Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Wiki, Woo, and the Winchester Widow (with Adrienne Hill and Richard Saunders)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feels so much more happiness. Truth, Usian wisdom
- 0:33will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start
- 0:40thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. Right before
- 0:57I went to junior high, I was in old in a program called ACE
- 1:03Accelerated Christian Education. And don't let the name fool you. It was not
- 1:08any kind of education. It was in doctrination, right. It was the
- 1:12praguer you of that time, except even worse, and it's still being used
- 1:17today. If you've seen the Amazon docu series Shiny Happy People, about the
- 1:22Dugger family and about Bill Gothard and the IBLP, the Institute for Basic Life
- 1:27Principles, then you're kind of on that page. ACE terrifying taught two children
- 1:34all around the world today. Well, somebody who is an expert on ace
- 1:41who was once programmed as I was, as so many of you were.
- 1:46She's going to join me to talk about it, to get into the specific
- 1:49lessons and how children are being trained to take over the country and the world
- 1:56with materials that will set your moral sent on fire. That's coming up here
- 2:02later on in the month of January. Also this month, I'm going to
- 2:07talk to Katherine Stewart. Her book The Power Worshipers was at least one of
- 2:13the inspirations for this new documentary that's coming out. It is produced by Rob
- 2:19Reiner, the director of Princess Bride and When Harry Met Sally and a few
- 2:27good men and this is Spine, Old Tap and so many others. He's
- 2:31behind this. That film's going to release nationwide next month. But I'm going
- 2:37to talk to Katherine Stewart about some of the big names and the big messages
- 2:40behind the movie God and Country. There is video of today's conversation. The
- 2:50link to that's in the description box of the show. A couple of very
- 2:58special guests, skeptical guests. Today, I've got my dear friend Adrian Hill.
- 3:05She is a gorilla skepticism on Wikipedia editor since twenty nineteen, we're going
- 3:10to talk about that former teacher. I guess she may still be a teacher
- 3:14in many regards today. A reporter for the Skeptic Zone podcast, she hosts
- 3:21virtual skeptic camps. What are those? I don't know, We're going to
- 3:24find out, and she is a contributor to magazines like Skeptical Inquirer or s
- 3:31I. Richard Saunders from Sydney, Australia. He starred as the skeptical judge
- 3:38on two seasons of the television show called The One, The Search for Australia's
- 3:44Most Gifted Psychic. He is host of the Skeptic Zone podcast. He is
- 3:47an origami expert and a children's author. We spoke to him. I want
- 3:53to say it was last year, maybe the year before, Richard, we
- 3:55were talking about the big psychic prediction project that was going on. Is that
- 4:00right? That was right? I can't exactly remember when that was. It's
- 4:04been a long year for me. I think it was last year, but
- 4:08yeah, that was a huge, huge undertaking. Adrian was part of the
- 4:12team, the international team, and we studied almost four thousand predictions to get
- 4:16a very good understanding of can people tell the future. I think we have
- 4:21to start there again because a lot of people have either forgotten or maybe missed
- 4:26that conversation. You did a study, I don't know. I want to
- 4:30call it peer review. I mean, how would you qualify the study of
- 4:34psychics? Richard good question. It's waiting to be peer reviewed. I hope
- 4:40it will be peer reviewed, or more precisely, I hope somebody will copy
- 4:44the format and the idea in their own area. Now, this was a
- 4:46study undertaken for published psychic or other predictions made in Australia over a twenty year
- 4:54period. So what I would really hope is that somebody in another country,
- 4:58so the United States might say, okay, well do Colorado. We'll look
- 5:00at all the psychic predictions published in Colorado for a year, because to do
- 5:04the whole of the United States would be untenable. But if they do it,
- 5:10then I would be interested to see the results. We came to the
- 5:12conclusion myself and the international team that roughly eleven percent of psychic predictions can be
- 5:19categorized as coming true, which means almost ninety percent or either wrong, too
- 5:26vague, or predicted. And so our conclusion was there's no reason to think
- 5:30that people have special mystical knowledge about future events. Well, let me I
- 5:36got hung up on that word. And you can speak to this if you
- 5:40want, Adrian. But vague isn't that the calling card of the psychic right,
- 5:44the Forrror effect, of the Barnum effect. You know, you throw
- 5:46out a kind of a bunch of vagaries, if that's even a word,
- 5:49and people just lean into those predictions. I'll let either of you speak to
- 5:54that. Yeah, I think that we definitely found most of the predictions.
- 5:58I don't know what percent. I'm sure there is a percent that you have
- 6:00Richard and your little pie charts, and we found a lot of them to
- 6:04be extremely vague, very difficult to even parse out sometimes and figure out what
- 6:09they were trying to predict. And lots of laughter, lots of fun.
- 6:13And I don't remember the exact number, but I think it was quite high,
- 6:16those vague Barnum statements. Well, give me an example of a vague
- 6:21Barnum statement. I'm sitting in your chair. There's the crystal ball. I
- 6:26mean, you know, work me a little bit. I gave you my
- 6:28hundred bucks or whatever you're charging. What am I looking at? You've come
- 6:32in here because you're a questioning individual. I can sense that I think you
- 6:38have some trouble. Well, you certainly had some trouble when you were younger
- 6:42coming to terms with just who you are. You do have an optimistic outlook.
