Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Anthony Adverse (1936)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:19I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we return to the show
- 0:24with yet another, well, I guess this isn't a
- 0:27biopic. I was going to say it was. It is, but
- 0:29it's a fictional one. Kind of, but you know what
- 0:32we are returning to? Who is it? Mervyn LeRoy.
- 0:35Oh, we are, yeah. Now, Mervyn LeRoy, we saw him
- 0:39previously a number of times, but we saw him
- 0:41for one of our favorite movies. I think it's
- 0:43safe to say of the pods so far of I Am a Fugitive
- 0:46from a Chain Gang. Where are you, I Am a Fugitive
- 0:50from a Chain Gang? You're craving that. I need
- 0:53something like that. You are craving the hunter,
- 0:56that. I am. Oh, yeah. Yeah, you saw what I did?
- 0:59Yeah. It was not good. Yeah, I agree. Like, I
- 1:03feel like we have, let's take a little pause
- 1:06real quick. I feel like we have been waiting
- 1:09for a hero. We have been waiting for someone
- 1:13to come along and kind of sweep us off our feet
- 1:15with like, you know, a five -star masterpiece.
- 1:18Yeah. It's been a minute. You know, we talked
- 1:19about it happened one night and we both really
- 1:21enjoyed that. You just a little bit more than
- 1:23me, but it's hard to argue how much of a classic
- 1:25it is in that sense. We talked about Mutantly
- 1:28on the Bounty and we both were looking forward
- 1:30to that because we've heard about it for so long.
- 1:31And we kind of just were a little, you know,
- 1:34not terrible. We didn't think it was terrible,
- 1:36but it didn't hit us the way we thought it was
- 1:38going to. So we're just waiting for something
- 1:40to hit us that way. And that's why I'm so excited
- 1:44to talk about Anthony Adverse with you and not
- 1:47change that at all. Yeah. You know, we talked
- 1:51for a while when we were coming out of the pre
- 1:54-code era. And I was very worried. You were.
- 1:57I was like, movies are going to take a hit. It's
- 1:59going to be a slump for a long time. And I was
- 2:03a little child with a spinny hat and a lollipop,
- 2:06and I was like, movies! Right. And I think that
- 2:09the code being removed has affected the movies
- 2:13a little bit, but we're still seeing themes and
- 2:16topics. That are kind of dark. This movie is
- 2:20no exception to that. There are some dark elements
- 2:22to this movie for sure. Absolutely. But I think
- 2:25that the shift in quality and kind of my enjoyment
- 2:28of these movies has nothing to do with the code.
- 2:30It's like Hollywood took a turn as a whole and
- 2:34said, we're going to do a lot of dramas. And
- 2:38we're going to do a lot of cookie cutter stories
- 2:41in a way. Yeah. And this one's not cookie cutter.
- 2:46This one's definitely one of those heavy -handed
- 2:48dramas. It is. And I think the way that I see
- 2:52it is it's almost like studios kind of looking
- 2:55out into the horizon and being like, hey, you
- 2:57like this? That's just how it feels. It doesn't
- 2:59feel like it's resonating with a ton of people.
- 3:01It's just more they're taking chances on stuff.
- 3:03Which, again, you know, it's a funny stance to
- 3:06be in in 2026. Because my immediate thought is
- 3:09like studios may be taking more chances. But
- 3:12at this time, it feels like they're just kind
- 3:13of like doing stuff and seeing if it sticks rather
- 3:15than having confidence that it's going to. And
- 3:18I mean, clearly something hits because these
- 3:20films are nominated for Best Picture. And maybe
- 3:23it is just like more, you know, Great Depression.
- 3:26Like we've talked a lot about these films and
- 3:28like films that are designed to kind of bring
- 3:29people, their spirits up. Maybe there's a market
- 3:32for the opposite of look at the adversity that
- 3:35this person faces. And isn't it? it amazing when
- 3:38they get out of it or if they're kind of succumbed
- 3:40to it. So it's interesting. I also think a lot
- 3:44about, I've been thinking about Eddington a lot
- 3:46recently. Did you end up seeing that? I haven't
- 3:48seen it yet, no. You should. I think you would
- 3:51enjoy it now. Time has remembered it well, I
- 3:53think, in the years since it's been out. But
- 3:56I think that, like, I think about how a film
- 3:59like Eddington would hit in 1935. Sure. 1936
- 4:03even. how that would be embraced. And I think
- 4:07of it a similar way of like something like this,
- 4:09because this is, to your point, a very dark,
- 4:12like, I don't want to say sad, but it's trying
- 4:15to be hopeful. Anthony kind of exists in the,
- 4:19I mean, we'll get into the synopsis here in a
- 4:20minute, but Anthony kind of exists in this world,
- 4:23but doesn't try to let that like succumb to that.
- 4:26He doesn't let that overtake him. So maybe that's
- 4:29hopeful, but that's not really the message I
- 4:31got from this. Yeah. I know that a big, Part
- 4:34of the code as well was like kind of the bad
- 4:37guy can never win and all of this. And this kind
- 4:41of goes against that, I feel. A little bit, but
- 4:43I think by the end they're like, nah, not really,
- 4:45right? Which we'll get to. The other thing, too,
- 4:49is I think the code exists to hide so much from
- 4:52the general audience. Right. Sex, drugs, a number
- 4:56of violence. I mean. You know what? You know
- 4:59what I don't mind spoiling? There's no rock and
- 5:01roll in this movie. No, there's not. So you can't
- 5:03prove that wasn't up to the point. Most violence
- 5:06you don't see present here. But what's funny
- 5:09is, especially looking back at these times, especially
- 5:11something filmed or taking place in the 1700s
- 5:14or 1800s, there's a lot of stuff in there that's
- 5:16like, hey, yeah, we didn't put the sex or the
- 5:18drugs in here. Got it. Maybe you take that out,
- 5:21too. Maybe we just don't see this anymore. Yeah.
- 5:24And I have a feeling you know what I'm talking
- 5:25about, and we'll get to it. But we're talking
- 5:27about Anthony Adverse. This is a pretty large
- 5:30film. I don't mind telling you that I've never
- 5:32heard of this before covering this. We went through
- 5:35our list of the 1937 Academy Award nominees,
- 5:38and I got to this one. I was like, I've never
- 5:41heard of that a day in my life. Yeah. And that's
- 5:43not the first time it's happened on this pod,
- 5:44but just that name. I was like, yeah, I don't.
- 5:46I have no idea who stars in this. Anything about
- 5:49it, never heard in my life. Right. Couldn't find
- 5:52a DVD copy of this either for physical media.
- 5:55Not something I found. So I did have to watch
- 5:57this online. But look at how surprised I am now.
- 6:01Seven nominations behind Anthony Adverse. Right.
- 6:04Very largely nominated as much as Mutiny on the
- 6:07Bounty was last week. Or sorry. Last year. Last
- 6:11year. And there's something else that received
- 6:13seven nominations. No, even more than Story of
- 6:15Louis. Story of Louis Pasteur. As many as great
- 6:18Ziegfeld. That's what I'm thinking. Ziegfeld.
- 6:21So sorry. So let's get into those nominations.
- 6:24Art Direction was from Anton Grott. The Assistant
- 6:27Director nomination was for William H. Cannon.
- 6:30Film Editing was for Ralph Dawson. Original Score,
- 6:34someone we've talked about a lot, Eric Wolfgang
- 6:37Korngold got the nomination here. Cinematography
- 6:41was for Tony Gaudio. Supporting actress was for
- 6:45Gail Sundergaard as Faith. An outstanding production
- 6:49on behalf of Warner Brothers. Yeah, so you mentioned
- 6:53this was directed by Mervyn LeRoy. Welcome back.
- 6:56Big fan. Big fan. Yeah, Warner Brothers picture
- 6:59here. I had read that this, up to this point,
- 7:02was Warner Brothers' longest film. Boy, does
- 7:06it feel it. Yes, it does. So thanks for that,
- 7:08guys. Appreciate it. We have in this film the
- 7:11return of... Long time podcast star, I guess,
- 7:16Frederick March, as the titular Anthony Adverse.
- 7:20And Olivia de Havilland, who we talked about
- 7:22a number of times last year, is still going strong
- 7:25as love interest Angela Giuseppe. There's a bunch
- 7:29of other people in this movie. We'll talk about
- 7:31them as we get to them. Yeah, we will. The screenplay
- 7:34here was written by Sheridan Gibney, and it was
- 7:36based on the book series. This was a whole series
- 7:39of books, which I'm going to tell you. If I read
- 7:42the first book and half of the stuff happened
- 7:43that takes place in this movie, I'd be like,
- 7:46no, no, absolutely not. Give me more Twilight.
- 7:48I don't need this. Ocelot, clip that. Yeah, clip
- 7:52it, Ocelot. Big, big fan of those Twilight movies.
