Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Creepy teacher, borderline couples, and grumpy boomers
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob emails, what do you say? Yep, let's do it.
- 0:02Middle tier patron Megan from Arizona. She says, my therapist and I have
- 0:06determined that our therapy relationship is likely coming to a close and that I will
- 0:10be graduating for my time in therapy with her. I am wondering if it
- 0:15is appropriate to ask to see her notes on our sessions from the past few
- 0:19years so that I can have a summary of what we have worked on.
- 0:24Or is that weird to ask for Is it a confidential thing? Is it
- 0:29inappropriate? What do you say to that, Bob, It's not confidential.
- 0:33I mean they're your notes. It's not inappropriate. They are your notes.
- 0:37If a client asked me that, if asked me for that, I would
- 0:40talk with them about what they wanted. Did they just want to read them
- 0:44or did they want me to write up a summary? And in any case
- 0:46I would charge them for the time. Yeah, it's not weird to ask
- 0:50for your Well, it's not inappropriate, it's not inappropriate. Unusual, Yeah,
- 0:55it is unusual in all, like, how many times in your career
- 1:00has anyone asked you for the file? Nuts? Never? Well, one
- 1:06person, but they wanted to use the file in a divorce proceeding, and
- 1:11I resisted that as legally but as strongly as I could. Did you give
- 1:15them the file? You didn't give them the file. It was a couple
- 1:19and it gets kind of tricky with issues of confidentiality when only one person can
- 1:23sense. Yeah. Yeah, So I had a talk with our lawyer about
- 1:27that, and it's been a bit so I don't remember all the details,
- 1:32but I don't want my notes to be used for any kind of divorce or
- 1:38forensic purpose, and I will resist that because I think it will get in
- 1:44the way of therapeutic alliance or possible future work. They actually resolved and then
- 1:51considered returning. And if I had, if I had just you know,
- 1:55handed of the notes, there would have been a liability problem, and liability
- 1:59for what for not getting consent from both parties. So I wasn't going to
- 2:02do it unless until I was really sure that it was that I was protected
- 2:07in whatever action I took. But it would have it would have just undermined
- 2:12any future work. Yeah. Well, perfect scenario, unfortunately, is that
- 2:19your notes are so boring that very there's no use in pulling it and no
- 2:27risk of say, you know, one of the partners gets their hands on
- 2:31the file, there's no risk that anything could be used against the other partner.
- 2:38So that's what I tell all my supervisors to do. But it's so
- 2:43rare that it happens, and when it does happen, it's pretty low risk
- 2:47anyway, you know, Like the say that you had included something in the
- 2:53file that might be able to be used against the other person, as long
- 2:57as it's within a certain boundary, there's no chance that anyone could be able
- 3:01to sue you, especially effectively, because you included a relevant clinical detail in
- 3:09the client file. You know, it's not your fault that they disclosed it
- 3:15to you, Right Like if you go to your physician and you say to
- 3:21your physician, I've been smoking my whole life and now I have problems breathing,
- 3:29and then the physician just writes that in the file. It's it's relevant
- 3:32clinically obviously smoking your whole life. That's important to put in a note.
- 3:38And then later they're trying to sue their employer for air pollution and the client
- 3:45the patient file is pulled and it says in the notes, well, actually
- 3:49says here that you you disclosed to your doctor, you've been smoking your whole
- 3:53life, but in court you're saying you never smoked, so this is being
- 3:57used against you. You can't sue the physician for writing a relevant detail in
- 4:01the same way that as a as a therapist, if it's if it's relevant,
- 4:05and it happens to be used against somebody, then we can't be constantly
- 4:13looking over our shoulder about that. Having said that, it's a lot easier
- 4:16to sleep at night in those situations if you can hand over your file and
- 4:21be pretty sure that that won't even happen, you know what I mean.
- 4:25But yeah, getting back to Megan's question, is it unusual. Yeah,
- 4:30But regarding confidentiality, yeah, it's confidential between you and your and your clinicians.
- 4:39It's your confidential information. It's your file. In the same way that
- 4:43all of us have legal access to our medical file, you have legal access
- 4:48to your to your therapy file, which is considered a medical file in the
- 4:54United States. It's all under HIPPA. You know, health information now.
- 4:57And in terms of what Bob was saying early, in terms of having a
- 5:00conversation with a client, I've only had my file pulled once that I can
- 5:05remember. Out of thousands of clients, and well, did they pull the
- 5:11file for the client that died by suicide? Who's the they? Nobody did,
- 5:15No one did. Yeah, So because I thought there was an investigation,
- 5:19I mean there was, right like you were contacted. I was told
- 5:24that the person was found. I don't recall if there was any investigation beyond
- 5:29that her family were estrange from her, so they weren't pursuing anything. And
- 5:34the only other people were some friends and we're colleagues, and nobody requested anything.
- 5:41I yeah, I just sat in the door. Yeah. It's kind
- 5:45of weird because in the medical world, you know, with online charts and
- 5:51whatnot, you just have to click through a couple menu items and there's your
- 5:57session notes, your progress notes, you know, Like I had my colonoscopy
- 6:00and I'm on, it's through my chart, and so I get a notification
- 6:06that there's a new note for the colonoscopy itself. By the way, I
- 6:12don't know if I've said it, I have a clean bill of health,
- 6:15no issues at all, and the colonoscopy itself was a breeze, was a
- 6:23pun I thought I thought about saying, you know, so to speak,
- 6:28and I didn't know where it fit. But when I think about it,
- 6:30yeah, you know, because they gave me photos of my insights. Is
- 6:38you get the doctor signed the pictures and it's like a cavern, right,
- 6:44so they must be blowing air or carbon dioxide or something some some form of
- 6:49gas gas that has to come out eventually. Yeah, so I figure it
- 6:57they either take it out while I don't remember farting a lot when I will
- 7:00go or after yeah. Yeah, so it doesn't take long for it to
- 7:04evacuate. But they don't do anything. It just finds its way. At
- 7:08least that's what happened for me. Oh really, I have very vague memory
- 7:11of any of it, but I did get my doctor to sign off my
- 7:14pictures. You do remember having the colonoscopy. I remember just snips snips of
- 7:19you know during no, no, no, no, I remember anything during
- 7:23it was I was after yeah, after, Yeah, but I do remember.
- 7:26I asked the guy to sign sign the pictures, so he did,
- 7:30and I had it framed him and gave it away as a Christmas present.
- 7:33Oh, at the White Elephant. At the White Elephant. Yeah apparently.
- 7:38So I was talking about this on the podcast and some folks were commenting from
- 7:44other countries, saying that there's a wide variety of anesthesia procedure things, and
- 7:50in other some countries they don't have you don't get any anesty. WHOA,
- 7:55Yeah, I was very happily unconscious. Yeah. It they just roll you
- 7:59over and go for it. And then in other countries they'll give you a
- 8:03slight amount of sleepy relaxing, but you're still basically aware of the whole thing.
