Latest / Newcomer Pod / Elizabeth Holmes' Moveable Feast (with Erin Griffith)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. How's it going, everybody?
- 0:14Welcome back to dead cat. This is Tom here.
- 0:16I'm with Eric and returning Champion.
- 0:19Our first time. Second appearance on the show,
- 0:22Aaron Griffith of the New York Times.
- 0:24Welcome back, Aaron. Thanks for having me.
- 0:26That's quite an honor. Yeah, before we get into the
- 0:29specifics of the trial itself, Aaron is, of course, covering
- 0:32the theranos trial for the New York Times.
- 0:35Gavel to gavel. She's all over it.
- 0:37I want it. I understand there's a bit of
- 0:39breaking news from you because last time one of the big
- 0:42discussion or topics of discussion that we had was what
- 0:45you were able to eat, like just how you were able to find time
- 0:49and the answer was actually incredibly depressing but it did
- 0:52get a lot of attention. So it sounds to me that there's
- 0:55been something of a development in terms of your break and
- 0:59eating habits at the trial. Can you fill us in on what's
- 1:01going on there? Yeah, so, yeah.
- 1:04So this is This is really important and I'm glad that
- 1:06we're getting a, you know, out of the way right at the top of
- 1:08the episode. So I've stopped eating the
- 1:11Starbucks sandwiches on principle.
- 1:13It's just too depressing and I've also now in all of them
- 1:17like enough times that like I can't anymore.
- 1:20So I bought a giant box of Luna bars that I think I am just
- 1:26having I have them in my purse at all times and so now I don't
- 1:29have to leave for lunch because often I'm trying to file because
- 1:32we're now filing kind of daily stories and to bring it.
- 1:35For everyone. I have shared some with our
- 1:38reporting fellow Aaron. Woohoo has been down there with
- 1:40me for some over just within the times.
- 1:42You don't give excellent protocol or anyone else.
- 1:45Everyone else is like packing. Their own peanut butter and
- 1:47jellies or something. I haven't gotten that advanced
- 1:51yet. So yeah I'm just after this
- 1:53trial these, these specifically the lemon ones I'm never going
- 1:56to be able to eat another one of probably eating like 50.
- 1:59So we are in the homestretch of the trial.
- 2:01Yeah, the prosecution has rested their case.
- 2:03Why don't you actually summarize for Us what the prosecution's
- 2:07case, essentially was like how did it, how did it, you know,
- 2:12what was like its strongest point that it was trying to make
- 2:14to the jury? Yeah.
- 2:16So the prosecution at the start outlined I think six or seven
- 2:20areas of alleged fraud and they pretty much went through all of
- 2:25them with almost every count. So there's eleven counts to of
- 2:31conspiracy to commit wire fraud and nine of water fraud and
- 2:35they're all tied to specific investors or patients.
- 2:41There's like I think a couple patients that are in there, one
- 2:44got thrown out and then one related to like an ad
- 2:47advertisement purchase and so the areas of the fraud, our
- 2:53military, she lied about their not having military contracts.
- 2:59I'll see pharmaceutical company. She lied about like their
- 3:04relationship. Chip in their work with
- 3:06pharmaceutical companies. The Walgreens rollout she
- 3:10they're alleging that she lied about how well that was going
- 3:13when she knew it was falling apart and telling investors
- 3:15they'd be you know National and thousands of stores.
- 3:18When in fact they weren't there's the financial
- 3:20projections climbing fairness is going to have a billion dollars
- 3:23in Revenue in 2015 when it had like almost zero and and and
- 3:27those were actually even given to investors.
- 3:29I feel like the end of the year in like October, so they knew
- 3:32they were nowhere close. And then there may be a A couple
- 3:35other ones but those are those are the ones that I've paid
- 3:39closest attention to. And throughout all of it, they
- 3:42have to show that she intended originally defrauded.
- 3:45So they're also constantly tying all of these claims to her
- 3:50directly basically showing her. Oh, I forgot.
- 3:53Sorry. Let me go back.
- 3:54The lab. She knew the obviously that the
- 3:55tests weren't working and that she told people that the third
- 3:58party devices that they had modified third-party devices
- 4:00instead of using their own proprietary technology.
- 4:03So anyway, they have gone. Through and basically lay it out
- 4:07that entire case, which they had previewed in the beginning.
- 4:09And I think they've pretty much delivered on on most of that
- 4:12stuff. And then, of course, the defense
- 4:14has worked, very hard to debunk it, right.
- 4:16We'll get to that in a second, but when you bring up Elizabeth
- 4:19herself, and what she knew or didn't know, I mean, it's one
- 4:21thing to mislead investors, but another thing to do it
- 4:24knowingly, and in some way provably, you know, do it while
- 4:30telling yourself boy, I'm really pulling a fast.
- 4:32One on everyone here, right, right.
- 4:33Her whole defense is that Is naivete.
- 4:36Could you kind of explain to me a little bit about, you know,
- 4:39the guilty mind aspect of it and how the prosecution has been
- 4:42trying to make the case. That not only did she mislead
- 4:44people but she did it knowing that what she was doing full
- 4:47well was not legal. Yeah and so this has been a big
- 4:51part of her testimony. So are the cross examination of
- 4:55her because until this until she testified all the evidence for
- 4:59that part of it was circumstantial, you know, they
- 5:01have to show that she knew about this by showing she was told Old
- 5:05or by seeing emails that she cc'ed on, you know.
- 5:10But now with her on the stand, the prosecutors can just really
- 5:14Hammer her on like, but you knew this was wrong, you knew, and
- 5:18because you knew that fairness test were struggling you and so
- 5:22they did that over and over and just like so repetitively.
- 5:26Like one of the ones that stuck out to me was around the
- 5:28military. You know, they asked her like
- 5:32ten different ways. The same question like you knew
- 5:34that their nose Vices were never used in Afghanistan.
- 5:36They were never used in the Middle East.
- 5:38They were never on a Medevac. They were never used by the
- 5:40military, like just like ten different times in a row.
- 5:42So, the jury, like, clearly gets the point.
- 5:44She knew that this stuff was never being used and she's
- 5:48trying to split a hair and claim.
- 5:50I never really exactly specifically kind of told
- 5:53investors that I hinted at it and they jumped to their own
- 5:56conclusions. She was obviously very prepared
- 5:58for the, the, you know, defenses questioning.
- 6:01She had all her answers ready with the cross.
- 6:05She was pretty prepared and she did a lot of, I don't know, I
- 6:10don't recall. And so she had like, a crystal
- 6:13clear memory for all questions, asked by her lawyers and then
- 6:17when the prosecution asked, she's right kind of funny how
- 6:19that works. She said no a lot to a lot of
- 6:22their questions that were leading and then she would kind
- 6:24of like try to split hairs and be like well you know so she
- 6:28sent this, Roger par La Fortune article that had a lot of
- 6:31incorrect information in it, out to investors as promotion.
- 6:35And they're using that as part of their argument saying like
- 6:38you knew this was wrong and yet you still sent it to investors
- 6:41and never said it was wrong. And she is say, you know, she's
- 6:46trying to like basically say, well, I didn't I sent it to them
- 6:50and I said it contains some information about their nose,
- 6:54you know? So like selected.
- 6:55And I thought, yes, yeah, exactly.
- 6:57She's trying to she's kind of trying to do that around a lot
- 7:00of things. And like with parle off, you
- 7:02know, she told him where She told him, like we can do all
- 7:07these tests and we don't, she didn't.
- 7:10She told him that she didn't say, we don't by third-party
- 7:13devices. She said, we do all of our tests
- 7:16on our own machines that are proprietary.
- 7:19And I didn't tell him like the difference because it's a trade
- 7:22secret. And so, there's just been a lot
- 7:25of, like, kind of weaselly. And so it would seem hard for
- 7:27any, it would seem hard for any, like, rational jury to see that
- 7:31not as bright, navigating your personal lives, like, dealing
- 7:34with Liars, like, Like they're few Liars that just want to get
- 7:37caught out right in line. They would much prefer to let
- 7:41you come to beliefs that are useful to them.
- 7:43Like, yeah, I'm still busy with Coach to say things like that
- 7:46because I just feel like the concept of lying and a liar is a
- 7:49very broad-based accepted like people have a visceral reaction
- 7:53to someone doesn't matter if you understand the industry or not,
- 7:56people have like a spidey sense of like, if this person is lying
- 7:59to me, I don't like that person, you know, people related to like
- 8:01their jobs or their family members and I think the defense
- 8:05has Has countered that with two things for one.
