Latest / The Lancet Planetary Health in conversation with / Healthpunk: Imagining the Planetary Health We Actually Want
Transcript
- 0:01This is an AI generated transcript
- 0:01Welcome to this, uh, new episode of, uh, The Lancet Planetary
- 0:04Health In Conversation.
- 0:06Within, should say rather than with.
- 0:10Because of the topic we are gonna talk about, I think we
- 0:13should do something different.
- 0:14I should change the soundtrack if I could, I would, but I can't.
- 0:21I'm here with Al, editor-in-chief of The Lancet Planetary Health.
- 0:24Hi, Matteo.
- 0:25And, uh, we are gonna talk about health punk
- 0:34A viewpoint article that has been published a while ago in the journal.
- 0:40And to start, can you explain me what is a viewpoint?
- 0:44Yeah, sure.
- 0:45Yeah, so the viewpoint section is what, you know, sits within the
- 0:48green section of the journal, which is essentially the review section.
- 0:51So in the review section we have r- obviously traditional reviews and
- 0:55including systematic reviews, and we have these kind of more looser
- 1:00categories of content, which includes viewpoints and personal views.
- 1:03And the, um, they're essentially a space for people to talk a little bit more
- 1:09speculatively, still in a scholarly way and, and root in the literature, but more
- 1:12speculatively about, you know, maybe a, the, where a field needs to go or where
- 1:16they think it's going, or talk about wider issues about, uh, uh, that sort of
- 1:20situate the research in a wider context.
- 1:22Okay, that's very interesting.
- 1:24And, uh, in this section of the journal, you published this paper that
- 1:29is Health Punk: Speculative Methods for the Future of Planetary Health.
- 1:33I love the title, so tell me a little bit about it.
- 1:37First of all, punk.
- 1:40Immediately, um, conjures up images of kind of 1980s, uh, mohawk.
- 1:45Yeah, yeah.
- 1:45Uh, definitely, definitely.
- 1:47I mean, I think the punk, punk reference here is, uh, is kind of, um, you know,
- 1:51against the status quo, if you like, or in contrast to the status quo.
- 1:54So I think the, the punk component invites people involved in Health Punk,
- 1:59if you like, to think, uh, more broadly and potentially critically about the
- 2:04way things are, are currently organized.
- 2:06Reading the article, I loved it.
- 2:08Taking these problems about planetary health and healthcare and basically the
- 2:13author, they made this experiment, no?
- 2:16And they took some students and they challenged them to think at healthcare
- 2:22problem in a completely different way.
- 2:24That's right.
- 2:25Yeah, so if we just take a step back for a minute, there are a lot of problems
- 2:29in society, including within lots of specific disciplines, but I think it's
- 2:33exemplified within kind of sustainability and planetary health, that we have
- 2:37problems in society which is hard to imagine how they can be easily addressed
- 2:42within the kind of current systems.
- 2:44And in fact, if you think about it, they're not just kind of like
- 2:48quirks of the system, they're actually features of the system.
- 2:50So un- unsustainable use of resources, you know, no real plan to do
- 2:55anything other than just keep using resources as fast as we possibly can.
- 2:59These are kind of fundamental problems the way that the world operates currently.
- 3:04And so if you do research that highlights these problems, fairly quickly gets
- 3:08you to a point where you say, "Well, what can we do about this? How can we
- 3:11solve this problem?" And in order to do that, you have to be able to think
- 3:14about, well, how should the future look or how could the future look?
- 3:17And very often when you start trying to make changes, it has to fit
- 3:21within the kind of status quo, within the kind of the norms of the day.
- 3:25And they seem, it seems quite hard to make the s- the scale of changes that the
- 3:29evidence is showing that we need to make.
- 3:31So there's this kind of like fundamental tension between- You know, the world
- 3:34that we're observing and the sort of the level of change that we would
- 3:38need to address the, them, and the kind of resistance to those changes.
- 3:43And so the how we think about the future and how open we are to thinking
- 3:48about the future is ac- is actually really fundamental to how we come
- 3:51up with solutions and the type of solutions that are, that are possible.
- 3:55And I think what this piece is trying to do is, is kind of illustrate the fact that
- 3:58most people are actually very constrained in their visions of the future.
