I was saying with age is when I started dating,
- 46:27or I imagine when someone starts dating in general, you sort of don't
- 46:31know what's right and what's wrong, Like what you even are supposed to expect
- 46:36out of dating someone, you know, because you see in movies like okay,
- 46:40the thing is dating, but in reality, like what's it supposed to
- 46:45feel? Like? What am I supposed to say? What am I supposed
- 46:46to do? So I imagine when you're young and you start dating someone,
- 46:50let's say you're a girl and you start dating a guy. If the guy
- 46:52sort of like doesn't say too many things, he doesn't like, he doesn't
- 46:55cry in movies, is whatever, like any number of things. How are
- 47:00you supposed to know if that's normal or not normal? The only thing you
- 47:04could base it on is, well, are my brothers like that? Is
- 47:05my dad like that? As my uncle like that? You know stuff like
- 47:07that. Yeah, but if you've dated throughout your life, maybe you at
- 47:09least have some frames of reference of like, yeah, you know, this
- 47:13guy never compliments me or something, you know, things like that. Yeah,
- 47:15I'll give you that. Yeah. What about callousness and lack of empathy?
- 47:20Yeah, I mean certainly, at least in his words and final actions.
- 47:25We also don't know if he did worse things that we you know,
- 47:30neither of us nor the police know about. What about using others and being
- 47:32a parasite? Definitely he was perceived as a parasite by the entire family except
- 47:38Deborah. Yeah, he's a classic psychopathic parasite in that he found a woman
- 47:45who had money and just proceeded to be a parasite. Yeah, so there's
- 47:52that. What about poor control over behavior? Yeah, I mean like you're
- 47:55saying, I didn't get the sense that when he was blowing up on the
- 47:59phone and seeing all these three like it was this part of a master plan.
- 48:01It was him losing control, right right, Yeah. Promiscuous sexual behavior.
- 48:06Well, so two things. There was the indication in college. I
- 48:08mean they made very very poign in comments about how he was around women and
- 48:15what he did with women, without going into graphic detail because they're like,
- 48:19we don't want to talk about it. The second thing was when he was
- 48:22no longer with Debra, there was that thing about how he had been seeing
- 48:27women like NonStop. Do you remember this, Like, was it his sister.
- 48:32I think it was his sister that was saying that that he was seeing
- 48:37or maybe this was before he started seeing Debra. I can't quite remember.
- 48:40The sister was saying something about it that she realized that John was just like
- 48:45going through women and dating them. Yeah yeah right, So definitely promiscuous sexual
- 48:52behavior when he was younger and maybe during his adult older adult life too.
- 48:58Behavioral problems early in life, well, I don't remember if they talked about
- 49:05him getting in trouble in school and stuff like that, but it sounds like
- 49:07he was always a troublemaker. Right, This is basically a symptom to demonstrate
- 49:16that it's been a lifelong behavioral pattern related to his personality. Have you seen
- 49:22the movie it? The new One? No? Is it good? I
- 49:25liked it? Yeah? Maybe if you watch it, we should talk about
- 49:28it. I'm not into horror. Do you think it would be good?
- 49:31I don't know if you're If you're not into horror, maybe it's not.
- 49:34But it's not a cheesy horror movie like Stranger Things. Yeah, I heard
- 49:37it's kind of like Stranger Thing. It's like Stranger Things. Someone described it
- 49:40as Goonies meets Oh what was the other movie they compared it to, Well,
- 49:47oh, stand by Me or something, you know like. But but
- 49:50but it is horror. I mean it's you know, scary, lack of
- 49:53realistic long term goals. And yeah, certainly, yeah, his entire life
- 50:00is one lack of realistic long term goal. What about being impulsive, Well,
- 50:06he was. He was impulsive in his reactions towards people, totally,
- 50:09for sure. He was very impulsive. Being irresponsible yeah, I mean yeah,
- 50:15he's extremely irresponsible, blaming others and refusing to accept responsibility. Yes,
- 50:21and even because I was gonna say about the responsibility, but I think it
- 50:23also applies in this one. Remember the story about how he started like he
- 50:29wasn't even doing a good job as a nurse a sociologist, and they were
- 50:35and it was causing patients to like come out early and like all sorts of
- 50:38problems. So yeah, yeah he was. He was taking drugs from work
- 50:45and blah blah blah, blaming others and yeah, having several marital relationships,
- 50:51yes, delinquency when young, yes, criminal acts and several realms in several
- 50:57realms. Well we know for a fact he tried to kills someone. Yeah,
- 51:00we know. Well that's debatable. What Yeah, but anyway, well
- 51:07at the very least he was assaulted. Extreme in the extreme. Wait wait,
- 51:09why do you think it's debatable. Well, let's let's continue this.
