Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Juvenile Delinquency Explained: Why Teens Break the Law & How the System Responds
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology undergrad. Grab a chair,
- 0:03clear some desk space, and thanks for joining
- 0:06our study group tonight. Yeah, we are currently
- 0:08camped out in the library, completely surrounded
- 0:10by, I think, six empty coffee cups at this point.
- 0:14Oh, at least six. Right. And we are aggressively
- 0:17cramming for our massive forensic psychology
- 0:19final tomorrow. So tonight's deep dive is into
- 0:23the source material for Chapter 7, which is Juveniles
- 0:27in the Legal System. which is arguably the most
- 0:30complex area of forensic psych to synthesize,
- 0:33honestly. Totally. Our mission tonight is to
- 0:35figure out exactly how the justice system treats
- 0:37young brains, why adolescents commit crimes in
- 0:41the first place, and what actually works to stop
- 0:43them. And I want to say, even if you aren't sitting
- 0:45here stressing over a psych final with us, this
- 0:47matters. It matters deeply if you ever watch
- 0:49the news. Oh, absolutely. Because society is
- 0:51constantly debating this really heavy moral question.
- 0:55If a 15 -year -old commits a horrific crime,
- 0:57are they a broken child who needs a doctor? or
- 0:59are they a malicious adult who needs a cage?
- 1:02It's a massive debate. And to understand how
- 1:04we judge youth today, we first have to look at
- 1:07how wildly our moral compass has swung over the
- 1:10centuries. It's basically a pendulum. Right.
- 1:12Yeah, a pendulum of morality. Because if you
- 1:14go way back, like pre -1300s, age basically didn't
- 1:19matter in the eyes of the law. At all. Nope.
- 1:21If you committed a crime, you were punished.
- 1:23So just the completely binary view of justice.
- 1:27You break the law, you pay the price. Exactly.
- 1:29But then, in the early 1300s, English common
- 1:32law introduces this doctrine called Dolly Incapax.
- 1:36Dolly Incapax, right. Let me check my notes.
- 1:38That's the one that gave immunity, right? Yeah.
- 1:40It established that children under seven were
- 1:42completely immune from criminal liability. The
- 1:45idea was their brains were literally incapable
- 1:47of forming criminal intent. Makes sense. Seven
- 1:50is pretty young. Right. But for kids between
- 1:52seven and fourteen, it was a gray area. You were
- 1:55only held liable if the crown could actively
- 1:57prove malice. Or, and this is wild, if a physical
- 2:01exam proved you had hit puberty. Wait, really?
- 2:03A physical exam? Yeah. Because until, like, 1602,
- 2:07mandatory birth registration just wasn't the
- 2:09thing. Oh right, they literally didn't know how
- 2:12old people were. Exactly, so they had to rely
- 2:14on biological markers. That's fascinating. But
- 2:17you know, taking a step back, this whole concept
- 2:20of proving malice or hitting a specific age to
- 2:24be liable... It perfectly mirrors the religious
- 2:27concepts of the time. Oh, completely. Like, it
- 2:29aligns perfectly with the theological idea of
- 2:32the age of accountability or the age of reason.
- 2:35That exact age when a soul is deemed morally
- 2:38responsible for its sins. Right. The medieval
- 2:40law was just manifesting the religious assumptions
- 2:43of that era. So it stayed like that for a while.
- 2:46For centuries, yeah. But then the pendulum swings
- 2:49incredibly hard in the late 1800s. We enter what
- 2:52the text calls the welfare era. Right, the whole
- 2:54disease model. Exactly. Society suddenly decides
- 2:58that juvenile deviance isn't a sin to be punished
- 3:00anymore, it's a disease to be cured. So they
- 3:04blamed the environment. Yeah, it was viewed as
- 3:06the result of bad parenting or social evils.
- 3:09And this ushers in the legal doctrine of parents'
- 3:11patrii. Which means the state acts as the parent.