- 8:07They've had her admit to mistakes.
- 8:11So they've tried to like make her more credible by saying.
- 8:14Oh I regret the way we handle the Wall Street Journal article
- 8:17or I regret the way that we dealt with Erica Chang or I
- 8:21regret putting those logos on those pharmaceutical documents.
- 8:24If I had known that they were misleading, so they're trying to
- 8:27get credibility there and they're just trying to
- 8:30complicate things. So they, you know, know this is
- 8:34a jury of late. People who are not super
- 8:37well-versed necessarily in the inner workings of Finance
- 8:40business technology science. And so like I think if they just
- 8:46make it really complicated and then they make it seem like
- 8:49homes, you know was just a little bit confused or maybe
- 8:52Miss keep miscommunicated and other people didn't like
- 8:55understand her or they wanted to believe other things than, like,
- 8:59maybe it was just really complicated and a
- 9:01miscommunication, a big piece of it is how much Like her Co Sunny
- 9:07new verses, which she knew right?
- 9:09She's blamed a lot of it on him. I mean that's that has been a
- 9:12tour. Yeah, I want to actually want to
- 9:15back into Sonny for a bit because of that kind of speaks
- 9:17to sort of the emotional elements of her testimony,
- 9:20right? I mean, so it may be just
- 9:22rewinding for a bit. Let me set it up a little bit
- 9:23better. I remember for in following you
- 9:25in a few other reporters on Twitter when the prosecution
- 9:27rested and the defense began, you know their case was it an
- 9:32open question whether or not Elizabeth Holmes was going to
- 9:34testify because So just from the tweets it seemed like you guys
- 9:37were all very, you know excited. I was shocked.
- 9:41I mean, really the whole time we've been speculating, will
- 9:44she? Or will she not testify and all
- 9:47you know we've all quoted experts saying like why it's a
- 9:50huge risk and why she shouldn't or why she wouldn't or why?
- 9:53It's so rare and white collar crimes for the defendant to ever
- 9:57testify. And, you know, that on the other
- 9:59hand, people are like, well, she's a big risk taker and this
- 10:02is part of her defense or lawyers have said she's going to
- 10:04testify. I am like this is her best shot.
- 10:08And so anyway I everything about this trial has been
- 10:11unpredictable and so it definitely came as a surprise.
- 10:14To me particular did you find out?
- 10:16Well, I was sitting in the courtroom, it was the very few
- 10:21of the days have gone. All our of the weeks have gone
- 10:23all five days but it was for whatever scheduling reason five
- 10:27days in a row, I was exhausted. It was 3:00 like one hour before
- 10:33court was about to be out. Out and like I know other
- 10:37journalists were thinking of leaving.
- 10:38I was like do I need to really need to stay?
- 10:40Like this is pretty boring like the defense's argument had not
- 10:44so far. They had had like, a former lab
- 10:46director and and like a paralegal from their own Law
- 10:50Firm testifying. And then, you know, we're all
- 10:53like, oh, what's going to happen this last hour?
- 10:56And then they called her to the stand and oh my God, I like
- 11:00almost had a heart attack. It was absolutely not what I had
- 11:04expected. You know, we had Paradise live
- 11:06blog are like you know, sort of a live feed that we were going
- 11:09to spin up just in case. Like I had a story pre-written
- 11:12just in case but like I was not ready for it to happen at that
- 11:14moment at 3:00 after the very at the very tail end of a super
- 11:18long week. He should have to call her when
- 11:21it's time, you would think they'd want to start the day
- 11:24with her and have it be sort of finish.
- 11:26I feel like it was almost a good way for her to like get
- 11:30acclimated to the court. Like it was low stake.
- 11:33They didn't talk about anything important on that.
- 11:35At first, our it was just like getting her like, used to being
- 11:39in the corner. That's smart.
- 11:41I see it kind of like screwed the journalist though because
- 11:43it's like, all right, I've been here all for three months,
- 11:47almost every day and like, I should at least get some head
- 11:51start on like, getting some exclusive information but then
- 11:56like, so we got really nothing out of that first hour and then
- 11:58Monday, of course, everybody flies in.
- 12:01You know, everyone who has at the trial, right working
- 12:04journalists Yeah, it sucks. We got no circus atmosphere that
- 12:08had probably died down as people were like, man, trials can be
- 12:11really boring and it's just like a recitation of documents and
- 12:15all this other like oh here's the star witness, who is going
- 12:17to be played by, you know, Jennifer Lawrence in a couple of
- 12:20months. Yeah, she's showing up at like
- 12:22325 on a, this is why the media is broken, you know, the
- 12:26outlets, the put in the work. Yeah, this that's specifically
- 12:30is exactly the crew system needs to write the local news cameras
- 12:34that have been covering like shoplifting in San Francisco,
- 12:37like, suddenly turned around and we're rushing down the
- 12:39courthouse. There were a lot of Spectators
- 12:42that I mean, cuz there's been a Spectators throughout, but there
- 12:44are a lot of Spectators that day that left at lunch because it
- 12:47was so boring. And I was like, no man.
- 12:50It's like the people that were leaving Dodger Stadium in 89
- 12:52because I thought the World Series was over right?
- 12:55Right. Yeah.
- 12:56Miami serious. Yeah, right.
- 12:58So so but it seems that the core of her case Beyond just her
- 13:03being naive. That she was a victim.
- 13:07She was a victim of abuse and that she was being manipulated
- 13:10by Sonny bhawani. Now, I remember like before the
- 13:13trial even started, people were suggesting that that could be
- 13:15one route that they take. I don't know if they probably
- 13:18would have needed to call her if that was going to be the route
- 13:21but totally but because their relationship was a secret.
- 13:24And so really like she's one of the only people that can even
- 13:27testify about it, right? They had, they had indicated,
- 13:31they might do this in filings, so we had that preview, but it
- 13:34was still on Open question, mark of whether not, she'd actually
- 13:37go for it. I'm sure they're waiting to see
- 13:39how everything else went before deciding.
- 13:41Yeah, and just from the reading of it, it sounded like it was
- 13:43fairly emotional. Like she went, you know, when
- 13:45she took the stand it was describing, you know, her
- 13:47allegations of abuse, she was crying, she was tearful and I
- 13:51did that surprise you at all. I mean, obviously she's someone
- 13:54who in the media has been depicted as like this kind of
- 13:57stony-faced monotone. Baritone, you know, uncaring
- 14:01unblinking person did she Blink by the way, when she was on the
- 14:04stand? Yeah. and I made a joke once
- 14:07where I thought I had noticed that she was like, Blinking a
- 14:12lot while looking forward. And I was like, a she'd just
- 14:14getting all her blinks out now. Robert like so she can then
- 14:17stare when. But yeah, it's also a way to get
- 14:20the tears going, not just as their crocodile tears.
- 14:23She has made some intense eye contact and when the jurors were
- 14:26walking in and out anytime she would try to individually, make
- 14:29eye contact with each one of them.
- 14:31My God maybe only one ever really looked up at her but yes
- 14:34there's that one invested in her company that's in her, you know,
- 14:37morning notebook routine, stare intently and to each jurors.
- 14:41I mean, so one thing that came up that I thought was really
- 14:44interesting in this argument about the emotional and physical
- 14:50or sexual abuse that she that happened in her relationship
- 14:54with Sonny about wani which to be fair.
- 14:55This guy's 20 years older than her and he was like her business
- 14:58mentor. And so, I mean, I think that
- 15:01felt very credible to me that they had a lopsided dynamic in
- 15:07their relationship. But doesn't necessarily didn't
- 15:09really connect it very well to the actual fraud. but and so
- 15:14that's going to be, I think the challenge for the jury but like,
- 15:19one of the things I thought so interesting is like, so all the
- 15:21investors that we've heard talk about how impressive she was and
- 15:25how she was so put together and confident and like, you know,
- 15:28unlike a 19 year old girl might be, you know, and that was all
- 15:34because Sonny was coaching her to be like that he was basically
- 15:37telling her and kind of he was berating her but he was also
- 15:41telling Her like don't say awesome, don't giggle, don't
- 15:44like, you know, put your hands in your pockets, don't gesture,
- 15:47you know, he was like really kind of like pushing her to
- 15:52present herself that way. And it worked.
- 15:55How old was she for some of this?
- 15:57Well she she met him when she was in college.