- 6:46You can be the life of the parties, except sometimes you need to
- 6:49be alone. What we discussed I've got you to a tea right, Well,
- 6:56we discovered in the predictions we looked at. When we say vague,
- 7:01they were more like if they was talking about a famous film stuff. This
- 7:06famous film star has great opportunities ahead of her. Sometimes she wonders if she's
- 7:12taken the right career path. Financial troubles are always a concern. Okay,
- 7:16that's that's what we were getting a lot of those sort of things was from
- 7:21North America. Was when we learned what klucky was, because one of the
- 7:27predictions was around Clucky Venus having an effect on I believe it was Angelina Jolie
- 7:31or some other star, and we thought that was hilarious and klucky in Australia
- 7:39means you want to have a baby. Well, what is wait, what's
- 7:43klucky mean in the States. I'm just a minow. I don't know what
- 7:46that means. I don't think it means anything. I mean, I've only
- 7:49heard it in Australia or I guess the UK. It just means you want
- 7:55to have children, You're clucky, you want to have children. But I've
- 7:59called up the stats just quickly and so I can see that eleven percent we
- 8:03could say of all the nearly four thousand predictions, eleven percent we could sort
- 8:09of categorize as coming correct. The vague, which we were talking about before,
- 8:11took up nineteen percent of all the predictions. The expected like there will
- 8:16be earthquakes in California took up fifteen percent, and a tiny percentage two percent
- 8:22was unknown. We couldn't get to the bottom of the prediction. It was
- 8:26too hard to find out, and over fifty percent fifty three percent were fled
- 8:31out wrong. So that's that's the quick breakdown. Adrey, and I know
- 8:35that you do a lot of work with Wikipedia. Explain what you are doing
- 8:39on Wiki trying to make sure that fringe topics such as ghosts and anything health
- 8:48related that's you know, the wellness industry, anything that's not scientifically backed,
- 8:52those pages have good sources, good resources, and good information on them,
- 8:58and so science people so if there's somebody in the science world, a science
- 9:03communicator, we want to make sure that they have good pages, good accurate
- 9:07pages, that they stand the test of time. And it's a constant battle.
- 9:13There's not a lot of us. There's millions of Wikipedia editors. We
- 9:16are a small group of about one hundred and twenties. Usually. What we're
- 9:20around from around the world, in multiple languages, trying to make sure that
- 9:26good, reliable information is on science pages and fringe pages, and making sure
- 9:33that good information is out there. And we also try and put on our
- 9:35psychic hats and predict who might be next and get the page ready and have
- 9:41it there for when they blow up in the news. And that has happened
- 9:46to a few of us. And of course we don't have psychic hats.
- 9:48It was just luck. One of my favorite ones was Christiane Northrop. I
- 9:52did her page. She is a gynecologist, or was a gynecologist. I
- 9:58believe her license has been revol appeared on Oprah Winfrey sold books, sold crazy
- 10:03stuff about women's health, and someone said you need to do her page.
- 10:07I did her page, and within six months she was listed as one of
- 10:13the dozen people that misinformation from COVID was coming from one of the top dozen,
- 10:20and her page went through the roof, so lots of people were suddenly
- 10:24running to her page and seeing that maybe we shouldn't listen to this woman because
- 10:30her information is not very valid. It is not accurate, it's not based
- 10:35in science. So if I'm understanding, you were able to sort of front
- 10:39load the page with the skeptical aspect of it before somebody else goes in and
- 10:45front loads it with the celebrity aspect that I don't know if it would be
- 10:50frontloading it with skepticism. I would like to treat it as I'm frontloading it
- 10:54with accurate information. And you know that's what we want to do, is
- 11:00make sure that it's as accurate as possible. And will people come in and
- 11:03try and remove it and change it, Yes, yes they will, but
- 11:07the editors there's strict rules in Wikipedia, and yes it can be changed.
- 11:11It can be changed quickly, but it gets reverted back very quickly if it's
- 11:15considered vandalism or if there's an interest in it. For example, I just
- 11:18finished the Sarah Winchester page, and last year I did the Winchester Mystery House
- 11:26and what happened almost immediately when I did that page, because the page was
- 11:31there before, but it was filled with the stuff that you're just talking about.
- 11:37It was all about the lore, and it was stated as truth that
- 11:41she was a crazy woman, when in actual fact she wasn't, and there
- 11:45were reasons why she did what she did, and she wasn't afraid of ghosts,
- 11:50she wasn't spiritual at all, and yet the rumors persisted from the time
- 11:54of her living for one hundred years. The hundred years of her death was
- 11:58just this last year, and immediately we believe it was somebody from the Winchester
- 12:03Mystery House came on and tried to revert everything that I had done. However,
- 12:07other editors not part of the Grilla skeptics came in and went, you
- 12:13can't do that. This person has used very good sources like historians, Brian
- 12:18Dunning, Joe Nicol, people who are well known in the community, and
- 12:22we have to keep it this way. And they later divulged if it was
- 12:26the same person, that they did indeed work for the house, for the
- 12:30Winchester Mystery House, and they wanted the idea that she was afraid of ghosts,
- 12:33that she built crazy things because she was afraid of the spirits, and
- 12:37I think that does an injustice to somebody who was really smart and really good
- 12:41with mathematics. Of course, that's my background, so I kind of had
- 12:45a liking for this woman. She was fascinating to learn about it. I
- 12:48know ghost fans and ghost story fans like me already familiar, but I want
- 12:54to do my due diligence and talk about what you're talking about. The winchest
- 13:00legend was that what her husband had died and she had to continue to build
- 13:05onto the house because of the angst she felt that her family was behind the
- 13:11creation of Winchester rifles, weapons that had killed and to ward off the ghosts
- 13:18of those who died at the end of a Winchester rifle, she felt she
- 13:22had to appease the spirits by building the mansion. Am I remembering that right
- 13:28to either one of you. That's one one of the many lores that exists,
- 13:31But yes, that is definitely one of the big ones as well as
- 13:35she built the maze like house because she was trying to trick the spirits so
- 13:41she could be safe. So there are lots of reasons around that, and
- 13:45what's really interesting about that particular story is it was highly unlikely that she felt
- 13:50any guilt because of the Winchester rifles. One she remained on the board of
- 13:56the company until she died. The other one was at that time owning a
- 14:01gun was seen as a survival necessity, so that lore was actually not correct
- 14:07just because of the culture of the time, as well as she stayed on
- 14:11the board. If there had been any guilt, my guess which she would
- 14:15have sold the stocks and got rid of them. She would have been more
- 14:18financially well off if she had done it, actually, because after the First
- 14:22World wore, the stocks plummeted a lot and she lost most of her fortune.
