Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch, and the Wardrobe / Clontarf Classic Blend
Transcript
- 0:00In 2005, director Andrew Adamson and starred Georgie Henley gave
- 0:04the world an earnest interpretation of one of the
- 0:07world's most beloved children's books.
- 0:10In 2024 we go cheap and we go Irish.
- 0:15The film is The Chronicles of Narnia, The Lion, The Witch and
- 0:20the Wardrobe. The Whiskey is Clontarf Classic
- 0:23Blend, or as I like to call it, the Clonicles of Tarfia.
- 0:27Hey, we will be reviewing both of those chronicles, Bob.
- 0:36This is the the. Filming Whiskey Podcast
- 0:58Welcome to the Film and Whiskey Podcast, where each week we
- 1:01review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 1:04I'm Bob Buck. I'm Brad G.
- 1:07And today we are looking at the third highest grossing film of
- 1:092005. The Chronicles of Narnia, Colon,
- 1:13The Lion The Witch and the Wardrobe.
- 1:16Now, Brad, I've already said something that I feel like I
- 1:19need to correct. I said this was the third
- 1:20highest grossing film of the year.
- 1:22It was on a worldwide scale. On a domestic scale it was the
- 1:264th highest grossing film of the year.
- 1:28And once again we find ourselves in the middle of this season
- 1:31where we are reviewing high grossing films with a fork in
- 1:35the road. We have reviewed the top two
- 1:37grossing films of this year, which were Star Wars Episode 3.
- 1:41And what was the other one? Who cares?
- 1:45Cause Star Wars Episode 3. What a movie, man.
- 1:48Oh, A Goblet of Fire, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.
- 1:51Oh yeah, and so yeah, three and four were either Steven
- 1:55Spielberg's War of the Worlds or The Chronicles of Narnia.
- 1:59Which I I want to watch War of the Worlds at some point.
- 2:02It is a fantastic movie until like, the last five minutes, and
- 2:07even then it's still a really good movie.
- 2:08I have a sneaking suspicion we'll probably watch it someday.
- 2:11We we just like Spielberg. So I'm I'm assuming that we're
- 2:15going to continue watching Spielberg stuff the farther we
- 2:17get into this podcast, you know? Speaking of Tom Cruise.
- 2:22We had first thing, we hadn't spoken of Tom Cruise, but but go
- 2:26ahead. Literally yesterday Baba, I was
- 2:29running an event for my for my work and we had a participant
- 2:34from Singapore and she told me that I looked like Tom Cruise.
- 2:39Wow. And I said, I am that short.
- 2:43Thank you so much for the compliment.
- 2:47I'm not going to, I'm not going to crash that.
- 2:49Dream for you. It made my day, man.
- 2:51Yeah, I bet it did. I'm not going to say anything
- 2:53else. You You know what, Brad?
- 2:54You do look like Tom Cruise. That's right.
- 2:56I do. All right.
- 2:59Let's get into talking about the Chronicles of Narnia folks.
- 3:03If this is your first time listening to our podcast, we
- 3:05want to say hello. Welcome in This is the Film and
- 3:08Whiskey Podcast. We watch movies.
- 3:10We drink whiskey this year. We are looking at the highest
- 3:12grossing films of each year from 1988 to 2019.
- 3:16Brad, as I've been saying the last few weeks, we are in the
- 3:19sort of calm before the storm where even though we're starting
- 3:22to get into IP Ville here and Disneyville, it still seems like
- 3:27these are real movies, You know what I mean?
- 3:29Like, this seemed like a big deal of a movie when it came
- 3:31out, at least for Disney. Oh, Chronicles was huge when it
- 3:34came out. I I remember it like, really
- 3:37doing it. It really made big waves,
- 3:40partially like in the Christian world, 'cause it's a it's an A
- 3:44Christian IP that was taken seriously, but also in the
- 3:49general populace, it seemed like people really liked this movie.
- 3:53Yeah, especially people of a certain age.
- 3:55This was, I think it did have the the spectre of Disney
- 3:59hanging over it. And it was.
- 4:01I think when people looked at it less generously, it was always
- 4:04looked at as kind of this is Disney's knock off of Lord of
- 4:07the Rings and it is both not as good as Lord of the Rings and
- 4:10also has to be PG. And so it can't be as good as
- 4:13Lord of the Rings. And I think that was always kind
- 4:15of hindering it a little bit. But at the end of the day, this
- 4:18is an adaptation of a children's book and you can argue that Lord
- 4:21of the Rings is. I wouldn't say that about Lord
- 4:22of the Rings, but. No, This is The Hobbit is a
- 4:26adaptation of The Children. Exactly.
- 4:28And I will say I think this is better than the adaptations of
- 4:31The Hobbit in a number of ways. You're deck on, right?
- 4:34It is, Bob. You don't.
- 4:35You don't have Benedict's Cumberbatch saying I am death at
- 4:40the end of the film, which is the only.
- 4:43That's the best part of the whole trilogy.
- 4:45Not just the best, the only good part of those trilogies.
- 4:50All right. So as we can start looking at
- 4:51Narnia, Brad, what is your association with this IP like?
- 4:56Did you grow up reading the books?
- 4:57Did you grow up watching the movies?
- 4:59Where where are we on Narnia? As a as a podcast?
- 5:03Yeah, I I love Narnia. I grew up reading the books.
- 5:06I remember I, you know how you have like early memories where
- 5:10you're like, I don't remember anything else that was
- 5:12happening. But I have a vague memory of
- 5:14being like 7 and watching the old, I believe, BBC like
- 5:20television movies. Do you know what I'm talking
- 5:23about? So I I do recall watching
- 5:26Eustace turn into a dragon and back on the BBCTV show that's
- 5:31that's emblazoned upon my memory.
- 5:34So I yeah, I have been very closely affiliated with Lewis's
- 5:41works here for for a long, long time and I remember when this
- 5:44came out, being very excited. Yeah, and I'm in the opposite
- 5:47camp. I mean, I didn't.
- 5:48I didn't grow up Christian and I didn't grow up reading fantasy.
- 5:51So like, that kind of took me out of the running for being a
- 5:54Narnia fan. And so, you know, after I became
- 5:57a Christian later in life and went to college and studied
- 6:01theology, CS Lewis's books, non Narnia books were always
- 6:06recommended to me. And I I love Lewis, and Mere
- 6:08Christianity is one of my favorite books of all time.
- 6:10Dude, the Great Divorce. Oh, dude, I love The Great
- 6:13Divorce so much. It's so good.
- 6:15That's my let's make it a double.
- 6:17Read The Great Divorce and then watch this movie.
- 6:19Yes, yes. But I will say like it, it came
- 6:23with that sort of, like, evangelical snootiness that
- 6:27people would be like, you never read Narnia.
- 6:29You never watch Narnia. No, I didn't.
- 6:31Super funny because, like, Lewis is so Catholic.
- 6:36And also, but Lewis has a great quote about chronological
- 6:39snobbery, and I think that goes over a lot of Christians heads
- 6:42anyway. So at some point I was just
- 6:45like, I'm not going to read Narnia.
- 6:47It was more of like a stamp my foot and cross my arms.
- 6:50Like I don't need Narnia. I'm going to read Harry Potter.
- 6:53I don't need Narnia. I was already past the target
- 6:55age and I was reading Lewis's stuff for adults and loving it,
- 6:58and people were like, well, you don't know about Aslan.
- 7:00I'm like, you. Who the hell cares?
- 7:01You know what I mean? Like, mind your business.
- 7:04So my association with Narnia was way different.
- 7:07And I think, honestly, this movie was probably my first
- 7:10exposure to the world of Narnia at all.
- 7:14And so it's a really interesting place to start, because being
- 7:18familiar with the books now, it is both a pretty faithful
- 7:21adaptation of the book and also kind of a lackluster adaptation
- 7:24of the book in a lot of ways. And I'm excited to dive into
- 7:27talking to you about it, Brad, because Lord of the Rings this
- 7:31is not. But I do think that it is a
- 7:34pretty good movie on its own merits and not just a pretty
- 7:36good Lord of the Rings knockoff. Yeah, 100%.