- 16:00So like 1819. But then when During the period
- 16:03of the alleged fraud, she would have been in her 20s.
- 16:06Late 20s early 30s. Okay.
- 16:08But I mean, some of the investors met her In like the
- 16:11early 2000s when their nose had first started.
- 16:14So they were testifying about all the way back at that point.
- 16:17Like the Don Lucas's is, it was it a son or nephew anyway?
- 16:22Yeah, so Insider we ran a piece I Believe by Adam Le schinsky
- 16:27saying that her taking the trial and the tenor and pitch of her
- 16:32testimony turned the tide that basically it's suddenly been
- 16:37suddenly became because she made it about her.
- 16:40A victim. And a lot of the most devious
- 16:43acts of the company's life, were the result of, you know, the
- 16:47Svengali Sunnyvale wani that she was merely a naive and innocent
- 16:51bystander or like a puppet for the true evil.
- 16:55That was, I mean what, what did you bought into this now?
- 17:00He, yeah, let's this is going to be an IT situation where Eric
- 17:03screams at me, I did not read the story, but the headline of
- 17:07the story, I read the story I'm Adam with his writing has been
- 17:10good. Yeah.
- 17:11So I don't want you to make Adams case for him.
- 17:14But what do you think about at least that idea that, you know,
- 17:17suddenly the momentum shifted entirely towards the defense, I
- 17:21have no idea what the jury is thinking and so I that's one
- 17:26part of it that's challenge. But I do think it kind of
- 17:29upended the dynamic, for sure. I mean, this has been a very
- 17:33long, very tedious white collar crime case about business and
- 17:40And Tech and Science, and it's just been like so in the weeds
- 17:44and now we have this, extremely emotional narrative injected
- 17:49into it. Like, it's hard, not to only
- 17:51focus on that. And I feel like the jury is
- 17:54that's going to be at the heart of a lot of their discussions.
- 17:57I'm on, or maybe they decide to throw it out, I don't know.
- 17:59But like, well, that and actually to me when the
- 18:03prosecution has said, they plan to file a motion to throw out
- 18:06some of that, because they did not the defense did not bring in
- 18:10an Expert testimony or expert witness to testify as to the
- 18:14relevance of it, to this fraud case.
- 18:18Don't you want to throw things out before the jury hears,
- 18:21right? They can't.
- 18:22Yeah, they can't like, this is even if they remove it, it's not
- 18:27like the jury can like special emotional case, right?
- 18:30I mean, like, it's one thing to material fact.
- 18:33It is kind of the same as like when the when they ask
- 18:35questions. They know they're not allowed to
- 18:36ask, and then they it gets objected.
- 18:39And then the judge says, okay. Ignore that it's like, well,
- 18:41they already heard it. And that's kind of like a little
- 18:43bit of a slimeball move but they vote will science.
- 18:46Have definitely used it. Okay.
- 18:47Sorry. This is a very basic question,
- 18:49but like Elizabeth and Sonny are both on trial in this case or
- 18:54they are separate cases. No, sonny is separate has a
- 18:58separate case separate trial that will start next year.
- 19:00They were they should have been tried together but they got
- 19:03their cases. Severed.
- 19:04And part of the reason that they argued for successfully for it,
- 19:08was that she said she can't be in the same room as him.
- 19:10Him because of this abuse. And I mean it kind of works the
- 19:15both of their advantages because they might be able to both get
- 19:18off by blaming each other. But they're they're both very
- 19:22important and relevant in each side's case because it want to
- 19:27of the charges are conspiracy. And so they conspired together
- 19:31and we're seeing all these text messages where they're allegedly
- 19:33conspiring. You know when you contrast it
- 19:36with her being able to answer these very specific rapid-fire
- 19:40questions Like yes, yes, yes. And from her lawyers and then
- 19:45and so a lot of the actually the prosecution has done a lot of
- 19:48hammering her on the I don't know.
- 19:49Like he'll say that's your testimony.
- 19:51That this is your inhale, repeat it back to her.
- 19:53This is your testimony. That you don't know this thing.
- 19:55And I mean, we'll see if that if that would be infuriating to
- 20:00watch. I mean, it's just but it's
- 20:02interesting. I mean, it seems to me like most
- 20:04of the defense's case is that she was a victim.
- 20:07Not that an end if she misled people was only because Does
- 20:10that is the nature of raising money where you have to Project,
- 20:14Blue Sky Futures in order to get people excited about it and if
- 20:17it doesn't work out you know, don't hate the player, hate the
- 20:20game and and does she seem like a cult leader like just you have
- 20:25a reality Distortion field or she seems.
- 20:27She's trying to project being a little bit more me core.
- 20:29How much does it seem like you could see why a bunch of
- 20:33investors were wooed by her. I mean when you when she is gets
- 20:39a question that she liked Sure that she knows the answer to.
- 20:42She does this thing which I think you can see on any video
- 20:45interview of her back in the in the Heyday where she like nods
- 20:50and makes this really sincere eye contact and like has this
- 20:54like kind of like kind of weird smile and yeah you can see how
- 21:01it's like very practiced and it's like it.
- 21:04You can see how it's compelling especially for people who want
- 21:07to, you know, believe in what she's pitching.
- 21:09I think it could also be be off-putting, knowing what we
- 21:12know. Now, you're not about to join
- 21:14her call. You're like, right, it's either
- 21:16like charming and effects. It's a thin line between
- 21:19charming and effective in a sociopath.
- 21:21Yeah. It's kind of like, when customer
- 21:22service people are like, like, handling, you, with kid gloves
- 21:25and you're like, just just do think your name over and over
- 21:27again? Yeah, stop doing that.
- 21:29It's like really off-putting. Let me give you the money,
- 21:32Elizabeth. How's the jury doing?
- 21:35What's your sense? Just this many weeks into this
- 21:38whole thing. I know there was a bit of drama.
- 21:40Leon people wanted to take vacations.
- 21:43What did we talk about the sodoku player?
- 21:45I don't think so about halfway through one of the jurors was
- 21:49dismissed for playing sudoku during testimony.
- 21:53One of the other jurors knocked her out and they had she her
- 21:57excuse was that she's like very fidgety and she needs to like
- 22:00have something to do with her hands.
- 22:02And so it was just to keep her occupied.
- 22:04Did that'll play out during the trial, was there just like that,
- 22:07you know, like a teacher calling out a students like, what do you
- 22:09have there? No.
- 22:10They did it in the judge's Chambers and so we didn't find
- 22:13out about. We just heard that a juror was
- 22:14dismissed and we didn't find out about it until it came out later
- 22:17and the transcripts and she was like, very apologetic and she's
- 22:20like, I'm swear. I'm taking this seriously.
- 22:22And, and essentially the both, the sides, agreed to just let
- 22:27her go. I must be mortifying to tell
- 22:30your family, you've been gone for like or you're not gone.
- 22:33But, you know, your things you wanted to crochet, but like that
- 22:37seemed inappropriate. Do they let you do that.
- 22:40No, I don't think. I mean, no.
- 22:42I think that would be worse. Probably there goes the book
- 22:45deal. But okay, so we lost one for
- 22:49playing sudoku but generally, I mean, what's your senses to
- 22:53their energy level, you know, this many weeks and I would just
- 22:56be flagging, like, I couldn't pay attention.
- 22:58I know it's crazy and they seem like they seem engaged, but it's
- 23:02so hard to tell, because they have masks on, and they really
- 23:05are not reacting to anything. And like, there's either all
- 23:09taking notes, There is one guy who likes top proceedings and
- 23:13like, waved his arm and we're like, oh no, what's happening?
- 23:16And oh, his pen, ran out of ink. And so like, somebody had to
- 23:19bring a pen over to him. And I'm like, man, I mean, so
- 23:23they seem they seem pretty engaged.
- 23:24I don't know. Sometimes I look and I'm like,
- 23:27is that person sleeping, but their exhibits are below them.
- 23:30So I think they're just looking at the exhibits, but I don't
- 23:32know, man. It's, it's impressive.
- 23:34When the judge was planning the timing for the rest of the
- 23:38trial, like, I thought I would be in court today.
- 23:40A and yesterday and you know, most of next week.
- 23:44And for some reason, closings aren't starting until like a
- 23:47full week after the prosecutor, the defense rested and the jury
- 23:52is, they're like, oh yeah, we're fine to deliberate on Christmas
- 23:56Eve. We don't care.
