Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / In Bitcoin, We Trust: Avoiding Administrative Pitfalls in Trusts and Estates with Large Concentrations of Crypto and Other Digital Assets with J.D. Rees
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to today's program, In Bitcoin We Trust,
- 0:07avoiding administrative pitfalls in trusts and
- 0:09estates with large concentrations of crypto and
- 0:12other digital assets. We are thrilled to have
- 0:15you join us today. My name is Jacqueline Yu,
- 0:18and I'm the co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:20Association's trust and estate section. Before
- 0:23we begin, I'd like to take a moment to introduce
- 0:25Brian Joy of the Sanborn team. The Sanborn team
- 0:28has been the official sponsor of this section
- 0:30since 2006. Brian, please say hello. Hi. Thank
- 0:35you, Jacqueline. I just want to take a moment
- 0:37to reintroduce the Sanborn team to everyone.
- 0:40We have over 40 years of experience specializing
- 0:43in probate and trust real estate sales. While
- 0:47we're based in Beverly Hills, we represent properties
- 0:50throughout California, as well as other states,
- 0:53thanks to our trusted network of agents within
- 0:55the Berkshire Hathaway Probate and Trust Division.
- 0:59Just last week, we closed the property in Coronado
- 1:01Island in San Diego. And this week, we're listing
- 1:05farmland in Utah. Whatever the scenario or location,
- 1:09we're confident we could help you and your clients.
- 1:12Thank you, everyone. I'm looking forward to JD's
- 1:14presentation. Thank you, Brian. In addition to
- 1:18the Sanborn team, the Trust and Estate section
- 1:21is also sponsored by Bond Services of California,
- 1:25Liberty Mutual Surety. California Title Company,
- 1:29and Pickford Escrow Company. Now I'd like to
- 1:31turn things over to Rochelle Schultz to provide
- 1:34this month's legal updates. Thanks so much. Good
- 1:38afternoon. Today I will be presenting the case
- 1:40of Herron versus George S. This case involved
- 1:43a wealthy 86 -year -old man with severe dementia
- 1:46and visual impairment named George. George had
- 1:49two daughters, Susanna and Gabriella. After two
- 1:53doctors determined that George lacked capacity
- 1:55to make financial decisions, Gabriella contacted
- 1:57a trust in the state attorney and arranged to
- 2:00have the attorney meet with George privately.
- 2:03The attorney met with George alone at his house
- 2:05for over an hour after insisting that his caregivers
- 2:08leave them alone. At the meeting, George signed
- 2:10the attorney's fee agreement requiring a $100
- 2:15,000 retainer after the attorney told George
- 2:19where to sign. At the time, the attorney knew
- 2:22George's vision was impaired and that two doctors
- 2:24had determined George lacked capacity. The same
- 2:27day, the attorney sent a letter for payment of
- 2:30the retainer to the trustees of George's trust.
- 2:32Susanna, as George's attorney in fact, filed
- 2:35a request for an elder abuse restraining order
- 2:38against the attorney and the attorney objected.
- 2:41After a lengthy evidentiary hearing, the trial
- 2:43court issued a restraining order against the
- 2:45attorney. after finding that the attorney committed
- 2:48financial elder abuse because the attorney exerted
- 2:52undue influence to obtain a property right from
- 2:54George, namely an agreement to pay a $100 ,000
- 2:58retainer. And the attorney knew or should have
- 3:01known that the attorney's conduct would be harmful
- 3:03to George. The attorney appealed on several grounds,
- 3:06including that the trial court could not issue
- 3:08the restraining order without first determining
- 3:10George's capacity and that there was no no substantial
- 3:13evidence that she committed financial elder abuse.
- 3:17The appellate court affirmed the restraining
- 3:18order concluding that an elder abuse restraining
- 3:21order may issue without determination of the
- 3:23elder's capacity. The attorney's fee agreement
- 3:26is a property right and there was substantial
- 3:29evidence that the attorney committed financial
- 3:31elder abuse by exerting undue influence to obtain
- 3:34that property right from George. I hope you enjoy
- 3:36the program. Thanks Rochelle. Now onto the program.
- 3:41It's my pleasure to introduce today's speaker,
- 3:43JD Reese. JD is special counsel in the business
- 3:46trial practice group of Shepherd Mullen Century
- 3:48City Office. His practice focuses primarily on
- 3:52trust in a state's litigation and administration.
- 3:54JD litigates all manner of probate court disputes,
- 3:57including trust and mole contests, airship disputes,
- 4:00fiduciary removal and surcharge actions, elder
- 4:02abuse actions, contested conservatorships and
- 4:04guardianships, and more. JD also practices in
- 4:07civil court regularly, both in probate and in
- 4:09general commercial matters. In addition to litigating
- 4:11matters through mediation and trial, JD advises
- 4:13his individual, institutional, and nonprofit
- 4:16clients on adverse administrations of trusts
- 4:18and estates with assets that span the globe.
- 4:21Additionally, for the past several years, JD
- 4:22has helped clients in drafting and arising their
- 4:24estate plans. Thanks, JD. We're really looking
- 4:26forward to your presentation today. Thank you,
- 4:31Teal. Thank you so much, everyone, for being
- 4:33here today. And thank you also to the Beverly
- 4:35Hills Bar Association's Trust and Estates Law
- 4:38section for inviting me to be here with you all
- 4:40today. It's an honor to get to speak with such
- 4:43an esteemed group of lawyers on a topic that
- 4:45I'm passionate about, which is the intersection
- 4:47of trusts, estates, and digital assets like cryptocurrencies.
- 4:52Before we get into it, I'll share a little bit
- 4:54about myself. A lot of it was covered in that
- 4:56very generous introduction by Teal. Thank you.
- 4:59I will say that I have represented clients, in
- 5:01addition to speaking and presenting on this topic,
- 5:04I've represented clients who have dealt with
- 5:06considerable concentrations of digital assets
- 5:10within trusts and within estates, all kinds of
- 5:13complex issues involved with marshaling, administering,
- 5:15and distributing those assets. So I don't just
- 5:18talk about it. I've also walked the walk here
- 5:19a little bit. and I'm thoroughly excited to get
- 5:21to be here with you. If you'd like to check out
- 5:23more information about me and my contact information,
- 5:26LinkedIn and there. But with that, let's get
- 5:29into what we're really here to talk about today.
- 5:33So before we get started, I'd like to - You need
- 5:36to share a slide, sorry. Oh, thank you so much.
- 5:40Sorry, I forgot to start my slideshow. Thank
- 5:41you. There we go. Okay, there is my contact information.
- 5:51This will also be there at the end, so no worries.
- 5:54Let's start today with a short story about an
- 5:57American businessman named Matthew Mellon. Mr.
- 6:00Mellon was the heir to the Mellon Bank fortune.
- 6:03And famously, about a decade and a half ago,
- 6:06Mr. Mellon turned a $2 million investment in
- 6:08cryptocurrency into more than a billion dollar
- 6:12investment. Sadly, Mr. Melon passed away suddenly
- 6:15and unexpectedly at the age of 54 in April 2018.
- 6:21Now, April 2018 was an interesting time in the
- 6:24crypto space for those who were following it.
- 6:28Let's look first at a chart showing the price
- 6:30of Bitcoin in April 2018. And we're looking at
- 6:33Bitcoin first because at the time Bitcoin was
- 6:35a really strong indicator for how the overall
- 6:37crypto market was performing. As you can see
- 6:40here in April 2018, that was that red arrow on
- 6:43the right side of the screen. That was about
- 6:46four months after Bitcoin had peaked at its then
- 6:48all -time high value of more than $20 ,000 per
- 6:52Bitcoin. But four months later when Mr. Mellon
- 6:54died on April 16th, the value of Bitcoin had
- 6:58plummeted to less than $8 ,000 each, so a 60
- 7:02% decrease in value in just four months of time.
- 7:06And the volatility was just beginning. According
- 7:08to some probate of filings in the estate of Mr.
- 7:10Mellon, the holdings of his estate cryptocurrency
- 7:13continued to fluctuate an additional 30 % from
- 7:17their date of death value in just a matter of
- 7:20a couple of weeks after his death. Now, this
- 7:22is a chart for Bitcoin, but what about the crypto
- 7:25that made up the large bulk of the assets of
- 7:28Mr. Mellon's estate? In April 2018, Mr. Mellon
- 7:33had most of his assets were in a crypto called
- 7:35Ripple. In four months prior to his death, the
- 7:39Average price of Ripple was trading at more than
- 7:42$4 each, but then four months later in April
- 7:462018, they were trading for 65 cents each. So
- 7:49Ripple had lost 83 % of its value in just a few
- 7:53months before Mr. Mellon passed away. So the
- 7:56administrator to be was walking into a situation
- 7:58here where the value of the state assets wasn't
- 8:00just theoretically risky or potentially problematic.