- 3:14The ultimate parent, yeah. You know, on the surface,
- 3:17that sounds remarkably progressive. Like, treating
- 3:20crime as a symptom of a sick environment rather
- 3:22than just inherent evil. It sounds super compassionate,
- 3:25right? Yeah. Until you look at the actual practical
- 3:28application. It was devastating. Why? What did
- 3:31they do? Well, because the courts decided they
- 3:34were there strictly to help the youth, they completely
- 3:37stripped away all their procedural rights. Oh,
- 3:40wow. Yeah. Young people were denied public hearings.
- 3:43They were denied juries and they were denied
- 3:45lawyers. Because the judge is supposed to be
- 3:47on their side. Exactly. The logic was, you know,
- 3:51you don't need a defense attorney if the judge
- 3:53is basically acting as your benevolent father.
- 3:55That is so messed up. It gets worse. Kids were
- 3:58locked up for things adults couldn't even be
- 4:00arrested for. Like what? Like truancy or promiscuity,
- 4:04and they were handed indeterminate sentences.
- 4:06They were just kept in institutions until the
- 4:09state unilaterally decided they were cured. Wait,
- 4:12so by taking away their right to a lawyer under
- 4:14the guise of helping them, it's like a surgeon
- 4:17saying, hey, you don't need to know what surgery
- 4:19I'm performing. I'm just here to cure you. Trust
- 4:21me, I'm a doctor. Yeah. It completely strips
- 4:23the kid of all agency. Like, it sounds compassionate,
- 4:27but it's actually terrifying. And it led to massive
- 4:31systemic abuses of power, which is exactly what
- 4:34triggered the rights era in the 1960s. OK, the
- 4:36pendulum swings back. Exactly. The US Supreme
- 4:39Court looked at this paternalistic system and
- 4:42realized benevolent judges were just throwing
- 4:45kids in jail without due process. Was there a
- 4:48specific case for this? Yeah, the landmark case
- 4:50was in result in 1967. A 15 -year -old boy was
- 4:55arrested for making an obscene phone call. Just
- 4:57a prank call. Basically, his parents weren't
- 4:59notified. He had no lawyer. No record of the
- 5:01hearing was even made. And he was facing years
- 5:04in a state institution for a phone call simply
- 5:07because the judge thought the institution would
- 5:09be like good for him. Right. So the Supreme Court
- 5:12ruled that juveniles must be afforded fundamental
- 5:14constitutional rights and Canada followed suit
- 5:17with the Young Offenders Act in 1984. Yep. And
- 5:20later, the Youth Criminal Justice Act, the YCJA
- 5:23in 2003. The current system heavily emphasizes
- 5:27diversion. and keeping kids out of custody while
- 5:30guaranteeing those legal rights. Okay, so to
- 5:33help you study, and honestly to help me study,
- 5:35let's use the three P's to remember this historical
- 5:37arc. Oh, the three P's is a great mnemonic. Right.
- 5:40So historically, the legal system decided to...
- 5:43punish like adults in medieval times, parent
- 5:46like children in the 1800s, and protect with
- 5:49procedural rights in the modern era. Punish,
- 5:51parent, protect. I love that. Thanks. So that
- 5:54synthesizes the history perfectly. But, you know,
- 5:56understanding how the law changed naturally leads
- 5:58us to ask why the modern justice system treats
- 6:01youth so differently today. And the answer there
- 6:03lies entirely in developmental psychology. Brain
- 6:05science. Exactly. The core realization is that
- 6:09teenage brains are quite literally unfinished.
- 6:12Which is wild when you look at the crime stats,
- 6:14because crime peaks exactly at ages 17 and 18.
- 6:18A huge spike. Mostly property crimes, but still
- 6:20that specific window is the absolute peak of
- 6:23human criminality. I mean, overall, youth crime
- 6:26did drop like 22 % in the 2000s, but that 17
- 6:30to 18 bracket is still the danger zone. And Dr.
- 6:32Terry Moffat's developmental pathways theory
- 6:34explains why that happens brilliantly. Oh, this
- 6:37is the LCP versus AL thing, right? Yes. She separates
- 6:40youth offenders into two distinct groups. The
- 6:42first is the life course persistent offender
- 6:45or LCP. Long term criminal potential. That's
- 6:48how I remember it. That works. These are individuals
- 6:51whose conduct problems begin super early in childhood.