- 51:14Yeah, he was like in money fraud, he was he would steal stuff
- 51:19from his work. In terms of drugs, there there were several realms of
- 51:23criminality. The idea is is that you have a general personality problem that leads
- 51:30to crypt it just leads to general criminality. You know, someone who doesn't
- 51:35have a personality problem like psychopathy will be will tend to be a criminal in
- 51:39one area, you know, like I steal makeup or I rob banks or
- 51:45something. But when I'm not robbing banks, it's not like I'm just impulsively
- 51:51a criminal, you know. So yeah, let's go to the very end.
- 51:53The twist at the end is he is trying to to intimidate Tara,
- 52:00the daughter, to back off. Oh is that why you're saying. You're
- 52:06saying that he might have just been trying to scare her. Yeah, I
- 52:08mean if he wanted to, if he wanted to just take her out.
- 52:13And this is I think what they speculated, what the La Times guy was
- 52:19speculating, was like he he went to Tara to try to intimidate her to
- 52:24be with a knife, but didn't plan on actually using it on her.
- 52:29But I don't remember the exact Remember that in there in his trunk they found
- 52:32a rope, duct tape, some other stuff. Now, again to your
- 52:37point, though he may be having tons of fantasies, Yeah, but not
- 52:43fully intending to go through, right, which is still bad enough. Yeah,
- 52:45fantasies. But my and they said like he was kind of weak and
- 52:51whatnot. He had lost so they said that at his peak, he was
- 52:53like two hundred and twenty five pounds or two hundred and thirty one and twenty
- 52:58pound and he was a yeah, I was down to one hundred and thirty
- 53:00twenty Yeah, it's like crazy, yeah, because he had Yeah, so
- 53:04what happens is Dirty John has this massive stomach problem. He's in the hospital
- 53:09for like a month, and Deborah decides, now this is this is when
- 53:14I'm gonna leave. And so yeah, she gets all of his stuff,
- 53:16puts it in the garage and and and blah blah blah. And then that's
- 53:21when Dirty John kind of escalates from there. Yeah. And Tara the this
- 53:28like five foot zero, she's five four, right, Oh, well she's
- 53:31really small, it's the thing. Yeah, but she's not she's not big.
- 53:35He's six two. Yeah. And and and she he's waiting for her,
- 53:38like outside of her car or something, and he tries to intimidate her.
- 53:45They get into a scuffle and he starts to stab her. He stabs
- 53:49at her yeah, yeah, and stabs her like several times although yeah,
- 53:52yes, right, and then her arm is particularly badly ste yeah, and
- 53:57then the knife gets out of his hands, which is actually really common in
- 54:02knife fights like this because blood makes things really slippery and and then she grabbed
- 54:08the knife and proceeded to like stab him a bunch of times and then stabs
- 54:13him through the eye, through the eye and kills him. And although he
- 54:17doesn't know, he doesn't die right away. Remember he goes into a coma.
