Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Eli Clifton - Senior Advisor & Investigative Journalist | Responsible Statecraft
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to success story. I'm your host, Scott Clary. The success story podcast is part of the
- 0:05HubSpot podcast network. HubSpot has been a huge supporter of the show. They have so many tools
- 0:11that can help your business. The one that I want to just mention today so you go check it out
- 0:15is their new AI chatbot. It's called campaign assistant and it's a totally free to use AI tool
- 0:21made for marketers and business leaders who spend hours a day on content creation.
- 0:26Campaign assistant will transform the way you build marketing campaigns at scale,
- 0:30craft personalized emails, ads and landing pages in a matter of minutes. Just pick the content
- 0:35type, add key selling points and let AI take it from there. It works seamlessly with all of HubSpots
- 0:41marketing and sales tools to scale your output across email, social and more. So AI your way to your
- 0:48most effective campaigns yet at HubSpot.com slash campaign dash assistant.
- 1:05I first got interested in investigative journalism as a product of being a news junkie.
- 1:11I thought journalism sounded like a fascinating line of work to be in and I was fortunate enough
- 1:17to get to intern and later work for a small wire service based in out of their DC bureau
- 1:24called Interpress Service. Part of my job there was to cover think tanks which sounds incredibly
- 1:30boring and wonky and I guess aspects of it are. The thing that maybe I was bored at a lot of these
- 1:38events and I started to look around and see that you know the buildings that these think tanks
- 1:43were and were really nice and they had a lot of expensive catered food and they seem to be paying
- 1:50a lot of their employees a lot of money and they had the names of billionaires and major
- 1:57fortune 500 corporations on plaques and naming their conference centers after companies and
- 2:04individuals with a lot of resources and I started to wonder how is what's the economics of all
- 2:08this how is this all put together and I quickly learned that that's not a question you're really
- 2:12supposed to ask you're just sort of supposed to swim in that you know in that golden trough or
- 2:18whatever it is and enjoy the the perks and not ask too many questions about how all of this is
- 2:25put together and maybe even whose interests are being represented. If you can just describe
- 2:31describe what a think tank is people don't quite understand that concept because people may not
- 2:35have ever experienced this before or really understood how this world works. So one interesting
- 2:39thing about think tanks that people always assume is first of all that there is a definition and
- 2:42that there is such a legal thing as a think tank there is no such thing as the legal entity of a think tank
- 2:47but a lot of research institutions in Washington DC and elsewhere usually in capitals around the world
- 2:54are independent entities that conduct policy research and to be clear the audience the intended
- 3:02audience for this research is really generally not the general public it's policy makers and that's
- 3:09not a bad thing it's a good thing I work at a think tank now I'm I'm I will defend that but it's
- 3:15not academic research you're doing it because you're trying to criminal with policy solutions for
- 3:21policy makers to implement so it's a it's a way that one tries to inject ideas and policies
- 3:27into the policy making process. Okay no that makes sense okay so sorry I didn't interrupt your story
- 3:34I just wanted to understand what that was and yeah the more I started looking at it and I was
- 3:40you know reporting on foreign policy and I could very clearly see that a number of institutions
- 3:44in Washington DC where I was were you know I had a very outsized influence in the foreign policy
- 3:49debate they seem to be generating a lot of the analysis and policy proposals and within a
- 3:56peer before congress as witnesses that we're clearly being implemented it is as policy and I started
- 4:03to report more and more on who was funding these entities and who was trying to shape the foreign
- 4:09policy debate and I think the thing that I always come back to with the foreign policy debate is
- 4:14that you know people think of it as very exotic you know that foreign policy is maybe above normal
- 4:19politics in some ways you know politics ends at the water day just nothing very complex and
- 4:25the more I looked at the more I was realizing you know it's not that it's not different than any other
- 4:29contested policy space at least in American politics and probably in contested politics anywhere in
- 4:35the world you know that there's interests there's private interests there's public interest there's
- 4:39foreign interests and they're all competing the only difference is that we don't talk about it
- 4:46we don't talk about it the same way we pretend that this is somehow just a very fair and pure
- 4:51competition of ideas and that everybody wants the same outcome and if you walked into a room where
- 4:58you had people let's say abortion or same-sex marriage or environmental protection of people who
- 5:06are on opposite ends of the debate and said hey guys I assume you all want the same outcome they
- 5:12would laugh at you of course yes of course yes so in disingenuous place to start the discussion right
- 5:19you guys want different out it's okay right that's all right yeah exactly that's how that's how
- 5:24works so I guess the whole point is you know you're you hope that the policy decisions are that are
- 5:29implemented are done by somebody that represents you and represents your country and you feel
- 5:33that they're you know they're they they've reached a level in their aptitude that they can make
- 5:37those smart decisions and you I think everybody understands that there's going to be money that are
- 5:41funding up opposing ideas constantly you just hope that there's enough money funding both sides
- 5:47and then you come to an educated idea after the data and exactly exactly and I think part of that
- 5:52is is to you know and again in other policy spaces I think we talk about it very openly that there's
- 5:57dark money there's influences people want different outcomes um we we have a pretty good conversation
- 6:02about that and foreign policy I don't think that we do um and I think it's really you know it's
- 6:07it's harmful to to to the United States and probably to other countries as well that we are having
- 6:12you know a more honest conversation about the fact that this is a debate that has people
- 6:17want different outcomes and some of those interests are um you know serving a very narrow group of
- 6:23people or even other countries um and you know that's okay but we should at least be having a
- 6:28conversation about it and that's what that's sort of prompted your career path that's why you
- 6:33started to focus on some of these so some of these foreign policy focus think tanks so you have
- 6:38on both sides people putting money into try and what are they trying to solve for like a it obviously
- 6:44foreign policy is immense and massive so there must be some topics that are uh probably more