- 8:09And in the United States you're out. You're out like a lit oral
- 8:13though now I don't think it was I never had gas. Did you have
- 8:16some kind of gas, meaning like nitrous or I don't know what they use.
- 8:22I think it's a relaxing, but it's propothol, that's what they use.
- 8:26Propothol. What's that? Is that oral thing? Or is that no
- 8:28ivy ivy ivy. Yeah, I guess they gave me an IVY. I
- 8:31don't remember it. Oh yeah, colonoscopia. They definitely gave you an IV
- 8:35and they definitely gave you propofol. Yeah, because the alternative is a general
- 8:41anesthesia where they literally stop your your breathing. I mean, or you're so
- 8:46knocked out, you're so unconscious that year I think I think It subdues your
- 8:50brain stems essentially, so you I used to know all these terms. But
- 8:56that sort of anesthesia is for more involved proceed like open heart surgery or something,
- 9:01and they have to breathe for you, and therefore there's a lot more
- 9:05risk of people dying, whereas with propothol you're just just having struck down.
- 9:11I mean, there are risks, and there needs to be an antisesiologist that
- 9:16knows what they're doing. It is what I believe killed Michael Jackson. He
- 9:20was having a really hard time sleeping, I think because of his PTSD from
- 9:26massive amounts of trauma he went through with his dad. Apparently there's there's a
- 9:31Michael Jackson biopic coming out. Yeah, I heard that, and that'll be
- 9:35interesting to see how they handle that because the things that his father did,
- 9:39I mean, there's abuse, and then there's what Michael Jackson's father did to
- 9:43me. It is like beyond the it's psychopathic, it's cruel, it's sadistic
- 9:50what his father did, and they all were abused as far as I know,
- 9:56but Michael had a particular hard time with it because he was so young,
- 10:00and his older brothers I can't remember. But also you know, because
- 10:03kids turn on each other. Also, there were a lot of kids,
- 10:07and so the little bit of love you're going to get is going to be
- 10:09spread out pretty thinly. And also the amount of pressure that was on him,
- 10:16given his talent. As soon as he could form memories at the age
- 10:20of four or five or six, he was thrust into the whole system,
- 10:26and you know, the touring and the reforming and the rehearsing, and the
- 10:31rehearsing and the rehearsing and the perfectionism. It was really harmful to him.
- 10:37And if he did abuse children, I think it's you know, from my
- 10:43memory of my hypothesis, having looked over all the data, was that he
- 10:48had as an adult what some people will have, which is arrested development of
- 10:54they're not really an adult. They think of themselves as a child, and
- 11:00they feel like a child and they want to regress to that place because that's
- 11:05where they last left off with their growth developmentally. And yet they also had
- 11:09He also had sexual urges and felt safe around other kids, you know,
- 11:16neverland and all the kid stuff, and also a good dose of modeling about
- 11:22exploitation of bodies and not caring about other people's feelings. Really, you know,
- 11:28and a desperation of wanting to just feel okay in the world, and
- 11:35self hatred about his face and his skin and his nose, and you know,
- 11:41of course racism, but you know, I imagine that mostly because of
- 11:45his father. And then you get what you get, I think anyway,
- 11:48But so propothal, he was having a hard time sleeping. From an understanding,
- 11:54he had a full time a physician who would put him to sleep every
- 12:00night, and from my memory, it was a concoction of several different substances.
- 12:05But anyway, so my colonoscopy went really well, great, and I
- 12:11have a note in my chart. But for Megan in Arizona, she's asking
- 12:18if if it's okay to ask for the file. But the thing is,
- 12:20Megan, is that Oh, getting back to what I was saying earlier,
- 12:24I have very minimal questions. If someone were to ask me, which has
- 12:31only happened once, like I said, but I would say, oh,
- 12:33I just you know me, can I ask what you want it for?
- 12:35Only because I would want to temper expectations. So if Megan were to ask
- 12:39me this question, can I have the file because I want a summary of
- 12:43our work? I would tell her I will absolutely give you the file.
- 12:46I'll tell you it's kind of a process because I have to, like,
- 12:48you know, print it out and da da da. But some people it's
- 12:52literally online so that they can I think I'm pretty sure some people younger therapists
- 12:56or newer therapists today it's it's just like a lot or something. I don't
- 13:01even know. I write them on paper. Yeah, and so there's that.
- 13:07But I would tell Megan that the notes are not going to be a
- 13:11summary. If you want a summary, like what you were saying Bob earlier
- 13:15is if you want me to write something up, I could certainly do that.
- 13:18I charge for the time, and I'd be happy to do that.
- 13:22That would be much more of a summary. And I you know, i'd
- 13:26look over the notes and i'd reflect and think and try to put But in
- 13:31terms of the notes, it's going to be very, very boring for a
- 13:33variety of reasons. I think people think that you're write you know, detailed
- 13:37notes about what they talk about or you know, but actually no, as
- 13:43little as possible, I do not want to write anybody's biography. And yeah,
- 13:50we have psychotherapy notes or process notes that we can keep separate in a
- 13:54separate file that is not in the official patient class file. And we're allowed
- 14:01to have that as therapists because they HIPPA and the laws, and you know,
- 14:05society wants us to be able to take notes that aren't at risk of
- 14:11harming the client. So if a client were to be talking in a certain
- 14:16direction, and I might wonder, sounds like, well, like I guess
- 14:20an example would be, I might say, it sounds like my client is
- 14:24abusing their partner. You know, I might hear that and there, you
- 14:28know, they're not telling me that directly, but I'm hearing signs, and
- 14:31I'm like, one't you know, I might write that down sounds like maybe
- 14:37she's abusing her husband at home, And I write that in the fought and
- 14:41I want that to be on the radar. And if I don't write it
- 14:46in my notes somewhere, I might forget to assess for that. And psychotherapy
- 14:52notes are the property of the therapist, right, and so those are separate
- 14:56and would be much more descriptive and typically a client file would be. But
- 15:01anyway, so Megan, that's what i'd say about that. So personally,
- 15:05if I were in your shoes, Megan, I would just ask your therapist
- 15:09to write a summary if they would like to, or the two of you
- 15:15can write one together, or something. I don't know. Next email anonymous
- 15:18Middleitier patron. She says, Hi, doctor Kirk and Bob. I've recently
- 15:22connected with my former teacher who taught me when I was twelve. I'm twenty
- 15:28one now and he's now in his late forties. I had always really admired,
- 15:33respected, and even had a crush on him when I was young.
- 15:35He never made me feel uncomfortable when I was a student, but now he
- 15:41does. I was excited to talk to him, but I felt conflicted when
- 15:46he started making it sexual, and I sometimes reciprocated even though it made me
- 15:52feel uncomfortable. Eventually, I told him I couldn't talk to him anymore if
- 15:56it continued, and he apologized, but he continues to cross the same boundaries.
