Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #25: CBB Week 1 Recap, timeline of the first week, and the first Top 25 in the CSR
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:17This is episode number 25, where I will be recapping the first week of the college basketball season.
- 0:23I'll point out the most crucial matchups that went the way of the underdog.
- 0:26I'll take you on a timeline of last week and how results on the court impacted the Common Sense Rankings.
- 0:32I'll take you through the top 25 in the CSR at the end of the first week and how it compares to the AP poll.
- 0:38We'll put together a theoretical bracket based on the Common Sense Rankings, and we'll discuss the most important games of week two.
- 0:47There were a total of 478 games played in Division I last week.
- 0:5229 of those matchups were going to be crucial to the Common Sense Rankings.
- 0:56In the CSR, it's all about conference head-to-head matchups on the court.
- 1:00So if conference A wins more than 50% of the matchups against conference B, then a win over conference A is worth just a little bit more, and a loss hurts a little bit less.
- 1:09When conferences play just once or twice all season, it counts as crucial to both conferences involved.
- 1:15Of those 29 crucial matchups, eight involved power conference teams, and two of them were upsets that will have implications the rest of the season.
- 1:23On Friday night, St.
- 1:25Louis took down Missouri 90 to 84 in the first of two Atlantic 10 SEC matchups.
- 1:31Since the SEC cannot gain a winning record against the A10, pending any early season tournament results, the SEC has now lowered their ceiling in the CSR.
- 1:41The Big East's Butler fell to the Pac-12's Boise State on Sunday 100 to 81.
- 1:46Similar to the SEC, the Big East cannot now have a winning record over the Pac-12 and will have a lower ceiling in the 2026-27 CSR.
- 1:57On the preview pod, I looked at what teams could start three and O against the toughest D1 opposition, and I called out the Pittsburgh-Penn State matchup on Sunday as the one where if both teams are two and O going into it, then the winner will likely be number one in the CSR.
- 2:11I absolutely nailed that prediction, and the Pittsburgh Panthers exit the first week in the number one spot.
- 2:18There are ten conference head-to-head matchups that are already decided coming out of the first week of the season.
- 2:23The West Coast Conference and Sun Belt are both guaranteed to beat two conferences this season.
- 2:28The WCC won their only matchups with the Big South and Horizon last week, and the Sun Belt won their lone matchup with each of the NEC and the Patriot.
- 2:37The A-10, American, Atlantic Sun, Big East, Big West, and MAC have all raised their floors with a crucial head-to-head win in week one.
- 2:46Among conferences that play twice, we have 17 that played their first matchup, meaning those winning conferences are guaranteed at least a 50/50 split this season, but would need to win the second game too to take the conference head-to-head.
- 2:58The Big East had three such situations against the CAA, UAC, and Summit Leagues.
- 3:04The Big South find themselves in two of those favorable positions against CUSA and the Pac-12.
- 3:10The Atlantic 10, American, Big 12, Big Ten, Missouri Valley, Mountain West, NEC, Pac-12, Patriot, Southern, SWAC, and West Coast Conference all have one each.
- 3:23I'm going to try something new.
- 3:25I'm going to take you on a timeline of the first week of college basketball.
- 3:28I'm going to speak through the conference hierarchy as the week progresses, and give some insight into the CSR rankings and how they are determined.
- 3:35If you're listening to this podcast but aren't watching, know there are visuals that will likely help explain how the week turned out if you want to tune into this podcast on YouTube.
- 3:44If you're a data nerd like me, welcome to the fun part of the podcast.
- 3:49At 1:30 PM Eastern on Monday, nine Division I teams had picked up wins, five over D1 schools and four against lower division programs.
- 3:57In the conference rankings, those five D1 wins allowed five conferences to pick up a winning head-to-head, putting a win over the ACC, the Atlantic Sun, the Big South, the Sun Belt, and the SWAC as the most impressive wins up to that point.
- 4:11Only one team had a win over those conferences through early Monday.
- 4:15That was Queens with their win over Winthrop in the opening day 24-hour marathon.
- 4:20Queens, having the best win up to that point, was the undisputed number one in the CSR.
- 4:25High Point, App State, Notre Dame, and Grambling also had wins over a Division I school, so they were numbers two through five, with the tiebreaker being win margin.
- 4:34Tiebreakers will quickly become irrelevant when more games are played, but I do need some way early in the season to distinguish between schools, so we'll use win margin when necessary.
- 4:43Numbers six through nine were all schools with wins over a lower division program, so IU Indy, Hofstra, Middle Tennessee, and Mercer wrapped up that early look at the CSR.
