Latest / Deep Dive / The Precarious Inclusion of Diversity on Australian TV
Transcript
- 0:00You know, we all like to think of social progress as this
- 0:04fairly straightforward line. Like you started exclusion, you
- 0:07March steadily toward it, the perfectly inclusive society, and
- 0:11eventually everyone just gets along.
- 0:13Yeah, I mean, it is a very comforting narrative.
- 0:15It feels clean, you know, and it gives us this sense of
- 0:18inevitable momentum that things will just naturally get better
- 0:21on their own. Right, exactly.
- 0:23But when you actually dig into the history and the sociology,
- 0:26you realize it is not a straight line at all.
- 0:28It's, well, it's more like a highly volatile pendulum swing.
- 0:32Oh, absolutely. A very volatile.
- 0:33Swing. And today, our mission is to
- 0:35unpack a deeply ingrained paradox that sits right at the
- 0:39center of that swing. We're looking at what it
- 0:41actually means to be a multicultural society versus
- 0:45what that looks like on our screens and, you know, in our
- 0:47political policies. Yeah.
- 0:49And to get to the bottom of this, we are pulling from a
- 0:51really fascinating stack of research.
- 0:53Today we're blending some academic work by Sukhmani
- 0:56Khurana, which looks at how diverse populations are
- 0:59represented on television, with some deep sociological
- 1:02breakdowns of your sentiments. And there's a new paper in there
- 1:05too, right? Yes, a comprehensive 2024 paper
- 1:09by Lou you and right and that one explores the incredibly
- 1:14precarious nature of Asian inclusion and exclusion
- 1:18specifically in Australia. Now for you listening, I want to
- 1:22make something very clear right up front.
- 1:24While a lot of this data is anchored in the Australian
- 1:27context, the underlying mechanisms we are going to
- 1:30explore, things like how media actively shapes our reality, how
- 1:34societies react to rapid demographic changes, those
- 1:37affect everyone. Definitely.
- 1:39It's universal. Right.
- 1:40Like who actually gets to decide what is considered normal?
- 1:43No matter where you live? This deep dive is going to
- 1:45change how you watch your favorite television shows, and
- 1:48it will absolutely change how you understand the new.
- 1:50It changes the entire lens through which you view culture
- 1:54Because, you know, to understand the television we consume today
- 1:57or the society we navigate right now, we first have to understand
- 2:00the historical baseline. Which means looking at who was
- 2:02even allowed to be in the audience in the first place.
- 2:04Exactly. And if we?
- 2:10Very stark. I mean think about the founding
- 2:12of the nation. The very first legislative bill
- 2:16passed by the Commonwealth Parliament after federation in
- 2:1919 O One was the Immigration Restriction Act.
- 2:22Right. And that legislation formed the
- 2:24absolute bedrock of what became known as the White Australia
- 2:27Policy. This wasn't some accidental
- 2:30byproduct of a bygone era. It wasn't just a slip up.
- 2:33No, not at all. It was a deliberate,
- 2:35meticulously engineered attempt to build a white national
- 2:39identity from the ground up. The state was actively curating
- 2:43its demographics. And the level of fear driving
- 2:45this at the time was intense. There was this overwhelming
- 2:48mainstream Yellow Peril anxiety. Oh, he was everywhere.
- 2:52Yeah, take a unionist from the era named William Lane.
- 2:55In 1888, he wrote this wildly dystopian narrative warning
- 2:59people that if immigration wasn't restricted, the Chinese
- 3:01would, quote overrun everything. He was really stocking the
- 3:05flames. Completely.
- 3:06He warned his readers that this minority group would monopolize
- 3:09industries, sit in parliament and essentially take over over
- 3:11the entire society unless they were expelled by cattle.
- 3:14Which, hearing that kind of visceral language today is
- 3:17jarring. But it was incredibly effective
- 3:20political messaging at the time. The nation was defining itself
- 3:24explicitly in opposition to its geographic reality in Asia.
- 3:28Right, they wanted to be a European outpost.
- 3:30Exactly. It was clinging to the
- 3:31self-image of being a far-flung, isolated outpost of Europe, and
- 3:35the policy achieved exactly what it set out to do.