- 7:56Yeah? Yeah, but not like I... You immediately
- 7:59back down. Like, I like watching them because
- 8:02I'm just like, what are we doing? Okay. It's
- 8:06that kind of thing. So... Uh, I'll tell you,
- 8:08I think I've shared this story on the pod. If
- 8:10I have, I'm so sorry. And if I haven't, I'm so
- 8:12sorry. Um, we, I was dating. Nope. Take that
- 8:16back. I was interested in this girl and we went
- 8:19to go see Twilight and this was our first date,
- 8:21right? Like a date. We went to go see Twilight,
- 8:24came out in theaters, watched it. I hated it.
- 8:27Hated it. Couldn't stand it. I wasn't on board
- 8:30with what was going on. I haven't read the book,
- 8:31so I was not familiar with anything and I didn't
- 8:34really enjoy the story. And then afterwards.
- 8:36And I didn't share this opinion. I wasn't like,
- 8:38ooh, like afterwards. I was like, yeah, okay.
- 8:41I'm glad you liked it. And afterwards she was
- 8:43like, hey, I think we're better off as friends.
- 8:45And I was like, hey, that's okay. 100%. We can
- 8:48still be friends. I'm not worried about that.
- 8:50Tell me before Twilight. Just tell me that before
- 8:53Twilight. And then I don't have to worry about
- 8:55not destroying this movie in front of someone
- 8:58else. So since then. A number of my friends have
- 9:01thought it would be funny if we went to go see
- 9:03the other Twilight movies in theaters because
- 9:05of that experience that I had. So I saw New Moon.
- 9:08And because I embraced New Moon and on with that
- 9:12like levity of like, oh, this is going to suck.
- 9:14I enjoyed those more. Sure. So I'm with you on
- 9:17that. I'm like, oh, boy, check this out. It got
- 9:19a little too jumping the shark for me by the
- 9:22end with the Renesmee and everything. The baby
- 9:24with eyes. plugging out of its head or whatever
- 9:27was going on there. Sure. Yeah. Can't say I'm
- 9:30a big fan. And someone did the edit of Jacob
- 9:34seeing Renesmee and playing Careless Whisper
- 9:37over it. Yeah, that's rough. And to me, it's
- 9:40like, well, that's what's in the movie. Like,
- 9:41I just think of the movie now. Anyways, little
- 9:43diatribe before we even get into the synopsis
- 9:45here. That's my Twilight story, so I'm kind of
- 9:48with you on that. Beautiful. I'm not going to
- 9:50say it's a good series. It's like my Riff Trax
- 9:53movie. That's it. I sit there and I go, look
- 9:56at these guys. And I do the Ross meeting. Get
- 10:00a load of these guys. But yeah, let's talk about
- 10:03it. Call me next time and I'll be your crow.
- 10:06Perfect. So I want to start here. Before we get
- 10:08into the synopsis, we talked a lot about Mervyn
- 10:10LeRoy. Yeah. Very big fans of him. Did you know
- 10:12that he wasn't originally directing this? I did
- 10:15not know that, but that does not surprise me.
- 10:17So, it's not even one of those things where he
- 10:19took over halfway. It was from the get -go, he
- 10:21started directing, and that's him. But, originally,
- 10:25William de Turley was promised the directing
- 10:29role for this movie. But, instead it went to
- 10:33Mervyn LeRoy, and I don't know if you know this,
- 10:35Mervyn LeRoy is Harry M. Warner's son -in -law.
- 10:38I did not know that. So, a little favoritism
- 10:41here. A little nebitism. I gotta tell you. I
- 10:44would rather see a Mervyn LeRoy film than a William
- 10:46de Turley film at this point in time. I don't
- 10:49think it really affected this movie too much.
- 10:51I mean, God, can you imagine a somehow worse
- 10:53version of this story? Again, spoiler for our
- 10:56thoughts. Yeah, I don't know that de Turley would
- 10:59be the contributing factor for a worse version
- 11:03of this movie. I kind of like the story of Louis
- 11:06Pasteur. True. And honestly, no, you're right.
- 11:10And I like the story of Louis Pasteur more than
- 11:13this. But I will say... One of the unfortunate
- 11:17things in my introduction to Tertulli was Midsummer
- 11:19Night's Dream. Sure. And I was like, yeah, just
- 11:22yikes. Big yikes all around. We're Mervyn LeRoy
- 11:25fans overall. We are. Even outside of his podcast
- 11:28movies, I'm a big Little Caesar guy as well.
- 11:30So there's that. I'm leaving that alone. I could
- 11:33just go on a diatribe about that. So the synopsis
- 11:36of this film is we are introduced to Anthony
- 11:39Adverse. Before he was born, as a child, and
- 11:43then even as an adult. And we see the adversity
- 11:46that he has faced, hence his name that's given
- 11:49to him at a later time in his life. And we see
- 11:54all the events that he has to face in order to
- 11:56live the life that he wants. This is a soap opera.
- 11:59It really is. 100 % a soap opera. There are things
- 12:02that take place in this movie where I'm like,
- 12:04wow, I can't believe that happened. When does
- 12:07the evil twin show up? Yeah. It's so heavy -handed.
- 12:12Because of General Hospital, I hear you on The
- 12:15Evil Twin. I'm almost waiting for a vampire.
- 12:18Oh, okay. That happened on General Hospital.
- 12:20Really? Really. I'm not joking. There's a guy
- 12:24named Caleb, I think. My mom watched it all the
- 12:26time. I remember because I'd get home from school
- 12:28and I'd hear like the... Have you ever seen General
- 12:30Hospital? Nope. There's a theme song with a saxophone.
- 12:33Okay. Where, like, everyone's just kind of standing,
- 12:35like, looking at the camera one by one. And the
- 12:37saxophone's just like... And that saxophone solo
- 12:41is so ingrained in my brain that I just can't
- 12:45not think of it. Anyways, Caleb was introduced
- 12:47later on, and he's a very handsome... tall, dark
- 12:50-skinned individual. Actually, very similar to
- 12:53you, so credit where it needs to be. But I saw
- 12:56him, and I was like, oh, he looks like he'd be
- 12:57a vampire. My mom was like, yeah, he is. And
- 12:58I thought she was joking with me, but I watched
- 13:00some scenes. No, he's a vampire. And I don't
- 13:04know why they did it. They kind of just did it
- 13:05to do it. But this is the same series that has
- 13:08recently done a three -episode arc with John
- 13:10Oliver. Where he just comes in and he's just,
- 13:12like, the head of a CIA agency or something?
- 13:15Interesting. I don't know. Anyways, point is,
- 13:17I was waiting for the other shoe to drop when
- 13:20it came to, like, the dramatic soap opera aspect
- 13:24of this. And even from the get -go, this movie's
- 13:26a soap opera. Yeah. It has, like, this cold open,
- 13:31almost. Like, if they would have just moved when
- 13:33the title screen dropped. This totally could
- 13:35have been the cold open of the movie where you're
- 13:37introduced to a wealthy woman, a woman of some
- 13:42kind of nobility. Her father has a lot of, yeah,
- 13:45a lot of riches. Yeah, he's got business owner.
- 13:48And she is set to marry Don Luis. I think she
- 13:53does marry Don Luis, who is this kind of like
- 13:55hoity -toity Spaniard stuck -up guy. And he's
- 14:00really a creep. He has a broken leg at the beginning
- 14:04of this film, and he's like, we got married,
- 14:06and I cannot consummate our marriage because
- 14:09my leggy hurts. She's like, that's okay. I'll
- 14:13wait for you. Real Disraeli problem. Yeah. She
- 14:16doesn't wait for him at all. She ends up having
- 14:18an affair with another man, and they have relations.
- 14:25Don Luis finds out about this, hunts down the
- 14:29affairee, whatever it's called, Kills him. And
- 14:33then. Like a sword fight. Like it's a duel. Right.
- 14:37Yeah. Like it's, it's action packed. And they,
- 14:40the, the, the woman, Anthony adverse's mother
- 14:44dies in childbirth. So like, even before you
- 14:49meet Anthony himself, you're like, boy, that
- 14:51was, that was a lot. That was rough. How did,
- 14:55did you like it? I'm asking you. Oh, I'm sure
- 14:59he didn't. no no yeah i don't mind telling you
- 15:04no uh i i didn't and you know it just i was so
- 15:09disinterested by the time that like anthony even
- 15:12shows up and by the way anthony isn't given a
- 15:14name until like he's 10 right yeah like they
- 15:18kind of just like keep him around but the point
- 15:20is his father And by father, we're never really,
- 15:24because of the code, you never get too far involved
- 15:27in the idea of who his father really is, whether
- 15:30it is Don Luis or the other gentleman who, by
- 15:33the way, the only thing that you kind of skipped
- 15:35over here about that relationship is that they're
- 15:36kind of in love. Like, yes, she's married to
- 15:38Don Luis, but like this person that she's having
- 15:40an affair with, she's really interested in that
- 15:42person. Oh, yeah, they're definitely in love.