- 23:57Like they don't seem like stressed which is kind of crazy
- 24:02and impressive, so forth. When's this thing gonna get
- 24:05wrapped up or I hope Before Christmas?
- 24:07It's so there's two days of Closing statements or arguments
- 24:12next week and then it will go to the jury maybe as early as next
- 24:15Friday. And then the week of the 20th is
- 24:18all open for deliberation. So I hope you know, it takes him
- 24:21a day or two and they come back and we can all have a Christmas.
- 24:26Yeah. Well then you'll have to talk to
- 24:28the jurors, right? I mean that's always the
- 24:29exciting moment post-trial when they finally.
- 24:31So, that's Morgan V, right? I mean, yeah.
- 24:34Now we'll have to do it to. I'm a little stressed about that
- 24:36honestly. Because who knows if they're
- 24:39going to want to Talk to us or just like, get out of there and
- 24:44yeah, I want to know everyone. That's what everyone wants to
- 24:47know. Is like what the discussions
- 24:48inside that room were right? Right, depending on the outcome.
- 24:52So my last question for you, Aaron, because we gotta let you
- 24:55go is So is Elizabeth Halsey product of Silicon Valley?
- 25:01Oh my God. I think about this so much
- 25:04because I've gotten, you know, a lot of VCS in my DMs, like, come
- 25:09on. This is not a pie made the
- 25:10mistake of engaging in that debate and I am still getting
- 25:13mentions from it. Yeah.
- 25:15And I think I need to like, just dig in and do a story on it,
- 25:19but, you know, some people are really worked up about this.
- 25:21They're so angry. They don't want to be associated
- 25:23with this at all Eric's buddy. Keith raboy said that when a
- 25:26reporter Stood that she was a private Silicon Valley said that
- 25:29was more, there's more untruthful that anything Trump
- 25:32has ever said. Oh my God, oh my God, that's
- 25:37ridiculous. Wow, what I mean.
- 25:40Okay, so just the facts here. Palo Alto is in Silicon Valley.
- 25:46Stanford is very closely associated with Silicon Valley.
- 25:50She went to Stanford the Hoover Institute as Stanford is where
- 25:53she recruited all of her board her initial.
- 25:57Mr. Don Lucas legendary Silicon Valley investor, Tim Draper also
- 26:03like fifth generation or whatever, you know, Silicon
- 26:07Valley investor and on down the line and she had a number of VCS
- 26:12and they the the current, you know, industry and commentators
- 26:16want to dismiss them and be like they're not real Silicon Valley
- 26:18visas. We all pass on a great.
- 26:20Many people did pass on this and many people said it didn't pass
- 26:24the smell test, whatever, like that's fantastic, but And shirt
- 26:28DeVos the DeVos family, the Murdock's The Waltons, the Cox
- 26:33family. Those are not Silicon Valley
- 26:35investors but like she was still following the Playbook, she was
- 26:39trying to emulate Steve Jobs. She was physically here in
- 26:43Silicon Valley, that all of that makes me like and it's sort of
- 26:49it's sort of if it's into like how Elizabeth Holmes lies right.
- 26:53Instead of directly telling you sort of a misstatement.
- 26:57It's Letting you come away with an impression and sort of
- 27:00letting the chips fall where they are.
- 27:02And I do think there's a degree to which Silicon Valley culture
- 27:05is also sort of very interested in that kind of line.
- 27:08Like, you know, Marc Andreessen would block people who didn't
- 27:11like their nose, his wife wrote an op-ed defending Elizabeth
- 27:15Holmes, you know, there can I really something really quickly
- 27:17because when that was going on I just Googled dfj fairness and
- 27:21there is a Facebook post from dfj that is still up that says
- 27:25under dfj proud to have back. Elizabeth Holmes and fairness
- 27:28for over a decade as her very first, investor homes is
- 27:31company. There are no stands on the cusp
- 27:33of unleashing, a revolution and Drug development and home health
- 27:36care. That could spawn a new industry
- 27:37much like the bay area's Genentech did Ababa.
- 27:40This is still fuck it up there under D fj's payment.
- 27:42When was that published, March, 1st, 2014, I can send it in the,
- 27:46okay, so that's that's before the the downfall but yeah, yeah,
- 27:50yeah. But if you solve, if Silicon
- 27:52Valley didn't want to get blamed for their nose, they could have
- 27:56taken a principal. Then, you know, we could have a
- 27:58alternative story where she tries to raise money from.
- 28:01Some very credentialed, VC, and they're the ones blowing, the
- 28:04whistle and saying she's trying to defraud us.
- 28:07Well, there's some of the things she's saying isn't true.
- 28:09Instead, it was, you know, her employees that blew the whistle.
- 28:12So I just think their failure to stand up if they were to say
- 28:17anything. And, and also they were
- 28:19constantly, sort of rejecting sort of push back on Twitter.
- 28:24You know, it felt like the presumption.
- 28:27It was a it was Dave Moore and didn't Dave Moore in criticized
- 28:30on the information? Yeah it's that but I'm saying
- 28:32like every Silicon Valley character was still sort of like
- 28:36trying to show their credentials for how you could be raw and
- 28:40supportive and was not at all. Trying to say o, Silicon Valley
- 28:43is actually about being Discerning and separating sort
- 28:47of the good from the bad and so then when it's really bad for
- 28:50them. Yeah, of course you're going to
- 28:52get blamed because you didn't take any sort of proactive
- 28:55action to separate yourself. From a and so now you're mad at
- 28:59people for attaching new to it when everything you said is
- 29:02absolutely true. So I do agree their failure to
- 29:05say anything at the time. Partially justifies why they get
- 29:10tagged with it. Even if, you know, probably the
- 29:13most directly, you know, family has is, are the biggest it also
- 29:18speaks to, like, a current circle, the wagons and
- 29:21groupthink mentality from a lot of VCS right now, which is at
- 29:25the Press, is out to get us and there are Comparing us to the
- 29:28worst of what the, you know, Peter and every has other words,
- 29:32if you were to extend that to any other industry would make
- 29:34any sense, if you were to say that someone who makes a movie
- 29:36that bombs had nothing to do with Hollywood culture or that
- 29:39Bernie Madoff had nothing to do with Wall Street culture.
- 29:42He's like go ahead and try that argument right away.
- 29:45They are products. They are products of the world
- 29:47that you though. You're successful.
- 29:48And hopefully on the up-and-up are not examples of.
- 29:52It's still in the same. You're still swimming in the
- 29:54same pool. Right.
- 29:56Many of the strategies that she used are used by other Founders.
- 30:00They just don't go that far. They just don't like get, you
- 30:03know, they just don't take it to the level of actual fraud or
- 30:07some do when they don't get invited for it.
- 30:10I think, if Silicon Valley wants people to know what they stand
- 30:13for. They have to say it explicitly,
- 30:16but we give us one concluding. What's been your favorite
- 30:20vignette or moment? Or like, doesn't have to be
- 30:22serious, or like, who's the, who's the celebrity?
- 30:25Sir, who's the, like, what's, what sort of the funny or I
- 30:28would be trying to be made along the way.
- 30:30Elizabeth Holmes, family members, behaving, strangely, or
- 30:32what's, what's going on? It's not making this story, that
- 30:35sort of like the talk among reporters.
- 30:37So much for the gadflies. Like, who are you going to miss
- 30:40when? You don't have to go to the
- 30:41courthouse. There's so much weird stuff that
- 30:43has happened. Like I, I like inadvertently got
- 30:47in a fight with this guy who had driven up from LA and chugged 5,
- 30:51red bulls and was like confused about the order of the line.
- 30:55I'm going in and like, there's this cut off at 34 and so
- 30:58there's actually a lot of a lot at stake.
- 31:01If you're under 30 for you, get in the courtroom and if you're
- 31:03over you again, the mean number of number of people not to yes.
- 31:07Yes. Ari.
- 31:08Okay. And so anyway that was a little
- 31:11bit dramatic. What were you?
- 31:13I was he was trying to cut in front of me.
- 31:15Basically. I was maybe like 32 or
- 31:18something. Oh Jesus that's high-stakes.
- 31:19How was he was? Just trying to force it.
- 31:22Like he was confused because there are multiple Scots in
- 31:24line. He was confused.
- 31:25Which Scott, he was. And anyway, we it all worked
- 31:29out, it was fine, but there's always a little bit of like line
- 31:32drama and there's a lot of Spectators.
