Latest / Stage Talks with Bellingcat / "Protecting the people within your research" with Eliza Anyangwe
Transcript
- 0:04You're listening to a stage talk titled protecting
- 0:07the people within your research. This week we
- 0:10were joined by the Fuller Projects editor -in
- 0:12-chief Eliza Inyangwe. Eliza provided invaluable
- 0:16tips for speaking to potential sources and ways
- 0:20to ensure your reporting does more good than
- 0:22harm. Join us as we discuss the people at the
- 0:26centre of your story and the editorial decisions.
- 0:29that should be taken to protect them. This talk
- 0:31was hosted by me, Charlotte Mar, on Thursday
- 0:34the 22nd of May 2025 in the Bellingcat Discord
- 0:37server. Welcome to this week's stage talk. I'm
- 0:52fascinated by today's topic. It's something that
- 0:55I hold quite dear to my heart. Building on the
- 0:58wonderful talk by Dr. Alexa Konig, and if you
- 1:01haven't listened to that, please check out our
- 1:03RSS feed where you can find all of our stage
- 1:06talks, previous ones including the one by Dr.
- 1:09Alexa Konig. We wanted to revisit the issue of
- 1:12consent when it comes to reporting on sensitive
- 1:15subjects like gender -based violence. Today,
- 1:19we're joined by the Fuller Project's editor -in
- 1:21-chief, Eliza and Yang Wei. The Fuller Project
- 1:24is a newsroom dedicated to reporting on issues
- 1:27that affect women with a mission of enacting
- 1:30positive change for women and I will drop the
- 1:32link to the reporting in a second in the chat.
- 1:37It is a unique setup to have a newsroom with
- 1:40such a sole focus and within this sole focus
- 1:43the team work on an array of topics from labour
- 1:45rights to health to climate change. Eliza is
- 1:48not here today to look at a singular topic, Carla.
- 1:51She's here in her editorial role capacity to
- 1:54give an insight into how her team has garnered
- 1:56a reputation of trust and transparency when it
- 1:59comes to sharing individual stories. We're going
- 2:02to explore what preserving the dignity of those
- 2:04featured in your reporting looks like, both in
- 2:07a traditional journalism sense and when it comes
- 2:09to open source research, which many of you in
- 2:12this room practice. What questions should you
- 2:15be asking yourself when you're looking to engage
- 2:18with testimonies or coming to publish a story
- 2:20on a sensitive subject? Hopefully we'll be covering
- 2:23that today. Before I pass on to Eliza, a little
- 2:27reminder that while we'll be taking questions
- 2:30in the chat, which you can find on the top right
- 2:32-hand side of your screen, it's important to
- 2:34note this is being audio recorded. So if you
- 2:37do not want me to mention your name when I bring
- 2:41up your question in the discussion, please note
- 2:44that within your question. All right, okay Eliza
- 2:48the floor is yours and we'll come back in a little
- 2:50bit for Q &A. Hey, hi, Charlie. Hi, everyone.
- 2:57Nice to meet you all and to be invited into your
- 2:59community for this conversation. I'm hoping very
- 3:03much to make it a conversation. So I will talk
- 3:07for as little time as I can so that perhaps in
- 3:12the Q &A and in the conversation with you, I
- 3:15might not just share more details, but also learn
- 3:19from all of you as well, because part of the
- 3:23reason I was very excited to do this is I'm so
- 3:25admiring of the work of OSINT investigators,
- 3:29obviously in journalism spaces for the last several
- 3:33years. The sense that we can hold power to account
- 3:36in different ways. We can reveal truths that
- 3:39have been obscured by getting granular and piecing
- 3:43together big data or other forms of open source
- 3:46information has been something that I have really
- 3:50admired. And so it is a real privilege also for
- 3:52me to learn from this community as well as to
- 3:54share from my own experiences to it. In the introduction,
- 3:59I will just tell you a little bit more about
- 4:01myself. This is very much part of my journey
- 4:05to doing this work and has helped inform some
- 4:08of the perspectives that I have developed over
- 4:10the years. and in working with other folks. I
- 4:14didn't actually study journalism. I was born
- 4:18in Cameroon. I won't give you the whole bio.
- 4:21I'm sure that information is all online. So you
- 4:24can find that pretty easily. But grew up in a
- 4:29context where a lot of the reporting on whether
- 4:32it's Cameroon or any part of Africa is around
- 4:35sort of like patriarchy. And women are usually
- 4:37presented as victims in stories and never have
- 4:42any agency. And so when I eventually started
- 4:44working in journalism, my first role was at The
- 4:47Guardian where I was for many years. I got really
- 4:52fed up of seeing women from the African continent
- 4:55reflected in a very sort of two -dimensional
- 4:59way and tried to set up my own platform focusing
- 5:01on African women's stories. And I've spent the
- 5:03entirety of my career, I think, really just kind
- 5:06of like nerdishly obsessing around two things,
- 5:09trying to broaden what we consider a story, the
- 5:12types of subjects that are worth reporting on,
- 5:14interesting for audiences, as well as trying
- 5:17to change who we think of as storytellers, who
- 5:20gets to tell the story who gets to determine
- 5:23what the narrative is. And that is the work that
- 5:25I've continued at the Fuller project, which I
- 5:28joined in January, I run their newsroom from
- 5:30Amsterdam, where I moved to be managing editor
- 5:33of a member funded journalism platform called
- 5:35The Correspondent. And so I've worked for a range
- 5:38of different news organizations, including the
- 5:39Bureau of Investigative Journalism, where I had
- 5:41a very funky role called community organizer,
- 5:45which is not usual in newsrooms, right, to have
- 5:47community organizers. And I think at the at the
- 5:50heart of my career is always about thinking about
- 5:53the relationship of people to the media. And
- 5:56I think, of course, being a product of coming
- 5:59into the newsroom at the height of sort of...
- 6:03social platforms and thinking about how they
- 6:06could really rethink our relationships with subjects
- 6:09in our stories has been very much something that
- 6:12I've explored in our work. The Fuller Project
- 6:14itself is 10 years old, started off first by
- 6:17focusing on the missing voices in conflict. So
- 6:20it was often the voices of women. And every time
- 6:23I say women, I mean that expansively. So women,
- 6:25genderqueer folks, gender diverse communities,
- 6:29and has also then broadened its journalism. to
- 6:32think about the under -reported stories, whether
- 6:36it's in conflict situations or other contexts.
- 6:38So we know that only 0 .02 % of mainstream international
- 6:44reporting focuses on issues that disproportionately
- 6:46affect women. And so the Fuller Project exists
- 6:49to try and bridge that gap in coverage. We also
- 6:51know that a lot of audiences, particularly young
- 6:55people and people who identify as women, are
- 6:59less interested in the traditional subjects that
- 7:01journalism and journalists have been obsessed
- 7:03with. And so again, it's trying to sort of serve
- 7:07those audiences also. I have worked on investigations
- 7:11and stories that I've had to do with, you know,
- 7:13that had required mining sex worker data. We
- 7:17did a very sensitive investigation at the Guardian,
- 7:20sorry, at CNN. I've just noticed that the video
- 7:22component of that is up for an Emmy. I'm no longer
- 7:25there, so if we win, there will be no statuette
- 7:27in my house. But it was an investigation on sexual
- 7:31violence against Rohingya hydras, and hydras
- 7:34are a gender minority in that region. of South
- 7:38Asia. We've looked at the experiences of children
- 7:44as they're being sort of exploited online, as
- 7:48well as Last year, I believe I did an investigation
- 7:52with a reporter in India following an Afghan
- 7:55family that fled Afghanistan and crossed illegally
- 7:59into Pakistan. And the reason I named these examples
- 8:02is that they're all examples of sensitive where
- 8:05there's either sensitive data, underage characters,
- 8:11people who if their stories were to come to light,
- 8:14as much as we want to hear them so that we can
- 8:16empathize with their experience, it can put them
- 8:19in greater danger. We spent a long time thinking
- 8:23and talking about how we presented the story
- 8:25of the Afghan sisters who fled with their little
- 8:28brother and what the repercussions would be,
- 8:30not just for them as they were undocumented in
- 8:33Pakistan, but also for other people who might
- 8:35be using the same essentially illegal or informal
- 8:39migratory routes and whether the Taliban might
- 8:42take retaliatory action to then close down those
- 8:45routes following their departure. involved at
- 8:49some point, multiple phone calls with the US
- 8:51State Department. But that is a story over a
- 8:53beer and not for now. So those are the kinds
- 8:57of ranges of things that we've worked on. And
- 9:00in preparing for this call, thinking about how
- 9:02to protect the people in your investigation,
- 9:04I thought it might be useful to sort of establish,
- 9:06and forgive me if I'm starting with the basics,
- 9:09but not knowing who is in the room, I think it
- 9:11might just be useful to establish an answer.
