Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Dan Carlin: Are We Too Weak to Survive the Next Collapse?
Transcript
- 0:00What would it be like if even one of those terrible diseases
- 0:03revisited us today? I mean, look at the panic we can
- 0:05have over an Ebola type virus or a Marburg type virus.
- 0:09Some of these hemorrhagic fevers, like they might get out
- 0:12of control or an AV in the flu, but we don't know what that
- 0:15means. Nobody in living memory knows
- 0:18what that means. Well, when we talked about using
- 0:20history as laboratory experiments, right?
- 0:22There's too many variables to draw real conclusions from, but
- 0:25it's interesting to look. We had a terrible flu known as
- 0:28the Spanish influenza strike at the end of the First World War
- 0:30191819191920 and it shut down whole American cities because
- 0:35people weren't willing to go out and do their jobs and risk
- 0:39infection. But when you realize what
- 0:41happens when the cops don't show up to work right and the the
- 0:44basic people who keep your society running stay home, it
- 0:48was a bit of a wake up call. If you go back and read that to
- 0:50see exactly how quickly, not disease, but simply the fear of
- 0:55disease can take our societies and throw a monkey wrench into
- 0:59the whole machine that sort of regulates and runs our whole
- 1:01lives. Welcome to Hidden Forces in
- 1:22History, Dan Carlin. Thank you for having me.
- 1:25Dan, I got to tell you, I am super stoked to have you on.
- 1:29I have been a Hardcore History listener.
- 1:31For. Many, many episodes at this
- 1:33point. I actually even buy all of your
- 1:35extra episodes in your addendum feed as well.
- 1:37So I'm really stoked to kind of dive into some things with you
- 1:40today. Well, that's fantastic.
- 1:42Listen, I'm just glad that you've been listening for so
- 1:44long. I appreciate that.
- 1:46Totally. I so I wanted for, for those of
- 1:48my listeners that aren't really familiar with the concept of
- 1:51Hardcore history, I, I want to just kind of set the stage here
- 1:55before we jump into your book, which is the major thing I want
- 1:58to discuss with you today. You know, what is the Hardcore
- 2:01History podcast? Why did you start it?
- 2:04And I, I want to get into that a little bit, what your process is
- 2:07like, but let's handle that first.
- 2:08So what is the show? Why did you start it?
- 2:12Well, you know, I, I've actually, you mentioned the
- 2:15Hardcore History addendum feed, which is the third podcast we've
- 2:18ever done. The first podcast I ever did was
- 2:20something that we adapted from terrestrial radio that I used to
- 2:24do. And so it wasn't a really
- 2:25original concept. And then when we decided to do a
- 2:28podcast about a year at maybe a year and a half after starting
- 2:32that one, I thought, well, you know, by then you'd learned a
- 2:35little bit about the artistic parameters of this new medium.
- 2:38And we're talking about 2005, Hardcore History, probably 2006.
- 2:43And so until I'd done it for about a year or so, it I wasn't
- 2:47really clear on on the, the, let's call it the canvas you had
- 2:50to play with as as A and. Isn't a common sense feed.
- 2:54I'm sorry, say that one more time.
- 2:56Is this your common sense feed the?
- 2:57Common Sense Feed was the one that started 1st and so that was
- 3:00the one that I grew from the radio show.
- 3:01But then somewhere along the line we thought, well, we, you
- 3:03know, maybe we do another podcast as well.
- 3:05And when we thought about that, we had internalized whatever
- 3:08lessons we had learned from a year of the Common Sense
- 3:11podcast. And instead of repurposing some
- 3:14other thing that was originally created for a different format,
- 3:17we had the chance to create something from scratch that that
- 3:19took more advantage of all this open canvas space that the
- 3:22medium allowed. The only problem was is we
- 3:26really didn't have any idea what it was going to sound.
- 3:28I mean, but you know, you have to remember back in this era,
- 3:31there were no professional outlets doing podcasts at all.
- 3:34This was totally, and I mean, this was mostly kids in dorm
- 3:37rooms and stuff. So, so we weren't really sure
- 3:41what would work and what made sense.
- 3:43And, and I always compare maybe the 1st 10:15 of our podcast to
- 3:48the 1st 10 or 15 episodes of some long running TV series you
- 3:51like. I mean, I always say Seinfeld
- 3:54wasn't Seinfeld for the 1st 10 episodes.
- 3:56If you go watch it, they're they're figuring it out, right?
- 3:58They had a concept they started with and that based on
- 4:01experience and growth and chemistry and all that, it
- 4:04develops into what it ever it eventually develops into.
- 4:07So if you go listen to the first Hardcore History show we ever
- 4:09did, it's like 20 minutes long and doesn't it doesn't really
- 4:12sound like the show. That's a joke to what you put
- 4:15out. Now, well, and listen from, from
- 4:16our standpoint, it might be a heck of a lot easier to be
- 4:18putting on 20 minute shows, but you only have, it's funny to say
- 4:22this when you really control every aspect, but you have less
- 4:24control over the growth of these things and the evolution of
- 4:27these things than you might think.
- 4:29Sometimes you find out based on listener feedback, stuff that
- 4:33you had assumed was right is wrong and stuff that you'd never
- 4:37thought about doing, you could think about doing.
- 4:39I mean, the first time we ever had a show that went over an
- 4:42hour long, I inserted an apology to the listeners at the end of
- 4:45it 'cause I thought this was such a profound imposition on
- 4:49their time. And the feedback we got from the
- 4:51listeners, which have been fascinating ever since, was we
- 4:54have pause buttons. And I never thought about that.
- 4:56I had never occurred to me that, oh, you know, maybe we don't
- 4:59have to worry so much about these deadlines that we thought
- 5:01we did, these artificial constraints.