- 3:39By 1947, the Asian population in Australia had been
- 3:42systematically reduced to just .5% of the total population.
- 3:46Wow. Half of 1%.
- 3:48The society was thoroughly engineered.
- 3:50But then, you know, we Fast forward to the 1970s and the
- 3:53pendulum swings hard in the other direction.
- 3:56It does. The Whitlam Labour government
- 3:58formally ends the White Australia Policy in 1973.
- 4:01Now, the natural optimistic assumption here is that this was
- 4:04a great moral awakening. Society suddenly looked in the
- 4:07mirror, realized systemic racism was abhorrent, and decided to do
- 4:11the right thing. I wish that were the case, but
- 4:13the underlying drivers were far more pragmatic than a sudden
- 4:16moral epiphany. It was pure geopolitical
- 4:18realism. So it was about money and power.
- 4:20Mostly, yeah. The Whitlam government
- 4:23recognized that Australia was geographically situated on the
- 4:26edge of Asia and the economies in that region were starting to
- 4:29grow at an unprecedented rate. Right, you can't ignore your
- 4:32neighbors when they're getting rich.
- 4:34Exactly. The Prime Minister specifically
- 4:36stated that the country quote cannot afford the stigma of
- 4:40racialism if it wanted to engage in trade, secure economic
- 4:44partnerships and thrive in the modern world.
- 4:46It's like a corporate rebrand. Yes, that's a perfect way to put
- 4:49it. It's like a legacy company
- 4:51changing its logo and updating its mission statement to look
- 4:53progressive and globally minded because, well, they want to
- 4:56attract international investors. But you have to ask, did the
- 5:00internal corporate culture actually change, or are they
- 5:03just putting on a fresh coat of paint to secure the bag?
- 5:05Your corporate rebrand analogy gets right to the heart of what
- 5:08the researchers are saying. Because of that pragmatic, trade
- 5:12driven shift, multiculturalism was born as something the
- 5:16country has like a tool utilized for economic and political
- 5:19benefit, rather than something the country fundamentally is.
- 5:22So it was a strategic asset, not a core identity.
- 5:26Precisely. And if a government is treating
- 5:28diversity like a commercial strategy to attract
- 5:31international trade, that same commercial logic is going to
- 5:34bleed directly into how we entertain ourselves.
- 5:37Which brings us to television. TV is the ultimate mirror, Or at
- 5:41least it's the mirror we prefer to look into.
- 5:44And for a very long time, the television landscape provided
- 5:48what sociologists call nostalgic whiteness.
- 5:51Nostalgic whiteness. OK, give me an example of that.
- 5:53Think about a long running cultural staple like the soap
- 5:56opera Neighbors. For decades, it was ironically
- 6:00known for being overwhelmingly white and liking almost any
- 6:03diversity, despite being set in suburban pockets of a country
- 6:06that was rapidly changing its demographic makeup.
- 6:09But why hold on to that? I mean, if the world outside
- 6:11your window is diverse, why do viewers want a fictional suburb
- 6:14that looks like a 1950s postcard?
- 6:16Because it provides emotional safety when the real world is
- 6:19undergoing rapid, sometimes confusing demographic chefs, a
- 6:23segment of the dominant culture craves A psychological anchor.
- 6:27So it's not about historical accuracy.
- 6:29Not at all. Nostalgic whiteness on
- 6:31television isn't about reflecting historical reality.
- 6:34It's about offering a safe, familiar haven where the
- 6:37dominant culture remains the unquestioned default.
- 6:40But obviously, the media landscape couldn't ignore
- 6:43reality forever. As we move into the 1990s and
- 6:462000s, networks like SPSI start heavily championing something
- 6:51called productive diversity. Yes, but we need to look at why
- 6:55they championed it. They weren't necessarily arguing
- 6:58for diverse casting just because representation matters, they
- 7:01were arguing for it on economic grounds.
- 7:03Right. They were operating under the
- 7:04logic of the neoliberal era, which essentially believes that
- 7:08the free market can solve social issues.
- 7:10Exactly. The pitch was that diversity
- 7:12makes broadcasting globally competitive, it is marketable,
- 7:16it can be exported and you know it attracts A wider viewership.