- 7:40I as I was watching this film, you feel the Lord of the Rings
- 7:49influence, like pushing this movie forward.
- 7:53And yet this movie remains too silly to ever like.
- 7:58Dive into the depths that Lord of the Rings has created for
- 8:02sure and and the beautiful thing is it should be silly.
- 8:06Like you're following a group of four children who become Knights
- 8:10in a matter of a day and they're they're all of a sudden they're
- 8:14kingly because Aslan says that they're kingly.
- 8:17Like there's so much more going on here than just what you see
- 8:22on the screen and that makes it it is what it is.
- 8:27And I I I think when you look at what it's trying to do, I think
- 8:32it does a a relatively good job. Yeah, I'm kind of in that place
- 8:36too. And and it is OK to watch a
- 8:39movie that is pretty good. And honestly, Brad, it's kind of
- 8:42freeing for this podcast because when we watch movies that have
- 8:46reputations of being greats, then it's like, Oh my gosh, we
- 8:48have we have the weight of critical consensus on our side
- 8:52here or we're working against us and now it's like we're just
- 8:55watching a movie that's pretty good.
- 8:56It's got a 6.9 on IMDb and we can talk about.
- 9:00Like a little low, a little low. But like, not terribly low.
- 9:04I was surprised to see it under seven.
- 9:07I I would have thought it was like a 7273.
- 9:10All right, man, Let's get into our first segment of the day,
- 9:13which we call. Brad explains.
- 9:15Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 9:19ticking on the clock, so let's go ahead and hear your take with
- 9:22this little segment that we call.
- 9:24Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 9:27podcast where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he
- 9:30has just seen, often for the first time.
- 9:33I have not asked you this yet, Brad.
- 9:34How many times have you seen this movie?
- 9:38This is probably in, you know, one of my highest watched films
- 9:42about 3-4 times. This is time #2 for me.
- 9:48I saw this in the theater in 2005.
- 9:50I have not seen it since. So it's kind of cool to revisit
- 9:53because I remember like vague things about it.
- 9:56I remember certain images or I thought I did and and it was
- 9:59really nice to revisit it after almost 2 decades and get a
- 10:03better picture of what the movie actually is versus what I've
- 10:06made it out to be, which is just a knock off Lord of the Rings.
- 10:10Honestly, that's kind of how I felt last week with passion,
- 10:13where I'm like, yeah, I like vaguely remember watching that.
- 10:16Like I think twice. Like, right when it came out.
- 10:19And then I hadn't seen it in 20 years and was like, yeah, I kind
- 10:23of remember some, you know, weird old baby stuff.
- 10:26But I I don't know. I cried a lot.
- 10:27Can I tell you a a quick story about the Passion of Christ?
- 10:31So in my town growing up, there was the like the Multiplex movie
- 10:35theater and then there was a theater across town that only
- 10:37had one screen. It was like a big old movie
- 10:39theater and they would get second run movies.
- 10:42And I had seen The Passion with a church group when it first
- 10:45came out at the Multiplex and then like three months later it
- 10:48was playing at the other theater.
- 10:49And one of my friends had said like, I really want to see The
- 10:51Passion, but I I haven't had a chance.
- 10:53And so we we went to see The Passion of the Christ together
- 10:57in this big empty movie theater where, like, the only other
- 11:00person in the movie theater sat in the row right behind us.
- 11:02And we're like 14 years old. And of course, like we're
- 11:06teenagers, so we're hungry all the time.
- 11:07So we get a big bucket of popcorn to watch The Crucifixion
- 11:11of Christ. And like mid Crucifixion, the
- 11:15bucket of popcorn falls off my lap and lands on like all the
- 11:20way upside down on the floor. And when we try to pick it up,
- 11:22all the popcorn spills out. And so now we're giggling, and
- 11:25we're trying to kick the popcorn, like, under the chairs
- 11:28in front of us to tide the evidence.
- 11:30It was perhaps the most sacrilegious thing I've ever
- 11:33done, Brad. It was that it was an accident.
- 11:35But my memory of the passion is like, this is what you're doing
- 11:39while the crucifixion is happening.
- 11:41Dude, I can just see it now. I am making all things new,
- 11:45mother. Popcorn.
- 11:47Everywhere, everywhere. All right.
- 11:51On that note, Brad, you have 60 seconds to break down the plot
- 11:54of this movie, The Chronicles of Narnia, and go.
- 11:59During World War Two. Oh wait, Bob.
- 12:02You you you didn't get to pass the intro in there, yeah.
- 12:06The Chronicles of Narnia, The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe
- 12:08is a film about the four Pevency children who are shipped off in
- 12:13the middle of World War 2 to the country of the side of England.
- 12:17They live in a house owned by an old, eccentric professor.
- 12:21In the midst of exploring the house, they find themselves lost
- 12:25in a magical wardrobe where whereupon they stumble into a
- 12:30land an entire country called Narnia.
- 12:33Once they're in Narnia, Lucy goes 1st and comes back and
- 12:37tries to convince her brothers and sisters about it.
- 12:39Edmund goes at some point as enchanted by the White Witch,
- 12:44who tells him to bring his siblings back to her.
- 12:48Eventually they all make it in. The White Witch captures Edmund.
- 12:52The other three siblings go on an adventure to find Aslan who
- 12:56will help them save Edmund. Once they are there, they save
- 13:00Edmund, but Aslan has to sacrifice his life for Edmund's
- 13:04betrayal, upon which Aslan has a deeper magic is resurrected.
- 13:09Definitely not like last week's movie.
- 13:12And he saves the day killing the white witch.
- 13:16And dude, when Aslan says it is finished.
- 13:24Oh, come on man, get out Bob. You can go kick, Ross.
- 13:29It's fine. It's fine.
- 13:31There's there's really good moments in this movie.
- 13:33That one didn't quite land for me.
- 13:35Oh man. Here's The thing is, like in the
- 13:37book there there's certain things that I think are not
- 13:41unadaptable but certainly lost in translation when you when you
- 13:45adapt from one medium to the next.
- 13:47And one of the famous lines from the book is right at the end of
- 13:52the movie here as well, where where they say Aslan is not a
- 13:56tame lion, but he's a good one. And like when you read that in
- 14:00the context of the theology of the book and this is a very
- 14:03obvious naked metaphor for the death and resurrection of
- 14:06Christ. And when you when I know right
- 14:09when you read that in the book, it's like, oh, that hits really
- 14:11hard in the context of the movie.
- 14:13It's just dialogue between Tumnus and Lucy.
- 14:16And it it just kind of doesn't like.
- 14:19It's just two lines that are split between 2 characters and
- 14:22you almost don't really hear it. It doesn't land with the same
- 14:25impact. And in the book, yes, as land
- 14:28doing those things and saying it is finished, like absolutely,
- 14:31yeah, 'cause I 'cause it's right there and I get it, 'cause I'm
- 14:33seeing, I'm seeing the words. It just doesn't quite work as
- 14:38well for me in the context of this movie.
- 14:41And sure, you know, it's not that it doesn't work at all.
- 14:44It's just that you're kind of like at the Leonardo DiCaprio
- 14:47pointing at the screen meme. You're like, I see it.
- 14:49I see what you did there, Jesus. Yeah, IIA 100% agree with you on
- 14:55the Aslan's not a safe lion, but he's good like like that.
- 15:01Just didn't feel. It just felt like, weird.
- 15:05Partially because they never set up that he's like not safe.
- 15:08Like, I don't know. Yeah, it feels like that line
- 15:12would have been better if it was.
- 15:14And I think in the book it's when Beaver is describing as and
- 15:19that that would make a lot more sense than like as he's leaving
- 15:24the scene, like, Oh yeah, he's not safe, but he's good.
- 15:28It's like, well, we already knew that he was good.
- 15:30And also that he's not tame and we just saw him eat a woman's
- 15:33face like 3 minutes ago. What are you what are you
- 15:35talking about? Yeah, Tilda.
- 15:37Poor Tilda Swinton, man. Yeah, you know what Fun fact
- 15:41this is Apocryphal to the books. But after Aslan ate her face, he
- 15:45wandered off and became the main lion in the Siegfried and Roy
- 15:49show. Yeah.