- 5:04And so the show becomes something that was never part of
- 5:07the original intention. So when you say, how did you
- 5:09come up with a show where we talk sometimes for six hours
- 5:12straight about history? It was an evolutionary process
- 5:15and the listeners played a pretty decently sized role in
- 5:18getting us there. Well, I want to talk a little
- 5:21bit about your process too, because I've, I've heard you
- 5:23talk a little bit about it before, how you, I believe in
- 5:26the Tim Ferriss show, how you, you know, you, you sit down and
- 5:28do some recordings. It takes you some time because
- 5:30you know, these episodes now you're talking about them being
- 5:32six hours and sometimes it's, you know, six months before they
- 5:38come out. And, and I, I want to make a
- 5:40comparison here to, to the, when I listen to one of your
- 5:43episodes, like, I feel like I did some work, man, because
- 5:46they're very, very involved. It's like watching like a, an
- 5:48Oliver Stone movie where I feel like I like had to work this
- 5:51whole time I watched it. So what is your process like in
- 5:54terms of, you know, putting together an episode?
- 5:58Well, I mean, one of the things we try to focus on, because I
- 6:00think it makes a lot of sense when you're getting a a history
- 6:03podcast from a guy who does not have a PhD in history, is what
- 6:07the heck are you getting from me?
- 6:09That's unique and valuable because otherwise, why wouldn't
- 6:11you just go pick up a book from one of the people that we use
- 6:16for our research? Or why wouldn't you go watch a
- 6:18movie or, or a historical documentary or something?
- 6:21And so at the outset, we try to figure out what the hell it is
- 6:24I'm giving you. That's, that's worth your time.
- 6:27And, and this aspect is usually, I always describe it like the
- 6:30weaving of a rope where you have different strands.
- 6:33And we try to, we, so I mean, for example, we did a series
- 6:37and, and I think about these more like audio books now rather
- 6:39than podcasts, because it's a, it's probably a more accurate
- 6:42representation of what you're getting.
- 6:44So when you say you felt like you worked, it feels a little
- 6:46like reading a history book, but, but hopefully one that,
- 6:49that grips you because we try to include these, these questions.
- 6:55And I'm a big questioner. I come from a journalistic
- 6:57background. I'm not a big answerer.
- 7:00We did one on the Mongols, for example, and we wove through the
- 7:03the tail one of these really human questions that history
- 7:08raises, doesn't answer, but raises.
- 7:10And it had to do with generations having to pay some
- 7:14sort of terrible price in order to maybe we would say create
- 7:19historical process progress. So with the Mongols, there are
- 7:21people that write books today that maybe we would call them
- 7:25devil's advocate positions or trying to make up for historical
- 7:29injustices. And they'll talk about all the
- 7:31wonderful things that Genghis Khan and the Mongols did.
- 7:34And so one of the things we wove through that series is, OK,
- 7:37we'll accept that premise, but it's undeniable all these
- 7:41terrible things that happened to is that the price that a
- 7:43generation has to pay so that a future generation can have
- 7:47something better. In other words, does one
- 7:48generation have to pay the historical bill or the
- 7:51historical tab for another generation's good times?
- 7:56And, and when you weave that through the story, I feel like
- 7:59that's where we add our own personal little twist or spice
- 8:02or value. And then when you, you, you get
- 8:06to the end of the story, hopefully it's been a whole lot
- 8:08more than just names and dates and facts and stuff like that.
- 8:12It it tries to give you a sense of the dramatic situation these
- 8:16people are in, in these stories and some of the larger human
- 8:18questions that they raise. Absolutely.
- 8:21Well, I just finished your your book, which is amazing.
- 8:24It's called the end is always near apocalyptic moments from
- 8:26the Bronze Age collapse to nuclear near misses.
- 8:30And in terms of putting together the show versus putting together
- 8:34a book, did you find it difficult?
- 8:37And I do recommend people pick up the the audio edition because
- 8:40you read it if you get the Audible edition.
- 8:42But in terms of putting together the book versus putting together
- 8:45an episode, like was that difficult for you to adapt from
- 8:49one to the other? Because like you just said, it
- 8:51is more of like an audio book that you're doing every time you
- 8:53produce one of these or so. What was that I guess adaption
- 8:56like for you? Differently.
- 8:57And so you, you, you wish that you weren't.
- 9:00At least I wish that I wasn't such a novice at it because it's
- 9:02been a long time since I've been a novice at anything and I'm out
- 9:05of practice. And I'm also, you know, a verbal
- 9:09person. I speak relatively naturally.
- 9:12And the wordsmithing that is a part of writing, you know, where
- 9:15you agonize over the construct of a sentence or a paragraph,
- 9:18those sorts of things are somewhat foreign to me.
- 9:21I've written a lot of articles, so 750 word pieces, which is a
- 9:24very different animal as a than a book, as you might expect.
- 9:28So I guess I guess I found it to be, in my opinion, a a less
- 9:35direct way for me to communicate because I'm used to doing it the
- 9:39way you and I are now, but it has undeniable advantages too.
- 9:42So learning experience is the best way I would describe it.
- 9:46Absolutely. Well, I, I guess then I want to
- 9:48take a look at some of the concepts in the book.
- 9:50And, and the thing that I, I found really interesting is
- 9:53you're talking about this concept of people raised in
- 9:56different eras and what we would see as child abuse.
- 10:00Now, if you looked at it like, let's say, you know, several
- 10:03thousand years ago with the Spartans, you know, they, they
- 10:06took the children they thought were going to survive and kept
- 10:08them. The ones they didn't, they got
- 10:09rid of and, and they spent a lot of their life in the agogi
- 10:12training and things like that. So I, I want to take a look at
- 10:15that, that concept. How does the era we're raised
- 10:19in, you know, how does it make us, I guess, more Hardy or more
- 10:22able to survive? Well, it's, you know, and we, we
- 10:26talked a second ago about some of these concepts that we weave
- 10:29through stories that are interesting.
