Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Directed Share Programs to Woo Institutional Investors
Transcript
- Lucas: When a company goes public, the IPO is just the beginning. The real work of managing the shareholder base happens in the years after — and one of the more subtle tools for that is something called a directed share program, or DSP. It's an allocation mechanism that companies use during follow-on offerings to steer shares toward specific institutional investors. Luna: So it's not just 'we're selling more stock, here's the prospectus, anyone can buy.' The company actually hand-picks who gets in on the deal. Lucas: Exactly. And it's become more common among post ipo tech companies. Look at Palantir — it's up about four percent in the past five days, trading around $134. When it did a follow-on offering last year, it used a directed share program to allocate a chunk of the offering to a handful of long-only funds. The idea is to build a stable, institutional shareholder base that won't flip the stock on the first pop. Luna: Right, because the alternative is you sell into the market, maybe the stock gets volatile, and you end up with a lot of retail or hedge fund holders who might not stick around. Lucas: That's the thinking. A directed share program lets the company and its underwriters target investors who have a reputation for holding through cycles. It's a form of relationship investing. The company gets to decide, 'We want this pension fund or this mutual fund to be a long-term partner, so we're going to give them priority access to the offering.' Luna: But there's a trade-off, right? If you're giving a few investors preferential access, you're potentially leaving other shareholders — or the broader market — out of the allocation. And that can create resentment. Lucas: It can. And that's why DSPs are controversial. Critics say they create a two-tiered system where insiders and favored institutions get better terms. But proponents argue that building a committed shareholder base actually benefits all shareholders in the long run — because you get less volatility and more alignment between management and owners. Luna: I remember Airbnb used a directed share program in its 2021 follow-on. At the time, they were trading around $150 — it's at $148 now, so not far off. They allocated shares to a group of travel-focused funds. Lucas: Right. And that was a smart fit — if you're a travel platform, you want investors who understand the travel industry and can be patient through pandemic cycles. The DSP let Airbnb handpick those investors rather than leaving it to the book-building process alone. Luna: So how does it actually work mechanically? I mean, in an IPO, the underwriters build a book and allocate shares. In a follow-on, who decides who gets the directed shares? Lucas: The company and its underwriters work together. Typically, the company submits a list of proposed investors to the underwriters. The underwriters then do their due diligence — they check whether those investors have the capacity to buy, whether they have any regulatory issues, and whether they're likely to hold. Then the allocation is made at the offering price. Luna: And the offering price is usually at a discount to the market, right? To entice buyers. Lucas: Exactly. In a typical follow-on, the offering price is set at a discount of maybe three to five percent to the last sale. So the directed share recipients get that discount. That's part of the incentive. But they also get the signal that the company wants them as a partner. That can be valuable in itself. Luna: It's kind of like an IPO version of 'we want you on our cap table.' Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just about the allocation. Often, the company will also enter into lock-up agreements with those investors — they agree not to sell for a certain period, say 90 days or six months. That gives the market confidence that there won't be a flood of supply right after the offering. Luna: Let's talk about the regulatory side. Are there any rules around who can get directed shares? I know the SEC has guidelines about fair allocation. Lucas: The SEC requires that allocations be made in a way that is not unfairly discriminatory. Underwriters have to have a reasonable basis for why one investor gets a directed allocation and another doesn't. But the rules are fairly flexible — the company can legitimately say, 'This investor is a long-term holder, they have a track record of supporting management, they add strategic value.' That's generally acceptable. Luna: I think the tricky part is when the directed shares go to friends of the CEO or board members. Then it starts to look like favoritism rather than strategy. Lucas: That's the criticism. There have been cases where directed share programs were used to reward business partners or even personal acquaintances of executives. That's where it crosses a line. But in practice, most companies are careful because they don't want the reputational risk or a shareholder lawsuit. Luna: Let's talk about Coinbase. It's up almost six percent in the past five days, trading near $168. When they did a convertible note offering last year, they didn't use a DSP — they went with a traditional convertible. But they could have used one. What's the deciding factor? Lucas: Usually it comes down to the type of offering. Directed share programs are most common in follow-on equity offerings, not convertibles. In a convertible, the buyer is often a hedge fund that's more focused on the arbitrage than on long-term ownership. But in an equity offering, you can target long-only funds. So the type of investor you want determines whether a DSP makes sense. Luna: And the size of the offering matters too, right? If it's a small offering, it's not worth the administrative hassle. Lucas: Exactly. For a $50 million offering, the underwriters might not want to bother with a DSP. But for a $1 billion follow-on, it's standard practice. The larger the offering, the more likely you'll see a DSP component — sometimes up to 20 percent of the deal. Luna: I want to bring up a specific example from last year. When Snowflake did a $2 billion follow-on, they used a DSP to allocate about $400 million to a select group of institutional investors. I remember the stock was volatile at the time, and the company said the DSP helped stabilize the shareholder base. Lucas: That's