- 15:51Wow, that's really cool. I didn't know that.
- 15:53Just eating faces left and right.
- 15:55So Brad, oh, you mentioned something about how they don't
- 15:59really set up things in the movie.
- 16:01And that's one of my main points that I'd like to hear from you
- 16:03about. I say all the time like we don't
- 16:06need all this back story, like just get us into the movie.
- 16:10And I'm kind of like eating my words a little bit with this
- 16:13movie because. This whole season, man, I I feel
- 16:16like there's been a few movies where you're like, I want 10
- 16:18more minutes of qui gon, Give me a back.
- 16:21Story baby. I know.
- 16:22And and this movie in particular, it's like, I think
- 16:24it's 1/2 hour too long. But I think that it also it
- 16:28needs to lose that half hour and then give like 4 minutes back
- 16:31into just giving me some sort of context for like where are these
- 16:35children living? Who is this guy?
- 16:37What what's the relationship? Is he an uncle?
- 16:39Like, I don't. Did I miss a line of dialogue?
- 16:42And then all of a sudden, like, they find this wardrobe, they're
- 16:45in Narnia, they come back and they talk to the professor and
- 16:48he's like, yeah, I don't know, like maybe that does.
- 16:50That does happen and it's like, wait, what?
- 16:52Like, are you aware of the what's going on here?
- 16:56Not just any professor, Professor Horace Slughorn from
- 17:00Hogwarts. Of course, Jim Broadbent.
- 17:05My point being I don't feel like they really established and
- 17:10again, like he is not Narnia, so they want to get to the Narnia
- 17:13parts. I get that.
- 17:14But like, who is this man? From whence did this wardrobe
- 17:19come? How does he know about his
- 17:20magical powers? Like just a little bit of world
- 17:23building would have been really helpful there.
- 17:25I I can't disagree with you more.
- 17:28I like, I think that the opening like 30 minutes of this movie
- 17:33are literally perfect. Like the the opening bombing
- 17:38scene is great. It establishes the characters
- 17:41and what they want and who they are And the the rift that is
- 17:45growing between the children and like them getting sent off to
- 17:49the country to somebody that they don't really know works
- 17:53perfectly because the film is is given from the viewpoint of the
- 17:58children. And so the children are being
- 18:01sent off to this weird eccentric uncle person that their mother
- 18:05knows that they don't know anything about.
- 18:08And you discover things about the professor as they do.
- 18:12And I I just, I think that that part of it was perfect.
- 18:16You don't need the explanation. You just need to see it from the
- 18:19kids point of view so that you get that feeling of like
- 18:23uncertainty. And I I don't know what's going
- 18:25on and I'm away from home and I I don't know who this person is
- 18:28and this this housekeeper is kind of a bee and we're we're
- 18:32running away from her. And I I just, I think that if
- 18:35there's anything of this movie that needed needed to be
- 18:38explained more It's a lot of the stuff in Narnia that like when
- 18:44you started talking I thought you were going to say like, yeah
- 18:46there's so much stuff happening in Narnia that I wish I had more
- 18:49context for. And I would have said yes, I I'm
- 18:51with you 100%. But the opening part of the
- 18:56movie, man, I'm, I'm all in on that.
- 18:58That for me was like a nine out of ten.
- 19:01I thought they were hitting on all cylinders.
- 19:05Cool. OK, so moving on, I just and
- 19:13again like it's it's a nitpick for me, but it's also the part
- 19:16of the movie that matters the least.
- 19:17So it's like I, you know, I'm not going to argue with with you
- 19:19on that. OK, let's dive into the
- 19:23performances here a little bit. And this is an interesting movie
- 19:26to talk about performances, because usually the child actors
- 19:29are the performances that we try to talk about, either the least
- 19:32or the last, because it's like you don't want to criticize kid
- 19:36performances. But this movie.
- 19:38Boy, are we getting ready to. This movie is centered on four
- 19:43different child actor performances.
- 19:46Have you ever seen a movie with like 4?
- 19:48Lead child actors. No, I mean like, like Charlie
- 19:54and the Chocolate Factory or like, you know, the old Willy
- 19:56Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. But Yep, that's anchored by
- 19:59Grandpa Joe and and Gene Wilder. Like, yeah, the stars of this
- 20:03movie are four children. The youngest of which is like
- 20:08the most on screen. Yes, and they're all pretty good
- 20:12for children. Like you do have to grade them
- 20:13on the scale of children actors, but on the scale of children
- 20:17actors, they're all like an 8 out of 10 I would say.
- 20:20Yeah, I was. That was the main thing I wanted
- 20:23to take note of. I think that if I had to rank
- 20:27them in terms of like who I think is is best, I would
- 20:31probably go. Lucy, Edmond and Susan are kind
- 20:37of both interchangeable in the middle for me.
- 20:40And I think that the oldest boy, Peter, I I don't have the
- 20:45actor's name pulled up. William Mosley.
- 20:48William Mosley I I think he's the least.
- 20:51There's moments where I'm like, oh he's a solid 8 1/2 out of 10
- 20:55B actor. But there's also a few where I'm
- 20:58like, you don't really have any emotion going on in your face.
- 21:01What's What's going on, dude? Yeah.
- 21:03And there's also a few moments where they ask the kids to have
- 21:06an outpouring of emotion and you can kind of see them straining
- 21:09for I need my body needs to produce tears right now.
- 21:12So it like and and that those kind of moments really do take a
- 21:16viewer out of the actual movie. At least they did for me.
- 21:20And you know, like when Aslan dies, spoiler alert, when when
- 21:24Aslan dies and we get them kind of weeping on his body.
- 21:28It's effective, but it could have been more effective.
- 21:31And I think that's kind of my my whole, if I could sum up my
- 21:35entire take on this movie, it's like it is effective.
- 21:39I am going to give this movie a good score.
- 21:42But I was left wondering through most of the film, like how much
- 21:45more effective could this have been if only X?
- 21:48Like there was always something in almost every scene, whether
- 21:51it was man, if this was just a little bit, if the set didn't
- 21:55look so fake here, or if the CGI was a little better, or if this
- 21:57didn't have like AC minus director like something could
- 22:02have something could have made this movie better.
- 22:05Bob Salmon. Oh, I'm horror.
- 22:07Do we, Andrew? I was going to say, do we have a
- 22:09big Andrew Adamson fan in the house today?
- 22:12It's. Just a huge Adamson stand over
- 22:15here. Do we know any other movies he's
- 22:18directed? Well, let's see.
- 22:20He directed. No, he did Prince Caspian after
- 22:25this. Oh, he directed Shrek Two and
- 22:29Shrek One. He directed Shrek.
- 22:30One dude. There you go.
- 22:32See, this is world famous Andrew Adamson.
- 22:36My guy. He's so forgettable that I
- 22:40literally wrote his name into my intro like 3 weeks ago for Shrek
- 22:45that I didn't even. November it Nope.
- 22:49All right, so let. I mean seriously though, my take
- 22:52being this is pretty good, it could be a lot better.
- 22:57Is that a fair take on the movie overall?
- 23:00I think it is. And I I think that the reason it
- 23:04it falls away from being great is because they don't.
- 23:10There's so much to put into this movie and and it's wild because
- 23:16the actual book of you know, The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe
- 23:19isn't a long book. Like you're not you're not
- 23:22dealing with The Fellowship of the Ring.
- 23:24And yet, I felt like they kind of rushed through so much of the
- 23:30Narnia stuff that I I was always left wanting to know more about
- 23:35Narnia. I think that everything through
- 23:39Edmund's visit to Narnia, everything after that just feels
- 23:45rushed and like, OK, I guess there's Santa now.
- 23:48And I I guess freaking Santa. Discount Dumbledore wanders into
- 23:54this movie. It's like, ho ho ho kids, here's
- 23:56a sword. Go fight a witch.
- 24:01Oh, that was one of the things that pissed Tolkien off about
- 24:05Lewis's books. He was like, listen man, you
- 24:09can't write fantasy and just put put Christmas like Santa Claus
- 24:14in your fantasy novel. That's not OK.
- 24:17Tell me about Christmas and Narnia.