- 9:13Why is it important to protect people? I think
- 9:16a lot of us get into this work. because we are
- 9:20either social justice minded like think that,
- 9:24you know, systems and processes are really unfair
- 9:26and want to expose them. We want to see things
- 9:29change or we might be interested in the technology,
- 9:32the approach, you know, less about the people,
- 9:35less even about the systems change and just more
- 9:37about how far can I go using this tool or this
- 9:40approach? But I think it is also important to
- 9:44remember that I think the difference to my mind
- 9:47between journalism and academic research is that
- 9:52we don't, journalists don't see ourselves as
- 9:54just providing information, we tell stories.
- 9:56And the difference is that stories are meant
- 9:58to connect emotionally with people and human
- 10:00beings connect with the experience. of other
- 10:03human beings more than they connect with data
- 10:06or information, right? It's really hard to conceptualize
- 10:09how many people have died in an explosion and
- 10:13much more impactful when you hear the experience
- 10:16of one person whose life was lost in that explosion
- 10:18to think about the sort of relative harm. And
- 10:21we sort of have this great capacity for empathy
- 10:24to then multiply that across the large numbers
- 10:27and don't so much register emotionally when we
- 10:30just hear the large numbers. And so it's. Often
- 10:35important to think about, well, it's important
- 10:37to think about why to protect the people in your
- 10:40research and your investigations because often
- 10:42doing so is a matter of life and death for them.
- 10:45That might not be immediately apparent. They
- 10:48might not be currently in a situation where their
- 10:51lives are at risk, but we never can fully think
- 10:54about the repercussions and the retribution that
- 10:58might come for exposing and revealing harm. As
- 11:02I mentioned with the Afghan story, example that
- 11:05I gave. It's often also the case that if we're
- 11:08speaking truth to power, power has power that
- 11:11it can use against people and oftentimes depending
- 11:15on where we ourselves are situated, if that harm
- 11:19or that power might not be exercised against
- 11:21us, but against the people who have worked with
- 11:23us to help report the story. And so thinking
- 11:26about it in a sort of networked way, not just
- 11:29about me as the storyteller, me as the investigator
- 11:33and the reporter, but who had any touch points
- 11:35with this reporting and might be a bit more vulnerable
- 11:38in terms of their nationality, in terms of their
- 11:41gender, in terms of lots of different identifiers
- 11:44and the ways in which the ways in which we show
- 11:47up means that we are exposed to different types
- 11:49of harms. Right. So we're not all. share the
- 11:53same sort of privilege of safety in all different
- 11:55spaces that we might be in. Mental trauma is
- 11:59often as bad as physical trauma. And so oftentimes
- 12:03when we've collected the data that we may have,
- 12:06and we then need a character and we're thinking,
- 12:08okay, I just need someone to tell me their story,
- 12:10asking them to rehash their lived experiences
- 12:14is probably going to be and or can be re -traumatizing
- 12:17for them. And it is a question not just on whether
- 12:19if or how we ask, if we ask rather, but how we
- 12:23ask them to do so. It's often about also thinking
- 12:26in sort of a trauma -informed way, which is that
- 12:29people who have experienced trauma are not going
- 12:32to give you a sort of blow -by -blow sequential
- 12:35event, sequential retelling of the events of
- 12:38their lives, and oftentimes it does mean that
- 12:40we have to go back multiple times or that In
- 12:44the work of journalism or journalistic investigation
- 12:46and research, having to sort of what I would
- 12:49say, bring the receipts right when someone tells
- 12:51you a story, we both have to assume that people
- 12:56are trustworthy because that. making that assumption
- 13:00builds trust with them, but at the same time,
- 13:03we have to prod because we need to substantiate
- 13:06anything that they've said, right? And so there
- 13:09is a way in which we can do this that can either
- 13:11break trust or build it, that can re -traumatize
- 13:15people. that can actually cause further harm
- 13:19to them aside from the harm that they initially
- 13:21experienced. And that every journalist or investigator
- 13:25is representing not just themselves, but the
- 13:27wider industry. And oftentimes you might not
- 13:30be thinking about this, but if you're in marginalized
- 13:32communities, really anywhere in the world, right?
- 13:34I lived in London, if you are in... Migrant communities
- 13:39in central London, they have a distrust of the
- 13:42media as much as folks who live in Liverpool,
- 13:46where I went to university, because of how someone
- 13:49some time ago went about doing their reporting,
- 13:53went around doing their journalism, and that
- 13:55breaks trust that is often very, very difficult
- 13:58to repair. And so when folks parachute into a
- 14:01community, get the quotes that they need, leave
- 14:05and report it, when any of our work is seen as
- 14:07extractive, it might not harm us directly, but
- 14:11it definitely impacts on the capacity of other
- 14:13researchers and other journalists and investigators
- 14:15that come after us to be able to work with that
- 14:18same community. And the fact is... that especially
- 14:21if you're looking at systemic issues, we might
- 14:24want to revisit a community over and over again,
- 14:28right? We might want to speak to people who have
- 14:29been harmed, maybe not the same characters. If
- 14:33you're doing work on sort of like sexual, I don't
- 14:35know. grooming gangs, for example, the chances
- 14:41are that if that is place -based, you might be
- 14:43coming back to a same community over and over,
- 14:46and that lots of journalists may have walked
- 14:48that path before you. And so the ways in which
- 14:50we treat people, establish trust, protect them
- 14:56is going to be impactful beyond your reporting.
- 15:01And so that's kind of just the setting of the
- 15:03scene. So then, well, what do we now do? How
- 15:06can you approach this work? And there are lots
- 15:08of approaches, lots of information online. But
- 15:11from my own experience, there are a few things
- 15:13that we have done that have worked. The first
- 15:17is, and none of these are in order, so not necessarily
- 15:21approaching them sequentially. try to build in
- 15:26time, particularly I would imagine that folks
- 15:29who are in the OSINT community are like folks
- 15:31in the slow journalism community or investigative
- 15:34reporting in other ways, which basically means
- 15:37we have got more time. We've got much more time
- 15:39than folks who are working on breaking news,
- 15:43sort of just chasing stories down. And so to
- 15:45be honest, as an editor, I often think that we
- 15:50have fewer excuses to not build in some of these
- 15:53sort of like care practices into our work because
- 15:55often our work is very laborious and takes time.
- 15:58It takes time to go from hunch to, you know,
- 16:02reporting, co -publishing, whatever our approach
- 16:04is. And so really, what was our excuse to not
- 16:07build into that time some steps to make sure
- 16:12that the people we're working with, the people
- 16:14we're reporting on feel safe, trust us, are involved.