- 10:31The one you just mentioned is one of those endlessly
- 10:34fascinating. And it's, it's almost like a
- 10:36third rail of, of human history because it, there were so many
- 10:40awful things attached to it. But I try to, I try to relate it
- 10:44to a Star Trek episode. There, there was the one that
- 10:47had the character Khan in it and, and, and he's a race of
- 10:50genetic Superman created in an era of human history when
- 10:55genetics and trying to create superior human beings through
- 10:58breeding was supposed to be popular.
- 11:00So this is all science fiction, but there have been a lot of
- 11:03times in human history where this issue of, I mean, when you
- 11:07go to like the Spartans, I don't, I don't know how much
- 11:09they thought about it the way like the Nazis thought about it.
- 11:12But there have been a lot of times in human history where
- 11:14increasing the quality of the breed, for lack of a better
- 11:18term, has fascinated people. Now, obviously we see where that
- 11:22can lead, right? When you got Nazis who are
- 11:25executing disabled people and and subhuman species as they see
- 11:29them. So we obviously can see how that
- 11:31kind of stuff goes. But when you look at some of the
- 11:34history where, where societies seem to be trying to mold a
- 11:39certain kind of human being, I don't know how you can't help
- 11:42but find a certain weird fascination in the plasticity of
- 11:46our genetics. And, and, and, you know, I mean,
- 11:49I often have this fantasy. There are, there are a lot of
- 11:51rulers in history that would have, you know, I mean, maybe
- 11:54you could go back to biblical times, 1000 wives, all of them
- 11:57bearing multiple children. And I thought to myself, how
- 12:00interesting would it be to be an individual who got a chance to
- 12:03see 1000 different ways your genes could scramble together to
- 12:08create a different set of DNA and and different outcomes.
- 12:12Well, I mean, the Spartan idea of creating sort of a superior
- 12:16species. And like I said, I don't know
- 12:17how much they thought about it that way.
- 12:18They may have just been thinking, you know, if we have
- 12:21weak offspring and infants, we expose them and we don't need
- 12:24them if they're going to be too weak.
- 12:25I mean, maybe that they thought about it in a much more
- 12:28utilitarian fashion. No big high minded, you know,
- 12:31creating a better species. But the end result is
- 12:34fascinating to, you know, to just look at human plasticity
- 12:37and wonder about if, if you could, for example, if you could
- 12:42just breed. This is so Nazistic, I don't
- 12:44even believe. But I mean, if you could just
- 12:46breed the very smartest or the very strongest or, you know,
- 12:50fill in the adjective of human beings for like 10 generations,
- 12:54Do you end up with something down the road worthwhile or do
- 12:58you end up with something that's a completely, I mean, like a a
- 13:01twisted strange non human? I mean, I guess what I'm saying
- 13:05is, is that there are very few actually useful laboratory
- 13:08experiments where you can look at him and even begin to examine
- 13:11questions like that. But, you know, history will
- 13:14provide examples that are a little like using human beings
- 13:18as Lab Rats and letting you sort of go.
- 13:21Did the Spartans acting this way with their own version of
- 13:24ancient Greek eugenics actually accomplish anything in the end?
- 13:28I mean, if you met a Spartan warrior today and compared them
- 13:31to your average Athenian, would you notice anything that
- 13:34appeared to you beyond training and working out and, and a
- 13:38healthy diet? I mean, I, I, I think it's got
- 13:41this horrible evil sort of tinge to it, but that doesn't make it
- 13:45less fascinating. Well, I, I guess then taking
- 13:48this too and also looking at you, you mentioned what Tom
- 13:50Brokaw caused calls the greatest generation, which was the the
- 13:53World War Two generation. And I guess like looking at our
- 13:57generation now, it does seem like, you know, I guess we've
- 14:01lost some toughness in a way. I, I guess like taking a look at
- 14:04that then. And do you feel like we've lost
- 14:06toughness? And and if so, like what things
- 14:08do you think creates that in a people?
- 14:12Well, I mean, I'm fascinated with this issue specifically
- 14:14because I'm not even sure it's real.
- 14:18I mean, so if we ask about something like toughness, I
- 14:21mean, go look it up in terms of a dictionary term, what the hell
- 14:23does that mean? It's one of those things where
- 14:26if you and I are talking about some guy we know and you say
- 14:30something like, well, that's a very tough guy.
- 14:33That might have a meaning, that word in that context between you
- 14:36and between me. But but does that mean anything?
- 14:40I mean, if you have a lot more tough in air quotes people in
- 14:43your society, does that impact your society in any way?
- 14:46It's it's not something, you know, this is part of why human
- 14:49history resists being a hard science because what the hell
- 14:52would you, I mean, how would you even define toughness?
- 14:54So to go back to the Spartans that we talked about earlier,
- 14:57the Greeks uniformly considered the Spartans of their day to be
- 15:01the toughest Greeks out there. But how would they compare to
- 15:04any non Greeks, right? The Greeks are only comparing
- 15:06them to the people they know. So so are they as tough as an
- 15:10Aztec warrior? Are they, You know, I mean, see,
- 15:12so it becomes one of those relative terms that that doesn't
- 15:15mean anything overall, but if you think it means something
- 15:19when we're talking about that guy we know well then there's an
- 15:21intrinsic non definable value. And it's natural, I think.
- 15:25And historians ever since the Greek times have been doing
- 15:28this. It's natural to look at
- 15:30different societies and wonder about it on a collective level.
- 15:33So you mentioned Brokaw's, let's call it a marketing term when he
- 15:36called the Second World War generation the greatest
- 15:38generation. I always call it a marketing
- 15:40term because I'm pretty damn sure like every group of parents
- 15:43that's ever existed, the World War 2 generations parents
- 15:46probably thought they were a bunch of softies, you know.
- 15:49So I mean, I think that's one of those things that always
- 15:52continues throughout human history, right?
