Latest / Backfire Guns Podcast / What You Didn't Know About Accuracy...
Transcript
- speaker-0: Welcome back to the Backfire Guns podcast, everybody. Jim says we have something really cool to talk about. speaker-1: We got something great to talk about today. So I unleashed Chat GPT and and Gemini on the rifle accuracy database. And boy did it come up with some interesting insights. So this our rifle accuracy database anybody can download. It's available at backfire.tv slash rad. We've tested 80 different rifles, most of them hunting rifles, and that's gonna color this whole discussion. We are mostly talking about hunting rifles here, but you'll see most of this will apply to, you know, ⁓ precision rifles and other things as well. Now, 80 different that's a lot. Like I don't know of anywhere else on the internet that has this much data. Shooting 20 shot groups with all of these guns, meticulously measured everything. You can see what the most accurate ammo is, the most accurate cartridges, the most accurate rifles. It's all in a big leaderboard. You can go get it backfire.tv slash rad. But aside from the things that we've already publicly shared about it, this one, this is new. I had the AI, I had it just look at at the sheet and I said, what could be some cool things that we could analyze about this? It came up with a list and then I told it to actually analyze quite a few of the things and actually get us the numbers. I'm blown away. Ready for you to just start off with a banger right? speaker-0: I'm excited. You came to me before this podcast and you were like, I've got something I think you're gonna be pretty interested in. So I've been waiting. I have I I'm excited. All right. ⁓ speaker-1: Okay, so this is this is a great one to just blast your buddy with when your buzz your buddy comes, shares a target with you, just texts you a target or sends like, ⁓ this gun's shooting good. It's kinda like in golf when somebody says, ⁓ yeah, you know, I shot, you know, well, I broke eighty or something. ⁓ huh. The immediate question is, what tease did you play from? And they're like, The Reds. You know, it's like this is kind of how you this is kind of what tease did you play from? Four guns. This is what to say. So your buddy shares a good group with you. It it's sub MOA for their hunting rifle. So in all of these 80 tests we did, 70% of the time, if you have a five-shot group that is sub MOA, if you keep shooting, you shoot four more groups, 70% of the time the actual truth of what that that gun is capable of is actually over one MOA. Wow. speaker-0: 70%? That's a l That's crazy because I mean I would say it's probably the majority of hunters are probably a little more casual with like how they set up their guns. And so when you think about I mean, I would imagine most of them, you know, they go to the range, they shoot a group, their first one, ⁓ yeah, that's a shooter. It's three quarter MOA or nine tenths or whatever. That's a shooter. You tell me there's only a thirty percent chance that they're right. speaker-1: A lot. Yeah. Now now this is that is if we if we call if we're talking about one inch. If we go to one MOA, one point ⁓ four seven inches, it actually drops to sixty percent. That's sixty point five. speaker-0: Still not great odds. I mean it's a little better, but it's still not good odds. speaker-1: Almost a flip of the coin of if you actually if you ⁓ really do have a one MOA rifle. speaker-0: It's less than a flip of a coin. speaker-1: ⁓ yeah, yeah. And i it it it's pretty fascinating. So then I I saw that and I thought something doesn't quite sound right then. because why would it in general the group increase? and and so part of it is a lot of those times it's just that we have too small of a sample size, and once we get the full sample size, it's over. ⁓ speaker-0: Okay. speaker-1: And of course there are some times where you could be over in your first group, and if you shoot more data, it could come down, of course, right? But then there's this other factor that I I wondered if was part of this whole discussion because it made me worried about the integrity of our data. Mm-hmm. Because I thought, if it's that often, what if the problem is we as shooters are starting to fatigue as we shoot more groups and it Which would mean it's us and not necessarily the rifle. The rifle actually may be more accurate. And then the other factor is, so in our testing procedure, we give a rifle twelve minutes to cool down between groups. Now, I should say that there is a little bit of wiggle room on that. For example, when we're shooting tiny little light, light, light cartridges, sometimes we'll go a little bit shorter than that. And conversely, when we're shooting, you know, a a 300 ROM. You know, you're just burning a crap ton of powder down that thing. We're gonna give it more than twelve minutes. And similarly, sometimes we've shot really cold mornings and the the guns cool pretty quick. Other times we're shooting and it's a hundred degrees outside and it's like, well, we're gonna take like twenty minutes to cool this thing. So twelve minutes is our standard. We're generally sticking to it, but we're also putting a little bit of just common sense into that nego into that to make sure we're trying to get the best data possible. Okay, so what percentage speaker-0: Right. speaker-1: larger, I will say it's larger, from group one, where we shoot the first five shot group, and then we shoot a second five shot group, third shot five shot group, and then the fourth. How much bigger do you think on average the fourth group is than the first group? speaker-0: Ooh, I would say Fifteen percent? speaker-1: It's a lot it's better than that. So on average it's only nine point six percent barrel. Which is a pretty small difference. I I mean, we're going ⁓ we're going from a you know a point nine one inch to point one inch. We're we're really close there. And so but there is some element of either barrel heating or just shooter fatigue that is that is in our test. Yeah. That group four is being slightly, slightly impacted, but a tiny amount. speaker-0: Okay. Nine percent, that's pretty small. speaker-1: Yeah, and when you put that in the whole the whole of the twenty shots, I mean, i it's that's barely moving anything. Well we're talking about, you know, maybe a two percent error there. Right. Pretty tiny. Okay, so barrel heating though, i isn't it is a factor. The false sub MOA claim though, that's pretty wide. speaker-0: Right. That one's crazy to me. Now yeah, because I I would think it's definitely the vast majority of hunters sight in their guns and group their guns. Like they just go shoot a group. Yeah. And if the group's good, they call it, you know? Because not everyone has all the time in the world. Like for us it's their it's our