- 4:01They tend to think very narrowly, very sort of technically, tactically, if you
- 4:05like, rather than kind of strategically and, or, and even more broadly than
- 4:09that, you know, kind of creatively.
- 4:10What kind of future do we want?
- 4:12If we're thinking about forecasting, you know, climate scenarios to the
- 4:162100s, so the end of the century, you know, what kind of world
- 4:19would we want that to look like?
- 4:21We don't only want to avoid terrible risks, we also, uh, we, you know,
- 4:25invites the question, well, what sort of future would we like, um, it to be?
- 4:30Uh, and I think there's a kind of a political tendency, perhaps it's
- 4:34engineered, perhaps it's a, just a, a pattern of thought or maybe both,
- 4:38where just people, uh, assume the status quo will continue more or
- 4:42less, and then we will just tweak it a little bit this way or that.
- 4:45And I think Health Punk is really a way to, to open the people's
- 4:48minds beyond that, that framework.
- 4:50Do you think this should be addressed not only to researchers, but also to
- 4:55politicians and everyone that is involved?
- 4:58Are we suggesting that we are doing the wrong thing?
- 5:01Well, I think that there's a big value judgment about what, that there's
- 5:04no right answer to what the future should look like, and many people…
- 5:08Part of the process is to have lots of people participate in
- 5:12that v- vision and think about it.
- 5:15Um, I think to simply accept that the way we're doing things now is the right
- 5:18way and will inevitably continue, that's not an apolitical thing, that's a, that's
- 5:22a, actually a choice in and of itself.
- 5:25And the evidence certainly shows that if we carry on doing that, then we're gonna
- 5:29come up against all kinds of environmental barriers which we're already pushing
- 5:33up against or even pushing through.
- 5:35And not only that, we're also gonna fail to achieve many of the
- 5:38kind of social and health outcomes that we're trying to achieve.
- 5:41So in that sense, you can say, yeah, therefore, if we carry on doing what
- 5:46we're doing, we can readily identify all kinds of problems that are either
- 5:50already happening or will, will continue to happen or will become worse.
- 5:54So we need to be able to think about the future in a more open way,
- 5:58and in ways that might genuinely help to tackle these, um, issues.
- 6:02I think that's fair.
- 6:03Of course, there's lots of debate about what that should look like.
- 6:06I love the idea of having an open mind when approaching
- 6:10healthcare and research questions.
- 6:13Probably my old former colleagues from the university will hate me
- 6:17for this, but I always thought that research, they struggle to
- 6:22have a broader view among things.
- 6:24Uh, maybe it's part of, uh, the scientifical process as well,
- 6:28the observational process.
- 6:29So you look at a problem, and you look at the problem confined in these boundaries.
- 6:34As a first approach to the solution is within those boundaries.
- 6:37Instead, what is Health Punk is suggesting is open up the boundaries.
- 6:41Try not to think just at what you see, but what you foresee.
- 6:46Yeah, there's a few things to touch on there.
- 6:48I think what you're describing, it, it largely probably comes under this category
- 6:52of kind of siloed thinking, right?
- 6:53Which is like if you're a doctor, then you're concerned with the health of
- 6:57individuals, and so the things within your remit are probably things that
- 7:01you can do to help your patients on a day-to-day basis within the current
- 7:05system that we're operating in.
- 7:07So for example, if you're a, you know, cardiac surgeon, and lots of people are
- 7:12coming to you with advanced heart disease, and there are surgical solutions, but
- 7:16they're- That you also might see that there are kind of lifestyle and, you
- 7:21know, social and economic factors that are pushing people towards the lifestyles
- 7:24that are causing these problems.
- 7:27But as a surgeon, you might not feel that that's within your remit, that's,
- 7:30that you have the power to ch- to influence or change those things.
- 7:33So now some, some do, you know, take a, an, an interest in lobbying in
- 7:38more broadly and looking at those upstream drivers, but many don't
- 7:41because they don't see it as their sort of wheelhouse, if you like.
- 7:44So I think that's a kind of an analogy for how if you think only within silos,
- 7:48it kind of cuts off your capacity and, and within narrow expertise, it
- 7:52cuts off your capacity or even your kind of legitimacy to have an opinion
- 7:56outside of that territory, right?