- 4:56As six more hours passed, a handful of other matchups brought nine conferences up to that one head-to-head winning record, meaning there were now nine conferences against which you could earn more credit for a win.
- 5:07Welcome the A-10, the Horizon, the Missouri Valley, and the Mountain West to that level.
- 5:12Three teams had wins over one of those conferences, giving them the top three spots as of 7:30 Monday evening.
- 5:18Northern Kentucky, Queens, and Grambling were the top three teams at that point.
- 5:23Down to number nine were wins over Division I, and then numbers 10 through 17 were schools with wins over lower division teams.
- 5:31Less than two hours later and a cavalcade of games had finished.
- 5:35The ACC, Big East, and Big Ten sat atop the conference rankings, each with four conference head-to-heads.
- 5:41Then came the Big 12 with three, then the A-10, American, Horizon, Ivy, and SEC with two each.
- 5:50As a result of those changes, Florida, with their win over the ACC's Miami, and Notre Dame, courtesy of their win over Villanova from the Big East, could now claim the two most impressive wins and were numbers one and two.
- 6:01Nobody had beaten the Big 12 at this point, so the next six teams had wins over teams from the conferences with two head-to-heads.
- 6:07Numbers 10 through 25 all had wins over conferences with one winning head-to-head.
- 6:13As Monday turned into Tuesday, the ACC and the Big 12 were at the top of the CSR conference standings, each with ten winning head-to-heads over other conferences.
- 6:22The Big Ten sat third with nine, the Big East with eight, then the A-10 and SEC each with six.
- 6:28So through Monday, a win over the SEC and Atlantic Ten was worth the same amount.
- 6:33There were still five conferences that were sitting with no head-to-head winning records against other leagues.
- 6:39Courtesy of those conference rankings, Florida, UCLA, and Memphis were one through three after Monday's games, each having beaten a team from the ACC or the Big 12.
- 6:49BYU and Gonzaga had wins over the Big Ten, putting them at four and five.
- 6:54Because each team had a sample size of one game, teams that were in the top twenty-five briefly but I marked as not likely to see again at this point were Youngstown State and East Texas A&M at nine and ten.
- 7:04San Jose State, McNeese, Wright State, Northern Kentucky, North Alabama, Elon, New Hampshire, Hawaii, and Cornell were all in the top twenty-five after Monday's games.
- 7:18There were far fewer games Tuesday than there were Monday, but that doesn't mean the CSR was stagnant.
- 7:23The Big Ten joined the ACC and Big 12 in a tie atop the conference rankings, each having winning records against ten other conferences through two days.
- 7:31The SEC was fourth and the Big East fifth.
- 7:34The top mid-major conferences were the A-10, American, Mountain West, Pac-12, Ivy League, and West Coast Conference.
- 7:42So since no team had two Division I wins yet, we're still going off what team has the best win, and that would be any team with a dub over the ACC, Big 12, or Big 10.
- 7:53There were six such schools following Tuesday's games: BYU, Florida, UCLA, Gonzaga, Memphis, and South Dakota State.
- 8:01East Texas A&M was number seven due to their win over an SEC squad, then Notre Dame at eight for their win over the Big East.
- 8:08We still had several unusual names in the top twenty-five and far more mid-majors than are going to last.
- 8:14After the games on Wednesday, the ACC moved up to the top of the heap again, earning an eleventh head-to-head courtesy of California's win over Radford.
- 8:23The Big 12, Big Ten, and SEC were all tied just behind the ACC, with the Big East taking its customary fifth spot.
- 8:30The West Coast Conference also moved up a spot, and just five conferences were still winless head-to-head on the season.
- 8:36Now, through Wednesday, we do have Division I teams who have picked up two wins.
- 8:41So when a team wins twice as many games as another, it won't matter what teams or conferences those one and oh schools have defeated, the two-win team is gonna have the better resume in the CSR.
- 8:52So the six teams that went two and oh against Division I competition Wednesday night are our top six: Queens, Northern Kentucky, St.
- 9:00Mary's, Santa Clara, Butler, and High Point.
- 9:03As more conference head-to-heads are played and the conference ranking shifts, so do the resume.
- 9:07For example, New Hampshire was in the top 25 after Tuesday due to their win over Brown from the Ivy League.
- 9:13But now that the Ivy League is further down the pecking order of conferences, New Hampshire's win looks less impressive, and they've moved down the rankings.
