Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Onramp Webinar Series E005: Bitcoin is the Ultimate Savings Technology
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Onramp webinar series.
- 0:02In this edition of the show, we tackle the concept of Bitcoin as
- 0:06a revolutionary savings technology which addresses the
- 0:09shortcomings of traditional currencies and other saving
- 0:11methods. Our speakers on this edition of
- 0:14the show include Jesse Myers, Onramp's Co founder and Bram
- 0:18Constein, Onramp's head of growth.
- 0:20They discuss the problem at hand in terms of Fiat debasement and
- 0:24the solution that is Bitcoin. The speakers discussed the
- 0:27inherent problems with Fiat money, the mechanics of Bitcoin
- 0:30supply and demand, and its potential valuation in the
- 0:33global asset landscape. They emphasize the importance of
- 0:36understanding Bitcoin's properties and the long term
- 0:38outlook for its adoption as a store of value, as well as the
- 0:41migration of capital from other asset classes into Bitcoin.
- 0:45To stay up to date with everything that On Ramp produces
- 0:48in terms of education and research, please be sure to sign
- 0:51up for the On Ramp Research and Insights newsletter, which can
- 0:54be found on our homepage at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 0:57And if you'd like to learn more about our products or services
- 1:00and our approach to Bitcoin custody, please reach out to
- 1:03schedule a consultation with our team.
- 1:05Now time for the show. Without further ado, I will kick
- 1:08it over to Bram first to elaborate a bit more on the
- 1:12problem at hand and why we think that coin is an important part
- 1:16of the solution. Yeah.
- 1:19Thanks, Brian, and welcome everyone.
- 1:21I think or we think it's good to start with the problem, right?
- 1:27Like we can think of a solution, but if we don't have a clear
- 1:30picture of the problem beforehand, then we also think
- 1:34that the solution that we obviously think is Bitcoin will
- 1:38land a bit a bit less. So yeah, what is the problem?
- 1:41I think Brian already mentioned it.
- 1:43You know, like if we think about saving, you know, why, why do we
- 1:47actually save? What is the purpose of of
- 1:49saving? And I think the the discussions
- 1:53that that we have here kind of revolves around certainty and
- 1:57uncertainty, right? So for everyone, the future is
- 2:00uncertain. We literally do not know how
- 2:02much time we have. And so within the limited or
- 2:06finite time that we all have in our lives, we expend energy
- 2:10either every day or every week, every month, which is basically
- 2:14our productivity for which we get rewarded.
- 2:17But the reward that we use, which represents, you know, in
- 2:20an abstract way, are our productivity or that energy and
- 2:24time, which we call Fiat money, is kind of corrupted in a sense,
- 2:29right? Because we can create that
- 2:32money, that money can be created infinitely.
- 2:34So we basically trade our most finite asset of our time and our
- 2:38energy and time for a reward that can infinitely be created.
- 2:42Now that doesn't really sound like a good trade, but we all
- 2:46basically do it. But what is the what is the
- 2:48effect of that? Well, because we all don't
- 2:52really know how much time we have in our lives, you know,
- 2:55like they, we all have some sort of anxiety or insecurity about
- 3:00the future. There is a level of how do you
- 3:04say that like risk towards the future because we don't know how
- 3:08much time we have. So the uncertainty that that we
- 3:11have, we basically want to mitigate that.
- 3:13And we were able in the past or our parents or our grandparents
- 3:17were able in the past to just gather more units of a currency,
- 3:22which we call saving, right, to kind of lower that uncertainty
- 3:26towards the future. So they could build some capital
- 3:28to eventually spend that on, you know, whatever they wanted to
- 3:31spend it on in their life, whether it was starting a family
- 3:34or buying a house or moving somewhere or, you know, whatever
- 3:37they wanted to to spend it on. But we can still, you know,
- 3:41gather more units of the currency that's used in in your
- 3:46country. But because of the monetary
- 3:48debasement, each unit is devalued over time, which
- 3:53actually increases the uncertainty towards your future.
- 3:56So that is basically the problem that kind of our TS is also
- 4:01around Bitcoin revolves around because we think and and Jesse
- 4:05will elaborate on that, that Bitcoin is the ultimate savings
- 4:08technology. Bitcoin is kept in supply.
- 4:11As Brian said, that is also the entire point of Bitcoin is that
- 4:15it's monetary rules that are captured in in the computer code
- 4:20basically are continuously checked every 10 minutes.
- 4:25We check the entire Ledger, we check if the code is still
- 4:29running and we say, OK, this, this can still go on, which
- 4:32basically the output of Bitcoin is certainty, the certainty that
- 4:36it stays the same as long as it's protocol is running.
- 4:41And So what we believe is that if you use Bitcoin as the
- 4:45savings technology, so basically, you can choose to get
- 4:49rewarded in Bitcoin for, you know, spending your energy and
- 4:52time, or you can turn the Fiat money that you get as a reward
- 4:55into Bitcoin and help you yourself and your family and
- 5:00your progeny to lower the uncertainty towards the future,
- 5:04which will actually eventually give you the time and space to
- 5:08build by whatever you want. So whatever that is, whether
- 5:12that's a family or a home, etcetera.
- 5:14So we see Bitcoin as a superior savings technology, which
- 5:17eventually helps anyone who adopts it lower the uncertainty
- 5:21towards their future, which frees up the space and time to
- 5:24build out their life basically. Yeah, I think that's a short
- 5:27intro. I'm not sure if Jesse has
- 5:29anything to add. No, yeah, that that's, that's
- 5:33the right frame framework to think about what we're going to
- 5:37talk about here, you know, because, because what and we we
- 5:39say the ultimate savings technology, what is savings
- 5:43really? It's, it's propagating your
- 5:45value today into the future so that you can use it at a future
- 5:50date. And doing that in a, in a way,
- 5:55in a manner that has high certainty that it will propagate
- 5:59safely through time is paramount.
- 6:02And, and because of the properties of Bitcoin, we
- 6:05believe that it not only does it in a higher certainty way than
- 6:09any other asset out there, but because of its properties, it
- 6:12has a more attractive uplift to the purchasing power of that
- 6:16savings over time as well. And so we can.
- 6:19So I guess that's a good, good place to tee up the slides that
- 6:24we will be getting into here at On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin
- 6:28is the most important asset of the 21st century.
- 6:32The hard part is securing it, right?
- 6:34There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 6:36exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 6:39arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 6:42concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 6:44solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 6:48ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 6:51possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 6:55your family is protected as well.
- 6:57On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 7:00whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 7:03to your existing self custody setup.
- 7:06For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 7:10Maybe before Jesse starts, I I had to think of one of the
- 7:14insights that really helped me in my journey is and it ties
- 7:18into what you said, Jesse. So if you want to save towards
- 7:20the future and eventually spend that basically monetary energy
- 7:23on something else, once I realized that everything that
- 7:27you know, we have. So if you're sitting behind your
- 7:28screen right now and you look around wherever you are, like
- 7:31everything you see costs energy to create or maintain.
- 7:35And so if you eventually see money as a reward for your
- 7:39energy, but also as like an like a tool to eventually spend on
- 7:44energy again in the future, as as everything is uses energy to,
- 7:49to be created or be maintained and realizing that Fiat money as
- 7:55a tool to do that basically loses energy every year.
- 7:59And that is, I think again, the core of the problem.
- 8:04But also as Jesse will show the magic of Bitcoin in the sense
- 8:09that it cannot leak that energy over time, actually more people
- 8:13will store more energy into Bitcoin as a, as a tool for
- 8:18that. So I think that's what what that
- 8:20Jesse's going to show. Yeah.
- 8:22And and Jesse, before, before you jump into the to the slides,
- 8:25just wanted to mention to the audience, if you have any
- 8:28questions during the presentation about, you know,
- 8:31things we're talking about or anything else related to
- 8:33Bitcoin, please submit them in the Q&A chat and we will get to
- 8:37as many of them as possible. Yeah, our our goal here is the
- 8:40back half of this will be a conversation based on your
- 8:44questions and and hot topics. So please submit those.
- 8:49OK. So, so sort of two topics here
- 8:53that we'll we'll dig into is Bitcoin's full potential
- 8:55evaluation and and that's this report that I that I put
- 8:59together most two years ago now. And then and then as part of
- 9:06that. And then these are kind of
- 9:07interconnected, the savings technology mechanics of Bitcoin
- 9:12and how those go hand in hand with Bitcoin, Bitcoin's full
- 9:15potential evaluation and where this, this thing is headed.
- 9:19So as of now, Bitcoin has been the best performing asset of the
- 9:26last 15 years. And so it feels like you missed
- 9:31it, right? It's, it's over, it's done,
- 9:33it's, it's already become what it's going to become.
- 9:37And it, it feels like there's no opportunity left with Bitcoin.
- 9:43But all of this performance and, and you know, Bitcoin being the
- 9:47best performing asset most years has gotten us to here.
- 9:52So Bitcoin is still only 0.2% of the world's assets.
- 9:57It's now a $2 trillion asset class.
- 10:01And and that is in this $900 trillion global asset ocean.
- 10:06So it's still a very small bucket here.
- 10:10And this was kind of the important jumping off point for
- 10:13figuring out what is bitcoins full potential valuation.
- 10:16You know, how big how, how much of the, the pie, how much of
- 10:21this picture can Bitcoin eventually eat?