- 16:17Um, so when I think about listening, I often
- 16:21think about that because, um, we tend to have
- 16:24a very hierarchical view of expertise, right?
- 16:28So it's often people who have, um, degrees of
- 16:31some sort to have researched a subject that we
- 16:34consider experts and that the people who tell
- 16:37us our stories oftentimes let's talk about whether
- 16:39it's, you know, gender -based violence or just
- 16:41victims. I would like to argue, and I'm not the
- 16:43first to do so, that experiencing gender -based
- 16:47violence makes you an expert in lots of things
- 16:51that have to do with gender -based violence.
- 16:53And so considering those people, considering
- 16:56experience as a form of expertise, the two are
- 16:59not equivalent, but it is a form of expertise.
- 17:01So it changes how you think about your characters
- 17:04and the people who talk to you. They're just
- 17:06not there solely for the color, right? They're
- 17:09not just there solely for the kind of like, bringing
- 17:11to life the data, bringing to life the information
- 17:16that you have, they might be able to inform your
- 17:18reporting in many more ways if given the opportunity
- 17:21to do so. And so that's why one of my thoughts
- 17:23is actually, if ambitious, if you have a newsroom
- 17:26or an editor or a time to do so, are there ways
- 17:30in which you can imagine collaborating with people
- 17:33you are reporting on so that they're not just
- 17:35characters in your story but actually might share
- 17:38a byline with you because actually they're much
- 17:40more invested in the reporting. I think this
- 17:42is going to open up some questions for folks
- 17:44about sort of objectivity and wonky word positionality,
- 17:48perhaps. But actually, there are many instances
- 17:51where that has been done, where people have gone
- 17:53into prisons and have made incarcerated people
- 17:57and co -reporters and stories, perhaps, you know,
- 18:00from one investigation to the next, it might
- 18:02not work, but it's definitely something to think
- 18:03about. And again, you have time. Ask people on
- 18:07a very sort of small but important point, ask
- 18:10people how they self identify, whether that is
- 18:13survivor or victim, whether that is you're doing
- 18:16reporting on something to do with the LGBT community.
- 18:21We find in our work, particularly if it is you
- 18:24try and report on issues that are globalized,
- 18:27that the language in one community is not the
- 18:29same as the other. I can't remember what country,
- 18:31but I remember we did reporting on trans people
- 18:35somewhere in Latin America, and the word they
- 18:39used just wouldn't be the word we would use in
- 18:43the West and in English at the moment. I think
- 18:46it was transvestite or may have translated as
- 18:49that, which might seem very dated, but that was
- 18:52the word used in that community. And so I think
- 18:54in terms of making people feel safe and in terms
- 18:56of making sure that you represent them in the
- 18:59ways that they see themselves. It's also about
- 19:02asking them what language they use, right? And
- 19:05if you then need to do the work as, you know,
- 19:08this is going from research to reporting now
- 19:10when you're then presenting it to audiences.
- 19:12If your audience are not in the community that
- 19:15you reported on, it's about providing that extra
- 19:18detail and saying, hey, this person chose to
- 19:20refer to them as this. Right. So don't come at
- 19:22me. Yes, I know that we like to think of people
- 19:25as survivors, but actually this character, this
- 19:28person very much sees themselves as a victim.
- 19:30Right. And they and it's about honoring that
- 19:33and then explaining why you have chosen to use
- 19:36that language. If you're reporting, for example,
- 19:38on racialized issues and you're reporting in
- 19:40South Africa, there is a category of people who
- 19:43are who self identify as colored. If you're in
- 19:46America, that language will get you punched in
- 19:48the streets. However, it's about reflecting on
- 19:51the language of the people who you're reporting
- 19:54on and not necessarily of the audience you're
- 19:56reporting to and then acting as a bridge builder
- 19:58to kind of then explain the context. Explain
- 20:04the extent of visibility. So when you are at
- 20:08the stage where you are now talking to people
- 20:10about an investigation and you want them to consent
- 20:12to be in your reporting, Is it already going
- 20:15to be placed somewhere? And do they have the
- 20:18full understanding of the reach of that work?
- 20:21Particularly when we are dealing with people
- 20:23who might not consume the media we consume, do
- 20:26not take it for granted that they understand
- 20:29how long their information is going to last to
- 20:32live online, right, in perpetuity, or how what
- 20:36the reach of that reporting is going to be and
- 20:37how it might come back at them. If you are collaborating
- 20:40with multiple newsrooms and their story is going
- 20:43to be translated, into multiple languages. Do
- 20:45they understand this? Do they understand that
- 20:47it is going to be reported beyond their local
- 20:50context? Sometimes maybe in it, right? Sometimes
- 20:52someone might feel comfortable to talk to you
- 20:54because you represent foreign media. But actually,
- 20:57if you're like, we have a local co -publishing
- 21:00partner or want to disseminate that journalism
- 21:03locally. Do they know that that is going to be
- 21:06the case? So really asking people to fully consent,
- 21:10to be sure that they understand what they're
- 21:13participating in, and also providing them with
- 21:17multiple opportunities to change their minds.
- 21:23It makes me nervous to say even now because there
- 21:26have been many times when in many of the examples
- 21:29that I set out at the start of this talk, we
- 21:31have provided people, you know, you've got a
- 21:34story, you think it can be really impactful,
- 21:36it can shift the dial in some way. And the last
- 21:39thing, there's a sort of knot in my stomach when
- 21:42I think, oh, we have to go back to this person
- 21:44and find out if they're still okay with us reporting
- 21:46their story because it's often been many months
- 21:49since we started on this journey. Do they still
- 21:51want to talk to us? Do they still want their
- 21:53story? to go out there. And there is always the
- 21:55risk that they won't. But actually, if we're
- 21:57trying to live our values and to do journalism
- 21:59differently to how it's been traditionally done,
- 22:01we just have to take that risk. And it has indeed
- 22:03happened that at the 11th hour, somebody decides,
- 22:06actually, I don't wish to be part of this anymore.
- 22:09I don't want to be involved in your reporting,
- 22:11and we have to take them out. On the instances
- 22:13where we make people or invite people to be collaborators
- 22:16with us, really thinking about the distribution
- 22:19of power, right? So that that is not just symbolic.
- 22:22but that actually they have some kind of say
- 22:25is really important. It is very exceptional.
- 22:29It's unusual, not the practice traditionally
- 22:32in journalism that we would give somebody our
- 22:35reporting to read once it's been done. And so
- 22:38it's not like we go back to folks with the entire
- 22:40story, but we often take back to them. their
- 22:44quotes, snippets of text or the audio to make
- 22:49sure that they feel comfortable. If it is accompanied
- 22:51by video to make sure that they feel comfortable
- 22:53with how they are seen, particularly if it is
- 22:56sensitive, particularly if they run a risk of
- 22:59being revealed in ways that we haven't thought
- 23:01about. Again, thinking about identifying features.
- 23:06It is not enough, and I'm sure this is things
- 23:09you all know, to retract names. There are other
- 23:12identifying characteristics of folks, particularly
- 23:15in tight -knit communities, that you have to
- 23:17think about in order to protect the people in
- 23:19your investigation. And then finally, check when
- 23:24it's safe to publish. Oftentimes, a big investigation
- 23:27doesn't need a news hook, right? Because you're
- 23:29not trying to ride the news wave, you're trying
- 23:32to make the news yourself. So you set your own
- 23:35timelines. But oftentimes there might be a reason
- 23:39to go at a specific moment, not another, right?