- 15:54But that having been said, it's pretty easy to look at my
- 15:58grandfather and see that in, by many metrics that we might look
- 16:03at today. You know, how do you judge
- 16:05toughness? Well, how about the ability to
- 16:07withstand privation or whatever? I, I would say he was a much
- 16:10tougher person than I am. The question that's interesting,
- 16:14though, that takes this out of the realm of just being a silly
- 16:16sort of question is does it matter And, and is something
- 16:20like toughness something that you need more in certain
- 16:23conditions? The Spartan needs it in his
- 16:25world, but we don't need it as much now.
- 16:28In other words, there might be an offsetting quality.
- 16:31Toughness may come at the expense of some other human
- 16:34condition. That's important, right, that
- 16:36that it offsets. And if you get more toughness,
- 16:38maybe you get less of this other human quality.
- 16:40Could we suggest that we're benefiting now from having more
- 16:43of that? I mean, if you said that
- 16:44toughness has an inverse relationship to something like
- 16:47art, which it doesn't, but let's just, I mean, I'm trying to put
- 16:50in a value for X here. I mean, this went when
- 16:52historians in earlier times used to think of life cycles of
- 16:56nations that start out with really tough people.
- 16:59And then those tough people, because they're tough, go and
- 17:01conquer. You know, great things have
- 17:02become, you know, the height of their power where they can
- 17:05devote some leisure time to arts and entertainment and the softer
- 17:08cultured pursuits. And then they supposedly, and by
- 17:10that old standard, slip into sloth and gluttony and all those
- 17:13sorts of things and lose all their toughness.
- 17:15And that's that old life cycle of nations people used to
- 17:18believe in a long time ago. Well, that would imply that
- 17:21there were some values that that once the toughness goes down a
- 17:25little, you can begin to indulge it.
- 17:27So to answer your question, it might be interesting to wonder
- 17:30if we don't need the kind of toughness the Second World War
- 17:32generation had because we live in different times.
- 17:35And to offset, you know, what they brought to the table, we
- 17:38have other skills. And to to give you an example of
- 17:41what I mean, I mean, we've got war fighters who operate with
- 17:44video game tools from the center of the United States now and
- 17:47kill terrorists on the other side of the globe.
- 17:51How many push ups do you have to be able to do in order to do
- 17:55that job? Well, you see what I'm saying?
- 17:57So. Zero.
- 17:58They never have to face anybody. But, but so perhaps you need a
- 18:02certain level of toughness for a certain reality and you don't
- 18:05for another reality. So it's not necessarily saying
- 18:07that we've lost something to say that we're less tough than
- 18:10previous generations. It's more an examination of the
- 18:13adjective itself and what it would mean as applied to human
- 18:15beings and how you would measure or study it or anything like
- 18:18that. Does it matter or doesn't it
- 18:19matter? Well, I think it's almost, it's
- 18:22morphed a little bit if we look at the American experience
- 18:24specifically. And and I guess to put this into
- 18:27into perspective, like what I mean is I feel like, I guess
- 18:30football specifically, and you know, maybe hockey to some
- 18:32extent, but football specifically, I said feel like I
- 18:34started to fill that. What would have been that
- 18:37campaigning season or that toughness thing that a lot of,
- 18:41you know, men of that age would have fulfilled, let's say, you
- 18:43know, hundreds or thousands of years ago.
- 18:45Do you, do you think that's correct in that, in that thought
- 18:46process, Dan? Well, I mean, I think sports
- 18:49have always provided a a sort of a pseudo combat environment for
- 18:53you. I mean, if you look at the
- 18:54Native American lacrosse type games that they used to play, I
- 18:57mean, if you if you go to societies all around the world,
- 19:00I mean, they have competitive sports that involve athletic
- 19:03prowess. And so I think there's a
- 19:04connection there. And I think the more violent and
- 19:09more warlike the sport, the more obvious the connection.
- 19:12But I do think that you could suggest pretty easily, although
- 19:15we have to talk to an anthropologist or something like
- 19:17that, that that they fulfill some of the same needs.
- 19:21And if you look at it from a societal point of view, I would
- 19:24suggest that maybe blows off some of the same steam that in
- 19:29early warrior societies, the occasional raid or whatever blew
- 19:33off. I just know that when I played
- 19:35football, I got a charge out of it.
- 19:37And you know, I would just play with friends, but it was full
- 19:39tackle football and I got such a afterwards, just such a charge
- 19:43out of it. And I I can't explain why or
- 19:45how, but I can certainly see how it would have fulfilled a
- 19:48similar need for people in other times and other places and.
- 19:52Absolutely. Well, well, one of the other
- 19:53concepts that you talked about in your book and is, is the idea
- 19:57of the great plague. And you spent some time on the
- 19:59plague of Athens and you know, how Heracles lost his sons
- 20:01during that standpoint and, and, and things like that.
- 20:04But I think like historically, looking back, I, I think we look
- 20:07at it a little jaded and we say something like that can't happen
- 20:10again. But I think history time and
- 20:12time again, you know, proves to us that can happen again.
- 20:15And also how people respond during that time.
- 20:18As you know, I, I guess to compare that, let's say, to
- 20:20Hurricane Katrina, where, you know, there was shoplifting and
- 20:23stealing and things like that. And that all happened during.
- 20:25In these plague times. So I guess looking back, why do
- 20:28you think we think things like this can't happen again?
- 20:31Like historically looking back. Because we've had a pretty darn
- 20:35wonderful last 100 years in that regard.
- 20:38I mean, it's funny, but if you look at all of human history up
- 20:41till now, people 100 years ago would better be able to
- 20:45understand the rhythms of human life of a person in ancient
- 20:48Egypt and they would be able to understand ours and the and if
- 20:52you wanted to look at the many different things that separate
- 20:55us from the eras of 100 years or more beyond us, I I can't see
- 21:00how disease isn't number one on the list.