- 14:26Not that she was poor by any means. She had a very vast
- 14:30fortune. But you know, she would have definitely gotten rid of that if
- 14:35there had been any guilt. Why did she continue to add on to the
- 14:39mansion until she died? According to the story, and that's another myth,
- 14:43she actually did not keep building until the day she died. She stopped building
- 14:48after it was the nineteen oh six earthquake. It collapsed most of the house,
- 14:52so most of the house that was there actually was destroyed, and she
- 14:56stopped. She was getting old by then, her health was very and she
- 15:01just kind of gave up on her favorite project. Why did she build for
- 15:03the many many years that she did build, which was I think eighteen eighty
- 15:07six until nineteen oh six, so twenty years of building. There's speculation part
- 15:13of it is she had a love of architecture and design and her and her
- 15:18husband actually built a home with architects when they lived in the Connecticut region in
- 15:24New Haven, and when he died and she moved to California, it was
- 15:28kind of a natural progression for her to continue this passion. She tried to
- 15:33hire some architects and wasn't happy with what they wanted to do, so she
- 15:37just did it on her own. She was a project manager and designer of
- 15:41that house, and she kept building, and originally she wanted to build it
- 15:46so her whole family could stay with her. There's speculation based on letters that
- 15:50she kept building so that they wouldn't live with her. So Richard, is,
- 16:00aren't there stairways to nowhere and a bunch of hidden secret rooms? There
- 16:04are. It's a really interesting historical place to wander around and I remember seeing
- 16:11it on TV shows in the late nineteen seventies there was a show called That's
- 16:17Incredible, which was an American show but it was broadcast in Australia, and
- 16:19they made it out to be the craziest nonsense house you could possibly imagine.
- 16:25Why would you do this? But when I listened to the episode Brian Dunning's
- 16:30skeptoid episode about her in the house, and I listened to I read the
- 16:33research done by people like Adrian Hill, and you piece it all together.
- 16:37It's a wonderful story. The truth is a wonderful story. But I can
- 16:41understand there's an appeal about she did this because of ghosts or this hauntings or
- 16:48are there spirits really there? A lot of people really get off on that.
- 16:51You know, a lot of people that fires their imagination. Okay,
- 16:53it's a fun story, but the real story is really worth telling, and
- 16:59it's respectable to her. It's out of respect to her that the real story
- 17:03should be told. I didn't mean to spend ten minutes on the Winchester House,
- 17:07but I'm having been fascinated by it. I never saw the film,
- 17:11poorly reviewed, I didn't bother with it. I thought reading about it was
- 17:15actually much more compelling. Richard, any other ghost houses that marked you,
- 17:22and I mean terrified to you, because I know you better than that.
- 17:23But come on, you've gotten into the ghostly kind of thing. Give me
- 17:29some anydats I wish I could tell you. I went to the Australia's most
- 17:33Haunted House or Sydney's most Haunted house. There are a lot of most haunted
- 17:37houses in Australia, it turns out. I think there are a lot of
- 17:40most haunted houses in the United States and Canada, depending on who you talk
- 17:42to. But seriously, when I've turned up to investigate or ghost tours or
- 17:48whatever the case may be, it really struck me early on that I'm standing
- 17:52in a dark room at night and it's a bit quiet outside. And I
- 17:57even left recording equipment, walked away for half an hour, came back and
- 18:02listened to everything clearly, and you can hear the odd dog barking or something
- 18:06like that. But if you go into a haunted location with somebody who believes,
- 18:11then every imagined or real slight temperature change, I mean they're primed,
- 18:17you know, they primed for anything strange. And I'll interpret anything strange as
- 18:21a ghost or unworldly or something like that. But to be really frank,
- 18:26after a little while, it's just standing in a cold room at night.
- 18:30That's it. Nothing happens, you know, I wouldn't mind if the ghost
- 18:34of someone or rather walked by, and at least it would be something tedium.
- 18:41Yeah, And I certainly have spoken to people who couldn't. Not that
- 18:47they wouldn't, but they physically couldn't spend hours in a dark room in a
- 18:53supposedly haunted location. They would be too terrified. And I can understand that
- 19:00would be a huge mental problem for them, and it would be like a
- 19:03torture to make them do it. For me, just give me a comfortable
- 19:06chair and I'll just sit through it. You know that's about it, do
- 19:10you. I'm sure Adrian gets it too. People are pissed at you.
- 19:12They're upset you're attacking there. They wouldn't call them illusions. These are deep
- 19:18seated beliefs, things that they take very personally. And how dare you,
- 19:23Richard and Adrian, how dare you say these things about these cherished, beloved,
- 19:29sacred stories. You've heard that, either one of you. Yeah,
- 19:32And it's interesting because I'm relatively well known in Australia as being a skeptic with
- 19:37media appearances in the podcast and everything. I'll often get people coming up to
- 19:41me in a social situation, having a drink at a bar or at a
- 19:45party, and they say, all right, mister skeptic, what about this?
- 19:48And they want to put me on the spot and they want to show
- 19:52I'm wrong and you know, prove me to be a fool. And I
- 19:55always say to them, Okay, well, I'm happy to give give you
- 19:57my opinion, but please remember you approached me. All right, I'm here
- 20:03minding my own business of having a drink. If you if I'll tell you
- 20:06what I think And they say yeah, yeah, sure, and then they
- 20:08get upset with me. I'm sure. Well, I was like, I'm
- 20:11not going to see Adrian on the Winchester brochures that her photo is not going
- 20:15to be on their promotional materials now because she is sort of attacking what people
- 20:21have. There's an awe and wonder in a magic I'd buy that. I
- 20:25mean, you would agree, Adrian. People they love the yarn, they
- 20:29love the story, the mystery of it right well. And part of the
- 20:33fascination with the Winchester story is that these stories about ghosts started when she was
- 20:40alive. So this is nothing new, and I don't think we need to
- 20:45get rid of that. I think we need to say, Okay, this
- 20:47is what started in the eighteen hundreds because she was quite reclusive and so people
- 20:52made up stories and it was a big part of the spiritualist movement at the
- 20:56time. So somebody, some widow believing in ghost seemed to be a reasonable
- 21:02thing to surmise. But now let's add in the truth. Let's add in
- 21:06what has been discovered by historians, particularly Marry Joe Ignoffo, who wrote her
- 21:10biography wonderful book, and let's put that in there as well. One of
- 21:15the things that was really fun at Psichon that I just came back from a
- 21:18few weeks ago, Brian Dunning was there, who did the original Skeptoid episode
- 21:23that spurned this whole production of the Winchester Mystery Page revamp that I did.