- 23:41We did, while I was still at CNN, an investigation
- 23:45into how pro -democracy actors in Myanmar were
- 23:51being doxed and trolled on Telegram. That required
- 23:55a lot of data research to sort of go through
- 23:58and to identify that It was gendered because
- 24:01the ways in which women in that culture were
- 24:03being targeted for being pro -democracy was very
- 24:06different to how men were being targeted. It
- 24:08was often sexualized. It often involved trying
- 24:12to present them as promiscuous because of the
- 24:16social and cultural meaning of that and not directly
- 24:19related to the politics in any way. And so we
- 24:22did this big investigation on it. And we looped
- 24:24in the UN Special Rapporteur on Myanmar to try
- 24:27and increase the impact. of our investigation
- 24:30and they wanted to put out a letter and so you
- 24:32start to feel pressure for when to publish but
- 24:35it is often important that you should go back
- 24:37to the people who have been the sort of bedrock
- 24:40of your reporting to ask if it is safe for them
- 24:43for the story to come out now. Another example
- 24:46I will give is when we were doing reporting on
- 24:50I think it was in Slovenia and it was how sort
- 24:54of power, I think it was the former president
- 24:56and other powerful political forces were trying
- 24:59to build movements online to dox specific people,
- 25:04particularly women, and how they were responding
- 25:06to that. And because that the main character
- 25:09continues to live in the country that we're reporting
- 25:12on, because the man who is being accused of harm
- 25:16and mobilizing other to cause harm was still
- 25:22very powerful. I don't remember if he had already
- 25:24lost his... the presidency at that point. But
- 25:27it was very important that we thought very carefully
- 25:30about when we release that reporting so that
- 25:32she could get to safety, so that she could make
- 25:34sure that she deleted her social apps so that
- 25:37she didn't expose herself to the vitriol that
- 25:39might come online. And then for her to re -emerge
- 25:42when she felt safe and really just being diligent
- 25:45about, you know, the needs of the characters
- 25:48in your story and how to ensure that the people
- 25:51who give you so much that makes your journalism
- 25:54is are able to feel sort of taken care of through
- 25:57to the end. Okay, that's my sort of introductory
- 26:00presentation, and I'm very happy to take questions
- 26:04from any of you. Thanks, Eliza, so much. I mean,
- 26:08you're speaking from your own personal experience
- 26:11and best practices in your newsroom, but what
- 26:14you're saying resonates with my experience completely
- 26:16at various newsrooms as well, doing investigative
- 26:19journalism. I can see some questions already
- 26:22coming in. someone's just put this is absolutely
- 26:25fascinating information. So I think a lot of
- 26:27people are enjoying your tips and tricks. Thank
- 26:31you. I want to say that person is not a relative
- 26:33of mine. I also wanted to note that obviously,
- 26:44when it comes to Bellingcat, we often don't interview
- 26:48sources. We often don't actually have voices
- 26:51like the Fuller Project has in their pieces.
- 26:53They're not central to our work. That doesn't
- 26:56mean that we aren't thinking about the human
- 26:58element in our investigations as well. For example,
- 27:02and this is a bit more of a different kind of
- 27:05example, when you're looking at if you're monitoring
- 27:09a particular far right account, for example,
- 27:12and you've found out who this prolific far for
- 27:17right activist is, and you're willing to possibly
- 27:21reveal a little bit about about their name and
- 27:25identity, you also have to think about all the
- 27:28other people around them. For example, though,
- 27:31they might have a wife, a girlfriend, family
- 27:34members. So even when you're thinking about the
- 27:38human element in your story, it's not always,
- 27:40you know, there's victim or survivor in the central,
- 27:43central part of your story. It's also about the
- 27:46humans that are linked to whatever you are researching,
- 27:49whether it's the humans behind the big data that
- 27:52you've collected, or the people related directly
- 27:56to the subject matter that you're talking about.
- 27:59So I think it's really important that everyone
- 28:01also thinks about it in these contexts when we're
- 28:03talking about it as well. Going back though to
- 28:07the survivor kind of testimony and speaking to
- 28:11those with lived experience, I wonder if anyone
- 28:13in the audience has specific examples of when
- 28:16they've tried to cover something human -centric
- 28:18and have struggled to find someone to speak to.
- 28:21I'd love to hear your experiences in that. Eliza,
- 28:25what are your first points of contact when you're
- 28:27looking for a source for a story of any topic?
- 28:31Yeah, that's a good question. I also just want
- 28:33to chime in to what you just said, which was
- 28:35which is really important. And to also think
- 28:37about this phrase, right, duty of care. It's
- 28:42really, really difficult. And I don't think this
- 28:46is a fixed static and immutable perspective.
- 28:52How do we understand our duty of care as investigators,
- 28:57researchers, journalists? And when does it start
- 29:00and stop? And who do we extend it to, right?
- 29:03To your point about if you expose someone in
- 29:08the far right, that person we can identify as
- 29:10a malicious actor, what about the people around
- 29:12them? My answer to that, because it can be so
- 29:17murky, is to remain is to acknowledge it and
- 29:21to have conversations about it, particularly
- 29:23if you're going from sort of like data research
- 29:26and investigation through to the reporting stage.
- 29:29Really be open and if your editor doesn't start
- 29:33the conversation, I think you should start the
- 29:35conversation with them because we don't know
- 29:39sometimes where to draw that line, right? And
- 29:44what you said just made me think of this and
- 29:47that there is no hard and fast rule every time,
- 29:50but I think we should always kind of be prepared
- 29:53when you are trying to reveal harm and when there
- 29:56are people at the center of your journalism in
- 29:58whatever capacity to actually ask about and think
- 30:01about the duty of care, particularly if you're
- 30:03the kind of one leading the work. The final thing
- 30:07I'll say also related to that is I didn't speak
- 30:10at all to you know, the subject of this conversation
- 30:14is protecting the people in your investigation.
- 30:17Those are also other researchers, other investigators
- 30:19and other journalists, right? When the people
- 30:22on my team who had to sort of troll through,
- 30:25I'm sorry for my French, the shit that was. in
- 30:29telegram groups. When we have looked at material
- 30:32that's being used to dox women or other types
- 30:34of violence, we also have to be mindful. Myself
- 30:39as an editor, I have to think about what the
- 30:41cost is to the people on my team for doing so,
- 30:43right? Much in the same way as content moderators
- 30:46might be exposed to harm. And so it's trying
- 30:49to think about our duty of care even to other
- 30:52people who we're working with and reporting on.