- 7:57Like, if people might say to a surgeon who's worried about, you know,
- 8:01obesity, "Well, stay in your lane.
- 8:03You know, you're, you're an expert on, you know, surgical techniques.
- 8:06Deal with that.
- 8:07Don't start telling people what food we should tax." But similarly, that's a
- 8:10kind of a very limiting mindset, right?
- 8:12Because it means that you're not allowed, uh, to talk more broadly.
- 8:16And I think that's, that's just one example, but I think that actually
- 8:18cuts across pretty much all areas of knowledge, where people tend to
- 8:22think within quite strict silos, and they have a sense about what's their,
- 8:26like, legitimate, you know, territory where they're allowed to comment.
- 8:29And then outside of that, they, they feel that, uh, it's not really
- 8:33their place, even if they might have an opinion as a citizen.
- 8:36No, that's why I've, I've loved this article, and the authors challenge the
- 8:41students to write a science fiction story.
- 8:44That was the final exam of this whole course.
- 8:47So to use a science fiction to go a little bit beyond what they usually do
- 8:53and to think creatively, I would suggest people to go to the website and read
- 8:58some of the stories because they are very interesting, and there is a lot of more.
- 9:02But- I guess the one health aspect is very evident.
- 9:08So we need to look at everything as a whole system rather than
- 9:14a single system, isn't it?
- 9:16Yeah, I think that's right.
- 9:17I mean, so in the exercise that, in a, one of the kind of contributions of the piece
- 9:21was not just to, you know, talk about the fact that science fiction exists,
- 9:25right, and climate fiction exists, but to think about is there a framework with
- 9:29which it can be useful within the kind of wider program of planetary health
- 9:33and the, and wider kind of integrated ways of understanding the world.
- 9:37What they did was to challenge people to, to write, you know, more creatively.
- 9:42And perhaps one of the i- more interesting things, at least initially
- 9:45about it, is just that a lot of students found that very hard.
- 9:48Yeah.
- 9:49' Cause they're very used to thinking within certain boundaries and
- 9:52very comfortable sitting there.
- 9:54And when you invite them to step outside of that, it's difficult.
- 9:57Uh, and it's also can be kind of disempowering, right?
- 10:00Because you go, because it immediately takes you to a place where you
- 10:04don't have a lot of agency, right?
- 10:06To, to use the surgeon example again, it's like actually you have relatively large
- 10:10amount of agency in terms of the kind of technical details of your day job, but you
- 10:14don't have a lot of agency in terms of, you know, the wider marketing landscape.
- 10:20So it can be challenging, but I think that that's where the idea is, I suppose,
- 10:24that people in many different silos, if you like intellectual and, uh, like
- 10:29industrial silos, all have a more open mind to working more collaboratively with
- 10:35other individuals, and I think that's probably one of the key kind of challenges
- 10:38and perhaps one of the reasons why we have so many of the problems we have is
- 10:42because decisions are made in silos, as in without regard to other, um, factors.
- 10:49So we need to get much better at working across those different categories and
- 10:54doing that in a kind of a really joined up way where people don't just kind
- 10:59of, you know, ask for a little bit of input but still hold all of the power
- 11:02and decision making, but people are much more collaborative in trying to
- 11:04understand the nature of the challenges and how, you know, what the kind of
- 11:08complementarities and trade-offs might be in policies in different areas.
- 11:11And I think this kind of approach is potentially really opens people's minds
- 11:16to that because if people in all of these different areas Have this opportunity
- 11:20to essentially think much bigger, right?
- 11:22Think much more widely, and try and understand how their piece of the
- 11:26puzzle fits within that wider framework.
- 11:28It's kind of hard to avoid the understanding that you actually,
- 11:32to do your job well, you need to be talking outside of your
- 11:35immediate sphere of influence.
- 11:37Now, that's still hard to do, but it's gotta start with people wanting to
- 11:41do it, and I guess that's where this, this kind of idea of a health punk,
- 11:45you know, tasks within training or, um, potentially could really help.