- 9:21As we continued the week, many teams were playing their second games on Thursday and Friday, so the CSR top 25 was quickly filling with two-win teams.
- 9:30Through Friday's games, the Big 12 became the first conference to have a winning record against more than half of Division I, with the Big Ten dropping to second.
- 9:38The rest of the power conferences make up the top five.
- 9:41The Atlantic Ten is tops among the mid-major conferences, with the American and West Coast Conference seventh and eighth overall.
- 9:47There are 22 conferences with anywhere from one to four head-to-heads, and just the Big Sky and Big West are still looking to gain that first head-to-head conference winning record.
- 9:57Moving from Friday into Saturday, the biggest conference movers were the Atlantic 10, going from nine conference head-to-heads to 11, the American going from seven to nine, and the Pac-12, who gained three more head-to-head winning records on Saturday alone.
- 10:11Those three conferences now trail only the traditional power conferences and are in good position after the first six days.
- 10:18Which brings us to the final day before the first official rankings.
- 10:21On Sunday, the Pac-12 further separated themselves from those conferences behind them, and the Mountain West and Missouri Valley are now even with the West Coast Conference.
- 10:29A bunch of conferences are still mired in that two to three conference head-to-head range, with the Big Sky and Ohio Valley now looking for that first winning head-to-head record.
- 10:38So given all that we know through the first week of the college basketball season, here are the top 25 resumes based solely on wins and losses Numbers one through four all have three Division I wins to their name.
- 10:52Given that that's 50% more wins than teams with just two victories, those four teams will rise to the top.
- 10:58Number one is Pittsburgh.
- 11:00They picked up a dub over Penn State on Sunday, but they also have wins over Buffalo from the MAAC and Rider from the Metro conference.
- 11:07What gives them the edge over number two right now is the slight increase in the quality of their opponents' wins.
- 11:13Number two is Virginia.
- 11:14The quality of their three wins are equal to Pitt, with a victory over the SEC's Arkansas being the highlight.
- 11:19But the two wins their opponents have picked up just aren't quite as strong.
- 11:24Number three is High Point, also three and oh.
- 11:26They have wins over Conference USA, the MEAC, and the Pac-12.
- 11:30No power conference wins, but a more impressive conference variety than our number four team, the Santa Clara Broncos.
- 11:36One win each against the Horizon, Big West, and CAA, but High Point and Santa Clara both suffer from their opponents having a combined zero Division I victories through the first week.
- 11:47Starting with number five and going through number nine, we have teams that beat both a power conference foe and a team from one of the more successful mid-majors so far.
- 11:55Number five is Memphis, with their big win being over Iowa State.
- 11:58Number six is Houston, who beat California from the ACC.
- 12:02Number seven is UCLA, a win over Arizona being their power conference win.
- 12:07Number eight is San Diego State, having picked up a win over Colorado.
- 12:10And the last of this group is East Texas A&M, who upset both Oklahoma and Rice to start the season to be ranked number nine at the end of the first week.
- 12:19As we progress down the top 25, the conferences and success of the opponents starts to decrease.
- 12:25Ten through 16 all have a power conference win and a win over a lower tier conference.
- 12:30Ten is Connecticut, 11 Vanderbilt, 12 Florida, 13 St.
- 12:35Louis, 14 BYU, 15 Georgetown, and 16 Gonzaga.
- 12:41Seventeen through 25 are all teams with wins over a mid-tier conference or lower tier conference.
- 12:46Seventeen is Wright State with wins over the Mountain West and American.
- 12:50Eighteen is Kansas, 19 Nebraska, 20 is Notre Dame, whose win over Villanova from the Big East is nice, but Mercyhurst was their second win.
- 12:59Twenty-one is Valparaiso, who's another outlier in this group.
- 13:02They beat Purdue, but similar to Notre Dame, don't have an impressive second win to accompany it.
- 13:07Twenty-two is Nevada, twenty-three Southern Cal, twenty-four Richmond, and 25th this week is Davidson.
- 13:14This early in the season, there aren't enough games to overcome a loss, so any team who hasn't won all of their games won't sniff the top 25 or the hypothetical bracket this week.
- 13:23The top team with a loss in these initial CSR rankings is two and one Queens.
- 13:29In the CSR top 25 after week one, no conference has more than three representatives.
- 13:34The ACC, Big 12, Big Ten, and the Atlantic Ten each have three of the top 25.
- 13:40Then the SEC, Big East, and Pac-12 each have two.