- 6:54we see under -controlled temperament by age three.
- 6:57Wow, age three. Yeah. Delayed motor development,
- 7:00low verbal ability, underlying neurological impairments.
- 7:03But the crucial thing to remember for the exam
- 7:05is that this group makes up less than 10 % of
- 7:08all delinquent offenders. Right, which means
- 7:10the massive majority falls into her second group,
- 7:14the adolescent limited offenders, or AL, which
- 7:17I just remember as a phase, literally. A phase,
- 7:20literally. That is surprisingly accurate. because
- 7:22they don't have those early childhood neurological
- 7:24deficits. Their offending starts right at puberty.
- 7:27And Moffitt argues they are just trying to bridge
- 7:30the maturity gap, right? Yes. That frustrating
- 7:33phase where you're biologically mature, but society
- 7:36still restricts you and treats you like a child.
- 7:39So they act out to seize autonomy. And they're
- 7:41super influenced by peer pressure. Overwhelmingly
- 7:44influenced. And there's a massive gender disparity
- 7:47here, too. The ratio for life course persistent
- 7:50criminality is 10 to 1 for males. Okay, 10 to
- 7:541. But for females, it is a hundred to one. Wait,
- 7:57a hundred to one. So female delinquency is almost
- 7:59entirely adolescent limited. It is quite literally
- 8:02a phase for them. But a really dangerous phase.
- 8:04I mean, Kaufman and Steinberg expanded on this
- 8:06with their concept of psychosocial maturity.
- 8:09They did. They mapped out how adolescent decision
- 8:12making is fundamentally different from adult
- 8:14cognition. And it relies on three specific developmental
- 8:17capacities. I've got an acronym for this one
- 8:19to RTP. Responsibility, temperance and perspective.
- 8:22Let me make sure I'm synthesizing this. Responsibility
- 8:25would be the capacity to make autonomous choices
- 8:28independent of peer pressure, which teenagers
- 8:30are famously terrible at. Very terrible at. Right.
- 8:33And then temperance has to be impulse control,
- 8:36self -restraint. And perspective is the ability
- 8:40to weigh long -term costs against immediate thrills,
- 8:44like seeing the big picture. You nail it. During
- 8:46puberty, Sensation seeking just skyrockets, but
- 8:50temperance, the crucial impulse control lags
- 8:53way behind. You know, viewing this through a
- 8:55moral lens really reframes things for me. Impulsive
- 8:58risk taking in a 16 -year -old isn't some deep
- 9:01moral failing or original sin. No, it's biological.
- 9:04It's a biological gap. It's like the adolescent
- 9:07brain is a sports car where the accelerator,
- 9:10the sensation seeking, works flawlessly. But
- 9:13the brakes, the regulatory competence, haven't
- 9:16even been installed at the factory yet. I love
- 9:18that analogy. And biologically, we know exactly
- 9:20where those brakes are located. The frontal lobe.
- 9:22The frontal lobe. It's the brain's executive
- 9:24control center. It manages long -term planning
- 9:26and impulse inhibition. And MRI studies universally
- 9:29confirm it isn't fully developed until the early
- 9:32to mid -20s. Mid -20s? That's so late. The U
- 9:35.S. Supreme Court actually explicitly cited this
- 9:38exact brain science when they ruled against the
- 9:41death penalty for juveniles. The hardware required
- 9:43for ultimate moral culpability is literally still
- 9:46under construction. OK, so we have these impulsive,
- 9:50highly peer influenced teenagers with completely
- 9:53underdeveloped frontal lobes. Yep. What happens
- 9:56when these immature brains collide with the rigid,
- 9:59highly complex legal system? Well, usually it's
- 10:02a catastrophic mismatch. I can imagine. Like,
- 10:05take waiving your rights, for example. The law
- 10:07says you have the right to remain silent, right
- 10:09to a lawyer. But a teenager has to actually comprehend
- 10:13those rights to voluntarily waive them. And Eastwood's
- 10:16research on waiver forms across Canada shows
- 10:18how severely they fail at this. What did this
- 10:20study find? So the reading levels of standard
- 10:24police waiver forms are basically highly complex
- 10:26legal documents. When Eastwood gave these forms
- 10:29to high schoolers, they genuinely understood
- 10:32less than half of the rights presented. Less
- 10:34than half. Yet, they confidently claim they understand
- 10:37everything perfectly, don't they? Oh, of course.