- 30:54So to your question then about how do we identify
- 30:57characters, if you have started with listening,
- 31:02we are now at the Fuller Project. trying to scope
- 31:06out a series around AI and gendered work. We
- 31:10know that we live in societies where women's
- 31:14work is different to men's work, though we know,
- 31:16of course, that women were the early computer
- 31:18programmers because that was seen as mind -numbing
- 31:22calculations. And once computer programming and
- 31:25data work became sexy, it became men's work and
- 31:29not women's anymore. Somebody said to me yesterday
- 31:31that women were the original computers because
- 31:33they were manually doing the sort of computing
- 31:35themselves. And now they're being replaced by
- 31:38computers. But I digress. We're doing the series
- 31:40and we're starting by organizing what we call
- 31:44listening circles, where we bring together people
- 31:46with lived experience as well as sort of more
- 31:50academic expertise or other forms of knowledge
- 31:52to basically try and ask the questions around
- 31:55what should we be reporting, what's interesting
- 31:57and what's not. That often reveals to us communities
- 32:00of people. So somebody might suggest a really
- 32:04strong idea. Hey, there is a community of garment
- 32:07workers in Bangladesh who are doing X, Y, Z,
- 32:09and that is a way in. Other times, And in fact,
- 32:13often, reporters on my team, one of the kind
- 32:16of prized characteristics of the people I hire
- 32:19is how close are they to the ground in terms
- 32:22of having their ear to the ground, right? How
- 32:25many groups do they sort of belong to and discussions
- 32:29do they follow? It's really, really hard to reverse
- 32:32engineer. community belonging, right? Like you
- 32:35have no contact with a group of people. And then
- 32:38once the story is out, then you try and immerse
- 32:41yourself. And that doesn't mean necessarily in
- 32:44a very sort of rudimentary way. You can only
- 32:47report on communities you belong to, but rather
- 32:50that if you're interested in a subject, you are
- 32:52more likely to know where to find characters
- 32:55who will speak to you if you've been following
- 32:57it over time. Right. And so. If you are in, I
- 33:02don't know, Facebook groups or other groups where
- 33:04people are discussing an issue, Discord channels
- 33:06where people are discussing a subject, you're
- 33:09more likely to know the people who are impacted
- 33:11by that issue as a way of trying to then find
- 33:14characters. There is a lot of what we would call
- 33:18background research and calls that you make to
- 33:21just try and find your character. We knew from
- 33:24data that... in Afghanistan, the number of women
- 33:28who were leaving through irregular and informal
- 33:30migratory routes almost peaked, almost surpassed,
- 33:35rather, the number of men for the first time
- 33:37in a very long time, I think in at least 20 plus
- 33:40years, which was very unusual, right, made even
- 33:42more challenging by the fact that the Taliban
- 33:44has banned women from traveling on their own.
- 33:47So we knew from the data that women were in large
- 33:51numbers trying to leave Afghanistan through informal
- 33:53routes. But to be able to tell a story, we needed
- 33:56to find a way in that involved human beings.
- 34:00And actually, the capacity to be flexible about
- 34:03how you think about who your characters can be.
- 34:06So sticking with that example. Of course, the
- 34:08first thing we were looking for were women who
- 34:11themselves have traveled on this path. But because
- 34:15they're informal, because it's undocumented,
- 34:18they're not exactly announcing themselves. And
- 34:21you cannot present yourself as a journalist on
- 34:23that border looking for people to speak to. And
- 34:26so one of the things that we did was we went
- 34:28to the people who collected the research, the
- 34:30IOM, the Institute of Migration, and other organizations
- 34:33that were trying to service and work with migrants
- 34:37to basically build relationships with them to
- 34:39find out if they would broker access for us to
- 34:43anyone. And that's often the ways in which we
- 34:45get access, right? Brokered relationships. You
- 34:48find someone who is a gatekeeper of some or in
- 34:51some way, whether they are a nonprofit organization,
- 34:53a charity, a membership group and you ask that
- 34:57organization to broker access for you to the
- 35:01people who belong to that group. Having that
- 35:04gatekeeper as a trusted bridge into that community
- 35:09helps. But the other way that we looked at it
- 35:12was that actually if we weren't going to be able
- 35:14to get women themselves who had made that journey.
- 35:17could we tell the story through the lens of the
- 35:20people who are at the borders, counting the undocumented
- 35:23or trying to do these surveys, right? Using their
- 35:27experience of reporting from the borders because,
- 35:30or documenting experiences at the border, because
- 35:34often there would be local hires from within
- 35:37that community and that there was. a capacity
- 35:40for there to be an interesting story there and
- 35:42a way into what the data was showing us but not
- 35:45in the most sort of linear idea. Now that was
- 35:47not possible also because there were political
- 35:50risks for them to speak to us in that way and
- 35:53so we went back to the first approach and kept
- 35:55working at it until an Afghan support organization
- 35:59in Pakistan put us in touch with the three people
- 36:02who then became our main characters. Yeah, as
- 36:06I said in the chat, charities and stacked organizations
- 36:09are your friends. They are often the protocol,
- 36:12but it's important also not to cold email them
- 36:16as well. You've got to give a clear reasoning
- 36:19as to why you are getting in touch, what purpose
- 36:23them brokering that relationship will give you
- 36:26both. And I think it's important not to see that
- 36:30as an extractive. relationship as well, which
- 36:32it can be in times in the journalism world particularly.
- 36:36And we've got quite a few questions coming through
- 36:38now, so I want to make sure that we have time
- 36:40for them. So I'll kick off with Sarah who asked
- 36:43a specific question about something that they've
- 36:46struggled with in the past. When evaluating the
- 36:48risk to the person you're interviewing slash
- 36:50going to publish about, I have a question about
- 36:52how to understand the possible repercussions
- 36:55they will face specific to their community. How
- 36:58do you learn about the culture they come from
- 37:00and the feelings of their community regarding
- 37:02survivors of sexual violence? Of course, asking
- 37:05them is important and they are the expert in
- 37:07their own life, but I want to do my own due diligence
- 37:10to make sure I'm reporting as best as possible.
- 37:13So what would you say to that kind of situation?
- 37:16Yeah. The first thing I would say is there is
- 37:19a fine line we walk between doing due diligence
- 37:21and being paternalistic, right? Which is not
- 37:25at all what I'm suggesting, but I think it's
- 37:27important to check ourselves as to how we do
- 37:30that. So to speak a bit more to that, it's about
- 37:35sort of when you've done your research and when
- 37:37you've asked the person and then you still conclude,
- 37:40hmm, I think it's, you know, actually this isn't
- 37:43best for you, right? And we have to often have
- 37:48conversations on my team about sort of making
- 37:50sure that people maintain their sense of agency
- 37:53because people who are often have suffered harm
- 37:56or are oppressed in some way, their story is
- 38:00the last sort of bastion of power that they have
- 38:02and wanting to tell that story is about sort
- 38:04of reclaiming some kind of power and exercising
- 38:07that power. And so. Also worth saying, I guess,
- 38:12to your question, Sarah, that it's important
- 38:14to just kind of think, OK, once I have done some
- 38:17research and asked them. Even if I'm uncomfortable
- 38:22with the risk, that's when we then do all the
- 38:24other steps that we've talked about, right? Consult
- 38:26them when we're trying to publish, send them
- 38:28snippets of the reporting to make sure that they
- 38:30are happy with how they're presented, ask them
- 38:32how they wish to identify all of these things.
- 38:35So then to your question itself, I think this
- 38:38is really the value in particularly if you are
- 38:41investing yourself in investigative work. in
- 38:44building relationships with the community before
- 38:46it comes time to report, right? This is really
- 38:49the difference between sort of what I would call
- 38:52parachuting in or not. It's not often sort of
- 38:55physically going to a community in a different
- 38:58country that you don't know, but actually trying
- 39:00to get under the skin of an issue if you've not
- 39:03been following it closely. And I think it is
- 39:06about then asking those questions of people beforehand.
- 39:09Now, if you're talking about communities in the
- 39:12more sort of traditional sense, right, you want
- 39:13to cover gender based violence. I don't know.
- 39:18I can't remember which country is it in the Pacific.
- 39:19I think maybe PNG, Papua New Guinea probably
- 39:22has the highest rates of gender based violence
- 39:24in any place in the world. And you become fascinated
- 39:27with this and you want to do a story there. Thinking
- 39:30about how you navigate that culture involves
- 39:33working with local journalists. I often say if
- 39:36I'm working with, if I'm hiring a researcher
- 39:39or an investigator who is not from the community
- 39:41they're reporting on, one of the questions I
- 39:43always add in the list of questions we check
- 39:48off when we're commissioning a story is, how
- 39:50willing are you to work collaboratively? If you're
- 39:53not willing to work collaboratively and you're
- 39:55working on an issue that you don't know all the
- 39:57sides to, which let's be honest, for most issues,
- 39:59that's most issues, then I don't want to work
- 40:02with that reporter because it suggests to me
- 40:05that they're not open to having the input of
- 40:07other people who might enrich their journalism
- 40:09or actually keep us from fucking up, you know,
- 40:13because they can see blind spots that we don't.