- 13:43Conferences with one of the top 25 resumes are the American, Big South, Horizon, Missouri Valley, Mountain West, Southland, and the West Coast Conference.
- 13:54The AP poll over-ranked the ACC, Big 12, Big Ten, and SEC, go figure, and there were only power conference teams plus Gonzaga in their top 25.
- 14:05If you remember, in the off-season, the NCAA tournament was expanded from sixty-eight teams to seventy-six, allowing for eight more at-large bids to come into the picture.
- 14:14With thirty-two conferences, that'll give us forty-four teams that will not win their conference tournament that have a shot at the national title.
- 14:21Nine leagues would have multiple bids in a CSR-built tournament bracket.
- 14:25The ACC would lead with ten at this point, followed by the SEC with nine, the Big 12 with eight, Big Ten seven, Big East with six, the Atlantic Ten would have five, and the American, MAC, and Mountain West would each get two bids.
- 14:40The last four teams in, according to the CSR right now, would be Marquette, Miami Ohio, South Carolina, and Ole Miss.
- 14:47The first four out are Baylor, Clemson, Duke, and Florida State.
- 14:51Three ACC teams there, which would have given the ACC thirteen teams if the bracket had just been expanded to eighty.
- 14:58You can find the full bracket build out at commonsensrankings.com, where I attempt to follow the committee's seeding procedure and build a bracket.
- 15:06But here is what the top four seed lines would look like according to the CSR.
- 15:12In the East region, Pitt would be the one seed, Houston the two, Vanderbilt the three, and Gonzaga the four.
- 15:17My money there would be on Houston.
- 15:19In the Midwest, Virginia would look to have an easy path as the one seed.
- 15:23San Diego State would be the two, East Texas A&M the three, and Georgetown the four.
- 15:28I have an avid listener who's a huge Cavaliers fan who would kill to have that path to the Final Four.
- 15:34In the South, High Point is the one, Memphis the two, Florida the three, and BYU the four, so Florida would look to have an easy road.
- 15:41And finally, out west, Santa Clara is the one seed, UCLA the two, UConn the three seed, and St.
- 15:47Louis would be the fourth seed.
- 15:49And the anticipation there would be UCLA versus UConn in the Elite Eight matchup If anybody listening also tunes in to my college football weekly recaps, I typically put some blind resumes up against one another to see if we can determine who's had a better season so far.
- 16:06That will be slightly more difficult for college basketball, as there are three times as the teams and three times the conferences, but let's give one a shot.
- 16:13Team A in this blind resume test is one and O.
- 16:16Their only win is over a Southern Conference team that has no other victories over D1 competition.
- 16:22Team B, meanwhile, started three and O in the first week with wins over the Big Ten, a MAC team, and a Metro school.
- 16:28Those three defeated teams have two Division I wins.
- 16:32Spoiler alert, Team A is in the AP poll and Team B has zero votes.
- 16:36What the AP poll voters are telling us is Team A's win over that Southern Conference team was so unbelievably comprehensive that it is clearly better than a team with a power conference win and whose teams they've beaten have two D1 wins on their resume.
- 16:50Team A is Tennessee, who scheduled two more lower tier teams for their week two games.
- 16:55The Vols are 11th in this week's AP poll.
- 16:58Team B is the number one team in the CSR, the Pitt Panthers, who picked up exactly zero votes on this week's AP ballots.
- 17:05I will remind you that the AP poll voters are instructed to vote for the teams they have performed the best on the court this season without accounting for anything preseason or any future speculation.
- 17:16The voters this week unequivocally failed.
- 17:20So let's dig into that failure, shall we?
- 17:22Ten of the CSR's top 25 showed up on the AP poll this week, including three of the correct top 10.
- 17:28Honestly, for a poll this early in the season, it could have been significantly worse.
- 17:33The goods.
- 17:34Nebraska got a rank at number 25.
- 17:36They deserved it.
- 17:37Virginia jumped up to number six after their three and O start.
- 17:40Also warranted.
- 17:41Lastly, there was one voter who will be mentioned by name shortly that included both three and O High Point and three and O Santa Clara in their poll, both of whom are top five in the CSR courtesy of those three Division I wins.
- 17:53And the bad.
- 17:54We can start where the blind resume left off.
- 17:56Tennessee has a single win and is 11th.
- 17:58Are we serious?
- 17:59And Pitt's omission from every ballot is also criminal, and four teams who've won only half their games will see a number during their next week's games.
- 18:08For those who did well, I have to start with David Jablonsky.
- 18:11David is also a voter for football, so he's pulling double duty.