- 21:30It was because of his episode. He turned to me and said, well,
- 21:33that episode was like a year ago, and Mary Joe Agnoffo's book has
- 21:36been out since I think it's twenty fifteen. I mean, they're not doing
- 21:38that anymore, are they. I purchased the one hundred year Anniversary souvenir book
- 21:44and had it sent to me, and yes, it's still full of all
- 21:48of the lore and very little saying, well, actually this is not found
- 21:52to be true. So I think you know, wasn't it, hitchins if
- 21:55I can jump in? Hitchen said, the real world is wonderful enough.
- 22:00We don't have to lie to ourselves. And I also think we are human
- 22:03beings creatures of imagination. We can spin yarns fictitious tales and enjoy the wonder
- 22:08of fiction, always knowing it's fiction. That's fair right. Yeah, Well,
- 22:12as the old saying goes, we are storytelling animals. This is hardwired
- 22:18into us to tell stories. They are a huge part of what makes a
- 22:22human a human. Us stories it's how we remember things, that's how we
- 22:26learn things, It's how we carry the tradition of our ancestors. Stories.
- 22:30That's why soap operas, from everything from Star Wars to whatever works, because
- 22:34it's a story which resonates with us. And if that story is fanciful,
- 22:40or is wonderful or carries you away, well that's hardwired into us. Also,
- 22:45the true stories you hear about this, true crime and reality TV,
- 22:48supposedly reality TV, it boils down to stories. Macbeth is a story,
- 22:55so you can't underestimate how important that is to us as humans. It buggles
- 23:00me to think that people really don't have that perspective, and you have to
- 23:04take that into perspective. When people get carried away and it becomes real and
- 23:08true to them, it's not surprising and something we as skeptics really have to
- 23:12take into consideration. Stand by more to come with my special guests right after
- 23:19this. Talking here with Adrian Hill. She is a retired math teacher.
- 23:33Now she is a Gorilla Skepticism on Wikipedia editor and co chair of the annual
- 23:40Western Canadian Reason Conference. Also with me is Paranormal Investigators Skeptic TV host and
- 23:48author Richard Saunders. Did you find yourself becoming history students? Adrian said the
- 23:56word lore several times, So as you dig into you are students of history
- 24:03the stories behind the lore. Am I reading that right? Yeah? Definitely.
- 24:07And if you said to my twenty year old self, who was a
- 24:11math major at university, that I was going to be doing history when I
- 24:15retired and writing that's the other thing that's so incredible, I would have laughed
- 24:19at you. There's no way I would have thought that that would be a
- 24:22direction I would take. But I'm really enjoying it. It's fascinating quick digression.
- 24:26Just because you come from a teaching background, is it true from your
- 24:30perception? You're not on the hook, But people who are good at English
- 24:33and math are terrible at history and science. I mean, there are some
- 24:37rules that people have posited that said, if you're good at these studies,
- 24:41you're going to be shit at these studies. Is there any truth to any
- 24:44of that. I don't know, and I doubt it. I'm sure that
- 24:48there is more interest driven than anything that's my but it's true. I mean,
- 24:55like I was good at English and I was horrible at science, which
- 24:59is weird because in Christian school, our science wasn't even really science. It
- 25:03was like it was like God made the trees. That was our science books.
- 25:07God made the cells and Adam and Eve. It's weird. Richard,
- 25:11tell me about this television background of yours. You're on TV as the skeptic.
- 25:17Yeah, well, well, some time ago I did a two series
- 25:22of a show where I was a judge. You know, you have these
- 25:23TV shows where they have dancers or singers or whatever, and every week people
- 25:30get voted off. Well, I was on the show like that for people
- 25:33who claim to have psychic ability, and I would look at them and try
- 25:37to judge how well they did in a series of tests. I mean,
- 25:41it's television. It was mostly done for ratings and fun. It wasn't hopefully
- 25:45wasn't taken too seriously. But it did give me a good insight into a
- 25:49lot of psychics in Australia, and it gave me a great insight into how
- 25:55the public react to someone like me, how they were act to a skeptic.
- 26:00And I tried to be funny and pleasant and polite and cheerful and just
- 26:03no nonsense on the screen. But I would get letters from people saying,
- 26:10there, mister Saord, is that skeptic you play on TV? Are you
- 26:12really that arrogant? Or are you like that in real life? You're the
- 26:18bad guy in their story? How can you be the bad guy and you're
- 26:22just a teddy bear? I was, well, story needs a villain.
- 26:27I was painted like that because a lot of the people who were tuning in
- 26:30were tuning in to see their favorite psychic and here's me saying, oh,
- 26:36you know what, they really didn't do anything psychic today, So of course
- 26:38I was I was painted at the villain. But I I appear quite often
- 26:45whenever there's a story about the psychics or the UFOs or the paranormal, they'll
- 26:51call me up to the Australian skeptics and I'll front up to the cameras.
- 26:55I did a couple of TV appearances a couple of months ago, within days
- 26:59of each other, on two different networks. The story was there's a young
- 27:03man who's the latest psychic wonder kid on the block in Australia, and his
- 27:07stick is that he has a radio, which they call it a spirit box.
- 27:11It's simply a radio receiver where the mechanism has been altered so it scans
- 27:17like it car radio can scan the frequencies, but it never locks on,
- 27:21so it continually goes as it's scanning all the frequencies and you hear a snippet
- 27:26of what's being broadcast. Well to some people, they think this is how
- 27:33ghosts communicate with us. The ghosts use radio to send messages and if you
- 27:38listen long enough you can hear what the ghost's trying to tell you. Now,
- 27:44it's nothing new. These ghost boxes have been around for a while.