- 21:03I always try to make these comparisons because numbers mean
- 21:06something. And I think we use this one in
- 21:09the book. But everybody understands how
- 21:11upsetting and destabilizing and and terrible of the AIDS
- 21:15epidemic has been in in the planet since the late 1970s,
- 21:19really early 1980s. But if you actually wanted to
- 21:22put a number on it, the current death toll I think is about 34
- 21:27or 35 million people worldwide since the late 70s.
- 21:32Now that's devastating. But smallpox, which was only one
- 21:37disease out of a whole plethora of things people were exposed to
- 21:40all the time, used to kill 55 million people annually as
- 21:45recently as 75 years ago. And it kills you in a week.
- 21:50And there's a huge, you know, I, I, I think people who are
- 21:54heavily affected in communities that were heavily affected by
- 21:56AIDS would point out that that as devastating as it was, the
- 22:01fact that people were able to live with the disease for a long
- 22:04time, change the impact of it. Imagine that we had lost
- 22:07everybody that we've lost from AIDS, 3435 million people in a
- 22:12week that it's hard to get your mind around.
- 22:16And then when you realize that smallpox is but one of, like I
- 22:19said, all these different things that can get you.
- 22:22And you begin to realize how people like Edward Gibbon, who
- 22:25wrote The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, how a guy like
- 22:28that could grow to adulthood and have lost every one of his
- 22:32siblings by that time. And I think he had six of them.
- 22:36Now, that's an unusual killing rate even for back then.
- 22:40But when you realize how, I mean, and this was the example
- 22:44we did use in the book. But today, if you find out a
- 22:47couple has lost a child, that is one of the most devastating
- 22:50things we as parents can think about.
- 22:52And you have just you, you always wonder how they get
- 22:54through their day. How do you live with that?
- 22:55It's just, it's it's this albatross on the shoulder of
- 22:58people. It's horrible.
- 22:59But then you realize, what if everybody you know had lost a
- 23:02child? And what if a lot of people had
- 23:04lost multiple children? You can't quantify what that
- 23:07does to a society, but you don't have to be a genius just to know
- 23:11it does something. And so that's when we, when we
- 23:14wanted to talk about the impact of disease on human beings, all
- 23:18you have to do is talk about losing loved ones and losing
- 23:21lots of loved ones and then lots of people around you losing lots
- 23:25of loved ones. I mean, does that make you less
- 23:27likely, for example, to bond with your young children?
- 23:31And if it did, wouldn't you understand why?
- 23:34So I mean, these are the kind of intellectual dominoes that start
- 23:37tumbling when you start asking questions like, Gee, what would
- 23:40it be like if even one of those terrible diseases revisited us
- 23:44today? I mean, look at the panic we can
- 23:46have over an Ebola type virus or a Marburg type virus, some of
- 23:50these hemorrhagic fevers, like they might get out of control or
- 23:54an AV and the flu. But we don't know what that
- 23:57means. Nobody in living memory knows
- 23:59what that means. Right, like here in the, in the
- 24:01New York area, there was like a, a measles outbreak last year and
- 24:04it wasn't even that large, but the news was, was freaking out
- 24:08over it. So I think, you know, maybe we
- 24:10aren't able to handle right now as large scale things.
- 24:13And it's, I think, a gradient to getting there, to being able to
- 24:15handle something on that scale as well.
- 24:17Well, when we talked about using history as laboratory
- 24:20experiments, right, where there's too many variables to
- 24:22draw real conclusions from, but, but, but it's interesting to
- 24:24look the we had a terrible flu known as the Spanish influenza
- 24:29strike at the end of the First World War 191819191920 and it
- 24:33shut down whole American cities because people weren't willing
- 24:37to go out and do their jobs and risk infection.
- 24:40But when you realize what happens when the cops don't show
- 24:43up to work right? And the and the the basic people
- 24:45who keep your society running stay home.
- 24:48It was a bit of a wake up call if you go back and read that to
- 24:51see exactly how quickly, not disease, but simply the fear of
- 24:56disease can take our societies and throw a monkey wrench into
- 24:59the whole machine that that sort of regulates and runs our whole
- 25:02lives. Absolutely.
- 25:04Well, Dan, I just wanted to ask you because I know we only had
- 25:0640 minutes booked out. Do you have any more time than
- 25:09that? Because we are to run a little
- 25:10long and I'd like to keep it going if you have the time.
- 25:12I can do an extra 10 OK. Great.
- 25:14That's perfect. OK, so I'll keep you to the
- 25:16time, but I've had a couple more things that I want to talk
- 25:18about, which I think go basically what we're talking and
- 25:20I'll cut this out after. No worries.
- 25:22So one of the things that I found also really interesting is
- 25:26you talked about the movie Planet of the Apes.
- 25:28And you're talking about when, you know, they zoom out and you
- 25:30see it, see it's the Statue of Liberty on the ground.
- 25:32It's it's, you know, very shocking to you that it's
- 25:34happened. And looking at total
- 25:36civilization collapse. Is that as possible now as it
- 25:42was, let's say, you know, 200 years ago because we are so
- 25:45technologically connected? But you know, a great example of
- 25:49that is our our BMW the other day that the battery in the
- 25:51alternator went, which means we can't do anything with the car,
- 25:54including get it on a tow truck. So like what in this day and
- 25:58age, like can we see the type of collapses we see in the past,
- 26:02you know, word technology or something to fail?
- 26:05You know, I'm going to answer this in a very long winded way
- 26:08because I love the way he put it.
- 26:09There's an economic writer named Robert Samuelson who was talking
- 26:12about the Great Depression and talking about how much sort of
- 26:17fun that modern economists make at the people of that day for
- 26:20being so stupid that they've they've blundered into something
- 26:23that we would never blunder into with our knowledge today.
- 26:26And he basically was trying to say, no, we would not blunder
- 26:29into a Great Depression for the same reasons we would blunder
- 26:32into a Great Depression for totally new reasons, right?