- 8:04It was actually plunging again and again over
- 8:08a matter of weeks and days. some cases hours,
- 8:11so legitimately terrifying stuff from the perspective
- 8:14of a fiduciary or their counsel who might be
- 8:16responsible. And just to make sure this case
- 8:19truly reads like a law school final exam hypo,
- 8:22let's flag a few additional complications that
- 8:24Mr. Mellon left behind. When he died, he had
- 8:27two ex -wives, three children among them, and
- 8:30a long -term girlfriend. He was in the process
- 8:33of changing domiciles from one US state to another
- 8:36before he happened to die abroad in a foreign
- 8:38country. According to an accounting filed in
- 8:41the estate of Mr. Mellon, it's not just that
- 8:43he had a lot of crypto, more than 97 % of the
- 8:46value of his estate was invested in a single
- 8:49cryptocurrency, Ripple. Mr. Mellon also had millions
- 8:53of dollars worth of business and real estate
- 8:55interests that went across the country. And the
- 8:58last time he executed a will, of course, was
- 9:00five years before his death when he was still
- 9:03married to an ex -wife and when most states,
- 9:05including California, where he was domiciled,
- 9:07had no laws on the books regarding digital assets.
- 9:12So just imagine for a moment, a couple other
- 9:15complications there, no tax returns. I mean,
- 9:17just the worst kind of situation to be walking
- 9:19into. Imagine you're named as the personal representative
- 9:23or a potential client comes to you and says that
- 9:25they've been named as the personal representative
- 9:27of their ex -husband's estate that had at one
- 9:30point more than a billion dollars of crypto.
- 9:32How confident are we that we could help navigate
- 9:35that administration without reasonable prospects
- 9:37of liability? Or imagine that a client comes
- 9:40to you now and says that they are currently the
- 9:42trustee of a trust with over several million
- 9:45dollars of crypto. How would we begin to advise
- 9:48that trustee? That brings us to the theme of
- 9:52today's talk, which has two parts. First, things
- 9:55in the blockchain and cryptocurrency space are
- 9:58moving quickly, technologically, economically.
- 10:02a little more slowly legally. So keeping in mind
- 10:05that this is a space that's constantly evolving,
- 10:07I want to help orient you so we know which way
- 10:09is north and so that when a client comes to us
- 10:12with crypto estate planning or admin or litigation
- 10:15questions that we can start to help them spot
- 10:18and work through issues. Today's talk is not
- 10:21about whether cryptocurrencies are sound investments.
- 10:24It's about starting to put together the building
- 10:26blocks so we can be a resource for our clients
- 10:29and either help them or find someone who can
- 10:31after we spot some of these issues. So today's
- 10:34talk is about being prepared. With that in mind,
- 10:38here's a brief overview of the main topics we're
- 10:40going to cover today before we take some questions.
- 10:43First, we'll talk about blockchain and crypto
- 10:45basics. So before we get into the law, we'll
- 10:48speak briefly about what these technologies are
- 10:50and why it's important that we even care about
- 10:52them in the first place. Second, we'll review
- 10:54how folks are investing in blockchain and cryptocurrencies.
- 10:58This will help us understand from an estate planning
- 11:00standpoint, how might these assets even come
- 11:02to be in a trust or estate? Third, we'll go over
- 11:06some high -level estate planning and administration
- 11:08issues, things like how to access a person's
- 11:11crypto post -death, keeping assets safe during
- 11:14administration, and also some vital tax considerations
- 11:18as well. Fourth, we will touch on how California's
- 11:22web of fiduciary duties apply in the context
- 11:25of cryptocurrencies. And then fifth and finally,
- 11:27we'll try to close out by answering some of your
- 11:29questions. So with that, let's turn to our first
- 11:33topic, which is blockchain and crypto basics.
- 11:36What are blockchains and cryptocurrencies? Before
- 11:40we get into that, a quick disclaimer. I don't
- 11:42want to give the false impression that all blockchains
- 11:45and all cryptos are identical or even highly
- 11:48similar or that they all use the same technology,
- 11:51because in truth, there are nuances among blockchains
- 11:54and the types of protocols they use, the types
- 11:57of securities that they utilize, which in turn
- 12:00affect their respective risks and benefits. So
- 12:03for instance, whether a blockchain is open or
- 12:06private, whether it uses proof of stake or proof
- 12:09of work or some other consensus method, these
- 12:13are different axes on which a cryptocurrency
- 12:15or a blockchain asset might differ among another
- 12:18blockchain or crypto assets. So keeping in mind
- 12:21that it's impossible to give a universal definition
- 12:24that is perfectly accurate for all cryptos, let's
- 12:27look at some of the common features that are
- 12:30becoming defining among this type of asset. At
- 12:35its core, a blockchain is basically just a digital
- 12:39ledger of information. Electronic record books
- 12:42that keep track of certain kinds of transactions
- 12:45like sales of goods, transfers of ownership of
- 12:48a parcel of real property, or steps in a supply
- 12:50chain. So, for example, in the same way that...
- 12:53a county recorder's office maintains a ledger
- 12:56of all transactions affecting certain pieces
- 12:59of real property, or in the way that Venmo keeps
- 13:02track of all the debits and credits on your account,
- 13:05blockchains are fundamentally just ledgers of
- 13:08transactions. So blockchain technology isn't
- 13:11really unique in terms of what it does. Instead,
- 13:13what makes blockchain technology unique is how
- 13:16it does what it does. And when done right, blockchains
- 13:20are decentralized or known as distributed. And
- 13:24what that means is that instead of a single master
- 13:26ledger being stored on a single central database
- 13:29at a single location with a single point of failure,
- 13:33blockchain ledgers exist and are maintained across
- 13:37a peer -to -peer network of computers, and each
- 13:41computer or node in that network maintains its
- 13:45own independent copy of the ledger, and the nodes
- 13:49in the network only update their individual ledgers
- 13:52with new transactions once a critical mass of
- 13:56the other nodes in them agree that the new transactions
- 13:59to be added are legitimate. So I don't want to
- 14:02get too bogged down in the details of how new
- 14:04transactions are verified as legitimate. It is
- 14:07absolutely fascinating, but it's not really vital
- 14:09for today's conversation. The important thing
- 14:11to take away about this conceptually is that
- 14:13this approach of decentralizing the ledger across
- 14:17multiple points of failure is arguably the defining
- 14:20feature of blockchain technology. Decentralization
- 14:25also leads blockchains to have several other
- 14:27attributes. Perhaps most fundamentally they are
- 14:30designed to be so inherently resistant to fraud
- 14:33that probabilistically it's just not even worth
- 14:35trying it. So it'd be like trying to crack a
- 14:38safe that has a code that is a hundred digits
- 14:40long. You don't have any idea what that code
- 14:42is and oh by the way that code changes every
- 14:45five minutes or so. So sure theoretically if
- 14:48you spend long enough trying to crack that safe
- 14:50you might stumble into the right answer, but
- 14:54the probability of any one guess being right
- 14:56is so infinitesimally small that it's just not
- 15:00even worth trying. And blockchains essentially
- 15:02accomplish this with computer science and cryptography
- 15:05and by leveraging an entire network of computers
- 15:09that are competing against one another and checking
- 15:11one another's work. Because blockchain technologies
- 15:15are so resistant to fraud, they're said to be
- 15:18trustless. You don't really need to trust or
- 15:21know anything about a person who is sending you
- 15:23Bitcoin for you to have reasonable certainty
- 15:26that the Bitcoin they're sending you is legitimate
- 15:29because the chances that they cheated and created
- 15:32fake Bitcoin to send you is so small that it's
- 15:34not really worth holding your breath for that
- 15:36possibility. Because blockchain transactions
- 15:39are maintained by computers they are relatively
- 15:42instantaneous. Some blockchains confirm new transactions
- 15:46every few seconds. Bitcoin does a new block of
- 15:49transactions every 10 minutes or so. Compare
- 15:53that to how long it might take someone in Los
- 15:55Angeles to wire a big amount of money to someone
- 15:58in rural Asia or Africa. Admittedly, this might
- 16:02not seem like a huge deal to Western folks like
- 16:04us who are used to settling transactions instantly
- 16:07with credit cards and with Zelle and Venmo. But
- 16:11for international businesses, that are settling
- 16:13enormous transactions or for the estimated 20
- 16:17% of the world's population that are unbanked
- 16:19and don't have access to rapid settlement of
- 16:22transactions, the speed and reach of blockchain
- 16:25technologies is really transformative for them
- 16:27in a financial standpoint. Finally, blockchains
- 16:30are said to be resistant to censorship or neutral.