a great case. Snowflake was coming off a big run-up, and they wanted to lock in some patient capital. The DSP allowed them to hand-pick investors who had a long-term view on cloud data warehousing. And it worked — the stock remained relatively stable after the offering, which is exactly what they wanted. Luna: So for a company thinking about a follow-on, what's the checklist? When should they consider a DSP? Lucas: First, do you have a clear strategic rationale for wanting specific investors on your cap table? If the answer is yes — maybe you want industry experts, or you want to replace short-term holders with longer-term ones — then a DSP is worth considering. Second, is the offering large enough to justify the extra work? Third, do you have the relationships to identify the right investors? If you don't know who you want to target, you probably shouldn't be doing a DSP. Luna: And there's a timing element too. If the stock is very volatile, it's harder to price the offering, and the discount might not be enough to attract even the loyal investors. Look at Tesla — it's down about three percent in the past five days. If Tesla were doing a follow-on, would they use a DSP? Lucas: Interesting question. Tesla has a very retail-heavy shareholder base. A DSP could help them bring in more institutions. But Tesla's management has historically been skeptical of big Wall Street allocations. They might prefer to do a traditional offering or even an at the market program. It really depends on their strategic goals. Luna: One thing I find fascinating is how DSPs are used in cross-border offerings. When a Chinese company lists in the US and then does a follow-on, they often use a DSP to allocate shares to US institutional investors who can help them navigate regulatory issues. It's a relationship-building tool as much as a financing tool. Lucas: That's a great point. In those cases, the DSP is not just about capital — it's about governance and expertise. The company wants investors who can advise on compliance, who understand the US market, and who can be a bridge to other investors. So the selection criteria go beyond just 'long-term holder.' Luna: Now, what about the investors themselves? Is being on the receiving end of a directed share allocation always a good thing? Lucas: For most institutional investors, yes — they get access to an offering at a discount, and they get a signal that the company values them. But there's also a risk: they might end up with a large position that they can't easily exit if the stock drops. And if they're tagged as a 'strategic investor,' the market might expect them to hold through volatility. So it can be a double-edged sword. Luna: There's also the issue of transparency. In some jurisdictions, directed share allocations have to be disclosed. In the US, companies usually disclose the existence of a DSP in the prospectus, but they don't always name the investors. That can lead to speculation and rumors. Lucas: Right. And that's another reason some companies avoid DSPs — they don't want the scrutiny. They'd rather just do a traditional book-built offering and let the market decide who gets shares. But for companies that value a curated shareholder base, the trade-off is worth it. Luna: I think it's also worth noting that DSPs are not just for follow-ons. Some IPOs have a directed share component. In fact, it's common for IPOs to have a 'directed share program' for friends and family, but that's different — it's usually a small allocation for individuals, not institutions. Lucas: Exactly. In the IPO context, a directed share program for friends and family is often a PR move. But the institutional DSP in a follow-on is a strategic capital markets tool. It's about shaping the ownership structure of the company for years to come. Luna: And it ties into the broader theme of how companies manage their stock after going public. You have buybacks, at the market offerings, self-tender offers, and then DSPs. It's a whole toolkit. Lucas: It really is. And one of the reasons we cover these tools is because they're not well understood outside of investment banking. But they have a real impact on shareholder value. A well-executed DSP can reduce volatility, attract committed investors, and even improve the company's access to capital in future offerings. Luna: On a related note — actually, this kind of deep dive is exactly why we do these shows. A handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that support helps us keep producing episodes like this without any ads or sponsors. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small group, but it makes a big difference. It lets us focus on the substance rather than trying to sell you something. So if you find these conversations useful for what you're building or running, that's how you can be part of it. It's at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: And we mean it — every bit helps. Now back to directed share programs. Lucas, you mentioned that DSPs can help reduce volatility. Is there any actual data on that? Lucas: There's some academic research. A study from a few years ago looked at follow-on offerings with DSPs and compared them to those without. They found that companies using DSPs had lower post-offering volatility and fewer large block trades in the following months. The theory is that the directed shares go to holders who don't flip, so the supply overhang is smaller. Luna: That makes sense. And it's consistent with the idea that a stable shareholder base is valuable. But the key is execution — you have to pick the right investors. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the art of it. The best DSPs are the ones where the investor list looks like a who's who of long-term, engaged institutions. The worst ones look like a list of the CEO's golf buddies. The difference is night and day in terms of outcomes. Luna: So to sum up: directed share programs let companies hand-pick institutional investors during follow-on offerings. They can help build a stable shareholder base, but they come with risks of favoritism and lack of transparency. Used well, they're a powerful tool for post ipo capital management. Lucas: That's exactly right. And as more tech companies mature and do follow-on offerings, we'll likely see DSPs become even more common. It's one of those behind the scenes mechanisms that really shapes who owns your company.