- 54:21Well, no, he was brain dead when oh, okay, faint
- 54:23fine, but but he still had a pulse, right, So they were
- 54:27the paramedics arrived, they were they like, get his heart right, but
- 54:30his brain was dead, and so they pulled him off the off the you
- 54:34know, life support a few days later. So essentially, you know,
- 54:38she turned off his brain. And so it is just totally I did not
- 54:45see that coming. I'm like, I'm like, I thought what was going
- 54:49to happen was he was going to end up in jail. Because as I'm
- 54:52listening to the podcast, I'm like, well, we haven't heard from him,
- 54:55and they haven't said what happens to him, and Devers kind of talking
- 54:59like he's out of the picture now, right, So where is he,
- 55:02you know? Or did he kill himself or something? And so so yeah,
- 55:07it's it's kind of so there's two scenarios here. One is that he
- 55:10showed up. He wanted to get revenge on Tara, and he flubbed it
- 55:15and she ended up killing him. Yeah, well it was by the way,
- 55:20the whole podcast opens with, uh, and there's ten knife wounds and
- 55:24there's stab in the neck, you know, like I don't remember that,
- 55:29I don't. Yeah. The podcast opens with this police description of all these
- 55:31stab wounds. So immediately I was expecting, Okay, we're gonna hear about
- 55:35all the victims that this guy killed and all these things. So it was
- 55:38actually quite interesting that he didn't know he did. He might have, but
- 55:43we never hear about any deaths until he dies, right, And that's that's
- 55:47another thing. I assume he hasn't killed anybody, right, And I assumed
- 55:52that, yeah, he had fantasies because he had all this stuff in the
- 55:54trunk, or he had this stuff in the trunk because he wanted to intimidate
- 55:59people. Yeah, he might have. She wanted to kidnap her, right,
- 56:00And yeah, I mean again, the guy is terrible, Yeah,
- 56:04horrible. No, but yeah, right, but but again, if you
- 56:07want to kill someone, if you just want to murder someone, get a
- 56:10gun. It's obviously easy in our country to get a gun and just walk
- 56:15up behind him and kill him, like why would you show up with?
- 56:17And it wasn't even like a huge knife, it was like, you know,
- 56:21and and so so there's all that kind of stuff, and so there's
- 56:27so there's one scenario where he showed up, he wanted to kill her.
- 56:29He wanted to bound her, you know, bind her and dump her,
- 56:31or he wanted to kidnap her and intimidate her and and then set her free,
- 56:37and you know, and then you know, she would be intimidated and
- 56:40not talk about not talk shit about him anymore or something, or she would
- 56:45just feel better getting revenge and and it's hard to know. But the the
- 56:52but the most comical thing about it is Tara and her husband are really into
- 57:00Walking Dead. Right, so early in the podcast, they go on this
- 57:06long jag about how Tara, so Deborah's daughter, you know, the daughter
- 57:09who hated hated John from the beginning. They go on this long jag about
- 57:15how Tara met her boyfriend and how they started dating and I'm like, why
- 57:21are we going down this road? And they start talking about how they bonded
- 57:23over the Walking Dead, and there's these lines of Tara talking about, Yeah,
- 57:29I just kind of like Walking Dead because you know, it kind of
- 57:34teaches you, like survival skills, and you know, it's just kind of
- 57:38interesting to think about, like what if the zombie apocalypse did happen and you
- 57:44had to defend yourself. You know, it's just good life. She's treating
- 57:47it like it's a like it's a life skills kind of survivor man. Yeah,
- 57:52and then she talks about after killing, you know, through self defense,
- 57:59killing dirty John. She attributes her success in that altercation to watching The
- 58:05Walking Dead. You gotta get him in the head, Yeah, you gotta
- 58:07get him in the head. She says something like that, Yeah, like
- 58:10you gotta get how you get this. You can't kill him in the body.
- 58:13You gotta get him in the head. And she that's what she did.
- 58:15She stabbed him through the eye, right, And which is a common
- 58:20thing to do in The Walking Dead, right, because it's a lot easier
- 58:22to drive a knife through an eyeball than it is through a skull, is
- 58:24it. Well, yeah, I mean is it? I mean an eyeball
- 58:28is fluffy, and but I mean you have you have skull, well you
- 58:30don't have to, you know, Plus there's a little gap at the back.
- 58:36You don't have to worry yourself with all the details. That was.
- 58:39Yeah, that I just thought, you know, the way they presented it
- 58:44or the way I took it, I mean, did you take it as
- 58:45kind of comical? Yeah, although I mean I guess in the in the
- 58:49moment, I wasn't laughing just because it was I was still sort of like
- 58:53pig. I was actually putting myself in the situation of seeing this happening and
- 58:59like just like, oh my gosh, how do you stop something like that?
- 59:01You know, in the middle of it. Yeah, you know,
- 59:02I was imagining there's this scuffle and even if you know clearly who's the aggressor,
- 59:08there's a knife and and like the mess of that situation, you know,
- 59:13and so that gal that came out and she was like trying to help
- 59:15out and stuff like that, Like that would be so messy, you know,
- 59:17so scary and messy. So I but I see what you're saying.