jobs, you know. We do this all the time. But like not everyone has all the time in the world and all the money to spend on ammo and stuff. Mm-hmm. And so that's like just the norm. But There's really only a thirty percent chance that that's that's what your gun's capable of. Mm-hmm. And so yeah, well what can't well so it begs the question, what does one five shot group tell you then? What kind of information speaker-1: For asking because I looked at this one extensively. Uhhuh. So you went out to shoot a new a new Wildcat this morning that we're working on. So Stiller Firearms, sister company of Horizon, sent us a ⁓ a barreled action for a twenty-five PRC Wildcat. Yeah. So that is that's a cool speaker-0: So excited. I when I went to that range, by the way, ⁓ a lot of the people had never heard of I thought twenty five PRC was kind of a common wildcat. Mm-hmm. They'd never there was a lot of people there this morning and everyone was everyone was like looking at it. They were definitely all experienced shooters, a lot of like bench guys, and they were looking at it, and I didn't know if you could really tell the difference from a six five PRC to twenty five PRC, because you're just necking it down to twenty five caliber. It doesn't just with the naked eye, it doesn't look that big of a difference. Yes. And but they were and they were like, What is that? And I told ⁓ it's a twenty five PRC and they're like, Really? I've never heard of that before I was kinda surprised actually. I thought it was more common than it is, but speaker-1: Yeah, so I guess a little background of people that you know aren't familiar. So th we're taking the six point five PRC, the brass, and we're squeezing down the neck smaller. So instead of the six point five millimeter bullet, we're shooting a two fifty-seven caliber bullet. So just barely smaller. And so this cartridge doesn't exist. You can't go buy a twenty-five PRC cartridge. But Stiller and a couple other companies are making this, you know, small batch, you know. ⁓ as an option for for guys that want to reload and and create some some twenty five PRC or you can get a custom barrel in it. speaker-0: I feel like it'll be in production p eventually. ⁓ speaker-1: ⁓ our conspiracy theory on the plus peak podcast, that that sounds right to me. Remember we were talking about the Federal came out with the plus peak ammo that you know turns your six five Creed and just shoots it way faster. It's just a really hot load by using a high pressure case. Yeah. And so what we ended that podcast with was the the thought that what if the reason that Hornity so obviously Hornady's testing high pressure right now. Like I promise you within the next couple of years, Hornady has high pressure loads out. Yeah. I promise. There's no way they're gonna let Federal run away with this thing. So the thought was, what if they came out with the twenty five Creedmore and everybody kept asking about twenty five PRC and they said, ⁓ we just had problems with it. I just couldn't get it quite right. What if the real reason is they're planning to just bring out a high pressure load for the twenty five Creedmore that would Mimic what a twenty-five PRC would do. Sounds right. Sounds right. speaker-0: I wouldn't be surprised. Sounds right to me. That sounds right. Because the twenty five PRC sounds like something they would do. Yes. Right? The twenty five caliber is coming in is becoming increasingly more popular. It's PRC. Everyone loves the PRC line. that seemed like that was the next step for them. But now it kind of seems like this definitely is. speaker-1: Yeah, and the reasoning I heard is that they said in testing it was just a little bit too much and it was causing some deformation on parts of the brass and it just you really couldn't get more than two or three loadings. And I'm like, that only kind of makes sense because I'm like, well, just don't shoot such a hot load. ⁓ like if it's too much, then just just chill it. But still make it way more than a twenty five Creed, but just not so crazy. Right. Switch powders. That doesn't seem too hard to me. I don't know. speaker-0: Yeah. Yeah, I don't know. speaker-1: Stuff that I just don't understand. It seems like a simple fit. Just keep just calm it down. Anyway. speaker-0: Yeah. Anyways, back to went to the range to test the the cards. Okay. Yeah. Okay. What does one five shot group tell us? speaker-1: Yeah. So you sent me a picture of a single five shot group and you were just saying, ⁓ it it's it's not working. And I I think y stiller makes amazing, you know, barrels and actions and stuff. I it's we just need to switch loads. Yeah. This thing going. But it was a large group. And so both of us just said, ⁓ abandoned ship. Like this isn't working. We need a drastically different load. And so it got me to thinking though, like, were we too hasty? I mean, we've talked so much about You know, we're shooting 20 shot groups with all these to really get, you know, statistical significance and stuff. And so the question is, how much can you tell from a five shot group? If your buddy sends you a five shot group, how much off would that end up being from if you had continued to shoot like a 20 shot group, you know, get a really good sample? So here's the number. So if you shoot a five shot group compared to if you n and now okay, sorry. I'm not trying to like pause too much here. I just want to make sure this is clear. So when we talk about a 20 shot group, we're not saying shooting 20 shots at the whack one target and measuring it. Obviously that's going to be bigger than five shots, right? The more shots, the dispersion's gonna extend. What we're saying is if we shoot a single five shot group or do two five shot groups, three five shot groups, or four shot groups, four five shot groups. And that four five shot groups equals twenty, right? That we're digitally putting together the five sh the the multiple five shot groups to get the average. Does that make sense? Okay. So a five shot group is only gonna be within twenty percent of the actual measurement, about fifty nine percent of the time. It's about a coin, a coin flip, if you're even gonna be within twenty percent of the correct answer. So if somebody sends you a three-quarter MOA group, there's we're about a coin flip to say this is within twenty percent of a three-quarter MOA group. That's not good. But what does it tell us? It tells me that when you text me a that picture of a three inch group, we can both rightly say abandoned ship. Yeah. Because I mean, yeah, not. In fact speaker-0: Not good. speaker-1: Let we we I actually ran that chat ran that analysis for us here. So what if we took a five shot group compared to four five shot groups, what percentage of the time was the single five shot group like more than fifty percent off? Like