- 16:34Essentially, because blockchains are decentralized
- 16:36and no single authority can direct how those
- 16:39blockchains are to proceed, that means there's
- 16:41no central authority. that can censor or stop
- 16:44certain people from transacting. Contrast that
- 16:46with here in the US, where if you get a court
- 16:48order, a bank account can be frozen, or certain
- 16:51assets in foreign countries might be subject
- 16:53to freezing or forfeiture based on illegitimate
- 16:56government attempts to control citizens. Obviously
- 17:00not something we're used to dealing with here
- 17:01in the States, but thinking about the broader
- 17:04public of the world, why they care. Censorship
- 17:06resistance is actually a pretty important feature.
- 17:09There are several other distinguishing factors
- 17:11for blockchains. They can be public or private,
- 17:14permissioned or permissionless. They can reach
- 17:16consensus in a variety of different ways. I could
- 17:19talk all day about these things, but I want to
- 17:21use our valuable time a little bit more focused
- 17:24on the T &E stuff. But really, I just want to
- 17:26show this again to highlight the fact that not
- 17:28all cryptos are the same, not all blockchains
- 17:30are the same. So we've talked a little bit about
- 17:33what blockchain technologies are. What about
- 17:36cryptocurrencies? In short, cryptocurrencies
- 17:39are applications or programs that use blockchain
- 17:42technology and allow for trading of tokens. So
- 17:46blockchains are the underlying technology or
- 17:49platform that enables the use of a cryptocurrency.
- 17:52Just like you couldn't use email before someone
- 17:54invented the internet, cryptocurrencies weren't
- 17:57really possible before the advent of blockchain
- 17:59technology. Now cryptocurrency tokens that people
- 18:03trade can do various things. Sometimes they're
- 18:05just Units of currency like Bitcoin or Bitcoin
- 18:09cash, but there are some cryptocurrencies that
- 18:12have more advanced features They may represent
- 18:15ownership interests in companies or other going
- 18:18concerns, which may or may not be blockchain
- 18:20related Some tokens permit voting or participation
- 18:23in other kinds of network or company wide decisions
- 18:27some cryptocurrencies even allow a and support
- 18:30what are known as smart contracts, which are
- 18:33self -executing digital contracts written into
- 18:36blockchains like the Ethereum blockchain, which
- 18:38is the second most popular blockchain in existence
- 18:40right now. By way of demonstration, this is sort
- 18:44of how a typical Bitcoin transaction works. Let's
- 18:46say I want to send my friend Billy a Bitcoin
- 18:48So I go to my computer log into my wallet I enter
- 18:52in Billy's public address and how much Bitcoin
- 18:55I want to send then I click the send button that
- 18:58proposed Transaction is then broadcast across
- 19:01the Bitcoin network in a gossip like way over
- 19:04time nodes in the network that validate these
- 19:08transactions, they're called miners, verify that
- 19:12I am who I say I am, I have a Bitcoin to give
- 19:14and the address that I'm sending it to is legitimate.
- 19:17Over time, once a critical mass of those miners
- 19:20authenticate my transaction is valid, it eventually
- 19:23gets batched up into what's known as a block
- 19:26or a group of other transactions. And then over
- 19:29time, those blocks are added to the chain of
- 19:32pre -existing historical blockchain transactions.
- 19:36After that happens, Billy receives his Bitcoin
- 19:40that I transferred to him and he's able to spend
- 19:43it and use it how he sees fit. It's out of my
- 19:45possession. I can no longer control it. That's
- 19:48typically how this works. Why should we care
- 19:52about blockchain and crypto? Why should anyone
- 19:54care, right? Isn't this just the next fad like
- 19:57pogs in the 1980s or teeny beanie babies in the
- 20:0090s or tulips in the mid 1600s Holland for those
- 20:04of the history fans out there? Rather than try
- 20:07to convince people or explain the various hypothetical
- 20:10and actual use cases for thousands of cryptos
- 20:12and blockchain technologies. Let's do something
- 20:15different. Let's just look at some data for a
- 20:16moment. Adoption is a key metric that tells us
- 20:20whether a user base for some new technology is
- 20:23growing. One way to look at the number is to
- 20:27look at the number of people and entities, new
- 20:30people over time coming into the use of this
- 20:33technology, the growth. These graphs show the
- 20:36number of users over time on the three largest
- 20:39crypto exchanges operating in the US, Coinbase,
- 20:42Binance, and Kraken. I had trouble finding clean
- 20:45versions of these graphs extending into the last
- 20:48year. I recognize they're a year outdated, but
- 20:50these are well in line with what we've seen over
- 20:53the last year and a half. Over time, we're seeing
- 20:56the last decade or so, steady, consistent growth
- 21:00in the adoption by users and institutions of
- 21:04blockchain and cryptocurrencies. This data is
- 21:08also consistent with what we're seeing worldwide
- 21:09as well, which is a growth steady and consistent
- 21:13growth by users, rich and poor, and countries
- 21:16large and small. Another metric we can look at
- 21:20is what's known as on -chain metrics. This one
- 21:23in particular is the number of transactions per
- 21:26day. When we look at the volume of Bitcoin transactions
- 21:29today, which is what we see in this chart here,
- 21:31we see, for instance, that Again, the growth
- 21:34over time and the number of transactions that
- 21:36this network is supporting is significant. And
- 21:39although we are not quite as high as we were
- 21:41at the end of last year in terms of daily transactions,
- 21:45we're still hovering between 300 and 500 ,000
- 21:48Bitcoin transactions being confirmed per day,
- 21:51which is remarkable. Ethereum, the number two
- 21:55cryptocurrency by market cap, looks similar and
- 21:58in fact has remained relatively steady since
- 22:01it shot up in 2021. It's less susceptible to
- 22:04the whims of the market. A lot of transactions,
- 22:07a lot of business is being done on the Ethereum
- 22:09network right now, in part because it is supportive
- 22:12of these smart contracts. As of today, I think
- 22:15there are about 1 .3 million transactions on
- 22:17the Ethereum network per day, which is up about
- 22:1915 % from a year ago. Here's another graph that
- 22:23shows the market capitalization or the market
- 22:26cap of all crypto So all crypto is in existence
- 22:29multiplied by their respective value and then
- 22:32aggregated and this graph shows us that we eclipsed
- 22:37two trillion dollars last year and that we've
- 22:39been in the three trillion dollar market cap
- 22:42range for most of this year, so As of today,
- 22:45Bitcoin is the sixth largest asset in the world
- 22:48by market cap, coming in just after Microsoft,
- 22:52Apple and Amazon, and right before Alphabet,
- 22:55Google and Silver. Now, why do these graphs show
- 22:59us that we should care? I would submit that they
- 23:02show us that these are not just fads like pogs
- 23:06and teeny beanie babies. These aren't assets
- 23:08that have a meteoric rise in popularity and then
- 23:12plummet to non -existence shortly thereafter.
- 23:15Instead, we're noticing that these assets have
- 23:17some staying power and that they, over the course
- 23:19of the last decade and a half now, not all of
- 23:22them, but many of them have hung around. Maybe
- 23:26they're not going away anytime soon, and as a
- 23:29result of that, maybe we should be familiarized
- 23:31with what these things are to some degree so
- 23:33that we're not caught totally flat -footed. Specifically,
- 23:37why should trusts and estates and fiduciaries
- 23:39care about this kind of stuff, attorneys and
- 23:41the fiduciaries that we represent? I'll go back
- 23:44to that graph from a few minutes ago, which shows
- 23:46that the number of users over time on major crypto
- 23:50exchanges in the US is growing. And so the bottom
- 23:53line is that whether or not we think these are
- 23:55sound investments, we are seeing an increased
- 23:58likelihood that decedents in the US and California
- 24:01are going to have some amount of cryptocurrency
- 24:03in their estate or trust. And so that As a result
- 24:07of that, it's our responsibility as the attorneys
- 24:09and folks guiding the administration of these
- 24:12trusts and estates to be familiar with these
- 24:14things. So quick recap, blockchains or blockchain
- 24:18technology are just digital decentralized ledgers
- 24:21of information. Cryptocurrencies are tokens that
- 24:25can be traded and that use leverage blockchain
- 24:28technology. And finally, adoption is increasing,
- 24:31so we want to be prepared. We've talked a little
- 24:36bit about what blockchain and crypto are and
- 24:38why we should care. So let's talk now about the
- 24:41ways in which these digital assets might appear
- 24:44in someone's estates. Although most of us are
- 24:47familiar with the concept of buying and selling
- 24:50directly, that's not really the only way that
- 24:53we're seeing folks investing in these things.
- 24:56So first and foremost, of course, is the people
- 24:59going and buying and selling cryptos directly
- 25:01on exchanges. These are online websites where
- 25:04you can buy, sell, trade, and transfer crypto
- 25:06using all kinds of fiat currency like US dollars,
- 25:11euros, and other things to fund those purchases.