- 6:48prevalent than others or is it just there's a think tank for literally every conversation every
- 6:54different problem that's being trying to solve the the the US wants to have a hand in at least
- 7:00influencing some way well you know I think that the diversity of think tanks and of ideas
- 7:06inside the beltway for you know to narrow the scope a little bit it's far more limited than
- 7:12um most people would think um and and and and this kind of goes back to merit area of interest
- 7:17in my area for reporting that you know there really is something called the so-called blob which is
- 7:22what uh Benjamin Rhodes referred to as the um you know sort of the foreign policy establishment and
- 7:28excuse me it's it's politicians it's but it's a lot of people who are these analysts at think tanks
- 7:34and they sort of police what are the acceptable uh uh policy lines to take what are the
- 7:40acceptable objectives that we're trying to pursue and the more closely what I look at it the more
- 7:45I I've seen and I've written about this extensively that it's also kind of the same set of funders
- 7:51throughout you know the weapons companies are major funders of uh of think tanks that work on
- 7:56foreign policy so are uh a small set of foreign countries uh the United United Arab Emirates
- 8:02Taiwan Norway Japan are some of the big foreign funders of think tanks and they don't just fund one
- 8:08think tank um they don't just fund uh progressive or liberal think tanks and cons or conservative
- 8:14think tank they'll want to fund across the spectrum and I don't think it's that big of a coincidence
- 8:18then that you don't see an enormous array of of policy ideas coming out little lone policies that
- 8:24make question the US relationship with let's say uh autocratic countries like the United Arab Emirates
- 8:30or question serious questioning of um the size of the defense budget or about whether we need
- 8:35certain weapon systems that are incredibly expensive um those are the types of conversations that
- 8:40it seems like the conversation around that is very constrained interesting so it's it's almost like
- 8:46if you have certain entities that fund both sides then then you're never going to have a discussion
- 8:52around a certain policy that could actually negatively impact uh that entity but you're going to
- 8:57have seemingly an un seemingly like a perceived unbiased view or unbiased donations towards
- 9:03think tanks because it seems like well we're we're funding uh progressive uh liberal and
- 9:09conservative and republican ideas so how can you say that we've ever been biased
- 9:12exactly because they're funding both sides okay I love wrapping my hand around this because
- 9:17this isn't that new to me so I'm like there's all complete layman in this interesting quality here
- 9:20that you know is you know in journalism or in academia there's kind of some rudimentary concepts
- 9:25of uh uh conflict of interest avoidance um yeah but your comments and stuff like you know let's
- 9:31say one of your funders may stand to benefit from the work that you're doing or the argument you're
- 9:36making you would proactively disclose that and you know academic journals talk about doing it journal
- 9:41newspapers talk about this it doesn't mean you can't publish it doesn't mean you can't make that
- 9:46argument um that's not what it doesn't even mean that there's anything in corrupt going on it just
- 9:50means that to protect yourself you proactively say hey you know there's this financial link over here
- 9:58and that's usually considered very positive but also a common sense thing it basically doesn't
- 10:03exist in Washington uh and I've looked very closely at it and sort of in the foreign policy realm
- 10:08you know regularly you'll see think tanks publishing materials that are beneficial to let's say
- 10:12one of their foreign government funders that's urging closer relations between the united states
- 10:16and that country it doesn't mean it's a bad argument it doesn't mean it's wrong but there is
- 10:21something deeply flawed with a uh you know a set of standards that that seem to say that you don't
- 10:29need to disclose a potential conflict of interest like that and that obviously extends in a major
- 10:34way to the weapons companies that are funding or a lot of the foreign policy research in Washington
- 10:38and and and can't believe like I'm just thinking through like the reason why this would be
- 10:43why you protect yourself is because if that if this ever came to light then obviously your argument
- 10:47or your or your policy is discredited immediately but you're saying the issue is that there's not
- 10:51enough conversation so this stuff doesn't really come exactly exactly yeah your your couple steps
- 10:56ahead of me there yeah that the fact is the conversations are there the scrutiny isn't there
- 11:00and as a result some simple standards that you think that are really really you know rudimentary
- 11:06and that people get their heads around in academia or in journalism just don't exist they get thrown
- 11:11out the window you know I asked a major think tank without naming names here um I have a couple times
- 11:16ask them because I've seen them doing things that are beneficial to their funders and I've said
- 11:19do you guys have a conflict of interest policy they said yeah absolutely and I said well can I see
- 11:24it and I said yeah sure we'll send it over and they send it over and it's a really good in-depth
- 11:30policy dictating how to avoid conflicts of interest between outside work and work being done for
- 11:37the think tank by employees of the think tank but it never crossed their minds that there could be a
- 11:44potential conflict of interest between the funders of the think tank and the work that they're producing
- 11:49I mean it's kind of amazing that they were several steps ahead and they hadn't even thought about
- 11:53a more rudimentary one so this is this is your passion this is what you've gotten so when you start
- 11:59to when you start to go into this world um where do you decide to spend your time what what drives
- 12:04you to look at one thing versus another and also how do you immerse yourself in this world so that
- 12:07you can investigate on something that seems to be just that seems to have no discussion around it
- 12:13well I think that that's that's a large part of it and having frankly a lot of people who
- 12:17who who help flag these things to me you know and say hey there's something interesting going on
- 12:21here because I don't I don't pretend to be an expert let's say on you know the the debate over
- 12:27the how or if there should be an end to the Korean War but um you know people have have have
- 12:32assisted me in being like hey there's something going on here there seems to be you know a flood of
- 12:36money um that is pushing you know in a certain direction and no one's talking about it and I am
- 12:44amazed by how often that happens you know normally if there was no a massive sort of dark money
- 12:50for lack of a better term campaign towards a contested policy issue there would be uh you know
- 12:57some questions and other investigative journalists would would dig into it and I think in foreign
- 13:02policy um again it's sort of seen as a elite it's seen as also maybe not something that it's expected
- 13:09that that every day people are supposed to be paying attention to or engaged with and I think