- 15:44Right. So you're not really sure of who. the
- 15:48his father really is oh no it's the it's the
- 15:50guy right i mean well right because they didn't
- 15:52consummate you're right but uh clearly this shame
- 15:56that don luis has when his wife dies in childbirth
- 16:00he then tells everyone including uh the his father
- 16:06-in -law yeah that both the child and the mother
- 16:10died in childbirth when in reality the son survived
- 16:13but they dropped him off at the convent Right.
- 16:16And he did this out of the goodness of his heart,
- 16:18quote unquote. And everyone believes outside
- 16:22of the father, Don Luis, that Anthony is dead.
- 16:26And Anthony just exists in the school for girls
- 16:30and is trying to make the best of it. He's named
- 16:33Anthony for religious purposes. And then adverse
- 16:36is given to him by his father -in -law. I'm sorry,
- 16:40by his grandfather. Now, this is weird, too,
- 16:42because... While he's staying at the school for
- 16:45girls, it's the priest who serves kind of as
- 16:49his first father figure. Yes. Who is quite literally
- 16:52a father. Yeah. He decides, look, he's got to
- 16:55go learn like how to be a man and all of this
- 16:57and live like a real life. So let's take him
- 17:01to this gentleman who like will be able to raise
- 17:05him properly. And this ends up being Edmund Gwynn
- 17:08playing John Bonnyfeather, who is the father.
- 17:13of anthony's mother so he's anthony's grandfather
- 17:15right yeah nobody knows this not even uh bonnie
- 17:20feather himself until until like they're having
- 17:24a discussion about anthony where he's like yeah
- 17:27this kid didn't have a father he was born this
- 17:30many years ago and bonnie feather's like wait
- 17:33a minute everything's lining up so This scene
- 17:37that you're talking about, it really is that,
- 17:39I know this isn't where it originated. I think
- 17:41maybe it was a beautiful mind that originated
- 17:42it. But you know the meme of Zach Galifianakis,
- 17:45where the numbers are flying by? You could see
- 17:48this happening to Bonnie Feather in real time.
- 17:50Yeah. But it's really when he sees Anthony. And
- 17:54when he sees Anthony, to him, the resemblance
- 17:56to his daughter is uncanny. So he immediately
- 17:59starts questioning, like, oh, my God, like, what's
- 18:01going on here? And then that bit of information
- 18:03that you're giving is the last bit that he needs
- 18:07to kind of piece it all together. Right. That
- 18:09he was lied to by Don Luis, and this is actually
- 18:12his grandson. Now, he never tells Anthony this
- 18:15outright. Right. Yeah, no. It's just so weird
- 18:18to me because he comes to that realization. There's
- 18:22no way for him to actually know that. There's
- 18:24no record of this child even being born. So it's
- 18:27weird. And I don't know if maybe in the book
- 18:30it's explained like why he knows for sure. But
- 18:33in the movie you're just like. That's a big assumption
- 18:36to be making my dude. It's a big assumption,
- 18:38but it's also one that he's kind of made to himself
- 18:39and only himself. Yeah. He doesn't address it
- 18:42with Anthony. It's not like someone he brings
- 18:44in. He just kind of believes this enough to where
- 18:47he changes his will to where it, when he passes,
- 18:50everything is going to go to Anthony. Right.
- 18:52Right. So the. The aspect of this where this
- 18:56changes for me, and I was a little more interested,
- 18:58I was like, oh, yeah, I really like Bonnie Feather.
- 19:00I like the actor who portrayed him. What did
- 19:01you say his name was? Edmund Nguyen. Edmund Nguyen.
- 19:04Really, really liked his performance, and I thought
- 19:07that he was a nice brightness to this movie that
- 19:09was missing beforehand. Didn't last very long.
- 19:12He's interested in, while he's at this school,
- 19:15he meets Angela Giuseppe, who is the daughter
- 19:20of the cook. at the convent, and he falls in
- 19:23love with her, and then he ends up connecting
- 19:27with her later in life, too. They want to have
- 19:29a relationship and get married, but in the middle
- 19:32of this happening, he obviously starts working
- 19:34for his grandfather at the, is it Casa de Bodyfeather?
- 19:39Sure. Casita? I don't know. Anyways, this is
- 19:42taking place in Italy, and he sends him off to
- 19:46work, and he works for his grandfather, and at
- 19:48one point he tells him, look. You're going to
- 19:50have to go deal with this trade. It's going to
- 19:52take you away from home for a while, but you'll
- 19:54come back. And essentially, it's slave trading.
- 19:57Right. And I'm sorry. Man. Let me take this back.
- 20:00I used a very harsh word here. I said essentially.
- 20:03It's slave trading. Yeah. He goes and handles
- 20:06the handling of slave trading in different countries.
- 20:11And yeah, to me, this was just like, oh, I can't
- 20:14get into this. Right. It's a little blind side
- 20:17of, like, this white boy is going to solve the
- 20:20slave trading problems in these countries. He's
- 20:22not a fan of it, but he's going to make sure
- 20:23that everything's handled appropriately. So he's
- 20:26actually the hero of slave trading without ruining
- 20:28it. It's not even that. Like, let me take it
- 20:31back a step real quick. You have young Anthony
- 20:35Adverse, right? Define young. Like 10? Yeah,
- 20:3810 -year -old who's played by a different actor.
- 20:40It's Billy Malk. Right. And it's almost the first
- 20:44hour. that you're watching different points of
- 20:48Anthony's life. And it's not until just after
- 20:53his grandfather makes the realization that, okay,
- 20:56this is actually my grandson. He needs a last
- 20:59name, but I can't give him my last name because
- 21:01he is, quote unquote, a bastard child. And his
- 21:06life will be so much harder if I do that. So
- 21:09what do I name him? Oh, he's gone through a lot
- 21:11of adversity already. I'm going to name him Anthony
- 21:13Adverse, which... I don't know about you, but
- 21:15I rolled my eyes pretty hard. Yeah. Can you imagine
- 21:19if someone named me, like, Ryan Depression? Like,
- 21:23Ryan Terrible Events? Boy, you're really setting
- 21:25up for a positive spin on life. And I get it.
- 21:29Like, it's supposed to be, like, even in the
- 21:31face of it, like, you know, nevertheless, he
- 21:33persisted. Like, I get it, but it just kind of
- 21:37comes across as, like, heavy -handed and very,
- 21:41like, dumb. That's the best way to put it. I
- 21:43was trying to find another word. When I saw the
- 21:44title of this movie, I was like, what a strange
- 21:46last name. Patronizing. I didn't expect to be
- 21:49explained in the movie as like, hey, this is
- 21:52the story of a guy who has some real tough luck.
- 21:56It's almost like if the movie is called Tommy
- 21:58Troubles. Yeah. Like, is the movie better if
- 22:01it's called Tommy Troubles? No. I mean, it's
- 22:03funnier. It is funny. But like Anthony Adverse.
- 22:06Yeah. That's like the lead character in any Tums
- 22:09commercial. here comes tommy troubles yeah yeah
- 22:14but the other thing too is like this will probably
- 22:17make me sound bad because you're watching this
- 22:1910 year old kid who has grown up in this in this
- 22:21all -girl school like with a very positive fatherly
- 22:26figure in father xavier things have gone well
- 22:28for him he's been okay yeah like yeah he didn't
- 22:31have parents and and that can be very rough obviously
- 22:34for a child but he has had positive influences
- 22:37in his in his life it's really not until as an
- 22:40adult that he travels for work that i think things
- 22:42actually get difficult for him right so mostly
- 22:45things have been good for him just in the face
- 22:46of all those bad things yeah so it feels weird
- 22:50for his grandfather to be like Your mom had it
- 22:53real rough, so I'm going to name you Adverse.
- 22:56So I don't know. I rolled my eyes pretty heavily
- 22:59at that. And then it's not until like an hour
- 23:01into the movie that you're meeting like your
- 23:03top -billed cast in Frederick March playing adult
- 23:08Anthony Adverse and Olivia de Havilland as Angela
- 23:11Giuseppe. And you get to see a little bit of
- 23:16their romance in the movie, but not much. They're
- 23:19not in it for very long together. No, you're
- 23:21just told that they're in love, and that's kind
- 23:23of it. Yeah. They do have kind of like their
- 23:26secret marriage, because for some reason Anthony
- 23:29doesn't want to tell his quote -unquote dad,
- 23:32his ward, his father figure, his grandfather.
- 23:36So they get married almost in secret, and it's
- 23:40right before his dad sends him to Cuba is where
- 23:44he goes first. That... He's like, well, I can't
- 23:47go. I just got married yesterday. He's like,
- 23:50well, tough, tough. Go together, I guess. I don't
- 23:53know. Figure it out. And he's not even going
- 23:56for like a noble reason. It's something where
- 23:59like the Bonnie Feathers money is in danger.