- 27:47We know the phenomena called audio paradolia, where your brain is making sense out
- 27:51of randomness. But the TV networks they hadn't quite seen this before, so
- 27:56they were amazed and they ring me up. Do you know what a spirit
- 27:59box? Is? Amazing? You can hear the ghosts and I'm just going
- 28:04but welcome to the party. You are late, all right. But I
- 28:10did appear on two different TV shows and at least on one I got to
- 28:14bend a spoon, so that was quite fun. I saw you do that
- 28:18at a conference in Canada. Do you just I'm trying to remember, do
- 28:22you just pre bend the spoon or do you break another spoon? Do they
- 28:26have to be a certain kind of spoon? All my spoons I get I
- 28:30either get from a giant catering store in Sydney which is for restaurants and hotels
- 28:34and stuff, so they're just standard spoons. Or Adrian Hill, when I
- 28:38turned up in Canada, she went to eBay and bought hundreds of standard spoons.
- 28:44Now, there are various ways to bend a spoon. There's lots of
- 28:48methods to the trick, but to start with, all you need to do
- 28:52is get relatively cheap tea spoons that you would normally use in cafes and whatnot.
- 28:56From that aspect, it can be easy have to learn learn how to
- 29:00do it. But knowing how to do it, I mean, you could
- 29:03be ridiculously wealthy. You could be the eury Galla of Australia. You could
- 29:08you could cash those chips in, right, Adrian, I mean if he
- 29:11went in Ben spons Big. Someone told me that Uri once was allegedly hired
- 29:17by a government to be a psychic for that. I don't know if that's
- 29:22that may be law or I don't know if that's true New Times recently.
- 29:26I think he probably was. There are there people are people. People are
- 29:30in all walks of life throughout society, from scientists, the journalists, of
- 29:33politicians, and a certain percentage of our fellow humans may not be as aware
- 29:40as we are about certain magic tricks and ways of thinking. So people in
- 29:44government make blunders and ridiculous errors all the time. So it's natural that every
- 29:49now and then, something like the police calling in a psychic, or a
- 29:52government official calling in someone like a warder diviner, that happens. That's true.
- 30:00So you talked about I mentioned Jerry Geller and I obviously have an amazing
- 30:04segue, totally unintended, but I'm going to take credit for it anyway,
- 30:07because it was James Randy who helped to debunk this psychic spoonbender, who is
- 30:15I think still out there even today, yes, and admired and loved by
- 30:21a whole culture of people who think he's the real deal. But James Randy,
- 30:26who he called himself a conjurer but also a great skeptic, one of
- 30:30the world's greatest magicians. You may be able to introduce the legend of the
- 30:34late James Randy better than me either. One of you want to tell everybody
- 30:38more about Randy before we talk about his work, I'll grab it really quickly.
- 30:42Randy and I were actually very good friends. I met him first,
- 30:47I'm guessing twenty twenty five years ago, but certainly in the last ten years
- 30:52before he died, he and I became very good friends. We collaborated a
- 30:55lot, and I toured ran with Brandy in Australia. He did a big
- 30:59speaker engagement and I was one of the people on the tour who would be
- 31:03doing the fireside chat, you know, interviewing Randy on stage. So Randy
- 31:07was originally from Canada, and when he was a very young man, he
- 31:11knew some basic magicians routines and tricks, and he went to a spiritualist church.
- 31:18How am I saying? It's a church that deals with the spirits and
- 31:22contacting the dead and all that sort of stuff. And the guy at the
- 31:26front was doing a magic trick. It's called the one ahead routine, where
- 31:30you get an envelope and you open it up and it's like magic. You
- 31:34knew what the envelope the card would say, but it's actually because he saw
- 31:38the previous card and now you see what this card is. It's an old
- 31:42magician's trick. You can look it up, called one ahead. And he
- 31:45was incensed and he said, you know, at that young age, how
- 31:48can these people be lying to their congregation. They're using a standard magic trick.
- 31:53And that sort of set him on the path later in life to exposing
- 31:59when magicians go off the rails and hoodwink and con and lie and cheat.
- 32:06Because he always said what he does was honest. He was an honest liar.
- 32:10He said, I'm going to fool you, I'm going to lie,
- 32:13and I'm going to do it. He never said I'm going to really bend
- 32:16the spoon using psychic power. So that's what Randy was all about. But
- 32:21he was amazing in one sense. He never stopped being a professional conjure.
- 32:25He had a big career as a conjurer, an escape artist like Houdini.
- 32:30But whenever he had three or four people around him in any situation to almost
- 32:35his death, he would break out the cards and just wow everybody and make
- 32:38things disappear, and it was quite extraordinary. He was a wonderful man,
- 32:44and as a friend, I miss my friend. But of course he was
- 32:47just an amazing guy. I had the honor of bumping into him at a
- 32:52skeptic's convention somewhere years ago, obviously, and there's no pretense. I've got
- 33:00a camera rig in the other room. I'm shameless. I walk up,
- 33:04mister Randy. You know James Shames. Please, I would love to sit
- 33:07you down on camera and just talk to you for fifteen minutes. I mean,
- 33:10I know everybody's pawing at you, and it's he's like, yeah,
- 33:14come on, let's go. We just immediately walked in and he sat down,
- 33:17and the guy was as freaking sharp as attack and talk about an Encyclopedia
- 33:23of Amazing Experiences. You ever meet him, Adrian, Do you ever get
- 33:27a chance to shake his hand? Or mostly? Do you know him by
- 33:30legendary reputation. I just know him by the legendary reputation. He was at
- 33:35the psychon I was at twenty eighteen. That was my very first psychon.
- 33:38I just started my training for a girl of Skepticism on Wikipedia. Believe it
- 33:44or not. I was quite shy and didn't really approach people very much,
- 33:49but I did admire from a distance, and he did talk in from his
- 33:53wheelchair and as you say, sharper than anything. The stories were mesmerized.