- 13:14just a lot more flies under the radar for lack of a better term and as an investigative journalist
- 13:18I did the the crudest way of putting it but I think it is also true is that it is a very target
- 13:22rich environment because there's not that many people covering it with a high degree of scrutiny
- 13:28and as a result people by acting incredibly brazen ways um yeah yeah um so what did you that
- 13:38makes it's unfortunate it's not right but it's it's not unexpected I guess really no one's
- 13:45looking at it it's exactly it's it's there's a push pull to this you know when there's more scrutiny
- 13:51I think people generally behave better um when there's less scrutiny they don't have to think about
- 13:56it's not even that they go out there saying I want to be I want to do things unethically but
- 14:02you just don't have to put a lot of thought they don't give it a second thought yeah
- 14:04they don't give it that's they don't give it a second thought at worst they do purposely act
- 14:09unethically and knowingly but yeah that's sort of the that's sort of the gamut of of it unscrupanized
- 14:14and heavily financed um arena like that's so as you okay so as you go into this um this particular
- 14:21story what was the what was the the the point that sort of pushed you or the information or the
- 14:30lack for better word I'm not a journalist so the tip that pointed you in this direction to start
- 14:35to look more into this yeah well I think the thing that there was sort of the first step to be
- 14:41there was definitely a first step here which is that I had colleagues that were flagging that
- 14:45there was this really expensive ad campaign or what appeared to be very expensive involving
- 14:49you know video billboards and times square and newspaper advertisements attacking
- 14:57well I mean the creative president Moon Jae-in and the members of the US Congress who had been trying to
- 15:05excuse me in the case of president Moon he'd been you know talking about what end of
- 15:08Korean war may look like in the case of the US Congress it was some very specific legislation
- 15:14HR3446 and I think it was resolution another one 826 which were pretty innocuous pieces of
- 15:22legislation that's what really jumped out um this this was proposed legislation that would have
- 15:26like one of them would have essentially asked the the State Department to explore what what
- 15:32a kind of war situation might look like you know explore you know what diplomatic engagement with
- 15:38North Korea in pursuit of a binding peace agreement is what the language that it used would
- 15:43would look like yeah that that's all sort of explore that something that it's a 70 year war
- 15:48why are we not pursuing on it makes a pretty good sense there's 30,000 Americans still deployed
- 15:54in South Korea mostly to the DMZ why not pursue that the other legislation was even more innocuous
- 16:01it was I think it was called the Divided Family Reunification Act and it just essentially said
- 16:08the United States government should prioritize efforts to to to to to to for there to be meetings
- 16:15between I guess Korean Americans and and and their family members in North Korea potentially just
- 16:22over video you know via zoom or something stuff that I can't imagine really finding this to be
- 16:29at all offensive um and as I looked at this story I was like well yeah for who who would possibly
- 16:34put in Times Square billboards about this um is someone who's pretty passionate somebody
- 16:40very passionate this big old topic yeah um and what is this and and and and then the next two steps
- 16:46really um maybe really think I was not there or something here which was seeing that well for
- 16:52starters it was um there were sort of two sponsors of this one was called the One Korea Network
- 16:56which I had never heard of before and I went and looked and they have this website and it's just
- 17:00chock full of conspiracy theories um a lot of them attacking sort of leftists in South Korea but also
- 17:08being very very very pro-Trump attacking people in the left of the United States and and promoting
- 17:13election conspiracy theories both in South Korea and in the United States um and the other
- 17:21co-sponsor was something called KC PAC which was the Korean conservative political action conference
- 17:26which was an offshoot of a very well-known uh conservative group here in the United States called
- 17:32the consists called CPAC the conservative political action conference uh which holds an annual
- 17:36conference in Washington it was like well why is there a Korean version of this um and then the more
- 17:41I sort of dug into this the more it became clear that you know all of this came back to one woman
- 17:45who had founded both one Korean network and I think it was the chair of both one Korean
- 17:50network and of um KC PAC and her name was Annie MH Chan she was a very very wealthy woman living
- 17:59in Honolulu who had sold bought and sold very expensive properties in Hawaii as well as in California
- 18:07and she and her then husband back in California had over the past several decades being in and
- 18:12out of various technology related businesses and it clearly accumulated you know a fortune that
- 18:18runs into the hundreds of millions of dollars and okay that's interesting but I was like
- 18:25clearly that you know she must not maybe she just wrote it in the background here still
- 18:29still not having a war like I'm sure there's like a thread that runs between all this but it still
- 18:33doesn't make sense to me why um because you know you said KC PAC and CPAC and and right wing and
- 18:39and somebody's associated with conspiracy theories it still doesn't make sense to me and you'll get
- 18:44to that I'm just sure in a second how this all ties back to like North Korea South Korea and
- 18:50bills that really don't do anything negative for anyone like it's all net positive like I don't
- 18:55understand why somebody on the right or the left would be against zoom calls with family members
- 19:00and it doesn't make sense right well well first I'll give you the most sort of innocent innocuous
- 19:06explanation which is I actually think that she genuinely believes this stuff uh you know I've
- 19:11seen a letter that she wrote to Donald Trump um I've seen things she signed on to reports she's
- 19:17signed on to that you know she very much believes that there is a vast conspiracy involving uh uh
- 19:23Chinese and North Korean agents inside the United States and in South Korea who are perpetrating
- 19:29acts of election fraud to uh fundamentally undermine both South Korea and the United States
- 19:35so they can be overrun by by the Chinese and the North Koreans um which I mean I I guess
- 19:41ones entitled to hold that view I don't think there's a lot of evidence to support it um the
- 19:46thing that things get a little more concerning when um I started to look at some of her business
- 19:52interests and she was involved in something called IP3 international which was a uh civilian nuclear
- 19:59firm based here in the United States that was uh involved a few years ago in a rather sketchy
- 20:07to try to export a sensitive civilian nuclear technology to Saudi Arabia it was blocked it was a