- 31:35I don't know if you guys read about, there was one group that
- 31:37came they were selling black turtlenecks, red lipstick.
- 31:42They kept getting in trouble though because you're not
- 31:45allowed to sell things on federal property.
- 31:48And so, the security guard kept yelling at them and they're
- 31:50like, no, it's performance art. And oh my God, I got to use that
- 31:54one. There was there's a A guy who
- 31:56has hung around a few times. And when Holmes walks in, he
- 31:59yells you go girl, boss your girl boss.
- 32:02There's been some tarot cards playing in the line because
- 32:05we're sitting there for five hours every day before the court
- 32:08even opens. And so we have a lot of we have
- 32:10a lot of time to kill all of you guys.
- 32:12Well, we did a reading for homes and it was it looked pretty
- 32:16positive for her. Wow.
- 32:18Wow. I mean, that's what Colleen.
- 32:21Yeah, I think that. Yeah, that would definitely
- 32:23affect the betting markets. So, What was your read and
- 32:26remember the cars. So, I'm a terrible person but I
- 32:30think one of them was like the was about was like a kind of a
- 32:35girl boss card. And then I think one of them was
- 32:37like, is that a real Taro? This was the interpretation of
- 32:42the person who's doing it and one of them was maybe something
- 32:47about, oh crap now I'm sorry, I'm totally the great unblinking
- 32:51eye. Yeah there was one about like
- 32:55fortune or Having having things work out for you.
- 32:57There's one of maybe about deception.
- 32:59I really can't remember now. Sorry?
- 33:01Disappointing. Have a break for the price of
- 33:02anything. Anyway, Aaron this is great.
- 33:08Yeah, thanks so much for joining.
- 33:10Enjoy your days off and hopefully enjoy having a real
- 33:13Christmas. Yeah, yeah.
- 33:15Thanks, I'm not San Jose. All right.
- 33:17Cool. That was great.
- 33:18Oh, the judge also keeps keeps calling the trial a moveable
- 33:22feast which like it's really a fan, really upset.
- 33:25Me because I'm like this could not be further from.
- 33:28I'm sitting on the ground for find a bar wrappers all around
- 33:32you. Yeah, eating Luna bars.
- 33:34This is this could not be farther than Hemingway's pairs.
- 33:37Yeah. Kicking me the recap on Aaron.
- 33:43Did she think that Elizabeth Holmes was convincing?
- 33:46Hmm, didn't seem like it. No, and I'd asked her because
- 33:50Insider ran a piece by a demotion ski actually saying
- 33:53that. Like, when Elizabeth Holmes
- 33:54testified and gave a t read, you know, whatever tearful
- 33:59explanation of how she was manipulated and abused by
- 34:02Sunnyvale hwanhee, that that changed the entire momentum of
- 34:06the trial into the defense's favor.
- 34:08And she was, I think a little more skeptical.
- 34:10All right. Yeah, but she's not I don't
- 34:13think she can really say outright.
- 34:15That was my interpretation. But what is this?
- 34:18Chris Dixon tweet. So, so what happened?
- 34:21When I can give you the whole rundown?
- 34:22It's like the Twitter recap section.
- 34:26Yeah. So some Bloomberg reporter
- 34:29tweeted out, something to the effect of like someone just told
- 34:32me that crypto is is Mary Kay for males and I'm dying right
- 34:36now or some like internet and collect Medics company that You
- 34:40have to uses anymore. Yeah.
- 34:42So it was like a pretty weak joke, like a 4 out of 10 but it,
- 34:46it, you know, became viral because that's what succeeds
- 34:49these days. So we got like seven thousand
- 34:51retweets. You know, I blame Tick-Tock for
- 34:53that cuz it's made us all laugh at things aren't funny anymore.
- 34:56It's all funny, especially reporters, Tracy.
- 34:58All the way. Just saw someone described
- 35:01crypto as Mary, Kay for young men and now I'm dying.
- 35:04Yeah, it has like 13,000 awful's, awful, just no effort,
- 35:09no degree of Uncle teacher. I see I'm say it's just a way
- 35:12for Bloomberg to try and insult web three yet again on.
- 35:16December 7th. This is Chris Dixon.
- 35:18Yeah, so then he has a follow-up tweet to that.
- 35:20That says, this is why we should never talk to reporters.
- 35:23All they do is use it as an opportunity to dunk on you.
- 35:26Later on Twitter, on December 8th.
- 35:27You says whether he is unusual in that innovators dilemma plays
- 35:31out at every level including media coverage.
- 35:33And then he says, which is also why it's a great opportunity for
- 35:36up-and-coming journalists, you know, they know that they need
- 35:39your illness but they can't. Themselves, but should on
- 35:42journalists constantly. It's, yeah, I'm trying to find.
- 35:45I think maybe Everything's changed since I left, but I
- 35:48vaguely recall. When I lived in California, that
- 35:52a 16z actually didn't hate the kind of like that.
- 35:55I mean, it was like, it was mixed, right?
- 35:57Like, they like this one. I like to say, I didn't when
- 35:59they didn't like any normal company, so it's just now, like,
- 36:02just a all, they're all out there, like, no, never mind.
- 36:06I mean, Chris Dixon is super anti-media, I mean, definitely,
- 36:09I'm looking through all this Former board member at BuzzFeed.
- 36:11So a big led the entries that investment in in bone.
- 36:16So oh yeah. Oh yeah.
- 36:19One of my favorite investment posts so but they're the must
- 36:22still be locked up. I mean, the IPO don't let anyone
- 36:25else. Well, he stepped down from the
- 36:26board so I don't know what BuzzFeed injuries and state
- 36:29currently is in BuzzFeed, but yes, they invested in 2014.
- 36:33I remember this because it wasn't long after I joined the
- 36:35information and Chris Dixon put out a post explaining their
- 36:38investment saying that Actually, BuzzFeed is a tech company if
- 36:42you want a real web 3 News go direct and follow primary
- 36:44sources, I mean, clearly the flip side of this is that
- 36:49Andreessen is super Vindicated in their anti-media stance.
- 36:54And recent is super Vindicated this week because of that
- 36:57businessweek piece that basically said that Marc
- 37:01Andreessen and Ben Horowitz were starting to phase back their
- 37:05involvement in the firm when they seem like the most
- 37:07workaholic. And if anything I would say, The
- 37:10Narrative and reason is that those two are domineering over
- 37:13the firm that there's a very clear hierarchy within the firm.
- 37:17And there is a lot of jealousy among Partners about who gets
- 37:21status and sort of what the pecking order is.
- 37:24So I was very surprised, sure, they're moving places and like
- 37:28we're all remote now. But the idea that they're
- 37:32stepping putting they're taking their foot off the gas and
- 37:34anyway because they're on fewer board seats.
- 37:37I found super implausible. Then Mark and been jumped on
- 37:43Twitter, to make fun of the story and it just was I feel bad
- 37:49for my former colleagues a little bit because I didn't
- 37:51think it made them look great. And also, like they're stepping
- 37:57back, is it proven that they're the people who made all the best
- 38:00investments and it would actually impact the firm's
- 38:02performance at all? I mean, I thought then, I mean,
- 38:06Mark, Mark is not Mark. Yeah, I mean, I think there's a
- 38:09story that, you know, Mark is Not personally necessarily the
- 38:13best picker but is a good seller for the firm is good.
- 38:16At the Vivid Visions or the marketer.
- 38:19Superheated you need a, you need a Salesman but that's been true
- 38:22for ever. That's not a change, I mean
- 38:24right in bet. But then I mean is you know
- 38:28super involved a lot of the hard decisions and I know he's super
- 38:31involved in the crypto fund. So, yeah, I found that story a
- 38:36little, maybe they'll look smart but I mean You know, these
- 38:40things phase out for so long. I just I feel like it was a big
- 38:44claim to make to well the other part of it was that they had
- 38:46stepped off of a couple of their boards, right?
- 38:48They'd gone from like 11 boards to seven boards which I don't I
- 38:52don't know what that really means.
- 38:54If that's, I mean at a time well you know, formation predicting,
- 38:58you know what berber and the information predicting the and
- 39:00reasons going to go public, I don't have this sourcing to say
- 39:04that I wrote a story saying that they had Ambitions to be like an
- 39:08Apollo. I didn't think That meant they
- 39:10needed to do a public listing, but they're clearly growing that
- 39:14firm enormously so they're doing a ton of work.