- 10:38Because teenagers are terrified of looking stupid
- 10:41in front of authority figures. Exactly. So they
- 10:43just nod, sign the paper, and wave away their
- 10:46constitutional rights because they're intimidated.
- 10:48They lack the perspective to understand the long
- 10:50-term legal consequences. And that mismatch becomes
- 10:53even more glaring when we evaluate fitness to
- 10:56stand trial. How so? When an adult is deemed
- 10:59unfit to stand trial, it's almost exclusively
- 11:02due to severe psychosis or profound intellectual
- 11:05disability. But for youth, unfitness is rarely
- 11:09psychotic. It's developmental. Yes. A 14 -year
- 11:11-old might be unfit just because they have severe
- 11:14ADHD or poor verbal skills or just a profound
- 11:18lack of maturity to grasp the adversarial nature
- 11:20of a courtroom. So they literally cannot instruct
- 11:22counsel because they don't even understand what
- 11:24a defense attorney does. Exactly. Man. And this
- 11:27clash between brain development and the law reaches
- 11:30its absolute peak when we look at adult sentencing
- 11:32for youth. Oh, the reverse onus. Right. Under
- 11:36the Canadian YCJA, if a youth commits a presumptive
- 11:39offense like murder or manslaughter, there used
- 11:42to be this reverse onus. which meant the law
- 11:44presumed they would receive an adult sentence.
- 11:47And the burden was placed entirely on the teenager
- 11:50to legally argue why they shouldn't. Think about
- 11:53how absurd that is in practice. You're asking
- 11:56a teenager with an underdeveloped brain who likely
- 11:59has poor verbal skills and zero impulse control
- 12:02to navigate a complex legal argument proving
- 12:06their own lack of cognitive maturity to a judge.
- 12:09They're biologically set up to fail. Which is
- 12:11exactly why the Supreme Court struck down the
- 12:13reverse onus in RVDB. Now, the Crown has to prove
- 12:18why an adult sentence is needed. That ruling
- 12:26definitely aligns the law with the science. But,
- 12:29you know, the stakes of that specific decision,
- 12:31whether a kid goes to a juvenile facility or
- 12:33an adult prison, they're monumental. Absolutely
- 12:36monumental. Because the assumption among the
- 12:38general public is usually that transferring a
- 12:40violent youth to adult court will better protect
- 12:43society, like lock them away longer. That's the
- 12:45common perception, yeah. I mean, I have to pause
- 12:47here because put yourself in the shoes of a victim's
- 12:50family for a second. If a 17 -year -old violently
- 12:54takes a life, telling a grieving mother, oh,
- 12:56well, his frontal lobe is under construction,
- 12:59that feels like a massive, cruel insult. It does.
- 13:02Society naturally demands retribution. Doesn't
- 13:05the public have a fundamental right to vengeance,
- 13:07or at least the safety of knowing that offender
- 13:09is in a maximum -security adult prison? It is
- 13:13an incredibly powerful and valid emotional response.
- 13:17But... As scientists evaluating the justice system,
- 13:20we have to look impartially at the data regarding
- 13:22what actually protects society. And what does
- 13:23the data say? The empirical evidence is unequivocal.
- 13:26Yeah. Treating violent youth as adults does not
- 13:29protect the public. Studies consistently show
- 13:31that transferring youth to adult systems actually
- 13:33increases their future criminal behavior. Wow.
- 13:36So makes them worse. You are essentially putting
- 13:38a highly impressionable adolescent in a master
- 13:41class for criminality. Because their new peer
- 13:43group is suddenly hardened adult convicts. Precisely.