- 11:49So we should integrate the medical school, uh, curricula with, uh, some
- 11:56kind of a more creative subject, movie history, science fiction history.
- 12:01I think it would be fun for them who are studying medicine.
- 12:04Sure.
- 12:04I mean, I think that, you know, I'm sure that medical curricula are already very
- 12:07packed, and there's all kinds of reasons why it would be hard, you know, to fit in.
- 12:12So … And it's always hard, it's always easy to just argue for
- 12:14more of everything, but that's not necessarily gonna be practical.
- 12:17But I do think that if it's possible to create environments where people are able
- 12:23to think more broadly and to challenge the kind of, the norms, um, that they
- 12:28operate within, then I, I think that is potentially helpful in being more
- 12:33innovative and more creative about how we might solve problems in the future.
- 12:37I would come back to this idea that I think because the way that things
- 12:40are done at the moment is, in certain respects at least, is pretty effective-
- 12:45People sit within that framework and they assume it's the right framework
- 12:48that's gonna solve all problems, and to step outside of it seems kind of radical
- 12:53and crazy, you know, dangerous even.
- 12:56You know, we need to be willing to, to look at the positives about the
- 12:59way things work at the moment, but we also need to be willing to look at the
- 13:02negatives and look at the constraints.
- 13:04And I think that the only way that you… Well, certainly one way that you can do
- 13:08that is to kind of try and think more broadly and try and really understand, you
- 13:11know, conceptually how your piece of work fits in with the wider landscape of things
- 13:16that, you know, we're trying to achieve as, you know, people and societies.
- 13:20So I do think there's, there's probably is a place for it.
- 13:23I'm sure that there would be many people that would find it, you know,
- 13:25that would resist it and would consider it to be a kind of a distraction from
- 13:28just getting on with the kind of detail of what they want to get on with.
- 13:31But I would probably say maybe they're the people that would benefit the most
- 13:34from, you know, being challenged, or, or at least, you know, I wouldn't claim to,
- 13:38to have the right answer here, so I'm not s- like claiming that this is, um, truth,
- 13:42but I would, but simply that from my point of view, having some challenges to
- 13:48your standard ways of thinking is likely to open your mind and make you more able
- 13:52to look at the problems and come up with a wider range of solutions essentially,
- 13:57rather than a very tightly constrained set of kind of managerial level solutions.
- 14:02And it seems it, it's the author's view as well.
- 14:05I mean, uh-
- 14:05For sure.
- 14:06I mean, you can't work in planetary health really and have any other
- 14:08view because you… What the science is telling us is that there are all
- 14:12these really big problems, fundamental problems which are not getting
- 14:17resolved anything like quickly enough.
- 14:18You know, at the moment we're kind of, you know, in a supertanker heading
- 14:22towards cliffs, and the people are arguing about, you know, the, to use
- 14:28the kind of analogy of, you know, people are arguing, rearranging the
- 14:30deckchairs on the Titanic kind of thing.
- 14:32People are arguing about small nuances about, you know, how you
- 14:36arrange things within the tanker, but fundamentally the tanker's still…
- 14:39It's not just drifting, it's motoring in that direction.
- 14:43And so there is just the nature of what we understand about the risks
- 14:47is that we need to change course.
- 14:49That means we need to look ahead, we need to look at what the other obstacles are.
- 14:53We need to be much more open-minded about how we go about solving those problems.
- 14:57Um, and that's not gonna be easy.
- 14:59It starts with looking up and looking forward and, and being open.
- 15:03Yeah.
- 15:03About this, it's, it's a hot topic, I know, and, uh, it seems that we are all
- 15:07talking about AI and one of the most important AI limitation is that it's
- 15:13not creative, it's not intelligent.
- 15:15There is serious issues with the skilling, with always doing the same things.
- 15:21It's like templates.
- 15:23Now, when you base everything on a template, everything will, will
- 15:26look the same at a certain point.
- 15:28Do you think this can be a problem in this kind of approach?
- 15:32I'll obviously caveat this with I'm no expert on AI.
- 15:35I think that ironically, AI is quite good at making connection, because
- 15:39essentially it's statistical models making connections between things, right?
- 15:43Based on, on known data.
- 15:45Yeah.