- 26:34And and things we can't foresee. So don't get, don't get so
- 26:38arrogant about it was his point. Our society has more built in
- 26:42redundancy than a lot of earlier societies that failed.
- 26:45And so on one hand, you would say there's backup systems,
- 26:48there's safeties, there's this, there's, there's, there's,
- 26:51there's other countries. So I mean, there's a, when you
- 26:53think about how dark ages, you know, in air quotes, right, used
- 26:57to happen, part of the way that they were made possible was that
- 27:00it was in times before the planet was completely connected.
- 27:03And so if a place like China, for example, had a down period,
- 27:07that whole part of the world had a down period.
- 27:10But if China had a down period today, the other powers on the
- 27:13planet would sort of make up or so if you think about nations
- 27:16and cultures and civilizations, like giant power outlets, back
- 27:20in the day when you relied on a single power outlet, if Rome
- 27:23fell, all those places that depended on Rome also had a
- 27:27downtime. But if you have multiple power
- 27:30stations, you know, Rome goes, but you still have China, well,
- 27:33maybe you've you've you've reduced your chance of a
- 27:36complete blackout. So on one hand, we have more
- 27:39redundancy. So you say, well, we don't have
- 27:41the same chances of falling. Robert Samuels Some will say,
- 27:44don't get too cocky because what we also have is more complexity,
- 27:48right. On the on the one hand, the
- 27:50redundancy should save you, but on the other hand, the
- 27:52complexity itself breeds problems that we don't, you
- 27:55can't foresee till they happen. So there's a wonderful book
- 27:59edited by Nick Bostrom, who's at Oxford called Global
- 28:04Catastrophic Risks. There's a lot of math in it, but
- 28:07the bottom line is he talks about all these different things
- 28:11that could go sideways on us, but you won't know till it
- 28:14happens. And one of the most famous
- 28:15chapters in the book is on artificial intelligence.
- 28:18He actually took that whole chapter out and expanded it into
- 28:21an entire book. But the idea of artificial
- 28:24intelligence is a perfect example of something that could
- 28:26create theoretically that catastrophic dark age type risk.
- 28:31But it's not a sort of a risk the people in the Middle Ages or
- 28:34the ancient world ever had to deal with, right?
- 28:36It's a new risk. So, so along with the many
- 28:38safeguards that make us less likely to have a dark age are
- 28:41many new threats that that increase the chances.
- 28:44I mean, just look at let's look at one thing, just one.
- 28:48Anyone who wants to do any research on the biggest nuclear
- 28:52explosion that's ever been detonated, go look up Czar Bomba
- 28:56is what we call it in the West. I forgot what it is.
- 28:59I'm thinking 50 megatons. Sounds about right.
- 29:02Thermonuclear weapon. The largest US test was the 15
- 29:05megaton tassel Bravo test, and that was enormous.
- 29:09The 50 megaton test is a reminder of how nuclear war in
- 29:14the future is not going to be anything like Hiroshima and
- 29:17Nagasaki. I mean, this is a bomb thousands
- 29:19of times more powerful than those bombs.
- 29:22And that when you look at, I mean, there are there are
- 29:24wonderful things online that will show you what would happen
- 29:26to Paris if that bomb went off, right compared to the Hiroshima
- 29:31bomb. When you realize that you could
- 29:33have lots of those bombs go off in a in a third World War, you
- 29:38begin to say, OK, so all this redundancy that makes it harder
- 29:42for us to have a dark age is maybe offset by the fact that we
- 29:45have such greater efficiency in terms of dark age creating
- 29:49tools. And so I'm not sure that that we
- 29:54can say that modern society is any less or more likely to have
- 29:58some sort of future age where the Statue of Liberty emerges
- 30:01partially buried in the sand. But I think the whole point of
- 30:04the version on the Planet of the Apes had to do with nuclear war.
- 30:08So maybe you would say it's a wash.
- 30:14Well, it's, it's almost mutually extruded, mutually assured
- 30:17destruction to some point in time, like I'm going to blow you
- 30:19up, but I'm going to blow you up bigger.
- 30:21So. So there may not be anything.
- 30:22The other funny part about it is, once again, you know when
- 30:25you start talking about nuclear war, and I don't mean a war like
- 30:27the Second World War where a couple of atomic weapons are
- 30:30used, but a real full on nuclear war.
- 30:32It's all theoretical. We have no case studies to even
- 30:36look and examine, right? I mean, a lot of the
- 30:38information, and I had to do a lot of research for this, for
- 30:41one of the podcasts we did on it.
- 30:42But a lot of the information we have is, is stuff that the
- 30:45experts mathematically extrapolated from the Hiroshima
- 30:50and Nagasaki bombs, The only ones where you have any real
- 30:52world tests. But they are so different than
- 30:55than what would be involved in the modern weapons.
- 30:58And nobody has any idea if you have lots of these modern
- 31:01weapons go off what that means. I mean, you've heard the
- 31:03scenario of nuclear winter, but that's only one of them.
- 31:07Nobody knows. And as, and some of the friends
- 31:09that I have who are always pointing out how we exaggerate
- 31:12threats would say you could have a third World War and have it
- 31:14not be as bad as some of the experts predict.
- 31:17But how would you know, You know, So I mean, I, I think that
- 31:21in terms of, of, of something like that, the lack of, of real
- 31:25world case studies to look at makes everything sort of seem
- 31:28like fantasy until it, I mean, that's what we talked about in
- 31:31the book to this. There's a weird sort of
- 31:34fantastic element to these kinds of topics that sound more like
- 31:38movie titles or science fiction tropes like Planet of the Apes.
- 31:43Then they sound like real swords of Damocles hanging over our
- 31:47head. The Cuban Missile Crisis.
- 31:50You know, if the way that the world felt the day after the
- 31:53Cuban Missile Crisis ended, you could make an argument as the
- 31:56way we should feel every day of our lives because of the threat
- 32:00level. But human beings can't operate
- 32:02that way. And once you get about a
- 32:04generation after those sorts of times, you have people being
- 32:07raised with no memory of that at all.