- 20:15scandal Mike Flynn was involved um and they had pivoted since then towards trying to uh build up a
- 20:22business continuing to export civilian nuclear technology but justifying the proliferation of
- 20:29these small reactors on the basis that if they're that in a world with great power competition
- 20:36where the United States is challenged by China and Russia that uh energy is going to be a component
- 20:42of this competition and the only way to compete is to uh approve the export of these sensitive
- 20:48technologies to Europe into the Middle East uh technologies which incidentally South Korea has
- 20:54quite a bit of as well and they were going to do this in partnership with South Korean um uh nuclear
- 20:59power firms so there is a profit dimension to what she was doing or at least it appears that way
- 21:05where she was saying you know the South the Chinese are coming to get us the North Koreans are
- 21:10coming to get us um and at one level it's you know if this is purely philanthropic or interests
- 21:16and she's funding these and news outlet that's publishing you know basically fake news
- 21:21just outlandish conspiracy theories about the elections um she's publishing reports
- 21:27alongside really conspiracy theory oriented organizations in Washington that we're talking about
- 21:33election fraud in the in the 2020 election that again are totally baseless um and in the other
- 21:41on over here then she's engaged in being involved in a company that says it's going to profit
- 21:47effectively from great power competition in the world so it sort of is like the ugly underside of
- 21:53when people talk about great power competition when people talk about um you know uh uh approving
- 21:59the export of nuclear technologies for that purpose you know you don't get there without making
- 22:05people afraid you don't maybe you don't get there organically to have that type of a hostile
- 22:10relationship between countries maybe it needs a little bit of a nut it's funny though and
- 22:15that's where I see you what she was doing and I think it's kind of sinister it is it is sinister
- 22:19and and I'm just curious why it feels like there's a need to do this because I don't think
- 22:24the average American has a positive view of North Korea anyways I don't think that I don't think
- 22:30but I feel like this is actually instigating fear in an incorrect way like I feel like the actual
- 22:37things that she's campaigning against those have nothing to do with North Korea and their policies
- 22:44and I feel like North Korea really doesn't have any uh ability to significantly impact the US in
- 22:49any meaningful way at all but I mean like nobody looks at North Korea and is like oh that's a
- 22:53you know that's a place that I'd want to go on a trip right like no they haven't really
- 22:56done a lot of great stuff for them for themselves but still to do that is just hurting it's it's
- 23:01it's instigating fear it's creating fear it's hurting people that those bills are actually trying
- 23:05to help which are the people that are actually living in North Korea that are not the bad guys in
- 23:10North Korea they're just the families that are there trying to live their life right well I mean
- 23:16I think in a sense the uphill battle that she is fighting is even harder than what you just
- 23:23portrayed now I agree most Americans don't don't wake up and and say you know wow I'm really
- 23:31concerned that the North Koreans are coming to get me or I believe that North Korea and the Chinese
- 23:37are subverting our elections true yeah um but I think the problem that maybe she is up against
- 23:46and I think a lot of people who are concerned about you know the talk about wanting to sort of
- 23:52fan the flames again of these of these conflicts are that the public is actually shifting away
- 23:59from being sympathetic to those views so maybe there's a need to overcompensate and and and I
- 24:04I would sort of look back at polling data that shows you know 70 percent of South Koreans you know
- 24:08have basically said they agreed with President Moon's proposal to end the Korean War and Americans
- 24:13are also you know pretty tired of of the endless wars that have defined the past the past in two
- 24:20decades you know nearly nearly two-thirds of Americans who are under 30 you know believe the US
- 24:26should respond to China's rise by decreasing US troop presence in Asia which is and that number is
- 24:33growing of Americans who who feel that way and you know over and a growing number of Americans
- 24:39also think United States should make greater effort to engage in diplomacy in as a leading
- 24:44component of US foreign policy so I think that there's a that people like her and people who
- 24:52not just stand up potentially profit from great power competition but genuinely probably believe
- 24:56that these countries are hell bent on destroying not just the United States but apparently South Korea as
- 25:04well must look at that data must look at the trends look at the fact that you know look in the
- 25:09last presidential election candidates like Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders both of whom are very
- 25:15critical of you know the endless wars that have been waged by the United States see which will
- 25:21but either those candidates you know they both were consistent with that messaging I think they see
- 25:26that and it probably concerns them a great deal what I think where I think things kind of go off
- 25:30the rails is that maybe they feel that the situation is getting so that they are losing control of
- 25:36the narrative to such a degree that it necessitates some really extreme frankly absurd
- 25:43types of messaging and outright lives a quick break from this podcast to recommend another podcast
- 25:49we have to check out it's called the product boss is hosted by Jacqueline and Mina it's part of the
- 25:53HubSpot podcast network if you have a physical product this podcast is hyper tailored to you it's
- 26:00going to help you take your business to the next level in a recent episode for example
- 26:04you spoke about the power of TikTok for product businesses and how to use it to drive sales and
- 26:09as somebody who is a little new to TikTok I really learned some great tips for creating content
- 26:14that actually converts viewers into customers they have a workshop style format that makes it
- 26:20really easy to follow along to take your business to the next level so if you sell physical
- 26:24products subscribe to the product boss wherever you get your podcast to unlock social media
- 26:29marketing and business strategies that create your dream business and then your dream life which
- 26:34is which is horrible because as always with with any with any fear there's like there's some you
- 26:42know like that sometimes there's levels to whether or not that's valid or not but I think you have
- 26:47to uncover like the truth in that particular fear so for example like in some parts of the world
- 26:54I'm sure countries don't love the US but other parts I'm sure the cut it's not as bad as we think
- 26:58it is but when you do things like this I feel like it polarizes people it does exactly it again like
- 27:05exactly what you said it it removes people's ability to think for themselves critically because
- 27:10the facts are so absurd and it removes proper understanding of foreign policy because the foreign