- 40:15And so thinking about who you are asking, right.
- 40:18So, for example, I've worked a lot. in sub -Saharan
- 40:22Africa, you can't just sort of go into a community
- 40:25and ask the head of the household, the man, which
- 40:29it usually is, about sexual violence. You can't
- 40:31even ask the woman, often in the presence of
- 40:34the man, right? So it's trying to think about
- 40:35how you navigate that. And the same organizations
- 40:38that brokered your access are really the first
- 40:40place to start by trying to learn what you can.
- 40:44Also, I would suggest reading other people's
- 40:46reporting because sometimes and not always as
- 40:49a sort of example of best practice, but what
- 40:51not to do. So I would look at stories sometimes.
- 40:54I've done a lot of sort of teaching journalism
- 40:57students about sort of. questions around power
- 40:59and agency. And we will look at the stories by
- 41:02some high flying New York Times reporter. And
- 41:05we will count the people who were quoted in the
- 41:07story for sharing their expertise and who is
- 41:10quoted for just sharing their pain and their
- 41:12experience. And, you know, usually if all the
- 41:15black and brown people have bad or the women
- 41:18have. terrible things happen to them and then
- 41:20everyone else then puts that experience in context.
- 41:23I also think that there is a problem there because,
- 41:26of course, as I said at the start, there are
- 41:28other people who can inform the reporting. So
- 41:30I would read widely and weirdly. I would speak
- 41:35to the NGO, the charity or the whoever that has
- 41:38brokered you access. I would ask people, but
- 41:40I would also think about the settings in which
- 41:42we ask them to make sure that you are mindful.
- 41:46And I would pair up with a local journalist and
- 41:50I would share bylines or credits with them beyond
- 41:53sort of fixers, because really those people are
- 41:58sometimes the sort of difference between whether
- 42:00what we just have is data or whether we have
- 42:03a human. centric stories, it's often a fixer.
- 42:07A local journalist who stands in that gap and
- 42:09sort of like elevating them to a role of core
- 42:11reporting is just just use. If you have any other
- 42:17questions on gender based violence, particularly
- 42:19in terms of the survivor approach, we will also
- 42:24have Leila Hussain coming in in a couple of weeks
- 42:27time who has lived experience of FGM and works
- 42:30as a therapist who will be coming in to chat
- 42:32about how you might know how from the survivor's
- 42:35point of view what it's like to be approached
- 42:37by journalists and researchers and how best to
- 42:41kind of approach those situations. But we have
- 42:43kind of stumbled on the issue of informed consent
- 42:46and this kind of ties into Stephanie's question
- 42:48that she asked. Stephanie asked what do you do
- 42:52when your victim or the person the people that
- 42:56you're reporting on are children? Have you got
- 42:58any experience of working with child sources
- 43:01and what are the kind of things that you have
- 43:03to keep in mind when doing work with children?
- 43:08The Afghan family that we were talking about
- 43:11were two sisters and a brother and two of them
- 43:15were minors. In that context, and this is where
- 43:20I'm really grateful for newsrooms that, you know,
- 43:22it might be a pain in the ass when you're going
- 43:25through all the sort of like editing and verification
- 43:27processes, but really important when you're trying
- 43:30to protect people. And we had a long discussion
- 43:33because there was no adult to ask for consent
- 43:36to be able to speak to the kids, right? They
- 43:37had left on their own with finance and the blessing
- 43:42of their parents to try and get to safety and
- 43:45to make a better life for themselves in Pakistan,
- 43:47which meant that the only people that we had
- 43:51direct access to was them. And so in that scenario,
- 43:56because of the ages involved, it was deemed that
- 44:00they can represent themselves. And so we were
- 44:02able to go ahead. But in other instances, I think
- 44:05we were looking at questions around child pornography
- 44:07in the Philippines. As a general rule, we have
- 44:16generally not done stories where we would need
- 44:19to work with child sources just because of, I
- 44:25think, some of the sensitivities around doing
- 44:30the kinds of due diligence and, you know, as
- 44:32I said at the start, like they're trying to get
- 44:34the receipts. So to substantiate the claims of
- 44:40a child and oftentimes thinking about who the
- 44:45trusted adult is, who you can go to, I think
- 44:50that is a very difficult situation. And I think
- 44:54particularly in contexts where you don't have
- 44:58protective services, where you don't have institutions
- 45:05that are there. with the child protection and
- 45:08child safety in mind. We have often gone through
- 45:11third parties, so not so much to get the views
- 45:17of children in situations where they've been
- 45:22harmed. I worked on, my God, it took us nearly
- 45:25a year, on a collaborative project that we did
- 45:28with an NGO to basically find the experiences
- 45:33of girls using the internet and using their phones.
- 45:37And of course, even trying to get consent from
- 45:42girls in lots of different countries, because
- 45:44this is the other thing that we want to avoid.
- 45:47You want to avoid creating archetypes, right?
- 45:49You want to avoid, if you speak to one person,
- 45:52one child or one woman or one whoever's experience
- 45:56of an issue doesn't then represent the entire
- 45:58community of people who have had that experience.
- 46:00And so it is, again, very difficult trying to
- 46:05think about how do you presents the one character
- 46:10who's willing to talk to you without trying to
- 46:12extrapolate from that, the lived experience of
- 46:15lots of people. And so with this investigation,
- 46:18we tried to get the views of young women, so
- 46:21teenagers, in lots of different parts of the
- 46:24world. We couldn't figure out how to negotiate
- 46:28that access without working with an NGO that
- 46:30worked across all of those cultures and those
- 46:33communities rather, and already had a program
- 46:35in place. And so what we did was then craft a
- 46:38specific questionnaire with the NGO to ask of
- 46:41the young women questions that we were editorially,
- 46:44journalistically interested in. which is in part
- 46:47why it took so long, because it wasn't just survey
- 46:50results that would come from the types of things
- 46:52that the NGO usually surveyed them to find out.
- 46:55And so going through the NGO who has done all
- 46:58the due diligence in the community, who is known,
- 47:00who has gotten the consent of all the parents,
- 47:02and then putting our questions, crafting with
- 47:04them the types of questions to ask. There was
- 47:07another time we were working on doing something
- 47:10similar for women who had had postpartum depression
- 47:13and working with an NGO to think about the questions
- 47:16we ask, right? So again, the question of language.
- 47:19So for example, those of us who are kind of like
- 47:22chronically obsessively online might be thinking
- 47:25about sort of like trauma and postpartum depression,
- 47:27but in other contexts, people are not using that
- 47:29language when a woman might have. you know, postpartum,
- 47:33she might be talking about just being sad or
- 47:35being tired. And so working with clinicians in
- 47:39the country where the where we were trying to
- 47:42speak to people to find out what is the language
- 47:44they use, because just asking someone, have you
- 47:46experienced postpartum depression isn't going
- 47:49to get the answer because it is the wrong question.