- 7:19Hold on though, representation is representation, right?
- 7:22If a network is casting diverse actors, even if it's just to
- 7:25make a quick buck or hit a viewership metric, isn't that
- 7:27still a massive win compared to the door being completely
- 7:31slammed shut? Once you're in the room, you're
- 7:33in the room. Well, getting a foot in the door
- 7:35is a step, yes, but we have to look at the ceiling this
- 7:38creates. When diversity is purely
- 7:40productive, meaning it only exists to generate profit, the
- 7:44core institutions of broadcasting remain completely
- 7:47unchanged. Unchanged how?
- 7:49The executives, the green light committees, the people actually
- 7:52holding the institutional power behind the scenes, they remain
- 7:55overwhelmingly white. Wait, so when you say they
- 7:57remain unchanged, you're talking about the underlying assumption
- 8:00of who actually owns the culture?
- 8:02Yes, that is what academics call the settler paradigm.
- 8:06It's the unspoken assumption that white European descendants
- 8:10are the default owners and hosts of the culture, and everyone
- 8:13else is essentially a guest. A guest who has been invited in
- 8:17because they bring some kind of economic or entertainment value.
- 8:20Right. So you end up with institutions
- 8:22that look incredibly diverse on a billboard or ATV screen, but
- 8:26the power dynamic hasn't shifted an inch.
- 8:28That perfectly explains the split between what we experience
- 8:31in real life versus what we see on TV.
- 8:33The research talks about this concept of banal
- 8:36multiculturalism versus official multiculturalism.
- 8:40Yes, that's a crucial distinction.
- 8:41Banal multiculturalism is just everyday life.
- 8:44It's sitting in a suburban shopping mall food court hearing
- 8:485 different languages eating fusion food.
- 8:51It's messy, it's organic, it's totally normal.
- 8:54Exactly. But official multiculturalism,
- 8:56culturalism, which is what TV networks often produce, relies
- 9:00on these hyper real tokenistic stereotypes.
- 9:03It's diversity, neatly packaged so the mainstream audience can
- 9:07consume it without feeling challenged.
- 9:09Which is precisely why serious dramatic television really
- 9:12struggled to escape that trap for years.
- 9:15If a creator pitched a serious drama about systemic racism, it
- 9:18often made mainstream network gatekeepers uncomfortable.
- 9:21Because it threatened that sense of emotional safety we talked
- 9:24about. Earlier, exactly.
- 9:25But marginalized creators didn't just give up when they hit that
- 9:28wall. They found a brilliant
- 9:29workaround. They used comedy.
- 9:31I love this part of the evolution.
- 9:33Comedy is such a vital space. In the 90s and early 2000s there
- 9:37was this genre dubbed Wog exploitation.
- 9:40Right shows and films like The Wog Boy and Fat Pizza.
- 9:43Yeah. Instead of making sensitive
- 9:46heavy dramas, these creators pivoted to highly commercial,
- 9:50self satirizing entertainment. They actively spoke back to the
- 9:54traditional ochre Australian stereotype by leaning into the
- 9:57absurdity of the cultural clash. They took the very insults and
- 10:01stereotypes used against them and weaponized them for laughs.
- 10:05And you see this strategy evolved brilliantly over the
- 10:08years. Look at creator Paul Fennick and
- 10:11his series Husos. Oh, Housos is a great example.
- 10:14He didn't just focus on ethnicity, he blended ethnic
- 10:17diversity with working class bogan culture.
- 10:20He tapped into this broad, almost mythic appeal of the
- 10:23underdog. If you were struggling, if you
- 10:25were on the fringes of society, that show resonated with you
- 10:28regardless of your background. And it creates this incredible
- 10:31bridge. Benjamin Law did something
- 10:33similar with his series The Family Law, but with a slightly
- 10:36different emotional hook. Yes, Law's approach was very
- 10:39intentional. He explicitly stated his
- 10:41strategy was essentially to make the audience laugh, but only
- 10:44after making them cry and tear their guts out.
- 10:46Because it drops the audience's defenses.
- 10:49When you are laughing, you are completely vulnerable.
- 10:53You are in a state of connection.