- 32:10It's almost unrealistic to expect them to have the same
- 32:13level of fear and concern or to be able to sustain it as a
- 32:16society. At the same time, if we ever
- 32:18have a nuclear exchange, people are going to look back and say
- 32:21why work me more on this subject back in peacetime, you know?
- 32:25Well, and I think I think too is that the long lasting
- 32:28ramifications of what something like A cause, not even the
- 32:31construction. I, I just spoke in Kiev, Ukraine
- 32:33a couple months ago and one of one of the top sites to go see
- 32:36in in for Taurus there is to grab a Geiger counter and go to
- 32:41Chernobyl and, and kind of walk around and see what you can pick
- 32:43up. And, you know, we're how many
- 32:44years down the road from that and they're still picking up
- 32:47radiation from something like. I was going to say you're a
- 32:49brave man. I wouldn't.
- 32:50Do it man. I have a.
- 32:52One year old I would not have done that.
- 32:54Why don't you just smoke 4 packs of cigarettes today for a couple
- 32:56of years? I think the risk levels pretty
- 32:58close. Well, I, I want to bring this
- 33:01background to the, the core concept of, of what you talked
- 33:04about about here in the book, Dan.
- 33:05And it's, you focused really on the end always being close in
- 33:09these like apocalypses that can always happen.
- 33:11Like, why did you want to focus on that core concept of that
- 33:14that type of society shift? Well, apparently it's what I'm
- 33:18interested in. One of the you know I had
- 33:19mentioned earlier about how I'm. Showing my many of your
- 33:22episodes. Yeah, maybe.
- 33:23Well, this is how it happened. I mean, one of the things I'm in
- 33:26neophyte at book writing. So the editors were helping me
- 33:29try to figure all this out and they suggested that I must have
- 33:31a lot of material in the files, which I do.
- 33:34And they said, why don't you lay it all out sort of on the floor
- 33:37and see if you can find any sort of connecting strands of topical
- 33:41DNA between a bunch of the topics.
- 33:43And to be honest, I'm not somebody that likes to go back
- 33:46and look at my previous work. So I'd never done that.
- 33:50And it was a little bit like doing maybe the inkblot test
- 33:53that your psychiatrist's office or something.
- 33:55Because you know, you're looking at these shows and you're going,
- 33:57wow, you know, they, they do have a lot to do with like
- 34:00apocalyptic this and end of the world that or what I mean,
- 34:03enough of them did so that you could easily see it as a book.
- 34:06And so it kind of it kind of was an extrapolation of a lot of
- 34:09ideas And, and we call them spines, but you could think
- 34:12about them as one of the minor themes or one of the strands in
- 34:15the rope that we talked about earlier.
- 34:17A lot of those spines had to do with the sort of those subjects
- 34:20in the book. And the 1st 2 chapters in the
- 34:22book, the one on child rearing and the one on toughness seem to
- 34:26be a little bit outliers compared to the other topics
- 34:29which are so directly related to things that cause problems like
- 34:32disease or nuclear war or the fall of of your government.
- 34:35But those first two chapters are supposed to represent elements
- 34:38of the plasticity of the human species, right?
- 34:41We keep being told that our number one survival trade is our
- 34:46ability to adapt, right? So you think of like a coyote.
- 34:49And if you poison coyotes, they have more pups to make up for
- 34:52the fact that you poison them. And so we wanted to discuss 1st
- 34:56and maybe it should have been at the end, I'm not sure I, the
- 34:58organization turned out the way I, I intended, but but we wanted
- 35:01to discuss the ability of human beings to roll with these
- 35:04historical punches should they happen again.
- 35:08And the combination of how we are born and how we are raised
- 35:12seem to be the two elements that involve, you know, you had
- 35:16mentioned the Spartans sort of the the way that they do
- 35:20eugenics. Maybe whether human toughness
- 35:23and the way we raise our kids could compensate for living in a
- 35:26post nuclear world, for example. I felt was was sort of the crux
- 35:30of the story, right? Because we're not just talking
- 35:32about these bad things happening, but we're talking
- 35:34about our ability to survive them, deal with them, react to
- 35:37them, and then try to create some kind of meaningful
- 35:40existence in the wake of them. One of the things we talked
- 35:43about I, I think in the book and I've always wondered about is I
- 35:45mean, think about the difference in try as a parent in trying to,
- 35:49to create children who can function well in their world.
- 35:52If you're raising them in Beverly Hills today versus if
- 35:55you're raising them in Stalingrad in 1944, It's a
- 35:59different, you know, sometimes you need to be raising Apaches
- 36:03and sometimes you need to be raising computer geeks.
- 36:06I mean, different times call for different levels of adaptation.
- 36:10And so we thought that those first two chapters were a way of
- 36:13of giving you sort of the practical human side of, you
- 36:16know, we talked about Edward Gibbon losing his six siblings,
- 36:19I think it was 6, and how with a lot of parents at that same time
- 36:22period also lost siblings. How does society react?
- 36:24And so we wanted to talk about how you roll with those
- 36:27historical punches. And so that's kind of the way
- 36:29the book is outlined. Well, I guess just as we're
- 36:32we're coming down here for a landing.
- 36:34Dan, I, we we got one listener question for you and Michael
- 36:37Woodward wanted to know was there a topic or currently is a
- 36:41topic you're intimidated to cover on a future Hardcore
- 36:45History episode? Oh my goodness, lots of them.
- 36:48You know, it's, it's funny because the, the real compliment
- 36:51on the part of the listeners is that they often think I can talk
- 36:54about any historical subject and I get requests for things all
- 36:56the time. Can you talk about 17th century
- 36:59India, please? And it's flattering as heck that
- 37:01someone would think I knew enough to do that, but I don't.
- 37:04I mean, the all the topics that we talked about are things that
- 37:07I already have a foundational knowledge base to begin.