- 24:19Are they aware of the birth of Jesus Christ?
- 24:22Like what is going on? Dang.
- 24:24I better won't believe that they are.
- 24:28Oh man, I it's stuff like that that as an adult, I'm like, I'm
- 24:33kind of with Tolkien on this, but when you're a kid reading
- 24:37like Chronicles of Narnia, it's this moment of like they
- 24:41celebrate Christmas too. And like, you know, it feels
- 24:46like a cheap way of garnering audience, you know, approval.
- 24:50But when your audience is like 4 to 9 year olds, who cares?
- 24:54Man, everybody likes Christmas. So last week we reviewed, I
- 24:58guess two weeks ago we reviewed Pirates of the Caribbean, and
- 25:02you talked about how incredibly violent that movie was.
- 25:05And I got to be honest man, I remember seeing this movie in
- 25:07the theater and being kind of like this is trying really hard
- 25:12to do the Battle of Pellinore Fields from the third Lord of
- 25:16the Rings. And this is a poor imitation of
- 25:18that. And I will eat my words from 15
- 25:21year old Bob today, because the especially the first half of the
- 25:25battle, there is some really inventive camera work when
- 25:28you're following the the eagle bird, whatever they are as
- 25:31they're dropping the rocks on people.
- 25:33The the Griffin, Bob. Sure.
- 25:35Whatever they the rocks hit those guys with such impact and
- 25:39it's like, Oh yeah, this is so first point is Andrew Adamson, I
- 25:44will give you credit you you designed a really, really good
- 25:48half of a battle before they cut away to Aslan, 'cause I think
- 25:51the second-half of the battle is kind of poopy.
- 25:52But yeah, but secondly, what a violent film this is to to
- 25:58secure APG rating. Many people getting slashed to
- 26:03death, getting faces eaten, getting crushed by rocks.
- 26:06No blood though. No blood so.
- 26:09It's totally OK, yeah. Do you think that there was
- 26:13blood when Aslan ate her face? Oh no, she's a she's a witch.
- 26:19She just kind of poofed into smoke.
- 26:20Yeah, and they cut back to Aslan and there's there's no, there's.
- 26:23No blood? No.
- 26:25Can you Can you imagine if there was just?
- 26:28Just like her. Her face.
- 26:30The entire just flap of her face just hanging from a tooth.
- 26:35It's like in Return of the Jedi. Like he's like throwing her arm
- 26:39up in the air and like gobbling it down.
- 26:41Like he's the rancor burps some some of her dreadlocks out.
- 26:51Oh man, that would be incredible.
- 26:54Bob, I'm with you 100% on this battle.
- 26:58I think especially the first half is killer.
- 27:00I like the second-half. I think the fight between Peter
- 27:03and the White Witch is pretty well done.
- 27:06Not great for me. There's something about seeing
- 27:10like a traditional knight that I realized I was like, I don't
- 27:14know if I've ever seen in a movie a truly traditional knight
- 27:21who's like the main character fighting with, like old school,
- 27:25like chainmail and plate armor and a shield and a sword.
- 27:29And there was something about that that I just it really, I
- 27:34really enjoyed that at the end of the fight scene, but do the
- 27:38opening part of the fight scene. I also don't know if I've ever
- 27:41seen such a cool geography laid out like they're fighting in
- 27:45this like hilly, like almost like a Scottish Highland crags
- 27:50and you see the armies like pouring through it like water.
- 27:54And I'm like, yeah, most fight scenes that you ever see.
- 27:58You know, Battle of Pelenor Fields, you know, all these
- 28:01famous things, they're either set around like a fortification,
- 28:04like Helms Deep, or they're just in a giant open, empty space.
- 28:09And I like I thought the choice of geography was incredible for
- 28:13the final battle. I agree.
- 28:15And one of the things that has really bothered me about this
- 28:18movie, upon this rewatch, it had a $180 million budget.
- 28:22It was a huge budget for a movie like this, and it's really clear
- 28:26that they put a lot of that money into the CGI and they put
- 28:28a lot of the money into the special effects in the battle
- 28:31scene. And I think that especially in
- 28:34the first part of that battle scene, you get these huge
- 28:36sprawling kind of vistas. There's a lot of aerial shots
- 28:40where the camera is literally moving overhead.
- 28:42It's really well done and and you can see how much effort they
- 28:47put into the coverage and the filming of that sequence.
- 28:51What really bothers me though is like, there are times in this
- 28:54movie where they'll just the the kids will just be like I I was
- 28:58right after they came out of the waterfall and you could tell
- 29:02that everything was green screened and it was like, wow,
- 29:04this must have been reshoots or something Because like there's
- 29:06some really bad green screening going on.
- 29:09And there are other times where it just seems like, oh, this is
- 29:12like this isn't even outside. This is on a set in a sound
- 29:15stage somewhere that you just covered in fake snow.
- 29:17And there are moments where the sets just look really chintzy in
- 29:20this movie. And it it kind of pulls me out
- 29:22of the movie. And I don't know if it's just
- 29:24the way they lit them, the way they filmed them, the lensing
- 29:27like, I just, I don't know enough about the the movie
- 29:30making magic that did not go into parts of this movie.
- 29:34But like, you know, I have to imagine Lord of the Rings was
- 29:36the same. Everything there was, was built
- 29:39on sound stages. And yet those the way that they
- 29:43shoot those scenes, I think about like Rivendell and it's
- 29:47like Oh my gosh, like this is there's so much detail here and
- 29:50ministerith and the kind of grind that lives on the
- 29:53Whitestone of ministerith. It's like everything feels lived
- 29:56in, everything feels real, but it still feels massive and
- 29:59regal. And Narnia kind of feels like it
- 30:03exists in like a three square mile radius and they're like,
- 30:07yeah, we got to get over that hill there and that's like the
- 30:09end of Narnia. And so, like, you never feel
- 30:12like you're in this great, big world.
- 30:13And I think it's because of the limitations of the filmmaking.
- 30:16And that's what really sucked is I wanted to.
- 30:19I wanted this to be a world I was curious about, but it felt
- 30:21like it was like a small village that I was getting curious
- 30:25about. I I think for me the reason that
- 30:29that all kind of comes about is with Lord of the Rings.
- 30:35You have this deep sense of adult adventure, like End of the
- 30:40world type of stuff. I think with Chronicles of
- 30:43Narnia, because the main characters are four children,
- 30:47like as the viewer you just feel like the stakes are lower.
- 30:53Like I don't know how else to describe it other than to say
- 30:57everything in the world feels a little more like a fairy tale
- 31:01than a fantasy, you you know what I mean?
- 31:04Like Lord of the Rings is a fantasy adventure.
- 31:07Even though Tolkien like meant it as a fairy tale and Lewis's
- 31:12feels like a fairy tale, like it feels like a place that
- 31:15Tinkerbell would live in. Yes, so much more so than like,
- 31:19the grounded, gritty, real world built in Lord of the.
- 31:22Rings Well, and I think part of that is like Lord of the Rings
- 31:25has a very focused narrative of like this and then this, but
- 31:28this, so this and like everything that we've ever
- 31:31talked about with how to construct a compelling
- 31:34narrative. Whereas I think fairy tale is
- 31:36the perfect phrase for this Brad because like other fairy tales,
- 31:39even like Grimm brothers fairy tales, it's not so much about
- 31:43what happens in the fairy tale as it is about the moral that
- 31:46they're trying to teach and the moral here is the gospel.
- 31:49So the the actual motivations for the characters sometimes
- 31:52feel a little muddy or non existent and they're told that
- 31:56there's a prophecy and that they're going to be kings and
- 31:58Queens. So let's go do this stuff.
- 32:02And they're then their brother gets kidnapped and they're like,
- 32:04OK, well now we have to rescue our brother.
- 32:06But it still feels like there are thinner character
- 32:10motivations here than there are throughout the Lord of the
- 32:13Rings. And it's because this is a fairy
- 32:16tale and Lord of the Rings is not.
- 32:17I think you really hit the nail on the head here.
- 32:19Yeah, and that's that is a key thing that I feel like is
- 32:23underdeveloped is the well, this is, this is a prophecy.