- 16:03When I tried to cut him off, he said he thought that I
- 16:07was probably a catfish if I didn't want to see him, and I finally
- 16:11give in. Bob, I assume, since you're LETTI, you don't know
- 16:15what a catfish is. I don't think I know what that is. Yeah,
- 16:18so catfishing is when one will act like someone else, Like if I
- 16:22were to create an account called Bob Gettle and use your picture and then start
- 16:30go on Tinder and I act like I'm you, Oh got it. A
- 16:34typical situation would be, I don't know, you're trying to scam people out
- 16:38of money, and so you pull a model's picture, you know, and
- 16:44you act like you're this really attractive person, and then you get desperate people
- 16:49to fall in love with you online, and then you eventually start asking for
- 16:52money like I really want to come see you, but I need some money.
- 16:56Da da da, And then yeah, it's a scam, but will
- 17:00do it just because they're cruel. And there's some pretty famous cases. There
- 17:03was an NFL player where it happened, a real sensational case where I think
- 17:10he ended up dying. I can't remember exactly a story, but this happened
- 17:15like ten years ago or something. Young young man football player had been catfished
- 17:21and was totally in love with someone and had never actually spoken with her.
- 17:27Everyone knew about her, you know, like he would he would say this
- 17:30is my girlfriend and that verse. I can't remember anyway, And there's a
- 17:33lot of and I watched reality TV. It happens on a ninety day fiance
- 17:37sometimes and it's real sad. You know, at first you're thinking, how
- 17:41could you possibly believe that? Right? Like, what would you think?
- 17:45Why would this happen? Why would somebody believe it? Yeah, they were
- 17:49lonely, they were intrigued, they were attracted, and they wanted to believe.
- 17:59And also maybe you know, people don't lie, Like if I have
- 18:02a worldview where people basically tell the truth, then yeah, right exactly.
- 18:07So anyway, he is saying, hey, if you don't meet up with
- 18:12me in person, I think you're catfishing me. Well and okay, yeah,
- 18:19and so she says, I finally gave in. Oh I'm sorry.
- 18:23He was pretty normal in person, but he wants to meet with me again
- 18:27over drinks. He even drove to the grocery store I was at to try
- 18:33to see me without my permission. I feel trapped. I know logically I
- 18:37can just block him, but I don't want him to dislike me. Oh.
- 18:41End of email. What do you say to that, Bob, Well,
- 18:48he's not respecting your boundary. You're saying no, and he's pushing or
- 18:53pulling whatever you want to call it, to have contact with you. And
- 18:56it's actually working. So there's a there is a component of reinforcement that may
- 19:03be happening here where a bunch of no's with a yes thrown in will create
- 19:11that I'll create a reinforcing loop or the person that'll actually try harder. So
- 19:17if you want to get him out of your life, you want to be
- 19:22as consistent with your no and short as possible. You don't have to respond,
- 19:29and if you do, or when you do, very short and and
- 19:33just stick to the same consistent message no, and eventually he'll give up and
- 19:37go away. But it sounds like he's using some kind of tactic to guilt
- 19:41you or make you feel ashamed or whatever, make you feel like you should.
- 19:45That's bullshit. You are not You don't know anybody anything. And you
- 19:52know, if he finds that disappointing, well fuck it. So he finds
- 19:56it fucking disappointing, who gives a fuck? Protect yourself, that's the main
- 20:00thing. You know. Yeah, maybe it's going to cost you him liking
- 20:03you, but I'm not really sure that that's worth it. And you might
- 20:06ask yourself, why is that so important to me? Somebody who's actually abusing
- 20:10my trust? And I want them to like me. What's that about?
- 20:12Like, that's a worthy question, right, and you should still protect yourself.
- 20:17It's totally cool, and we're not on this earth for people to like
- 20:19us, right, so yeah, especially this fucker. Yeah it's not okay
- 20:26man. Yeah, well, first off, anonymous military patriot, I'm so
- 20:29sorry this happened. Yeah, yeah, what I think about the teachers that
- 20:34I liked growing up to think that something like this would happen to me would
- 20:41just be a real doozy on my trust or hope and humanity or something like.
- 20:49Yeah, it's awful, and you can retain the memories that you have
- 20:55of him when you were twelve. Yeah, you say that he wasn't inappropriate
- 21:00back then, so and he probably wasn't great. So that's great and for
- 21:04you you can hold on to that, you can value that, you can
- 21:08you don't have to discard it. You don't have to second guess everything that
- 21:12you've ever thought of, you know, like, was I wrong about him?
- 21:15You know, he's different to you now, and he could have been
- 21:21a very good person that wasn't out to exploit you or any of the other
- 21:26kids potentially. But yeah, run run, run, run, run.
- 21:34Let me tell you, anonymous patron. This person is dangerous capital D.
- 21:42Let me just I mean, halfway through the email, I was like run,
- 21:47and then as I'm reading more, I'm like, run, run,
- 21:49run. It's like watching a you know, a horror movie and someone's going
- 21:56deeper into the haunted house. It's like, no, no, no,
- 21:59no, no, no no no no no, just turn around, go
- 22:00home, watch Netflix. Move on at Your curiosity or whatever it was that
- 22:07was attracting you is not worth it. There's so much danger here because let
- 22:17me tell you, let me highlight what's happening. So you reach out to
- 22:22him, and you're excited to talk to him, and he starts to make
- 22:29it sexual, which is bizarre to one someone that's that much younger than him.
- 22:37You know, if you guys consented to a tender date or that was
- 22:41the premise. Like you're at a dance club and you start talking and one
- 22:48thing leads to another and he starts to say, hey, you look good
- 22:52in that dress, and maybe you're not so into him. Okay, you
- 22:56know it's it's context. But for a former student, you know, is
- 23:03it legal? Yeah, for him to proposition you you're twenty one, it's
- 23:08absolutely not illegal. It's not pedophilia, it's not child abuse, but it's
- 23:15not typical. You know, most teachers in his position would, even if
- 23:22they had a sexual attraction, would say, well, this is not the
- 23:26time or the place. Yeah, so the fact that he even started that
- 23:33is a little questionable at the very least, but not like I said something
- 23:38that would be automatically something to judge him over. But then you say that,
- 23:45you know you tried to push back. But here's the thing, even
- 23:48though it was uncomfortable for you, you sometimes reciprocated. So not only is
- 23:55he a big problem, but you have a vulnerability to this because if I'll
- 24:02tell you, if it were me, and I could say this because I'm
- 24:06a man, it's easier for me to say this, I would not reciprocate
- 24:10if I wasn't comfortable. I've been in situations where I've been forced to reciprocate
- 24:15those kinds of things, and it's a lot, like I said, safer
- 24:18for me because generally speaking, men are not targeted or as much in danger
- 24:23in the least. Men can be in danger in situations like this, for
- 24:26sure, but just given my trauma history or whatever, that's not a vulnerability
- 24:32of mine. So you can't necessarily even trust that you will be able to
- 24:37know that you deserve boundaries given your behavior already. So there's that. But
- 24:45eventually you say, I told him I couldn't talk to him anymore if it
- 24:48continued, the sexual stuff continued. So at that point, now we are
- 24:55at the why in the road. If he respects that and is mortified and
- 25:00like, oh shit, yeah, sorry, totally that. Yeah I think
- 25:07I thought things were but okay, sorry, yeah, I feel so awkward
- 25:12down So I feel so bad. If he did that and stuck to it,
- 25:17yeah, as a normal humid would, then maybe you trust him moving
- 25:22forward. But the fact that he continues, yeah, you told him no
- 25:29more and he continues to cross the same boundaries. In any situation, if
- 25:37it's your husband, for fuck's sake, that does this, that's a problem.