- 39:17I mean it's a huge. The management of the firm is
- 39:20becoming bigger and bigger. The only reason I think that an
- 39:23IPO for injuries might be smart and probably not for a lot of
- 39:26other VC firms is because their operation is so large and
- 39:31encompasses so much outside of investing like an order for just
- 39:35the profits from investment to continue to always consistently.
- 39:40For that many human beings who do that many not investing
- 39:44activities, it would be possibly nice to have a public market
- 39:49support system, so they could build off of that, you know,
- 39:52kind of like the what Blackstone did I met?
- 39:54Chris Dixon Wells. He'll never remember me.
- 39:56But we met at a recent event and I thought he was really smart
- 40:00and interesting talk to. I don't know.
- 40:02I guess that's too like these people.
- 40:04I met him also at one and I was, of course, trying to work him
- 40:07for information about BuzzFeed hilarious.
- 40:10Little did. I know he didn't really give a
- 40:11shit about Buzz? Yeah, well, I was listening to
- 40:17him, talk, never heard on that, is on the Tim Ferriss podcast
- 40:21with navall. And the funny thing about, you
- 40:24know, obviously sort of Chris and of all seem much smarter
- 40:28than Tim and Tim just plays sort of bemuse, like, explain this to
- 40:32me, which is, you know, I guess the softball Tech loves that.
- 40:38It's just like, oh, yeah, yeah, where the Gods?
- 40:40In the world to you. But I mean, Chris like clearly
- 40:43loves philosophy and some ways use the kind of person reporters
- 40:48like where he's very sort of Humanity's interested.
- 40:53So it's sort of sad that there's this breakdown who knew this was
- 40:57going to be a love letter to Chris Dixon.
- 40:59Here you go. There you go.
- 41:01That's a contrarian stance. I mean he's you know on the
- 41:05Forefront of crypto right now. One of the most important things
- 41:08going on in the world and Exciting thing, it's sort of sad
- 41:12because the breakdown with the media and some ways is a
- 41:15breakdown, you know, with the public it's like, oh fuck you
- 41:18like translated I'm saying. And that's a big, you're like,
- 41:23what's this doing? And that's like just a bigger
- 41:25thing altogether when they would never say that.
- 41:27Obviously, they would take great umbrage at the idea that the
- 41:30media, and the public could be switched, you know, for each
- 41:34other in a sentence. But I just think realistically,
- 41:37that's, that's the truth. Yeah.
- 41:41I'll tell you who has no problem getting hype and excitement.
- 41:43From the media though, is every a, our product that ever was
- 41:46released in the last couple of years.
- 41:50There's no shortage of reporters willing to traipse over to
- 41:53whatever location to try on the next pair of ugly ass glasses
- 41:58that do like 2% of what hoop analogy.
- 42:01It's the latest one. Well and I don't want to call it
- 42:03reporters individually because if I were covering the company,
- 42:06I would probably have gone to and written something nice about
- 42:09it that you might have. Been forced to go.
- 42:11Yeah. Well that's part of it too.
- 42:14Snap had like a developer day for reporters where they put out
- 42:18their latest version of their augmented reality glasses and
- 42:21got pretty pretty. Nice.
- 42:23Write-ups from The Verge Alex Heath, former colleague of mine
- 42:27and and Casey Newton who basically we're saying like
- 42:30look, it's limited. What it can do the field of
- 42:33vision from for augmented. Reality is not all that great
- 42:36and the things it can do or mostly in the realm of toy
- 42:39rather than huge You know world changing technology but the
- 42:42colonel of what it could be is there and for the first time in
- 42:45my life I can see you know over the horizon.
- 42:48What this thing is promise and like look maybe in the Elation
- 42:52of some trying something cool and new you might think
- 42:54something like that but it's again hard for me to square that
- 42:58mentality with the either ignorance or derision of crypto
- 43:03which is like I was saying for we start recording probably at
- 43:05the same stage in terms of public acceptance and like by I
- 43:09think I was you reporter As you mentioned are also very
- 43:12intrigued by crypto to. So that's one.
- 43:15Flaw with your, your claim here that somehow a are gets more fun
- 43:19and coverage than crypto mean they both, they both are, I
- 43:22guess. What?
- 43:22I want to see is like, watch someone write a piece saying,
- 43:25how the, I just had a crypt like an AR demo and it sucked.
- 43:29And this kind of goes back to the conversation.
- 43:30We had ages ago, where it was like what is the benefit of
- 43:35writing that something is just bad, right?
- 43:38Why not just ignore it. Not just ignore it.
- 43:41Like did we nobody wanted to say I don't know, write a big story
- 43:46about how the flying car was stupid waste of money and it was
- 43:48going to be a drag companies that tried it.
- 43:51Like it's just like why bother just look funny phenomenon.
- 43:55You know is people who quote tweet tweets that they hate, you
- 43:59know, it's like, oh, you're Distributing this very thing.
- 44:02You profess to despise and and so it's just a very human
- 44:09online. Isshin that you amplify the very
- 44:12thing you wish to suppress. But do you read stories about
- 44:15things that people don't like? I mean I don't unless it's
- 44:17Anthony mi re do he just likes him.
- 44:19I mean obviously if it's well-written did you read the
- 44:21wonderful piece about that the one-star Michelin restaurant?
- 44:26I think it was in some Italian city.
- 44:29It was I think 27 courses, mostly consisting of like fish
- 44:33flavored foam. They left Hungary, it was just
- 44:36terrible. That's true but I didn't see
- 44:39that as Necessarily something about, I didn't see that as this
- 44:44is something I disliked, I saw that Maura has this is something
- 44:47that was extraordinarily weird and unlikable.
- 44:51Yeah, what I loved more was the chef's response which is the
- 44:54increasingly abstract, but pictures images of a man on the
- 44:57horse right? Beautiful.
- 45:00Well somebody somebody translated it as like oh is
- 45:04response wasn't do the food's actually good.
- 45:07Like fuck you. It's I'm trying to abstract Act
- 45:10a way, the nests necessity of food because which is
- 45:24exactly exactly. It was like, it was like, you
- 45:28know, watching the movie Breaking the Waves or something
- 45:30or let's say, I mean, it was just like, right?
- 45:33Yeah, anybody can charge you $200 and make you feel like you
- 45:36just had a great time. I'm going to do something
- 45:38different, right? Students and enjoyment bike,
- 45:41that's very 20th century when it comes to food.
- 45:44Like, what about just pure confusion and like, discuss,
- 45:48right? I will say, I actually thought I
- 45:50liked the article, I thought it was kind of annoyingly written
- 45:52and it's like a certain kind of Internet language that I just
- 45:55find sort of tired. I knew that it was probably
- 45:57going to go viral or is written as sort of like yeah.
- 46:00I don't know, just what just language, I'm curious where you
- 46:03didn't, like, I can bring up the article.
- 46:05Specifically there was just lines here and there that were
- 46:07just like derivative of a certain type of Like internet
- 46:10humor that I just thrust tiresome and it just like, yeah,
- 46:14like the front. I will take all of it to me all
- 46:17of it. To me, was worthwhile just for
- 46:20the photo and idea of licking, whatever, fish foam out of a
- 46:24mold cast of The Chef's mouth. I mean, that is that is genius
- 46:28level stuff. Like that idea is so it wasn't
- 46:32purely novel in the other restaurants have done
- 46:35specifically like the cast of The I thought when I saw some
- 46:38other pictures of Yeah, no one's done that at nopa.
- 46:42So this is, this is much as I know.
- 46:44Yes. Let he who has not gone to a
- 46:47tasting meal. Cast the first stone?
- 46:49Yeah, I went to guy Savoy in Paris, which is many several
- 46:55Michelin stars. It's just like the problem with
- 46:58that is you just need to be like, you get wealthy enough,
- 47:02you can afford the wealthy thing but you're not wealthy enough to
- 47:04not care about the things, you know, it's like Iris to
- 47:07price-conscious, you know, suck I Maybe enjoy that meal of.
- 47:11It was like, the amount of money was like, a throwaway to me.
- 47:13So then it was like, whatever. But it's just there if you see
- 47:17it, as why are you guys trying to upsell me?
- 47:19Like every time the I think the water bottle, we got to we're
- 47:23sorry, we didn't get tablet. We asked for just water and what
- 47:25they gave us was like a 30 dollar twenty thirty dollar
- 47:29bottle of water. We had two of them.