- 10:24And that's kind of the, the starting question for that line
- 10:28of inquiry. And this the, the full details
- 10:32of the analysis and methodology are available on on ramps
- 10:37website. And that link points you to
- 10:42where it can be downloaded. Brian, if you could actually add
- 10:44that to the chat, maybe that would be helpful for everyone.
- 10:49So the, the core of of this analysis is that you know, at
- 10:55all these, all those different buckets that that we saw on
- 10:58that, on that graphic, they're all value, they're all value
- 11:03stored in different assets in the world and because of
- 11:08bitcoins properties. And that's what we'll dig into
- 11:10in the second-half here, I believe.
- 11:13And we believe that value will migrate, will be siphoned off,
- 11:19will osmotically flow from those buckets to Bitcoin because it it
- 11:26has more attractive properties as a store of value asset and as
- 11:31an investment asset than any of the other buckets out there.
- 11:36And so I went through the exercise of of in my opinion,
- 11:40somewhat conservatively assessing all right, of the
- 11:44capital sitting in the buckets that were outlined in in that
- 11:48overview of global asset value. What percentage of the capital
- 11:52stored in those buckets might be interested in shifting from that
- 11:57bucket that it's currently in to Bitcoin because of its superior
- 12:02properties? As the individuals and companies
- 12:06who hold those assets learn about Bitcoin because the
- 12:10reality of it is that 99.9% of the world doesn't understand
- 12:14anything more than the very surface level of Bitcoin.
- 12:18And it takes some some learning and, and some time to understand
- 12:23the properties underneath that are very compelling and make it,
- 12:27in my opinion, the most attractive asset in the world to
- 12:30hold. And so going through that
- 12:33exercise personally, I kind of put out some rather conservative
- 12:37numbers in my view about what percent of their capital in
- 12:41those buckets would would flow towards Bitcoin.
- 12:44And you can see my, my Bitcoin capture numbers here.
- 12:48And I, and when I summed all those up, came out to $200
- 12:52trillion of the $900 trillion of, of value in today's dollars.
- 12:57And that would mean $10 million per Bitcoin in today's dollars,
- 13:02which would be 100 X in real terms from today.
- 13:08And so I think that for me, that's the, the quick summary of
- 13:10the report of that's what I think is bitcoins full potential
- 13:13evaluation. And this, this framework was
- 13:22also adopted by, by Michael Saylor.
- 13:25So he, he found this approach to, you know, establishing what
- 13:31Bitcoin could become in the global asset landscape
- 13:34compelling. And he used in, in my report, I,
- 13:39I recommended running your own analysis, you know, using this
- 13:44sort of framework and deciding for yourself what percentage of
- 13:48those different buckets Bitcoin could capture.
- 13:51And so in the in the bottom left, that that is Michael
- 13:53Saylor's version of what he thinks Bitcoin can do.
- 13:58And based on his numbers, he came out one important
- 14:04difference is he includes inflation in his numbers,
- 14:09whereas I did everything in today's dollars.
- 14:13So you can see in the in the bottom right, his global asset
- 14:16value landscape grows for X over the next 20 years because of
- 14:21that inflation. But his numbers come come out to
- 14:25his base case is a $13 million per Bitcoin valuation in 21
- 14:31years should be 140 X from today.
- 14:37And so, so I guess my what one point to make is I recommend you
- 14:44take a look at that report and think through it for yourself.
- 14:49And like this table in the bottom left, come up with your
- 14:52version of what percentage of value sitting in the existing
- 14:57buckets might migrate to Bitcoin in order to come up with your
- 15:01full potential valuation. It's not to say that that is
- 15:04what Bitcoin will do, but what's the scale of what this, what
- 15:07digital capital could be in a world of $900 trillion of analog
- 15:12physical capital. So that's the that's my numbers
- 15:18on what Bitcoin can become. And now it's that that doesn't
- 15:25really make sense out of the context of the mechanics of
- 15:29Bitcoin and how it has gotten to where it is today and why I
- 15:34believe it will continue to attract capital from other
- 15:37buckets. And, and the answer to the
- 15:41answer to, to those questions, to those topics is bitcoins,
- 15:45savings, technology, mechanics. So it's worth, we'll breeze
- 15:50through this, but it's worth understanding what it is about
- 15:54Bitcoin that makes capital drawn to it and why that will likely
- 15:59continue into the future. So for me, everything that's
- 16:04special about Bitcoin as a store value asset comes back to its
- 16:08supply expression, supply function.
- 16:11How do you go from zero Bitcoin in existence on day one to
- 16:14eventually at 21 million Bitcoin hard cap in the future?
- 16:20And that supply expression is here on the left.
- 16:23This is how this is, you know, bitcoin's entire monetary
- 16:26policy. And what it comes down to is
- 16:29this concept of increasing scarcity of new supply issuance.
- 16:35And that's the table that we see on the right here of the block
- 16:39subsidy per four year era. And that's what this expression
- 16:45shows on the left. Every four years, the amount of
- 16:47new Bitcoin issued per block gets cut in half.
- 16:52And, and that's very special and, and hasn't, was never
- 16:55possible in the traditional asset landscape because you
- 16:58can't do that with commodities. You can't say we're going to
- 17:01decrease the amount of gold produced from mining every year.
- 17:06It's it's just not possible. But it's possible in the digital
- 17:10landscape where you can establish these rules and and
- 17:12have a, a supply issuance schedule that's set in stone.
- 17:17And this is it. This is what it looks like in
- 17:19the Bitcoin protocol. This is that supply expression
- 17:24manifested as as code and by using the Bitcoin protocol, you
- 17:29are agreeing to this supply schedule and and you know, all
- 17:36it takes for it to be enacted is new blocks being found.
- 17:41And that's the entire incentive structure of of Bitcoin mining.
- 17:45So and that's how Bitcoin works. So the blocks will be mined and
- 17:49then halvings will be triggered and then new supply issuance
- 17:52will decrease over time. And that's what this chart
- 17:56shows. This is where we are currently
- 17:59in the in the supply issuance of Bitcoin.
- 18:04We just had the 2024 halving about 8 months ago now and we
- 18:10are the existing supply of Bitcoin is this asymptotic line
- 18:15going up into the right which is approaching that flat line of 21
- 18:19million will only ever be 21 million Bitcoin.
- 18:22And the gold bars here show the the Bitcoin released per block.
- 18:29So the newly issued Bitcoin per block starting at 50 Bitcoin per
- 18:33block and you can see that exponential decrypt decay down
- 18:37to 0 eventually over time. So this is you know, bitcoins
- 18:42supply issuance is increasing scarcity of new supply issuance
- 18:46terminating in absolute scarcity.
- 18:49There will never be more Bitcoin created beyond 21 million.
- 18:54And this moment in time is, is pretty special too because this
- 18:58having means that we have dipped below gold's annual supply
- 19:04growth historical average of 1.5 percent per year.
- 19:10And so now we are down. Now we now Bitcoin is a harder
- 19:15asset to make more of than gold, And that, in my view, lends it
- 19:22to being a better store value asset that should attract more
- 19:26capital over time to park in that store value asset because
- 19:30it has this this smaller dilution per year effect.
- 19:39So to take a step back a little bit and kind of take this to the
- 19:43abstract, I think this is a helpful way of thinking about
- 19:46how Bitcoin supply issuance schedule is special.
- 19:51So this is your your classic Marshall Cross, your econ one O
- 19:551 stuff where supply this is your supply curve and your
- 19:59demand curve and prices set where they meet.
- 20:03But Bitcoin is different. Bitcoin has a completely
- 20:07inelastic supply curve, meaning that no matter how much people
- 20:14want Bitcoin, Bitcoin is pre programmed to release the set
- 20:19amount of it every four years based on the supply issuance per
- 20:25block and that and that table progressing through time.
- 20:31So so you know, in theory here supply and demand meet at at
- 20:35that price point, but then the next having comes along and half
- 20:39as much supply as being issued per block.
- 20:43And you can see how that change in the supply issuance amounts
- 20:50to the intersection of supply and demand now going up on the Y
- 20:56axis, which is price and that process continues.
- 21:01So the next having reduces supply issuance again.
- 21:04And you can see how that might impact where price between is,
- 21:11is, is set because of where supply and demand meet.
- 21:17A different lens of the same idea here is this is where we
- 21:21were at right before the having based on the market price of of
- 21:28Bitcoin at the halving and, and the price had been going
- 21:34sideways for a few months before that.
- 21:38We had been mining $1.8 billion of new Bitcoin every month in
- 21:44the 30 days before the halving and because the price had been
- 21:50going sideways. There's a lot of noise here.
- 21:52There's a lot of external variables, but in theory there
- 21:58had to have been $1.8 billion of net inflowing demand for the
- 22:03price of Bitcoin to be going sideways at that point in time.
- 22:06It had to absorb the new supply issuance, and that's what was
- 22:08happening. Then the having comes along and
- 22:12suddenly half as much new supplies being created per
- 22:15month, dropping that down to $900 million at at the prices at
- 22:20the time of of the having. But ostensibly there's still
- 22:24$1.8 billion of demand flowing into the market every month
- 22:28because that, you know, that wouldn't change.
- 22:32Of course it does because of noise.
- 22:34But on average, you would expect the same sort of net interest in
- 22:38Bitcoin and accumulation of Bitcoin to be occurring.