- 10:54The comedic mode invites the dominant culture in making them
- 10:58feel comfortable. And then it hits them with the
- 11:00real stuff. Exactly.
- 11:01It explores the specific, sometimes painful realities of a
- 11:04migrant experience only after the mainstream audience is
- 11:07already emotionally invested in the characters.
- 11:10It's a Trojan horse. You sneak complex identity
- 11:12politics, generational trauma, and the reality of systemic
- 11:16barriers into the living room disguised as a 22 minute A.
- 11:20Very effective Trojan horse. And everyone's defenses are down
- 11:23because they're too busy laughing at a chaotic family
- 11:25dinner scene. It is a highly effective
- 11:28delivery system, and in recent years new media has completely
- 11:31supercharged this strategy. Diverse storytellers don't even
- 11:34need the traditional television network gatekeepers anymore.
- 11:37Because they can just go straight to the audience.
- 11:39Right The debut of The Family Law actually happened on
- 11:41Facebook, pulling in 1.1 million views.
- 11:44Platforms like YouTube allow creators to speak directly to
- 11:48younger, more fragmented audiences.
- 11:50But there is a massive catch to that digital freedom, isn't
- 11:53there? Paul Fenick gives a really stark
- 11:55warning about relying entirely on these global platforms,
- 11:59especially for smaller markets like Australia.
- 12:01He does, and it comes down to the underlying mechanism of how
- 12:03these platforms operate. YouTube and Facebook are driven
- 12:07by US centric algorithms. These algorithms are designed
- 12:11with one goal, maximize watch time on a global scale.
- 12:14So. How does that actually throttle
- 12:16local content? Because if a teenager in Sydney
- 12:19opens the YouTube app, the algorithm is far more likely to
- 12:23feed them clips of an American late night talk show or
- 12:26Kardashian style reality content.
- 12:28Those have a proven massive global retention rate.
- 12:31So local comedy just gets buried.
- 12:33Exactly. Highly localized, culturally
- 12:35specific Australian comedy is seen as a niche risk by the
- 12:38algorithm. So while the digital landscape
- 12:40feels democratic, it actually operates as a closed shop.
- 12:44It flattens local culture and buries diverse voices under a
- 12:47mountain of homogenized, globally safe content.
- 12:49Man, so even when you find a backdoor like comedy or you
- 12:52manage to build an audience on social media, the inclusion is
- 12:55still incredibly fragile. Very fragile.
- 12:57It is constantly at the mercy of algorithms or network executives
- 13:01or market trends. Which brings us to the most
- 13:04sobering part of the research we're digging into today.
- 13:07Because being able to make the majority laugh does not
- 13:10guarantee permanent safety. No it doesn't.
- 13:12When a society undergoes rapid changes or faces a crisis, the
- 13:16backlash reveals just how conditional this inclusion
- 13:20really is. The sociological breakdown of
- 13:22viewer discomfort explains the mechanics of this backlash
- 13:25perfectly. It details a psychological
- 13:27phenomenon known as the latter effect.
- 13:29I found the latter effect fascinating, but also kind of
- 13:33tragic. How does it actually play out in
- 13:35people's minds? Imagine someone from the
- 13:37dominant culture who feels they have played by the rules their
- 13:40whole life. They've used social progression
- 13:43as a ladder. When the demographic makeup of a
- 13:45society changes rapidly, or when media starts heavily amplifying
- 13:49diverse voices, this person suddenly feels like their
- 13:52position on the ladder is being threatened.
- 13:54Like someone is skipping steps. Exactly.
- 13:57There is a very real perception that minority groups are being
- 14:00offered a shortcut, that they are bypassing the traditional
- 14:04rules of fairness and that their sudden visibility isn't earned.
- 14:08It's the loss of the cultural default when the unspoken rules
- 14:11of a society change quickly. People who are used to being the
- 14:15absolute center of the universe experienced genuine cultural
- 14:18displacement anxiety. It feels like the ground is
- 14:21shifting beneath their feet. And the tragic part is how that
- 14:24confusion gets weaponized. Right.