it was a one inch group in your five shot group, but it actually is a one point five inch on average group size for that gun. Never. speaker-0: Okay. speaker-1: In eighty samples, there was never a time that the first group was off by more than fifty percent, the first five-shot group. speaker-0: Yeah. So that I mean it gives you a decent bit of information then. Yes. It tells you okay, you're within it does give you a a kind of a range of what your gun's capable of. speaker-1: I mean an eighty test it never happened. That's that's really good, right? And so what what that means is if somebody sends you a five shot group that's measures one inch, you can confidently say there's basically no chance that this is more than one and a half or less than half. You're within point five inches and one point five inches. You're within fifty percent of what it is every time. speaker-0: Right. Yeah. And okay, so now the thing is there, so you could say for some people, you know, you maybe could say that's acceptable depending on what that first group looks like. Mm-hmm. Like, for example, if my first group was a point four inch group and I'm li and my benchmark is okay, this is a hunting rifle. I don't want this to be more than one MOA. Yeah. I'm gonna be within point four to point nine. ⁓ that tells me enough there that I'm okay. But speaker-1: If you shoot a point four you can walk away and say you you speaker-0: Right. But if I shoot a a point nine inch group, I'm like, ⁓ this could be teetering on the wrong side of one inch. Exactly. And so that's where it gets tricky. So yeah, at what point would you say one f what would if if you were to just shoot one five shot group, what size what how big would that group need to be for you to say, Okay, I I'm okay with hunting with this gun? speaker-1: Shit. Well, for me personally, just b we're spoiled. I I have so many different hunting rifles that if a if a hunting rifle can't put in every shot in three quarter MOA, I'm just not interested. Mm-hmm. Because I have others that do. So why would I pick that one? Right. Right? It's not that it it can't do the job or whatever, but you know, i if you're taking a four hundred yard shot on a deer. Would you like the gun that shoots 1.2 inches or the gun that shoots 0.7? Well duh. Even though you're probably gonna be fine with the 1.2 inch gun, obviously you're gonna pick the 0.7. And we're spoiled since we have that option. I I'm just if a gun is over three-quarter MOA for really all the shots, then I just I'm not that interested. Right. Because I have others that can. Not that it's it can't accomplish the job. Just anyway, makes sense, right? Yeah. So speaker-0: Three point seven. speaker-1: When you're watching a YouTube video and you're watching a review of a rifle on another YouTube channel that isn't giving you the twenty shot groups like we are, it's not completely a throwaway to show a five shot group. It does mean something. It just doesn't mean what that person is probably telling you it means. If they are shooting this and saying, Whew, this is an amazing three quarter inch gun, no, that they that The five shot group did not tell you that. It could be over one inch. But ⁓ it at least means it's not a two inch gun. Yeah. So five shot groups are not throwaway, but they they they don't mean what we think they mean. Okay. speaker-0: Okay. Now it's five shots. So like, what if you shot two? It's not that big of a deal to shoot five more. Yeah. What more information does that give you? Okay. speaker-1: Okay. So let's jump with that. ⁓ let's say you shoot ⁓ 10 shots total, so two five shot groups. And let's let's stick with that 20%. We want an answer that's within twenty percent of the what would be the the real correct answer if we kept shooting, right? So 0.8 to one inch gun. Within 20%, if you shoot 10 shots, 78% of the time you're within 20% of the right answer. 78. speaker-0: Seventy eight percent of the time. It's getting pretty good. It's not like it's it's not like you know you're not gonna know with dead certainty, but like if you only had ten shots, you're probably pretty safe with what you see out of a ten shot. speaker-1: It's good. Yeah. The problem is, what if we're teetering right at one inch, like you brought up before? Right. That's a big breaking point for shooters, ⁓ especially for hunters. That's a big breaking point. You really don't want your gun over. speaker-0: That's true 'cause if I'm if I'm going from point eight to one speaker-1: URA could also go from one to one point two. speaker-0: I go from one to one point two, where do we draw the line? Right. It's like one of those things where it's like, Okay, I'm okay with a little bit of change. And then it's like, Okay, what if it's a little more? Yeah. And a little more. And then eventually it's a lot of change, but it was just in little steps, and so it didn't feel like it was a lot of change. Yeah. And so it's kind of that thing. You have to draw the line some You gotta stop. Yeah. speaker-1: Point. ⁓ And so that's tough for like a reloader. Let's say you're working up a load. You know, if we say five shots isn't enough, okay, that's fine. I'll load up 10 of each different bullet, whatever, all these different settings that I'm testing. Okay, I'll load up 10. But now, still one in five times, you're not even within 20% of the answer. That's still pretty bad. speaker-0: Still not great. speaker-1: For the type of accuracy decisions that a lot of guys are making and reloading, that's pretty frustrating. Yeah. You know, and and especially I see every day of my life, I'll see somebody, whatever, running a ladder test or something where they're taking one shot at each setting. You know, they're they're changing the the amount of powder by a tenth, you know, a tenth of a grain or whatever, or they're changing the jump. by a very small amount, you know, ten tao. and they're taking one shot, three shots, you know, to to get that to get that data. That is absolute garbage. Like you're getting nothing from that. speaker-0: Yeah, one shot is pretty ludicrous. speaker-1: And again, we're t we're talking about the the initial being a five shot group and we're still saying, ⁓ that's just like coin flip status. If we're talking three shot groups, that's not even a coin flip. Yeah. You you're way off from speaker-0: Even two three shot groups, that's one five shot group basically, you know? Okay. speaker-1: So let's continue. So if the five-shot group can really only only tell us a basic accuracy band, a 10-shot group at least kind of tells us what we're dealing with. You know, are we dealing with a gun that's hovering around one inch, hovering, hovering around a half inch, etc.? But that's probably all we can kind of say. But if we really want to know, what if we jump to three five-shot groups? At that point, that's really, really good. 94.5%. 