- 24:04with with the slave trade so he's like go figure
- 24:06it out go take care of it for me they're indebted
- 24:09uh yeah to another company which i think is a
- 24:11slave trading company so instead he goes to work
- 24:14for that company to pay off that debt right so
- 24:17the first taste of like real adversity for anthony
- 24:21and not just like his family line right is he's
- 24:24married angela they agree to meet up before he
- 24:29leaves for cuba she gets to the meetup location
- 24:32first and has like this letter written just in
- 24:35case she doesn't get to see him and she she tells
- 24:38the the carriage driver like leave the letter
- 24:41on the door so he can see it right and the letter
- 24:44blows away in the wind as they ride off so he
- 24:47thinks that she has abandoned him yep so he goes
- 24:49to cuba and she thinks that he has abandoned
- 24:52her because he didn't show up to that spot exactly
- 24:54and it's something like he was just running late
- 24:57Yeah, that's it. So that's the first moment where
- 25:00not only do is he faced with some adversity,
- 25:04but it starts to chip away at like the morality
- 25:07of his character. So not only have you just been
- 25:11introduced to Frederick March playing this character,
- 25:15but now you're starting to. see things that you're
- 25:18not going to like about his character right so
- 25:21when he goes to havana that's when he first uh
- 25:23starts to kind of get involved in the company
- 25:26business uh overseas and then he finds out about
- 25:29this uh company they're in debt to and he agrees
- 25:32well let me work for them and i'll pay off that
- 25:34debt in my you know work here that's kind of
- 25:37what my grandfather signed me up for he isn't
- 25:39again not his grandfather but his boss right
- 25:41so fine that's what i'm going to do and i forget
- 25:44where he travels to is it Africa. It's Africa.
- 25:47Yeah. Boy, we don't have a great track record
- 25:50with these movies traveling to Africa. No. So
- 25:52I was hoping better for this. But he becomes
- 25:56kind of the... He is the one who is looking out
- 26:00the most for these individuals. And when they
- 26:02are low in health and they need help, he is the
- 26:05first one to step in and say, no, you can't do
- 26:07this. That's wrong. You got to get him to a doctor.
- 26:09Anyways, bring on the next slave. And for some
- 26:13reason, I think we're supposed to see this as
- 26:15like... Oh, he's the good guy. He's the good
- 26:17guy. And it is quite near impossible to see that.
- 26:21Yeah. But again, we're in a different time now.
- 26:25Well, let me phrase that differently. That was
- 26:26a different time back then in 1700. So I guess
- 26:30they're seeing it in 1936. I guess they're trying
- 26:32to like look at it a little fondly too, which
- 26:35is not ideal. Granted, I won't even say not ideal.
- 26:39Wrong. it's just wrong all around yeah even outside
- 26:42of like oh he he's the moral the noble yes slave
- 26:47trader even outside of that he's the north compass
- 26:49of these people he has a a relationship with
- 26:52with a slave as well that's not great either
- 26:56because he's very like manipulative and abusive
- 26:59in that situation well and that's when he starts
- 27:01like it's eating away at his soul And he's just
- 27:04becoming now a ruler with an iron fist. Everyone
- 27:08kind of fears the name Anthony Adverse. I want
- 27:10to stop here real quick. I feel like the majority
- 27:13of these movies that stop every 15, 10 to 15
- 27:17minutes to give you a title screen. Hey, here's
- 27:21the context of what's been happening since that
- 27:23last scene you just saw. that's almost a surefire
- 27:26way for me not to be interested in the movie.
- 27:28Sure. And I'm not saying there's something about
- 27:30that specifically that makes me not interested.
- 27:31It's just what tends to happen is whenever I
- 27:34see that, I'm like, tell me in this, in the scenes,
- 27:36dude, like you don't have to give me the cut
- 27:39scenes of, and thus the journey started for Anthony
- 27:41where he did this and this and this and this.
- 27:43Yeah. I just want to see it in the character.
- 27:45Because then it almost feels kind of like a stage
- 27:47play where it's like, well, we don't want you
- 27:48to see how he got to this point. We just want
- 27:50to let you know he got to this point. It's almost
- 27:52like the crew is setting up the set for the next
- 27:57scene. Exactly. And they're like, well, we got
- 27:58to, you guys read this while we do that. You
- 28:01know, it also, it feels kind of like, and I'm
- 28:03not really throwing accusations like this around,
- 28:05but I'm just saying it feels this way. It almost
- 28:08feels like in editing on the back end, they're
- 28:10like, we didn't film the connective tissue to
- 28:12this at all. That's fine. We've got inner titles.
- 28:14Yeah, just do an inner title. It's fine. And
- 28:16it feels like it pieces that together and that
- 28:18makes it feel so unearned because then you're
- 28:20not invested in that character as much. Now,
- 28:23granted, any goodwill that you had towards Anthony
- 28:25is then again gone because he's working as a
- 28:27slave trader in this company. So it's not even
- 28:31like he had a lot to work with to begin with,
- 28:33but I think those inner titles also take away
- 28:35any kind of character connection that we have.
- 28:38So I just, really, as soon as he went to Africa.
- 28:42I was like, I'm not interested in this. And that
- 28:44makes him a very ruthless leader. It makes him
- 28:47very determined. He's afraid to return home.
- 28:50He almost doesn't want to return home because
- 28:52he's like, I got to finish my work here. And
- 28:53even when I finish my work here, I want to make
- 28:55sure people fear my name and everything. So we
- 28:58got to do this right. So you don't even see that
- 29:00morality at play for him. It's chipping away
- 29:02at his morality. And you're right. He's having
- 29:05an affair with another woman in Africa. And she
- 29:08clearly is trying to... take over his position.
- 29:12Yeah. This is something that's kind of, this
- 29:15is one of the only things I think I liked about
- 29:16the movie was the subtlety of her performance,
- 29:18where you kind of have to piece together what
- 29:21she's doing, because she isn't saying much. Anthony
- 29:23gets really sick at one point, but it's when
- 29:26she's really coming around more that you start
- 29:28thinking she's maybe poisoning him a little bit.
- 29:30Did you read into that at all? She's definitely,
- 29:35like, doing. things behind the scenes. Yes. Like
- 29:39she has a, a motive, but I don't know. I didn't.
- 29:42Cause even like his bodyguard or like his friend,
- 29:44like would come in and see her and she kind of
- 29:46glared him. So it's like, she's pushing the people
- 29:48closest to him away. Right. So you could tell
- 29:51that something was happening there and it wasn't
- 29:52just solely a love affair. Yeah. Which I don't
- 29:55love that either though, because they're taking
- 29:57this, this woman from Africa who he is having
- 30:01this really manipulative relationship with and
- 30:03kind of. painting her not so much as uh oh look
- 30:07at her getting back at him it was kind of like
- 30:09hey anthony this is why you shouldn't mess around
- 30:12with the locals yeah and that it's just more
- 30:15gross like there's a sting that happens every
- 30:20time we're like yeah he was a slave trader i'm
- 30:22like i i hate saying that but i almost feel like
- 30:26Hey, that's what we should call him because that's
- 30:27definitely what he is in this movie. And that's
- 30:30his role. Right. Right. It's not like a slang
- 30:31term. That's like the role that they gave him.
- 30:34Right. And even though he tries to like or the
- 30:36movie tries to paint him at least for a little
- 30:38while is like the moral compass of all of that.
- 30:42He's still a slave trader. Yeah. He's not great.
- 30:46So I also lost interest in this character overall.
- 30:49And once he leaves Africa and he heads back home.
- 30:54He's so jaded at this point. He feels not like
- 30:57Anthony Adverse, but more like Anthony A -hole.
- 31:01Where I'm just like, I don't like him. Got him.
- 31:04Got him. Take that, Anthony. I don't know, dude.
- 31:07Like, he's really rude to everybody. He's rude,
- 31:11but he also has like a little Bruce Wayne to
- 31:13him. And I don't necessarily mean that in a good
- 31:15way. Bruce Wayne's pretty rude, too. Well, I
- 31:18think that's kind of what I mean. I think when,
- 31:20so when he arrives back to Italy, he tries to
- 31:25go to Casa de Bonifeather, and he asks to go
- 31:28there, and they're like, oh, yeah, it's weird
- 31:29you want to go there because it's been, you know,
- 31:30closed down for so long. Yeah. He's like, yeah,
- 31:32you know, once old man Bonifeather died, and
- 31:35this is, of course, news to Anthony, and Anthony
- 31:38is dressed pretty lavishly. Right? Like, now
- 31:41that he's arrived back in Italy, he's dressing
- 31:42lavishly again. He looks like Dr. Jekyll. He
- 31:45really does. Like, top hat, big jacket. So he
- 31:48arrives, and he's talking to his driver. The
- 31:52driver's telling him all this information. And
- 31:54he tells him, you know, all the money was left
- 31:56to a guy. Oh, Anthony Adverse. That's right.
- 31:58And all the money's left to him as the sole heir.
- 32:01But we're waiting for his return, and no one
- 32:03ever really sees him. We just presume he's dead.
- 32:06Yeah. And... There's a moment that I think Anthony
- 32:09feels really cool about himself, but it definitely
- 32:11doesn't come across as cool, where he gets out
- 32:13and he gives him this big tip. Oh, he gives him
- 32:16a big tip. And he's like, hey, can you drop all
- 32:17my luggage off at this place? And he's like,
- 32:20yeah, well, that's a really fancy place. And
- 32:22he's like, well, tell him Anthony Adverse sent
- 32:25it. Yeah. And the driver's like, oh, good heavens.