- 22:42So this is what happened. This, this is what they're
- 22:46having triggered, which is a $900 million shortage per month
- 22:51and overtime that accumulates. So a quick walkthrough of of
- 22:55those mechanics is this is in in my mental model of how the
- 23:01halving plays out over time to generate a a post having bull
- 23:04market. So the prior slide that we saw
- 23:08was, you know, the left half of it was the orange square here
- 23:13and the Blue Square being in balance for a month and price
- 23:18goes sideways. Then the halving occurs.
- 23:21Now there's half as much new supply being created, but just
- 23:24as much demand. And the key here is this
- 23:27available for sale portion, because the the full circle
- 23:33below is the the full circulating supply of Bitcoin,
- 23:37but not all Bitcoin is available for sale at any given time.
- 23:40In fact, it seems to be a much smaller portion, something like
- 23:435% based on that's that's my assumption based on how much
- 23:47Bitcoin moves in in an average month.
- 23:52And so that that available for sale sets the price in the
- 23:56marketplace because that, you know, the marginal sale of
- 24:03Bitcoin is the price for for all Bitcoin and you and we'll see
- 24:07how the accumulation of the supply shortage impacts the
- 24:11available for sale bucket and how that impacts price.
- 24:15So the having happens, nothing feels different.
- 24:18That supply shortage starts to accumulate and you can see here
- 24:22three months, three months worth of bites out of the available
- 24:26for sale supply. And after six months of this
- 24:33price starts to drift upwards. Suddenly there's a big chunk
- 24:36taken out of available for sale supply.
- 24:39Buyers need to raise their bids in order to find supply because
- 24:44the low hanging fruit has been eaten through here.
- 24:48That process of the price starting to drift upwards does
- 24:51an interesting thing with Bitcoin where people get excited
- 24:54and now there's more demand coming into Bitcoin because
- 24:58market participants and especially people who've been
- 25:00sitting on the sidelines see the price of Bitcoin rising and they
- 25:03want in. So now demand increases in the
- 25:06imbalance between new supply issuance and inflow and demand
- 25:12increases. And now you're starting to eat
- 25:14through chunks of available for sale supplied at a greater clip.
- 25:18Granted, you're also inspiring holders, long term holders to
- 25:21start selling as well. But this process keeps playing
- 25:25out. And you know, 12 months after
- 25:27the halving, you have a real shortage and demand has net
- 25:32inflowing. Demand has continued to grow and
- 25:35now you're starting to look at the conditions of mania.
- 25:38So, so this process naturally fly flywheels.
- 25:43What starts out as a very small supply shortage per day over 12
- 25:49months has flywheeled into a, into a, a mania where there's
- 25:54more and more demand coming in and the price starts to run and
- 25:59that causes a bubble. And so the mania flywheels into
- 26:05a bubble and that bubble pops. But on the back end of that, the
- 26:12on the back end of the of that bubble, the changes that the
- 26:16halving had created are not undone.
- 26:21So the the new supply issuance each day that the halving
- 26:28triggers is is permanent and compounding.
- 26:31And so you don't undo the conditions that created that
- 26:35bubble, the halving and that new supply issuance level.
- 26:40So you can find the equilibrium where, you know, you you
- 26:43overextend in in the run up of that bubble that that mania
- 26:47causes you to overextend. What is equilibrium for that era
- 26:52of new supply issuance? And then the crash causes the,
- 26:56you know, the opposite effect of it goes below where it probably
- 26:59should be based, you know, based on supply demand price
- 27:02equilibrium. And then it's, it spends the
- 27:04next couple years finding equilibrium just in time for the
- 27:07next having to set the process in motion again.
- 27:12So this phenomenon, this is my, my sort of mental model of how
- 27:17Bitcoin's price moves over time when shown on a log graph.
- 27:21And this takes out, obviously takes out all the noise and
- 27:25ignores the numbers on the axis just to show the mechanics of
- 27:29how I think this thing plays out over time.
- 27:33But this up into the right trend of purchasing power amounts to a
- 27:38savings technology. And that's what's really special
- 27:40about Bitcoin. If you put value into Bitcoin
- 27:44today and you hold for more than four years, you will grow that
- 27:49purchasing power because of this of these mechanics playing out
- 27:55over time and adoption of this asset because of those mechanics
- 28:01also helping to to lift the purchasing power of the the
- 28:06Bitcoin that you hold today for four plus years.
- 28:10And so then the question becomes if, if Bitcoin's mechanics cause
- 28:15it to be a savings technology, how much of the world's value
- 28:20sitting in this $900 trillion global asset ocean will be
- 28:24interested in migrating from these assets like bonds or real
- 28:30estate or any of them into Bitcoin as individuals and
- 28:36companies and state, nation states learn about the
- 28:40properties of Bitcoin as a savings technology.
- 28:45So that's, that's where I wanted to, to leave that conversation.
- 28:49And we can, I can, I guess I got first of all, open up to Brahm
- 28:54for any additional thoughts or commentary there.
- 28:57And then we can get into Q&A. Yeah, yeah.
- 29:00So I think what's good to add is that, you know, sometimes it
- 29:04might sound like people see Bitcoin as an investment, right?
- 29:08You could perhaps even draw that conclusion from what Jesse just
- 29:12shared. But I think it's better to see
- 29:15it as moving your economic energy that we talked about in
- 29:19the beginning, basically to a different monetary system.
- 29:23That's also why we call it the savings technology, right?
- 29:26We focus on the long term preservation of the purchasing
- 29:31power that we acquire right now with again, you know, the
- 29:35productivity that we expend in in any amount of time.
- 29:38So that's also, I think part of understanding Bitcoin is, you
- 29:44know, from the paradigm that that we live in, it might be
- 29:49quick and dirty to look at it as an investment, but over the
- 29:52longer time, yeah, we see it as a totally different monetary
- 29:56system and a better savings technology.
- 29:58As we mentioned. I think maybe, Jesse, if you can
- 30:01show the slide of the, the few, the future slide of this one
- 30:05with the blocks, because I think 1, you know, one thing to add
- 30:11there, which is important is that, you know, sometimes when
- 30:16people talk about Bitcoin, it's like all the dollar is going to
- 30:18fail or all the field money's going to fail, etcetera.
- 30:21I think what this example greatly shows, let's say the
- 30:26bottom right one of, of sailor is that it's more about this.
- 30:30Jesse also alluded to it's kind of moving around and kind of
- 30:34like getting store value dollars basically that have now been put
- 30:41into real estate or art or collectibles, whatever, moving
- 30:45to, to Bitcoin. So even when we get to, you
- 30:49know, the base case of sailor in the middle, I think it's a honey
- 30:52badger, right? The 13 million per Bitcoin, that
- 30:56doesn't mean the world breaks or the, the, the legacy financial
- 31:00system breaks. I, I, I think that's a, a good
- 31:03point to further iterate and, and this is a great
- 31:07illustration. I think that that shows that.
- 31:10So in order for Bitcoin to succeed as a superior savings
- 31:13technology, that does not mean that all, all the Fiat money
- 31:17dies or, or are we going to some terrible chaos or, or something
- 31:20like that. So currently, you know, some
- 31:24people will trade it. They do see it as an in, as an
- 31:27investment. I think we are proponents of a a
- 31:32buy and hold strategy with a long enough time time horizon
- 31:37and you know, like these boom bust cycles that that Jesse
- 31:40showed is basically human psychology.
- 31:42I don't know. We, we do not have what the
- 31:45so-called hollow waves in this presentation.
- 31:47But I think just from the top of my head, probably like 60 plus
- 31:52percent of all the Bitcoin in circulation has not moved in in
- 31:55three years. I think I can say that, but
- 31:57Jesse, correct me if I'm wrong, but like so the people that that
- 32:00hold this, they understand what this is and they have a long
- 32:03term outlook. And so the Bitcoin that's
- 32:05actually actively traded, that's actively leveraged with, you
- 32:10know, sometimes we see these flushes or you know, shoots up
- 32:13or down, that's actually not a lot of Bitcoin that's involved
- 32:18there. So that trading market is
- 32:20smaller than the amount of Bitcoin that's being held by by
- 32:23long term holders. And I think we also see, but I'd
- 32:29love to get your thoughts on that, Jesse, that, you know, the
- 32:31possibility that the that the time of of -80% draw downs could
- 32:35be behind us as more and more capital finds its way into
- 32:39Bitcoin also with this longer term outlook.
- 32:43And so that means, you know, once this asset class grows,
- 32:47more capital is also needed to go either either go up or down.
- 32:52And so, you know, I personally think that that these bigger
- 32:56draw downs are behind us. But again, you know, that's just
- 32:59human psychology of, of, you know, plus understanding of
- 33:02people that, you know, do gamble with it in terms of leverage
- 33:06and, and, and stuff like that. Last point, as we see in in
- 33:12these blocks, right, we really talk about store of value in
- 33:16original white paper of Bitcoin. You know, it's, it's, it's
- 33:20called peer-to-peer electronic cash.
- 33:23You know, eventually we can see Bitcoin moving to becoming a
- 33:28medium of exchange. So people exchanging Bitcoin for
- 33:31for goods and and services. But actually today I saw a
- 33:36really great tweet about it. I'll quickly look it up here.
- 33:43It's very important to understand that store value
- 33:46comes before medium of exchange, right?
- 33:48So if I cannot save with this new type of asset, why would I
- 33:53ask it for or as a reward for the work that I'm doing on the
- 33:58products or services that that I'm selling?