- 27:16policy that's presented is so abstract and absurd and polarizing that you feel like that you have to
- 27:22go all the way to one end of the spectrum or the other and that's where you have to sit where the
- 27:26truth is probably like somewhere more in the middle somewhere more moderate like I'm sure like I
- 27:30like again I said this before I don't think North Korea like loves the US but I don't think I don't
- 27:36think China's relationship is as bad as definitely as North Korea is definitely not but I do believe
- 27:40that by having these types of campaigns not only is it serving like a very selfish a selfish
- 27:46initiative but also it removes people's ability to think for themselves well and critically and
- 27:51that's the worst thing about it it basically dumps down the it dumps down the message to extreme
- 27:56opposites exactly and you're dumbing it down in a way that's it's so and I think you just hit
- 28:02the nail on the head here it's it's centered on a feature horrible you know that where you look
- 28:07at what one Korean network in KC pack and you know sort of the network of Annie Chan was producing
- 28:13it's telling people basically that their political identity their cultural identity their national
- 28:20identity is all under threat which is not true and it's coming from the Chinese and the North
- 28:25Koreans and the only solution is to back you know basically you know right-wing nationalists
- 28:32in in both countries and to oppose even the most innocuous attempts at diplomacy and that's
- 28:40pretty concerning you know that that that that those are some dangerous threads that she's pulling
- 28:46and I think that you know again I go back to the election conspiracy stuff that's really disturbing
- 28:52to see that you know she was pushing and one Korean network and and other folks in her network
- 28:57were pushing theories about the election in South Korea that was before the US election in 2020
- 29:03and that the those conspiracy theories were ones that were later present in the United States
- 29:12and I think it's you know we think that a lot of it you know it's United States we you know we kind
- 29:15of think in the insular way sometimes when we think that these you know crazy conspiracy theories
- 29:20about Chinese vote tampering are you know entirely something produced by and for Americans for the
- 29:27American election and that that's where it came out of and instead you see that no some of this
- 29:31was actually going on in South Korea earlier you know a lot of these theories didn't just come out
- 29:36of nowhere I'm not saying that you know that that they were you know the same people running them
- 29:41in both countries but it was absolutely in South Korea before the United States some of those theories
- 29:46and she was a very vocal person who was amplifying them and and I think that you know it may explain
- 29:52to some degree the role with which you know those those became so prevalent here to give an example
- 29:58Trump's rally in Tulsa in which in I guess it was maybe June of 2020 got a lot of attention
- 30:05because Korean K-pop fans and and teen users of TikTok bottle the tickets it was really funny
- 30:13the Trump campaign thought that they were like going to have overflow exactly after lockdowns
- 30:20from the pandemic and and they were like you know they they had like overflow capacity in the
- 30:25parking lot because they had like sold out three times over on the arena on the tickets
- 30:29and and then like nobody showed up because of these K-pop and and and teens K-pop fans and teens
- 30:35on TikTok bottle the tickets was hilarious and you know even within the Trump campaign there was
- 30:40you know there's emails leaked out where they were talking about everyone knows what happened
- 30:43after the fact at least except this woman who was publishing you know in this letter she wrote
- 30:48a Donald Trump she was claiming that the that actually this was the work of you know of of of
- 30:55North Korean and Chinese intelligence um you mean that type of a mindset like really really
- 31:02out of touch really she's applying that prism to everything that she's seen and that's and like
- 31:06very very much out of touch with reality but also very wealthy and that's dangerous that's very
- 31:11dangerous absolutely and you know this yeah exactly so well I mean so she has these crazy views
- 31:16that's fine you know there's no shortage of people that probably hold these views unfortunately
- 31:21however this is somebody who put you know around a million dollars probably now over a million dollars
- 31:26into this effort and that's where it starts to get a little bit scary that you know how can this
- 31:31person who can bring these types of resources to bear be essentially a ghost largely unknown
- 31:39um you know welcomed onto the board of this Virginia very close to Washington DC based nuclear
- 31:44power company that has former diplomats uh former senior military officials on it involved in it
- 31:51yeah that this is kind of disturbing that you can see how the combination of money some kind of
- 31:57radical views and frankly people just not paying a lot of attention uh to who's funding these
- 32:04things and what they're saying could let someone like that really move in a lot of different circles
- 32:09and starts to seriously influence the policy debate so so we understand the issue
- 32:14and we understand uh what what she did and and and some of the reasons is to is to why she did it um
- 32:20but what's what's the solution like what like you're you're one journalist and as much as you can
- 32:25pick one story at a time and one person to focus on at a time that's a lot of work for one person
- 32:32so how do we actually move the needle on this stuff how do we create more exposure how do we hold
- 32:36people accountable so that this doesn't this doesn't poison the minds of people and doesn't
- 32:45create that fear god knows we've had enough of it in the past three years we don't need anymore
- 32:50so what do we do well you know i think part of it is exposing ourselves to these stories
- 32:56reading them uh and recognizing that for every one of these stories that that we do discover
- 33:02and hear about there's probably a dozen more um i think it's the idea and i think people are
- 33:08becoming a tune to the fact that dark money is actively involved in shaping the US political
- 33:13debate um and i would hope that as we do that it starts to make it something that
- 33:21sort of gatekeepers as it were at major institutions as well as in media start to uh pay attention to
- 33:29and so i guess there's that there's that answer which is that i hope we're facing a cultural shift
- 33:34here and i think that you know for the most part people skepticism about the role of money in politics
- 33:38has has really been helpful um in in that respect that when i write a story like this i'm not just
- 33:44starting from scratch explaining how you know money people with moneyed interests may want to
- 33:49influence the political system in a ways that are beneficial to them and actually detrimental to
- 33:53the majority of americans um or in this case people in south korea as well so i think there is
- 33:59that quality that the more we see these stories the more they get reported the the more we start to