- 32:28It's like he's Tony Stark. Yeah, you could feel
- 32:30him being like, Batman sent you. I'm like, all
- 32:32right, Anthony, chill out. And this then kind
- 32:35of spawns the next set of the story, which is
- 32:38Anthony returning home to then collect his inheritance.
- 32:41But the inheritance is tied up in, this is kind
- 32:45of the most interesting thing about the movie
- 32:47to me, in the character of Faith. And the Faith
- 32:50character is introduced as kind of the, I don't
- 32:55know if like housemaid or housemother. Is the
- 33:00right term for it? So Faith is in a position
- 33:02of power within the household and served underneath
- 33:05Bonnie Feather. And now she is trying to take
- 33:09that inheritance for herself. But Anthony not
- 33:13showing up would have helped that. Unfortunately,
- 33:15he has shown up. And what's interesting is we
- 33:19see this like. conspiracy relationship where
- 33:22she actually is in a relationship with returning
- 33:25Claude Rains as Don Louise. And now Don Louise
- 33:28is trying to get this money from his ex -father
- 33:32-in -law and was using a backdoor device in Faith,
- 33:37who is portrayed by Gail Sundergaard. And the
- 33:41reason I'm so interested in talking to you about
- 33:42this movie is, well, we'll kind of dive right
- 33:44into this. Normally, we talk about the art direction,
- 33:47the assistant director, film editing, score,
- 33:49and we'll talk about those things. But I think
- 33:51the most interesting thing about this movie is
- 33:52it received one acting nomination, and that's
- 33:55for Gail Sondergaard. And granted, it was supporting
- 33:58actress. Thank you, Mutiny on the Bounty, for
- 34:01this being an option. Yeah. And I don't mean
- 34:03to say that, like, you know, well, you're only
- 34:05supporting, so you've only been it for so long.
- 34:06It kind of blows my mind that she was nominated
- 34:09for this movie. She's not in it that much and
- 34:11she's not doing a ton. What did you think when
- 34:14you saw, because we were talking about like,
- 34:16you know, well, who is the best supporting actress
- 34:18in this? Who is Gail Sondergaard? And we talked
- 34:20about it. We were both like, we did the rest
- 34:22of development like her. So what did you think
- 34:24about this? So I'm going to, I'm going to give
- 34:27you a peek behind the curtain right now. I am
- 34:29staring at the plot synopsis. Like the whole
- 34:33plot breakdown. I don't have to do that. We just
- 34:35did it perfectly on the pod. Right. Okay, go
- 34:37ahead. But I'm like, let me try and really remember
- 34:40what she was even doing in this movie. Yeah.
- 34:43And in this whole plot breakdown, her name is
- 34:46not even mentioned once. Yeah. That's how little
- 34:49she's in this movie. So I don't really know where
- 34:52this nomination is coming from. The biggest thing
- 34:55that I can maybe like tack this on to is it is
- 34:58a really villainous performance. So she and Don
- 35:00Luis have to be very villainous in this in order
- 35:03to sell this story. So because she is, I guess,
- 35:07so evil to the story, it stands out. Again, she's
- 35:13just not in it that much to where I thought it
- 35:14was that large of a deal. And it doesn't make
- 35:16a ton of sense to me. But there's so much that
- 35:19happens in this movie, he says negatively, that...
- 35:22it helps it makes me lose track because you think
- 35:25this would be the end of the story the end of
- 35:27the story would be him coming home fighting for
- 35:29his inheritance and that's it but the majority
- 35:31of you know we'll figure out the inheritance
- 35:33thing is his thought i'm looking for my wife
- 35:35i need to find where angela went off to yeah
- 35:38and this aspect of the story to me is when i
- 35:42think it becomes the most um i have a five -year
- 35:44-old niece lover she's incredible but she just
- 35:48makes things up Her parents asked her about school
- 35:51the other day. And they're like, I don't know
- 35:54what's true and what isn't. Because she just
- 35:57makes things up. And she just starts telling
- 35:59a story and just gets kind of like lost in the
- 36:01story and just starts making things up. That's
- 36:03how this movie feels. This movie by the end just
- 36:05feels like, yeah, and Napoleon Bonaparte was
- 36:08there. And then he tried to steal my girl and
- 36:11there was a necklace. And then I have a son.
- 36:13And anyways, it's okay. I was like, what? None
- 36:17of that is in the court. What? That's not in
- 36:20the movie. It's only in the last 20 minutes that
- 36:22all those things are introduced. And it just
- 36:25feels rushed. And this is a movie that did not
- 36:29need to be any longer by any means. But it feels
- 36:32like a rushed ending. And I just... As soon as
- 36:35they said the name Napoleon... Look, granted,
- 36:37his name is mentioned in the inner cards that
- 36:39you talked about, the inner titles. But when
- 36:41he's actually on screen and he is a character
- 36:44in the movie that has consequence, it's like,
- 36:46what's going on? Like, this is just... I couldn't
- 36:49get into it. Not that I was into it before. Because
- 36:52the plot twist here that occurs is Anthony makes
- 36:57his way back and he's asking about his wife,
- 36:59Angela. Yes. And someone says, oh, well, she's
- 37:02an opera singer now and she's on tour. And he's
- 37:05like, okay. Has zero interest in going to find
- 37:07her, really. Which, again, I'm just like... Red
- 37:10flag. This guy is a problem. I don't really want
- 37:13to be following him. And then you... You learn
- 37:17about Napoleon. You hear more historical stuff
- 37:20like that. But there's a like a masquerade ball
- 37:25that takes place that Anthony attends along with
- 37:27Napoleon is there and Angela is there as well.
- 37:32And you learn this is like a plot twist that
- 37:35was kind of like very obvious to see from a mile
- 37:39away. Well, it was like dripped out to you, you
- 37:42know, like because she is in the musical. Or
- 37:45she's in the opera. Well, I'm talking about the
- 37:47ball. Oh, the ball. Yeah. Yes. Because you see
- 37:50her with Napoleon and you're like, oh, she ended
- 37:53up with Napoleon. Yeah. That's not revealed to
- 37:57Anthony in that moment. Like, I feel instead
- 37:59of the plot twist of, oh, she is with Napoleon
- 38:02romantically. Yeah. It doesn't hit hard where
- 38:06you're like, oh, my God, that's it. Because it
- 38:09takes Anthony. Another 30 minutes to get to the
- 38:12point where he learns that information. Doesn't
- 38:14she have a blonde wig at the party? I think so.
- 38:17And I think that's the kind of thing that's supposed
- 38:19to deter you. It's like, well, that can't be
- 38:20Angela because she has a blonde wig on. And then
- 38:23because she has a mask on the whole time, remember?
- 38:26Yeah. At one point, Napoleon tries to take it
- 38:27off and she sees that Anthony is there and she's
- 38:30like, no, no, no, you can't take this off. So
- 38:32there's the whole she's trying to hide her identity
- 38:34from him, which again, we know. Right. The audience
- 38:37knows. And then later on, they try to do a rug
- 38:41pull reveal of, well, hey, guess what? You actually
- 38:45have a son, Anthony. Yeah. And he's right here.
- 38:49And he's been wanting to meet you for so long.
- 38:51Completely fine. You guys should hang out. I'd
- 38:53love for you to be a part of his life. That's
- 38:55great. You should come see me perform. He goes
- 38:57to see her perform. And while he's going to see
- 38:59her perform, he hears that Mademoiselle can't
- 39:02think of her name. There's like a stage name
- 39:04for her. Yeah. Mademoiselle something is in this.
- 39:08opera she's the best singer and she got this
- 39:11giant necklace diamond necklace from napoleon
- 39:14because that is napoleon's mistress right so
- 39:17then anthony is watching this whole opera and
- 39:20he hears her sing he's like hey that's angela
- 39:22and someone's like no it's not it's mademoiselle
- 39:23whatever and she comes out and they're like yeah
- 39:26that's mademoiselle whatever and she has like
- 39:28the necklace and everything right and that's
- 39:29when anthony pieces together oh She is this woman
- 39:33and she is with Napoleon and I never have a shot
- 39:36against Napoleon. And there's this weird, if
- 39:39I liked the movie, I'd like the shot, but I don't.
- 39:41So I don't like this shot of him walking down
- 39:43the hallway past all these ushers waiting outside
- 39:46of the door of him just defeated and broken and
- 39:49walking towards the camera. And I think I'd like
- 39:52this shot if I liked the movie, but I don't.