- 34:00So store value comes before medium of exchange and that
- 34:03might take some time already as as we can also see in these in
- 34:08these graphs like this, this will not happen within the next
- 34:12year or or two years. You know, the the outlook of
- 34:15Michael Saylor's 2045 in order to get to that 14,000,000
- 34:20Bitcoin price. So I thought that would be an
- 34:22important addition to make as it might be confusing, you know,
- 34:27hearing people discuss Bitcoin saying well, I cannot buy a cup
- 34:29of coffee with it. You know, the entire point is
- 34:32that we first established it as a store of value before it can
- 34:36even become a medium of exchange.
- 34:38Yeah, that's, that's a great point to highlight here that
- 34:42when I when I put out the full potential evaluation piece, I
- 34:47was, I didn't put a timeline on it.
- 34:50I said decades and because I think that's the right way to
- 34:55think about where Bitcoin is at in its life cycle and its
- 35:00development. It is very early in the S curve
- 35:04of monetization, in my opinion. And and that's, that's Bitcoin
- 35:09becoming a store of value for, for the world.
- 35:12I think right now Bitcoin is, is viewed as a store of value, as
- 35:16as the preferred store of value asset in the world by a very
- 35:20tiny bunch of people that we call Bitcoiners.
- 35:24And that's, that's a, you know, that's a contrarian group at
- 35:27this point, truly small in the grand scheme of things.
- 35:32Maybe a million people as Brahm and I have talked about, maybe
- 35:35it's 100,000 people really in the world to who understand
- 35:39Bitcoin as a, as the best store value asset to be holding.
- 35:44And if Bitcoin's properties are, you know, what are what we
- 35:47talked through? And I think they are the world
- 35:52will eventually wake up to those properties and discover, wait a
- 35:56second, this this Internet money, this Monopoly money
- 35:59online that doesn't have any intrinsic value is the best
- 36:05store value asset in history. And I want to hold that.
- 36:09And so I think we're, we're, you know, if you think about the the
- 36:12S curve of monetization of bitcoins total value over time,
- 36:17we haven't really reached that hockey stick yet.
- 36:20But I think that's coming as, as we make our way through the bell
- 36:24curve of technology adopters. And you know, the bulk of the
- 36:29those individuals are in the center of the bell curve.
- 36:34And as we kind of progress into that bell curve, we'll see
- 36:36larger and larger cohorts of new adopters come in with bigger
- 36:40chunks of capital per year than we have seen.
- 36:45And that will, I think, rapidly scale that'll be that the fast
- 36:49part of the S curve of the coins monetization.
- 36:52And, and again, that's this is all in the context of Bitcoin
- 36:55becoming the store of value for more and more people in the
- 36:58world. And the, the, the step after
- 37:03that is, is once, once a large portion of the world views
- 37:07Bitcoin as a valid store of value asset, then you can start
- 37:11to price goods and exchange value in that medium of
- 37:15exchange, because people want to settle in Bitcoin as a store of
- 37:19value. Then you can conduct trade in
- 37:22that medium of exchange. And all the infrastructure that
- 37:24is, is being built on layer 2 on lightning and and whatnot for
- 37:29that transactional future. But you know what we're focusing
- 37:33on here and what I think the investment opportunity is for
- 37:36individuals with Bitcoin is because we are early in the
- 37:39store value monetization phase of Bitcoin.
- 37:43Yeah, few things to add to that. I, I think the, the long term
- 37:49outlook is perhaps difficult for, for some people, but I want
- 37:55to remind everyone that Bitcoin is basically taking on the
- 37:59biggest topic in the world, right?
- 38:00It's money. It's how we exchange value with
- 38:03each other. So the fact that it has already
- 38:06survived 15 years and and we are in the midst of this
- 38:12monetization period, the fact that there are countries using
- 38:15government resources to mine Bitcoin, the fact that, you
- 38:19know, multiple presidential candidates in the US have taken
- 38:25Bitcoin as an important subject. There was a Treasury report this
- 38:29week that put Bitcoin or define Bitcoin as digital gold, gold.
- 38:35You see the path opening, but the path is is still long.
- 38:40But we have seen this in the past, right?
- 38:42So this is nothing new. Currencies come and go, but also
- 38:47what Jesse said eventually the moving to a medium of exchange.
- 38:51There are several examples of stores even in Canada taking on
- 38:58U.S. dollars and giving Canadian dollars in return.
- 39:01I heard someone, I spoke to someone last week who mentioned
- 39:04that in the Eastern Caribbean you have the Eastern Caribbean
- 39:06dollar. People take U.S. dollars, they
- 39:08give the weaker currency, the Eastern Caribbean dollar back.
- 39:11So we can also imagine a time where there will be a like a
- 39:15dual pricing in our economy for the people that understand that
- 39:20Bitcoin is a better reward for whatever they are selling.
- 39:24Perhaps you will get a discount if you pay in Bitcoin, but then
- 39:28you also get a weaker currency like the US dollar, for example,
- 39:32in return. And the last, the last point I
- 39:34wanted to add, you know, sometimes we hear critics
- 39:38mention this, you know, intrinsic value.
- 39:40I think there's a, there's a whole that's a whole different
- 39:43discussion, even to talk about what is value and, and, and then
- 39:46definitely what is intrinsic value.
- 39:48But I wanted to share a read a tweet that I saw yesterday,
- 39:52which I think illustrates it well, right.
- 39:56We mentioned that, you know, what does Bitcoin produce?
- 39:59It produces the certainty that basically stays the same.
- 40:02But what is this Ledger of Bitcoin and, and, and this was
- 40:05the tweet that said all data must live on a Ledger in order
- 40:08to record truth for dissemination.
- 40:11The Bitcoin network is the first time in human history the
- 40:14ledgers are incorruptible, immutable and publicly audited
- 40:19every. 10 minutes. And this is basically what the
- 40:22product of Bitcoin is. It's not only that certainty
- 40:24that it stays the same, but all the information in the Bitcoin
- 40:29network is basically the pure truth of that system.
- 40:34And if the system is a monetary system, then we can basically
- 40:38conclude that, you know, this is this is the best money, it's the
- 40:41fairest money, right? If we talk about the dollar,
- 40:44which is the best currency of all the currencies, we don't
- 40:49know how many dollars there are in supply.
- 40:52The Federal Reserve has never been audited.
- 40:54Like, you know, just two simple examples that are just a total
- 40:57180 of Bitcoin and anyone can verify that for themselves.
- 41:02That's also the entire point. You know, if you listen to us
- 41:04talking about Bitcoin or anyone talking about Bitcoin, I think
- 41:08we always share, you know, you should study Bitcoin yourself
- 41:11and you don't even have to believe us or anyone else.
- 41:14You can basically verify it for yourself.
- 41:16And that is part of the core of the value of Bitcoin as well,
- 41:20that you are in total control of judging whether this is what it
- 41:26says it is. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 41:29keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 41:32sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 41:35Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 41:37with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 41:39device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 41:44and our Multi institution custody solution.
- 41:47Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 41:50multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 41:53a key on Ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 41:58unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 42:01over your coins. With On Ramp's multi institution
- 42:05Custody, you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 42:08stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 42:11tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 42:14going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 42:17exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 42:21in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 42:25you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 42:28custody set up. On ramps, Multi institution
- 42:31custody, eliminates single points of failure, reduces your
- 42:34personal attack surface and technical burden, and provides
- 42:38access to financial services that allow you to confidently
- 42:40secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 42:44backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 42:47cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 42:51asset. Secure it right.
- 42:53Learn more at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 42:56Very well said both of you. I think one question that comes
- 42:59to mind and, and really for both of you is, you know, this idea
- 43:04or this concept of a monetary premium, I think is, is
- 43:07important to elaborate on. So most of those other asset
- 43:10buckets which you've you've shown on that global asset
- 43:13landscape page, Jesse are not valued purely on their utility
- 43:19value per SE. And so there's some amount of
- 43:22monetary premium associated with all these other assets.
- 43:25And so in your mind, you know, do you have a, a sense for which
- 43:30particular asset buckets are most likely to cede ground to
- 43:34Bitcoin over time? Are there any that are more
- 43:36likely in your mind? I think, you know, I've heard
- 43:38arguments for real estate or bonds in particular as being,
- 43:41you know, the most likely areas where we'd see capital flow
- 43:46really that monetary premium flow or a road out of those
- 43:49asset buckets and into Bitcoin. But any thoughts around that?
- 43:52Yes, it's, it's really interesting and fun topic.
- 43:57I think that. So I guess part of the, the full
- 44:01potential valuation report is establishing that all the value
- 44:09in the world is, is relevant, meaning that when, when people
- 44:16buy an asset, they're buying that asset because they're
- 44:19trying to propagate their value into the future and hopefully
- 44:22grow that purchasing power over time.
- 44:26And that's true of like anybody allocating any amount of, you
- 44:30know, their portfolio. That's constantly the question
- 44:32that's being asked, which means that any, any value in the world
- 44:37is, is, is relevant to what Bitcoin can take or, or, or, you
- 44:44know, where Bitcoin can siphon off from.
- 44:47And then of those buckets out there, the ones that I think are
- 44:53most likely to have outflows that go point towards Bitcoin
- 45:00bonds is the number one for me by a lot.
- 45:05And I think that the important thing to consider there is, you
- 45:09know, what is the value proposition of bonds to A to a
- 45:13buyer, to a holder of bonds. Well, that is OK.
- 45:18You will park dollars here today and you will receive a 4% per
- 45:24year nominal yield. And, and you know, that's,
- 45:28that's your reward for tying up your capital.