- 34:00So I hadn't the opportunity to see him live, but I've never met him.
- 34:04Well, you know, his book The Faith Healers was such a brave
- 34:07takedown. You know, I come from Tulsa, sort of the home of
- 34:10Oral Roberts, the traveling evangelist, the tent revivals, and he would go
- 34:15around and they would have people climb up on stage and they were miraculously quote
- 34:21unquote healed and they would throw their crutches and you know, as James Randy
- 34:24who helped to blow the lid off that and talk about how there were actors
- 34:29and how some of these people were handpicked, and then they would go home
- 34:31and die after they had thrown their medications away. So this stuff was never
- 34:36harmless. Now, some people were like, oh, gives them hope,
- 34:38right, Why would you ever criticize somebody who was giving them hope? And
- 34:43I'm like, well, first of all, I think he's selling hope at
- 34:45the end of an offering plate. But too many of these people believing they
- 34:47were healed. It was just what endorphins. Maybe they just were caught up
- 34:52in the moment, but then they go home and they're back in the same
- 34:54boat. Right yep? Wikipedia, and I had this in my notes.
- 35:00I don't want to forget it, Adrian. So there are editors for pages,
- 35:04there are people who submit information and then they source the information, and
- 35:07there are others who fact check the information. But isn't Wikipedia the wild West.
- 35:13One of the criticisms is it's insane over there, like you never know
- 35:16what you're going to get. It's how do you know it's reliable? Who
- 35:19watches the watchers kind of thing? Tell me about Wikipedia and reliability from your
- 35:24perspective, would you, Yeah, sure, I'll do the best I can
- 35:29I do believe there have been studies saying it has become as reliable as something
- 35:34like the Encyclopedia Britannica. I think if you find an old article from when
- 35:38it first started in the wild West that truly was the wild West of Wikipedia,
- 35:44it will be problematic, and if it survives, it's just because nobody's
- 35:47noticed it. There's a lot of articles on Wikipedia, and essentially the you
- 35:54have a sandbox, sir, I got to move this out of the way.
- 35:57I keep knocking to go ahead, move a stuff. That's all The
- 36:00sandbox is what we call our sandbox, where we do our initial work before
- 36:05we publish it, and then when we're ready to go, we publish it
- 36:07to the page and immediately in my instances, at least an admit there's somebody
- 36:15who has been around a long time, and these are all volunteers. We'll
- 36:19check it out, make sure it meets the criteria for reliable sources. And
- 36:22there is pages and pages of what a reliable source is and it's very fluid.
- 36:28So New York Times, for example, is considered a reliable source.
- 36:30However, there are certain articles in the New York Times that would not be
- 36:36considered reliable particularly moving forward because things change. Headlines change, science changes,
- 36:44and so if we've got something updated and new, you could say in the
- 36:47Wikipedia page, well that used to be what we thought, but now we
- 36:52know it's wrong. And so it's very fluid. Opinion pieces are not considered
- 36:57reliable sources, even from New York Times watch and can post, et cetera.
- 37:00So you have to be very careful. So, yeah, there's people
- 37:04other editors who watch, who know the rules. There's a lot of rules,
- 37:07and that's why if you watch to just go and start editing Wikipedia,
- 37:12you can easily get banned because if you keep editing, and even though you're
- 37:16trying to do your best, if you're not following the rules, you can
- 37:20get banned by the adminds who are kind of watching things. And so yeah,
- 37:25in the background, go to a talk page on some of the fringe
- 37:29issues and you'll see some heated arguments that are happening. But that's basically what
- 37:32it is. People put in an edit, somebody reviews it, and then
- 37:37they it either stays or it doesn't. So is it like wiki whack a
- 37:40mole? Is that what you're doing? Somebody posts something? So I do
- 37:45have all my pages I think I've got nine pages that I've done. All
- 37:49of them are on a watch list, and I get emailed if somebody changes
- 37:52that. What I'm amazed at, though, is I don't think I've ever
- 37:55had to revert myself. Somebody else always beats me to it. It's a
- 38:00bot. There's a lot of bots on Wikipedia, and they can suss out
- 38:04vandalism pretty easily. On my Haunted House page, for example, somebody posted
- 38:07something about chickens and chicken dinner. Well, obviously that has nothing to do
- 38:12with ghosts, and it was vetoed right away. But other things, like
- 38:15the woman who tried to change back the page to what it used to be
- 38:19for the Winchester Mystery House that was caught by somebody who's not GSoW. There's
- 38:23other people who are watching. Remember there's millions of editors, and don't forget
- 38:28too what I was talking about is creating or recreating a whole page. I
- 38:32do lots of little If I see a spelling mistake, I'll just go in
- 38:36and change it very quickly. Those kinds of things are appreciated and can be
- 38:39done by anybody. But if you really wanted to get into making a page,
- 38:44I highly recommend getting trained by Susan Gerbek. It's no, yeah,
- 38:50I have to go back to chicken and haunted page or Haunted house page.
- 38:53There is a haunted chicken story. I did it on the radio or on
- 38:57the podcast years ago. I think it was a a chicken that they took
- 39:00to the butcher's block and yet the headless chicken. I called it a poultry
- 39:06geist. Now it's a poultry geist and it's it's wandering the woods and people
- 39:10will see the headless chicken. I don't know. Yeah, so it was
- 39:17an historical case of a headless chicken that was towed around as a freak,
- 39:22as an attraction, and it lived it could you know. They were able
- 39:25to feed at sustenance, but it had most of its head missing. So
- 39:30I don't remember the details now, but my good friend in Australia, doctor
- 39:34Carl Kruzelnisky, who's Australia's version of Bill Nye, often talks about the headless
- 39:37chicken. So there's some truth behind that. It's so sad, Richard that
- 39:43I know the name. There's a website Mike the Headless Chicken, es Google
- 39:49Mike the Headless Chicken, and apparently this headless bird they fed with an eye
- 39:53dropper and it finally keeled over when a corn kernel got stuck as us I
- 40:00think you're right, Yeah, I'm sorry, Page, I don't know.