- 25:42I don't care how close your relationship is. This relationship, it's already
- 25:48suspect that it's happening. And the fact that you drew a boundary and he
- 25:52continues to cross it, Like I said, in any circumstance, that's a
- 25:57huge red flag, especially in one like this, because of least the energy
- 26:07around the fact that you were once twelve and in his class, so you
- 26:11know you would. It's just it has that feel to it, and exploitation
- 26:17and preying on someone that is power have a lot less power. So that's
- 26:25red flag number one, massive red flag. If you told me if you
- 26:29stop there, I'd be like, run, run, run, because it
- 26:34takes a special kind of human being to continue to do what he is doing.
- 26:40He is a very particular sort of sicko that you need to be as
- 26:47far away as possible from danger. And it's not just innocent, cross or
- 26:55innocent, but it won't stop with just him crossing these actual boundaries. That
- 27:02is not what I see. What I see is the beginning of massive exploitation
- 27:07and harm and maybe even getting off on watching other people squirm. Because for
- 27:15Bob and I, as red blooded American dudes that have all the horniness or
- 27:26whatever that you would expect to a person within the Bell curve to have,
- 27:33isn't that a sexy statement? That's what if I was dating right now,
- 27:37that would be on my belt, that'd be on my Tinder program. The
- 27:38curve, I'd say, like, I'm smack. I'm somewhere within one or
- 27:44two standard deviations of horniness, right now. But for Bob and I,
- 27:52you couldn't pay us enough money to do what he's doing. Oh god.
- 27:57This has nothing to do with him being attracted to you or you being attractive
- 28:06or whatever. You know what I mean. This is something sick. This
- 28:08is a dynamic. This is a power dynamic, some kind of push,
- 28:11some kind of exploitation or attempt at it. He wants to do this.
- 28:17He's risking a lot by doing it because usually, or a lot of the
- 28:21times, this probably doesn't work. So he's going beyond that. He's accepting
- 28:26that risk because he likes this. And that is the problem with people like
- 28:34this. It does not stop with well I'll just get together with him,
- 28:40or I'll just entertain this boundary crossing. It won't stop there. It's not
- 28:45well, I'll just give him this one gift. It'll calm him down and
- 28:49then then I'll be safe. No, No, it just reinforces. Yeah,
- 28:55it'll the line just keeps moving. So now I can't know that with
- 29:00one hundred percent certainty, but I'm pretty damn sure about this because again,
- 29:04ninety nine percent of people wouldn't even come close to this. Like I said,
- 29:10most people would be Oh my god, I'm so sorry. If even
- 29:14if you, anonymous patron, were the one who was flirting first, and
- 29:19you initiated everything and then eventually you're just like, yeah, I don't want
- 29:25to do that anymore, most people would be more of oh my god,
- 29:29you know, yeah, yeah, yeah, sorry, because most people don't
- 29:34want to cross those lines. You know, they want to they want that,
- 29:38they want there to be overt consent. So going on, it says,
- 29:47eventually I told him I couldn't talk to him anymore if it continued,
- 29:51all right, right, and then that's when you and then he crossed okay.
- 29:53When I tried to cut him off, he said he thought I was
- 29:57probably a catfish, so he tugged at that string and you went with it
- 30:03again. I'm not victim blaming an almost patron, but you can't trust yourself
- 30:11given these I'm hearing. I wasn't comfortable with it being sexual to begin with,
- 30:15but I reciprocated anyway. I didn't want to talk to him anymore.
- 30:22I cut him off. He accused me of catfishing, As Bob was saying,
- 30:26who cares? He can believe it was a catfish, all the better,
- 30:29honestly, because if he thinks it's a stranger, then you can claim
- 30:34it was a catfish and that you never talked to him, but you actually
- 30:40gave in. I'm not victim blaming, but you can't trust yourself. So
- 30:45when it comes to stocking and abusive people, we need a whole team of
- 30:52Yeah, team, I like that. Yeah. And then you say he
- 30:56was pretty normal in person. Of course he was, because he's trying to
- 31:00suck you in love bombing the whole thing. But he wants to meet with
- 31:03me again over drinks because I'd give it a fifty percent chance he wants to
- 31:07drug you with those drinks. But at the very I mean, honestly,
- 31:12I would not be surprised. But if at the very least he wants you
- 31:18to be intoxicated because he's hoping that you'll be pliable. Yeah, and you
- 31:26are pliable is a thing. I'm not blaming you, but you can't trust
- 31:32yourself without a team. You need a team around you, You need support.
- 31:38This cannot be done even if you're not vulnerable to this dealing with a
- 31:47stalker, which this is. It is impossible for anyone to cope alone because
- 31:55of how scary it is, how confusing it is, how sort of gaslighty.
- 32:00It can become brainwashing. It can be going on here and here and
- 32:06so again. At this point in the email, I'm like, run,
- 32:07run, run on run. You say he even drove to the grocery store
- 32:12I was at to try to see me without my permission? What the fuck?
- 32:21How did he know you were there? I mean, even if you
- 32:22said I'm at the at the QFC or the Kroger or the Safeway or whatever
- 32:28in such town, even if he said that, he drives out to see
- 32:35you. Yeah, stalking run, Yeah, sadistic rapist run and yeah.
- 32:47As Bob says, uh, you know when you say you don't want him
- 32:52to dislike you, I want him to dislike you. I want him to
- 32:58dislike me. I don't want anyone of this nature. If they like you
- 33:04or me or anybody like us, that's not a good sign. We want
- 33:12stalkers to be so frustrated with us that they hate us, because if they
- 33:20like us, then in a situation like you know, then it means so
- 33:25that's your gauge homics patron is, if he likes you, you're on the
- 33:30wrong path, right. If he dislikes you, you're on the right path.
- 33:34So and again another indication, patron, that you're not that you don't
- 33:42have the foundation to do this alone. You're saying you need a foundation,
- 33:50you need a team to support you and help you hang in perspective and getting
- 33:57back to what Bob said, Yeah, as short of a communication as possible
- 34:01that is firm and never reply. You know, it's something like I've contacted
- 34:07the authorities. I well, I don't know if you want to say that,
- 34:12because sometimes you want to play a game where you just want to gray
- 34:16rock them and slowly back your way out the door, because if you go
- 34:22after them with threats, they might come back with threats and that might make
- 34:27it hard to sleep at night. So like what I would do if I
- 34:31were in your if I were a part of your team, I would recommend
- 34:35that you tell him I'm sorry that I you know, I can't continue with
- 34:42this relationship. I just want to tell you that I had a you know,
- 34:47I have fond memories of you as a teacher when I was growing up,
- 34:52and I don't want to date you, and I don't want to be
- 34:55a friend. I don't want to talk to you anymore. Yeah, it
- 34:59was nice to catch up at times with you and then you say, and
- 35:07I would appreciate it if you didn't try to contact me because I don't want
- 35:15to continue with this. And then you send that off, he replies.