- 25:14This is a screenshot of what Coinbase looked
- 25:16like several years ago. In fact, you can see
- 25:19I proposed to a fake transaction one Bitcoin
- 25:22at the time was trading for $4 ,201. I think
- 25:26as of today, it was like $117 ,000 per. I don't
- 25:29think I've made this purchase here, but this
- 25:31shows you what it looks like. In the same way
- 25:33that you might go into your brokerage account
- 25:34and enter buy and sell orders for stocks, you
- 25:36can go on an exchange, enter buy and sell orders
- 25:39for crypto and fund it with a wire transfer or
- 25:42a credit card or with funds that you've transferred
- 25:44and deposited with that account. And then a couple
- 25:47moments later, you're the proud owner of a new
- 25:49cryptocurrency. Another way people are buying
- 25:52and selling cryptos directly is at these specialized
- 25:55crypto ATMs. A decade ago, there were only a
- 25:58few hundred of these across the world, most of
- 26:01which only allowed the buying and selling of
- 26:03Bitcoin. But over the last decade, really, they've
- 26:06been exploding in popularity. Today in the US,
- 26:09there are between 25 ,000 and 30 ,000 of these
- 26:11crypto ATMs, and they allow buying, selling,
- 26:14transferring, trading of all kinds of crypto,
- 26:17not just Bitcoin. Developing countries in particular,
- 26:20like Latin America, have seen explosive growth
- 26:22in the use of crypto ATMs, especially because
- 26:26they help international transfers. They remove
- 26:29a lot of the friction on those sorts of things.
- 26:31Another way people are directly owning cryptos
- 26:33is when new cryptos are minted in what are known
- 26:36as initial coin offerings or ICOs similar to
- 26:39an initial public offering or an IPO of a company.
- 26:42Sometimes select investors get access to a coin
- 26:44before it goes public and so this is another
- 26:47way where you might get access to a crypto in
- 26:49your portfolio. There are indirect ways to gain
- 26:52exposure to crypto that a lot of people are using.
- 26:55One way is that people are buying and selling
- 26:58companies, stocks, and exchange traded funds
- 27:01whose values are pegged to cryptocurrency. So
- 27:04here we have an example of the Grayscale Bitcoin
- 27:06Investment Trust, which was one of the longer
- 27:09running publicly traded assets whose value was
- 27:13pegged to the value of Bitcoin. Over the last
- 27:15year, we've had the approval of ETFs in the US
- 27:18for spot Bitcoin. You no longer have to deal
- 27:21with the issue of custody and keeping your private
- 27:24keys and passwords all secure. You can just invest
- 27:27in publicly traded companies who deal with all
- 27:29that for you, and you pay a slight premium as
- 27:32a result of the costs and other issues that are
- 27:34associated with that. There are other more advanced
- 27:38trades I'll flag briefly, not because they're
- 27:40advisable, but just so that you're aware that
- 27:42they're out there. Some exchanges allow for more
- 27:44advanced trading of crypto. For instance, they'll
- 27:47let you short Bitcoin or other cryptos. And since
- 27:51December 2017, people have also been able to
- 27:53invest in crypto futures. And so instead of trading
- 27:56on the value of what Bitcoin or other cryptos
- 27:58are today, you could trade based on what you
- 28:00think it'll be a month from now. Many exchanges
- 28:03also allow margin trading, again, not advisable.
- 28:06or prudent, but someone can invest and risk more
- 28:10crypto than they actually own to try to amplify
- 28:13their gains. And if their bet goes the wrong
- 28:16way, then their account gets liquidated in a
- 28:18margin call. I don't flag these because they're
- 28:22a good idea. Merely to flag that they exist and
- 28:25that to the extent a decedent dies with these
- 28:27kinds of assets, that will be something to clean
- 28:30up, of course. And while they're certainly less
- 28:33popular now than a year or two ago, I want to
- 28:35flag NFTs and confirm that they're still a thing.
- 28:39NFTs are non -fungible tokens or digital assets
- 28:42that are unique and hence non -fungible. Most
- 28:45cryptos are fungible. It doesn't matter which
- 28:47Bitcoin you have. They're all worth the same
- 28:49amount. But NFTs are different. By purchasing
- 28:52them, you're typically acquiring ownership of
- 28:54digital or other real world items like art or
- 28:57trading cards like crypto kitties. On the one
- 29:00hand, it seems crazy. Why would anyone pay any
- 29:02amount of money for an NFT of Jack Dorsey's first
- 29:07tweet when you can just go and take a screenshot
- 29:09of it for yourself and it's free? But on the
- 29:12other hand, I think people could make the same
- 29:13argument for famous paintings or trading cards
- 29:16or all sorts of other things that humans ascribe
- 29:18value to. Don't take my word for why people care.
- 29:22At one point, this is what the trading volume
- 29:25on OpenSea looked like. OpenSea is one of the
- 29:28world's largest NFT trading platforms. Over the
- 29:31course of 2021, we saw explosive growth in the
- 29:35number of unique buyers on OpenSea. Some of this
- 29:38may have not been legitimate, of course, but...
- 29:40Then again, we also saw a precipitous drop off
- 29:43in volume of NFT trades since 2021. We can see
- 29:48now that there is an embarrassingly small amount
- 29:51of NFTs being traded. So maybe this is the example
- 29:54of POGs or something that's been more of a fad
- 29:57than a long -term asset. I would say that while
- 30:01NFTs themselves maybe aren't as popular as they
- 30:03used to be, maybe we're less likely to see them
- 30:04now, I think they are emblematic of the fact
- 30:07that digital assets are not just limited to cryptocurrencies.
- 30:10Cryptocurrencies are certainly the most popular,
- 30:12but there are other non -crypto assets out there
- 30:15that may find their way into estates over time,
- 30:17depending on the whims of what the market says
- 30:21is popular or not. Okay, so before we move on
- 30:24quick recap about how people are buying and selling
- 30:27Certainly direct buying and selling of cryptos
- 30:29remains the most common But the number of investment
- 30:32vehicles by which one can indirectly invest in
- 30:35crypto are increasing And lastly advanced trades
- 30:38are available Less commonly used sure but they
- 30:43you know, maybe gateways to massive losses And
- 30:45so we want to make sure we check on those things
- 30:47and lastly NFTs and other non crypto digital
- 30:50assets do exist So we want to check for them
- 30:53Okay, so we've talked about what blockchain and
- 30:56crypto are how those investments might show up
- 30:59in the context of trust in estates Now let's
- 31:01talk about some key estate planning and administration
- 31:04Considerations and I want to talk specifically
- 31:07about three things today ensuring post -death
- 31:11access, safekeeping in custody, and of course
- 31:14preparing for taxes. So starting first with ensuring
- 31:18access. Making sure that someone can obtain access
- 31:21to crypto is of paramount importance. That typically
- 31:25entails keeping track of usernames, passwords,
- 31:28accounts, wallets, where they might be online
- 31:31or... If you have devices that are holding wallets,
- 31:34that as well. If someone's preparing a will or
- 31:39a trust or otherwise preparing to pass on responsibility
- 31:42for crypto assets, they need to ensure that that
- 31:45successor fiduciary has access to all of those
- 31:47login details. Otherwise, they won't be able
- 31:50to get access to any of that stuff. There may
- 31:53be two -factor authentication involved. Depending
- 31:57on the transition involved, it could be complicated.
- 32:00Ideally, an estate planner is helping them out
- 32:02with those sorts of things, including by considering
- 32:04a grant of Rufata rights to access digital accounts.
- 32:10It's sort of beyond the scope of today, but essentially,
- 32:12you can grant your successor fiduciary rights
- 32:15with respect to accessing emails and authenticating
- 32:18things that might be helpful here. And then we
- 32:21need to make sure that we guard that information
- 32:23against unwanted eyes. If someone were to stumble
- 32:26across a document that had usernames, passwords,
- 32:30login information, account location. That's all
- 32:33they would need to loot those funds and potentially
- 32:36take them away forever. So if someone is smart,
- 32:39we're not just going to have the password of
- 32:42the keys to the kingdom in our desk. We would
- 32:44think about putting it somewhere like a fire
- 32:46safe or in a safe deposit box. At the same time,
- 32:50we want to try to break up that information so
- 32:52that there's not one central point of failure.
- 32:56And we want to make that easy to update. We don't
- 32:58want to put it in a position where the fiduciary
- 33:01has to go through 100 steps just to get access
- 33:03to and update that information. it's vital that
- 33:08we think about this. And as the attorneys representing
- 33:11them, of course, we don't want access to any
- 33:13of this information. We don't want to have received
- 33:15a copy of the names and passwords and login information
- 33:18because then if something happens to that account,
- 33:20we may be part of a small group of people who
- 33:22had access to the information that was needed
- 33:24to do that. And so it's not our job to get involved
- 33:28in handing off that information, but we, of course,
- 33:31do as the attorneys want to make sure that a
- 33:33process is in place by which that information
- 33:36can be transferred. Here's an example of how
- 33:40failing to ensure access can go horribly wrong.