- 15:45Uh, but it finds its own patterns.
- 15:47And so there, ironically, it might actually be quite good at helping
- 15:51to break down disciplinary silos if employed in the, in the correct way But
- 15:56certainly yes, that also it's trained on the existing data, if you like, of
- 16:01society, and that tends to have all kinds of intrinsic biases within it.
- 16:05Um, I would probably say from my point of view, I'm most worried
- 16:07about the fact that, you know, who owns the biggest models and what's,
- 16:10what are their vested interests.
- 16:13You know, I think to draw again on, like, sci-fi literature, there are
- 16:16kind of two models of, um, you know, the rise of the machines kind of
- 16:22that, that spring to mind for me.
- 16:24One is kind of Terminator, right?
- 16:25Which is, oh, they become self-aware and they destroy us all, which is, you know,
- 16:28s- they keep telling us that there's a non-zero risk of, which is alarming.
- 16:33But maybe I'm naive, but I'm not too worried about that.
- 16:36Another, uh, sci-fi that kind of explored this was kind of RoboCop, right?
- 16:39Which was it was essentially big, sinister corporations running
- 16:44robots and intelligent, uh, machines to, to their own interests.
- 16:48The way this is tied to kind of Plan 2 health and these ideas is
- 16:51that they, these interests tend to be tied to existing norms, right?
- 16:56Which is like fossil fuel use and it, it, you know, existing structures.
- 16:59So I do think that there is a real risk the owners of the AI tools kind of skew
- 17:05them towards certain worldviews and certain kind of solutions, which are quite
- 17:10constrained to maintaining the interests of those people that own those models.
- 17:15Oh, how that will play out in reality, of course, who knows?
- 17:18Because there might be th- there'll be some backlash against these big models
- 17:21and lots of creation of lots of other small alternative ones, I don't know.
- 17:24But for me, that's probably what worries me mostly is like the who
- 17:29owns the models and what do they benefit from, and are they really
- 17:31generating them in a way that is, that's not pursuing their own interests.
- 17:36And is there transparency for us to even know?
- 17:38You know, how do we know?
- 17:39So I think that that's the kind of concern for me.
- 17:41Uh, but there is also, of course, as, as you say, this, this issue.
- 17:45For example, underserved groups, there's probably not much data,
- 17:48there's probably not much information.
- 17:49We probably don't talk about them or think about them much enough, and
- 17:53that, and the AI is gonna pick up on that and cast that, those kind
- 17:56of, um, you know, biases forward.
- 17:58So, so, so that's certainly an issue as well.
- 18:00Yeah.
- 18:02While you were talking, I was thinking that punk exactly like fight
- 18:06the power, you know, in a certain way, and so I, I believe that the
- 18:10title of this paper is magnificent.
- 18:12I, I lo- I love it.
- 18:14The punk concept of it is getting more and more important as we talk.
- 18:20So I think, yeah, we should all look at everything from a
- 18:23different point of view sometimes.
- 18:25Yeah.
- 18:26And from a br- more inclusive point of view, trying to think not
- 18:30only what we know and what we are.
- 18:32And I think w- it's just important to always, uh, be willing to
- 18:35criticize systems of power and influence, essentially.
- 18:38There's, there's no… Even if we were to, to significantly change the, the way
- 18:43that things operate, there would still be structures of power and influence,
- 18:46and we would still need to criticize them and be aware of how they might operate
- 18:50badly, if you like, and pursue the interests of the few rather than the many.
- 18:55So I think that it's not, it's not just a critique of the current system.
- 18:59I think it's something that even if we were to have some kind of significant
- 19:02change in the way that we operate things, you always need to be, you know, skeptical
- 19:07about whether the kind of powers that be are doing things in the interests
- 19:10of the right people, if you like.
- 19:13So I think that this isn't like a project to just kind of push
- 19:16until, you know, things change.
- 19:18It's an ongoing project to think openly and creatively both about
- 19:22what's working, for sure, but also about what's not working and about
- 19:24how we might go about changing that.
- 19:26This is the right time for a little story I found while I was doing some
- 19:30research before recording that I think is fitting now because sometimes all it
- 19:35takes is looking at an issue creatively.
