Latest / SWOP Behind Bars Advocacy from the Margins / Jeffrey Epstein Is Not Your Nordic Model Success Story
Transcript
- Jeffrey Epstein Is Not Your Nordic Model Success Story.
- /A weekend reed from The Pink Patriarchy Files, timed for the Florida NOW State Conference St.
- Petersburg, August 14–16, convened under the banner “Feminists Fight Fascism.”
- A fitting moment to ask which feminism shows up: the one that fights concentrated state power, or the one that keeps asking for more of it in the name of protecting women.
- /There may be no name in America more synonymous with sex trafficking than Jeffrey Epstein teenage girls, powerful men, private jets, sealed deals, and a justice system that somehow knew everything and did nothing about it for years.
- /So of course the Nordic Model crowd came running.
- Almost before the ink dried on the 2019 indictment, Epstein was drafted into the End Demand gospel: Exhibit A for the claim that wherever a man will pay, a victim is being made, and that the fix is to arrest the buyers.
- His victims girls with names and sworn testimony were conscripted into an argument they never made.
- The pitch never changes.
- Pass the right law against demand and trafficking simply evaporates, as though exploitation were a market you could legislate out of existence with enough moral conviction.
- /There is one rather enormous problem.
- /Jeffrey Epstein wasn’t buying consensual adult sex work.
- He was sexually abusing children, some as young as 14 which, last anyone checked, was already about as illegal as a thing can get.
- Nobody needed a new prostitution statute to arrest him.
- There was no loophole for rich men who exploit 14-year-olds, no gap in the law waiting politely for the Nordic Model to come fill it.
- /And here’s what the abolitionists never quite get around to saying out loud: this wasn’t prostitution.
- Not adult, not consensual, not commercial sex in any sense their own framework recognizes.
- Insisting that a demand-side sex-work law would have “eradicated” Epstein isn’t an argument it’s a category error in a feminist costume.
- You cannot end, through prostitution law, a crime that was never prostitution to begin with.
- The silence is strategic: concede that Epstein was a child rapist and not a customer, and the case stops proving anything they need it to prove.
- /So what actually failed? Not the statute book.
- Everyone had the laws.
- Police investigated, victims spoke, the FBI got involved, prosecutors built a case and Epstein still strolled out with a sweetheart non-prosecution deal.
- The Justice Department’s own watchdog later concluded that U.S.
- Attorney Alexander Acosta had exercised “poor judgment” and that the victims were never treated with the honesty they were owed.
- /The state had laws.
- It had investigators, prosecutors, victims, and evidence.
- What it did not have was any willingness to use them against a rich man.
- That is not a failure of End Demand.
- It’s a failure of power.
- /And before someone objects: no, the review found no proof that Acosta was bought.
- That’s exactly the point.
- Power doesn’t require a bribe.
- It runs on ordinary discretion whose word gets believed, whose case is “too messy” for a jury, which victims are worth the paperwork.
- Epstein didn’t need anyone to be corrupt.
- He needed a system already inclined to hand a wealthy, well-connected man the benefit of every doubt.
- It took Julie K.
- Brown and the Miami Herald whose Perversion of Justice investigation dragged the survivors back to the center of the story to force the only honest question: how did so many institutions know so much and still do nothing? /Which is where the Pink Patriarchy earns its name.
- The Nordic Model takes a tangled mess poverty, migration, coercion, trafficking, abuse, and consensual adult work and flattens it into one word, demand, with one magic fix: arrest the men and exploitation withers away.
- Tidy.
- Also useless for understanding Epstein, whose crimes had nothing to do with a shortage of prostitution laws and everything to do with money and impunity.
- /Run the experiment.
- Drop the perfect Nordic Model into Palm Beach circa 2002: buyers criminalized, stings on every corner, demand-reduction billboards everywhere.
- Then Epstein recruits a 14-year-old.
- What should happen? Exactly what the laws already required investigate, protect the child, follow the money, believe the victims, prosecute the man.
- Not one line of it requires arresting an adult for consensual sex.
- /Meanwhile, the people actually being hunted keep getting waved past.
- While the movement debates whether to arrest clients, sex workers watch the system shrug at the predators stalking them.
- The gap is measurable: in one British study, murders of sex workers were solved about 63 percent of the time, against 98 percent for other murdered women.
- Some of that is because the cases are hard; stranger killers, victims no one was looking for but that is precisely the vulnerability predators shop for.
- They pick the people they’re betting no one will bother to prioritize.
- /Which leaves the only question that matters: whose testimony does the system value, and whose can it afford to ignore? /And this is the blind spot the abolitionists never account for.
- Feminism set out to dismantle a system that polices women’s bodies, disbelieves their testimony, and decides on their behalf what they may do with their own lives.
- Backed into a corner by that same patriarchy, one wing of it built a mirror image: more police, more surveillance, more prosecutors sorting women into victims and criminals, more of the state climbing into women’s beds to save them from themselves.
- The Nordic Model doesn’t tear down the master’s house it repaints it pink and calls the renovation liberation.
- You cannot arrest your way out of male domination using the machinery of male domination, and forgetting that isn’t a footnote they left out.
- It’s the whole argument they can’t afford to finish.
- /None of this is a plea to go easy on Epstein.
- Decriminalizing consensual adult sex work doesn’t touch trafficking, rape, coercion, or the abuse of children: a trafficker stays a trafficker, a child abuser stays a predator, and minors cannot consent to commercial sex, full stop.
- The ask is embarrassingly modest arrest fewer consenting adults, and catch the next Epstein while the institutions still have the chance they keep wasting.
- /So, no.
- Epstein is not your Nordic Model success story.
- He’s the opposite: what happens when everyone has enough laws, enough power, and enough warning, and the institutions still decline to stop a man they could have stopped at any point.
- The problem was never that his crimes weren’t illegal.
- It’s that making them illegal was never going to be enough to make powerful people care.
- /So Which Feminism Shows Up? /That brings us back to St.
- Petersburg and a conference convened under the banner “Feminists Fight Fascism.”
- If we mean that, feminism cannot warn about concentrated state power on Friday and demand more police, surveillance, arrests, and control over women’s sexual decisions on Saturday.
- Sex worker-led feminism does not ask anyone to ignore trafficking, exploitation, or violence.
- We are asking feminists to get better at fighting them.
- Believe the person who says she was trafficked.
- Believe the person who says she wasn’t.
- Protect children.
- Prosecute rapists and traffickers.
- Give people who want to leave sex work housing, money, health care, and real options.
- And when sex workers tell you a policy designed to “save” us is making us less safe, listen.
- /Support sex worker-led feminism.
- Fund sex worker-led organizations.
- Put lived experience at the policy table before laws are written, not after the damage is done.
- And stop confusing punishment with protection simply because the hand holding the handcuffs calls itself feminist.
- /The patriarchy has spent centuries telling women that someone else knows what is best for them.
- /Feminism should know better.