- 47:52So really, I yeah. To be succinct specifically
- 47:58on children. You know, we have largely avoided
- 48:01situations where we've had to go to. Well, they've
- 48:03not they've not often come up or we've had to
- 48:05go directly to kids because of what it is to
- 48:08navigate working with minors and trying to get
- 48:11consent and have often instead opted for situations
- 48:15where we can go through sort of broker trusted
- 48:17networks to be able to solicit and get the views
- 48:22of young people. Yeah, thanks for that. I used
- 48:28to work for an organization that did speak to
- 48:32younger people and filmed younger people as well
- 48:38on their lived experience. So we covered subjects
- 48:42from FGM to, you know, businesses that young
- 48:46people had set up as well. And even to cover
- 48:49that from from the basic level, we had to have
- 48:51several processes that happened from contacting
- 48:54them originally on social media where you know,
- 48:57a lot of young people are posting, whether people
- 49:00like it or not. And then going through different
- 49:03layers of guardianship and permissions and video
- 49:06interviews prior to the filmed video interview
- 49:09and making sure that everything, it was a huge
- 49:12process to go into a one two minute video that
- 49:14ended up on social media. So when you're entering
- 49:17in discussions, when it comes to child sources,
- 49:21you also have to think about the lengthy process
- 49:23that comes with that as well and how much time
- 49:25you have to invest in that can be really, really
- 49:28powerful when you pull it off. But it's really
- 49:31important to make sure that they have informed
- 49:33consent and they know that this could be a lasting
- 49:37thing that could impact them in the future particularly.
- 49:41OK, I want to get to more and more questions
- 49:44because we are running out of time. So as if
- 49:46I'll actually ask something related to this.
- 49:48I'm curious on the protection angle. What best
- 49:50practices does Eliza recommend if it does get
- 49:52to the point of potential recorded interviews
- 49:55with sources? One thing I've noticed a lot of
- 49:57people go to lengths to blur things like faces,
- 50:00but leave backgrounds visible, for example. So
- 50:02what kind of protections do you put in place
- 50:05when you're videoing sources? Yeah, that's a
- 50:08great question. So it's thinking about identifiable
- 50:11locations. I mean, of course, folks who work
- 50:13on sort of like open source research, particularly
- 50:17if it's dealing with sort of geographical information
- 50:21and sort of like topography and thinking about
- 50:23sort of look. Locations probably think a lot
- 50:27about this much more so than sort of like other
- 50:29journalists, just features, reporters, et cetera.
- 50:32But really thinking about identifying features,
- 50:35thinking about also things like birthmarks. So
- 50:38oftentimes when we have tried to capture videos
- 50:41and we can't show a face, you might want to get
- 50:44a sense because again, that is able to stir emotion
- 50:47and make a connection with the viewer by just,
- 50:49you know, you're hearing a voice and you're seeing
- 50:51someone rubbing their hands together. If they
- 50:54have distinguishing features, I have dot tattoos
- 50:58on each of my fingers. Anybody who sees my hands
- 51:01will know that it is me. Maybe and so just thinking
- 51:07about stuff like that. So moving them out of
- 51:09their their their location Oftentimes actually
- 51:11when you're also going in particularly if you're
- 51:14doing video interviews And there is nothing subtle
- 51:17about it, right? And there are ways to make it
- 51:19more subtle, but it is much more visible than
- 51:25just going into a community with a notepad and
- 51:28a recorder or your phone and going into someone's
- 51:31home. Especially if you're reporting on tight
- 51:33-knit communities, anyone who is coming into
- 51:36that situation is going to be a very visible
- 51:38outsider. And so thinking about what you then
- 51:44do when you've got a camera with you and where
- 51:48you interview this person and where you record.
- 51:51There are many occasions where we've also had
- 51:53to sort of obscure someone's voice or do voiceovers
- 51:58because just running the risk of somebody being
- 52:03identified also by their voice. So yes, think
- 52:05about where you take them. Oftentimes when you're
- 52:07thinking about duty of care, it is often, you
- 52:10know, sometimes it's not the best thing to take
- 52:13people out of their communities. And, you know,
- 52:16let's say you book, I don't know, a hotel and
- 52:19you think, oh, this is nice. And you're going
- 52:20to put out a spread or something to try and make
- 52:22them feel comfortable. But oftentimes taking
- 52:24people out of their communities into a different
- 52:28area. might make them less comfortable but at
- 52:32the same time recording in their community might
- 52:34require you to be a bit more sort of like subtle
- 52:36in terms of how you approach that and mindful
- 52:39not just of their face but of other distinguishing
- 52:41features including the locations around them.
- 52:45Great tips. I actually was just writing in the
- 52:46chat that the BBC I used to hate having to go
- 52:48in with the massive camera and the boom mic when
- 52:51you're trying to get a sensitive story out of
- 52:54someone and you're coming in with this huge camera
- 52:56like this and saying, please tell me your story.
- 52:59You just see people kind of hide away. It's quite
- 53:04difficult. It's a quite difficult thing to have
- 53:06to have to do when you're working in broadcast
- 53:10newsrooms, for example. Soto Knife says even
- 53:13the old fashioned notebook. can be distracting.
- 53:17Absolutely. Absolutely. You're no longer making
- 53:19eye contact. You're now writing down. But just
- 53:22to think about whatever approach, particularly
- 53:25if you're not recording. make sure that your
- 53:30notes can be legible. There have been times when
- 53:32we have been co -publishing with another newsroom
- 53:34and they have wanted to see the reporter's notes
- 53:37as part of their fact -checking. So just think
- 53:42about that, right? In the ways in which you're
- 53:43organizing your data and your evidence when you're
- 53:45getting to the step where you're being sort of
- 53:47like, where the fact -checking is being done,
- 53:49make sure that someone can verify the things
- 53:51that you have written down, someone has said.
- 53:54And it's not just in some, you know, your own
- 53:56kind of version of shorthand or whatever it is.
- 53:59Because then it then the last thing you want
- 54:02to do when you're collecting sensitive information
- 54:04is go back to a character and say, I'm sorry,
- 54:06can I get this again? Yeah, Michael, my colleague
- 54:09is also put in the chat and in general on sensitive
- 54:11subjects with marginalized individuals and communities.
- 54:14I basically insisted on interviews and previous
- 54:16work being done in the person's native tongue
- 54:18or when they feel most comfortable speaking with
- 54:21a translator or fix it, even when they can communicate
- 54:23with me in English, which is another. I think
- 54:25really good points. And we had a question earlier
- 54:28about the risks of being an open source researcher
- 54:32when you're kind of removed from the topic and
- 54:35when you're looking at it kind of through a lens.
- 54:39I'm interested in your perspective when it comes
- 54:41to using imagery or videos of individuals in
- 54:43a traumatic setting. So for example, your team
- 54:45often cover labor abuses like your coverage of
- 54:48bad working conditions and sexual harassment
- 54:51at diamond sellers debiers. If a video or image
- 54:54appeared on your desk depicting abuses relevant
- 54:57to your story, how would you treat that video
- 54:59or image in order to be confident in the ability
- 55:01to publish it slash protecting those featured
- 55:04in your story? Would you reach out for consent?
- 55:08What kind of precautions would you put into place?
- 55:10Because that's a realistic example of something
- 55:13that many people in the audience would be encountering
- 55:15every day. And so this is a question of when
- 55:20you don't know the provenance of that video as
- 55:22opposed to you've asked someone to record a video,
- 55:25let's say. Exactly, exactly. For example, you've
- 55:27come across the video on social media, but it
- 55:29depicts something in the story that you're already
- 55:32writing. that's relevant to your case. Well,
- 55:35I think this is actually an example where I feel
- 55:37like this community might have many more examples
- 55:40of best practice than the rest of us do, right,
- 55:42in sort of like source verification. Because
- 55:45of course, there are ways, you know, whether
- 55:46it's looking at the metadata, trying to figure
- 55:48out when the video was taken, trying to understand
- 55:52who shared it. I'm also I'm interested, oftentimes,
- 55:56thinking about the motivations of the people
- 55:59who shared it. We've often had to have conversations
- 56:01about why could somebody have sent this to us?