- 39:54So I'm just not interested in the shot. Because
- 39:57it's a very emotional, like, it's not in the
- 39:59technicality of it. It's in the emotion of the
- 40:00performance. And it just doesn't feel earned
- 40:03at this point. Because, again, we just watched
- 40:05event after event after event happen. And you're
- 40:08just not, you don't care about this guy. It feels
- 40:10like karma paying off in a way. Right. Where
- 40:13you're just like, not for nothing, dude, but
- 40:15you kind of deserve this. I mean, look what you
- 40:17did in Africa, man. Yeah. This is never going
- 40:19to go well for you. And this results in, I mean,
- 40:24a semi -sweet moment. Even this feels kind of
- 40:27like evil from Olivia's perspective. It makes
- 40:31Olivia feel evil to me in that she leaves a letter
- 40:34for Anthony. And it's at the bedside of their
- 40:38son. And she's like, hey, he should be with you.
- 40:43And he should live with you. He deserves to be
- 40:44with his father. I'm going to chill with Napoleon
- 40:46and keep being the opera singer that I always
- 40:48wanted to be. So I'm going to go off and do that.
- 40:51That was the last time you'll see me. You're
- 40:53never going to see me again. You just go off
- 40:55and enjoy a life with your son. And she abandons
- 40:59her son. And she abandons Anthony, which, you
- 41:01know, at that point, who cares? She hasn't seen
- 41:03him for that long anyways. But she abandons her
- 41:05son. And now it's Anthony and his son. going
- 41:09up against like you know the world and sailing
- 41:11off into this the horizon and there are two lines
- 41:15that i liked from this movie a lot one of them
- 41:18is in that scene and it's where um i can't remember
- 41:21the question he asks but his son asks him a question
- 41:23and he says my father gave me the name anthony
- 41:26adverse brother francois a soul and your mother
- 41:30a heart yeah and i really liked that line him
- 41:33kind of like looking back romantically at the
- 41:35people who brought him here And it was, you know,
- 41:38his father, who he looks at negatively with Don
- 41:40Luis, obviously. Well, not his father, but, you
- 41:42know. He looks at negatively? Don Luis, he'd
- 41:44look at negatively. He's talking about his grandfather.
- 41:47That's why, yeah, I confuse those two. Gave him
- 41:49the name Brother Francois, a soul, and then your
- 41:52mother, a heart. I really liked him looking back.
- 41:54I liked the evolution of his character. Right.
- 41:56So I liked that. A little unearned, but still,
- 41:58I liked that. The other thing was something that
- 42:01I think you and I are going to start saying.
- 42:02At one point, he meets with Faith and Don Louise
- 42:05as an adult, and she tells him all this information,
- 42:09but she also gives him something to drink. And
- 42:11at the end of the conversation that did not go
- 42:13well for Faith, he stands up and he's about to
- 42:18leave, but he comes back and he says, I am indebted
- 42:22for the tea, and then leaves. But he says it
- 42:26just like that. He says, I am indebted, and pauses
- 42:29and looks at her and says, for the tea. And I
- 42:31know that he's thanking her for the beverage,
- 42:34but she just gave him a lot of information. So
- 42:37I definitely took this as him being like, I'm
- 42:40going to start saying that whenever Taylor tells
- 42:41me after hanging out with a friend and she tells
- 42:43me information, I'm going to start saying like,
- 42:44I am indebted for the tea. Yeah. So just letting
- 42:47you know. That's good. I'm going to start using
- 42:49that. I do like it even in the context that he
- 42:51was using it for, where he's like, you just gave
- 42:54me all of this stuff, but I'm only going to thank
- 42:56you for the actual. tea right like the the drink
- 42:59which is how i also feel when people give me
- 43:01information yeah it feels like uh thanks for
- 43:03the beverage but hey appreciate that screw you
- 43:05yeah that's what it feels like i agree yeah it's
- 43:09and i don't mean to just say everything that
- 43:11happens in this movie but like it is just baffling
- 43:15because the first i think there are three parts
- 43:18of this movie I mean, God, there might be eight
- 43:20parts of this movie, honestly. There's a lot
- 43:22of parts. But, like, it just, it feels like it
- 43:25goes absolutely nowhere the entirety of the movie.
- 43:29Yeah. And, you know, I think the middle section
- 43:32of this movie feels like it meanders a lot. It
- 43:34does. But it's mostly because everything you're
- 43:36watching, you're like, I don't like that. Yeah.
- 43:38Get rid of that. Hate it. So by the time you
- 43:42get to the end and you're really at the substance
- 43:44of the movie of, okay, well, what? What is he
- 43:48going to do now that he is returning allegedly
- 43:52to like the people he loves and cares about?
- 43:54Well, Bonnie Feather's dead. He doesn't seem
- 43:57to care much about Angela. And when he does finally
- 44:00find her, it's more of a just, oh, well, time
- 44:03to move on. Not that I even put that much effort
- 44:06into her to begin with. Yeah, I think. I think
- 44:09ultimately this is a movie that I have an issue
- 44:11with the screenplay. Ironically, of seven nominations,
- 44:14not something it was nominated for. So I think
- 44:16that's worth pointing out. It's also interesting.
- 44:19We talk a lot about Cavalcade being one of the
- 44:22worst. Herald is one of the worst Best Picture
- 44:26nominations, let alone Best Picture wins. I've
- 44:29heard Broadway Melody also enter that canon.
- 44:33I don't think that's too soon. I don't agree
- 44:34with that. This is interesting. As of this year,
- 44:382026, Anthony Adverse is the lowest rating on
- 44:41Rotten Tomatoes of any Best Picture nominee.
- 44:43What do you think it's at? On Rotten Tomatoes?
- 44:46Yeah. 42%. 18%. Wow. 18 % on Rotten Tomatoes
- 44:52for Anthony Adverse. Yeah, that's got to be looking
- 44:54at it and being like, this is so politically
- 44:56incorrect. I'm sure there's a large portion of
- 44:59that. A lot of those reviews have to come post,
- 45:01like, 1990. Right. So, I mean, granted, that
- 45:06makes sense. Not an easy movie to look back on
- 45:08and think fondly of. But I think it's worth pointing
- 45:10out that, you know, lowest rating on Rotten Tomatoes
- 45:13of any Best Picture nominee. I think it's earned.
- 45:16I think it's a difficult one to look back at.
- 45:18I thought that Cavalcade was, too. But, I mean,
- 45:20this is... Yikes. Yeah, I think the other thing
- 45:22here is that you have, like, intense melodrama
- 45:26paired with the absurdity of, like, the sober...
- 45:31soap operatic script. Yes. So you're just like,
- 45:34man, all of this feels over the top and just
- 45:37so hand fisted, hand fisted, hand fisted, hand
- 45:41fisted. It feels very soapy. Yeah. It's just,
- 45:44it's so much. And a lot of it feels gross. And
- 45:48a large portion of this movie, I wanted to grab
- 45:52Anthony and just be like, dude, get over it.
- 45:54Just deal with it. I'm tired of you. I say that
- 45:57it's a screenplay issue for me because I did
- 45:59like the acting. I think the acting is good.
- 46:01Yeah. Frederick March, someone we're both a fan
- 46:04of. Yeah. I think he did well. It's just, you
- 46:07know, he's in half the movie and it's a difficult
- 46:09role to deal with. Olivia de Havilland, I like
- 46:13her as well. She has my favorite moment at the
- 46:15end when she is on stage and she's singing and
- 46:18there's a close -up of her and she's crying and
- 46:21under her breath she says, goodbye, Anthony.
- 46:23I think that's the best delivery in the entire
- 46:26movie, personally. I think you're right. I still
- 46:29don't think that it kind of redeems her character
- 46:31of like, hey, take our son and leave. You know,
- 46:34you can look at that as a negative towards her,
- 46:36but you could look at it as a negative towards
- 46:39Anthony as well, where this woman is so like,
- 46:42I feel so bad for Anthony, for everything he's
- 46:46gone through, for him showing up and like, I'm
- 46:48happy. I know that I'm happy because I'm with
- 46:50Napoleon. He doesn't have anything. So I'm going
- 46:54to give him something that he can love, and that
- 46:56is his son. If you look at it from that perspective,
- 47:00Anthony is kind of like, he wins again, you know?
- 47:04I guess so. And, like, the way the son plays
- 47:06it is just like, gee whiz, I'd love to go on
- 47:08the ocean with you, Daddy. Let's go, Dad. And
- 47:11never once is he like, when are we going to see
- 47:12Mommy again? Exactly. He's like, Mommy kind of
- 47:15sucks, huh? Yeah. I thought Claude Rains, Gail
- 47:18Sondergaard, they all did well. I think you're
- 47:21right that Olivia de Havilland might be the standout
- 47:23for that moment that she has. But otherwise,
- 47:26there isn't really anything that stands out as
- 47:27like, oh, the acting in this movie is phenomenal.
- 47:29It's just good. And I don't think it's the problem.
- 47:32Art direction, I think, is good as well. I like
- 47:35how they depicted Italy, Havana, Africa. I think
- 47:40that all this did pretty well. The thing I did
- 47:42really like is there are... moments where it
- 47:45shows uh ships uh on the sea they reuse the miniatures
- 47:50from the port royale scene in captain blood i
- 47:53did see that this was from fred jackson fred
- 47:55jackson's miniatures that he built uh those are
- 47:57reused i like that i like being able to see that
- 48:00in there but it's used to much less excitement
- 48:03and intention. Intention is the right word, meaning,
- 48:07than it was in Captain Blood. So I don't think
- 48:09it's like a highlight of the movie or a standout
- 48:12that people should see it for. Right, right.