- 34:03look at this with a critical eye but i think there's another dimension here and this is something that
- 34:08i've i've started to to to engage with more i wrote a report last year about this which is that
- 34:14you know we do need to have some ethical standards in the institutions in Washington dc that
- 34:19oftentimes shape the foreign policy debate um and the policy debate more broadly because most
- 34:24think tanks don't just do foreign policy um and that's that as we were going back to earlier
- 34:29that think tanks really need to to implement certain fundamental transparency standards which means
- 34:34showing who your funders are would be on major one uh and and i will say that there has been
- 34:40really good does a really good trend with that which is that i'd say in the past 10 years the vast
- 34:45majority of think tanks in Washington especially the big ones are disclosing their funding
- 34:50and that's a huge huge huge positive development to be as i was saying earlier they don't have
- 34:55their legal status is that they are a 501c3 which is a non-profit that has no obligation to disclose
- 35:00their funders so they need to voluntarily do it and they are um second i would like to see them
- 35:07actually comply with the foreign agent registration act which to in sort of broad terms is a law
- 35:12we have in the United States which which says that you know if you're acting as the agent of a foreign
- 35:16principle um you need to disclose that and what does that what does that mean exactly because that
- 35:22because because in this particular case that wasn't the case she's resident of Hawaii of so she's not
- 35:27even uh a foreign agent in her case it is in her case it wouldn't have mattered but in terms of
- 35:32the foreign policy debate more broadly it goes on it's pretty prevalent you know that we have
- 35:36think tanks that are taking foreign money and they produce content that is designed to influence
- 35:43policy and often that is um you know part of conditional grants given to them by foreign
- 35:48governments and uh and they basically have refused to file to disclose that under the foreign
- 35:53agent registration act so it's also complying with the law what i think help a lot with the with
- 35:58with with with how the debate is conducted and and finally and i think this does kind of go back
- 36:05to somebody like Annie Chan the idea of a conflict of interest is something that um most people
- 36:13understand and Annie Chan has a big one which is that she was a board member of a company
- 36:19that stood to benefit financially and it talked about how it would benefit from great power
- 36:26competition as she called as they call it um with with Russia and China and the work that she
- 36:33was actively involved in producing at one Korean network and KC PAC was pretty explicitly about
- 36:39furthering that agenda you know pushing out crazy conspiracy theories about the role of China
- 36:45pushing out the idea that even the nuclear power was part of a solution to that uh to that
- 36:50competition and would give the United States an advantage so that's actually stuff that they
- 36:53published at one Korean network while never disclosing that the chair of this organization uh in this
- 37:00news outlet um had potentially uh an opportunity to profit from that argument and those policies
- 37:09and policies that would come from it and i think that starting to have an open conversation about
- 37:14conflict of interest is probably the most important thing we can do and it's something that um
- 37:19uh folks again inform policy about a nathema too and i think in other policy areas there's a little
- 37:24more awareness of it and i think that this is just a glaring example of somebody who stood to
- 37:30make a lot of money potentially from uh bringing out some of the worst uh policies that we could come
- 37:35up with uh prolonging a war that a lot of Americans think we need to end and then a lot of people in
- 37:41South Korea uh would like to see uh come to an end as well i mean endless war in on the Korean
- 37:47peninsula is really not in uh very many people's um uh interest maybe maybe for Andy Chan and her
- 37:55business associates it was and and maybe just help me understand like i probably should have asked
- 37:59this a bit earlier but when you say that she puts up a billboard and time square and she spends
- 38:04about a million dollars even that seems inconsequential in the grand scheme of things like can you
- 38:09change an entire country's perspective on a particular thing with a a a million dollar budget
- 38:14because i i know how much it would cost to reach that many people repeatedly to actually influence
- 38:18so it doesn't need to be a lot more than that or is it significant
- 38:23in the foreign policy debate it's significant uh a lot of and i think this is a great example
- 38:28actually of why it's significant because a lot of the time that we're talking about when you think
- 38:34about the budgets that are required to move policy generally we're talking about policy areas where
- 38:40there's a lot of attention on it where it's already in the media where it's already top of mind
- 38:45for a lot of Americans um and where there are uh very well-defined um uh parties pushing on both sides
- 38:54so there is a that's a very expensive competition to be involved in uh you know the most expensive
- 39:00example would be American presidential elections where you know a billion dollars is you know
- 39:06kind of where the budget is headed towards for some of these campaigns uh it's incredibly costly
- 39:12partially because it's contested and i think in this example it's a good example of where
- 39:17you know these were advertisements that were targeting specific members of congress
- 39:22doing so uh to try to reach out i think to korean americans and get them to call their members of
- 39:28congress how many korean american members of congress call any given member on a day with a specific
- 39:36policy ask about a piece of legislation involving uh video calls with uh to know not many not many
- 39:46not many you don't need to mobilize a lot of people uh if you could make some noise if you can
- 39:54scare some people if you can mobilize them you're going to be moving them to press on a member of
- 40:00congress where foreign policy is definitely not their top priority because most of it i don't think
- 40:05there's a single congressional race that is determined by foreign policy um so this is this is
- 40:11this is not generally a top issue for a member of congress it's not generally a top issue for a voter
- 40:17and if you can get in there and apply a little bit of pressure and make people a little bit uncomfortable
- 40:22there is definitely a possibility that you can have outsized impact so i think one of the reasons
- 40:27that relatively small sums of money can make a big difference in foreign policy is that while
- 40:32objectively the stakes are high it's matters of war and peace often um the number of actors are
- 40:40limited the target audience is limited the number of people paying attention is limited and all of
- 40:47that could mean that the total cost don't have to be that high so that's that's even scarier to be
- 40:52honest it is scarier exactly it makes it just a rip for people like Annie Chan and people who have