- 45:32And the idea there is that it, that should outpace the 3% CPI
- 45:38inflation. We, we, we believe we have.
- 45:43But I think inflation is higher than the CPI numbers state.
- 45:48I think there's every cent incentive in the world to
- 45:51massage those numbers down and I think they do that.
- 45:54I think a better barometer of true inflation is the growth of
- 45:57the money supply over time, which has been averaging M2
- 46:01money supply growth has been averaging 7% a year and has been
- 46:06increasing over time that that rate of growth has been
- 46:10increasing. So Sailor in this model, in his
- 46:14model assumes 7% continues into the future for inflation.
- 46:18I think that's right at minimum. I think it could be higher than
- 46:21that. And so if you're holding bonds
- 46:23generating a 4% nominal return, but inflation 7%, you're
- 46:29destroying 7%, three percent of your value every year that you
- 46:32hold your bonds. And so that's a burning
- 46:35platform. So it's $300 trillion of capital
- 46:39in the world that is sitting in a in an asset that looks like
- 46:43it's growing your value over time, but I think is actually
- 46:47destroying value in real purchasing power terms every
- 46:51year that you hold it. So as bondholders wake up to
- 46:55that, they have the greatest incentive to get the hell out of
- 46:59bonds and go to an asset that provides a similar utility, a
- 47:05similar value proposition. Park your money here today, grow
- 47:11it over time, but it does it with different mechanics and has
- 47:16a much better performance because of its endogenous
- 47:21properties and also where it is in the early stage and its
- 47:24adoption curve as a financial asset and that's Bitcoin.
- 47:27So I think that bitcoins becomes the 21st century substitute for
- 47:33bonds in a portfolio. If an investor wakes up enough
- 47:38or, you know, does their homework enough to understand,
- 47:40here's what bonds do, here's what Bitcoin does, but it does
- 47:44it way better. And so maybe I should sell my
- 47:46bonds and, and buy more Bitcoin. So in, in my, in my
- 47:49calculations, I, I said only 30% of the capital stored in bonds
- 47:55will migrate to Bitcoin. But I think that the number
- 47:58could actually be much higher than that.
- 48:00It could be 90%. Even that wouldn't actually
- 48:04surprise me because there's no there's no utility to holding
- 48:08bonds as an asset it it's purely a store of value and investment
- 48:15value proposition. So all of that capital will
- 48:20should be interested in migrating to an asset that
- 48:24fulfills the same value proposition but does it much
- 48:26better maybe. That interesting?
- 48:30Go ahead, go ahead. Mark, I think the interesting
- 48:32thing here is that because and, and I think the 7% is a, is a,
- 48:37is a good percentage to calculate with, right?
- 48:40I think it's somewhat conservative, but I think it's
- 48:43good, good enough. Yeah.
- 48:47Like if you have a 10 year bond and and that rate is lower than
- 48:537%, then you basically also lose money, right.
- 48:55So in some ways. And, and I mean, if you, if you,
- 48:59if you, if you study a little bit, you sometimes see like.
- 49:01OK, Well, nominally I, I will get a certain amount of of
- 49:05dollars, so that seems like more than what I put in.
- 49:09But you know, over 10 years, 7% of the year is more than half a
- 49:16loss of more than half of the purchasing power of those same
- 49:20dollars. And that is what you need to
- 49:22take into account there. The difference with Bitcoin,
- 49:27right, because we talked about this debasement, where does that
- 49:29come from? It comes from the inflation of
- 49:31the, the, the money supply, which debases the value of the
- 49:35existing supply, which eventually inflates, you know,
- 49:38all the prices that, that we see.
- 49:39And so one of the kind of like memes or, or, or topics talking
- 49:44points that people have in Bitcoin is that they say one
- 49:46Bitcoin equals one Bitcoin. And the one Bitcoin now is the
- 49:50same Bitcoin as in 10 years because the supply of Bitcoin
- 49:54cannot be diluted. But the $1.00 now in 10 years
- 49:58will not be $1.00, right? It will be like 40-2 cents or
- 50:01something like that. So I think once you approach it
- 50:04like that and integrate that into your calculator
- 50:07calculations of, OK, where do I store the money that I have
- 50:13right now? Yeah, you can store it within
- 50:15the the paradigm of all the field money with, with all the
- 50:21instruments that are also there or you move it to this newer
- 50:25paradigm that basically promises and shows you in a way that you
- 50:30can verify yourself that it's not being debased as happens in
- 50:34the in the older paradigm. And so even having a small
- 50:38percentage of whatever you want to park or save somewhere
- 50:44already, if you take let's say the 10 year example already
- 50:49gives you a lot of return even with conservative numbers.
- 50:57I, I think that's probably a, a great time to dip into some of
- 51:00the questions that we have in, in the, in the chat here.
- 51:03I see the this recent one from Stanley asking if we're talking
- 51:08about the $2 trillion in Bitcoin in the $900 trillion asset
- 51:12landscape. What about the other digital
- 51:13assets that amount to $1.6 trillion on top of that?
- 51:17Where do they belong and, and, and why does this view exclude
- 51:23them? Funny enough, if anything, that
- 51:29maybe they should be included in equities.
- 51:32My view is that the other digital assets out there, other
- 51:36cryptocurrencies are largely, if not entirely unlicensed
- 51:41securities. They're, they're really
- 51:43companies. They're venture venture
- 51:46companies masquerading as a currency.
- 51:49And so my view is, is that Bitcoin is different.
- 51:54It is the invention of digital scarcity.
- 51:57It is the invention of digital capital.
- 51:59And it's the only real story. It has won the store value use
- 52:03case for digital assets. And in my opinion, that's 95%
- 52:08plus of the, of the value of digital assets is to have a
- 52:12digital store value asset. And so I, I think that over time
- 52:16Bitcoin grows based on, on that value proposition and that use
- 52:22case and other cryptocurrencies remain a sideshow and shrink in
- 52:29relative scale compared to Bitcoin.
- 52:33As Bitcoin continues to monetize and grow much larger, I don't
- 52:36think crypto beyond Bitcoin will keep up.
- 52:43So that's that's my view on that we can.
- 52:46Yeah, maybe I'll, I'll combine a few here that we have in the
- 52:49chat really, you know, talking somewhat about cycle
- 52:54positioning, where are we in terms of this current bull run?
- 52:58And you know, one of the questions is around, you know,
- 53:01should people be tempted to take profits off off the table during
- 53:04a bull run in order to, you know, redeploy that in the next
- 53:07bear market? And then alongside that, you
- 53:10know, a question around on chain metrics, is there any particular
- 53:14metrics that you guys focus on to get a sense of where we are
- 53:18in the cycle? I'll, I'll answer that that last
- 53:21part first of on chain metrics I think are very interesting and
- 53:26there's probably some value in there.
- 53:28The last time that I tried to trade Bitcoin, I got burned
- 53:32because I paid too much attention to it.
- 53:34And a particular on chain metric that had, you know, incredible
- 53:39fidelity of back testing, you know, if you look back in time
- 53:42was NVT signal, which was being popularized by a Willy Woo four
- 53:47years ago. And I got burned by that.
- 53:49And I, and I ended up with, if I had not dabbled in that, I would
- 53:55have 10% more Bitcoin than I do. So and that was an on chain
- 54:00metric. It was, it was, it was the
- 54:02darling of the era. And it, it ended up not, it
- 54:07ended up predicting that we were going lower and we didn't, that
- 54:10was the very bottom. And I got caught on the sideline
- 54:13and I regret it. So that's my take on on chain
- 54:17metrics is that they, it can be very interesting and there
- 54:20probably is some information, you know, actionable information
- 54:26in there, but there's so much other noise or contrasting
- 54:34information, information that that would point you in the
- 54:37wrong direction that my take is you're better off by and holding
- 54:42then acting on on chain signals. To trade, I I would agree with
- 54:47that. One thing to add, you know, part
- 54:50of the way I think about it is all on chain metrics are of
- 54:54course backward looking. So I don't necessarily put
- 54:57predictive power in on trade metrics, but it can be helpful
- 55:01in getting a sense of, you know, where we are in terms of, you
- 55:06know, historically during bull runs, you you start to see long
- 55:10term holders distribute coins. It's happened every time.
- 55:13It'll happen again this time in terms of people taking profits
- 55:16who have a very low cost basis. And so seeing that on chain, I
- 55:19do think is actually helpful in terms of getting grasp for where
- 55:23we are in the bull run. The most recent data I've seen
- 55:27on this is, you know, we're not, we're not anywhere near sort of
- 55:31overheated levels in terms of that long term holder cell
- 55:35pressure. You're starting to see it here
- 55:37and there, but we're still, I would say early innings in terms
- 55:40of some of those metrics. But like I said at the at the
- 55:43beginning, you know, I, I don't think there's predictive power
- 55:47necessarily in these because, you know, the future can always
- 55:49change. We have a new class of buyers
- 55:51that are now in this market, which I think is important to
- 55:53consider, you know, harkening back to what Bran was suggesting
- 55:56around, well, you know, are we going to have another 80%
- 55:58drawdown? My thinking is, you know, it'll
- 56:01probably be less severe than that just because we have new
- 56:04market participants that are looking for a better entry.