- 48:14It's just there. It's funny, the last line, the
- 48:17note I have from the movie is, I'm a sucker for
- 48:19ship footage, it turns out. Yeah. Where it ends
- 48:22with the ship sailing away and Anthony heading
- 48:24to America. And just looking at the ships, I'm
- 48:27like... They do this. They always look good in
- 48:29these old films. They do. And at least that's
- 48:31a positive that it ends on that note. The art
- 48:34direction, I do want to shout out. Much as I
- 48:38despise the middle section that took place in
- 48:40Africa, that is a 12 acre African set that they
- 48:43built. And up to this time, it was the largest
- 48:46set to build. So Warner Brothers breaking records
- 48:48left and right with this movie. I just don't
- 48:50like any of those records. I mean, when I saw
- 48:54that they were going to Africa and it dealt with
- 48:57any kind of like slave trading and I saw there
- 49:00was a nomination for assistant director, I was
- 49:02like, oh, no. Yeah, what happened out there in
- 49:05Africa? I was like, I had flashbacks of Trader
- 49:08Horn or of Lives of a Bengal Lancer. And not
- 49:14too much. Like he said, they built a set for
- 49:15it. So thank God nothing really happened there.
- 49:18Film editing from Ralph Dawson. Sure. I didn't
- 49:23really see any issues with film editing on this.
- 49:24No reason for him not to be nominated. This has
- 49:26got to be one of those where it's like, this
- 49:27movie's over two hours long. There was a lot
- 49:30of footage, and he put it together. Into a cohesive
- 49:34story. I, okay, the only reason that I can't
- 49:39really comment and say like film editing is great
- 49:41is to me, the film editing, I also lump that
- 49:44in with, or I should say factor that in with
- 49:47the inner titles. I see. Yeah. So I don't like
- 49:52that aspect. I don't like how that pieces the
- 49:54story together. And that to me is the editing.
- 49:55You know, what's really interesting in relation
- 49:58to that is I said this was based on the book
- 50:01series. Of Anthony Adverse. Apparently this is
- 50:04based on the first eight of nine books. I don't
- 50:07know what happens in that ninth book. Boy, I'm
- 50:09not interested. But I think that's, people were
- 50:12mad when they took The Hobbit and stretched it
- 50:14into three movies. This is the opposite where
- 50:17they said, let's take eight novels and put it
- 50:19all into two and a half hours. Oh, that makes
- 50:21so much more sense because there are like, when
- 50:24we got to hour two, really hour three, and they
- 50:27were like, hey, Napoleon Bonaparte's a character
- 50:29in this. I was like, can you end? Can this movie
- 50:32just be over? What is going on? Original score,
- 50:36I got nothing bad to say about Korngold. I got
- 50:38nothing good to say either. I don't remember
- 50:40the music. And, you know, I almost feel bad going
- 50:44down the list at the end here and just being
- 50:46like, yeah, this thing was good. This thing was
- 50:48okay. This was fine. The reason that I want to
- 50:50go through this, though, is that for film editing,
- 50:52score, cinematography, and best supporting actress,
- 50:55it took the win. Yeah, four wins there. Yeah,
- 50:59you know, we're not done watching everything
- 51:00yet, so our thoughts on that as a whole will
- 51:04remain unseen until the ceremony episode at the
- 51:07end of the month. Right. But I am kind of like,
- 51:09this isn't it. This isn't the one, guys. I think
- 51:12that the reason this happens is, and again, you're
- 51:15right, we haven't seen everything, so we can't
- 51:17say with full certainty, but I think that I am
- 51:19a very big advocate. I should take that back.
- 51:22I'm a big believer in the Academy following a
- 51:26trend. And I think that they see something working
- 51:29like an epic and they're like, Hey, these epics
- 51:31are doing really well. Yeah. Great. Let's film
- 51:33more epics. And you kind of lose sight of what
- 51:36epics means. Does that mean epic adventure like
- 51:38a Captain Blood? Does that mean epic in terms
- 51:40of the storytelling of a David Copperfield, like
- 51:43just a day in the life? And I think this falls
- 51:46more in the camp of David Copperfield. Sure.
- 51:48Nothing really happens, but it is this one person's
- 51:51life. And I think that the Academy is like, yeah,
- 51:54that's the stuff. That's the stuff we're capable
- 51:57of now. Because now we're getting to a point
- 51:59where we are seeing what we are fully capable
- 52:01of with these cameras and these new... technology
- 52:04this new technology that we can do i say new
- 52:07it's been years old at this point but audio visual
- 52:10look at what we can do now let's push the limits
- 52:12on this and these epics are the way that we do
- 52:14that and that will change we will see movies
- 52:16in the coming months for us years of the academy
- 52:19that i think will change the way they look at
- 52:21these movies but for right now cavalcade I'm
- 52:25trying to think of another one that won Best
- 52:26Picture. Cimarron. Cimarron. I think that is
- 52:29what we are currently looking at and saying,
- 52:31hey, this is what we can do to win these awards.
- 52:33And it's working. That brings up what I want
- 52:36to ask you about. There's two little concepts
- 52:38here I want to talk about briefly because we're
- 52:41running on time. Oscar bait. Yeah. This feels
- 52:45like Oscar bait. It does. And I don't know if
- 52:47that is a concept. Even the name. Yeah. I don't
- 52:49know if that's a concept that has existed as
- 52:51early as 1936. But man, it feels that way. I
- 52:56think it's less bait. I think that's what the
- 52:59term has come to be known as. And I think it's
- 53:01more the studios look at what has worked. Yeah.
- 53:04And we have now put the importance of this title.
- 53:07So they are following that trend. And that is
- 53:10what becomes Oscar bait. And that leads me to
- 53:13the second part of this is the studios know what
- 53:17works. Yeah. You brought up a comparison to modern
- 53:21day at the beginning of this episode. I think
- 53:24that, like I said, it's not the code like coming
- 53:29out of the pre -code era that's making these
- 53:31movies feel rough for me. I think that we are
- 53:34falling into studios following trends and pumping
- 53:38out kind of very similar products and really
- 53:42kind of treating the films like products. It's
- 53:44not until you get like these auteur directors.
- 53:47doing unique things and trying risque things
- 53:49like John Ford with the Informer. Those are the
- 53:52things that I'm enjoying seeing, but it's when
- 53:54the studios have like a very tight grip on what's
- 53:58being produced, which I think is happening in
- 54:01the modern day as well. That's why we're seeing
- 54:03Disney live action remakes or we're still in
- 54:06the superhero craze or, you know, like indie
- 54:08films aren't making a headway in the box office
- 54:12sans obsession this year. Yeah, I think it's
- 54:15that mirror of, okay, we've reached the product
- 54:19series of films. Yeah, I think that's right.
- 54:23I wonder if that's why I like Frank Gaffer so
- 54:25much. I wonder if, you know, and you're right,
- 54:28there are like John Ford's like the Informer,
- 54:31the Mervyn LeRoy of like I Am Future from a Chain
- 54:33Gang. So it's not even just like you can tell
- 54:35by director, but there are like specific names
- 54:38that I think when you hear it, you're like, oh,
- 54:40I'm more likely to like this one because of what
- 54:43they've done. And maybe that's why I like Capra
- 54:45so much, because in a sea of studios trying to
- 54:47give you what they think is popular, you have
- 54:49a vision from a director that's like. Well, despite
- 54:52on whether this is popular or not, this is what
- 54:54I believe. And granted, the Venn diagram is a
- 54:58circle, right? That is what the Academy wants
- 55:02and what Capra is giving. It's that. Sometimes
- 55:05it's more successful than others, but that's
- 55:06it. So maybe that's why. But I mean, you're dead
- 55:09on. Like, that's what's happening at this point
- 55:11in time. It continues to happen. Some years are
- 55:14better than others, but this continues to happen.
- 55:15And studios will say, hey, these movies, this
- 55:18is what we've been awarded in the past. And this
- 55:20is going to get us like a guaranteed boost in
- 55:22sales. So let's aim for that. Yeah. Yeah. And
- 55:25I don't want to say I'm really looking forward
- 55:28to the 60s and 70s because that is years away.
- 55:31Yeah. There's still a lot of good stuff to come
- 55:34in between then. There is. It's just we're going
- 55:36to have to go through a sea of studios still
- 55:38thinking that this is going to get them the win.
- 55:41Sometimes it does and sometimes it doesn't. I
- 55:43don't want to say I'm dreading. I'm like anticipating
- 55:46the next few years at least being like walking
- 55:50through a minefield, but you really hope you
- 55:52hit the mines. Yes. Because those are the good
- 55:55ones and they're very few and far in between.
- 55:57And then sometimes you watch Anthony Adverse
- 55:59and you're like, I hope I step on a mine. Right.