- 40:59pretty radical views on foreign policy to say hey you know what maybe there's a number of different
- 41:04policy areas that i have an interest in i know i want to make the biggest bank for my buck that i
- 41:08can foreign policy might be where it's at has there been any has she been held accountable for
- 41:15anything since your story has been published has there been any action taken at all she's been
- 41:20removed she's been been she appears to have been removed from the board of the nuclear company
- 41:25she they they've deleted her photo name and profile from their website okay well that's
- 41:30something they're not responding to me when i've asked about what happened um one of the one of the
- 41:35points in the article that i thought was interesting just to provide a little bit of context about
- 41:40how big this issue is you mentioned uh Chan appears to be borrowing borrowing from a well-worn
- 41:44playbook in her efforts to inject money into the US political system to generate personal profits
- 41:48while also influencing influencing a lead opinion to steer foreign policy and
- 41:52militaristic direction east Asia how often does stuff like this happen for people that aren't aware
- 42:00it happens often and it happens at the um the upper echelons of political funding
- 42:10um i think the best example that i point to is uh excuse me is um the late uh sheldon adelson
- 42:19who was the top the top funder of the republican party he was so for many election cycles
- 42:24um and the coverage of his giving to to again i'm gonna bring my media criticism here
- 42:30of his political giving was people that there were every single election cycle he he and his wife
- 42:35Miriam who is going to continue to give apparently at a high level in the republican party um and
- 42:40the two of them to be clear were the biggest funders have not just the presidential racist but also
- 42:44congressional racists for the republican party and there would always be these speculations about
- 42:49why do they give their money and these they would say well you know hey they have interest in the
- 42:53gaming industry you know they have one of the biggest casino firms united states and and and
- 42:58Macau and you know well maybe they care about gaming regulation it's a possibility another
- 43:04speculation was that maybe they did it because they they wanted to get the estate tax lowered so
- 43:10they could pass on more money to their children which is a possibility all totally fair
- 43:14speculations for people somebody who was worth you know tens of billions of dollars
- 43:19but we never talked about or at least the mainstream media never really gave too much
- 43:23credence to the fact that he had actually been pretty clear about why he gave the money which was
- 43:27foreign policy um and it was about you know maintaining uh US support not just for Israel but for
- 43:35Israel's you know right wing liquid party in some pretty radical respects Sheldon Adelson
- 43:41talked about that he thought that the US negotiating position with Iran should be to drop a
- 43:44nuclear weapon on on in the Iranian desert as he put it and tell them that the second one is
- 43:50going to fall on Tehran if they don't give up their nuclear program um these are people who
- 43:56went on to lobby for the for the release of Jonathan Pollard convicted spy um that the US
- 44:04intelligence agencies had been very adamant should not be released and certainly his the terms
- 44:08of his parole when he was let out of prison shouldn't let him leave the country um and the
- 44:13Adelson's actively you know we're very open about the fact they were lobbying for his for his
- 44:17release and for his parole to be lifted so he could leave the United States he was spied for
- 44:22Israel and they flew him on one of their private planes to Israel in the last days of the Trump
- 44:27administration um so they did these things openly you know they talked about it new gingrich who
- 44:32is a recipient of their money said you know their top issue is foreign policy and it's
- 44:36it's about you know maintaining US support for Israel so I think it happens at the top levels
- 44:43of the party and we saw during the Iran nuclear deal debate in 2015 that you know the Republican
- 44:48party fell in line effectively with where Sheldon Adelson was uh because he funded every single one
- 44:53of their campaigns um and we saw it in the presidential election in 2016 when Donald Trump after
- 45:01saying initially that he was not going to take Sheldon Adelson's money and that he was really
- 45:05thought the United States should be a neutral arbiter in the Israeli Palestinian conflict and his
- 45:09main complaint about the Iran nuclear deal was that uh Iran wasn't buying too many air bus
- 45:14planes and not enough Boeing planes uh turned around and said you know after he won the nomination
- 45:19and he needed to shuttle out Sheldon Adelson's money he reversed course on all of that
- 45:25ended up abrogating from the nuclear deal uh very much in Adelson's encouragement
- 45:29so to go back to sort of where I concluded with that story about you know that this is a time this
- 45:35is this is a this is a strategy that has been utilized a great deal um and I I think it happens
- 45:41at the top level of the political process again because there's not a lot of scrutiny about it
- 45:46people don't pay as much attention as they should before policy and money talks it works
- 45:53it really works and I think people like Sheldon Adelson and to maybe you know and more
- 45:59limited model for looking somebody like Annie Chan they know what they're doing and they know that
- 46:05we see these sums of money and say how could you shift U.S. foreign policy with it and they would
- 46:10say well because because that's quite easily yeah um yeah and again you look at Sheldon Adelson
- 46:16I think he shapes the Republican Party it shapes shaped because he died last year but he
- 46:20shaped the Republican Party's foreign policy platform quite effectively and people openly it's
- 46:27not a secret that he did this um to to to wrap this up because I want to go into some rapid
- 46:32fire just to close it out just to pull it from your insights but with with your work and and what
- 46:38you've done over your career and some of the things you've exposed and and investigated
- 46:43what did you what do you hope will sort of like what do you hope you will accomplish or you will
- 46:49be able to accomplish in your career what do you want your legacy to be when people speak about your
- 46:54work in a hundred years from now what do you want them to say I want to it's not a um it's not the
- 47:05sexy answer but there is no sexy answer do you answer whatever you want it to be that's important
- 47:11I want to normalize the foreign policy debate okay I think it should be normal I think we should
- 47:17uh it's okay if it's partisan it's okay if people have different views it's okay if people want
- 47:21different outcomes but let's stop pretending that it's something else let's stop pretending that
- 47:28the adults are in the room and they all want the same outcome and they're all pulling in the same
- 47:33direction and and the differences are really just differences of how we're gonna execute on this
- 47:37it's not a matter of wanting different outcomes it's unhealthy uh it gets you bad policy I think it tends