- 33:43Several years ago, the CEO of one of Canada's
- 33:45biggest crypto exchanges, Quadriga CX, died at
- 33:49age 30 without providing anyone the password
- 33:52to the exchange's cold wallets of crypto. That,
- 33:55in turn, caused more than $137 million worth
- 33:58of crypto to be lost irretrievably forever. I'm
- 34:02sure that number is far higher today based on
- 34:04what current values are. But suffice it to say
- 34:07that if an state planner or a fiduciary were
- 34:10somehow responsible for that password log information
- 34:13being lost, the liability could be unimaginably
- 34:17high. So again, we don't want that information
- 34:19coming into our possession, but we do want to
- 34:22make sure that processes are in place for that
- 34:24to be transitions to this accessor. One way to
- 34:28help prevent access issues is by using multi
- 34:31-signature accounts or M of N accounts. Most
- 34:35crypto transactions are single signature transactions,
- 34:38which means that you just need one person to
- 34:40enter one password or a private key to initiate
- 34:44or sign a crypto transaction. But many cryptos,
- 34:47including Bitcoin, support more complicated transactions
- 34:50than that, including ones that require signatures
- 34:53or private keys of multiple people before funds
- 34:56can be unlocked and moved. So these multi -sig
- 34:59wallets are a great way to ensure access. Maybe
- 35:02you do a two of three wallet. Maybe you do a
- 35:04three of five wallet where you have a larger
- 35:07number of people each receiving unique passwords.
- 35:10And that way if something happens to one or two
- 35:12of them, you've got backup folks in place who
- 35:14together with other trusted individuals could
- 35:16still get access to that account. So for instance,
- 35:22if you had a two of three account, a multi -sig
- 35:26account that only needed two of three people
- 35:28to enter a password, you could conceivably have
- 35:30a husband, a wife, and their estate planner each
- 35:33take one of those three passwords. Again, we're
- 35:36not going to accept this as lawyers, but that
- 35:39would be a breakup. You could do it among three
- 35:41kids. If you have two children and two parents,
- 35:45you could do a three of five account where at
- 35:48least two survivors plus the estate planner or
- 35:50someone else some other trusted individual needs
- 35:52to be involved. That way we don't have a single
- 35:54point of failure where someone with a password
- 35:56dies and crypto is lost irretrievably. Safekeeping
- 36:01and custody is a really big issue during administration.
- 36:05As we discussed a few moments ago, cold storage
- 36:07wallets are really common and probably a best
- 36:11practice. A cold storage wallet is an offline
- 36:14wallet that holds crypto funds. So with cold
- 36:17storage, the wallet is stored on a platform that
- 36:20doesn't have a hot internet connection. And that
- 36:22in turn prevents you from unwanted cyber attacks
- 36:25or hacks or other vulnerabilities from a system
- 36:27that is constantly connected to the internet.
- 36:30Hardware wallets are similar to a cold storage
- 36:33wallet, except the difference is you need to
- 36:35connect a piece of hardware and unlock it before
- 36:38you can access your account. Usually it's a thumb
- 36:40drive device like you can see on the screen here.
- 36:42This is a Trezor. It's a really common hardware
- 36:45wallet. You plug it into your computer and in
- 36:47addition to logging in and using your private
- 36:49key or password to log in, you also separately
- 36:52need to unlock this device sort of in its own
- 36:55multi -signature account. It also need to be
- 36:57unlocked for you to get access to those. ones.
- 37:00Honestly, though, for large concentrations of
- 37:02crypto, which I know is the principal topic of
- 37:04today, I think you're probably going to want
- 37:06to look into using a professional crypto custodian.
- 37:09As the financial ecosystem has evolved in this
- 37:12space, has evolved in the last few years, we've
- 37:14seen the emergence of professional custodians
- 37:17who use state -of -the -art security and best
- 37:20practices for cold storage and have all kinds
- 37:23of other features that they offer as well step
- 37:25into this space and start to offer their resources
- 37:28to folks like We've seen with these ETFs, there's
- 37:32a huge amount of investment companies and other
- 37:34publicly traded companies that are now holding
- 37:36crypto. Professional custodians are stepping
- 37:38into that space and at the same time, Trust in
- 37:41estates, folks like us are having access to broader
- 37:45and broader suites of options for professional
- 37:47custody on the estate and trust level. So much
- 37:50lower than, you know, Black Rock's investment
- 37:52funds. But, you know, we now have the ability
- 37:55as lawyers and fiduciaries of crypto estates
- 37:58to go out and get an honest to God professional
- 38:01handling this stuff. Whereas for a long time,
- 38:03we really our fiduciaries had to white knuckle
- 38:05it themselves in a way that was just not good
- 38:08from a risk management standpoint. So There's
- 38:11no bright line test. If you have this much crypto,
- 38:15you must go get a professional custodian below
- 38:17this amount. You shouldn't do it. But I would
- 38:20say that once you start having between the low
- 38:22and mid six figures and crypto assets under management,
- 38:26the peace of mind and the security that you'll
- 38:28get from using a professional custodian is probably
- 38:30worth that. As one example of how custody can
- 38:35go horribly wrong, I'd like to tell the story
- 38:37of the British IT engineer who in 2013 accidentally
- 38:41threw away an old computer hard drive that had
- 38:44a wallet on his desktop with about 7 ,500 Bitcoin
- 38:48on it. Today, that's approximately $877 million
- 38:52worth of Bitcoin that this guy just accidentally
- 38:55threw away. poor guy has gone to the local city
- 39:01council multiple times, has petitioned, he's
- 39:04filed legal actions, trying to get permission
- 39:06to excavate the local landfill to try to find
- 39:10and recover this hard drive. He's proposed using
- 39:12all kinds of technologies to scan the landfill,
- 39:15but he continues to lose and it doesn't look
- 39:18like there's any prospect of those funds being
- 39:20found. So suffice it to say that if a fiduciary
- 39:23is responsible for something like this, the financial
- 39:25exposure could be incredible. Another pitfall
- 39:29involves leaving one's crypto on an exchange.
- 39:33Leaving your crypto on an exchange is actually
- 39:35super risky because the funds there generally
- 39:38are not really in your control. They're actually
- 39:40held and managed and controlled by whatever exchange
- 39:43or company you've invested them with. The term
- 39:46in the crypto community is not your keys, not
- 39:48your crypto. If you need some other company to
- 39:52authorize your transaction like Coinbase or someone
- 39:55else, that's not really crypto in your possession
- 39:57or custody. So imagine you're one of the users
- 40:00of Quadriga CX, that Canadian exchange where
- 40:03the CEO died without providing the password for
- 40:06over $137 million in crypto. If those funds disappeared,
- 40:11you might not be made whole from your deposits
- 40:13anymore. And the same thing happened in 2013
- 40:16with Mt. Gox or Magic the Gathering Online. At
- 40:20one point, Magic the Gathering Online was doing
- 40:2270 % of all of the worldwide volume of Bitcoin
- 40:25trades up until... somebody realized at one point
- 40:29that approximately 650 ,000 Bitcoin had slowly
- 40:33been looted, unknown to anyone, from Magic the
- 40:36Gathering online. And one day that was revealed
- 40:39and that caused a multi -year crypto bear market.
- 40:42Suffice it to say that's a perfect example of
- 40:44why we don't want to leave our assets on a crypto
- 40:46exchange because not your keys, not your crypto,
- 40:49you could lose everything. Let's talk about taxes
- 40:52briefly, everyone's favorite topic. First, this
- 40:56should come as a surprise, hopefully to no one
- 40:58here, but you do have to pay taxes on your crypto.
- 41:02I've noticed it's really common for folks to
- 41:05think that because crypto has anonymity or pseudonymity,
- 41:09where you can't really tell who it is that's
- 41:11transacting without doing a little bit of work,
- 41:13that that means they don't ever have to pay taxes
- 41:15and no one's ever going to catch them. Don't
- 41:17let your clients be one of those people who think
- 41:19they can get away with it because they probably
- 41:21won't. The clearest tax guidance we have on crypto
- 41:24from the IRS is in IRS Notice 2014 -21, which
- 41:30is the starting point for any lawyer who wants
- 41:31to understand crypto taxes. And IRS Notice 2014
- 41:35-21 clarifies that for tax purposes, digital
- 41:39currencies like cryptos are property, not currency.
- 41:43So that means the familiar short and long -term
- 41:46gain rules apply to purchases and sales of crypto.