- 37:12And then I begin my research from there.
- 37:16To try to educate yourself from Ground Zero on something is
- 37:20simply not possible. You know, in the time frame that
- 37:22we have between shows and and so when he says is there something
- 37:26you're intimidated by? Holy cow.
- 37:28I mean, most of the things would be most of the things is a good
- 37:31is a good answer. I mean, the few things that I'm
- 37:33not intimidated by are the things you get episodes on.
- 37:36How about that? Well, I, I guess looking at like
- 37:39future content plans, like, you know, is there something that
- 37:42you're putting out in terms of an episode thought process that
- 37:45you're really excited about? I know for myself, I'm I'm
- 37:48hoping that someday in the future to see something either
- 37:50about Alexander the Greater or Cesare Borgia that I find to be
- 37:53two of the most intriguing historical characters.
- 37:55But is there any big episode ideas you have coming down the
- 37:58Pike? I keep certain ones in my back
- 38:01pocket, certain ones that I, you know, you say to yourself, OK, I
- 38:03know somewhere down the road this will be a great show,
- 38:06right? Because I, I know, I know what I
- 38:07know about, right? So the First World War topic was
- 38:10when we had in our back pocket for a long time and then we
- 38:12decided to do it for the Centennial of the conflict.
- 38:16And that was, and that was I think a pretty good series.
- 38:19I'm pretty harsh on myself, but you know, I give it AC pretty
- 38:22good by our standards. The the idea of future shows
- 38:26that we have in our back pocket. A good example is Alexander.
- 38:29You mentioned Alexander. I tiptoe around Alexander a lot.
- 38:32So I've done shows about. The King of Kings series you
- 38:35mentioned. That and we did a whole early on
- 38:38a a show called the the Macedonian Soap Opera, which is
- 38:41about the sort of the succession afterwards.
- 38:44So there's a lot of Alexander, They're tiptoed around there.
- 38:46I may do one in the future about another.
- 38:49So we're trying to sort of stay clear of directly talking about
- 38:53Alexander, even though the first park race show we ever did was
- 38:57called Alexander versus Hitler and we still tiptoed around
- 38:59Alexander. So there, there will be at some
- 39:01point a massive, I think, look at him.
- 39:06The Borgia thing probably won't happen for the men.
- 39:08The things I mentioned earlier in terms of, of really knowing
- 39:11the subject well enough. But I've been studying Alexander
- 39:13my whole life and I still feel like, you know, there's so much
- 39:17more to know and I'm still waiting for them.
- 39:19There was a story the other day they may be getting, I mean,
- 39:22I've been saying this for 35 years, so bear with me, but they
- 39:25may be getting close to fighting the guys tomb.
- 39:28I mean, I would, that would just be, I'm not sure there would be
- 39:31somebody compared it to finding Tutankhamun's tomb in terms of
- 39:34importance. And I thought it's not even
- 39:36close. Tutankhamun was not an important
- 39:38Egyptian ruler, but Alexander, So, so to answer your question,
- 39:42I'm, I'm so taken with the guy as a historical figure, whether
- 39:45he was a butcher or a philosopher king or something
- 39:49between the two, that I got that in my back pocket.
- 39:52And hopefully we can turn that into at least AC plus show
- 39:55whenever I do it. Well, I'm, I'm very excited for
- 40:00that because I think he's the great example of absolute power
- 40:02corrupting absolutely because he tried to be the philosopher
- 40:04king, but then he kind of went the other way and went a little
- 40:07crazy when he killed his friend Clitus to Black.
- 40:09And a lot of that. Stuff that happened along that
- 40:11way, I mean, that's the. When you start thinking about
- 40:13ancient history and Alexander was one of the first really
- 40:16great propagandists the world has ever known, what the hell do
- 40:20we really know about this? So I mean, that's that's right
- 40:22there. You know, when you talk about
- 40:23him, what are the fun things is going to be?
- 40:25How do we think we know what we know about the guy?
- 40:29Well, and, and that's the, the interesting concept about him
- 40:31is, is he was one of the first ones to take his, his publicist
- 40:35with him on campaign. And that's what the the writer
- 40:36Arian was. He was like, Alexander was like,
- 40:38all right, write this stuff. And that's most of the remaining
- 40:41stuff we have, other than what Plutarch wrote hundreds of years
- 40:44down the road. So what?
- 40:45Do we remember the guys basically like murdering
- 40:47everybody by the end of his his young life?
- 40:49So if you're Aryan writing what he wants you to write, how
- 40:53likely is it to show the blemishes and the warts?
- 40:56And and then when he shows the blemishes and the warts, you
- 40:59have to say to yourself, OK, why did Alexander allow him to show
- 41:02the blemishes? I mean, it becomes one of these
- 41:04things where you're trying to dissect the propaganda of
- 41:07somebody who lived more than 2000 years ago, who was hated by
- 41:11a lot of his contemporaries and then lionized by a bunch of
- 41:14people centuries later. I mean, the whole thing is just
- 41:17I'm going to have a good time with that show only because I've
- 41:19been thinking about Alexander on my own spare time for about 50
- 41:22years now. Well, I have about 11 books in
- 41:25the bookshelf next to me as we're speaking.
- 41:27Dan, this has been so much fun. I was really excited for this
- 41:31episode and I really appreciate you spending time today.
- 41:33For the people out there listening, if they want to check
- 41:35you out, check out Hardcore History or your book, The End is
- 41:39Always Near. Where's the best place to go?
- 41:41Well, listen, you can always go to the website dancarlin.com and
- 41:44somehow, someway, it ought to be able to get you to where you
- 41:46want to go. So listen, I hope it was a good
- 41:49show. I appreciate you having me on
- 41:51and I hope your audience gets something out of it.
- 41:53Absolutely. Thank you so much for hanging
- 41:54out with me today, Dan. Thanks for having me man, I
- 41:55appreciate it.