95% of the time you're within 20% of the right answer. So you get your 95% confidence interval that you that whatever you measure, you're within 20% of the correct answer. Pretty good. Yeah. But again, that's only good enough to tell within 20%. So let's say you loaded up two different cartridges today. You loaded a burger 133. speaker-0: Take those odds. That's time. speaker-1: And ⁓ 128 ELDX, is that right? Yep. So if if one measures 0.8 and you shot fifteen fifteen shots of each, if one measures 0.8 and the ⁓ other measures one, then ⁓ there's still a five percent chance that that we don't even know which load is correct at this point. ⁓ that that's not Com ⁓ that's close to correct. I I said that a little bit wrong, but that's close to correct. Okay. So that's ⁓ all right. So but that's fifteen shots to even know which load was better. Yeah. That's kind of tough. And then if we if we and then we go to to twenty shots and you know, there we're gonna do we're gonna do pretty good at that point. But speaker-0: So okay, just real quick before you move on, that nine percent margin of error from, you know, the guns heating up from shot group one to group four, how at what point do you say only shooting three shot groups makes up for not shooting that fourth because of the margin of error? speaker-1: Well, okay, so you bring up a very interesting point. When you're shooting a three shot group, so you imagine three three holes on a piece of paper, you're actually only measuring two data points. You're measuring if it's a horizontal group, you're measuring which hole is at the furthest left and the difference between that and the one that's furthest right. Now, if you're taking a five shot group, again, let's assume they're kind of horizontal on the page. You're still only taking two data points, the furthest on the left from the furthest on the right. Right. We're throwing away basically those three other data points. Kind of. I mean, we at least know we're not outside of that, but we're not accounting for, they're not measuring them from the center. And that's where that's where a three shot group can actually be better if we're stacking those three shot groups. For example, if we take What goes in fifteen. If we take three five shot groups, is it better to take five three shot groups instead? And the answer is yes. Yeah. It would be better to shoot the five three shot groups instead of the three five shot groups, because now we're getting a little bit more information. Right. More measurements are going in. Right. Or the this the power play here is we start using dun dun dun dun. the main radius where we're we get the statistical center of where of where those holes are and we measure out the spoke distance to each one of the holes. I I don't know that we're ever going to convince the gun industry to go from which side to go to the main radius. speaker-0: Because that just makes more sense to me. speaker-1: Yeah, because now if we measure twenty shots, every single hole has adds to the data. speaker-0: Right. And if you're a ⁓ so for example, you're aiming at an animal, like it that's not saying, okay, your gun if your gun say it's a two inch gun. It's not saying you're gonna be two inches off from where you aimed. It's gonna say you're one inch off from where you aimed because you're splitting the difference of those two furthest shots is where you aimed, I would assume. And so that just makes more sense to me because it gives you a better idea of Okay, this is how accurate I was compared to what I was aiming for. You know what I mean? Like that just makes sense to me. speaker-1: I do think the mean radius is a better general number. There are and the way that you get the mean radius is really by using apps these days. Hornady Ford off app is great for this. They have a little add on, it's like a couple bucks. ⁓ you can pay that you can take a picture of your group, mark the impacts, and then poo it calculates the mean radius. Great. It it's not the end all be all number though. For example, let's let's say hypothetically you take twenty you shoot a twenty shot group. 19 of them 19 shots literally stack in the exact same hole. And then one shot just is a flyer, kicks off four inches over. How big is your 20-shot group? Four inches. We're only measuring the furthest out ones. But isn't that valuable to know that 19 shots went in the same hole? So your mean radius would actually be teeny teeny tiny on that. Because on average, the distance to the spoke 19 times was zero. And then we had one that's out. Yeah. And so on average, you're gonna have a teeny tiny mean radius. But also, it's not the end all be all. Because the fact that you did have a flyer does matter. I don't want the flyer happening when I have a stone sheep in my scope. Right. Right. And so if I know one out of 20 times something crazy happens, ooh, that's I I do need that info. Right. So all of these measurements have value. It's not like there's just one number. Yeah. All right. So i if I we set a lot of numbers and stuff. I hope our we haven't lost our podcast audience. So I'll just simplify it right here. A three shot group is garbage. A five shot group tells you a rough coin flip kind of band that we're within. A 10 shot group is decent to know, you know. 80% of the time you're within 20%. You're you're we got a pretty good idea of of what this thing is. But a 10-shot group is probably not good enough to tell you, is load A better than load B? Because usually that's pretty close. It can tell you that, like, hey, this load has some real value and maybe we need to investigate this more. You know, it you can it's it's good for cutting answers out. We'll we'll see that something's real bad. And we're like, okay, we don't need to spend more time on that. So that's a 10-shot group. A 15-shot group is going to be sufficient for most shooters, especially most hunters. There's really not much point in going past 15 shots for most hunters. But if you're a a reloader trying to test, you know, ⁓ small-ish dis dis ⁓ differences, say a 30 foul difference in jump, we're probably going to need 20 shots or more to really tell the difference. ⁓ And the other time that you really need the 20 shot groups is if we're talking about extremely accurate rifles. If we're talking about rifles that are, you know, 0.2 to 0.5, I'm going to be shooting at least 20 shot groups to really tell anything. One, because The inaccuracy of your measurements is really gonna throw things off there if you're not absolutely perfect and we need to account for that. And, you know, let's say say you take a six-dasher and you wanna know if whatever, thirty-one grains is better than thirty-one point three grains. I doubt that you're even gonna be able to tell in