- 47:44to steer the United States towards uh not questioning the mistakes that it's made in the past and
- 47:50frankly I think it leads toward the United States being involved in endless wars if you're not willing
- 47:54to question the policies you've pursued no it's very smart so I think normalizing that debate
- 48:00broadening it so you can bring in more voices getting rid of some of the gatekeepers on it um
- 48:06and acknowledging that hey there's money to interest here there's foreign interests here
- 48:10there's people who who who want conflict because it happens to be good for their bottom line
- 48:15you know the weapons firms do not want peace any chance does not want peace she is very clear she's
- 48:20involved in a business that wants a great power competition I don't think you should outlaw that
- 48:25but people should know it but I think we should be able to at least at least we should know
- 48:28what we should talk about it you know and not pretend that this is a very clean space that's
- 48:33somehow different than other dimensions of uh uh the US political debate uh people want to
- 48:39connect with you where should they go all the social website all that stuff social
- 48:44Eli Clifton on Twitter uh check me out there I publish a responsible statecraft org which is the
- 48:51publication of the Quincy Institute which I was involved in founding I'm very proud of it
- 48:56it's an awesome think tank that tries to promote policies that will uh have the United States engaging
- 49:03with the rest of the rest with the rest of the world with vigorous diplomacy instead of with
- 49:07endless war um and uh I like to think that we're part of normalizing that political amazing okay
- 49:13good all right it's a couple of rabbit farted closes out so vigorous challenge yeah yeah perfect
- 49:18um biggest challenge you've overcome in your own personal life what was it had you overcome it
- 49:22what you learned from it that's a good one uh the biggest challenge um writing things
- 49:30that I thought were meaningful that nobody found interesting I think that's actually the biggest
- 49:35challenge in my work and I think that made me want to just give up on it sometimes is when you
- 49:40think you have something meaningful to say and you think you've done some interesting research
- 49:44and um and it's just not something that others see as meaningful and I I know that's sort of a
- 49:51broad thing it's not a creative though any creator but it's the biggest challenge as a journalist
- 49:55is like you know when you feel like you're just banging your head against a wall how do you how do
- 49:58you keep going like what drives you where do you find that motivation to write the next one
- 50:03it's the hope that the next one will will redeem that you know it's that hope that that
- 50:09you know it's being a gambler to some degree right it's that you want that dopamine hit and it's
- 50:13well maybe I missed um maybe I didn't tell the story the right way maybe maybe there was nothing
- 50:19I could do and I just picked the wrong story to tell um but it's it's the it's the it's the
- 50:25wanting to redeem oneself from the stories that that didn't that didn't hit if you had to choose
- 50:30one person obviously there's been many pick one person who's had a major impact on your career
- 50:34on your life who was it what did they teach you oh one person um I mean I would have to give credit
- 50:40to to to Jim Loeb who uh you know was the first person to give me an opportunity to do journalism
- 50:46he was the bureau chief in Washington DC at Interpress Service and he encouraged me to go to those
- 50:51think tanks and not just start writing up the reports and the press releases verbatim and start
- 50:56to dig into who was behind this who was paying for it who was financing it uh if you had to
- 51:04recommend a book or a podcast something that's impacted your life um book or a podcast um I would
- 51:14say for I would I'm far more drawn I mean I listen to variety podcasts but I do think the books
- 51:20have you know a timeless element to them um so I guess there's a few that that really do
- 51:28um jump out at me dark money is is it just an incredible one what's it about just a people know
- 51:34that it's it's about the role of dark money by by vain mayor um and she digs into the
- 51:44uh networks that have funded the American political debate in ways that um that the shape
- 51:51policy outcomes that affect everyday Americans um and I think it's uh I think it's very very powerful
- 51:58other books that that I've really that that have done so much for I think shaping my world view
- 52:04would be king leopold's ghost which is amazing the story of the Belgian Congo again at how
- 52:09decisions made a continental way can impact the lives of so many people um on the other side of the
- 52:15world um and and finally I would I would point to to to Steve Cole's uh books the uh ghost wars
- 52:25the binladens um which offered degree of um of detail and storytelling about about the endless
- 52:36wars especially in Afghanistan but also al-Qaeda and the global war on terror um in a way that I
- 52:42can't recommend highly enough you know that just you you feel like you're you feel like you're there
- 52:47for for events that are occurring you feel like you get to understand the ins and outs of the binladen
- 52:50family and about al-Qaeda and about the u.s. war in Afghanistan uh in ways that I think
- 52:55of more people had um had understood at that level we probably wouldn't have engaged in in two
- 53:01decades of of endless wars and failed nation building very good um if you could tell your 20-year-old
- 53:07self one thing what would it be piss more people off it's fun and i love that the most part it
- 53:13it pays it pays dividends um you know the journalism that that gets you those angry phone calls
- 53:21the number of times you get told you'll never work in this town again are are all are all
- 53:26badges on her and i love those phone calls and last but i've learned to love those phone calls
- 53:32i've learned to love those phone calls i think i think i think when you expose people or when you
- 53:37when you bring things to let you have to have tough skin it's not easy it's not easy at all yeah
- 53:42yeah and i and i used to actually despite the fact that i love the research and i love exposing
- 53:47things i used to dread those calls and those emails and um and now to the opposite now i look
- 53:53forward to them uh in last question what is success mean to you success to me means getting to
- 54:00do what one loves you know you only you only have one life and um i'm i'm very very fortunate that uh
- 54:09i've gotten to do things that i find meaningful and that i really enjoy uh and i think that's a
- 54:15privilege uh that probably most people don't don't get to have uh and you know every day that i'm
- 54:22doing what i'm doing i'm just incredibly grateful that i get to do it uh i think a lot of times
- 54:27in journalism you know it's uh there's not a lot of jobs out there and every time i see somebody
- 54:32that's good at it get the opportunity i always you know right that that email but you know hey
- 54:38you know congratulations but you know also just you know just remember this is this is incredible
- 54:44you know most most people don't get to do this i agree uh and it's it's pretty cool when you get to