- 19:38It involves Roald Dahl.
- 19:40You know the author of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
- 19:43and Matilda, among others.
- 19:46Well, his son was involved in a terrible accident and started
- 19:49suffering from hydrocephalus.
- 19:52Although he was in one of the best hospitals in the world, he couldn't live
- 19:55a proper life as the drainage system wasn't very much effective and the trained
- 20:02staff wasn't able to think to a possible solution or a different way to do this.
- 20:07Dahl thought that this wasn't right, moved the kid to London and with the
- 20:12help of a surgeon and a toy engineer came out with a new cerebral fluid shunt, now
- 20:18called Wavedahl-Til valve, presented in The Lancet in 1964 actually That helped
- 20:26thousands of kids with hydrocephalus.
- 20:29So they look at the problem differently, and although the medical staff thought
- 20:33it was a solved problem with some issues, they challenged it with an
- 20:39open mind and found a better solution.
- 20:41Yeah.
- 20:42I mean, uh, as … I've never heard that.
- 20:43That's an interesting example.
- 20:45I mean, I think that in some ways the, those kinds of, like, instrument
- 20:50development or te- you know, you know, issues, I think probably even though
- 20:54Roald Dahl's an author and he came to it from a non-medical perspective,
- 20:58and maybe that, uh, helped, I think, um, it sits more within the kind of
- 21:02normal way of progressing medicine.
- 21:04Whereas I think where it gets harder is when you're doing something more broadly.
- 21:10So again, we came to the, the kind of cardiovascular health, uh, example
- 21:14I gave earlier, which is probably a bit crude, but nevertheless, the
- 21:18current way of thinking is mostly to deal with the individuals, right?
- 21:22So you might
- 21:23So it might either be through surgery or it might be through, you know, a general
- 21:26practitioner might talk to someone earlier in their lifetime and s- and
- 21:29make them some personal recommendations and say, "Oh, you sh- you know, you,
- 21:33you're currently not eating a very good diet, and you should eat a better diet.
- 21:37This is a recommendation." But it doesn't take account of the kind of
- 21:40wider social and economic drivers that people are subject to, right?
- 21:45So the reason that we have an obesity epidemic now as opposed to in the
- 21:49past is probably not because, you know, p- individuals are just making
- 21:52bad choices, but because we live in this kind of environment that pushes
- 21:55s- you know, us certain kind of foods and s- incentivizes certain things
- 22:00and disincentivizes other things.
- 22:02It's more in that territory, I think, where this kind of more, the wider
- 22:06perspective is especially helpful insofar as it really opens up that territory
- 22:12to look at, well, how could we go about intervening or, or at least asking
- 22:16questions, the kind of wider system.
- 22:19I think the example of being creative in kind of instrument development, I think,
- 22:22is, is part of the same spectrum, but I think it's kind of, um, more within
- 22:26the kind of normal decision-making processes that actually we do quite
- 22:29well within the current framework.
- 22:32Whereas I think how do we solve the kind of the issue of obesity, I think,
- 22:37falls more within this kind of wider framework because it's driven by many
- 22:42different factors across society, and it's quite hard to solve through even quite
- 22:47creative thinking within just one domain.
- 22:49In, in fact, we need to think more broadly, and we need
- 22:51to collaborate more broadly.
- 22:52And I think that's, I think that's really where the kind of health punk
- 22:56ideas potentially come into play.
- 22:59Yeah.
- 22:59It's challenging the way we think.
- 23:01It's not just what you see, look at everything that is around you.
- 23:06It's- Nothing more than a good, very good advice
- 23:10I think it works-- I think it, it probably works at every level.
- 23:13I just think, you know, there are places where there's a relative disconnect,
- 23:17and then there are places where there's almost a complete disconnect.
- 23:19You know, decision-making in one domain is, is almost completely
- 23:22isolated from decision-making in another domain, even though in the
- 23:25real world these issues are related.
- 23:27And so that's kind of… That's a, that's a problem of imagination.
- 23:30That's a problem of, uh, practice, and you, you only start to solve that by
- 23:36first being aware that it's a problem.
- 23:38And not just a problem that's kind of like in the generic sense,
- 23:40like, "Oh yeah, it'd be nice to do something about that, but we can't.