twenty shots. That could take a hundred shot group. Yeah. And the problem with a hundred shot group is one we wasted Well, we have to test test both methods, right? So now it's like we shot 200 shots. Well, in 200 shots your barrel condition changes. How do you decide where you clean in that? Your throat has eroded in 200 shots a minimal amount. And so you actually can't know that answer. And so when I see somebody I speaker-0: I'll say that. You can say that. speaker-1: Can't know that. The only way you could know it is if maybe you bought 15 of these barrels and we're shooting thousands of shots, is how you could could really know that. speaker-0: How much can you get? Like speaker-1: Well, okay, so so three Yeah, I mean l so let's say let's say we're we're in that scenario where we're we're testing what I see people doing all the time with ladder tests and stuff, right? And they're we're gonna find a node. Well, if if we're testing well okay, that thirty-one grains of powder versus thirty-one point five grains of powder. In terms of the accuracy, sometimes there's a difference if we're, you know, dealing with, you know, hitting up near pressure, but probably. The difference in accuracy is going to be so small that you will never know unless we're talking multiple barrels and some kind of insane thousands and thousands of dollars test to actually know the difference. So whenever you see somebody testing small changes in reloading settings, they are just wasting their money. speaker-0: That's unfortunate 'cause I think that's how most people do their testing. speaker-1: Yeah, so we've talked about this a lot, especially in our our paid community in Backfire Plus, and still constantly, and part of it's just, you know, more people are coming in and kind of going through the resources. Just because somebody's in there doesn't mean they've seen everything that that's in there. But we've talked about this quite a few times and still, like somebody posted last week. This was a great post. I'm glad they they posted it because it led to a valuable discussion. Somebody had done a ladder test, you know, where you're adding. 0.1 grains of powder and seeing how the velocity changes, right? So we're gonna shoot 20 shots. Each shot has 0.1 grains more powder in it. The idea is you wanna see, I mean, in theory, the it's gonna go from the bottom left to the top right, the graph is, right? Every time you add more powder, it gets the same amount faster. The problem is ⁓ that there's inaccuracy, like there's ⁓ Every shot you shoot, you shoot isn't going to be the exact same velocity, right? There's there's a little bit of extreme spread. But they're only shooting one or maybe three shots at each setting. And so they're seeing that the graph flattens out at some point, that we added more powder, but it didn't actually get a whole lot faster at that setting. And they say, aha. If we load there at that flat spot, then ⁓ If I am a little bit off on my powder, it's still not going to change the velocity a lot, and we have a more accurate load. Does that make sense? Yes. So that's when when you hear people talking about a node, that's what they're talking about. There's a problem though with these nodes, these flat spots. They don't exist. There is no such thing as a node, a velocity node. Does not exist. And I've told people this lots of times, and I keep hearing like, Yeah, but this is how reloading's been done for decades. Like I'm still gonna do it because it still seems science-y. Uh-huh. And so speaker-0: I've seen how people look when you when you say that, they look at you like you're crazy. speaker-1: Uh-huh. Because this is how every intelligent person has done reloading forever. Right. The Satterly method, some people call it whatever, the kind of variations on it. But it it just a velocity node does not exist. And I I in the Backfire Plus community I posted about this and it was led to a really good discussion. I just said, okay, look, here's I I ran this test that everybody's talking about. I I ran one tenth grain more powder going up, and yep, there are flat spots. And so if the test is good, that means that if I run the test again, I'm gonna get the same result, right? So I ran it again, another 20 shots. Uh-oh. The flat spots are in completely different areas. And I ran it a third time and a fourth time. I ran the same test nine times. ⁓ this is a lot of shots that had to be taken to to prove this. ⁓ hundreds of shots. And when you average together all nine shots at each powder setting, you know what you get? A perfectly straight line. There's no node. The node is gone. so the reason there are flat spots is because there's variation in velocity between each shots and unlucky. That one we had a slow one next to a fast one. Yep. And that's what happened. And so th that it simply does not work. And so for reloaders This leads to immense hand-wringing, immense hand wringing, because they say, but wait, my friend wins shooting competitions all the time, and that's what he taught me to do. And my answer is, that is not why he won the shooting competition. He may have thought so, but that did not help him, because it's just bad data. It just does not work. Otherwise, we'd repeat the test and we'd see the flat spots every time in the same spot, but we do not. It's easy to prove. And so ⁓ then it leads to more hand-wringing among among the reloaders because then they say, So what do we do then? Like how do I know that I if I should use 32 grains of powder or 32.3 grains of powder? And I believe that the only correct answer there is you probably can't know, because again, the thousands of shots kind of thing to actually prove which ended up being more accurate. And so if we're talking about about mm, small variations like that, the real answer is pick one and move on. And what we do need to focus on is the big levers. We need to focus on the big levers and see how those work. And so we'll walk walk us through. Yesterday we were working on this wildcat. How did you come up with the two loads that you ended up testing? speaker-0: Well, one, they were the only two bullets. We had we only had two different kinds of bullets. So those are the two bullets we chose. speaker-1: Okay, so tha that's a big one though, because that is the biggest lever of all. Yeah. Like i you if we're talking about all the different things that you could change in a load, that's by far the biggest lever is which bullet. I ⁓ every probably start there. Yeah. speaker-0: Yeah. I mean I every time we've had an accuracy problem with ha reloading, we alwa like a big one. We say, Okay, the boy doesn't like the bullet. And we and we switch the bullet. We never go to, well, maybe we should have gone thirty thou off the lands instead of sixty. That's never our first go to. Yeah. Or, you