- 56:08And so that, you know, there's a lot of capital on the sidelines
- 56:10that is now, you know, looking through to a new administration,
- 56:14you know, better regulatory environment and saying, you
- 56:16know, when I get a chance to buy this thing in mass, I'm going to
- 56:19do it. So there, there could be just
- 56:21larger, more sophisticated dip buyers effectively as the next
- 56:25couple of years plays out. So that's another thing to
- 56:27consider that, you know, the future is not necessarily going
- 56:30to be indicative or or you know, look like it did in the past.
- 56:34But Brandon, do you have any other thoughts there?
- 56:38Yeah, I think, I think it's an interesting question.
- 56:41I will, I will. Which question were you
- 56:45referring to? I'll, I'll share in the chat.
- 56:47I can type an answer I found. There was a.
- 56:51Few that we were speaking to just around cycle positioning
- 56:55and on chain metrics. Yeah, I'll type an answer here
- 56:58to Patrick. I think that would be public.
- 57:02There's a guy on Twitter called the Rational route who I think
- 57:05has an interesting model where he kind of follows these.
- 57:10You probably know like this classical graph of like what's
- 57:14it called like despair, hope, etcetera, euphoria, we go up and
- 57:17down, etcetera. But he made it into like a
- 57:19circle, which I think is an interesting angle.
- 57:21But again, I think to Brian's point, it's all backward looking
- 57:28and it's good to consider that we are going through, as Jesse
- 57:32mentioned before, the monetization phase of a totally
- 57:35new asset that at least to our understanding based on
- 57:42information that anyone can study is superior to any other
- 57:46store of value asset that's currently out there that people
- 57:48are using. So I mean the fact that we are
- 57:51going through this phase, I think it's an added dimension
- 57:54with which makes it harder to trade it.
- 57:58Jesse maybe knows this better, but there's probably in the last
- 58:02cycle there's like 10 days where you could have made the most
- 58:06amount of money if you if you paid attention as a trader.
- 58:10Overall for the general person, once you understand that having
- 58:14the long term outlook is the best, you will just buy and
- 58:18hold. I always say, you know, I bought
- 58:20at 300, I sold everything at 4000, which at that time I felt
- 58:25great, but now I have less Bitcoin than before.
- 58:27This is 10 years ago, right? 810 years ago, you know,
- 58:31overtime thinking about that use case of lowering your
- 58:36uncertainty towards the future, acquiring this asset to create
- 58:41capital to build whatever you want to build in the future.
- 58:44Once you look at it at at it from that viewpoint, yeah, that
- 58:51at least personally. But I think the guys who are
- 58:53kind of tested that like the trading questions kind of our
- 58:55fears and stuff kind of disappear because then it
- 58:58becomes more about accumulating more of this thing and doing
- 59:03your best in the field world or however you make money in order
- 59:08to acquire more of this asset. So I think, yeah, we can share
- 59:13our thoughts around these questions, but I think they're
- 59:16mainly geared towards, OK, like how do I, how do I trade?
- 59:20And notoriously, yeah, trading has been difficult if you're not
- 59:25a, you know, professional day trader, basically like trying to
- 59:28time the market, it's very hard. And I've also been burned quite
- 59:32a few times. Did that so.
- 59:34Yeah, every time I've tried to do anything fancy, I get burned.
- 59:37So hold is the winning strategy. And that's because it volatility
- 59:41with Bitcoin is to the upside, meaning that you got your down
- 59:46days, you got your up days. And then every so often there's
- 59:50a there's a + 510% day and it catches everybody by surprise.
- 59:56It comes out of nowhere and you better have been holding.
- 1:00:00Otherwise you missed out on that.
- 1:00:01And that's the real that that's what really moves Bitcoin over
- 1:00:07time is, you know, 10 days like that a year is where all the
- 1:00:11games happen and you want to be holding to to enjoy that.
- 1:00:15There's a question from Michael here about given the transition
- 1:00:20to a new type of buyer, you know more sophisticated investors in
- 1:00:23nation states, do you still expect large boom bust cycles
- 1:00:28that we've experienced before? So my mental model for that,
- 1:00:32even though we just talked about how inactionable, unactionable
- 1:00:39market cycles maybe for trying to time the top and and trade,
- 1:00:44my mental model is that we will continue to see what we've seen,
- 1:00:48which is actually a decreasing draw down over each subsequent
- 1:00:56cycle. I think the first bear market
- 1:00:59for Bitcoin was like a 91% draw down, you know back in like
- 1:01:0320-12 and then 85% and then 80%. And then I think the most recent
- 1:01:10one was like 75%. And I think that trend will
- 1:01:13probably continue. And I think that's the the
- 1:01:15maturation of an asset over time.
- 1:01:18And part of that is the increasing confidence of the
- 1:01:21market that, OK, if you're, if you're experiencing experiencing
- 1:01:24a strong downturn, that's a buying opportunity because this
- 1:01:28thing keeps coming back. And also that, you know, as this
- 1:01:32asset matures, you start to view it as a long term asset that
- 1:01:37you're going to not be as as moved to try to trade in and out
- 1:01:41of or you know, view as a short term asset.
- 1:01:44So I think that trend continues. I my sort of base case is we'll
- 1:01:48probably see like a 70% draw down at some point.
- 1:01:51It is possible that the scale of these new end market entrance
- 1:01:57changes that and you know, like micro strategy will be buying
- 1:02:02the dip in the next bear market that that you can be sure of.
- 1:02:07And and does that mean we only see a 60% draw down as possible,
- 1:02:11But my mental model for you know, until that is proven
- 1:02:15wrong, I, I will continue to believe we'll just see
- 1:02:17decreasing amplitude of draw down each subsequent bear
- 1:02:23market. Well said.
- 1:02:26We, we had a question around custody, which I think is worth
- 1:02:30elaborating on. So self custody is really hard
- 1:02:32for those familiar with it or even for those familiar with it
- 1:02:36will, will Bitcoin adoption accelerate rapidly when a
- 1:02:38customer friendly solution is launched?
- 1:02:40Jesse, maybe you could speak to this and and also the realities
- 1:02:44around different custody models, the trade-offs and also what
- 1:02:48we're building here at On Ramp. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:02:51It's a great question. And and I, I think it's the
- 1:02:53right question. I, I think that self custody is
- 1:02:56really hard even for those familiar with it exactly as
- 1:03:00Johnny here stated. And I think that part of moving
- 1:03:06through the bell curve of adoption and getting into the
- 1:03:09mainstream of technology adopters is having more user
- 1:03:16friendly solutions that the don't sacrifice much at all.
- 1:03:22And, and I think that's the, that's what has to happen for
- 1:03:25the technology as it, as it develops in order for adoption
- 1:03:29to happen with, you know, the mainstream, mainstream
- 1:03:32individuals are not that tech savvy or, and, and I think self
- 1:03:36custody as it exists maybe more daunting than people in the
- 1:03:42middle of the bell curve are, are willing to, to take on.
- 1:03:46And so that's, that's really why where on ramp came from.
- 1:03:50So what we do at on ramp is multi institution custody, which
- 1:03:55is a type of multi sig custody, which provides the best security
- 1:04:00possible for an individual's Bitcoin where they don't have to
- 1:04:06participate in the technical or security requirements of setting
- 1:04:11up and maintaining that custody arrangement.
- 1:04:15Instead, they're hiring the best companies in the world to act on
- 1:04:20their behalf as key holders in this three key multi sig setup.
- 1:04:25So, you know, on ramps product on ramp holds the key, bit go
- 1:04:30holds the key and coin cover holds the key in a two of three
- 1:04:34multi sig setup, meaning that two of those keys need to sign
- 1:04:39any transaction for it to be processed.
- 1:04:45And and so in that way, you've you have you have fault
- 1:04:48tolerance where two of three, but not all three are required.
- 1:04:52So any one of those companies could go under or somehow lose
- 1:04:56that key and the the assets in that vault would be just fine
- 1:05:01because two of three is still there.
- 1:05:05And it also means that no individual, no no key holding
- 1:05:09institution can you unilaterally control the funds in that vault.
- 1:05:13Only the end user, the client has the legal relationship
- 1:05:18directly with each of those three key holding institutions
- 1:05:21to authorize that institution to sign any transaction on their
- 1:05:26behalf. So in that way, this this new
- 1:05:29form of this evolution of the multi multi sig format is very
- 1:05:35attractive for removing a lot of the complexity and technical and
- 1:05:39security requirements from the end user and making it more
- 1:05:43accessible to the mainstream or or the the average adopter of
- 1:05:47Bitcoin to have their Bitcoin in an on chain address that they
- 1:05:52that they control without having to figure out the technical and
- 1:05:57security requirements that are that are quite daunting for self
- 1:06:01custody. Yeah, it's, it's, it's really
- 1:06:05well said. And I think the question is well
- 1:06:09stated and it's the right question to be asking because I
- 1:06:11think, you know, the reality to me at least, is that the reason
- 1:06:16Bitcoin is in a much larger asset already today is because
- 1:06:21of the difficulty of self custody and also the peril of
- 1:06:24trusting a single counterparty. And so everything that we're
- 1:06:27doing in on RIP is trying to solve for exactly that, to
- 1:06:31extract away complexity of key management while still
- 1:06:34eliminating a single point of failure in a third party custody
- 1:06:37set up. And in my view, that will allow
- 1:06:41us just on board for more people at a much faster rate than, you
- 1:06:46know, telling people that they need to take hours, you know,
- 1:06:50potentially years to learn cryptographic security in order
- 1:06:53to adopt the asset, while also saying we recognize it's not,
- 1:06:58it's been a pretty poor decision to just trust one single
- 1:07:01counterparty unilaterally. Historically, whether you know,
- 1:07:04from Mount Cox to FTX, there's countless examples of of that
- 1:07:07going wrong. And so everything that we're
- 1:07:09doing is, is really trying to solve for exactly that and be
- 1:07:12able to more quickly and more securely on board people to this
- 1:07:17asset. OK, One other question you know,
- 1:07:25I had going back to the asset buckets, Jesse, you know,
- 1:07:28there's been a lot of conversation recently from the
- 1:07:31sellers of the world and also from people in government around
- 1:07:35the idea of selling gold in order to buy Bitcoin.