- 35:21If he's like cool, you know, nice catching up, then you move
- 35:24on with your life. If he's like, hey, you know, I
- 35:28thought you said you'd be you know, he'll do something. He's going to
- 35:30try to get his hooks into you. He might even literally show up at
- 35:36your work or something. And so at that point you want and you want
- 35:42to be ready for that. You don't want it to catch you off guard
- 35:45because that could absolutely happen. I would absolutely expect it to happen. Be
- 35:50weird if it didn't, honestly, given what he's shown us. And then
- 35:53you want to have a response to that and say, you know some of
- 35:59the communication, Okay, I told you I wanted it over, and you
- 36:04are continuing to try to engage. I am now going to block you.
- 36:09And if I see you, I have been told that I need to call
- 36:14the police if you show up at my work, or if you show up
- 36:16at the grocery store, or you know, I've been told by my friends
- 36:22and family and my therapist or whoever it is that you want to identity,
- 36:25because if you say you've talked with a bunch of people, that's what deflates
- 36:30them. They want you isolating. So if you tell them I have told
- 36:37everyone what's happening, I've shown them the exchange. You know, again,
- 36:44you don't necessarily want to lead with this. There's a lot of strategy that
- 36:46goes on because if you lead with it again, it could provoke. But
- 36:52you so you want to give them a chance to just you want to be
- 36:55firm, give them a chance to just drift away. But if they don't
- 37:00do that, then you have to bring up a little bit more of a
- 37:02heavy gun of I've talked with everybody, and again, this is all I'm
- 37:06writing is you never talk you know. I've talked with my friends and family
- 37:12and my therapists, and they've all told me that you are not to be
- 37:16trusted, given that you weren't respectful of boundaries, right, And so I
- 37:22am now going to be blocking you. And if I see you again,
- 37:25or you contact me again, I will at the very least alert my therapist
- 37:30and my support system. I might even call the authorities. And then if
- 37:37he contacts you, you follow follow through. Yeah, And maybe even have
- 37:40other people contact him, like like if you get a police officer involved,
- 37:45or a domestic violence advocate, or your mom or somebody, just anyone,
- 37:53because if you get enough, if you get other people to contact him,
- 37:57then again it sends a signal you're not dealing with a vulnerable, isolated person,
- 38:04You're dealing with a whole team, and that'll typically end it right there.
- 38:08But I would be very, very concerned, and I would around those
- 38:13times not sleep alone, honestly, not to freak you out, but for
- 38:20a while, I would have make sure that you have people around you that
- 38:23are with you twenty four to seven kind of a thing. As a man
- 38:29myself, that's what I would do, let alone if I were a very
- 38:31young, vulnerable woman in the society. So this is this is no joke,
- 38:38no fucking joke. This guy is a People talk about red flags all
- 38:43the time, and this is beyond red flag. This is what's beyond red
- 38:49like infrared, it's red hot infrared flag. This flag is like burning red
- 38:58with my rage. Okay, let's take a break. What do you say?
- 39:00Yeah, all right, back from the break. So middle tier patron
- 39:08Mimi from Oklahoma, she says and I'll summarize the beginning. Basically, she
- 39:14was trained as a marriage of family therapist thirty years ago, but for whatever
- 39:20reason, she didn't work in the field until recently. So she's getting back
- 39:24into it, and so she says, could there be such a thing as
- 39:28a borderline couple? Combined? They present with borderline features. I have been
- 39:35seeing a couple for six years. I wouldn't describe either as borderline, but
- 39:39together I find myself with similar feelings as I do with individuals I would consider
- 39:44borderline. Side note, I'm fairly confident my mother was also borderline, so
- 39:49heightened emotions challenged me the most heightened emotions challenged me. With my couple,
- 39:55I sometimes sense their fear of abandonment, more so with one. Times I
- 40:00have felt idealized and at other times devalued by the couple. They have no
- 40:06strong identity outside of a conflict about his mother. Potentially borderline as well as
- 40:12a couple, they present often with anger and mood changes. He can be
- 40:16hyper vigilant and she can dissociate. Both have had childhood sexual trauma. I
- 40:22love your podcast and give you much credit for helping me to re enter this
- 40:28amazing arena and of email, Bob, you're shaking your head. What's your
- 40:32reaction? As a case conceptualization, I don't understand the question, Like,
- 40:38I don't know how you're helped by thinking about things in terms of this,
- 40:40in these terms like borderline personality disorder is a way to think about what happens
- 40:45for somebody so that you can understand them and try to help them. But
- 40:49a borderline couple isn't isn't the case conceptualization? I think that you can do
- 40:52anything with So if it were me, I'd be thinking about are they Are
- 41:00they folks that tend to be more high arousal? And are they folks that
- 41:04tend to be either avoidant or angry angry? What are they called? Angry?
- 41:07Anxious? Anxious angry something like that, So the pursuing type or the
- 41:12withdrawing type, And then are they low arousal or higher arousal? So it
- 41:15just sounds like you have two people that are higher arousal who are both maybe
- 41:22on the on the like the pursuing or the what do they call it,
- 41:25I don't know why, I don't know this language. Distancing, No,
- 41:30the other one pursuing distancing. Yeah, but they sounds like they're both the
- 41:34description occupied. Yeah, preoccupied, thank you, that's the sword. They
- 41:37both sound like they're preoccupied. Just the little little here. That's what went
- 41:42through my head is that maybe they're both just preoccupied. Okay, fine,
- 41:47So if if it's a couple, I think the thing you think about is,
- 41:52well, what's happening in their relationship? What are they what are they
- 41:55setting off in one another? What are they triggering in one another? And
- 41:59how are they reinforcing their cycle? And so I don't find this a particularly
- 42:06helpful way to conceptualize a couple, So I would encourage you to drop it
- 42:09and find a different way to concede them so that you can help them.
- 42:14Yeah. I think the only thing I'll add I agree with everything Bob is
- 42:19saying nothing in your description of them would lead me down a road of conceptualizing
- 42:27anyone as borderline. Really, and honestly, there seems to be a lot
- 42:30of borderline labeling happening here. Maybe now, maybe it's all accurate and if
- 42:37we or at least cogent and demonstratable by data. You know, it's a
- 42:44short email, but in this pretty short email, you have kind of diagnosed
- 42:50a number of people. Your mom which I would respect more than these other
- 42:55labels because you know your mom very well. But the couple and someone's mom,
- 43:01I think that the husband's now Again, if you gave us the full
- 43:06story, maybe we'd be like, oh, okay, maybe there's something there.