know, maybe we should go from H one thousand to Rotumbo. That's never what our first resort is. It's always the bullet. Anyway. speaker-1: lever is the bullet. Yep. Now after after that, now what do you do? So you picked, okay, I'm these are the two bullets I want to test. We have our big lever is we're we're testing it. Yep. Now what? speaker-0: ⁓ now pick the powder is the next one. ⁓ and it's tough because with Wildcats and now personally I've I've done reloading of a lot of regular cartridges, but this is my first time doing a Wildcat, so it's pretty tricky to figure out what to do. speaker-1: Yeah, you're it's a lot of checking forums and like speaker-0: Yeah. So I spent probably maybe two hours looking on forums for like what are people using and ⁓ we don't have this powder. What's something comparable enough that I could do a a similar load, a similar charge? ⁓ we had somebody send us his I don't remember who it was. Somebody sent us their load for 25 PRC that he said got to work. Okay, yeah. speaker-1: Derek from Horizon. speaker-0: And he said he was using N five sixty five powder. speaker-1: We couldn't find her. Right. speaker-0: ⁓ at 58 grains. And so we just we tried figuring out, okay, what where could we get close to that? ⁓ we settled on fifty seven and a half grains of H1000 is what we settled on. and we just went with his and since it's a wild cat, there's no I mean, the really the only way to check like max case overall length would be to take one of our case templates we have and neck. And neck it down to twenty-five caliber. So the horse. So we can use the OAL gauge. Correct. we haven't done that yet, so we just went with what his case overall length was. ⁓ we used basically his exact load, except obviously we didn't use that powder. and yeah, we obviously did not get the results he got. speaker-1: Can use Yeah. So we're gonna have to do some testing. So if I were to tell reloaders then the the process that that we go through that actually is working is for sure, let's test a couple bullets to begin with. For the powders, generally I I'm I I like to be way under pressure. I don't want to be anywhere near the max load. If you feel like you're needing to press up against the max load to get every little bit out of it, change cartridges. Like if ⁓ when somebody when I see somebody trying to hot ride their seven PRC and how can I get to max pressure, you know? I'm like, what you really wanted was a twenty-eight nozzler. Yeah. You didn't actually want a seven PRC. Yeah. You know, and it it just feels like it doesn't matter what cartridge it is, people are trying to hot rod it. And I'm like, just go up. It's not like we don't have containers that can't hold more powder. Yeah. Right. There's a r but there's a reason that cartridge was designed and it's It's it's to be lower. Right. speaker-0: It's not even seven PRC at that point, you know, if you're loading it to twenty eight Nazar levels, you know. speaker-1: I you're just gonna get better results being way down. The other reason is we're in the desert. It's very hot here in the summer, commonly one ten. And I had one year where I had loaded not at max, still, you know, you know, three tenths of a grain down or whatever, on several different cartridges, and I was getting great results. And then the summer came and I started going over pressure. And I'm like, he got it. Yeah. And so I was like, I I just would way rather, instead of chasing my tail on how close to the edge would I be. I'm just gonna come way down. And the groups are better, you have fewer problems, it's safer. ⁓ it just there's a lot of reasons. Yeah. And so I just don't push velocity ever. I just don't see the point. speaker-0: That'll ever not be a craze. The hot rod ideal. speaker-1: The faster is always gonna be better in the podcast. Which is weird. speaker-0: Because it doesn't make better accuracy. I don't understand why speed is so much more important to people than accuracy. For me, I could care less how fast it's going. You know, if my 308 going twenty six ninety is shooting more accurate than my seven PRC going three thousand fifty, then I'll take the three ⁓ eight, you know? speaker-1: Right. Trying to hot ride a six five Creedmore is like putting a carbon fiber spoiler on your Toyota speaker-0: Which I've seen before. I have seen before. speaker-1: It's like old this car was just not designed for that. Yeah. We're we're not trying to make this car go faster. That's not the point. Right. ⁓ anyway. So ⁓ yeah, so big lever is bullet. We're gonna test that. Next we're gonna go to powder. Now, which powder? Literally, I'm gonna go find people that have great results and see which powder is like the common denominator there. You're gonna find with certain if you're shooting a six-dasher, I promise you you want varget. Like stop trying other things. You want Varga. If you're shooting a 6-5 crate, there are a couple options, but H4350. You want H4350. You know, it's so go find what's really working across a lot of people that they're getting amazing results from. There's probably just that magic powder for it. And then what what load of that powder? Again, just get to where you are happy with accuracy and pressure. That's it. Just go go there. We we really don't even need to check a whole bunch for ac for accuracy. Just get one that's that you're happy with for the for the velocity and the pressure. And then jump. So jump is the distance between where the bullet sits in the cartridge and where it's going to start hitting into the lands, right? Because when I close the bolt, the bullet isn't rammed up against the rifling yet. There's a little space there. That's what we're talking about when we talk about jump. And There are some bullets that are jump sensitive and you make a 30 thou change and it will impact things. And there are others that are ⁓ probably not gonna change anything. And so I think the your best bet is probably figuring out generally what jump that bullet's gonna like. You know, we're shooting a burger VLD hunting. You know, I'm probably gonna start somewhere like sixty thou, seventy thou of jump. They like a little bit of jump. And if I'm shooting, you know, an ELDX that I reload a lot of it, ⁓ start at 30,000, 25,000, something like that. You're probably gonna be just fine. And I'm probably not gonna feel like I need to test a bunch of settings there. It's it's those those are kind of where those bullets like to sit usually. ⁓ and so now we took the jump and we can kind of take that out of circulation. We're probably just gonna stick with what the the bullet is generally going to like. Although I will say I definitely have time, found times that I test several different jump settings and whoo, one is really, really nice. And sometimes that's different than what the default would