- 40:04We have to have Adrian go check that fact check the wiki page on it.
- 40:08So back in the James Randy Foundation days, the million dollar challenge was
- 40:15presented. Explain because I want to find out if there's any version of that
- 40:21or a hybrid of that going on today. Explain what the challenge was,
- 40:24if you would. Richard. Well, Randy and I was only talking about
- 40:29this with somebody the other day, and it was either nineteen sixty four or
- 40:34nineteen sixty five. I think it was sixty four. Randy was doing a
- 40:37radio show and a psychic or somebody said we'll put your money where your mouth
- 40:42is, and Randy did. He wrote a check on the spot and said,
- 40:45well, you know, if you can do your psychic ability, here's
- 40:47a thousand dollars. And that amount varied up and down according to Randy's fortunes
- 40:53and misfortunes financially. Eventually, with the James Randy Educational Foundation, it became
- 41:00a million dollars and it was a million dollars until Randy retired, and I
- 41:04was part of the committee in the later years at the Amazing meetings in Las
- 41:07Vegas, and we would test claimants for the million dollar prize and all they
- 41:13had to do was tell us what their claim was succinctly. So we understood
- 41:19we couldn't have anything too vague, like, oh, I can tell what's
- 41:22in people's heart sometimes or something of that. Now, tell us exactly what
- 41:25you can do. Tell us under what conditions are you happy to do it
- 41:30on stage? Would that worry you? Can you do it on Fridays?
- 41:32That sort of thing. And we'd also need to know what success rate can
- 41:38we or can you expect? You know, it's no good saying I've got
- 41:43this amazing ability. I can predict the toss of a coin fifty percent of
- 41:46the time, you know. So they had to tell us exactly all those
- 41:50things, and then we would sit down and devise a test, a test
- 41:54they would pass if they had the ability that they claimed to have. And
- 41:59I think I was involved in six presentations in Las Vegas where we tested people,
- 42:06and they're all documented. You can see the videos of them. Needless
- 42:08to say, nobody ever passed the passing mark and the money was retained by
- 42:15the foundation. But the money, there's money. In Australia, there's one
- 42:19hundred thousand dollars and that's been on offer for four decades. I think in
- 42:23California the IG I think have half a million dollars, a lot of money
- 42:29and various skeptical groups around the world. It serves two purposes. One is,
- 42:35if somebody has a psychic power or something which completely defies the laws of
- 42:39physics, then we would be happy to hand over the check because it would
- 42:45be major news. If this person, whoever it is, could do this
- 42:50from water, divining too, talking to the dead, a million dollars would
- 42:53be peanuts. It would be nothing. The second point to it is that
- 42:58it enables us in Australia, for example, well to say to somebody we
- 43:00think is not quite legitimate, to say, well, we have one hundred
- 43:05thousand dollars, can you prove your claim? And if they run and hide,
- 43:08then that's good publicity for us to say, well, look why did
- 43:12they run and hide? You know, here's the money. Why didn't they
- 43:14take our money? So that's the reason for the cash prizes around the world.
- 43:17Yeah, but Richard I mean, if you've been involved in six or
- 43:21seven when it didn't work out, what did they say, I'm trying to
- 43:24move stuff with my mind or I'm trying to predict the future. Oh that
- 43:28didn't work out? What did they say as an excuse or reason? The
- 43:32ones I remember just off the top of my head were the skeptics were cheating,
- 43:37which is a It's an interesting psychological point of view because if you think,
- 43:43and we suspect the people who came to be tested, they really thought
- 43:45in their hearts, they really thought they had these magic powers. So when
- 43:50they were tested they failed, they need to find an excuse. They can't
- 43:54just let it. Oh I failed, Oh well there you go. I
- 43:58can't do it. No, they looked for an excuse, and the easiest
- 44:01excuse is the tests were rigged against them. So that's what some of them
- 44:07said. And I can understand that. I mean, if I was tested
- 44:12on my ability to to you know, I do o regami. I do
- 44:15lots of paper folding. I've written books about it. Say somebody said to
- 44:20me, Richard, come along, here's one hundred thousand dollars. All you
- 44:22have to do is fold a little bird for us. I think these people
- 44:25are crazy. It's three hundred thousand dollars for me and I turn up in
- 44:30suddenly the paper melts, or I can't remember what to do, or something
- 44:35crazy happens. I would be looking to blame the organizers. Well, that's
- 44:38the same sort of thing that's going on in the heads of the people who
- 44:42really think they can divine for water or they have some sort of magical power,
- 44:46partly because they never test themselves, they just assume they can do this.
- 44:53It's all boils down to psychology. It's really interesting to at Okay,
- 45:00how do we protect ourselves against all the junk and the bunk out there?
- 45:04I'm going to ask my expert guests next. Thank you so much for listening
- 45:15here in the new year, don't forget to subscribe to my second podcast,
- 45:20Five Minute Vignettes, True Stories with Seth Andrews, three times a week.
- 45:24You never know what you're going to get. True crime, celebrity trivia,
- 45:29weird news, fascinating history. True Stories with Seth Andrews. Continuing now with
- 45:37my special guests skeptics Adrian Hill and Richard Saunders, Let's talk a little bit
- 45:45about how we can I don't know, bunk proof our lives Adrian is I'm
- 45:51in this increasingly crazy world, the world of I don't know, conspiracy,
- 45:54but beyond that, the deep fake and the AI stuff and the misinformation,
- 46:00and how in the world can I I don't know. Pre bunk is the
- 46:04word. Give me some skills, give me some tools. Oh, skills,
- 46:08that's a big one. Well, I'm going to go to my easy
- 46:12one, which is look at Wikipedia, because generally speaking, it's pretty well
- 46:15done. And the other thing that I've been asked about when you're talking to
- 46:21somebody who has crazy ideas that don't agree with yours, it's, you know,
- 46:25if you want to maintain the conversation. I quite often get asked,
- 46:30well, what how do you tell if a source is a good one or
- 46:31not? And that's something I have to do as a Wikipedia editor, So
- 46:36I usually use media check media Oh my goodness, what's it called media bias
- 46:43fact check? There I go media bias fact check And it's a wonderful website
- 46:46because it waits it not only for the political view left or right, but
- 46:51also accurately. So if it does well with accuracy and it's on the right
- 46:54or left, it will get a fairly good rating. But if they start
- 46:58using a lot of adjective, I guess it's a good way to say it.