- 13:47Furthermore, the human cost within the walls
- 13:49of those prisons is staggering. I remember reading
- 13:52this part. It's really dark. Yeah. Youth in adult
- 13:55prisons are five times more likely to be sexually
- 13:58assaulted. Five times. And twice as likely to
- 14:00be beaten by staff compared to those in juvenile
- 14:03facilities. So if the objective is genuine public
- 14:07safety and rehabilitation, the adult system objectively
- 14:10fails. It just manufactures more dangerous individuals.
- 14:14OK, so. If adult prison just creates better criminals,
- 14:18how do we evaluate how dangerous a kid actually
- 14:21is? And more importantly, how do we fix the behavior
- 14:24without destroying them? This is where advanced
- 14:27forensic risk assessment tools come in. And one
- 14:30of the gold standards is the SAVRY. The Structured
- 14:33Assessment of Violence Risk in Youth. Exactly.
- 14:36Unlike older models that just looked at past
- 14:38bad behavior, The SEVY is brilliant because it
- 14:41measures historical risk factors alongside contextual
- 14:44factors like peer delinquency and individual
- 14:46factors like impulsivity. Right. But most importantly,
- 14:49it heavily assesses protective factors. OK, protective
- 14:51factors. Those are things like pro -social involvement,
- 14:54strong attachments to an adult or a commitment
- 14:56to school, right? Yeah. So it isn't just assessing
- 14:58what's broken. It is measuring the structural
- 15:01integrity of what's holding the youth together.
- 15:04Exactly. If a kid has high impulsivity, but incredibly
- 15:08strong family attachments, those protective factors
- 15:11can actively buffer the risk of violence. That
- 15:14makes a lot of sense. But we can't talk about
- 15:16risk assessment without confronting the demographic
- 15:19realities of the system. The Aboriginal youth
- 15:21statistics. Yeah, they are massively overrepresented
- 15:23in Canadian youth custody. Nationally, they are
- 15:26eight times more likely to be incarcerated than
- 15:29non -Aboriginal youth. And in some provinces,
- 15:31it's even higher. In Saskatchewan, it is 30 times
- 15:34higher. And that isn't just a statistical anomaly.
- 15:37It is the direct result of systemic mechanisms.
- 15:40Poverty and systemic discrimination compounding
- 15:43at every step. Exactly. An Aboriginal youth from
- 15:46a marginalized community is more likely to be
- 15:48arrested rather than warned. They're less likely
- 15:50to get bail due to lack of resources. Which means
- 15:53they're more likely to just plead guilty to get
- 15:55out of remand. Right. The system systematically
- 15:57strips away those very protective factors that
- 16:00SAVRY is looking for. We also see stark realities
- 16:03regarding gender and trauma. Standard punitive
- 16:06measures completely fail girls in the juvenile
- 16:09system. Because their criminality is tied to
- 16:11victimization. deeply tied to severe victimization.
- 16:1465 % of girls in custody meet the criteria for
- 16:18post -traumatic stress disorder. 65%. That's
- 16:21a huge majority. And we see incredibly high rates
- 16:24of comorbidity, meaning... two or more disorders
- 16:27occurring simultaneously, like ADHD paired with
- 16:30substance abuse. Right. You can't simply punish
- 16:32a teenager for drug use when the substance abuse
- 16:35is basically a coping mechanism for untreated
- 16:38PTSD. Exactly. So how do we actually treat the
- 16:42root causes? I know the interventions are broken
- 16:44down into three levels for the exam, primary,
- 16:46secondary, and tertiary. Let's use a medical
- 16:48analogy to keep this straight. Let's hear it.
- 16:50OK. So primary prevention is like a universal
- 16:52vaccine. You give it to everyone before there's
- 16:54any sign of a problem. Like the obvious anti
- 16:57-bullying program implemented across entire elementary
- 17:00schools. Right. And then secondary prevention
- 17:02targets those already showing symptoms. Exactly.
- 17:05It's like early medication for high blood pressure.