be. So that can be valuable to test. The bullet is the big one. The powder, we're kind of cutting out here. Stick with a known good powder and a velocity and pressure you like. And then, you know, we the last bits are your primer ⁓ that you know kind of looking at usually I'm picking that just based on the reloading book, what what primers that they're they're using that I can follow the same numbers from. And your brass. What what brass you've chosen that you're probably not gonna buy four different brands of brass and test. And so honestly, reloading, you know, it sounds like we've made it much, much more difficult by r removing all these little tenth grain tests and stuff and ladders and all that kind of stuff. And actually we've simplified it dramatically. Yeah. It's kind of like if you're cooking making cookies. Instead of trying one cup of flour and then another batch, you try 1.1 cups of flour and then 1.2 cups of flour. Now you could try that and it could take a lot of cookies before you know what the perfect amount of flour is. The other option is why not try two completely different recipes? speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: And see which one tastes better. Yeah. Because you could spend years tweaking little bits in your chocolate chip cookie recipe to get one that tastes good. Or how about we find five known good recipes and just eat them? Let's see which one gets us 90% of the result right there. Yeah. And so that's kind of what we're doing. It's like we're making three different our best guesses on each setting, three different ⁓ factory loads, we'll call ⁓ and we'll see which one tastes the best. Yeah. I mixed our metaphors there and it could lead to disastrous resources. Disastrous. Can you imagine what the lawsuit is like? Well in second That was a dangerous mixed metaphor. I hope people will will follow that. It will save you hundreds of hours reloading. All of your guns are gonna perform better. You're you're gonna have better data. It's just it's easier to reload this way and you're gonna end up with better info, but people just won't. speaker-0: Money. It'll save you money. Yeah. Lots. Big time. And trips to the range and speaker-1: Time. Everything. The truth is there are magic recipes for loads. There just are. If we're shooting a six dasher, I promise I can make a load, one load, that I put in almost every six dasher that's gonna work. Yeah. If I buy a new Bartline barrel and put it on my six dasher, I'm not gonna start reload my load development again. I know what load it's gonna like. Like it's weird if it doesn't like it. Yeah. If you get a new six five Creedmore ⁓ hunting rifle and you put in forty one point three grains of powder of of H forty three fifty and we put in a one forty three ELDX and run it at whatever two point nine five five I would run it at a at a at our normal case overall length. It should shoot. Mm-hmm. If it doesn't shoot, something's probably up. I'm not saying that there there isn't any customization, but probably it should work. Yeah. And so finding just kind of the magic loads in each cartridge, I feel like is ninety percent of reloading. And so it those who are in Backfire Plus, we do have the kind of the magic load document ⁓ in there of some of just tried and true loads for a lot of different cartridges. But find them online. Especi a great resource is what the pros use, that blog series from the Precision Rifle blog. If it's a cartridge that it's used in competition, it's gonna be easy to find kind of those known good loads. speaker-0: They show everything on there, like what powders, what bullets, what steam depths, everything. speaker-1: Everything. It's pretty awesome. Yeah, very, very good resource. And I would love to put together a similar resource for NRL Hunter. Because they're using a lot of hunting cartridges and see what's being used there. Anyway, that's I I believe that is the modern smart statistically driven method ⁓ to good reloading practices. But the ironic thing is Most people are going to look at it and say, hmm, not sciencey enough. Right? They're going to be like, I'm going back to my ladder desk. speaker-0: Complicated enough. It's too simple. It's speaker-1: ⁓ Right. Instead, I'm gonna try a tenth cup more powder. More more flour. Yeah. All right. So we got our our approach to to to reloading and how many shots we need. Now another interesting insight that we got, two more interesting insights. So for a lot of the cartridges, we don't have enough a data, being that there are 80 guns that we tested in various cartridges. There are ⁓ We don't have enough data to say what the most inherently accurate cartridge is, what the least accurate is. We we would need more samples of each cartridge. However, of the cartridges that we did have enough samples of, guess what the most ammo sensitive cartridge is? So what I mean by ammo sensitive is if we try five different loads in this cartridge, we're more likely to get wildly different results. That there could be one magic and one terrible. speaker-0: gonna say well the first ⁓ it's gotta be seven PRC. speaker-1: seven PRC is up there, but the most ammo sensitive was six five PRC. What? Yeah. Your favorite speaker-0: No way. speaker-1: Now, I don't know totally what that means, because it could just mean there are a couple ammo manufacturers that make crappy six five PRC loads, and so it makes the cartridge look bad, and we test it. speaker-0: ⁓ that could be. I was gonna say, does that make it less inherently accurate than we thought? But maybe it's just hasn't been around as long as like well, what was the what was the most consistent? speaker-1: Most consistent and not gonna surprise you, six five Creed four. Okay. Six five Creedmore. Yeah. And we've seen that like anecdotally. We didn't need data to sell us that. Like it is startling how regularly a gun ⁓ we get a new gun in that we're reviewing. Like if it's in six five Creedmore, we're probably not going to have accuracy issues. Like, probably. It's rare that we have accuracy issues in a six five. speaker-0: I can think of one gun and we've shot a lot of six Ruger Gen two. I don't know if we've shot another six five Creed. That just was bad. Maybe the How fifteen hundred super light, that one wasn't great. That's just a unique like setup. Like that's just a poor doesn't matter what you shoot in that thing. That's that's the gun, not the car. speaker-1: Five remote. Which one was it? ⁓ yeah. Yeah. Well is there. Yeah, but that was Or that gun was just too light. cartridge. Yeah. For sure. Yeah. And so then the the broad answer that we can get, we've talked a little bit about, so we won't I won't dive in too much, but recoil massively affects accuracy. And it matters less when we're talking about 20 pound competition rifles, but most of our