- 41:50Let's take a quick hypothetical. Your client
- 41:52buys a Bitcoin, holds it for 364 days, and then
- 41:57sells it. Because they held that Bitcoin for
- 42:00less than a year. They would owe short -term
- 42:02capital gains taxes on any increase in value
- 42:05So if the Bitcoin grew in value from you know
- 42:08$1 ,000 to $2 ,500 over those 364 days that your
- 42:13client would owe short -term capital gains taxes
- 42:15on that $1 ,500 increase On the other hand, if
- 42:19your client held that Bitcoin for more than a
- 42:21year before selling it, they would owe long -term
- 42:24capital gains taxes on that $1 ,500 increase
- 42:27in value. Another thing we learned from IRS notice
- 42:312014 -21 is that All crypto transactions are
- 42:35taxable events. So it's not just when you buy
- 42:38and sell crypto or when you sell crypto for US
- 42:40dollars that are taxable events. Even if you
- 42:43go to a coffee shop and they let you, you know,
- 42:45swipe your Bitcoin wallet and use Bitcoin to
- 42:48pay for a copy. Coffee, that is a taxable event.
- 42:52It is as if you sold that Bitcoin for US dollars
- 42:55and then use those US dollars to buy that coffee.
- 42:58You owe whatever the capital gains taxes are
- 43:02on the increase in value of that Bitcoin that
- 43:05was sold for the US dollars to buy that coffee.
- 43:08So very aggressive in terms of all transactions
- 43:10being taxable events. Don't be people, you don't
- 43:14want your clients to be the folks who think trading
- 43:16cryptos aren't taxable events or this isn't a
- 43:18taxable event. Odds are everything is a taxable
- 43:22event when it comes to crypto transactions. In
- 43:252019 the IRS released additional guidance in
- 43:29IRS notice 2019 -24. Among other things, notice
- 43:332019 -24 clarified that FIFO is the standard
- 43:38default basis way for calculating basis in crypto.
- 43:42FIFO being first in first out unless a taxpayer
- 43:47can specifically identify and can prove what
- 43:49the tax basis was for a specific crypto sold.
- 43:53So let's take a hypothetical and see how that
- 43:55would rear its head. Let's say your client buys
- 43:57a Bitcoin two years ago for ten thousand dollars.
- 44:01And then yesterday, they buy a second Bitcoin
- 44:04for $120 ,000. And then tomorrow, they sell one
- 44:09Bitcoin for $130 ,000. How much in taxes would
- 44:13they owe? Under 2019 -24's guidance, FIFO controls
- 44:18first in, first out. And the default presumption
- 44:22is that you sold the first one you bought. Two
- 44:25years ago and so it would the basis for that
- 44:28would be ten thousand dollars and you would owe
- 44:30taxes on the hundred and twenty thousand dollar
- 44:32gain from ten thousand to one hundred and thirty
- 44:35thousand the On the other hand, if you can show
- 44:40that the Bitcoin you sold tomorrow was actually
- 44:43the one you bought yesterday, you would owe $120
- 44:46,000. That would be your tax basis, and you would
- 44:49only owe the $10 ,000, the taxes on the $10 ,000
- 44:52gain. So this does have the potential. This method
- 44:56of calculating basis has potentially huge ramifications
- 44:59on tax bills that are ultimately calculated.
- 45:01And under 2019 -24, you have to use FIFO unless
- 45:05the taxpayer can specifically identify. IRS notice
- 45:102019 -24 confirmed a few other things that are
- 45:15more bespoke, but which may affect your particular
- 45:17holdings, including how hard forks. are taxable
- 45:21events, but soft forks aren't, rules about deducting
- 45:24charitable contributions. I won't get lost in
- 45:26the weeds in that, but definitely important to
- 45:28look at if those are things coming across your
- 45:30desk. Lastly, I want to flag a really interesting
- 45:33IRS revenue procedure ruling that came out last
- 45:36year, caused a lot of chaos, only to end up having
- 45:39its implementation effectively deferred for a
- 45:41year until the end of this year. So in short,
- 45:44IRS revenue procedure 2014 -28 did a couple things.
- 45:49First, it confirmed the tax basis must not only
- 45:52be calculated using FIFO as a default rule, but
- 45:56must be calculated on a wallet by wallet basis.
- 46:00So what that means is that before what was commonly
- 46:03done is taxpayers essentially aggregated all
- 46:05the crypto that they bought and then divided
- 46:07the basis evenly among them. And so if you owned
- 46:10one Bitcoin that cost you $100 ,000 and another
- 46:14Bitcoin that cost you $50 ,000, then you sold
- 46:17a Bitcoin, you could combine those bases and
- 46:20say that the one you sold is half of that combined
- 46:22basis. But under this new revenue procedure from
- 46:262014 -28, 24 -28, you no longer are able to do
- 46:33that. Instead, you have to look at the actual
- 46:36basis of the crypto in that wallet and then determine
- 46:40what the cost basis is from that. This was devastating
- 46:44for lots of taxpayers and it caused such an uproar
- 46:48that they essentially immediately came out with
- 46:50guidance saying that this no longer is going
- 46:53into effect until the end of this year. The other
- 46:56thing that the IRS revenue procedure 2024 -28
- 47:00did is it created a safe harbor procedure. Because
- 47:04this was causing such a significant change in
- 47:06the way taxes were done, the IRS Allows people
- 47:11to make a one -time allocation of basis among
- 47:15all of the crypto that's in their possession
- 47:17as of a certain snapshot in time. The snapshot
- 47:20in time was originally as of the end of last
- 47:22year. That snapshot in time has been extended
- 47:25basically to the end of this year under a subsequent
- 47:27revenue procedure. But essentially, you have
- 47:30one last chance to take advantage of the way
- 47:32the rules used to be. And then from that point
- 47:34forward, we are going to be in this land where
- 47:37basis is not only going to be default FIFO, but
- 47:39also on an account by account or wallet by wallet
- 47:42basis. Let's talk briefly about best practices
- 47:47for taxes. First and foremost, please make sure
- 47:50the fiduciaries are keeping good records of all
- 47:52crypto transactions. Thankfully, we have a lot
- 47:55of API -based services now that can plug in directly
- 47:59to Coinbase or all of these other wallets and
- 48:02pull transaction data, calculate what your taxes
- 48:05are, and give you a pretty good estimate for
- 48:07a lot of this. But that's not necessarily...
- 48:10always the case, depending on which exchanges
- 48:12or wallets are being used. So you can't always
- 48:15bank on them. And just for your own purposes,
- 48:17you probably want to have backup records. And
- 48:19so I would recommend keeping track any time crypto
- 48:22assets are sold or transferred, you know, the
- 48:25date, the time, the exchange, the price in crypto
- 48:27and fiat, you know, fees. These are all things
- 48:30that are going to feed into the tax calculations
- 48:32at the end of the year. And you can use the API
- 48:34based automatic stuff to double check your work.
- 48:37But I would want to have that as well. Another
- 48:40thing we want to do is monitor taxable gains
- 48:43and losses throughout the year so that we're
- 48:46not caught flat -footed in tax season. We'll
- 48:49talk in a moment about how that can go wrong.
- 48:51We want to keep an eye on that. We don't want
- 48:53to have no idea what our taxes are going to be
- 48:55until the new year has started, when we no longer
- 48:58have a chance to mitigate it. And then, of course,
- 49:01we want to make sure that we're in constant contact
- 49:04with our tax professional. And not only that,
- 49:06but our tax professional is competent and fluent
- 49:09in cryptocurrencies. There are a ton of great
- 49:11tax folks out there who just have not had a chance
- 49:14to really become experts on the crypto space
- 49:16yet. And so they have to learn a lot of the stuff
- 49:19on the fly. If you're in a situation where you've
- 49:22got a large concentration of trust or estate
- 49:24crypto, I think you want to spend the extra money
- 49:27to go out and find someone who's fluent in this
- 49:29stuff and knows how to calculate these transactions,
- 49:32knows which forms to populate, knows what kind
- 49:34of backup information, knows what kind of audit
- 49:36questions they might get. I think they are going
- 49:39to be easily worth the extra effort there. Now
- 49:44in terms of how this can go wrong. I like to
- 49:46point back to what happened in December 2017
- 49:49At that time that was when bitcoins value jumped
- 49:52up to $20 ,000 for the first time and the run
- 49:55-up to it was insane It was every single person
- 49:58who threw money at Bitcoin was making money at
- 50:00this time And so people kept investing and investing
- 50:03and then all of a sudden in January 2018 the
- 50:05prices of Bitcoin plummeted but at that point
- 50:09all of the prior year's transactions and taxable
- 50:12gains had accrued. People all of a sudden owed
- 50:15enormous tax bills in April 2018, but the crypto
- 50:19market had fallen so much that their assets weren't
- 50:21even worth all of the taxes that they owed. A
- 50:25ton of people had to sell everything, had to
- 50:28realize enormous losses just to pay taxes from
- 50:33all of these transactions that were happening
- 50:35when the market was great. maybe they should
- 50:38have taken out, they should have realized some
- 50:40gains, set aside some funds to make sure that
- 50:43they had funds set aside to pay tax bills in
- 50:45the next year. These are the kinds of reasons
- 50:47why you want to make sure that you're keeping
- 50:49an eye on what the taxable gains are going to
- 50:51be for next year. Again, if a fiduciary is responsible
- 50:55for something like this, it could be enormous
- 50:58liability. We don't want to let that happen to
- 51:00our fiduciaries. There are a number of other
- 51:03crypto -specific administration issues that might
- 51:06come up. We don't have time to cover all of them
- 51:08today. Many of these were mentioned in the estate
- 51:11of Mellon filings though, and I thought they
- 51:13were interesting, so I at least wanted to put
- 51:14them on your radar just to give you a sense of
- 51:16the kind of messes that you could be called in
- 51:18to clean up if there's a large concentration
- 51:20of crypto in a trust or estate. Okay, last substantive
- 51:24topic of the day, and that's fiduciary duties.