- 14:26Instead of being anxious about the abstract concept of
- 14:29globalization or economic shifts, the anger gets
- 14:32misdirected. It gets pointed directly at the
- 14:34ethnic groups themselves. And we can track this
- 14:37misdirected anxiety through specific historical touchpoints.
- 14:41The research highlights the politician Pauline Hanson.
- 14:44In 1996, she delivered a highly publicized speech warning that
- 14:48the country was in danger of being quote swamped by Asians.
- 14:51And then the target just shifted later on.
- 14:53Yes, move forward 20 years to 2016.
- 14:57And she delivers another speech, this time warning that the
- 15:00country is being swamped by Muslims.
- 15:03The specific target of the anxiety shifts based on the
- 15:07geopolitics of the decade. But the mechanism is identical.
- 15:10Exactly the underlying mechanism, the dominant culture,
- 15:13feeling displaced and reacting with hostility, remains exactly
- 15:17the same. It makes you step back and look
- 15:19at the sheer cognitive dissonance of it all.
- 15:21Like, how can a society simultaneously embrace the
- 15:25so-called Asian Century, cheering for the lucrative trade
- 15:28deals, the international student revenue, the incredible food
- 15:31culture, while immediately turning on that exact same
- 15:34community the second there is a crisis?
- 15:36It's a jarring contradiction. Because we saw this play out in
- 15:39real time during the COVID-19 pandemic.
- 15:41We did. The 2020 4 paper by Liu Yu and
- 15:44Wright points to the pandemic as the ultimate, undeniable proof
- 15:48of how precarious multicultural inclusion really is.
- 15:51When the pandemic hit, the glowing narrative of the
- 15:53economic Asian century vanished almost overnight.
- 15:56Just poof. Gone.
- 15:57It was immediately seamlessly replaced by a revival of those
- 16:011880s Yellow Peril stereotypes we discussed earlier.
- 16:05The whiplash was staggering. I mean the examples in the
- 16:09research are just jarring to read.
- 16:11A major tabloid run a headline that literally read Chinese
- 16:15Virus pandemonium. Yes, and the paper details this
- 16:18massive spike in microaggressions and outright
- 16:21hostility toward anyone presenting as Asian people
- 16:24moving away from them on public transport, coworkers making
- 16:28incredibly inappropriate jokes, businesses being boycotted.
- 16:31It viscerally ripped away the progressive logo of that
- 16:35corporate rebrand we were talking about.
- 16:37It showed that beneath the surface of this pragmatic,
- 16:39tolerant multiculturalism, Asian Australians were still occupying
- 16:43the periphery of society. They were happily included when
- 16:46they brought economic or cultural value.
- 16:48But they were instantly re excluded and rendered as a
- 16:50foreign alien threat the moment the dominant culture felt
- 16:53scared. Forces us to ask the biggest,
- 16:56most difficult question of this entire deep dive.
- 16:58Right. If multiculturalism as it is
- 17:01currently practiced is just this conditional precarious
- 17:04arrangement that can be revoked the second a crisis hits, what
- 17:08is the actual solution? How do we stop the pendulum from
- 17:10constantly swinging back to exclusion?
- 17:13The academic consensus points toward a necessary systemic
- 17:16evolution. We have to move from precarious
- 17:19multiculturalism to what they define as systemic inclusion.
- 17:22Systemic inclusion. OK, where do we even start with
- 17:25that? Well, the very first step in
- 17:26making that leap is interrogating the language we
- 17:29use in our institutions. The researchers level a heavy
- 17:32critique at the widely used acronym CALD, which stands for
- 17:37Culturally and Linguistically Diverse.
- 17:39Oh, I hear that term used constantly in corporate HR
- 17:42seminars and government policy documents.
- 17:44It sounds incredibly professional and well meaning.
- 17:46Why is it actually a problem? Think of the term CALD like
- 17:50applying a heavy blur filter over a highly detailed
- 17:53photograph. It takes a massively
- 17:56heterogeneous group of people, people with entirely different
- 17:59histories, different levels of privilege and different
- 18:02experiences with systemic barriers, and blurs them all
- 18:05together under one polite, corporate friendly label.
- 18:07So it hides the real issues. Exactly.