- 59:22It's like like I played Call of Duty and now I know how to you
- 59:25know, how to fight? Yeah, all right. The final word about
- 59:30this is that it's a great podcast. It's short. If you're interested in
- 59:36this kind of thing, maybe you're not. It's not scary like other scary
- 59:38podcasts are. It's more of a case study of an abusive person who it
- 59:49also kind of teach you about domestic violence actually interpersonal intimate partner violence, in
- 59:54that he solely isolated Debora from the family. He would lie, he would
- 1:00:00do bad things, Deborah would threaten to leave, and then he would beg
- 1:00:04her to come back. He was extremely nice to her uncertain times, and
- 1:00:12would kind of make her depend on him in certain ways, right, and
- 1:00:17was very traditional in some ways, and so the so it's a good case
- 1:00:22it's a good case study in domestic violence as well. And one of the
- 1:00:27most shocking parts that you sort of alluded to earlier was that at some point
- 1:00:31Deborah totally leaves him. You know, forget. You're just like you as
- 1:00:37you're hearing this story, You're like, Deborah, leave this guy, leave
- 1:00:40this guy, and it and it just gets worse and worse and worse.
- 1:00:44And then finally she leaves him, and then and then she lets him back
- 1:00:50into her life and then they secretly get married. It's crazy, yeah,
- 1:00:54And the whole time you're just like Deborah, why there's so many other fish
- 1:01:00in the sea, Why this guy? And The part that I didn't think
- 1:01:06they portrayed well enough was the romance that is involved in these kinds of things.
- 1:01:14She talked about how she's like, well, you know, I was
- 1:01:16in love with him, yeah, And she doesn't say like, I'm finally
- 1:01:21so glad because I didn't see how much he was hitting me in abuse and
- 1:01:24stuff. She talks about him in those in those ways of like I really
- 1:01:29was in love with him, right, and we all will. We all
- 1:01:34have to forgive our spouses for their faults. That's a requirement in order to
- 1:01:39be in a long term relationship. You have to you have to forgive even
- 1:01:45without them apologizing. You have to tolerate your spouses shortcomings. That's just part
- 1:01:53of the ghost of the territory. And so it's hard for people to know
- 1:02:00what's too much faulse, you know. And I also love this person,
- 1:02:07I need this person. I depend on this person emotionally. It feels good
- 1:02:12when things are good. And what if I never meet anybody else? You
- 1:02:15know? These are these are questions I think I hope everyone can relate to.
- 1:02:21And they make it really hard in that in that situation, and and
- 1:02:25it and the way it's often presented is like, well, you know,
- 1:02:29he tricked her and he manipulated her, And certainly you could say that,
- 1:02:34but you could also just say like, look, you know, love is
- 1:02:36blind. It's hard, it's hard to it's hard to quantify the good feelings
- 1:02:42that she was getting getting getting Yeah, why did I say it like that?
- 1:02:47The good feelings she was getting? You know? It occurs to me.
- 1:02:54I've never understood when someone gets together with someone else and they sort of
- 1:03:02turn off the rest of their relationships. That's always been very puzzling to me.
- 1:03:07I can understand to a certain extent, like, well, if you're
- 1:03:09going to try to build a relationship together, you maybe have to not spend
- 1:03:14as much time with everyone else. That makes sense. But I've seen it
- 1:03:17a few times in my life where someone starts dating a person and they sort
- 1:03:22of like, because of that relationship, cut ties left and right and seemingly
- 1:03:30unnecessary ways. And I've always been like, wait, if that person is
- 1:03:35making you change your social circle so dramatically, well, first of all,
- 1:03:39how and secondly why? Right, Like, why do you do that?
- 1:03:43Well, there's a number of reasons for that. Obviously, One is right
- 1:03:47that the new spouse is threatened by the friends and will create enough problems for
- 1:03:55the person that the person's like, a, it's just easier if I just
- 1:03:59avoid my friends. Right. Another is that for you know, your friend
- 1:04:04they might have there's a certain attachment style that lends itself to becoming when you
- 1:04:16when you start a relating So you have a bunch of friends, but you
- 1:04:18have basically an insecure attachment style. You find someone to attach to and you
- 1:04:25put all your eggs in that basket because you're so desperate for that closeness and
- 1:04:31and you yourself don't even want to hang out with your friends because you don't
- 1:04:35want anything to interfere with that. With that little bit of security you have
- 1:04:40with that person, it's fascinating. So I feel like that's why I was
- 1:04:43saying earlier that there must have been something on her end. Oh yeah,
- 1:04:46that made it so she was so attracted to this kind of situation. Right.