- 23:43It's impossible.
- 23:43We're too constrained." But well, actually, this is a problem.
- 23:47It's getting worse.
- 23:48We need to address it.
- 23:49How can we address it?
- 23:50Let's start thinking much more openly about it without initially worrying
- 23:54about, oh, how immediately possible is it to implement these changes?
- 23:57We have to start with the question: Well, what could a future that we
- 24:01could address these problems look like?
- 24:03And what would we want that to look like?
- 24:05You know, another example might be we need an energy transition And there is
- 24:10some kind of hope among some certain people who have a kind of a very, uh,
- 24:14like technocentric viewpoint that fusion reactors are gonna just solve the energy
- 24:18crisis at some point in the future.
- 24:21Now, there is obviously a technical component to that.
- 24:23It's been very resistant to… W- We still seem to be a long
- 24:26way from reliable fusion power.
- 24:29But if they were to solve the problem even technically, the… it would still lead
- 24:34to a solution which, which is very, like, top down, led with large companies or,
- 24:40or governments running these reactors and then selling that power to individuals,
- 24:45which is a very different model from one where we have s- a distributed
- 24:48network of solar panels and, and wind farms owned by communities themselves.
- 24:54So there's a question about whether those two alternative futures, there's technical
- 24:57questions about, you know, what do we need to do to solve the distributed networks?
- 25:02Do you know we need better smart grids, and we need more storage?
- 25:04Uh, what do we need to do to solve the kind of fusion problems?
- 25:08But there's also just the social and political questions about, well, which
- 25:11one of those futures seems more desirable?
- 25:13Would you like to have these, the power in the hands of a few people
- 25:17running these big plants, or do you actually prefer a vision of a future
- 25:21where you've… where there's more community ownership and more community
- 25:24participation in the energy network?
- 25:26And that's, you know, it's probably obvious what, what I think about that.
- 25:29But, um, but that's, but that's a, a question that, um, you know,
- 25:34which is not usually discussed.
- 25:36We usually talk about them just as if they're technical questions, but in fact,
- 25:39there are much wider questions about, well, what, what future would we like
- 25:42to see, and therefore strive towards?
- 25:44And obviously, we tend to get what we invest money and energy
- 25:48and time in, into finding out.
- 25:50We don't just get there by accident.
- 25:51We tend to… So you have to be… imagine a future that you want,
- 25:55and then work towards that future.
- 25:56At the moment, I think there's a tendency to work towards a future imagined by
- 26:01a few wealthy people for their own interests rather than necessarily the,
- 26:05you know, wider group of people thinking about what's best for society at large.
- 26:09All of these are s- are things that can be… There's a space created within
- 26:13a, a kind of a health punk framing that allows you to, like, look at those
- 26:16things much more openly and feel like legitimately discuss them rather than
- 26:21just get down to, you know, arguing about whether which technical solution
- 26:24is likely to be the more realistic.
- 26:26Yeah.
- 26:27As you said, it's a problem of imagination, and I would close like
- 26:32this, citing Roald Dahl again, but in the movie version, and welcome
- 26:37in a world of pure imagination.
- 26:39Yeah, absolutely.
- 26:40That would be a very nice thing to do.
- 26:43Thank you for this amazing conversation.
- 26:46It has been very interesting.
- 26:47I would suggest to everyone to go and check the, the viewpoint on, uh, The
- 26:53Lancet Planetary Health, and check the, the website, uh, from the author about
- 26:58health punk, and lose yourself in your mind, and try to think of a better future.
- 27:04Thank you very much
- 27:08Thank you for listening to In Conversation with The Lancet Planetary Health.
- 27:12If you enjoyed this episode, please leave a rating and a review on Apple Podcast
- 27:17or Spotify, and subscribe to stay updated on our latest research and conversations.
- 27:23I'm your host, Matteo Simonetti.
- 27:25Our editorial team includes Editor in Chief, Alastair Brown, Deputy Editor, John
- 27:30Carson, and Senior Editor, Haoyu Wang.
- 27:34This program is part of The Lancet In Conversation With series and
- 27:37was produced by Matteo Simonetti