testing is lightweight factory produced hunting rifles. That's what most of this data is. And in those What cartridge you shoot is by far the number one factor into just is this thing gonna be accurate. There's a much tighter correlation between the the recoil and accuracy than there is from the price you paid of the rifle and accuracy. Like ⁓ way tighter correlation. It's not close. speaker-0: How many people do you think th think do you think that's like a super common misconception, or do you think a lot of people are coming to figure that out? speaker-1: I think it's a tiny fraction of the industry that knows that. Really? People that are in into this, it's like, well yeah. Yeah. But if you just go survey gun shops and you say, hey, on average, is a 300 win mag more accurate or a whatever, six arc, they're gonna be like, different cartridges. Yeah. You know? It's like yeah. So why is that the case? speaker-0: They know. speaker-1: Well, two reasons. One, very practical that people are gonna flinch more ⁓ on a bigger cartridge. We've kinda corrected for that in our data. We're we're not perfect shooters, but we are shooting multiple times a week, thousands and thousands of rounds a year, and you know, the best groups in the database, ⁓ you know, we're capable of holding it for twenty shots, you know, we can shoot point two inch groups. So that being the case, I I don't think it's the shooter. ⁓ I I think the reason that that we get i I don't think it's flinch. Yeah, in our data at least. I think the reason is it's just more vibration in a very lightweight hunting rifle. And the the barrel's moving more. We got bedding is gonna be stressed more. Everything is good just every problem in that rifle system is gonna be exacerbated. Yeah, it seems like a pretty speaker-0: I say it's pretty common sense that when more things are happening, there's more variables, which just causes more inconsistency. And when you when you cause inconsistencies, you never know what's gonna happen. Yeah. You know? And in guns, the more I mean, you want consistency is the number one thing you want, right? And so like yeah, it makes sense to me. And I feel I I think most people it like if they heard it. It would make sense to them. Mm-hmm. And they would know. Because it is Yeah, it's a logical it's a logical argument. speaker-1: So about that then, that's I argue with myself all the time that when I go to the gun store, inevitably somebody's gonna stop me and say, hey, you know, hey, I I watch backfire with you. Which gun should I get here? Inevitably. And in the fall, the number one question I get is I'm buying an elk gun, right? Because a lot of people have other bolt action rifles, but they drew an elk tag this year and that's their reason for buying a new gun. Inevitable. I mean, we're in Utah. It's it's elk territory, right? And I always say, ⁓ I just like a little step up in cartridge if we're hunting elk. But based on this information, it does make me think, is that bad info? Am I giving a bad advice there? Because one, we're not accounting for flinch here, I think, because of of who's shooting these. But Most people are going to flinch more on the bigger cartridge. Right. Plus the fact that just the bigger cartridges are not shooting as well in these lightweight rifles. And so, okay, great. I talked you into going from your six, five Creed more to a whatever, a seven PRC for this elk hunt. But now you could that that one decision, yeah, you had got a little bit more horsepower to kill that elk. But now we went from You know, maybe you're shooting that at three quarter MOA to one and a half MOA. And often when, you know, when you get that four hundred inch bull cross canyon, I know you're gonna try. Yeah. I know you're gonna try. As much whatever ethics you think you have, I know you're gonna shoot. You try. speaker-0: Throw them down the as he walks into your picture. speaker-1: And so if you are making that shot, man, I w I would rather you had the lighter cartridge that's gonna be a little bit more accurate. Maybe the six five creed wasn't a great example there because I don't like that for long range shots. Just the velocity. I I don't like any bullet under two thousand feet per second. Yeah. Copper or lead. There are differences. Some do better than others, but I've never seen a bullet that performs better under two thousand feet per second, right? Velocity is what helps that bullet. Yeah. And every we've tested quite a lot of times. long range ballistics gel with a a variety of different bullets. And I'm very underwhelmed at the sub 2000 feet per second performance. I'm ⁓ like, it just speaker-0: That might hurt a little, but is that gonna kill it? Yeah. I don't know. speaker-1: little underwhelming. And again, some bullets do better than others, but I'm underwhelmed. Yeah. With with that performance. And so for me, I'm always going to s to if I for whatever max distance I potentially could shoot, I'm going to make sure my cartridge can maintain 2,000 feet per second. And if it's after that, I'm just out. I'm just not shooting that. That's more my limit, I would even say. ⁓ then you know, ⁓ can I push this another fifty yards of my skill? Yeah. If if it's under two thousand, that's a hard stop for me. I just won't. Okay. Yeah. All right. So recoil i is a big one. That that's if you want an accurate rifle, go first to the lighter cartridge. Yep. Tons of insights from this rifle accuracy database looking through it with a speaker-0: So good stuff. finding more and more stuff. It's so fast. speaker-1: Pretty fascinating. Well, and as we add more data, we have enough info to start drawing more and more conclusions. Yeah. speaker-0: One that I really want to do is like what's the most accurate factory load? That's when I really wanna find out. But where it's you know, it is eighty different samples we have right now, but how many different loads have we shot? speaker-1: Yeah, it's ⁓ you know, we may only have three, four samples of some loads and some cartridges. I think we're maybe getting close to being able to do it with six five creed more though. Mm-hmm. With the we could at least say what the best six five creed load is. We might need another ten guns or something to to start drawing a conclusion on something like that. Yeah, it it is fascinating, fascinating to see though. Yeah. Well, thanks everybody for joining the Backfire Guns Podcast. speaker-0: Maybe in a year or then. speaker-1: Please tell somebody about it. You know, post about it in a forum if there was something interesting in in this. Post about it in a forum, post it online. You know, it's a brand new public podcast that we're doing. And so we'd love to just get it spread a little bit. So thanks for hanging out with us on the third, thirteenth, and twenty-third of every month.