- 47:30So our water budget for that meal was like $50 alone and it
- 47:35was also lunch. We went for with the water
- 47:37paired with the individual dishes.
- 47:39Now there was not a Our sommelier and, you know, we went
- 47:42for lunch and then you get the like actual lunch menu and to
- 47:46get like the Velar. Something is like a 60 Euro up
- 47:49charge. Oh, I share a joke.
- 47:52Sarah, Joe is overhearing me. She just she chatted me the
- 47:56bottle. It was 28 Euros.
- 47:58A bottle. I'm underselling it.
- 47:59But was the restaurant, like, was a place where you're like,
- 48:03this is really fancy and lovely. And did you feel like not doing
- 48:06something like very special? There was a loss.
- 48:10Opportunity like a big milestone event.
- 48:12Did you feel like you lost an opportunity because it might
- 48:16have been the best setting for right?
- 48:18I think. I can't get it.
- 48:20I can't get it. Oh, I was just gonna say, Eric
- 48:24lost the opportunity to write a blog post about it, but maybe
- 48:27there are things that matter more than that, I don't know.
- 48:29Of course, the restaurant you enjoy the most is the one we had
- 48:31this terrible bike ride. That was like so many times too
- 48:35difficult for us but the lunch we had, you know, frantically
- 48:40The lunch places were going to be closed, was, you know, the
- 48:43best meal of the trip. Because you're like exhausted,
- 48:45we ordered a espressos during the cheese course, you know,
- 48:50during Desert, and the waitress who seemed like she must have
- 48:53been the owner, like, scolded us that we couldn't wait until the
- 48:56cheese. Course was done have the
- 48:57espresso at the appropriate time and she she literally walks up
- 49:01to one table. And she's like, you're a good
- 49:03french. Couple she goes up to Anna.
- 49:05You're a good french couple and you okay?
- 49:08Kids have no, I mean, it wasn't good.
- 49:10It fun but it was just like classic like we're anxious about
- 49:13you know, get it where we want to get out of there.
- 49:15Like continue our bike ride, it's like take the lunch, you
- 49:19know, enjoy the espresso. When you're honestly, Eric, let
- 49:23him have it, give it to them. Because that's literally the
- 49:24last thing Europeans have I know it's like they're better than us
- 49:29is better than us in any sort of like, you know, refined cultural
- 49:34setting. I'm the terrible American who
- 49:36comes back and I'm like nobody was working there like we're The
- 49:40white collar workers on their laptops like grinding away like
- 49:43it seems like a very special, all these enjoying them, learn.
- 49:47Exactly, who has, who has time for these like lunches, you
- 49:51know, did you write them? Oh God, I gotta get that gig.
- 49:55I gotta get whatever. Jig Is affording them.
- 49:58Take a lunch. I think, just like socialism
- 50:03plus a declining Empire. I mean, we've got the declining
- 50:06him, right? That's it.
- 50:07That should be the next step for America then is like, if we are
- 50:10Ready are in the point of like Decay as a as a nation and as a
- 50:13power, like why can't we just start enjoying ourselves?
- 50:15We'll see. That's the problem we're Square
- 50:16going. The, you know, excretes this G
- 50:19for scarce resources, route. While like five people have
- 50:22everything, it's a really, really tough row to hoe, right?
- 50:26Yeah. It's like, let's invent like a
- 50:27war with China and try to like out work there 997 or whatever
- 50:31the fuck they call it. Yeah.
- 50:33Friends were just like or we could just drink espresso for 7
- 50:37hours a day. It's great.
- 50:38That's why she's drink so much. Hot night, get some right.
- 50:41I actually the one aspect of that, you know, the bad
- 50:44restaurant review, that resonated with me was the fact
- 50:47that they left Hungary at the end, they're just like it
- 50:50didn't, it wasn't even filling. And actually, that's kind of a
- 50:53perk because any time, I've gone to those, like, multi-course
- 50:56restaurants, you eat so much, and it's too many different
- 51:00foods in your stomach, I always gross, it's gross.
- 51:03I always feel terrible that's why the fanciest place you
- 51:06should go is the place where you can spend as much as you.
- 51:10You need to have a buffet a good time, right, right.
- 51:14Just go back for seconds. Like, it's your fault.
- 51:15If you're still hungry. Exactly.
- 51:17There was a place in La when I lived, there were rows.
- 51:20And I went to that when we ordered dessert, it was like a
- 51:23cake or something. Could slice a cake?
- 51:24And it was just crumbs, it was just like crumbs of various
- 51:27sizes on the plate and the waiter brought it out and Rosen.
- 51:30I just started laughing. It's like if you eat this and we
- 51:33looked at the waiter looked at it and he kind of shrugged and
- 51:36we're just like and what are you gonna do?
- 51:39Like I don't think. The intention like I'm pretty
- 51:41sure the chef just brought the cake and then just try to like,
- 51:44Cobble it together back on the plate.
- 51:46If I ran across, I mean, that's very New York.
- 51:48You guys probably know. Yeah, we've been playing.
- 51:52That was a restaurant where the portions I thought were we ate
- 51:55way too much. We ordered like it was like one
- 51:57of those small plates things we were literally destroyed.
- 52:02Yeah it was so rich. So weird thing about that place
- 52:05is that because it was one of the only like one of three
- 52:08places people went to in Miami. I like her and about it so much.
- 52:12And then I just conflated the New York restaurant with like
- 52:16this weird Miami Outpost and like this culture.
- 52:19Just like I just I so I have this weird vibe bad feeling
- 52:24about it but the food is good. Yeah, well, there's a whole
- 52:26genre of tick talker. Who tells you what places are in
- 52:30in New York. And I do finally, I'm obsessed
- 52:32with. I sort of got brainwashed by,
- 52:34like the Carbone takes until you're both on.
- 52:36Take, Eric, I thought you were getting up.
- 52:38I deleted it. Literally, I deleted it.
- 52:40Of the week up until today. I was like, I'm bored.
- 52:43Like what am I doing? I just published like I'm
- 52:45allowed to be on Tick-Tock like what else?
- 52:47Will I text people but Tick Tock videos.
- 52:49Like it's not like I talk to anyone anymore.
- 52:51Here's a link, that's it. Well you're both lost.
- 52:54Then the used to spend our chance.
- 52:55It's already done. I made a clean break.
- 52:57All right, let's talk one more thing of substance.
- 52:59What do you want? Oh yeah.
- 53:00Okay, I don't you want to talk about Facebook?
- 53:06I don't even know people like it.
- 53:08I mean now I do worry that it There's a lot of little people
- 53:11are tired of now. It's like, it looks like we got
- 53:13Facebook. Like, people don't.
- 53:14Yeah, no, that's okay though. I did there was a story of the
- 53:17Erickson over that I'd very dutifully red.
- 53:20Hold on the one with the better CEO my wife CPS oh yeah well
- 53:23that was just like hmm may not a huge surprise just sort of your
- 53:27basic shitty corporate Behavior but this whole thing about
- 53:31Carolyn ever seen leaving so soon I didn't I was really Tom's
- 53:36like I can talk about what I can talk about.
- 53:39It's fine. Like, I didn't, I mean, I guess,
- 53:42of course, Tom that is one of your companies, but I just
- 53:45thought it was interesting because she had had such an
- 53:47amazing career at Facebook. She responds to Sheryl Sandberg
- 53:51Lieutenant, right? And then she got passed over for
- 53:53Marnie, right? But she was not in the Cheryl
- 53:55crew, she wasn't this. Yeah.
- 53:57And this is something I don't quite understand about, like
- 53:59being powerful and like super wealthy is that when you get
- 54:05passed over for a job, but you still have the really powerful
- 54:09job, you had that Made you wealthy, we're lost before
- 54:12respect you. You're so irritated that you get
- 54:14passed over that. You just throw up your hands and
- 54:15walk away. That is something I don't
- 54:17understand because I guess I've never been powerful enough to be
- 54:21like, you know what, then screw you.
- 54:23I'm, I do not accept this extremely powerful position.
- 54:27I already. Right.
- 54:28That's a bit of continued having well.
- 54:30It's just like, I don't think that's how you say screw you in
- 54:33the Sheryl Sandberg world. I'm sure it's like, you say,
- 54:35fuck off your eyes are so, you know, totally blank and you're
- 54:39like I'm so grateful for the time I've had working and I'm so
- 54:43sorry that I need to leave to do nothing specific yet.