- 43:10But I can't. I'm trying to imagine a situation in which me I
- 43:16would I don't. I don't know if I could septualize them as being a
- 43:20quote unquote borderline couple, But I'm trying to imagine a situation which two people
- 43:25that I did not believe were on the spectrum of borderline personality, and yet
- 43:31together they would demonstrate that that the data point that you're pointing to is the
- 43:37way that the couple makes you feel, which is something that I absolutely pay
- 43:42attention to. Hell yeah in my early assessment of any personality disorder, because
- 43:47I typically will have an inducement of some fear and some terror, you know,
- 43:54some adrenaline that I will have a hard time putting my finger on,
- 43:58you know. Yeah, So it makes sense to consider your countertransparence as you're
- 44:01trying to understand what's happening in a couple, right or an individual right.
- 44:06In this case of couple, right, But there's so many pathways to having
- 44:10that familiar terror feeling that don't involve borderline. Now you know it's a language
- 44:19system. Maybe you could convince me, me, me, that the way
- 44:22you're looking at it actually helps you to help them. But I would suspect
- 44:28given that you've been out of the field for thirty years, I don't know
- 44:32if you're currently being supervised again or if you have a refresher in refamiliarizing yourself.
- 44:40You know, I personally can't imagine having you know, well, Bob
- 44:45and I went to graduate school about almost thirty years ago. Yeah, twenty
- 44:50nine years ago when we started, that's right, And I think from your
- 44:54email you were saying it was more than thirty years that you graduated. I'm
- 44:58not sure, but anyway, you know, similar to since you and I
- 45:00can't imagine having not worked in the field, had not had a podcast,
- 45:07and not been a professor, and not been a supervisor, and then suddenly
- 45:12I'm hanging a shingle and I'm meeting with people. I can't imagine how overwhelmed
- 45:17and how ungrounded I would feel. For me, if I were in your
- 45:22shoes, I would consider my graduate degree to essentially be gone from my brain
- 45:30because it's a cursory introduction to the field to begin with, yes, and
- 45:37to have that just a distant memory. And plus the education back then and
- 45:44the requirements back then were half literally or less than what they are today.
- 45:49Like your degree, Oh, your counseling degree was a year and a half,
- 45:54six quarters. Yeah, sixteen classes, so I know at least two
- 45:59of them were agnostics and psychopathology, which is a cursory introduction to the DSM.
- 46:07And then I know that you and I had pro sem at least two,
- 46:12if not three quarters that was essentially like counseling skill or person of the
- 46:16therapist kind of stuff. I know there was a so that's five classes and
- 46:22again an introduction. I know that we had a counseling skills class, communication
- 46:27counseling. I don't know what it is called back then, but like had
- 46:30a general therapy skills class. There was a theories class that we took.
- 46:35I remember personality theories, right, well, therapy theory, therapy theories,
- 46:39right yeah. And I remember one of the weeks that we took this class,
- 46:44we studied reality therapy, which nobody talks about anymore. And so and
- 46:51again, we had like a week on cognitive behavioral therapy, a week on
- 46:57psycho analysis. Yeah. Yeah, and so that's seven classes. I know.
- 47:01We had a development class you and I took, and it was I
- 47:07liked the class. One of the more memorable classes that we took, but
- 47:10had almost nothing to do with human development. It was a class in which
- 47:15we wrote a myth, a myth right, It was about although I will
- 47:22say that I learned, like dear listener when you hear me yamor about ceremony
- 47:28and ritual and rights of passage and how American mainstream culture, because of the
- 47:36immigration assimilation mandate erased all of the protocols from the homeland. You have a
- 47:45bunch of Americans that have almost no rituals, no rights of passage, no
- 47:50traditions about how to demarkete the before and the after, the betwixt in between,
- 47:57as our book was titled. And we have things like graduations or like
- 48:04weddings or funerals, but those are often especially funerals, don't have enough in
- 48:10there. And when you see other cultures that have had a longer time to
- 48:15develop ritual and ceremony and meaning, you'll see a lot more details to it
- 48:22not that we need to be doing that, but it just shows that certain
- 48:27transitions in life, you know, in terms of our mental health, require
- 48:30a lot of activity. Like in you know, some places of Southeast Asia,
- 48:36they will have an entire altar to their ancestors that's just sitting in their
- 48:42living room. And there are some cultures where a year after death, I
- 48:46think they'll they'll dig up the remains and you know, then there'll be a
- 48:52whole ceremony around what you do with the bones and the whatnot. And it's
- 49:00a you know, it's it's built into a religious notion of like the afterlife
- 49:05and this kind of thing. But I think more importantly, it shows that
- 49:09our grieving process doesn't end after a few weeks, you know, like a
- 49:15year later, there's there's a revisiting of it. And if we have something
- 49:20to gather around in terms of ritual, like digging up the remains and taking
- 49:27care of it, right, it feels like you're still tending to this loved
- 49:30one. And it gives you a chance to talk as a community or as
- 49:35a family about the individual. Gives you a chance to think about that individual,
- 49:39and you know, all that is important. And so I got that
- 49:43from this class. But the class was supposed to talk about general human development,
- 49:49like the basics in our field, and we didn't get that anyway.
- 49:52There's a few other classes we were in novels actually as part of the learning,
- 49:55and I agree not it was a good class for what it was,
- 50:00but it wasn't something It was certainly wasn't rigorous in terms of developing psychology or
- 50:05counseling skills. We should have at least touched on attachment theory and nobody,
- 50:12but that was not even the discussed at least really in any class. We
- 50:15took a sex class, human sexuality, sexuality class, right, we took
- 50:19that together as well. I took a family systems class. Our human sexuality
- 50:23teacher was arrested ye later. I don't know that that reflects on our learning,
- 50:28but it is kind of interesting though, because he was arrested, if
- 50:34I remember right, for propositioning a minor. He had propositioned young like teenagers.
- 50:42Yeah, he also in our human sex So but when we when I
- 50:45look back at our human sexuality class, there are some kind of I don't
- 50:49know how to interpret it. Now, do you remember the what we did
- 50:52in that class? Not much well, well, we wrote our papers,
- 50:55we wrote our sexual autobiography. Oh that's right. You have talked about this
- 51:00a few times, like, is he getting off on reading people's histories?
- 51:04Well maybe I did not think at the time. No, But he was
- 51:07very specific in requiring us to be as self disclosing and detailed as possible about
- 51:17our developing sexuality. We're supposed to talk about us as teenagers and how our
- 51:23sexuality was developed. I didn't have a whole lot to say. What great
- 51:31did you get? I do know this. I accidentally put my name in
- 51:37the header. So we're supposed to just identify by a number, right,
- 51:40But I had a habit. I used to put my name in the header
- 51:44on all papers. So my name was I still have that paper my attic
- 51:47digged out. Yeah. Yeah, So he had us anonymize our papers because
- 51:54he wanted to encourage us to be as self disclosing as possible during the class.
- 52:00I felt I felt fine, and I still basically feel fine. But
- 52:04hearing about his issue, you wonder wonder another thing that he did, is
- 52:09he you know we watched porn and I don't remember that, Oh I do.