- 18:14He was the voter who included High Point and Santa Clara, but he also managed to find a way to include East Texas A&M and Nevada.
- 18:21So well done, David.
- 18:23Michigan was the team farthest down the CSR that was included in this week's top 25.
- 18:28There were just four voters who left them off their ballot.
- 18:30David Jablonsky, again, Donna DeTota, Harold Kuntz, and Jackson Payne.
- 18:35Congrats to you.
- 18:37Lastly, I spoke to the lack of resume for the Tennessee Vols, and two voters correctly left them off their ballot.
- 18:42CJ Moore and David Borges, I salute you.
- 18:46Now there is a lot of bad, so I'll try to summarize.
- 18:48There were 10 voters who included five one-loss teams in their ballot.
- 18:52I'd argue that if you're losing 50% of your games at any point, you probably shouldn't be sniffing the top 25.
- 18:58Those voters were Chris Lea, Chris Nee, Eric Crawford, Janir Cooper, Joe Cook, Lance Allen, Mark Ziegler, Peter Rout- Rauterkus, excuse me, Randy Heights, and Sam Rothman.
- 19:09Usually, the CSR prefers smaller conference teams that start hot, but Utah State is down at number 89 in the CSR, but did get a vote.
- 19:17That voter was Jackson Payne the early season rankings will continue to be led by teams that have played the most games and have managed to win them all.
- 19:26Pittsburgh only has one game this coming week, but each of Virginia, High Point, and Santa Clara could be five and O at the end of week two.
- 19:34The only two and O team that has three Division I opponents this coming week is Rhode Island, so the Rams are another team to keep an eye on at the end of the week.
- 19:41There are another 30 matchups that will feature conferences that will play just once or twice this year, meaning it'll be important to both teams' leagues for their representative in that game to win.
- 19:51The Big 12 is up one-nil on the Ivy League, and the second matchup is Tuesday night when Yale visits Baylor.
- 19:57If Yale wins, the head-to-head between those two conferences will be tied one-one, and with no more scheduled chances, there will be no superiority.
- 20:05That conference matchup would end in a stalemate and award points to neither conference in the CSR.
- 20:11The Big South could finish the year two and O against Conference USA if Winthrop can beat Kennesaw State on Tuesday.
- 20:17The SWAC could win a conference head-to-head if Alabama A&M can beat Cleveland State.
- 20:23Thanks to Grambling's win over Northern Illinois, the SWAC are in control of that head-to-head matchup.
- 20:29The Southland can't win the head-to-head battle with the NEC, but they could tie.
- 20:33East Texas A&M would need to beat Fairleigh Dickinson on Wednesday, but if FDU wins, the NEC will own the head-to-head over the Southland for the entirety of the season among power conference matchups, there are a handful of games where an upset would lower a league's ceiling in the CSR.
- 20:51The ACC is still void of any crucial matchups for the time being.
- 20:55The Big East is also off the hook after having five vital matchups in week one.
- 20:59I mentioned Baylor and Yale, but also in the Big 12, Texas Tech will play Stonehill's.
- 21:05That's the first of two matchups the Big 12 will play against the NEC and will need to win both to prove they're better on the court this season.
- 21:12The Big Ten will play its second crucial matchup Thursday when Indiana hosts Tennessee Tech out of the Southern Conference.
- 21:18In the SEC, Kentucky will play Northern Arizona Friday night in the first of two matchups the league will play against the Big Sky.
- 21:25The entire conference will be cheering for the Big Blue.
- 21:28The SEC only plays the Pac-12 twice this season, the first game of which will feature LSU playing Gonzaga on Saturday.
- 21:35It'll be a huge pickup for the Pac-12 if the Bulldogs could get a win, but if the Tigers do emerge victorious, they could shut the door on the Pac-12 later in the season when they play Washington State.
- 21:46And that is where I will wrap another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 21:50I hope you enjoyed the week one college basketball episode.
- 21:53In future weeks, the men's and women's basketball podcast will be merged into one, but for the first week, I wanted to give each season its due.
- 22:01If you want to give me a follow on the socials, you can do so at commonsensranking.
- 22:05I'm mostly posting on X at this time.
- 22:08College basketball rankings will be updated daily throughout the season at commonsensrankings.com.
- 22:13While the resumes aren't as deep right now, you can also find the blind resume comparison tool there, as well as the conference strength rankings and a bracket based on the CSR.
- 22:23I'll be back again soon for a women's basketball recap, and until then, please, as you go about your day, use some common sense