- 54:48You know, like write it, you know, it's who's Afraid of
- 54:50Virginia Woolf, but that Harvard knows that it like a lady sewing
- 54:57Circle. But um, I just, you know, she
- 54:59goes into car as unclear. What she's going to do, you see
- 55:03that she's overseeing marketing messaging?
- 55:07You know all Washington legally related things.
- 55:10Like, kind of, she should ever saying anything that touches any
- 55:12human being outside of instacart.
- 55:15And then she was like, you know what, this is not for me.
- 55:17And I'm going on three months in like, what happened and she was,
- 55:21she was friendly with Fiji to. It wasn't like they were, you
- 55:24know, like oh, I didn't realize what I was getting into.
- 55:26Like, they worked closely together because Fiji was one of
- 55:28the top at, you know, digital not top.
- 55:30But she was definitely involved in the digital ads world within
- 55:32Facebook. So this wasn't like, you know,
- 55:34an odd couple that was yoked together through requirements
- 55:38and you know, obligation to get It's in there.
- 55:41I mean, to me, what's interesting now without tipping
- 55:44my hand too much about the topic is like, for the longest time,
- 55:48the instacart instability which has been going on for years now,
- 55:51they just churn through Executives over there, they were
- 55:54able to chalk that up to the founder.
- 55:56A port of a meta who was just kind of a Maniac running that
- 56:01company just nobody could get along with him.
- 56:03He didn't know how to be clear with his directives.
- 56:05I wrote a piece about it a couple months ago that they just
- 56:08couldn't keep product people, like anyone who He sort of had
- 56:10any product sense were like, this guy's unworkable.
- 56:13He has no vision and he's not the CEO anymore like they pushed
- 56:16him out of that roll to the side and yet the instability
- 56:20continues. Well, it's very hard to unlearn
- 56:23companies become like their Founders.
- 56:25And I mean, watching The Uber thing, I mean people just rise
- 56:29to the top because they have the traits valued by the founders.
- 56:32So I do think it's in defense of the new CEO you know the culture
- 56:37doesn't change overnight but But this one is persistence in URLs
- 56:42and a cute is leaving. You know, it's like oh the
- 56:44people that were part of the old regime year.
- 56:46I'm not going to make it but someone that you like one of
- 56:48your first orders of business was like, let me bring in like
- 56:51my solid ads you nobody to run things, it's not a, not a good
- 56:56sign about the company in any way.
- 57:00And so I mean I basically had its moment in the pandemic and
- 57:03whatever if it couldn't grab land then and IPO then that was
- 57:07such like a good moment. Well that's the other thing.
- 57:10Thing to, I think a lot of people that went to instacart,
- 57:12on the way up or like, I'm going to be rich because my options
- 57:16are going to be so valuable and we know that they're not going
- 57:19to IPO next year. They were supposed to IPO this
- 57:23year. They're not going to do it next
- 57:24year. Who knows if 2023 is on the
- 57:26table and so if you're Carolyn you're not loving things over
- 57:29there and you're not sure about, you know, how stable your jobs
- 57:32going to be and you're not even able to cash out your shares and
- 57:35who knows how valuable they'll be anyway.
- 57:37You know, like if it's occurred, has to raise another round.
- 57:40And it's a Down Round, like that's really bad.
- 57:42So I should think about this in the way like this is akin to
- 57:46Symone Sanders leaving, Kamala Harris office.
- 57:50She's like I don't want to be the outward face for, you know,
- 57:53what's clearly the implosion of this?
- 57:57Yeah, she'll he's made in a year.
- 57:58I mean to you, what is your Kamala if you make it here?
- 58:02I mean I thought so January, 2020 is when everyone started.
- 58:07It's it's December 11 months. Yeah.
- 58:09I'm not her, you know, there was the big piece, was it CNN?
- 58:14That did the big reported peace and identity Politico has done
- 58:19some stuff, too. I thought her quotes were sort
- 58:21of like, I'm not leaving because it's terrible.
- 58:24It wasn't like, I mean, that's obviously not a direct quote,
- 58:26but it wasn't like, it's not terrible.
- 58:28It's like, I'm not leaving because of the thesis of your
- 58:32story, right? Not speaking to the thesis of
- 58:35your story, one way or the other, you know, that's what
- 58:37about red. What about bad fit does it?
- 58:39Make sense to you. What about cultural mismatch?
- 58:44Don't you get? Absolutely.
- 58:47Absolutely. Yeah, I don't really understand
- 58:49how I mean, I don't know enough about I mean, again, just a
- 58:53reminder. I don't cover politics.
- 58:55Technically. The justice department is law
- 58:57enforcement, right? And clearly a political to yeah,
- 59:00fall, but But yes, I it's true. When I say, I don't understand
- 59:05the inner workings of these offices, like Congressional
- 59:07offices and like, the office of the president, or the vice
- 59:10president, because they're kind of their own little fiefdoms.
- 59:13And so, I mean, when I see them, I get that.
- 59:16Like, I just, I get nervous because it's like once you go
- 59:19through the Looking-Glass, like God only knows what's going on
- 59:21back there. Well, I sort of feel bad.
- 59:23I was out with some somebody's more senior in the industry last
- 59:28night for drinks. And, you know this Person was
- 59:33just real like you know, I could have been this bigger role, you
- 59:36know. But I didn't get the job this
- 59:38person got it and I was just sort of like to myself.
- 59:41Like, I don't know that other person either.
- 59:44Like, what would your life ever? Really been that different if
- 59:46you'd been? Like, sure, you would've been
- 59:48richer. You definitely would've been
- 59:49richer, but it's like you're under another name that nobody
- 59:53has heard of and life in jail for something better to come to
- 59:56peace with like that. He feels like he should have
- 59:59been the CEO of like this, you know, like it's just sort.
- 1:00:02Out of, I mean, obviously, not too, but Life's a chain of sort
- 1:00:06of wanting. With the next person above you
- 1:00:09has everything. Has to be that I think no, I
- 1:00:14agree. I mean, is it better though?
- 1:00:18To not get the job at you? Thought you were that you
- 1:00:20deserved and was part of your life's plan or to get the job
- 1:00:23and realize that it's like it's empty that it gives, you know,
- 1:00:26sort of, you know, Soul nourishment.
- 1:00:28But the ROM is, you just say, oh well the problem is, it's not
- 1:00:30the top top job, you know, it's right next.
- 1:00:32Winner, and if you're the founder, it's because my board
- 1:00:35wouldn't let me be great and they stop me.
- 1:00:37You know, it's there is no like, I mean, it's sort of its like
- 1:00:41insecurities all the way down. Hurry up.
- 1:00:42And you know, if you're Bezos you can be like well they don't
- 1:00:45think I'm an inventor. They think I'm the op.
- 1:00:47You know, you can always feel so I'm going to actually I think he
- 1:00:50feels okay about himself, I know, I think he's okay.
- 1:00:53But I do think there's a degree to which, you know, even the top
- 1:00:56then you just refrain yourself as saying, well I'm I'm pursuing
- 1:01:00to be a once in a generation. Talent.
- 1:01:02And then you weigh yourself against the base was thing is
- 1:01:05great to me because I don't think he feels like it through
- 1:01:08that way, and yet still that insecurity that drives
- 1:01:10Executives at a different level, clearly affected him when the
- 1:01:13Lauren Sanchez, you know, texting Scandal broke out
- 1:01:16because it wasn't enough that like her shitty brother leak the
- 1:01:20text messages like know, this had to be a plot led by the
- 1:01:22Saudis in order to smear me because I had one time shafted
- 1:01:26like MBS which of course turned out to be complete bullshit.
- 1:01:30But at that level it's like one clearly an important In person
- 1:01:33because why else would my you know my love Tex get out there.
- 1:01:36Absolutely. Whilst the Saudis only hack,
- 1:01:38very American people, right? That's the only way that it
- 1:01:41could have gotten out there. There is that picture where
- 1:01:43Leonardo DiCaprio was like looking at her and then Bezos
- 1:01:47literally put up like some tweet likes flexing.
- 1:01:51Like I feel like this is Nana I know you're talking about.
- 1:01:55Yeah I think we're going into part of people's psyche, that's
- 1:01:58like really dangerous. This is more Bezos has Petty
- 1:02:03petty foibles, like the rest of us or even more amazing.
- 1:02:06Yeah. Anyway, instacart watch that
- 1:02:08space. Okay.
- 1:02:12Sounds good. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:02:27Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 1:02:12Sounds good. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:02:27Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.