- 52:15It was it was not your typical porn let's just put it that way,
- 52:20okay. I mean, I don't even know if you would call it
- 52:22porn. It was more instructional demonstration of sexual function of sexual acts, you
- 52:29know. And I don't remember that either. I do not remember watching anything
- 52:35in that class. I can see the movie or the instructional video. There's
- 52:40a few scenes that I remember. I mean, you know, it was
- 52:44just notable that we're in graduate school and and it's fine, you know,
- 52:47and hey, everyone was fine. But but again, hearing later, you
- 52:52wonder, what's something going on, something something weird. Yeah, maybe anyway,
- 52:57So, Mimi, point is, if your education was similar to ours,
- 53:01which I'm guessing it was in terms of how brief it was compared to
- 53:06today, I would just make sure that you have a lot of in person
- 53:09instruction and supervision. I've had people who have in the past hired me postgraduation
- 53:16as their supervisor, and they've explicitly told me that they chose me because I
- 53:22am a professor, and they said, I need you to basically start from
- 53:28the beginning of graduate school for me, because I don't trust that my graduate
- 53:34school instructed me adequately. When I would work with these folks, I would
- 53:38find that it was true for one reason, either they forgot it or their
- 53:43program wasn't very good, and I would not supervise them in the typical way.
- 53:49I would basically be teaching them alongside of supervising their practice. So now
- 53:57we could just be reading your email wrong. But there's nothing here like Okay,
- 54:01Well, getting back to the question, like of a borderline couple,
- 54:04So if a couple didn't present this way, but maybe they had leanings,
- 54:09and then the two of them, but if this were true, I could
- 54:15only come to conclusion that they were already on both of them the borderline personality
- 54:21spectrum. And I just have not looked into it deeply enough because if they're
- 54:25both triggering each other and both of them look like they are presenting with borderline
- 54:30features, I can't imagine a scenario where I would think otherwise. Now,
- 54:37there are people who can be triggered to become more preoccupied as you were getting
- 54:42at, Bob, and that can look borderline, and you might even say
- 54:45that it's on the spectrum given certain presentations. And so yeah, I could
- 54:52see I could see two people if they go through a particularly bad time and
- 54:55normally they operate mostly secure attachment style and there's some incursion and they both tend
- 55:04to react with more preoccupation, more pursuing, maybe some paranoia, hypervigilance.
- 55:09Yeah, so maybe, But I wouldn't call them a quote unquote borderline couple.
- 55:14I would just call it two people that when threatened, they tend to
- 55:16react with preoccupation or something. Anyways, take a break. There's lots of
- 55:21good training to be had. So you know, there's lots of good couple
- 55:23therapy training and you can avail yourself of it. I am the king of
- 55:29go get trained. Yeah, always take a breakway yep. Okay, let's
- 55:37do an opp and old patron praise. These people became patrons all the way
- 55:42back in twenty twenty one, and of state patrons through thick and thin,
- 55:45through all the good moments of the bad moments. All these folks, these
- 55:51patrons are from outside the United States. I group them together. So we
- 55:57have Renal from Paris, France. So I think I'm pronouncing that right.
- 56:00I'm not sure. We have Evgenya from Southampton, Great Britain, Amena from
- 56:08Manchester, Great Britain. Also Mary from Manchester, Jacqueline from Caterham, Great
- 56:15Britain. I'm sure them pronounced that wrong right, Caterham, it's probably like
- 56:20or so, I don't know. Jelina from Witten, Great Britain. I'm
- 56:27just gonna pronounce it as it looks. I'm sure it's wrong. Becky from
- 56:30Sheffield, I know that one Sheffield, Sheffield or maybe it's shuffled anyway,
- 56:35Great Britain. Robert from Dublin, Ireland. Shane from Limerick, Ireland,
- 56:42Eva from i s Oh Raykovic from from Iceland, held Raycovic, Christine from
- 56:50Harlem, the Netherlands. Zeida from Amsterdam, Netherlandsnria, Mahandria or probably in
- 57:00Majandria from Norway. Uh snafrisk I'm sure I'm getting us wrong from Norway.
- 57:07E Dune from Norway, brit from Norway, mister Dunsky from Poland, warsaw
- 57:14Una from Serbia, Aza from s a Riad Riod Where's what? Where's Riod?
- 57:23Oh? I should know Saudi Arabia? Uh okay? Getting an f
- 57:29in geography Maria from Stockholm, Sweden. Karen from Sweden as well. The
- 57:37problem is is Patreon, when it tells me what city it is, it's
- 57:43a It's there's like wing dings in the name because in other languages they have
- 57:47like umlats and sense and stuff, and if you're going off of the English
- 57:53available symbols for letters, it gets translated into our system with basically what looked
- 58:00like wing dings, you know, like there's in this Swedish city name,
- 58:06there's a y that looks that's the but it's a symbol for yen. You
- 58:08know, the Japanese symbol for yen. Is that like a see with the
- 58:12lines. No, it's a y with two lines in it. Oh yeah,
- 58:15yeah, oh. And they that's that's the character, that's part of
- 58:17the word that that's part of the of the the way they're spelling this town
- 58:22in Sweden, and and and so it makes it hard for me to and
- 58:29some of their names have this like this one has more wing dings in it,
- 58:32and so I don't know how to pronounce it, but it looks like
- 58:36Dahlia daya from Slovenia, from maribor Slovenia. Anyway. This has been the
- 58:44geography section of this Butch Butchering Geography. I could like do some homework beforehand,
- 58:52but I find it's much more entertaining when I struggled my way through it.
- 58:57Still amazing yeah, like all over the world. Man, Yeah,
- 59:02middle toier patron Cain from Richmond. I assume Virginia if they don't give like
- 59:07where right, probably Richmond, probably Virginia. But don't we have a Richmond,
- 59:13Washington, Richland, rich Lynde. Yeah. Many therapy goers like to
- 59:19talk about inspirational and influential things their therapists have said to them. Have any
- 59:24client interactions been particularly influential or inspirational in your personal or professional life as a
- 59:30therapist, Bob? Yes, many, though you're going to ask me to
- 59:36sort of name one. Well, I had a DBT student who completely shifted
- 59:39my attitude around how to respond to folks who are asking for money on the
- 59:45street. That was sticks with me and think about it often. The answer
- 59:51to my question to your question is absolutely And I can't remember a single one
- 59:55right now. Yeah. I would say that it's much more common, and
- 1:00:00that for me, and I'm guessing for you, Bob, that it's not
- 1:00:05a mind blowing inspirational experience, but in the moment an inspirational experience. It's
- 1:00:13quite common after a session that I will, you know, go to my
- 1:00:17wife and say I love you or I'm sorry for something because I'll see a
- 1:00:25client do it and I will say, oh, that's I'm inspired now to
- 1:00:31do it myself. So that happens, you know, I would say at
- 1:00:37least once a week, if not more. Or I was talking with a
- 1:00:42client recently and they discovered this mindfulness practice and they were talking about how much
- 1:00:50it helped them, and I said, wow, you're reminding me about how
- 1:00:54to be in the moment and how to pay attention to my body and how
- 1:01:00to notice when my mind is going far away from my body and into the
- 1:01:05future or something right, and uh, you know, thank you for that,
- 1:01:08you know, I said that. So it's much you know, that
- 1:01:13happens all the time. But in terms of just like the kind of things
- 1:01:16that a client would feel like, and I wouldn't say this is incredibly common,
- 1:01:22but you can imagine times where as a client you might think like,
- 1:01:25wow, there was that one moment in therapy that just completely upended things for
- 1:01:30me and helped me like me for as a client. I remember my therapist
- 1:01:37that I asked for word of mouth, uh, you know, references for
- 1:01:43a therapist that would quote unquote kick my ass, and certainly was given a
- 1:01:47reference for that, and he, uh, and I told him the beginning
- 1:01:52too, you know, I said, I don't want to be coddled.