- 1:04:50So there's two things. One is that, yes, because she she
- 1:04:55very much comes across and even I think says that she feels like she's kind
- 1:04:58of a naive trust person. So there's that. But another part of this
- 1:05:05is that it's very possible that she suffered from attachment issues. Herself, and
- 1:05:13when this guy came along who was extremely giving, you know, he he
- 1:05:16was very nice to her, would take do her dry cleaning, would make
- 1:05:21dinner for her, complimented her all the time. Tot told her, I
- 1:05:27want to marry you right away. He's like, I want to be with
- 1:05:29you forever, and like there's a there's a very seductive quality to these kinds
- 1:05:33of people. And so this is why I'm throwing in a little borderline in
- 1:05:38here. I think he had a little of that. And maybe all psychopaths
- 1:05:43have a little bit of borderline in them. I don't know, but he's
- 1:05:45he certainly had that need for closeness and that attachment and security that I think
- 1:05:50he was manifesting. The other the other side to this whole thing, you
- 1:05:56know, aside from looking for issues that she was suffering, is and you
- 1:06:01can take the healthiest human being on the planet, that someone who is the
- 1:06:05most securely attached, has the most you know, psychological resources, has the
- 1:06:11most social resources, is privileged, blah blah blah blah, and you you
- 1:06:15have them fall in love with someone who has these even like five percent of
- 1:06:20these qualities that Dirty John has, and that person will have a hard time
- 1:06:25extracting themselves once the relationship turns abusive. Abusive relationships, if you've never been
- 1:06:31in one, or you've never been close to one, you probably don't really
- 1:06:36understand it because it's a very particular experience to go through. It's and it's
- 1:06:42it's very it's very scary, the fact that you feel perpetually scared of,
- 1:06:48you know, with Debrah after a while, as she started to learn more
- 1:06:56about Dirty John and his lying, imagine what would go through your head in
- 1:07:00terms of like what is this guy capable of? If I break up with
- 1:07:04him? You know, I can imagine him doing all sorts of terrible things
- 1:07:12and so why risk that? One? Two? If I just do some
- 1:07:17mental gymnastics, I can you know this isn't that sounds so bad? And
- 1:07:24it's it's all based on fear, though, and so there's a there's a
- 1:07:27chance that Deborah was experiencing that or at least partially interesting. And you know,
- 1:07:32because that's what people say. It's like, why do you just leave
- 1:07:34him? You know, why do you just leave the asshole? And it's
- 1:07:36like unless you have the sort of gumption to actually kill the guy, and
- 1:07:45he's going to be walking around able to do things. And if you've ever
- 1:07:50been in that position where you're afraid that someone's going to take you out,
- 1:07:55you know that the world is a very unsafe place. Like you know,
- 1:08:00your house is only so secure and you've got to leave at some point,
- 1:08:02you know, if someone wants to kill you or kill someone you love and
- 1:08:06get away with it. It's actually not that hard, right, you know,
- 1:08:11you just can't you can't like draw up an actual barrier around yourself and
- 1:08:15everyone. Yeah, you can't have a bulletproof barrier all the time, right,
- 1:08:20And and plus you just sort of think, like, well, even
- 1:08:26if I did have all these measures, do I really want to lay awake
- 1:08:29at night worrying something's going to happen? And and so it's so scary and
- 1:08:34so pervasive that you just say, well, it's not that bad, you
- 1:08:41know, and there's good times. And as long as I don't push those
- 1:08:45buttons, don't rock the boat, he's you know, he's he's okay.
- 1:08:47And so now that's a slippery slope, and you just it just gets you
- 1:08:53know, the guy gets worse and worse, and you it's just a tiny
- 1:08:56little step down the road and before you know it you're in this like super
- 1:09:00super dysfunctional, horrible, abusive relationships, and you have a lot of mental,
- 1:09:06you know, defenses to to essentially protect It's a weird way of protecting
- 1:09:13the self, you know, and it's also a little bit of the gamblers
- 1:09:15dilemma where you you'll feel like I've invested so much in this, Yeah,
- 1:09:20I can't, I can't walk away now, Like so interesting podcast. Thanks
- 1:09:26for joining us out there. Please take care of yourself because you deserve it.