- 18:10By calling everything culture, it effectively dilutes and
- 18:13erases the very real uncomfortable power dynamics of
- 18:17race. Wow, it's another rebrand.
- 18:19It makes the dominant culture feel comfortable because talking
- 18:21about cultural diversity is easy and pleasant, But talking about
- 18:25race and systemic inequity requires acknowledging who holds
- 18:29the power, and that makes people defensive.
- 18:31And that is why systemic conclusion demands actual
- 18:34structural change. It moves entirely away from this
- 18:37top down model where the state merely tolerates minorities as
- 18:40long as they can prove they're economically valuable or
- 18:43assimilated enough. So what does it look like in
- 18:45practice? Systemic inclusion means actual
- 18:48power sharing. It means changing the makeup of
- 18:51institutional structures. Who sits on the Broadcasting
- 18:54Commission? Who is making the decisions in
- 18:57the immigration system? Who is green lighting the
- 19:00television shows? It makes you wonder, have we
- 19:03been confusing tolerance with inclusion all this time?
- 19:07Because if you think about it, tolerance sounds like putting up
- 19:10with a bad roommate. A bad roommate?
- 19:12Yeah, like you stay on your side of the fridge.
- 19:13I'll stay on mine. Just don't make too much noise.
- 19:15That's tolerance. But inclusion means they
- 19:18actually get a say in how we decorate the house.
- 19:21They have equity in the building.
- 19:23That is a brilliant way to frame the shift the research is
- 19:26calling for. It is the leap from an
- 19:28individual's conditional right to be tolerated by the majority
- 19:31to a community's fundamental right to represent themselves
- 19:34and participate in democratic decision making at every single
- 19:38level. It is about minority groups
- 19:39setting the terms of their own inclusion.
- 19:41Yes, rather than waiting for an invitation from the settler
- 19:44paradigm. OK, let's take a breath and
- 19:47recap the incredible journey we've been on today.
- 19:49We started by tracing that volatile pendulum swing, looking
- 19:54at the deliberate engineered exclusion of the White Australia
- 19:57Policy in 19 O1 and how geopolitical realism forced a
- 20:01pragmatic, economically driven embrace of multiculturalism in
- 20:05the 1970s. Right.
- 20:06And we then explored how that deep societal tension plays out
- 20:09on our screens. We analyzed the psychological
- 20:12comfort of nostalgic whiteness and the severe limitations of
- 20:16neoliberal profit driven diversity.
- 20:19And we can't forget the brilliant, subversive ways
- 20:21creators have used the Trojan horse of comedy to sneak
- 20:24authentic stories past network gatekeepers.
- 20:26But then, of course, we confronted the harsh reality of
- 20:28the backlash. Yeah, the heavy stuff.
- 20:30We broke down how the latter effect and cultural displacement
- 20:33anxiety caused societies to instantly revoke their tolerance
- 20:36during a crisis, exposing just how fragile conditional
- 20:39acceptance really is. Which?
- 20:41Is why the transition to systemic inclusion is not just a
- 20:44theory, it is a necessity. The media you consume, the
- 20:48algorithms you interact with, and the language your
- 20:50institutions use are actively shaping who is deemed to belong
- 20:55in your society. So the next time you stream a
- 20:58new show, or scroll through your video feed or read a news
- 21:01headline, I want you to look critically at it.
- 21:03Who is actually on the screen, but more importantly, who holds
- 21:06the institutional power behind the camera?
- 21:08Are they truly sharing power? Exactly.
- 21:10Is the diversity you're seeing truly systemic or is it just
- 21:13productive? Are they helping decorate the
- 21:15house or are they just the tolerated roommate?
- 21:18It requires an active critical eye from all of us.
- 21:20It really does, and I want to leave you with one final thought
- 21:22to Mull over, building on everything we've unpacked today.
- 21:26If truth systemic inclusion means actual power sharing.
- 21:30Are we prepared for a media landscape where the default
- 21:32culture isn't just diversified, but entirely redefined?
- 21:36Imagine what a television show would look like if it completely
- 21:39stopped trying to explain its diverse characters to a dominant
- 21:42majority and just allowed them to exist.
- 21:44What story would they tell then? Maybe then the pendulum can
- 21:47finally stop swinging.