- 1:01:55I want you to really get after me. And he did, and he
- 1:02:01I remember, I was complaining and you know, saying I was very upset
- 1:02:06about something, and he's and I was describing what I was doing in the
- 1:02:10moment, and I thought he was going to say, oh, good for
- 1:02:13you that you advocated for yourself or that you were having your feelings. And
- 1:02:16what he said was wow, pretty histrionic and not, you know, because
- 1:02:25I was opening up and I was looking for the opposite kind of response from
- 1:02:31him. Sure, and it stung like hell, but it very quickly was
- 1:02:37appreciated because it was histrionic, meaning it was narcissistic in a way. I
- 1:02:45was focusing on me or some kind of distortion, imposing really on others.
- 1:02:52And it stuck with me. You know, as a therapist, I'm trying
- 1:02:59to think of a time when I wonder if that's really hard to achieve given
- 1:03:05my mindset when I'm working with clients, right, I'm not there for me.
- 1:03:09No, So if something were to transform me, I would it would
- 1:03:15have to be so mind blowing that it would pull me out of paying attention
- 1:03:20to the client and pull me into myself. Next email military patron Sonia,
- 1:03:27She says, Hi, doctor Kirk, and Bob, why do you think
- 1:03:30older people often complain? I've been spending a lot of time with my eighty
- 1:03:36three year old grandmother lately, and she does what seems to be common for
- 1:03:38people her age. She complains about the modern world a lot and doesn't feel
- 1:03:45like learning new things. She likes thinking about the way things used to be.
- 1:03:51Do you think this is natural? Or is it something that should be
- 1:03:53treated despite how common it is? Common it is, Bob, what do
- 1:03:57you think I wasn't aware that old people complain, so it's definitely a stereotype.
- 1:04:02Yeah you know, old man shakes fist. Oh yeah, yeah,
- 1:04:05yeah right right right, get off my driveway, damn kids? Right yeah?
- 1:04:13Why? Maybe because we fear death? If it's true, maybe it's
- 1:04:16because we fear death, or because we feel lonely, or maybe we feel
- 1:04:21like life has passed us by. Maybe we feel like we're no longer relevant.
- 1:04:29Colleen said to me last week, She's like, I'm sixty one.
- 1:04:33I am now invisible because the world only looks at women who are, you
- 1:04:39know, whatever, young or something. I mean, I would say,
- 1:04:41given the sexism in our society that happened long ago. Yeah right, right,
- 1:04:46unfortunately, you know, yeah, like actors right will say women actors
- 1:04:51will say that they hit forty and it's over right. So you know,
- 1:04:56maybe it's a compounding of if this happens, maybe it's compounding of loss and
- 1:05:01sadness grieving. But I don't know, I never thought about it before.
- 1:05:08Yeah, it's a stereotype, and therefore I will resist it unless I saw
- 1:05:15the data. The amount of agism, especially that I see online, is
- 1:05:19it's just infuriating the way that people talk about quote unquote boomers. It's fucking
- 1:05:25annoying because all the quote unquote boomers meaning my parents' generation, which I believe
- 1:05:32my parents are technically the forgotten generation because they're born during the war. Yeah
- 1:05:38yeah, yeah, but if we just sort of say they were late forgotten
- 1:05:43in early boomers or something. Every older person that I know never complains.
- 1:05:48I want them to complain more, but they don't. So this notion that
- 1:05:54somehow they're always complaining, it's just perpetuated by stereotypes. The one that the
- 1:06:00way that older people are depicted in media. Two, the way that they're
- 1:06:05talked about online. Agism is alive and well and the license that people have
- 1:06:15to just and not just old people, but young people as well. As
- 1:06:19there's agism is going all over the place and it needs to fucking stop.
- 1:06:24And this idea, you know, it'd be like saying, you know,
- 1:06:27what's that with black people and looting or something. You know, I went
- 1:06:31on, you know, how come black people are always looting stores? That's
- 1:06:35what this is? Like, how come old people complain all the time?
- 1:06:40It's a stereotype. Now, if you have data that shows that the bell
- 1:06:45curve is a little bit to the right of on average, as we age,
- 1:06:49we're more likely to be negative or complain, maybe, you know,
- 1:06:55we could definitely point to how older people have an in their risk of depression,
- 1:07:01which could make someone negativistic. Also, the older you get, everything
- 1:07:06starts falling apart for you. Everyone starts dying around you. The world is
- 1:07:12moving on without you. The world is treating you like shit in general,
- 1:07:18and so are there. You know, It's sort of like, how come
- 1:07:21women are always complaining and wives are always nagging and nagging and nagging, And
- 1:07:26it's like, well, maybe because they live in a misogynistic, paternalistic society
- 1:07:31that one never listens to them and two like is constantly a thorn in their
- 1:07:35side. So maybe that's why they're quote unquote nagging all the time. And
- 1:07:40this notion of like you I was complaining, like your grandmother is complaining.
- 1:07:45But this notion that somehow all old people aren't complaining is I'd love to see
- 1:07:51the data. And also the simplistic notion that somehow, just because you're old,
- 1:07:58you're supposed to start complaining here just because you're grumpy and old or something,
- 1:08:02I don't you know, yeah, yeah, Now, whatever she's complaining
- 1:08:08about, if you want to focus on her and say, hey, you
- 1:08:12know, maybe it's your attitude, because maybe it is, you know,
- 1:08:15maybe she's just choosing to be negative. Some people do that. Then help
- 1:08:20her with that. But you know, it's quite possible that her complaints are
- 1:08:26valid. People don't usually complain. In fact, nine times out of ten
- 1:08:30when there's a reason to complain, people don't complain because they're afraid of being
- 1:08:34not heard and stigmatized. You know. So I love it when people complain,
- 1:08:39especially if it's not about me, because you know, I don't have
- 1:08:45to do anything. I can listen and go, wow, that fucking sucks.
- 1:08:47I mean, that's, you know what, half of what being a
- 1:08:49therapist is. Some extent, complaining is one of my favorite things to participate
- 1:08:57in, and once it happens, you know, to pick the complaining will
- 1:09:00end because you're being heard. Okay, well that does it for that episode,
- 1:09:06Bob. Everyone out there please take care of yourself because you deserve it.