- 17:08You intervene with high risk groups. Like the
- 17:11Montreal Preventive Treatment Program. The one
- 17:13for kindergarten boys. Yeah, it specifically
- 17:15targeted boys who were already showing disruptive
- 17:17behavior, teaching them social skills before
- 17:20they could offend. And then tertiary prevention
- 17:22is the open -heart surgery. It happens after
- 17:24the massive heart attack, after the youth has
- 17:26already committed a crime, to stop them from
- 17:28doing it again, like multi -dimensional treatment
- 17:30foster care. The most effective open -heart surgery
- 17:33we currently have is multi -systemic therapy,
- 17:36or MST. MST, right. MST recognizes that a teenager
- 17:40doesn't exist in a vacuum. Putting a kid in a
- 17:43therapist's office for one hour a week and then
- 17:46sending them back to a toxic environment does
- 17:48not work. It's useless. So MST targets the individual,
- 17:51their family dynamics, their peer group, and
- 17:53their school community simultaneously. It is
- 17:56an intensive multi -target approach. It addresses
- 17:59all those contextual factors from the SAVRY.
- 18:02Exactly. And the financial argument for this
- 18:04is bulletproof. Over a 14 -year period, treating
- 18:08a single juvenile offender with MST saves taxpayers
- 18:11and potential victims up to $199 ,374. Almost
- 18:17200 grand saved per youth because they aren't
- 18:19cycling back through the court system, they aren't
- 18:21victimizing new people, and they're actually
- 18:23entering the workforce. Contrast that success
- 18:25with what the data proves absolutely does not
- 18:28work. scared straight programs. Oh man, remember
- 18:31those? Yeah, in the 80s and 90s the trend was
- 18:34to bring at -risk kids into maximum security
- 18:37prisons to be screamed at and terrified by adult
- 18:41inmates. Because society still clung to this
- 18:43idea that you could punish or frighten a kid
- 18:45into having better impulse control. But meta
- 18:47-analyses show those programs actually increase
- 18:50future criminal behavior. They backfire completely.
- 18:53Fear does not build psychosocial maturity. It
- 18:56doesn't magically install the brakes in the frontal
- 18:58lobe. If we connect this back to morality, the
- 19:01massive success of focusing on protective factors
- 19:04and multi -systemic therapy aligns perfectly
- 19:07with the moral duty of community. The whole it
- 19:09takes a village idea. Exactly. The old adage
- 19:12holds entirely true in forensic psychology. It
- 19:16takes a village to raise a child. And the data
- 19:19proves it takes a village to rehabilitate one.
- 19:21That's a great way to put it. Well let's zoom
- 19:23out and summarize this whole study session. Let's
- 19:25do it. We've traced the incredible arc of youth
- 19:28justice. We started in the medieval era where
- 19:31we punished children just like adults based on
- 19:34rigid religious concepts of malice. Then we swung
- 19:37to the 1800s where we acted like parents but
- 19:40stripped away all their fundamental rights. Right.
- 19:41And finally, we arrived at the modern era guided
- 19:44by the empirical discovery that the teenage brain
- 19:47is physically under construction. Heavy on the
- 19:50gas, light on the brakes. And most importantly,
- 19:52we have the hard data proving that community
- 19:55-based, multi -systemic rehabilitation isn't
- 19:58just more compassionate. It practically saves
- 20:00money and saves lives compared to the brutal,
- 20:04recidivism -driving reality of adult prisons.
- 20:07It is a profound evolution, moving from assumptions
- 20:10of inherent malice to a nuanced understanding
- 20:12of biological maturity and environmental risk.
- 20:15Well, thank you so much for joining our undergrad
- 20:17study group tonight. We hope that the next time
- 20:20you are scrolling through the news and you see
- 20:22a tragic headline about juvenile crime, you have
- 20:24a deeper, more empathetic and more scientifically
- 20:27grounded lens to evaluate the debate. And as
- 20:31we close our notes for the night. I want to leave
- 20:33you with a final lingering question derived straight
- 20:35from the brain science. Oh, hey, hit us. The
- 20:38research explicitly proves that the frontal lobe,
- 20:41the very center of long -term decision -making,
- 20:43perspective, and impulse control, isn't fully
- 20:46developed until the early to mid -20s. So if
- 20:49biological maturity is the true foundation of
- 20:51moral and legal accountability, why does the
- 20:54justice system magically draw the line at age
- 20:5618? Oh, wow. Should juvenile justice actually
- 20:59extend to age 25?