- 51:26We will talk about investment duties in a moment,
- 51:30but starting first with general fiduciary duties,
- 51:32we know that trustees must first and foremost
- 51:35administer the trust according to its terms.
- 51:37They must also act with reasonable care, skill,
- 51:42and caution that a prudent trustee would use.
- 51:45If an expert is involved, they're going to be
- 51:47held to a higher standard. This is basic boilerplate
- 51:49stuff. But what about when we get into the Uniform
- 51:52Prudent Investor Act? There we've got some heightened
- 51:55duties. Again, we're looking at the reasonably
- 51:57prudent investor standard, but there are certain
- 52:00specific - burdens that we take on in managing
- 52:03investments. The trustee must evaluate decisions
- 52:06about investments, not just in isolation, but
- 52:09looking broadly at the overall portfolio. They
- 52:12have to look not only at their own investment
- 52:14decisions, but they need to look at inception
- 52:16assets, investments that were made by the prior
- 52:18trustee or whoever was in charge of these assets.
- 52:22And while they can delegate some of these investment
- 52:24functions, they remain responsible for the performance
- 52:27of these assets if they're not properly overseeing
- 52:30them. So what does that entail here? We have
- 52:34to gather information about specific factors
- 52:36set forth in the probate code, things like purposes,
- 52:39terms, distribution requirements, and circumstances
- 52:42of the trust. And there's eight other factors,
- 52:45of course, that the UPA requires us to look at
- 52:47and gather information about in making investment
- 52:51decisions. Those things include general economic
- 52:54conditions, effective inflation or deflation,
- 52:57potential tax consequences, some additional items
- 53:00as well here. And so by statute, trustees are
- 53:04supposed to be looking at all of these factors
- 53:06and trying to navigate how they might align with
- 53:09the underlying investment portfolio. And where
- 53:12the underlying assets don't align with these
- 53:15factors, they should be thinking about how to
- 53:17change those investments so that they do. What
- 53:20are some best practices in this standpoint? Number
- 53:23one, we have to not only gather that information
- 53:26or make sure that whoever our delegate is gathering
- 53:28that information, but also documenting that information.
- 53:33And we'll get to a moment in diversifying. So
- 53:35again, gathering information about blockchain
- 53:38and crypto investments isn't easy. There's a
- 53:40lot of them out there and all of them look really
- 53:43enticing. The true fact is that most of them
- 53:46are probably scams. Even if they're not outright
- 53:49Ponzi schemes or money laundering enterprises,
- 53:52most cryptos have virtually no benefits over
- 53:55those that are already in existence. They're
- 53:57just a cash grab. They're the equivalent of pets
- 54:00.com during the dot com bubble. And so, you know,
- 54:03we do need to do our research on this and not
- 54:05just take people at their word when they say
- 54:07this is going to be the next new Bitcoin. This
- 54:09is super Bitcoin. You're going to be 10 times
- 54:11richer than if you'd held Bitcoin here. In doing
- 54:15that research, got to document it here. We don't
- 54:18want to be in the position of having to reconstruct
- 54:20supporting investment analysis after the fact,
- 54:24and especially in a place like crypto, where
- 54:27assets are extremely volatile and risky and where
- 54:29there's just so much fraud and mismanagement
- 54:32by underlying crypto projects. This is a place
- 54:36where you almost can't put too much effort in.
- 54:39So I would say not only does a fiduciary want
- 54:41to have data compiled in a report that they're
- 54:44reviewing and deciding how to handle a crypto
- 54:47investment, but a lot of times, especially with
- 54:51large concentrations, they're going to want to
- 54:52check in with the beneficiaries about that. If
- 54:55you have a situation where a settler dies with
- 54:58a huge portfolio of trust assets. The trustee
- 55:01may not want to take on the risk of keeping those
- 55:03assets largely over invested in crypto, but maybe
- 55:07the beneficiaries will want that. I think that's
- 55:09a perfect situation where a report from an investment
- 55:13advisor can set forth the potential risks. Sure,
- 55:17there's some benefits, but here are all the risks.
- 55:20Here's why the trustee doesn't think that it's
- 55:22prudent to keep all these assets invested in
- 55:24crypto. Again, I think the more writing and paper
- 55:27you have, whether you share it with the beneficiaries
- 55:29or not, is going to bolster your defense if someone
- 55:32later tries to say that there was an imprudent
- 55:33allocation of crypto. The third and final practice
- 55:40I want to flag here is diversification. We need
- 55:43to make sure that crypto assets are diversified.
- 55:46We have to insist on it. And again, there's a
- 55:49lot of folks who, people who are investing in
- 55:52cryptocurrencies aren't always the most prudent
- 55:54investors. They're not, you know, carefully allocating
- 55:57investments in a way that's, you know, up to
- 55:59what the standards might be. But if success or
- 56:02fiduciary doesn't have that luxury, if you're
- 56:05a trustee coming in, It doesn't matter if your
- 56:07settler made a bunch of really risky bets on
- 56:10crypto and thought that was great. If you're
- 56:12called in to manage those assets, you need to
- 56:15start thinking about what's prudent. And if the
- 56:18inception assets, the existing assets when they
- 56:20come in aren't prudent, you need to think about
- 56:22diversifying. And so one of the big problems
- 56:25we face in diversification with crypto is that
- 56:28essentially It's really difficult to get a properly
- 56:33diversified portfolio of crypto because they're
- 56:35all so correlated with one another. Under investment
- 56:38theory, we want assets that have a low or negative
- 56:41correlation so that if one asset goes down, it
- 56:43doesn't tank all your other assets. Maybe they
- 56:45go up or maybe they stay unchanged. But with
- 56:48crypto, they're all so correlated with one another
- 56:51that it's really difficult, if not impossible,
- 56:53to construct a properly diversified portfolio
- 56:57where crypto makes up a huge portion of it. Excuse
- 57:02me. So what do these high correlations suggest
- 57:05for a hypothetical prudent investor? I can think
- 57:08of at least four things number one proper diversification
- 57:12for most trust is going to require a portfolio
- 57:15that is balanced with lots of non crypto holdings
- 57:18Especially assets that don't suffer from some
- 57:21of the same issues that cryptos do high volatility
- 57:24high incidence of scams and fraud very little
- 57:27in terms of you know, distributions over time.
- 57:31And so we would try to counterbalance a portfolio
- 57:34with a lot of crypto with things like maybe treasury
- 57:36bills or income and dividend paying stocks and
- 57:39bonds, low risks ETFs and the like. But the more
- 57:44risk we take on with an overbalanced crypto portfolio,
- 57:46the more we're going to want to try to counterbalance
- 57:48that. Second, in light of the hacks to individual
- 57:52cryptos and exchanges, a prudent investor is
- 57:55going to want to spread their assets across multiple
- 57:58crypto assets and platforms. That way, they're
- 58:01limiting the risk of any single asset or platform
- 58:04being the target of a devastating hack like Bitcoin
- 58:08was with Mt. Gox. If you're spreading your crypto
- 58:10among other assets or platforms, you may be less
- 58:13susceptible to the diversifiable risk there.
- 58:18Oops, sorry, getting ahead of myself. Number
- 58:21three, it's easy to be allured by advertisements
- 58:24inviting you to lend or stake your crypto for
- 58:27a regular return on your investment. Some companies
- 58:29offer rates as high as five to 10 % annually
- 58:32for staking your crypto with them, depending
- 58:34on which coins and the term and the period of
- 58:37time involved. But if one of those companies
- 58:39gets hacked or makes a bunch of bad investment
- 58:42bets or, you know, has a bunch of schemers and
- 58:46pyramid schemers and scammers involved, you as
- 58:50an investor could lose all of your asset just
- 58:52because you were chasing a couple percent in
- 58:54yield. So while I think a prudent investor might
- 58:57think about some amount of income generation
- 59:00from your crypto, I think that they're also probably
- 59:03going to diversify across multiple assets, but
- 59:06then also leave a significant amount outside
- 59:08of the staking realm because they don't want
- 59:11to lose all of that. You want to protect the
- 59:13bulk of your assets from being lost to those
- 59:15kinds of risks. Fourth and finally, a prudent
- 59:18investor that wants to gain access or exposure
- 59:21to the blockchain and crypto markets. Do it that
- 59:27don't involve directly buying and selling crypto.