- 56:05What might they want? sort of what the might
- 56:08ulterior motives be as we were talking about
- 56:10that sort of networked effect, right. But yes,
- 56:14I think that, you know, I think we would definitely
- 56:17particularly now Fuller, the Fuller project,
- 56:21while we're moving towards video is not necessarily
- 56:23a newsroom that has traditionally used a lot
- 56:25of video. And I'm thinking of in previous jobs,
- 56:28right, because there is no doubt that the Internet
- 56:32is an increasingly sort of like video led space.
- 56:34And so the appeal. if a video of harms that was
- 56:38appearing in my story landed on my desk of using
- 56:40it. The question of informed consent of the people
- 56:45in the video. I think it really depends on the
- 56:48access. If you have already established access,
- 56:51let's say you're working on, as you've said,
- 56:53harms in a factory and you've already reported
- 56:57your story or you're reporting your story, that
- 56:59means you have access to the community or maybe
- 57:01it is the labor rights group or the women's group
- 57:05that they belong to or whatever it is. And it's
- 57:07just also about checking with them, again, referring
- 57:10back to my point about. asking your characters
- 57:12or your sources to actually be co -reporters
- 57:15in some ways and bringing them into this and
- 57:17trying to find out what their thoughts of that
- 57:21content is, as well as the sort of due diligence
- 57:23we would do to make sure that the video indeed
- 57:26isn't doctored in any way, it shows what it shows,
- 57:28the timeline is accurate. What would you add
- 57:32to that as things that you would like to see
- 57:34done before that video could be used? Yeah, I
- 57:38think you've covered quite a few points. I think
- 57:40in some cases you might even want to consider
- 57:42blurring those features if you cannot find their
- 57:46identity. I think some people often may not think
- 57:51about the individuals depicted as much as they
- 57:53should, so making sure that if you can't verify
- 57:57the identity of those featured and make sure
- 58:00that they are happy to be broadcast to the world,
- 58:04it's quite important to make sure that you're
- 58:06not. kind of showcasing their face in such a
- 58:09traumatic event without permission. And I think
- 58:12this is what, again, Dr. Lezkovic went into quite
- 58:15a bit in our discussion last. I know we're running
- 58:18out of time, but I have one more question and
- 58:20I hope that's OK. I wanted to bring this up because
- 58:25it's something that I myself struggled with when
- 58:28I was first reporter. And I think if you are
- 58:30new to interviews, it's something that would
- 58:32be difficult when first working with sources.
- 58:36And that is when a source makes a claim. So,
- 58:39for example, if an individual that you've built
- 58:43up trust for has made a substantial claim within
- 58:46their testimony, how do you approach that when
- 58:51you need to kind of back up a statement with
- 58:53data? How do you navigate that relationship?
- 58:55Because that's quite a difficult thing to do.
- 58:57And I know from experience that it takes often
- 59:00years for reports to get into the kind of practice
- 59:03to be able to kind of have those difficult conversations
- 59:06with sources. So what's your best practices in
- 59:08your newsroom for that thing? And then we'll
- 59:12wrap up so everyone can enjoy that evening. Absolutely.
- 59:17So I think this just actually it's foundational,
- 59:20right? It goes back to you establishing who you
- 59:22are and what you do and how you do it. I think
- 59:24a lot of people who particularly sort of like
- 59:27traditional journalists assume that everybody,
- 59:29the public understands what journalists do and
- 59:33how they do it. And this is a completely incorrect
- 59:36assumption. Right. And so it is important once
- 59:41you are establishing a relationship with someone
- 59:42before you even sit down for the formal interview
- 59:45to really situate yourself and to say, this is
- 59:48what I'm doing. If I, you know, if we got to
- 59:51the place where you were telling me your story
- 59:53on record, I will need to ask you. you know,
- 59:57to think about what kinds of ways in which you
- 59:59can verify it. I often say to the reporters,
- 1:00:03build some sympathy with your source by telling
- 1:00:06them how laborious the editing process is, right?
- 1:00:09Like get them to feel for you because you're
- 1:00:12like, you know, make me the editor seem like
- 1:00:15an asshole because like, oh my God, my editor
- 1:00:17is going to need. to see this, this, this, and
- 1:00:20this, so that the person has some sense of both
- 1:00:23the time and the sort of breadth of evidence
- 1:00:27that they will need to show, right? Because even
- 1:00:30when there is a sense of there is a... we also
- 1:00:33have a duty of care to the people we're accusing
- 1:00:35of wrongdoing. So if we cannot verify the claims,
- 1:00:39if we cannot get a right to response, if we cannot
- 1:00:45show any sort of data, we did an investigation
- 1:00:48which was about women getting pregnant from having
- 1:00:51taken contraceptive pills that were faulty. We
- 1:00:57needed to confirm that these women were in fact
- 1:00:59indeed on the contraception that they said they
- 1:01:01were on. And so we could not work with the characters
- 1:01:03who had no sorts of proofs. We had to work with
- 1:01:06those who had their medical prescription, who
- 1:01:08maybe even still had the packet of the drugs.
- 1:01:11And then we took that picture, actually, and
- 1:01:12included it in the reporting to show people what
- 1:01:15the pills she was taking looked like. So my best
- 1:01:19practice for this is be granular and absolutely
- 1:01:22clear before someone enters into a relationship
- 1:01:27with you where they have committed to telling
- 1:01:28you their story because you have made them some
- 1:01:31promise. that it will be published or it will
- 1:01:33be shown. It's for them to understand what it
- 1:01:36will take to get from you speaking to them to
- 1:01:38the story going out. And then they become a sort
- 1:01:42of co -conspirator with you, trying to find these
- 1:01:44files, trying to get this evidence as opposed
- 1:01:46to you promising them that all they will need
- 1:01:48to do is tell their story and then they will
- 1:01:50never have to speak to you again. That's false
- 1:01:52because you're going to have to, you know, need
- 1:01:54to corroborate the story. Absolutely, and obviously
- 1:01:59communicate that all with your editors as well.
- 1:02:01If there is a problem, for example, if a migrant
- 1:02:03that you're speaking to doesn't have the paperwork
- 1:02:06that you need to tell the story, communicate
- 1:02:09that with your editor early on and problem solve
- 1:02:12it rather than kind of keeping it to yourself,
- 1:02:15trying to do the interview and then it becoming
- 1:02:17a problem later on. Eliza, thank you so much.
- 1:02:21It's been fascinating to speak. with you and
- 1:02:23thank you to everyone who's sat in the audience
- 1:02:25and listened and asked questions. We're going
- 1:02:28to continue this series on looking into these
- 1:02:32kinds of topics and ways to keep survivors and
- 1:02:36those at the centre of your stories protected.
- 1:02:39Sarah has mentioned in the chat as well. Before
- 1:02:42we all disperse, I wanted to point out that the
- 1:02:44Muro code is going through an update with guidance
- 1:02:46for open source research and the pilot is available
- 1:02:49till the end of June. So you can check that out
- 1:02:51at the Gender -Based Violence Massage and New
- 1:02:53Channel. Sarah's going through it. She's going
- 1:02:55to put some notes on there asking for feedback.
- 1:02:57So please have a look at that in your spare time.
- 1:03:00Thank you, everybody, for listening and thank
- 1:03:02you, Eliza, again for coming. Thank you for having
- 1:03:04me. Bye, everyone. Thanks for coming. Bye. Thank
- 1:03:07you, everyone. Thank you for listening to the
- 1:03:13stage talk. If you'd like to catch a stage talk
- 1:03:16live where you can ask the guest questions, join
- 1:03:20the Bellingcat Discord server by visiting www
- 1:03:23.discord .gg slash Bellingcat. The music you've
- 1:03:29heard is titled Dawn by Newer Self and is courtesy
- 1:03:33of Artlist.