- 1:07:37So when you look at that bucket of gold, do you think that that
- 1:07:41gold just gets demonetized by Bitcoin over the next couple
- 1:07:45decades or you know, I think there is also a an argument on
- 1:07:49the other hand, that because of, you know, rampant inflation and
- 1:07:54Fiat debasement that there's a value prop for gold still in
- 1:07:58this world over the next couple of decades.
- 1:07:59So maybe you see gold sort of grind upwards in tandem with
- 1:08:03Bitcoin, but obviously at a much slower rate.
- 1:08:07Do you describe ascribe to either of those lines of
- 1:08:10thinking of well, if all these nation states are going to sell
- 1:08:13their gold and that could be pretty bad for the price of
- 1:08:15gold, but any thoughts there? Yeah, I think that, yeah, I
- 1:08:22think you, you nailed it with one of your, your, your possible
- 1:08:25scenarios. I, I think that gold does well,
- 1:08:29but very interestingly, I, I think that gold underperforms
- 1:08:33Bitcoin significantly. So, you know, I, I think that
- 1:08:38what we've seen over the last 50 years, well, I guess I'll, I'll,
- 1:08:44I'll start by saying Peter Thiel put out a great slide a couple
- 1:08:48years ago. I think it was 1981, global
- 1:08:53equities were the same were $1 trillion and I think it was $1
- 1:08:58trillion and gold was $1 trillion.
- 1:09:02All, all the gold in the world and all the equities in the
- 1:09:04world were the same value. And what we've seen since then
- 1:09:08is equities has 10X relative to gold roughly.
- 1:09:14And then now gold is starting to catch up a little bit.
- 1:09:18And I, so I think that gold has suffered in the Fiat era as
- 1:09:24other assets have been monetized and possibly the price
- 1:09:30suppression of gold from paper gold issued by central banks has
- 1:09:37played into that. But I think that the, the
- 1:09:41sovereign debt levels that we're currently facing will cause a
- 1:09:46flight to hard assets in general.
- 1:09:48I think there'll be a, a, a major shift.
- 1:09:52I think this is going to be a prevailing trend for the coming
- 1:09:55decades of people shifting value from bonds and, and money and
- 1:10:03Fiat money itself, which are two of the larger buckets on that
- 1:10:05page, which in in those two assets are Fiat money itself or
- 1:10:11contracts for future Fiat money. And I think you're going to see
- 1:10:16a transition from those buckets back towards hard assets and,
- 1:10:21and gold will do well because of that.
- 1:10:23But I think that Bitcoin will vastly outperform gold.
- 1:10:27So I think, you know, while gold will grow and and probably grow
- 1:10:31as a relative relative to other assets in the global asset
- 1:10:35landscape, bitcoins growth will probably order a magnitude
- 1:10:39outpace gold's relative growth. So you know, if you think about
- 1:10:43the hard asset category as Bitcoin plus gold today, that's
- 1:10:48like a $20 trillion asset class, roughly 10% of which is Bitcoin.
- 1:10:54And I think we will over the coming decades see that flip
- 1:10:57where, you know, 90% will be Bitcoin and 10% will be gold,
- 1:11:02even though gold grew relative to bonds and, you know, the
- 1:11:06other traditional asset buckets. Yeah, I, I think what I can add
- 1:11:11to that, that's that that requires just a rational
- 1:11:16approach. You know, I think there's, there
- 1:11:19are two main arguments for gold. 1 is the narrative of gold.
- 1:11:22You know, when you look at, you know, these overview charts of
- 1:11:26characteristics of, of of gold and Bitcoin, for example, of
- 1:11:29course, gold has been used for over 5000 plus years.
- 1:11:32That's mainly the only thing where it basically wins in terms
- 1:11:37of characteristics from Bitcoin. I think the other part that's
- 1:11:41not necessarily in the kind of like these overviews like that
- 1:11:44is that of course central banks are still buying gold.
- 1:11:47So that helps in in the narrative for gold.
- 1:11:50But if you just look at it in an objective way, I once heard
- 1:11:54someone say, if you want to move 100 million in gold, it'll cost
- 1:11:57you 10 million. We can move 100 million of
- 1:11:59Bitcoin for $3 basically to anyone in the world without any
- 1:12:03counterparty risk with final settlement, etcetera.
- 1:12:05And so, yeah, just wanted to add that as a little, I don't know
- 1:12:11tidbit because I, I, I do believe there's a place for gold
- 1:12:15in the world. I also, but I do believe it's
- 1:12:17part of the, you know, inflated asset classes as, as, as Jesse
- 1:12:22just described, you know, if you just look at the properties
- 1:12:27Bitcoin is, is a better, has better characteristics.
- 1:12:30There's no fake Bitcoin. For example, you know, you need
- 1:12:33like 3 machines to figure out if your gold bar is real, You know,
- 1:12:37so there's like these these pretty important things that I
- 1:12:40think show the benefits of, of Bitcoin there.
- 1:12:46Maybe one question that sort of circles back to how we started
- 1:12:50the conversation around the problem at hand of inflation and
- 1:12:55Fiat debasement. And could, could each of you
- 1:12:58talk a little bit about, you know, why that is likely to
- 1:13:00persist if we think about 36 trillion in debt in the United
- 1:13:06States, You know, I think with the new administration coming
- 1:13:09in, there is A at least reinvigorated sense of the
- 1:13:15government needs to be more efficient.
- 1:13:18And so that's on net a positive sort of development.
- 1:13:22But you know, even if they're able to RIP out 2 trillion of,
- 1:13:27you know, wasteful spending and, and sort of cut back on, on the
- 1:13:31deficit deficits that we've been running, that's 36 trillion
- 1:13:34still exists. So I think if, if each of you
- 1:13:37could talk about, you know, just circling back to the problem at
- 1:13:39hand and why the Fiat debasement will continue to persist over
- 1:13:43time and why, you know, Bitcoin as a as a sort of release valve
- 1:13:47for that persistent reality makes sense.
- 1:13:52Yeah, maybe I was thinking maybe to quickly answer one more
- 1:13:56question that I saw in the chat from Nicholas.
- 1:13:59Yeah, before we we talk about this and I, I think eventually
- 1:14:02wrap it up. Wrap it up.
- 1:14:03He says, as a software engineer, I know how the sausage is made.
- 1:14:06Can you speak to the code security vulnerabilities?
- 1:14:09Well, I think that's a wonderful question, right?
- 1:14:12Because we talk about, you know, what is the promise of Bitcoin,
- 1:14:15What does it deliver us, right. Like it never changes.
- 1:14:19That's basically the premise. And because it never changes in
- 1:14:22the sense that one Bitcoin will always stay one Bitcoin, no one
- 1:14:24can change the code and say like, oh, there's going to be
- 1:14:27100 million Bitcoin, right? That is of course the, the, the
- 1:14:31promise of stability that that it gives.
- 1:14:34I think there's two things. Bitcoin is open source software,
- 1:14:37right? Anyone can copy this code.
- 1:14:40You can start Nicholas coin tomorrow.
- 1:14:42I can start Brom coin tomorrow with the same code as Bitcoin
- 1:14:46and then make it maybe 100 million Brom coin units for for
- 1:14:51example. Why is that not happening?
- 1:14:55It's because Bitcoin has this network effect, right?
- 1:14:58So this code or the proliferation of the code of the
- 1:15:04network is basically secured by a growing amount of not only
- 1:15:09nodes that check the Ledger, the blockchain of Bitcoin every
- 1:15:13every 10 minutes, but also by miners that put electrical power
- 1:15:19towards the computers that are used to mine Bitcoin, which is I
- 1:15:25think at an all time high or or almost at an all time high, this
- 1:15:28this computing power. And it's basically the most
- 1:15:31powerful computer network in the world.
- 1:15:35And it's also decentralized. And so if someone would want to
- 1:15:40change the code of Bitcoin or for example, double spend a
- 1:15:45certain amount of Bitcoin or have control over the network
- 1:15:48for 10 or more minutes, the attack costs are, I think just
- 1:15:54from the top of my head, probably like 10 to $15 billion
- 1:15:58to control this network for for 10 minutes.
- 1:16:02So if you want to know how the sausage is made, you can
- 1:16:05actually look up the source code.
- 1:16:06You can go through the source code.
- 1:16:08This is software code that has been scrutinized for 15 years
- 1:16:12already. And I think what could help you
- 1:16:17in that assessment is understand that there are a lot of
- 1:16:22participants or all the participants, the main
- 1:16:24participants in the network, the notes and the minors basically
- 1:16:27validate that this code is the right code that that we are
- 1:16:31using. I don't know if the guys have
- 1:16:33anything to add but that that will be my quick answer to to
- 1:16:36that question. Yeah, the, the, the one small
- 1:16:39addition I'd make is, you know, it's interesting that that
- 1:16:41Bitcoin is this live experiment. There's $2 trillion in Bitcoin
- 1:16:48now. And if anybody could figure out
- 1:16:50how to break Bitcoin, they, they could win up to $2 trillion by
- 1:16:57shorting it and then breaking Bitcoin.