- 59:29You can invest in companies that build hardware
- 59:31or peripherals for miners or energy companies
- 59:34because we know that the energy needs involved
- 59:36for these kinds of technologies are enormous.
- 59:38Those are ways where if you're a crypto believer,
- 59:39you can gain access to it without necessarily
- 59:41needing to buy and sell and hold and manage and
- 59:44administer crypto, which for a lot of people
- 59:46is just over their head. The last big thing I
- 59:52want to flag here is key tools for trustees and
- 59:55their council. I mentioned this earlier, but
- 59:59RUFADA, the Revised Uniform Fiduciary Access
- 1:00:03to Digital Assets Act, is the main set of statutes
- 1:00:07that in California under our probate code and
- 1:00:09nationwide, really every state uses RUFADA. This
- 1:00:12is the set of statutes that we would use to gain
- 1:00:14access to a decedent's crypto accounts after
- 1:00:17they've passed away. Essentially a trustee or
- 1:00:20fiduciary responsible for marshalling the assets
- 1:00:23would send a written request to Coinbase or Kraken
- 1:00:27or whatever third party entities holding crypto
- 1:00:30or other digital assets of a decedent. Some information
- 1:00:33would need to be provided, like a desk certificate,
- 1:00:36letters of appointment, et cetera. But once you
- 1:00:38go through that process under Rufada, a successor
- 1:00:41trustee or fiduciary is required to be given
- 1:00:45access to whatever digital assets that were held
- 1:00:47by the decedent. The one exception is for emails,
- 1:00:52contents of emails. It's not quite as straightforward.
- 1:00:54There's a little bit more involved. But for digital
- 1:00:56assets, Bitcoin, cryptocurrencies, that sort
- 1:00:59of thing. a successor fiduciary can basically
- 1:01:02always get access to those things under RUFATA.
- 1:01:06Probate code section 850 or Hegstad petitions.
- 1:01:09As we know, this is a really common way in California.
- 1:01:12for us to get assets that are outside of a trust
- 1:01:14deemed to be within a trust. You can use these
- 1:01:17to retitle crypto accounts and assets that up
- 1:01:20until now were really difficult. It's very hard
- 1:01:22to open an account in the name of the trust on
- 1:01:25Coinbase or Kraken or something like that. And
- 1:01:27so for a lot of users, really the only way to
- 1:01:29get those titled in the name of a trust was after
- 1:01:31the fact using an 850 or Hangstad petition. I've
- 1:01:34done this successfully. Cold storage wallets,
- 1:01:37you'll want to make sure you're using that kind
- 1:01:39of thing, or a professional custodian for large
- 1:01:41concentrations of crypto. I mentioned the crypto
- 1:01:44tax software, the API -based stuff that you can
- 1:01:47have pulled data for trades directly from Coinbase
- 1:01:50and whatever else you might be using that can
- 1:01:52help your fiduciaries and your accountants in
- 1:01:54figuring out what taxable gains or losses might
- 1:01:58be and keeping track of that throughout the year.
- 1:02:00And then finally, I've got, who doesn't like
- 1:02:02being linked to the IRS homepage here, but I've
- 1:02:05got a link to the IRS page here, specifically
- 1:02:07on crypto and digital assets. I know it says
- 1:02:09small businesses there, but this is a compendium
- 1:02:11of really all of the official guidance, publications,
- 1:02:16frequently asked questions, and other resources
- 1:02:18from the IRS, as do crypto and digital assets.
- 1:02:21So it's great for you as a taxpayer. It's great
- 1:02:24for whoever's going to be handling the taxes
- 1:02:26for that. Really, it's a one stop shop for anyone
- 1:02:28who wants to see what the complete IRS guidance
- 1:02:31is on that. And with that, we've covered all
- 1:02:34of the substantive sections from today's talk.
- 1:02:37In closing, I want to reiterate that it's been
- 1:02:38an honor to get to speak with you all today.
- 1:02:40happy to stick around and do my best to answer
- 1:02:42some questions. If we can't answer them all,
- 1:02:44I'm happy to follow up on them after the fact.
- 1:02:47And I guess the last thing I'd say is if you
- 1:02:49enjoyed today's talk, please consider finding
- 1:02:51me on LinkedIn and endorsing me. And here's where
- 1:02:54you can do that. This time, it's actually on
- 1:02:55the screen. So with that, any questions? Teal,
- 1:03:03we actually can't hear you. There we go. Sorry.
- 1:03:16Can you hear me now? We can hear you now. Perfect.
- 1:03:19Thank you. We have a couple questions. If you
- 1:03:21have a couple minutes, I think these would be...
- 1:03:23I don't think they're going to be super intensive
- 1:03:24and I think they would be beneficial. So the
- 1:03:26first one is, can cryptocurrencies be used to
- 1:03:30fund a living trust? Yes. Perfect. The next one
- 1:03:36is, will crypto get a step -up in basis for the
- 1:03:39heir when owner passes away? Ooh, that's a great
- 1:03:43question. Not something I've come across yet,
- 1:03:45but I'd be happy to look into that and circle
- 1:03:47back with folks. OK, perfect. And then last one,
- 1:03:51what are the provisions for tracing or otherwise
- 1:03:54trying to recover digital assets lost if a client
- 1:03:56was the victim of a bad decision or recovery
- 1:03:58from a pump and dump scam? Yeah, really common.
- 1:04:03There's just so much fraud and scams rife in
- 1:04:05this area. I will say that there's a couple different
- 1:04:09things that are at your disposal. Number one,
- 1:04:11for a lot of crypto transactions, the types of
- 1:04:14crypto, they are upon public databases. So if
- 1:04:17this involved Bitcoin, you can go and look at
- 1:04:19what the current list of every transaction that's
- 1:04:21ever happened. There are companies out there
- 1:04:24that can work with you forensically to follow
- 1:04:26up on specific transactions. You know, it's not
- 1:04:29necessarily going to have the name. of the person
- 1:04:31who engaged in that transaction. But with really
- 1:04:34stunning accuracy, there are companies that can
- 1:04:37reverse engineer who these people are and then
- 1:04:39see where their wallets go. You might be able
- 1:04:42to use that to subpoena a financial institution
- 1:04:44if you can see the wallets are being. eventually
- 1:04:47those funds are transferred to a Coinbase account
- 1:04:49or a Kraken account. There are ways you can look
- 1:04:52at the public database of transactions to try
- 1:04:54to do that. And then furthermore, the other tool
- 1:04:56I'd say is going back to my slide a moment ago
- 1:04:58is under Rufata, the Revised Uniform Fiduciary
- 1:05:02Access to Digital Assets Act. You can request
- 1:05:05from custodians of digital assets information
- 1:05:09about emails that you've sent, a really long
- 1:05:12-winded way of saying, I've had a decedent die.
- 1:05:14I sent a request to Hotmail. This is a case that's
- 1:05:17over for years now. But a decedent died. We were
- 1:05:22afraid that he had been subjected to undue influence
- 1:05:24and fraud right before his death. And we sent
- 1:05:28an email. We sent a request for Rufada to Hotmail,
- 1:05:31which had his emails. And we got a list of not
- 1:05:33the contents of emails, but Boke's names who
- 1:05:36had been sending him emails and we saw emails
- 1:05:38from a major crypto company. We had no idea that
- 1:05:42crypto was on the sky's radar, but from that
- 1:05:44we were able to reverse engineer. He was in talks
- 1:05:47with crypto and we were able to use that to find
- 1:05:50several cryptocurrency assets that had previously
- 1:05:53not been known to us and recover those for the
- 1:05:55estate. So I'd say, use a forensic person with
- 1:05:59publicly available trade data. And then you might
- 1:06:01also have a backdoor by using Rufata in a certain
- 1:06:03way. I've had success doing that anyway. Perfect.
- 1:06:07That's super helpful. I think that's all the
- 1:06:11questions that we have. So thank you so much
- 1:06:12for your time today. I know that was really interesting
- 1:06:15to me, and I'm sure our members got a lot of
- 1:06:17value out of it, too. I learned a ton. So that
- 1:06:20concludes today's program. Thank you so much,
- 1:06:21JD, for your time and an excellent presentation.
- 1:06:24Our next program will be regarding short form
- 1:06:26versus full form settlement agreements and trust
- 1:06:28in the state's litigation. This program will
- 1:06:30take place on August 19 with Michael Brophy.
- 1:06:33Thanks for joining us this afternoon, and everyone
- 1:06:35have a great day. Thanks. Bye now.