- 32:28And so you know that this is what's happening, dude.
- 32:31All you have to do is have, like have a recall.
- 32:36So like you, they're in Beaver's Hut talking to Mr. and Mrs.
- 32:40Beaver and they're explaining the prophecy.
- 32:43And have you dude, have you seen the clip of the Great British
- 32:48Baking Show where the the woman brings up a cake that is a
- 32:53cartoon Beaver and the and the lady goes, let's talk about your
- 32:58Beaver. Listen, I like I watched this
- 33:03whole movie without chuckling. But what are you saying?
- 33:05They're in Beaver's Hut. He's like, what a euphemism.
- 33:12I'm sorry. Please finish your point while I
- 33:14continue being juvenile. I'm trying to set the stage
- 33:18here, Bob. All you have to do is have Mr.
- 33:21Beaver tell the four children like the prophecy.
- 33:24Like, like line by line, like a poem.
- 33:27Read the prophecy. It's like, you know, 6 lines
- 33:30long. Doesn't take that long and have
- 33:32the music that Mister Tumnus plays on his little little flute
- 33:37to put Lucy to sleep. Have that playing like really
- 33:39softly in the background and boom, you have an epic scene
- 33:43with an epic prophecy and now all of the children, right?
- 33:47Because the movie is filmed from the children's perspective now,
- 33:51we, the audience and the children have received the
- 33:55prophecy and it's been placed upon us and we feel the
- 33:59mysticism and there's cool music playing in the background and
- 34:03and I'm like, oh, that's that's all you had to do.
- 34:05And now you have the prophecy and you have your motivation.
- 34:08But instead it's just there's a prophecy.
- 34:11Go go go. Yeah, a prophecy that like you
- 34:14didn't even buy into. There's just a prophecy that
- 34:17people are going to come and then they are kings and you seem
- 34:19like those people, so go ahead. You're going to come and then
- 34:24then the Kings. Listen, dude.
- 34:27So one of the reviews that I read for this movie was from The
- 34:30New Yorker, and I almost sent you the passage.
- 34:33It was one of the funniest movie reviews I've ever read.
- 34:36And the the critic was talking about how the the story of
- 34:41Narnia has for decades stirred the souls of the faithful.
- 34:45But then he says, it has also stirred the loins of
- 34:48professional Freudians. Then he laid out like the Why
- 34:52what the Freudian reading of this movie is.
- 34:55Uh, huh. First Lucy, then Edmund, then
- 34:57all four children feel their way uncertainly through the folds of
- 35:01a deep furry passage and into another world.
- 35:06And boy, oh boy, if that isn't the place where we need to break
- 35:09for whiskey, Brad. Yeah, Lewis the pedophile.
- 35:13That's that's definitely the take we wanted to come away with
- 35:16here. Let's drink some Clontarf.
- 35:20What do you say? I'm ready, man.
- 35:22Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 35:30checking out Clontarf 1014 Classic Blend Irish Whiskey.
- 35:36Brad, this is a cheap, cheap Irish W1 that I've heard is good
- 35:40as a mixer and I picked it up on the OHLQ Ohio Liquor Last Call
- 35:46shelf because they stopped carrying this size of it or this
- 35:49bottle or something. It cost me like $11.00 and I
- 35:52said boy oh boy is that a film and whiskey selection right
- 35:55there. Heck yeah, dude.
- 35:57So this is made by Pernod Ricard.
- 36:00They have a subsidiary called Irish Distillers and they are
- 36:04the ones who create this brand. It's not attached to any
- 36:06particular distillery because it is a blended Irish whiskey.
- 36:10Apparently in Ireland there are other things that are released
- 36:12under the Clontarf brand, like a single malt, but in the States
- 36:16we only get this and so I am very excited to dive into this
- 36:19Brad. It's been a while since we've
- 36:21had a cheapo whiskey and it's been a minute since we've had an
- 36:24Irish whiskey, so like, we're just crossing things off the
- 36:27list here. Well, and this is perfect to
- 36:29pair with as the author of the famed Cronkles of Narnia is
- 36:34Irish. And probably a fan of cheap
- 36:37whiskey. I don't know, man.
- 36:40I I could see Lewis and Tolkien putting down some really
- 36:43expensive Scotch. But also having debates with a
- 36:46just a giant glass of Clontarf in hand.
- 36:49Oh yeah dude, 100% all. Right, man, let's dive in.
- 36:52I'm drinking this live. You are drinking it in the past,
- 36:55apparently. I think you have notes to bring
- 36:57here, so. Yeah, hold on.
- 37:00Let me get my time machine and go back to when I was drinking
- 37:02it. Brad, what are you picking up on
- 37:04the nose of Clontarf? This is a a relatively pleasant
- 37:09nose. I think that it's got some it's
- 37:12got some floral notes, it has some like really nice light milk
- 37:17chocolatey things going on. There's some honeysuckle.
- 37:22It it's overall a really pleasant, light, unoffensive
- 37:26nose. If I had to give a negative
- 37:28note, it feels young and that's what you'd expect.
- 37:33Here. I think it's decent.
- 37:35I'll give it a 6 1/2 Bob. Brad, I really like this nose
- 37:38for what it is. It is very light, very airy.
- 37:42If you look at the color of it in the glass.
- 37:43It is not a very dark whiskey, but it has what I love on a lot
- 37:47of these Irish whiskeys that Scotches sometimes don't have,
- 37:50which is a sort of almost like a floral heathery kind of note to
- 37:55it. It's like really deep honey and
- 37:58some floral as well. And I really like that.
- 38:00You can tell that it's gonna be a little bit harsh on the
- 38:03pallet, or it's at least hinting that way, but it's covered up
- 38:06really, really nicely by these softer notes.
- 38:09I'm digging this, man. I'm gonna give it a 7 out of 10
- 38:11on the nose. Yeah.
- 38:13I think as we get into the pallet here it the flavor drops
- 38:16off a little bit because it just there's a youth that underlies
- 38:21this that you can't get away from.
- 38:24But I will say it has some really nice vanilla notes that
- 38:27are strong for me. There's some rose petals, some
- 38:31toffee and the young grain taste isn't bad, but it is present.
- 38:37I I think I'll come down just a little bit from the nose, but
- 38:40I'll I'll stick it a six out of 10.
- 38:43I don't know how to say what I'm going to say in a moment without
- 38:45it sounding like super harsh on this whiskey.
- 38:48But when you're tasting whiskey for review purposes, you're not
- 38:52just sipping it and immediately swallowing it.
- 38:54You're like swishing it around your mouth.
- 38:56You're kind of kicking it from the back front of your mouth to
- 38:58the back of your mouth on the front of the palate.
- 39:01This is like syrupy sweet, and it's actually pretty viscous
- 39:04too. I thought it was going to be
- 39:05super thin, but it coats the mouth really nicely.
- 39:08But it's it's almost sickly sweet.
- 39:11And when I went to kick it to the back of my mouth, it just
- 39:13hit this one small part of my tongue that I got like a really
- 39:18weird, like, really weird note on.
- 39:21And it almost made me gag for a second.
- 39:23Not because it was like it tasted so bad, but because I
- 39:26think it tipped something off in my brain that it was going to go
- 39:29to bad places. And so I was like, and then it
- 39:32didn't like it, just it it became a very sort of smoky,
- 39:36almost ashy, sort of bitter taste on the back of my tongue.
- 39:40But what I'm left with is this sense that they're trying to
- 39:44cover up some of the harsher edges with a really sickly sweet
- 39:48flavor. Now they obviously are not.
- 39:50They're not adding anything to this.
- 39:51They're not doing that. But you can tell that this is
- 39:54not a a really high quality whiskey and BA, very well aged
- 39:58whiskey because those harsh edges are still there and
- 40:02they're it just kind of tastes like they dumped sugar on top of
- 40:06a pretty rough whiskey. It's not unpleasant, but I think
- 40:10my palate was trying to tip me off to something here.
- 40:12Brad, I'm going to give it a six out of 10 on the flavor.
- 40:16And I I probably sounded harsher than I meant to be, but at the
- 40:19end of the day, like this is a $18.00 bottle of whiskey for a
- 40:22reason. Yeah, yeah, 100%, man.