- 1:17:01And so that, you know, that's that incentive is always there
- 1:17:04and has been there and has been material for 15 years.
- 1:17:09And nobody's done it. In fact, everybody who's, you
- 1:17:12know, really taking a look under the hood has come away more
- 1:17:16certain that it, that it, it is resilient, robust and, you know,
- 1:17:21and unbreakable. So, you know, that's, that's
- 1:17:28the, the other way to think about it is, is everyone in the
- 1:17:31world has had an incentive to try to break it, to profit
- 1:17:33massively for 15 years and, and has been completely unable to do
- 1:17:37it. So at what point does that speak
- 1:17:42to this sufficient security and, and strength of the network and,
- 1:17:47and the protocol? You know, for me that that's,
- 1:17:50that's enough. But, you know, maybe, maybe your
- 1:17:53individual threshold is higher and maybe it takes 30 years
- 1:17:57before you're persuaded. Yeah, good point.
- 1:18:04Brian, can you repeat the last question?
- 1:18:07Yeah, I just wanted to tie it back to, you know, how we
- 1:18:09started the conversation around the problem at hand and why
- 1:18:14Bitcoin is a solution and why in particular that problem is, is
- 1:18:17likely to persist, right. The, the, the debt problem is
- 1:18:21not going away. The interest expense on the debt
- 1:18:24is only accelerating as we roll over some of that debt at higher
- 1:18:27interest rates. So just talk, talk a bit about
- 1:18:30sort of why that's likely to persist and why it's sort of
- 1:18:35imperative that people think about Bitcoin right now and, and
- 1:18:38today and, and start figuring this out because those problems
- 1:18:41are are not going away. Yeah, I think Jesse probably has
- 1:18:46a deeper answer to this, but I think I'll refer back to the the
- 1:18:50path that I mentioned in the introduction, right?
- 1:18:53Like the we have Lynn Alden in the in the Bitcoin space who
- 1:18:57says this, this train ain't stopping, you know, and, and she
- 1:19:01means the dollar depth train. And why do we talk about the
- 1:19:04dollar, right? It's the, it's the best of all
- 1:19:07the Fiat currencies, but it's inherently flawed in the same
- 1:19:12way as as all the Fiat money systems that are used around the
- 1:19:15world, but it has the advantage of being the world reserve
- 1:19:19currency. I approach it like this.
- 1:19:22If anyone goes to theusdebtclock.org, you can see
- 1:19:26that the US debt is probably 36 trillion something something Per
- 1:19:31citizen, it's around 100,000 from the top of my head.
- 1:19:35Per taxpayer, it's 250,000 from the top of my head.
- 1:19:38So basically Americans work three days, three out of five
- 1:19:42days a week to pay tax on that income tax to help their
- 1:19:47governments pay interest on that outstanding debt.
- 1:19:51None of the principal, just interest.
- 1:19:54So that doesn't go to any other things that the government can
- 1:19:58do. The yearly deficits are more
- 1:20:03than or the interest payments yearly are more than the entire
- 1:20:06defense budget. I think there's a stat from
- 1:20:09history that once that happens, the the end of that Fiat money
- 1:20:13system is or that's the beginning of the end of of a, of
- 1:20:17a of a Fiat money system. But also, if you go to
- 1:20:20theusdebtclock.org and you go to the bottom right, you will see
- 1:20:23all the unfunded liabilities, which are like 220 ish trillion,
- 1:20:30which are basically all the promises made by the government
- 1:20:34that are set in law like Medicare and, and pension and
- 1:20:38and stuff like that. That's basically promised.
- 1:20:42But in essence, it's not there, right?
- 1:20:44Because it's unfunded like that money is not there.
- 1:20:48And I think the simple case to be made is that, you know, to
- 1:20:53add income or to create debt for the US government.
- 1:20:57They sell their treasuries. But yeah, what is the point at
- 1:21:01which the former buyers of those treasuries will realize that
- 1:21:05this debt will never be paid? Or if it's nominally paid back,
- 1:21:09then, you know, each unit of what is paid back will have,
- 1:21:13will, will have lost significant value.
- 1:21:16So that will eventually lead to the US government printing their
- 1:21:21own money to buy quote on, you know, air quotes to buy their
- 1:21:27own debt, which eventually, you know, will, will, will, will be
- 1:21:32socialized in, in terms of, of, of inflation of prices for
- 1:21:36anyone and debasement of, of all the existing money units.
- 1:21:39So the, the train that's not stopping is in my understanding
- 1:21:43this which other people like James Lavish, for example, that
- 1:21:47talks who talks a lot about, you know, the, the American debt
- 1:21:51that the US dollar debt spiral. It's basically accelerated.
- 1:21:54It's like you're paying off your credit card with a new credit
- 1:21:57card, but the interest rate and the total amount that you need
- 1:22:00gets higher and higher. So I think that is a good
- 1:22:04realization to understand that that is the system that we are
- 1:22:08all in and that, yeah, we see Bitcoin as the lifeboat to kind
- 1:22:13of get out of that or protect yourself against that inevitable
- 1:22:18end result. Yeah, you nailed it.
- 1:22:22I think that the unfunded liabilities thing is that the
- 1:22:26real smoking gun that most people ignore.
- 1:22:28I mean, we talked about $36 trillion in debt and and I'm
- 1:22:31certainly guilty of this, but it's much bigger than that.
- 1:22:34If you account for the, the full obligations of the of the US
- 1:22:40government into the future, it's much bigger than that.
- 1:22:44And yeah, I mean, we haven't, we haven't balanced the budget in
- 1:22:4722 years. We've normalized multi trillion
- 1:22:49dollar deficits. Now we have a trillion dollars
- 1:22:51of interest expense because after a decade of 0 interest
- 1:22:56rates, interest rates set at 0, now we have real interest rates
- 1:23:03again. And and we, we got used to
- 1:23:06having debt for free and now we have to pay for it.
- 1:23:09And now that's a trillion dollar expense that didn't exist five
- 1:23:13years ago and will only add to our deficits.
- 1:23:17And again, we we just entirely lack the political will,
- 1:23:21especially as an electorate. You know, think about the last
- 1:23:24time you heard on, on the news, people talking about the
- 1:23:27importance of balancing the budget.
- 1:23:30It just doesn't happen anymore. It used to happen 15 years ago,
- 1:23:33but it doesn't anymore. So the political will to rein in
- 1:23:39spending and, and balance a budget is non existent.
- 1:23:42So, you know, that means we won't be able to, to really
- 1:23:47materially change things. And, you know, Elon and the, the
- 1:23:51Doge branch of the government is, is well-intentioned, but I
- 1:23:57have a feeling they'll run up against a whole lot of red tape
- 1:24:02as they actually try to extract money out of the budget.
- 1:24:07And, and, and we'll see how effective they, they actually
- 1:24:10are. They, they could be entirely
- 1:24:12effective and it still couldn't solve the problem.
- 1:24:14I mean, we'll find ways to spend and, and add to the deficit even
- 1:24:19if they take $2 trillion out of our budget.
- 1:24:22And, and even if they've managed to balance the budget, it
- 1:24:25doesn't address the fact that we've already over promised with
- 1:24:28Social Security and other unfunded liabilities that, you
- 1:24:32know, we're not running surpluses.
- 1:24:34So we're not, we're not going to be able to like shrink the, the,
- 1:24:37the magnitude of those future promises into the future.
- 1:24:42Yeah, and I think that's the urgency that that in general we
- 1:24:46try to emphasize is that and, and, and, and anyone can verify
- 1:24:50this for themselves, of course. But the fact that this path
- 1:24:54exists and, and we have our whole future in in front of us.
- 1:24:59And can, you know, basically argue that that will be a very,
- 1:25:03very uncertain a future makes at least us when we, you know,
- 1:25:09going into Bitcoin act on the fact that that we know that that
- 1:25:13is the road and that is the the the endpoint of the road
- 1:25:17basically makes us act and, and, and move into Bitcoin.
- 1:25:21And I think that's general, in general part of what we're
- 1:25:25trying to communicate here. Very well said.
- 1:25:29Well, we're just about at times. So maybe we'll we'll wrap here.
- 1:25:32Just wanted to reiterate, thank you everyone for joining,
- 1:25:35carving out some time to to spend with us today.
- 1:25:38And and like I said at the beginning, to stay up to date
- 1:25:42with everything that On Ramp is producing from a content
- 1:25:44perspective, future webinars and research, please sign up for our
- 1:25:49research and insights newsletter, which you can find
- 1:25:51just right on the homepage of our website on rampbitcoin.com.
- 1:25:55And also, if you are interested in learning more about our
- 1:25:59products and services and how we can help you with your custody
- 1:26:02set up and all financial services that surround Bitcoin,
- 1:26:06please reach out and and schedule some time to meet with
- 1:26:08our team. And you can find that on our
- 1:26:09homepage as well. But yeah, that's it for today's
- 1:26:13session. Thanks everyone for joining and
- 1:26:15thank you Jesse and Bram for leading the discussion.
- 1:26:18Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:26:21If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:26:23episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:26:26app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:26:28today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:26:31Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onramp Media is
- 1:26:33for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:26:36nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:26:39Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:26:41to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:26:45to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:26:48advisors.