- 56:01Yeah. Just give it to me. With that said, let's
- 56:04get right into ratings. I think you and I landed
- 56:07the same where. Yes, we did. Yeah, we landed
- 56:09in the same place on this. So we both gave it
- 56:11two and a half stars. Yeah. And normally what
- 56:13we do is we sit back and we say, you know what?
- 56:16You and I talked about it. I feel differently.
- 56:18I think maybe I want to rate this three. Is this
- 56:20the rare occasion where I think we change it
- 56:23and go down? I wouldn't be against that. I, cause
- 56:27talking about this, even the positive things
- 56:29I had to say about it, I don't think it gets
- 56:31that two and a half. I'm going to change it right
- 56:32now. I'm going to put it. I think it's two. Yeah.
- 56:34I think it's two. I think that I noticed Bryce
- 56:37rated this at two. Yeah. And sometimes I look
- 56:40at Bryce and I'm like, I don't know, man, I think
- 56:41you were a little harsh on it. And then talking
- 56:42about it with you, I'm like, now you're right.
- 56:44Danny Reed also gave it a two. Look at that.
- 56:46So I think it's two. I think it's two. I'm changing
- 56:49mine as well. It is a drag. I kind of, this is
- 56:53rare, but I agree with Rotten Tomatoes. This
- 56:56isn't the one. I mean, it's sitting at a 2 .9
- 56:59on Letterboxd. That's too high. That's 2 .9 high.
- 57:03It's true. No, it's too high. Also, it's two
- 57:06hours and 21 minutes. Yeah, it is. It feels three
- 57:09and a half. It's very long. And I think we've
- 57:13just seen a lot of very long, uninteresting movies
- 57:16recently. I'm thinking Midsummer Night's Dream
- 57:18is a big comparable. The Great Ziegfeld. Great
- 57:22Ziegfeld. I enjoyed it, but I can't disagree
- 57:25with you on the length of it and how long it
- 57:27feels. And if you don't enjoy it, my God, is
- 57:30that just going to be even longer? So weird time
- 57:32that we're in right now. I did do a double feature
- 57:35here where I compared this to the only other
- 57:38movie I could think of that kind of tackled.
- 57:41traveling to an international location and the
- 57:45idea of like i really did try to stay away from
- 57:48slave trading as much as i could here but the
- 57:50idea of uh money coming into play with love and
- 57:54how that can complicate things and i actually
- 57:56went with the 2008 bosnian film australia okay
- 58:00did you ever see this nope I saw it in theaters,
- 58:02and it definitely sells itself as an epic, and
- 58:06it's Baz Luhrmann just trying to show you what's
- 58:08so great about Australia. It's a period piece,
- 58:12Nicole Kidman, Hugh Jackman. The Australians?
- 58:15Yeah, exactly. And I believe she is like an heiress,
- 58:20or she's recently come to some money, and she
- 58:23comes in to kind of oversee the production here,
- 58:26and she falls in love with a stock. Or not stock,
- 58:29but like a trader of sorts. Yeah. And that's
- 58:31Hugh Jackman. And then the sweeping romance of
- 58:34them falling in love in Australia in this time.
- 58:36That to me just kind of stood out as Anthony
- 58:38Diverse. I enjoyed Australia more than I enjoyed
- 58:40this. And I'm not going to tell you Australia
- 58:41is a great movie. But I enjoyed it fine in theaters.
- 58:44And I think it's a nice subtle movie from Baz
- 58:46Luhrmann, who otherwise is a very like flashy
- 58:48director. Yeah. So worth checking out if you
- 58:51have like a free Sunday. But that's my double
- 58:53feature. My favorite thing is the tagline for
- 58:55Australia is welcome to Australia. That's it.
- 58:59There's no other aspect. It's literally just
- 59:01welcome to Australia exclamation point. Let's
- 59:03get to yours. So my double feature, I went with
- 59:06the story of somebody who is so unlucky. That
- 59:10it almost feels like maybe they are cursed. Did
- 59:13you reference this movie earlier? No. Okay. What
- 59:17was it? I thought you were going to do Alexander
- 59:18and the No Good. Oh. Terrible, horrible day.
- 59:21That would be good. That would be good. No, I
- 59:23went with Sam Raimi's Drag Me to Hell. Yeah,
- 59:26that's right. Now, was this a double feature
- 59:28that you had because of the content of the movie?
- 59:31Or was this your sentiment finishing Anthony
- 59:33Adverse? Well, I felt like I had been dragged
- 59:36to hell while I was watching Anthony Adverse.
- 59:39But this very much is like, I don't think this
- 59:42guy had it this bad. You know who did have it
- 59:44bad? The girl who had a goat spew goo all over
- 59:50her. That's what I think. I was wondering what
- 59:52this movie was missing, and I think you nailed
- 59:54it. It was missing a cartoonish anvil landing
- 59:57on someone's head. Exactly. That's what I'm saying.
- 1:00:00I love when that movie's Looney Tunes. Yeah,
- 1:00:03it's a great movie. Well, that's one of my favorite
- 1:00:06Sam Raimi movies. I don't think that's a controversial
- 1:00:08thing to say. Yeah. I think that's like so Sam
- 1:00:12Raimi. Quintessential Sam Raimi is what I'd say.
- 1:00:15An hour and three? Real quick. Oh, I took a lot
- 1:00:17of breaks, so it's like an hour. Justin Long's
- 1:00:19face at the end of that movie when what happens
- 1:00:22happens, that face is like so real shock and
- 1:00:26horror to me. It's like one of my favorite small
- 1:00:29little performances where I'm like. Give him
- 1:00:32the Oscar for that one 30 -second clip. I think
- 1:00:36that'd be so funny if you give someone an acting
- 1:00:38performance. You give an acting performance award
- 1:00:41in Drag Me to Hell, and it's not Alison Lohman
- 1:00:44or The Witch. Yeah. That's really funny. Also,
- 1:00:47one quick thing about Drag Me to Hell. I always
- 1:00:49really liked the poster for that movie. It's
- 1:00:51just a huge spoiler. Yeah. It's just the last
- 1:00:54scene of the movie, which is great. I used to
- 1:00:56have this, I worked at Blockbuster, so we had
- 1:00:58the window clings of posters all the time. And
- 1:01:01we would just throw that away. And I was like,
- 1:01:03give it to me. And I had like a giant, giant
- 1:01:06window cling in my bedroom of the poster of Drag
- 1:01:09Me to Hell. And it was just Alison Lohman's face.
- 1:01:11Perfect. Just being dragged to hell. I like that
- 1:01:13movie a lot. It's great. Guys, that's Anthony
- 1:01:15Advers. If you have, I wasn't, it was Drag Me
- 1:01:18to Hell. I want to know what you guys think of
- 1:01:22this movie if you've seen it, but also, like,
- 1:01:25what do you think is the most egregious example
- 1:01:29of, like, an Oscar bait movie? Because really
- 1:01:33this year that we've been covering kind of feels
- 1:01:36like the introduction to that type of movie,
- 1:01:38and it's starting to feel a little sour. It is.
- 1:01:43And also let us know what do you think was...
- 1:01:46Some of the worst Best Picture nominees. Yeah.
- 1:01:48Clearly, this is the lowest rated. So what do
- 1:01:51you think of what you've seen was what you would
- 1:01:53consider the lowest rated? Yeah. Shoot us an
- 1:01:55email at OUTAOPodcast at gmail .com with your
- 1:01:59thoughts on those topics. Also, be sure to check
- 1:02:02out the Patreon. We do this all the time. Let's
- 1:02:04start the next episode with this. I was just
- 1:02:06about to say we're going to start it because
- 1:02:08I think it's better to say it up top. I think
- 1:02:09so too. That's so funny. I was literally just
- 1:02:10thinking that. But yeah, check out the Patreon,
- 1:02:13patreon .com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast for
- 1:02:16all of the benefits. The link down there is in
- 1:02:18the show notes. Also, we always say like there's
- 1:02:20benefits included, which I think is a good like,
- 1:02:22hey, this is what you get. But it does also help
- 1:02:26us as well. Like there are monetary. requirements
- 1:02:30for running the podcast with like hosting and
- 1:02:32all of that so that tiny little contribution
- 1:02:35to the show does actually benefit us a lot it
- 1:02:38means a lot and it allows us to do more in the
- 1:02:40future uh so if you are enjoying the podcast
- 1:02:43please continue to support it both in downloading
- 1:02:46and following and also subscribing to the patreon
- 1:02:49and sharing and sharing because we look forward
- 1:02:51to uh doing more for you in the future yeah but
- 1:02:54that's going to do it next episode we will be
- 1:02:56covering Romeo and Juliet. One of the two adaptations
- 1:03:02that were nominated? I think so. That's a wild
- 1:03:04thing to ask me to speak on. Do it right now.
- 1:03:07You should. It is. There's a later one in the
- 1:03:1050s or 60s. Gotcha. So stay tuned for that. As
- 1:03:13always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you
- 1:03:16at the movies.