- 40:26I think that the finish is fine. It's light and floral.
- 40:30I give it a 6 1/2 on the finish. I think a balance wise, I'll
- 40:34give it a 7 1/2. I don't think that there is
- 40:37anything wrong with this whiskey.
- 40:39I think that the negative notes are consistent throughout.
- 40:43The positive notes are consistent throughout.
- 40:46And so because of that, I'm not going to give it anything super
- 40:48high, but a 7 1/2 on the balance and Bob for 18 bucks like this
- 40:54is a really solid value. I'm going to give it a 7 1/2 out
- 40:58of 10 here. All right.
- 41:00So just to recap, I'm going to give mine, I'm going to go back
- 41:02to where you started finish. I'm going to give a 6 1/2 like
- 41:06you balance. I'll give a 7 1/2 like you.
- 41:09And what'd you give on value? 7 1/2.
- 41:14Yeah, I mean, I think that this is about as good as you can find
- 41:19for $18.00. It's also like not a great
- 41:22whiskey. I'm not mad at it 'cause it's
- 41:24$18.00, but there's a there's an almost like Splenda sweetness to
- 41:29this on the on the back part of the palate and it's kind of
- 41:33hanging with me. I don't know if it would make a
- 41:34great mixer. I think it's a little bit too
- 41:36light to really stand up in a cocktail.
- 41:39You know, if you want to use this for Irish coffee or
- 41:41something like, go for it. But it's a nice little sipper
- 41:44when you have already had the good stuff.
- 41:46It's like Jesus at the the wedding at Cana.
- 41:48You know what I mean? Like drink your good whiskey and
- 41:51then bust out the Clontarf. I'll give it a 7 1/2 as well,
- 41:54Brad. And that's taking me to a 34.5
- 41:58out of 50. Yeah, I am at a 34 out of 50
- 42:02Bob. Like I think this is a solid
- 42:05Irish whiskey at a bargain price.
- 42:08I would probably pay like $2324.00 for this.
- 42:13So at at a sub 20 price, you really can't beat this Bob.
- 42:18No, you can't. And we're coming out to a 34.25
- 42:21out of 50 or 68 1/2 out of 100. That sounds a little low, like a
- 42:2668 is like a failing grade. I actually think this is
- 42:29significantly better than that. But like at the end of the day
- 42:32it's pretty much a six whiskey across the board at a really
- 42:35good price point. I'm going to recommend this
- 42:38Brad. Like, you know, if you want to
- 42:40try an Irish whiskey just to get a sense of what it could taste
- 42:44like, this is not a bad place to start.
- 42:47Yeah, 100%, man. I I think that Klon Tarf is
- 42:49doing good stuff here. I kind of want to go to Ireland
- 42:52and try some of the things they have over there 'cause I can
- 42:55imagine a world where a little better age single malt would be
- 43:00really solid from this distillery.
- 43:02This might have been the perfect thing to match up with this
- 43:04movie. Like, it is good and it it is
- 43:07clearly hinting at and mimicking other, better products.
- 43:12But like, I'm not mad at it, you know.
- 43:15Yeah, 100% dude. All right, let's get back into
- 43:17talking about the Chronicles of Narnia.
- 43:19What do you say? All right, everybody.
- 43:25That was Clontarf. Something, something, something,
- 43:28a whiskey that we really liked for what it was.
- 43:30Yeah, And it was something. Something something.
- 43:33Yeah, What? What was it actually called?
- 43:35Clontarf Classic Blend. Ah, that good old classic blend.
- 43:40I do still like calling it the clonicles of Tarpia, so continue
- 43:44doing that. The clontarficles of Narnia.
- 43:51All right, Brad, after we took a week off last week, I am very
- 43:54eager to get into our next game, which we call 2 facts and a
- 43:58falsehood. Brad is going to try to stump
- 44:01your bomb. Two are right and what is wrong?
- 44:072 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts and a Falsehood is the part of
- 44:10the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 44:14the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie and I
- 44:17have to figure out which one that is.
- 44:19Last week Brad said that he felt guilty because he didn't want to
- 44:24shame Catholic Jesus and so we took took a week off.
- 44:28I'm going to claim it as a moral victory, if nothing else.
- 44:32My record is. This Jesus dying on the cross
- 44:34for your sins is a moral victory for you Bob.
- 44:39Yeah. It's not gone right.
- 44:42That's a That's a trick. Question.
- 44:43I was gonna say, wait a minute. I think I understand how this
- 44:46works. All right, so I'm sitting at
- 44:5011:00 and 6:00 on the season. Brad, let's see what you got.
- 44:53Hit me with your two facts and a falsehood.
- 44:56Fact #1. The wardrobe featured in the
- 44:58film belonged to Lord Lord, Lord George Cummington, Earl of
- 45:05Belfast, CS Lewis's hometown. Covington's father shared a
- 45:09friendship with Lewis himself, prompting his son to offer the
- 45:13wardrobe for use in the film as a tribute.
- 45:16Fact #2 When the adults swearing got out of hand on set, Georgie
- 45:20Henley, who played Lucy, set up a swear jar.
- 45:24James McAvoy was supposedly the worst offender.
- 45:26Even her teenage costars had to pay their toll.
- 45:30Fact #3, the movie was primarily shot in chronological order,
- 45:34with the exception of the final scene where the Pevencies fall
- 45:37out of the wardrobe. That scene was shot before all
- 45:40of the outdoor shots, so that the kids would still be pale and
- 45:43look like they had and look like they had at the film's
- 45:46beginning. OK, I'm just going to say this
- 45:50now. We have already made mention of
- 45:52the Freudian reading of this movie and we have made fun of
- 45:55the word Beaver. So I really hope that you didn't
- 45:59just make up a character named Lord Cummington.
- 46:03That's all I'm gonna say. I'm gonna, I'm gonna take it.
- 46:06I'm just gonna hope that one is true.
- 46:08I'm not gonna pick it as the falsehoods because the Freudian
- 46:12reading will be really weird if that's the falsehood.
- 46:16So #2 or #3? I don't know man, #2 sounds
- 46:20really plausible. And James McAvoy loves to drop
- 46:23an F bomb in a lot of movies #3 sounds really plausible too,
- 46:27because not just because the kids are are pale in those
- 46:30sequences, but a lot of times you only have locations secured
- 46:33for a few days so you have to shoot everything you can there.
- 46:38Brad, I'm going to say that Three is the falsehood because
- 46:48they just didn't shoot it in chronological order anyway, and
- 46:52I have no other reason for saying that other than I just
- 46:54don't want it to be Lord Cummington.
- 46:56Bob, do you know why #2 and #3 sounded so plausible?
- 47:02Because they're facts. Because they're facts, baby.
- 47:04You made-up Lord Cummington. I did not.
- 47:09I googled, make up a British name and it came up with Lord
- 47:15George Cummington. It is spelled COMING.
- 47:19Sure it is, Brad. It sure is.
- 47:23Anytime that was so, that was not a creation of of my own.
- 47:27It was Google having a a bit of a edible, complex Freudian
- 47:32Freudian thing. Anytime we watch a movie that
- 47:35you'd say is dirty. From now on, I'm just going to
- 47:37say, oh, what did Lord Cummington show up?
- 47:42All right. I will take my L Lord Cummington
- 47:45got me again. Brad he.
- 47:48Got you again. When did he get you?
- 47:51The first time. Don't ask, don't ask.
- 47:55Bro, this is this is a children's movie.
- 47:57Let's get back into talking about Marnia and Brad.
- 48:01We haven't talked about Tilda Swinton, who is the top build
- 48:03person in this movie. Really interesting career Tilda
- 48:06Swinton has had. She's been an working actress
- 48:08since at least the 90s, maybe earlier than that.
- 48:11She's an indie darling. She's still working in an
- 48:14independent film a lot and like she is known amongst the general
- 48:18population for being like the weird looking one.
- 48:21And I I hate to say it like that, but like she's a very
- 48:23interesting looking face. She's a phenomenal actress and I
- 48:28had some weird struggles with her performance here.