- 47:00Inflammatory language on either of the extreme left or right. It will tell
- 47:05you that as well. So it's a good starting point to know if the
- 47:07source you're actually using is something that maybe you can listen to also. I
- 47:14mean, I like Science Based Medicine, Skeptical Inquirer the Skeptic from Australia.
- 47:19Listen to some good podcasts that would be good. We lost doctor Harriet Hall,
- 47:24the skeptic over at Science Based Medicine. I was sad to hear that
- 47:29she had passed away a while back. And she was always you know,
- 47:32I know she went hard at things like Cairo practic and boy that was a
- 47:37that was a blow up, wasn't it. I mean, of all the
- 47:39things to go after, you know, she was pretty pretty fearless. By
- 47:44the way, before I asked Richard sort of his resources, I know that
- 47:46US has its own sort of flavor of ghost stories, superstitions, et cetera.
- 47:52Are there things really specific indigenous to Australia? Do you have your own
- 47:58type of lore down there? Yes? But you know what, generally speaking,
- 48:02it's pretty much the same sort of thing you're going to get everywhere.
- 48:07Ghosts of ancestors, people disappearing, mysteriously strange, monsters lurking in the water.
- 48:15You know, humans are humans. These and we get back to the
- 48:17storytelling. These are stories being told. Water divining water dowsing is popular in
- 48:22Australia, but it's a worldwide thing. You can find water which is anywhere.
- 48:29It's thousands of years old. So you know, we're all one race.
- 48:34We're on one human race. You know, we're all the same animal.
- 48:37Our brains work more or less the same way. So it's not surprising
- 48:40that you see the same themes repeated again and again around the world, with
- 48:45maybe a bit of cultural flavor. All right, well as you are,
- 48:50but I have to sorry. I keep saying we're almost done, and then
- 48:52I have another question. But this is how my mind works. I'm like
- 48:55a child easily distracted by flashy shining things oregami or where did that start?
- 49:02I mean, I don't even know what the where the word oragami comes from.
- 49:06So what what's going on, Richard? What's going on? It's paper
- 49:09folding, It's making animals and shapes and wonderful things out of paper. Just
- 49:15sitting down and folding. I've been doing it for fifty years. This is
- 49:17my fiftieth year. My parents bought me a really big, lovely book when
- 49:22I was eight years old, just to date. And kids do it.
- 49:24A lot of kids like oregami. They'll make one or two things and forget
- 49:28about it. I kept it going. It was I thought it was a
- 49:30wonderful art form. I ended up writing twenty plus books. I can't remember.
- 49:35They're all last century. How do you write a book about folded paper?
- 49:40Like I know what origami is, but I don't know anything about it
- 49:45is there's enough there, like the history and techniques. What you do is
- 49:50you invent new oragami models and you write instructions and if people bought the book
- 49:57or later on I did a DVD and they want to look, Oh,
- 50:00how do I make a kangaroo? How do I make a koala? How
- 50:02do I make a shark? Or a flapping bird? You buy the book
- 50:06and you say, ah, step one, do this, step two,
- 50:07do that. And just in the last few weeks I invented an owl for
- 50:14Brian Dunning for the Skeptoid Media Company, and I've just completed and Adrian has
- 50:19been my beta tester, one of my beta testers. I've just written all
- 50:22the instructions and soon that's going to be published and people can download their own
- 50:27instructions and make their own little owl. Adrian. I mean, he's a
- 50:30man of many gifts. He just can't put him in a box. He's
- 50:34just so filled with creativity and surprises. Let's debunk some study, help bunk
- 50:40proof our audience, Richard, do you have any resources you like, any
- 50:45masts? Well, you mentioned one of them, The Faith Healers. People
- 50:49read The Faith Healers. It's really it makes you angry. It's a good
- 50:52book. Another good book about skeptical investigation is another James Randy book called The
- 50:58Mask of Nostrodamers, because he went to France and he did his research and
- 51:02he really studied the methods of Nostradamus and what nostrod armist did. I read
- 51:07those books earlier on in my skeptical career and they taught me a lot.
- 51:12But luckily for us, all you have to do is google. One documentary
- 51:15I would recommend it's called The Secrets of the Psychics. If you put that
- 51:22in the Secrets of the Psychics plus James Randy, there is a it's an
- 51:27hour ninety minute documentary Randy made all about investigating the paranormal and how he goes
- 51:34about it and lots of cases where he did it. It's a wonderful primer
- 51:37on skepticism. Reminds me a little bit of the work of Darren Brown,
- 51:42a big popular illusionist in and de Bunker. And you know, he actually
- 51:45brought somebody over to the United States and faked him as a as a faith
- 51:52healer before he finally exposed and te he actually did what Randy did. He
- 51:55said, I've been lying to you. You know this is a setup,
- 52:00But understand the mechanisms of why, perhaps why you have bought into this.
- 52:05Richard. You're an amazing storyteller. Adrian, I have a hard time believing
- 52:07you were ever shy. Is that I just don't buy that. You are
- 52:12just bubbling with charisma. So somebody report cards It says she's quiet and sits
- 52:17at the back of the classroom. I don't know what happens now. So
- 52:21the bodies were switched. The aliens came and they replaced Adrian with another.
- 52:25Both of you are amazing. I'm going to put a bunch of links for
- 52:28some of the stuff we've talked about in the description box. We will continue
- 52:31to follow your work at Skeptical, Inquire and Beyond, but just love you
- 52:37both and be safe. Happy New Year, and thanks for talking to me.
- 52:40Thank you, Seth. Let's follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter
- 52:45for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts
- 52:50featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 52:55on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our webs site, The
- 53:00Thinkingatheist dot com.