- 48:31Not because she's bad, but I almost feel like she's she gave
- 48:36this move, this character, too many layers for the movie that
- 48:41was being made around her. She's like she's developing a
- 48:44very complex character because the White Witch is not just
- 48:48like, I'm going to shout at you and be demonically evil.
- 48:52She's cunning and she's really, really good at tricking.
- 48:56Especially that scene with Edmund at the beginning, She's
- 48:59it's like chilling how you're watching her manipulate a child.
- 49:03She's not playing it with like a wink to the camera.
- 49:05She's not playing it as I'm, you know, the witch with an apple
- 49:09seducing Snow White. It's it's like psychological
- 49:13damage. She's doing this kid and it's
- 49:15played so well, but it almost feels like the movie paints in
- 49:21really broad strokes and it almost needed somebody who was
- 49:25more of a standard cartoonish villain.
- 49:27And so I feel weird saying that like the performance doesn't
- 49:30work, but it it kind of doesn't work because she's doing more
- 49:35than the movies doing around her.
- 49:38Bob, you know what? You just said?
- 49:41Tilda Swinton is too good for this movie.
- 49:43Kind of. I mean, yeah.
- 49:47I think there's a version of this performance that she's just
- 49:49like, OK, like, I'm just gonna do the, like, Jeremy Irons as
- 49:54Scar, like just ham it up, you know, and and it's great.
- 49:58But she doesn't do that. She's trying something more
- 50:00subtle here and it kind of just sticks out like a sore thumb, if
- 50:03I'm being honest. Oh man, I I will.
- 50:08I have watched enough movies and reviewed enough with you, Bob,
- 50:11to know that you are not the Snooty cinephile.
- 50:16But but Tilda turns in a hell of a performance here.
- 50:20I like. I don't know what there is to
- 50:22complain. She gives this movie a depth
- 50:26that would not exist without her.
- 50:28I think the movie could work with a Jeremy Irons a scar type
- 50:33performance. Like, I'm not saying that that
- 50:35part of the point is invalid. I guess what I'm saying is of
- 50:40all the performances in this movie, Tilda Swinton is an A+
- 50:45and she doesn't need to be. She could take her paycheck.
- 50:47That's what I'm saying like. A garbage performance, but she
- 50:51doesn't. This is this is Michael Caine
- 50:56with a bunch of freaking Muppets around him and it makes the
- 50:59movie better. And I am all in on Tilda Swinton
- 51:01here. That's a great analogy, dude,
- 51:04because I I agree with the analogy.
- 51:06I don't agree that it makes the movie better and it's but it's
- 51:09not her fault so I'm not complaining about her.
- 51:12But it's like she is adding layers and layers of depth to a
- 51:15character that would be right at home in Lord of the Rings and
- 51:20and doesn't feel at home in this movie.
- 51:23And it's almost like, I don't know, I just felt like I was
- 51:26having the world of Narnia opened up to me.
- 51:29Every time I looked at her, I was like, what is this?
- 51:31I I feel wonderment at this character.
- 51:34And then every other character is just like, oi, I'm a Beaver,
- 51:38do you know what I mean? Like there's just there's no,
- 51:41there's no no other subtle things happening in the whole
- 51:44movie. Oi, I'm a Beaver.
- 51:48That's my whole personality. Oh man.
- 51:53Although Ray Ray Winstone voicing that Beaver.
- 51:56Oh, he's incredible. It's so good.
- 51:58It's so good, man. Would you see him running around
- 52:02with armor on? You're like, yeah, why not?
- 52:05Of course. He's a warrior dude.
- 52:07The the little back and forth jibes or digs that Mister and
- 52:15Misses Beaver taking each other are incredible.
- 52:17And they're all somehow related to her cooking, you know?
- 52:21Yes. And she's like making fun of him
- 52:23for like, drinking too much with his buddy.
- 52:27It See that man. Those are the moments that work
- 52:30in this movie. Like when we get away from the
- 52:34Here's a quest you are. There's a prophecy.
- 52:37Go, go, go, dude. When?
- 52:39When When Beaver looks at the stone version of Badger and
- 52:44like, you've heard the jokes with his wife about his
- 52:48relationship with Badger, and then you hear him go.
- 52:52He was my best. Dude, it's crushing.
- 52:55It's. So good.
- 52:56Those are the moments where this movie succeeds.
- 52:59It's kind of like an analogy that I would try to make is it's
- 53:02kind of like Dobby in the Harry Potter series, where Dobby is
- 53:07like they they made a vast improvement on the Jar Jar Binks
- 53:10prototype and they were like, this is Dobby and he's gonna
- 53:12kind of suck in the first film you see him in.
- 53:15Jar Jar 2.0. Yeah, 'cause, like you're like,
- 53:17oh, this is annoying as hell. And by the end of the movie he
- 53:20says Dobby is free. And you're like, yeah, Dobby
- 53:23Dobby's my boy. And then when you see Dobby die
- 53:26at the end of the 7th movie, you're like, that was one of the
- 53:29best characters ever made. I can't believe they just killed
- 53:31him. And I kind of feel like that
- 53:33with a lot of these side characters in Narnia.
- 53:36James McAvoy is inspired casting for Mr. Tumnus.
- 53:39He's so good and he brings a much more like a much softer
- 53:42side of himself to that performance.
- 53:44I think Ray Winstone as Beaver is incredible and and I wish
- 53:49that there was that much care and attention and color given to
- 53:54the human characters in this movie because the Pevency
- 53:57children, while they are like the audience surrogate, they're
- 54:00also the blandest characters I would say in the whole film.
- 54:05Yeah, yeah, they they kind of are just a little bit.
- 54:09And I like, I think that that's OK the, the film doesn't
- 54:13necessarily need them to like Shine crazily bright.
- 54:17But I don't know man, we're back to the Tilda Swinton thing.
- 54:21Like sure, everybody. It'd be better if everyone
- 54:24turned in an A+ performance. It would.
- 54:26It would be better this this band of four Mary hobbits that
- 54:31we have in these four children needed a Mary and Pippin, and
- 54:34they also needed a Frodo and Sam, and they didn't have any of
- 54:36those. Like, there's not fun characters
- 54:39represented in the four. And there's also not like the
- 54:43two characters you love the way there are Frodo and Sam, and I
- 54:47think they want it to be either Lucy and what's his sister's
- 54:51name, Susan or Lucy and Peter. But you don't really catch the
- 54:56bond between any of them that way.
- 54:59And so that, like, you already don't have as much of an
- 55:01emotional connection with these kids.
- 55:03And then, Brad, if I can make perhaps my most controversial
- 55:06statement in an episode where we've talked about Lord
- 55:09Cummington, I have never wanted to watch a child die on screen
- 55:14more than Edmund. That kid sucked so much.
- 55:19And I look like I understand how the gospel works.
- 55:22I know that, Aslan. Jesus especially dies for Edmund
- 55:27specifically because he is the worst among us and it is a
- 55:30metaphor. I get that I do not care.
- 55:32I like as Land forgives Bob book.
- 55:36Does not that kid have you? Seen The Voyage of the Dawn
- 55:40Treader. I have not, no.
- 55:42Oh dude, you don't even know what you're in for.
- 55:45Oh, does Edmond get drawn and quartered 'cause I.
- 55:48Know so there is a Their cousin Eustace goes into Narnia with
- 55:57with Edmond and Lucy. And Eustace is like Edmond on
- 56:03steroids. He sucks so hard.
- 56:08He is so much worse than Edmond and I'm with you 100%.
- 56:12Edmond is the worst in this movie.
- 56:14He has the most punchable face of any 11 year old I've ever
- 56:18seen. He he is like, in this.
- 56:20I wish I could have thought about my Mount Rushmore of kids
- 56:22like this, but he has the kind of face that reminds me of
- 56:26Alfalfa from The Little Rascals, where it's like like every time
- 56:30you see that kid come on screen, you're like this fucking kid.
- 56:33Like, you just like you just hate him and you want to punch
- 56:36him and he kind of looks like Alfalfa.
- 56:38And I don't know if you remember, but when the kid that
- 56:40played Alfalfa back in the 30s grew up, he was in It's a
- 56:43Wonderful Life for a Hot 2nd. And he's the kid that wanted to
- 56:46open the floor underneath George Bailey and make them all.
- 56:50Yeah, that's Alfalfa. That's Edmund.
- 56:52I hate both of those kids. And I like for the whole movie,
- 56:57I was like, man, why does Aslan have to forgive this kid?
- 57:00He's the worst. People died because of Edmund,
- 57:03and they're just like as like just like, oh, what's done is
- 57:06done. Like, whoa, hold on, Like, what
- 57:08about freaking Mr. Fox? He died because Edmond sucks.
- 57:13Yeah, he sure did. And I liked Mr. Fox.
- 57:16I did too. Yeah.
- 57:18I'm sorry, I I had to get that off my chest.
- 57:21No, it's OK man. Any any other children you want
- 57:23to murder? No, just that one.
- 57:24For now. All of my rage has been directed
- 57:26to Edmond. OK, yeah, that's that's fine
- 57:29with me, man. Cool.
- 57:31All right, Brad. Well, I think with that off my
- 57:32chest, if there's nothing else about the film itself that you
- 57:35want to talk about, then it is time for us to get to our last
- 57:38segment of the day, which we call Let's make it a Double.
- 57:42We're near the end of the episode, so thanks listening to
- 57:45the film and whiskey show. Let's pair another film with
- 57:48this one, even if it's struggling.
- 57:49It's a final segment of the day. Now let's make it a double.
- 57:52Let's make it a double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 57:55movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 57:58feature. Brad, I'm anxious to hear yours
- 58:01because I think the most obvious comparison point is Lord of the
- 58:04Rings. But I doubt that you went with
- 58:06that. So I'd like to hear what you
- 58:08thought of for your let's make it a double.
- 58:11You know, Bob, I, I was struggling with a movie to pick
- 58:14for this. I think a good a good pairing as
- 58:19far as like quality and enjoyability goes, because I
- 58:24think that Chronicles of Narnia is like a relatively high,
- 58:26enjoyably enjoyable film with like an above average quality of
- 58:32production. I'm going to pair it with
- 58:35Stardust from 2007. There's AI feel like there was
- 58:39100 movies like this in the mid 2000s.
- 58:42There was another movie called Zathura that was kind of like
- 58:45like I didn't see compass, I didn't see any of them and
- 58:49they're all the same movie in my like I I've just jumbled all
- 58:52their posters together. So tell me about Stardust.
- 58:55What's that movie? There is a young man who sees
- 59:00this beautiful girl, falls in love with her, follows her to
- 59:03like the edge of town, and it's almost like a magical version of
- 59:08what's the it's like the village or something.
- 59:11Is that the Shyamalan movie, where there's like at the edge
- 59:16of the woods there's others living out there?
- 59:18It's kind of like that where she disappears across this magical
- 59:22veil and he's trying to find her and he goes on this adventure to
- 59:27cross the magical veil and save her from this evil witch and and
- 59:31it's just kind of a generic fun action adventure movie that you
- 59:36know, it's it's nothing great. I think it has like a 7.57 point
- 59:426 on IMDb. So like, it's just a really fun
- 59:45action adventure fantasy movie. Nice.
- 59:48All right, so Brad's pairing it with Stardust.
- 59:50I'm going to pick a movie called A Monster Calls.
- 59:54It's a really good movie, and I I haven't had a chance to
- 59:57recommend it before on this podcast.
- 59:58But essentially it's a movie about a kid whose mom has a
- 1:00:02terminal illness and he runs off every day into the woods and he
- 1:00:08kind of imagines this giant monster that he talks to.
- 1:00:12And it's a movie that's it's all about processing through grief
- 1:00:15and processing through trauma. The monster in the movie is
- 1:00:18voiced by Liam Neeson. It's an incredibly emotional
- 1:00:21movie and like just a really good way.
- 1:00:24I think you know it, it'd be better for teenagers, but it's a
- 1:00:27really good way to teach kids about processing through trauma
- 1:00:30and grief. And it has Liam Neeson voicing
- 1:00:33the the main monster of the movie.
- 1:00:37But beyond the Liam Neeson of it all, I think it's just a really
- 1:00:40good example of how we can use creatures that aren't real to
- 1:00:46act as a metaphor for things that are happening in our lives
- 1:00:48or things that are happening kind of cosmically the way that
- 1:00:51Ashland does in this movie. So I really love this movie and
- 1:00:54I've never recommended it before.
- 1:00:55It's called A Monster Calls. All right, I I'm in.
- 1:00:58Man, that sounds really interesting.
- 1:01:00All right, Brad, let's give this movie some final scores.
- 1:01:04I'll go first. I don't think that this movie,
- 1:01:08I'm sure that there's someone out there that hates this movie.
- 1:01:10But what I think about this movie, I can't really see
- 1:01:13anybody giving it less than like A5.
- 1:01:15Like at at the worst reading of this movie is like it is
- 1:01:18mediocre. I also think that it's going to
- 1:01:20be hard to find anyone out there that thinks this movie is like a
- 1:01:2310 and it just kind of feels like the natural bell curve of
- 1:01:27this movie is between A5 and an 8.
- 1:01:30And so I I I look at the 6.9 on IMDb and I'm like it does look a
- 1:01:34little low, but I can see how it would land somewhere in there
- 1:01:38and you said like even a 7 two would make more sense.
- 1:01:40That's kind of where I'm at with this movie.
- 1:01:42It is like almost there in every facet and it kind of just
- 1:01:47depends on when you get out of this movie at the two hour and
- 1:01:5020 minute mark, do you ultimately feel like it was a
- 1:01:53good investment of your time or a waste of your time?
- 1:01:55And I think that's what's going to determine, are you a six or
- 1:01:57A7 on this movie? I didn't think it was a waste of
- 1:02:00time. I like this movie quite a bit.
- 1:02:02I don't. I don't think I'll give it a 7
- 1:02:041/2, but I will give it a 7 out of 10.
- 1:02:08OK. I I think that that's a fair
- 1:02:10score Bob. I I am a little bit higher.
- 1:02:12I really really enjoy this movie and and it's been an IP that
- 1:02:17I've liked for most of my life. I'm at an 8 out of 10.
- 1:02:22I I think that the the child performances are all as we said
- 1:02:26like B minus to B plus range. You have an incredible
- 1:02:30performance from Tilda Swinton and some of the voice actors
- 1:02:33from the animal characters. I I'm just I'm in on this movie
- 1:02:37man. It's a movie that I will come
- 1:02:38back to every three or four years like gladly and really
- 1:02:42enjoy it. All right, so we are at a 7.5
- 1:02:46out of 10 on average. But we'd like to know what you
- 1:02:48think. How long has it been since
- 1:02:50you've seen The Chronicles of Narnia, The Lion, The Witch, and
- 1:02:53the Wardrobe? I should say they did make two
- 1:02:55more movies. For me, it was 19 years.
- 1:02:58Does anybody have my record beat?
- 1:02:59Because I'm pretty sure I saw it like opening weekend.
- 1:03:01So come join me, Brothers in Arms.
- 1:03:04Let us know what you thought of this movie.
- 1:03:06You can find us on all of our social media accounts Facebook,
- 1:03:09Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube at Film Whiskey.
- 1:03:14Or you can jump onto the Discord.
- 1:03:16We are on there every single day talking to you guys, fans of the
- 1:03:19Film and Whiskey Podcast. If you want to join the
- 1:03:21conversation, you can find a link to our Discord at the end
- 1:03:24of every single one of our show notes.
- 1:03:26Next week we are just tipping things into Funville.
- 1:03:29For a week we're looking at a movie that I can't believe
- 1:03:31grossed this much money, but it is 2006's Night at the Museum.
- 1:03:36Fun fact. A film that Bob Book has never
- 1:03:38seen. What?
- 1:03:40Yeah, I'm pretty pumped. I've never seen it before.
- 1:03:43So we'll be joined by a very special guest who'll be making
- 1:03:46his first time appearance on the show.
- 1:03:48So TuneIn next week for Night at the Museum.
- 1:03:50But until then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:03:54And we'll see you next time.